pbfpfbesflrolcobefifba olppsri · 2015. 11. 15. · NSSU= ===== aNT=EuF aNP aN NO NN aV aNM aT aU...

9
NSSR SWrucWural Analysis of HisWorical ConsWrucWions – Jerzy Jasieńko (ed) © 2012 DPNH ProcławH PolandH ISSN 0860-2395H ISBN 978-83-7125-216-7 pbfpMfC BbeAsflro lc A obeABfifTATba Colpp sAriT Mouzakis ChK N I Adami ChK-bK O I harapitta iK P I sintzileou bK 4 ABpToACT ti thin the framework of kfhbo project EcmTJbksJOMMVJNFI the seismic behaviour of subassemblies before and after interventions is investigatedK tith this general purposeI a series of biJaxial shaking table tests are performed on a subassembly that consists of a cross vault resting on two parallel piersK cor the execution of testsI the shaking table facility of ibbLkqrA is being usedK qhe original specimen was constructed and tested previously within a research program related to the monument of hatholikon of aafni jonastery xNzK After the completion of the testing campaign of the asJbuiltJ specimenI the subassembly is strengthened using timber struts and steel ties in the cross vault and external vertical prestressing in the piersI as well as grouting of masonryK qhen the specimen is reJ tested and the behaviour of the strengthened specimen is compared to that of the original oneK mrior to the earthquake tests of both the unJstrengthened and strengthened subassemblyI the dynamic properties of the specimen are assessed through whiteJnoise or sweep testsK qhe comparison of the performance of the subassembly before and after strengthening highlights the positive effect Ein terms of capacityI observed damages and relative displacementsF of the selected intervention techniques to the seismic behaviour of the modelK heywords: phaking table testsI Cross vaultI droutingI pteel elementsI Timber elements NK fNTolarCTflN saults are quite frequently met in cultural heritage buildingsI where they are used to bridge large spansK eoweverI the system of vaults and the vertical elements supporting them is rather vulnerable to seismic actionsK ActuallyI even under vertical loads aloneI the vaults exert horizontal forces to their supports Ethe horizontal component of the thrust lineFK qhusI the vertical supporting elementsI namelyI masonry piers or wallsI are subjected to outJofJplane bendingK As the outJofJplane flexural stiffness and capacity of masonry are lowI the horizontal component of the thrust line may lead to outwards displacements of the supports of the vault andI henceI to damages in the vault andLor damages of the vertical supporting masonry elementsK qhe situation is obviously significantly aggravated when seismic actions of alternating sign occurK qhe behavior of vaulted structures is investigated by means of testing an adequate subassembly on the earthquake simulatorK After the occurrence of severe but repairable damagesI the subassembly is repaired and strengthened using techniques aiming at EaF grouting of all cracks in the vault and the archesI EbF strengthening of masonry through groutingI EcF enhancement of the capacity of piers to outJ ofJplane bending through external vertical prestressing and EdF alleviation of the effects of the horizontal component of the thrust lineI through the arrangement of timber struts and steel ties at the N Assistant mrofessorI kational qechnical rniversity of AthensI pchool of Civil bngineeringI iaboratory of barthquake bngineeringI harrismo]centralKntuaKgr O arK Civil bngineerI kational qechnical rniversity of AthensI pchool of Civil bngineeringI iaboratory of oeinforced ConcreteI adamis]centralKntuaKgr P arK Civil bngineerI kational qechnical rniversity of AthensI pchool of Civil bngineeringI iaboratory of barthquake bngineeringI klucia]centralKntuaKgr 4 mrofessorI kational qechnical rniversity of AthensI pchool of Civil bngineeringI iaboratory of oeinforced ConcreteI elvintz]centralKntuaKgr

Transcript of pbfpfbesflrolcobefifba olppsri · 2015. 11. 15. · NSSU= ===== aNT=EuF aNP aN NO NN aV aNM aT aU...

Page 1: pbfpfbesflrolcobefifba olppsri · 2015. 11. 15. · NSSU= ===== aNT=EuF aNP aN NO NN aV aNM aT aU Ou Z u D4X A8X/A9Y Z S4 (interior leaf) S1 (extrerior leaf) S3 (interior leaf) S2

=

NSSR=

SWrucWural Analysis of HisWorical ConsWrucWions – Jerzy Jasieńko (ed) © 2012 DPNH ProcławH PolandH ISSN 0860-2395H ISBN 978-83-7125-216-7

pbfpMfC BbeAsflro lc A obeABfifTATba Colpp sAriT Mouzakis ChKNI Adami ChK-bKOI harapitta iKPI sintzileou bK4 ABpToACT tithin=the=framework=of=kfhbo=project=EcmTJbksJOMMVJNFI=the=seismic=behaviour=of=subassemblies=before=and=after= interventions= is= investigatedK=tith= this=general=purposeI=a= series=of=biJaxial=shaking=table=tests=are=performed=on=a=subassembly=that=consists=of=a=cross=vault=resting=on=two=parallel=piersK=cor= the= execution= of= testsI= the= shaking= table= facility= of= ibbLkqrA= is= being= usedK= qhe= original=specimen=was=constructed=and=tested=previously=within=a=research=program=related=to=the=monument=of=hatholikon= of= aafni= jonastery= xNzK= After= the= completion= of= the= testing= campaign= of= the= asJbuiltJspecimenI= the= subassembly= is= strengthened= using= timber= struts= and= steel= ties= in= the= cross= vault= and=external =vertical =prestressing =in =the =piersI =as =well =as =grouting =of =masonryK =qhen =the =specimen =is =reJtested=and=the=behaviour=of=the=strengthened=specimen=is=compared=to=that=of=the=original=oneK=mrior=to=the= earthquake= tests= of= both= the= unJstrengthened= and= strengthened= subassemblyI= the= dynamic=properties= of= the= specimen= are= assessed= through= whiteJnoise= or= sweep= testsK= qhe=comparison= of= the=performance=of=the=subassembly=before=and=after=strengthening=highlights=the=positive=effect=Ein=terms=of=capacityI= observed= damages=and=relative=displacementsF= of= the=selected= intervention= techniques= to=the=seismic=behaviour=of=the=modelK= heywords: phaking table testsI Cross vaultI droutingI pteel elementsI Timber elements NK fNTolarCTflN =saults =are =quite =frequently =met =in =cultural =heritage =buildingsI =where =they =are =used =to =bridge =large =spansK=eoweverI=the=system=of=vaults=and=the=vertical=elements=supporting=them=is=rather=vulnerable=to=seismic=actionsK=ActuallyI= even=under= vertical= loads=aloneI= the=vaults= exert= horizontal= forces= to= their=supports=Ethe=horizontal=component=of=the=thrust=lineFK=qhusI=the=vertical=supporting=elementsI=namelyI=masonry=piers= or= wallsI= are=subjected=to=outJofJplane=bendingK=As= the=outJofJplane= flexural= stiffness=and=capacity= of= masonry=are= lowI= the=horizontal= component= of= the= thrust= line=may= lead= to=outwards=displacements=of= the=supports=of= the=vault=andI=henceI= to=damages= in=the=vault=andLor=damages=of= the=vertical= supporting= masonry= elementsK= qhe= situation= is= obviously= significantly= aggravated= when=seismic=actions=of=alternating=sign=occurK=qhe=behavior=of=vaulted=structures=is=investigated=by=means=of=testing=an=adequate=subassembly=on=the=earthquake= simulatorK= After= the= occurrence= of= severe= but= repairable= damagesI= the= subassembly= is=repaired= and= strengthened= using= techniques= aiming=at= EaF= grouting= of= all= cracks= in= the= vault= and= the=archesI=EbF=strengthening=of=masonry=through=groutingI=EcF=enhancement=of=the=capacity=of=piers=to=outJofJplane= bending= through= external= vertical= prestressing= and= EdF= alleviation= of= the= effects= of= the=horizontal=component=of=the=thrust=lineI=through=the=arrangement=of=timber=struts=and=steel=ties=at=the=

================================================N Assistant=mrofessorI=kational=qechnical=rniversity=of=AthensI=pchool=of=Civil=bngineeringI=iaboratory=

of=barthquake=bngineeringI=harrismo]centralKntuaKgr=O arK=Civil=bngineerI=kational=qechnical=rniversity=of=AthensI=pchool=of=Civil=bngineeringI=iaboratory=

of=oeinforced=ConcreteI=adamis]centralKntuaKgr=P arK=Civil=bngineerI=kational=qechnical=rniversity=of=AthensI=pchool=of=Civil=bngineeringI=iaboratory=

of=barthquake=bngineeringI=klucia]centralKntuaKgr=4 mrofessorI=kational=qechnical=rniversity=of=AthensI=pchool=of=Civil=bngineeringI=iaboratory=of=oeinforced=

ConcreteI=elvintz]centralKntuaKgr=

Page 2: pbfpfbesflrolcobefifba olppsri · 2015. 11. 15. · NSSU= ===== aNT=EuF aNP aN NO NN aV aNM aT aU Ou Z u D4X A8X/A9Y Z S4 (interior leaf) S1 (extrerior leaf) S3 (interior leaf) S2

=

NSSS=

base=of=the=archesK=fn=what=followsI=the=experimental=program=is=presented=and=the=main=test=results=are=discussed=and=commented=uponK=====OK abpCofmTflN lc pmbCfMbN =qhe=original=subassembly=xNz=consists=of=a= cross=vault= that= rests=on=two=parallel=piersI=made=of= threeJleaf=stone=masonryK=qhe=specimen=was=constructed=according=to=the=typology=and=the=properties=of=the=original=materials=of=the=masonry=of=aafni=jonasteryK=aue=to=the=limitations=of=the=shaking=simulator=E4KMM=×=4KMM=platformFI=the=model=was=built=in=reduced=scale=of=OWP=EcigK=NFK===

= aF= bF==

================ = cF= dF=

cigK N=aF=qhe=cross=vaultX=bFI=cF=Arches=during=constructionX=dF=bxperimental=setJup=of=the=original=subassembly=on=the=shaking=simulator=

=qhe=dimensions=of=the=specimen=in=plan=are=OKTMR=×=OKSM=mOK=qhe=piers=are=OKSM=m=highI=whereas=the=total=height=of=model=is=approxK=equal=to=OKUR=mK=qhe=piers=are=MK4R=m=thickK=qhe=two=exterior=leaves=of=piers= of= the= model= are=of= unequal= thickness= ENVO= mm= and=NPR= mmFK= joreoverI= the= external= leaf= is=made=of=bigger=stones= than=the=internal=oneI=whereas=solid=bricks=are=arranged=along=both=horizontal=and=vertical= joints= in= the=external=masonry= leafK=qhe=thickness=of=stones= in=both= leaves=was=varyingI=both=inJlength=and=inJheight=of=wallsK=qhusI=the=thickness=of=the=intermediate=filling=material=Emade=of=small= stones= and= mortarF= is= also= varying= both= horizontally= and= vertically= Eaverage= thickness= Z=NOP=mmFK=Concerning=the=materials=used=for=the=construction=of=the=piersI=a=travertine=having=similar=properties= to= those= of= the= inJsitu= main= type= of= stones= was= usedK= Based= on= the= type= of= mortar=encountered= on= the= monumentI= a= limeJpozzolan=mortar= with= a= mixed=aggregate= matrix= composed= of=siliceous=river=sand=and=limestone=gravels=was=designedK=qhe=inner=part=of=the=piers=was=a=mix=of=small=stones=and=mortarK=aetailed=data=related=to=the=properties=of=the=piers=of=the=subassembly=can=be=found=in=xOzK=qhe=cross=vault= was=made=of=solid=bricksI= similar= to=those=of=the=original=structureK=qhe=cross=vault=was=constructed=with=solid=bricksK=qhe=specimen=was=constructed=on=a=steel=base=EcigK=NdFK=As= mentioned= aboveI= before= reJtesting= the= model= within= kfhbo= projectI= several= repair= and=strengthening=techniques=were=applied=on=the=specimenI=namelyW===

aF= drouting= of= diagonal= cracks= occurred= in= the= piersK= cor= this= purposeI= a= natural= hydraulic= lime=based=grout=developed=using=pCB=material=was=applied=xPzK=

bF= oepair=of=the=arch=and=the=vault=Eby=means=of=groutingFK=

Page 3: pbfpfbesflrolcobefifba olppsri · 2015. 11. 15. · NSSU= ===== aNT=EuF aNP aN NO NN aV aNM aT aU Ou Z u D4X A8X/A9Y Z S4 (interior leaf) S1 (extrerior leaf) S3 (interior leaf) S2

=

NSST=

cF= pince= cross= vaults= are= very= vulnerable= when= the= piers= are= subjected= to= outJofJplane= actionsI=horizontal=timber=elements=EstrutsF=and=steel=elements=EtiesF=were=positioned=in=order=to=improve=the=connection=between=vault=and=piers=EcigK=OFK==

dF= cinallyI= the=piers= were=strengthened= for=outJofJplane= bendingI= using=prestressed=Ccom= platesK=qhe=plates=used=EpfhAJCarboaur=SO4F=were=placed=vertically=on=both=faces=of=the=piers=EcigK=PFK=A= total= of= NMM= kk= prestress= force= was= applied= in= each= of= the= four= piersI= corresponding= to=a=compressive=stress=equal=to=MKOM=jmaK=

==

=

cigK O mositioning=of=timber=and=steel=elements=at=the=base=of=the=arch=of=the=vault==

=

cigK P deneral=view=of=the=repairedLstrengthened=specimen=on=the=shaking=simulator=

=PK TbpT pbT-rm =qhe=experimental=setup=is=shown=in=cigure=PK=qhe=specimen=was=securely=fastened=on=the=shaking=table=through=the=rigid=steel=baseK=qhe=instrumentation=used=in=the=shaking=table=experiments=was=designed=so=as=to=measure=the=accelerations=along=u=and=v=directions=at=the=top=of=the=specimenI=the=acceleration=and= the=absolute= displacement= at= the= top= and= base= of= piers= along=u= and= v= directions= EcigK= 4FK= qhe=acceleration= and= the= displacement= of= the= shaking= taking= table= were= also= recorded= during= each= testK=AdditionallyI=strain=gauges=were=used=to=measure=the=strain=of=the=prestressed=Ccom=platesK=

Page 4: pbfpfbesflrolcobefifba olppsri · 2015. 11. 15. · NSSU= ===== aNT=EuF aNP aN NO NN aV aNM aT aU Ou Z u D4X A8X/A9Y Z S4 (interior leaf) S1 (extrerior leaf) S3 (interior leaf) S2

=

NSSU=

===========

aNT=EuF

aN4

aNP

aNO

aNN

aNM

aV

aT

aU

AOu

Z

u

D4X

A8X/A9Y

Z

S4 (interior leaf)S1 (extrerior leaf)

S3 (interior leaf)S2 (extrerior leaf)

D2YA13Y

D5Y

A4X/A5Y

D1X

A10X/A11Y

D3YA12Y

=========================================aF==============================================================================bF=

cigK 4 jeasurement=points=of=acceleration=and=displacement=for=the=aF=asJbuilt=and=bF=strengthened=specimen=

=4K fNmrT MlTflN ANa TbpTfNd molTlCli

=4KNK Base motion qests= were= performed= using= the= signals= recorded= at= Calitri= during= the= OP= kovember= NVUM= frpinia=earthquake=Ejs=Z=SKVFK=qhe=basic=features=of=recorded=accelerations=are=the=long=duration=Eof=the=order=of= VM=secF= and= the= sequence= of= two= main= shocks= of= similar= peak= accelerationK= cor= the= execution= of=testsI= the=reference=base=input=consists=of=the=first=section=of=the=long=inputI=of=about=4M=sec=durationK=qhese=shorter=excitations=have=frequency=content=similar=to=that=of=long=excitationsK=Both=bJt=and=kJp=components=were=applied=in=the=horizontal=u=and=v=direction=respectivelyK=qhe=time=histories=of= the=base=accelerations=are=shown=in=cigure=RI=while=the=corresponding=response=spectra= for=RB=damping=are=depicted=in=cigure=SK==

=

0 R 10 1R 20Time (sec)

-2.00

-1.00

0.00

1.00

2.00

Base

Acc

eler

atio

nX

(m/s

2 )

==0 R 10 1R 20

Time (sec)

-2.00

-1.00

0.00

1.00

2.00

Base

Acc

eler

atio

nY

(m/s

2 )

=aF bF=

cigK R frpinia=earthquakeW=Base=acceleration=time=histories=along=aF=u=direction=and=bF=v=direction=

=

0 1 2 3Time (sec)

0.00

2.00

4.00

6.00

oes

pons

eA

ccel

erat

ion

X(m

/s2 )

===0 1 2 3

Time (sec)

0.00

2.00

4.00

6.00

oes

pons

eA

ccel

erat

ion

Y(m

/s2 )

=aF bF=

cigK S frpinia=earthquakeW=Base=acceleration=time=histories=along=aF=u=direction=and=bF=v=direction==

4KOK Testing procedure qhe=test=procedure=consisted= in=a=series= of= seismic= tests=on= the=strengthened=subassemblyI=using=the=shaking= table= of= iaboratory= of= barthquake= bngineering= at= kqrAK= cor= the= sake= of= comparisonI= the=experimental= campain= carried=out=by= xNz= on= the=unstrengthened= specimen= was= also= followed= for= the=strengthened=oneK=qables=N=and=O=show=the=test=protocol=for=the=two=conditionsI=namelyI=before=EBpF=

Page 5: pbfpfbesflrolcobefifba olppsri · 2015. 11. 15. · NSSU= ===== aNT=EuF aNP aN NO NN aV aNM aT aU Ou Z u D4X A8X/A9Y Z S4 (interior leaf) S1 (extrerior leaf) S3 (interior leaf) S2

=

NSSV=

and=after= strengthening=EApFK= ft= is= noted=thatI= in=both=casesI= the=model=was= subjected=to=subsequent=increased=scaled=motions=up=to=appearance=of=significant=damageK=

=Table N=rnstrengthened=specimenW=mrotocol=of=tests=

=

koK=of=test= bxcitation= airection=of=excitation=

Amplification=of=original=record==

EBF=NBp= thiteJnoise= v= –=OBp= thiteJnoise= u= –=PBp= thiteJnoise= w= –=4Bp= frpinia=earthquake= u= PM=RBp= frpinia=earthquake= u= RM=SBp= frpinia=earthquake= u= TR=TBp= frpinia=earthquake= u= NMM=UBp= frpinia=earthquake= u= NOR=VBp= frpinia=earthquake= u= NRM=NMBp= frpinia=earthquake= u= NTR=NNBp= frpinia=earthquake= u= OMM=NOBp= frpinia=earthquake= u= ORM=NPBp= frpinia=earthquake= u= PMM=N4Bp= frpinia=earthquake= u= PRM=NRBp= frpinia=earthquake= u= 4MM=NSBp= frpinia=earthquake= u= 4RM=NTBp= frpinia=earthquake= u= RMM=NUBp= frpinia=earthquake= uJv= RM=NVBp= frpinia=earthqauke= uJv= NMM=OMBp= frpinia=earthqauke= uJv= NRM=

Concerning= the=unstrengthened=specimenI= the= subassembly=was= tested=under= earthquake=excitationsI=first=in=the=longitudinal=direction=EuF=and=then=in=both=longitudinal=EuF=and=transversal=EvF=directionsK=mrior= to=earthquake=testsI= the=dynamic=properties=of= the=specimen=were=assessed=through=whiteJnoise=testsK=qhe=experimental=campaign=is=shown=in=qable=NK=fn=detailI=the=original=specimen=was=subjected=to= several= excitations= in= u= direction= with= the= base= acceleration= increased= gradually= up= to= RMMB= of=original= recordK= auring=qest= NMBpI= where= the=base= acceleration= along=u= direction= was= amplified= to=NTRB= of= original= recordsI= cracks= appearedK= fn= subsequent= tests= along= u= directionI= the= specimen=suffered= increasing= level= of= damage=as= the= excitations= became= more=severeK= qhenI= three=biaxial= tests=were=executed=with=the=base=acceleration=increased=stepwise=up=to=NRMB=of=original=recordsK=

Table O=ptrengthened=specimenW=mrotocol=of=tests=

=

koK=of=test= bxcitation= airection=of=excitation=

Amplification=of=original=record==

EBF=NAp= pineJsweep= u= –=OAp= pineJsweep= v= –=

Application=of=vertical=load=of=the=postJtensioned=system=PAp= pineJsweep= u= –=4Ap= pineJsweep= v= –=RAp= frpinia=earthquake= v= RM=SAp= frpinia=earthquake= u= NMM=TAp= frpinia=earthquake= u= NRM=UAp= frpinia=earthquake= u= OMM=VAp= frpinia=earthquake= u= ORM=NMAp= frpinia=earthquake= u= PMM=NNAp= frpinia=earthquake= u= PRM=NOAp= frpinia=earthquake= u= 4MM=NPAp= frpinia=earthquake= u= 4RM=N4Ap= pineJsweep= u= –=NRAp= pineJsweep= v= –=

Page 6: pbfpfbesflrolcobefifba olppsri · 2015. 11. 15. · NSSU= ===== aNT=EuF aNP aN NO NN aV aNM aT aU Ou Z u D4X A8X/A9Y Z S4 (interior leaf) S1 (extrerior leaf) S3 (interior leaf) S2

=

NSTM=

fn=the=case=of=the=strengthened=specimen=Efor=details=see=qabK=OFI=the=base=accelerations=were=amplified=to=various=values=of=pgaI=up=to=4RMB=of=the=original=recordK=fn=other=wordsI=the=strengthened=specimen=withstood= three= times= higher= seismic= input= than= the= unstrengthened= specimen= EqabK=NFI= in= terms= of=maximum=accelerationK==fn=order=to=identify=the=dynamic=characteristics=of=the=modelI=sine=logarithmic=sweep= tests= were= also= executedK= ft= is= noted= that= sweep= tests= performed= both= prior= and= after= the=application= of= the= postJtensioning= systemI= separately= along= each= one= of= the= horizontal= u= and= v=directionK=joreover=and=in=order=to=determine=the=change=in=the=dynamic=properties=of=the=specimen=after=the=damageI=this=procedure=was=repeated=after=the=completion=of=shaking=table=testsK==RK TbpT obpriTp

=RKNK lbserved damages Both=before=and=after=the=application=of=the=repairLstrengthening=techniquesI=the=specimen=was=visually=examined=and=the=observed=cracks=were=plotted=after=each=excitationK==

=RKNKNK rnstrengthened ppecimen auring=qest=OMBp=ENRMB=of=frpinia=earthquakeFI=the=specimen=suffered=several=damages=as=shown=in=cigure =TK =fn =detailI =due =to =outJof =plane =bending =the =cross =vault =was =detached =from=the =piersI =cracks =were=formed=at=the=arches=Eat=the=brickLmortar=interfaceFI=whereas=horizontal=cracks=were=formed=at=the=piers= Eat=both=sides= of= the=masonryFK= curthermoreI= a= permanent= deformation=Eequal= to=NR=mmF=of= the=specimen=along=its=vertical=axis=was=recordedK===RKNK2K ptrengthened ppecimen qhe=damages=observed= in=the=strengthened=specimen=at=the=end=of=biaxial=tests=were=similar=to=those=presented=by=the=asJbuilt=specimenK=lf=courseI=in=the=case=of=the=strengthened=specimenI=the=damages=occured= at= higher= values= of= the= base= accelrationK= fn= detailI= during= qest= VApI= in= which= the= base= ==

====== == aF== bF==

===== == cF== dF=

cigK T rnstrengthned=specimenK=lbserved=damages=at=aF=the=piersI=bF=the=arches=and=cF=and=dF=at=the=vault==

acceleration=was=scaled=up=to=ORMB=of=the=original=recordsI=cracks=were=formed=at=the=south=arch=Eat=the=brickLmortar=interfaceF=of=the=strengthened=specimenK=auring=the=same=testI=cracks=started=forming=also=at=the=cross=vaultK=qhese=cracks=appeared=at=the=region=of=connection=between==the=vault=and=the=

Page 7: pbfpfbesflrolcobefifba olppsri · 2015. 11. 15. · NSSU= ===== aNT=EuF aNP aN NO NN aV aNM aT aU Ou Z u D4X A8X/A9Y Z S4 (interior leaf) S1 (extrerior leaf) S3 (interior leaf) S2

=

NSTN=

piers =Ebetween =the =two =prestressed =Ccom=platesFK =fn =subsequent =testsI =the =cracks =became =larger =and =they=propagated=towards= the=archI=as=well=as= the=top=of= the=vaultK=AdditionallyI=damages=occurred=in=both=archesK=qhe=crack=pattern=at=the=end=of=the=testing=procedure=is=presented=in=cigure=UK=ft=has=to=be=mentioned= thatI= no= damages= were= visible= at= the= piersK= eoweverI= after= the= completion= of= the=experimental=campain=and=the=removal=of=the=prestressing=systemI=the=appearance=of=horizontal=cracks=at=the=base=of=the=piers=was=evident=as= in=case=of=the=unstrengthened=specimenX=they=were=of=smaller=opening=thoughK=

=

= ==

= aF= bF==

= ==

= cF= =dF==

cigK U ptrengthened=specimenK=Cracks=at=the=end=of=qestingW=aF=crossJvault=EintradosFX=bF=crossJvault=EextradosFX=cFW=north=archX=dFW=south=arch=

=RKOK aynamic characteristics of specimens fn =qable =PI =the =frequencies =and =their =damping =are =presented =for =whiteJnoise =tests =along =u =and =v =directions= for= the= unstrenthened= specimenK= qhe= frequencies= were= calculated= using= the= transfer=functions=of=recorded=response=acceleration=and=input=base=accelerationK=qhe=damping=was=calculated=from=the=transfer=function=plots=by=applying=the=halfJpower=bandwidth=method=xPzK==cor =the=strengthened=specimenI =sine=logarithmic=sweep=tests =were=performed=at =several =stages=of =the=experimental=campainI=separately=along=the=u=and=v=directionK=qhe=frequency=range=was=between=NKM=ez=and=PO=ez=at=a=rate=of=one=octave=per=minute=with=an=amplitude=of=MK4M=mLsecO=EMKM4=gFK=fn=qable=4I=the= natural= frequencies= and= the= damping= ratios= are= given= at= the= several= stages= of= the= experimental=procedure=for=the=strengthened=specimenK==

=Table P=rnstrengthened=specimenW=aynamic=characteristics=

=

qest=koK= airection= crequency=EezF=

aamping=ratio=EBF=

NBp= u= NOKPM= NKMM=

OBp= v= RKVS= OKMM=

Page 8: pbfpfbesflrolcobefifba olppsri · 2015. 11. 15. · NSSU= ===== aNT=EuF aNP aN NO NN aV aNM aT aU Ou Z u D4X A8X/A9Y Z S4 (interior leaf) S1 (extrerior leaf) S3 (interior leaf) S2

=

NSTO=

Table 4=ptrengthened=specimenW=aynamic=characteristics==

qest=koK==

airection= crequency=EezF=

aamping=ratio=EBF=

NAp= u= NMKSU= PK4T=

OAp= v= PKRO= 4KST=

Application=of=vertical=load=of=the=postJtensioned=system=

PAp= u= NPKNR= PK4R=

4Ap= v= 4KVU= 4KUM=

N4Ap= u= NOKPU= PK4U=

NRAp= v= PKTU= SKVS=

=fn=both=the=asJbuilt=and=the=strengthened=specimenI=there=is=a=significant=difference=in=frequency=along=the=two=main=directionsK=qhe= low=stiffness=of= the=subassembly=along=the=v=axis= is= evidenced=by= the=lower=frequency=values=as=compared=to=those=measured=along=the=u=axis=Esee=qabK=P=and=qabK=4K=ln=the=other=handI= the=grouting= = together=with=the= =horizontal=elements=Esteel= ties=and=wooden=strutsF= led=to=a =signficant = =increase =of =the =value =of =the =damping =ratio =Efrom =approxK =N =and =OB =at =the =u =and =v =direction =to =P =and =4BI =respectivelyFI =as =well =as =to =a =decrease =of =the =frequencyI =as =the =subassembly =became= stifferKqhe= subsequent= application= of= the= external= vertical= prestressing= has= led= to= further=increase =of =the = =frequency =of =the =specimen =in =both =directions =Eu =and =vFI =whereas = =the =value =of =the =damping=ratio=remained=practically=the=sameK=After= the=completion=of= the=tests= Eqest=NPApW=4RMB=of= frpinia= earthquakeI= tabK=OFI=a=decrease= in=the=frequency=of =the=specimen=mainly=in=v=direction=was=measured=Esee=qests =4Ap=and= =NRApI=qabK =4FI =due=to=the=damage=that=had=occurred=at=the=arches=and=the=vaultK=ln=the=contraryI=the=dampingI=mainly=in=v=directionI=was=increasedK==RKPK oelative displacement and acceleration at the top fn=qable=RI=the=relativeI=to=the=baseI=displacements=at=top=of=piers=are=given=together=with=the=absolute=recorded=peak=values=of=accelerations=for= the=unstrengthened=specimen=Eqests=NVBpW=NMMB=of=frpinia=earthquake=and=OMBpW=NRMB=of=frpinia=earthquakeFK=fn=qable=SI=the=corresponding=values=are=given=for=the=strengthened=specimen=Eqest=SApW=NMMB=of=frpinia=earthquakeI=TApW=NRMB=of=frpinia=earthquake=and=NPApW=4RMB=of= frpinia=earthquakeFK=Τhe=comparison=of= the=results=presented=in=qables=R=and=S=shows=that=for=the=same=seismic=input=ENMMB=or=NRMB=of=frpinia=earthquakeF=the=relative=displacements=in =the =vJdirection =are =more =or =less =equal =for =the =two =conditions =of =the =specimen =Ebefore =and =after =interventionsFK= qhis= proves= that= the= interventions= led= to= reJinstatement= of= the= overall= stiffness= of= the=subassembly=in=its=weak=directionK=qhe=same=holds=true=for=the=accelerations=measured=at=the=top=of=the=piers=before=and=after=strengtheningK===ln=the=other=handI=the=strengthening=of=the=subassembly=has=proven=to=be=efficientI=as=the=strengthened=specimen= EaF= was= able= to= withstand= significantly= higher= seismic= input= E4RMB= versus= NRMB= of= the=frpinia=earthquakeF=and=EbF=it=withstood=significantly=larger=deformations=along=both=u=and=v=axes=Esee=qable=SFK= ft= is= important= to=note= that= the=damages= that= occurred= to= the=strengthened=subassembly=are=similar= in= morphologyI= as= well= as= in= intensity= with= those= observed= on= the= asJbuilt= subassemblyI=although=the=specimen=at=its=strengthened=state=was=subjected=to=a=significant=number=of=tests=at=higher=seismic=input=valuesK========

Table R=rnstrengthened=specimenW=qop=acceleration=and=relative=displacement==

koK=of=test= Acceleration=EmLsecOF=

oelative=aisplacement=

EmmF=

AOu= ARv= oaOMv=

NVBp=ENMMB=of=frpinia=earthquakeF= NKST= OKU4= 4KPN=

OMBp=ENRMB=of=frpinia=earthquakeF= OKPS= RKNN= NNK4O=

Page 9: pbfpfbesflrolcobefifba olppsri · 2015. 11. 15. · NSSU= ===== aNT=EuF aNP aN NO NN aV aNM aT aU Ou Z u D4X A8X/A9Y Z S4 (interior leaf) S1 (extrerior leaf) S3 (interior leaf) S2

=

NSTP=

Table S=ptrengthened=specimenW=qop=acceleration=and=relative=displacement==

koK=of=test= Acceleration=EmLsecOF=

oelative=aisplacement=

EmmF=

ANMu= ANPv= oaOv=

SAp=ENMMB=of=frpinia=earthquakeF= NKVT= PKPT= RK4S=

TAp=ENRMB=of=frpinia=earthquakeF= PKMP= 4KUR= VKNT=

NPAp=E4RMB=of=frpinia=earthquakeF= NMKPT= VKSP= 4MKRT=

====SK ClNCirpflNp =ln=the=basis=of=the=experimental=results=presented=in=this=paperI=the=following=conclusions=can=be=drawnW=

NK qhe=vulnerability=of=vaulted=structures=perpendicularly=to=the=supporting=masonry=elements=was=evident= both= before= and= after= strengthening= of= the= subassembly= Edamages= concentrated= in= the=vaultI=in=the=archesI=as=well=as=at=the=top=and=the=bottom=of=the=piers=due=to=out=of=plane=bendingFK=

OK qhe=selected=intervention=techniques=were=successfulI=as=they=have=led=to=a=significant=increase=of=the=maximum=base=acceleration=the=subassembly=could=withstandI=as=well=as= to= the=deformation=capacity=of=the=specimen=along=both=its=main=axesK=

PK ft= should= also= be= mentioned= that= the= intervention= techniques= applied= to= the= subassembly= are=acceptable=for=historic=structuresK=ActuallyI=EaF=the=use=of=timber=andLor=steel=struts=and=ties=is=quite=common= in= historic= structuresI= even= at= the= time= of= their= constructionI= EbF= the= external= vertical=prestressing=constitutes=a=NMMB=reversible=techniqueI=whereas=EcF=grouting=is=of=general=acceptanceI=although=it=is=clearly=a=non=reversible=techniqueK=cinallyI=

4K ft= is= considered= that= the= scheme= of= interventions= is= acceptableI= as= it= improves= the= seismic=behaviour= of= the= subassembly= without= altering= the= original= function= of= the= bearing= systemK=ActuallyI= the= damages= observed= in= the= strengthened= model= are= similar= to= those= of= the=unstrengthened=specimenI=whereas=the=dynamic=characteristics=of=the=subassembly=at=both=states=Ebefore=and=after=interventionF=are=similar=for=similar=seismic=inputsK==

AChNltibadbMbNTp =qhis= research=was=carried=out=within=the=cmT=funded=buropean=mrogramme=kfhbo=Emroject=Contract=koK=O44NOPFI=httpWLLwwwKnikerKeuLK=qhanks=are=due=to=pfhA=ebiiAp=fndustrial=C=Commercial=pKAK=and=ptresseead=Ad=for=the=design=and=the=application=of=the=external=vertical=prestressing=systemK== obcbobNCbp xNz Carydis=mKI=jouzakis=eKI=harapitta=iK=EOMMTF=fnvestigation=of=mechanical=behaviour=of=byzantine=

type= masonry= with= or= without= mosaic= and= evaluation= of= different= interventions= techniquesW=Application=to=the=hatholikon=of=aafni=jonasteryK=Technical oeport ibbLkTrA Ein=dreekFK

xOz sintzileou= bKI= jiltiadouJcezans= AKI= srouva= AKI= Anagnostopoulou= pK= EOMMSF= jechanical=properties=of=threeJleaf=stone=masonryK=fnW mroceedings of the fnternational Conference ptructural Analysis of eistorical Constructions pAeCMSI kew=aelhiI=fndiaK=

xPz Badogiannis= bKI= halagri= AKI= fpsilanti= bKI= aedeloudis= CKI= sintzileou= bK= EOMNOF= jix= design= and=performance=evaluation= of= grouts= with= superfine=natural=pozzolanI= submitted= fn mroceedings of the fnternational Conference ptructural Analysis of eistorical Constructions pAeC 2MN2I=troclawI=molandK

x4z Clough=oKtK=menzien=gKI=ENVTRF=aynamic=of=ptructuresI=edK=jcdraw=eillI=kew=vorkK=