Supuesto Gestión Procesal Pi 2011

8/11/2019 Supuesto Gestión Procesal Pi 2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/supuesto-gestion-procesal-pi-2011 1/17

SUPUESTO GPA-PI 2011

En diferentes ocasiones he sido preguntado sobre la posibilidad de que en el 3º

ejercicio del proceso selectivo de Gestión Procesal pueda haber preguntas sobre la

materia del Registro Civil, sobre todo en un momento de incertidumbre como el actual

y con dos leyes publicadas en el BOE, la vigente (de 1957) y la de 2011 (que tiene que

entrar en vigor en julio de este año pero sobre que está afectada sobre lo que se decida

en las próximas semanas).

Como sabemos, para el proceso selectivo de este año sólo es exigible la legislación

vigente, la Ley de 1957 y su Reglamento de desarrollo de 1958, y ya no ha sido la

primera vez desde que existe modalidad de ejercicio consistente en un supuesto práctico

en el proceso selectivo de Gestión (año 2006) que alguna pregunta ha versado sobre esta

materia.

Pongo a continuación a vuestra disposición, con intención meramente pedagógica, el

supuesto práctico que pusieron en la convocatoria de 2011 en el turno de

promoción interna, que versaba sobre materia de incapacidades, matrimonio y,

precisamente, sobre Registro Civil.

El tribunal nunca hizo públicas las respuestas oficiales de este ejercicio, así que las

que os encontraréis a continuación son las que he elaborado para utilizar el supuesto en

las clases con los alumnos. Va como Anexo una sentencia de la Sala 1ª del Tribunal

Supremo tal sólo tres meses antes de la fecha en que se realizó el ejercicio y que creo

que fue la que sirvió de base para el supuesto de la oposición.

Es discutible para la categoría de funcionarios a la que va destinado el supuesto, el

contenido de la pregunta nº 4, ya que dista de ser mero derecho procesal y se adentra en

la opinión jurisprudencial, pero en fin, tal y como se recoge a continuación fue como la

planteó el Tribunal.

Esperando que sirva de ayuda y orientación a todos los que estáis preparando el 3º

ejercicio os ofrezco a continuación el planteamiento del supuesto y sus posibles

respuestas.



!"#"$%&' #)*+&,+' "#$%&'( )*'+#$,- . ,/0&(&$%*,%&1,

#2#*+&+&' /# +'(1'+,%'*&, 3 "#$%&'( )*'0'+&'( &(%#*(, 4566789:; <8;=>?;9>@AB 4CD56D64&(+,),+&%,+&'( . 0,%*&0'(&,-

%R



Supuesto práctico GPA Promoción interna 2011 – Blog de Justicia de Adams

+,$' )*S+%&+'

"# $%&'()* + ",# -.(/. 0*1)(.2'(*1 3.)(43*14* '1 5'06. 78 9' 2:14* 9' ;88;< )'14'19*'% =%)43* 9*3404%4* 0*1+:>.% '1 %. %*0.%49.9 9' ?*>(*@*#

"*@. -.(). A:5(' .0049'1)' 9' 04(0:%.04B1 '% 9/. 7C 9' .>*A)* 9' ;88D< E:'9.19*)')(.F%G240.# -.1)4'1' A: ('A49'104. '1 ?*>(*@*#

?*A F.9('A 9' 9*@. -.().< ('A49'1)'A '1 -.9(49< 41)'(F*1'1 9'3.19. 9'410.F.04).04B1 9' %. 34A3. . 0*1A'0:'104. 9' A: 'A).9* 9' A.%:9< .1)' '% H:I>.9*"'0.1* 9' -.9(49J .A/ 0*3*< 9'3.19.A 9' A'F.(.04B1 + 9' 94K*(04* 0*1)(. 9*1$%&'()* F*( 5.%). 9' .)'104B1 9' A:A 9'&'('A 0*1+:>.%'A F.(. 0*1 A: 3:2'(#

)*#"T(%,$

7L MN:G H:I>.9*< 9' %. %*0.%49.9'A .1)'(4*(3'1)' A'@.%.9.A< 'A 0*3F')'1)' F.(.0*1*0'( 9' %. 9'3.19. 9' 410.F.049.9 + 9' %. 9'3.19. 9' A'F.(.04B1 + 94K*(04*OP.I*1' A: ('AF:'A).#

;L M?. '15'(3'9.9 9' 9*@. -.(/. F:'9' A'( 0.:A. 9' 410.F.04).04B1O# "' A'(%*< M'A)Q1

%'>4)43.9*A %*A F.9('A F.(. A*%404).( 9406. 410.F.049.9O# P.I*1' A: ('AF:'A).#

RL MS*9(/. 0*3F.('0'( 9*@. -.(/. '1 A: F(*0'A* 9' 410.F.04).04B1O T '1 A: 0.A*<ME:4G1 F*9(/. .0):.( '1 9'5'1A. 9' A:A 9'('06*AO# P.I*1' A: ('AF:'A).#

DL U1 '% 0.A* 9' E:' %*A F.9('A *&):K4'(.1 %. ):)'%. 2:9404.% 9' 9*@. -.(/.< 'A).(/.1%'>4)43.9*A F.(. 41)'(F*1'( 9'3.19. 9' A'F.(.04B1 + 94K*(04* 0*1)(. 9*1 $%&'()*O#P.I*1' A: ('AF:'A).#

CL M$ E:4G1 * E:4G1'A 0*(('AF*19' 5*(3:%.( %. F')404B1 F.(. 41404.( '% F(*0'A* 9'

('41)'>(.04B1 9' %. 0.F.049.9 + 3*94540.04B1 9'% .%0.10' 9' %. 410.F.04).04B1O




*#$)T#$%,$ *,U'(,/,$

*8JLI8JK; AV 6

U% ,<KW9I=F RXY 9' %. ?UV 94AF*1' E:' WA'(Q 0*3F')'1)' F.(. 0*1*0'( 9' %.A 9'3.19.AA*&(' 0.F.049.9 + 9'0%.(.04B1 9' F(*94>.%49.9 '% H:'I 9' S(43'(. X1A).104. 9'% %:>.( '1E:' ('A49. %. F'(A*1. . %. E:' A' ('54'(. %. 9'0%.(.04B1 E:' A' A*%404)'Y#

S*( %* ).1)*< '1 'A)' 0.A* '1 0*10(')*< F.(. 0*1*0'( 9' %. 9'3.19. 9' 410.F.049.9 9'-.(/.< A'(/.1 0*3F')'1)'A %*A H:I>.9*A 9' S(43'(. X1A).104. 9' ?*>(*@*#

U% ;<KW9I=F RYZ 9' %. ?UV 'A).&%'0' E:' WA.%K* E:' 'ZF('A.3'1)' A' 94AF*1>. *)(. 0*A.<

A'(Q )(4&:1.% 0*3F')'1)' F.(. 0*1*0'( 9' %*A F(*0'9434'1)*A . E:' A' ('54'(' 'A)'0.F/):%* [F(*0'9434'1)*A 3.)(43*14.%'A + 9' 3'1*('AL '% H:I>.9* 9' S(43'(. X1A).104.9'% %:>.( 9'% 9*3404%4* 0*1+:>.%#

S*( %* ).1)*< '1 'A)' 0.A* 0*10(')*< A'(Q1 0*3F')'1)' F.(. 0*1*0'( 9' %. 9'3.19. 9'A'F.(.04B1 * 94K*(04* %*A H:I>.9*A 9' S(43'(. X1A).104. 9' ?*>(*@* [%*0.%49.9 9*19''A)Q 542.9* '% 9*3404%4* 0*1+:>.%L

*8JLI8JK; AV 4

U% .()/0:%* ;88 9'% VB94>* V4K4% 94AF*1' E:' WA*1 0.:A.A 9' 410.F.04).04B1 %.A'15'(3'9.9'A * 9'5404'104.A F'(A4A)'1)'A 9' 0.(Q0)'( 5/A40* * FA/E:40*< E:' 43F49.1 .%. F'(A*1. >*&'(1.(A' F*( A/ 34A3.Y#

S*( %* ).1)*< + .:1E:' '1 '% A:F:'A)* A*%.3'1)' A' 41940. E:' -.(/. 6. E:'9.9*W)')(.F%G240.Y< F*9(/. 'A). A4):.04B1 0*1A)4):4( :1. 9'5404'104. F'(3.1'1)' 9' 0.(Q0)'(5/A40* E:' %' 43F49. >*&'(1.(A' F*( A/ 34A3.< 0:'A)4B1 E:' )'19(Q E:' 9'0494( '% H:'IF*( A'1)'104.< )(.A %. )(.34).04B1 9'% 0*(('AF*194'1)' F(*0'9434'1)* 9' 410.F.049.9#

?*A F.9('A 9' -.(/. 'A)Q1 F'(5'0).3'1)' %'>4)43.9*A F.(. A*%404).( %. 9'0%.(.04B1 9'410.F.049.9 9' A: 642.< +. E:' '% .()/0:%* \C\ 9' %. ?UV [%'>4)43.04B1 '1 %*A F(*0'A*A 9'

410.F.04).04B1 + 9' 9'0%.(.04B1 9' F(*94>.%49.9L< 94AF*1' %* A4>:4'1)']

W?. 9'0%.(.04B1 9' 410.F.049.9 F:'9' F(*3*K'(%. '% F('A:1)* 410.F.I< '% 0B1+:>' *E:4'1 A' '10:'1)(' '1 :1. A4):.04B1 9' 6'06* .A434%.&%'< %*A 9'A0'194'1)'A< =FJ;J98AH>8AK8J< * %*A 6'(3.1*A 9'% F('A:1)* 410.F.IY#

*8JLI8JK; AV [

U% .()/0:%* \C^ ?UV 94AF*1' E:' W'% F('A:1)* 410.F.I _ F:'9' 0*3F.('0'( '1 '%F(*0'A* 0*1 A: F(*F4. 9'5'1A. + ('F('A'1).04B1Y# S*( %* ).1)* -.(/. F*9(/.

0*3F.('0'( '1 '% F(*0'A*< 9'A4>1.19* .&*>.9* + F(*0:(.9*( E:' '2'(I.1 A: 9'5'1A. +('F('A'1).04B1 %'>.%#




`4 -.(/. 1* A' F'(A*1. '1 '% F(*0'9434'1)* '1 '% F%.I* 9' K'41)' 9/.A< A'(Q 9'5'1949.F*( '% -414A)'(4* a4A0.%< A4'3F(' E:' 1* 6.+. A49* GA)' '% F(*3*)*( 9'% F(*0'9434'1)*[04(0:1A).104. E:' 0*10:((' '1 'A)' 0.A*< 9*19' A' 41940. E:' A*1 %*A F.9('A 9' -.(/.%*A F(*3*)*('A 9' %. 9'0%.(.04B1 9' 410.F.049.9L#

S.(. '% A:F:'A)* 9' E:' 6:&4'(. A49* '% -414A)'(4* a4A0.% '% F(*3*)*( 9'%F(*0'9434'1)*< '% b(4&:1.% )'19(/. E:' 9'A4>1.( :1 9'5'1A*( 2:9404.%< . 1* A'( E:''A):K4'(' +. 1*3&(.9*#

*8JLI8JK; AV \

$:1E:' %. .004B1 9' 94K*(04* )4'1' 0.(Q0)'( F'(A*1.%/A43*< A'>=1 %. 2:(4AF(:9'104. %*A):)*('A 'A)Q1 %'>4)43.9*A F.(. '2'(04).( %. .004B1 9' 94K*(04* '1 1*3&(' 9' :1.F'(A*1. 410.F.04).9.< A4'3F(' E:' F*( A:A 0*19404*1'A< 1* F:'9. .0):.( F*( A/ 34A3.

y siempre que '% '2'(0404* 9' 'A). .004B1 *&'9'I0. . %*A 41)'('A'A 9'% 410.F.I#

$A/ %* 'A).&%'04B %. `'1)'104. 9'% b`< `.%. 7,9' %* V4K4%# S%'1*< c;Cd;877< 9' ;7 9' A'F)4'3&('# P'0:(A*7De7d;88^< A4 &4'1 F.(. :1 0.A* 9' .0049'1)' 9' 04(0:%.04B1< 0*3* 0*1A'0:'104. 9'% 0:.% %. 410.F.IE:'9B )')(.F%G240. + '1 'A).9* 9' 0*3. K4>4%< 9'% E:' 1* A' 6. ('0:F'(.9* 6.A). %. 5'06.#

UA). A*%:04B1 1* 'A 'Z)(.K.>.1)' '1 '% *(9'1.34'1)* 'AF.@*%< +. E:' '% VB94>* 04K4% %'>4)43. .%-414A)'(4* a4A0.% + W. 0:.%E:4'( F'(A*1. E:' )'1>. 41)'(GA 94('0)* + %'>/)43*Y '1 %. .004B1 F.(. F'94( %.9'0%.(.04B1 9' 1:%49.9 9' :1 9')'(341.9* 3.)(43*14* [.()# \D VV L< .A/ 0*3* . F.9('A< ):)*('A<>:.(9.9*('A + -414A)'(4* a4A0.% 0:.19* %. .004B1 )'1>. F*( *&2')* F'94( %. 1:%49.9 9' :1 3.)(43*14* F*(5.%). 9' '9.9 [.()# \C VV L _ Y

*8JLI8JK; AV X

"' 0*15*(349.9 0*1 %* 94AF:'A)* '1 '% .()/0:%* \c7 9' %. ?UV [('41)'>(.04B1 9' %.0.F.049.9 + 3*94540.04B1 9'% .%0.10' 9' %. 410.F.04).04B1L< W%. A'1)'104. 9'410.F.04).04B1 1* 43F'94(Q E:'< A*&('K'149.A 1:'K.A 04(0:1A).104.A< F:'9. 41A).(A' :11:'K* F(*0'A* E:' )'1>. F*( *&2')* 9'2.( A41 '5'0)* * 3*94540.( '% .%0.10' 9' %.410.F.04).04B1 +. 'A).&%'049.Y#

?. F')404B1 %. F:'9' 5*(3:%.( %. F(*F4. 410.F.04).9.< 'A).19* %'>4)43.9. F.(. '%%* '1 '%F('0'F)* .1)'(4*(3'1)' 04).9*< A4 &4'1< + F.(. '% 0.A* 9' E:' A' 6:&4'(. F(4K.9* . %.

410.F.04).9. 9' %. 0.F.049.9 F.(. 0*3F.('0'( '1 2:404*< 9'&'(Q *&)'1'( 'ZF('A..:)*(4I.04B1 2:9404.% F.(. .0):.( '1 '% F(*0'A* F*( A/ 34A3*#

$9'3QA 9' -.(/.< F*9(/.1 F(*3*K'( %. ('41)'>(.04B1 9' %. 0.F.049.9 * 9'% .%0.10' 9'%. 410.F.04).04B1< A: 0B1+:>' * E:4'1 A' '10:'1)(' '1 :1. A4):.04B1 9' 6'06*.A434%.&%'< %*A 9'A0'194'1)'A< %*A .A0'194'1)'A< %*A 6'(3.1*A 9'% F('A:1)* 410.F.I< %.AF'(A*1.A E:' '2'(04'('1 0.(>* ):)'%.( * ):K4'(.1 &.2* A: >:.(9. .% 410.F.04).9*< + '%-414A)'(4* a4A0.%#?. A'1)'104. E:' A' 940)' 9'&'(Q F(*1:104.(A' A*&(' A4 F(*0'9' * 1* 9'2.( A41 '5'0)* %.410.F.04).04B1< * A*&(' A4 9'&'1 * 1* 3*94540.(A' %. 'Z)'1A4B1 + %*A %/34)'A 9' GA).#




$fUgh i "hVj-Ufb$VXkf

!"#$%$&'($)* ," -./ %0%.1"/ 2'1' "3"1($%'1 -' '(($)* ," ,$4.1($. "* *.&51" ," /0 6$3'$*('2'($%','7 898 :;<=;>??

@AB

!"#$%"&' !" $%& '('%)*& *&'+, $*-.'./01%& 20)0 *3*)4.'0) $0 044.5, 1* 1.6%)4.% *, ,%/7)* 1* (,0

2*)&%,0 .,40204.'0108 &.*/2)* 9(* 2%) &(& 4%,1.4.%,*&8 ,% 2(*10 04'(0) 2%) &: /.&/0; <&'0 &%$(4.5,

,% *& *=')060-0,'* *, *$ %)1*,0/.*,'% *&20>%$8 ?0 9(* *$ @51.-% 4.6.$ $*-.'./0 0$ A.,.&'*).% B.&40$ ? !0

4(0$9(.*) 2*)&%,0 9(* '*,-0 .,'*)C& 1.)*4'% ? $*-:'./%D *, $0 044.5, 20)0 2*1.) $0 1*4$0)04.5, 1*

,($.101 1* (, 1*'*)/.,01% /0')./%,.% E0)'; FG @@ H8 0&: 4%/% 0 201)*&8 '('%)*&8 -(0)101%)*& ?

A.,.&'*).% B.&40$ 4(0,1% $0 044.5, '*,-0 2%) %73*'% 2*1.) $0 ,($.101 1* (, /0')./%,.% 2%) I0$'0 1*

*101 E0)'; FJ @@ H " )

98C 8'-' D1$&"1' ," -. E$4$-7 D-"*.C :;<=;>??C ," ;? ," /"2%$"&51"7 F"(01/. ?GH?=;>>I7

D.*"*%"J K@ELF@LEMA@ FAEL 9FML87

L@9KEKNK@9K8 NK OKEOA

DFMPKFA* +&," "- .$/0123 2" 456%"51 7&#,1&861 &9%"53 : 2" ;6,3561< 6&,"5=$#6"53& 2"%1&21 2"

26>35863 ?* @$6# +&,3&63 A ?B1* C-#1 < 18,$1&23 83%3 ,$,35"# 2" #$ D6E1 4$51 83&,51 ?* F1G6%6&3 * C-

#$=-683 2" -1 2"%1&21 "# 2"- ,"&35 #60$6"&,"' HI* #" 2"8-15" "- 26>35863 83& -3# "J"8,3# 6&D"5"&,"# 1

268D3 =53&$&861%6"&,3< A 83& "G=5"#1 6%=3#686K& 2" 83#,1# 1 -1 =15," 2"%1&2121 #6 #" 3=$#6"51 1

"--3< E$&,3 83& ,323 -3 2"%L# M$" =538"21 "& ?"5"8D3)*

+2%6,621 1 ,5L%6," -1 2"%1&21 J$" "%=-1/123 "- 2"%1&2123< 1-"01&23 -1 5"=5"#"&,186K& 2" ?*

F1G6%6&3 -3# D"8D3# A J$&21%"&,3# 2" 2"5"8D3 M$" "#,6%K 2" 1=-68186K& 1- 81#3< =151 ,"5%6&15

#$=-681&23' HI #" 2"8-15" -1 6%=538"2"&861 2"- 26>35863 #3-686,123 =35 J1-,1 2" -"06,6%186K& 18,6>1

2" -3# ,$,35"#< 3 #$N#6261561%"&," =35 -1# 23# 8$"#,63&"# 2" J3&23 =-1&,"121#< #6& "G=5"#1

6%=3#686K& 2" 83#,1#< #6& ="5E$6863 2" -1 2"%1&21 5"83&>"&863&1- M$" #" J35%$-1 #3N5" -1

26#3-$86K& 2"- 5O06%"& "83&K%683 %1,56%3&61-)* 2"%1&21 83& "G=5"#1 6%=3#686K& 2" 83#,1# 1 -1

=15," 18,351*)

C& 268D3 "#856,3 #" J35%$-1 2"%1&21 5"83&>"&863&1-< 1-"01&23 -3# D"8D3# A J$&21%"&,3# 2"

2"5"8D3 M$" "#,6%K 2" 1=-68186K&< =151 ,"5%6&15 #$=-681&23' H**268," "& 2"J6&6,6>1 #"&,"&861 =35 -1

M$" #" 2"8-15" 26#$"-,1 A "G,6&0$621 -1 #386"212 2" 01&1&861-"# A "- 5O06%"& "83&K%683 %1,56%3&61-

2" -3# 8K&A$0"# 83& J"8D1 2" "J"8,3# 2" PP 2" F15/3 2" QRRR< #$N#6261561%"&," "- S 2" ?686"%N5"

2" QRRP< A #$N#6261561%"&," 1 -3 1&,"5635 "- PT 2" F1A3 2" QRRQ< #6& ="5E$6863 2" -1 -6M$62186K& M$"




2"N1 "J"8,$15#" =35 -3# 81$8"# -"01-%"&," "#,1N-"8623# 2"#2" -1 J"8D1 M$" "- .$/01235 "#,6%"

3=35,$&1)*

C- F6&6#,"563 U6#81- =5"#"&,K "#856,3 6&,"5"#1&23' HI#" 268," #"&,"&861 83&J35%" 1 2"5"8D3<

>"-L&23#" #6"%=5" =35 -3# 6&,"5"#"# 2" -3# D6E3# %"&35"# 2" "212 1J"8,123# "& "- =5"#"&,"

=538"#3)*

V3&,"#,121 -1 2"%1&21 A 2123# -3# 3=35,$&3# ,51#-123#< #" 18352K #"B1-15 2W1 A D351 =151 -1

8"-"N5186K& 2" -1 >6#,1< -1 M$" ,$>3 -$015 83& =5"#"&861 2" -1# =15,"#* @1 =15," 18,351 #" 1J65%K A

51,6J68K "& #$# =5","&#63&"#< -1 =15," 2"%1&2121 #" 1J65%K A 51,6J68K "& #$ #3-686,$2< =53=3&6"&23

1%N1# "- 5"86N6%6"&,3 2"- =-"6,3 1 =5$"N1< =518,68L&23#" -1# 12%6,621# A 2"8-15121# ="5,6&"&,"# 83&

"- 5"#$-,123 M$" 3N51 "& 1$,3#* C- F6&6#,"563 U6#81-< &3 =53=$#3 =5$"N1< A #" 12D656K 1 -1 =53=$"#,1

=35 -1# =15,"#*

C- .$/0123 2" 456%"51 7&#,1&861 268,K X"&,"&861< 83& J"8D1 Q: 2" #"=,6"%N5" 2" QRRY< A 83& -1

#60$6"&," =15," 26#=3#6,6>1' HU+@@Z' [$" 2"#"#,6%1&23 -1 2"%1&21 6&,"5=$"#,1 =35 -1

5"=5"#"&,186K& 2" ?B1* C-#1 A ?* @$6# +&,3&63 83&,51 ?* F1G6%6&3 < 2"N3 2"8-1515 A 2"8-153 &3

D1N"5 -$015 1 -1 26#3-$86K&< =35 26>35863< 2"- %1,56%3&63 J35%123 =35 ?B1* 4$51 A ?* F1G6%6&3 *

X" 2"8-151 26#$"-,1 -1 #386"212 2" 01&1&861-"# 83& J"8D1 2" #"&,"&861 2" #"=15186K& 268,121 =35 -1

+4 2" \-1>1< QR 2" 2686"%N5" 2" QRR: *

V121 =15," 1N3&15L -1# 83#,1# 81$#121# 1 #$ 6&#,1&861 A -1# 83%$&"# =35 %6,12)*

8KQR@NA* V3&,51 268D1 X"&,"&861 6&,"5=$#6"53& 5"8$5#3 2" 1="-186K& ?* @$6# +&,3&63 A ?B1* C-#1 <

18,$1&23 83%3 ,$,35"# 2" #$ D6E1 4$51 * X$#,1&86121 -1 1="-186K&< -1 X"886K& P] 2" -1 +$26"&861

453>6&861- 2" \-1>1 268,K X"&,"&861< 83& J"8D1 T 2" E$&63 2" QRR^ < 83& "- #60$6"&," J1--3' HCX_7F+!

"- 5"8$5#3 6&,"5=$"#,3 =35 ?* @$6# +&,3&63 A ?] C-#1 83%3 ,$,35"# 2" 4$51 < 5"=5"#"&,123# =35 "-

=538$51235 X5* 2" -1# `"51# 83&,51 -1 #"&,"&861 268,121 =35 "- .$/0123 2" 456%"51 7&#,1&861 &a : 2"

;6,3561 "& "- =538"26%6"&,3 2" ?6>35863 V3&,"&863#3 &a :S:bRY< !C;ZV+c?Z -1 %6#%1< A< "&

83&#"8$"&861< M$" CX_7F+c?Z -1 2"%1&21 6&,"5=$"#,1 =35 @$6# +&,3&63 A C-#1 2"N"%3#

?CV@+!+! d ?CV@+!+FZX "- ?7;Z!V7Z "&,5" 4$51 A F1G6%6&3 83& ,323# -3# "J"8,3# 6&D"5"&,"#<

,323 "--3 #6& "G=5"#1 6%=3#686K& 2" 83#,1# "& &6&0$&1 2" -1# 6&#,1&861#)*

9KFEKFA* +&$&86123 5"8$5#3 2" 81#186K& =35 ?* F1G6%6&3 < 83&,51 -1 #"&,"&861 2" 1="-186K&< "-

_56N$&1- 2" 6&#,1&861 -3 ,$>3 =35 =5"=15123 A 268D1 =15,"< 5"=5"#"&,121 =35 -1 4538$512351 2" -3#

_56N$&1-"# ?]* 41,56861 XL&8D"/ X3N56&3< -3 6&,"5=$#3 1&," -1 X1-1< 15,68$-L&23-3 "& -3# #60$6"&,"#

%3,6>3#'




456%"53*e 7&J51886K& 2" -1# &35%1# #$#,1&,6>1# #3N5" 26>35863 f15,#* ^g A ^P V*V h< A 5"=5"#"&,186K&

2" -3# ,$,35"# f15,#* QgY< QYP A QYQ V*V *h A 2" -1 E$56#=5$2"&861 5"#="8,3 2"- 815L8,"5 ="5#3&1-W#6%3

2" -1 1886K& 2" 26>35863 =35 "- 81$8" 2"- 15,* :YY*Q*Sa A S 2" -1 @CV*

X"0$&23*e 7&J51886K& 2" -1 E$56#=5$2"&861 #3N5" "- 815L8,"5 ="5#3&1-W#6%3 2" -1 1886K& 2" 26>35863

"& 5"-186K& 83& &35%1# #$#,1&,6>1# 2" 1=-68186K& f15,#* ^P< ^g< QgY< QYP A QYQ V*V *h c"8"#6212

6&,"5O# ,$,"-1N-" 2"- 6&81=1/< =35 "- 81$8" 2"- 15,* :YY*Q*Sa A S @CV *

_"58"53*e 7&J51886K& 2" -1# &35%1# #$#,1&,6>1# 2" 1=-68186K& #3N5" "- 26>35863 f15,#* ^P A ^g V*V *h

83& >60"&861 6&J"5635 1 86&83 1B3# A #6& 238,56&1 E$56#=5$2"&861- "#="8WJ681i =35 "- 81$8" 2"- 15,*

:YY*Q*Sa A S 2" -1 @CV*

435 5"#3-$86K& 2" J"8D1 Q 2" #"=,6"%N5" 2" QRR^< -1 +$26"&861 453>6&861- 18352K -1 5"%6#6K& 2" -3#1$,3# 35606&1-"# 1 -1 X1-1 456%"51 2"- _56N$&1- X$=5"%3*

ERLF9A* !"86N623# -3# 1$,3# A J35%123 "- =5"#"&," 53--3 #" ="5#3&K -1 4538$512351 ?] j"%1

U"5&L&2"/ek-1&83 X1& F60$"-< "& &3%N5" A 5"=5"#"&,186K& 2" ?* F1G6%6&3 < "& 81-6212 2" =15,"

5"8$55"&,"i 1#6%6#%3 83%=15"8" -1 4538$512351 ?] F15W1 !325W0$"/ 4$A3-< "& &3%N5" A

5"=5"#"&,186K& 2" ?* @$6# +&,3&63 A ?] C-#1 < 83%3 ,$,35"# 2" ?] 4$51 < "& 81-6212 2" =15,"

5"8$55621* C# 6&,"5>6&6"&," "& "- =5"#"&," 5"8$5#3 "- F6&6#,"563 U6#81-*

+2%6,623 "- 5"8$5#3 =35 1$,3 2" J"8D1 PR 2" %15/3 2" QRRl A ">18$123 -3# ,51#-123# 83&J"5623# 1-

5"#="8,3< -1 4538$512351 ?]* F15W1 !325W0$"/ 4$A3-< "& &3%N5" A 5"=5"#"&,186K& 2" ?* @$6# +&,3&63

A ?] C-#1 < 18,$1&23 83%3 ,$,35"# 2" #$ D6E1 4$51 < 6%=$0&K "- %6#%3< #3-686,1&23 #" 2"8-151#" &3

D1N"5 -$015 1- 5"8$5#3*

C- F6&6#,"563 U6#81-< =5"#"&,K "#856,3 6%=$0&1&23 "- 5"8$5#3 2" 81#186K&*

SRM@9A* X" #"B1-K 83%3 2W1 =151 >3,186K& A J1--3 2"- 5"8$5#3 "- 26"86#O6# 2" %15/3 2" 23# %6- 3&8"<

A =35 5"#3-$86K& 2" "#1 %6#%1 J"8D1 #" 18352K< >6#,1 -1 %1,"561 #3N5" -1 M$" 2"N" 5"#3->"5#"<

#$#="&2"5 "- #"B1-1%6"&,3 A #3%","5 "- 83&,"&623 2" 268D3 5"8$5#3 1- 4-"&3 2" -1 X1-1< #"B1-L&23#"

"- >"6&," 2" E$-63 2" 23# %6- 3&8"< "& "- M$" "- 18,3 ,$>3 -$015*

`1 #623 =3&"&," -1 CG8%1* X51* ?]* C&815&186K& !381 _5W1# <

TR@NLPK@9A8 NK NKFKEOA

DFMPKFA* !"#$%"& 2" -3# D"8D3# =53N123#*

Pa ?] 4$51 A ?* F1G6%6&3 83&,51E"53& %1,56%3&63 "- Pg %1A3 Pll^i 2" 268D3 %1,56%3&63 &3

&186"53& D6E3#*




Qa C- PP %15/3 QRRR ?] 4$51 #$J56K $& 051>" 18862"&," 2" 8658$-186K&< 83%3 83&#"8$"&861 2"- 8$1-

M$"2K ,",51=-OE681 A "& "#,123 2" 83%1 >606-< 2"- M$" &3 #" D1 5"8$="5123 D1#,1 -1 J"8D1*

Sa X" 6&686K $& =538"26%6"&,3 2" 6&81=186,186K&* C& -1 #"&,"&861 2" P] 7&#,1&861 #" 1,56N$AK -1 ,$,"-1

1- %15623< ?* F1G6%6&3 < 5">38L&23#" 268D1 #"&,"&861 =35 -1 2" -1 +$26"&861 453>6&861- M$"

83&8"26K -1 ,$,"-1 1 -3# =125"# =35 51/K& 2" #$ %1A35 26#=3&6N6-6212 =151 D18"5#" 81503 2" -1

,$,"-121*

:a @3# =125"# ,$,35"# 6&,"5=$#6"53& -1 1886K& 2" #"=15186K& 2" -3# 8K&A$0"#< M$" J$" "#,6%121 =35

-1 #"&,"&861 2" -1 +$26"&861 453>6&861- 2" \-1>1< 2" QR 2686"%N5" QRR: * C& -1 #"&,"&861 #"

83&#62"51N1 M$" 83&8$55W1& 81$#1# 2" #"=15186K& 1&,"# 2"- 18862"&," 2" -1 "#=3#1 M$"

2"%3#,51N1& H$& 86"5,3 2"#1J"8,3 "&,5" -3# 8K&A$0"#)< 83%3 M$"' 6h -1 "#=3#1 D1NW1 83&#$-,123 1 $&

1N30123 =151 1#"#3515#" #3N5" "- =538"26%6"&,3 2" #"=15186K& 1&,"# 2"- 18862"&,"i 66h M$" "& "-

&3%N51%6"&,3 2" -3# =125"# 83%3 ,$,35"#< 6&J-$AK "- D"8D3 2" M$" 1- #"5 "- %15623 E3>"& =32W1

5"D18"5 #$ >621i 666h "- %15623 6N1 %$A =383 1 >6#6,15 1 -1 "#=3#1 6&,"5&121 2"#=$O# 2"- 18862"&,"< &6

D1NW1 18$2623 1- 8"&,53 &6 -1 D1NW1 --1%123< -3 M$" 6&2681N1 H-1 "G6#,"&861 2" $& 6&8$%=-6%6"&,3< 1-

%"&3#< 2" -3# 86,123# 2"N"5"# 2" 1A$21 A #383553 "&,5" -3# 8K&A$0"#)< 2" %323 M$" -1 #"&,"&861

83&8-$W1 M$" Hm***n1&," ,1-"# 8658$&#,1&861# 5"#$-,1 2"- 6&,"5O# 2"- 6&81=1/ 2"8-1515 -1 #"=15186K&)*

?"#2" 1M$"- %3%"&,3< =35 83&#60$6"&,"< -3# 8K&A$0"# ?] 4$51 A ?* F1G6%6&3 #" "&8$"&,51& "&

#6,$186K& -"01- 2" #"=15186K&< =$"#,3 M$" -1 #"&,"&861 "# J65%" 1- &3 D1N"5 12%6,623 "- 1$,3 2" "#,1

X1-1 2" S E$-63 QRRY < "- 5"8$5#3 2" 81#186K& 6&,"5=$"#,3 =35 "- %15623*

Ta @3# ,$,35"# ?* @$6# +&,3&63 A ?] C-#1 < 6&,"5=$#6"53& 2"%1&21 2" 26>35863 "& 5"=5"#"&,186K& 2"

#$ D6E1 ?] 4$51 * ?* F1G6%6&3 #" 3=$#3 1 -1 2"%1&21*

ga @1 #"&,"&861 2"- E$/0123 2" P] 7&#,1&861 &a : 2" ;6,3561ej1#,"6/< 2" Q: #"=,6"%N5" QRRY< "#,6%K

-1 -"06,6%186K& 2" -3# ,$,35"#< #60$6"&23 "- 856,"563 2" -1 X_V 2" P^ 2686"%N5" QRRR < ="53 2"&"0K "-

26>35863* ?6E3' 1h M$" &3 "#,L 8-151 -1 1=-68186K& 2" -1 238,56&1 2" -1 X_V SPPbQRRR 1- 26>35863<=35M$" O#," #60&6J681 -1 5$=,$51 A 26#3-$86K& 2"- >W&8$-3 %1,56%3&61-i Nh -1 =5"#,186K& 2"-

83&#"&,6%6"&,3 =151 83&,51"5 %1,56%3&63 "# $& 18,3 ="5#3&1-W#6%3 A &3 #" ="5%6," M$" #"1

=5"#,123 =35 3,51 ="5#3&1i "& 83&#"8$"&861 "#,1 %6#%1 -6%6,186K& 1J"8,1 1- 83&#"&,6%6"&,3 =151 "-

26>35863i 8h "- "E"586863 2" ,1-"# 18863&"# #3-3 =$"2" #"5 83&#"8$"&861 2" $& 18,3 2" -1 >3-$&,12 2"-

=53=63 8K&A$0"*

Ya* +="-153& -3# =530"&6,35"#b,$,35"# ?* @$6# +&,3&63 A ?] C-#1 * @1 #"&,"&861 2" -1 #"886K& P] 2" -1

+$26"&861 453>6&861- 2" \-1>1< 2" T E$&63 QRR^ < 5">38K -1 1="-121* ?68" M$"' 1h "- 150$%"&,3 2"12%6,65 -1 -"06,6%186K& 18,6>1 2" -3# ,$,35"#< ="53 2"&"015 "- 26>35863 --">1 1 $&1 #3-$86K& >18W1 2"




C- F3,6>3 =56%"53 "G1%6&1 -3# 150$%"&,3# 2" -1 #"&,"&861 5"8$55621* C- %3,6>3 #" ,6,$-1 HX"&,"&861

2" 1="-186K&' 150$%"&,3#* 456%"51 5O=-681 =35 6&J51886K& 2" -1# &35%1# #$#,1&,6>1# #3N5" 26>35863

f15,#* ^g A ^P VV h A 5"=5"#"&,186K& 2" -3# ,$,35"# f15,#* QgY< QYP A QYQ VV h A 2" -1 E$56#=5$2"&861

5"#="8,3 2"- 815L8,"5 ="5#3&1-W#6%3 2" -1 1886K& 2" 26>35863i =35 "- 81$8" 2"- 15,* :YY*Q< S A S @CV H*C& "- 2"#1553--3< 1&1-6/1 -1# 83&8-$#63&"# 2" -1 #"&,"&861 5"8$55621< M$" 5"8D1/1< 1=35,1&23 -1#

#$A1# =53=61#*

C- =56%"5 %3,6>3 &3 #" "#,6%1*

C- 5"8$55"&," #" 2"2681 1 5"#$%65 A 3=3&"5#" 1 -3# 150$%"&,3# 2" -1 #"&,"&861 5"8$55621< "& $&

%3,6>3 M$" 2"N"5W1 D1N"5#" =-1&,"123 1 ,51>O# 2"- 5"8$5#3 "G,513526&1563 =35 6&J51886K& =538"#1-<

A1 M$"< "& 2"J6&6,6>1< #" "#,L 8$"#,63&1&23 -1 %3,6>186K&* C& 2"J6&6,6>1< "& "#," =56%"5 %3,6>3 #"

"#,L 6&8$556"&23 "& "- >6863 81#1863&1- 83&#6#,"&," "& D18"5 #$=$"#,3 2" -1 8$"#,6K&< M$" 2","5%6&1

-1 2"#"#,6%186K& 2"- %3,6>3 "& "- M$" #" 6&8$55"*

ERLF9A* C&$&86123 2" -3# %3,6>3# #"0$&23 A ,"58"53* CG1%"& 83&E$&,3

F3,6>3 #"0$&23 * 7&J51886K& 2" -1 E$56#=5$2"&861 #3N5" "- 815L8,"5 ="5#3&1-W#6%3 2" -1 1886K& 2"

26>35863 "& 5"-186K& 83& -1# &35%1# #$#,1&,6>1# 2" 1=-68186K&< M$" 83&#62"51 #3& -3# +5,#* ^P< ^g<

QgY< QYP A QYQ VV ' &"8"#6212 2" 83&8$55"&861 2"- 6&,"5O# ,$,"-1N-" 2"- 6&81=1/* C- 6&,"5O#

81#1863&1- "#,L E$#,6J68123 =35 -1# #"&,"&861# 2"- _56N$&1- X$=5"%3 2" QY J"N5"53 Plll A Qg %1A3

Pl^Q * `1A M$" 1&1-6/15 "- 815L8,"5 ="5#3&1-W#6%3 2" -1 1886K& 2" 26>35863 M$" -1 #"&,"&861

5"8$55621 &6"01< 815L8,"5 2"- M$" #" 2"#=5"&2" -1 "G60"&861 2" $& 6&,"5O# ,$,"-1N-" "G8-$#6>1%"&,"

2"- 6&81=1/ "& "- "E"586863 2" -1 1886K& 2" 26>35863* C- 9&683 18,3 ="5#3&1-W#6%3 83%=151N-" 1 "#,1

1886K& "# "- %1,56%3&63< 8$A3 83&#"&,6%6"&,3 &3 =$"2" #"5 #$#,6,$623 =35 -3# ,$,35"#* ?"- +5,* QgY

VV #" 2"#=5"&2" M$" -1 %1A35 3 %"&35 "G,"&#6K& 2" -1# J18$-,12"# 5"=5"#"&,1,6>1#< &3 6&8-$A"& "-

"E"586863 2" -1# 18863&"# ="5#3&1-W#6%1#* ?68" M$" 2" -1 X_X 2" QY J"N5"53 Plll < #" 2"2$8" -1

"G60"&861 2" $& 6&,"5O# ,$,"-1N-" 2"- 6&81=1/ =151 M$" =53#="5" -1 1886K& 2" 26>35863 $&1 >"/

83&8$551& -3# 5"M$6#6,3# -"01-"#*

C- F3,6>3 ,"58"53< =5"#"&,1 $&1 $&6212 150$%"&,1- 83& "- #"0$&23< =35 -3 M$" #" >1 1 "G1%6&15

83&E$&,1%"&,"* ?"&$&861 -1 6&J51886K& 2" -1# &35%1# #$#,1&,6>1# 2" 1=-68186K& #3N5" "- 26>35863<

+5,#* ^P A ^g VV < 83& >60"&861 6&J"5635 1 86&83 1B3# A #6& 238,56&1 E$56#=5$2"&861- "#="8WJ681* @1

%326J68186K& 2"- VK2603 86>6-< 5"1-6/121 =35 %"263 2" -1 -"A PTbQRRT < &3 1$,356/1 1 -3# ,$,35"# =151

5"=5"#"&,15 1- ,$,"-123 "& "- "E"586863 2" -1 1886K& 2" 26>35863* +- #"5 "- 26>35863 =5L8,681%"&,"

1$,3%L,683< #" 2"N" 6&,"5=5",15 83& 81$,"-1 -1 &35%1 2" 1=-68186K& 2"- +5,* ^g VV < "& 5"-186K& 83& "-

+5,* ^P * 7&#6#," "& M$" #" 5"M$6"5" $& 6&,"5O# ,$,"-1N-" "G8-$#6>1%"&," "& N"&"J6863 2"- 6&81=1/ =151




M$" H"#,1 1886K& 2" 26>35863< D3A 1$,3%L,681< 2" 815L8,"5 ="5#3&1-W#6%3< =$"21 M$"215 "#,6%121 "&

8$1&,3 1- J3&23 2"- 1#$&,3)*

@3# %3,6>3# #"0$&23 A ,"58"53 &3 #" "#,6%1& *

SRM@9A* 4-1&,"1%6"&,3 83&#,6,$863&1- 2" -1 -"06,6%186K& =151 "E"586,15 -1 1886K& 2"- 26>35863 =35

-3# 5"=5"#"&,1&,"# -"01-"# 2"- 6&81=1/*

+ -3# "J"8,3# 2" -1 %3,6>186K& 2" -1 =5"#"&," #"&,"&861< 5"#$-,1 6&26#="&#1N-" "- "G1%"& 2" -1 X_V

SPPbQRRR< 2" P^ 2686"%N5" < 1-"0121 =35 -1# =15,"# 1 -3 -1503 2"- =5"#"&," =538"26%6"&,3 A "& "-

=53=63 5"8$5#3 2" 81#186K&*

@1 X_V SPPbQRRR #" =53&$&86K #3N5" "- 1E$#," 1 -1 V3&#,6,$86K& 2" -1# #"&,"&861# PRT A PRg< 2" QS

J"N5"53 Pll^< 268,121# =35 -1 +$26"&861 453>6&861- 2" +#,$561# < M$" D1NW1& &"0123 -"06,6%186K&

=151 "E"58"5 -1 1886K& 2" #"=15186K& 1 -1 %125" A ,$,351 2" $&1 ="5#3&1 6&81=186,121* C- _V 2"8626K

M$" 2"NW1 =53,"0"5#" "- 2"5"8D3 1 -1 ,$,"-1 E$26861- "J"8,6>1 2" -1 ="5#3&1 6&81=1/ A 2"8-15K M$" #"

D1NW1 -"#63&123 "#," 2"5"8D3 =35 -1 &"01,6>1 1 M$" -1 %125" ,$,351 =$26"51 "E"586,15 -1 1886K&* @1

X_V #" =-1&,"K< "& =56%"5 -$015< #6 83&8$55W1 3 &3 $& 6&,"5O# -"0W,6%3 M$" #" D1N5W1 6%="2623 =35 &3

D1N"5#" ="5%6,623 "- 188"#3 1 -1 ,$,"-1 E$26861- "J"8,6>1* C- 150$%"&,3 M$" $,6-6/K -1 #"&,"&861 2"

5"J"5"&861 2"8W1 M$" Hm***n-1 #"=15186K& %1,56%3&61- A -1 1886K& E$26861- M$" 83&#,6,$A" "- %"263 =151

3N,"&"5-1< >6"&"& 1 #1,6#J18"5 $& 6&,"5O# -"0W,6%3 2" 2"J"&#1 2" -3# 8K&A$0"# J5"&," 1 -1 #6,$186K& 2"

83&>6>"&861 %1,56%3&61-< 8$1&23 O#,1 -"# 5"#$-,1 ="5E$26861- m***n) < 6&,"5O# M$" =$"2" 5"#6265 N6"& "&

$&1 #6,$186K& 2" ="-6053 JW#683< N6"& "& $&1 #6,$186K& H=1,56%3&61- "& #$=$"#,3# JL86-%"&,"

5"83&2$86N-"# 1- 6&8$%=-6%6"&,3 2" "#,3# 2"N"5"#) * c"015 -"06,6%186K& 1- ,$,35 H2","5%6&1 2"

%323 6&"G351N-" "- 86"55"< 2"#=53=35863&123 =35 #$ 560356#%3< 2"- 188"#3 2"- 6&,"5O# -"0W,6%3 2"

O#,1 1 -1 ,$,"-1 E$26861-< #6 #" 12>6"5," M$"< =56>123 "- 6&81=186,123 83& 815L8,"5 0"&"51-< 2"- =3#6N-"

"E"586863 2" 18863&"#m***n< "- "E"586863 2" -1 #"=15186K& #3-3 =$"2" >"56J6815#" =35 %"263 2" #$ ,$,35<

83& -3 M$" #6 1 O#," #" -" &6"01 -1 -"06,6%186K& =151 "--3< 268D3 86"55" 1N#3-$,3 "# #$ 6&"-$26N-"

83&#"8$"&861m***nH* C- 86"55" 2" -1 =3#6N6-6212 2" "E"586863 2" -1 1886K& 2" #"=15186K& "& 1M$"- 81#3<Hm***n&3 8$%=-" -1# "G60"&861# 2" 51/3&1N6-6212 &6 2" =53=35863&1-6212 5"#="8,3 2" &6&09& J6&

26#8"5&6N-" "& "- 5O06%"& 2" -1 ,$,"-1) < =35 -3 M$" Hm***n 2"#"%N381 "& $&1 6&18"=,1N-" #6,$186K& 2"

2"#60$1-212 2" -3# "#=3#3# "& -1 2"J"&#1 2" #$# 6&,"5"#"# =1,56%3&61-"#< A1 M$" &3 5"#=3&2" 1

&6&09& J$&21%"&,3 3NE",6>3 A 51/3&1N-" M$" =$"21 E$#,6J6815 $&1 26J"5"&861 2" ,51,3 2" ,1-

&1,$51-"/1< %LG6%" #6 #" 1,6"&2" 1 -3# %1&21,3# M$" #" 2"56>1& 2"- 15,* :l VC "& 8$1&,3 1-

,51,1%6"&,3 2" -3# 6&81=18"# A 2"- 15,* SQ*P VC "& 8$1&,3 1 -1 =3#686K& 2" 60$1-212 2" 1%N3#

8K&A$0"# "& "- %1,56%3&63) *




C- >3,3 =15,68$-15 83&8$55"&," 2"- =53=63 =3&"&," >1 %L# 1--L< "& 8$1&,3 M$" #$="51 "& #$

150$%"&,186K&< -1 ,5126863&1- 26#,6&86K& "&,5" 2"5"8D3# ="5#3&1-"# A 2"5"8D3# ="5#3&1-W#6%3#< M$"

#3-3 =325W1& #"5 "E"586,123# =35 "- ,6,$-15 A &$&81 =35 #$ 5"=5"#"&,1&," -"01-* +#W 1J65%1N1 M$"

&"015 1- ,$,35 -1 -"06,6%186K& =151 "- "E"586863 2" -1 1886K& 2" #"=15186K& H&3 #" N1#1 "& $& =5"8"=,3-"01- 6&"M$W>383< #6&3 %L# N6"& "& $& 83&8"=,3 238,56&1- 2" 18863&"# ="5#3&1-W#6%1#< M$" "# "- M$"

#$NA18" "& -1 6&,"5=5",186K& 2"- 15,* ^P VV ) *

C#,1 X_V "# J$&21%"&,1- =151 -1 5"#3-$86K& 2"- =5"#"&," 5"8$5#3< #6 N6"& O#," #" 5"J6"5" 1 -1 1886K&

2" 26>35863 =-1&,"121 =35 -3# =125"#b,$,35"#< #$=$"#,3 M$" 815"8" 2" 5"0$-186K& "& -1 -"06#-186K&

"#=1B3-1 18,$1-%"&," "& >6035 A M$" 3J5"8" 1-0$&3# =53N-"%1# =53=63#< 26J"5"&,"# 1 -3# =-1&,"123#

"& -1 X_V SPPbQRRR < "#="861-%"&," 6%=35,1&,"# 1 51W/ 2" -1 %326J68186K& 2"- 26>35863< "J"8,$123

=35 -1 -"A PSbQRRT * @1 X_V SPPbQRRR< 2" P^ 2686"%N5" =-1&,"1 "G18,1%"&," "- =53N-"%1< 1- 8"&,515-1 8$"#,6K& "& "- 6&,"5O# 2"- 6&81=186,123 fU.:h< ="53 #" 5"J6"5" 1- 6&,"5O# "& -1 #"=15186K& "& $&

%3%"&,3 "& M$" "- VK2603 86>6- "G60W1 -1 1-"0186K& 2" 81$#1# A #3-3 #"5W1 1=-681N-" =-"&1%"&," "& -1

#"=15186K& 18,$1-< =35M$" #$ "#,5$8,$51 2"#=$O# 2" -1 5"J35%1 "# %$A #6%6-15* 435 ,1&,3< &3 =$"2"

#3-$863&15#" "- =5"#"&," 5"8$5#3 83& -1 #6%=-" 5"J"5"&861 1 -1 X_V "G1%6&121< #6&3 M$" 2"N"

"#,$2615#" #6 "- 26>35863< M$" 83%=35,1 -1 26#3-$86K& 2"- %1,56%3&63 1 26J"5"&861 2" -1 #"=15186K&<

=$"2" #"5 "E"586,123 =35 "- ,$,35 "& $&1 1886K& =-1&,"121 "& &3%N5" A 5"=5"#"&,186K& 2"- 8K&A$0"

6&81=186,123*

8KU9A* C- "E"586863 2" -3# 2"5"8D3# J$&21%"&,1-"# 8$A3 "- ,6,$-15 "#,L 6&81=186,123*

C& "- =5"#"&," #$=$"#,3 A #6"%=5" M$" #" ,51," 2" -1 1886K& 2" #"=15186K& 3 26>35863 "E"586,121 =35

-3# ,$,35"# "& &3%N5" " 6&,"5O# 2" $&1 ="5#3&1 6&81=186,121< "#,L& =5"#"&,"# 23# 2"5"8D3#

J$&21%"&,1-"#'

Pa C- 2"5"8D3 J$&21%"&,1- 1 -1 -6N"5,12 2" 83&,6&$15 3 &3 81#123* C- 26>35863 18,$1- &3 5"M$6"5"

1-"0186K& 2" 81$#1 8$1&23 -3 "E"586,1 ="5#3&1-%"&," "- 6&,"5"#123< M$6"& &3 ,6"&" M$" E$#,6J6815 #$#

%3,6>3#< =35M$" 2" "#,1 %1&"51< "- 352"&1%6"&,3 =53,"0" "- 2"5"8D3 1 -1 6&,6%6212 2"- 8K&A$0"=",6863&1563 2"- 26>35863* + "--3 3N"2"8" -1 5"0$-186K& =$"#,1 "& >6035 =35 -1 -"A PSbQRRT < 1- &3

"G6065 -1 1-"0186K& 2" 81$#1#*

Qa C- 2"5"8D3 1 -1 ,$,"-1 E$26861- "J"8,6>1 ="5%6," "E"58"5 -1# 18863&"# 8$A1 ,6,$-156212 8355"#=3&2"

1- 6&81=186,123 =35 %"263 2"- 5"=5"#"&,1&," -"01-< ,1- 83%3 "#,1N-"8" "- 15,* QYP<g VV < M$" 1,56N$A"

1 -3# ,$,35"# -1 -"06,6%186K& H=151 "&,1N-15 2"%1&21 "& &3%N5" 2" -3# #$E",3# 1 ,$,"-1)< #6"%=5"

83& 1$,356/186K& E$26861-< M$" &3 #" 5"M$"565L H"& -3# 1#$&,3# $50"&,"# 3 2" "#81#1 8$1&,W1)* C#,1

&35%1 &3 26#,6&0$" -1 &1,$51-"/1 2" -1 1886K& M$" #" "#,L "E"586"&23 "& &3%N5" 2" -1 ="5#3&16&81=186,121< A 1#W "#,L& ,1%N6O& 6&8-$621# "& "- 15,* QYP<g VV -1# 18863&"# =151 ="265 "- 26>35863 A -1




#"=15186K&* @1 ,$,"-1 E$26861- "J"8,6>1 M$"21 =53,"0621 =35 "#," %"263 A -1 ,5126863&1- ,"35W1

1812O%681 18"581 2" -3# 2"5"8D3# ="5#3&1-W#6%3# &3 =$"2" 1=-6815#"*

8VD9MPA* 45"8"2"&,"#*

@1 =3#6N6-6212 2" M$" "- ,$,35 2" $&1 ="5#3&1 6&81=186,121 81#121 =$"21 3 &3 "E"58"5 -1 1886K& 2"

26>35863 ,6"&" =383# =5"8"2"&,"# "& -3# 352"&1%6"&,3# 2" &$"#,53 "&,35&3* + "--3 83&,56N$A"& 23#

83&26863&1%6"&,3#' 6h -1 ,$,"-1 ,6"&" 1#="8,3# %$A 26#,6&,3# "& "#,3# 352"&1%6"&,3#< 1 ="#15 2"

"#,15 83&#,5$621 "& ,323# "--3# 83%3 #6#,"%1 2" =53,"886K& 2" 26#81=186,123# " 6&81=18"#< A 66h "-

26>35863 ,6"&" $&1 5"0$-186K& &3 $&6J35%" "& "#,3# 352"&1%6"&,3#*

Pa C- VK2603 86>6- J51&8O# &3 12%6," "- "E"586863 2" -1 1886K& 2" 26>35863 =35 83&#"&,6%6"&,3 %$,$3

=35 "- 5"=5"#"&,1&," 2" %1A35"# 2" "212 =53,"0623#< #"1 8$1- #"1 "- 5O06%"& 2" =53,"886K& 1 M$"

"#,O& #$E",3# f15,* Q:le: hi "& 81%N63< #W 12%6," -1 1886K& "& &3%N5" 2"- 8K&A$0" #3%",623 1 ,$,"-1

"& -3# 81#3# 2" 26>35863 83&,"&863#3 f+5,* Q:l h* C- ,$,35 =$"2" "E"586,15-1 #3-3 #6 D1 3N,"&623 -1

1$,356/186K& 2"- 83&#"E3 2" J1%6-61< =5">63 "- 6&J35%" 2"- %O2683* +#6%6#%3< "- +5,* Q:leP "#,1N-"8"

M$" -1 1886K& #" "E"58"5L 83&,51 "- ,$,35 #6 "- 8K&A$0" 83&,51 "- M$" #" =5"#"&,1 -1 2"%1&21< "#,L

#3%",623 1 ,$,"-1*

Qa C& +-"%1&61< "- o ^<& P 2" -1 U1%6-6"&>"5J1D5"&#0"#",/ f-"A 2" =538"26%6"&,3# 2" ?"5"8D3 2"

J1%6-61h< "#,1N-"8" M$" $&1 ="5#3&1 6&81=1/ =$"2" #"5 =15," "& -3# =538"26%6"&,3# %1,56%3&61-"#<

="53 -1# ="5#3&1# M$" 5"=5"#"&,1& 1 268D1 =15," 2" 18$"523 83& -1# 26#=3#6863&"# 2" 2"5"8D3 86>6-

2"N" 18,$15 83%3 =15," fol fQ h U4+h< 2" ,1- %1&"51 M$" #6 -1 ="5#3&1 "# %"&,1-%"&," 6&81=1/<

2"N" 18,$15 "- 5"=5"#"&,1&,"< M$6"& 2"N" #"5 1$,356/123 =35 "- .$/0123 3 "- _56N$&1- 2" J1%6-61 3 "-

_56N$&1- 2" ,$,"-1# foPQT fQh U4+h*

Sa C& 7,1-61< #6& "%N1503< &3 D1A =5">6#6K& #3N5" "#,1 =3#6N6-6212*

:a @1 @"A "#=1B3-1 2" 26>35863< 2" PlSQ 12%6,6K M$" -3# ,$,35"# =$26"51& "E"586,15 "#,1 1886K& "& #$

15,* :R < M$" 2"8W1 M$" H=35 -3# 6&81=186,123#< 1 ,"&35 2"- +5,* QPS VV < =325L ="265 -1 #"=15186K& #$

,$,35< 83& 1$,356/186K& 2"- V3&#"E3 2" J1%6-61)* c3 #" "#="86J681N1 &121 "& 5"-186K& 1- 26>35863< ="53

"- +5,* :^ "G60W1 -1 6&,"5>"&86K& 2"- F6&6#,"563 U6#81- "& "#,3# =538"26%6"&,3# 8$1&23 "G6#,6"51&

H%"&35"#< 1$#"&,"# 3 6&81=18"#)*

@1 V3&>"&86K& #3N5" -3# 2"5"8D3# 2" -1# ="5#3&1# 83& 26#81=186212< D"8D1 "& c$">1 d35p "- PS 2"

2686"%N5" 2" QRRg< 51,6J68121 =35 C#=1B1 "& QRR^< "#,1N-"8" "& "- 15, PQ*S< M$" HS * @3# C#,123#

415,"# 123=,15L& -1# %"2621# ="5,6&"&,"# =151 =53=35863&15 188"#3 1 -1# ="5#3&1# 83&

26#81=186212 1- 1=3A3 M$" =$"21& &"8"#6,15 "& "- "E"586863 2" #$ 81=186212 E$5W2681) A 1




83&,6&$186K&< "& "- 15,* +5,W8$-3 PS< #" 268" M$" HP * @3# C#,123# 415,"# 1#"0$515L& M$" -1# ="5#3&1#

83& 26#81=186212 ,"&01& 188"#3 1 -1 E$#,6861 "& 60$1-212 2" 83&26863&"# 83& -1# 2"%L#< m***nH*

C#,3# =56&86=63# 2"N"& #"5 ,"&623# "& 8$"&,1 "& -1 5"#3-$86K& M$" #" 2"%1&21< =35M$" -1

51,6J68186K& 2"- V3&>"&63 2" c$">1 d35p A #$ 83&#60$6"&," 6&835=35186K& 1- 352"&1%6"&,3 "#=1B3-<

3N-601 1 -3# _56N$&1-"# 1 1=-6815 -3# =56&86=63# M$" 83&,6"&" A J186-6,15 -1 18,$186K& 2"- 6&81=1/ 1

,51>O# 3 =35 %"263 2" #$# 5"=5"#"&,1&,"# -"01-"#* X6 &3 #" 12%6,6"#" 268D1 18,$186K&< "& "- 81#3 2" -1

1886K& 2" 26>35863 #" "#,15W1 5"#,56&06"&23 #$ "E"586863 A >$-&"51&23 "- 2"5"8D3 1 -1 ,$,"-1 E$26861-

"J"8,6>1< 83& "- 5"#$-,123 M$" "- %1,56%3&63 #" 83&>"5,65W1 2" D"8D3 "& 6&26#3-$N-" "& 1M$"--3#

81#3# "& M$" -1 3,51 =15,"< -1 81=1/< &3 M$6#6"51 2"%1&215-3*

AE9LBA7 !' -"#$%$&'($)* ," -./ %0%.1"/7

!'/ '*%"1$.1"/ 1'W.*"/ --"4'* ' (.*(-0$1 X0" -./ %0%.1"/ "/%Y* -"#$%$&',./ 2'1' "3"1($%'1 -''(($)* ," ,$4.1($. "* *.&51" ," 0*' 2"1/.*' $*('2'($%','C /$"&21" X0" 2.1 /0/

(.*,$($.*"/C *. 20",' '(%0'1 2.1 /Z &$/&'7 K/%' /.-0($)* *. "/ "[%1'4'#'*%" "* "-

.1,"*'&$"*%. "/2'\.-C ]' X0" "- E),$#. ($4$- -"#$%$&' '- P$*$/%"1$. T$/('- ] ^' (0'-X0$"1

2"1/.*' X0" %"*#' $*%"1_/ ,$1"(%. ] -"#Z%$&.` "* -' '(($)* 2'1' 2",$1 -' ,"(-'1'($)* ,"

*0-$,', ," 0* ,"%"1&$*',. &'%1$&.*$. a'1%7 bG EE cC '/Z (.&. ' 2',1"/C %0%.1"/C

#0'1,',.1"/ ] P$*$/%"1$. T$/('- (0'*,. -' '(($)* %"*#' 2.1 .53"%. 2",$1 -' *0-$,', ," 0*

&'%1$&.*$. 2.1 d'-%' ," ",', a'1%7 b< EE c7

!' 1"21"/"*%'($)* -"#'- ,"- %0%.1 -" $&2.*" "- ,"5"1 ," $*#"1"*($' "* -' "/d"1' 301Z,$(' ,"-

$*('2'W (0'*,. /"' *"("/'1$. 2'1' .5%"*"1 /0 21.%"(($)*C /$ 5$"* *. -$51"&"*%"C /$*. (.* -'/

-$&$%'($.*"/ X0" ,"1$4'* ," -' *'%01'-"W' ," d0*($)* X0" %$"*" -' %0%"-' ] 2.1 "--. "- "3"1($($.

," -' '(($)* ," ,$4.1($. 2.1 2'1%" ," -./ %0%.1"/ ,"5" 1"/2.*,"1 ' -'/ &$/&'/ 1"#-'/ X0"

1$#"* -' 1"21"/"*%'($)* -"#'- 2.1 -'/ /$#0$"*%"/ 1'W.*"/7

?e N"5" '2-$('1/" -. ,$/20"/%. "* "- '1%7 ;?:7? EE C X0" "/ -' *.1&' #"*"1'- X0" 1$#"C "*

(0'-X0$"1 ('/.C -' '(%0'($)* ," -./ %0%.1"/C 2.1X0" ^-'/ d0*($.*"/ %0%"-'1"/ (.*/%$%0]"* 0*

,"5"1C /" "3"1("1Y* "* 5"*"d$($. ,"- %0%"-',. ] "/%'1Y* 5'3. -' /'-4'#0'1,' ," -' '0%.1$,',

30,$($'-`7 D.1 "--.C "- '1%7 ;b? EE "[$#" '0%.1$W'($)* 30,$($'- 2'1' "*%'5-'1 (0'-X0$"1 %$2. ,"

,"&'*,'7

;e K* /"#0*,. -0#'1C "- "3"1($($. ," "/%' '(($)* ,"5" .5","("1 ' -./ $*%"1"/"/ ,"- $*('2'WC 2.1

-. X0" ,"5" 30/%$d$('1/" X0" -' '(%0'($)* /" --"4' ' ('5. "* $*%"1_/ ,"- $*('2'WC %'- (.&.

(.*(-0])C "* 0*' -"#$/-'($)* ,$/%$*%'C -' 89E f??=;>>> 7

fe O'] X0" %"*"1 "* (0"*%' X0" "* -./ 21.(",$&$"*%./ ," ,"1"(6. ," d'&$-$' "* -./ X0" /.*

2'1%" &"*.1"/ " $*('2'("/ /" 1"X0$"1" -' '(%0'($)* ,"- P$*$/%"1$. T$/('-C X0" ,"5"1Y 4"-'1

2.1 /0/ $*%"1"/"/C (.* -. X0" /" #'1'*%$W' X0" -'/ '(($.*"/ ," -./ %0%.1"/ *. /"'* ('21$(6./'/

. '15$%1'1$'/7



Supuesto práctico GPA Promoción interna 2011 Blog de Justicia de Adams

c3 #" 83&#62"51 =538"2"&," 6%=3&"5 -1# 83#,1# 1 -1 =15," 5"8$55"&,"< "& >65,$2 2" -3 26#=$"#,3 "& "-

15,* Sl: @CV< "& 5"-186K& 83& "- Sl^ @CV< 2123 M$" "- 1#$&,3 =5"#"&,1 #"561# 2$21# 2" ?"5"8D3<

83%3 #" 2"#=5"&2" 2" -3 51/3&123 1- "G1%6&15 -3# %3,6>3# 2"- 5"8$5#3 2" 81#186K&*

435 -3 "G=$"#,3< "& &3%N5" 2"- !"A A =35 -1 1$,356212 83&J"5621 =35 "- =$"N-3 "#=1B3-*

TL!!LPA8

Pa X" 2"#"#,6%1 "- 5"8$5#3 2" 81#186K& J35%$-123 =35 -1 5"=5"#"&,186K& =538"#1- 2" ? F1G6%6&3

83&,51 -1 X"&,"&861 2" -1 +$26"&861 453>6&861- 2" \-1>1< X"886K& P]< 2" T E$&63 QRR^< "& "- 53--3 2"

1="-186K& &a SPbR^ *

Qa c3 D1 -$015 1 81#15 -1 #"&,"&861 5"8$55621 =35 -3# %3,6>3# J35%$-123#< M$" 5"#$-,1 83&J65%121

83& "#," 1-81&8"*

Sa c3 D1 -$015 1 -1 6%=3#686K& 2" -1# 83#,1# 2" "#," 5"8$5#3 2" 81#186K&*

@WN5"#" 1 -1 %"&863&121 +$26"&861 -1 8"5,6J68186K& 8355"#=3&26"&,"< 83& 2">3-$86K& 2" -3# 1$,3# A

53--3 2" 1="-186K& 5"%6,623#*

+#W =35 "#,1 &$"#,51 #"&,"&861< M$" #" 6&#"5,15L "& -1 VZ@CVV7qc @Cj7X@+_7;+ =1#L&23#" 1- "J"8,3

-1# 83=61# &"8"#1561#< -3 =53&$&861%3#< %1&21%3# A J65%1%3#

Supuesto Gestión Procesal Pi 2011

Documents

Transcript of Supuesto Gestión Procesal Pi 2011