المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk...

125

Transcript of المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk...

Page 1: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2
Page 2: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2
Page 3: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

G9QRS]

!E*?XJGD:uQG9LT?TvZ

6/3/2017

Page 4: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2
Page 5: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

Gy}"%H

p,EC=9JG}|(QGyj+=+v?

�A������¿t�u½—����

Page 6: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

It(bGya=h|Jq(c?

Gya=g?G}hy)

1438$vvvvv2017e

Page 7: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

Gygt+OIyj?k

hGYa;I9

k

|OL{Ey)<9HGygt+OI:

G vvvEvvv$vvvJuG vvvKjC1vvv.f vvv!vvvcvvv2vvv.O#vvv(vvv,vvv@G vvv9vvvL1vvv1vvv7G vvvrvvv.0vvv$vvv7kvvv2qvvvLB&vvv-

G v$v?v1vJ,hChXvF v!vcv. v$v1v)#v2v.O+G vHv1vLhG v,vJihG)Uv0Mkv2CDvuv.e

RvvLbvv-G vvEvv(vv1vvm@hG vvEvv$vvJuCf1vvcvv=Ovv1vvJ&vv.#vvEvv$vvJGk

�#vv&O1vv.k

h#vvcvv!vv$vv.k

k#&Mdb!1-8SL0c.k

0Ers !2SL07CO$/B0.JbMq+.h#?J+.@

hG vvEvv$vvJuCf8vvlvvYvv"bvv!vv/G vv2vvSvvL0vv71vv$vv(vv,vv.LRvv.#vv"qvv.0vv%kvv28vvL1vv1vv7

G v(vlv.S,h8v(vSv,v7G$>v1v.d,h8vuv.0v)G$#v%h1v(v.AG vEvYv.QGJh@@@h#v.

PGcE/ v9vEv.0v"G)&vPv.&v1v7G v9v.Fv,v7#v)v̂!v$v.JG vSvLchG v?v,v. v7hG vYv0d

hG l.X/,E /&.QG 9.D1JhG c!%hG ,JihG/O9rLGQ@@@

hUvvJbGuG vvcvv_vv1vv%Dvv1vv=qvv.d:{@@@?@ABCDE:15FGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVW:16}(1)@

(1)G $.FJI:15vvvv16.

5G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 8: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

kvvv$vvv.G vvvPvvv2vvv1vvv"G!f)Uvvv0M+vvvKgG$#vvv7#vvv)>vvvJ0vvvJ?h#vvv.tvvv1vvvlvvv1vvv7

EGvLG>v,v.#v)Xv0 v,v.h8vcv(qv9v,v.h#v.Rv.1v,v,v.#v)kvPv.Ohv̂!v%hkvPv.b?@@@

G&v9vSvLG v_v!v%hXv.YG vcv!v%,h[vfv:G$&v.&v1v7bv!v/G v(vlv.ShG vrv!v.Hh v%

0vvcvvJ0vv!vv(vv.Dvv.dh/qvv.IE/EPGhqvvlvv(vv.hqvvlvv78vv##vv"h8vvlvvuvvLh8vvPvv.Dd: pvv%n

hUvv!vv(vv.E vv/+vvKGG/&vvEvv\vv.WG vvHvv!vvrvv2?htvv1vvmhUvv!vv(vv.E vv/+vvKgG vv9vvlvv.+vv.J

kvvv2G vvvcvvv1vvvT?h vvv$vvv.PG8vvvHvvv!qvvv1vvv(vvv.bvvv)#vvv2vvv.OFvvv(vvv.h>vvvlvvv.&vvv.#vvv(vvv,vvv?vvv(vvv.G vvv9vvvL1vvv.j

G r.0%?@@@

htv1vmG vPv2v1v"E v/G vcv!v%G v$v(v1vL,hG v$v(v,v@G vrv.0v%?kvrv]1vcvrvJG v(v1v7

bvv!vv/G vvcvv.OIE vv/G$Uvv",E vv/G vv$vv(vv,vv@G vvL1vv.&vv2G vvrvv.0vv%,E vv/#vv(vv,vv@Gu

G vPv!v1v%,kv.uG vHv. vsCbv!v%1vEv.>v.Jbv2v.OghCbv!v%1vSv&h&v,v%hXvLhQGJ

D1.8,%@

kvv$vv. vv(vv.E/GOvv9vvEvvVvv.d#vv.kvvrvvJ&vv.g#vv);vvrvv9vv(vv.1vv#&vvlvvPvv(vv.h1vv$vv(vv,vv@O0vv(vv(vv.

G vvvvEvvvv(vvvv1vvvvmhG vvvvcvvvv.OIE vvvv/8vvvvcvvvv!vvvv%O0vvvv(vvvv(vvvv.h8vvvvJ1vvvvLB0vvvv.8vvvv-,hG/qvvvv9vvvvJGA1vvvvPvvvv(6vvvv7

QOvv.dGu�h[vvL0vvrvv78vvL1vv1vv9vv-$UvvEvv.1vv-G vvK0vv)kvvHvvLJ1vvPvv1vvL8vv,vv%G vv2vvSvvL0vv7

>vv$vvcvv.Ah#vvJDvv,vv%Gukvv2tvv9vv.1vv-G vv$vv?vv1vvJ,kvvrvv.dvvvv8vvcvv. vv/vvvv:{CD

EFGHIJKLMNOPQ

RSTUVWXYZ@@@}(1)@

hqvvv.dkvvv2#vvvJDvvv,vvv%C0vvvYvvv.k

:{rstuvwxyz{|}~!"#$%:23}(2)@

(1)G l9F:29.

(2)G$DMGH:23.

6G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 9: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

kvv!vv(vvcvvJ&vv(vv,vv"#vv)#vvcvv1vv)kvvYvv.AG vvLOvv.d�,hkvvYvv.Fvv"G vvVvvEvv.1vv7

G vuvLGe,h&vPv9vYv-1v(v.Q#vuv.Q#v,v%,h&v(v,v@kv2G v9vL1v1v7&v,v?v,v%,h&vPvL1v,v$v7

h0vrv1v)h&vSv.W v(v2v(v2#v?vJGk

bvM0vMGk

h#v?v9v$vcv.k

kv.Xv0k

8vlvHvL1v-G$#v7h8vPvcvJ

1v-G)&vPv.&v1v7#v)>vJ0vJ@@@kv!v(vcvJE v/tv9v.HGuhOv(6v7QOv. v-h&vcvrvJG v(v1v7

G vvVvv.Oqvv7bvv!vv/G vv9vvSvv2vv=1vvcvvrvv1vvJ8vv,vv%,hG vv9vv$vvPvvv1vv$vv(vv,vv?vv,vv%G vv9vvL1vv.j vv(vv(vvrvvK

C1(.A&.hCDl.O&.#)X0dG _!$.JhG ?,"@

|g")Gygt+OIyj?k

(1):

PtvLkv2z vPv.fG vcvLHy#vcv(v/bvrvJ:hbnvrnvJn

G vcv,vJhG v1v$v2v)0vcvrvJ+v.

bvvvrvvvJGk

:CtvvvJ+vvv.C1vvv.R0vvvJkvvv2qvvv. vvv-vvvv8vvvcvvv. vvv/vvvv:{&’(

)*+,-./012

345678@xx}(2),hbvv.qvvJJC0vv$vv.&vvuvv%,hqvvJ

qvvL+bvvrvvJJ1vv. vv9vvSvvJ0vvJh#vvcvv(vv.gG vv9vv.tvv1vvJhG vv9vvfvv!vv1vvatvvrvv. vv-vvvv8vvcvv. vv/vvvv:

{yz{|}~!"#$%

&’()*+,-.@v~}(3)kvvvvvv2

G vvEvv!vvmC0vvYvv.k

,hkvv2DvvJ0vv=G1vv)bvv2vv.Skvv2qvv. vv-vvvv8vvcvv. vv/vvvv:{-

./}(4)@

G v$vcv.qvJI:G v$vcv.+vJIhG v$v1v<v.b,hG$0v$v.f>v$vd0v$v1v)G vrvPv%.hqv.d

(1)G1)#(_.Q, P.fG cLH,G ?MAG <. =,U301vvvv303.

(2)G (P.A:33.

(3)G (E":91.

(4)G (P.A:33.

7G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 10: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

bvrvJG vEv2v"hG v2v1vdhG vcv,vJkv.&vcvrvJ.hG vcvrvJ:G vcv,vJ,hG v?v$vdbv,v.Oh+v2

Ctq

JG c,.O.

hG vv$vvcvv.qvvJI:G vv$vvcvv.+vvJI.hbvv.qvvJg:bvv.+vvJgh8vvcvv.qvvJG vvrvv.e:8vvcvv.+vvJhG.

hqvvvvv. vvvvv-vvvv8vvvvvcvvvvv. vvvvv/vvvv:{;<=>?}(1).qvvvvv1vvvvv"+vvvvv2

G vcv,v.O,hqv1v"+v2G vlvLGFvZG v9v2C vM#v.+v.,qv.dG vM>v.L:Chkv.G1v. vcvrv.O

G 92brJ+.Guvvvv8c. /vvvv ,%.

vvKG&vv?vvJCfq

vvlvvaG vvcvvrvv1vvJI1vv$vvcvv(vv/G vv.kvv.AhG vvcvv,vvJhG vv$vvcvv.+vvJI vv1vvQ

#vcv(v.gG v9vVvJ0vs,kv. vrvLBfG vuvL0v%GOv9vcv$v" vlvaG)0v$v.fh#v<v!v-kv2G vEvJ0v=

G SL0m,1$c(/G 9VJ0s@

|ZazKGygt+OI(2)

:

vv%0ovvKtnvvLGOvv%G vvcvvrvv1vvJItvvcpvv!

rvv%kvv2G vvrvvLfG$hdG vv,vv?vvLj, vvKGqvvJ

O$2+KGG c!%1#O$.At<1LI#(,.:

1vvvvG vlvrv-G$tv2vL:tv$v.Ov$v.gC1v.Dv(v1vlv7kv2G vuv9v.HG v$v(vPv.HE v1v-

zG vlvrv-G$tv2vLyDv1v=PtvLCfq

G vlvrv-kv2G vJ0v)+v.G$Uv"Dv1v=bv.OE v/

DJ0=QO.dGu�:z#)0oLpOpGuo1-Go1rLGk0ol

nr8

,o-ok2G J8

0p)y(3).

(1)G $.FJI:1.

(2)#vvvEvvv$vvv.OOvvv. vvv%bvvv2vvv1vvvJGJ,G vvvcvvvrvvv1vvvJIG)Ovvv0#vvv1vvv7,bvvv$vvv.f,G$QOf,OGQG vvvlvvvLqvvv.f,O.W,1998,U12vvvv13.

(3)UvEv1vFG v2vHv.Qj,tv9v.HG vcv!v%,1v.H#v)0vLOGu1v-Gv1vLGk

0vlvrv-kv2G vJ0v),DvJ0v=Qqv%71h8vv9vv$vv7G vvEvvJ0vv=:zhE&vv$vv.C&vv.qvv.Ovv%hGu0vvcvv\vv2h vv)8vvMGd+vvKgG$#qvv7qvv.Fvv$vv7bvv!vv/C#LGu/0YL

q+%#)G. l,%D9/0#82C#LGuy.

8G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 11: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

2vvvvbvv!vv%G vvuvv0e:hqvvJv̂v,vvL+vvKGG vvcvv!vv%Dvv1vv)v̂v,vv.QkvvLqvv7G vv$vvcvv9vvM vv7(1)

G vv9vv2GRvv9vv,vvLJkvv2bvv,vvJ+vv%kvvuvvLICfq

G vvrvvLBfG vvuvvL0vv%#vvHvv!vv.b,hqvvJCGvvKJ

+vvKgG vvlvvuvvLI#vv)#vvPvv# vv7tvv0eGuvvvv8vvcvv. vv/vvvv,h+vv"tvv0eGuvvvv8vvcvv. vv/vvvvCR vv2

q.F%1KG8-Ce#H!.bD.OK??kP$2+KGG c!%1c!%G u0e.

3vvvvCUvv.dG vvJ0vv)(2)tvv$vv.Ovv$vv.gG vv2vvMOhj(3)hG vv2vvfvvJGOj(4).hOvv$vv2

(1)kvLqv7G v$vcv9vM v7:G v$vcv9vM v7GOv%0v\v!vsbv!v/8v!vvG vlvLqv7G v9v2v̂,vLJkv2G)Ov0ekv2ChGFv"G vvrvvLfG vv<vv.&vv2bvv!vv/0vvJhGUvv"1vv)bvv\vv.A(G vv2vvVvvLjG vvfvvMqGdG vv$vv9vvuvv!vv%,tvv.f#vv)C>vv0

qA

G vv$vvcvv9vvM vv7,Ovv$vvdG vvEvvPvv)G vv2vvVvvLj),hOvv!vvuvv:#vv(vv,vv?vv.k

bvvrvv!vv13vv.UvvLkvv.k

kvv21vvEvv=G vvcvvrvv.FvvJ,hqvvLQJCf

6G vv$vvcvv.Qatvv!vv,vv.bvvrvv!vv1vv7DvvVvv./

khh>vv.1vv.

kqvv2vv"G vvSvvLYh1vvcvvJg,h+vv%CQ1vv.H

G vvuvv0ehCUvvEvv.HG vv?vvJd,hG vv9vv$vv1vv1vvM,hG/Ovv9vv(vv2vv.Wbvv!vv/#vv)Gvv. vvlvv,vv%.G&vv_vvL:#vv1vvMGfG/b9JGd !K+22,G ?MAG LG1d,U32919VLa.

G vK+v2v2,G)#v.eG vEv.kvaRv$vQG vJ0v),G v$v9v.k6v/Ov(v7806+vvvvv,#v1vMGfG/bv9vJGdkv2&vrvJ

G vvL>vv.d,8vvEvvrvv1vvsbvv2vvJG vvlvv9qvv.MC1vv.Ovv(vv7hbvv!vv2#vvEvv$vvJbvv.Vhbvv.OdCDvv$vvJbvv2vvJG vv$vv.>vv.O,11LhJ,OGQG u93G c!$17,G \2c7G <.&17,1429+vvvv|2008e@

(2)G vvPvv1vvJG vvSvvL0vvmG vv?vvL>vv.&vv2,G vv9vvcvvL0vvlvv.J,8vvEvvrvv1vvs#vvEvv$vvJG vvPqvv.O,1vv1vvLhJ,OGQG vvuvv9vv3

G vcv!v$v1v7,G v\v2vcv7G v<v. v<v7,2009e,U32,+vKGG v$vVv\v!vFqvJGRv9v,vL1v1v)G vPv!vm#vL8v2v\v.k

1vv. vvlvvrvv-,E/q

CfGqvv9vvLG&vv-0vv. vvJ0vv)tvv.f>vv,vv$vv2G vv$vv(vvSvv#hG vv9vvuvv.0vv),kvv. vv$vvcvv9vvM vv7C[vv!vvrvv.gbvv!vv/CUv. v,v%G vHv$vPv7,h>vcv!v.G8v!vvG$Uv.dCOv.Ov.

k v!vJ0v),C#qv.Cev!v3G vK0v)GOv9vcv$v!v.g#v)

#vv9vvuvv!vv$vv2G$RvvcvvL0vv7kvvuvv.&vv.G0vvLevv2vv.fCf8vvuvv.f vv,vv%CUvv. vv,vv%G vvcvvrvv!vv1vv7#vv9vv$vv1vvMIbvv)G$Uvv.dG vHv$vPv7bv)G v$vcv9vM v7,Dv1v=Gbv9v2vLhGC&vlvPv,v%C+v"G vPv(6v7hG v?v$v.bv7@G&v_vL:tv9v.HCUv.dG vvvvcvvvvrvvvv1vvvvJI,O.#vvvvEvvvv$vvvv.Obvvvv2vvvvJG vvvvLGRbG vvvvLXvvvv.G&vvvv2,#vvvvuvvvv9vvvv2vvvv7Ovvvv!vvvvPvvvv2vvvv1vvvv",G vvvv\vvvv2vvvvcvvvv7G$h vvvv/,

1430+vvvv|2009e,G $?!JG$hd,U242vvvv243.

(3)G v2vMOhj:C1v.G vEvPv)bv!v21v)#vEv$vJ1v)G vEvPv1v)1v)bv2vJG vuvL0v%kvHvLG)Ov0eG v2vMOhj,kvrv1v-CUv. v2#v)Ctv.1vLG vEv(vlv1v7h#v)Ovuv.fOv$vLqv(vJ&vPv2v9v-E v/1vMOgqv!vcv71vrvLH&vPvm. v-8vVv.&v1vm

#vv(vv,vv.:tvv(vvMG vv.Uvv.dkvv2CUvv.dG vvlvvrvv-h0vvcvvLaCUvv.dG vv2vvMOhj,8vv.kvv2Ovv(vv7482+vvvvvv.G&vv_vvL:

CUvvv.dG vvv2vvvMOhj,tvvv(vvvMG vvv.Uvvv.dE vvv/#vvvcvvvLkvvv7G$Uvvv.d, vvv!vvvuvvv.8vvv3bvvv!vvv21vvv)#vvvEvvv$vvvJG vvv2vvvMOhjG E(l2,#\2c7>.h0J1LS,tLG8S2.hG&_L:O1LCb0eG (20A(18|602vvvv603)@

(4)G v2vfvJGOj:C1v.#v(vVv.QG v$v9v.k6v/Ov(v7429+vvvvv,G vlvLb1v1v)G vlvLb,8vEvrv1vs#vEv$vJ#vEv1v2

9G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

=

Page 12: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

+vKGG vcv!v%1vcv!v%CUv.dG vJ0v)$fq

G$Uv.d>v$vdCUv",h+v.kv2G v!vfv7

#vv.0vv(vv2vv(vv2bvv!vv1vv-evv1vvLg,kvv.)0vv$vv.f+vv.CUvv"G vv$vvcvv.QaG vvJ0vv(vv1vv7G vvKj0vvL8vvuvvM

bv!v1v-G vJ0v),h#vPv.Fv!v-+v2G vrv.GbvJG v9v2/0vVvFG)0v$v.f1vJh&v,v.,h+vKG

GOvvv%0vvvVvvvFCf0vvvuvvv.f#vvvrvvv.1vvv"CUvvv.dG vvvlvvvrvvv-G vvvKj0vvv2vvvEvvv=kvvv2qvvv.GbvvvJ

G/>9,.OhCDu.#-h#.09c!s1$V.OQG 9SL0d.

4vvvvbvvvv!vvvv%G vvvv9vvvv.Dvvvv1vvvvJ:tvvvv$vvvv.Ovvvv$qvvvv.gG1vvvv)8vvvv1vvvv$vvvv1vvvv7(1)h#vvvvEvvvv$vvvvJ1vvvv)

bv2vJG v.+v.H(2)hOv$qv2+vKGG vcv!v%1vcv!v%G v9v.Dv1vJ$fq

CUv"#vcv(v/G v9v.Dv1vJ

Gbvvv9vvvrvvv.OCfq

GuhGDvvvJ/RvvvL0vvvv vvv-kvvv2PG8vvv-h/kvvv2Uvvvlvvv.8vvv-h/kvvv2

Ckvcv. v-,;v%>vcv"+vKGG/Ov%zbv!v%G v9v.Dv1vJybv!v$v.k

v,vKGG vcv!v%8vPv$v1v7 v-

1#+%#2.D<-hCRLaqY.0.g,h+2G 9.D1JhG Vl.JG) vsv,17.

5vvvvbvvvv!vvvv%G vvvvcvvvvrvvvv1vvvvJIChbvvvv!vvvv%G vvvvcvvvvrvvvv.FvvvvJ:tvvvv$vvvv.Ovvvv$vvvv.gG vvvv(vvvvPvvvvlvvvv2(3)

G vvvvJ0vvvv)bvvvv2vvvvJG vvvvEvvvv$vvvvJj,1vvvv1vvvvLhJ,G vvvv$vvvvuvvvv9vvvv2vvvv7G vvvvcvvvvVvvvvL0vvvv7 vvvv!vvvv\vvvv2vvvv.bvvvv.hG vvvv(vvvvSvvvvL,O.W,

1413+vvvv|1993e.b. %Q0.X1.JbL12b.T11)980ehb.e1037e.

(1)G1vv)8vv1vv$vv1vv7:Rvv1vvIG)Ovv0e8vvrvv2G vvJ0vv),CDvv$vvJ1vv)bvv2vvJG vvEvv!vv1vv%1vv)bvv2vvJG vvPvv0e1vv)C1vv2G vvrvv.Ovv%1vv)G vvHvvYvvLG1vv)8vv1vv$vv1vv7G vv(vv$vvLjG vvEvvLqG&vv2,>vv$vvd1vv1vv)G vvcvv!vv.eG vv(vvrvv!vv1vv7hG vvcvvrvv!vv1vv71vv#&vv.Gbvv,vv.,h#vvKG+vv3C+vv"G vv$vv!vv"hG vv(vvEvv"hBQGAG vv$vvKG+vv3h#vvrvv./JG vvlvvLb.h vvJbvv.e

671+vvvvvh8v.kv2bv.e728+vvvvv1vcvJ#vLV&vMd1v-kv2G vPv?v)kv2O#vSvs@G)#v.e#vEv$vJC1v.R+LI,8.Q0IG $KG+3G)O0#17, (Jfq2LU,OGQG EJ0=,1987e,U627.

(2)bv2vJG v.+v.H1v)#vEv$vJ:+v.#v(vSv-#vK+v3G v.+v.1v1v7,G v$v9v.kv/Ov(v71787e,hqvJOQS

#vv& vvlvv.JG1vv)8vv1vv$vv1vv7,kvvLGqvv:kvv2&vv_vvLgh8vvcvv$vvskvv1vv,vv.hCGvvL>vv,vv.#vv)Dvv1qvvMG vv(vv_vvLE vv/Dvv1qvvMG c$".

(3)G vv(vvPvvlvv2:#vv1vv$vv.f1vv)#vvEvv$vvJG vv(vvPvvlvv2G vvSvv,vv1vvL1vvvvvv:C1vv2G vv$vvcvv1vv)G vv(vvPvvlvv2,G vv$vv9vv.kvv/Ovv(vv7508+vvvvvv, vv-tvv9vv.H1vvEvvLG vvuvv0e,0vv9vvEvvJKbvv)8vv.Q0vvIbvv!vv%G vvuvv0eh8vv\vv.qQg#vv9vv2vvd#vv(vv,vv@

G$Rvv.bvvLI,h+vv.#vv)bvv!vv$vv.AG vvrvvLfG vvHvv.#vvQG vv,vv?vvLjhChGFvv"G vvPvv.OS.Ovvuvv)1vvHvv.Qi

10G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

=

Page 13: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

hG vv2vv1vv,vvrvv2(1)hOvv$qvv2+vvKGG vvcvv!vv%1vvcvv!vv%G vvcvvrvv.FvvJCGvvKGk

#vv)bvvrvvJG vvEvv2vv"hevv1vvLg

EPGCDu%1SJI.

hqJhXdG c!$.AbJI8cL0l.J !cr1JIk2G/U\0M,#(,.:

Cfq

+vvKGG vvcvv!vv%(bvv!vv%G vvJ0vv))0vv9vv\vv!vv3Eqvv.#vv7G vvJ vv1vv"bvv!vv1vv-#vv)G vvrvvLBf

G vvvuvvvL0vvv%ChG vvvPvvv(6vvv7G vvv(vvv2vvv.0qvvv7(G$O qvvv7G vvv(vvvrvvv!vvv1vvv7),C#qvvv.bvvv!vvv%G vvv9vvv.Dvvv1vvvJkvvv2

G/U\0MG P.FJk2bVLG (2.qIk,.t. 9. 2:

CkvvLOG)#vv.eG vv2vvHvv.Qj1vv.1vv.kvv2G vvVvvEvv1vvF1vvcvv(vv.Gftvv9vv.HG vv9vv.Dvv1vvJ,

qvv.dkvv1vv-:(1vv.H#vv.>vv.Akvv2Obvv.IG vv(vv2vv2�C#qvv9vv-E vv/8vv.Dvv1vvJGu8vv2vv.Qc

h8vcv. v/).;v%bvrqv31vEvJ0v=G1v)bv2qv.SS0vrv.d: v$v.1vcv=G v(v2v2�

#vvcvv.P1vv)>vv2vv"SE vv/C+vv"G vv1vv$vv),qvv.d vv-:zE&qvvv8vvrvvJebvv!vv/qvv.e#vv)C+vv"G vvuvv9vv.H,kvv!vv1vvuvv)Chqd#vv.8vvJbvv.+vv%E vv1vv-Cf0vv.DvvJhGGuvvvv8vvcvv. vv/vvvv,kvv(PGbvvLkvv.GP vvv,kvv#Gvv2vvL+vv%Cf

qGuGkvv9vvLVbvv!vv1vv,vv%Gvv$vvQUvv!vv.GJkvv2

0vvv.#vvv,vvv%h vvv1vvv!vvv9vvv,vvv%,kvvv(PGUvvv!vvv.Gkvvv#Gvvv2vvvL+vvv%Cfq

Guvvvv8vvvcvvv. vvv/vvvvqvvvJGkvvv9vvvLV

bv!v1v,v%Rtv.Ikv2C#v.G v,v%8v&GvK#v)ev(v1v,v%kv9vLOqbv!v/kvrv1vL+v%,kv(PGCqvLqhG

h+vvvv.Dvvvv(vvvvlvvvv2G vvvv$vvvvK+vvvv3,Qhibvvvv(vvvv-Rvvvv1vvvvIG)Ovvvv0e#vvvvEvvvv$vvvv.O1vvvv)CDvvvv$vvvvJG vvvvPvvvv.evvvvL>vvvv2,hbv2vJG vLRv1vJG v. v.G v?v2,htv.f#v)G vcv!v$v.AG$bv0eG v$vSv,v.Q v,v%1vfvMGQIG vcv!v%,htv.f

CUvv. vv13vv.kvvrvv1vv,vv.k

#vv9vv2vvEvvLGk

kvv2G vvcvv!vv.ehG vv$vvcvv.Qa,h0vvcvvJ#vv)bvv!vv$vv.AG vvuvv0e.G&vv_vvL:1vvEvvL

G vvvvuvvvv0e,#vvvv1vvvv$vvvv.f1vvvv)#vvvvEvvvv$vvvvJG vvvv(vvvvPvvvvlvvvv2,O#vvvvSvvvvs,OGQG vvvvlvvvvLkvvvv.Q,G vvvv\vvvv2vvvvcvvvv7G$h vvvv/,1417+vvvv|1997e,U34.

(1)G vv2vv1vv,vvrvv2,G vvEvv.kvvaG)#vv.eC1vv21vvuvvLCDvv$vvJ1vv)G vvEvvPvv),G vv$vv9vv.k6vv/Ovv(vv7458+vvvvvv,G/bvv9vvrvv.O

hG v,vJG0v7E v/Ov2v1v"G vLRv.O,Dvrvrv-C1v.bv2vJGuCDv$vJ1v)E1vLG+v1v%C1v.G vcv1v(v1v),1v1vLhJ,

OGQG1)DMe,G \2c7G$h /,1420+vvvv|1999e@

11G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 14: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

1K vkHK#(,%,hn8n.nb

6tLGF%C#.GdG (.Sy(1).

hkvv2QhG0vv7;vv.&vv1vv7bvv)G1vv)bvv2vv.SSqvv.d:Cfq

G vv(vv2vv2�1vvcvv=

#vvcvv.PGE vv/G vv1vv$vv),kvvrvv.d:zGObvv,vv%E vv/Rvv,vv.OICf/E vvvsv-E/q

GuhC&qvv2QOv.dGu,kv(PG+v%C[v.bv.G vK vv,kv#bv!v$v,v%Cf

qGuqvJGkv9vLVbv!v1v,v%

Gvv$vvQUvv!vv.GJkvv2tvv"0vv.eh vv1vv!vv7,kvv(f+vv%C[vv.bvv.G vvK vvv,kvv#bvv!vv$vv,vv%CfGuGkv9vLVbv!v1v,v%UvJqv7kv2C#v.G v,v%,8v&GvK#v)Cev(v1v.Fv,v%h8vLObv!v/krLGF,%y(2).

hqvvvJPtvvvLG1vvv)GvvvM0vvv$vvv7(3)kvvv2tvvv9vvv.1vvv-zG vvv9vvv.Dvvv1vvvJy(4)htvvv9vvv.HE;vvv2vvv.J

(1)G vv2vvHvv.Qj,kvv2tvv9vv.HG vv9vv.Dvv1vvJ:1vv.HObvv.AG vv(vv2vv2�E vv/8vv.Dvv1vvJGu,DvvJ0vv=Qqvv%7372.

hRGOkv2QhG0v7:zhG8vsObv.IG v$v_v!v.e,kv(&qv- v1vQ1v1v(v-h1v1v)GuDv?v.Hy,CGvL>v-G v2vHv.Qj

kv2G v$vfv.Rj:1v.H1vcv=C1v2#v.Ov/h#vcv.PE v/G v1v$v)qv2v"Dv?v7G v.OGY,hkv2G vMtv.I:1v.H

h>vv.HG vvMtvv.I,h1vv.H/8vv&GvvKtvvLGFvv%C#vv.GdG vv(vv.Skvv2G vvVvvJqvv7,h1vv.HCGvvKG vvVvvJqvv7#vv)G$evv(vv1vv.Ah8vvLOkvv2G vvlvvrvvLGA.hkvv2G vv$vv_vv. vv%:1vv.HG)8vvrvv.AhG vvEvvKQ#vv)Obvv.IG vv$vv_vv!vv.e.hkvv2G vv9vv.Dvv1vvJ:1vv.H#vv.>vv.Akvv2Obvv.AG vv(vv2vv2�C#qvv9vv-E vv/8vv.Dvv1vvJGu8vv2vv.Qch8vvcvv. vv/.hCGvvL>vv-#P!%k2G)0$.f:1.HG Jb.AE /G S,.O81)hRLGFdG)O0e.

(2)G 2H.Qj,t9.HG Mt.I:1.Hh>.HG Mt.I,DJ0=Qq%1395.

(3)+v.#vEv$vJ1v)EOvEv.bG vPv!v$v2,C1v.1vuvL,E#v.e&v1vPv.1v.Qkv2bvVvLg,tv.fkvrv1v,v.k

#v?v9v,vJGk

bvv. vv$vv.k

1vv. vvEvvJ0vv=,E#vv.eG$Fvv$vv7hUvv.Dvv3G vv9vvVvv.&vv1vvm.h vvJOvv(vv7223+vvvvvv1vv(vv1vvPvv.1vv.Qh&vvSvv#

1vv,vv.,kvvPvv$vvd#vv)#vvEvvJKhbvv. pvv%GvvLGOvv.fG)#vv.eEOvvEvv.b1vv)QG+vv.0vv-,tvv$vv.Ovv$vvd#vv)G)#vv.#vv1vv)G vv2vvHvv.Qjh#vvPvv!vv%, vv-tvv<vv1vvL#vv)G vv$vvVvv(vvlvv.J#vv)Xvv$vv(vv-tvv9vv.HG vv9vv.Dvv1vvJhE;vv2vv.J

Uvvvlvvv.JG vvvLHN,8vvv.kvvv2qOvvv(vvv7311+vvvvvvvhbvvv$vvvLg0vvv(vvv.+vvvM89Ovvv(vvv7.#vvv)8vvvL>vvv$vvv7G $& mk2t9.HG .D1J,U5.

(4)h+vv.tvv9vv.HC;vv2vv:kvv1vv,vv.G1vv)GvvM0vv$vv7Uvvlvv.JG vvLHNG vv9vv2hUvvm1vv,vv.&vvlvvPvv-kvv28vv(vvM0vv!vv-bv!v/&v2v1v-G v$vVv\vlv/�hbv!v/ vPv.f&v2v1v-,&vrv"G$Gv2v.QG v<v.1v9v7G vVvEv1vEv7,&vrv"G vcvJhdbv)bvJhd,#v)ev1vLG&vrv\v.Ykv2G)Ov(v.Oh/>vLMkv2&v.qv!v2G$Gv2v.QG v<vrv.J,1v1vLhJ,

OGQG1)DMe,,G \2c7G$h /1425+vvvv|2004e.

12G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 15: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

Uvvlvv.JG vvLHqN#vv$vv.C;vv2vv:kvv1vv-Cf8vv.Dvv1vvJGuN+vv.1vv9vv.Dvv1vvJUvvlvv.8vv-

hCO$.F-.

h1vvvvK vvvvvbvvvvLqkvvvv.GG vvvv9vvvv.Dvvvv1vvvvJbvvvv!vvvv/C&qvvvv-ChqdhG>vvvv3 vvvv!vvvv$vvvvcvvvvLkvvvv7+vvvv.

8vv.Dvv1vvJGu,h vv!vvLOvv.d�+vv.G vvLOvv. vv7hG vv(vv2vv.qI,h0vvcvvLkvv.fQ1vv,vv%N1vvVvvlvv.8vv-G vv9vv2&vv\vvs1vv,vv.hDvv1vv-h8vv(vvM0vv!vv-,ChRvv,vvJ vv-1vv,vv.QOvv. vv-�bvv!vv/

#v.hQOJG$Gv2v.QG vVvEv.M1v-,h&vrv!v9v-G vcvJhdG v<vrv.Jbv(v-.h0v<v2v9v.f v-

>"q>0 -#.C;29- (lP-k2t9.1-,h#.>.Ab!/ P.fQO.dGu�,

hb!1-t.&:br1JIG VE.17G uLGeh#)82c,%1(DP.fE /0.eG r1.#7.

kv. v$vrvVv.O1vcv!v%G v9v.Dv1vJkv2G/Uv\v0M:+v.bv!v%0vcvLa1v-[vL0vrv7

G vvVvvEvv.1vv7hG vv9vv.1vvcvv1vv)kvv28vv.Dvv1vvJGu1vv. vvcvv2vv.O0vv7,hE;vv2vv.JG vvcvvrvv.FvvJG)0vv$vv.&vv1vv7

1vvv#O qvvv9vvv,vvv.G vvv(vvvrvvv!vvv1vvv7hG vvvcvvvrvvv!vvv1vvv7,hG vvvLOqbvvv!vvv/G vvv$vvv2vvv9vvvJbvvv1vvv)kvvv2G vvvcvvv2vvv.OGJ,

hG $H. l1)k2G/b9r.OGJ1.$O 7G (r!17hG cr!17(1).

hbvLqaC1v.1vuvLG v?vMGFvLjkvrv.d:G vcvrv1vJI+v2#v?v$v.bv7#v)qvYv.0v.

G vEvsG v2vJ+v1qv7G v$vPqv!v$v71v. vcvrv"|hG vPv$vd,hG vlv\vLI,0vcvrvJbv!v1v,v.G)&vPv.f

qvv!vv2vv-,h0vv<vv(vv2bvv!vv1vv,vv.UvvJQg>vv.R#vv.k

1vvVvvEvv9vv,vv.,qvv.[vvcvv.k

1vv.>vv.O+vv.h;vv2vv.8vv,vv.,

/0LiG0k,.C&q

-0VFCf0u.fC1JGk(2).

(1)G1v)G vrv1v%G v?v.R0v7,#vJGQLG vPv. vuv1v)1v1v)#v(v.RdE0qv.c&vcv2vJhE0qv.c&vPv9vcv1v),Dvrvrv-hXv2v]

&vvVvv-CDvv$vvJkvvHvvLjG vvLkvv.bvv2hbvvVvv.ekvv.QSG vvEvvLOvv9vv.&vv2,1vv1vvLhJ,OGQG vv?vv1vv",G vv\vv2vvcvv7

G$h /,1991e,G ?MAG$hqdU454,hG ?MAG <.&236519VLqa.

(2)C1vvv.1vvvuvvvLG vvv?vvvMGFvvvLj,bvvvrvvv1vvvJIG vvv$vvv&#vvv),#vvvVvvvL,G vvvrvvv.+vvvLI,OGQG vvvPvvv0e,O.W,/.J,

U15.

13G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 16: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

hbqvvvLkvvv,vvv.bvvv$vvvLOvvv!vvv1vvv$vvv.fG$RvvvrvvvLkvvvrvvv.d:zhG vvvcvvvrvvv1vvvJI vvv1vvvPvvv:C#vvv.QG

bv$v!v1qv7,1v"C#v.Qbv!v$v1v70v?v3bv!v/G v$vPv!v%Cf0vcv9vrvJ+v.kv2qv!v2v-,$fq

Gu

CG2Lg1,.1\L0r7t9.1-,Ch1\L0shD1-E /QO. -�y(1).

hG vvcvvrvv1vvJI+vv2#vv.0vvrvvVvvJ1vv-G/bvv9vvrvv.OOhfG vvcvv$vv",Ch+vv2G vv?vv.&vv3

G vv(vv_vvLjvvvvG vvcvv$vv!vv2vvvvG vvKj0vv\vv!vv3G)0vv$vv.f1vv-E0vv$vv.&vv.k

/0vvLqvv/E vv1vv-G vvSvvv

h/8vv&;vvLkvv1vv-Rvv2vv,vv7tvvcvvrvv1vvJIhG>vv3G vv.>vv.OGuhG8vvVvv.kvv-1vv. vvuvv$vv./J,

h8(M0,-b)G (r.FW,h&MhdG .D2,hEQO.dG LO"h&E.P v(2).

q q q q q q

(1)bvvv$vvvLOvvv!vvv1vvv$vvv.fG$RvvvrvvvL,G vvvcvvvrvvv1vvvJIkvvv2Gu,G$QOf,bvvv$qvvv.f,OGQG vvv(vvvlvvv.FvvvQ,G vvv\vvv2vvvcvvv7

G c.RLI,1415+vvvv|1995e,U12.

(2)bvv2vvJG vvEvv$vv1vvJG vvPvv.FvvF,bvvrvv1vvJIG vv$vvPvv!vv%h#vv.0vv9vvVvv"1vv,vv.,hRGQIG$hqvv.aG$QO&vv1vv7,bvv$vv.f,1979e,U27.

14G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 17: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

CQv9fGygt+OIG S;|+?

CQv9fGygt+OIG S;|+?:

C[v!vs#vVv\v!vFG)0v$v.fbv!v/#vPv.Fv"G v9v.Dv1vJhG vcvrv1vJI$&qv,v.qvYv.0v.

89c!sk2G r!3@@@

Dvvv1vvv=Uvvv(qvvvmG vvv9vvv.Dvvv1vvvJE vvv/&vvv.bvvv1vvv)1vvv(vvv.Abvvv!vvv/G vvv(vvvVvvv.UG vvvrvvvLB&vvv1qvvv7

hG$D.O0=G (2.07>$!7k

h8lV10k.

h0vvKtvvLbvv!vv$vv.AG vvPvv!vvmG vvVvv. vvFCfq

Dvvrvv1vvrvv7G)0vv$vv.fhG vv9vv.Dvv1vvJ8vvuvv$vv)

kv28vVvJ0vsG vHv2vL1v$v.>v.A1v-QOv.dGu�#v)hDv2G vPv$v.AE#qv.kv2

G vrvLBfG vuvL0v%Ch1v#Dv.O0v<v-G vVvEv1vEv7G v$v(vrv. v7bv)G vcvJhd,h8v(vlv1vKG$#vL

1$.>.A1-QO.dGu�#)b(JGu.

hqvvvJ1vvv1qvvv)P vvvvG1vvv)G vvvrvvv1qvvv%hevvv1vvvLg#vvv)bvvv!vvv$vvv.AG vvvPvvv!vvvmCfq

>vvv$vvv.Y

G vJ0v):8vVvJ0vsG vHv2vLh[v.bv7G$#vL,hCfq

COv.SG v9v.Dv1vJhG v,vJG0v7G v9v2

#vv)qGu1vv,vv.bvv!vv/G vv$vv.DqvvJ0vv),0vv9vvL8qvv3bvv!vv/8vvVvvJ0vvsGvv2vvLGu,#vv)evv1vvL

Gbv9vLGVRv2v,v78vrvJMkv28vVvJ0vrv-,hE#v9v<v.dC#vLg#v)ev1vLEbv9vLGVRv,v.I

8$(dG#9<. -.

15G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 18: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

;vvvv%qvvvv.dq:zhbvvvv!vvvv/+vvvvK0vvvv)G$Uvvvv!vvvv1vvvv)#vvvvJGQG)0vvvv$vvvv.fh+vvvv$vvvv.

8vVvJ0vsG vHv2vLh[v.bv7G$#vL,h0v9v2vcv,v$v.C#vLGfBGvLGf,h+v$v.&vlv2Rv2v,v.J

G vv2vv.[vv"G vv.GQOIbvv!vv1vv-,G vv$vv.&vvcvv7#vv)tvv$vv.dG vv9vvVvvJ0vvs,hCf/0vvHvv$vvT1vv,vv.

h>vv-8vvVvvJ0vvrvv-,hOkvvdRvv,vv.GJG vvfvv2qG vv.GQOIbvv!vv1vv-,G vv$vv.&vvcvv7#vv)tvv$vv.d

G/#9<.dy(1).

vvvKG#vvv.hQOkvvv2DvvvJ0vvv=>vvv2vvvL0vvv"p#vvvdQOvvv.dGu�Dvvv1vvv)

Ov# v-bv)G)0v$v.fC>v.1v-:G)0v$v.fCf8v&#v)1v.uh#v0Fvuv9v-htv9v2v-hQOv!v-

hG v1v.eG!GvLhG vrvYv.AhG vrvJQGv1vLghRvLqg.h vrvJkvPvLbv!v$v.AG vPv!vmCf

G)0$.f+.G 9VJ0s1. r!3hG)qLGQ1. !P.fhG c$"1.$Qt.f.

hkvvvvPvvvvLJCQtvvvv.fG)0vvvv$vvvv.f:h#vvvvcvvvv(vvvv/CQtvvvv.f:>vvvv$vvvvdQtvvvv),hQtvvvv)

G vvSvv2A>vv.&vv2vv-G$qvv.i,htvv$vv.Cfq

tvv"1vv(vv.A/0vvrvv.eE/q

bvv!vv/COvvQqvv.0vv7

;.19-,tK vk(fq

1(.A+KGG J0)/0r.eE/q

b!/8!vG$Qt.f.

hqvvYvv1vv7G)0vv$vv.f+vv2G vvrvvYvv1vv7G$h vv/G vv9vv2>vv.AG vv(vv2vv1vv.fhG vv$vvLOvv!vv.f

$>vvv!vvv,vvv.,hG vvv9vvv2&vvvMdG vvv.Dvvv2G vvvuvvvL0vvv% vvv9vvv<vvv2vvv1vvv9vvv,vvv.,hG vvv9vvv2tvvv.&vvv:#vvvEvvv.Q

G vLOv./Jtv!qv,v.,tv$v.tv.&v:#vEv.QQOv. v7QOv.dGu�Gv.8v%G$&v2v1v.A

hG v$vLOv!v1v),kv!vrvJ>v.AG vrvLBfG vuvL0v%h>v.AJG vPv(6v7G vSvL0vlv7 v9vcv. v@+vKg

G vrvYv1v7G vuv2vLi,h8v.XvEv,v.h8v2v1v(v,v.1v1v.&v.k

tv.#v0k

,1v1v.&v.k

v!v2vSvL0v7tv!qv,v.,1v1v.&v.

k

Gvv.8vv$vv.k

/1vv1vv.f1vvcvvJg.h>vv.AJOvv.FvvLG vvrvvYvv.0vv.G vv9vv20vvcvvLXvv,vv.#vv(vv,vv.LGuvvvv

(1)G1v)G vrv1v%G v?v.R0v7,#vlv9v.MOGQG vPvcv.OIh#v(vSv.Qh/0v7C+v"G vcv!v%hG)QGOI,Dvrvrv-C1v.bvv2vvJGuR+vv.j,1vv1vvLhJ,Uvv1vvJG,G vv$vvuvv9vv2vv7G vvcvvVvvL0vv7,O.W,1424+vvvvvv|2004e,G vv?vvMA

G$hdU55.

16G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 19: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

qvvLB&vv.k

hOvv(6vv7k

vvvv#vvL8vv2vv\vv71vv,vvKgG vvEvvrvv1vvrvv7G$h vv/G vvuvv2vvLi,h8vvrvv.ebvv!vv1vv,vv.qvv1vv.#vv.k

t.#0k

,k0GO9rLGQ ,.1Jh&,.,h/q.Ih/t1.f.

h vvrvvJCRvv.QG vvrvvLBfG vvuvvL0vv%E vv/Gvv\vv.QI+vvKgG vvrvvYvv1vv7kvv2tvv"Ovv.QI

#v)Ov.Qg,hC vFq

bv!v1v,v.E vEv.Dv.k

RvJ0vJGkv2tv"Ov.QItvK vv,Dv9v/8v_v"

+vvvvvKgG vvvvvrvvvvvYvvvvv1vvvvv7+vvvvv2C+vvvvv%qvvvvvYvvvvv1vvvvv7kvvvvv2Dvvvvv1vvvvv.IG)&vvvvvPvvvvv.fbvvvvv!vvvvv/G$QV.

qv.dvvvv8vcv. v/vvvv:{W6789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[@xv}(1)(2).

h vvrvvJCkvvLOG vv2vvHvv.Qjkvv2ChqdUvvEvv1vvEvv-bvv)tvv9vv.HG)0vv$vv.f,1vv.H

C#.QG)0$.f,q. -vvvv8c. /vvvv:

{Wijklmnopqrs

tuvwxyz{|}~!

"#$%&’()*

+,-./01234

56789:;<=@||v}(3),hqvv. vv-

vvvv8c. /vvvv:{‘ab@v}(4).

(1)G S.Qi:13.

(2)bvvJ&vv.fbvv!vv2QXvv.G vv(vvEvv.j,G vv9vv.Dvv1vvJhhGqvvcvv(vv.G vv$vvcvv.UvvL,G vvL0vv.V,OGQG vv(vvEvv.j vv!vv(vvSvvL

hG 9.R0d,W2,1413+vvvv|1993e,U18vvvv19.

(3)G 2rLI:177.

(4)G $&#(.f:1.

17G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 20: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

C#qvv.kvv2zUvvEvv1vvF#vvPvv!vv%ykvvrvvJhQOkvv2tvv9vv.HG)0vv$vv.f,1vv.H1vv1vv.f

G)0vv$vv.fhG)Ovv0eG)DvvPvv.f,h>vv.HG)0vv$vv.f1vv(;vv2vv.JqvvJQGuOvv2vvEvv.&vv-

h8vvvcvvv. vvv/,h1vvv1vvv.fG vvvJ vvv1vvv"bvvv!vvv/G vvv9vvv2vvvLqj#vvv$qvvv)/0vvv&#vvv)1vvv. vvvrvvvJQ,hEevvv0X

G vrv.dkv2Dvrqv-kv2QhG0v7bv)bv$vL1v)G vHv\

qv.HS,qv.d:1v1v(v$v.&vEv)

bvvvv(vvvvJQOvvvv.dGu�PGJ0vvvv.e,EP[vvvv!vvvvdbvvvv!vvvv1vvvv(vvvv.Q>vvvv"RvvvvJ0vvvvJ1vvvv1vvvv.V

G vv<vv1vv.H,RvvJ0vvJOvv.GOG vvSvvcvvL,/0vvLibvv!vv1vv-C;vvLG vvPvvlvvL,h/0vvcvvLkvv-#vv(qvv.

CDvvJ,Dvv9vv/>vv!vvQE vv/G vv(vv2vv2q,kvv#Ovv(vvJQtvv2vv9vv1vv-E vv/Qtvv2vv9vv1vv-,hhXvvdtvvlvv1vv-

bvvvvv!vvvvv/kvvvvvHvvvvvK0vvvvv-,hqvvvvv.d:0vvvvv.#vvvvvEvvvvv$vvvvvJ,CGvvvvv2vvvvvL&vvvvv2bvvvvv)G)Ovvvvv0e,kvvvvvrvvvvv.d

QOvvvv.dGu�:zG)Ovvvv0eCf8vvvvSvvvv,vvvvJCf/E vvvvvsv-E/GuhCfq

#vvvvEvvvv$vvvvJGk

QOvvv.dGu,h8vvvrvvv1vvv%G vvvVvvv0I,h8vvv&8vvv2G vvvMtvvv.I,h8vvvVvvv.eQ#vvvYvvv.f,h8vvvEvvv@

G vv2vv1vv:,EfGOvv9vv\vvcvv:E vv1vv-Ovv2vv1vv0ky,qvv.dUvvJqvv:.qvv.d:kvvcvv?vv2vv(vv. vv-0vvPvv# vv-

h0vvVvvJqvv-.qvv.d:kvv#Gvv2vvL&vv2bvv)G)0vv$vv.f,qvv.d:zCf8vv&#vv)1vv.u,h#vv0Fvvuvv9vv-

htvv9vv2vv-hQOvv!vv-hG vv1vv.eG!GvvLh8vv&#vv)1vv. vvrvvJQGvv1vvLghRvvLqgy.qvv.d:UvvJqvv:.

qv.dkv#Gv2vL&v2bv)G)DvPv.f,qv.d:zCf8vcv2vJGutv#&qvv8vLGgkv(f v%8vuv)

8vvLGgkvv(&qvv-0vvLGcy.qvv.d:kvv#Gvv2vvL&vv2bvv)G vvPvv.bvv7,qvv.d:z#vv.G vv$vvPvv&hdbvv(vv,vv.

1vv#bvv!vv%#vv)G vvPvv.Fvv"y.qvv.d:kvv#Gvv2vvL&vv2bvv)C#vv.QG8vv,vv.,qvv.d:zCf8vv!vvJG$#vv7

Q1qv9v,v.,hCf8vLiG vEvlv.IG vcvLGIG vcv. v7Qbv.AG vSv.A0v9v\v.h v.fkv2G v2v(v1v.fy.

qvvvv.d;vvvv%G&vvvv\vvvv!vvvvskvvvv!vvvv2vvvv<vvvv:#vvvv!vvvv1qvvvv.,;vvvv%qvvvv.d vvvv2:z0vvvv.bvvvv$vvvvL,C8vvvvJQj#vvvv)

G vvPvv.Fvv"?y.qvv!vv::GuhQOvv. vv-Cbvv!vv%.qvv.d:zkvv(&qvv->vv2vvL0vv"C8vv.tvv%0vvcvv!qvv$vvuvv%

O0(u%y(1).

(1)UE1F#P!%,t9.HG)0$.f,Qq%G EJ0=8.

18G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 21: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

hG vvSvv.+vvJ#vv)G vvEvvJ0vv=+vv.Cfq

CQtvv.fG vvJ0vv);vv0;vv7:G)Ovv0e,

G)0vvv$vvv.f,hG)DvvvPvvv.f@h#vvv)Xvvv$vvv(vvv,vvv.#vvvcvvvLkvvv7CRvvvLGWG vvvPvvv.bvvv7,hCfq

tvv.fG)0vv$vv.fOvv9vv7CqvvPvv.e#vv)Xvv$vv(vv,vv.G)0vv$vv.f1vv. vvrvvYvv.AhG vvrvvJQGvv1vvLg

hRLqg.

h vvrvvJPtvvLGuNCf#vv)Uvvlvv.JG vv$vv&#vv(vv1vv),+vv%G vvK0vv)0vv&#vv(vv.f

1vv. vvfvv1vv3{FGH}.hG vvfvv1vv3#vv.tvv.f#vvfvv1vv2vv.k

bvv)G vvcvv1vv.f,h+vv.

tv"#v.C#vL&v.1v.)0v$v.f1v-#v$v.ev.Hbv)C1vVv.Q&v.,qv.dvvvv8vcv. v/vvvv:{F

GHIJKLM@xN

OPQRSTUVWXY@y}(1).

C#qvv.kvv2ChGGvvLOvv.QIG vv2vvrvvLIkvvrvv.dGuvvvv8vvcvv. vv/vvvv:{VWXYZ[\]^_‘abcdefghijklmnop@z}w}(2).

hqJkPqLG1)t<1L(0&#(.f1. f13)k28lP1Lgkr.d:

qvv.dG1vv)>vvL0vvL:hG$h vv/Cf0vvuvv.&vv.G#vv.Uvv.kvv1vv)1vv.)0vv$vv.f1vv. vvfvv1vv3

qv./k

hGbv9vrv.OGk

hbv$v0k

hqvJ8vJGv"G vHvSv1v7ukv2#vcv(v/G)0v$v.fG vKj+v.

8VJ0sG r.d1. c$".

hG)0v$v.ftv!v$v7>v.#vcv7 v*0v$v.f1v.uhtv9v2v-hQOv!v-h8vVvJ0vsG)qvLGQ

(1)G 2rLI,G!09.f:3vvvv4.

(2)G 2rLI:285.

19G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 22: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

1v. vlvcv"(qv!v:)C#qv.G)0v$v.fkv2G v!vfv7kv1v\v!vsbv!v/G v9vVvJ0vsG v$vEvZhqvJ

0vvPvv9vvcvv$vv"kvv2G vvrvvLBfhG vv$vvLGO1vv-P vvvtvv$vv.qvv.dvvvv8vvcvv. vv/vvvv:{:;<=}(1).htvv$vv.qvv.dEGvv.I0vv.Ovvm$1vv1vv,vv%:{cde

fghi}(2)(3).

htvvK vvvEPGGOovv9vvcvv$vv"#vvrvvLh&vv.

k#vvdG$bvv$vv.dtvvrvv. vv-vvvv8vvcvv. vv/vvvv:{0

1234}(4).kvvvv##qvvvv.EPGGOvvvv9vvvvcvvvv$vvvv"#vvvv\vvvv!vvvvrvvvv.k

kvvvv.)0vvvv$vvvv.f

G vSvLbv2qG v$v\v!v.H/0vuv.fE/q

Gbv9vrv.OGk

hqv./k

hbv$v0k.+vuvKGP+v3E v1v-

Ctvv<vvLG$Fvv$vv71vv"qvvJDvvuvv.gG vvSvv.kvvcvv2hCDvv$vvJ1vv)Dvv(vv2vv"hC1vv.bvv2vv1vvJghevv1vvL

q./k

hGDJGk

E>$.b.k

,zCfq

G)0$.fq.dhb$"0M0Jh0(rWy@@@

C#qvv.G vvfvv1vv3G vv$vvLGO+vv.+vv(vv.kvvrvvJGGvv9vv!vvlvv:bvv2vv.QGJG vvPvv!vvmkvv1vv-htvv!vv,vv.

UvvvEvvv1vvvEvvv78vvvL>vvvdE vvv/Cfq

#vvvLGOG vvv?vvv$vvv1vvvd:0vvv&#vvv(vvv.f1vvv.uh#vvv0Fvvvuvvv9vvv-htvvv9vvv2vvv-

hQOv!v-hG v1v.eG!GvLh>v(v9v-h&v.Qgh vrv.Fv-,h0v&#v(v.f1v. vEv1v.I1vcvJG v$v.J

h1. 2c=,k,KGe13t!-(5)@@@

hG vfv1v3+v.tv"Rv2Aev.Hbv)Dv.GOv(v.kv$v<v.dbv!v/P vvCQhGDv(v.

G vvPvv.Q0vv7kvv2C>vvPvv.#vv(vv.,/&vvPvv$vvcvv,vv.h/&vvLG+vv.h/&vv!vv$vvPvv,vv.,h#vvdP vvv

+v2#v.>v.OIkv1v(v.Dvr3v.,&v&#v)1v,v.h&vEvLUbv!v1v,v.tv"G vEvLU,hev1vL+v.

(1)G1)t<1L,8lP1LG rLBfG c_1%,G ?MAG$hd,U43vvvv4419VLa@(2)G 9.17:61.

(3)0.Om:17.

(4)G ScLGA:227.

(5)G E.kaC12G lJGA1)t<1L,8lP1LG rLBfG c_1%,G ?MAG$hdU43.

20G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 23: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

G vuv<v1vL#v)G vcv.G v%G vfv1v2v1v7G v9v2/&vLG+v.h vuv)0v?v3G)0v$v.f1v.>v.O+v.,

kvlv2DvJ0v=bv$vL1v)G vHv\v.HSDv1v)0vEvJq

K1v-qv.dQOv.dGu�

bvv)>vv2vvL0vv"p,Cf&vv&#vv)1vv#Qtvv.fG vvJ0vv)h#vv)CQtvv.fG vvJ0vv)G)Ovv0e

hG)0vvv$vvv.fhG)DvvvPvvv.fhCRvvvLGWG vvvPvvv.bvvv7,Cj0vvv?vvv3Cf&vvv&#vvv)1vvvuvvv"C#vvvL

e122CG2Lb(-QO.dGu�.

vvrvvJCGvv2vvLGuNkvv2G vvrvvLBfG vvuvvL0vv%bvv)G vvfvv1vv3kvvrvv.d:{@ABCDEFGHIJKL@ww}(1).

hq.dvvvv8c. /vvvv:{23456@~}(2).

h#vv)+vvKgG vvfvv1vv2vv1vv.JG vv9vv2CGvv2vvLbvv(vv,vv.QOvv.dGu�,kvvrvvJQhi

G v2vHv.Qjkv2DvJ0v=DvK0vlv7S,qv.d:z vrvJGv\v2v(v.G v(v2v2�Gv\v2v7#v.

8vLckv1v,v.Rv1v,v.k

E v/qv1v.eG vPv.bv7E/q

PtvLg,bv!v$v-#v)bv!v$v-,h>v,v!v-#v)

>vv,vv!vv-,Eftvv(vv:$QiG vvSvv2AqvvJ&vvPvv1vv9vv-,kvv#bvvLkvv-tvv$vv.0vvcvvLaG vvL>vv"

G L>"EPGe.Hb(-kLBgkcLk-y(3).

kvv.)0vv$vv.f1vv. vvfvv1vv3COvv.SG/bvv9vvrvv.OG vvJ0vv(vv2;1vv"E&qvv-0ovvcvvJq#vv)C1vvLR

GvVv.FvWG v9v.Dv1vJuOv2vEv.&v-h8vcv. v/,hG)0v$v.f1v. vfv1v3Obv.E v1v->v$v1vd

G$&vv2vv1vv.AhG vvLOvv",#vv) vvJf&vv.MpE vv/Gvv.8vv%G vv(vv2vv1vv1vv)#vvEvv$vvJ�,

kv. vfv1v3+v.G vKjCGv2vLJ1v-G vLOv"G vuvLGe+v.tv"C#vL0v$vuv)#vSv.+vJ8v-

(1)G ESL:22.

(2)G LbJ:9.

(3)UvvvEvvv1vvvFG vvv2vvvHvvv.Qj,tvvv9vvv.HG vvvrvvvJQ,1vvv.H{56789:38}[G$DvvvMGH:

38]Qq%G EJ0=(6604).

21G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 24: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

hG)DvvPvv.S1vv-1vvcvvJG vv$vv.Jhkvv2G vvJGQG!GvvLI,h#vv)G$#vv.QG vvfvv1vv2vv1vv7#vv.

qvvvVqvvv-Gubvvv!vvv1vvv(vvv.#vvv)qvvvVvvvWG$h vvv1vvv),qvvv.dvvvv8vvvcvvv. vvv/vvvv:{@AB

CDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRS@yy}(1).

hqvvv.dvvvv8vvvcvvv. vvv/vvvvkvvv2qvvvVqvvv70vvv.Ovvvmp:{mnop

qrstuvwxyz@wuv}(2).h#vvvvvv)

G$#v.QG vfv1v2v1v7#v.Ov1vEvJKkv20v.eG vPv.bv7h+v.0v.eG vrv1v.#v7,hqvJ;v2v:

Cfq

>vvv$vvv1vvvdG vvvLOvvv"hG vvvuvvv9vvv3G vvvPvvv$vvv.h0qvvv7>vvv.DhG)&vvvKGQCqvvv.G#vvv,vvv%1vvv. vvv1vvv.e

G!GvvL,qvv.dvvvv8vvcvv. vv/vvvv:{,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJ

KLM@v|}(3).hqvvv.dvvvv8vvvcvvv. vvv/vvvv:{lmnop@}vqrs@~v}(4).

G)0vvv$vvv.f1vvv. vvv1vvv.eG!GvvvLQCS+vvvKgG vvv$vvvrvvv.UvvvJ,hCUvvv"#vvv)CUvvv.d

G)0vvv$vvv.fhCQtvvv.&vvv-tvvv$vvv.qvvv.dvvvv8vvvcvvv. vvv/vvvv:{ijklmn

opqrstuvwxy

z{|}~}@@@(5).kvv. vvEvvVvv.dbvv!vv/G vv2vvLq,/0vv9vvEvvrvvs

(1)Bdb$LGf:44.

(2)0.Om:102.

(3)G M#L:71.

(4)G$b!/:18vvvv19.

(5)G 2rLI:177.

22G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 25: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

E/q

1vvv.)0vvv$vvv.f1vvv. vvv1vvv.eG!GvvvL,h vvvK vvvvkvvv(fq

vvv*0vvv$vvv.fC;vvvLGk

bvvv_vvv1vvv$vvv.k

bvvv!vvv/

G)&vvPvv.fkvv2G vvJ&vv1vv.hG!GvvLI@kvv(fq

G)0vv$vv.f1vv. vv1vv.eG!GvvLhG)tvv<vv.Q#vv)PtvvvLg,hG vvv9vvvVvvvJ0vvvsG vvv?vvv.Re1vvv.qvvv.bvvv-,0vvvM0vvvJE0vvv$vvv.fG)&vvvPvvv.fh0vvv?vvvcvvv!vvv-#vvv)

G v$v9vrv1v),h+v&/A+v%G vK0v)0v&#v(v.f1v. vfv1v3,kvrvJQ8qv3GuNDvVv.d

G vvv9vvvrvvv.ihG vvvlvvv0M vvv*&vvvPvvv.fkvvv2G vvvJ&vvv1vvv.hG!GvvvLI.qvvv.dvvvv8vvvcvvv. vvv/vvvv:{>

:1?@ABCDE:2FGH

IJKLM:3NOPQ

RSTUVWXY:4Z[\]

^_‘a:5}(1).h vvv$6vvv.tvvv.fG)0vvv$vvv.f1vvv. vvv1vvv.eG!GvvvL

#vv)G$#vv.QG vvfvv1vv2vv1vv7,Cbvv.fGuOvv2vvEvv.&vv-h8vvcvv. vv/Gvv!vvrvv-bvv!vv/G$0vv$vv.f1vv-

1vvv##vvv.Qtvvv<vvv1vvvLI,h#vvv)P vvvvQ1vvv]+vvvKGG vvvfvvv1vvv31vvv.$#vvv.QG vvv$vvvEvvvPvvv.Ovvv7,kvvv(fq

G vvfvv1vv3EPGQ1vv]1vv.$#vv.QG vv$vvEvvPvv.Ovv7Ovv,vv"1vv-bvv!vv/G)&vvPvv.f,h#vv)+vvKg

G$#vvv.QG vvv$vvvEvvvPvvv.Ovvv7G vvv9vvv28vvvcvvv1vvv)bvvv!vvv/G)0vvv$vvv.f1vvv. vvv1vvv.eG!GvvvL,CRvvvLGW

G P.b7.

hC+v$v1v7#vcvLkv7+vKgG$RvLGWhG$#v.QGJ,8v_v,vL#v)C+v$v1v7G)0v$v.f

1v. v1v.eG!GvL,h vK vvkv(fq

G)0v$v.f1v#RvLGWG vPv.bv7hbv0#v.8v,v.G vVvEv1vEv7

G vv<vv.1vv9vv7,>vvMA/0vv9vv?vvMC#vv)G)0vv$vv.f1vv. vv1vv.eG!GvvL,hG vvKj+vv.>vvMA/

09?MC#)G)0$.f1. f13.

hG vvEvvJ0vv=bvv)CRvvLGWG vvPvv.bvv7#vv,vv%q,h/Ovv1qvv$vv.EPGG1vv9vvcvvJG vv(vv.S

bvv)8vvKtqvvLG!GvvLIhG&vvSvvfvv!vv.G1vv. vvJ&vv1vv.h#vv!vvKG8vv,vv.,kvv(fq

kvv2CRvvLGWG vvPvv.bvv7

(1)G 2rLI,G!09.f:1vvvv5.

23G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 26: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

G v$vEvPv.Ov7G v9v28v_v,vLh0vLG+v.G v(v.S1v#bv1v(v,v%tv$v.CGv2vLG v(v2v2�,#v.0c1JG (.SE /Q1q,%h0.q_,%#)el!9,%(1).

0vvvrvvv.dG vvvrvvvL[vvv2vvv2q:qvvv.dG vvvcvvv!vvv$vvv.AQDvvv$vvv,vvv%Guvvvv8vvvcvvv. vvv/vvvv:

G vvEvvuvv$vv7kvv28vvrvvJ0vv%G$RvvLGW,hO/ vv7G vv(vv.Sbvv!vv1vv,vv.,8vv(vv2vv1vv-G vv(vv.S#vv)

QqvJ8v,v%hDv<qv,v%bv!v/G/Dv9v1v.W$&vlvPv,v%1v. v9v.1v7hG)&v.1v7,tv2/0v2v.ev9v.G

1vv. vvEvv.d1vv1vv(vv,vv%h1vv1vv)8vvJGQcG vvcvv.GQV#vv(vv,vv%,kvv1vv(vv2vvfvv2 vv!vv(vv.SCf0vvuvv.&vv.G

1vvcvvJ^vv,vv.QCRvvLGWG vvPvv.bvv7,qvvJ&vv_vvLhG$&vvlvvPvv,vv%hG&vvrvv\vvcvv.Gbvv)G vvJ&vv1vv.

hGOvvv9vvvcvvvJq

hG vvv!vvvPvvv.bvvv7G vvv$vvv.bvvv.O1vvv,vvv.,hGuCbvvv!vvv%.h8vvv!vvvvG$RvvvLGWbvvv0#vvv7

/&9,.AG J&1.hG&rY.F,.(2).

hqvvvvv1vvvvv.eG vvvvvPvvvvv.bvvvvv7qvvvvvJCGvvvvvlvvvvv2hqvvvvv:hqvvvvv.bvvvvv-,h vvvvvuvvvvv) vvvvv,vvvvv.CRvvvvvLGW

hbvvv0#vvv.J,qvvv.dvvvv8vvvcvvv. vvv/vvvv:{$%&’()*+,

-}(3).qvJRvLDv,v.G1v)Dv?vLG vcvPvrv0&v2:G v$vLGO1v#RvLGW:G vcv0#v.J

(1)bvvv2vvvJGu1vvv)Ovvv!vvv1vvv$vvv.fG vvvfvvvlvvv1vvv!vvv2,CRvvvLGWG vvvPvvv.bvvv7,G vvvL0vvv.V,hRGQIG vvvSvvv&hfG)Ovvv0#vvv1vvv7hG$hqv.ahG vJbv.IhG)QRv.O,1422+vvvvv,U7.#vEv$vJ1v)bv2vJG vLDv$vvsv)G vcvL0vlv2,&v,v.0v7G vvcvv. vv%CRvvLGWG vvPvv.bvv7G vvVvvfvvLihG vvuvv2vvLi,G vvL0vv.V,OGQG vv9vvJ#vvL0vv7,G vv\vv2vvcvv7G vvPvv.1vvcvv7,

1431+vvvvvv|2010e,U19vvvv20.#vvEvv$vvJ1vv)EOvv$vv.bvv1vv"G vv$vvrvvJe,kvvrvv-CRvvLGWG vvPvv.bvv7,G)Ovuv(vJQ0v7,#vVvL,OGQG vHv!vlv.AG vLGRvJ0v),G v\v2vcv7G$h v/,1430+vvvvv|2009e,U17

vvvv21.CDvvv$vvvJ#vvvVvvv\vvvlvvv/#vvv9vvv. vvv2,UvvvEvvv1vvvFG vvvJGQG!GvvvLI,OGQG1vvv)G vvv?vvv.Rj,G vvv\vvv2vvvcvvv7

G$h /,426+vvvv|2005e,U88.

(2)Rvv$vvQG vvJ0vv)bvv2vvJGuG vvrvvL[vv2vv2,G vv$vv9vv.kvv/671+vvvvvv,G vv9vvKtvvLIkvv2CDvv.GdG vv$vv.8vv/hC#vv.QG!GvLI,1v1vLhJ,OGQG vuv9v3G vcv!v$v1v71987,G v\v2vcv7G v<v.&v1v7,U709.+v.#vEv$vJ1v)CDvv$vvJ1vv)C1vv21vvuvvL1vv)kvvLMG$&vvVvv.Qj,C1vv.bvv2vvJGuG vvrvvL[vv2vv2,G)#vv.eG vv$vvlvvPvvL,tvv.f

RG+vJGk

bv.1vJGk

DvPv)G v9vVv(v1vm,QDv"E v/#vVvLhGOv9vrvLkv1v,v.,#v)tv9v2v-:G v?v.#vd$Dvuv.e

G rLBf,hG 9KtLI1#D.GdG $.8/hC#.QG!GLI,8.k2O(7671+vvvv

(3)#E$J:18.

24G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 27: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

G v9v20vcvrv2v,v.qv1v.eG vPv.bv7.h#v)+vKgG$RvLGWkv2DvJ0v=bv$vL1v)G vHv\v.H

Dvv1vv)qvv.dQOvv.dGu�:z#vv.G vv$vvPvv&hdbvv(vv,vv.1vv#bvv!vv%#vv)G vvPvv.Fvv"y.hqvvJPtvvLG)Ovvlvv.Q0vv(vv2kvv2tvv9vv.1vv-z vv.G#vvdG$&vv.GQybvv)bvv0#vv.JG vvPvv.bvv7:G!0vv.J

k2P vt<1LI,hC#q.G$D.O0=k08u.O8EV/@@@

h vvv$vvv.tvvv.fC#vvvLG vvvPqvvv.bvvv7RvvvJ0vvvJG

kh+vvv. vvv,vvv.#vvvM0vvvJG

khC#vvvL+vvv.1vvvcvvv1vvvJG

ktvvv.f

G/+v9v$v.e1vSv#&v,v.Ctv<vL#v)ev1vL+v..h v,vKGCtv<vLG v(v2v2�#v)1v1v.fCRvLG[v,v.

hC#vv.QG8vv,vv.hCGvv2vvLbvv$qvv.1vv1vv)0vvJ0vv,vv.#vv)G vvlvv9vv)G vv2vvcvv1vvJIhG vvrvvL0vv2vv7,h&vv2qvv-C#qvv9vv-

hDvvvKq

Q+vvv% vvv1vvv9vvv#+vvv2qvvv.G vvv9vvv!vvvvG vvvcvvvrvvv2vvv7G vvvSvvvJ0vvvJI@@@hqvvv.d:Cbvvv!vvv%Cfq

CRvvvLGW

G vvPvv.bvv7hC#vv.QG8vv,vv.8vv(vvrvvPvv%E vv/;vv0;vv7CqvvPvv.e,qvvPvv%v̂v,vvLhG&vvrvvYvv/,hqvvPvv%

v̂v,vvLh vv%0vv(vvrvvZ1vv"/0vvMGdkvv2R0vv.OIDvv9vv/EPG1vv!vvgG vvfvv.0vv7v̂v,vvLG vvrvvPvv%

G vv<vv. vv=h+vv2G$#vv.QGJG vvrvvL0vv2vv7G vvuvv2vv1vvLIG vv9vv20vvcvvrvv2vv,vv.G vvPvv.bvv7,hC&qvv,vv.8vv9vv.1vvd

tv(v_v.eGvLRGJG&vrv\vdOv!vuv,v.@@@)(1). vKGDv.>v7G v(v.SvvvvGv.Uqv7kv2+vKG

G vvcvvVvvLvvvv vv$vvcvvLkvv7CRvvLGWG vvPvv.bvv7Chq/k

:0vvPvv,vv%kvv28vv.>vv1vv-Ovv!vv.tvv,vv%E vv/

O21"G H1LhG/O9cJGO 1.eG $c.O.

;vvvv.&vvvv1vvvv.k

:h>vvvv.O1vvvvcvvvvZG vvvvuvvvv9qvvvv.Hkvvvv2+vvvvKGG vvvvcvvvvVvvvvL,G vvvvK0vvvv)CGvvvvKhG

0vvSvvuqvvuvv.fkvv21vvcvvZG$#vv.QG vvfvv1vv2vv1qvv7,G vv9vv2CGvv2vvL&vv.QOvv.dGu�bvv(vv,vv.,

h#vv(vv,vv.CRvvLGWG vvPvv.bvv7,RGbvv$vv1vv)Cfq

+vvKG0vv(vv.kvv2G vvcvvrvv"h0vvVvv.O#vv-,h+vvKg

Dvv?qvv7hG+vv1vv78vvJd

qbvv!vv/bvvJeG)0vv$vv.f1vv. vvfvv1vv3hbvv!vv/bvvJe8vvcvv_vv1vv%C#vvLGu

hC#LQO.dGu�.

(1)#vvvEvvv$vvvJG vvvPvvvlvvv.Q0vvv(vvv2(1188+vvvv), vvv.G#vvvdG$&vvv.GQhOvvv.G[vvvdG$OvvvLGQ,1vvv1vvvLhJ,G vvv$vvvuvvv9vvv3

G)O0#2,1991,G \2c7G <. <7,G ?MAG <.&2,U65vvvv66.

25G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 28: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

|"9WGyJw~p,G:fA}9O

fz)G}Oyq

?Gy"tz+?

p,EC=9JG}|(QGyj+=+?

G *}9f<9yj+>:

bv!v%G vfv1v2v1v.J#v)G$#v.QG v9v2GOv9v#;vLGuvvvv8vcv. v/vvvv1v,v.,hGGv9vWq

1vv,vv.&vvlvvPvv->vv"qhbvv0,OhfOvv.Gg#vv)#vv!vvv#vvrvvLqHCh&vv2vv2q#vvLOvv",h+vv.

0vv\vv!vvd#vv)0vvL8vvYvv1vv-#vv)QOvv!vv-bvv!vv/1vvcvvZG vvfvv1vv3#vv9vv/Rvv.AhEPGRvv.A,

h1K v>.AJG!0.JhG$D.O0=,q.dO2E.&-h8c. /:

{nopqrst@{wuvwx

yz{|}~!"#@|w}(1).

{@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNO@xwv}(2).

(1)G ?)q,G!09.f:26vvvv27.

(2)+.O:123.

26G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 29: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

{NOPQRSTUVWX

YZ[\]@uw}(1).

hq. -vvvv8c. /vvvv (21q-#E$J�:

{;<=>?@ABCD}(2).

0r.dG)#.eG \2Lj(3)qk28lP1Lg+KgG!07:

zqv" v,v&/AG v$v(vuvL0v)&v2v.q8vv, vPv:Cqv.d vuv%E&qv2G vLHqG vKj v-

GvvvMGFvvv)G vvvPvvv$vvv.hGJhG$QV,kvvv#bvvv!vvv%evvv1vvv3G$Rvvv1vvv.AG vvvHvvvlvvv1qvvv7,G vvv9vvv2/

0vvcvv!vv$vv,vv.E/q

G vvLHqG vvKj/0vvHvvlvv/bvv!vv1vv-Rvv2Akvv9vvuvvK1vv.&vv2kvv1vv$vv.Cqvv.d#vv)

P vv,$&qv-/0v(v2vfv2Cf0vuv.fQ1qv.E/#v) v-#v!vvtv"qRv2A,h1v1vJgtv"q

R2A,h#)/0Hl/b!1-G.k1-,hP v+.GuG Kj/E vsv-e1Lgy(4).

h1vv$vv.Cfq

G)0vv$vv.f1vv.$#vv.QG vvfvv1vv2vv1vv7+vv.#vv)bvv(vvJGu,kvv01vvJq#vv)

G)0vvv$vvv.fhG vvv9vvvVvvvJ0vvvsCfq

tvvv"#vvv.0vvv#8vvv2#vvv)evvv1vvvL+vvvKGG vvv$vvvVvvvJQ+vvv.[vvvLb

G vvJ>qvv. vv1vv)hG vv$vv(vv?

qvv$vv1vv)hG vvcvvLqGkvv1vv)hG vvuvv,qvv.f,Dvv1vv)0ovvEvvJq

;vv.fbvv)G$DvvJGK

(1)0.&Q:20.

(2)G$&c.e:50.

(3)+v.>vcvlvL#vEv$vJ1v)>vL0vL1v)0vM0vJG v\v2vLj,G)#v.eG v2v.QYG v$vlvPvL,qv.dG vK+v2v2bv(v-:Ctvv<vvL#vv)G vv9vvLDvv.dh vvrvv2tvv<vv1vvL#vv)G vvL>vv.d,htvv.f#vv)CkvvLGOG vvJ+vvLbvv!vv$vv.

khPtvv.Akhtvv<vvLI

8vvVvv.&vv1vvm.#vv)#vvVvv(vvlvv.8vv-:>vv.#vvdG vv2vv1vv.fkvv28vvlvvPvv1vvLG vvrvvLBf,8vv.kvv21vv2vvfvvJGOOvv(vv7310+vvvvvv.G&_L:O1LCb0eG (20A14|267vvvv282.

(4)C1v.>vcvlvL#vEv$vJ1v)>vL0vLG v\v2vLj,G v$v9v.kv/Ov(v7310+vvvvv,8vlvPv1vLG v\v2vLj>v.#vdG v2v.fbvv)8vv#h0vv"G vvrvvLBf,8vvEvvrvv1vvsUvv0Mbvv2vvJG vvlvv9vv.MG vvHvv. vvJj,O#vvSvvs,OGQG vvrvv!vv%,G vv\vv2vvcvv7

G$h /,1418+vvvv|1997e,G $?!JG <. =,U417.

27G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 30: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

G vv$vvPvv9vvrvv2vv!vv1qvv7#vv)bvv(vvJC&vvlvvPvv,vv%.kvv$vv.G vvrvv.GbvvJG vv9vv2&vv9qvv2vvcvv,vv.kvv2#vv(vv.WG vvEvvuvv%

b!/G$O q

7G (r!1q7k2E;2.JG$#.QG f121q7?

C;v2v9v(v.Cfq

CRvLGWG vPv.bv7hbv0#v.JG vPv.bv7+v2#v)#vPv.Fv"G v9v.Dv1vJ

h+vv2Uvv!vv3G vvJ0vv)G)Ovv0#vv2hCUvv!vv-G$Uvv1vv"h1vv,vv.0vv$vv1qvvMG vv$vv&#vv)#vv)

G vvuvv.kvvL,h0vv$vv1qvvMCUvvEvv.HG vv?vv(qvv7#vv)CUvvEvv.HG vv?vvEvv1vv%,h#vv$vv.G1vv9vv!vv21vv-

G)&vPv.fkv2+vKgG vJ&v1v.+v.#vcvLkv7G vSv2v,v.J,h8vSvuv1vvG v(qv.S1v$v.CGv2vL

1v-QOv.dGu�,kv,vKGG/1v9v0A v1v$v1qvMG vHv2v1v=#v)G v\v1qv3,hG v$vVvJq

b

#)G u.PH,hG $H\-#)G $V13.

{FGH},kvvv$vvv.G vvvrvvv.bvvvJIG$Uvvv1vvv!vvv7G vvv9vvv2Ovvv.Qbvvv!vvv1vvv,vvv.

+&/AG $&#(.f 1VJq

q.G1##.Qe121q7PtL+.QO.dGu�?

qvv2vv"G vv2vvJA1vv$vvcvvLkvv7+vvKgG vvrvv.GbvvJ,ChqO8vv.Xvv1vvFC#vvL#vv,vv%q,h+vv.:tv1vm0vJQcG)&vPv.f#v.Dv. v-?h#v$v.Gv!vs+vKGG)&vPv.f?h#v.G v$vrv.q#v.J

G 92#(E: - $cLk7#.OHLqgGu -?

ztvvvv.fGuh vvvv%0vvvvuvvvv)Rvvvv2A#vvvvcvvvv-y(1),Gvvvv!vvvvsGuG vvvvuvvvv.f vvvvEvvvvuvvvv$vvvv7

bvv_vv1vv$vv7, vv9vv_vv,vvLB;vv.QCOvv$vv.Fvv-hB;vv.QQDvv$vv9vv-,hB;vv.QqvvJQ8vv-,hB;vv.QDvvuvv$vv9vv-,

hB;vv.Q>vv2vvLh8vv-,kvv!vv%0vvSvv,vvJCj#vvHvv!vv.b,h/CjCDvvJtvv1vvmGovv!pvvs

n+vvKG

G u.f.

vv%0vvSvv,vvJCDvvJGvv!vvsG vvPvv$vv.hGJhG$QVh/0vvPvv9vv\vv1vvdCDvvJkvv2

(1)QhGgG vv2vvHvv.Qj,bvv)bvv$vvLGf1vv)DvvVvv1vv),tvv9vv.H1vvJAG vvHvv!vvs,#vv.>vv.Akvv2qvv. vv-8vvcvv. vv/:{CDEFGHIJK},DJ0=Qq%319.

28G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 31: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

+vvKGG vvuvv.fCf0vvJqbvv2C&qvv-Rvv,vvJGvv!vvsG vvPvv$vv.GJhG$QVCh#vv.1vv1vv(vv,vv$vv.,

qvvvvvv.dvvvv8vvvvvvcvvvvvv. vvvvvv/vvvv{W)*+,-./0

12345@vz}(1).hP vv vuv2/0vuv.f+v(v.cDv?qv7

v$v)0v9qvHvK&vlvPv-E v,v.kv1vcv2vJgG v(v.S,kv.uOv2vEv.&v-+v.G vHv. vsh+v.G$hqd

hG!GvvvLhG vvv_vvv.+vvvLhG vvv2vvv.[vvv)@@@G$hd vvv1vvvQ vvv-1vvvJG0vvv7hG!GvvvL vvv1vvvQ vvv-

&vv,vv.0vv7h vv1vvQ1vvcvvJgRvv2A,h+vv.G vv_vv.+vvLkvv!vv1vvQkvv.qvv-Rvv2Ah+vv.G vv2vv.[vv)

kvv!vv1vvQOh&vv-Rvv2A@@@ vv%0vv!vvJh vv%0vv. vvJh vv%0vvuvv) vv-tvvlvv.GCh&vvJ3GCh

#<10k

ChR21,.k(2).

QhiG vv2vvHvv.Qj(3)kvv2DvvJ0vv=bvv)bvv$vvLGf1vv)DvvVvv1vv):qvv.d:qvv.d

C+v"G v1v$v) vLOv.dGu�:>v,v(v.c v(v9vlvrqv-kv2G vJ0v)h v(vPv# vvbv)Chqd

+vvvKGG$#vvvL,kvvvrvvv.d:tvvv.fGuh vvv%0vvvuvvv)Rvvv2Aqvvv2vvv!vvv-,htvvv.fbvvvLRvvv-bvvv!vvv/

G vvvv$vvvv.A(4)htvvvv9vvvv3kvvvv2G vvvvKtvvvvLvvvvG vvvv!vvvv.MG vvvv$vvvvEvvvvlvvvv.Xvvvvtvvvv"qRvvvv2AhGvvvv!vvvvs

G P$.hGJhG$QV.

qvvvvv.dvvvv8vvvvvcvvvvv. vvvvv/vvvv:{yz{|}~!"#

$%&’()*+,-./01

234567@x}(5).

(1)G u,m:51.

(2)U0Mb2JG l9q.MG H. Jj,O1LIBOep,#&OP7G .QqGb,O.W,2003e,U9.

(3)QhGgG vv2vvHvv.Qj,bvv)bvv$vvLGf1vv)DvvVvv1vv),DvvJ0vv=Qqvv%7418,tvv9vv.HG vv9vv.Dvv1vvJ,1vv.H

{,-./}.

(4)/&vvPvv#dbvv)tvv1vvlvv1qvv7P vvvh/#vvuvv.fG vv$vv.A,h/C0vv)Gvv!vvrvv-,kvvuvv"#vv.&vvcvvLkvv-Cfq

G vv$vv.A#H!.bhCf

qbLR-b!/G $.A,hCf

q+KGt.fq2"G)&P.fhG!sG P$.hGJhG$QV.

(5)0.&Q:3.

29G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 32: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

hbvvv)C1vvv2+vvvL0vvvLISqvvv.d:CGvvvKQOvvv.dGu�1vvv1vvvJjkvvvrvvv.d:

zGvv!vvsGuG vv9vvL1vv70vv.eG vvPvv2vv:,hGvv!vvskvv1vv,vv.G vv?vv2vv.d0vv.eG$DvvJhGvv!vvsG vvSvv?vvL0vv.eG);vv(vv1vv),hGvv!vvsG vv$vvuvvLhg0vv.eG vv<vv0;vv.A,hGvv!vvsG vv(vv.Q0vv.eG$Q1vvcvv.A,h1vv=kvv1vv,vv.G vvJhGH0vv.eG vvHvv$vv1vvQ,hGvv!vvsBOe1vvcvvJG vvcvvVvvL#vv)0v.eG v?v$vcv7kv2BGvLG vHv!vs,kv2BGvLOv.bv7#v)Ov.bv.JG v?v$vcv7,kv1v$v.11)G cVLE /G !1"y(1).

hGv!vsGuNtv"+vKgG$Uv(v.a8v,v1v,v7k

h8v?v,v1vMGk

v!vEv1v.Ibv!v/h>v-

G$QV(2).Gvv!vvsGuN>vv$vv1vvdG vv$vvHvv!vv.qvv.J,h+vv1qvv#G$QV/Ovv9vvrvv2vv.d

G vHv!v1vlv7,kv?v$v1vdG vHv0Fvs8vcv2vJGuN,Gv!vsG v$v0Fvuv7hkv\vL+v%bv!v/

[vv.bvv9vv-,h>vv$vv1vvdG vv$vvHvv!vv.qvv.J8vvVvv!qvv2h8vvPvv?vvJ,h8vvPvv2qvvFGuN,qvv.dvvvv

8vvvvcvvvv. vvvv/vvvv:{#$%&’()*+,-./01234567@vy}(3).hqvvvvvv.dvvvv

8vvvvvvcvvvvvv. vvvvvv/vvvv:{BCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVW

XYZ[\]^_‘abcdef$@}v}(4).

h1vvvcvvvJ#vvv.tvvv9vvv3G vvvrvvv!vvv%h>vvvLi#vvv.+vvv.tvvv.Fvvv)E vvv/0vvv.eG vvvrvvv1vvv.#vvv7tvvv$vvv.

(1)CGvvL>vv-#vvPvv!vv%,tvv9vv.HUvvlvv7G vvrvv1vv.#vv7,1vv.HG1vv9vvJGAG vvHvv!vvshGvv!vvsBOepDvvJ0vv=Qqvv%2789.

(2)U0MG H. Jj,O1LIBOep,U14.

(3)G (.Q:41.

(4)G E@:18.

30G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 33: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

C#vvvvLgGu.h#vvvv(vvvv-bvvvv!vvvv%GuC&qvvvv-Ovvvv1vvvvHvvvv!vvvvsBOephCf

q#vvvv.0vvvv$vvvv1qvvvvM+vvvvKG

G v$vHv!v.bbv)1v.qv2G v$vHv!v.qv.JC&qv-Cbv\v.g1vcvZG vVvlv.JG v9v20vPv9v\v1vd

1vv,vv.Cf0vvcvv$qvvLG$QVh0vvuvv.fkvv1vv,vv.Gvv!vv1vvlvv70vvEvvlvvaG vv(vvcvv%h0vvcvv9vvLa1vvlvvYvv"

Gu,h#vvv)+vvvKgG vvvVvvvlvvv.JG vvvcvvv!vvv%hG vvvrvvvJQIhG)QGOItvvv$vvv.#vvv1qvvvMgbvvv)evvv1vvvLg

1. EL0q7hG $P&h 1q7h>c" -G EP.HhG 9u!1mk2OGQG/190A(1).

P vvvCfGuNqvvJGvv!vvsBOep vv1vvuvv.fGvv!vv1vvlvv7kvv2G$QV

bvvv!vvv/h>vvv-G/1vvv9vvv0A,kvvv1vvvEvvv1vvv.#vvvPvvv9nvvvHrvvv!nvvvlvvv.

kkvvv1vvv,vvv.:0vvv9vvvrvvv!vvv31vvv1vvv)qvvvJQIGu

hDvvuvv$vv9vv-,hkvvYvv!vv-hQDvv$vv9vv-,hbvvJ vv-hqvv.q8vv-,kvv. vvfvv.0vv7#vv)Gvv!vvsG)&vvPvv.f

8vv9vv$vv<vv"kvv2bvv2vv.O8vv-u#vv)Gvv0dCkvvcvv. vv-kvv2G$QVhG vv9vvMG#vv-1vv$vvLGOGu

G SLb2,Cjk1$.GO9##(-Guk1-hGO9Lb.ghG.q -hG190g(2).

kvvv$vvv.G vvv$vvvrvvv.#vvv.JG vvv9vvv2#vvv(vvvEvvv,vvv.GuN!Oeph vvvKQ0qvvv9vvv-#vvv)

1cJg?

Chq/k

:G!sGuNBOepk2CDP)8r.0%.

;.&1.k

:b!q

%BOepG$O$.At!q

,..

;v. v<v.k

:Ov!qvEv-1v. vlv\vLI+v.hPQ0qv9v-#v)1vcvJgDv1v)CGvKG v$v1v<v.bbv!v/

PQ0q9-h+%k2b. %G KQq.

qvvvvvv.d8vvvvvvcvvvvvv. vvvvvv/:{MNOPQRSTU

(1)Uv0Mbv2vJG vlv9v.MG vHv. vJj,G vrv2vPv.JG vPv(v1v7kv2RvLMG vcvrv1vJIG v\vEv.h0v7,O#vSvs,OGQ

G r!%,G \2c7G$h /,1421+vvvv|2000e,U13.

(2)#vvEvv$vvJbvv2vvJG vvLRGbG vvLXvv.G&vv2,#vv(qvv7G vvrvvJ0vvL,G vvrvv.+vvLI,#vvuvv9vv2vv7Ovv!vvPvv2vv1vv",G vv\vv2vvcvv7G$h vv/,1430+vvvv|2009e,G ?MAG <.&2,U490vvvv49319VLa@

31G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 34: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

VWXYZ[\]^_‘ab

cdef@w|v}(1)@+vvKGG vv$vv1vv<vv.b+vv.COvv.Skvv\vvLIG vv9vv.Dvv1vvJ

kvv2tvv"E&vvPvv.f.kvv. vvlvv\vvLIG vv9vv2kvv\vvLGuG vvHvv0Fvvsbvv!vv1vv,vv.Gqvv9vvYvv:Cf8vv!vv?vv#

G vv(vvlvv.SE vv/qvv.qIbvv!vv1vv.bvv(vvJXvvcvvlvv,vv.,h8vv\vv!vv3evv(vv1vv.Cbvv!vv/bvv(vvJkvvrvvL+vv.,

h8v.qG1v.k

QDv1v$v.k

bv(vJP&v2v,v.,hOv$v1vcv.k

qvL0v2v.k

1vVv1vLGk

bv(vJOv&G v,v.,htv"P vv

0vvJbvv.G vv(vvlvvQE vv/G vv9vv.Dvv1vvJhG)Ovv0e,hG vvcvv.OI1vv. vvYvvLhQIE vv/G vv$vv!vvv

G rJhSG P0e.

qvvvvv.dvvvv8vvvvvcvvvvv. vvvvv/vvvv:{"#$%&’()*+,-./01234

567@ux}(2).

;vvv%bvvvLVGuNbvvv!vvv/G vvvPvvv$vvv.hGJhG$QVhG vvv?vvv2vvv.dG$#vvv.&vvv7

vvEvv$vv!vv,vv.,h8vvEvv$qvv"G vv$vvPvv&h vv1vv7bvv(vv,vv.,kvv#1nvv1rvv)nCf0vvEvv$vv!vv(vv,vv.hCRvvlvvrvv)#vv)

Dvvv$vvv!vvv,vvv.h#vvv)8vvvEvvv$qvvv"G vvv$vvvPvvv&h vvv1vvv7bvvv(vvv,vvv.,;vvv%bvvvLXvvv,vvv.bvvv!vvv/BOep,

kvEv$v!v,v.hGOv9vcvJq

Cf0v9vEv$qv"G v$vPv&h v1v7bv(v,v..h+vKG0vJdqbv!v/Cfq

#vcvLkv7

DvsqG$#v.&v7hG)qvLGQ1v,vKGG vEvs

q,hG/Ov9vcvJGO v!v.kv.A1v-,C#vL#vfvLhRkv2

b$sk\LIG)&P.ft$.>.Ak2G EJ0=G KjhQOb)QO.dGu�:

zEfq

G$#vv.&vv7&vvM vv:kvv2>vvKQqvv!vv.HG vvL>vv.d@@@y(3). vvuvv)G)&vvPvv.ftvv.f

bvv(vvJ8vv(vvlvv1vvKQDvv!vv7G/#vv9vvEvv.fkvv2G vvEvv1vv.IG vvJ&vv1vv.,v̂v!vv.#vv.k

>vv,vv./k

,kvv!vv%0vv&O

(1)G$bLGa:172.

(2)G Lhe:30.

(3)QhGgG 2H.Qj,t9.HG Lq.b,1.HQkdG$#.&7,DJ0=Qq%6497.

32G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 35: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

#vvv)G$#vvv.&vvv7G vvv9vvv2Dvvv$vvv!vvv,vvv.hGOvvv9vvvcvvvJq

Cf0vvv&OqjDvvvrvvv.qvvv,vvv.#vvv.0vvv?vvv3bvvv!vvv1vvv-

k1,.(1).

KG&9P.F"#%q09u.fG)&P.f?+KGG)&P.fG _!.eG ?,.d?

h1vvcvvJG vv9vv##vv"kvv2G vvJQGOvv.JG vv$vv9vvcvv!vvrvv71vv$vvuvv.&vv.JG)&vvPvv.f/Dvv_vv:

C&-#Lt3#)G$>MGAG!817(2):

1vvvvG vvv?vvvPvvvJ:+vvv.#vvv.Gvvv!vvvrvvv-GuN#vvv)8vvvLGH,kvvvuvvv.f[vvv1vvv(vvv.,

h1vcvJ+v.Uv.Q[v1v(v.k

/R1v.k

,;v%8vLc v1v?vmq

kv2G v,v.GAkvuv.fUv!vVv./#v)

kHq

.Q@{KLMNOPQRS@v|}

2vvvvG vLhM:h1v,v.8vuv.fDv1v.IG)&vPv.fh1vHvLh>v,v.0vuv.fG v$v.J,

qvv.dvvvv8vvcvv. vv/vvvv:{:;<=>?@ABCDEFG@z}}(3).

3vvvvG vEv.GS:hn+v2#v(v.kvKG v$vcvLqkv7 v*&vPv.f0v9vcvLqa1v.GOv\v9v,v.E v/

#.0E1]1-#)D.>.JhCR1.Ah#H!.q.J.

4vvvvG vvcvvrvv":hn+vv.PGcG vvlvvuvvLhG)DvvPvv.SG vvKj0vv?vvcvv"G)&vvPvv.f

G vvcvv.qvv"0vvEvv2vvQ&vvlvvPvv-h0vvLOq+vv.bvv)+vv.G+vv..hG vv9vvcvvrqvv"XvvJq

G vvEvv$vv.qvv7hOvv$qvv2

G vcvrv"bvrv0k

,$&v-0vcvrv"(0vEv?vMh0v$v(vd)Uv.Dv2v-,hG vcvrv"kv2G v!vfv7:+v.

(1)bvv2vvJG vvLDvv$vvvsv)DvvPvv)Dvv(vv2vvuvv7G vv$vv1vvJG&vv2,QhGFvvd#vv)Cqvv.GdG vvLOvv.d,O#vvSvvs,OGQG vvrvv!vv%,G \2c7G H.#P7,1412+vvvv|1991e,U335.

(2)bv2vJG vLDv$v)DvPv)Dv2v(vuv7G v$v1vJG&v2,G$Gv0bG)Ov0#v1v7hCOvPv,v.,O#vSvs,OGQG vrv!v%,G \2c7G <. <7,1413+vvvvvv1992e,G $?!JG$hd,229vvvv265vvvv327.

(3)G)OLGA:85.

33G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 36: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

G Ep?LhG (,2,h+.XJq

G E$shG ?,"(1).

C#qvv.G vvcvvrvv"kvv2G vvrvvLBf:kvvrvvJqvv.dvvvv8vvcvv. vv/vvvvkvv1vv-:{./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCD@{y}(2).hXvvdGuNG vvcvvrvv"

kvv2qvv!vv.HG vv$vv$vv9vvEvv(vv1vv)#vv)bvv2vv.Og/&vvcvvLatvv1vvlvv1qvv9vv-,h vvuvv)q&vv9vvcvvLqabvv!vv/

h>.Og#)q.dG !P.fhCkc.dG)&P.f(3).

5vvvvG vvrvv!vv3:#vv)G vv?vv.&vv3G vv$vvEvvPvv.Skvv,vv.G! vv7G vvHvv.Qqvv7G vv9vv2/

8vvvcvvvLaG vvv9vvvcvvv3,kvvv,vvv.G vvvKj8vvv9vvvEvvvrqvvvskvvv1vvv-EDvvvJi#vvvrvvv.q#vvv.JG/Gvvv9vvv1vvv.Qkvvv2

G)&vPv.f,kvrvJqv.dG vfvMG v2:zhG vrv!v3+v.G v?v.&v3G v$vJQc#v)G)&vPv.f,

h+vvv.#vvvEvvv"qG vvvcvvv!vvv%,hG vvv9vvvrvvv.ihG)Gvvv0UhG vvvKtvvvLhG vvvEvvv3qhG vvv2vvvfvvvZ

hG vHv\vLGJ,h+v.#v.XvdG)0v$v.fhG vuvlvL,hG)&v.1v7hG)UvLGQhG v\v$v#&v1v(v7

hG)X\LGHy(4).

hkvv2G vvrvv!vv3#vvLtvvMG vvHvv.G[vvLhDvvJ0vv=G vv(vvlvvQ,Dvv1vv=kvv2G vvrvv!vv3

#vvvvvVvvvvvJQG vvvvvHvvvvv.G[vvvvvLhG$kvvvvvuvvvvv.Q,h#vvvvvEvvvvv"G) vvvvv,vvvvv.ekvvvvv2G)&vvvvvPvvvvv.f.hqvvvvvJ

hUvmGuNG vrv!v31v#&qv-0v$vLVh0vrvPv.1v. v(vlv.b,hC&

qv-0vVvF

q1v. vVvJb

hG)Gv0UhG v9v.Dv1vJ,hqvJ0v2vJhG vrv!v3tv. v2v1v:G v$vrvlv",kv,v./0v(vlv9vF

(1)G1)#(_.Q, P.fG cLH,>MA11,U458.

(2)G E@:46.

(3)#E$.Ob2JG LRGbG LX.G&2,#(7G rJ0L,G $?!JG <.&2,U250.

(4)C1vv2Dvv.#vvJ#vvEvv$vvJG vvfvvMG vv2,EDvv1vv.Abvv!vv.eG vvJ0vv),8vvEvvrvv1vvsbvv2vvJGuG vvHvv. vvJj,1vv1vvLhJ,

RLt7OGQG$Qq%1)C12G$Qq%,G \2c7G$h /,1419+vvvv|1998e,L3,U3.

34G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 37: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

vv.GQOGJG vvHvv1vvLhG vv,vvJG0vv7,E/q

1vv$vvlvv.8vv1vvFGvv.Uqvv7,hqvvJ0vvSvv9vvJ

qG$#vvLDvv9vv/

0vvHvv9vv9vv%h0vv\vv2vvdbvv!vv1vv,vv.,hqvvJ8vvcvv$vv2G vv2vvVvv1vvLIbvv$vv.A8vv.#3vv.,qvv.dvvvv8vvcvv. vv/vvvv:

{XYZ[\]^_‘abcdefghi@ywvjklmnopqrstu@zwv}@@@(1).

6vvvvG vv(vvlvvQ:1vv$vvcvv(vv/G)&vvPvv.ftvv!qvv-QhDvv.

kh>vvPvvJG

k.qvv.dvvvv8vvcvv. vv/vvvv:

{KLMN@vw}(2).

qvvvv.qIG)&vvvvPvvvv.fG)OQGtvvvv1qvvvv7:vvvvG vvvv(vvvvlvvvvQG)&vvvvPvvvv.&vvvv1vvvv7#vvvv)Dvvvv1vvvv=G vvvv(vvvv.Y

hGDvvJI,hEfq

#vv.0vvHvv9vv!vvmkvv1vv-G vv(qvv.S+vv.&vvlvvPvv1qvv.8vv,vv%G vv$vvuvv9vvPvv2vv7@CjCfq

#vv.

kvv\vvLgGuvvvv8vvcvv. vv/vvvvkvv21vv(vv2BOehGDvvJbvv(vvJG vvHvv!vvs,hEfGGvv9vv!vvlvv.Gkvv2

G vvvJQ>vvv7/0vvvHvvv9vvv!vvvlvvv.fkvvv2G vvv(vvv.Y,hCfq

+vvvKGG/Gvvv9vvv0akvvv2G vvvJQ>vvv7+vvv.

QDvv$vv71vv. vvcvv2vv.O vvuvv20vvPvv9vvHvvJe1vvcvvYvv,vv%1vvcvvYvv.OvvHvvL0qvv.,hG vvKj1vvfvv1vvLg/

8vPv9vrv1v%G vEv1v.IG)&vPv.&v1v7.;v%/0vHv9v!vmG vcv!v$v.ACfq

G v2vJf+v.hbv.A+vKg

G v(vlvQ.h+vKGG8vlv.bkv28vLG1v1qv7G v?vPvJG)&vPv.&v2qhkv2&v.YG v(vlvQG v2vSvL0qv7

b(J>$1dG (q.SvvvvQ>0k

t.fCeG#LCIvvvv(3).

C#qvv.#vv(vv.kvvKG vv(vvlvvQ(4)

kvv,vv2:kvv2OGGvv"G)&vvPvv.fqvv.qIEOQGtvv1qvv7tvv2vv1vvLI

h vvuvv)#vvJQtvv.8vv,vv./8vv(vv2vvd#vv)OGGvv!vv,vv.hE&qvv$vv.8vv#8vv1vv,vv.#vv)G vvcvv. vv%G vvHvv.QL

(1)G 9.17:124vvvv125.

(2)G KGQ0.J:21.

(3)&.0m#cLha,G)&P.fhG cr",11LhJ,OGQO21"G LR.O,W1,1995,U153.

(4)bv2vJG vLDv$vvsv)G v$v1vJG&v2,G vcvrv1vJIG)Ov0#v1v7,O#vSvs,OGQG vrv!v%,W6,1992e,U15

vvvv2219VLqa.

35G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 38: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

bvv(vv,vv..h vv,vvKgG vvrvv.qIG)OQGtvv1qvv7kvv2G)&vvPvv.f#vv(vv.kvvK8vv\vv"q#vv(vv,vv.bvv!vv/G vvcvv. vv%

G vvvHvvv.Q>vvv2q(G vvvEvvv.GS#vvv<vvv"G vvv2vvvVvvvLhG vvvKhbhG vvv!vvv$vvvQ,tvvv$vvv. vvv,vvv.Uvvv0J

CGvvLi8vv\vv"q#vv(vv,vv.bvv!vv/bvv. vv%G vv(vvlvvQh8vv9vv$vv<vv"1vvEvv.Ovv7G)&vvlvvcvv./Jtvv. vvLXvv.

hG vfvYv3,hG vEv3qhG vuvLG+v1v7,hDv.Ov7G$ v%,hDv.Ov7G v9v.GRf,hDv.Ov7

G S,.GJ@@@E I.

kv$vrvJGQ#v.8v(vrv"+vKgG vEv.GS#v)Dvrv.Fvs v!vrv.qIG)OQGtv1v7,8vPv9v\v1vd

Cf8vvv9vvvHvvv1qvvv"h8vvvJQch8vvvLtqvvv3h8vvvPvvv9vvv(vvv@G vvvrvvv.GbvvvJG vvvcvvv.#qvvv7,h8vvvrvvv1vvvQG$Rvvv2vvv.g

hG (_.FLb!/1cY,.G 2cZh/8P9\1dR1,.k

e1LP v.

h&vPv9vHv!vW#v)P vv,Cfq

G v(vlvQE&qv$v.8vJQcG$Rv1v.AG v$v(v9vSvLIkv2

+vvKGG vvuvv.fG vvuvv2vv1vvLbvv)[vvL0vvs#vv(vv.kvvK+vv.G vv9vv28vv\vv"q#vv(vv,vv.bvv!vv/G vvcvv. vv%,

h ./+. $.COQt:#)G .>.OG H.Q>2R1,.h 2r1:k2>,"t.#".

GyM+9dhIOhOg:

h>vvcvv"Gu vvJ0vv(vv.kvv2#vvLtqvv3(#vv.Xvvd)qvvJQIG)OQGcRGh0vv7Gvv.U

qvv7

qv.OQIbv!v/8vHv1qv"CRv1v.Aev1vL#v.>v.OIC#v.#v(v.hkvs+vKGG v9vLtv1v3G v9vHv1qv!v2q.

vvvuqvvv(vvv(vvv.#vvv,vvv$vvv.Dvvv.h vvv(vvv.Cf&vvv9vvvHvvv1qvvv"Uvvv.QI#vvv.#vvv)G vvvVvvv.QG vvvfvvvL0vvv2vvv7,Ch

G v?vJ0vJIChG)1vJGbv1v7,h#v,v$v.Ov2vEv(v.kv1v,v.#v)G$h+v.eG vHvLGkv1qv7,kv(&v(v.

/&vvPvv9vv\vv1vvdCf&vvlvvcvv"Rvv1vv,vv.k

>vvJ0vvJGk

Ctvv<vvL#vv)Cf&vvYvv%qC>vvMGAk#vv.>vv.OI

&vcvLkv,v.,h&v$v1qvM+v.,h&vLG+v.kvcv0kv2G vuv.f&vYv$qv,v.1vcvYv,v.E v/1vcvZ,

v(vVv(vd#v(v,v.Rv1v,v.>vJ0vJG&vJqbv2C&qv-#v)G1v9vuv.Q&v.h#v)Uv(vcv(v.hGGv9vLGbv(v.,

vvuvv)kvv2G vv.Gqvvd+vvKgG$>vvMGAqvvJCOQtvv(vv.+vv.kvvcvv0bvv)[vvL0vvsDvv.GOqvv(vv.,

h1vvv.GOvvv\vvv7+vvvKGG vvv9vvvHvvv1qvvv"G vvv$vvv.>vvv.Okvvv2OGGvvv!vvv(vvv.Xvvv$vvv$vvv(vvv.+vvvKgG$>vvvMGA

36G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 39: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

G vv$vv.>vv.OI1vvSvvuvv"#vv9vv2vv.bvvJkvv9vvHvv1vv!vv(vv.+vv.bvv!vv/Rvvuvv"hDvvJI#vv9vv$vv.Ovvuvv7kvv2

Uvvv.QI>vvvJ0vvvJI@ vvvKGkvvv(fq

Gvvv1vvv. vvv(vvv.#vvvEvvvVvvv.QDvvvVvvvLG8vvv.#qvvv.kvvv1vvv$vvv.8vvvJQtvvv-

Dvv.GOvv(vv.,kvv(vvEvv)#vv,vv$vv.Ch8vv1vv(vv.#vv)qvvJQIGvv1vv. vv1qvv7/&vvPvv9vv\vv1vvdCf&vv9vvHvv1qvv"

Dvvrvv1vvrvv7#vv.#vv)G vvEvvrvv.Fvvs#vv. vv%&vv0#vvQCh&vvLCh&vvJQc&vv$vv.P>vv.bvv(vv,vv.

1vEv.GOv(v.,h#v)P vv0vPv9vEv1v"bv!v1v(v.8vHv1qv"G$#v.QG vfv1v2v1qv7#v,v$v.hUv!v:

1(.G rJQIb!/G 9H1q".

h#v)C>v"P vv0vVvcv3bv!v1v(v.1v"h0v9vcvKq

QCf&v9vHv1qv"Dvrv1vrv78vuv.0v)

G $0Fu7hG ?)qhC#<.dP v#)#H!.q.J1c1JIb)#?.dDPq(..

Gygt{hIOhOg:

G vcvrv"#vrv1qvJ1vcv. v%G vEvQq,h/bv$v" v-bv!v/bv. v%G vfv1v3,P vv

$fq

G vvvrvvv.qIG vvvcvvv.qvvv!vvv7kvvv1vvv(vvv.8vvv?vvv$vvvd1vvv1vvv)G vvv$vvvVvvv.qQIhG vvvKGtvvvLIhG vvv$vvvHvvv1vvv!vvv7

hG vvvKtvvv.A(1),h(G vvvcvvvrvvv")#vvvVvvvJQ vvvlvvvcvvv"(bnvvvrvvv"n),Cj+vvv.GOvvv%/h>vvv.O

vKGJ v-kv2G vHv.QL,kv. vEvJK+v.G$#vLG vKj0vrvd1v-G vlv.bv".EPGk

vfv7

vvvv+vvv.Rvvv2AGOvvv$vvv-(G vvvcvvvrvvv")$&qvvv- vvv1vvvQ vvv-PGJ0vvvrvvvdkvvv2OGFvvvLIG vvvEvvv.GS

G vvHvv$vvQ,h/tvv1vv.f vv-0vvcvvLa1vv-,E&vv$vv.0vv_vv,vvLC;vvLg#vv)Gvv0dG vvcvv(vv.UvvL

G vv$vvuvv.q&vv7 vv,vvKGG vvEvvJK.#vv)+vv(vv.&vvJQcC&qvv- vv1vvQ vv!vvcvvrvv"tvv1vv.fPG8vv2q0vv$vvuvv)

Cf8vvvrvvvdbvvv!vvv1vvv-Dvvv.GOqvvv(vvv.,h vvvuvvv2&vvvLiC;vvvLg/1vvvJ

qCf8vvv9vvv%bvvv$vvv!vvv1vvv7G vvvcvvvrvvv"

(G v9vlvuv1vL),h1v. v9v. v2/1vJ#v)8v.GkvLG vcv(v.UvLG v$vuv.q&v- v,vKgG vcv$v!v1v7.C/

h+2:

(1)b2JG LD$vsv)DP)D2(u7G $1JG&2,G cr1JIG)O0#17,U19.

37G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 40: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

Chq/k

:/1Jq#)(hGqd)0u.f#.X.b.

k !9lu1L.

;vvv.&vvv1vvv.k

:/1vvvJq#vvv)G&vvv9vvvrvvv.d+vvvKGG vvv.GqvvvdE vvv/G)&vvvPvvv.f,hP vvvvbvvv)

[L0sD.Oq

7ChCt<L#)G E.GSG H$Qb2Lq(.GJG)DP.S.

;. <.k

:/1Jq#)O#.Z0P9r2"G .GqdG $EP.S.

QG1vcv.k

:/1vJq#v)#vcv!v.#v.JOv.1vrv7#vHvMh&v7kv2G vJ#v.Z v9vlvPv1vL+vKG

G vv.GqvvdG vv?vvJ0vvJ, vvuvv20vv9vv$vvuqvv)G)&vvPvv.f#vv)EUvvJGQDvvuvv%#vv.Dvv.d+vvKG

(G $.X.Y).

h#vv. vv%0vv9vvEvvrqvvsh>vv.O+vvKgG vvcvv(vv.UvvLG$Q1vvcvv7kvv!vv)0vv9vv$vvu

qvv)G)&vvPvv.f

#vv)E8vv$vv.ebvv$vv!vv1qvv7G vv9vvlvvuvv1vvLG vv9vv21vv.&vv9vv,vv.Fvv,vv.0vv9vv%q(G vvcvvrvv")G vvKj8vv$vv1qvvM1vv-

G)&vvPvv.fbvv)Ovv.FvvLG vvcvv?vv$vv.hGJ.h/0vvPvv9vv\vv1vvdG vv$vvLACf0vvlvv.Xvv"1vv1vv)+vvKg

G vvcvv(vv.UvvLG$Q1vvcvv7.kvv. vvJ#vv.ZG vvKj0vv2vvJhvvvv vv!vv.+vv!vv7G$h vv/vvvvC&qvv-G vvcvv(vvVvvL

G$+v%hG$Ov.S,0vlvrvJqv1v$v9v-h/0v9v$vuqv)#v)G vrv1v.e1vJhQgEf v%8vMhqOg

G E.GSq1$.X.b.JG cr"hhq.Fc-(1).

GyJ(GShIOhO$9:

Dv1v(v$v.&v9vEvJKbv)G vEv.GSG vHv$vQtv.GDvJ#v)bv(v.UvLG vcvrv"

kv(&v$v.&vcv(v2G vEv.GSG vHv$vQG v9v28vSvuv"&v.GkvKG/8vVv.d1v1v)G)&vPv.f

h1v1v)#vEv1v\v-G vHv.Q>v2,EP+v2&v.GkvKG v$vcvLkv7G)&vPv.&v1v7G v9v20vSv9vLc

kvv1vv,vv.G vv(qvv.Stvv"qG vv(qvv.S.vvvvCOvv.O+vv%hC1vv1vvYvv,vv%,CDvv$vvL+vv%hCUvvlvvL+vv%,

(1)#cLha,&.0m,G)&P.fhG cr",U178.

38G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 41: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

G vv$vv&#vv)#vv(vv,vv%hG vvuvv.kvvLvvvvC#qvv.G)DvvPvv.SG vvJGGvv!vv2G vv$vv9vv$vv<qvv"1vv. vvSvvcvv.Q

G vv$vv9qvvVvv"1vv. vvEvv.>vv.JG vvcvvYvv.0qvv7ChG vv$vvSvv.bvvLG vvfvvL0vvM0qvv7kvv0OGvv" vv,vv.kvv2

+vvKGG vvSvv#f,/#vv)qvvL0vv3h/#vv)1vvcvv1vvJ,$&qvv,vv. vv1vvPvv:bvv(vvVvvLG

k#vv)

bvv(vv.UvvLG vv9vvlvvuvv1vvL.h/8vvcvvJhCf8vvuvv.qfRvvcvv.QGk

h#vvSvv.bvvL8vv\vv!vv3G)Rvv2vv.Y

vv1vvQevv1vvL(1).hC#qvv.Dvv.GOvv(vv.G vv9vv2+vv2G vvPvv2vv1vv"G vv.Dvv1vvJ vv(vv9vvcvvLqabvv!vv/

G .>.O#)D. (.,k,2#(.kK#EJhOIt$q.ht1l.(2).

h#$.O2s89!HqW J0(.G Er.FsG 9. 17(3):

1vvvvEfq

G E.GSq#EJhOI.

2vvvvEfq

qJQIG 9H1q"k1(.#EJhOI.

3vvvvEfq

br. (.#EJhOI/8P9\1dCf8JQc>$1dG Er.Fs.

h1vvv$vvv.Cfq

G vvvcvvv. vvv%#vvv)Dvvv. vvv(vvv.,#vvvrvvvPvvv.eE vvv/bvvv. vvv%#vvv.Ojq#vvvSvvv,vvv.O

h#vvEvvPvv.S,hbvv. vv%evv1vv2vv2q#vv?vvLqO/0vv$vvuvv)Cf8vvLGgG vvcvv1vv.f,h#vvdP vvv

/0vv$vvuvv)Cf&vv(vvuvvLg vvcvvJeQD0vv9vv(vv. vv-h/0vv$vvuvv)Cf&vv9vvVvv.Qqgtvv$vv.&vvL0vvJ

h/0vv$vvuvv)Cf&vv9vvlvvuvvL1vv-#vv)Gvv0dG vvHvv1vv.dChG vvcvvrvv"$>vv"P vvvkvv(fq

G vv.Dvv2+vv.G vv\vvL0vvsG vv.Dvv1vvJ vv9vvcvvL0vvlvv(vv.1vvEvvrvv.FvvsG$Rvv1vv.AG vvJGGvv!vv7kvv2bvv. vv%

G vvfvv1vv3,h#vv)C>vv"P vvvCQOvv"Gu>vv"qhbvv0G vvLOvv",G vvK0vv)G8vvVvv!vv.G

1v. v.Dv2#v)bv. v%G vfv1v3,kv. v.Dv20v2v!vfv,v%1vcvZG vEvrv.FvsG v$vfv1qv2v7bv(qv.,

(1)#cLha,&.0m,G)&P.fhG cr",U182vvvv183.

(2)b2JG LD$vsv)DP)D2(u7G $1JG&2,G cr1JIG)O0#17,U19.

(3)b2JG LD$vsv)DP)D2(u7G $1JG&2,G cr1JIG)O0#17,U21vvvv22.

39G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 42: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

h+v%0v2v!qvfv.&v(v.#v.&vrv!v.gbv)G v.Dv21vSvuv"0vrv1v(v2qhGXvF.h#v.bv!v1v(v.E/

qCf

&VJq

q,%1$.CG2LhG1-#)b(JGuvvvv8c. /vvvv.

vvvKG0vvv?vvv3Cf&vvv&#vvv)>vvv.R#vvv1vvv)h#vvv9vvv1vvvrqvvv(vvv1vvv)1vvv$vvv.>vvv.A&vvv.bvvv)G vvv.Dvvv2

G vvVvv.Ob,OhfCf&vvM0vvJbvv!vv1vv-Rvv1vv,vv.k

#vv)G vv9vvHvv1qvv0JChG vv9vvVvv.qQGJ,hOhf

Cf&90b3k1-19#h00J.

h1vv,vvKG&vvJQcC&qvv-/0vv$vvuvv(vv(vv.#vvcvvLkvv7G$#vv.QG vvfvv1vv2vv1vv7E/q

bvv)[vvL0vvsG vvvHvvv2vvvLG vvvVvvv.Ob,G vvv$vvvLOvvv"#vvv)Gubvvv)[vvvL0vvvsG vvv.Dvvv2hG vvv$vvv<vvv2qvvv:kvvv2t9.HGuvvvv8c. /vvvv,hG $c.TG $&tqJb)[L0sO(67QO.dGu�@

q q q q q q

40G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 43: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

Gy}"%Hp,EC=9JG}|(QGyj+=+?

C#qvvv.G vvv$vvv(vvv,vvv@kvvv2E;vvv2vvv.JG$#vvv.QG vvvfvvv1vvv2vvv1qvvv7kvvv,vvv.G vvv$vvv(vvv,vvv@G vvvrvvvLB&vvv2

hG EJ0=G (2.jq,h+.#(,@>$1dG LO"hG$&21.A.

h+vv.#vv(vv,vv@Guvvvv8vvcvv. vv/vvvvkvv2Gvv!vvrvv-;$&vv-Cbvv!vv%1vv,vv%h1vv#Dvv.G vv,vv%,

h1vvvvEvvvv.>vvvv.8vvvv,vvvv%.+vvvvKGG vvvv$vvvv(vvvv,vvvv@0vvvvrvvvvmG vvvvcvvvvrvvvv"G)&vvvvPvvvv.&vvvv2qkvvvv1vvvv-bvvvv(vvvvJDvvvvJq

G v9vVvJ0vs1v.u,;v%q1vcvJP vv0v9v!vrqv/#v)+vKGG v$v(v,v@bv)Guvvvv8vcv. v/vvvv,

hG vv9vv.Dvv1vvJXvvLhQIG vv1vvrvv1vv)1vv.uG vv.GDvvJ,hG)0vv$vv.f1vv$vv0Fvvuvv9vv-htvv9vv2vv-hQOvv!vv-

hG 1.eG!GLhG rY.AhG rJQ.

hG vvcvvrvv"G)&vvPvv.&vv2q+vv(vv.0vv9vvJ1qvvLhDvv2Guh0vvlvvrvv,vv-,h/0vvHvv.Vkvv2

+vKgG vrvYv.0v.1vcv1vJGbv$qv.ChDv/Guvvvv8vcv. v/vvvv1v-E v1v-.hbv!v/G v$vPv!v%kv2

+vvKgG vvEvv.dCf0vv9vv#tqvvJ#vv)UvvJb&vvPvv2vv7G vv(vvVvv.UE vv/QOvv.dGu�,

kvvv(ftvvv.&vvv:Uvvv.Oqvvv7,kvvvcvvv!vvv1vvv-Cf0vvv9vvvLcQC0vvv-h+vvv.Gg,h0vvvEvvvuvvv%0vvvrvvv1vvv(vvv.1vvv$vvv.

ChDvv/Guvvvv8vvcvv. vv/vvvv,h#vv)P vvvCRvvLGWG vvPvv.bvv7$fq

kvv1vv,vv.Dvv=q

G vv(vvlvvQ

bv!v/[v.bv7Gu,hG/Ov9vcvJGO v1v.eG vrv1v.#v7,kvlv1v-E0vrv.X v!vfv.kv!v1v),hDv<qv,v%

bv!v/G v9v.1v7,hbvJeG vLtv.fE v/G vJ&v1v.,h+vKG#v.kvcv!v-G v$vVv\vlv/�),

bvv)R0vv(vv31vv(vv:>vvEvvTZC&vv,vv.qvv. vv::GOvv9vv1vvrvvaG vv(vv2vv2q�#vv)G vv(vv.e

41G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 44: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

#vEv$vLGk

h>v,v-0vrv.d:z/E vvsv-E/Gu,h0v" v!vcvLH#v)RvLqqvJGqv9vLH,

kvvv9vvvFG vvv1vvv.e#vvv)QOe0vvv#>vvv.Lh#vvv#>vvv.L#vvv<vvv"+vvvKgy.qvvv1vvv":Cn

&nvvv,vvv!vvvvhkvvv1vvv(vvv.

G vvVvv. vvEvv.f?qvv.d:z&vvcvv%,EPGtvv<vvLG vvHvv2vv=y(1).hkvv1vv-C0vvYvv.k

bvv)CeOvv!vv$vv7

RhLG vvv(vvv2vvv2q�qvvv. vvv::GOvvv9vvv1vvvrvvvaQOvvv.dGu� vvv1vvv!vvv7kvvvMbvvv.k

,0vvvrvvv.d:

zOvv2vvEvv.fGu,#vv.PGC&vvMdGu#vv)G vvHvvMGFvv),h#vv.PGC&vvMd#vv)G vvlvv9vv),#vv)0vv.qvvaUvv.GDvv3G vvEvv?vvLGJvvvv0vvL0vvJCRhG>vv- vvuvv20vvVvv!vv1vv)vvvv,QHqtvv.Ovv1vv7k2G J&1.b.Q07k2G!GLIy(2).

hG$+vv%q#vv)P vvvCf#vv)CRvvLGWG vvPvv.bvv7G vvEvvJ0vv=bvv)G vvlvv9vv)h#vv.

0EJKk2BGLG M#.f,#$.0JkdG)&P.f 19qr2+KgG l9)(3).

#v.G vrv.GbvJG v9v2G8v2vcv,v.G vPv!vmG vVv. vFkv2#vcvLkv7G$#v.QG vfv1v2v1v7,

h#9/1JCG P!mG V. F0rcJ ,KGG c!%?

vrvJ;v2v: vJjq1vcvJG v9vJqv1vskv2#vLG>vcv7tv9v3CUv.dG vlvrv-h#v(v.+v@G v9vSvL0vdG)Ov0#v2(4)vvvvhG v2vcvZ#v)tv9v3G vcvrv1vJIvvvv#v.0vEv1vLG vEv!v1v%#v)

(1)UvvEvv1vvFG vv2vvHvv.Qj,tvv9vv.HG vvlvv9vv),1vv.Hh0vv" vv!vvcvvLH#vv)RvvLqvvJGqvv9vvLH,DvvJ0vv=Qqvv%7059,hQhGg#P!%1EJ0=Qq%2880.

(2)UvvEvv1vvFG vv2vvHvv.Qj,tvv9vv.HG vvlvv9vv),1vv.H/0vv#8vv2R#vv.fE/G vvKj1vvcvvJgCRvvLq#vv(vv-,DvvJ0vv=

Qq%7069.

(3)#vvEvv$vvJ1vv)bvv2vvJG vvLDvv$vvvsv)G vvcvvL0vvlvv2,&vv,vv.0vv7G vvcvv. vv%CRvvLGWG vvPvv.bvv7G vvVvvfvvLihG vvuvv2vvLi,G Pc.O07,[2c7Ch /,OGQG 9J#L07,1431+vvvv|2010e,U4vvvv519VLa.

(4)0(_Lb!/O21"G $<.d:1-G vvvSvvv.kvvvcvvv2(204+vvvv),G$e,1vvv1vvvLhJ,OGQG1vvv)DvvvMe,G vvv\vvv2vvvcvvv7G$h vvv/,1426+vvvv/

2005e.

2-G vvvSvvv.kvvvcvvv2(204+vvvv),G vvvLOvvv. vvv7,1vvv1vvvLhJ,OGQG vvvuvvv9vvv.HG vvvcvvvL1vvv2,O.W,1426+vvvv/2006e.

42G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

=

Page 45: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

tvv1vvlvv1vv7G8vvHvv.P+vvKGG vv$vv(vv,vv@G vvKj0vvPvv1vvLbvv!vv1vv-#vvcvv_vv%G vvSvvcvv.HG vv1vv.ekvv2CUv.dG vlvrv-G)Ov0#v2h#v(v.+v@G v9vSvL0vdG)Ov0#v2,#v)zqv\vcv2qG vJ/ v7yhz^vv(vv2qG vvJ/ vv7y#vv. vv%C>vvJ vv-C;vvLGkkvv1vv$vv.bvv!

qvv$vv(vv.E0vv.gQOvv.dGu�,

h vPv:1vVvJOG vSvLhYkv2tv9v.1v7+vKGG vcv!v%kv21vEv<v2Ov.i#v.Ov#8v\vLb

E vvv1vvv-#vvv)G$GvvvK1vvv#Dvvv.O0vvv=G!Dvvv.Okvvv2G$#vvv.QG vvvfvvv1vvv2vvv1vvv7G vvv9vvv2evvv.1vvv:bvvv(qvvv.hCGvv2vvL&vv.bvv(vv,vv.QOvv.dGu�,h vv)COGvv"kvv2qvv.dG vvPvv!vvmG vvVvv. vvF,

h#vv)+vv%G vvPvv!vvmG vvVvv. vvF,Ch vv$vv.PGG8vvHvvK+vvKGG vvcvv!vv%,G vvKjOvv#8vvEvvJK

b(-D1)G EJ0=b)G lLb,G 92GL>:1cJhk.IQO.dGu�.

vKG,Ef8v9v2qvcv(v.G v9v.Q0vI v$vcvLkv7Chd#v)Ov)q+vKGG vcv!v%&v?vJCfq

,

3-G1v)DvMeG v_v.+vLj(456+vv),G)Dvuv.ekv2CUv.dG$Dvuv.e,1v1vLhJ,OGQG vlvuvL,

O.4,1427-1428+v/2007e.

4-C1vv2Dvv.#vvJG vvfvvMG vv2(505+vvv),G vv$vvPvv9vvVvvlvv/#vv)bvv!vv%G$Uvv.d,1vv1vvLhJ,G vv$vvuvv9vv2vv7

G cVL07,O.W,1430+v/2009e.

5-G1v)qv1v%G v?v.R0v7(751+vv),Ebv0eG v$v.qvcv1v)bv)QHqG vcv. v$v1v),1v1vLhJ,G v$vuv9v2v7

G cVL07,G \2c7G$h /,1424+v/2003e.

6-C1v.EOvEv.bE1vLG+v1v%G vSv.[v2v2(790+vv),G/bv9vVv.e,G vrv.+vLI,OGQG vEvJ0v=,O.W,

1424+v/2003e.

7-h v-C0vYv.k

G v$v.Gkvrv.Jkv2CUv.dG vSvL0vcv7,1v1vLhJ,OGQG v$vcvLkv7,G v\v2vcv7G vPv.OOv7,

1425+v/2004e.

8-#vvEvv$vvJ1vv!vv9vv.>vv2,#vv(vv.+vv@G vv9vvSvvL0vvdG)Ovv0#vv2kvv2G vvrvvLfG vv<vv.&vv2G vv,vv?vvLj,OQGOvv7

CUvv. vv1vv7#vvrvv.Q&vv7 vv$vvVvv.OQG$Dvvuvv.ebvv(vvJG$Fvv$vv7:[R0vvJ1vv)bvv!vv2->vvcvvlvvLG vvVvv.Ob-C1vv.Dvv(vv1vvlvv7-G$hRGbvv2-G vv<vv.Qj-G vv!vv1vv=1vv)OvvcvvJ-#vv. vvv-G vvSvv.kvvcvv2],G vvrvv.+vvLI,OGQG P0e,G \2c7G$h /,1425+v/2004e.

9-#vvEvv$vvJ1vv)bvv!vv2G vvSvv.tvv.&vv2(1250+vvv),EQRvv.OG vvlvvEvv.dE vv/8vvEvvrvv1vvsG vvEvvskvv2bvv!vv%G$U.d,G r.+LI,OGQG P0e,G \2c7G <. <7,1430+v/2009e.

43G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 46: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

kv28v.Q0vIG v9vSvL0vdG)Ov0#v2,G vSv.kvcv2+v.Chd#v)Ov?qv"kv2hXv.M,

h8vvlvvVvv1vv"Gvv\qvv9vv-G vv9vvSvvL0vvcvv1qvv7kvv2GOvv9vv(vv2vv.WG$Dvvuvv.e.h0vvL>vvdG vvPvv2vv3kvv2Cf

q

G vSv.kvcv2Chqd#v)hXvd+vKGG v9vSvL0vd,$&qv- v%0vuv)qvJG1v9vJC1vcvJbvVvL

8vvrvvcvv1vvJqvv.GbvvJ vv!vvcvv!vv.eG vvSvvLbvv1qvv7,h8vv#Uvv1vv"CUvv.d#vv(vv,vv?vv1qvv7 vv,vv.,h8vvJh0vv(vv,vv.

1v\vLbbv!v$v1qv7#v(v_qv$v7.1v"Ef#v?vLqO8vJh0v)G vcv!v.eG vcvL1v1v7tv!

qv,v.qvJ&vSv#kv2

G vvrvvLfG vv<vv.&vv2,h vv%0vvMO+vvLh0vv#GvvKUvv.QI>vv$vv.bvv1qvv7E/kvv2G vv(vvVvvmG vv<vv.&vv2

#vv(vv-.hqvvJCRvv.QE vv/P vvvC0vvYvv.k

COvv9vv.P&vv.#vvEvv$vvJC1vv.R+vvLIDvv1vv=PtvvLCf

R0vvJ1vv)bvv!vv2q vv%0vvJhqf#vv(vv,vv?vv-kvv2G/>vv9vv,vv.O,h vv%0vvlvvcvv"P vvvC0vvYvv.k

C1vv.

Dvv(vv1vvlvv7,h/G$hRGbvv2,h/#vv. vvv,h1vvK vvv0vvuvv.fG vvSvv.kvvcvv2y+vv.Chqd

E#vv.e1vv1qvv)#vv(vv,vv?vv-,$fq

G vv9vvJh0vv)h8vv#Uvv1vv"G vvcvv!vv.etvv!qvv,vv.qvvJv̂v,vvLJbvv!vv/

bv,vJg;h#v.0v,v$qv(v.+v.G v$v(v,v@G vKjG8v2vcv-G vVvEv.1v7,QXv.GfGubv!v1v,v%,

kvv2G vv9vvVvvJ0vvs1vv.$#vv.QG vvfvv1vv2vv1qvv7.kvv2vv. vvcvv.OIE vv/G vvlvv9vvLIG vvM#vv(vv1vv7G vv.Gqvvcvv7kvv2

G vvrvvLfG$hdhG vv<vv.&vv2G vv,vv?vvLj,&vvLiCf#vv)G/Fvv$vv7G vvK0vv)bvv.UvvLhG+vvKg

G l9LIhks#10O+%+%t.!82:

1vvvvG)#.eC1.D(1l7G (c$.f(80vvvv150+vvvv)@

2vvvvG)#.e#. v(93vvvv179+vvvv)@

3vvvvG)#.eOl1.fG <.Qj(97vvvv161+vvvv).

4vvvvG)#.eOl1.f1)b11(7(107vvvv198+vvvv).

5vvvvG)#.eb2JGu1)#2.Qc(118vvvv181+vvvv).

6vvvvG)#.eG S.kc2(150vvvv204+vvvv).

44G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 47: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

7vvvvG)#.eC1.G r.O%1)O0q

e(150vvvv224+vvvv).

8vvvvG)#.eCD$J1)D(2"(164vvvv241+vvvv).

9vvvvG)#.eG 2H.Qj(194vvvv256+vvvv).

10vvvvG)#.eG JQG#2(200vvvv280+vvvv).

11vvvvG)#.eC1.OGhO(204vvvv261+vvvv).

12vvvvG)#.e#P!%(204vvvv261+vvvv).

13vvvvG)#.eG 9L#Kj(209vvvv279+vvvv).

14vvvvG)#.eG1)#.>-(209vvvv273+vvvv).

15vvvvG)#.eG (P.F2(215vvvv303+vvvv).

C#q.G rLfG <.&2hG <. =krJ>.A:

1vvvvC1.1uL1)GM0$7(223vvvv311+vvvv).

2vvvvC1.>clLG \E.hj(238vvvv321+vvvv).

3vvvvC1.G EP)G$RcLj(260vvvv324+vvvv).

4vvvvC1.b2JGu1)#(Jg(310vvvv395+vvvv).

+vvv&/A8vvv.1vvvcvvv.G vvv9vvv.1vvvcvvv1vvv)Ovvv.QhGbvvv!vvv/OQHG vvvVvvvEvvv.1vvv7G vvvuvvvLGekvvv2

kv,v$v,v% v!v9v.Dv1vJhG vcvrv1vJIG)Ov0#v1v71vlv\vL8v,v%G v(vrv1qv7,hDv.RhGbv!v/#vL8v2v7

bvv!vv%G vv1vvrvv1vv)hbvv1vv)G vv1vvrvv1vv)hDvvsG vv1vvrvv1vv),1vv9vvVvvJ0vvsGvv2vvLQOvv.dGu�,

$fb!%G 1r1)RLW#)RLhW/E vsv-E/Gu.

45G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 48: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

8vvLi+vv"kvvLqbG vvVvvEvv.1vv71vv1vv)CDvv.O0vv=QOvv.dGu�?kvv. vv$vvcvvLha

Cfq

G vVvEv.1v7hG v9v.1vcv1v)tv.&v.G0v9v!vrqv.f&vVv.UG vrvLBfG vuvL0v%h#v.;v2v:kv2

G vvPvv(vv71vv. vv9vvVvvJ0vvshG vv9vvPvv!vv1vv%h0vvrvv.1vv!vv.&vv,vv.1vv. vvHvvYvv.YhG vvEvv3hG vv9vvcvv_vv1vv%,kvv0

0vvlvvLqqvv.fkvv1vv,vv.1vv1vv)G vv$vv9vv.G8vvLhG!Dvv.O,1vv"C0vvrvv(vv.G1vvlvv\vvL8vv,vv%G vvPvv!vv1vv$vv7Cf

>v$v1vd#v.UvFqh#v.;v2v:bv)QOv.dGu�+v.hDv2#v)GuNE v/

Ovv.FvvLG vvcvv2vv.O,h/1vvJq vv,vv%Cf0vvVvvJ

qqvv.GGvv2vvLg1vvSvvLWG vv1vvrvv1vv),h/1vvJ

q#vv)

8(l1KC#Lg1u$.dG/&r1.O(1)@

hqvvvJCkvvvLOG vvv2vvvHvvv.Qjkvvv2UvvvEvvv1vvvEvvv-tvvv9vvv.1vvv1vvv)0vvvJ/q

fbvvv!vvv/UvvvJb+vvvKG

G vvuvv0e:tvv9vv.HCGvv2vv.QG!Dvv.Ohtvv9vv.HG/bvv9vvVvv.e1vv. vvuvv9vv.HhG vvPvv(6vv7,kvv?vv.A

kvvv2G vvv2vvv.HG$hd:#vvv.>vvv.Akvvv2E>vvv.RIGvvv2vvvLG vvv.GDvvvJG vvvVvvvJhbkvvv2G$PGf

hG vvvVvvv0IhG vvvVvvv.ehG vvvlvvvLGFvvvZhG$Dvvvuvvv.e,C#vvv.tvvv9vvv.HG/bvvv9vvvVvvv.ehG vvvPvvv(6vvv7

hXvFG+v9v$v.#v-kv2G$1v.GHE v/G$GvK1v#Dv.O0v=QOv.dGu�#v)ev1vL

t<LIG P&GdhG f!.k2G J0)hG 2JY,hPeG LCjh8u!mG r1.S(2).

hG8vvlvvsG vvVvvEvv.1vv7bvv!vv/G vvcvv$vv"1vvHvv2vvLG vv.GDvvJ,h+vv.tvv$vv.bvvLkvv(vv.:#vv.

QhGgG vv.GDvvJChG/;vv(vv.fOhfCf0vv2vv!vvgDvvJG vv9vv.G8vvLChG vvSvv,vvLI,hbvv$vv"

G vvvVvvvEvvv.1vvv71vvv-kvvv2hqvvv.Fvvvd/8vvvcvvvJh/8vvvEvvvVvvv/..h0vvvrvvv.dG1vvv)C1vvv2G vvvcvvvMq

G vvEvv(vvlvv2:zhGvv2vvLG vv.GDvvJEPG8vv!vvrvv9vv-G$#qvv71vv. vvrvv2vv.dbvv$vv0k

1vv-h8vvVvvJ0vvrvv.k

vv-

(1)Uvv0Mbvv2vvJG vvlvv9vv.MG vvHvv. vvJj,G vvrvv2vvPvv.JG vvPvv(vv1vv7kvv2RvvLMG vvcvvrvv1vvJIG vv\vvEvv.h0vv7,U131.

#vvEvv$vv.Obvv2vvJG vvLRGbG vvLXvv.G&vv2,CUvv.dG vvcvvrvv1vvJI,G vv$vv?vv!vvJG vv<vv.&vv2,U923.hG vv.G1vv",0vvv.Ovvvmbvvv2vvvJGu,CRvvvLGWG vvvPvvv.bvvv7,G vvvL0vvv.V,G vvv$vvv$vvv!vvvuvvv7G vvvcvvvL1vvv1vvv7G vvvPvvvcvvv.O0vvv7,OGQG1vvv)G ?.Rj,G \2c7G 9.Oc7,1418+vvvv|1997e,U41.

(2)UE1FG 2H.Qj,t9.HG/b9V.e1. u9.HhG P(67,U1387.

46G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 49: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

0vvlvv1vvJG vvcvv!vv%G vv1vvrvv1vv(vv2bvv(vvJ>vv$vv.+vv1vvLG$#qvv7,h+vv.CDvvJqvvPvv$vv2G vv$vv9vv.G8vvLh vv%

0u)11)O!mG$#q7k2P v&MGYy(1).

hkvv2QhG0vv7#vvPvv!vv%:tvv"#vv.;vv2vv:bvv)G vv(vv2vv2q�C&qvv-CGvv2vvL1vv.qvv.bvv-

kvvvvv.)0vvvvv$vvvvv.f1vvvvv-hG>vvvvv3,hP vvvvvv#vvvvv)8vvvvvEvvvvvrvvvvv1vvvvvsG vvvvvSvvvvv,vvvvv.OI1vvvvv#fq

#vvvvvEvvvvv$vvvvvJGQOvv.dGu�,8vvEvvrvv1vvrvv,vv.#vv)CUvv.dG)0vv$vv.f,h/0vvuvv.fG vv$vvLA#vv&#vv(vv.#vvcvvVvv.eG vvJehG vv$vv.dDvv9vv/0vvEvvr

qvvsG vvSvv,vv.OI1vv. vvLOvv. vv7, vvrvv.dG vv(vv2vv2�

zC#vvvLJCfCqvvv.8vvv"G vvv(vvv.SDvvv9vvv/0vvvSvvv,vvvJhGCf/E vvv-E/q

Guh0vvv&#vvv(vvv.G1vvv2h1v$v.>v,v:1v-kv(PGkvcv!v.GP vvbvVv$v.G#v(qv2O#v.A+v%hC#v.G v,v%E/

q1vEvr

qv,v.

hDP.1,%b!/Guy(2).

vKGtv"#v.CGv2vL1v-QOv.dGu�,G)0v$v.f1v-#v9vcv!qvs1v. vcvrv1vJI,

$&q

-/09%qG)0$.f1. LO.d�E/q

1.)0$.f1#G2.Qg.

C#qvv.G1vv)DvvMeG vv$vv9vv.kvv/456+vvvvvvkvvrvvJPtvvLkvv2tvv9vv.1vv-G)Dvvuvv.ekvv2

CUvvvv.dG$Dvvvvuvvvv.eqvvvv.d:qvvvv.dC1vvvv.Ovvvv!vvvv1vvvv$vvvv.fhG vvvvEvvvvPvvvv1vvvv)bvvvv)C1vvvv2bvvvv!vvvv2

G vvuvvLG1vv1vvPvv2,hG vvEvv.QK1vv)COvvJG vv$vvEvv.Ovv2vv2hevv1vvL+vv%,Cfq

Gvv2vvLG vv.GDvvJ

G vvcvvJdbvv)#vv<vv!vv-E vv/QOvv.dGu�0vv.>vv3G vvcvv!vv%hG vvcvv$vv"#vvcvv.,h1vv,vvKG

&vrv.d:#v.&vrv!v-G v.GDvJbv)G v.GDvJ,kv,vKGEPGG8vVv"1vLhG0v7G vcvJhdE v/

QOvv.dGu�h>vv3G vvcvv$vv"1vv-,hh>vv3G vvcvv!vv%1vvVvvEqvv9vv-C0vvYvv.(3)@@@

(1)bv!v21v)C1v2G vcvM,RvLMG vcvrv1vJIG v\vEv.h0v7,Dvrvrv-1vSv1vL#vEv$vJbv1v.f,O#vSvsh1v1vLhJ,

#u927G $&0Jh#u927G 21.f,W3,1413+vvvv|1992e,G ?MAG <.&2,U394.

(2)QhGg#vPv!v%#v)DvJ0v=C1v2+vL0vLIS,tv9v.HG)0v$v.f,1v.HG$#vL1vrv9v.dG v(qv.SDv9v/0r. .G/E -E/Gu#E$JQO.dGu,DJ0=Qq%34.

(3)G vvHvv2vvLG vv.GDvvJG vvcvvJdG vv$vv9vvVvv"E vv/QOvv.dGu�kvv2CDvvuvv.eG vv9vvSvvL0vvd0vv.>vv3G vvcvv!vv%,h/0?.Rk1-G 29q-G uKHh/G .+%.

47G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 50: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

hG vv2vvL+vv.fbvv!vv/UvvEqvv7h>vv.Hqvv2vv. vv-qvv.dGuN:{789:;<=>?@ABCDEFG}(1)hqv.dC0vYv.:kvVvF

qCfq

tv0eQOv.dGu�tv!qv-kv2

G vJ0v)hhDv2#v)bv(vJGuN,/Rvvq

kv2P vvh/Gv0a1v1v)CDvJ

#vv)C+vv"G vv!vvfvv7hG vvSvvL0vvcvv7kvv2Cfq

tvv"hDvv2&vvMd#vv)bvv(vvJGu8vvcvv. vv/kvv,vv.

PtvvL#vv(vvMqd,kvv. vv.Dvv2tvv!qvv-#vvEvvlvv.X1vvEvvlvvaGu8vvcvv. vv/ vv-1vv1vvrvv1vv),htvv"#vv.

8vvuvvlqvv"Gu1vvEvvlvv_vv-kvv$vvYvv$vv.fC/

q0vvYvv1vvd#vv(vv-hC/

q0vvEvvLqa#vv(vv-Rvv2AC1vvJG

8EL0l./0#82G 21.f12\0&-(2).

C#qv.#v.C;v2v9v-G1v)qv1v%G v?v.R0v7kv2tv9v.1v-#vHv9vVvLG vVv.GbvsG v$vLOv!v7

bvv!vv/G vv?vv,vv$vv1qvv7hG vv$vvcvv\qvv!vv7qvv.dbvv)Gvv2vvLG vv.GDvvJ:EPGUvvFqG vvHvv2vvLbvv)

QOv.dGu�,hQhGgG v<vrv.JhG$Fv$qv7hCOv(vJgGv!vlv,v%bv)Ov!vlv,v%E v/

G v(v2v2�,h8v!vrv9v-G$#qv71v. vrv2v.d,kv(&qv-0v.>v3G vcv!v%kv1v$v.Ov2v1v!v-G vcv$v",

+KGq.db.#q7C+"G EJ0=hG $<rl1)#)G r.F$1)b!/G P(7(3).

hqvvvJ&vvvrvvv"G vvvPvvvlvvv.Q0vvv(vvv2kvvv2tvvv9vvv.1vvv- vvv.G#vvvdG$&vvv.GQ(4):bvvv)G)#vvv.e

EOvEv.b1v)QG+v.0v-.qv.dkv2G v$vPv.qOICfq

>vEvJCDvJCGv2v.QG!Dv.OtvlvL,

(1)G 9.17:122.

(2)G1vvv)DvvvMeG vvv_vvv.+vvvLj,G vvv$vvv9vvv.kvvv2456,G$Dvvvuvvv.ekvvv2CUvvv.dG$Dvvvuvvv.e,1vvv1vvvLhJ,OGQ

G vvlvvuvvL,&vvPvvHvv7#vv(vvrqvvEvv71vv(RvvLGa#vvuvv9vv3G vv2vvEvv.KhG vvJQGOvv.J,O.W,1427+vvvvvv|2007e,

G$hd,U80.

(3)G1vv)qvv1qvv%G vv?vv.R0vv7,G vv$vv9vv.kvv2Ovv(vv7728+vvvvvv,#vvHvv9vvVvvLG vvVvv.GbvvsG vv$vvLOvv!vv7bvv!vv/G vv?vv,vv$vv1vv7hG vv$vvcvv\vv!vv7,8vvEvvrvv1vvsOvv1vvJE1vvLG+vv1vv%,G vvrvv.+vvLI,OGQG vvEvvJ0vv=,/.W,1425+vvvvvv|2004e,

551.

(4)#E$JG Pl.Q0(2, .G#dG$&.GQ,1vvvv19.

48G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 51: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

kv.!Dv.Otv. v$v9v.G8vLbv(vJ&v.kv(&qv-0v.>v3G vcv!v%hG vcv$v"1v-.C#qv.G vJtv9v.Qbv$vL

Ovvv!vvv1vvv$vvv.fG$RvvvrvvvLkvvv2tvvv9vvv.1vvv-G vvvcvvvrvvv1vvvJIkvvv2Gu(1)qvvv.d:hE&vvv(vvv.Ef vvv%&vvvrvvv"

1vuvlvLg,&vrv.d: vrvJOv!vv+vKGG vKjQOqCDv.O0v=G vLOv.d�G vVvEv.M

kv2G/Dv9v?v.L1v,v.kv2G vcvrv.FvJ#vPv!vuv.1v1qv)G vHv\v#,h0vHvSv/bv!v1v-Cf0vM0vg

1vvPvv2vv3QOqg vv,vvKgG$Dvv.O0vv=hCf0vv2vv9vv!vv1vv-Gu1vv. vv$vvYqvv0J{NOPQRSTUVWXY}(2).

hPtvvvLG1vvv)G vvvVvvv0Mkvvv2#vvvrvvvJ#vvv9vvv-:zCfq

#vvv.G8vvvlvvvsbvvv!vvv1vvv-G vvv2vvvHvvv.Qj

h#vPv!v%#v)G vEvJ0v=#vrv\v.Y1vVvEqv9v-,hG vcv!v%G v1vrv1v(v2G v(v_vLjhGqvd1v-,

Gvv0kvv. vvrvv.d#vv)&vvlvv/P vvv#vvEvv9vv?qvv.C&qvv-/0vvlvv1vvJkvv2CUvv!vv-E/

qG vv_vv),

hE&qv$v.8v!vrqv9v-G$#qv71v. vrv2v.d,$&

qv-0v?v3bv!v1v,v%G vcv$v"1v. v_v)q,hG v_v)qqvJ

0vHv\v-,hqvJtv(v:C#v1v"E v/+vKGhCDvPv2v-qv.0qv.,;v%1v.f v2Cfq

G v$vK+v3

G vvvvKjGGvvvv9vvvvL&vvvv.gChq/+vvvv.G vvvvVvvvvEvvvv1vvvvF$&qvvvv-^vvvv)#vvvv)+vvvv.#vvvvcvvvvVvvvv.e#vvvv)

G vHv\v#y@@@h+vKg&vuv9v7&vlv1vPv7&v.kvcv7h#v)kv.GFvJ+v.:G vrv.d1v#f#v.G&vlvLO

1vv-G vv2vvHvv.QjCh#vvPvv!vv%,#vv(vvJQLkvv2qvv2vv1vv"#vv.0vvrvv\vvd1vvVvvEvv9vv-, vv9vv!vvrvv2G$#qvv7

t"hGDJ#)t9.11,$.1. r2.dy(3).

h0vrv.dG vSv.tv.&v2:zh/&vMGYkv2Cfq

Gv2vLG v.GDvJ,EPGhqvdG)>v$v.Ybvv!vv/G vvcvv$vv"1vv$vvrvv9vvYvv.g,kvv(&qvv-0vvlvv1vvJG vvcvv!vv%,$f

qG)>vv$vv.Ybvv!vv1vv-Uvv1qvvLg#vv)

(1)bvvv$vvvLOvvv!vvv1vvv$vvv.fG$RvvvrvvvL,G vvvcvvvrvvv1vvvJIkvvv2Gu,bvvv$qvvv.fvvvvG$QOf,OGQG vvv(vvvlvvv.FvvvQ,W10,

1415+vvvv|1995e,63.

(2)G (.Q:63.

(3)G vvEvv.kvvaR0vv)G vvJ0vv)G vvcvvLGqvv2(806+vvvvvv),G vv9vvrvv1vv1vvJhG)0vvYvv.MRvvLM#vvrvvJ#vv7G1vv)G vvVvv0M,11LhJ,OGQG EJ0=,W2,1405+vvvv|1984e,28.

49G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 52: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

G $c!.eUJq-,h+uKGG2LG .GDJEPG8!rq9-G$#q71. r2.dy(1).

h1vvvvK vvvvv&vvvvLiCfq

CFvvvv$vvvv7G vvvvPvvvv!vvvvmh8vvvv.1vvvvcvvvv1vvvv,vvvv%0vvvvEvvvv9vvvv?qvvvv.f1vvvv.$Gvvvv2vvvv.Q

G vvvVvvvEvvv1vvvEvvv7OhfG vvv(vvv_vvvLE vvv/qvvvYvvv1vvv7G vvvrvvv\vvvdhG vvv_vvv)q,hOhf8vvvlvvvL0vvvs1vvv1vvv)

G$Dvuv.ehG vcvrv.FvJh1v1v)#v.8vcv%q1v-G v2v!v.ih#v./8vcv%q1v-G v2v!v.i,h1v1v)

#vv.0vvPvvrvv]1vv. vvSvv2vv,vv.Jh#vv./0vvPvvrvv]1vv,vv.,h1vv1vv)#vv.RGObvv!vv/G vvrvvLBfh#vv.

tv.f#v2v1v(v. v-Ch#v.Gkvrv. v-,h1v1v)#v.0vrv.dE&qv-#vHv. vm v!vrv1v.SCh#v.Gkvs

vv-,1vv"tvv.&vv.G0vv#GvvKhf1vv. vvEvvJ0vv=#vv9vv/UvvFqh vv%0vv.>vvJDvvJ0vv=UvvEvv1vvF

&.OI -(2).

C#q.G P23k2bJeG$GK1#G2.QG!D.Ok,.t. 9. 2:vvvv

0vvrvvPvv%G vvcvv!vv$vv.AG vvcvv!vv%G vvKj>vv.A1vv-QOvv.dGu�#vv)Q1qvv-E vv/

;0;7CqP.e:vvvv

1vvvvqvPv%EGv2v.Qjh+v.0v9vcv!qvs1v##v.QG vfv1v3hG!GvLItvVvlv.JGu

Ov2vEv.&v-h8vcv. v/hCbv$v. v-hG vLOv./JhG v$v0Fvuv7hG v?v(qv7hG v(v.QhG vEvPv.H

he1LP v#$.0JG"k2#P.F"G f13.

2vvvvhqvPv%0v9vcv!qvs1v.$bv$v.dh+v.G v9vSvL0vdhG$bv$v.dG v9v2tv!vlv(v.1v,v.

kvv$vv(vv,vv.#vv.0vv9vvcvv!qvvs1vv. vvVvv!vv71vv1vv)G vvcvv2vvJhQ1qvv-kvv9vvPvv$qvv/G vvcvv2vv.OGJhCbvv_vv$vv,vv.

(1)G vEv.kva#vEv$vJ1v)bv!v2G vSv.tv.&v2,G v$v9v.kv/1250+vvvvv,EQRv.OG vrvEv.dE v/8vEvrv1vsG vEvskvv2bvv!vv%G$Uvv.d,8vvEvvrvv1vvsCO.Rvvcvv2vv.f#vvEvv$vvJEOvv$vv.bvv1vv",G vvrvv.+vvLI,OGQG vvPvv0e,W3,

1430+vvvv|2009e,1|176.

(2)C1vv2bvv2vvJGu#vvEvv$vvJG vvSvv.kvvcvv2(204+vvvvvv),G vvLOvv. vv7,8vvEvvrvv1vvsGvv. vvJG vvPvv2vvdG vvcvv!vv$vv2,R+vv1vvLRl1sG u22,11LhJ,OGQG u9.HG cL12,O.W,1426+vvvv|2006e,296vvvv297.

50G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 53: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

G vVv0IhG vVv.ehG vMtv.IhG vEv@,h#v(v,v.#v.0v9vcv!qvs1v1v)G v(v.S1vcvYv,v%#vd

1vcvZtv. vMhGLhG v\v0bhG v2v1vd,hG v,v2v7hG v$v1vLGKh+vuvKGtv.kv7G vSv&hf

G $. 17hG P1.O17@@@

3vvvvhqvvvPvvv%;vvv. vvv=:vvvv0vvv9vvvcvvv!qvvvs1vvv. vvvuvvv$vvv.dG)&vvvPvvv.&vvv2h+vvv.G$Gvvv0b

hG vv9vvMtvv1vv7,h+vvKGG vvrvvPvv%0vv9vvcvv!qvvs1vvuvv0G vvrvvPvv$vv1vv)G!&vvlvv1vv).kvv,vv.#vv)&vv.Dvv1vv7

bvv$vv"qvv!vv2vv2,tvvPvv0#vv7G vvVvvJQ#vv)G vvfvv"qhG vvEvvPvvJ,h+vv.#vv)&vv.Dvv1vv7;vv.&vv1vv7

bv$v"v̂.+vLjq8vSvL0vcv2q,tv. vPv$v.Dv7hG v2vKdhG vSv?v.bv7hEtvLGeG vYv1vmh#v.

E /P v#)Cb$.d^.+L07.

hG vvrvvPvv%G$hqd:G vvcvvrvv.FvvJ/0vvJGvv!vv-G vv9vvfvv1vv1vvLh/G vv9vv2vvJ0vv"h/R0vv.OI

Ch&rWk,.;.1:k2G LO./J>$1c,.hb!/ P.fG$&21.A>$1c..

hC#qvv.G vvrvvPvv%G vv<vv.&vv2:kvv,vv.Gvv.Xvvd vv!vv_vvLhahG vv$vv01vvPvv.JhG vvM#vv.f

hG vvv$vvvuvvv.f1vvv"+vvv.kvvv2DvvvLtvvv7OGFvvv$vvv7tvvv$vvv.qvvv.d8vvvcvvv. vvv/:{DEF

GH}(1).h vvK vvvGGvv9vv!vvlvv:RvvLGFvvdG$&vv2vv1vv.A1vvcvvYvv,vv%bvv)1vvcvvZ,

h/0vvcvv(vv2+vvKGG/Gvv9vv0a#vv)>vv$vv1vvdG vv.>vv.g1vv"CUvv.dG vvSvvLGFvvdC0vvYvv.

#9qlr7.

h1vv. vvLevv%#vv)Cfq

RvvL0vvcvv7G)Ovv0eqvvJtvv$vv!vv:1vv.kvv.IG vv(vv2vv2�kvv(fq

G vv$vvPvv!vv$vv1vv)kvv28vv.Q0vvHvv,vv%G vv\vv.0vv"qvvJGDvv9vv.>vv.GE vv/Cf0vvPvv9vv(vv2vv\vv.G#vv)+vvKg

G vSvL0vcv7CDvuv.#v. vrvYv.0v.+v%h#vSvuv08v,v%G v$v9v?vJq

OI1v9v?vJq

OG vM#v.fhG v$vuv.f

hG vvEvv.GOK.h vvK vvvtvv.f8vvSvvL0vvdDvv1vv.I#vv9vvEvvLqtvv7#vv9vv?vvJq

OI1vv9vv?vvJq

OG vvEvv1vv.I.

(1)G $.FJI:48.

51G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 54: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

h+vKG0vcv(v2C0vYv.hqvmG v9vSvL0vd v!v.qv.FvdG v$v9vfv1qvLI,+v.bvMdG vSvL0vcv7bv)

Dv1v.IG v(v.S$fq

G vEv1v.I#vPv9v$vLqI,h v!v9vSvL0vdXv.G1v] v,vKgG vEv1v.IhG vEvLtv7

#vvPvv9vv$vvLqI.hEPG8vvHvv!qvvlvv:+vvKgG vvYvv.G1vv]G&vvlvv!vv:G vv(vv.SE vv/RvvLGFvvdCGvvLi

hqv.G&v1v)>vJ0vJI,h+vKG#v.DvJK8v$v.#v.1v. v(vPv2v7 v!vSvL0vcv7G)Ov0#v1qv7Dv1v=

bvvM vv:bvv)Dvv1vv.IG vv(vv.S,hbvv)G vv9vvrvv(vv1vv) vv,vv%1vv?vv$vv.OG vvEvvLtvv7G vvlvvrvv,vv1qvv7

G 9SL0c1q7Chq/,;%1. cMdG P1.O2hG/>9$.b2 !9SL0dG)O0#2.

G vvvrvvvPvvv%G vvv<vvv. vvv=:hC#qvvv.G$Gvvv0bkvvv2vvv. vvvLevvv%#vvv);vvv2vvv.8vvv,vvv.#vvv)Dvvv1vvv=

G vvv$vvv2vvv.O+hG$Uvvv.d,kvvv. vvv?vvv.&vvv3G vvvcvvv$vvv!vvv2kvvv1vvv,vvv.0vvv9vvvfvvv1qvvvL8vvv2vvvcvvv. vvv!vvv_vvvLha

hG v$v01vPv.J,kv. vVv2vLhG vSv?v.bv7hG vuvLehEftv.fG v$vcv(v/G$Uv!v2kv1v,v.

;.19.1.q1.,E/q

Cfq

G $.GqmG 928r9Y2P v#9f1qLIC0Y..

vKGG$GvK1vEvJ0v=G!Dv.O+v.#v)G$Dv.O0v=G v9v28vPv9v!vMeG$GvK

1v,v.hE/q

QOqJ#v,v.JG$Dv.O0v=G vVvEv1vEv7G v<v.1v9v7bv)G v(v2v2q� v$v?vLqO

tvv.&vv,vv.kvv2G vvcvvrvv1vvJI(1),h vvrvvJPtvvLO.bvv$vvLG$RvvrvvLkvv2tvv9vv.1vv-G vvcvvrvv1vvJI;

G cr.FJG 92;29:1#D.O0=G!D.OG VE1E7#(,.:vvvv

1vvvvCkY!17&21(.�b!/>$1dG$&21.AhG $LO!1).

2vvvvRl.b9-G c_$/k2G $ESL.

3vvvvRl.b9-�$+"G u2.FL#)C#q9-.

(1)#vvEvv$vvJ&vv.UvvLG vvJ0vv)G$ vv2vv.&vv2,h>vv.HG$GvvK1vv#Dvv.O0vv=G!Dvv.Okvv2G vvcvvrvv1vvJI,O#vvSvvs,

#vuv9v2v7OGQ1v)bv2vJG vLDv$vvsv)1v)bv!v2G v?vL0vPv2,O.W,1974e,19vvvv201v9vVvLqa.h v-

C0vvYvv.:G vvEvvJ0vv=Dvv?vv71vv(vvlvvPvv-kvv2G vvcvvrvv.FvvJhG$Dvvuvv.e,G vvL0vv.V,#vvuvv9vv2vv7G vv$vvcvv.Qa vv!vv(vvSvvL

hG 9.R0d,G \2c7G$h /,1425+vvvv|2005e,49vvvv50.

52G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 55: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

4vvvv#c?MG8-t!q

,.#.bJGG rLBf.

5vvvvtvv1vvlvv1qvv71vvJAG vvHvv!vvs,hUvvlvv-G vv$vv0Fvvuvv7hG vv?vv),hUvvlvv-G vv?vv(qvv7

hG (.Q,#$q. %0KtLk2G rLBfG uL0%.

6vvvvO&Gd#(uLh&u1Lk2G r2L.

7vvvvXf\7G r2L !$1:.

8vvvvG VLGW,hG E.V,hG $1MGfPhG ulq

91).

9vvvvG)0vvv$vvv.f1vvv#fq

Gu8vvvcvvv. vvv/tvvv9vvv3bvvv!vvv/tvvv"E&vvvPvvv.fOvvvcvvv.O8vvv-Ch

Rr.h8-,hQRq-hC>!-h+.k21\)C#q-.

10vvvvGvvvvVvvvv.Uvvvv1qvvvv.8vvvv-�,G vvvv9vvvv2>vvvv$vvvvcvvvv,vvvv.G vvvvPvvvv1vvvv.[vvvv2kvvvv2tvvvv9vvvv.H

zG HV.FWG u2LiyhEO0eqL0(-#)G ?).

11vvvvG r\d1#fq

G cSLIG $2SL0)1. ?(q7#)C+"G ?(q7.

12vvvvbJeG!.OC+"G u2.FLk2G (.Q.

13vvvvG)0v$v.f1vuv"q#v.UvFq

kv2G vEvJ0v=kv2Uvlv7G vrv1v.#v7hG vEvSvL

hG (SL#$q. %0LOk2G rLBfG uL0%.

14vvvvG)0vv$vv.f1vv#RvvLGWG vvPvv.bvv7,tvvHvvLhLG vv$vv,vvJj,h&vvMhdbvv1vvPvv/

bvvv!vvv1vvv-G vvvPqvvv0e,hGvvvLhLG vvvJ>

qvvv.d,hGvvvLhLG vvv(qvvv.Q,h[vvv!vvv.YG vvvSvvv$vvvQ#vvv)

#fL1,.,hG JG17,he1LP v.

hG vVv.GH#v)G vrv.dEfq

CDv.O0v=G!Dv.OG vVvEv1vEv78vlv1vJG v1vrv1v)EPG

GDvv9vvlvv:1vv,vv.qvvLGFvv)hO/Fvv"tvv$vv.&vvrvv!vv(vv.P vvvbvv)>vv$vv!vv7#vv)C+vv"G vvcvv!vv%,

53G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 56: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

kv.$Dv.O0v=G v9v2hQOJkv2tv9v3G vPv(v7hUvEvEv,v.C+v"G vcv!v%h v%0v\vcv)

kvv2UvvEqvv9vv,vv.hGDvvJ#vv(vv,vv%8vvlvv1vvJG vv1vvrvv1vv))>vv$vv.YG$#qvv7bvv!vv/UvvE

qvv9vv,vv.,h#vv)

P vv#v.G8vlvsbv!v1v-Uv.Dv2v.G vVvEv1vFChhQOkv2hGDvJ#v)G vVvEv1vEv1v),

h vvv%0vvv\vvvcvvv)kvvv2UvvvEqvvv9vvv-hGDvvvJ#vvv)C+vvv"G vvvcvvv!vvv%.h#vvv)P vvvvCf0vvvuvvv.f

G vvEvvJ0vv=#vvSvv,vv.QGCh#vvPvv9vvlvv1vvYvv.ChQhGgG$Fvv$qvv7G vvuvv2vv.Qtvv$vv. vvvbvv)&vv.kvvd

b)G1)b$L.

Gv0Uv7G vrv.dkv2G v$vPv# v7:Efq

bv!v$v.AC+v"G vPv(qv70vrv2v!v.fCDv.O0v=

G!Dv.OG vVvEv1vEv7kv2G vcvrv.FvJhG$Dvuv.e#v)ev1vL8vlvL0vskv2P vv,0vJ qvv

bvv!vv/+vvKG8vvHvvL0vv@CFvv$qvv7C+vv"G vvPvv(qvv7tvv$vv. vvvhCDvv$vvJhG vv2vvHvv.Qjh#vvPvv!vv%hC1vv2OGhOhG vv9vvL#vvKjhG vv(vvPvv.Fvv2hG vvJGQ#vv2hevv1vvL+vv%,G$Dvv.O0vv=G vv$vv<vv2vv9vv7 v!vcvrv.FvJkv2#vJhq&v.8v,v%,hG v$v9v.G8vL#v(v,v.qv!v1v",h v. v%0vL8vYv.GG/Ov9vJ/d1vv,vv. vv$vv.C8vvcvv2vv.GC&vvlvvPvv,vv%kvv2QhG0vv9vv,vv.hXvv2vv\vv,vv.h8vvJh0vv(vv,vv.,h#vv)qvv.dbvv(vv,vv%Gvv0aP vvvkvv(&qvv-qvvJGkvv9vvLibvv!vv1vv,vv%,h/OGvv" vvuvv.fG$Dvv.O0vv=G!Dvv.O

8l1JG _)qG LG>FChG 1r1)k2G $P# 7(1).

hkvv2G vvEvvrvv1vvrvv7Cfq

G vv9vvlvvL0vvs1vv1vv)G vv9vv.G8vvLhG!Dvv.Okvv2Ekvv.OIG vvcvv!vv%,

GUvv\vv0MDvv.OK vv%0vvJdbvv!vv1vv-tvv9vv.Hh/Ovv(qvv7h vv%0vvcvvLkvv-G vvVvvEvv.1vv7h/

G vv9vv.1vvcvv.f,kvv. vvLOvv.d�qvvJUvvJq

qvv-G vv$vv&#vv(vv.fkvv1vv$vv.CGvv2vvL1vv-OhfDvv.>vv7

#vv(vv,vv%E vv/8vv.G8vvLG vv$vvHvv2vvL0vv),htvvK vvvtvv.fG vvLOvv.d�0vvVvvJq

bCUvvEvv.1vv-

kvv1vv$vv.0vvHvv2vvLh&vv-1vv-,htvv.fG vvVvvEvv.1vv70vvVvvJq

b1vvcvvYvv,vv%1vvcvvYvv.kvv1vv$vv.0vvHvv2vvLbvv)

G vvLOvv.d�,h vv%0vvrvv"hGDvvJ#vv(vv,vv% vv$vv)DvvJq

;vv-,Gvv2vvLhGDvvJ,/0vvlvv1vvJ

(1)b$LO!1$.fG$RrL,G cr1JIk2Gu,56vvvv57vvvv58.

54G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 57: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

G vvcvv!vv%Dvv9vv/0vv9vv.G8vvL,h8vv.qvvm#vv(vv,vv%Dvv9vv/bvvYvvJgBGvvL,/0vvJdbvv!vv/bvvJe

qvv2vv.dGvv2vvLG vv.GDvvJhE&qvv$vv.tvv.&vv.G0vvPvv9vv<vv2vv9vv.fCDvv1vv.&vv.&vv.OQI>vvJG.hqvvJP+vv3

>vv$vv.bvv7#vv)C+vv"G$Uvv.dbvv!vv/Cfq

G)>vv$vv.YG vvKjG&vvcvvrvvJbvv!vv/G vvcvv$vv"

1vvHvv2vvLG vv.GDvvJUvv.Qtvv. vv$vv9vv.G8vvL,h@@@hqvvJP+vv3>vv$vv.bvv7#vv)CUvvEvv.H

CDv$vJhEOvEv.b1v)QG+v.0v-,Cfq

#v(vuvLEkv.OIGv2vLG v.GDvJ v!vcv!v%E v/8vuvlv1vL

#)0?EJ#.;2:1H2LG .GDJG cJd(1).

q q q q q q

(1)G1)q1%G ?.R07,#H9VLG V.GbsG $LO!7b!/G ?,$17hG $c\!7,551.

55G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 58: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

Cs(GdG}F}?p,Gygt+OIGyA,$,ft+OIC${GyT"?hGyG}9f?

kvv(&vv- vv$vv.tvv.fbvv!vv%CUvv.dG vvJ0vv)CRvvLaG vvcvv!vv.e,EPRvvLaG vvcvv!vv%

1vSvLaG v$vcv!v.e,h+v.G vlvrv-G$tv2vL1v. v(vPv2v7E v/kvrv-G vlvLhY,h v,vKGOv$v/

G)#vv.eC1vv.Dvv(vv1vvlvv7QDvv$vv7Gubvv!vv1vv-#vv.qvv. vv-h>vv$vvcvv-kvv2ChQGb#vv)CUvv.d

G J0)1vvvzG lr-G$t2Ly@

hDvvv.>vvv7G vvvcvvv2vvv.OE vvv1vvv-kvvv.btvvv"Dvvv.>vvv7,hXvvvLhQ8vvv,vvv%E vvv1vvv-kvvv.btvvv"

XvvLhQI,$&vv-/Dvv1vv.I vv!vvrvv!vv.Hh/&vvcvv1vv%h/[vv$vv#&vv1vv(vv7;E/q

1vv#f8vvcvvLa

Q1vv,vv.h#vvcvv2vv.O+vv.hkvv.[vvL+vv.,1vv#Ovv$vv.Fvv-hUvvlvv.8vv-hCkvvcvv. [email protected]#vvdP vvv

tv!v-CDv3E v1v,v.#pv$6v.Ov.Gg,h0vuv.fOvcv1v,v.kv1v$v.0vrvL1v,v.E v1v-Ohfev1vLg#v)

O.FLG!r-@

h#vvv)G vvv$vvvEvvv.dCf8vvvPvvv9vvvrvvv"G vvvcvvvrvvv.d1vvv$vvvcvvvLkvvv7P vvvvhEOQGtvvv-bvvv!vvv/

G vv9vvlvvVvv1vv",kvv.qvv9vvYvv:QDvv$vv7G vvcvvM0vvMG vvLDvv1vv%Cf1vvcvv=G vvLOvv"1vv-#vvcvvL8kvv1vv),

hE vv1vv-QGbvv1vv)h vv$vv)C>vv.1vv,vv%#vv2vvSvvL0vv),h vv$vv)Gvv. vvlvv,vv%#vv(vvKQ0vv),h>vvcvv"

#vvvlvvv9vvv.MObvvv.8vvv,vvv%,hR1vvvJIQOvvv. vvv9vvv,vvv%,#vvvcvvvLkvvv7G vvv$vvvcvvv2vvv.OOvvv2vvvEvvv.&vvv-1vvv#Ovvv$vvv.Fvvv-

56G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 59: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

hUvvlvv.8vv-hCkvvcvv. vv-,EPbvv!vv/+vvKgG vv$vvcvvLkvv78vv2vv(vv/#vv\vv. vv3G vvLOvv. vv7tvv!vv,vv.#vv)

Ch ,.E /BGL+.@

;%82dP vCU0fb_1$.f:

CDvJ+v$v.:8vcvL0vmG v\vL0vsG v$v.Uv"E v1v-,[h+v2RvL0vcv9v-G v$v9vYv$v(v7

$#Lgh&,1-]@

;v.&v1v,v$v.:8vcvL0vmG vPv. vuv1v)h#v. v,v%1vcvJG v.Uv.dE v1v-,#v)G v(vcv1v%

G $r1%@

kvv#bvvLaG vv(vv.S1vv.uNC8vv2vvcvv,vv% vv!vv\vvL0vvsG vv$vv.Uvv"E vv1vv-,hCbvvLkvv,vv%

1vvEvv.dG vvPvv. vvuvv1vv)bvv(vvJG vvrvvJhebvv!vv1vv-,h vv,vvKGOvv$qvv/GuN#vv.C&vvM vv-bvv!vv/

QOvv. vv-�QhDvv.k

vv9vv.qvvmG vvEvv1vv.IG vvEvvrvv1vvrvv1vv7bvv!vv1vv-,h&vv.QGk

vv9vv.qvvmG vv,vvJG0vv7

bvvvvv!vvvvv1vvvvv-kvvvvvrvvvvv.d8vvvvvcvvvvv. vvvvv/:{/01234567}(1)

hqvvvv.d8vvvvcvvvv. vvvv/:{9:;<=>?@ABC

DEFGHIJKLMNOPQ

RS:52TUVWXYZ[\]^

_‘ab:53}(2)h/QhME/kvvv1vvv$vvv.>vvv.A1vvv-G vvvLOvvv.d,h/

&vv.QE/kvv2G/Ovv9vvYvv.AI1vv-,hOvv$vv.gG vvSvvlvv.Atvv$vv.qvv.d8vvcvv. vv/:{PQRSTU}(3)@

hGu8vcv. v/CQOv"QOv. v-1v. v,vJihO0v)G vEvs,kv0+vJiE/kv1v$v.

(1)O.QIG $&#(.f:15.

(2)O.QIG S.Qi:52vvvv53.

(3)O.QIkV!::44.

57G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 60: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

>vvvv.A1vvvv-h/Q0vvvv3C&vvvv-0vvvv?vvvv3bvvvv!vvvv/tvvvv"hGDvvvvJCf0vvvv&#vvvv)1vvvv$vvvv.>vvvv.A1vvvv-

G vLOv.dE0v$v.&v.k

0v(vlv2G v.+v%hG vSvvhG v_v),h/Q0v3Cf#vcvLkv7#v.>v.A

1v-G vLOv.d�bv!v/G v9vlvVv1v"kvLVbv!v/G v$vuv!vm@hqvJ#vYv/bv!v/#v.

tvvv.fbvvv!vvv1vvv-G vvvLOvvv.d�Gvvv1vvvLG vvvrvvvLhf,h+vvv%G vvvVvvvEvvv.1vvv7hG vvv9vvv.1vvvcvvv.f vvv,vvv%

1vv(DvvPvv.f,0vv.Uvv/1vv-G$hdG!GvvL,h0vvrvv9vvJjkvv1vv-G vv0Dvvs1vv. vvPvv.1vvs,h+vv%

kv2P vvtv!v-1v(v2v1v,v%#vEv$vJ�#vrv9vJhf,hbv!v/#v(v,v.>v-Ov. vuv.f,tv$v.

qvv.d8vvcvv. vv/kvv2tvv9vv.1vv-G vvcvvM0vvM:{MNOPQRSTUVW}(1)kvv(ftvv.fqvv. vv-:{VW}#vvcvv\vv.kvv.

kbvv!vv/G vvYvv$vv1vvL

k2COb.,k,.O 1"b!/G82.b-+%G Jb.IE /Gu(2)@

hEftvv.f#vvcvv\vv.kvv.k

bvv!vv/G vvYvv$vv1vvLG vv$vv(vvlvvVvv",kvv,vv.UvvL0vvFCf6

C8vv2vv.bvv-

+%C+"G 2V1LIk1$.>.A1-Ohfe1L+%,ht0G $c(11)Ds@

hqvvvvvJ1vvvvv!vvvvvgG vvvvvLOvvvvv.d�G vvvvv2vvvvv0ZG vvvvv$vvvvv2vvvvv1vvvvv),hChXvvvvvFG vvvvvEvvvvv?vvvvv7

vv!vv$vvPvv9vv2vvVvvL0vv)hOvv!vvvOvv2vv1vv!vv-Gvv1vvLG vvrvvLhf@;vv%Gvv!vvm#vv)1vvcvvJ+vv%Gvv!vvm

G8v2vcv.GC+v.GFv,v%,hGkv9vLqv.G,kv#qv.eGu v,vKgG$#v7#v)0vEvlvabv!v1v,v.CUv.d

O0v(v,v.,tv$v.CGv2vLG vVv.Ob�1vrv. v-:z/8vMGd[v.Fvlv7#v)C#v9v2v̂.+vL0v)b!/G Es,/0YL+%#)GK ,%@@@@y(3)@

(1)O.QI0.Om:108.

(2)G1)81$17,#.Gkr-UE1FG $(r.d VL0FG $cr.d@

(3)#vv9vvlvvsbvv!vv1vv-#vv)DvvJ0vv=>vv$vvd#vv)G vvVvvEvv.1vv7,QhGgG vv9vvL#vvKjhqvv.dOvv# vv:#vvEvv$vvJGk

bvv(vv-1vrvVvJG)#v.eG v2vHv.Qjkvrv.dG v2vHv.Qj:Ov# v:bv(v-bv!v20vrvVvJG1v)G v$vJ0v(v2,kvrv.d:+v%C+"G EJ0=@

58G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 61: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

h#v$v)qv.e1v,vKGG vEvs#v)bv!v$v.AG v$vPv!v$v1v)G$Fv$v7G$Q1vcv7,tv#1v2

Dvv(vv1vvlvv7QDvv$vv-Gu,h#vv. vvv,hG vvSvv.kvvcvv2,hCDvv$vvJkvvrvvJqvv.dG)#vv.eC1vv.

Dvv(vv1vvlvv7(1)QDvv$vv-Gukvv2tvv9vv.1vv-G vv$vvPvv$vv/1vv. vvlvvrvv-G$tvv2vvL,C&vv-0vv(vv2vvfvv2Cf

0vuv.fG/+v9v$v.e1v-+v.G$tv<vL,0vrvVvJG vlvrv-G$tv2vL,CjCUv.dG vJ0v),

$&v-#vJGQG)0v$v.fh#v2v(v/UvEv7G$Qtv.fh#vcv(v/ev.0v7G)DvPv.f,h&v,v.0v7

G vvcvvLkvv.f1vvcvvJG vv2vvPvv$vv!vv7G vv$vvSvv9vv$vv!vv7bvv!vv/#vvYvv$vv.fzG vvEvv$vvJuyEGvv2vv.Qkvv2

G vv$vv2vv(vv/hE&vvSvv.Akkvv2G vv$vvcvv(vv/uG vv?vv.#vvd vv!vvVvvlvv.JG vvEvvPvv(vv/hG vv(vvcvv.J

G c!1.@

h vuv)kv2bvVvLC1v2Dv1v(vlv7QDv$v-Gu1vJCC+v"G$+v.GAhG v2vJYkv2

Ebvv$vv.dbvvrvv. vv,vv%kvv2G!0vv.JG vv9vv28vv(vv.h vv:G$Ovv$vv.AhG vvVvvlvv.J,kvv9vvLtvv.G

G v$v(vrv.dh#v.UvFbv)G vVvEv.1v7hG v9v.1vcv1v),kv.&vPv!vHv.Gbv)>v.OIG v\vL0vs

G v9v2bv!v1v,v.C+v"G vPv(v7hG v?v$v.bv7,htv$v.CGv2vL1v-G vVv.ObhhkvsG v.Gqvd

G vv$vv\vv.1vvsbvv!vv/#vv.QhGgG vv9vvL#vvKjhevv1vvLgC&vv-�qvv.d:zEf1vv(vv2EOvvLGFvv1vv"8vvlvvLqvv:bvv!vv/G;vv(vv9vv1vv)hOvv2vvcvv1vv)#vv!vv7,h8vvlvvLbC#vv9vv2bvv!vv/;vv0KhOvv2vvcvv1vv)#vv!vv7tv!v,v%kv2G v(v.QE/#v!v7hGDvJI,qv. v.G:#v)+v20v.QOv.dGu?qv.d:#v.

(1)qvvv.dG)#vvv.eG vvvK+vvv2vvv2kvvv28vvvKtvvvLIG vvvEvvvlvvv.X:1|168:+vvv.G vvv(vvvcvvv$vvv.f1vvv);vvv.1vvv:G1vvv)Rh[vvv.

G v9v$v1v$v2,G vuv.kv2,#v. v/1v(v28v1qv%Gu1v);vcv!v2v7,#v. vJg80+vvvvvQCiC&vQ1v)#v. vvev1vL#vvLqI vv$vv.qvvJebvv!vv1vv,vv%G vvuvv.kvv7DvvJ

qKbvv)bvv\vv.A,h&vv.kvvd,h#vvEvv$vvJG vv2vv.qvvL8vvlvvrvv-1vv-RkvvL,

hOGhOG vvvv\vvvv.Fvvvv2,hC1vvvv.0vvvv.Ovvvvm,h#vvvvEvvvv$vvvvJ1vvvv)G vvvvEvvvvPvvvv),hCOvvvvJ1vvvv)bvvvv$vvvvLh,hG vvvvEvvvvPvvvv)G vv!vv& vv&j,h&vv.MG vv?vv.#vvd,hbvvJI,hqvvJkvvrvv-1vvEvv$vv.O1vv)C1vv2Ovv!vv1vv$vv.fhevv1vvLg,DvvJ

qKbvv(vv-

htvv1vvd,hbvv2vvJG vvLRGb,hC1vv.&vvcvv1vv%Rvv1vvIG vv2vvHvv.Qj,htvv.fE#vv.#vv.k

hQbvv.k

bvv.#vv0k

tvv2vv1vvLG vvSvv#f

/0vrv2v">v.GFvMG vPv!v\v.f1v",XvL1v-0vM0vJ1v)bv$vLbv!v/G vrvYv.Akv#1v/Cf0vuv.fqv.Xv1v.k

,

8.k2QD$-Gu150+vvvvv@

59G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 62: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

C&.b!1-hCUE.12y(1)@

hkvv2QhG0vv7CDvv$vvJhC1vv2OGhObvv)#vvcvv.h0vv7S:zG;vv(vv9vv.fhOvv2vvcvv.f

k2G (.QhhGDJIk2G ?(7h+2G ?$.b7y(2)@

0vvcvv(vv2Ctvv<vvLC+vv"G vv$vv!vv7kvv(fC#vv9vv-bvv!vv1vv-G vvVvv0IhG vvPvv0e/8vv?vv9vv$vvd

bvv!vv/G vvYvv0 vv7(3)bvv!vv/#vv.hQObvv(vv-bvv!vv1vv-G vvVvv0IhG vvPvv0e,hkvv2QhG0vv7

bvv!vv1vvuvv%1vv. vvPvv.GOG$bvv_vv%,hbvv)Ovvlvv1vv.fQDvv$vv-Gu, vv.Cfkvvrvv1vv,vv.k

hGDvvJGk

bvv!vv/QCS>vv2vv" vvuvv.f+vv.G vv?vv$vv.bvv7h#vvcvv(vv.gC&vv-Dvv1vv=qvv.e1vv$vv.qvv.e1vv-

G vv?vv$vv.bvv7kvvuvv#&vv->vv$vv.bvv7h#vv(vv-qvv. vv-8vvcvv. vv/:{defg}(4)

CjhDJghqJq1":

h vv1vvQbvv!vv/Gu1vv$vvPvv9vv(vvuvvL:Cf0vv?vv$vvdG vvcvv. vv%kvv2hGDvvJhqvvJqvv.d:

(1)EOvvv(vvv.OgDvvvPvvv)CGvvvL>vvv-C1vvv.OGhO2596hG vvv9vvvL#vvvKj2640hG1vvv)#vvv.>vvv-3996hCDvvv$vvvJ2|2332hUvEvEv-G1v)Dv2v.f6731vvvv6247,hG vEv.tv%1|128,hC1v.0vcv!v/5910,

3991hG1vv)C1vv2bvv.Uvv%kvv2G vvPvv(vv766tvv!vv,vv%#vv)DvvJ0vv=C1vv2+vvL0vvLI,qvv.dG vv9vvL#vvKjDJ0=DP)UE1F@

(2)CGvvvL>vvv-C1vvv.OGhO4567,hCDvvv$vvvJ4|102,hG1vvv)C1vvv2G vvvcvvv.Uvvv%kvvv2G vvvPvvv(vvv7tvvv!vvv,vvv%#vvv)DvJ0v=#vcv.h0v7h+v.DvJ0v=UvEv1vF1v$v.qv2v!v-,h v-Rv.+vJBGvL#v)DvJ0v=C&vQbv)G1v)#vv.>vv-3993hCDvv$vvJ3|145,hG1vv)C1vv2bvv.Uvv%64,hG vvEvvJ0vv= vv-Ovv:[vvLbCGvvLi

#(,.#)[L0sC&QhR.G+Jb)>$d#)G VE.17@

(3)CGvL>v-G vEv.tv%11511vvvv2116hG v\v2vLG&v2kv2G vuv2v1vL3|209vvvvhG1v)C1v2bv.Uv%kv2G vPv(v78#v)DvJ0v=G1v)bv$vL1v(Ov(v.OXvcv1vm,h vlv_v-:z#v.tv.f v1v?v$vd+vKgG$#v7bv!v/G vYv0 v7C1vJG

k,h0vJGubv!v/G v?v$v.bv7+vuvKGkvcv!v1vuv%1vPv.GOtvKGG$bv_v%,kv(&v-#v)RvK

RKk2G (.Qy@

(4)G (E":120.

60G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 63: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

G1v)bv2v.SS:8vuvlv"Gu v$v)qvLCG vrvLBfhbv$v"1v$v.kv1v-Cf/0vYv"

kvvv2G vvvJ&vvv1vvv.h/0vvvSvvvrvvv/kvvv2G!GvvvLI(1),;vvv%qvvvLC+vvvKgG!0vvv7:{wxyz{|}}(2)@

hC#vvv.#vvv.hqvvvd#vvv)tvvvLG+vvv7Ctvvv<vvvLC+vvv"G vvvPvvv!vvvmh>vvv$vvvd#vvv)G vvvHvvv!vvvs

h#vv(vvcvv,vv%#vv)bvv!vv%G vvuvv0eG vvKj>vv.A1vv-G vv$vv2vv9vvJbvv7,h#vv.8vv2vvcvv-#vv)G vv$vv(vv\vvs

h#.0rL1-#)G $LGe@

Dv9v/qv.dG)#v.eC1v.0v.Ovm(3) v2vSvLG v$vL0vPv2(4)G vcv!v%1v. vuv0e+v.

G v?v,v",hG v?v,v"1v. vuv0e+v.G vcv!v%,htv#&v-CQGO1v. v?v,v"1v-Gbv9vrv.ObvJe

UE9-,k(fP vb!%&.kdChCQGO1-G)bLGVb(-@

hb(-C0Y.k

:

#vvv)[vvv!vvv3G vvvcvvv!vvv%1vvv. vvvuvvv0e8vvvM&vvvJb,h#vvv)[vvv!vvv3G vvv$vvv.d1vvv. vvvuvvv1vvv$vvv1vvv.A

(1)CGvvvL>vvv-G vvvEvvv.tvvv%2|381hUvvvEvvvEvvv-hhGkvvvrvvv-G vvvK+vvv2vvv2#vvv)[vvvL0vvvs#vvvEvvv$vvvJ1vvv)kvvvYvvv"1vvv)evMhGfbv)bv\v.A1v)G vPv.Fv3bv)Ovcv1vJ1v)>v2v1vLbv)G1v)bv2v.S,hChQOgG vPv1v.[v2kv2G vvvvJQG vvvv$vvvv(vvvv<vvvv.Q:4|2311hG vvvv2vvvv1vvvv,vvvvrvvvv2kvvvv2Rvvvvcvvvv3G)0vvvv$vvvv.f,hCGvvvvL>vvvv-bvvvv2vvvvJG vvvvLRGbkvvvv2G $V(m@

(2)O.QI[-:123.

(3)+vv.G)#vv.eG vv$vv?vv9vv,vvJG vvcvv0#vv7G vv$vvEvvJKtvv2vv1vvLG vvrvvYvv.IC1vv.0vv.Ovvm0vvcvvrvv.H1vv)E1vvLG+vv1vv%G$&vVv.QjG vuv.kv2,UvEv3C1v.Dv(v1vlv7Ov2vdbvSvLIOv(v7,h8vlvrv-bv(v-,h+v.C&v2v"8v0#vK8v-hCb!$,%@8.k2182+vvvv,O1LCb0eG (20A8|535vvvv539.

(4)+vv.1vvSvvL1vv)evv1vv.KG vv$vvL0vvPvv2,C1vv.bvv2vvJG vvLDvv$vv)G vvcvvJhj,#vv./+vv%G vv2vvfvvJGOj,kvvrvv1vv-#vv9vvuvv!vv%,#vvcvv9vvM vv2QCSG vv\vv.Fvvlvv7G vv$vvL0vvPvv1vv7,CGvvKG vvlvvrvv-bvv)C1vv20vv.OvvmUvv.Dvv3C1vv2Dv(v1vlv7,Qhibv(v-Dv$v.O1v)Ov!v$v7hev1vLg8v.kv2218+vvvvvqv.dbv(v-G vK+v2v2#v2v9vJYXv.d/

0vv(vv2vvfvv2Cf0vvLhibvv(vv-h/tvvLG#vv7h vv%0vvJQc>vv,vv%1vv)Uvvlvv.GfhE&vv$vv.qvv!vvJ#vvrvv. vv9vv-kvv2Gvv!vvs

G rLBfhGD9@1,.hOb.E 1,.,O1LCb0eG (20A10|199.

61G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 64: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

Ck!Q,h#)[!3eL03G EJ0=krJtKH(1)@

hqv.dG)#v.eG vSv.kvcv2QDv$v-Gu(2):Dvuv$v2kv2G vcvSv.FvLhG vrv2v.Fv",

0vrv.d:+vKG>vMGA#v)8vLcG vuv9v.HhG vPv(v7hCqv2v"bv!v/tv0eC+v"G v2vJbv7

hq.dC0Y.k

:

tvvv"G vvvcvvv!vvv.eOvvv.iG vvvrvvvLBf#vvvSvvvfvvv!vvv7E/G vvEvvJ0vv=hE/G vvlvvrvv-kvv2G vvJ0vv)

vvvvcvvvv!vvvv%#vvvv.tvvvv.fkvvvv1vvvv-qvvvv.d:DvvvvJ;vvvv(vvvv.hOvvv.iPGchOvvv.GSG vvvSvvv1vvv.[vvv1vvv)(3)

h#vvv)tvvv0#vvv-C0vvvYvvv.k

$f0vvv!vvvrvvv/GuG vvvcvvv2vvvJ1vvvuvvv"P&vvv3Gvvv0G vvvSvvvLc

Gvv1vvL vv-#vv)Cf0vv!vvrvv.g1vvSvv2A#vv)bvv!vv%G vvuvv0e,hqvv.d: vvrvvJC[vv!vvcvv:#vv)

C+vvv"G vvvuvvv0ebvvv!vvv/Rvvv2A#vvv.v̂vv(vvv(vvv:#vvvPvvv!vvv$vvv.k

0vvvrvvv. vvv-,hqvvvJqvvv.dG vvv?vvv0d

G vPv1v.[v2(4)E&v-0vEvLebv!v.eG vlv!vPvlv7tv$v.G v$v(v\vs)>v$v.YG vPv!vmhCtv<vL

G vv$vvlvvPvvL0vv)G vv$vvcvv9vv2vvL0vv)#vv)G vvHvv!vvs,h#vv$vv)>vvLM1vvK vvvG1vv)G vvVvv0M(5)

(1)CGvL>v-G v2vfvJGOjkv2:RvLaCUvEv.HG vEvJ0v=,hChQOgG vK+v2v2kv2G vPv1vL8|537kv28L>$7C120.Om,h+.k2PcG u0e !,Lhj6|104|1.

hkvvv2RvvvLMG vvvcvvvrvvv1vvvJIG vvv\vvvEvvv.h0vvv7/1vvv)C1vvv2G vvvcvvvM(1|18)hCqvvv2vvv"bvvv!vvv/G vvvuvvv0e,hqvvv.dG vvSvv.kvvcvv2PtvvLgG vv2vv1vv,vvrvv2kvv2#vv(vv.qvv3G vvSvv.kvvcvv21|462,hqvv.dG vvSvv.kvvcvv2PtvvLgG vv2vv1vv,vvrvv2kvv2#vv(vv.qvv3G vvSvv.kvvcvv21|462,hG vvHvv\vv1vv3kvv2RvvLaGUvvEvv.HG vvEvvJ0vv=2168,hG1vv)Dvv?vvL

k28.G 2G 9#O1QU46hG K+22k2G P1L10|29.

(2)G)#vv.eG vvSvv.kvvcvv2+vv.#vvEvv$vvJ1vv)EOQ0vvQG vvSvv.kvvcvv2bvv. vv%bvvVvvLg,h&vv.UvvLG vvEvvJ0vv=hkvvrvv1vv-G $!7C1.b2JGuG rLR28.k2204+vvvv,O1LCb0eG (20A:10|99.

(3)G vv2vv1vv9vv.f#vv(vvPvv.1vv.f vv!vvSvv.kvvcvv2kvv2[vv2vvrvv.JG vvPvv2vvuvv21|297,hG vv2vvJG0vv7hG vv(vv,vv.0vv7/1vv)tvv<vv1vvL10|254.

(4)+vv.G)#vv.eG vv$vv?vv9vv,vvJG vvEvv.kvvabvv2vvJG vvLDvv$vv)1vv)G vvuvv$vv.d1vv)C1vv21vvuvvL1vv)#vvEvv$vvJ1vv)Ovv.1vvs

G$O1.[2G $VLjG S.kc2G $!r31?0dG J0)G $. .O849+vvvvG $9.k/911+vvvv@(5)G)#vv.eG vvEvv.kvvaG vv$vvlvv9vv2Rvv1vvIG)Ovv0e8vvrvv2G vvJ0vv)C1vv.bvv$vvLhbvv<vv$vv.f1vv)bvv2vvJG vvLDvv$vv)

62G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

=

Page 65: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

hG (.hj(1)hG!s/0EV.f@

hPtvLG vEv.kvaOvLGLG vJ0v)G vrvMh0v(v2(2)#v)G vEv(vlv1v7kv2tv9v.HC vlv-

k28EL0$-@

CfG vfvMG v2(3)Q>vdE v/8vEvL0v$v-1vcvJ1v(v.Fv-bv!v1v-kv2ChdG v$v(v9vrv/hE v/

8vvvEvvvL0vvv%P+vvv3G vvvSvvv.kvvvcvvv2,h#vvvEvvv$vvvJ(4),h#vvv. vvvv(5),hCDvvv$vvvJ1vvv)Dvvv(vvv2vvv"(6)

G vvvSvvv,vvvLRhQjG vvvSvvv.kvvvcvvv2h vvvJOvvv(vvv7577+vvvvvvvv8vvv.kvvv2643+vvvvvvv8vvvL>vvv% vvv-G vvvK+vvv2vvv2kvvv28vvvKtvvvLI

G El.X@(1)+vv.G)#vv.eG vv$vvEvvJKG vvlvvrvv1vv-0vvEvv1vv/1vv)RvvLaG vv(vv.hjG vvJ#vvSvvrvv2h vvJ631+vvvvvvUvv.Dvv3

G v9vVv.&v1vmG vrv1v$v7G vcv_v1v$v7CRv,vLB;v.QgG v$v?v$v.YRvLMG v$v,vKHQhXv7G v\v. v2v1v)vvvvRvLM

UE1F#P!%he1L+.#)G 9V.&1mG u<1LIG r1$78.k2676+vvvv@(2)+vv.bvv$vvL1vv)bvv2vvJG vvLDvv$vv)G vvlvv.QOvv2OvvLGLG vvJ0vv)C1vv.DvvlvvWG vvrvvMh0vv(vv28vv.kvv2745+vvvvvv

#vv)8vvVvv.&vv1vvlvv-G vvcvv_vv1vv$vv7(G vvuvvSvvmbvv)G vvuvvSvv.a vv!vvM#vvHvvSvvLj)G vv$vvPvv!vv%G1vv9vv!vv/1vv2vvEvv=

G $(\s@(3)+vv.G vvSvv1vvIC1vv.Dvv.#vvJ#vvEvv$vvJ1vv)CDvv$vvJG vv\vv.Ovv2G vvSvv.kvvcvv2G vvfvvMG vv2Uvv.Dvv3G vv9vvVvv.&vv1vvm

G vuv<v1vLI#v)G vlvrv-hG vlv!vPvlv7hG vLqv.Fvs8v.kv2505+vvvv,G vPv1vL19|204hkv2tv9v2v-#v&GGvKGJ

&2-b!1,.C+"G c!%,hPtL#c_$,.G)#.eG K+22k28L>$9-@(4)+vv.C1vv.bvv2vvJGu#vvEvv$vvJ1vv)G vvEvvPvv)G vvSvv1vv2vv.&vv2CUvv!vv-#vv)O#vvSvvs8vv. vvJ131+vvvvvvh&vvSvv#kvv2

G vvvuvvv.kvvv7hUvvvEvvv2vvv-C1vvv.Dvvv(vvv1vvvlvvv7hCGvvvKbvvv(vvv-G vvvlvvvrvvv-hQhi#vvv.[vvv##vvv. vvvv@hGvvv!vvv\vvv-1vvv2vvvcvvvZ

G$D.O0=G Yc1l7 1(9VL !$K+3@(5)+vv.Dvv?vv7G$#vv7Rvv1vvIG)Ovv0eE#vv.eOGQG vv,vv?vvLI,C1vv.bvv2vvJGu#vv. vvv1vv)C&vvQG$Uvv2vvcvv2

G vv$vvJ&vv28vv. vvJ93+vvvvvvCGvvKbvv)bvv!vv$vv.AG vv$vvJ0vv(vv7G vvuvv2vv.Q#vv<vv"Q1vv1vvcvv7G vvLCj,hG1vv)Rvv,vv.H

G vM+vLj,h&v.kvd#v. v/G1v)bv$vL,h0vEv1v/1v)Ovcv1vJG$&vVv.Qj,h+vSv.e1v)bvLhIhhC1v2G vvvM&vvv.Ohbvvv2vvvJGu1vvv)O0vvv(vvv.Qh[vvv2vvvrvvv9vvv,vvv%8vvv.kvvv2179+vvvvvvvOvvv1vvvLCbvvv0eG vvv(vvv2vvv0A8|3,h8vvvKtvvvLI

G vvEvvlvv.X1|207,G vvuvv.Rvvm3|5329E>vv$vv.YG vvcvv!vv% vv!vvSvv.kvvcvv2242,[vv2vvrvv.JG1vv)OvvcvvJ

9|250.

(6)+vv.E#vv.eC+vv"G vvPvv(vv7qvv.#vvdG vv2vvJbvv7G vvKjOGvv"G vvlvv9vv(vv7kvvHvvLL#vv(vv,vv.P+vv2vv.k

Gvv.Uvv.k

,G)#vv.eG vvEvv.kvvaG vv$vvEvvJKC1vv.bvv2vvJCHCDvv$vvJ1vv)#vvEvv$vvJ1vv)Dvv(vv2vv"1vv)+vv0d1vv)COvvJ1vv)bvvJ&vv.fG vvSvv1vv2vv.&vv2G vv$vvLhRjG vv2vvfvvJGOj,Ovv$vvdOvvlvv1vv.f1vv)bvv1vv1vv(vv7,hE1vvLG+vv1vv%1vv)OvvcvvJ,h0vvEvv1vv/

63G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

=

Page 66: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

hOvlv1v.f(1),h>v$v1vdCFv$v7G vEvJ0v=#v)G vPv!vmQDv$v,v%Gu>v$v1vcv.k

,hQhi

bvv)+vv&/A>vv1vv$vvcvv.k

C&vv,vv%qvv. vv.G:&vvPvvuvv:bvv$vv.Ovvuvv:bvv(vv-G vvVvvEvv.1vv7#vvdEqvvLGQ

1v#fG vVvEv.1v7CbvLa1v. vEvrv.FvshC&vVvFkv28vL8v1v3G$ vlv.X#v)Ov.FvLG vHv0Fvs

E/ $.09. J#(-G SLh KGq.d�:z+!vG $9(\c.fy(2)@

hqvvJ>vv.Akvv2evv(vv1vv7G vv$vvlvv9vv2bvv)C1vv20vv.OvvmC&vv-/0vv?vv.RG vvVvv0I

Gvv!vvmG vv$vv9vvuvv!vv%hEf8vvuvv!vv%1vvEvvs$&vv-#vv2vv9vvJY,h/8vv?vv.RG vvVvv0IGvv!vvm

G v$v2v9vJY,qv.dG)#v.eG vMG+vJj(3)tv.fC1v.Dv(v1vlv7QDv$v-Gu0vuvLgG v?vJd

bvv!vv/Ovv2vv1vv"G vvEvvs,Dvv9vv/Qhibvv)C1vv20vv.OvvmQDvv$vv-GuC&vv-qvv.dtvv(vv.

G vvvrvvv\vvv.f,h+vvvSvvv1vvv$vvv.k

hhtvvv1vvvcvvv.k

hG1vvv)bvvv!vvv1vvv7,hG1vvv)#vvv,vvvJj,hbvvv2vvvJG vvvLRGb,bvvv)G vvvL1vvv1vvvd1vvv)[email protected]:qvv.d vv(vv.G vvSvv.kvvcvv2:CDvv$vvJE#vv.ekvv2;vv$vv.&vv2GvvVvv.d:E#vv.ekvv2G vvEvvJ0vv=,

E#v.ekv2G vlvrv-,E#v.ekv2G v!vfv7,E#v.ekv2G vrvLBf,E#v.ekv2G vlvrv-,E#v.ekv2G vM+vJ,E#v.ekvv2G vv.QY,E#vv.ekvv2G vvPvv(vv7,hQhiC0vvYvv.

kbvv)G vvSvv.kvvcvv2C&vv-qvv.d:bvv(vvJqvvJh#vv-E vv/#vvVvvL

#v)G vcvLGb#v.Gv!vlv:kv21v. vcvLGbCDvJGk

0vSv2v-CDv$vJ@8v,vK0v3G vuv$v.d(1|35),8v,vK0v3

G vv9vv,vvK0vv3(1|72)Gvv0Uvv78vv,vvK0vv3G vvuvv$vv.d(10|29)G vvuvv.Rvvm(1|68)8vv.Q0vvIG vv2vvHvv.Qj

G u21L,(2|5)8.Q0I1H.QjG Vf1L(2|375)O1LCb0eG (20A11|177.

(1)+v.Rv1vIG)Ov0e,G)#v.eG vEv.kva,Ov1vJG vcv!v$v.AG vcv.#v!v1v)kv2R#v.&v-Ovlv1v.f1v)Ovcv1vJ1v)#vvPvvLhb1vv)Dvv2vv1vv3C1vv.bvv2vvJGuG vv<vv.QjG vvuvv.kvv2G vv$vv?vv9vv,vvJ,C#vv1vvLG vv$vv&#vv(vv1vv)kvv2G vvEvvJ0vv=

8.k2161+vvvv -8L>$7D.k!7k2O1LCb0eG (20A7Qq%82.

(2)CGvvvvL>vvvv-#vvvvPvvvv!vvvv%2670,C1vvvv.OGhO4608,hCDvvvv$vvvvJ1|386#vvvv)DvvvvJ0vvvv=bvvvv2vvvvJGu1vvvv)#vPvcv.O,hG v$v9v(v\vcv.f:qv.dG vHv\v.1v2kv2#vcv. v%G vPv(v)4|300:G v$v9v(v\vd:G v$v9vcv$vskv2G vSv2AG v$v9vuv!vmkv2G v2vEv=bv(v-bv!v/#vKG+v3C+v"G vuv0eG vJGGv!v1v)kv1v$v./0vcv(v1v,v%,G vvHvv.FvvYvv1vv)kvv1vv$vv./8vv2vv!vvfvv-bvvrvv. vv,vv%,hqvv.dG1vv)G$;vv1vvL+vv%G vv$vv9vvcvv$vvrvv.fG vv$vvfvv. vv.fkvv2G vuv0e,G v$v9vuv!v$v.f1v#qvVv/Dv!v.qv,v%#v#Gv.P#v)G v(v\vdh+v.G vfv.QG$bv!v/#v)G vlv%,;v%GO9c$"k2t"8c$sq./

khkc0

k@

(3)+v.#vHv9v.Q1v)#vEv$v.OC1v.G vL>v.A&v?v%G vJjG vMG+vJjG vfvL#v1v(v2vvvv&vPv2v-E v/evL#v1v)#v)qvVv2v.JGv.GQReG vEv(vlv2G v$v9v.kv/658+vvvvvtv.f#v)tv2v.QG$Fv$v7hG$bv1v.fG vlvrv,v.Abv. v$v.

k

t.#0k

@

64G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 67: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

>vvv!vvv.Ovvv.k

bvvv(vvvJC1vvv2Dvvv(vvv1vvvlvvv7vvvvEPOGvvv"bvvv!vvv1vvv->vvv$vvv.bvvv7kvvv2C0vvvJ0vvv,vvv%Q>vvv0f

kvvrvv. vv.G:EfCDvvJ+vvK0vv)0vvrvv.dEfG vvrvvLBf#vvHvv!vv.b,h+vvKG0vv(vv.Rbvv-h0vvrvv.d:

+v.ev1vL#vHv!v.bqv.d:/8vVv!v.GGv!vlv,v$v.,C#v.G$hdkv(vcv%kv(&v-/0vrv.d

1vvvrvvvJeG vvvrvvvLBf,hC#vvv.G!GvvvLkvvv$vvv.1vvv. vvv-/0vvvVvvv!vvv2Gvvv!vvvlvvv-?kvvvrvvv.d:E&vvv,vvv$vvv.

0vvv9vvv(vvv.Rbvvv.fkvvv2G vvvJ0vvv),hG vvv$vvv(vvv.Rbvvv7kvvv2G vvvJ0vvv)1vvvJbvvv7,tvvvKGkvvv2#vvvlvvv9vvv.M

G Pc.OI(1)@

hqvv.dG vvSvv.kvvcvv2QDvv$vv-Gu:EPGOvv$vvcvv:G vvL>vv"0vvrvv.d:G/Ovv%+vv.

G vvv$vvvPvvv$vvv/Chevvv1vvvLG vvv$vvvPvvv$vvv/kvvv.Rvvv,vvvJ1vvv#&vvv-#vvv)C+vvv"G vvvuvvv0e,h/O0vvv)

vvv-@@@@hqvvv.dC0vvvYvvv.k

vvv.bvvv!vvv%G vvv(vvv.S#vvv.kvvv2+vvvKGG vvvuvvv0e#vvv)G$+vvv.GA

vvlvvLhG#vv(vv,vv%kvvLGQ+vv%#vv)G$OvvJ(2)@hqvv.d#vv. vvvQDvv$vv-Gu:/8vv?vv.R

Rvv,vv.OIC+vv"G vv2vvJYhG$+vv.GA,kvvrvv.d1vvcvvZCUvvEvv.1vv-kvv28vv#h0vv"P vvv(3),

C&vv-CQGO1vv#+vv"G$+vv.GAC+vv"G vvuvv0ebvv!vv/Cj#vvK+vv3tvv.&vv.Gh#vv(vv,vv.C&vv-

0vv&OjE vv/G vvSvvv,hE vv/G vv9vvLOOkvv1vvVvv1vvLR&vvJ0vvrvv.k

1vvcvvJ#vv.tvv.fUvvJq0vvrvv.

k@@@

kvLhibv)CDv$vJ1v)Dv(v2v"C&v-qv.d:bv!v$v.AG vuv0eR&v.Oqv-,hqv.dC0vYv.k

:

/0vVv!vFUv.Dv3G vuv0eC1vJGk

h/&vuv.O&vLiCDvJGk

&v_vLkv2G vuv0eE/

hkvv2qvv!vv2vv-Revv",h vvrvvJ1vv. vvgkvv1vv-Dvv9vv/+vv?vvLG vvEvv.QK1vv)COvvJG vv$vvEvv.Ovv2vv2

#vvdR+vvJghhQbvv-1vvPvv2vv38vvVvv(vv1vvlvv-tvv9vv.1vv.k

kvv2G vvLObvv!vv/G vv$vv2vv9vvJbvv7hqvv.d:

(1)+vvv.#vvvlvvv9vvv.MG vvvPvvvcvvv.OIkvvv2G vvvlvvvLhY,h+vvv.tvvv9vvv.H#vvvSvvv9vvv$vvv"bvvv!vvv/G vvvcvvv2vvv.OGJhC vvvlvvv.XG vvvuvvvlvvvL

hG/O9EP.fkr]hG9$,.1.)0$.fhG 9.17, u$.dG J0)1)CO.0QG SLhG&2@(2)G fMG 2,ED1.Ab!.eG J0),1|95.

(3)G fMG 2,ED1.Ab!.eG J0),1|95.

65G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 68: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

h0vvEvvv vvPvv:8vvEvvuvv21vvJbvv9vv,vv%Ch/k

;vv%q8vvLObvv!vv1vv,vv%?C vvPvv:8vvEvv$vv"G vv(vv.S

1vv9vvVvv(vv1vvlvvvbvv!vv/#vv\vv. vvcvv7G vv2vvJbvv7,hG vv9vvlvvuvvLkvv2G vvSvv2vv,vv7kvv1vvJbvv.+vv%P vvvE vv/

G LCjhG 2E=(1)@

hGv0Uv7G vuv0ehOv0Ov7G v$vLGeCfG vcvrv.FvJG vVvEv1vEv7h#v.0vrv.0v,v.

#vv)G$O vv7G vvVvvL0vvEvv7tvv$vv.8vv&;vvLkvv2qvv!vv.HC+vv"G vvJ0vv)h8vv<vv$vvLkvv2G vvrvv!vv3

h8vrvPv1v-h8v2vcvJgbv)DvYv.QG vLHh8vPv.Oh8vYvcvm0vrv1v(v-h8vM vMdO0v(v-,1v"

+vv2Cqvv.iCOvv2vv.HOvv.AG vvHvv.8vv$vv7&vvPvv#dGuG vvcvvlvv.hG vvcvv.kvv1vv7@C/8vvLiEf

G vSv1v\v.fEPGCQGOCf0vPv!v3E0v$v.fG vcv2vJ1vL1v-kv(&v-/0vPv!v2v-#v(v-E/1v( vrv.A

G vvcvvrvv.FvvJG vv2vv.[vv!vv7kvv2qvv!vv2vv-,h#vv(vv,vv.G vvHvv.Vkvv2bvv!vv%G vvuvv0eh8vvLcG vvcvv!vv%

1vv#Dvvuvv.eG)Ovv0eG vv$vvPvv9vvrvv.I#vv)G vvuvv9vv.HhG vvPvv(vv7hE>vv$vv.YG$#vv7Dvv9vv/Ef

1vvcvvYvv,vv%0vv?vv9vv,vvJ;vv0;vv1vv)Ovv(vv7 vv1vvVvv1vvLtvv0#vv1vv.k

,;vv%0vvJQSkvv1vv-h0vv9vvuvv!vv%1vv$vv.

0v.Gkvrv-h0vJkvd#v.0v(v.kv1v-h v.Ov,v"bv)#vcv(v/B0v7ChDvJ0v=Ch#vPv# v7#v,v$v7

#v)G vlvLhYG v$v9vcv!vrv71v. v\v,v.QIhG vVv.ehG vVv0Itv.f>v.+v0k

bv(v,v.hOv.tv9v.k

kvv1vv,vv.#vvdCf>vv$vv1vvdG vvcvvrvv.FvvJG vv<vv.1vv9vv7#vv.>vv.OIkvv2G vvuvv9vv.Hqvv\vvcvv1vv.k

, vvKGqvv.d

8vcv. v/:{234}(2)CjG vrvLBftvlv.0v7 v,v%kv2G v$v.bv_v7kv2C#vL

#vvvvvcvvvvv.Rvvvvv,vvvvv%h#vvvvvcvvvvv.O+vvvvv%,hqvvvvv.d8vvvvvcvvvvv. vvvvv/:{]^_‘abcd}(3)CjG vvrvvLBf8vvJhe8vv0h8vv-bvv!vv1vv,vv%kvv2tvv"R#vv.f

h#vvuvv.f#vvdbvv!vv$vv,vv%C&vvvC#qvv2/8vvrvvLCh/8vvuvv9vv3h#vv(vv,vv.Cf#vv,vv dbvv!vv%

(1)G $0b!2G r.Qj,RLMG lr-G$t2L,OGQG u93G c!$17@(2)O.QIE1LG+1%:52.

(3)O.QIG c(u2.J:51.

66G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 69: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

G vuv0ehG v?vJdE v/G vEv1vLIkv2G vEv.dhG vYv0dhG vSvvkv2G v$v,v dtv$v.

qvvvv.dG1vvvv)QRvvvv1vvvvJG vvvvEvvvvlvvvv1vvvvJh+vvvv.#vvvv)Cbvvvv!vvvv%G vvvv(vvvv.S1vvvv$vvvvK+vvvv3G vvvvlvvvv0Ovvvvlvvvv7

h#vvrvv./8vv,vv%kvv2tvv9vv.1vv-z8vv,vv.kvv:G vv9vv,vv.kvv:y(1)h#vv)G vvKjqvv.dkvv2G) vv,vv1vv.J

R1,.k

0c9J1-,htK vq.dG!#Jj(2)@

CkvvvYvvv"C+vvv"R#vvv.&vvv-G vvv.Gqvvvmkvvv2G vvv$vvvPvvv.Fvvv"G vvvuvvv2vvv.Q>vvv.FvvvL,htvvvK vvvv

G vfvMG v2G&v9v,v/BGvLC#vLgE v/G v9v.qvmhG vEv1vLIkv2G v$vPv.Fv"G vuv0#v1v7,;v%

CbvvvLVbvvv)8vvv!vvvvG vvv\vvvLbhCqvvv2vvv"bvvv!vvv/CDvvv.O0vvv=QOvvv.dGu�kvvv$vvv.J

hG vv2vvHvv.Qjbvv!vv/UvvJQg,htvvKGG vvLGRj:C0vvYvv.k

Q>vvdbvv)Cqvv.G vv-E vv/qvv.d

G P!mG V. Fk,.CO!% !cr"hCt$" *0$.f@

htvvKGqvv.dG vvSvv,vvLOvv9vv.&vv2(3)QDvv$vv-GuE&vv- vv%0vv?vvJbvv!vv/G vvlvv0Ovvlvv7

hG $9u!$1)E/G E1LIhG (JeD1=q.d:

vvcvv$vvLj vvrvvJ[vvlvv:G vv$vvcvv.+vvJtvv!vv,vv.hOvv1vvLJ[vvLkvv21vv1vv)8vv!vvvG vv$vvcvv. vv%

kvvvvv!vvvvv%CQE/hGXvvvvvcvvvvv.k

tvvvvvmDvvvvv.FvvvvvLbvv!vv/Pqvv)Chqvv.Qbvv.k

Ovv)&vv.Oe(4)@

(1)8,.k:G 9,.k:U88.

(2)+vv.C1vv.G vvEvvPvv)bvv!vv21vv)C1vv2#vvEvv$vvJ1vv)Ovv. vv%G vv9vvfvv!vv2vv2G vvlvvrvv1vv-G$Uvv. vv2G vv$vv!vvrvv3Ovv1vvm

G vvJ0vv)tvv.fChdGRvv9vvfvv. vv-Dvv(vv2vv!vv2G vv$vvK+vv3;vv%G&vv9vvrvv"E vv/G vv$vvK+vv3G vvSvv.kvvcvv2h8vvcvv!vv%kvv21vfvJGOhG vSv.ehG&v9vrv"E v/G vrv.+vLIkvJQSkv1v,v.;v%GvLLE v/Dv$v.g;v%E v/O#vSvs8v.kv2

631+vvv7O1LCb0eG (20A322Qq%230.

(3)+vv.#vvEvv$vvJ1vv)bvv2vvJG vvuvvL0vv%G vvSvv,vvLOvv9vv.&vv2#vv)kvv0Ovvlvv7G)Ovv0etvv.fE#vv.#vv.k

kvv2bvv!vv%G vvuvv0e

bvv!vv/#vvK+vv3G$RvvcvvLj#vv)8vvVvv.&vv1vvlvv-zG)qvvJGekvv2bvv!vv%G vvuvv0ey@Ovv1vvLCbvv0eG vv(vv2vv0A,

20|Qq%194.

(4)hqvJQObv!v1v,v.1v1v9v)#vEv$vJHEOv$v.bv1v"G$#v1vLtv$v.h>vJ1vHv\v-1v,v.CUv"zOQA8vcv.QV

G cr"hG (r"y1|159+$.:

67G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

=

Page 70: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

htvvKGqvv.dG vv?vv.0vv(vv2(1)0vv.CUvvEvv.1vv(vv./Rvv9vvfvv!vv.G1vv. vvuvv0ekvv!vv.bvvLkvv:

CfG vvuvv0e0vv2vv!vvg1vv2E vv/#vv.1vv!vvg#vv.GRvv9vvfvv!vv:1vv-,hqvv.dbvv(vvJ#vv.8vv-: vvrvvJ

GvYv:G v2vEvLG vHvYv%h[v!v2v:C+v"G)Ov0ehbv!v.#v,v%hOGv!v:kv2G vKj

&v,v.&v2bv(v-,hG!fkv(f v%0v9vJGQtv(v2Q1v21vLDv$v9v-kv. v.0v"/1v)G v?v.0v(v2,

h+vvvv.C&vvvv.C#vvvv.Jbvvvv!vvvv/bvvvvrvvvv1vvvvJIC#vvvv2Chqvvvv.dbvvvv!vvvv/bvvvvrvvvv1vvvvJIbvvvv?vvvv.FvvvvLC+vvvv"

&1P.1.Q(2)@

tv.fC+v"EOv9vrvLGA vuv0eG vcv!v$v.AhBQGFv,v%kv2Pebv!v%G vuv0ehPe

#vv)8vvuvv!vv%1vv-,hQ>vv.Y1vvcvvYvv,vv%bvv$vv.Gbvv9vvrvvJg#vv)kvv!vvPvvlvv7RGevv:1vv-bvv)

>vv.OIG vv\vvL0vvshG1vvcvvJ8vv-,QDvv.#vv)G vvM#vv)bvv)bvvrvv1vvJIG vvPvv!vvmG vvVvv. vvF#vv)

G vvVvvEvv.1vv7hG vv9vv.1vvcvv1vv)hCFvv$vv7G vvcvv!vv%tvv$vv. vvvhC1vv2Dvv(vv1vvlvv7hG vvSvv.kvvcvv2hCDvv$vvJ

hOvvlvv1vv.fhG vv2vvHvv.Qjhevv1vvL+vv%#vv)bvv!vv$vv.AG$#vv7QDvv$vv,vv%Gu>vv$vv1vvcvv.k

Dvv1vv=

C#vvPvvuvv.Gh vv%0vvHvv.Xvv.GhCDvvuvv$vv.Gbvvrvv. vv,vv%kvv1vv$vv.8vv(vv.qvv!vv.g1vv. vv(vvrvv"G vvVvvEvv1vvF

hG 2J 1"G VL0F@

+vvKgbvvrvv1vvJ8vv(vv.G vv9vv20vv?vv3bvv!vv/tvv"#vvPvv!vv%bvv.qvv"Cf0vv9vv$vvPvvv1vv,vv.

vv1vvPvv!vv%1vv,vv.bvvrvv!vv-h0vvuvv$vv"O0vv(vv-kvv,vv2bvvrvv1vvJIG vvVvvEvv.1vv7h#vv)8vv2vvcvv,vv%1vv(DvvPvv.f

hG$F$7>$1c.k

E/#)RGZq!2-@

q q q q q q

vvvvvvvcvvvvvvv!vvvvvvv%C+vvvvvvv$vvvvvvv!vvvvvvv:G vvvvvvv\vvvvvvv.Ga1vvvvvvv$vvvvvvvcvvvvvvv,vvvvvvvJG vvvvvvvvvLOvvvvvvvvv.dh#vvvvvvvvv)/qvvvvvvvvv.gkvvvvvvvvv2tvvvvvvvvv"bvvvvvvvvv.e

kvvvvv$vvvvv.Dvvvvv.R#vvvvv$vvvvv)0vvvvv,vvvvvJj1vvvvv,vvvvvJj#vvvvvEvvvvv$vvvvvJh vvvvvvvvvvvvPvvvvvvvvvvvv:8vvvvvvvvvvvvLGgqvvvvvvvvvvvv.Qbvvvvvvvvvvvv.k

Ovvvvvvvvvvvv)&vvvvvvvvvvvv.Oe(1)Rv1vIG vSv.kvcv1v7bv2vJG v$v!vv1v)bv2vJGu1v)0v.Ovm1v)#vEv$vJG v?v.0v(v2G v(v1vPv.1v.QjG v$vcvLha

1(#.eG EL#1)8.k2478+vvvvO1LCb0eG (20A18|468.

(2)G $0b!2G r.Qj,RLMG lr-G$t2L@

68G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 71: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

Cs(GdG}F}?G}Q<g?p,EC=9JG}|(QGyj+=+?

69G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 72: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

70G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 73: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

G |9eC<,I"+q?

#v)G v$vlv1vJqv2v"8vlvVv1v"G vEvJ0v=bv)G$Fv$v7G$Q1vcv7#vcvLkv7G vPv2v3

kv2G8vHv.P+v%Dv?qv7kv2#vcvLkv7G v<v.G1v:#v)G vcvrv1vJIG vLGOvHv7,hkv28v2v1v.f

#vv.Gqvvlvv,vv%h>vv,vv.O+vv%h8vvYvvEvv1vv.8vv,vv% vv(vvVvvLIG vvEvvsq,kvv2R#vv)tvv<vvLkvv1vv-C+vv"

G lLbhG$+.GAhG c!.ehG l!Pl7ht<LG ,LLhG $LL.

kvvrvvJPtvvL&vv.kvv2G vvlvvVvv"G vvPvv.1vvsG vv$vv(vv,vv@kvv2E;vv2vv.JG$#vv.QG vvfvv1vv2vv1vv7,

Gvv.Uvv7,hC;vv2vv9vv(vv.Cfq

G vvVvvEvv.1vv7G vvuvvLGevvvvQXvv.GfGubvv!vv1vv,vv%vvvvh1vvcvvJhkvv.I

G vv(vv2vv2q�tvv.&vv.G0vv9vv!vvrovv.f&vvVvv.UG vvrvvLBfG vvuvvL0vv%h#vv.;vv2vv:kvv2G vvPvv(qvv7

1v. v9vVvJ0vshG v9vPv!v1v%h0vrv.1v!v.&v,v.1v. vHvYv.YhG vEv3qhG v9vcv_v1v%,kv00vlvLqqv.f

kvv1vv,vv.1vv1vv)G vv$vv9vv.G8vvLhG!Dvv.O,1vv"C0vvrvv(vv.G1vvlvv\vvL8vv,vv%G vvPvv!vv1vv$vv7Cf>vv$vv1vvd#vv.

UvFqh#v.;v2v:bv)QOv.dGu�+v.hDv2#v)bv(vJGuNE v/Ov.FvL

G vvcvv2vv.O,h/1vvJq vv,vv%Cf0vvVvvJ

qqvv.GGvv2vvLg1vvSvvLWG vv1vvrvv1vv),h/1vvJ

q#vv)8vv(vvlvv1vvK

C#Lg1u$.dG/&r1.O.

kvv,vv"tvv.f vv%Fvv$qvv7G$Q1vvcvv7>vv,vv.O8vv<vv2vv:P vvv?hEftvv.&vv: vv,vv%+vvKg

G vv?vv,vv.Okvv,vv"0vv?vv3Cf&vv9vv2vvcvv,vv%kvv2&vv,vv?vv,vv%kvv2E;vv2vv.JG$#vv.QG vvcvvrvvJ0qvv7?

kvv.$#vv7G vv1vv.e8vv9qvv2vvcvv,vv%kvv2G$#vv.QG vv9vvcvv2vvJ0qvv7hG vv9vvSvvL0vvcvv1qvv7,hkvv1vv$vv.0vvcvvLabvv)

G vlvrv,v.Akv2G vlvuvLG)Ov0#v2C&v,v%Gbv9v(v.rG1v.Ov9v(v2v.WG$Dvuv.eG vSvLbv1qv7#v)

71G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 74: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

CO qvv9vv,vv.G vv9vvlvvVvv1vv!vv1qvv7,hqvvJOvv?

qvv"G vv9vv.Q0vvI+vvKGG vvlvvrvv-kvv2tvv9vv2vv,vv%1vv.Ovv9vvlvv.Xvv7.

8vvLi+vv"&vvrvv!vv:bvv(vv,vv%C0vvYvv.k

C#vv.Q8vv\vv.dG vv$vv?vv./JG vvcvvrvvJ0qvv7hG vvPvv1vv.Ovv1qvv7

hG$G0q1q7,CeC&,%Cel!.G8$.#.+KGG $?.d?

kvv. vv,vvJa#vv)OQGOvv7G$Fvv$vv7G$Q1vvcvv7kvv2QOvv. vv9vv2+vvKg+vv.8vvVvvJ0vvrvv,vv%

vHv2vLG!Dv.OhGbv9v2v.Q+v%C&v-#v)G$#v.QG vcvrvJ0qv7G v9v20v?v3Cf0v&#v)1v,v.

G)&vvvPvvv.f. vvv1vvvuvvv.fP vvvvDvvv?qvvv7bvvv!vvv/+vvvKgG$#qvvv7G vvv1vvv.etvvv20vvv9qvvvHvvvKhG#vvv)

CDu.#,%G 9c2J0q7hG 9SL0c1q7O0J&.k

k2#E.t$,%hOhQEk9.F,%.

h vvcvv"#vv)C1vvLRG vv<vv.G1vv:kvv2Dvv1vv.IG vv(vv.SC&vv,vv%/0vvPvv9vvfvv(vv.fbvv)

#vvcvv9vvrvvJ0vv. qvvJkvvuvvLG

k,hUvvJQbvv(vv-Ovv!vv.c,1vvVvvLaG vv(vv_vvLbvv)UvvEvv7+vvKG

G $c9rJChbJeUE9-.

kvvv9vvv!vvvv[vvv2vvv1vvvcvvv7G vvvPvvv!vvv.cG vvv2vvvSvvvLj; vvvKG/0vvvcvvvJeG vvvEvvvJ0vvv=kvvv2Cj

DY.QIb)G cr.FJ1Su"Ch1 GL.

h vv$qvv.tvv.fG)Ovv0e+vv.G vvJ0vv)bvv(vvJGu,htvv.f#vv9vvYvv$qvv(vv.k

vv!vvVvvEvv1vvF

#v)G vcvrv.FvJkv2Guh#v0Fvuv9v-htv9v2v-hQOv!v-hG v1v.eG!GvLhG vrvYv.AhG vrvJQ

Gvv1vvLghRvvLqgh>vvJ&vv.G+vv9vv$vv.#vv.k

hGXvvEvv.k

1vv##vv.QG vvcvvrvv1vvJIh#vvPvv.Fvv!vv,vv.kvv2G vvrvvLBf

G vuvL0v%hG vPv(6v7G vSvL0vlv7,hqvJtvlv/G v$v(v,v@G vrvLB&v2hG v(v2v.jqG v$vPv!v$v1v)kv2

+vvKGG vvVvvJOkvvlvv,vv$vv.GG vv$vvLGOhbvv$vv!vv.G1vv-,G$#vvLG vvKj>vvcvv"G vvVvvEvv.1vv7vvvv

QXv.GfGubv!v1v,v%vvvv/0vHv9v!vlv.fkv2C#v.QG vcvrv1vJIGGv9v0kv,v%kv2#vPv.Fv"

G vvvlvvvrvvv-. vvvuvvv)+vvvKGG$#vvvL vvv%0vvvPvvv9vvv$vvvLq[vvv.0vvv0k

,Qevvv%h>vvv.OG vvv$vvvVvvvJQ#vvv)

G vuv9v.HhG vPv(v7,P vvC&v->vLJ^vLhah1vLRJCDvJGKCh>vJJ>vJ/k

D.d1cZG $P.F"G crJ07.

72G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 75: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

kvvv2vvvcvvvJDvvv.O;vvv7G vvv9vvvEvvvuvvv1vvv%&vvvSvvv#JkvvvLbG vvvHvvv.GQLhv̂vv,vvvLJG vvvSvvv1vvvcvvv7,

hG v$vL>v,v7,;v%8v2vcv,v.1vcvJR#v)v̂,v.QkvLbCGvLitv. v$vcv9vM v7hG$Rv.bvLI,

h#(KG lLbG$h /1JCG EJ0=b)G $P.F"G crJ07(1).

hbv(vJG v2vEv=kv2>v,v.OG vlvrv,v.AG$Q1vcv7 v*#v.eC1v2Dv(v1vlv7hG)#v.e

#vvvv. vvvvvhG)#vvvv.eG vvvvSvvvv.kvvvvcvvvv2hG)#vvvv.eCDvvvv$vvvvJ1vvvv)Dvvvv(vvvv2vvvv"vvvv&vvvvLi>vvvv,vvvv.O+vvvv%

G vvYvvHvv$vv7h8vvYvvEvv1vv.8vv,vv%G vvuvv2vvLikvv2>vv$vvdtvv"#vv.C;vvLbvv)G vv(vv2vv2�#vv)

qvv.dChkvvcvv"Ch8vvrvvL0vvL.h&vv_vvLGk

vv_vv,vv.QG vv.Xqvv.bvv1vv)hC+vv"G$+vv.GAG vvK0vv)

Gkvv9vvLhGbvv!vv/QOvv.dGu�hqvv. vv.G#vv. vv%0vvrvv!vv-,kvvrvvJGRvv9vvL[vv.Gkvv2&vvrvv"

G vvPvv(qvv7#vvcvvLkvv7G)Ovv(vv.O,hqvv. vv.G:G)Ovv(vv.O#vv)G vvJ0vv),h vv./G)Ovv(vv.O vvrvv.d

#v)Rv.A#v.Rv.A,h1v.Jbv!v%G)Ov(v.O+vKGhG vrv.GbvJG vcv!v$v1v7G v9v2RvL[v,v.

bv!v$v.AG vEvJ0v= vrv2v.dG$Gv2v.Q#v)Cbv_v%#vlv.GvLG v$vPv!v$v1v)bv!v/ev1vL+v%

#vv)C#vv%G vvJ&vv1vv.,h1vv-DvvlvvaGu+vvKGG vvJ0vv)#vv)bvv2vv=G vvcvv.1vv<vv1vv),h#vv)Cf

09uJq

Q&2c-G$U1"Ch09!2Qk1-G Es1. 2.["(2).

kvv,vv.+vv.G vvSvv.kvvcvv20vv(vv9vvVvv3tvv. vv\vv.OG vvSvv.#vvI,0vvJGkvvdbvv)G vvcvvrvv1vvJI

G vVvEv1vEv7,h0vEvKq

QG v(v.S#v)G v.qv.Ykv21vLG;v)G vlv!vPvlv7G v1v.&v.&v1v7hbv!v%

G vvuvv0e,h0vvrvv.d:z$f0vv!vvrvv/GuG vvcvv2vvJ1vvuvv"P&vv3#vv.Gvv0G vvSvvLc1vv.u,

G1L#)Cf0!r.g1S2A#)G$+.GAy(3).

(1)C1vv.G vv1vvM0vvJC1vv.R0vvJG vvcvv?vv$vv2,G vvcvvrvv1vvJIG)Ovv0#vv1vv7bvv(vvJG vvlvvrvv,vv.AG$Q1vvcvv7,G vvrvv.+vvLI,OGQG P0e !\2.b7hG (SL,,G \2c7G$h /,1428+vvvv|2007e,3.

(2)bvvJ&vv.fC#vv.#vv7,G vv9vv?vvJ0vvJkvv2G vvlvvuvvLG)Ovv0#vv2,G vv$vv$vv!vvuvv7G vvcvvL1vv1vv7G vvPvvcvv.O0vv7,OGQG1vv)G ?.Rj,[2c7Ch /,1424+vvvv,91.

(3)G1)t<1L,G 2JG07hG (,.07,G c.RL,265.

73G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 76: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

h0vvcvvJqG vvSvv.kvvcvv2Chd#vv)Uvv(qvvmkvv2CUvv.dG vvlvvrvv-,hCQOvv/qvv.GbvvJg

1vv0GGvv9vv0ah/GQ8vv1vv.H,hP vvvkvv2tvv9vv.1vv-zG vvLOvv. vv7y,h0vvrvv.dCDvv$vvJ

Rvv.tvvL#vvEvvrqvvsG vvuvv9vv.H:zh vv1vvQtvv9vv.HG vvLOvv. vv7Chdtvv9vv.HC

o qvvmkvv2bvv!vv%

CUvvv.dG vvvlvvvrvvv-,1vvv"+vvv.Chdtvvv9vvv.Hkvvv2bvvv!vvv%CUvvv.dG vvvEvvvJ0vvv=,$f#vvv.

bvvvLXvvv-G vvvSvvv.kvvvcvvv2kvvv2tvvv9vvv.HG vvvLOvvv. vvv7#vvv)1vvv1vvv.f vvvEvvv?vvv1qvvv7Gvvv2vvvLG vvv.GDvvvJ,

hRvvLhWUvvEvv7G vvEvvJ0vv=,hbvvJG vv7G vvLhGI,hQOGvv2vvLG vv$vvLOvv"hG vv$vv(vvrvv\vvd

hE v/ev1vLP vv,+v.CObhCev!v/#v.tv9v3G vcv!v$v.Akv2CUv.dG vEvJ0v=,

1v"EfG v$v9vlvrqv-kv2bv!v.eG vEvJ0v=0vcvLaCf#v.tv9v31vcvJgE&v$v.+v.kvLhY

#(-hb. 7b!1-hC&->$dP vhU(ql-b!/e1L#<.dO2sy(1).

!Wz@&hsOQG@&hYq9@&GyWMZ+?:vvvv

qv.dbv(v-G vEv.kvaG vK+v2v2:zG)#v.ekvrv1v-G v$v!qv7,bv. v%G vcvLGb,C1v.

Dvvv(vvv1vvvlvvv7G vvv(vvvcvvv$vvv.f1vvv);vvv.1vvv:G1vvv)Rh[vvv2G vvv9vvv$vvv1vvv$vvv2,G vvvuvvv.kvvv2,#vvv. vvv/1vvv(vvv2

8v1qv%Gu1v);vcv!v2v7,0vrv.d:E&qv-#v)C1v(v.Akv.QSy.h vJOv(v7;v$v.&v1v)kv2Dv1v.I

Uf.QG VE.17,hQCiC&Q1)#. v(2) $.qJeb!1,%G u.k7(3).

(1)G S.kc2,G LO. 7,13.

(2)#vvv. vvvv1vvv)C&vvvQ1vvv)G vvv(vvvYvvvL1vvv)Xvvv$vvvYvvv%,Gvvv.OeQOvvv.dGuUvvv!qvvv/Gubvvv!vvv1vvv,vvv%hOvvv!

qvvv%

hUvv.Dvv2vv-,hC#qvv-CeDvvLGe#vv!vv1vvuvv71vv(vv:#vv!vvEvv.f@@@,Rh>vv7C1vv2[vv!vvEvv7R0vvJ1vv)Ovv,vv"G$&vvVvv.Qj,#vv.Jh vv-#vv.Fvv7hOvv2vvdOvv(vv1vv),h+vv.BGvvL#vv)#vv.J#vv)G vvVvvEvv.1vv71vv. vv2vvVvvLI,

hqvvJGGvv9vv!vvmG vv$vv&QGvv.fkvv2Ovv(vv7hkvv.8vv-,qvv1vv"Ovv(vv790hqvv1vv"92hqvv1vv"93hGuCbvv!vv%.G&_LG 2JG07hG (,.07,10vvvv97.

(3)#vvEvv$vvJ1vv)CDvv$vvJ1vv)bvv<vv$vv.fG vvK+vv2vv2(J748),Ovv1vvLCbvv0eG vv(vv2vv0A,#vv&OvvPvv7G vvLOvv. vv7,G \2c7G$h /,1401+vvvv,6vvvv360.

74G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 77: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

&vSv#G)#v.eC1v.Dv(v1vlv71v. vuv.kv7hbv.TCtv<vLDv1v.8v-kv1v,v.,htv.f1v1v)

COvvLI8vvSvv1vvLG vvSvv.G+vvJC&qvv,vv.#vvPvv!vv$vv7#vv)>vv,vv7,hC&

qvv,vv.PGJ0vvPvv.Q#vv)>vv,vv7

CGvLi,kv!vcv"hG vJC1v2Dv(v1vlv7tv.f8v.>vLG0vuvPv3qv.JCOvL8v-#v)8v?v.QI

G vHvMqG v9v2GDv9vLkv,v.C1v.Dv(v1vlv7G v(vcv$v.f.hG vcvLGbqv2v"G)Ov0eh#v)1vcvJg

vvvv#vv.[vv)G vv$vv!vv"hG vv(vvEvv"vvvvEPtvv.f#vv.[vv(vv. vv$vvJ&vv1qvv.JhDvvYvv.QGJqvvJ0vv$vv7,

htvv.fG vvPvvL0vv.fqvvJG&vv9vvSvvLhGkvv1vv-,hC&vvSvv#hG vv,vv%#vvJGQS,qvv2vv"G/Ovv0e,

tvv.&vv:#vv<vv.1vv7 vvlvv!vvPvvlvv7G vv1vv.&vv.fhDvvuvv$vv7G vvlvvLS,htvv.&vv:kvv2G vvcvvLGbBQGA

89Y.QHk2G P1.O7hCU.dG/b9r.O.

h vvvJG)#vvv.eC1vvv2Dvvv(vvv1vvvlvvv7kvvv2bvvv,vvvJG)#vvv.eG vvvHvvv!vvv1vvvlvvv7bvvv2vvvJG vvv$vvv!vvvv1vvv)

#LhGfq,k2b,J1(2C#1q7(1).

Dv1v=Ovrv\v:Oh v7G vHv0kv7G$#v.0v7Ov(v7132+vvvvv,kv2bv,vJ#vLhGf

G v<v.&v2(1v)#vEv$vJG v?vcvJj),hqv1v.eOh v7G vHv0kv7G vcv2qv.Ov1v7,kvcv.UvLC1v.

Dvv(vv1vvlvv7Oh vv7G vvHvv0kvv7G$#vv.0qvv7hOh vv7G vvHvv0kvv7G vvcvv2qvv.Ovv1vv7G$h vv/,h#vvdCfq

G vvJh vv7G$#vv.0qvv7qvvJDvvrqvvrvv:C#vv?vv.OG

kQGFvvcvv7kvv2#vv?vv.dG vvlvv9vv.Dvv.JhG&vv9vvSvv.Q

G)Ovvv0e,kvvvrvvvJGRvvv9vvv,vvvLG)#vvv.eC1vvv.Dvvv(vvv1vvvlvvv7kvvv21vvvJG0vvv7bvvv,vvvJgE vvv/G$GvvvK

1v. vLCj,kvrvJtv.fbv.Qkv.1v#Dv.GdG vEv1v.I,#vPv9v.bv2v.;vrv.kv7tv"#v)Ov2vrv.g

h#vvv)bvvv.UvvvLhg,Gvvv2vvv1vvvLG1vvv. vvvL>vvv.d,RvvvJ0vvvJGk

bvvv!vvv/C+vvv"G vvv2vvv.[vvv",#vvvL0vvvL

G vvPvvHvvL0vv71vv. vv$vvM0qvvlvv1vv),/Pbvv.#vvdG vv$vv(vv.kvvrvv1vv)#vv)#vv9vvcvv.[vv2G vvlvvrvv-hG vvcvv!vv%

(1)GOvv9vv!vv%G vvHvv0kvv7#vvcvv.h0vv71vv)C1vv2Ovvlvv1vv.f,1vvcvvJCf8vv(vv.RdG vvEvvPvv)1vv)bvv!vv21vv)C1vv2[vv. vv3

bvv)G vvHvv0kvv7 vv-,E0vvKG&vv.1vv2vvJG0vv7#vvLDvv!vv7Ovv1vv.Ovv1vv7>vvJ0vvJI#vv)#vvLGDvv"G vv9vv.Q0vvIG)Ovv0#vv2,8vvrvv!

qvvJkvv1vv,vv.G$#vv.0vv1vv)G vv?vvuvv%.G&vv_vvL8vv.Q0vvIG vvJh vv7G)#vv.0vv7,O.#vvEvv$vvJOvv,vv1vv"[vvrvv.T,

11LhJ,OGQG (l.FQ,1416+vvvv|1996e,W1,201.

75G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 78: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

hG v<vrv.kv7kv2bvVvLg,h+v.bvVvLevL0v3Dvrv.,bvVvL#v!v2A1v. v9v\vLa,h+v.

G vcvVvLG v2v.+vL1v. vlv9v.Dv.JhG v<vLGAG vlvuvLjq,h+v.kv2G v.qv:&vlvPv-bvVvL

G vvVvvcvv. vv1vvvG vvuvv2vv.Q,bvvVvvLevv.#vvL1vv. vv2vv\vv./JhG$Dvv0ehG vvHvv\vvLhG vvfvv(vv/

G vvvLhDvvv2,bvvvVvvvL#vvvlvvvcvvv%1vvv#UvvvJGAG vvv$vvv#Ovvv.I,hG$DvvvMGf,bvvvVvvvL#vvv!vvv9vvv,vvv3

1.$R.GbE /G cJdh1. E(1)E /G LD$7hG VJbhG)DP.f.

G vv9vvrvv/C1vv.Dvv(vv1vvlvv71vv#&vvQ1vv)#vv. vvvG vv$vv9vv.kvv/kvv2Ovv(vv793 vv!vv,vv?vvLI

htv.fbv$vLg13Ov(v7.QCiC1v.Dv(v1vlv7B;v.QG vVvEv.1v7hQCi8v0#v1vKbv2vJGu

1vv)#vvPvvcvv.OG vvKjtvv.f#vvJQOvv7kvvrvv,vv1qvv7kvv2G vvcvvLGbDvv1vv=&vvSvv#G)#vv.eC1vv.

D(1l7h8LbLY(1)

GOvv9vvrvv2vv!vv:G vvuvv.kvv7C1vv.Dvv(vv1vvlvv7htvv.&vv:B&vvKGcDvv.XvvLI#vv)Dvv.GXvvL

G vvcvv!vv%,8vv$vv.L1vvEvv!vvrvv.JG vvlvvrvv-hG vvEvvJ0vv=hG vvrvvLGAGJhG vv!vvfvv7hG vvcvv!vv.e,

h8vv$vv9vv!vv-#vvPvv.>vvJ+vv.1vvSvv1vv.NG vvcvv!vv%hCFvv$vv9vv-,hkvv2+vvKgG vv$vvJ0vv(vv7qvvYvv/C1vv.

D(1l7#c_%D1.8-#9c!q

$.hb. $.(2).

h8vvLOqOkvv2Uvv2vv.g,1vvcvvJCfDvvlvvaG vvrvvLBf,bvv!vv/+vvKgG vvEvv!vvrvv.J, vvuvv(qvv-

tv.f#v(vVvLkv.E v/#v,v(v7G v9v?v.QI#vdC1v1v-.hv̂"tvK vvDv9v/&vVvEv-G vSvcv2v2(3)

(1)G K+22,O1LCb0eG (20A,6,220.

(2)G $VJQ&lP-,6,221.

(3)G vvSvvcvv2vv2:bvv.#vvL1vv)RvvLGDvv1vv"1vv)bvv2vvJG vvSvvcvv2vv2,#vv)+vv$vvJGfh vvJ vvPvv:Ovv(vv1vv)Gvv!vv:#vv)Gvvv0kvvv7bvvv<vvv$vvv.fSh#vvv.JOvvv(vvv7CQ1vvvdh#vvv.Fvvv7,hqvvv1vvv"Ovvv(vvv7Ovvv2vvvdh#vvv.Fvvv7h+vvv.G1vvv)G;vvv(vvv9vvv1vvv)h;v$v.&v1v)Ov(v7,qv.dG vM+vLj:G vcv!v$v.ACQ1vcv7:Ovcv1vJ1v)G v$vPv1v31v. v$vJ0v(v7hbv.#vLG vSvcv2v21v. vuv.kv7hG vEvPv)1v)C1v2G vEvPv)G v2vVvLj1v. v2vVvLIh#vuvEv.d1v. vSv.e.G&v_vL[v2vrv.JG vlvrv,v.A

$12GOE.bG S1LGRj,11LhJ,OGQG LGFJG cL12,W2,1401+vvvv|1981e,81.

76G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 79: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

1v#f0v9vlvLqZ v!vcv!v%h/0vHv9v!vmE v/G vPv.bE/q

vEv.>v7G vEv1v.I.QhiC1v.#vEv$vJ

G vEv.Q;v21vPv(vJgE v/G)#v.eE1v2Dv(v1vlv7q8vcv. v/qv.d:#vLQJ0v.#v.bv!v/

G vvSvvcvv2vv2h+vv.>vv. vvQ,kvvJbvv.&vv2hqvv.d:zbvv!vv1vvv1vv. vv(vv_vvLkvv2G vvcvv!vv%h#vv?vv. vvPvv7

G c!$.Ak(&q

2CQik1v0r_7hDLt7.q.d:k.qdk2q!22#)q. -,k9Lt:

G/G90aE /G P.b,vvvvhCGKJk2G c!%,k(lc(2Gu8c. /1r. -(1)).

hkv2G vcvLGbtv.&v:G!QGA#v9vYv.Q1v7kv2G vPv1v.Ov7hCUv.dG vcvrv.FvJ,

1vv1vv)G vvHvv.GQLhG vvSvv1vvcvv7.kvvlvv2bvv,vvJG vvHvv!vv1vvlvv7bvv<vv$vv.fSbvv.e30+vvvvvv,

1vJCJG vlv9v(v7kv2G v_v,v.Q,htv.&v:#vJ0v(v7G vuv.kv7#vLtvMG vSvfv3hG vlv9v)kv2

1vvJG0vv.J8vv.Q0vvIG vv$vvPvv!vv$vv1vv),Dvv1vv=1vvJCJG vvlvv9vv)1vv1vv)G vv$vvfvvLXvv1vv)hG vvHvv2vv<vv.A

hG vvvvHvvvv.Q>vvvv1vvvv)bvvvv!vvvv/G)#vvvv.e,h1vvvvcvvvvZG vvvvSvvvv2vvvv.HG vvvv$vvvvHvvvv. vvvvmG vvvv$vvvvL8vvvvuvvvv3

v!v$vEvL#qv.J.h&v_qv$v:#v?v$v.bv7#v)CbvJGAG)Ov0eG v$v.8v.Q0v)#v)G v1v,v.O

hG vv(vvVvv.QihG vv$vv?vv.Sz>vv$vvcvv1qvv7OvvL0qvv7yGvv2vv1vv<vv7,htvv.fbvv!vv/QCOvv,vv.0vv,vv.Ojq

#v)0v,v.OG v1v$v),GObqv/G)Ov0ekv2Gv0kv7bv<v$v.f1v)bvl

qv.fS,hRbv%

C&qvv-Uvv.Q#vv)G vv$vvPvv!vv$vv1vv)@@@E&

qvv-G vv1vv,vv.Ojzbvv2vvJGu1vv)h+vv31vv)Ovv2vv#y

G vv$vvcvvLha1vv.1vv)G vvPvv.OGA,$fq

C#qvv-tvv.&vv:Ovv.OGA,h0vvcvvLaC8vv2vv.bvv-1vv.Ovv%

G vvPvv2vv,vv1vv1vv),h vv,vv%G vvJhQG$hqdkvv2G vvHvvLhLbvv!vv/bvv<vv$vv.fS;vv%qvv9vv!vv-,

h1cJP vG HLhLb!/b!2qShCQX.g,;%q9!-(2).

(1)#vEv$vJC1v.R+vLI,8v.Q0vIG v$vKG+v3G)Ov0#v1v7,OGQG vEvJ0v=,Ohf[v2vcv7,1987,349

vvvv3591v9vVvLqa.h#vEv$vJ1v!v9v.>v2,#v(v.+v@G v9vSvL0vdG)Ov0#v2kv2G vrvLfG v<v.&v2G v,v?vLj,G r.+LI,OGQG P0e,W1,1425+vvvv|2004e,199.

(2)C1vv2>vvcvvlvvL#vvEvv$vvJ1vv)>vvL0vvLG vv\vv2vvLjG vv$vv9vv.kvv2310+vvvvvv,8vv.Q0vvIG vv\vv2vvLj,OGQG vvlvvuvvL,

1v1vLhJ,W2,1423+vvvvv|2002e,5|147.hC1v2G vEvPv)G$RvcvLjJ330+vvvvv,#vrv./J

77G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

=

Page 80: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

G8v?v-G)#v.eC1v.Dv(v1vlv7E v/OQGOv7bv!v%G vuv0eDv9v/1vLYkv1v-1vLGbv7#vuqv(v9v-

#v)#v?v.O v7CUvEv.HG vlvLbG v$vHv9v!vlv7h#vEv.>v.8v,v%kv21vcvZ#vPv.Fv"G vcvrv1vJI,

;v%G&vVvLaE v/G vlvrv-h vMeDv$qv.O1v)C1v2Ov!v1v$v.f(1),h[v. v:#v0R#v9v- v-Dv9v/

1vv!vvg;vv$vv.&vv1vv7bvvSvvLbvv.#vv.,hG&vv,vv/E vv1vv-G vvlvvrvv-h8vvrvv!qvvJRbvv.#vv7#vvJQOvv7G vvLCj#vv)1vvcvvJ

Rvvv1vvvHvvv-,hG vvv9vvvmDvvv. vvv-G vvvLGevvv2vvv.fkvvv2G vvvlvvvrvvv-,h1vvvLR#vvv(vvv,vvv%C1vvv.0vvv.Ovvvm(2)(3),

G)Ovvvv0#vvvv1vvvv1vvvv)1vvvv9vvvvEvvvvrvvvv1vvvvs#vvvvEvvvv$vvvvJ#vvvvEvvvv1vvvv2G vvvvJ0vvvv)bvvvv2vvvvJG vvvvEvvvv$vvvv1vvvvJ,OGQChOvvvvrvvvv,vvvv.,W2,

1405+vvvvv|1985e,85.bvMG vJ0v)C1v.G vEvPv)G1v)G$;v1vL,(555vvvv630+vvvvv),Gbv9v(v/1v-C1vv.Uvv,vv1vv3G vvuvvL#vv2,G vvuvv.#vv"kvv2G vv9vv.Q0vvI,1vv1vv:G$kvvuvv.QG vvJh vv1vv7,G$QOfhG vvPvvcvv.O0vv7,O.W,O.J,391.G vvSvv,vvLOvv9vv.&vv2,C1vv2G vvlvv9vvF#vvEvv$vvJ1vv)bvv2vvJG vvuvvL0vv%,G vv$vv9vv.kvv2Ovv(vv7

548+vvvvv,G v$v!v"hG v(vEv",UvEvEv-G$Ov9v.PCDv$vJkv,v$v2#vEv$vJ,OGQG vPvLhQ,1v1vLhJ,

W1,1367+vvvvvv|1948e,289.C1vv.R+vvLI,#vvEvv$vvJ,8vv.Q0vvIG vv$vvKG+vv3G)Ovv0#vv1vv7,OGQG vvvEvvvJ0vvv=,1987,38.G)OvvvlvvvLG0vvv1vvv(vvv2,#vvvEvvv$vvvJ, vvv.G#vvvdG$&vvv.GQ,1vvv1vvvLhJ,G vvv$vvvuvvv9vvv3

G)O0#2,1367+vvvv|1948e,1|80.

(1)Dv$v.O1v)C1v2Ov!v1v$v.f:#v. v/G1vLG+v1v%1v)C1v2#v.Ov/G$RvcvLj.qv.dCDv$vJ:#vrv.QH#v.Qhibv(v-G vrvJ#v.AOvlv1v.fhRvcv2v-.hqv.dC0vYv.Ov$v.Y+vSv.e#v(v-Uv. vF.qv.d:h vuv)Dv$qv.O0vcv(v2G1v)Ov!v$v7bv(vJgbv(v-8vHv!v1v]tv<v1vL.hqv.dG1v)Rv2vL#v7:#v.CDvJC#qv)bv!v2q1vcv!v%#v)

Dvv$qvv.O.hqvv.d#vvcvv$vvL:#vv.QC0vv:Ckvvrvv-#vv)+vv&/AG vvM+vvLj,hDvv$vv.O,hqvv9vv.OI.8vv.kvv2Ovv(vv7bSL0)h#.F7.G&_L8,K03G 9,K03/1)D?LG cPr0&2,14|3.

(2)C1vv.0vv.Ovvm,0vvcvvrvv.H1vv)G1vvLG+vv1vv%G vvuvv.kvv2(113vvvv182).+vv.0vvcvvrvv.H1vv)G1vvLG+vv1vv%1vv)Dvv2vv1vv3G$&vvVvv.QjUvv.Dvv3G)#vv.eC1vv2Dvv(vv1vvlvv7h8vv!vv$vv1vvKghChqd#vv)&vvSvvL#vvK+vv2vv-,h+vv.Chqd#vv)Obvv2zqvv.Xvv2G vvrvvYvv.Iykvv2bvv,vvJG vvLRvv1vvJ,tvv.f vv-G vvlvvYvv"G$tvv2vvLbvv!vv/#vvK+vv3C1vv2Dvv(vv1vvlvv7kvv28vvJh0vv)CUvv. vv-,h&vvSvvLBQGFvv-kvv2Cqvv\vv.QG$QV,htvv.f#vv?vv9vv,vvJG#vv\vv!vvrvv..G&vv_vvL

RvLMG vlvrv-G$tv2vL$1v2Dv(v1vlv7G v(vcv$v.f,G v$v0bv!v21v)Ov!v\v.f#vEv$vJG vrv.Qj,8vEvrv1vs

G vvvSvvv1vvvI#vvvLhGf#vvvEvvv$vvvJG vvvSvvvcqvvv.Q,1vvv1vvvLhJ,OGQG vvv(vvvlvvv.FvvvQ,W2,2009e,U23,kvvv2G vvEvv.Rvv1vv7hG&vv_vvLO.h+vv2vv7G vvMDvv1vv!vv2,G vvlvvrvv-G)Ovv0#vv2hCO

qvv9vv-,O#vvSvvs,OGQG vvlvvuvvL,W3,

1989e,30.

(3)#vvvEvvv$vvvJ1vvv)G vvvEvvvPvvv)G vvvSvvv1vvv2vvv.&vvv2(132vvvv189+vvvvvvv),h vvvJ1vvv.GOvvv],htvvv.fhG vvvJg#vvv)C+vvv"DvLOv9v.1vJ#vSvs,h&vSv#1v. vuv.kv7,hbv.Tkv21vfvJGO,h8v.kv21v. vLj,8vlvrv-Ch/bv!v/C1v2

78G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

=

Page 81: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

hRkvL(1),hbv$v!v.G#vcv-bv!v/8vuv.0v)G v$vK+v3G vEv(vlv2.Efq

G v_v$v#E v/G v$vcvLkv7

>vvcvv!vv-0vvL8vv.ODvv!vvrvv.JG vvcvv!vv$vv.Akvv2#vvPvv?vvJG vvuvv.kvv7,htvv.f1vvcvvYvv,vv.0vv9vvJGQS

CUv.dG vcvrv.FvJ(bv!v%G vuv0e),h1vcvYv,v.G$Dv.O0v=G v(v2v.0v7,h1vcvYv,v.G vlvrv-

hCtv<vL+v. v!vrvLBfG vuvL0v%,;v%#vYv/0v(vSvJG vcv!v%kv2Dv!vrv.JG v2vVvLI.h1v,vL8v-

Dv!vrv7bv!v$v.AG vuv0e, v$v.tv.f0v<v.Qkv1v,v.#v)>vJd#vPv9vrv"0vLXv/kv9v.8v-.h vMe

C+vv"G vvuvv0e;vv%bvvJdbvv(vv,vv%E vv/Dvv!vvrvv.JCGvvLi.htvv.fCtvv<vvL#vv.GRvv9vv,vvL1vv-

G vvlvvrvv-h0vv!vv1vv-G vvEvvJ0vv=,0vvrvv.dG)#vv.eG vvK+vv2vv2(2):G vvPvv2vv3kvv2OQGOvv9vv- vvcvv!vv%

G vvuvv0e+vv.G vv?vvJdG vvJGFvvL1vv1vv)G vvlvvLbG vv$vvHvv9vv!vvlvv7#vv)Rvv1vvcvv7(3),hGvv.GQL(4),

Dv(v1vlv7,;v%C8v%q8vcv!v$v-bv!v/C1v20v.Ovm,h/Re#v. vv1v)C&vQ#vJqI,hG&v9v,v:E v1v-Q0v.Ov7

G vvlvvrvv-1vv. vvcvvLGb1vvcvvJC1vv20vv.Ovvm,htvv.f&vv.1vvfvv7#vv)CPtvv1vv.AG vvcvv!vv%h#vv?vv9vv,vvJG#vv\vv!vvrvv.,Uvv(qvvm

G vv9vvVvv.&vv1vvmG vvuvv<vv1vvLIG vv9vv2Dvvlvva1vv,vv.kvvrvv-C1vv2Dvv(vv1vvlvv7,kvv,vv.Uvv.Dvv3G vvlvvYvv"kvv28vvJh0vv)G $K+3G E(l2ht92-z^.+LG LhG07y+2G E?7G $c9$JIb(JG E(l17.

(1)C1vvv.+vvvK0vvv",RkvvvL1vvv)+vvvK0vvv"1vvv)qvvv1vvvQG vvvuvvv.kvvv2(110vvvv108+vvvvvvv),h vvvJkvvv2CUvvv2vvv,vvv.f,h8v.kv21v. v2vVvLI,tv.f#v)CUvEv.HG vEvJ0v=;v%ev!v3bv!v1v-G vLCj,h#v,vLkv2G vrv1v.S,

Dvvv9vvv/Uvvv.QCqvvv1vvvQ8vvv0#vvvKIC1vvv2Dvvv(vvv1vvvlvvv7hCUvvvEvvv.1vvv-,htvvv.f#vvv?vvv9vvv,vvvJG#vvv\vvv!vvvrvvv..G&vvv_vvvLG vvvlvvvrvvv-G)O0#2hCOq 9-,O.h+27G MD1!2,O#Ss,OGQG luL,W3,1989e,30.

(2)G vvK+vv2vv2,G vvEvv.kvvaRvv$vvQG vvJ0vv),Ovv1vvLCbvv0eG vv(vv2vv0A,CRvvLabvv!vv/8vvEvvrvv1vvrvv-#vvVvv\vvlvv/b2JG r.OQb\.,11LhJ,OGQG u93G c!$17,W1,2004e,6,222.

(3)G vSv1vcv7:CUv"G vSv1vcv7G vlvLqv7#v)G v(v.S,h8vrvdbv!v/G v.GDvJhG/;v(v1v)hG v?v$vdhG v$vKtvL

hG vv$vv&&vv=1vv!vvlvvahGDvvJh#vvcvv(vv/hGDvvJ,hqvvJevv!vv3+vvKGG/Ovv%bvv!vv/tvv"#vv)0vvMbvv%C&qvv-

0v9v. qv/bv!v1v.ShC+v"1v1v9v-Dv9v/Uv.Q v,v%GOv$v.Gv.U

qv.,hCUv!v,v%#v)C8v2v.Ybv2vJGu1v)O2#t$.8rJe.G&_L:8.Q0IG $KG+3G)O0#17,G)#.e#E$JC1.R+LI,33.

(4)G vHv.GQL:tv"#v)GvLLbv!v/G)#v.eG vEvsG vKjG8vlvrv:G v?v$v.bv7bv!v1v-0vPv$qv/Gv.Q>v1v.,h&vvSvv#JG vvHvv.GQLbvv)[vvL0vvsPhG vvHvv.0vvVvvLIQ>vv"#vv)1vv(vv28vv$vv1vv%GvvLLbvv!vv/G vv(vv2vv2�

hGvL>v:G vHv.GQLbv!v/bv!v21v)C1v2[v. v3hkv.Qqv.g,hkv.Qqv.G>v$v.bv7G v$vPv!v$v1v).G&v_vL

8.Q0IG $KG+3G)O0#17,G)#.eC1.R+LI,60.

79G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 82: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

h#vvcvv9vvM vv7(1),hkvv2Ovv(vv7110+vvvvvvGbvv9vvMdhGUvv"1vv)bvv\vv.A#vv?vv!vvQG vvEvvPvv)

G v2vVvLj(2),vvvvh+v.#v)bv!v$v.AG vPv!vmG vVv. vFvvvvkv?v.AE v/G vEv!vrv7Q>v"

#vv)bvv.#qvv7G vv$vvPvv!vv$vv1vv)0vvPvv#dbvv)G vvEvvuvv%G vvSvvLbvv2kvv2#vvL8vvuvv3G vvuvv2vv1vvLI?.

h#vvvcvvv!vvv.eCfq

C+vvv"G vvvPvvv(vvv70vvvrvvv. vvv.f1vvv#fq

#vvvL8vvvuvvv3G vvvuvvv2vvv1vvvLI#vvvPvvv!vvv%kvvv.Ovvvs,

/0vvvHvvvLL#vvv)G vvv$vvv!qvvv7.hG vvvHvvv.GQL0vvvrvvv. vvv.f:#vvvL8vvvuvvv3G vvvuvvv2vvv1vvvLItvvv.kvvvL1vvv.u

G vcv_v1v%#vHv!vJkv2G v(v.Q,hqv2v"Cf0v?v1v3G vSv1vIG v2vVvLjqv.ehGUv"0v)

bv\v.Ahqv.d:Efq

G vlv.Ovs#v)+vKgG$#qv7/+v.#v&#v)h/+v.tv.kvL,+v.

k2#(M 711)G $(M 91)(3).

vvrvvJGtvv9vvSvvmbvv(vvJ#vv.&vvYvv@Cfq

G vvPvv!vvmtvv.&vv.GCbvv!vv%1vv#Uvv.dG vvcvvrvv.FvvJ

h vv%0vv?vv.O vv.Gkvv2+vvKGG vv?vvJd.h#vv)G vvHvv1vvLCf0vv,vv9vv%1vv. vv9vvlvvrqvv-kvv2G vvrvvLBf

G vvuvvL0vv%hG vvEvvJ0vv=.hG&vv9vv,vv:1vv-QDvv08vv-1vv1vv)G vv2vvVvvLIhG vvuvv.kvv7E vv/G vvcvv.OI

E vvv/#vvv.[vvv(vvv-1vvv. vvvuvvv.kvvv7,hE vvv/G/Ovvv9vvvrvvvLGQkvvv2Dvvv!vvvrvvv.JG vvvlvvvrvvv-, vvv$vvv.G>vvv,vvv7

G$qvvYvv1vv7G vvEvvJ0vv<vv7G vv9vv2GOvv9vvEvvJ;vv:kvv2bvvVvvLg,h vvJQGOvv7[vvLGFvvsGOvv9vv(vv2vv.W

G$Du.e.

(1)G vv$vvcvv9vvM vv7:qvv1vv"Efq

hGUvv"1vv)bvv\vv.A+vv.G vvKjhXvvdCUvv.d#vvK+vv3G vv$vvcvv9vvM vv7,hqvvJtvv.f

#vv$vv)0vvEvvYvvLhf#vv?vv!vvQG vvEvvPvv)G vv2vvVvvLjG vvcvv!vv$vv2kvv<vv.QJ#vvPvv# vv7#vvL8vvuvv3G vvuvv2vv1vvLI,kvvrvv.d

hGUvv"#vvHvv. vvlvv.G vvEvvPvv):C&vv.Cqvv.dCfq

Uvv.Dvv3G vvuvv2vv1vvLI vv1vvQ1vv$vv&#vv)1vv([vv0b1vv"+vv.kvv2#vv(vvM vv71vv1vv)G vv$vv(vvM vv9vv1vv),;vv%Gbvv9vvMd#vv?vv!vvQG vvEvvPvv),hG8vvHvvK vv-#vv?vv!vvPvv.BGvvLkvv2BGvvL

G $P?J.G&_L8.Q0IG $KG+3G)O0#17,#E$JC1.R+LI,124.

(2)G vEvPv)G v2vVvLj:+v.C1v.Ovcv1vJG v2vVvLjG)#v.eG vlvrv1v-G v$vSv,v.Q,CDvJG v9v.1vcv1v)G vuv2v.Q

G$>v0q

Abv!v$v.hbv$v0hEGv0Uv.,h vJG vEvPv)kv2Gv0kv7bv$vL1v)G vHv\v.HS,hC8v/1vv-kvvJbvv. vv-hDvv(vvu

qvv-.h#vv.J1vv. vv2vvVvvLIkvv2Ovv(vv7bvvSvvLh#vv.Fvv7,hGuOvv2vvEvv.&vv-Cbvv!vv%.G&vv_vvL

G 2JG07hG (,.07/1)t<1L,285|9.

(3)G S,LO9.&2,G $!"hG (E",1,46.

80G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 83: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

#)CU.d#K+3G)#.eC12D(1l7:vvvv

tvv.fC1vv.Dvv(vv1vvlvv7q0vvrvv.d:BGvvK#vv.kvv2tvv9vv.HGuh1vv$vv.UvvFbvv)QOv.dGu�hQ1v$v.GRv9vLWR0v.OIbv)G vVvE

qv7hG vSv,vLIkv1v$v.8vrv9vYv1v-#v)

G$Dvvuvv.ehG vv$vvPvv.Fvv",kvv(f vv%C>vvJ1vvrvv.dG vvVvvEvv.1vv7,BGvvK1vvrvv.d#vv)Rvv,vv:

#vv(vv,vv%hCOYqvv.d#vv)Rvv,vv:#vv(vv,vv%bvv(vvJ#vv.0vvHvv9vv!vvlvv.f,h vvuvv(qvv2C vvMe&vvlvvPvv2

1v.$GvK#v)G vVvEv.1v7hEPGBdG$#vLE v/E1vLG+v1v%G v(vHvcv2(1),hE v/G v9v.1vcv1v)

tvv.$hRGbvv2(2),kvv(&qvv2C>vv9vv,vvJtvv$vv.G>vv9vv,vvJhGh/C vvMe&vvlvvPvv21vv(8vv2vv.YQCjhGDvJ#v(v,v%#v.OGeG$#vLG>v9v,v.O0v..htv.f0v#GvK1vEvJ0v=G!Dv.Oh0vcv$v"1v-#vv.C#vvuvv).kvv,vv$qvv-Cf

q1vvEvv.KG vvcvvrvv1vvJI+vv2G vvlvvrvv-G$tvv2vvL,hqvvJ>vv.AJ8vvPvv$vv1vv7

1vvcvvZB;vv.Qg1vv,vvKGG/Ovv%,hqvv.dC1vv.Dvv(vv1vvlvv7:zhG vvlvvrvv-kvv2G vvJ0vv)CkvvYvv"#vv)

G vvlvvrvv-kvv2G$Dvvuvv.e,h$f0vv9vvlvvrvv-G vvL>vv"tvv1vvm0vvcvv2vvJQ1qvv-Gvv1vvL vv-#vv)Cf

0v?v$vdG vcv!v%G vuv<v1vLy.qv.dC1v.#v\v1vd:qv!v:kv#Gv2vL&v2bv)CkvYv"G vlvrv-?qv.d

(1)E1vvLG+vv1vv%1vv)0vvM0vvJ0vv)G$Ovv.O1vv)bvv$vvLh1vv)Q1vv1vvcvv7G vv(vvHvvcvv2.qvv.dCDvv$vvJ:#vv.JOvv(vv7Ovv:

h8vPvcv1v).hqv.dG vSvcv2v2Dv1v)1v!vfv-#v.JE1vLG+v1v%:C+v!vvG vL>v"?qv1v" v-&vcv%,qv.d: v.qvv!vv:C&vvcvv2G vvcvv!vv%,#vv.Gvv!vvm1vvcvvJg#vv<vv!vv-hG vvcvv?vv3 vv-Dvv1vv)0vvlvvYvv"G1vv)>vv2vv1vvLbvv!vv/&vvlvvPvv-hOvv#Gvv2vvLtvv%bvv)P vvv,E&

qvv-&vvSvv#kvv2C+vv"1vv1vv:kvvrvv-kvv#GvvKkvvrvv,vv,vv%;vv%>vv!vvPvv(vv.kvv#GvvKUvvlvv.

DvvJ0vv<vv(vv.hE vv/kvvrvv-1vv1vv9vv-kvv$vv)tvv.f#vv<vv!vv-?G&vv_vvL[vv2vvrvv.JG vvlvvrvv,vv.A$1vv2EOvvEvv.bG vvSvv1vvLGRjG S.kc2,82.

(2)G$hRGbv2bv2vJG vLDv$vvsv):h vJOv(v7;v$v.fh;v$v.&v1v)h#v.JOv(v7Ov2vdhGv$vPv1v)h#v.Fv7.htv.f

#vv)Ovv2vv2C+vv"G vv1vv$vv)h vv%0vvuvv)#vv)G$hRGY,h#vv.Jh vv-Ovv9vv.fOvv(vv7.hOvv,vv"bvv)G vvlvvrvv-h v-;v0KbvSvLIOv(v7,hqv.dbv2vJG vLDv$vvsv)1v)#v,vJj:#v.tv.fCDvJ1v. vSv.eCbv!v%1v. vPv(v7#vv)G$hRGbvv2.hqvv.d+vvrvv"1vv)R0vv.O:C>vv.HG$hRGbvv2kvv2Ovv2vvcvv1vv)C vvm#vvPvv# vv7.hQhi

Cfq

Ovlv1v.fG v<v.Qj1v!vfv-#vrvJeG$hRGbv2kvHvLLDv9v/G v9vrv.g1vKj[v.i,CGvKbv(v-G vcv!v%C1v.GOvEv.bG vlvMGQjhbv2vJGu1v)G v$v2v.Qc.G&v_vL[v2vrv.JG vlvrv,v.A$1v2GOvEv.bG vSv1vLGRjG S.kc2,76.

81G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 84: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

C1vvv.Dvvv(vvv1vvvlvvv7:zCf0vvv9vvvcvvv!qvvv%G vvvL>vvv"G)0vvv$vvv.f1vvv.u,hG vvvSvvvLGFvvvd,hG vvvPvvv(vvv),

hG vvEvvJhO,hGGvv9vv0aG$#qvv7hG8vvlvv.qvv,vv.y(1).hqvvJC;vv2vv:C1vv.Dvv(vv1vvlvv7#vv.qvvlvv-#vv)

kv,v%G vVvlv.JG) v,v1v7kv2G vlvrv-G$tv2vL,CUv"G v9v.Dv1vJh#v.0vVvFqG/bv9vrv.O

bvv!vv1vv-0vv?vv3Cf0vvrvv.d:B#vv(vv:1vv.u,h#vv0Fvvuvv9vv-,htvv9vv2vv-,hQOvv!vv-,hG vv2vvcvv=

1vvcvvJG vv$vv.J,hG vvrvvJQGvv1vvLghRvvLqg#vv)Gu8vvcvv. vv/,hG vvEvvPvv.HhG vv$vv1vvMGf,

hG vv?vv(qvv7hG vv(vv.Q,Dvvstvv!qvv-.hGu8vvcvv. vv/hGDvvJ/#vv)[vvL0vvsG vvcvvJO,h vvuvv)

#v)[vL0vsC&qv-/RvL0vv v-{3456@v78@w9

:;<@x=>?@A@y}./0vSv2v,v-Rv2A

#v)G$Rv1v.A#v)Gv!vrv-h/0vSv2v-Rv1v,v.#v)Gv!vrv-, v%0vMdh/0vMGd1v#Ov$v.Fv-

hUvlv.8v-G vKG8v1qv7hG vlvcv!v1qv7. v%0vMdbv. v$v.1vcv!v$v-,hG vcv!v%Uvlv9v-kv2G$Rd,

hqv.OQG1vrvJQ8v-,hG vrvJQIUvlv9v-kv2G$Rd,h#v9vuv!qv$v.1vuv0#v-hG vuv0eUvlv9v-

kvv2G$Rd,hGvv. vvrvv.1vv9vvHvv!vv1vvrvv-hG vv9vvHvv!vv1vvsUvvlvv9vv-kvv2G$Rd,hkvv.bvv01vvlvvcvv!vv-

hG vvlvvcvv"Uvvlvv9vv-kvv2G$Rd,hG vvlvv.bvv"+vv.Gu8vvcvv. vv/,hG vvlvvcvv"Uvvlvv9vv-kvv2

G$Rd,hG vv$vvlvvcvv.d#vvHvv!vv.b,hkvvcvv"Gu8vvcvv. vv/evv1vvL#vvHvv!vv.b,hUvvlvv.8vv-kvv2

G$Rdevv1vvL#vvEvvJ;vv7h/#vvHvv!vv.qvv7,kvv$vv)qvv.dE&qvv,vv.#vvHvv!vv.qvv7,Ch#vvEvvJ;vv7,Ch

hqvvvmChRvvvvq

kvvv1vvv,vvv.kvvv,vvv.tvvv.kvvvL1vvv.u8vvvcvvv. vvv/.hG vvvrvvvLBfkvvv2G vvv$vvvVvvv.Dvvvm

#vvuvv9vv.H,hkvv2G vvrvv!vv.H#vvEvvlvv.X,hbvv!vv/G$ vvPvv)#vvrvvLhA,hbvv!vv/G vv(vv2vv2

#v(vMqd,h vlv_v(v.1v. vrvLBf#vHv!v.b,htv9v.1v9v(v.hqvLGA8v(v. v-#vHv!v.bhG vrvLBfev1vL

#vvvHvvv!vvv.b.0vvvcvvv!vvv%/tvvvcvvv!vvv$vvv(vvv.,h0vvvrvvvJQ/tvvvrvvvJQ8vvv(vvv.,h0vvvPvvv$vvvd/tvvvPvvv$vvvcvvv(vvv.,

(1)G)#v.e#vEv$vJC1v.R+vLI,C1v.Dv(v1vlv7Dv1v.8v-hbvVvLgvvvvBQGDghkvrv,v-,G vrv.+vLI,OGQG vlvuvL

G cL12,1974e,W2,207.

82G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 85: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

h0v9vuv!v%/tvuv0#v(v.,h&vEv)&v9vuv!qv%1v.!/JhG vEvLha,hGu8vcv. v/0v9vuv!

qv%

1v0B v7,h/DvLha,hG vEvLha#vHv!v.qv7,htv0eGu8vcv. v/ev1vL#vHv!v.b.

h+vv.Rvv2A/tvv.$Rvv1vv.A,h vv-0vvJhh>vv-h&vvlvvQ,kvv$vv.PtvvLgGu8vvcvv. vv/kvv2

G vrvLBf#v)PtvLG v.>v-hG v1vJhG v(vlvQkv,v.Uvlv.J v-1v0tv1vm,h/0vrv.d

Efq

0vvJgqvvJQ8vv-Ch&vvcvv$vv9vv-,$fq

kvv1vv-E1vv\vv.dG vvVvvlvv7,h+vv.qvv.dC+vv"G vvrvvJQ

hG)bv9vMGd,h vuv)q0vJgUvlv9v-1v0tv1vm,hevYv2v-hQXv.gUvlv9v.f#v)Uvlv.8v-

1vvv0tvvv1vvvm.Gvvv!vvvsGu8vvvcvvv. vvv/G$Rvvv1vvv.A/#vvv)Rvvv2A,htvvv.fGubvvv. vvv$vvv.kvvv2

G$Rd1v.$Rv1v.Aqv2v"tv.&v,v.,h+v.G vKjqvJq

QG$Rv1v.AhqvYv.+v.,h/0vuv.f

kvv2G vvJ&vv1vv.hG!GvvLIRvv2AE/q

1vv$vvSvv1vv,vv9vv-hbvv!vv$vv-hqvvYvv.Fvv-hqvvJQg,htvv9vv2vv-kvv2

G !.MG $El.Xh u)t92-1. .Um/1. Eu%(1).

C#qvv.#vv(vv,vv?vv-kvv2QhG0vv7G vvPvv(vv7,kvvuvv.f#vv2vvEvv=G vvPvv(qvv7bvv(vvJC1vv2Dvv(vv1vvlvv7

C+vv%G vv$vv2vv.Dvv=G vv9vvlvvVvv1vv!vv1vv7kvv2#vv(vv,vv?vv-tvv!qvv-,#vv(vv,vv?vv-kvv2qvv2vv.dChQOq#vv.

0vLh0v-#v)DvJ1v=#v(vPv.H vLOv.dGu�:vvvvChq/:G v$v9v.G8vL:tv.f0vLiCfq

ChqdCqvvvvPvvvv.eG vvvvPvvvv(vvvv7+vvvv.G vvvvEvvvvJ0vvvv=G vvvv$vvvv9vvvv.G8vvvvLG vvvvKjhUvvvv"E vvvv1vvvv-bvvvv)QOv.dGu�1v0Rv2v,v7Dv9v/Uv.Qtv. v$vPv$v.Y#v(v-,hP vv1v#f0vLh0v-

kvv2G vv\vv2vvrvv.JG vv<vv0KG vvVvvEvv.1vv7hG vv9vv.1vvcvv.fh8vv.1vvcvv.G vv9vv.1vvcvv1vv)#vv(vvKbvvVvvL

G vLOv.d�,qv.e/0v9v.+qv%8v.G[v&+v%bv!v/G vuvKH, vuv<vL8v,v%hbvJG v9v,v%

82.0)C#.t(,%.

;vv.&vv1vv.:G vv$vvSvv,vv.QG vv$vvPvv9vvlvv1vvZ:tvv.f0vvrvvPvv%G$Dvv.O0vv=evv1vvLG vv$vv9vv.G8vvLI

(1)G v$v0q

bv!v21v)Ov!v\v.fG vrv.Qj,8vEvrv1vsG vSv1vI#vLhGf#vEv$vJG vSvcqv.Q,RvLMG vlvrv-G$tv2vL$12D(1l7G (c$.f,11LhJ,OGQG (l.FQ,W2,2009e,15vvvv16.

83G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 86: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

E vv/qvvPvv$vv1vv)QFvv1vvPvv1vv1vv):G$Gvv2vv.QG vv$vvSvv,vv.QIG vv$vvPvv9vvlvv1vvYvv7,hCGvv2vv.QG!Dvv.O

G vv9vv2 vv%8vvVvv"E vv/DvvJG/&vv9vvSvv.Q@kvv. vv$vvSvv,vv.QG vv$vvPvv9vvlvv1vvZ#vv)G$Gvv2vv.Q,+vv.kvv2CUvv!vv-Gvv2vvLBDvv.O, vvuvv(qvv-G&vv9vvSvvL1vvcvvJP vvvh8vv!vvrqvv.gG vvcvv!vv$vv.A1vv. vvrvv2vv.dkvVv.Q0v(vrv!v-qv.e/0v9v.+qv%8v.G[v&+v%bv!v/G vuvKHkv2G v\v2vrv7G v<v.&v1v71vcvJG vvVvvEvv.1vv7,h+vvuvvKG1vvcvvJ+vv%,hQhGgqvv.e;vvrvv.JCFvv$vv7/0vv9vv,vv$vv.f,kvvVvv.Q1vSv,v.O8v,v%h8vVvJ0vrv,v%1v$v(vM v7G v$v9v.G8vL(1).hC1v.Dv(v1vlv70vrv2v"+vKGG v(v.Y#v)G$D.O0=t$.0r2"G $9.G8L#)OhfRLhW.

;vv. vv<vv.:Gvv2vvLG vv.GDvvJ:0vvSvv9vvLWkvv2QhGIG$Gvv2vv.QG)Ovv0e,hG vvcvvrvv"

hG vvYvv2vv]hG vvcvvJG vv7,hC+vv$vv1vv7Cf0vvuvv.fG vvLGhjUvv.Oqvv.k

vv1vvQ1vvKj+vv.i

0vvJkvvcvv-E vv/G vvuvvKHkvv1vv,vv.,h+vvKgG$qvv1vvPvv7/0vv\vv2vvrvv,vv.bvv!vv/G vvVvvEvv.1vv7#vv)

QhGICGv2v.QG!Dv.O,1v"0v\v2vrv,v.kv1v$v)8v0+v%1vcvJP vv#v$v)Qhjbv(v,v%,

hP vvvCfq

UvvEvv.1vv7QOvv.dGu�,tvv!qvv,vv%bvvJhdkvv2G vvLhG0vv7bvv(vv-,tvv1vvm

h+vv.0vv!vv9vvMe1vv$vv?vv$vv.YBQGFvv,vv%kvv2G vv$vvPvv# vv7kvv1vv$vv./0vvcvvLkvv.fG vvrvv.dkvv1vv$vv.

0v(vPv3E v/G v(v2v2�,h0vcv9v2vLg#vVvJQG8vSvL0vcv1v./0vHv. vlv-(2). vKGkv(fq

bvvvrvvv1vvvJIG)#vvv.eC1vvv2Dvvv(vvv1vvvlvvv7+vvv2bvvvrvvv1vvvJIG vvvPvvv!vvvmG vvvVvvv. vvvFkvvv2bvvvrvvv1vvvJ8vvv,vvv%

hO!.t,%.

q q q q q q

(1)G v2vHv.Qj,G)#v.ebv0AG vJ0v)(G v$v9v.kv/730+vvvvv),tvSvmG$OvLGQRvLMCUv.dG v2vMOhj482,8vvEvvrvv1vvsbvv2vvJGu#vvEvv$vv.O#vvEvv$vvJbvv$vvL,1vv1vvLhJ,OGQG vvuvv9vv3G vvcvv!vv$vv1vv7,G vv\vv2vvcvv7

G <.&17,2009e,G <.&2,689.

(2)O.#vEv$vJ1v!v9v.>v2,#v(v.+v@G v9vSvL0vdG)Ov0#v2kv2G vrvLfG v<v.&v2G v,v?vLj,G vrv.+vLI,OGQG P0e,W1,1425+vvvv|2004e,224.

84G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 87: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

G |9e|9yx<#C!U

CDvvvvJCbvvvv0eG)Ovvvv0eE#vvvv.eOGQG vvvv,vvvv?vvvvLI,C1vvvv.bvvvv2vvvvJGu#vvvv. vvvvv1vvvv)

C&vvvQ1vvv)#vvv. vvvv1vvv)C1vvv2bvvv.#vvvL1vvv)G vvvEvvv.QK1vvv)evvv1vvv$vvv.f1vvv)Gvvv<vvv1vvv"1vvv)

b$Lh1)G E.QK,h+.D!1m1(281q%#)qL0T(1).

Qhibvv)bvv.#vvL1vv)bvv2vvJGu1vv)G vvM1vv1vvL1vv)G vvcvv.qGeh&vvcvv1vv%1vv)bvv2vvJGu

G v$vEv$vJhR0vJ1v)COv!v%h&v.kvd#v. v/G1v)bv$vL.Ov,v"#vEv$vJ1v)EOv$v.bv1v"

G vv2vvHvv.Qjbvv)CUvvFG$Ovv.&vv1vvJkvvrvv.d#vv. vvvbvv)&vv.kvvdbvv)G1vv)bvv$vvLhqvv.d

bvv!vv2q1vv)G vv$vvJ0vv(vv2bvv)G1vv)bvv1vv1vv(vv7:#vv.tvv.fCRvvJq

G&vv9vvrvv.O#vv. vvv vv!vvL>vv.d

hCbvv!vv$vv-1vvSvv#&vv,vv%(2).h vvJG)#vv.e#vv. vvvOvv(vv7;vv0Kh8vvPvvcvv1vv)bvv!vv/CQ>vvF

G vLhG0v.J,kv2G v$vJ0v(v7G v$v(v.QI.;v%#v. v2v=CfG&v9vrv"hG vJgE v/G v$vJ0v(v7

(1)G vvEvv.kvvaRvv$vvQG vvJ0vv)G vvK+vv2vv2,G vv$vv9vv.kvv2Ovv(vv7748+vvvvvv,CRvvLabvv!vv/8vvEvvrvv1vvrvv-#vvVvv\vvlvv/bvv2vvJG vvrvv.OQbvv\vv.,Ovv1vvLCbvv0eG vv(vv2vv0A,1vv1vvLhJ,OGQG vvuvv9vv3G vvcvv!vv$vv1vv7,W1,2004,6,

303vvvv304.

(2)Rv,v.HG vJ0v)G vcvPvrv0&v2,G v$v9v.kv/Ov(v7852+vvvvv,8v,vK0v3G v9v,vK0v3,Dvrvrv-hbv!qvsbv!v1v-

#vVv\vlv/bv2vJG vrv.OQ,1v1vLhJ,OGQG vuv9v3G vcv!v$v1v7,1415+vvvvv|1994e,W1,10,5vvvv

6.hRv$vQG vJ0v)G vK+v2v2,G v$v9v.kv2kv2748+vvvvv,Ov1vLCbv0eG v(v2v0A,8vEvrv1vs#vVv\vlv/bvvvv2vvvvJG vvvvrvvvv.OQbvvvv\vvvv.,1vvvv1vvvvLhJ,OGQG vvvvuvvvv9vvvv3G vvvvcvvvv!vvvv$vvvv1vvvv7,2004,W1,6,303vvvv341

19VLqa.

85G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 88: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

kv.Gv9v.QzG vcvrv1vsyOvuv(v. v-,htv.fG vcvrv1vsB&vKGcXv.Dv1v7bv!v/#v2vcvJI&vEv.

#1!1)#)G $J0(7PGJ#.AhGYLIh1P.81).

C#qv.G v(vPv3kvcvL1v2q0v$v(v2q,+v.>vLJG$OvLIbv!v/bv,vJ>vJqghOv$v1qv-

#v. vvG v$vuv(qv/1v#1v2C&vQ(1).G&vHvLWG)#v.e#v. vvkv2Ov!vvG vJQGOv.J

G vvJ0vv(vv1vv7,1vv.>vv.Ogkvv2#vvJ0vv(vv7G vvLOvv.d�G vv$vv!vv1vv,vv71vvcvv!vv$vv.AG vvcvvVvvL,kvvYvv0

bv)Ceqkv.Xv!v78vEvPv)G v9vL1v1v7,h8v?v1vJG/Gv9v1v.QhG v9v.>v1v-.h>qv,v-C+v"1v1v9v-

E v/[v!v3G vcv!v%,h>vLqgG vSvfvm1v. vcv!v%E v/Cf0v2v1vdOvrvm1v1v9v-,hQCi

Cfq

8vvrvvJ0vv%CjRvv2Akvv2Ovv2vv1vv"G vvcvv!vv%C#vvL#vv\vv!vv.Hh vv.COqiP vvvE vv/

G vvlvvrvvL(2).1vvJC#vv. vvv0vv\vv!vv3G vvcvv!vv%Uvvfvv1vvLG,kvv#GvvKbvv)tvv<vv1vvL#vv)bvv!vv$vv.A

G vv$vvJ0vv(vv7,h vvcvv"CRvvJ+vv%C;vvLGkvv28vvuvv.0vv)bvvrvv!vv1qvv9vv-G vvcvv!vv$vv1qvv7G vv9vv2bvvLa1vv,vv.,

+vv.C1vv.1vvuvvLbvv2vvJGu1vv)0vvM0vvJG vv$vvcvvLha1vv.1vv)+vvL#vvM(3),kvvrvvJQhjbvv)

#v. vvC&qv-qv.d:ztv(v:B8v2G1v)+vL#vM#v)1vuvLIkv$v.CGvLL#v)1v1v9v-Dv9v/

G v!v1v"y(4).h/R#v-#v. vvbv!v/+vKGG v(vEv.Ov2vdOv(v.GJCh;v$v.f.h0vLhj

(1)#vvvVvvv\vvvlvvv/G vvvSvvvuvvvcvvv7,G)#vvv.e#vvv. vvvv1vvv)C&vvvQ,1vvv1vvvLhJ,OGQG vvvuvvv9vvv.HG vvv!vvv2vvv(vvv.&vvv2,W1,

1983,3.h#vvEvv$vvJC1vv.R+vvLI,#vv. vvvDvv1vv.8vv-hbvvVvvLgvvvvBQGDgG vvlvvrvv,vv1vv7,G vvrvv.+vvLI,OGQG luLG cL12,/.J,W2,20vvvv21.

(2)C1.R0JG c?$2,G cr1JIG)O0#17b(JG lr,.AG$Q1c7,197.

(3)bv2vJGu1v)0vM0vJ1v)+vL#vM,CGvKbv(v-#v. vvG vlvrv-,qv.d#v. vv:tv.f#v)Gbv!v%G v(qv.S1v$v.GGvv9vv!vvmkvv1vv-G vv(qvv.S#vv)+vvKgG$+vv.GA,tvv.f#vv)G vv\vv2vvrvv7G vv<vv.&vv1vv7#vv)kvvrvv,vv.AG vv$vvJ0vv(vv7,G&vv_vvL

[vv2vvrvv.JG vvlvvrvv,vv.A,C1vv.EOvvEvv.bG vvSvv1vvLGRj,U66.hbvv1vv.V,G vvrvv.Xvv2,G vv$vv9vv.kvv/Ovv(vv7544,8vvL8vv1vv3G vv$vvJGQch8vvrvvL0vv3G vv$vvPvv. vvv,8vvEvvrvv1vvsCDvv$vvJ1vvuvv1vvL,1vv1vvLhJ,OGQ#vvuvv9vv2vv7

G E1.I,O.W,/@J,G $?!JG$hd,120.

(4)|vvtvvO|vv?|vv(_vvzG |vv9e|vv9yvvx,YvvvJvvvJvvv&hQsqvvv}vvv&hLvvvQqLGIvvv9O*vvvDvvv&hfvvvz

qvvvufvvvzvvv+vvv&|vvvJvvv}vvvOpvvv|GO

f=OGy=9s,,<+QhJ,OGQGywA>Gygz}+?,O.W,O.J,26.

86G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 89: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

G v\v2vLjqv.d:DvJ;v(v2#vEv$vJ1v)G vEvPv)1v)R1v. v7qv.d:zOv$vcv:#v. vv1v)

C&vvQ0vvrvv.d:tvv(vv:B8vv2G1vv)+vvL#vvMkvv1vv##vvLG vv?vv.Q0vv7kvv9vvfvv!vvsG vv2vv.Hh8vvLGvv2

G vvPvv9vvL;vv%0vvKtvvLChqd+vvKgG$#qvv7;vv%0vv2vvuvv2Dvv9vv/8vvHvvYvv" vvEvv1vv9vv-(1).h#vv)

Rvv1vv.N#vv. vvvG1vv)Rvv,vv.HG vvM+vvLj,G vv$vv9vv.kvv/Ovv(vv7124.htvv.f#vv)Ctvv.1vvL

bvvv!vvv$vvv.AG vvv$vvvJ0vvv(vvv7kvvv2bvvvVvvvLg,h#vvv)ChGFvvv"G vvv$vvvJhq&vvv1vvv),htvvv.f#vvv)Q>vvv.d

G$#v.0v1v)1v. vSv.e,h8v. qv/ v,v%G vrvYv.AhG vl

ov9v1v.hQDv"E v/G v$vJ0v(v7kv9vMGDv%

bvv!vv1vv-[vv0HG vvcvv!vv%0vv#GvvKhfbvv(vv-h#vv(vv,vv%#vv. vvv(2).hG vv$vvJ0vv(vv7B&vvKGc8vvcvv@

q

1v. vcv!v$v.A#v)G v9v.1vcv1v)G$Gv1v.Qhtv.&v:#vJQOv9v,v.#vPv?vJG vLOv.d�.kv2

CQ>v.Fv-8v(v9vSvLDv!vrv.JG vcv!v%.h0v?v!vQbv!v/QCStv"Dv!vrv7CDvJG vcv!v$v.A

G vv$vvL#vv.qvv1vv)#vv)C#vv<vv.dQ1vv1vvcvv71vv)C1vv2bvv2vvJG vvLDvv$vvvsv),hG1vv)+vvL#vvM,h&vv.kvvd,

hG1v)Rv,v.HG vM+vLj,h#vEv$vJ1v)G v$v(vuvJQ,h>vcvlvLG vVv.Ob1v)#vEv$vJ

G vvv2vvv.qvvvLQCSBdG vvv2vvv1vvv:.htvvv.fG vvvcvvv,vvvJ1vvvcvvvVvvvLG vvvLOvvv.d�hGvvv!vvvlvvv.Fvvv-

G vvvLGRvvvJ0vvv)hUvvvEvvv.1vvv9vvv-G$Gvvv1vvv.Qevvv1vvvL1vvvcvvv1vvvJ.h#vvv);vvv%kvvv. vvvlvvv9vvv.hi1vvv.qvvv1vvv7kvvv2

G vVvJhQ.hG$Dv.O0v=G v(v2v.0qv7#vEvlv.^v7kv2G vrv!v.Hh#vLh0qv7bv!v/G$ vPv).

hkvvrvv-bvv2vvJGu1vv)bvv$vvLhbvv2vvJGu1vv)#vvPvvcvv.OhOvvcvv1vvJ1vv)G vv$vvPvv1qvv3,h#vv.

Ov?qv!v.G#v)#vPv.Fv"ChGOv9v(v2v\v.G#v)CDvuv.e/8vMGd8vLhikv2G vEv!vrv.J

>v1v01vcvJ>v1v".tv"P vvkvYv0bv);vrv7G v$vPv!v$v1v)1vPv.tv(v2OGQG v,v?vLI

G vK0v)8vcv!qv$v.Gbv!v/B;v.Q#vJQOv7G v(v2v.qI.hhQ;v.GRv$v.Fv"G vVvEv.1v7.h8vJGh v.G

CDu.eG lr,.Ab2LG 9.1c1)G$hq 1).

(1)G \2Lj,8.Q0IG \2Lj,9,229.

(2)#E$JC1.R+LI,#. vD1.8-hbVLgvvvvBQGDgG lr,17,W2,28.

87G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 90: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

hkv2Dv1v.IG)#v.e#v. vv,Rv,vJG vcv. v%G)Ov0#v28v\v.qQGJGv\v1vLI

tv.f v,v.C;vL+v.G vrv.jkv2G vEv1v.IG vPv1v.Ov1v7hG/>v9v$v.bv1v7hG vcvrv!v1v7,kvlv2

+vvvKgG vvvPvvv(vvv.GJ&vvvSvvv\vvv:Obvvv.IG vvvcvvv2vvv.Ovvv1vvv1vvv)h8vvv\vvv.qQJ+vvvKgG vvvJbvvv.IE vvv/

E&vvrvv0HG vvEvvuvv.#vv7,kvvPvvrvv\vv:Oh vv71vv(vv2C#vv1qvv7,h8vv. vv/G vvcvv2qvv.Ovv1qvv.fG$#vvL.

hOvvrvv.WOh vv7hqvv1vv.eCGvvLi0vv&OqjOGFvv$vv.E vv/ vv.f#vv)G)Xvv\vvLGH1vv1vv)

G vv(qvv.S,h0vv.>pvvJo

kvv1vv,vv%Rvv1vv,vv.#vv)bvvJeG vv\vv$vv#&vv1vv(vv7,h#vv)8vv2vv!vv2vv"G$kvvuvv.Q,

kv$v(v,v%#v)0v9vHvKG v9vrv1v7kv1vYv$vLev1vL#v.0v_v,vL,h#v(v,v%#v)0vPv9vPv!v% v%#vL

G vvv.Gqvvvd,h/0vvv#1vvv-1vvv$vvv?vvvLiG$DvvvJGKDvvv. vvv-,h#vvv(vvv,vvv%#vvv)0vvvrvvv.e#vvvd

G vEvuv.#v7G v?vJ0vJIG1v9vfv.AG v9vrvLqHhG vM vlv/ vJiCh v2G$#vL,h#v(v,v%#v)

0vv&GRQG vvEvvLtvv.JG vv9vv28vvL#vv2E vv/bvv.OIG vvEvvuvv.#vv7G vvrvvJ0vv$vv7,h+vvKG#vv.

DvvJKkvv2G vv9vv.Q0vvIG)Ovv0#vv2bvv(vvJG&vv9vvrvv.dG vvEvvuvv%E vv/G vvcvv2vv.Ovv1vv1vv),bvv!vv/

CfG vvcvv2vv.Ovv1vv1vv) vv%0vvHvvSvv.GC#vvLG$#vv.0vv1vv)GvvSvv1vv9vv,vv%#vv)DvvMHG vvcvv!vv.0qvv1vv),

htv.fG vEv?v.Rbv.#qv7hG v$vJ0v(v7Gv.Uv7htvLGk

v!vJbv.IG vcv!v.0qv7,hkv1v,v.tv.f

G)#vv.e>vvcvvlvvLG vvVvv.ObE#vv.eG vvSvv1vvcvv7bvv!vv/GGvv9vv0akvvLqvv,vv.,hkvv1vv,vv.GvvLL

#vEv$vJ1v)bv2vJGuG v$vcvLha1v. v(vlvQG vMtv1v7Ov(v7145+vvvvv,hGvLL#vcv-

bvvJO#vv)bvv!vv$vv.AG vv$vvJ0vv(vv7#vv(vv,vv%G1vv)+vvL#vvM(1)CDvvJRvv1vv.N#vv. vvv,C#qvv.

#vv. vvv&vvlvvPvv-kvvuvv.f#vvYvv\vvLGE vv/Cf/0vvPvv,vv%kvv2+vvKgG vv<vv.QI#vvPvv.+vv$vv7

E0vv?vv.1vv1vv7,P vvvCfq

G vv$vv(vvVvv.QG vvcvv2qvv.Ovv2CQOvv!vv-#vvd#vv)CQOvv"E vv/1vv(vv2

(1)G&vv_vvLG1vv)G$;vv1vvL,G vvuvv.#vv"kvv2G vv9vv.Q0vvI,816,hG vv\vv2vvLj,8vv.Q0vvIG vv\vv2vvLj,9,229.

h8vvv,vvvK0vvv3G vvv9vvv,vvvK0vvv3 vvv!vvvcvvvPvvvrvvv0&vvv2,10,7vvvv8.hDvvv!vvv1vvv7G$h vvv1vvv.Ah[vvv2vvvrvvv.JG$Uvvvlvvv1vvv.A, v!vEv.kvaC1v2&vcv1v%G$Uvlv,v.&v2,6,302vvvv348.h#vrvJ#v7G v$v.[v# v!v$vEvrvs#vEv$vJkv&GO

b2JG 2.q2,30.hC1.R+LI,#E$J,G)#.e#. v,52vvvv53.

88G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 91: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

G vvEvvPvv) vv1vvJkvvcvv.GE vv1vv-#vvEvv$vvJhE1vvLG+vv1vv%G1vv(vv2bvv2vvJGu,kvv!vv$vv.qvv.e#vvEvv$vvJ

hE1vvvLG+vvv1vvv%1vvv. vvv<vvv.QI, vvv%0vvvPvvvd#vvv. vvvvCf0vvvSvvv9vvvLckvvv1vvv,vvv.h+vvv.G vvvKjtvvv.f

QOv./ v9vPv!qv$v,v$v.1v.$#vQ,hkv2G v.qv:&vlvPv-tv.f0v(vrv%bv!v/G v$v(vVv.Q

>vv2vvLh8vv-h[vvfvv1vv.&vv-,h vv,vvKGtvv.f0vv#8vv1vv-C+vv"G vv$vvJ0vv(vv70vvPvv9vvlvv9vv.&vv-kvv2G vvHvvLhL

#vvd#vvEvv$vvJ(G vv(vvlvvQG vvMtvv1vv7)h0vvrvv. vv.fEfq

kvv2Cbvv(vv.qvv,vv%1vv1vvcvv7$1vv2>vvcvvlvvL

k1r.d:E&q

$.1.0c9%#uL+1),h 1Qb!/#uLg0$1)(1).

8v#;vLG)#v.e#v. vv1v.1v)+vL#vM,hC1vLRG!;v.Q v,vKgG v9v!v$vKIChG vVv!v7

G \.0!7C#LGf(2):

G$#vvvLG$hqd:kvvv2G vvv$vvv(vvv,vvv@,EPE&qvvv-E vvv/>vvv.&vvv3#vvv.CGvvvK#vvv)G1vvv)

(1)htv.fGvLhLG1v)+vL#vMbv!v/G vcv2v.Ov1v1v)hG&vYv$v.#v-E v/#vEv$vJG v(vlvQG vMtv1qv7Dv1v(v$v.Obv.

#vEv$vJ v(vlvPv-hOvcv/E v/E#v.QIG v$v&#v(v1v),htv.f#vEv$vJkv2qv$qv7G vVv0MhG v9vrv.i.htv.f

#vMOG&v.1v. vcv!v%,#v.Ov.#v.1v. vHv!vs,h+v.qv2v"P vvtv!qv-CRv2v-BdG v2v1v:1vPv1vJ&v.#vEv$vJ�,

h vvK vvvtvv.fG vv(vvlvvQG vvMtvv1vv70vv!vvrvv3z1vv$vvEvv$vvJG vvSvv2vv-y,+vvKGkvvYvv0bvv)Cfq

GOvv$vv-#vvEvv$vvJ1vv)bv2vJGu,GvLLG1v)+vL#vM#vd#vEv$vJG v(vlvQG vMtv1v7bv)bvrv1vJIO0v(v1v7,qv.OgE v1v,v.G>v9v,v.Og,hG&v9v,v/1v-E v1v,v.kvuvLg.P vvCf

qG vcv!v$v.A0vuv.&v.fOGFv$v.#v9v2v.bv1v)/8v.1vcv1v)#v,v$v.Ov$v.qvJQ

G vvEvv.tvv%,h#vv,vv$vv.1vv!vvg#vv)kvv\vv(vv7Ch>vv2vvLhJ. vvuvv)GOvv9vv\vv.YG vvcvv2vv.Ovv1vv.fCf0vvrvvYvv.Gbvv!vv/G vEvLtv7G vEvPv1v(v1v7,hbvlv.Gbv)G1v)+vL#vM vuv2vLOv(qv-1vcvJG&v9vVv.Q+v%hOvEvrv,v% v!v<v.QI. vuv)8vrvJ#v-kv2G vPv)q v%0v$v(vcv-#v)#v&GRQIDvLtv7#vEv$vJG vSv2v1v-,hqvJqv1v"/1v)+vL#vM:hGu

#v.kv1vvRv2Avvvv0vcv(v2/0v.>vJkv1vvRv2A0vPv.bvJcbv!v/G vEvLtv7vvvvkvuv.f0v?v1v3qv.Fv0:

qvJbv!v$v:,h vuv)0vLG&v2G v?v.+v"kv1vrv9vJj1v2,h v%8v$vZbv!v1v-1vcvJP vvE/q

Ov(v.GJCh

Cqvv"Dvv9vv/tvv.fqvvJG&vv9vvrvv"E vv/OGQG vv2vvrvv.AOvv(vv7148+vvvvvv.hqvvJ8vv#;vvL#vv. vvv1vv.1vv)+vvL#vvMkvv2bvvv!vvv$vvv-hkvvvrvvv,vvv-hhQbvvv-h8vvv#&

qvvv1vvv-kvvv2G)>vvv.1vvv7bvvv!vvv/G vvv$vvvPvvv.Fvvv"hqvvv. vvv-/COQjEPG vvv%8vvvuvvv)

G)>vv.1vv7tvv$vv.0vvEvv3,kvvrvvJ8vv#;vvL1vv$vv1vv. vv-G vvPvv1vv.Ovv1vv7bvv!vv/#vv.&vvL>vvF,hG8vvHvvK#vv.Gqvvmkvv2G P1.O7G c.#q7R21,719!vG 92hql,.G1)+L#M.

(2)G vvcvv?vv$vv2,C1vv.G vv1vvM0vvJ,G vvcvvrvv1vvJIG)Ovv0#vv1vv7bvv(vvJG vvlvvrvv,vv.AG$Q1vvcvv7,199vvvv200.hC1vv.R+LI,#E$J,G)#.e#. v,26vvvv27.

89G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 92: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

+vL#vMkv2G vlvrv-CGvKG vEvKQkv2G vLCjhG v9v<v2qv:qv2v"G)kv9v.Akv2#vPv# v7#v..

qvv.d#vv. vvv:zOvv$vvcvv:G1vv)+vvL#vvM0vvrvv.d:0vv(vv2vvfvv2Cf0vv.QKG vvcvv. vv%>vv!vvPvv.Ag

qv.d/COQj,Dv9v/0vuv.fP vvCUv0kv2C>v.1v9v,v%,kv(PGOv,v"CDvJ+v%

bvv$qvv./0vvJQjqvv.d/COQjy.hqvvJRvv,vvJ vv$vv. vvvtvv<vv1vvL#vv)bvv!vv$vv.AbvvVvvLg

1#&q

-[2q

s+KGG $(,@k2E>.19-h8c!1$- ?!P.F-.

G$#vvvLG vvv<vvv.&vvv2:8vvv$vvv1qvvvMG1vvv)+vvvL#vvvM1vvv(>vvv.O8vvv-G vvvLOqbvvv!vvv/C+vvv"G$+vvv.GA

hG vv2vvJY,h1vv1vv.f#vv.GGvv9vv!vvmkvv1vv-G vv(qvv.S#vv)+vvKgG$+vv.GA,hC&qvv-tvv.fOvvJ

qG

kvv2h>vv,vv,vv%,hqvvJtvv.f0vvLiG vv2vvcvvZCfq

#vv. vvuvv. vv%0vv9vvcvv$qvvskvv2+vvKGG vv(vv.Y

#vv)G vvcvv!vv.e vv$vvcvvLkvv9vv-C&qvv- vv!vvHvv.U

qvv7, vvuvv)G vvEvvrvv1vvrvv7Efq

C;vvLbvv!vv%Rvv1vvHvv-qvvJ

hXvvvFkvvv2#vvv.Gqvvvm#vvv. vvvv#vvvdC+vvv"G$+vvv.GA,hQOvvv. vvv9vvv-kvvv2G vvvLOqbvvv!vvv/

G vvrvvJQ0vv7h#vv.Qhjkvv2Ovv1vvL8vv-#vv)#vv.Gqvvm8vvJdq

bvv!vv/#vv.P+vv2vv(vv.E vv1vv-,h1vvKG

0vvuvv.fG1vv)+vvL#vvMqvvJ8vvLcC;vvLgG vv\vv1qvv3bvv!vv/RvvHvvVvv1qvv78vv!vv$vv1vvKgkvv2>vvMFvv1qvv7

+vv.#qvv7kvv2G vv$vv(vv,[email protected]#qvv.qvv.dhG vvJ8vv-C&vv-z8vvcvv!vv%#vv)CO1vv-qvv2vv"bvv!vv$vv-ykvv,vv.

O 1"b!/G$OHG lKq

G Kj8E!q

/1-G)#.e#. v.

C#qvv.G1vv)Rvv,vv.HG vvM+vvLj(1).kvv,vv.#vv)G vvlvvrvv,vv.AG vv$vvEvvJ;vv1vv)h vv-#vv)

8v.Q0vIbv!v%G vEvJ0v=#vuv.&v7Dv9v/ vrqv31v#bv!v%G vEvlv.X,htv.f0vrv.d:z#v.

Uvv2vvLCDvvJbvv!vv/G vvcvv!vv%Uvv2vvLj,h/&vvSvvLgCDvvJ&vvSvvLjy(2). vvrvv21vvcvvZ

UvvEvv.1vv7QOvv.dGu�hCGvvKbvv(vv,vv%,htvv.fbvv$vvLh1vv)O0vv(vv.Qh+vv.#vv)

G v9v.1vcv1v)qvJOv$vdbv(v-hbv)bv!v$v-,kvuv.f0vrv.dCjRv2Abv(vJG vM+vLj?

(1)8.k2O(7123Ch124Ch125+vvvv.

(2)#E$JC1.R+LI,G)#.e#. v,28.

90G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 93: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

vvrvv1vv:G1vv)bvv$vvLhG1vv)bvv2vv.Sh vv%0vv!vvrvv,vv$vv.!!;vv%qvvJeG vvM+vvLjE vv/#vvuvv7

hOv$vd1vK vvG1v)O0v(v.Q,htv.fRv1vHv.tv2v1vLG#vrvcvJGkvrv.d:GDv$v!v.&v2E v1v-,

kvEv$v"E v1v-h v%0vcvJE v/CUvEv.1v-E/ v1v0,kvrv. v.G v-tv1vmQC0v9v-??kvrv.d

hG)bvvv?vvv.H1vvv.Obvvv!vvv1vvv-,hGu#vvv.QC0vvv:#vvv<vvv"+vvvKGG vvvrvvvLRvvv2.hqvvvJtvvv9vvv3

bvv$vvL1vv)bvv2vvJG vvcvvM0vvMkvv2G!kvv.b:zbvv!vv1vvuvv%1vv.1vv)Rvv,vv.Hkvv(&qvvuvv%/8vv?vvJhf

Cbvvvv!vvvv%1vvvv. vvvvPvvvv(qvvvv7#vvvv(vvvv-y.hC#vvvvLgbvvvv$vvvvL1vvvv)bvvvv2vvvvJG vvvvcvvvvM0vvvvM1vvvv9vvvvJh0vvvv)CDvvvv.O0vvvv=

QOvvv.dGu�(1)@@@,qvvv.dG1vvv)bvvv2vvvJG vvvEvvvuvvv%:zqvvv.d vvv2#vvv. vvvv:tvvv(vvv.

&vv#8vv2G1vv)Rvv,vv.Hkvv2OGQgkvv21vv(vv2G vvJ0vv",htvv.&vv: vv-bvv9vv2vv7DvvPvv(vv7tvv(vv.

&?!Qb!1,.,&9JGkdEPGOG!(.b!1-y.

1v"tv.&v:8v9v$v!qvv#v. vvQev2v7G/&vlvLGO1v.1v)Rv,v.H[v!v2v. v$v.bv(vJg

#v)DvJ0v=,hQev2v7kv2#vM0vJ#v)G v9vcv!qv%#v(v-,hqvJDvVv"#v)G1v)Rv,v.H

bvv!vv/E>vv.RIChRvv,vv.OIkvv2G vvEvvlvvahG vvLhG0vv7(2).htvvK vvvCkvv.O#vv. vvv#vv)

RvHvVv1v7G1v)Rv,v.HG vcv!v$v1v7,kvrvJtv.fG1v)Rv,v.HG vM+vLjOvHv1qv.>v.GOG

Dvv9vv/qvv1vv"bvv(vv-:z vv%0vvuvv)G vvJ0vv(vv.QhG vvJQ+vv%bvv(vvJCDvvJC+vv.f#vv(vv-bvv(vvJ

G vvvM+vvvLjy(3).hqvvvJv̂vv,vvvLJ+vvvKgG vvvVvvvlvvv.Jkvvv2RvvvHvvvVvvv1qvvv7#vvv. vvvv1vvvSvvvuvvv"

hGXF $)0rLCO1LID1.8-.

h#vv)G vv$vvSvv.0vvIG$bvv0eG vvK0vv)CGvvKbvv(vv,vv%#vv. vvv,G vvlvvrvv1vv-G vv$vvEvvJq

K

&vv.kvvdh+vv.#vv. vv/bvv2vvJGu1vv)bvv$vvLG vvKjGvvJ#vv-;vv0;vv1vv)Ovv(vv7,h&vvrvv"bvv(vv-

(1)G)#v.eRv$vQG vJ0v)G vK+v2v2(G v$v9v.kv/748),8vKtvLIG vEvlv.X,8vEvrv1vsRtvL0v.bv$v1vLGJ,

11LhJ,OGQG u93G c!$17,G \2c7G <.&17,1428+vvvv|2007e,83vvvv85.

(2)C1.0M0JG c?$2,G cr1JIG)O0#17b(JG lr,.AG$Q1c7,200.

(3)G K+22,8KtLIG El.X,83.

91G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 94: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

bvv!vv$vv.k

tvv<vv1vvLGk.tvv.f&vv.kvvd#vv9vv.GXvvcvv.qvv!vv1vv"G vvuvv0ehkvv2 vvPvv.&vv- vvuvv(vv7 vvuvv.&vv-

O0vv!vv$vv1qvv..h#vvd+vvKGkvvrvvJOvv$vv:#vvuvv.&vv9vv-hQkvvdqvvJQghGvv!qvvJkvv2G vv9vv.Q0vvI1vv1vv)

kvvrvv,vv.AG vv$vvPvv!vv$vv1vv)hQhGIDvvJ0vv=QOvv.dGu�. vvrvvJQkvvdG)Ovv0e#vv)

Rv#&v-,hOv$v.G vcv!v%1vrvJQg,hbv_qv%G vEvJ0v=#v)#vuv.&v9v-E v/G v$vJiG vKj

>vvcvv"G vvLGRvvJG vvHvv.#vvQG vvHvv!vv1vvlvv7bvv$vvL1vv)bvv2vvJG vvcvvM0vvM0vv2vvcvv=1vv-E vv/C+vv"

#vvVvvL vvuvv20vvcvv!qvv$vv,vv%G vvP

qvv(vv).Efq

bvv2vvJGu1vv)bvv$vvL&vvSqvv##vv./g&vv.kvvcvv.bvv!vv/

G vvcvv!vv%,hkvvrqvv,vv-kvv2G vvJ0vv),htvv.f&vv.kvvd#vv)G vvKtvv.AhG vvEvvKb1vvEvv1vv=CGvvK

G vvvvEvvvvJ0vvvv=bvvvv)G1vvvv)bvvvv$vvvvL,hC1vvvv2+vvvvL0vvvvLI,hC1vvvv2Ovvvvcvvvv1vvvvJG vvvvHvvvvJQj,hCeq

G v$v&#v(v1v)bv.FvSv7RC>v$vcv1v).htv.fCbv!v%G v(qv.S1vlvrv-#v./gbv2vJGu1v)

bvv$vvLhG1vv)bvv$vvL+vv.GDvvJG vvcvv2vv.O vv7G vv<vv0;vv7G vvK0vv)G&vv9vv,vv:E vv1vv,vv%G vvLhG0vv7

hG$Du.e.

htvv.f&vv.kvvd1vvcvvJCftvv2vvL0vv!vvrqvv31vvlvvrvv1vv-G vv$vvJ0vv(vv7,tvv$vv.tvv.f0vv!vvrqvv3

1vvv.)#vvv.eG vvvcvvv!vvv%.h vvvrvvvJCkvvv.O#vvv. vvvv#vvv)&vvv.kvvvdkvvvrvvv,vvv.hDvvvJ0vvv<vvv.,hCGvvvKbvvv(vvv-

CDv.O0v=G1v)bv$vL,htv.f#v. vvRvJ0vJG v<vrv7kv2&v.kvd1vEv1v=tv.f0vrv.d:

zEPGOvv$vvcvv:DvvJ0vv=&vv.kvvdbvv)G1vv)bvv$vvL/C1vv. vv2C/q

COvv$vvcvv-#vv)CDvvJ

evv1vvLgy.h#vv)+vv(vv.qvv.dQ>vv.dG vvEvvJ0vv=:CUvvFG$Ovv.&vv1vvJ#vv. vvvbvv)&vv.kvvd

bv)G1v)bv$vL,hDv1v)0v9vVv"1v. vSv.kvcv21v,vKgG vPv!vPv!v7kv(&qv,v.8vPv$v/Ov!vPv!v7

G K+3y(1).

h1vvK vvvCUvv.H#vv. vvvbvv)&vv.kvvdOvv(qvv7hkvvrvv,vv.,hChQO vv-kvv2G vv$vv.[vv#

;$.&1)DJ0<.ChCt<Lb!/G H0a.

(1)#V\l/G Suc7,G)#.e#. v1)C&Q,24vvvv25.

92G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 95: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

h vv%0vvrvvVvvL#vv. vvv>vv!vv.Ovv-bvv!vv/+vv&/Akvvrvv]1vv"#vv.dE vv/CUvvEvv.H

#vvvvJGQSCGvvvvLi.kvvvvrvvvvJ>vvvv!vvvvQ#vvvv<vvvv0E vvvv/G)#vvvv.e>vvvvcvvvvlvvvvLG vvvvVvvvv.Ob(1)1vvvv)#vvEvv$vvJ1vv)bvv!vv21vv)G vvEvvPvv1vv)1vv)bvv!vv21vv)C1vv2[vv. vv3,h+vv.G vv$vvcvvLha

1vv. vv9vvrvv/hG vv.QYhG vv$vvPvv. vv$vv7,h>vv!vv.S#vv. vvvE vv1vv-tvv.fevv1vvL#vvPvv9nvvfrvvLH

m vv$vv.

0vv9vv$vv9qvvd1vv->vvcvvlvvLG vvVvv.Ob#vv)&vvPvv3RvvL0vvmhOvv!vv.c#vvPvv9vvrvv1vv%,hqvvJtvv.f

C;vLgbv!v/RvHvVv1v7#v. vvkv28vuv.0v(v,v.h1vHv.Uv7#v)G v(v.Dv1v7G vHv!vrv1v7.tv.f

G)#vv.e>vvcvvlvvLevvM0vvLG vvcvv!vv%,hGkvvLG vvEvvuvv$vv7,tvv.#vv"G$OH,RG+vvJGhQbvv.,

1vcv1vJGbv)G vfv!v.,1vL0v,v.#v)G v9v\vLqa,/0vEv3G/bv9vMGd. vrvJtv.fG)#v.e>vvvcvvvlvvvLvvvvbvvv!vvv/Gvvv0aG vvvSvvv1vvvcvvv7G vvv$vvv9vvv#GvvvL0vvv)vvvv0vvv&#vvv)1vvvHvvv0kvvv7C1vvv21vvvuvvvL

hb$L[,h/0KtL+$.E/1u"D$Jh;(.A.

C#qvv.#vv(vv,vv@#vv. vvvkvv2G vvcvvrvv1vvJI(2),kvvuvv.fG8qvv2vv.YG vvPvv!vvmG vvVvv. vvFkvv2

#v(v,v?v-,Dv1v=8vJGv"G v$vVv\v!vEv.JG v9v28vJhQkv2#vcv?v%#v(v,v?v-hkvuvLg,

kvv(&qvv-0vvrvvJeG vv(vvW

qG vvrvvLB&vv2h0vv#GvvK1vvlvv,vv%G vvVvvEvv.1vv7hG vv9vv.1vvcvv1vv) vv-,OhfCf

0vHv"P vv1v$vrv.#v.JG/>v9v,v.OhG vLCjbv(vJg,kvuv.f#v)C+v%G$#v.QG v9v2

G&v9v,v?v,v.G/1v9vcv.Obv)E[v0bG$Dvuv.e1v. vEv"ChG vEvL#v7,#vHv. vlv.1vK vv

#v.tv.f#v.>v.OGkv2bvVvLg#v)>vLCI1vcvZG vcv!v$v.Abv!v/+vKG,hqvJtv.f

#vvv. vvvvS0vvvcvvv!vvv%Cfq

+vvvKG+vvv.G vvvrvvv\vvvdkvvv2Dvvvuvvv%Gu,h0vvvPvvv9vvvSvvv,vvvJ1vvv#fq

G vVvEv.1v7h+v%Gv1v.QG$#qv7tv.&v.G0v9vEvLq>v.f#v)E[v0bG$Dvuv.e,htvK vv

#vv)&vv,vv@&vv,vv?vv,vv%#vv)bvv!vv$vv.AG$#qvv7,#vvHvv.kvv7G/kvv9vvLGAbvv!vv/GuOvv2vvEvv.&vv-

h8c. /k2G 9E!1"hG 9EL0%.

(1)#E$JC1.R+LI,#. v1)C&Q,83vvvv86.

(2)C1.R0JG c?$2,G cr1JIG)O0#17b(JG lr,.AG$Q1c7,212vvvv213.

93G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 96: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

qvvv.d#vvv. vvvv:z#vvv.Rvvv2ACRvvvJq

bvvv!vvv2#vvv)CfCOvvv#dbvvv)#vvvPvvv# vvv7#vvv)

G vEv0dhG vEvLGe,$fq

+vKG+v.G vrv\vdkv2Dvuv%Gu,h vrvJCOQtv:C+v"

G vvvcvvv!vvv%hG vvvlvvvrvvv-1vvv2vvv!vvvJ&vvv.,hEfq

CDvvvJ+vvv%EPGOvvv,vvv"bvvv)#vvvPvvv# vvv7tvvv#fG vvv$vvv.J

CRvvLabvv!vv1vv-@@@hC+vv"R#vv.&vv(vv.qvvJUvv.QkvvHvvL+vv%G vvlvv9vv1vv.,kvv2vvrvvJQ#vv.0vvlvv9vvF

vv,vv%#vv)G vvcvv!vv%,h vv%0vvuvv)#vv)C#vvLG vv(qvv.S,h/#vv)#vvYvv/#vv)Ovv!vvlvv(vv.

G vK0v)0vrv9vJi1v,v%vvvvh#vcv.qdG)Ov0ekv1v,v%vvvvCf0vrv. v.G+vKGDv0dh+vKG

DvvLGe,h vvuvv)0vvrvv. vv.f:C&vv.CtvvLgtvvKG,hCQitvvKG,hC#qvv.Dvv0dhDvvLGe

kvvv,vvv.G/kvvv9vvvLGAbvvv!vvv/Gu,C#vvv.Ovvv$vvvcvvv9vvv%qvvv.dGu8vvvcvvv. vvv/:{QRS

TUVWXYZ[\]^_‘a

bcd:59}(1);$fq

G vvEvv0d#vv.CDvv!qvv-GuhQOvv. vv-,hG vvEvvLGe

#v.DvLq#v-y(2).C#qv.#v.qvlv-#v)G v9v#h0v":kvrvJG&v9v,v@&v,v@G vPv!vmG vVv. vF

kv2QkvZG v9v#h0v"G vKj0vrv.OE v/G vrv.d1vfv1vLbv!v%,zE&qv$v.C+v!vvG v(qv.S

8vv#h0vv"#vv./0vvcvv!vv$vv.fy(3).hqvv.dG1vv)Ch0vvQ:Ovv$vvcvv:#vv. vvuvv.0vvrvv.d:zEfq

+vvKGG vvcvv!vv%O0vv)kvv.&vv_vvLhGbvv$qvv)8vv#GvvKh&vv-.h$fq

+vvKGG vvcvv!vv%O0vv)/0vv&GvvK

#vvv)Cjbvvv.QV vvv-,1vvv"/1vvvJ#vvv)#vvvrvvv.0vvv1vvvQ0vvv9qvvvVvvv"1vvvcvvvYvvv,vvv.1vvvSvvvHvvvVvvv1vvv7

G vvcvv. vv%,h1vvcvvYvv,vv.1vv(vv.Ybvv!vv$vv-h#vv(vv,vv?vv-,8vv\vv2vvsDvv9vv/0vvcvvLaG!GvvK#vv.PG

0vv#GvvKh#vv.PG0vvJY(4).C#qvv.bvv)G vvcvvrvv.FvvJkvvuvv.f0vv!vv9vvMe1vv$vv.CGvv2vvL1vv-G vvrvvLBf

hG vPv(qv7,hG)0v$v.f1v$v.Obv.E v1v-#v)ev1v2v1qv.JOhf1vEv=kv2G vuv1vm,hqvJ

(1)0.&Q:59.

(2)C1.G 1M0JG c?$2,G cr1JIG)O0#17b(JG lr,.AG$Q1c7,216.

(3)#E$JC1.R+LI,G)#.e#. v,30vvvv31.

(4)G $L>d&lP-,31.

94G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 97: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

tvv.f+vvKG&vv,vv@G vvVvvEvv.1vv7bvv!vv/bvv,vvJQOvv.dGu�hG vv9vv.1vvcvv1vv)1vvcvvJ+vv%;

hqvvJtvv.f#vv. vvv0vvLi>vv.GR8vvHvvVvv1vvWG vvrvvLBfG vvuvvL0vv%1vv. vvPvv(qvv7G vv$vv9vv.G8vvLI

h1vvHvv2vvLG!Dvv.OC0vvYvv.,hqvvJtvv.f#vv. vvv0vvLiCfq

G vvPvv(qvv70vv$vvuvv)Cf8vvPvv9vvrvv"

1vvvEvvvuvvv%>vvvJ0vvvJ, vvv%0vvvLOCUvvv0kvvv2G vvvrvvvLBfG vvvuvvvL0vvv%,#vvv<vvv"qvvv2vvv.dG vvvEvvvuvvv%

1vvv. vvv1vvv$vvv1vvv)#vvvdG vvvSvvv.+vvvJ(1).h+vvv.DvvvJ0vvv=#vvvLOvvv"8vvv#0vvvJbvvv(vvvJG vvvSvvv.kvvvcvvv2(2)

1vv#Dvv.O0vv=hB;vv.QCGvvLi.hqvv.d#vv. vvv:z#vvYvv:G vvPvv(qvv7kvv2G vvrvvYvv.A1vv. vv1vv$vv1vv)

#vdG vSv.+vJG v.GDvJ,0vEv!vmUv.Dv3G vEvs#vdRv.+vJgh0vPv9vEvsDvrqv-(3)

.h vv%8vvLORvv,vv.OIG vvSvv.+vvJG vv.GDvvJ#vvd0vv$vv1vv)Uvv.Dvv3G vvEvvskvv2G vvrvvLBf

G vvvuvvvL0vvv%qvvv],E&qvvv$vvv.G vvvKjhQO+vvv.Rvvv,vvv.OIRvvv.+vvvJ0vvv)Q>vvv!vvv1vvv)ChQ>vvv"

hC#vvLC8vv1vv),kvv2qvv. vv-8vvcvv. vv/{+,-./01

2345678}(4).EPGk

,kvvrvvJtvv.f vv!vvPvv(qvv7

bv(vJ#v. vvGbv9v2v.Qtv2v1vL,Dv1v=QCiC&qv,v.qvJ8vPv9vrv"qG1v9vJGA1vPv)q8vSvL0vcv.J

vvv%8vvvLOCUvvv0kvvv2G vvvrvvvLBfG vvvuvvvL0vvv%,kvvv,vvv2bvvv(vvvJg1vvv,vvvKGG/bvvv9vvv2vvv.Q#vvvVvvvJQ

8vSvL0vcv2#vPv9vrv"q/0vrv9vVvLbv!v/1v1v.f#v.kv2G vrvLBfG vuvL0v%Ch8vHvVv1vW

bv.#qv-. vuv)#v. vuv.vvvv#v)&v.Dv1v7CGvLivvvv v%0vuv)0vcv$v"1vuv"#v.0vLhi v-

#v)CDv.O0v=,kv( v/>v.&v3#vrv.0v1vPv-G vPv.1vrv7#v)G vLhGIvvvv&v?vJ#v)GOv9vrvLGA

kvrv,v-C&qv-qvJQkvZC0vYv.1vcvZCGv2v.QG!Dv.O; v$vHv. vlv7#vYv$v.&v,v. v%#v.Q

(1)C&Q1)#. v,G $.[#,11LhJ,OGQG u93G c!$17,/.J,/.W,445.

(2)#vvEvv$vvJ1vv)EOQ0vvQG vvSvv.kvvcvv2,G$eq,1vv1vvLhJ,OGQG1vv)DvvMe,#vv?vv!vvJ2,2486,tvv9vv.H

G$qY17,1.HG 1$1)#dG S.+J.

(3)C&Q,1)#. v,G $.[#,456.

(4)G 2rLI:282.

95G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 98: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

hG/b92.QGJG 9SL0c17G!817(1):vvvv

1vvvvEPGGvv. vvmG vvHvv2vvLv̂v.+vvLG vvrvvLBfOhfCf0vvuvv.f vv-#vv.0vvcvvYvvJg

#)E>$.YChb$"C+"G $J0(7.

2vvvvEPGG. mG H2LG$U.dhG r.GbJG SLb1q7G $rLqQI.

3vvvvEPGGvv. vvmG vvHvv2vvL#vv.0vv\vv!vvsbvv!vv1vv-#vv. vvv(bvv$vv")Ch(E>vv$vv.Y

C+"G $J0(7).

tv.f#v(v,v?v-G8qv2v.YG vVvLGWG v$vPv9vrv1v%G vKj+v.UvLGWGu8vcv. v/EP

qvvv.d:{z{|}~!"#$%&’()*+,@xzv}(2).h vvrvvJOvv!vvvkvv2+vvKg

G$#v.Q#v.Ov!vuv-kv2G vlvrv-hG vEvJ0v=,kvrvJqvLqQG8qv2v.YG vPv(qv7hG8

qv2v.Y#v(v,v.L

G P!mG V. F.ht.f09$<q

"OGF$.1r.dG S.bL:

hGvvvv1vvvvLC#vvvv.QG vvvv$vvvvLA#vvvv.tvvvv.fOvvvv(qvvvv7hRvvvvLG$#vvvv.QG vvvv$vvvvEvvvvJ;vvvv.JG vvvv2vvvvJGFvvvvd

htv.f0vcv?v31vrv.dbv$vL1v)bv2vJG vcvM0vM:zOv)qQOv.dGu�hh/I

G$#vvv.Q#vvv)1vvvcvvvJgOvvv(vvv(vvv.@@@G$GvvvK1vvv,vvv.G8qvvv2vvv.Y vvvuvvv9vvv.HGu,hGOvvv9vvvuvvv$vvv.d

v\v.bv7Guhqv.qIbv!v/O0v)Guh v1vQ$DvJ1vcvJ+v.8v2vJ0v!v,v.,h/G v(v_vLkv2

Rvvv2AGvvv. vvvlvvv,vvv..h#vvv)G+vvv9vvvJi1vvv,vvv.kvvv,vvv.#vvv,vvvJjq,h#vvv)GOvvv9vvv(vvvVvvvL1vvv,vvv.kvvv,vvv.

#v(vVv.Q,h#v)8vLtv,v.G8v2vdev1vLOv2v1v"G v$v&#v(v1v)&v.q v-#v.8v. qv/,h&vVv!v->v,v(qv%

hO.AJ#V1LGy@h+uKGO.Qb!/G P(q7k2OQGO9- !cr1JI(3).

(1)#E$J1!9.>2,#(.+@G 9SL0dG)O0#2,423.

(2)G$&c.e:153.

(3)#E$JC1.R+LI,8.Q0IG $KG+3G)O0#17,423.

96G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 99: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

G |9e|J}O<#EOQ*UGyW9pg,

#vEv$vJ1v)EOQ0vQ1v)G vcv2v.S1v)bv<v$v.f1v)Rv.kvd1v)G v$v\qv!v31v)

bv2vJ#v(v.a@@@G vrvLRv2.CDvJG$Fv$v7G$Q1vcv7bv(vJC+v"G vPv(qv7,hE v1v-&vPv2v7

G vSv.kvcv1qv7tv.kv7.h vJkv2evMqI1vlv!vPv\v1v)Ov(v7Gv$vPv1v)h#v.Fv7 v!v,v?vLIhDv$v"

#vv(vv,vv.E vv/#vvuqvv7h+vv.G1vv)Ovv(vv9vv1vv).C#qvv-#vv)qvv2vv1vv!vv7G$RO,#vv)G vv1vv$vv),PGb

#vLGQIkvrvJG$Hh+v.Uvfv1vL,h&vSv#kv2COvLIkvrv1vLI,Qhjbv)G vSv.kvcv2

qv. v-(1):ztv(v:0v9v1v$v.kv2Dv?vLC#v2,h v%0vuv)#vcv,v.#v.8vcv\v2G v$vcv!qv%,

htvv.fG vv$vvcvv!qvv%qvvJQXvv2#vv(qvv2CfCGvv!vvlvv-EPGqvv.e,kvv!vv$qvv.Gvv9vv$vv:G vvrvvLBf,

OG!:G $P?Jku(:C>. QG c!$.A,hCDlaG EJ0=ChG $P# 7y.

hPtvvLG vvK+vv2vv2kvv2tvv9vv.1vv-G vv$vv.Ovv.bvv2Ovv1vvLCbvv0eG vv(vv2vv0Ahevv1vvLgC&qvv-

&S#1$u7,hCq2"b!/G cL11q7hG SLY,k2LYk2P vh8rJq

e.

+vvKg+vv2G vvHvv\vv.GJG$h vv/G vv9vv2Gvv\vv.+vv.G vvSvv.kvvcvv2&vvEvv.G vvcvv!vv%,

h+vv2G vv9vvMhqO1vv.$Uvv"(G vvuvv9vv.HhG vvPvv(qvv7),;vv%G vvEvvLUbvv!vv/ vvfvv7G vvlvv,vv%

(1)C1vv.&vvcvv1vv%G$Uvvlvv,vv.&vv2,Dvv!vv1vv7G$h vv1vv.Ah[vv2vvrvv.JG$Uvvlvv1vv.A,8vvEvvrvv1vvs#vvEvv$vvJOvv1vvJbvv2vvJ

G LO.d,G r.+LI,#u927G LD.H,W1,2007,81|9.

97G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 100: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

hG v2v1v.f.>v!vQE v/G vcvJ0vJ#v)G v$vSv.0vI,hqvJqv1qvZGu v!vSv.kvcv2kvLUv7

8vvcvvJq

ORvv1vv.Gvv-h8vv(vv.qYG8vv?vv.+vv.8vv,vv%G vvlvvuvvL0qvv7,kvvuvv.fP vvv#vvEvvrqvvrvv. vv\vv$vv.Dvv-,

#vv2vvLRG vvSvvHvvVvv1qvv9vv-G vvcvv$vv!vv1qvv7,h#vv&;qvvLGkvv1vv$vv.8vvLc vv!vv(vv.S#vv)bvv!vv%.hqvvJOkvvd

G vvSvv.kvvcvv2;vv$vv)8vvEvvrvv1vvs[vv$vv.Dvv-,kvv#&vvlvvsG vv$vv.dkvv28vvEvvVvv1vv"tvv9vv31vvcvvZ

#vvSvv.0vvHvv-,hC&vvlvvsG vv?vv,vvJkvv2G$Ovvlvv.Q,tvv$vv.GOvv9vvcvvJq

bvv!vv$vv1qvv. vv!vvrvv.A#vvSvv.0vvHvv-

Dvv9vv/0vvrvv2vv"bvv(vvJ+vv%,h8vvuvv<vvLGOvv9vvlvv.O8vv-,hqvvJQUvvJG vv$vv&QGvv.f#vvSvv.0vvI,

&vvKtvvL#vv.PtvvLgG vvK+vv2vv2(1):hCGvvKG vvcvv!vv%1vv2vv!vvJg#vvuvv7bvv)#vvPvv!vv%1vv)Gvv. vvJG vvM&vv?vv2#vvlvv9vv2#vvuvv7,hOGhO1vv)bvv2vvJG vvLDvv$vvvsv)G vvcvv\qvv.Q,hbvv$vv-#vvEvv$vvJ1vv)bvv!vv21vv)Rvv.kvvd,hOvvlvv1vv.f1vv)bvv1vv1vv(vv7,hbvv2vvJG vvLDvv$vvvsv)G1vv)C1vv2G vv$vv!vv1vvuvv2,hOvvcvv1vvJ1vv)Ovv. vv%,hkvvYvv1vv"1vv)bvv1vv.V,hbvvJI@@@.hGQ8vvEvv"h+vv.G1vv)&vv1vvmhbvvSvvL0vv)Ovv(vv7,hqvvJCkvv9vv/h8vv#+vv" vv*#vv.#vv7E vv/G vv$vvJ0vv(vv7,kvvEvv$vv"bvv)#. v1)C&QG $.[#.

hDvvv$vvv"bvvv)E1vvvLG+vvv1vvv%1vvv)0vvvEvvv2,hbvvv2vvvJG vvvcvvvM0vvvMG vvvJQGhQOj.hCGvvvK

1vvv. vvv1vvv$vvv)bvvv)#vvv\vvvLa1vvv)#vvv.Rf,h+vvvSvvv.e1vvv)0vvv.OvvvmG vvvrvvv.Xvvv2h[vvv.Fvvvlvvv7.

h1vv2vvfvvJGObvv)#vvEvv$vvJ1vv)G vvEvvPvv)kvvrvv1vv-G vvcvvLGbh/R#vv-,hDvv$vv"bvv(vv-hqvvL

1c1L,hb)EO$.b1"G1)b!1q-,hb2JG .+.HG <rl2.

hUvv(qvvmG vv9vvVvv.&vv1vvm,hOhqfG vvcvv!vv%,hQOqbvv!vv/G$Fvv$qvv7#vv9qvv2vvcvv.G$;vvL,

hUvv(qvvmkvv2CUvv.dG vvlvvrvv-hkvvLhbvv-,h1vvcovvJn

Uvv1vv9vv-,h8vvuvv.;vvLbvv!vv1vv-G vv\vv!vv2vv7(2).

C>vv$vvdRvv1vv.Gvv-hqvvLqGDgh8vv0#vv1vvKgG vvK0vv)8vv!vvrqvv.Gbvv!vv1vv-C&qvv-tvv.fb

nvv!nvv$vv.1vv1vv)

(1)G K+22,O1LCb0eG (20A,7,336.

(2)G K+22,O1LCb0eG (20A,7,336.

98G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 101: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

G$bvv0eh/0ovv?vv.Qih/0ovv2vv.Qi.kvv$vv. vvvRvv1vvHvv-0vv<vv(vv2bvv!vv1vv-kvv2hqvv: vv%

0vvuvv)qvvJ8vvuvv.#vv"&vv$vv.g,h1vv!vvgRvv#hg(1).8vv!vvrvv/G)#vv.eG vvSvv.kvvcvv2G vvcvv!vv%bvv!vv/

bvJI#v)G vSv1v.NCUvEv.HG v$vKG+v3hG v(vMbv.JG v$vHv9v!vlv7,h1vK vv8v!vrv/

kvrv-Ctv<vLG v$vKG+v3G v9v2qv.#v:kv2bvVvLg@kv.>v9v$vd v-kvrv-#vuv7hG v$vJ0v(v7

hG vvSvv.eh#vvVvvLhG vvcvvLGb,h vv%0vv?vvJDvvL>vv.kvv2Cf0vv\vv!vv3G vvlvvrvv-bvv(vvJ#vv)

GRvv9vv,vvL1vv./bvv9vvMGd,hbvvLa1vv#&qvv-kvv2CUvv.dG/bvv9vvrvv.O/0vvPvv!vvvkvv2[vv!vv2vv,vv.

#vvPvv!vvvC+vv"G vvEvvJ0vv=hG vvlvvrvv-,hG&vvPvv.Ztvv"P vvvG vvcvv!vv%G vvuvv<vv1vvLkvv2&vvlvvQ

G vvvSvvv.kvvvcvvv2,kvvvuvvv.f#vvv(vvv-P vvvvG vvv$vvvM0vvv@G vvv$vvvEvvvuvvv%G vvvKj8vvv0qvvv:kvvv1vvv-tvvv"

G v(vMbv.J#v(vPv?v$v7#v9vcv.O v7,#v9v vlv7G v(vfv%ev1vL#v9v(v.kvLI,h8v. vJJ#v(v-8v!vv

G vv$vvcvv.&vv2G vvuvv!vv1vv7G vv9vv2Uvv,vvL+vv.G vvSvv.kvvcvv2,hqvvJq#vv,vv. vv!vv(vv.Skvv21vv1vv.fQGFvvd

hq.d#Eu%.

h0vvPvv9vvJdG vvlvvrvv,vv.Ah>vv.O#vvJQOvv9vv1vv) vv!vvlvvrvv-,GOvv9vvrvv.#vv:tvv"hGDvvJIbvv!vv/

#vv(vv,vv@hGDvvJ#vvcvv1qvv),hCfq

G vvlvvrvv,vv.Atvv.&vv.GE/q

qvv!vv1vv00vvPvv1vvLhfbvv!vv/#vv(vv,vv@EDvvJi

G v$vJQOv9v1v)#vJQOv7G vEvJ0v=htv.&v:1v. v$vJ0v(v7,hG v<v.&v1v7#vJQOv7G vLCjhtv.&v:

1. cLGb.

(1)#vEv$vJC1v.R+vLI,G vSv.kvcv2Dv1v.8v-hbvVvLgvvvvCQGDghkvrv,v-,G vrv.+vLI,OGQG vlvuvLG vcvL1v2,W2,1945,30.

99G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 102: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

VQ*K<#GA9QKGyw"Oj|9JS"?88

G}S(O<#*R*OGy"Mg,|9JS"?65

fzt}?<#s+UGy"Mg,|9JS"?62

|TQhb<#G}FOYGy%}OGP|9JS"?62

C<(I"+q?|9JS"?150

E<QG$+~Gy"Mg,|9JS"?95

f9|Q<#VQI=+{|9JS"?104

f=OGu<#|Tg(Of\<#CN_9y>

|OQS?CNI"+q?

|OQS?|9yx<#C!U

fQhI<#GyR<+Q|9JS"?

94

Gyt9S~<#I}O<#CN<wQ|9JS"?

106

Sg+O<#Gyv}T+>

|9JS"?93

Sz+}9f<#*T9Q|9JS"?

100

L9QF?<#R*O<#C9<B

|9JS"?100

S9D<#f=OGu|9JS"?

106

f=OGu<#f=OGu<#

fA=?<#|Tg(O|9JS"?

94

G<#V%9HGyR$Qj

!9ph|(]f=OGu<#

f}Q

C<(GyR!9O|9JS"?

131

L+)<#Sg+O|9JS"?

131

|9yx<#C!U

>9O<#CNSz}?

|9JS"?120

Q<+g?GyQCj136

100G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 103: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

h+vv(vv.c#vvJQOvv7;vv. vv<vv78vvcvv(vv/1vv9vvlvvPvv1vvLG vvrvvLBf,h8vvcvvLaCOvv2vv.H&vvMh vv-

hQhG0vv7G vv9vvlvvPvv1vvLG vv$vv#;vv.Qkvv1vv-,hbvv!vv/kvv,vv% vvfvv7G vvcvvLHhbvv.OG8vv,vv%,h8vvlvv,qvv%

G vvrvvLBfbvv!vv/Xvv.AP vvv.h8vv!vvvG vv$vvJQOvv7+vv2#vvJQOvv7#vvuvv7G vv9vv2G8vvHvvK+vv.

G1)b2.SS#r.#. -.

bvv.UvvLG)#vv.eG vvSvv.kvvcvv2G vvcvvVvvLG vvcvv2vv.Ovv2hbvv.Tkvv1vv-,hqvvJG#vv9vv.R

P vvvG vvcvvVvvL1vv$vv1qvvMGJtvv.f vv,vv.G$;vvLG$tvv2vvLkvv2EDvv1vv.AG vvcvv!vv.e,h&vv,vvYvv7

G vvlvvuvvLG)Ovv0#vv2,kvvrvvJtvv.&vv:1vvfvvJGO8vv$vv.L1vvcvv(vv.UvvL#vvHvv9vv!vvlvv7#vv)kvvLS

hQheh+vvv(vvv.Oh&vvv2vvv],htvvv.&vvv:1vvvfvvvJGO#vvv.[vvv)G vvvEvvvuvvv%,hDvvv.XvvvLIG vvvcvvv. vvv%

G)Ovv0#vv2,htvv.&vv:G vv.kvv.O8vv?vv2AE vv1vv,vv.#vv)tvv"1vvrvv.YG vvcvv. vv%G)Ovv0#vv2,

htvv"0vvEvv$vv"DvvYvv.QI>vv(vvPvv-kvv2C[vv.GA&vvlvvPvv-,hEfq

G vv$vv?vv9vv$vvdG vvKj0vvuvv.f

bvv!vv/+vvKgG vvSvv.tvv!vv78vvuvv<vvLkvv1vv-G$DvvJGKG)>vv9vv$vv.bvv1vv7(1). vvrvvJbvvLaG)#vv.e

G vSv.kvcv2G)8v?v.+v.JG v$vK+v2v1v7kv2bvVvLg>v1qvJG.kvrvJRv,vJbvVvLgG&vfv$v.S

G vJh v7G vcv2qv.Ov1v7kv2G v9vLahG>v9vLbv.GG v!v,v.,hGOv9vPv.ev.GG v$vEvLq#v.J,Ch

Dvv.#vv.GDvv. vv,vv.,hChevv!vv.Gkvv21vvcvvZG vv$vvSvv9vv2vv,vv.J#vv$vv.+vv.1vv1vv)G vvEvv0d

hG vvEvvLGe,hqvvJOvv.Okvv2bvvVvvL+vv%G vv9vvSvv1qvvd,kvvuvv.f#vv(vv,vv%G)#vv.#vv1qvv7G);vv(vv.

bvSvL0v7,htv.f#v(v,v%G)#v.#v1v7G)Ov$v.bv1v!v1v7,htv.&v:#v(v,v%G vM0vJ0v7,htv.&v:

#v(v,v%kvLqv7G v$vcv9vM v7G vK0v)GRv9v,vLhG1vcv!v%G vuv0e,hGRv9v,vLhG1v9vrvJ0v%G vLCj

bv!v/G v(vrv".hG vrvJQ0v7hG v$vL>v,v7hG vLGkvYv7hG vHv.GQL, vrvJ8v#;vLG vSv.kvcv2

1vvv,vvvKgG vvvlvvvLbhCGvvvK#vvv.qvvvmG vvvuvvvLG+vvv1vvv71vvv.bvvv9vvv2vvv.Q+vvvKgG vvvlvvvLb#vvv)G vvv2vvvJY

hG$+vvv.GA,kvvvuvvvLgG vvvHvvv.Vkvvv2+vvvKgG vvvcvvv!vvv.e,htvvv.f0vvvKeqbvvv!vvv%G vvvuvvv0e

(1)#E$JC1.R+LI,G)#.eG S.kc2D1.8-hbVLgvvvvBQGDghkr,-,37vvvv41.

101G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 104: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

1v.bv9v2v.Qg+v.i1v"COv.Ov.G v,v.i,tv$v.&vVvF1v. v2vcvJbv(v-.kv,v.0vrv.dkv1v$v.

0vvLh0vv-G vvL1vv1vvdbvv(vv-:z$f0vv!vvrvv/GuG vvcvv2vvJ1vvuvv"P&vv3E/G vvSvvLcGvv1vvL#vv)

Cf0!r.g1S2A#)G$+.GA(1).

qvv.dG vv$vvM&vv2:Ovv$vvcvv:G vvSvv.kvvcvv20vvrvv.d:Ovv,vv"#vv. vvvbvv)G vvuvv0e

hG vv9vv.Dvv1vvJ,kvvrvv.d:#vvEvv.dCf&vv_vv)1vv. vv(vv2vv2�C&qvv-bvv!

qvv%C#qvv9vv-G/Ovv9vv(vv?vv.A

h vv%0vvcvv!qvv$vv,vv%G vv9vv.Dvv1vvJ,hG vv9vv.Dvv1vvJ#vv.qvv. vv-G vv(vv2vv2�:(C#vvLJCfCqvv.8vv"

G vv(vv.SDvv9vv/0vvrvv. vv.G/E vv-E/q

Gukvv$vv.bvvVvv%1vv-G vvJehG vv$vv.d,Dvvrvv1vvrvv7

G 9.D1J(2)(3).

f;eGfA}OGyW9pg,p,EC=9JGygt+OI?:

G vvSvv.kvvcvv2qCDvvJCFvv$vv7G vvPvv!vvm,P+vv3kvv2P vvv#vvK+vv3C+vv"

G vvPvv!vvmG vvVvv. vvF,kvv,vv.0vvLiCfq

G vvuvv9vv.HhG vvPvv(qvv7+vv$vv.#vvVvvJQG vv9vvSvvL0vvd,

hE vv1vv,vv$vv.0vvL>vvdG vv$vvlvv9vv2,h vvK vvv8vvLGgbvv(vvJE;vv2vv.J#vvlvvLOGJG vvcvvrvv1vvJI0vv2vvJC

1vvKtvvLG vv(vvVvv.UG vv.GQOIkvv2P vvv#vv)G vvuvv9vv.HhG vvPvv(qvv7,h0vvEvv9vv@q

1vv$vv.>vv.A

1vvvvv,vvvvv$vvvvv.bvvvvv!vvvvv/G vvvvv$vvvvvHvvvvv. vvvvvm,h0vvvvvrvvvvv.dkvvvvv2#vvvvvcvvvvvLVQOqgbvvvvv!vvvvv/#vvvvv)qvvvvv.d

1v./Ov9vEvPv.f:ztv"#v.hUvlv:#vd#v.C&v.PGtvLhOv.tv:bv(v-Gtv9vlv.A1v$v.

PtvvLJ#vv(vv-,bvv$qvv. vv%CPtvvL#vv)Dvvuvv%Gu;vv%Dvvuvv%QOvv.dGu�,;vv%

Dvvuvv%G vv$vvPvv!vv$vv1vv)O vv1vv"bvv!vv/Cf/0vv?vv.R vv$vv)COvv9vv#+vv"Cf0vvuvv.fDvv.tvv$vv.

Ch#vvlvv9vv1vv.Cf0vvEvvuvv%h/Cf0vvlvv9vv2E/#vv)>vv,vv7Gvv2vvL/RehP vvvG vvuvv9vv.H

(1)G K+22,O1LCb0eG (20A,7,340.

(2)G 2H.Qj,t9.HG V0I,1.HkY"GO9r2.dG r2!7,DJ0=Qq%392.

(3)G K+22,S+QCf;eGy"=;A,7,343.

102G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 105: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

;vv%G vvPvv(qvv7Ch#vv.qvv. vv-C+vv"G vvcvv!vv%/0vvHvv9vv!vvlvv.fkvv1vv-Chqvv1vv.Sbvv!vv/1vvcvvZ

+vvvKG,h/0vvv?vvv.R vvv-Cf0vvvEvvvuvvv%h/0vvvlvvv9vvv21vvv./Ovvv9vvvEvvvPvvv.fEP vvv%0vvvuvvv)

G/O9EP.fhG>2.h/k2hGDJ#)+KgG $c.&2.(1)

C#qv.G$O qv7bv!v/h>v.H8vEvuv1v%G vuv9v.HhG vPv(qv7hC&

qv-/0v?v.R$DvJ

#vvHvv. vvlvv9vv,vv$vv.,qvv.d:qvv.dGuN vv(vv2vv1vv-�:{OPQRSTUVWXYZ[@{uv}(2)hqvvvvvv.d8vvvvvvcvvvvvv. vvvvvv/:{_‘

abcdefghijklmn

opqrstuvwxyz{|}

~!@~y}(3),;vvvv%>vvvv.Agqvvvv.ekvvvvPvvvv# vvvv.gbvvvv)CUvvvvEvvvv.HG vvvvuvvvv,vvvvm

hevv1vvL+vv%,kvvrvv.d:zCbvv!vv$vvuvv%evvJG,0vvcvv(vv2:COvv#d>vv2vvL0vv",;vv%Cbvv!vv$vvuvv%,

kvvvvvv#&vvvvvvMdGuN{<=>?@AB@xwCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRS@yw}(4).h>vvv.A8vvv-C#vvvLCIChS1vvv)G vvvVvvv.#vvv:8vvvSvvvuvvv.E vvv1vvv-ChOvvv.,kvvv!vvv%

0vv?vv2vv,vv.Dvv9vv/C&vvMdGu:{*+,-./0123456789:;@v}(5).h>vvv.AG vvvcvvv?vvv0&vvv20vvvrvvvKa

G#vvLC8vv-,qvv.d: vv%0vv(vvMdkvv1vvuvv$vv.,hG&vv9vv_vvLG vv.Dvv2kvv!vv$qvv.C&vvMdbvv!vv1vv-Obvv.+vv$vv.,

(1)G)#vvvv.e#vvvvEvvvv$vvvvJ1vvvv)EOQ0vvvvQG vvvvSvvvv.kvvvvcvvvv2G vvvv$vvvv9vvvv.kvvvv/204+vvvvvvvv,G$e,2,tvvvv9vvvv.HE1vvvv\vvvv.d

G)O9EP.f,h1.HE1\.dG)O9EP.f,294.

(2)G$&c.e:106.

(3)G $.FJI:49.

(4)G u,m:23vvvv24.

(5)G $?.O 7:1.

103G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 106: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

kv0bv)1v1v(v,v$v.tv$v.C#vLgGuN,hqv.d v(v2v1v-:{_‘abcd

efghijklmnopqr

stuvwxyz{|}~

!@~y}(1).hqvvvvvv.dGuN:{VWXYZ[

\]^_‘abcdefghij

klmnopqrs@{w}(2).h vvv1vvvQ0vvv&#vvvLCDvvvJ

Cf0vEvuv%1vEvsq,E/

qhqvJbv!v%G vEvs

q,h/0vuv.fG vEvsq#vcv!v.#v.E/

qbv)Gu

&vvVqvv.ChO/ vv7#vv)GukvvrvvJ>vvcvv"GuG vvEvvs

qkvv2tvv9vv.1vv-;vv%kvv2Ovv(qvv7&vv2vv1vv-�

kvv!vv1vvQ8vv(vvMd1vv#DvvJ&vv.R vv7E/q

hG vvuvv9vv.H0vvJdqbvv!vv1vv,vv.&vvVqvv.Ch>vv$vv!vv7;vv%0vv2vv1qvv)

G $LGO#$.&Md&Vq

..

(hPtvvLG$#vv<vv!vv7 vv-h#vv.&vvMd>vv$vv!vv7hkvvVqvv!vv9vv-G vvPvv(qvv7G vv(vv2vv.0vv7h1vv1vv)Cf

#v)qv2v"bv)QOv.dGu�kvrvJqv2v"bv)GuhC[v.dG v(vlvQkv2+vKG(3).

h+vKGG vuv0e0vJdbv!v/C&qv-0vLiCf

qGuOv2vEv.&v-h8vcv. v/#v.8vLc v(v.Rv1v,v.

#$.CQGOgE/q

hO q

(.b!1-k2t9.1-ChO(q7&21-�(4)

|w9!?GyT"q

?f"OG |9eGyW9pg,hQOq

gfz)|#C!wQIG+A%9:vvvv

0vvLiG)#vv.eG vvSvv.kvvcvv2qCfq

G vvPvv(vv7#vv<vv"G vvrvvLBfkvv2G vv9vvSvvL0vvd

kv$v.;v2v:kv2G vPv(qv7tv. vKj;v2v:kv2G vrvLBfh#v.DvLqekv2G vPv(qv7tv. vKj

(1)G $.FJI:49.

(2)U:26.

(3)G S.kc2,G$e,2|2939.

(4)G vSv.kvcv2,G vLOv. v7,94.DvJ0v=Qqv%289(#v.8vLtv:Rv1v,v.k

#v$v.C#vLtv%Gu1v-E/hqvJ

C#L8u%1-@@@).

104G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 107: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

DvLqekv2G vrvLBf.hG vPv2v3kv2P vvC&qv,v$v.>v$v1vcv.#v)Gu,0vrv.dq:

zkvvv!vvv1vvvPvvv:8vvv(vvvMd1vvv#DvvvJ#vvv)C+vvv"O0vvv)Gu&vvv.R vvv7,E/q

hkvvv2tvvv9vvv.HGu

G vvvJ vvv1vvv"bvvv!vvv/Ovvv2vvv1vvv"G vvv,vvvJikvvv1vvv,vvv..qvvv.d8vvvcvvv. vvv/:{OPQ

RSTUVWXYZ[\]

^@v}(1).hqvvvvvv.d8vvvvvvcvvvvvv. vvvvvv/:{BCDEF

GHIJKLM@yy}(2).hqvvvvvv.d8vvvvvvcvvvvvv. vvvvvv/:

{QRSTUVWXYZ[\]

^_‘abcdefg

h:89}(3).

hG!0vvvv.Jkvvvv2+vvvvKGG vvvv$vvvvcvvvv(vvvv/tvvvv<vvvv1vvvvLIhqvvvv.d,q,kvvvv2tvvvv9vvvv.H

G vLOv. v7:zhtv"#v.Ov)qkvrvJC vM#v(v.GuG8v2v.bv-,h>vcv"kv2G8qv2v.bv-[v.bv9v-,

hkv2G vcvMhabv)G8qv2v.bv,v.#vcvVv1v9v-G v9v2 v%0vcvKQ1v,v.Gv!vrv.,h v%0v?vcv"

vvvv-#vvvv)G8qvvvv2vvvv.YOvvvv(vvvv)QOvvvv.dGu�#vvvvHvvvvL>vvvv. vvvv$vvvv.hUvvvvlvvvv:,h#vvvv.qvvvv. vvvv-

QO.dGu�y.

hqvvJ8vvPvv9vvrvv"1vv2vvcvvZG$Dvvuvv.ehEf vv%0vvLO vv,vv.CUvv"kvv2G vvuvv9vv.H

kvvrvv.d:zGkvv9vvLVGubvv!vv/Gvv!vvrvv-#vv)[vv.bvv7QOvv. vv-h1vv1qvv)#vv.Xvvcvv-G vvKj

hXvvcvv-Gu1vv-#vv)O0vv(vv-.h#vv(vv,vv.#vv.C8vv/G vvuvv9vv.Hbvv!vv/evv.0vv7G vv2vv1vv.fkvv1vv-kvv!vv%

0vvEvv9vv@#vvdG vv9vv(vvM0vv"kvv1vv-E vv/evv1vvLg.h#vv(vv,vv.:#vv.C8vv/bvv!vv/evv.0vv7G vv2vv1vv.fkvv2

(1)E1LG+1%:1.

(2)G (E":44.

(3)G (E":89.

105G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 108: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

kvLXv-,hGkv9vLV[v.bv7QOv. v-kv2v1qv)QOv.dGu�bv)GuN:tv1vm

kvLXv-hbv!v/#v)kvLXv-h#v9v/0vMhd1vcvYv-h0v<v2v:h0v?v3.h#v(v,v.:#v.1v1qv(v-

bv)Ov(v7&v2v1v-1v0&vWtv9v.H.htv"Rv2A#v(v,v.1v1v.fkv2tv9v.HGu@kvuv"

#vvvv)qvvvv2vvvv"bvvvv)GukvvvvLGFvvvvYvvvv-kvvvv2tvvvv9vvvv.1vvvv-qvvvv2vvvv"bvvvv)QOvvvv.dGu�Ovvvv(vvvv(vvvv-

1vlvLVGuOv2vEv.&v-h8vcv. v/[v.bv7QOv. v-�bv!v/Gv!vrv-hCf0v(v9v,v.GE v/

Dvuv$v-,h#v)qv2v"bv)QOv.dGu�kvcv)Guqv2v" v$v.Gkv9vLXv-Gu#v)

[.b9-(1).

C#qvv.G$O qvv7bvv!vv/P vvvqvv.d:bvvLVGubvv!vv/G vv(qvv.SG8vv2vv.YhUvv1qvv7

hOvvvv(vvvv)QOvvvv.dGu�kvvvvrvvvv.dkvvvv2tvvvv9vvvv.1vvvv-:{@ABCD

EFGHIJKLMN

O@~wv}(2).hqv.d8vcv. v/C0vYv.:{123456789:;<=>?@A:151}(3)hqvvvv.d8vvvvcvvvv. vvvv/:{-./0123

456789:;<=

>?@ABCDE:164}(4)hevvvv1vvvvL+vvvv.G vvvvuvvvv<vvvv1vvvvL,

#vv$vv.Odq

bvv!vv/PtvvLGuG vvuvv9vv.Hh+vv.G vvrvvLBf,hPtvvLG vvEvvuvv$vv7h+vv2Ovv(qvv7

QO.dGu�(5).

(1)G vvSvv.kvvcvv2,G vvLOvv. vv7,1vv.H#vv.C1vv.fGu vvHvv!vvrvv-#vv)kvvLXvv-bvv!vv/QOvv.dGu�G8vv2vv.Y#vv.ChD2E 1-,165vvvv292vvvv293vvvv294.

(2)G 2rLI:129.

(3)G 2rLI:151.

(4)Bdb$LGf:164.

(5)G S.kc2,G LO. 7,t9.H11.fkLVGuk2t9.1-G82.YO(q7&21-,153.

106G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 109: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

C#qv.qv.dG)#v.eG vSv.kvcv2qkv2Gv2vLG!Dv.O:vvvvkvrvJ1v.qH1v.1v.

Gvv.Uvv.Ovv$qvv.gbvv!vv%bvv.#qvv7hbvv!vv%Gvv.Uqvv7.kvvrvv.d:qvv.d vv2qvv.Fvv":DvvJ

qO vv2

Cqqv"#v.8vrv.e1v-G vEv?

qv7bv!v/C+v"G vcv!v%(bv!v%G vcv.#qv7)(1).hDvJq

O#v.8vrv.e

1v-G vEv?qv7bv!v/C+v"G vcv!v%kv2qv2v.dG vHv2vLG v.GDvJ,kvrv.d:zGv2vLG v.GDvJ

bv)G v.GDvJDv9v/0v(v9v,v21v-E v/G v(v2v2q�Ch#v)G&v9v,v/1v-E v1v-Oh&v-.C#qv.

G2Lb!%G H.Uq

7k08r.e1-G E?q

7D9/0?$dC#.QG#(,.:

1vvvvCf0vvvuvvv.f#vvv)DvvvJq

K1vvv-;vvvrvvv7kvvv2O0vvv(vvv-#vvvcvvvLhkvvv.1vvv. vvvVvvvJbkvvv2

DvvJ0vv<vv-,bvv.qvv0 vv$vv.0vvEvvJq

K1vv-,bvv. vv$vv.1vv$vv.0vvEvv1vv"#vvcvv.&vv2G vvEvvJ0vv=#vv)

G vv!vvlvva,hCf0vvuvv.f#vv$vv)0vv&OjG vvEvvJ0vv=1vvEvvLhkvv-tvv$vv.Ovv$vvd,/0vvEvvJq

K

1vv-bvv!vv/G vv$vvcvv(vv/,h+vv.bvv. vv%1vv$vv.0vvEvv1vv"#vvcvv(vv.g:vvvv vv%0vvJQ vvcvv!vv-0vvEvv1vv"

G vvEvv0dE vv/G vvEvvLGe.hEPGCOqGg1vvEvvLhkvv-kvv!vv%0vv2vvsh>vv-0vvHvv.akvv1vv-EDvv. vv9vv-

G vEvJ0v=,Dv.kv_v.EfDvJq

K1v-#v)Dvlv_v-,Dv.kv_v. vuv9v.HGuEfDvJq

K

#vv)tvv9vv.1vv-.EPGRnvvLpc

nC+vv"nG vvEvvlvvakvv2G vvEvvJ0vv=hGkvvsDvvJ0vv<vv,vv%,1vvL0qvv.#vv)

Cf0vvuvv.f#vvJ vvPvv.:0vvEvvJq

Kbvv)#vv) vvrvv2#vv. vv%0vvPvv$vvd#vv(vv-,h0vvEvvJq

Kbvv)

G vv(vv2vv2q�#vv.0vvEvvJq

KG vv<vvrvv.JGvv0kvv-bvv)G vv(vv2vv2q�h0vvuvv.f+vvuvvKG#vv)

kv.qv-#v$qv)DvJ;v-,Dv9v/0v(v9v,v21v. vEvJ0v=#v.Uv./E v/G v(v2v2�ChE v/

#vvvv.G&vvvv9vvvv,vvvv/1vvvv-E vvvv1vvvv-Oh&vvvv-,$fq

tvvvv"hGDvvvvJ#vvvv(vvvv,vvvv%#vvvv<vvvv2vvvv: vvvv$vvvv)DvvvvJq

;vvvv-,

h#vvv<vvv2vvv:bvvv!vvv/#vvv)DvvvJq

Kbvvv(vvv-,kvvv00vvvPvvv9vvvfvvv(vvv2kvvv2tvvv"hGDvvvJ#vvv(vvv,vvv%bvvv$qvvv.

hUvvlvv:(2).C#qvv.#vv.Gbvv9vv2vvLgG vvSvv.kvvcvv2#vv.0vvlvv1vvJG vvHvv2vvLG vv.GDvvJ,C&

qvv-/0vvlvv1vvJ

(1)Gbvv9vv2vvLG vvSvv.kvvcvv2G vvcvv!vv%+vv.#vv.0vv?vv3bvv!vv/G vv(qvv.Sbvv!vv%G vvcvv.#qvv7G vvKj/0vvPvvd1vv. vvfvv.k

evv1vvL#f!.Hb!/br!->,!-.

(2)G vvSvv.kvvcvv2,G vvLOvv. vv7,250vvvv252,h+vvKgG vvSvvLhWG vv9vv2hXvvcvv,vv.G)#vv.eG vvSvv.kvvcvv2S

107G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

=

Page 110: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

G vvcvv!vv%#vv\vv!vvrvv.Ovv.GAGDvv9vvlvv:1vv-G vvrvvLGFvv)Ce/,h+vv.qvv.d>vv$vv.bvv7#vv)

CUvEv.HG vEvJ0v=,kvrvJC>v$vdG vVvEv.1v7R,#v$v)1vcvJ+v%#v)G v9v.1vcv1v)

hOv!vmG$#qv7G vVv. vFbv!v/h>v.HG vcv$v"1vHv2vLG v.GDvJ,Ov.GA#v)qv.d

E&qvv-0vvlvv1vvJG vvcvv!vv%Ch0vvlvv1vvJG vv_vv)q,h vv%0vvHvv. vvmkvv2+vvKGE/

q#vv)/Gbvv9vv2vv.Q

1vvHvv0kvv-,tvv2vvcvvZG vv$vvcvv9vvM vv7hG vvLGkvvYvv7.bvv!vv/P vvvkvv(fq

G vvSvv.kvvcvv2q/

0vvlvvLqbkvv2h>vv.HG vvcvv$vv"1vvHvv2vvLG vv.GDvvJ1vv1vv)#vvPvv.Fvv"G vvcvvrvv1vvJIhevv1vvL+vv.#vv)

C#.QG J0)(1).

Iw~|#QOq

L=QG6I9O:vvvv

qvv.dG vvSvv.kvvcvv2q(2):vvvv/0vv?vv.Rbvv(vvJjbvv!vv/bvv. vv%Cf0vv<vv2vv:

Gv2vLGk

hGDvJGk

tv<v1vLGk

h0vEv"qh0vEvLqeh0vLOq#v<v!v-E/q

#v)>v,v7Cf0vuv.fbv(vJg

DvvvJ0vvv=0vvvHvvv. vvvlvvv-Ch0vvvuvvv.f#vvv.Ovvv$vvvdh#vvv)Ovvv$vvvd#vvv(vvv-Ch;vvvs#vvv$vvv)DvvvJ;qvvv-

Gv0kv-,Ch0vuv.f#v)DvJq

;v- v1vQ1vEv.kvaCh0vuv.f#v9v,v$v.bv(vJg,Ch0v9qv,v%

#v)kv.qv-#v$v)DvJ;qv-,Ch0vuv.fG vEvJ0v=#vEv9v$v0#vcv(v1v1v)kv1v9v#hqdkv1vK+v3

E vvv/CDvvvJ+vvv$vvv.OhfG!GvvvL@@@kvvv(f vvv%0vvvPvvv!vvvvhGDvvvJG#vvv)+vvvKgG vvvPvvv2vvv"

k1cKQ12cY,.krJCG\#G\#/bKQk1-b(J&.,hGuCb!%(3).

q q q q q q

+vvv2CUvvv"G vvvSvvvLhWG vvv9vvv2hXvvvcvvv,vvv.bvvv!vvv$vvv.A#vvvVvvv\vvv!vvvFG vvvEvvvJ0vvv=,G8vvvVvvv.dG vvvPvvv(vvvJ,bvvvJG vvv7G LhGI,Cf0u.fG LGhjX.1\.,O0#9-#)G SKhPhG c!

q7G r.OD7.

(1)G S.kc2,G LO. 7,267h !$M0J#)G$O q

7QG>dt9.HG LO. 7.(2)G&_LG LO. 7 !S.kc2 0O9MGOI#)G$#<!7G 92GO9Jd1,.G$GK1H2LG!D.O.

(3)G S.kc2,G LO. 7,255.

108G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 111: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

G |9eCI}O<#I"={

h vvvvJCDvvvv$vvvvJS,kvvvv2Q1vvvv1vvvvdG$hqd#vvvv)Ovvvv(vvvv7164#vvvv)G vvvv,vvvv?vvvvLI

G vv(vv2vv.0qvv7,h8vv.kvv2/;vv(vv9vv2bvvSvvLI vv1vv!vv7Gvv!vv:#vv)Q1vv1vvdG$hqdOvv(vv7EDvvJi

hCQ1vcv1v)h#v.Fv9v1v),htv.&v:>v(v.R8v-0v.eG v?v$vcv7,h/evLG1v7kv2Cf0vcvLa

8v.Q0vIhkv.8v-1v. v9vcv1v1v),kvrvJtv.f0v.#v.#vSv,v.OGkv28v.Q0vI1vfvJGO,8v?v.h1v:

1KtLgG$q\.QG)O0#1q7, u<LIG K0)R1qc.G>(.R8-.

h vvJCDvv$vvJ1vv2vvfvvJGO,h&vvPvv2vv-bvvL1vv2q,kvv,vv.Rvv1vv2vv.&vv2qkvv2&vvPvv2vv-$1vv1vv-

hC#qvv-.hRvv1vv2vv.fqvv2vv1vv!vv7Q1vvcvv1vv7bvvJ&vv.&vv1vv7,8vv!vv9vvrvv2#vvdG vv(vv2vv2�kvv2&vvMGQ1vv)

#cJ1)bJ&.f(1).

h vJCDv$vJG v.QYG v9vrv2q#v)C1v.0v)bvL1v1v1v)tvL0v$v1v):tv.fC1v.g>v(vJ0v.k

0vEv$v2G vEv$v/,h0vJGkvdbv)G vEv.RI,h#v.Gv!vdRjG vfvMGI,1v"tv.fbv!v/

P vvvE vv/Cf#vv.J.hhQKbvv)COvvL8vv-bvvMqIG vv(vvlvvQhqvv.qIG vvcvvMe,hG vvVvv2vvL

hGDvv9vv$vv.dG vv$vvuvv.Qg,hG)0vv$vv.fG vvLGOvvIG vvrvv.j,htvv.fP vvvtvv!qvv-0vv(vv$vv.tvv!vv$vv.

R3qh8LbLY.

(1)#vvEvv$vvJC1vv.R+vvLI,CDvv$vvJG1vv)Dvv(vv2vv"Dvv1vv.8vv-hbvvVvvLgvvvvBQGDghkvvrvv,vv-,G vvrvv.+vvLI,OGQG vvlvvuvvL

G cL12,2008e,15.

109G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 112: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

h v%0vuvJCDv$vJ0vLi&v.QG v.>v.O,Dv9v/QCiC&qv-kvL0vJkv1v-,qvJkvrvJ

C1vvv.g,htvvv%8vvv-C#qvvv-,kvvv(fq

C1vvv.gqvvvJ#vvv.Jh+vvv.[vvvlvvv"Uvvvfvvv1vvvL.htvvv.fkvvv2+vvvKG

tvvSvv1vvHvv-G vvSvv.kvvcvv2:&vvPvv3Qkvv1vvd,hDvv.d#vv)G vvlvvrvvLG vvKj0vv?vvJkvv1vv-G vvuvvlvv.a,

h+v$qv7bv. v1v7,h&vlvQC1v1qv7,hbvrv"Ptv2CQ0v3,h vrvJ8vSv.1v,v:&vSv#IG v9v!v$v1vK

hG$Ov9v.P8vSv.1v,v.evL0v2v..tv0+v$v.tv.&v: v-Ceq8vLC#v-h8vJkvcv-E v/G vcv0.&vSv#

G)#v.eCDv$vJSkv21vfvJGO,h8vL1v/kv1v,v.8vL1v1v9v-G$h v/,hqvJtv.&v:8v$v.L

1vv. vv(vv.SG vvK0vv)GGvv9vv!vvlvv:#vvSvv.Q1vv,vv%,kvv1vv,vv.G vvrvvLqGAhG vv$vvEvvJ;vv.fhG vv$vv9vvVqvv.kvv7

hbv!v$v.AG v!vfv7hG vlv0Ovlv7hG vEvuv$v.A,kvrvJtv.&v:Dv.XvLIG vcv. v%G)Ov0#v2,

hqvvJGGvv9vv.QJCOvvLICDvv$vvJ vv-#vv(vvKUvv2vv.gCf0vvuvv.fQ>vv"G vvJ0vv)G vvKj0vv9vv.kqvvL

vv-h0vvcvvuvvmbvv!vv1vv-,h0vv9qvvHvvK vv-tvv"G vvcvv!vv.eG vv$vv$vv,vvJI vv-,#vv)bvv!vv%1vv. vv!vvfvv7

hG vvvEvvvJ0vvv=hG vvvrvvvLBf,h#vvv ;vvvLG vvvVvvvEvvv.1vvv7hG vvv9vvv.1vvvcvvv1vvv)hCDvvv.GdG vvvLOvvv.d�

hOvv1vvL8vv-,hOvv1vvLICh vv1vv.Fvv-G$qvvL1vv1vv)G vvK0vv)GGvv9vvVvv.G1vv\vv.dG vvVvvEvv2vv7,hkvvrvv-

G vJ0v)h v3qG v1vrv1v),hqvJG8vlvrv:+vKgG v9vL1v1v7,Ch+vKGG v9v.>v1v-,#vd&vMhbv-

G vv(vvlvvPvv2h#vv.tvv.&vv:8vvVvv2vv.E vv1vv-+vv$qvv9vv-#vv)evv.0vv.J. vvrvvJh>vv,vv9vv-COvvL8vv-E vv/

G vvvrvvvLBfG vvvuvvvL0vvv%#vvv(vvvK&vvvSvvv#8vvv-G$h vvv/,Dvvv9vvv/EPGC8vvv%qDvvvlvvvaG vvvrvvvLBf,hbvvv!vvv%

G vv!vvfvv7,G8vv?vv-E vv/G vvJ0vv.Gf vv1vv$vvLqfbvv!vv/G vv9vvEvvL0vvLhG vvuvv9vv.1vv7.h vvrvvJGGvv9vv.Qkvv2

UvJQDv1v.8v-Q>v.dG vEvJ0v=h#vPv!vuv,v%,kv.8v?v-E v1v,v%,hQGO[vL0vsG vlvrv,v.A

G vK0v)>v$vcv.G1v1v)G vLCjhG vEvJ0v=,kv1vLhiCfq

Chd8v!vrv1v-G vcv!v%tv.fbv!v/

G vvrvv.Xvv2C1vv20vv.OvvmUvv.Dvv3C1vv2Dvv(vv1vvlvv7(1).Cqvv2vv"bvv!vv/Ovv$vv.YG vvEvvJ0vv=,

(1)#vvEvv$vvJC1vv.R+vvLI,CDvv$vvJ1vv)Dvv(vv2vv",U18vvvv20.hG1vv)tvv<vv1vvL,G vv2vvJG0vv7hG vv(vv,vv.0vv7,

10,340.

110G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 113: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

kvuv.fChqd[v!v2v- v!vEvJ0v=hChqdOv$v.bv-#v)#vSv.0vHv-kv2Ov(v7;v$v.&v1v)h#v.Fv7,

hqvvJ1vv!vvg#vv)G vvcvv$vvLOvv:bvvSvvLIOvv(vv7(1).hqvvJ[vv.aCDvv$vvJ1vv)Dvv(vv2vv"kvv2

G v2v0OhG!kv.b,hOv$vd#v)#vSv.0vIG vcvVvL,htv.&v.G0v?v!qv.&v-h0vEv9vL#v.&v-kv2

Dvv.dOvv$vv.bvv-#vv(vv,vv%,hG>vv9vv$vvd1vv. vvSvv.kvvcvv2kvv2QDvv!vv9vv-G vv<vv.&vv1vv7E vv/1vvfvvJGOOvv(vv7

CQ1vvvdh8vvvPvvvcvvv1vvv)h#vvv.Fvvv7hbvvv$vvvLCDvvv$vvvJEPPGc&vvv1qvvvmh;vvv0;vvv.fOvvv(vvv7.qvvv.d vvv-

G vSv.kvcv2:0v.C1v.bv2vJGuEPGUvFq

bv(vJtv%G vEvJ0v=kv#bv!v$v(v21v-,$P+v3E v1v-

Dvv?vv.R0vv.tvv.fChRvv.#vv1vv.ChbvvLGqvv1vv.Ch0vv$vv(vv1vv..0vvcvv(vv2/0vvrvv.dkvvrvv,vv.AG vvEvv?vv.R

G vK0v)/0vrv2v!v.fE/q

QhG0v7G vEv?v.R0v1v)h0v(vM v.fCDv.O0v=#v)Ov.G+v%#v(vM v7

CDvv.O0vv=C+vv"G vvuvv9vv.Hvvvvhqvv.dG vvSvv.kvvcvv2 vv-+vvKgG vv$vvrvv. vv78vvcvv_vv1vv%$Dvv$vvJ

hE>vv0d vv-hC&qvv-bvv(vvJg1vv,vvKgG vv$vv<vv.1vv7EPGUvvE

qvvFChXvvcqvvm0vvL>vvdE vv1vv-,hqvvJ

tv.fG)#v.eCDv$vJ1v,vKgG v$v<v.1v7bv(vJG$Fv$qv7hG vcv!v$v.A(2).+v.>vLE v/G$#vVv.Q

kv2Ov2v1v"G vcv!v%,kvuv.f0vJhqftv"#v.0vPv$vd#v)CDv.O0v=QOv.d�hC;v.Q

CUvEv.1v-ev1vL#vcv9v$vJbv!v/G vEv.kv_v7hDvJ+v.,hP vv$fq

G vcvVvLtv.fbvVvL

8vvJh0vv)G vvcvv!vv.e,kvvlvv1vv-OhqfG vvlvvrvv-,hbvv!vv.eG vv!vvfvv7hbvv!vv.eG vvEvvJ0vv=,kvv$vv.tvv.f

0vvvuvvv9vvvlvvv21vvv./ vvv9vvvrvvv.W1vvv#P&vvv-,hG vvvEvvvlvvva1vvvcvvvrvvv!vvv-1vvv"tvvv.f0vvv.OY#vvv.8vvv!vvvrvvv.g1vvv\vvv.f

G vvrvvLG[vv1vvQ,tvv$vv.ChObvv-qvv!vv2vv-G vvEvv.kvvaG vv.Gbvv2,kvvuvv.f0vvEvvlvvaG$Dvv.O0vv=

tv!qv,v.,hEOv(v.O+v.1v\vLGFvrv,v.,h vuv(qv-EPGDvJ

qK/0vEvJ

qKE/

q#v)tv9v.H,Cj

#v$v.tv9v3h&vrv",GvSv1v7Cf0vYv"qbvrv!v-kv1v(vPv/,kv1vEvLqatv0eG vLOv.d�

(1)C1v2G vlvJGAG1v)tv<v1vL,G v2vJG0v7hG v(v,v.0v7,10,340.h#vEv$vJC1v.R+vLI,G)#v.eCDv$vJ1v)D(2",23.

(2)G1vv)tvv<vv1vvL,G vv2vvJG0vv7hG vv(vv,vv.0vv7,10,314.h#vvEvv$vvJC1vv.R+vvLI,G)#vv.eCDvv$vvJ1vv)Dvv(vv2vv",OGQG luLG cL12,G r.+LI,2008,23.

111G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 114: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

bvv)#vv.GXvvcvv-,hP vvv#vv)kvvLWG vv9vvrvv.i,h vv1vvPvv9vv$vvPvvv1vv. vvcvvLhIG vv.;vvrvv/G vv9vv2

tv.fbv!v1v,v.1vcvZG vPv!vmG vVv. vFG vK0v)tv.&v.G/0vEvJq

;v.fGvSv1v7Cf0vSv2v-

vvv,vvv%,tvvv$vvv.^vvv(qvvv.GC&qvvv-0vvvSvvv2qvvv- vvvfvvv1vvvL+vvv%(1)@tvvv.fG+vvv9vvv$vvv.eCDvvv$vvvJ1vvv)Dvvv(vvv2vvv"

1vv. vvEvvJ0vv=hB;vv.QG vvLOvv.d�hkvv9vv.hiCUvvEvv.1vv-hB;vv.Q+vv%G vvcvv!vv$vv1vv7h#vv.tvv.&vv.G

0v?v9v,vJhf#v)#vPv.Fv"kv1vEvlvatv"P vvh0v9vlv,v$v-,h0vcvLa#vLG#v1v-hev.0v.8v-,

h0vvv,vvv9vvvJj1vvvK vvvvG vvv,vvvJjG vvvuvvvL0vvv%.h8vvvcvvv!qvvv%G vvvEvvvJ0vvv=tvvv.f#vvvcvvv1vvv(vvv./Ovvv9vvv(vvv2vvv.W

G$Dvvuvv.e#vv)G vv(vvVvv.U,tvv$vv.tvv.f#vvcvv1vv(vv.1vv. vvLhG0vv7hG vvLhGI.G[qvv!vvdG)#vv.e

CDvvv$vvvJbvvv!vvv/BQGAG vvvlvvvLbG vvv$vvvHvvv9vvv!vvvlvvv7tvvv. vvvHvvv.GQLhG vvvSvvv1vvvcvvv7,hG vvv?vvv,vvv$vvv1qvvv7,

hG v$vcv9vM v7hev1vL+v%;C v%q1v,vKgG vlvLbDv1v)QDv"E v/G v2vVvLIGv$vQ#vLqGJ

vv\vv!vv3G vvEvvJ0vv=,htvv.&vv:Eqvv.#vv9vv-8vv$vv9vvJE vv/Ovv9vv7CRvv,vvLCh8vvM0vvJ,hG vv2vvVvvLI

tvv.&vv:#vv.[vv)G/bvv9vvMGd,hkvv21vv.O0vv9vv,vv.tvv.fG vvHvv.GQL0vvLG1vv\vv.fh0vvfvv1vvLhf,

htv.fG v?v,v$v1qv7hG v$vL>v,v7 v,v%[v.GFvmkv1v,v.hkv2G vuv.kv7,hG vcv. v%G v2v.Dv=

0vvVvv"E vv1vv-bvv!vv%tvv<vv1vvL#vv$vv)0vv?vv.hQ+vv%h0vvHvv. vv\vv,vv%h0vv9vvVvv"1vv,vv%,hCDvv.O0vv=

CUvvEvv.HG vvlvvLbtvv.&vv:8vvPvvLjkvv2G vv$vv?vv. vvQkvv2#vvPvv.bG/Ovv9vvEvvPvv.fkvv2

1vvcvvYvv,vv.,h#vvPvv.bG/Ovv9vv,vv?vv.fkvv21vvcvvYvv,vv.,kvvuvv.fC+vv"G vvcvv!vv%0vv!vv$qvv.f1vv,vv.

#vvvPvvv9vvv(vvvuvvvL0vvv)Ch#vvvPvvv9vvvEvvvPvvv(vvv1vvv),htvvv.fCDvvv$vvvJ0vvvL#vvv2CUvvvEvvv.H+vvvKgG!QGA

1vv./1vv9vvJGYhC&qvv,vv%tvv.&vv.G1vvcvv1vvJ0vv)bvv)#vv(vv,vv.LG vvPvv!vvm,h#vv.tvv.f vv$vv<vv"CDvv$vvJ

kv2DvLUv-hbvrv!v-Cf0vL#v2C&v.Ov.1v,vKgG vL#v1v7#v)ev1vLCf0vcvLa#vrv. v9v,v%,

EPG vEvuv%bv!v/G vSv2A&vlv1v.ChE;v2v.8v.,ChGOv9vEvPv.&v.ChOv9v,v?v.&v.,kvLYbv)

8vVv.qQgh#vcvLkv9v-.htv.fCDv$vJ0v(v9vrv2G vL>v.dG vK0v)0vLhjbv(v,v%DvLUv.bv!v/

(1)#E$JC1.R+LI,G)#.eCD$J1)D(2",26.

112G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 115: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

Cf0vuv.&v.G#v$v) v%0vHv.Xv.Gkv2C#v<v.d+vKgG$qv.GdG v9v2tv.f0vLG+v.1vJbv.

kv2G vJ0v),htv.fP vv1v0Q0v30vrv9vYv2Cf0vuv.f#v!v$qv.1vcvZG) v$v.e1v,v.,

hbvv.Qkvv.1vvcvvZG vv$vvcvvLkvv71vv,vv..G[qvv!vvdG)#vv.eCDvv$vvJbvv!vv/Cqvv.Gd+vvKgG vvlvvLb,

h vv%8vv9vv#;vvL1vv,vv.&vvlvvPvv-,h8vvSvvL1vv,vv.QhDvv-,EP vv%8vv9vvlvvs#vvd&vvMhbvv-,h vv%8vv9vv0b

#vd#v1v. v-,#vdG vcv!v%C&qv-tv.f0vcv!v%G vlv.QOv1v7,h0v9vuv!

qv%1v,v.CDv1v.&v.,EPGtv.f

#H.[2-/0EP)G cL117,h/0P9\1dG)k,.e1,.(1).

C#qv.1v. v(vPv2v7 v?v!v.Ov- v!v9vEvJ0v=hG vlv9v.i,kvrv.dG1v)G v?v.Rj:zEfq

CDvv$vvJ vv%0vv(vvVvv3&vvlvvPvv- vv!vvEvvJ0vv=hG vvlvv9vv.iE/q

1vvcvvJCf1vv!vvgG$Q1vvcvv1vv)y.

h00Dak2OQO-;0;7C#.Q:vvvv

Ch/k

:C&vv-tvv.f0vvPvv.O#vv?vv!vvPvv-G vv.qvv.QhG vvPvvuvv1vv(vv7#vvd8vv.GXvvdhG[vv$vv,vv(vv.f

&vlvPv2,h v%0vuv)G v.qv.Qkv2#v?v!vQbv!v$v-hDvJg,1v"tv.fkv2tv"#v?v. vPv-,

/0v$vMMh/0v!v,v.,$fq

G v!v,v.kv2>v$v!v9v-1v.[v",h$fq

tv"#vMDv7#v?qv7#v)

G vcvrv",hqvJbv!v%#vHv. v\v.g#v(v-P vv,kvuv.&v.G/0v$vMDv.fkv2DvYvL8v-qv],

kvv2#vv?vv!vvQbvv!vv%Chevv1vvL#vv?vv!vvQbvv!vv%.1vv"tvv.&vv:QhMG vv?nvvJ

8hG vvPvvuvv1vv(vv7+vv2

G vv9vv28vv\vv"q#vv)#vv?vv!vvPvv-,$fq

P vvv+vv.G vvKj0vv9qvvlvvs#vvdQhG0vv7G vvPvv(qvv7G vv(vv2vv.0vv7

G vvvSvvvL0vvvlvvv7,hB;vvv.QG vvvLOvvv.dG vvvuvvvL0vvv%,hkvvv9vvv.hiG vvvPvvv!vvvmG vvvVvvv. vvvFQXvvv.GfGu

8vvcvv. vv/bvv!vv1vv,vv%,h#vv)Rvv#fG vvPvvuvv1vv(vv7Cf8vv?vvcvv" vv!vvrvv.d#vvuvv.&vv7#vv)G vvrvv!vv3,

h#vv(vvM vv9vv-#vv)G vv(vvlvvQ,hE&qvv-hEftvv.&vv:G vvJbvv.1vv78vvK+vv3G vv$vv0d,kvv(f

qtvv<vvL8vv,vv.

8vK+v3G vLhbv7hQhGAG vcv!v%,hqvJ8v?v(v3CDv$vJG v$vMGM>v$v!v7EPQhG0v7G vPv(qv7

bv2v.OIbv(vJg,h/#vMMkv2hqv:G vcv2v.OI,1v"G v$vMM0v(v.kv1v,v.,h/Gv1vLkv1v$v)

(1)C1.R+LI,CD$J1)D(2",29.hC0Y.8.Q0IG $KG+3G)O0#17,491.

113G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 116: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

0$"#)G c2.OI1LhG07b!%G LO.d�,hG1L#.hU"E 1-CUE.1-.

G$#vvLG vv<vv.&vv2:vvvvC&qvv-/0vv!vvrvv2G vvJQS#vv)evv1vvL[vv!vv31vv"0vvPvv#dbvv)

G$Dvv.O0vv=G vv$vvLh0qvv7kvv2#vv.Xvv.Ykvv1vvPvv9vvEvvYvvLG vvuvv9vv3G vv9vv2Ohqfkvv1vv,vv.8vv!vvv

G$D.O0=.

G$#vvvLG vvv<vvv. vvv=:vvvvG vvv$vvv0Dvvvakvvv2OQhOvvv-C&qvvv,vvv.tvvv.&vvv:#vvv)Dvvv1vvv=

#vv.Xvv.bvv,vv.qvvPvv$vv1vv),CDvvJ+vv$vv.QhG0vv7G vvEvvJ0vv=h&vvrvv!vv-,h;vv.&vv1vv,vv$vv.kvv9vv.h0vv-

G vvlvvrvv,vv1vv7G vv9vv2tvv.f0vvYvv\vvLE vv/GOvv9vv(vv2vv.[vv,vv.,h+vvKg/0vvPvv$vvF vv9vv0#vv1vvKgCf

0vvvvv(vvvvvrvvvvv!vvvvv.+vvvvv.bvvvvv(vvvvv-,EPE&qvvvvv-#vvvvv.tvvvvv.f0vvvvvPvvvvv9vvvvv?vvvvv1vvvvvMG vvvvv9vvvvvJh0vvvvv)E/$Dvvvvv.O0vvvvv=

QOvv.dGu�,h0vvLiCfbvv!vv%G vvJ0vv)hDvvJg+vv.bvv!vv%G vvuvv9vv.HhG vvPvv(qvv7,

hCfq

#v)G v2vJY8vJh0v)BQGAG v(v.Skv2G vJ0v)1v?v.GQtv9v.HGuhG vPv(qv7(1).

htvv.fCDvv$vvJ1vv)Dvv(vv2vv"0vv9vv9vv2vvdDvv1vv.IG vvPvv!vvm#vv.GOvv9vv\vv.Y,kvv!vvrvvJ8vv?vvLqOkvv1vv,vv.

#vvv)#vvv01vvvPvvv.JG vvvcvvvVvvvLh#vvv(vvv.DvvvLG8vvv-,h#vvv.0vvv?vvvLj#vvv)#vvv(vvv.R/JkvvvuvvvL0qvvv7

hOvvv1vvv.Ovvv1qvvv7ChG>vvv9vvv$vvv.bvvv1qvvv7ChDvvvL1vvv1qvvv7,GGvvv9vvv.QCf0vvvEvvv!qvvvs1vvvLhDvvv-kvvv2>vvv.q

G vVvEv.1v7hG vVvlv.I#v)G v9v.1vcv1v),h#v)>v.A1vcvJ+v%,#v$v)&v,v@&v,v?v,v%,

hGGv9v.QOv2v1v!v,v%, vK vvtv.fbv!v$v-hkvrv,v-+v.G vPv(qv7hkvrv,v,v.,/0vHv.V

kvv2C#vvL,E/q

EPGbvv!vv%CfG vvVvvEvv.1vv7Gvv.Xvv.Gkvv2P vvv,kvv(fbvv!vv%P vvv

G8vv2vvdQC0vv,vv%,h&vvlvv/evv1vvLg,hEf vv%0vvcvv!vv%CfG vvVvvEvv.1vv7Gvv.Xvv.Gkvv2P vvv

G$#vL,tvmq

bv(v-hGOv9vcvVv%#v9v.qqvlv.DvKQG,kv00vrvlv.#v. v1vQ v-1v-bv!v%,

$&qv-0vcv9vrvJCfG vHvLhLbv)8v!vvG v?v.OqIR0vgbv)#v(v,v.LG vPv!vm,hE vEv.O

bvv)O0vv)GuOvv2vvEvv.&vv-h8vvcvv. vv/,/0vv9vvuvv!qvvmG vv9vvcvv$vvskvv2#vvPvv.Fvv"bvvrvv!vv1qvv7qvvJ

(1)#E$JC1.R+LI,G)#.eCD$J1)D(2",33vvvv35.

114G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 117: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

8vuv.f#v9v.+v.JG vcvrv"G v2vSvLj,hEfGvLLbv)hbv<v.Fv,v.Ov. v$v.kvrvJ>v,vJ

&vlvPv-kv2ev1vL[v.Fv",hRvfv"kvuvLgkv2ev1vL>vJhi,h v,v.bv)PtvLGu,

hqP.q!2-,hUJq&lP-b)O21"G c2.OI(1).

Efq

bvvVvvLCDvv$vvJqvvJevv!vv3kvv1vv-G vvcvv(vvVvvLG vvlvv.QOvv2G vvcvv(vvVvvLG vvcvvL1vv2,

hOvvv.OJG vvvEvvvYvvv.QIG vvvlvvv.QOvvv1qvvv7Chevvv1vvvLG vvvcvvvL1vvv1qvvv71vvvSvvvuvvv"bvvv.eG vvv$vvv?vvv9vvv$vvvd

G)Ovv0#vv2q,h#vv.>vv:G vv$vvJfG)Ovv0#vv1vv71vvcvv(vv.UvvL#vvHvv9vv!vvlvv7#vv)C#vv%#vv9vv2vv.0vv(vv7

G$Qh#vv7,h8vvL>vv$vv:G vvcvv!vv.eG vvlvv!vvPvvlvv1vv7#vv)G vv!vvfvv.JG vvPvvL0vv.&vv1qvv7hG vv1vv.&vv.&vv1qvv7

hevvv1vvvL+vvv$vvv.,hG#vvv9vvvM>vvv:#vvvJ&vvv1vvv.J,h8vvvVvvv.O#vvv:DvvvYvvv.QJ.kvvv_vvv,vvvLJG!QGA

G vv$vv(vvEvvLkvv7,hG$Gvv0bG vv$vv.>vv(vv7,htvv<vvLG vvSvvKhPG vvlvvuvvLjhG/>vv9vv$vv.bvv2,

D9/CU2FG S.P+.G P.FJ,hG fL03+.G $# .a.

v̂v,vvLJtvv"+vvKgG$#vv.Qkvv2G vvcvvVvvLG vvcvv2vv.Ovv2,hGOvv9vvrvvLqJRvv&hf

+vKgG vJh v71vPv2v3G vPv1v.aG vlv.QOv1v7, vuv)1vPv2v3Dvuv%G v$v(vVv.QG vrv.j vv%8vv9vv$vvuvv)tvv$vv.Ovvcvv:,kvv!vv$vv.>vv.AG vv$vv,vvJj^vv,vvLJkvv9vv);vv.FvvLIDvv.#vv!vv7

G vvvPvvv1vvvm, vvvuvvv(qvvv-GOvvv9vvv\vvv.YCf0vvvrvvv$vvvcvvv,vvv.,hCQGOG vvvLRvvv1vvvJCf0vvvfvvv. vvv3+vvvKg

G vv$vv(vv.RY,hqvvJOvvLJkvv2G vv$vv?vv9vv$vvdG)Ovv0#vv2OvvL0vv.fG vv(vv.Qkvv2G vv,vvSvv1vv%

h#vv)evv1vvLDvvLH,kvv#O&vv/E vv1vv-G vvlvvrvv,vv.AhG vv$vvEvvJ;vv1vv),htvv.f vv,vv%kvv2Oh vv9vv-

#vvuvv.fG vvVvvJGQI, vvuvv)1vvrvvJheG vv$vv##vv.fh1vvcvvJCf8vv%q vv-G$#vvLbvv!vv/CGvv1vv-

G$#v1v)(1v$vcv.&v7G vlvLShOv1v.kv,v%,qv.0v:G vcv(v.UvLev1vLG vcvL1v1v7hGRv9vJJ,

htvv.f vv!vvlvv!vvPvvlvv7hG vvcvv!vv.eG vv?vvJ0vvJI#vv)8vv#;vv1vvLbvv!vv/G vv$vv##vv.f.kvvuvv<vvLG vvlvvPvv.O

htvvv<vvvLG vvv$vvvHvvvL1vvv.fkvvv2G vvv$vvv?vvv9vvv$vvvdhtvvv<vvvLJG!QGAG vvvfvvvL0vvv2vvv7bvvv!vvv/G vvvcvvvrvvv"

(1)G $L>d&lP-,36.

115G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 118: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

G)Ovv0#vv2,kvv.Gvv9vv.QqvvPvv%#vv)G vv$vv9vv9vv2vvcvv1vv) vv!vvPvv!vvmG vvVvv. vvFCf0vvcvv1vvTkvv2

hOvvv]8vvv!vvvvG vvv$vvv(vvv.RYevvvL0vvv2vvv.bvvv(vvv,vvv.,#vvvEvvv!qvvvrvvv.kvvv2Ovvv$vvv.AOvvv1vvvLIG vvvPvvv!vvvm

hbvvrvv1vvJ8vv,vv%G vvVvv.kvv1vv70vv9vv9vv2vvcvv.fG vvVvvEvv.1vv7hG vv9vv.1vvcvv1vv)htvv.fC1vvLR+vv%G)#vv.e

CD$J.

Efq

CDvv$vvJ1vv)Dvv(vv2vv"qvv.[vvdG vvK0vv)0vvHvvYvvcvv.fkvv2evv1vvL#vv.C;vvLbvv)

G vPv!vm#vrv.[vcv78v.#qv7,Dv9v/E&qv-#v.tv.f0vPv9v?v1vM v(vlvPv-G vLOqbv!v1v,v%,htv.f

b!/P vE /Cf#.JS.

<9H|9CCQf"&p,<9HGygt+OI:vvvv

vv%0vvcvv2qvvLG)#vv.eCDvv$vvJbvv)G>vv9vv,vv.OgtvvlvvLO,hE&qvv$vv.tvv.f0vvcvv2qvvLbvv)

QCjC+vv"G vvPvv(qvv7>vv$vv1vvcvv.1vvEvvuvv%hDvvJIG vv$vvVvv.OQhG vv$vv(vv,vv@,htvv.f0vvrvv.d:

CUv.dC+v"G vPv(v7bv(vJ&v.G v9v$vPvv1v$v.tv.fbv!v1v-CUvEv.HQOv.dGu�

hG/qvv9vvJGA1vv,vv%,h8vvLcG vv2vvJY,htvv"1vvJbvv7Xvv0 vv7,h8vvLcG vvHvvVvv.#vv.J,

h8vvvvvvLcG vvvvvv?vvvvvv!vvvvvv.S#vvvvvvdCUvvvvvvEvvvvvv.HG$+vvvvvv.GA,h8vvvvvvLcG vvvvvv$vvvvvvLGAhG vvvvvv?vvvvvvJGd

hG vvHvvVvv.#vv.Jkvv2G vvJ0vv),hG vvPvv(qvv7bvv(vvJ&vv.B;vv.QQOvv.dGu�,hG vvPvv(qvv7

8vvlvvPqvvLG vvrvvLBfh+vv2O/Fvv"G vvrvvLBf,h vv1vvQkvv2G vvPvv(qvv7qvv1vv.Sh/8vvYvvLH

vv,vv.G$#vv<vv.d,h/8vvJQc1vv. vvcvvrvv.dh/G$+vv.GA,E&qvv$vv.+vv.G/8vv2vv.Yh8vvLc

G ,.i.

GOvv9vvHvvJeG)#vv.eCDvv$vvJ#vvVvv\vv!vvEvv.J#vv(vv,vv.:zCUvv.dG vvPvv(qvv7bvv(vvJ&vv.yhzG vvPvv(qvv7bvv(vvJ&vv.y,kvvuvv.f0vvcvv2qvvLbvv)#vvK+vv3C+vv"G vvPvv(qvv7hG vv?vv$vv.bvv7,htvv.f

0vvvcvvv2qvvvLbvvv(vvv,vvv.1vvvVvvvLGDvvv7kvvv2qvvv. vvv-:z#vvv)Uvvvlvvv7G vvv$vvv&#vvv)#vvv)C+vvv"G vvvPvvv(qvvv7hG vv?vv$vv.bvv7y,hbvv!vv/P vvvkvv(f

q8vv.>vv-CDvv$vvJ1vv)Dvv(vv2vv"kvv2G vvlvvrvv-hG vvcvvrvv1vvJI

116G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 119: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

+v.#v.bv!v1v-G vVvEv.1v7hG v9v.1vcv.fh8v.1vcv.+v%,h#v)Ov.Qbv!v/&v,v?v,v%G vK0v)8vcv!

qv$v.g#v)tv9v.HGuhOv(qv7&v2v1qv-kv2G vcvrv.FvJhev1vL+v.(1)y.Ef

q&v,v@G)#v.e

CDvvv$vvvJ1vvv)Dvvv(vvv2vvv"kvvv2bvvvrvvv1vvvJ8vvv-h1vvv1vvv.&vvv,vvv. vvv!vvv(vvv.S#vvv(vvv,vvv@G vvvPvvv!vvvmG vvvVvvv. vvvFhG vvv9vvv.1vvvcvvv1vvv)vvvvQXvvv.GfGubvvv!vvv1vvv,vvv%vvvvkvvv9vvvuvvv!vvv%kvvv1vvv$vvv.8vvvuvvv!

qvvv$vvv.G1vvv-,ChC;vvv2vvv9vvv-

G vvLOvv.d�,#vv)evv1vvLR0vv.OICh&vvrvvVvv.f,hG1vv9vvcvvJbvv)G vv?vvJdhG vvlvvLhV

hG v(v_vL0qv.J,htv"#v.GOv9vEvJ;v-G v(v.S1vcvJP vv.htv.f0vrv.dkv2tv"#v.>vv.Akvv2G vvrvvLBfG vvuvvL0vv%hG vvPvv(qvv7G vv(vv2vv.0vv7G vvSvvL0vvlvv7:B#vv(qvv.1vv-tvv"#vv)bvv(vvJQ1v(v.,#v2v9vcvJGbv)G v$v9vSv.1v-G1v9vcv.OGbv)G vlv9v(v7,hG1v9vcv.OGbv)8v#h0v!v-.htv.f

0vrv.dh#v)G vPv(qv7G v0R#v7G v9v2#v)8vLc#v(v,v.GvVv!v7 v%0vrv2v!v,v.h v%0v&#v)

1vvv,vvv., vvv%0vvvuvvv)#vvv)C+vvv!vvv,vvv..G)0vvv$vvv.f1vvv. vvvrvvvJQGvvv1vvvLghRvvvLqg,hG vvv9vvvVvvvJ0vvvs

1vv.$Dvv.O0vv=kvv1vv-,hG)0vv$vv.f1vv,vv.,/0vvrvv.d vv-: vv%?h/tvv1vvm?.E&vv$qvv.+vv.

G)0vv$vv.fhG vv9vvVvvJ0vvs1vv,vv.,h#vv) vv%0vvcvvLa8vvlvvPvv1vvLG vvEvvJ0vv=,h0vv2vv!vvfvv-bvvrvv!vv-kvvrvvJtvvlvv2P vvvhCDvvuvv% vv-kvvcvv!vv1vv-1vv.)0vv$vv.f1vv-hG vv9vvPvv!vv1vv% vv-,#vv<vv"DvvJ0vv=

G vvvVvvv.ObG vvv$vvvVvvvJhbh#vvv.tvvv.f#vvv<vvv!vvv-kvvv2G vvvrvvvJQ,h#vvv<vvv"CDvvv.O0vvv=G vvvLD0vvv7

tvv!qvv,vv.,hEf&vv2vv:bvv)G$Ovv$vv.YhGOvv9vv.DvvT#vv(vv,vv.G vv$vvPvv9vv$vvdkvv(&

qvv$vv.bvv!vv1vv-

G)0vvv$vvv.f1vvv,vvv.,hCf/0vvvLO#vvv(vvv,vvv.DvvvLkvvv.hGDvvvJGhevvv1vvvL+vvv.#vvv)G$Dvvv.O0vvv=

G vv$vv#;vv.QGJbvv)G vv<vvrvv.J,hCf/0vvHvv.Uvv%CDvvJGh/0vv(vv.v̂vL,h/0vv9vvcvv!qvv%

G ?JGd.

hqvJC>v$vd#v)&vrv"bv)G)#v.eCDv$vJ,h1v(v.Abv!v/Cqv.G v-h#v.C;vLbv(v-

C&qvv-:PeqG vvuvv0ehC+vv!vv-,$&

qvv,vv%0vvL>vvcvv.fE vv/G vvcvvrvv"Chq/,h0vv?vvcvv!vv.&vv-Dvvuvv$vv.

(1)C1.0M0JG c?$2,G cr1JIG)O0#17b(JG lr,.AG$Q1c7,324.

117G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 120: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

kvvv2G vvv$vvv(vvv.qvvvSvvv.JhG/Ovvv9vvvJ//J,kvvv(fhGkvvvrvvv,vvv%&vvvrvvv"tvvv.f#vvv&tvvvJG vvv-,hEf

Gvv. vvlvv,vv%Ovv!vvuvv.Gkvv2Ovv2vv1vv"G vv?vv$vvdhG vv9vv#h0vv"1vvJbvv.iCfq

G vvcvvrvv"CUvv" vv!vv(vvrvv",

kvv!vv.qvvJq

eG vv(vvrvv"bvv!vv/G vvcvvrvv"bvv(vvJG vv9vvcvv.QV vv2vv\vv"G vvcvvrvv"hG vv(vvrvv">vv$vv1vvcvv..h/

RvvvCfq

G vvrvv.bvvJIevv1vvLUvvEvv1vvEvv7,hG vvVvvEvv1vvFC&qvv-EPG8vvcvv.QVG vvcvvrvv"hG vv(vvrvv"

h>vv38vvrvvJ0vv%G vv(vvrvv",$fq

G vvcvvrvv"Odqbvv!vv/UvvEqvv7G vv(vvrvv",h>vv.Hqvv2vv.d#vv.

CGv2vL1v-G vLOv.d�,kv!v.C1v\v!v(v.G v(vrv" vuv(qv.qvJC1v\v!v(v.O/ v7G vcvrv"(1). vKG

&vv?vvJbvv(vv.0vv7G)#vv.eCDvv$vvJ1vv)Dvv(vv2vv"1vvJQGOvv7G vvrvvLBfG vvuvvL0vv%hG vvPvv(qvv7G vv(vv2vv.0vv7

G vSvL0vlv7,htv"#v.>v.Abv)G vPv!vmG vVv. vFhG v.qv.abv(vJDvJhOG v(vWOhf

G vvvHvvvLhLbvvv(vvv-E vvv/#vvv.bvvvLa1vvv-bvvvVvvvLg#vvv)tvvv0eh>vvvJdhDvvv.dP vvvv#vvv)

#vv(vv.Rbvv.JhGvvVvv.#vv.J,1vv">vvcvv"&vvVvv.UG vvuvv9vv.HhG vvPvv(qvv7COvv.Ovv. vvcvvrvv1vvJ8vv-

hkvvrvv,vv-#vv)G$Uvv.dhG vvlvvLhY.hG$Ovv.SG vvKj1vv(vv/bvv!vv1vv-bvv(vv.0vv9vv-1vv. vvuvv9vv.H

hG vvPvv(qvv7G vvSvvL0vvlvv7hG vv.qvv.abvv(vvJDvvJhO&vvVvv.Uvv,vv$vv.,Cfq

GuOvv2vvEvv.&vv-h8vvcvv. vv/

Gv.[v2v(v.1v$v.&vlv,v%h1v$v.8vJdbv!v1v-G$ vlv.XhG v9vcv.1v1vLG vcvL1v1v7,0vrv.dOv2vEv.&v-:

{UVWXYZ@w}(2),h0vvvvvvrvvvvvv.d:{@AB

C:192DEFG:193HIJKL:194M

NO:195}(3),hG vLOv.d�tv.fG v$v2v1qv)hG v$v.XvFh+v.G vrv.Fv"�

z8vLtv9vuv%bv!v/1v1vYv.A&v.Uvcv7 v1v!v,v.tv(v,v.Q+v./0vM0vgbv(v,v.E/q

+v. vvy.h vK vv

&vvLiG)#vv.eCDvv$vvJh#vv)qvv2vv!vv-#vv)CFvv$vv7G vvPvv(qvv7 vv%0vv?vvLDhGbvv!vv/#vv.>vvLDbvv!vv1vv-

(1)C1vv21vvuvvLG vvHvv0d,G vvcvvrvv1vvJI vv*#vv.eCDvv$vvJ1vv)Dvv(vv2vv",OQGOvv7h8vvEvvrvv1vvsG vvSvv1vvIbvv2vvJG vvcvvM0vvMG P1LhGf,O#Ss,OGQq9127,W11988e,35vvvv37.

(2)0.Om:2.

(3)G ScLGA:192vvvv195.

118G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 121: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

evv1vvL+vv%,1vv"GOvv9vvPvv!vv$vv.G vv$vv.hQOkvvrvv2vv!vv.gOhf8vv#h0vv"Ch8vv2vvJ0vv"Gvv.kvv.#vv)Gu

8c. /(1).

h&vLiCfq

CUv.dCDv$vJ1v)Dv(v2v"+v2G v(vVv.U,hkv9v.hiG vVvEv.1v7

hG$Uvv"G vv<vv. vv=G/Gvv9vv1vv.Qkvv2kvv9vv.hiG vvVvvEvv.1vv7EPGGGvv9vv!vvlvv.G,hG$Uvv"

G vLG1vd:G v$vLOv"#v)G vEvJ0v=EPG v%0v$vuv)kv2G v2v.HRv2A0vJkvcv-,h+v.

G vvKjQ>vvEvv-bvv!vv/G vvrvv1vv.S,h vv1vvQG vv$vvLGO1vv. vvYvvcvv1vvmbvv(vvJgG vv2vv.[vv"h/

G vv$vv(vvuvvLh/#vv.kvv2QhG0vv9vv-#vv9qvv,vv%,1vvEvv1vv=/0vvPvv.ZG vvK+vv.HE vv1vv-kvv. vvcvv$vv"

1vvv-,1vvv"G vvvEvvvJ0vvv=G vvvYvvvcvvv1vvvmbvvv(vvvJgqvvvPvvv1vvv%G vvvVvvvEvvv1vvvF,hqvvvPvvv%#vvv)CqvvvPvvv.e

G vEvPv),h v%0vuv)0vrvPqv%G vEvJ0v=E v/UvEv1vFhDvPv)hXvcv1vm1v"E v/

UvEv1vFhXvcv1vm,h v!vYvcv1vmbv(vJg#vLG8v3,kv(PG v%0v?vJkv2G v2v.HC;vLG

0vvJkvvcvv-h/qvv.dUvv.Dvv3,h/E>vv$vv.Ybvv!vv/Gvv0kvv-tvv.fG vvcvv$vv"1vv-bvv(vvJg

Ch vvv/#vvv)G vvvrvvv1vvv.Sh vvv1vvvQCDvvvJ#vvv)G$Fvvv$vvv7E/q

h+vvv.#vvv.Gkvvvrvvv-bvvv!vvv/+vvvKG

G$Uvv"#vv)Dvv1vv=G vv?vv$vv!vv7,kvv(&qvv-#vv.#vv(vv,vv%CDvvJE/

qhqvvJqvvJ

qeG vvEvvJ0vv=

G Yc1mb!/G r1.S.C#q.G r1.Sk.O9c$!- !YLhQI(2).

C#qvv.bvv)#vvEvv(vv9vv-kvvlvv2C0qvv.eG vv$vv##vv.fhG vv$vvcvv9vvVvv%;vv%G vv.G;vvs1vvPvv2vv3

G vvvrvvvLBfG vvvcvvv_vvv1vvv%h#vvv.CUvvv.1vvv-1vvv-#vvv)G vvvEvvv2vvvQG vvv\vvv.0vvv"hG vvvYvvvLHG vvvSvvvJ0vvvJ

hG v9v,vJ0vJ1v. vrv9v"1vPv.AG vcvKGH,hqv!qv7#v2v./8v-1v$v.tv.f#v(v,v%kv2P vvE v1v-

hUvvv2vvvLgbvvv!vvv1vvv-h8vvv$vvvPqvvvuvvv-1vvv$vvv.tvvv.fbvvv!vvv1vvv-#vvv)G vvvJ0vvv)G vvvrvvv.0vvv%hG vvvVvvvLGW

(1)C121uLG H0d,G cr1JI *#.eCD$J1)D(2",37.

(2)G1vv)qvv1vv%G vv?vv.R0vv7,Ebvv0eG vv$vv.qvvcvv1vv)bvv)QHG vvcvv. vv$vv1vv),8vvEvvrvv1vvs#vvEvv$vvJ#vvEvv2G vvJ0vv)b2JG E$1J,11LhJ,G $u927G cVL07,W1,1424+vvvv|2003e,1,28vvvv29.

119G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 122: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

G v$vPv9vrv1v%,htv.fCDv$vJbv. v$v.1v$v.hQO1v$v<v"Dv. v-#v)G!0v.JG v$v9v!v.qI,

hG$Gv2v.QG v$v#;v.QI,h1v!qvfv-#v.ChUv/1v-kv2G v$v(v.ehG v1vrv_v7kvLXv2hOv!

qv%

E0vv$vv.&vv.hGDvv9vvPvv.1vv.,hkvv.R1vvHvv1vvLG vvJ&vv1vv.h&vvcvv1vv%G!GvvLI,h+vv1qvv#gGu1vv$vv.B8vv.g

#vv)P vvv vv2vv!vv.ZCbvv!vv/#vv(vv.RdC+vv"G vv2vv0Akvv2Gu#vv)Ch vv1vv.Fvv-,hC vvEvvs1vv-

#vvEvv2vv1vv-kvv1vv$vv.&vv.d#vv)tvvLG#vv7Gu8vvcvv. vv/EfRvv.AGu#vv)evv1vvL1vv!vv1qvv7h1vv.u

G 9.k1shG cV$7.

vrvJGOv9vEv.Pbv!v/G v$v##v.f>v$v.bv7#v)G v$vcv9vM v7kv#Xv!qv.gbv)[vL0vs

G vvvEvvvsqE vvv/G vvv2vvv.[vvv",hR0qvvv(vvv.G vvv-G vvvrvvv.d1vvvHvvv!vvvsG vvvrvvvLBfh&vvvlvvv2G vvvVvvvlvvv.J

bvv)GuN.qvv.dG vv2vv1vv,vvrvv2:h vv%0vvuvv)kvv2G vvHvv!vvlvv.Aqvv2vv!vv-#vv)1vv(vv2C#vv1qvv7

h1vv(vv2G vvcvv2vv.SGvv!vv1vvlvv7E/q

bvv!vv/#vvK+vv3G vvPvv!vvm,kvv!vv$vv.h vv2+vv.G vvHvv0kvv7

G>vvv9vvv$vvvd1vvv-+vvv&/AkvvvEvvv$vvv!vvv.gbvvv!vvv/P vvvvhR0qvvv(vvv.G vvv-,hG8vvvlvvvsGvvvLh>vvv-E vvv/

[vvLOvv.S vvfvvMhG vvLhekvvuvv9vv3E vv/&vv.Fvv2vv-1vv2vvfvvJGOEOvvEvv.b1vv)E1vvLG+vv1vv%1vv)

#vVvcv30v##vLgCf0vJbv.G v(v.SE v/G vrv.d1vHv!vsG vrvLBf,hG8vlvs v-P vv

BGvvLbvv$vvLgqvv2vv"#vv.8vv-1vvSvv,vv.Qkvv2Ovv(vv7;vv$vv.&vv2bvvSvvLIh#vv.Fvv9vv1vv).kvv!vv$vv.hUvv"

G vuv9v.HGOv9vJbv/>v$v.bv7#v)CFv$v7G vEvJ0v=kvJbv.+v%E v/P vvkv.#v9v(vcv.G,

kvv9vv,vvJqO+vv%1vv. vvYvvLHhqvv\vvdG$QRGbkvv#>vv.HCtvv<vvL+vv%#vvuvvL+vv1vv),hGOvv9vv$vvL

bvv!vv/G/#vv9vv(vv.YCDvv$vvJ1vv)Dvv(vv2vv",h#vvEvv$vvJ1vv)&vv.MG vv?vv(vvJ&vv1vvPvv.1vv.Qj,

kvvvEovvv$vvv0bvvv!vvv/1vvvcvvv1vvvLhGDvvvJkvvv!vvv$vvv.tvvv.&vvv.1vvv2vvv0OG vvvLDvvv2vvv7>vvv.A+vvv$vvv.Q>vvv"#vvv)

G$bvLGH#v)bv2v.O+v%0vrv.d v->v.1vL1v)bv.#vL,kvPv!qv%bv!v/G)#v.eCDv$vJ

hqvv.d vv-:0vv.+vvKGE&qvvvhGkvvJG vv(vv.Skvv08vvuvv)Rvv&#vv.bvv!vv1vv,vv%,hE&

qvvvQCS

G vv(vv.SG vv1vv.ekvv(0qvv.cCf8vv?vv1vv2vv,vv%E vv/#vv.0vvJbvv.&vvvE vv1vv-,kvv1vv?vv1vv2vv.Gkvv9vvEvv$vv"

ChRGQ+v%0v.eG vrv1v.#v7,hEftv(v:8vEv3Gukv.Uv2vLbv!v/#v.C&v:kv1v-,kv(fq

120G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 123: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

#vv.1vv1vv(vvvh1vv1vv)G vv?vv(qvv7E/q

Cf8vvrvv9vv",hE&qvvvEf vv%8vvrvv9vv"8vv$vv:hEfbvvSvv:

bvvSvv:Dvv$vv1vvJG.qvv.dCDvv$vvJ:htvv.ftvv0#vv-#vv$vv.qvv.qibvvM#vv2bvv!vv/#vv.C&vv.

bvv!vv1vv-#vv)G/#vv9vv(vv.Y#vv)P vvvG vvKj0vvJbvv.&vv(vv2E vv1vv-.kvv!vv$vv.Gqvv9vvL1vv.#vv)>vv1vvT

G vvHvv!vv1vvlvv7h&vvM vv.GOh&vv-1vv$vvLDvv!vv7>vv.AGvv.Oeh+vv.0vv$vvPvvFO#vv.bvv-1vv\vvLa;vv.1vv-

h0vrv.d:0vcvMqbv!v2q0v.C1v.bv2vJGuEfq

G v$v##v.fqvJOv"qOv1vlv. v%0vPv!qv-qv2v"

P vvv,hE&qvv-0vvrvvPvv%1vvrvvLG1vv9vv-#vv)QOvv.dGu� vv,vv) vv%8vv?vv2vv-E vv/G vvrvv.d

1vHv!vsG vrvLBf vrv9v!vv1vK vvG vPv1vm.qv.dkv?v<v/G)#v.eCDv$vJbv!v/Qtv2v9v1v-

hQ#vvs1vv\vvLkvv-E vv/G vvPvv$vv.Ahqvv.d:Ovv1vvJjevvLqDvv!vv$vvv+vvKGG vvlvv.>vvLDvv9vv/

8v?vLqCbv!v/Ch v1v.Fvv1v. vYvLHhG vrv9v",G v!6v,v%kv(f0vuv)G vrvLBftv0#vvev1vL

#vHv!v.bkv.tvlv(v.#v&&v9v-.qv.d:kv?v.A+v%G vVvL0vI1v$v.JG v$v##v.fkv2G v<v!v=

G$Gv1vL#v)G v!v1v".qv.dCDv$vJ:kvlvLDv(v.,;v%>v.AG vHv2vL1v#fq

G v$vcv9vVv%qvJ

h vv2G vvHvv0kvv7hqvvJG&vvYvv%E vv1vv-CDvv$vvJ1vv)C1vv2ODGO,hCfG$#vvLRvvJ0vvJ,

kvvvLOh&vvv.E vvv/1vvvfvvvJGOkvvv2Ovvvlvvv1vvv(vvv7#vvvd1vvvcvvvZG$Ovvv.Qi,h&vvv. vvv(vvv2#vvv(vvv,vvv%CPi

tv<v1vL,htv.fkv2Q>v!v1v-G vrv1v.O,h#v.JUv.Dv2v-#vEv$vJ1v)&v.Mkv2G v\vL0vs

hUvv!qvv/bvv!vv1vv-CDvv$vvJ,kvv!vv$qvv.Q>vvdCDvv$vvJE vv/1vvfvvJGOOGvv!vv,vv.kvv2Q#vvYvv.f,

kvv#hOYG vvPvv?vv)&vvEvv.G#vv);vv$vv.&vv1vv7hbvvSvvL0vv)Rvv,vvLG,hqvv1vv"&vv1qvvlvv.h;vv0;vv1vv)

Rv,vLG,;v%CGvLLE v/G vYvLH1v1v)0vJjG v$vcv9vVv%(1).h1vK vv^v!qv:+vKg

G vrvYv1qv7kv2#v?v.dG v2vEv=hG v(v_vL,hkv2OGFvLIG)>v9v,v.Okv2qvYv1qv7bvrvJ0qv7

Dvv9vv/COGvv!vv,vv.G vv$vvcvv9vvM vv7[vv.QGBGvvL,C/h+vv.kvvLV+vvKgG vvcvvrvv1vvJIbvv!vv/

G vv(qvv.S1vv. vvrvv.IhEQevv.eG vvcvv!vv$vv.Abvv!vv/G vvrvv.d1vv,vv.,kvvuvv.f#vv.tvv.f#vv)C#vvL

(1)G1)t<1L,C12G lJGA,G 2JG07hG (,.07,G $?!JG H.#Q,10,U345.

121G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 124: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

G vvv$vvvEvvv(vvv7R#vvv)G vvv$vvv##vvv.fhG vvv$vvvcvvv9vvvVvvv%hG vvv.G;vvvs,h vvv%8vvvLkvvvdE/kvvv2bvvv,vvvJ

G $9.tq"(1).

Gvv\vv#G vv$vvcvv9vvM vv7G vvrvv.8vv"tvv.fGXvv\vv,vv.O+vv%bvv!vv$vv.AG$#qvv7, vvrvvJ+vvJ#vv.G

1vv#0vvJ0vv,vv%kvv21vvYvvdOvv(vv1vv)#vv.1vv(vv.gkvv2qvvLf#vv)G vvM#vv.f,h8vv.OrvvdG vvVvvJY

1vv1vv(vv,vv%h1vv1vv)C+vv"G vvPvv(qvv7E vv/OQ>vv7GOvv9vvEvv.d1vvcvvJ+vv.>vv2vvLg,htvv.&vv:#vvEvv(vv7

G)#vv.eCDvv$vvJ1vv)Dvv(vv2vv"#vvdG vv$vvcvv9vvM vv2CDvv$vvJ1vv)C1vv2ODGODvv1vv=Dvv.hd

h1vvvrvvv.qIG vvvJh vvv7E>vvv2vvv.Qgbvvv!vvv/G vvvrvvv.d1vvvHvvv!vvvsG vvvrvvvLBf.h1vvvVvvvLaG vvv(vvv_vvvLbvvv)

8vlv.Uv1v"G v$vEv(v7h#v.8v(v\v.jbv!v1v-#v)EXvLGQG v$vcv9vM v7kv2GOqbv.Fv,v%C&v,v%

Qbv.IG vEvL0qv71v$vEv.h v9v,v%GOv9vHvJGeG vrv.qI v9vfv1v1vLbvrv.FvJG v(v.S,kvrvJG#v9vEv)

#vdG)#v.eCDv$vJ1v)Dv(v2v"G vuv<v1vL#v)G vcv!v$v.A,Xvcvm1vcvYv,v%kv#>v.H,

h v%0vVv2vLE/q

CQ1vcv7+v%:CDv$vJ1v)Dv(v2v",hCDv$vJ1v)&vVvL,h#vEv$vJ1v)

&vv.M,h&vvcvv1vv%1vv)Dvv$qvv.O,hG&vvrvvSvvcvv:G vvfvv$qvv7h1vvrvv2G vvEvvsqG vvKjOGkvvdbvv(vv-

hq.d1-G)#.eCD$Jhq2!-h1cJgt<1Lhf#)b!$.AC+"G P(q7(2).

q q q q q q

(1)G $L>d&lP-,10,U351.

(2)G c?$2,C1.0M0J,G cr1JIG)O0#1q7b(JG lr,.AG$Q1c7,OGQG P0e,U331.

122G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167

Page 125: المنهج في إثبات الأمور الغيبية (PDF) · )1(7vv M9vvcvvvv$vv G 7vv qL vvk Q.vv,^vv )1vvDvv %vv!vvcvv G G Kvv+ Lvv,vv ^ J vvq h :e 0vvuvv G %vv!bvv vvvv 2

p%QSGy}(\(f9J

G $.X.YG VlE7

G cr1JI f7k

hGU\0D.k

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .5

#JG"E /1.HG cr1JI. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .5

#c(/G cr1JI f7k

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .7

#V\!FG cr1JI. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .8

CQt.fG cr1JIG)O0#17. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .15

#(.WG Eu%k2G/b9$.Ob!/G$O q7G (r!17k2E;2.JG$#.QG f1217. . . . .26

G)0$.f1. f13. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .26

G H1.dhDJhOg. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .36

G cr"hDJhOg. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .37

G E.GShDJhO+.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .38

G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f1217. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .41

Cq.GdG$F$7k2G cr1JIG 92+2br1JIC+"G P(7hG ?$.b7. . . . . . . . . . .56

Cq.GdG$F$7G$Q1c7k2E;2.JG$#.QG f1217. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .69

G)#.eC12D(1l7. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .71

G)#.e#. v1)C&Q. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .85

G)#.e#E$J1)EOQ0QG S.kc2. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .97

G)#.eCD$J1)D(2". . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .109

q q q q q q

123G $(,@k2E;2.JG$#.QG f12167