Fallo JNE Ollanta

7/25/2019 Fallo JNE Ollanta

1/18

Jurado Nacional de EleccionesResolucin N. 0057-2016-JNE

Expediente N. J-2016-00032LIMA - LIMA - LIMAJEE LIMA CENTRO 1 (EXPEDIENTE N. 00239-2015-032)ELECCIONES GENERALES 2016RECURSO DE APELACIN

L!"# $%&'* +% %&%, +% + ! +%/

VISTO# %& "+%&" " +% " 4%*"# % ,%, +% "%"& &'%,%' , C",E&,% C"$"%&'% C*"!,,# ,,"+, +% " P,%+%&" +% C&%7 +%M&',# %& &'," +% " R%& N. 001-2015-JEE-LC18JNE# +% 31 +% +%!,% +%

2015# %!'+" , % J,"+ E%'," E%" +% L!" C%&', 1# %& % %',%! %,%$ &%, %& &!%&' +% P%& +% J,"+ N"&" +% E%&% " &4,"&" ,& +% &%',"+"+ !%'+" , % %:, O"&'" M/ ;!"" T"#P,%+%&'% +% " R%" +% P%,# %& % !", +% " E%&% G%&%,"% < +%R%,%%&'"&'% P%,"& "&'% % P","!%&' A&+& 2016.

ANTECEDENTES

Sobre el inor!e de l" Dire##i$n N"#ion"l de %i"li'"#i$n ( )ro#e&o& Ele#tor"le&

A ',"$/ +% I&4,!% N. 0=>-2015-LCM-C?-JEE LIMAC18JNE-EG2016# +% 12 +% +%!,%+% 2015 (47" 3 " 2=# &+ "&%)# % ,+&"+, +% 4"@"& +% J,"+

E%'," E%" +% L!" C%&', 1 (%& "+%"&'% JEE) !& " P%& +% %'% ,"&%%'," " ,%&'" &4,"& " ,& +% &%',"+"+ %& % *",B" &,,+ % %:,O"&'" M/ ;!"" T"# P,%+%&'% +% " R%" +% P%,# %& % !", +% "E%&% G%&%,"% < +% R%,%%&'"&'% P%,"& "&'% % P","!%&' A&+& 2016.

E& +* &4,!%# % +%,%& ',%% ",*$ ,%""+ +% +'&' !%+ +%!&"& +% ""&% &"&"# " ',"$/ +% "% % +4&+%,& !%&'", =

A%,' ?7!, ! H"+,& +% !","!"


3/18


%&'+"+% ! % J,"+ N"&" +%E%&% ","&'@"& " &%',"+"+ %%',"< % &,!" ,% % % +%% %$", "".A!!# % ,"'4 %& +%","&% # N. 5# N. =# N. < N. 9# "',"$/ +% " % ,'" % %,& +% %,%+%&'% A%,' ?7!,# " %& "4"! H"+,& +% !"," !"


6/18


L" ,%4%,+" +%& 4% "+" '"&' %& % ,'" %%',& &''&" +% J,"+N"&" +% E%&% ! %& % "&% &'""+ %& % 4,&' +% JEE % 5 +% %&%, +%2016# & %!",# & % ,"' " &'4"& %,&" " ,%&' &4,"',.

*e&pe#to del re#r&o de "pel"#i$n

E& "'%&& " %# & 4%*" 12 +% %&%, +% 2016# C", E&,% C"$"%&'% C*"!,,#,,"+, +% " P,%+%&" +% C&%7 +% M&',# &'%, ,%, +%"%"& " 4& +% % % +%7% & %4%' " ,%& % +%'%,!& % % P,%+%&'% +% "R%" &4,& % +%%, +% &%',"+"+ %& %,+ %%',". D* ,%, % 4&+"!%&'"%& %&'%

". L" +%","&% +% P,%+%&'% +% " R%" H& &''# %+% %, $""+ , % L%"'$ , " ""+% &""+"+ !,"# +% "%,+ & ",'B 113# &!%," 2.

+. A+%!# %& ""& +% ,& +% ,"@&"+"+# '"!/& % %&%&'," &$%'+ +% "","&'B" ',"+" " &,%'" +% " R%" , % ",'B 93 +% " N,!"?&+"!%&'"# %& % " & & ,%&"% "&'% "',+"+ & ,"& 7,+&"

"& , " &&% < $' % %!'"& %& % %7%, +% 4&&%. E&&%%&"# %& " !%++" %& % @" +% " ! "'" 7%,",B"# %,B" &+%+&'%,,%'", % %+% %, 7%' +% "%, ""& +% &'%&+ & %&".

%. E& "&' " " 4"'" +% ,%"& %" ,%"!%&'","# &4,!% " ",'B 3># &!%,"3>.3# +% R%"!%&' +% P,""&+" E%',"# P+"+ E'"'" < N%',"+"+ %&P%,+ E%',"# ","+ , R%& N. 30>-2015-JNE# +% 21 +% ',% +% 2015#% JEE % !%'%&'% "," ",, ,%+!%&' "&&"+, , &4,&, % +%%, +%&%',"+"+ %& &'," +% "% 4&&", % '"& ! "&++"'# , %&+%#& % "" " P,%+%&'% +% " R%" ,% %& % ,%%&'% ,% %%'," & %"&++"' & " " ,%%%& & " "& ', ", +% %%& ",.

4. R%%' " " "4%'"& +% +%,%* +% +%4%&"# ,%" % & % *" &'4"+ ",%&' &4,"', & &&& +% "' < +!%&' % '%&'"& " +% "

6


7/18


%", +% % % % +%"," &4,"',# +% !+ % "," ,,", "'"+ 4%&%%", ,%,,, " !%+ +% !&" "B ! " %%+%&'% $,'" "+%& % ,'" %%',& &''&" +% J,"+ N"&" +% E%&%. A+%!# & %% *" "4%'"+ +%,%* " +%+ ,%# " " +%4%&"# " %, &4,!"+ +% "!'" " " &%& < " '%! "+%"+ "," ,%",", +%4%&" < +%,%* ",%,,, % 4".

. ?&"!%&'%# %& "&' " " 4"'" +% !'$" '%&% %# +% " &%$% &" %&4,!"& " ,% 4&+"!%&' %&'," % %&%&',"# "%&"# %& " '"$". E!# "4,!" % % H"'"!%&'% ",K %& %:"", % " +%","&% +%P,%+%&'% +% " R%" "4%'"& " "&++"'," +% ",'+ B' ?%,@" P",#H&4,!% *" %:""+ " +%,%" +% ?%,@" P",K# +% !+ % % JEE H% *""+"+ !%'%&" "," +%",", % +%,%* < ",%", *%* +% "7%' " &!%&'K. A!!# ,%%' " ', "&++"'# % JEE !%&&" % &%,+" & " && +% 4"@"+,# % % & 4&&", %& 4,!" ",'% +% ,"& 7,+&"# & %,%", " ,"@&% +% +*" &+%&".E %$+%&" " "%&" +% !'$"& %& " ,%& % % !&".

CONSIDE*ANDOS

El prin#ipio de netr"lid"d e&t"t"l ( lo& pro#e&o& ele#tor"le&

1. E ",'B 31 +% " C&''& PB'" +% 1993# % ,%&% % +%,%* +%",'"& B'" ! +%,%* 4&+"!%&'"# +&% %&'%

7" le( e&t"ble#e lo& !e#"ni&!o& p"r" 8"r"nti'"r l" netr"lid"de&t"t"l dr"nte lo& pro#e&o& ele#tor"le& < +% ",'"&+"+"&". E & < &% '+ "' % ,*B" !'% "+"+"& % %7%, +% +%,%* (/&4" ",%"+).

P, ",'%# % ",'B >5 +% +* % &,!"'$# ,%4%,+ " %7%, +% +%,+% E'"+# %:"" %

E +%, +% E'"+ %!"&" +% %. %&% %7%,%& *"%& & " !'"&% < ,%&"+"+% % " C&''&< " %


8/18


,% %%',"% , +% &" +%!,"" % % ,%" +% %, & ",+" & +%",, %,% %& &%'," C&''& PB'" +% 1993# & % %%B'! < &''&" % ""&%# B!'% < ,%&"+"+% , $&%,"& %"& %'"%+ , % %"+, " ',"$/ +% " %. A*," % %'% ,& &''&" % !&% & +%%, " '+" "',+"+#4&&", %,$+, +% E'"+# "," % %& % %7%, +% 4&&% & &'%,4%,"& % &,!" +%%&$$!%&' +% & ,% %%'," +% ",'"& B'"# *"+ +%",,"+ , % %"+,# %&',% ',# %& ",'B 3>6# 3>=# 361 < 362 +%" LOE.

5. C& ,%"& " ,& +% &%',"+"+ %,%"+ ! % +%%, +% % " "',+"+B'" " & ,"'% %& %&%," &&& "' % 4"$,%@" %,7+% " &",'+ "&++"' %& ",'",# " LOE %:"" +% !"&%," %,%"

Art9#lo 36.-E' ,*+ " '+" "',+"+ B'" "

". I&'%,$%&, %& % "' %%'," "," "'",# !%+, %,',"," %,'"+ +% 4,"# '@"&+ " &4%&" +% ", +% !%+ +% % %'/& ,$'" ,%",'&%.

b. )r"#ti#"r "#to& de #"l:ier n"tr"le'" :e ";ore'#"n oper


9/18


=. E !,'"&'% ,%"'", % %'" "',& +% " 7,+& %%'," +% "$"",+",% ,% %%',"% % +%%&$%$"& & " &'%,4%,%&" %& %&%," +% 4&&", < %,$+,% +% E'"+ +% " C&'' < , !%+, ,%&& 4&&"!%&'# +% J,"+ N"&" +% E%&% < ', ,"&! +% '%!"%%',".

11. D% %'" &,!"# % +%,%&+% % % P,%+%&'% +% " R%"# , %, % ,!%,4&&", +% " N" %' %# , " !,'"&" +% &$%'+,"# @" +%

&!&+"+# ", %' % '" ,'%& & % "'"# % % C&''


10/18


&,!" 4&&"!%&' +% &%'," +%!,""# %& '"&' 4,!" +% %,& "+'"+", " C&''& PB'" +% 1993. D*" %%&% & & '," % "*"'"& &''&" "," %, ""+ , "' +% !" ,"$%+"+ H!%+," %%&% ,%+%&"%# ","!%&'","# ,%&"% !&"%K# "B !, H!%+, " ,%&& 4&&"!%&' +% J,"+ N"&" +% E%&% < +% ', ,"&! +% '%!" %%',"K.

12. E' &4" % " ,'%& &!&+"+ % ,%$/ " C&''& PB'" +% 1993%' ,%4%,+" " % % P,%+%&'% & %+% %, ""+ , "%, *%* +,"&'% %,+ +% %, , "&' % "! % %& % %7%, +% 4&&% "'"%& %&%4 +% " N" % +%,# +% %& !&. E&'&%# " 4& +% %$'",',&% " %7%, ,%", +% " "',&% &''&"% % % '," "C&''& PB'" +% 1993# %'" % ,%&% &!&+"+ +,"&'% !"&+"'# " " +, %, &""% , %%& +% " ""% ,"$% %:""+".

13. AB# " &!&+"+ % @" % P,%+%&'% +% " R%" " %&%,", & '4,%&'% " %,'" ,%'%&&% +% '%,%,# " 4& +% ,'%%, "," % & %" &,%"+, %,'" "&% % % ,%&%& %B'!". E'# '+" $%@ % " C&''&PB'" +% 1993 "!% % " "'"& +% P,%+%&'%# %& %7%, +% "',&%# ,%&+% " &" ,,+"+ "," " %,&"+"+ +% "B.

1>. P, %'" ,"@ " &!&+"+ ,%+%&" +,"&'% % %7%, +% !"&+"' !+%

% % P,%+%&'% %" ""+# , ,%" %&%,"# , "%, *%*# "$ %:""+ %& 4,!" %,%" %& % ",'B 11= +% " C&''& PB'" +% 1993.E&',% %" %%&%


11/18


%+% ++" +% " 4%,@" $&"&'% +% ,& &'%&+ %& " C&''&PB'" +% 1993# % +*" ,%&"+"+ %+% %, &$%'"+" & ,%"& " "$&%,"& +% " &%',"+"+ %'"'"# & %, "+!% "%", " %%&%%'"%+" %& % ",'B 11=.

1. E'% ,'%, % %%' , "&' " ',",%& +% ,& +% &%',"+"+ %'"'"%& % !", +% ,% %%',"% % %% " C&''& PB'" +% 1993# , ,"$%+"+# %& & !!%&' +%'%,!&"+# %+% &4", % % ,% %%',",%+%&"# ","!%&'",# ,%&" !&" %& !",*"# , &'%,4%,%&" +,%'" &+,%'" +% P,%+%&'% +% " R%"# & ",+% " ","'%,B'" %% ","% " $'"&% ',"+@"& " %,%& "'/&'"# ,% < %&'&%" +% +"+"&.

19. AB# "&+ % C&''


12/18


"',+"+# " /& % !%'% "", < "&&",# +% %, % "# +,"&'% %%7%, +% !"&+"'.

Co!peten#i" del Jr"do N"#ion"l de Ele##ione& p"r" deter!in"r n" inr"##i$n delprin#ipio de netr"lid"d e&t"t"l por p"rte del )re&idente de l" *ep=bli#"

23. C& ,%"& " " %&'+"+ +% E'"+ " " % !%'% +%'%,!&", &" $&%,"& +%" &,!"'$" %%'," %& %&%," < " ,& +% &%',"+"+ E'"'" %& ",'",# "C&''& PB'" +% 1993# %& ",'B 1=# +&% %&'%

A,'B 1=.- C!%'% " J,"+ N"&" +% E%&%

1. %i"li'"r l" le8"lid"d del e. Ad!ini&tr"r


13/18


+% P,%+%&'% +% " R%" ,,%&+% " J,"+ N"&" +% E%&%# li&i& de #"&o #on#reto

30. P,%$ " & "& +% 4&+ +% " &+'" , " "% % % "" " P,%+%&'%+% " R%" +% *"%, $&%,"+ % ,& +% &%',"+"+# ,,%&+% *"%, &"$","& ,%%' " % ,%+!%&' %+ %& &'," *" ,%%'"+ % ,%%$"&'%,& +% +%+ ,%# %& %,%& +% +%,%* +% +%4%&"# %& '"&' %,%,,%&'% "%" % % JEE %& &&& !!%&' ,, ',""+ +% *%* , % % % *" *""+ ,%&"%.

13


14/18


31. A ,%%'# % $%,4" % %& &&& !!%&' % JEE ,, ',""+ +% &4,!% +%4"@"& % + ,%& " ,%+!%&' "&&"+, %+ &'," O"&'" M/;!"" T"# P,%+%&'% +% " R%"# < % '"! ',""+ ,%"+ % '%&'",&


15/18


%'&"+". E& %" !%++"# % "& +% JEE# !!% % ',"'" +% &" "',+"+,'%+" , &!&+"+ " &$% &''&"# &'", & ,%"+ +&% ","+%'%,!&", &" % &4,"& " ,& +% &%',"+"+.

36. E' $ +%'%'"+ *"& +% &%, % % P%& +% J,"+ N"&" +% E%&%+%",% " &+"+ +% " ,%,,+" < ,+%&% +%$$%, "'"+ "," % % JEE,%&%$% "'# & !!%&' +% ",!%', "B %%'# " 4& +% %+%'%,!&% %& 4,!" 4%&'% % P,%+%&'% +% " R%" *" $&%,"+ % ,&+% &%',"+"+ %'"'".

P, '"&'# % P%& +% J,"+ N"&" +% E%&%# %& +% "',&%# &% 4&+"!%&' "+&" +% $' +% !"',"+ ?,"& A. T$"," C,+$"#

*ES,E7VE

Art9#lo pri!ero.- D%",", N,7A" R%& N. 001-2015-JEE-LC18JNE# +% 31 +%+%!,% +% 2015# %!'+" , % J,"+ E%'," E%" +% L!" C%&', 1# % ,%$&%, %& &!%&' +% P%& +% J,"+ N"&" +% E%&% " &4,"& ",& +% &%',"+"+ !%'+" , % %:, O"&'" M/ ;!"" T"# P,%+%&'%+% " R%" +% P%,# %& % !", +% " E%&% G%&%,"% < +% R%,%%&'"&'%P%,"& "&'% % P","!%&' A&+& 2016.

Art9#lo &e8ndo.- DEVO7VE* "'"+ " J,"+ E%'," E%" +% L!" C%&',1 " 4& +% %# &4,!% " %%' %& % ,%%&'% ,&&"!%&'# ,%&%$% "',%"% & ,%"& " ,%+!%&' "&&"+, , &4,"& " ,& +%&%',"+"+ %'"'" %+ &'," % %:, O"&'" M/ ;!"" T"# P,%+%&'% +% "R%" +% P%,# %& % !", +% " E%&% G%&%,"% < +% R%,%%&'"&'%P%,"& "&'% % P","!%&' A&+& 2016.

R%B',%%# !&B%% < B%%.

SS.

T?VA*A C*DOVA

%E*N?NDE@ A7A*CN

A/VA* CA**ASCO

CO*NEJO ,E**E*O

*OD*,E@ VB7E@

"r"ll"no ro

S%,%'"," G%&%," (%)hec

15


16/18


Expediente N. J-2016-00032LIMA - LIMA - LIMAJEE LIMA CENTRO 1 (EXPEDIENTE N. 00239-2015-032)ELECCIONES GENERALES 2016RECURSO DE APELACIN

L!"# $%&'* +% %&%, +% + ! +%/

%,NDAENTO DE VOTO ADICIONA7 DE7 AIST*ADO %*ANCISCO A. T?VA*AC*DOVA )*ESIDENTE DE7 J,*ADO NACIONA7 DE E7ECCIONES

1. E& % ,%%&'% "# +%% +%'%,!&",% % P,%+%&'% C&''&" +% "R%" *" &4,&+ % ,& +% &%',"+"+.

2. S& %,7 +% % &+ & " ",'% ,%'$" < % 4&+"!%&' +% $' +% P%&+% J,"+ N"&" +% E%&%# &+%, &%%", %4%'", "&" ,%&%.

3. E& ,!%, '/,! +%% ,%"4,!",% %# +% &4,!+"+ & % ",'B 39 +% "C&''& PB'" +% P%,# % P,%+%&'% C&''&" +% " R%" % %,!%, !"&+"'",# & " ! "'" 7%,",B" %& % %,$ +% " &"&.

>. S& %!",# ! '+" "',+"+ 4&&", # % %&%&'," +%&', +%

""&% +% ,& +% &%',"+"+# & " 4&"+"+ +% ","&'@", " ',"&",%&" %!","+"+ %& % !", +% ,% %%',"%# "," "B %$'", "%,$%&'"7" %,7 &+%+ " &" ,"&@"& B'" "&++"'# +%,$"+ +%"


17/18


. S% ',"'" +% !%"&! % '+ %,& %& %7%, *" %!%"+# & %&4%*" '%,, " " &$"'," " ,% %%',"# " 4& +% ,%%$", , %&'%!" %&! < %& +4%,%&'% %',% < +%%&+%&" ("+# %+"',!# %,+"+ +"+"&"# %&',% ',).

9. C! '"!/& &+"! %& 4&+"!%&' "+&"% +% $'


18/18


&"&% % &'%,"& " A"&@" +% P"B4. M&', S%," "4,!" %"%%,"& % &+"K (23 +% %&%,).

- H=5 +% %,%"+ +% Q%" 1

Fallo JNE Ollanta

Documents

Transcript of Fallo JNE Ollanta