Tumores Solitarios Pulmonares Inusuales

download Tumores Solitarios Pulmonares Inusuales

of 8

Transcript of Tumores Solitarios Pulmonares Inusuales

  • 7/27/2019 Tumores Solitarios Pulmonares Inusuales

    1/8

    Rare Solitary Benign Tumors of the LungJames S. Allan

    Benign solitary neoplasms of the lung are relatively uncommon but nonetheless must be considered in

    the differential diagnosis of any solitary pulmonary lesion. Ironically, the advent of improved tomo-graphic imaging and its increasingly broad clinical application have led to a greater recognition of

    benign solitary pulmonary lesions, presenting the surgeon with a complex management dilemma.

    Most benign lesions are relatively bland radiographically, making their differentiation from carcinoma

    difficult. Often, diagnostic certainty can only be achieved with complete resection. Fortunately, ad-

    vances in minimally invasive thoracic surgery make this prospect less daunting for the patient and

    surgeon. This article reviews a subset of solitary lesions categorized as rare benign neoplasms from

    histologic, radiographic, and clinical points of view.

    2003 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.

    Key words: Lung, neoplasm, tumor, benign, solitary.

    The seemingly straightforward presentationof a patient with a small, asymptomatic sol-itary lung nodule raises one of the more difficult

    clinical situations that a thoracic surgeon is likely

    to encounter. In this scenario, it is incumbent

    upon the surgeon not only to exclude malignancy

    with a high degree of certainty but also to do so

    with a minimum of intervention. Moreover, most

    patients facing this situation expect a surgeon to

    provide them with a clear diagnosis, but few are

    prepared at the outset to undergo a potentially

    morbid operation simply to rule out a malig-nancy. This conundrum is further intensified

    when the lesion is radiographically bland, when

    the patient has a slightly increased risk for lung

    cancer, and when comorbidities are present that

    would make operative intervention less desirable.

    This article reviews a group of rare pulmonary

    neoplasms that typically present as solitary le-

    sions. For the most part, these lesions are asymp-

    tomatic and radiographically indistinct from

    many common neoplasms. Because of these

    traits, the majority of these diagnoses are only

    obtained after excisional biopsy, which is typicallycurative. Notably excluded from this review are

    the more common benign pulmonary lesions, in-cluding hamartomas, benign fibrous tumors ofthe pleura, granulomas, and other inflammatorynodules, all of which are considered elsewhere.

    Historical Notes

    The first major series addressing the issue of theasymptomatic solitary pulmonary nodule waspublished in 1963 by Steele.1 Steele compiledhistologic data from 882 male patients who un-

    derwent pulmonary resection. In this study, hefound that 36% of the resected lesions were ma-lignant, while 64% were benign. Granulomas rep-

    resented the overwhelming majority of the be-nign lesions. The relatively high incidence ofbenign granulomas (often tuberculous in etiol-ogy) in this series is both a reflection of thepatient population and the era in which the study

    was conducted. Also, this study was performedbefore the advent of computerized tomography(CT), and therefore, it only included asymptom-atic lesions that were large enough to be seen on

    plain chest radiography. If Steeles data set is

    limited just to true benign solitary neoplasms ofthe lung and tracheobronchial tree (excludingbenign fibrous tumors of the pleura), these be-nign neoplasms constitute approximately 10% ofthe resected neoplasms. Moreover, 94% of theseneoplasms were found within the lung paren-chyma, with only 6% occurring endobronchially.

    In a later series from the Mayo Clinic, Arri-

    goni and colleagues described the relative fre-quencies of some of the more common, benign

    From the Division of Thoracic Surgery, Department of Surgery,

    Massachusetts General Hospital, and the Harvard Medical School,

    Boston, MA.

    Address reprint requests to James S. Allan, MD, Massachusetts

    General Hospital, Blake 1570, 55 Fruit Street Boston, MA 02114.

    2003 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.

    1043-0679/03/1503-$30.00/0

    doi:10.1016/S1043-0679(03)

    315Seminars in Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery, Vol 15, No 3 ( July), 2003: pp 315-322

  • 7/27/2019 Tumores Solitarios Pulmonares Inusuales

    2/8

    lung neoplasms.2 These data are described inTable 1. As seen, the pulmonary hamartoma isthe most commonly encountered benign solitarypulmonary neoplasm, accounting for over three-fourths of the benign neoplasms resected. Thenext most common neoplasm reported by Arri-goni et al is the benign mesothelioma, which isnow more commonly called a benign fibrous tu-mor of the pleura.2 Once these 2 lesions areexcluded, only a handful of rare tumors remain.

    Although there is no recent autopsy series or casestudy that adequately addresses this issue, it islikely that the apparent prevalence of rare benigntumors will grow as the use of high-resolution CTincreases.

    Classification of Benign Lung Tumors

    Liebow made the first attempt at classification ofbenign lung tumors at Yale University,3 and amodification of Liebows original nosology wasadopted by the World Health Organization (Ta-ble 2). This classification schema was based pri-marily on the presumed cell of origin of the neo-plasm and has evolved to take advantage of ourbetter understanding of cell ultrastructure withthe use of electron microscopy. Also, over the

    years, several neoplasms originally thought to be

    benign are now properly recognized as low-grademalignancies and have been reclassified (eg,

    bronchial adenomas, pulmonary blastoma, tumor-lets, hemangiopericytomas, and mucosa-associatedlymphoid tumors).

    Benign Solitary Neoplasms of EpithelialOrigin

    Papillomas of the Tracheobronchial Tree

    Papillomas of the tracheobronchial tree are be-

    nign neoplasms of the squamous epithelium.

    They have been subclassified as (1) solitary be-nign papillomas; (2) multiple benign papillomas;(3) benign combined bronchial mucous gland andsurface papillary tumors; and (4) bronchial pap-illomas. In addition, there is a fifth variant, which

    is in fact malignant, known as the papillary bron-chial carcinoma in situ. This subsection will beconfined primarily to the solitary benign papil-loma.

    Most commonly, solitary papillomas are seenin the proximal airway. In the pediatric popula-tion, these lesions often present in the larynx,

    while in the adult population, these lesions typi-cally originate in the upper trachea. Only ahandful of cases have been seen distal to the

    carina, and these bronchial papillomas have ahigh association with subsequent bronchial carci-noma.4 Also, the solitary papilloma appears to bemore common in the adult male population,

    while children tend to present with multiple pap-illomatous lesions.5

    Histologically, the more proximal benign pap-illomas tend to be pedunculated with a thin cen-tral fibrovascular core covered by a stratified

    squamous epithelium. The more distal lesions

    Table 2. Classification of Benign Lung Tumors

    Epithelial neoplasms

    PapillomasBenign inflammatory polyps

    Mesodermal NeoplasmsVascular

    HemangiomasLymphangiomas

    BronchialFibromasChondromasLipomasGranular cell tumorsSclerosing hemangiomasLeiomyomas

    Neurogenic tumorsNeuromas

    NeurofibromasNeurilemomas

    Primary pulmonary meningiomasTumors of developmental or unknown origin

    TeratomasChemodectomasClear cell tumorsIntrapulmonary thymomas

    Inflammatory lesions and pseudotumorsInflammatory pseudotumorsNodular amyloid

    Table 1. Relative Frequencies of Benign LungNeoplasms2

    Hamartoma 100Benign fibrous mesothelioma 16Inflammatory pseudotumor 7Lipoma 2Leiomyoma 2Hemangioma 1

    Adenoma 1Mixed tumor 1Total 130

    316 James S. Allan

  • 7/27/2019 Tumores Solitarios Pulmonares Inusuales

    3/8

    are typically lined with a mixed epithelium, in-cluding glandular elements. It is believed thatsolitary benign papillomas result from a viralinfection with human papilloma virus types 6 and116 and that there is a small potential for malig-

    nant degeneration.The most common presenting symptom of a

    patient with a solitary papilloma is cough. Inaddition, patients may present with hemoptysis,

    wheezing, or recurrent pneumonia. Unless bron-chial obstruction has occurred, the chest radio-graph is typically normal. Lesions may be identi-fied on CT or plain-film tomography of thetrachea.

    The diagnosis is readily made on bronchos-

    copy. Likewise, treatment typically consists ofbronchoscopic resection using either conven-tional rigid bronchoscopic techniques or laser ab-lation. On a rare occasion, pulmonary resectionmay be necessary for a distal papilloma.

    Benign Inflammatory Polyps

    Benign inflammatory polyps (sometimes termedfibrous polyps) of the tracheobronchial tree arerelatively uncommon and are difficult to differ-entiate from papillomas. Like tracheobronchialpapillomas, benign inflammatory polyps have apredilection for the upper respiratory tract. How-ever, they tend to be covered by an epitheliumthat shows columnar differentiation as well asgranulation tissue. Like solitary papillomas,

    these polyps tend to present with a history ofchronic cough and occasional hemoptysis. Signsand symptoms of distal airway obstruction arequite rare. Again, bronchoscopic removal is gen-erally successful.7

    Benign Solitary Neoplasms ofMesodermal Origin

    Hemangiomas

    The pulmonary hemangioma is a benign vasculartumor that can be found throughout the respira-tory tract. Most commonly, this lesion is seen inthe wall of the trachea or a mainstem bronchus.However, it can also be found in the pulmonaryparenchyma, usually in a subpleural location. Ap-proximately two-thirds of pulmonary hemangio-mas are solitary. When multiple lesions are

    present, one must suspect the generalized disor-

    der of hereditary telangiectasia (Osler-Weber-Rendu disease).

    The pulmonary hemangioma is a true neo-plasm consisting of a cluster of thin-walled ves-sels with little supporting stroma. The term cav-

    ernous hemangioma is sometimes used to referto a hemangioma that has a cystic central com-ponent, often filled with a serosanguineous fluid.The term sclerosing hemangioma is a misno-mer and will be considered later in this article.

    When found in the central airway, the heman-gioma is readily identified on bronchoscopy and isseldom obstructing. Some investigators have rec-ommended Nd:YAG laser ablation due to its pro-pensity to bleed with classic bronchoscopic resec-

    tion techniques.8 Hemangiomas are also knownto regress with focal radiation therapy, if surgicalablation is not practical.

    When located in the pulmonary parenchyma,the solitary hemangioma tends to be a sharplycircumscribed rounded lesion with strong con-trast enhancement on CT. This result gives thehemangioma a radiographic appearance that isquite similar to that of some contrast-enhancing

    malignant lesions, such as carcinoid. A conserva-tive wedge resection is the preferred treatment ofparenchymal hemangioma.

    An important distinction must be made be-tween the true hemangioma and arteriovenousmalformations (AVM). AVM are not true neo-

    plasms but rather are congenital vascular anom-alies.9 Pulmonary AVM are generally asymptom-atic solitary nodules typically found in the lower

    lobes. Contrast-enhanced CT will typically showa vessel providing arterial inflow and another

    vessel providing venous drainage. Because thevascular inflow is typically derived from the pul-monary circulation, a large, pulmonary AVM maybe associated with significant right-to-left shunt-ing, creating clinical signs such as cyanosis, club-bing, and polycythemia.9 Like true hemangiomas,there is an association between multiple pulmo-

    nary AVM and hereditary telangiectasia.

    Lymphangiomas

    The lymphangioma is a relatively uncommon tho-racic neoplasm that typically presents in the me-diastinum or in the trachea of an infant orchild.9,10 Only rarely does a lymphangiomapresent as a solitary pulmonary nodule. Contro-

    versy exists in the literature regarding the demo-

    317Rare Solitary Benign Tumors of the Lung

  • 7/27/2019 Tumores Solitarios Pulmonares Inusuales

    4/8

    graphics of the patient population that can be

    affected by this lesion. Shafer et al have reportedthe presence of thoracic lymphangiomas in pa-

    tients ranging in age from 6 months to 67 years,

    with a slight female predominance.11 In contrast,

    Wilson and colleagues have found a strong malepredominance when only parenchymal lesions

    were surveyed.12

    Histologically, the lymphangioma is a benigncollection of proliferative, intercommunicating

    lymphatic vessels that lack systemic lymphatic

    communication. Cystic and cavernous featurescan sometimes be seen. It is most commonly

    found in the neck, where it referred to as a cystic

    hygroma. This benign lesion appears to be con-

    genitally acquired and is hypothesized to repre-sent the simplest extreme of a spectrum of

    lymphatic disorders that share a common patho-genesis, including lymphangiomatosis, lypmhan-giectasis, and the syndrome of lymphangiomyo-

    matosis.

    Although tracheal lesions in the pediatric pop-ulation can result in pneumothorax and respira-

    tory distress, the solitary parenchymal nodule is

    generally asymptomatic, although hemoptysishas been reported.13 Radiographically, these le-

    sions typically appear as a smooth cystic mass,

    although spiculation has been described occa-sionally.12 Wedge resection of solitary pulmonary

    lesions appears to be curative.

    Fibromas

    Pulmonary fibromas are benign lesions arising atany level from the walls of the tracheobronchial

    tree. Fibromas typically account for less than 1/10

    of 1% of all resected pulmonary tumors. How-ever, despite its rarity, the benign fibroma is the

    most common of the mesenchymal benign tu-

    mors.14 Histologically, these lesions are made ofbenign-appearing spindle cells with an abun-

    dance of collagen. Occasionally, these lesionsmay have a more myxomatous appearance.

    Peripheral fibromas are typically asymptom-

    atic, while those occurring in the more proximalbronchi can present with symptoms of respiratory

    tract obstruction.15 Because these tumors are rel-

    atively avascular, airway lesions are easily treatedwith bronchoscopic resection, and peripheral le-

    sions can be excised with parenchymal-sparing

    techniques.

    Chondromas

    Chondromas (and the related osteochondromas)are the second most common benign pulmonarytumors of mesenchymal origin.14 They are typi-cally found in association with the cartilaginous

    wall of a large bronchus. Histologically, they aredistinct from endobronchial hamartomas in thatthey lack the other tissue elements that are typ-ically found in a hamartoma. These lesions aregenerally asymptomatic unless they become ob-structing. The treatment of these lesions is sim-ilar to that described for benign fibromas.

    Lipomas

    The lipoma is perhaps the rarest of the benignlung neoplasms, and most thoracic surgeons willnever encounter this lesion. However, the pulmo-nary lipoma was ironically one of the first lunglesions ever reported in the medical literature byRokitansky in 1854.16 These lesions typically oc-cur in middle-aged males and are slow growing.They arise endobronchially and can either be in a

    central or peripheral location. Treatment is gen-erally accomplished by either endoscopic resec-tion or parenchymal wedge resection, as appro-priate.17,18

    Granular Cell Tumors

    Granular cell tumors (granular cell myoblasto-mas) are benign neoplasms composed of large

    ovoid or polygonal cells that take up periodicacid-Schiff stain. Originally thought to be derivedfrom skeletal muscle tissue, they are now be-lieved to be of Schwann cell origin. Deavers andcolleagues reviewed a series of 20 patients, rang-ing in age from 20 to 57 years, with granular celltumors.19 There was no sex predilection for thistumor. Also, in approximately half the cases, thetumors were asymptomatic and incidentally dis-

    covered. Most of these lesions were solitary andwere typically found adjacent to a large bronchus.

    A parenchymal sparing pulmonary resection isthe treatment of choice. However, the surgeonmust be attentive to achieving complete resec-tion because the recurrence rate for this lesion ishigh in the absence of complete excision.20

    Sclerosing Hemangioma

    As mentioned previously, the sclerosing heman-

    gioma is a bit of a misnomer. This lesion was first

    318 James S. Allan

  • 7/27/2019 Tumores Solitarios Pulmonares Inusuales

    5/8

    reported by Liebow and Hubbell in 1974 and hasbeen the subject of some controversy in the fieldof pulmonary pathology.21 In particular, some pa-thologists, on the basis of immunohistochemicalstudies, have asserted that the sclerosing heman-

    gioma may occur from the type 2 alveolar pneu-mocyte rather than a vascular mesenchymalcell.22,23

    Sclerosing hemangiomas typically present aswell-defined rounded masses arising in the pe-riphery of the lung. They most commonly occurin the lower lung fields of middle-aged women.Occasionally, partial calcification may be seen. Ina recent series, this neoplasm was identified inapproximately 1% of 919 patients who underwent

    pulmonary resection over a 17-year period, mak-ing this lesion second in prevalence to pulmonaryhamartomas.22 Sclerosing hemangiomas are eas-ily shelled-out at operation, and there have beenno reports of recurrence following parenchymal-sparing resection of this lesion.

    Leiomyomas

    Leiomyomas are an uncommon benign tumor ofmesodermal origin, although the exact incidenceis difficult to determine. Originally, leiomyomas

    were thought to be the fourth most commonbenign mesodermal tumor of the lung.14 How-

    ever, more recent series suggest that this lesion

    may be more common.24

    The majority of theselesions present as incidentally found, asymptom-atic peripheral solitary pulmonary nodules. Ap-proximately two-thirds of patients who are af-fected are female.25

    It is hypothesized that pulmonary leiomyomasoriginate from the smooth muscle present ineither the bronchial walls or the bronchial arter-

    ies. The histologic appearance is quite similar toleiomyoma found elsewhere in the body. The sol-itary leiomyoma of the lung should not be con-fused with a clinically distinct entity known asbenign metastasizing leiomyomas, which some

    believe to be of uterine origin, traveling to thelung via a hematogenous route. Because mostsolitary leiomyomas are asymptomatic, parenchy-mal-sparing wedge resection is usually sufficient

    therapy.

    Neurogenic Tumors

    Neurogenic tumors occur with high frequency in

    the posterior mediastinum. However, they are

    quite uncommon in the parenchyma of the lungitself.26 The thoracic literature contains scantreports of benign neurogenic tumors occurringcentrally and peripherally within the tracheo-bronchial tree. These tumors have included

    neuromas, neurofibromas, and neurilemomas(schwannomas). Like most other benign tumorsof the lung, symptomology depends on the loca-tion of the lesion. Therapy is either conservativeparenchymal resection or endoscopic removal/ablation, as appropriate.27,28

    Primary Pulmonary Meningiomas

    Meningiomas presenting in the pulmonary pa-renchyma are often metastatic from an intra-cranial source. Nonetheless, there have beenscattered reports of primary pulmonary meningi-omas, which typically present in older women.These lesions are usually well-circumscribed nod-ules and have been reported to be as large as 6cm. The treatment of pulmonary meningiomasconsists of conservative surgical excision, and

    the prognosis is excellent.29,30 Nonetheless, thefinding of a meningioma in the lung mandatescareful evaluation to exclude an intracraniallesion.31

    Tumors of Unknown or Developmental

    OriginTeratomas

    Teratomas are common anterior mediastinalmasses. However, they occur only rarely as aprimary lung lesion. It is difficult to determine

    the exact frequency of pulmonary teratoma be-cause many investigators may have erroneouslyreported mediastinal teratomas extending intothe lung as primary pulmonary lesions.32 Terato-mas have the characteristic histologic feature ofcontaining tissue derived from all 3 germ celllayers. Calcification and sebaceous matter are

    not uncommonly identified in these tumors. Themajority of pulmonary teratomas have been

    found in the anterior segment of the leftupper lobe, and resection has proven to becurative.

    Chemodectoma

    Tanimura and colleagues have reported a total of

    24 cases of primary pulmonary paraganglioma

    319Rare Solitary Benign Tumors of the Lung

  • 7/27/2019 Tumores Solitarios Pulmonares Inusuales

    6/8

    (chemodectoma) extant in the literature.33 For

    the most part, these lesions tend to be solitary

    and can grow to be quite large.34 When small,

    these neoplasms are typically asymptomatic.

    However, compressive symptoms can develop in

    patients as these tumors grow. Again, conserva-tive pulmonary resection is considered curative.

    One should also recognize that the solitary che-

    modectoma is distinct from a related pathologic

    condition of multiple small tumors, known as

    minute chemodectoma tumors, described by

    Torikata and Mukai.35

    Clear Cell Tumors of the Lung

    A total of approximately 35 clear cell tumors of

    the lung have been reported in the world litera-

    ture.36-38 Most of these patients were in their fifth

    or sixth decades of life and presented with asymp-

    tomatic, peripheral solitary pulmonary nodules.

    There was no sex predilection among these pa-

    tients, and these tumors were reported to shell-

    out easily from the surrounding parenchyma.

    There is a single report of the malignant degen-

    eration of a clear cell tumor in a patient who

    ultimately died of metastatic disease.39 Histolog-

    ically, the clear cell neoplasm consists of cells

    with abundant cytoplasmic glycogen with inter-

    spersed neurosecretory granules, suggesting that

    this unusual tumor may originate from Kul-chitsky cells. This tumor has also been given the

    eponym sugar tumor of the lung.

    Intrapulmonary Thymomas

    Thymomas are common tumors of the anterior

    mediastinum. However, ectopic thymic rests exist

    in both the lung hila and the peripheral paren-

    chyma.40 Occasionally, these ectopic thymic rests

    will become thymomatous. The optimal treatment

    for these rare intrapulmonary thymomas has notbeen defined. However, a recent histopathological

    examination of one such case suggests that these

    lesions can spread through the normal lymphatic

    drainage of the lung. Therefore, treatment strate-

    gies analogous to that of lung cancer, including

    formal lobectomy and lymph node dissection,

    have been advocated.41 These tumors are also

    known to be radiation-sensitive if surgical resec-

    tion is not possible.

    Inflammatory Lesions andPseudotumors

    Inflammatory Pseudotumors

    The term inflammatory pseudotumor includes a

    fairly wide histologic spectrum of diseases thathave been variably termed plasma cell granu-loma, histiocytoma, xanthoma, xanthofibroma,xanthogranuloma, and mast cell granuloma. Var-

    ious attempts have been made to subclassifythese pseudotumors based on their histology.However, the rarity of these lesions makes thiseffort difficult.42,43 In general, these benign tu-mors are composed of a mixture of plasma cells,lymphocytes, and varying quantities of fibroustissue. They are typically found as solitary pul-monary nodules presenting in children younger

    than 16 years of age. There is a slight femalepredominance.44 Although corticosteroids45 andradiation therapy46 have been used to treat thoselesions that could not be completely resected,conservative surgical excision is generally suf-ficient therapy. The pseudolymphoma is notconsidered here because it is now generally re-garded as a low-grade, mucosa-associated lym-phoid tumor.

    Nodular Amyloid

    Primary amyloidosis of the lung can present as alocalized solitary parenchymal lesion or as asessile endobronchial tumor near the orifices ofsegmental bronchi.1 These parenchymal tumorsare commonly identified at thoracotomy for asuspected malignancy, and treatment with con-servative surgical resection is generally adequate.The endobronchial lesion can be addressed byendoscopic resection or laser ablation.

    Conclusions

    In the United States, approximately 150,000 newsolitary pulmonary nodules (defined as lesionsless than 3 cm in diameter) are identified each

    year.47,48 The incidence of malignancy amongthese nodules is quite variable, ranging from 10%to 70% in published series.49-55 Therefore, it isimportant for the surgeon to be thoroughly fa-miliar with the differential diagnosis of the soli-tary pulmonary nodule and to develop strategies

    for diagnosis that do not rely on excisional biopsy.

    320 James S. Allan

  • 7/27/2019 Tumores Solitarios Pulmonares Inusuales

    7/8

    The rare benign tumors described here collec-tively account for less than 1% of all solitarypulmonary nodules, with hamartomas, granulo-mas, and other inflammatory lesions comprisingthe remainder of the benign lesions. Hamarto-mas and granulomas often have characteristicradiographic features, particularly regarding spe-cific patterns of calcification or fat inclusion.56

    These specific findings may correctly prompt the

    surgeon to pursue a nonoperative approach in themanagement of these lesions. Unfortunately, theless common benign lung neoplasms reviewedhere all tend to be radiographically bland and

    will most likely be identified in the course ofa resection undertaken to rule out malignant

    disease.Fluorodeoxyglucose-positron emission tomog-

    raphy (FDG-PET) is the one current modality

    that holds the promise of limiting the need forsurgical excision of solitary nodules of unknowncharacter. Presently, FDG-PET is extremely sen-sitive and has a strong negative predictive value

    when applied to nodules more than 1 cm in di-ameter. The utility of PET in determining a careplan is greatest when the PET data are incorpo-rated into a Bayesian risk analysis model thatassesses the risk of malignant disease for a given

    patient. Table 3 lists a series of likelihood ratiosfor malignancy derived from one particular caseseries, considering a variety of clinical and radio-graphic characteristics, including PET avidity.57

    Although Bayesian analysis is imperfect in itsapplication (largely because most risk factors arenot statistically independent), this approach be-gins to quantify and standardize the risk-benefitanalyses that clinicians have performed subjec-

    tively for many years.

    References

    1. Steele JD: The solitary pulmonary nodule: Report of a co-

    operative study of resected asymptomatic solitary pulmo-nary nodules in males. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 46:21, 1963

    2. Arrigoni MG, Woolner LB, Bernatz PE, et al: Benign

    tumors of the lung: Ten-year surgical experience. J Tho-

    rac Cardiovasc Surg 60:589-599, 1970

    3. Liebow AA: Tumors of the lower respiratory tract, in:

    Atlas of Tumor Pathology, Washington, DC, Armed

    Forces Institute of Pathology, 1952, pp 1-189

    4. Singer DB, Greenberg SD, Harrison GM: Papillomatosis

    of the lung. Am Rev Resp Dis 94:777, 1966

    5. Kaital RK, Ranlett R, Whitlock WL: Human papilloma

    virus associated with solitary squamous papilloma com-

    plicated by bronchectasis and bronchial stenosis. Chest

    106:1887-1889, 1994

    6. Popper HH, el-Shabrawi Y, Wockel W, et al: Prognostic

    importance of human papilloma virus typing in squamouscell papilloma of the bronchus: Comparison of in situ

    hybridization and the polymerase chain reaction. Hum

    Pathol 25:1191-1197, 1994

    7. Dail DH, Hammer SP: Pulmonary Pathology. New York,

    NY, Springer-Verlag, 1988

    8. Miller JI Jr: Benign tumors of the lower respiratory tract,

    in Baue AE, Geha AS, Hammond GL, Laks H, Naunheim

    KS (eds): Glenns Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery,

    vol 1 (ed 6). Stamford, CT, Appleton & Lange, 1996, pp

    345-356

    9. Spencer H: Pathology of the Lung (ed 4). Philadelphia,

    PA, Saunders, 1985

    10. Oshikiri T, Morikawa T, Jinushi E, et al: Five cases of the

    lymphangioma of the mediastinum in adult. Ann Thorac

    Cardiovasc Surg 792:103-105, 2001

    11. Shafer K, Rosado-de-Christenson ML, Patz EF, et al:

    Thoracic lymphangioma in adults: CT and MR imaging

    features. Am J Roentgenol 162:283-289, 1994

    12. Wilson C, Askin FB, Heitmiller RF: Solitary pulmonary

    lymphangioma. Ann Thorac Surg 71:1337-1338, 2001

    13. Holden WE, Morris JF, Antonovic R, et al: Adult intrapul-

    monary and mediastinal lyphangioma causing hemopty-

    sis. Thorax 42:635-636, 1987

    14. Baum GL: Textbook of Pulmonary Disease (ed 2). Boston,

    MA, Little Brown, 1974

    Table 3. Malignancy Likelihood Ratios for Various Clinical and Radiographic Characteristics57

    Characteristic Likelihood Ratio Characteristic Likelihood Ratio

    Age 60-69 yrs. 2.64 Lobulated mass 0.74Nonsmoker 0.15 Spiculated mass 5.5430 Pack/yr. 0.74 Malignant growth rate 3.40

    30-39 Pack/yr. 2.00 Not calcified 2.2040 Pack/yr. 3.70 Benign calcification 0.01Hemoptysis 5.08 CT enhancement 15 HU 0.04Previous malignancy 4.95 CT enhancement 15 HU 2.320-1.0 cm 0.52 PET SUR* 2.5 0.061.1-2.0 cm 0.74 PET SUR 2.5 7.102.1-3.0 cm 3.67 PET-positive 4.303.0 cm 5.23 PET-negative 0.04

    Abbreviations: SUR, standardized uptake ratio.

    321Rare Solitary Benign Tumors of the Lung

  • 7/27/2019 Tumores Solitarios Pulmonares Inusuales

    8/8

    15. Corona FE, Okeson GC: Endobronchial fibroma: An un-

    usual cause of segmental atelectasis. Am Rev Respir Dis

    110:350-353, 1974

    16. Watts CF, Clagett PT, McDonald JR: Lipoma of the

    bronchus: Discussion of benign neoplasms and report of a

    case of endobronchial lipoma. J Thorac Surg 15:32, 1946

    17. Sekine I, Kodama T, Yokose T, et al: Rare pulmonarytumors: A review of 32 cases. Oncology 55:431-434, 1998

    18. Spinelli P, Pizzetti P, Lgollo C, et al: Resection of obstruc-

    tive bronchial fibrolipoma through the flexible fiberoptic

    bronchoscope. Endoscopy 14:61-63, 1982

    19. Deavers M, Guinee D, Koss MN, et al: Granular cell

    tumors of the lung: Clinicopathologic study of 20 cases.

    Am J Surg Pathol 19:627-635, 1995

    20. Fisher ER, Wechsler H: Granular cell myoblastomaa

    misnomer. Electron microscopic and histochemical evi-

    dence concerning its Schwann cell derivation and nature.

    Cancer 15:936, 1962

    21. Liebow AA, Hubbell DS: Sclerosing hemangioma (histio-

    cytoma, xanthoma) of the lung. Thorax 29:1, 1974

    22. Sugio K: Sclerosing hemangioma of the lung: Radio-

    graphic and pathological study. Ann Thorac Surg 53:295-300, 1992

    23. Yousem SA, Wick MR, Singh G, et al: So-called sclerosing

    hemangiomas of the lung: An immunohistochemical

    study supporting a respiratory epithelial origin. Am J

    Surg Pathol 12:582-590, 1988

    24. Gal AA, Brooks JS, Pietra GG: Leiomyomatous neoplasms

    of the lung: A clinical, histologic, and immunohistochem-

    ical study. Mod Pathol 2:209-216, 1989

    25. Orlowski TM, Stasiak K, Kolodziej J: Leiomyoma of the

    lung. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 76:257-261, 1978

    26. McCluggage WG, Bharucha H: Primary pulmonary tu-

    mours of nerve sheath origin. Histopathology 26:247-254,

    1995

    27. Sugita M, Fujimura S, Hasumi T, et al: Sleeve superior

    segmentectomy of the right lower lobe for endobronchialneurinoma. Respiration 63:191-194, 1996

    28. Tolin DJ, Good RE: Nonmalignant tumors of bronchus.

    NY J Med 54:1771, 1954

    29. Lockett L, Chiang V, Scully N: Primary pulmonary me-

    ningioma: Report of a case and review of the literature.

    Am J Surg Pathol 21:453-460, 1997

    30. Kaleem Z, Fitzpatrick MM, Ritter JH: Primary pulmonary

    meningioma. Arch Pathol Lab Med 121:631-636, 1997

    31. Wende S, Bohl J, Schubert R, et al: Lung metastasis of a

    mangioma. Neuroradiology 24:287-291, 1983

    32. Gautam HP: Intrapulmonary malignant teratoma. Am

    Rev Resp Dis 100:863-865, 1969

    33. Tanimura S, et al: Primary pulmonary paraganglioma: a

    report of a case and review of the literature. J Jpn Assoc

    Chest Surg 7:88, 1993

    34. Mostecky H, Lichtenberg J, Kalus M: A non-chromaffin

    paraganglioma of the lung. Thorax 21:205-208, 1966

    35. Torikata C, Mukai M: So-called minute chemodectoma of

    the lung: An electron microscopic and immunohistochem-

    ical study. Virchows Arch Pathol Anat Histopathol 417:

    113-118, 1990

    36. Liebow AA, Castleman B: Benign clear cell (sugar) tu-

    mors of the lung. Yale J Biol Med 43:213-222, 1971

    37. Gaffey MJ, Mills SE, Askin FB, et al: Clear cell tumor of

    the lung: A clinicopathologic, immunohistochemical, and

    ultrastructural study of eight cases. Am J Surg Pathol

    14:248-259, 1990

    38. Liebow AA, Castleman B: Benign clear cell tumors of the

    lung. Am J Pathol 43:13a, 1963

    39. Sale GE, Kulander BG: Benign clear-cell tumor (sugar

    tumor) of the lung with hepatic metastases ten years

    after resection of pulmonary primary tumor. Arch PatholLab Med 112:1177-1178, 1988

    40. Greenfield LJ, Stirling MC: Benign tumors of the lung

    and bronchial adenomas, in Sabiston DC, Spencer FC

    (eds): Surgery of the Chest, vol 1 (ed 5). Philadelphia, PA,

    Saunders, 1990, pp 588-600

    41. Terashima H, Saitoh M, Yokoyama S, et al: A case of

    primary intrapulmonary thymoma: Its entity and the

    problem of lymph node dissection. Kyobu Geka 53:369-

    374, 2000

    42. Colby TV, Koss MN, Travis WD: Tumors of the lower

    respiratory tract, in: Atlas of Tumor Pathology, Washington,

    DC, Armed Forces Institute of Pathology, 1995, pp 61-338

    43. Omasa M, Kobayashi T, Takahashi Y, et al: Surgically

    treated pulmonary inflammatory pseudotumor. Jpn

    J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 50:305-308, 200244. Bahadori M, Liebow AA: Plasma cell granulomas of the

    lung. Cancer 31:191-208, 1973

    45. Doski JJ, Priebe CJ Jr, Driessnack M, et al: Corticoste-

    roids in the management of unresected plasma cell gran-

    uloma (inflammatory pseudotumor) of the lung. J Pediatr

    Surg 26:1064-1066, 1991

    46. Imperato JP, Folkman J, Sagerman RH, et al: Treatment

    of plasma cell granuloma of the lung with radiation ther-

    apy: A report of two cases and a review of the literature.

    Cancer 57:2127-2129, 1986

    47. Stoller JK, Ahmad M, Rice TW: Solitary pulmonary nod-

    ule. Cleve Clin J Med 55:68-74, 1988

    48. Lillington GA: Management of solitary pulmonary nod-

    ules. Dis Mon 37:271-318, 1991

    49. Siegelman SS, Khouri LP, Frank EK, et al: Solitary pulmo-nary nodules: Assessment. Radiology 160:307-312, 1986

    50. Higgins GA, Shields TW, Keehm RJ: The solitary pulmo-

    nary nodule: Ten-year follow-up of the Veterans Admin-

    istration Armed Forces Cooperative Study. Arch Surg

    110:570-575, 1975

    51. Ray JF, Lawton BR, Magnin GE, et al: The coin lesion

    story: Update 1976, experience with early thoracotomy

    for 179 suspected malignant coin lesions. Chest 70:332-

    336, 1976

    52. Khouri NF, Meziane MA, Zerhouni EA, et al: The solitary

    pulmonary nodule: Assessment, diagnosis, and manage-

    ment. Chest 91:128-133, 1987

    53. Swensen SJ, Jett JR, Payne WS, et al: An integrated

    approach to evaluation of the solitary pulmonary nodule.

    Mayo Clin Proc 65:128-133, 1987

    54. Toomes H, Delphendahl A, Manke HG, et al: The coin

    lesion of the lung: A review of 995 resected coin lesions.

    Cancer 51:534-537, 1983

    55. Libby DM, Henschke CI, Yankelevitz DF: The solitary pul-

    monary nodule: Update 1995. Am J Med 99:491-496, 1995

    56. Mazzone PJ, Stoller JK: The pulmonologists perspective

    regarding the solitary pulmonary nodule. Semin Thorac

    Cardiovasc Surg 14:250-260, 2002

    57. Fletcher JW: PET scanning and the solitary pulmonary

    nodule. Semin Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 14:268-274, 2002

    322 James S. Allan