Análisis General de las conductas exclusorias

7/29/2019 Análisis General de las conductas exclusorias

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/analisis-general-de-las-conductas-exclusorias 1/32

1%(5:25.,1*3$3(56(5,(6

$*(1(5$/$1$/<6,62)(;&/86,21$5<&21'8&7$1'5()86$/72'($/±

:+<$63(1$1'.2'$.$5(0,6*8,'('

'HQQLV:&DUOWRQ

:RUNLQJ3DSHU

KWWSZZZQEHURUJSDSHUVZ

1$7,21$/%85($82)(&2120,&5(6($5&+

0DVVDKXVHWWV$YHQXH

&DPEULGJH0$

)HEUXDU\

,WKDQN-RQDWKDQ%DNHU5REHUW*HUWQHU:LOOLDP/\QN*UHJRU\3HOQDU6DP3HOW]PDQ-5REHUW5REHUWVRQ

6WHYHQ6KDSLUR0L.KDHO:DOGPDQDQG0L.KDHO:KLQVWRQIRUKHOSIXOGLV.XVVLRQV7KHYLHZVH[SUHVVHG

KHUHLQDUHWKRVHRIWKHDXWKRUDQGQRWQH.HVVDULO\WKRVHRIWKH1DWLRQDO%XUHDXRI(.RQRPL.5HVHDU.K

E\'HQQLV:&DUOWRQ$OOULJKWVUHVHUYHG6KRUWVH.WLRQVRIWH[WQRWWRH[.HHGWZRSDUDJUDSKVPD\

EHTXRWHGZLWKRXWH[SOL.LWSHUPLVVLRQSURYLGHGWKDWIXOO.UHGLWLQ.OXGLQJQRWL.HLVJLYHQWRWKHVRXU.H



$*HQHUDO$QDO\VLVRI([OXVLRQDU\&RQGXWDQG5HIXVDOWR'HDO±

:K\$VSHQDQG.RGDNDUH0LVJXLGHG

'HQQLV:&DUOWRQ

1%(5:RUNLQJ3DSHU1R

)HEUXDU\

-(/1R/

$%675$&7

7KLVSDSHUDQDO\]HVWKHTXHVWLRQ:KHQVKRXOGDVLQJOHILUPKDYHDGXW\WRGHDOZLWKDQRWKHU"7KH

SDSHUXVHVDVHULHVRIH.RQRPL.PRGHOVWRDQVZHUWKHTXHVWLRQDVVXPLQJWKHJRDO LV WRSUHYHQWKDUPWR

.RPSHWLWLRQDQGDSSOLHVWKHH.RQRPL.DQDO\VLVWRWKHOHDGLQJ.DVHVWRVKRZZKHQDQWLWUXVWHQIRU.HPHQWLV

DSSURSULDWHDQGZKHQLWLVQRW7KHDQDO\VLVVKRZVWKDWWRSUHYHQWKDUPWR.RPSHWLWLRQWKHUROHIRUDQWLWUXVW

VKRXOGEHTXLWHOLPLWHGDQGWKDWWZROHDGLQJ.DVHV$VSHQDQGRGDNUHSUHVHQWDGDQJHURXVGLUH.WLRQIRU

DQWLWUXVWSROL.\

'HQQLV:&DUOWRQ

*UDGXDWH6KRRORI%XVLQHVV

8QLYHUVLW\RI&KLDJR

(DVWWK6WUHHW

&KLDJR,/

DQG1%(5



,,1752'8&7,21

7ZL.HLQWKHSDVWILIWHHQ\HDUVWKH6XSUHPH&RXUWKDVVXJJHVWHGWKDWDVLQJOHILUP

PLJKWXQGHUVRPH.LU.XPVWDQ.HVKDYHDGXW\WRGHDOZLWKDQRWKHUILUP,Q$VSHQWKH&RXUW

XSKHOGDMXU\YHUGL.WILQGLQJDQDQWLWUXVWYLRODWLRQZKHQDILUPWKDW.RQWUROOHGWKUHHRIWKHIRXU

GRZQKLOOVNLLQJPRXQWDLQVLQ$VSHQWHUPLQDWHGD.ROODERUDWLRQRQDQDOO$VSHQVNLLQJSDVVZLWK

WKHIRXUWKPRXQWDLQ,QRGDNWKH&RXUWGHQLHGVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWIRUWKHGHIHQGDQWZKHQ

RGDNWRRNVWHSVWRPDNHLWPRUHGLIIL.XOWIRULQGHSHQGHQWVHUYL.HRUJDQL]DWLRQV,62VWR

VHUYL.HRGDNSKRWR.RSLHUVLQSDUWE\GHQ\LQJWKH,62VD..HVVWRUHSOD.HPHQWSDUWVWKH\KDG

SUHYLRXVO\EHHQDEOHWRSXU.KDVHIURPRGDNRULWVDXWKRUL]HGSDUWVPDQXID.WXUHUV%RWK.DVHV

VXIIHUIURP.RQIXVHGH.RQRPL.UHDVRQLQJ7RWKHH[WHQWWKHVH.DVHVKDYHH[SDQGHGWKHGXW\

WKDWDVLQJOHILUPPD\KDYHWRGHDOZLWKRWKHUVWKH\UHSUHVHQWDGDQJHURXVGLUH.WLRQIRU

DQWLWUXVW

7KLVSDSHUDQDO\]HVWKHTXHVWLRQ:KHQVKRXOGDVLQJOHILUPKDYHDGXW\WRGHDOZLWK

DQRWKHU",WXVHVDQH.RQRPL.DQDO\VLVWRDQVZHUWKHTXHVWLRQDVVXPLQJWKHJRDOLVWRSUHYHQW

KDUPWR.RPSHWLWLRQDQGDSSOLHVWKDWDQDO\VLVWRWKHOHDGLQJ.DVHVWRVKRZZKHQDQWLWUXVW

HQIRU.HPHQWLVDSSURSULDWHDQGZKHQLWLVQRW7KHDQWLWUXVWGR.WULQHRIDGXW\WRGHDO

DXWRPDWL.DOO\.UHDWHVDWHQVLRQEH.DXVHWKHDQWLWUXVWODZVDUHSUHPLVHGRQWKHVLPSOHQRWLRQ

WKDWULYDOU\DPRQJILUPVEHQHILWV.RQVXPHUV\HWDGR.WULQHRIDGXW\WRGHDO.OHDUO\OLPLWVWKDW

ULYDOU\,QGHHGWKHGR.WULQHXVXDOO\DULVHVLQGLV.XVVLRQVUHJDUGLQJH[.OXVLRQDU\.RQGX.WZKL.K

DVPDQ\.RPPHQWDWRUVKDYHQRWHGLVGLIIL.XOWWRGLVWLQJXLVKIURPEHQHIL.LDO.RPSHWLWLRQ

EH.DXVHWKH\ERWKUHVXOWLQDQLQ.UHDVHLQVDOHVRIRQHILUPDWWKHH[SHQVHRIULYDOV

2YHUDJJUHVVLYHXVHRIDQWLWUXVW.ODLPVDJDLQVWH[.OXVLRQDU\.RQGX.WWKHUHIRUHZLOOLQHYLWDEO\

UHGX.HWKHLQ.HQWLYHIRUEHQHIL.LDO.RPSHWLWLRQ

$VSHQ6NLLQJ&RY$VSHQ+LJKODQGV6NLLQJ&RUS86



(.RQRPLVWVKDYHJURZQPRUHNQRZOHGJHDEOHDERXWKRZEXVLQHVVVWUDWHJLHV.DQEHQHILW

DILUPDQGKDUPLWVULYDOV,QGHHGHYHU\PDMRUEXVLQHVVV.KRROQRZKDV.RXUVHVLQVWUDWHJL.

EHKDYLRU(.RQRPLVWVKDYHDPX.K.OHDUHUXQGHUVWDQGLQJRIKRZYDULRXVPRGHVRI.RQGX.W

WKDWLQYROYHHLWKHUH[SOL.LWRULPSOL.LWUHIXVDOVWRGHDOHJH[.OXVLYHGHDOLQJWLHLQVDOHV

.ORVHGMRLQWYHQWXUHVSURGX.WLQ.RPSDWLELOLWLHVGLV.ULPLQDWRU\SUL.LQJVHWWLQJKLJKSUL.HV.DQ

EHXVHGHVSH.LDOO\LQLQGXVWULHVZLWKUDSLG.KDQJHDQGV.DOHH.RQRPLHVWR.HPHQWPDUNHW

SRZHU7KLVDGYDQ.HLQH.RQRPLVWV¶NQRZOHGJHLVDOOWRWKHJRRGEXWLWVKRXOGQRWQH.HVVDULO\

WUDQVODWHLQWRPRUHD.WLYHDQWLWUXVWSROL.\7KH]HDOZLWKZKL.KH.RQRPLVWVIRLVWWKHVHWKHRULHV

RQDQWLWUXVWSUD.WLWLRQHUVPXVWQRWREV.XUHWZRNH\ID.WV)LUVWWKHKDUPWRDULYDOLVQRWDKDUP

WR.RPSHWLWLRQ(PSLUL.DOO\GR.XPHQWLQJDKDUPWR.RPSHWLWLRQIURPYDULRXVH[.OXVLRQDU\

.RQGX.WLVXVXDOO\TXLWHGLIIL.XOWDQGLVQRWQH.HVVDULO\DQLPSOL.DWLRQRIWKHWKHRULHV(.RQRPL.

WKHRUL]LQJDERXWSRVVLEOHKDUPWR.RPSHWLWLRQKDVIDURXWSD.HGHPSLUL.DOYHULIL.DWLRQ,Q6H.WLRQ

,,RIWKLVSDSHU,H[SODLQZKDWH.RQRPLVWVRUDWOHDVWWKLVH.RQRPLVWQRZNQRZDERXWKRZ

H[SOL.LWRULPSOL.LWUHIXVDOVWRGHDOKDUP.RPSHWLWLRQ6H.RQGH.RQRPLVWVRIWHQQHJOH.WWRIR.XV

RQZKHUHDQWLWUXVWHQIRU.HPHQWLVOLNHO\WRKHOSRUKDUPWKHH.RQRP\WKHPRVW<HWH.RQRPLVWV

KDYHOHDUQHGTXLWHDELWDERXWWKHVRXU.HVRIH.RQRPL.JURZWKDQGWUDQVD.WLRQ.RVWV,GLV.XVV

LQ6H.WLRQ,,,VRPHSROL.\LVVXHVUHODWHGWRDQWLWUXVWHQIRU.HPHQWLQOLJKWRIWKH.XUUHQW

NQRZOHGJHDERXW5'DQGWUDQVD.WLRQ.RVWV

$OWKRXJKLWLVXQGHUVWDQGDEOHZK\VRPH.RXOGWDNHWKHSRVLWLRQWKDWWKHHYLGHQ.HWRGDWH

RQUHIXVDOVWRGHDOLVVRDPELJXRXVWKDWWKHUHVKRXOGEHQRDQWLWUXVWUHVWUL.WLRQV,GRQRWWDNH

VX.KDQH[WUHPHYLHZ,VWDUWIURPWKHSUHPLVHWKDWWKHUH.DQEHDOHJLWLPDWHUROHIRUDQWLWUXVW

UHVWUL.WLRQVRQUHIXVDOVWRGHDO6H.WLRQV,,DQG,,,GHYHORSDQH.RQRPL.IUDPHZRUNWKDW6H.WLRQ

,9XVHVWRDQDO\]HVHOH.WHGUHIXVDOWRGHDO.DVHV7KHDQDO\VLVVKRZVWKDWWRSUHYHQWKDUPWR

.RPSHWLWLRQWKHUROHIRUDQWLWUXVWVKRXOGEHTXLWHOLPLWHG,QSDUWL.XODU,ZLOODUJXHWKDWWKHWZR

.RQWLQXHG(DVWPDQ.RGDN&RY,PDJH7HKQLDO6HUYLH,Q86



OHDGLQJ.DVHV$VSHQDQGRGDNWKDWDUHIUHTXHQWO\.LWHGE\SODLQWLIIVVHHNLQJWRIRU.HDULYDOWR

GHDOZLWKWKHPUHSUHVHQWDGDQJHURXVGLUH.WLRQIRUDQWLWUXVW2QO\DQDUURZ.RQVWUX.WLRQRI

WKRVH.DVHVZLOOSUHYHQWKDUPWR.RPSHWLWLRQ

$WWKHRXWVHWOHWPHEH.OHDURQZKDWWKHSDSHUZLOOQRWDGGUHVV7KHSDSHUZLOOQRW

DGGUHVVWKHGXW\WRGHDOWKDWDMRLQWYHQWXUHRIULYDOVKDV7KDWLVDQLQWHUHVWLQJDQG.RPSOL.DWHG

TXHVWLRQWKDW,KDYHGHDOWZLWKHOVHZKHUH ,WUDLVHVGLIIHUHQWLVVXHVWKDQWKRVHUDLVHGE\WKH

GXW\WRGHDOWKDWDVLQJOHILUPVKRXOGKDYH7KHUHDVRQLVWKDWLQJHQHUDOWKHDQWLWUXVWODZV

WUHDW.ROOH.WLYHD.WLRQGLIIHUHQWO\PRUHKDUVKO\WKDQXQLODWHUDOD.WLRQLPSOL.LWO\DGRSWLQJWKH

YLHZWKDW.ROOH.WLYHD.WLRQLVPRUHOLNHO\WR.UHDWHD.RPSHWLWLYHKDUPWKDQLVWKHD.WLRQRID

VLQJOHILUP7KHSDSHUDOVRZLOOQRWGHDOZLWKDILUPWKDWLVVXEMH.WWRUHJXODWLRQ6X.KDILUP.DQ

XVHUHIXVDOVWRGHDOLQRUGHUWRHYDGHUHJXODWLRQZKRVHYHU\SUHVHQ.HVXJJHVWVWKDWWKHUHLV

DOUHDG\VRPHPDUNHWSRZHUWKDW.RPSHWLWLRQIDLOVWR.RQVWUDLQ

,,5()86$/672'($/(&2120,&$1$/<6,6

7KHUHKDVEHHQDQLQ.UHDVHGH.RQRPL.XQGHUVWDQGLQJRIWKH.LU.XPVWDQ.HVLQZKL.KD

6HH'HQQLV:&DUOWRQDQG$ODQ6)UDQNHO7KH$QWLWUXVW(RQRPLVRI&UHGLW&DUG1HWZRUNV $QWLWUXVW/DZ-RXUQDO YROD'HQQLV:&DUOWRQDQG$ODQ6)UDQNHO7KH$QWLWUXVW(RQRPLVRI&UHGLW&DUG1HWZRUNV5HSO\WR(YDQVDQG6KPDOHQVHH&RPPHQW $QWLWUXVW/DZ-RXUQDO YROE'HQQLV:&DUOWRQDQG$ODQ6)UDQNHO$QWLWUXVWDQG3D\PHQW7HKQRORJLHV5HYLHZ)HGHUDO5HVHUYH%DQNRI6W/RXLV1RYHPEHU'HHPEHUDQG'HQQLV:&DUOWRQDQG6WHYHQ6DORS<RX.HHSRQ.QRNLQJ%XW<RX&DQW&RPH,Q(YDOXDWLQJ5HVWULWLRQVRQ$HVVWR,QSXW-RLQW9HQWXUHV+DUYDUG-RXUQDORI/DZ7H.KQRORJ\ 9ROXPH6XPPHU

7KHSDSHUDYRLGVDQ\GLVXVVLRQRI³HVVHQWLDOIDLOLWLHV´7KDWGRWULQHLVDSXUHO\OHJDORQHSWQRHRQRPLRQHSWRIHVVHQWLDOLW\H[LVWVDVGLVWLQWIURPPDUNHWSRZHULQDQDQDO\VLVRIRPSHWLWLRQ%HDXVH,GRQ¶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



ILUPZRXOGUHIXVHWRGHDOZLWKDQRWKHUILUP,ZLOOGHDOZLWKVHYHUDOGLVWLQ.W.DVHVGHSHQGLQJRQ

ZKHWKHUWKHUHODWLRQEHWZHHQWKHILUPVLVKRUL]RQWDORUYHUWL.DODGLVWLQ.WLRQVRPHWLPHVORVWLQ

.DVHV,ZLOODOVRGLVWLQJXLVKVWDWL.IURPG\QDPL.PRGHOV'\QDPL.PRGHOVDUHHVSH.LDOO\

LPSRUWDQWLQDQDO\]LQJLQGXVWULHVHJ.RPSXWHULQGXVWU\UDSLGO\HYROYLQJRYHUWLPHZKHUHWKHUH

DUHGHSHQGHQ.LHVRYHUWLPH,ZLOODOVRGHV.ULEHKRZDUHIXVDOWRGHDO.DQEHHIIH.WLYHO\

LPSOHPHQWHGE\YDULRXVSUL.HLQ.HQWLYHVWLHLQVDQGLQ.RPSDWLEOHSURGX.WGHVLJQV

,QWKHIROORZLQJGLV.XVVLRQSURGX.W$ZLOOEHWKHSULPDU\SURGX.WRYHUZKL.K)LUPKDV

PDUNHWSRZHU7KHUHZLOOVRPHWLPHVEHD.RPSOHPHQWDU\SURGX.W%WKDW)LUP.DQSURGX.H

'HSHQGLQJRQWKHSDUWL.XODU.DVHRWKHUILUPVPD\EHDEOHWRSURGX.H$RU%RUERWK/HWXV

QRZORRNDWKRZDUHIXVDOWRGHDOE\)LUP.DQDIIH.W.RPSHWLWLRQLQYDULRXV.DVHV

&DVH )LUPDQG)LUPDUHULYDOVLQSURGX.LQJ$7KH\IRUPRU.RQWHPSODWHIRUPLQJDMRLQWYHQWXUHLQRUGHUWRSURGX.HRUPDUNHW$PRUHHIIL.LHQWO\)LUPUHIXVHVWR.RQWLQXHLWVSDUWL.LSDWLRQLQRUWRMRLQWKHMRLQWYHQWXUH

,Q&DVHZKL.KDVZHZLOOVRRQVHH$VSHQILWVLQWRWKHILUPVDUHULYDOVDQGWKHLU

.ROOH.WLYHD.WLRQUDLVHVWKHXVXDOLVVXHVDERXWWKHVXSSUHVVLRQRI.RPSHWLWLRQ7KHMRLQWYHQWXUH

LVOLPLWHGWRWKRVHD.WLYLWLHVQH.HVVDU\WRD.KLHYHHIIL.LHQ.\6RIRUH[DPSOHLIWKHSURGX.WLRQ

MRLQWYHQWXUHLVIRUPHGIRUHIIL.LHQ.\UHDVRQVLWLVQRWQH.HVVDU\IRUWKHSUL.LQJWREH.ROOH.WLYHO\

GHWHUPLQHG,QVWHDGWKHPHPEHUVRIWKHMRLQWYHQWXUH.RXOGEX\RXWSXWDWPDUJLQDO.RVWDQG

WKHQVHWSUL.HVLQGHSHQGHQWO\7KHUHIXVDOWRGHDOLVVXHDULVHVRQO\LQVRIDUDVRQHILUPUHIXVHV

WR.RQWLQXHLWVSDUWL.LSDWLRQLQRUWRMRLQWKHYHQWXUH%XWWKHGH.LVLRQRIDILUPWRSDUWL.LSDWH

PXVWGHSHQGRQWKDWILUP¶VDVVHVVPHQWRILWVJDLQIURPSDUWL.LSDWLQJ,ILWLVLQGHHGHIIL.LHQWIRU

WKHMRLQWYHQWXUHWRH[LVWWKHUHZLOOEHVRPHSD\PHQWVEHWZHHQWKHILUPVWKDWZLOOLQGX.H

6HHHJ-2UGRYHU*6DORQHUDQG66DORS³(TXLOLEULXP9HUWLDO)RUHORVXUH´ $PHUL.DQ(.RQRPL.5HYLHZ 0LKDHO:KLQVWRQ³7\LQJ)RUHORVXUHDQG([OXVLRQ´ $PHUL.DQ(.RQRPL.5HYLHZ (UL5DVPXVVHQ³1DNHG([OXVLRQ´ $PHUL.DQ(.RQRPL.5HYLHZ %'RXJODV%HUQKHLPDQG0LKDHO:KLQVWRQ³([OXVLYH'HDOLQJ´-RXUQDORI3ROLWL.DO(.RQRP\ DQG'HQQLV:&DUOWRQDQG0LKDHO:DOGPDQ³7KH6WUDWHJL8VHRI7\LQJWR3UHVHUYHDQG&UHDWH0DUNHW3RZHULQ(YROYLQJ,QGXVWULHV´:RUNLQJ3DSHU1R*HRUJH-6WLJOHU&HQWHUIRUWKH6WXG\RIWKH(RQRP\DQGWKH6WDWH8QLYHUVLW\RI&KLDJRUHYLVHG0DUK



SDUWL.LSDWLRQ,IVX.KSD\PHQWVGRQ¶WR..XULWLVKDUGWRVHHDMXVWLIL.DWLRQIRUWKH.RXUWVWRIRU.H

SDUWL.LSDWLRQLQWKHMRLQWYHQWXUHVLQ.HRQHRIWKHSDUWLHVZLOOEHPDGHZRUVHRIIE\WKH

SDUWL.LSDWLRQ8VLQJWKH.RXUWVWRLPSURYHWKHEDUJDLQLQJSRVLWLRQRIRQHSDUW\UHODWLYHWR

DQRWKHUZKHQQRDQWLWUXVWLVVXHH[LVWVWRMXVWLI\LQWHUYHQWLRQ.UHDWHVSHUYHUVHLQ.HQWLYHVLQZKL.K

RQHSDUW\PD\SUHIHUWRUHO\RQWKH.RXUWVWR.UHDWHRUSHUSHWXDWHWKHMRLQWYHQWXUHDQGPD\

KRSHWKHUHE\WRJDLQDILQDQ.LDODGYDQWDJHE\UHO\LQJRQWKH.RXUW¶VUH.NRQLQJRID³IDLU´GLYLVLRQ

RISURILWVUDWKHUWKDQRQWKHULJRUVRIPDUNHWSOD.HH.RQRPL.V

6LQ.HDQ\IRU.HGSDUWL.LSDWLRQZRXOGQH.HVVDULO\KDYHWRVHWWKHSUL.HWHUPVWKH.RXUWV

EH.RPHDW\SHRIUHJXODWRU\ERG\VHWWLQJ.RPSOH[WHUPVRIWUDGHDQGHQIRU.LQJ.RRSHUDWLRQLQ

DQDUHDZKHUHXQOLNHDUHJXODWRU\ERG\WKH.RXUWVKDYHQRVSH.LDOH[SHUWLVHDQGZKHUHLILW

ZHUHHIIL.LHQWWRGRVRWKHWZRILUPVKDYHDSULYDWHLQ.HQWLYHWR.RRSHUDWH,QVX.KD.DVHWKH

RQO\RXW.RPHWRH[SH.WIURP.RXUWLQWHUYHQWLRQLVLQHIIL.LHQ.\

&DVH )LUPDQG)LUPERWKSURGX.HDQG.RPSHWHLQSURGX.W$RUYDULDQWVRISURGX.W $)LUPLVWKHGRPLQDQWILUP)LUPUHIXVHVWRGHDOZLWKDQ\.XVWRPHURULQWHUPHGLDU\HJZKROHVDOHUUHWDLOHUWKDWDOVRGHDOVZLWK)LUP

&DVHLVWKH.ODVVL..DVHRIH[.OXVLYHGHDOLQJDVH[HPSOLILHGE\HJ6WDQGDUG

)DVKLRQ,WLVZHOONQRZQWKDWH[.OXVLYHGHDOLQJ.DQEHSUR.RPSHWLWLYHDQG.UHDWHLQ.HQWLYHV

IRU)LUPWRIRUH[DPSOHSURYLGH.XVWRPHUOLVWVSURPRWLRQDOKHOSDQGWUDLQLQJIRULWV

GLVWULEXWRUV:LWKRXWWKHH[.OXVLYLW\)LUP.RXOGXVHWKHVDPHGLVWULEXWRUVWRIUHHULGHRQ)LUP

¶VHIIRUWVGHSULYLQJ)LUPRIWKHIXOOLQ.HQWLYHWRHQJDJHLQVX.KD.WLYLW\+RZHYHULWLVDOVR

.RQWLQXHG)RUDQDQWLWUXVWDQDO\VLVRIMRLQWYHQWXUHVVHH&DUOWRQDQG6DORSVXSUDDW

,IDJHQ\RUPRUDOKD]DUGSUREOHPVSUHYHQWVXKSD\PHQWVIURPEHLQJLPSOHPHQWHGWKHMRLQWYHQWXUHZLOOQRWRXU+RZHYHULQWKLVDVHLWLVRPSOHWHO\XQOHDUZK\DRXUWDQUHDWHDRQWUDWXDOVWUXWXUHWKDWWKHSDUWLHVDQQRW7KHVROXWLRQLVDGLIIHUHQWRUJDQL]DWLRQDOIRUPQRWDRXUWDGPLQLVWHUHGMRLQWYHQWXUH

7KLVLVWKHDVHWKDW5DVPXVVHQVXSUDDWIRXVHVRQ+HVKRZVWKDWHYHQLIXVWRPHUV

RUUHWO\SHUHLYHWKDWH[OXVLYLW\ZLOOKDUPWKHPWKH\ZLOOWKURXJKRPSHWLWLRQZLWKHDKRWKHUEHIRUHGWRDHSWH[OXVLYLW\DQG)LUPZLOONHHSWKHUHVXOWLQJSURILWVIURPWKHPDUNHWSRZHULWUHDWHV6HHDOVR%HUQKHLPDQG:KLQVWRQRSLW

6WDQGDUG)DVKLRQ&RY0DUJUDQH+RXVWRQ&R86

6HHHJ'HQQLV:&DUOWRQDQG-HIIUH\3HUORII0RGHUQ,QGXVWULDO2UJDQL]DWLRQ6RWW)RUHVPDQ



NQRZQWKDWLQWKHSUHVHQ.HRIV.DOHH.RQRPLHVH[.OXVLYHGHDOLQJ.DQEHDZD\RIGHSULYLQJ

)LUPRULWVGLVWULEXWRUVRIWKHQH.HVVDU\V.DOHWRD.KLHYHHIIL.LHQ.LHVHYHQWKRXJKDEVHQW

WKHH[.OXVLYLW\)LUPDQG)LUPZRXOGERWKEHODUJHHQRXJKWRD.KLHYHHIIL.LHQ.\

,QDQWLWUXVW.DVHVLQYROYLQJH[.OXVLYLW\WKH.RXUWV³ZHLJK´WKHKDUPWR.RPSHWLWLRQDJDLQVW

DQ\EHQHILWVWRMXGJHZKHWKHUWKHH[.OXVLYLW\KHOSVRUKDUPV.RQVXPHUV$OWKRXJKWKDWVROXWLRQ

LVHDV\WRVWDWH,DPJHQHUDOO\XQDZDUHRIDWWHPSWVWRTXDQWLWDWLYHO\ZHLJKERWK.RVWVDQG

EHQHILWV,QVWHDG.RXUWVW\SL.DOO\IROORZWKHSDWKRIGH.LGLQJZKHWKHUV.DOHH.RQRPLHVDUH

UHOHYDQWVRWKDWWKH.ODLPRIH[.OXVLRQLVPDWHULDODQGLIVRWKHQILJXUHRXWZKHWKHUWKHID.WV

DOORZWKH.DVHWREHSOD.HGLQWKH.DWHJRU\³QRIUHHULGLQJVLJQLIL.DQWV.DOH³RU³IUHHULGLQJQR

VLJQLIL.DQWV.DOH´,¶PVNHSWL.DORIWKHDELOLW\RI.RXUWVWRGH.LGH.DVHVLQWKH.DWHJRU\

³VLJQLIL.DQWIUHHULGLQJVLJQLIL.DQWV.DOHH.RQRPLHV́ WKRXJK.RQ.HSWXDOO\H.RQRPLVWV.RXOG

SURGX.HTXDQWLWDWLYHHYLGHQ.HWRDLG.RXUWVWRZHLJKWKHWZRHIIH.WV

$OWKRXJKLWPD\VRXQGOLNHH[.OXVLYHGHDOLQJ.DVHVDUHUHODWLYHO\VWUDLJKWIRUZDUGIRU

.RXUWVWRLGHQWLI\DQGGHDOZLWKWKDWLVQRWWKH.DVHRQ.HRQHUHDOL]HVWKDWH[.OXVLYHGHDOLQJ.DQ

EHD.KLHYHGLQZD\VRWKHUWKDQH[SOL.LWSURKLELWLRQE\.RQWUD.W)RUH[DPSOHVXSSRVH)LUP¶V

SURGX.WLVGRPLQDQWDQGWKDWH.RQRPLHVRIV.DOHSUH.OXGHKDYLQJPRUHWKDQRQHGLVWULEXWRUSHU

.LW\)LUPLQVWHDGRIXVLQJH[SOL.LWH[.OXVLYHGHDOLQJVHWVDIL[HG.KDUJHWRHD.KGLVWULEXWRU

SHUKDSVEDVHGRQWKHGLVWULEXWRU¶VWRWDOSRVVLEOHVDOHVRIDOOEUDQGVDQGD]HURPDUJLQDO

.KDUJH*LYHQWKDWE\DVVXPSWLRQHD.KGLVWULEXWRU.DUULHV)LUP¶VSURGX.WHD.KGLVWULEXWRU

ZLOOKDYHDUHGX.HGLQ.HQWLYHWR.DUU\)LUP¶VSURGX.WEH.DXVHWKHGH.LVLRQWR.DUU\)LUP¶V

SURGX.WLV.RPSDUHGQRWDJDLQVWWKHDYHUDJH.RVWRI.DUU\LQJ)LUP¶VSURGX.WEXWDJDLQVWWKH

PDUJLQDO.RVWLHRI.DUU\LQJDGGLWLRQDOXQLWVRI)LUP¶VSURGX.W:LWKRXWDQ\.RQWUD.WXDO

H[.OXVLYLW\GLVWULEXWRUVLQWKHLURZQVHOILQWHUHVW.RXOGUHVSRQGWRWKHQRQOLQHDUSUL.LQJSUL.LQJ

WKDWGHYLDWHVIURP.KDUJLQJD.RQVWDQWSUL.HSHUXQLWRIIHUHGE\)LUPDQGEH.RPHH[.OXVLYHWR

.RQWLQXHG

&RWKLUGHGLWLRQ&K



)LUP7KXVQRQOLQHDUSUL.LQJRURWKHU.RQWUD.WXDOWHUPVOHVVH[WUHPHLQDSSHDUDQ.H

WKDQRXWULJKW.RQWUD.WXDOH[.OXVLYHGHDOLQJ.DQD.KLHYHWKHVDPHHQGVDVH[.OXVLYHGHDOLQJ

2QHDSSURD.KWRGHDOLQJZLWK.RQGX.WVX.KDVQRQOLQHDUSUL.LQJRURWKHU.RQWUD.WXDO

WHUPVWKDWD.KLHYHVH[.OXVLYLW\LVVLPSOHWRVWDWHWUHDW.RQGX.WWKDWD.KLHYHVWKHVDPH

H[.OXVLYLW\DVZRXOG.RQWUD.WXDOH[.OXVLYLW\DVDSRWHQWLDODQWLWUXVWLVVXH$OWKRXJKWKLVPD\

VHHPVHQVLEOHLIWKHJRDOLVWRSUHYHQWKDUPWR.RPSHWLWLRQ,.DXWLRQWKDWLWPD\QRWEHDQGWKDW

LIVX.KDQDSSURD.KLVIROORZHGLWVKRXOGEHXVHGUDUHO\DQGDSSO\RQO\WRH[WUHPHSUL.LQJ

.RQGLWLRQVVX.KDVWKHSUHYLRXVH[DPSOHZKHUHWKHPDUJLQDOSUL.HZDV]HURZKHUHPDUJLQDO

SUL.LQJEHORZPDUJLQDO.RVWLVXQDPELJXRXV2QHUHDVRQWKDWLWPD\QRWEHVHQVLEOHLVWKDW

YROXPHGLV.RXQWVDUHXELTXLWRXVLQ.RPPHU.HDVDUHVSH.LDOGHDOVIRUELJEX\HUV6X.KQRQ

OLQHDUSUL.LQJ.DQUHIOH.WUHDOH.RQRPL.VDYLQJVWKDWDUHGLIIL.XOWWRPHDVXUHORZHULQYHQWRU\

.RVWVSURPRWLRQDORUSURGX.WLRQ.RVWVRUVLPSO\PD\EHZD\VWKDWILUPV.KRRVHWR.RPSHWHIRU

WKHPRVWGHVLUDEOH.XVWRPHUV$WWD.NLQJVX.K.RPPRQ.RPSHWLWLYHEHKDYLRUZRXOGOLNHO\.UHDWH

PX.KWXUPRLODQG.KLOO.RPSHWLWLRQ

2QHPD\EHLQ.OLQHGWRHYDOXDWHQRQOLQHDUSUL.LQJHJSUL.HGLV.RXQWVDORQJ

WUDGLWLRQDOJURXQGVWKDWJRYHUQSUL.HSUHGDWLRQ.DVHV7KDWLVLIWKHLQ.UHPHQWDOSUL.HRIWKHODVW

XQLWWRWKH.RQVXPHULVEHORZPDUJLQDO.RVWVWKHSUL.LQJLVVXEMH.WWRIXUWKHULQTXLU\%XWWKUHH

SUREOHPVSODJXHWKDWDQDO\VLV)LUVWLQWKLVVWDWL.PRGHOSUHGDWLRQPDNHVQRVHQVHVR

DQDORJLHVEDVHGRQLWDUHWHQXRXV6H.RQGLWLVZHOONQRZQWKDW.DO.XODWLQJPDUJLQDO.RVWVIURP

D..RXQWLQJGDWDLVGLIIL.XOWVRLWPD\QRWEHVRHDV\WRGHWHUPLQHLIWKHLQ.UHPHQWDOSUL.H

H[.HHGVPDUJLQDO.RVWV7KLUGDQGSHUKDSVPRVWLPSRUWDQWWKHDQDO\VWPD\QRWREVHUYHD

SUL.HV.KHGXOHDVDIXQ.WLRQRIYROXPHDQGPD\KDYHWRLQIHULWIURPREVHUYDWLRQVRISUL.H

7KH'HSDUWPHQWRI-XVWLHDVHDJDLQVW0LURVRIWZDVORVHGEDVHGRQDRQVHQWGHUHHIRUELGGLQJ0LURVRIWIURPXVLQJVXKRQWUDWV.LWH

6HH:LOODUG7KRP'DYLG%DOWRDQG1HLO$YHULWW³$QWLRPSHWLWLYH$VSHWVRI0DUNHW6KDUH'LVRXQWVDQG2WKHU,QHQWLYHVWR([OXVLYH'HDOLQJ´ $QWLWUXVW/DZ-RXUQDOIRUDQDQDO\VLVRIKRZYDULRXVRQWUDWXDOWHUPVRQSULLQJDQGSHQDOW\ODXVHVDQDGYHUVHO\DIIHWRPSHWLWLRQE\UHDWLQJSDUWLDOH[OXVLYLW\6HHDOVR5RQDOG'DYLV³3ULLQJ:LWK6WULQJV$WWDKHG$W6HDLQ



D.URVVEX\HUVRIGLIIHUHQWVL]HV%XWLWLVZHOONQRZQWKDWLQPRGHOVWKDWGHYLDWHIURPSHUIH.W

.RPSHWLWLRQELJEX\HUV.DQREWDLQDPX.KORZHUSUL.HWKDQVPDOOEX\HUV6RIRUH[DPSOHD

EX\HURIXQLWPD\SD\ZKLOHDEX\HURIXQLWVPD\SD\RQO\SHUXQLW6XSSRVHWKDW

PDUJLQDO.RVWLVDQGWKDWD³ELJEX\HU´.DQYHUWL.DOO\LQWHJUDWHIRUDVXQN.RVWRI7KH

SUL.HWRWKHODUJHEX\HULV.OHDUO\DERYHPDUJLQDO.RVW\HWWKHLPSOLHGLQ.UHPHQWDOSUL.HWKDWWKH

DQDO\VW.DO.XODWHVIURPSUL.HGDWDD.URVVEX\HUVLVIRUXQLWSDLGLQWRWDOIRU

XQLWV$WWHPSWVWRLQIHUDQWLWUXVWOLDELOLW\EDVHGRQTXDQWLW\GLV.RXQWVLQIHUUHGIURPSUL.HVD.URVV

EX\HUVRIGLIIHUHQWVL]HV.RXOGOHDGWRWKHSH.XOLDUUHVXOWRILQKLELWLQJ.RPSHWLWLRQIRUWKHODUJH

EX\HUV7KH.RQVHTXHQ.HZRXOGEHPX.KOLNHWKH5RELQVRQ3DWPDQ$.WWR.KLOOSUL.H

.RPSHWLWLRQE\LPSRVLQJSUL.HXQLIRUPLW\D.URVV.XVWRPHUV,IDQWLWUXVWGRHVSXUVXH.RQWUD.WV

WKDW.UHDWHGHID.WRH[.OXVLYLW\LWZRXOGEHZLVHWROLPLWDWWHQWLRQWRWKRVH.RQWUD.WVZLWKH[WUHPH

SUL.LQJWHUPVOLNHWKRVHRIWKH0L.URVRIWW\SHZKHUHLWLVXQDPELJXRXVWKDWLQ.UHPHQWDOSUL.HLV

EHORZPDUJLQDO.RVWIRUPDQ\EX\HUV ([.OXVLYLW\D.KLHYHGWKURXJKQRQSUL.LQJWHUPVHJ

.RQWUD.WXDOSURYLVLRQVDIIH.WLQJGHDOLQJVZLWKRWKHUSDUWLHVVKRXOGDOVREHWUHDWHG.DXWLRXVO\

XQGHUDUXOHRIUHDVRQVLQ.HRIWHQVX.KSURYLVLRQV.DQJHQHUDWHHIIL.LHQ.LHV

.RQWLQXHG

&RQRUG%RDWDQG/H3DJH¶V´ $QWLWUXVW 6XPPHU1RWLHWKDWQRQOLQHDUSULLQJXQUHODWHGWRRVWVDYLQJVDQRQO\RXULIEX\HUVGRQRWHQJDJHLQDUELWUDJH,QVXKDDVHWKHH[DPSOHVKRZVZK\LWLVLPSURSHUWRLQIHULQUHPHQWDOSULHIURPDQDQDO\VLVRISULHDURVVEX\HUV,IDUELWUDJHLVSRVVLEOHWKHQWKHUHZLOOEHQRGHWHWDEOHGLIIHUHQHVLQLQUHPHQWDOSULHDVDIXQWLRQRIYROXPHDIWHUDGMXVWLQJIRURVWGLIIHUHQHV

,Q&RQRUG%RDW&RUSHWDOY%UXQVZLN86$SS/H[LVWKHRXUWVKRZHGDJUHDWUHOXWDQHWRHTXDWHQRQOLQHDUSULLQJZLWKH[OXVLYLW\,Q%DUU\:ULJKW&RUSY,77*ULQQHOO&RUSHWDO)G)LUVW&LUWKHRXUWUXOHGWKDWGLVRXQWVZHUHDOORZDEOHDVORQJDVWKH

GLVRXQWHGSULHH[HHGHGERWKDYHUDJHDQGPDUJLQDORVW7KHRXUWGLGQRWXVHLQUHPHQWDOSULHLPSOLHGE\RPSDULQJWKHH[WUDKDUJHIRUWKHLQUHPHQWDOYROXPHDQGHORTXHQWO\GHVULEHVWKHGLIILXOWLHVRIRQGHPQLQJEHKDYLRUWKDWLVJHQHUDOO\SURRPSHWLWLYH$VDJHQHUDOWKHRUHWLDOPDWWHULWPD\EHSRVVLEOHWRRQHLYHRIPRGHOVZKHUHDERYHRVWSULLQJLVDQWLRPSHWLWLYHEXWLGHQWLI\LQJVXKDVHVPD\EHKDUG7KH%URRNH*URXS/WGY%URZQ:LOOLDPVRQ7REDR&RUS86LGHQWLI\LQJDQWLRPSHWLWLYHDERYHRVWSULLQJLV³EH\RQGWKHSUDWLDODELOLW\RIDMXGLLDOWULEXQDOZLWKRXWRXUWLQJLQWROHUDEOHULVNVRIKLOOLQJOHJLWLPDWHSULHXWWLQJ´

([OXVLYLW\LVRIRXUVHQRWWKHNH\LVVXH,WLVWKDWWKHRVWRIREWDLQLQJHIILLHQWGLVWULEXWLRQRURWKHULQSXWVLVUDLVHGIRUDULYDOWKXVLPSDLULQJWKHRPSHWLWLYHHIIHWLYHQHVVRIWKHULYDOZLWKDUHVXOWLQJKDUPWRRPSHWLWLRQ



&DVHD )LUPLVDPRQRSROLVWRISURGX.W$DQGDOVR.RPSHWHVZLWK)LUPLQWKHVDOHRISURGX.W%3URGX.W$LVDQLQSXWRUDQLPSRUWDQW.RPSOHPHQWWRSURGX.W%IRUDOO.RQVXPHUV)LUPUHIXVHVWRGHDOZLWKHJVHOO$WR)LUP

7KLV.DVHZKL.KDVH[SODLQHGLQ6H.WLRQ,9RGDNEHORQJVWRKDVWKHVWULNLQJIHDWXUH

WKDWWKRXJK)LUPDQG)LUPDSSHDUWR.RPSHWHWKHULYDOU\LVLOOXVLRQDU\7KHUHDVRQLVWKH

DVVXPHGPRQRSRO\SRZHURI)LUPLQSURGX.W$7KDWSRZHUSUHVXPDEO\DOORZVLWWRVHWWKH

SUL.HIRU$DWDQ\OHYHORUWRXVHDQ\.RQWUD.WXDOPH.KDQLVPLWZDQWVWRVHOO$LQ.OXGLQJQRQ

OLQHDUSUL.LQJ,DPDVVXPLQJWKHPRQRSROLVW.DQHQJDJHLQSUL.HGLV.ULPLQDWLRQDEVHQWWKHWLH

,GLV.XVVEHORZWKH.DVHZKHUHWKHWLH.UHDWHVWKHDELOLW\WR>[email protected])LUPLV

DOUHDG\DWWKHPHU.\RI)LUP)LUPWKHUHIRUHJDLQVQRWKLQJE\WKHHOLPLQDWLRQRI)LUPLQWKH

.RPSHWLWLRQIRU%7KLVLVEH.DXVHLW.DQDOUHDG\H[WUD.WDOOWKHSURILWVRI)LUPWKURXJKSUL.LQJ

RI$,I)LUPKDSSHQVWREHPRUHHIIL.LHQWWKDQ)LUPLQWKHSURGX.WLRQRISURGX.W%WKHQ

)LUPKDVDQLQ.HQWLYHWRLQGX.H)LUPWREHWKHVROHVXSSOLHURISURGX.WEXWQRWWRDOORZ

)LUPWRSUL.HSURGX.W%DWDPRQRSRO\OHYHOWRDYRLGWKHXVXDOGRXEOHPDUJLQDOL]DWLRQ

SUREOHPDQG)LUPZLOOKDYHDQLQ.HQWLYHWRD..HSWVX.KDQRIIHU7KHNH\LQVLJKWLVWKDWD

UHIXVDOWRGHDOE\)LUPUDLVHVQRDQWLWUXVWLVVXHVLQ.HWKHUHLVQRDGGLWLRQDOPDUNHWSRZHUIRU

)LUPWRD.KLHYHE\HOLPLQDWLRQRIDQHTXDOO\HIIL.LHQWULYDOLQSURGX.W%

1RZ.RQVLGHUWKH.DVHLQZKL.KWKHWLHDOORZVWKHILUPWRSUD.WL.HSUL.HGLV.ULPLQDWLRQ

WKDWZRXOGQRWRWKHUZLVHEHSRVVLEOH6XSSRVHSURGX.W%LVGLVWULEXWLRQVHUYL.HVIRUSURGX.W$

DQGVXSSRVHWKDWWKHUHDUHWZRJURXSVRI.XVWRPHUV)LUPVHOOVWRRQHVHWRI.XVWRPHUVDQG

)LUPWKHPDQXID.WXUHURISURGX.W$VHOOVWRDQRWKHU7KLVW\SHRI.LU.XPVWDQ.HRIWHQDULVHV

ZKHQDPDQXID.WXUHUVHOOVGLUH.WWRVRPH.XVWRPHUVEXWUHOLHVRQGLVWULEXWRUVWRVHOOWRRWKHU

.XVWRPHUV6XSSRVHIXUWKHUWKDWWKHSUL.HVWRWKHWZRVHWVRI.XVWRPHUVDUHGLIIHUHQWVRWKDW

7KLVSRLQWKDVQRWKLQJWRGRZLWKZKHWKHU$DQG%DUHXVHGLQIL[HGSURSRUWLRQV,WRQO\KDVWRGRZLWKWKHDVVXPHGDELOLW\RIDPRQRSROLVWRI$WRSULH$DVKHVHHVILWSHUKDSVXVLQJQRQXQLIRUPSULLQJ,QVXKDVHWWLQJ)LUP¶VSURGXWLRQRI%JXDUDQWHHVWKDW)LUPDQHDUQRQO\DRPSHWLWLYHUHWXUQ7KLVSRLQWLVUHODWHGWRWKHVRDOOHG³&KLDJR´DSSURDKVHHHJ5LKDUG3RVQHUDQG)UDQN(DVWHUEURRN$QWLWUXVW:HVW3XEOLVKLQJ&RQGHGS



)LUPLVHVVHQWLDOO\XVLQJ)LUPWRHQJDJHLQSUL.HGLV.ULPLQDWLRQZLWKWKHSUL.HWRWKH

.XVWRPHUVRI)LUPKLJKHUWKDQRI)LUP¶V.XVWRPHUV7KHUHDUHQRXQDPELJXRXVQHJDWLYH

.RQVHTXHQ.HVRISUL.HGLV.ULPLQDWLRQDQGDV,XQGHUVWDQGWKHDQWLWUXVWODZV)LUP¶VD.WLRQV

DUHSHUIH.WO\ODZIXO6XSSRVHKRZHYHUWKDW)LUPGLV.RYHUVWKHSUL.LQJGLV.UHSDQ.\RU

.RQGLWLRQV.KDQJHVRWKDW)LUPEHJLQVWRHQJDJHLQDUELWUDJHE\VHOOLQJWR)LUP¶V.XVWRPHUV

DQGWKHUHE\SUHYHQWV)LUPIURPHQJDJLQJLQSUL.HGLV.ULPLQDWLRQ)LUPUHVSRQGVE\UHIXVLQJ

WRVXSSO\)LUPDQGSHUIRUPLQJDOOGLVWULEXWLRQLWVHOIWKHUHE\DOORZLQJLWWRUHVWRUHWKHSUHYLRXV

SUL.LQJDUUDQJHPHQW6KRXOGWKLVUHIXVDOWRGHDOEHGHHPHGDYLRODWLRQRIWKHDQWLWUXVWODZV

DVVXPLQJWKHJRDOLVWRSUHYHQWKDUPWR.RPSHWLWLRQ"1RIRUDWOHDVWWZRUHDVRQV

)LUVWLWLVZHOONQRZQWKDWWKHWKHRUHWL.DOHIIH.WVRISUL.HGLV.ULPLQDWLRQRQVR.LDOZHOIDUH

DUHDPELJXRXV7KHDELOLW\WRSUD.WL.HVRPHSUL.HGLV.ULPLQDWLRQGRHVQRWQH.HVVDULO\RU

JHQHUDOO\ORZHUVR.LDOZHOIDUHLQGHHGZHNQRZWKDWSHUIH.WSUL.HGLV.ULPLQDWLRQOHDGVWR

HIIL.LHQWRXW.RPHV6H.RQGLISUL.HGLV.ULPLQDWLRQZHUHWR.UHDWHDQWLWUXVWOLDELOLW\WKHQLWVKRXOG

GRVRHYHQLI)LUPGLGQRWH[LVWDQGRQO\)LUPGLVWULEXWHGWKHSURGX.W%XWDV,¶YHH[SODLQHG

HDUOLHUGLIIHUHQWSUL.HVWRGLIIHUHQW.RQVXPHUVDUHDXELTXLWRXVID.WRIRXUH.RQRP\DQGLWLVQRW

IHDVLEOHQRULQOLJKWRILWVZHOIDUHSURSHUWLHVGHVLUDEOHWREDQLW7RUH.RJQL]HKRZZLGHVSUHDG

SUL.HGLV.ULPLQDWLRQLVMXVWWKLQNRIDOOWKH.RXSRQVDQGUHEDWHVRQHJHWVGDLO\LQWKHPDLO

QHZVSDSHURUMXVWZDONLQJGRZQWKHDLVOHRIDQ\ODUJHVWRUH,W¶VKDUGWRLPDJLQHWDNLQJWKH

SRVLWLRQWKDWWKRVHGLV.RXQWVYLRODWHWKHDQWLWUXVWODZ%XWWKHQWKDWVDPHORJL.PXVWDOVRDSSO\

WR)LUPLQLWVGHDOLQJVZLWK)LUPLQWKLV&DVHD

&DVHE 6DPHDV&DVHDEXWQRZSURGX.WV$DQG%DUHQRW.RPSOHPHQWVIRUVRPH.RQVXPHUVDQGWKHUHDUHV.DOHH.RQRPLHVLQWKHSURGX.WLRQRI%

7KHQHZIHDWXUHRI&DVHE.RPSDUHGWR&DVHDLVWKDW)LUP.DQ.RPSHWHDJDLQVW

)LUPDQGKDYHDQLQGHSHQGHQWHIIH.WRQ.RPSHWLWLRQIRUWKRVHVXEVHWRI.XVWRPHUVZKRGRQ¶W

7RDYRLG5RELQVRQ3DWPDQLVVXHVDVVXPHWKDWRQVXPHUVDUHILQDORQVXPHUVZKRSHUVRQDOO\RQVXPHWKHSURGXW



GHVLUH)LUP¶VSURGX.W$,I)LUPHQMR\HG.RQVWDQWUHWXUQVWRV.DOHWKHQ)LUPZRXOGEH

.RPSOHWHO\LQVXODWHGIURPD.WLRQVRI)LUP%XWLQWKHSUHVHQ.HRIV.DOHRUV.RSHH.RQRPLHV

LWLVSRVVLEOHWKDW)LUP.DQLPSDLU)LUP¶VDELOLW\WR.RPSHWH7KLVLQVLJKWLVSULPDULO\GXHWR

:KLQVWRQ

7RVHHKRZDUHIXVDOWRGHDO.RXOGKDUP.RPSHWLWLRQLPDJLQHLQLWLDOO\KRZSUL.HVZRXOG

EHVHW)LUPZRXOGZDQWWRPDNHVXUHWKDW)LUPGLGQRWHDUQUHQWVRQVDOHVWR.XVWRPHUV

ZKRGHVLUH)LUP¶VSURGX.WVPX.KDVLQ&DVHD6XSSRVH)LUPUHIXVHVWRVHOOSURGX.W$

WRDQ\.XVWRPHUZKR.RQVXPHVSURGX.W%IURP)LUP7KLV.DXVHV)LUP¶VV.DOHWRGURS

EHORZDQH.RQRPL.DOO\HIIL.LHQWV.DOHDQG)LUPOHDYHVWKHPDUNHWIRUSURGX.W%7KLVPHDQV

WKDW.XVWRPHUVWKDWZDQWRQO\SURGX.W%QRZID.HDPRQRSROLVW)LUPDQGWKH\VXIIHUDKDUP

IURPWKHUHGX.HG.RPSHWLWLRQ7RIL[LGHDVLPDJLQHDPRQRSRO\UHVRUWKRWHORQDQLVODQGZKHUH

KRWHOZRUNHUVOLYH%\UHTXLULQJWKDWKRWHOJXHVWVHDWRQO\LQWKHKRWHOWKHKRWHOPD\SUHYHQW

RWKHUUHVWDXUDQWVIURPGHYHORSLQJWKDWZRXOGRWKHUZLVHVHUYHERWKWRXULVWVDQGQDWLYHV

$OWKRXJKWKHWRXULVWVZHUHDOUHDG\VXEMH.WWRWKHPRQRSRO\SRZHURIWKHKRWHOWKURXJKWKHURRP

UDWHQDWLYHVZHUHQRWDQGKHQ.HDUHKDUPHGE\WKHUHGX.WLRQLQ.RPSHWLWLRQ1RWHWKHVSH.LDO

IHDWXUHVUHTXLUHGIRUDKDUPWR.RPSHWLWLRQV.DOHH.RQRPLHV.RPELQHGZLWKDJURXSRI

.RQVXPHUVWKDWGHVLUHRQO\SURGX.W%

$VEHIRUHWKLVH[.OXVLYLW\.DQEHD.KLHYHGWKURXJK.RQWUD.WXDOPHDQVRWKHUWKDQH[SOL.LW

H[.OXVLYHGHDOLQJ7KHVLPSOHVWZD\ZRXOGEHIRUWKHKRWHOWREXQGOHWKHUHVWDXUDQWZLWKWKH

URRPVRWKDWRQ.HRQWKHLVODQGWKHPDUJLQDO.RVWWRDWRXULVWRIDKRWHOPHDOLV]HUR,QDQRWKHU

VHWWLQJWKHWLHLQ.RXOGEHD.KLHYHGWKURXJKSURGX.WGHVLJQEXQGOLQJD.KLHYHGHLWKHUWKURXJK

H[SOL.LW.RQWUD.WDVLQWKHKRWHOUHVWDXUDQWH[DPSOHRUWKURXJKWKHLQWURGX.WLRQRISURGX.W

GHVLJQLQ.RPSDWLELOLWLHVVRWKDWWKRVHZKREX\$DQGZDQWWRXVH%ZLWKLWPXVWEX\%IURP)LUP

RWKHUZLVHSURGX.W%LVXVHOHVV

0LKDHO:KLQVWRQVXSUDDW



&DVH'\QDPL.0RGHOV:LWK&RPSHWLWLRQLQ3URGX.WV$DQG%

7KHILQDO.ODVVRIPRGHOV,GLV.XVVDUHG\QDPL.RQHVZLWKWKHSRVVLELOLW\RI.RPSHWLWLRQLQ

DOOSURGX.WV,WLVWKHLQWURGX.WLRQRI.RPSHWLWLRQLQERWKSURGX.WV$DQG%WKDWOHDGVWR

XQGHUVWDQGLQJVRPHRIWKHPRWLYHVIRU.HUWDLQH[.OXVLRQDU\.RQGX.WWKDW&DVHPLVVHVDQGLW

LVWKHG\QDPL.QDWXUHRIWKHPRGHOVWKDWOHDGVWRUHDOLVWL.DSSOL.DWLRQVDQGQHZLQVLJKWVLQWR

EHKDYLRULQWKH,%0DQG0L.URVRIW.DVHV 0DQ\LQGXVWULHVWKDWKDYHEHHQDWWD.NHGRQ

DQWLWUXVWJURXQGVDUHUDSLGO\.KDQJLQJDQGKDYHG\QDPL.LQWHUGHSHQGHQ.LHVWKDW.UHDWH

LQWHUHVWLQJLQ.HQWLYHVQRWSUHVHQWLQDVWDWL.PRGHOIRUUHIXVDOVWRGHDO7KHNH\LQVLJKWRIWKLV

.ODVVRIPRGHOVLVWKDWD.WLRQVWRGD\WKDWNHHS)LUPVPDOO.DQEHQHILW)LUPODWHU7KHZHOO

VWXGLHGPRGHOVRISUL.HSUHGDWLRQHPHUJHDVRQHSRVVLEOHVWUDWHJ\LQWKHVHG\QDPL.PRGHOV

3HUKDSVPRUHUHOHYDQWLQOLJKWRIWKHUHODWLYHDEVHQ.HRIHPSLUL.DOHYLGHQ.HRISUHGDWLRQDVD

VX..HVVIXOVWUDWHJ\LVWKHREVHUYDWLRQWKDWLQDG\QDPL.PRGHOWKH.RVWRIEHLQJVPDOOLQLWLDOO\

.DQEHPDJQLILHGLQODWHUSHULRGVHVSH.LDOO\ZLWKDVVXPSWLRQVDERXWQHWZRUNGHSHQGHQ.LHV

LPSRUWDQ.HRILQVWDOOHGEDVHRUV.DOHH.RQRPLHV,QWKRVHVHWWLQJVVWUDWHJL.EHKDYLRUGHVLJQHG

WRNHHSDULYDOVPDOOLQLWLDOO\.DQ\LHOGODWHUVLJQLIL.DQW.RPSHWLWLYHDGYDQWDJH,WLVWKHVH

G\QDPL..DVHVLQWRZKL.KWKH0L.URVRIWDQG,%0.DVHVILW

&RQVLGHUILUVWWKHG\QDPL.YHUVLRQRIWKHSUHYLRXV&DVHD6XSSRVHWKDWLQLWLDOO\)LUP

LVDPRQRSROLVWRI$DQGDOVRSURGX.HVD.RPSOHPHQWDU\SURGX.W%)LUP.DQDOVRSURGX.HD

YHUVLRQRISURGX.W%ZKL.KKDVVRPHVXSHULRUSURSHUWLHVHJEHWWHUTXDOLW\ORZHUSURGX.WLRQ

.RVWWRWKHYHUVLRQRISURGX.W%SURGX.HGE\)LUP,WZRXOGVHHPDQGLQGHHGLWLVVRWKDW

)LUPZRXOGEHGHOLJKWHGWRUHO\RQ)LUPWRSURGX.HLWVVXSHULRUSURGX.W%EH.DXVHWKDWZLOO

PDNHSURGX.W$PRUHYDOXDEOH,QVX.K.LU.XPVWDQ.HV)LUPZRXOGQRWWU\WRGHVWUR\)LUP

.RQWLQXHG,WKDQN5*HUWQHUIRUWKLVH[DPSOH

6HHHJ86Y,%0'RNHW1R&,96'1<DQG86Y0LURVRIW)6XSSG''&6HH&DUOWRQDQG:DOGPDQVXSUDDWIRUDGHWDLOHGGLVXVVLRQRIVWUDWHJLEHKDYLRULQYROYLQJWLHLQVDOHVLQG\QDPLPRGHOV



RUUHVWUL.W)LUP¶VVL]H7KLVLVH[D.WO\WKHDQDORJRXVUHVXOWWR&DVHDDERYH7KHVDPH

UHVXOWV.RQWLQXHWRKROGLQDG\QDPL.YHUVLRQRIWKHPRGHOZLWKLQWHUWHPSRUDOOLQNDJHV.DXVHG

HLWKHUE\V.DOHV.RSHHIIH.WVRUQHWZRUNHIIH.WV%\V.DOHV.RSHHIIH.WV,PHDQWKDWWKH

DYHUDJH.RVWRISURGX.LQJDJJUHJDWHRXWSXWRYHUWLPHIDOOVZLWKRXWSXWHJWRWDO.RVW

RXWSXWLQSHULRGRXWSXWLQSHULRG%\QHWZRUNHIIH.WV,PHDQWKDWWKHGHVLUDELOLW\WRD

.RQVXPHURIDSDUWL.XODUYHUVLRQRISURGX.W%GHSHQGVRQKRZPDQ\RWKHU.RQVXPHUVXVHWKDW

YHUVLRQ)RUH[DPSOHLISURGX.W%LVZRUGSUR.HVVLQJVRIWZDUHD.RQVXPHUSUHIHUVWKH

VLWXDWLRQZKHUHRWKHUSHRSOHXVHWKHH[D.WVDPHZRUGSUR.HVVLQJSURJUDPUDWKHUWKDQDQRWKHU

ZRUGSUR.HVVLQJSURJUDPEH.DXVHLWPDNHVLWHDVLHUWRVKDUHILOHVRUWUDQVPLWGR.XPHQWVWR

RWKHUV

1RZOHWXV.KDQJHWKHPRGHODQGLQWURGX.HWKHSRVVLELOLW\RI.RPSHWLWLRQIRUSURGX.W$LQ

IXWXUHSHULRGVDQGLQWURGX.HHLWKHUV.DOHH.RQRPLHVRUQHWZRUNHIIH.WVIRUSURGX.W%&DOOWKLV

&DVH7KHNH\LQVLJKWLVWKDW)LUP.DQXVHLWVKHDGVWDUWDVWKHLQLWLDOPRQRSROLVWRISURGX.W

$WRKDUPIXWXUH.RPSHWLWRUVLQSURGX.W$E\GHSULYLQJWKHPRIDVRXU.HRIWKH.RPSOHPHQWDU\

SURGX.W%%\UHIXVLQJWREX\SURGX.W%IURP)LUP)LUP.DQNHHS)LUPDWDQLQHIIL.LHQWO\

VPDOOV.DOHDQG)LUP.DQWKHUHE\SUHYHQWD.RPSHWLWRULQ$IURPHIIH.WLYHO\.RPSHWLQJ

DJDLQVWLWLQWKHIXWXUH5HPHPEHUWKDWLIIXWXUH.RPSHWLWLRQWR)LUPLQSURGX.W$GLGQRWH[LVW

ZHZRXOGEHLQDG\QDPL.YHUVLRQRI&DVHDDQGWKHUHZRXOGEHQRUHDVRQIRU)LUPWRZDQW

WRKDUP)LUP7KHZD\VWKDW)LUP.DQUHIXVHWRGHDOZLWK)LUPIRUSURGX.W%DUHH[D.WO\

WKHVDPHDVEHIRUHHJH[.OXVLYHGHDOLQJWLHLQVDOHVRI%WR$.RQWUD.WXDOSURYLVLRQVWKDW

SURYLGHLQ.HQWLYHVIRUGHID.WRH[.OXVLYLW\SURGX.WGHVLJQWKDWPDNHV)LUP¶VSURGX.W%

LQ.RPSDWLEOHZLWK)LUP$¶VSURGX.W$OORIWKHVHEHKDYLRUVVHUYHWKHVDPHJRDOWRLQLWLDOO\NHHS

)LUPVRVPDOOLQLWVSURGX.WLRQRI%WKDWLWLVQRWDQHIIH.WLYHVXSSOLHURISURGX.W%WR

.RPSHWLWRUVWR)LUPLQSURGX.W$ODWHURQ

,WLVSRVVLEOHWRRQVWUXWDVWDWLYHUVLRQRI&DVH,QWKDWVWDWLYHUVLRQ)LUPSURGXHV$DQG%



7RJLYHD.RQ.UHWHH[DPSOHVXSSRVHWKDWDPRQRSROLVWRIRSHUDWLQJV\VWHPVLQLWLDOO\WLHV

DSSOL.DWLRQSURJUDPVWRLWVV\VWHPWRSUHYHQWQHZDSSOL.DWLRQVSURJUDPVIURPGHYHORSLQJ,Q

VXEVHTXHQWSHULRGVHQWU\RIQHZRSHUDWLQJV\VWHPVZRXOGR..XULIWKHUHH[LVWHGDVWR.NRI

LQGHSHQGHQWDSSOL.DWLRQSURJUDPV%XWE\DVVXPSWLRQVX.KSURJUDPVGRQ¶WH[LVWEH.DXVH

)LUPSUHYHQWHGWKHLUGHYHORSPHQWE\IRUH.ORVLQJWKHLQLWLDOPDUNHWWRWKHP)RUVX.KPRGHOV

WRKDYHHPSLUL.DOUHOHYDQ.HWKHGLVDGYDQWDJHWKDW)LUP.DQLPSRVHRQ)LUPVKRXOGEHODUJH

UHODWLYHWRWKHWLPHLWWDNHV)LUPWRRYHU.RPHWKHGLVDGYDQWDJH6RIRUH[DPSOHLISURGX.WV

.KDQJHVORZO\LWZLOOEHKDUGHUIRU)LUPWRKDUP)LUPEH.DXVHWKHUHZLOOEHDORQJSHULRG

ZKHQ.RPSHWLWRUVWR)LUPH[LVWUHPHPEHUWKHLQLWLDOPRQRSRO\RI)LUPODVWVRQO\SHULRG

DQGWKHUHIRUHDORQJWLPHIRU)LUPWRRYHU.RPHDQ\GLVDGYDQWDJHLQSURGX.W%.DXVHGE\DQ

LQLWLDOV.DOHUHGX.WLRQ

7KHUHVXOWVRI&DVHDUHDWRQ.HERWKQRYHODQGLQWXLWLYH,WSXWVWUDGLWLRQDODQWLWUXVW

SROL.\RQDPX.KPRUHVROLGIRRWLQJWKDQSUHYLRXVWKHRULHVLQYROYLQJUHIXVDOVWRGHDODLPHGDWD

.RPSOHPHQWDU\SURGX.W7KHRQO\VHQVLEOHWKHRU\:KLQVWRQ¶VWKHRU\WKDW.RXOGEHXVHGWR

DWWD.NH[.OXVLRQDU\.RQGX.WDLPHGDWSURGX.W%ZDV&DVHEWKHUHVWDXUDQWH[DPSOHDQG

WKDWWKHRU\H[SODLQVKRZWKH.RQGX.W.UHDWHVPDUNHWSRZHULQ%UHVWDXUDQWV,Q.RQWUDVWWKH

WKHRU\LQ&DVHH[SODLQVKRZH[.OXVLRQDU\.RQGX.WDLPHGDWSURGX.W%SUHVHUYHVPDUNHW

SRZHULQSURGX.W$,WLVD.HQWUDOLQVLJKWWKDW.DQH[SODLQZK\LWLVWKDWVRPHILUPVWKDWDUH

LQLWLDOO\GRPLQDQWZLOOUHPDLQVRHYHQZKHQWKHDV\PPHWU\WKDWD..RXQWHGIRUWKHLULQLWLDO

GRPLQDQ.HHJSDWHQWHDUO\HQWU\GLVDSSHDUVRQO\WREHUHSOD.HGE\DQHZDV\PPHWU\

.RQWLQXHG

)LUPSURGXHV%ZLWKVDOHHRQRPLHVDQG)LUPSURGXHV$¶DYDULDQWRI$)LUPXVHVDUHIXVDOWRGHDOZLWK)LUPWRNHHSLWLQHIILLHQWO\VPDOOVRDVWRSUHYHQW)LUPIURPKDYLQJDQHIILLHQWVXSSO\VRXUHWKHUHE\GHSULYLQJRQVXPHUVRI$¶DQG%,QWKLVPRGHOWKHUHIXVDOWRGHDOGRHVQRWDRPSOLVKPXKLIPDQ\SHRSOHGHPDQG$¶EHDXVHWKHQ)LUPDQDKLHYHWKHQHHVVDU\VDOHHRQRPLHVHYHQLILWPDNHVVDOHVRQO\WRRQVXPHUVRI$¶ZKLOHLIIHZGHPDQG$¶WKHQWKHUHIXVDOWRGHDOGRHVQRWDXVHPXKKDUPWRRPSHWLWLRQ7KHDGYDQWDJHVRIWKHG\QDPLPRGHODUHWKDWDVZHZLOOVRRQVHHLWDSSOLHVUHDGLO\WRDQGLVDPRUHUHDOLVWLGHVULSWLRQWKDQWKHVWDWLPRGHORIVRPHLPSRUWDQWLQGXVWULHV7KHPRGHORI2UGRYHUHWDOVXSUDDWSUHVHQWVDORVHO\UHODWHGVWDWLPRGHOZKHUHWKHDGYDQWDJHWR)LUPGHULYHVIURPLWVDELOLW\WRIRUH)LUPWRIDHPDUNHWSRZHULQ



.DXVHGE\WKHLUVWUDWHJL.EHKDYLRUWKDWH[SORLWHGWLPHLQWHUGHSHQGHQ.LHV$ILUPZLWKDKHDG

VWDUWVWD\VDKHDG

%XWWKHPRGHOVRI&DVHKDYHDQHYHQPRUHVWULNLQJLPSOL.DWLRQ,W.DQH[SODLQKRZ

)LUP.DQUHPDLQGRPLQDQWHYHQLISURGX.W$.KDQJHVGUDPDWL.DOO\RYHUWLPH,WWKHUHIRUH

H[SODLQVKRZ)LUP.DQWUDQVIHULWVPRQRSRO\RYHUWLPHIURPRQHSURGX.WWRDQRWKHU,W

H[SODLQVKRZILUPVOLNH,%0RU0L.URVRIW.DQVX..HHGLQNHHSLQJWKHLUPDUNHWSRZHUHYHQDV

WKHLUSURGX.WV.KDQJHHQRUPRXVO\RYHUWLPH7RVHHKRZWKLVZRUNVLPDJLQHWKDW)LUPLV

WKHLQLWLDOPRQRSROLVWRISURGX.W$3URGX.W%D.RPSOHPHQWWR$LVDYDLODEOHLQWKHLQLWLDO

SHULRGIURPRWKHUILUPVDVZHOODV)LUP,QSHULRGDQRWKHUSURGX.W.DOOLWSURGX.W&ZKL.K

.RXOGEHSURGX.W$LPSURYHGSURGX.W$RUDQ\RWKHUSURGX.WWKDWXVHVSURGX.W%EH.RPHV

DYDLODEOHDQGSURGX.LEOHE\PDQ\ILUPV,I)LUP.DQXVHUHIXVDOVWRGHDOLQLHWREX\

SURGX.W%WRSUHYHQWRWKHUILUPVIURPD.KLHYLQJWKHV.DOHQHHGHGWRSURGX.HSURGX.W%WKHQ

)LUP.DQEH.RPHWKHPRQRSROLVWRIWKLVRWKHUSURGX.W&LQSHULRGDVDUHVXOWRILWEHLQJWKH

PRQRSROLVWRI%7KHVLPSOHSRLQWLVWKDW)LUP.DQXVHUHIXVDOVWRGHDOWRPRQRSROL]HDQ\

IXWXUHSURGX.W&WKDWXVHVSURGX.W%DVD.RPSOHPHQW,QWKLVZD\)LUP.DQWUDQVIHULWVLQLWLDO

PRQRSRO\SRZHURYHUWLPHIURPSURGX.W$WRSURGX.W&$JDLQWKHHPSLUL.DOUHOHYDQ.HRIWKLV

WKHRU\LVOLNHO\WREHJUHDWHVWLQUDSLGO\.KDQJLQJLQGXVWULHVZLWKVWURQJSURGX.W

.RPSOHPHQWDULWLHVDQGV.DOHV.RSHHIIH.WVDQGQHWZRUNHIIH.WV7KLVWKHRU\SURYLGHVDPX.K

PRUH.RJHQWH[SODQDWLRQIRUUHIXVDOVWRGHDOWKDQHLWKHUWUDGLWLRQDOIRUH.ORVXUHWKHRULHVWKDW

IR.XVRQWKHOHYHUDJLQJRISRZHULQ$LQWR%DVLQ&DVHDDWKHRU\WKDWZHKDYHDOUHDG\

H[SODLQHGKDVOLWWOHEDVLVRU&DVHEZKRVHHPSLUL.DOUHOHYDQ.HDWOHDVWEDVHGRQH[LVWLQJWLH

LQ.DVHVLVQRWREYLRXV

.RQWLQXHG

SXUKDVLQJ%DQGWKHLQDELOLW\RI)LUPVDQGWRZULWHDQHIILLHQWRQWUDW,GLVXVVWKH0LURVRIWDVHVODWHU7RVHHKRZDVSHWVRIWKH,%0DVHVZRXOGILWLQWR&DVHRQHPXVWUHRJQL]HWKDWLQWHOOLJHQHDQUHVLGHLQHLWKHUWKHPDLQIUDPHRULQWKHSHULSKHUDODQGWKHUHIRUHLQWHOOLJHQHLQSHULSKHUDOVDQVRPHWLPHVVXEVWLWXWHIRULQWHOOLJHQHLQWKHPDLQIUDPH



,,,32/,&<,03/,&$7,216

$OWKRXJKWKHSUH.HGLQJWKHRULHVHQRUPRXVO\LPSURYHRXUXQGHUVWDQGLQJRIWKH

.RQVHTXHQ.HVRIVWUDWHJL.EHKDYLRULQYROYLQJUHIXVDOVWRGHDOVD.KLHYHGHLWKHUH[SOL.LWO\RU

LPSOL.LWO\WKHUHUHPDLQVWKHVHSDUDWHTXHVWLRQRIZKDWXVHDQWLWUXVWVKRXOGPDNHRIWKHVH

WKHRULHV2QHXVHLVWRUH.RJQL]HWKDWWKHSUH.HGLQJWKHRULHVWKDW.DQJHQHUDWHDKDUPWR

.RPSHWLWLRQQHHGVRPHVRUWRIV.DOHH.RQRPLHVHIIH.W+HQ.HDQ\VLWXDWLRQZKHUHVX.KHIIH.WV

DUHDEVHQWDUHXQOLNHO\WREH.DQGLGDWHVIRUKDUPIXOH[.OXVLRQDU\.RQGX.W

7KHNH\LVVXHLVZKHWKHURQH.DQGLVWLQJXLVKZKHQWKHVHWKHRULHVLPSO\DKDUPWR

.RPSHWLWLRQDVGLVWLQ.WIURPDKDUPWRDULYDO,WLVSRVVLEOHWRVKRZWKDWLQPDQ\RIWKHDERYH

PRGHOVEDQQLQJWKHH[.OXVLRQDU\.RQGX.W.DQVRPHWLPHVLPSURYH.RPSHWLWLRQLQWKHVHQVHWKDW

.RQVXPHUVDUHEHWWHURII+RZHYHULWLVDOVRLPSRUWDQWWRUH.RJQL]HWKDWVLQ.HWKHVHPRGHOV

KDYHV.DOHHIIH.WVRUQHWZRUNHIIH.WVLWLVSRVVLEOHWRVKRZWKDWWKHH[.OXVLRQDU\.RQGX.W.DQ

VRPHWLPHVEHQHILW.RQVXPHUV0RUHRYHUWKHUHDUHZHOONQRZQSUR.RPSHWLWLYHHIIH.WVIURP

UHIXVDOVWRGHDOLQDGGLWLRQWRV.DOHHIIH.WV7KHPRVWLPSRUWDQWRQHVLQ.OXGH

• H[.OXVLYHGHDOLQJHLWKHUH[SOL.LWRULPSOL.LW.UHDWHVLQ.HQWLYHVIRUPDQXID.WXUHUWUDLQLQJ

DQGSURPRWLRQ• SURGX.WGHVLJQSK\VL.DOWLHLQVDOORZVHIIL.LHQWSURGX.WGHVLJQ• TXDQWLW\GLV.RXQWV.DQHQ.RXUDJHHIIL.LHQWRUGHUVL]HDQG• UHIXVDOVWRGHDO.DQSURWH.WWKHIWRILQWHOOH.WXDOSURSHUW\

7KLVPHDQVWKDWDQ\DQWLWUXVWDWWD.NRQDQH[SOL.LWRULPSOL.LWUHIXVDOWRGHDOPXVW

UH.RJQL]HWKLVGLIIL.XOW\RILGHQWLI\LQJE\WKHRU\DORQHD.RPSHWLWLYHKDUPDQGLQVWHDGPXVWWXUQ

WRDTXDQWLWDWLYHDQDO\VLVZKL.KPD\EHGLIIL.XOWWRSHUIRUPEHIRUH.RQGHPQLQJWKHSUD.WL.HLQ

DQ\VSH.LIL..DVH,ZLVKWRKLJKOLJKWWZRHIIL.LHQ.\GHIHQVHVWRZKL.KDQWLWUXVWKDVRQR..DVLRQ

SDLGVSH.LDOKHHG.RVWVDYLQJVDQGLQQRYDWLRQ

(YHU\VWXGHQWRIDQWLWUXVWXQGHUVWDQGVWKDWLQ.UHDVHGPDUNHWSRZHU.UHDWHVDQDGGLWLRQDO

GHDGZHLJKWORVVLOOXVWUDWHGLQ)LJXUHDVWKHWUDSH]RLGDODUHDWKDWUHSUHVHQWVWKHGLIIHUHQ.HLQ

GHDGZHLJKWORVVEHWZHHQDQLQLWLDOVLWXDWLRQSUL.HDW3 DQGRQHZLWKVRPHDGGLWLRQDOPDUNHW

SRZHUSUL.HDW3$ILUPWKDW.DQORZHUSHUXQLW.RVWVIURP&WR&.UHDWHVDEHQHILWHTXDOWR



WKH.URVVKDW.KHGUH.WDQJOH7KHUH.WDQJOHZLOOKDYHDELJJHUDUHDWKDQWKHWUDSH]RLGLIWKHSHU

XQLW.RVWVDYLQJLVODUJHLIWKHVDOHVTVDUHODUJHRULIWKH.KDQJHLQRXWSXWIURPWKHLQ.UHDVHG

SRZHULVVPDOO7RSUHVHUYHHIIL.LHQ.LHVLQ.DVHVZKHUHWKH\VZDPSGHDGZHLJKWORVVDJRRG

SROL.\UXOHLV%HUHOX.WDQWWRLQWHUIHUHLQVLWXDWLRQVZKHUHODUJHHIIL.LHQ.LHV.RXOGEHORVWDQG

HVSH.LDOO\ZKHUH.RXUWVKDYHGLIIL.XOW\PHDVXULQJWKRVHHIIL.LHQ.LHV,WLVYHU\GLIIL.XOWIRU.RXUWV

RUH.RQRPLVWVWRILJXUHRXWZKHWKHUWUDQVD.WLRQV.DUULHGRXWZLWKLQDILUP.RXOGEHHIIL.LHQWO\

.DUULHGRXWLQWKHPDUNHWSOD.H)RUWKDWUHDVRQ.RXUWVKDYHEHHQUHOX.WDQWWRLQWHUYHQHWRRUGHU

DYHUWL.DOO\LQWHJUDWHGILUPWRRSHQVRPHRILWVGLYLVLRQVWRULYDOV6RIRUH[DPSOHD.RXUWLV

XQOLNHO\WRRUGHU*0HYHQDVVXPLQJLWZHUHDPRQRSROLVWRI.DUVWRVXSSO\SURGX.WLRQ

.DSDELOLW\RUPDUNHWLQJH[SHUWLVHWRDQHZILUP$VLGHIURPWKHGLIIL.XOW\RIVHWWLQJWKHWHUPVRI

WUDGHLQHIIL.LHQ.LHVDUHOLNHO\WREH.UHDWHGZKHQD.WLYLWLHVGRQHLQWHUQDOO\DUHUHTXLUHGWREH

GRQHH[WHUQDOO\$V&RDVHWDXJKWXV\HDUVDJRDILUP.KRRVHVWRSHUIRUPWKRVHIXQ.WLRQVWKDW

LW.DQPRUHHIIL.LHQWO\SHUIRUPLQWHUQDOO\WKDQE\UHOLDQ.HRQWKHPDUNHW+HQ.HDUDWLRQDOHIRU

DQWLWUXVW¶VUHOX.WDQ.HWRLQWHUYHQHLQD.WLYLWLHVZLWKLQDILUPLVWKHUH.RJQLWLRQWKDWVX.K

LQWHUYHQWLRQ.RXOG.DXVHWKHORVVRIHIIL.LHQ.LHVOLNHWKRVHRIWKHUH.WDQJOH

$OWKRXJKWKHDQWLWUXVWODZVJHQHUDOO\WUHDWWKHERXQGDU\RIDILUPDVLQYLRODEOHWKHVDPH

GRHVQRWKROGWUXHDERXW.RQWUD.WXDODUUDQJHPHQWVEHWZHHQILUPV$ILUPWKDWXVHVDGLVWULEXWRU

XQGHUDQH[.OXVLYHGHDOLQJDUUDQJHPHQW.DQEHUHTXLUHGWRDOORZWKDWGLVWULEXWRUWRVHOORWKHU

SURGX.WV7KHXQGHUO\LQJORJL.DSSHDUVWREHWKDWWKHREVHUYDWLRQWKDWWZRILUPV.DQ.RQWUD.W

ZLWKHD.KRWKHULQWKHPDUNHWSOD.HVXJJHVWVWKDWDOORZLQJDQDGGLWLRQDO.RQWUD.WZLWKDQRWKHU

ILUPZLOO.DXVHHLWKHUQRKDUPRUDKDUPWKDW.DQEHZHLJKHGDJDLQVWWKH.RPSHWLWLYHEHQHILWVRI

SUHYHQWLQJDUHIXVDOWRGHDO

6HHIRUH[DPSOH2O\PSLD(TXLSPHQW/HDVLQJ&RY:HVWHUQ8QLRQ7HOHJUDSK&R)GWK&LU³$PRQRSROLVWKDVQRGXW\WRH[WHQGDKHOSLQJKDQGWRQHZHQWUDQWV́

6HH5RQDOG+&RDVH³7KH1DWXUHRIWKH)LUP´(.RQRPL.D



7KHWUHDWPHQWRIUHIXVDOVWRGHDOHIIH.WHGWKURXJKRWKHUGHYL.HVVX.KDVD.RQWUD.WXVLQJ

QRQOLQHDUSUL.LQJSURGX.WGHVLJQDQG.RQWUD.WXDOWLHLQVLVPRUH.RPSOL.DWHGWKDQH[SOL.LW

UHIXVDOVWRGHDOXQGHUWKHDQWLWUXVWODZV)ROORZLQJWKHORJL.MXVWGHV.ULEHGWRSUHVHUYH

HIIL.LHQ.LHVZKL.KH[.HHGGHDGZHLJKWORVVHVWLHVD.KLHYHGWKURXJKSURGX.WGHVLJQVKRXOGEH

JHQHUDOO\DOORZHGVLQ.HLWLVGLUH.WO\DQDORJRXVWRYHUWL.DOLQWHJUDWLRQZKLOHH[.OXVLYLW\D.KLHYHG

WKURXJK.RQWUD.WWLHVRUWKURXJKQRQOLQHDUSUL.LQJRURWKHUWHUPVVKRXOGEHVXEMH.WWRV.UXWLQ\

WKRXJKUH.DOOWKH.DYHDWVLQGHDOLQJZLWKQRQOLQHDUSUL.LQJRURWKHUWHUPVGLV.XVVHGLQ&DVH

EH.DXVHWKH.RXUWVKDYHRIWHQLQWHUIHUHGZLWKVX.KPDUNHWSOD.HWUDQVD.WLRQVRQWKHLPSOL.LW

DVVXPSWLRQWKDWGRLQJVRGRHVQRWJLYHULVHWRODUJHWUDQVD.WLRQ.RVWV

$VLGHIURP.RVWUHGX.WLRQVWKH86.RQVXPHUKDVEHQHILWWHGHQRUPRXVO\IURPWKH

LQWURGX.WLRQRIQHZSURGX.WV7KHLQWURGX.WLRQRIQHZSURGX.WVKDVEHHQUHVSRQVLEOHIRUWKH

KLJKVWDQGDUGRIOLYLQJHQMR\HGLQWKH86,WLVHDV\WRVHHZK\,IWKHGHPDQG.XUYHIRUDQHZ

SURGX.WLV'WKHQWKHHQWLUHDUHDEHWZHHQWKHGHPDQG.XUYHDQGPDUJLQDO.RVW.XUYHLVDJDLQ

WRVR.LHW\(YHQWKHLQWURGX.WLRQRIDSURGX.WVXEMH.WWRPRQRSRO\SRZHU.DQUHSUHVHQWDJDLQ

WRVR.LHW\7KDWLVWKHXQGHUO\LQJORJL.RIRXUSDWHQWV\VWHPLQZKL.KWKHPRQRSRO\SURILW

H[SH.WHGIURPLQQRYDWLRQ.UHDWHVDQLQ.HQWLYHWRSURYLGHWKHJDLQWRVR.LHW\,WKDVEHHQ

HVWLPDWHGWKDWWKHVR.LDOUHWXUQWRLQYHQWLRQVLJQLIL.DQWO\H[.HHGVWKHSULYDWHUHWXUQ7KDW

PHDQVWKDWWRSURPRWHLQYHQWLRQDQWLWUXVWVKRXOGEHHVSH.LDOO\ZDU\ZKHQLWVD.WLRQUHGX.HV

WKHUHWXUQWRLQQRYDWRUVRILQWHOOH.WXDOSURSHUW\EH.DXVHZHNQRZWKDWWKHUHDOUHDG\LVWRROLWWOH

LQ.HQWLYHWR.UHDWHVX.KLQWHOOH.WXDOSURSHUW\

2QHRIWKHZD\VILUPVSURWH.WLQWHOOH.WXDOSURSHUW\LVWRSUHYHQWLWIURPIDOOLQJLQWKH

KDQGVRID.RPSHWLWRU2QHVWDQGDUGUDWLRQDOHIRUH[.OXVLYHGHDOLQJLVWKDWLWDOORZVRQH

PDQXID.WXUHUWRJLYHWRLWVGLVWULEXWRU.XVWRPHUOLVWVZLWKRXWKDYLQJWRZRUU\DERXWWKHGLVWULEXWRU

XVLQJWKHLQIRUPDWLRQWRVHOODQRWKHUPDQXID.WXUHU¶VSURGX.W7KHVDPHUDWLRQDOH.RXOGH[SODLQ

&KDUOHV,-RQHVDQG-RKQ&:LOOLDPV³0HDVXULQJWKH6RLDO5HWXUQWR5'´4XDUWHUO\-RXUQDORI



ZK\D)LUPZLWKPDUNHWSRZHULQ$PD\UHIXVHWRGHDOZLWK)LUPZKRVHOOV.RPSOHPHQWDU\

SURGX.W%LI)LUPPD\DOVREH.RPHD.RPSHWLWRURUGHDOZLWKD.RPSHWLWRULQSURGX.W$6R

IRUH[DPSOHVXSSRVHWKDW)LUPPDNHV.RPSXWHU.KLSVZKLOH)LUPVDQGSXU.KDVH)LUP¶V

.RPSXWHU.KLSVDVLQSXWVWRPDNHRWKHUSURGX.WV,QRUGHUWRVHOOLWV.KLSV)LUPPXVWH[SODLQ

WKHLUHQJLQHHULQJSURSHUWLHVWRWKHXVHU6XSSRVH)LUPQRZGH.LGHVWRGHYHORSLWVRZQ.KLS

EXVLQHVV)LUPUHIXVHVWRGHDOZLWK)LUPEXW.RQWLQXHVWRGHDOZLWK)LUP$WWD.NVRQWKLV

.RQGX.WDQGLPSRVLWLRQRIDGXW\IRU)LUPWRGHDORQQRQGLV.ULPLQDWRU\WHUPVZLWK)LUPZLOO

ZHDNHQSURSHUW\ULJKWVLQLQWHOOH.WXDOSURSHUW\GLPLQLVKWKHLQ.HQWLYHWRLQYHVWLQ.RPSXWHU

.KLSVDQGZLGHQWKHDOUHDG\H[LVWLQJJDSEHWZHHQWKHVR.LDODQGSULYDWHUDWHRIUHWXUQWR

LQQRYDWLRQ7KLVH[DPSOHKLJKOLJKWVWKDWLWLVQRW.RUUH.WWR.KDUD.WHUL]HGLIIHUHQWWHUPVRIWUDGH

EHWZHHQ)LUPVDQGDVGLV.ULPLQDWRU\EH.DXVH)LUPVDQGDUHQRWVLPLODUO\VLWXDWHG

+RZHYHULIQRSURWH.WLRQRILQWHOOH.WXDOSURSHUW\LVLQYROYHGWKHQWKHRQO\GLVWLQJXLVKLQJIHDWXUH

RI)LUPVDQGLVWKDW)LUPLQWHQGVWR.RPSHWHZLWK)LUP,QWKDW.DVHDQDQWLWUXVWDWWD.N

RQ)LUP¶VGLV.ULPLQDWRU\SROL.\PD\PDNHVHQVHXVLQJRQHRIWKHWKHRULHVSUHVHQWHGHDUOLHU

EH.DXVHWKHRQO\UHDVRQIRUWKHGLV.ULPLQDWLRQLV¶VDELOLW\WRHURGHPRQRSRO\SURILWVE\

.RPSHWLQJLQ.RPSXWHU.KLSV$OWKRXJKWKHUHLVDSURSHUW\ULJKWWRSURWH.WLQWHOOH.WXDO

SURSHUW\WKHUHLVQRVX.KSURSHUW\ULJKWWRSURWH.WPRQRSRO\SURILWV

.RQWLQXHG

(.RQRPL.V6KRXOGWKHUHEHDQ\OLPLWWKHQRQDOORZDEOHEHKDYLRUWRSURWHWLQWHOOHWXDOSURSHUW\LQOLJKWRIWKLVJDS"<HVDVVXPLQJWKHJRDOLVWRSUHYHQWKDUPWRRPSHWLWLRQ2QHVKRXOGQRWIRUH[DPSOHDOORZEHKDYLRUWKDWGHVWUR\VUHVRXUHVHJERPELQJDULYDO¶VDVVHWV,DOVRZRXOGQRWDOORZDUWHOVWRIRUPDPRQJULYDOVLQRUGHUWRUDLVHWKHUDWHRIUHWXUQ7KHGDQJHULVWKDWDUWHOVZLOOIRUPIRU

SUHWH[WXUDOUHDVRQVMXVWWRUDLVHUDWHVRIUHWXUQUHJDUGOHVVRIZKHWKHULQWHOOHWXDOSURSHUW\LVLQYROYHG $OVRLIWKHILUPKDVVKRZQE\LWVSDVWEHKDYLRUWKDWLWRXOGRQWUDWXDOO\SURWHWLWVLQWHOOHWXDOSURSHUW\ZLWKRXWUHVRUWLQJWRDUHIXVDOWRGHDOWKHQDGHIHQVHRIDUHIXVDOWRGHDOEDVHGRQSURWHWLRQRILQWHOOHWXDOSURSHUW\VKRXOGEHUHTXLUHGWRH[SODLQZK\SUHYLRXVDUUDQJHPHQWVDUHQRORQJHUDGHTXDWH+RZHYHUIRUUHDVRQVH[SODLQHGEHORZ,ZRXOGUHTXLUHWKHSODLQWLIIWRVKRZDVLJQLILDQWOLNHO\KDUPWRRPSHWLWLRQ

3URYLQJWKDWWKLVIDWSDWWHUQH[LVWVRXOGEHYHU\GLIILXOWDQGIUDXJKWZLWKHUURU7KLVVXJJHVWVWKDWRQHVKRXOGEHZDU\RISXUVXLQJDQDQWLWUXVWODLPXQGHUWKHVHLUXPVWDQHV

$SUDWLDOSUREOHPDULVHVLIQR)LUPH[LVWV7KHQIRULQJ)LUPWRGHDOZLWK)LUPUHTXLUHVVHWWLQJDSULHZLWKQRUHDGLO\DYDLODEOHEHQKPDUNV$QDQWLWUXVWUHPHG\ZRXOGOHDYHWKHDQWLWUXVWDXWKRULW\LQ



,QVXPPDU\H[.OXVLRQDU\.RQGX.WVKRXOGQRWEHDWWD.NHGDV.UHDWLQJDKDUPWR

.RPSHWLWLRQDEVHQWD.RKHUHQWWKHRU\H[SODLQLQJVRPHPH.KDQLVPRIKDUP7KDWPHDQVWKDWLQ

WKHDEVHQ.HRIVRPHVRUWRIVLJQLIL.DQWV.DOHHIIH.WVWKHUHLVXQOLNHO\WREHDEDVLVIRUDWWD.N

EDVHGRQWKHWKHRULHVZHKDYHUHYLHZHG%XWHYHQZKHUHWKHRU\VXJJHVWVWKHSRVVLELOLW\RI

.RPSHWLWLYHKDUPWKHGLIIL.XOW\LQLGHQWLI\LQJVX.KKDUPDQGLQGLVWLQJXLVKLQJDKDUPWR

.RPSHWLWLRQIURPDKDUPWR.RPSHWLWRUVVXJJHVWV.DXWLRQ$WDPLQLPXPLQRUGHUWRDYRLG

.RQGHPQLQJHIIL.LHQW.RQGX.WDSODLQWLIIVKRXOGEHUHTXLUHGWRVKRZDVLJQLIL.DQWKDUPWR

.RPSHWLWLRQDQGVKRXOGQRWEHDOORZHGWRSURYHRQO\QRHIIL.LHQ.LHVIURPWKHH[.OXVLRQDU\

.RQGX.W(IIL.LHQ.LHVDUHKDUGWRPHDVXUHDQGWKHEHQHILWRIWKHGRXEWVKRXOGJRWRGHIHQGDQWV

QRWSODLQWLIIVXQOHVVRQHLVSUHSDUHGWRMHRSDUGL]HWKH.RQWLQXHGJHQHUDWLRQRIWKHODUJH

HIIL.LHQ.\EHQHILWVUHVSRQVLEOHIRUUDLVLQJRXUVWDQGDUGRIOLYLQJ)LQDOO\.HUWDLQQRQ.RQWUD.WXDO

EHKDYLRUHJYHUWL.DOLQWHJUDWLRQSK\VL.DOWLHLQVZRXOGVHHPWREHEH\RQGWKHUHD.KRIWKH

DQWLWUXVWODZVXQGHUQRUPDO.LU.XPVWDQ.HVRQWKHJURXQGVWKDWLQWHUIHULQJLQD.WLYLWLHVZLWKLQD

ILUP.DQHQWDLOODUJHHIIL.LHQ.\.RVWV

.RQWLQXHG

WKHXQKDSS\SRVLWLRQRIKDYLQJWRVHWSULH1RWLHWKDWWKHVHLUXPVWDQHVZRXOGEDVHGRQWKHHDUOLHUGLVXVVLRQRIQRQLQWHUYHQWLRQZLWKLQDILUPJHQHUDOO\IDYRUQRQLQWHUYHQWLRQ6XKDSROL\XQIRUWXQDWHO\UHDWHVDGLVLQHQWLYHIRUILUPVWRWUDQVDWZLWKRWKHUVIRUIHDURIUHDWLQJDEHQKPDUNWKDWRWKHUILUPVZKRZLVKWRGHDODQSRLQWWR

7KHUHLVDVXEWOHSRLQWKHUH,I)LUPLVDPRQRSROLVWRI$EXWRPSHWHVZLWK)LUPLQWKHVDOHRIDRPSOHPHQWDU\SURGXW%WKHQIURPRXUHDUOLHUDQDO\VLV&DVHD)LUPDQVTXHH]HDOOSURILWVIURP%DQGWKDWVKRXOGQRWEHDYLRODWLRQRIDQ\DQWLWUXVWODZLIWKHJRDOLVWRSUHYHQWDKDUPWR

RPSHWLWLRQ+RZHYHULI)LUPDOVRRPSHWHVZLWK)LUPLQ3URGXW&DQDWWHPSWWRKDUP)LUP¶VDELOLW\WRRPSHWHLQ&RXOGYLRODWHWKHDQWLWUXVWODZ+HQHLIWKHUHZHUHIRUH[DPSOHDQHRQRP\RIVRSHEHWZHHQ%DQG&WKHRUHWLDOO\)LUP¶VUHIXVDOWRGHDOVHOOLQ3URGXW$ZLWK)LUPRXOGKDUPRPSHWLWLRQLQ&$SULHIRU$WKDWLVVRKLJKDVWRGULYH)LUPRXWRI%ZRXOGWKHQEHDQDWLRQWKDWKDUPVRPSHWLWLRQLQ&,I)LUPLVWKHRQO\ILUPWKDW)LUPGHDOVZLWKWKHQLWZRXOGOLNHO\EHDQHPSLULDOQLJKWPDUHWRGHLGHZKHWKHUWKHKLJKSULHIRU$WR)LUPZDVWRH[WUDWOHJLWLPDWHPRQRSRO\SURILWVDVLQ&DVHDRUWRGHVWUR\RPSHWLWLRQIRU&2QWKHRWKHUKDQGLIWKHUHDUHILUPVWKDW)LUPVHOOVWRWKDWGRQ¶WRPSHWHIRU$DQGLIWKH\SD\DGLIIHUHQWSULHWKDQ)LUPVXKDGLVULPLQDWRU\SROL\RXOGEHVXEMHWWRDQWLWUXVWVUXWLQ\WKRXJK,ZRXOGXUJHJUHDWDXWLRQWRPDNHVXUHWKDWWKRVHRWKHUILUPVSURYLGHDUHDVRQDEOHEHQKPDUNIRU)LUP6HHQRWH



,95()86$/672'($//($',1*&$6(6

,QRZZDQWWRXVHWKHH.RQRPL.IUDPHZRUNWRDQDO\]HVRPHRIWKHOHDGLQJUHIXVDOWR

GHDO.DVHV7ZROHDGLQJ.DVHV$VSHQDQGRGDNVWDQGRXWDVOHDGLQJ.DVHVIRUWKH

SURSRVLWLRQWKDWDVLQJOHILUPKDVDGXW\WRGHDOZLWKLWVULYDOLIWKDWILUPKDVPDUNHWSRZHU$VZH

ZLOOVRRQVHHWKRVH.DVHVGRQRWIDOOLQWRDQ\RIRXULGHQWLILHGPRGHOVZKHUHH.RQRPL.DQDO\VLV

VXJJHVWVWKDWUHIXVDOVWRGHDOKDUP.RPSHWLWLRQ+HQ.HWKHVHWZR.DVHV.DQEHYLHZHGDV

SODLQWLIIVVX..HVVIXOO\WDNLQJSURSHUW\IURPGHIHQGDQWV7KHVHWZR.DVHVUHSUHVHQWGDQJHURXV

SUH.HGHQWVLIWKH\DUHEURDGO\DSSOLHG,ZLOOWKHQEULHIO\GLV.XVVWZR.DVHVWKDWUHSUHVHQWLQ

WHUPVRIRXUIUDPHZRUNVHQVLEOHDSSOL.DWLRQVRIDQWLWUXVWLQUHIXVDOWRGHDO.DVHV7KRVH.DVHV

DUH/RUDLQ-RXUQDODQG0L.URVRIW

$$63(1

$VSHQ6NL6NLRZQHGWKUHHRIWKHIRXUPRXQWDLQVLQ$VSHQ$VSHQ+LJKODQGV

+LJKODQGVRZQHGWKHIRXUWK7KHWZRILUPV.RPSHWHGZLWKHD.KRWKHUIRUVNLHUV7KHILUPV

DOVR.ROODERUDWHGE\RIIHULQJDGD\SDVVDQGDPXOWLGD\SDVVWKDWDOORZHGVNLHUVWRVNLRQDQ\

RI$VSHQ¶VIRXUPRXQWDLQV7KHUHYHQXHIURPWKLV.ROODERUDWLYHHIIRUWZDVVSOLWSURUDWDLQ

D..RUGDQ.HZLWKWKHUHVXOWVRIDVXUYH\RQKRZPDQ\VNLHUVSXU.KDVLQJWKHIRXUPRXQWDLQWL.NHW

VNLHGRQHD.KILUP¶VPRXQWDLQV+LJKODQGVJRWDERXWRIWKHUHYHQXHIURPWKH

.ROODERUDWLYHHIIRUWIURP$IWHUVHYHUDO\HDUVRI.ROODERUDWLRQ6NLGHPDQGHGD

KLJKHUVKDUHRIWKHUHYHQXH+LJKODQGVUHIXVHGDQGWKH.ROODERUDWLRQ.HDVHG,QVXEVHTXHQW

.RPSHWLWLRQ+LJKODQGV¶VKDUHHYHQWXDOO\IHOOWRZKLOH6NL¶VURVH+LJKODQGVVRXJKWDYDULHW\

RIZD\VWRLWVHOIPDNHLWHDV\IRU.RQVXPHUVWREX\DIRXUPRXQWDLQVNLWL.NHWEXW6NLUHIXVHGWR

.RRSHUDWH+LJKODQGVVXHGDQGZRQEHIRUHWKH6XSUHPH&RXUW7KH&RXUWUXOHGWKDW6NLKDG

)RULQVLJKWIXODQDO\VHVRI$VSHQ$VSHQ6NLLQJ&RY$VSHQ+LJKODQGV6NLLQJ&RUS86VHH3KLOOLS($UHHGDDQG+RYHQNDPS $QWLWUXVW/DZ )UDQN(DVWHUEURRN³2Q,GHQWLI\LQJ([OXVLRQDU\&RQGXW´1RWUH'DPH/DZ5HYLHZ DQG-RQDWKDQ%DNHU3URPRWLQJ,QQRYDWLRQ&RPSHWLWLRQ7KURXJKWKH$VSHQ.RGDN5XOH´*HRUJH0DVRQ/DZ5HYLHZ



IDLOHGWRSUHVHQWDQHIIL.LHQ.\MXVWLIL.DWLRQIRU.KDQJLQJD.ROODERUDWLRQWKDWKDGSURGX.HGD

SRSXODUSURGX.WDQGWKHUHIRUHKDGYLRODWHGWKHDQWLWUXVWODZV

7KHUHDUHVHYHUDOWURXEOLQJIHDWXUHVDERXWWKHH.RQRPL.ORJL.XQGHUO\LQJWKHQRWLRQWKDW

$VSHQUHTXLUHVDILUPWR.RQWLQXH.RRSHUDWLRQZLWKDULYDODEVHQWDEXVLQHVVMXVWLIL.DWLRQ7KH

&RXUWWUHDWHG$VSHQH[D.WO\DVIDOOLQJLQWRP\&DVH:HZLOOVRRQVHHWKDWWKLVLVQRWHQWLUHO\

.RUUH.W,IWKHMRLQWYHQWXUHSURGX.HGDVXSHULRUSURGX.WWKDQHLWKHU.RPSDQ\.RXOGVHSDUDWHO\

SURGX.HWKHQWKHUHLVDQLQ.HQWLYHIRUWKHSURGX.WWREHSURGX.HG7KHRQO\TXHVWLRQLVKRZWKH

SDUWL.LSDQWVZLOOVKDUHWKHSURILWV%XWDGLVSXWHDERXW.RQWUD.WWHUPVLVDSULYDWHGLVSXWHZLWKQR

DQWLWUXVW.RQVHTXHQ.H7KDW6NLDQG+LJKODQGVHD.KZDQWPRUHLVXQGHUVWDQGDEOHEXWEHVLGH

WKHSRLQW0RUHRYHU+LJKODQGVZRXOGEHZLOOLQJWRSDUWL.LSDWHDVORQJDVLWREWDLQVPRUHE\

SDUWL.LSDWLQJLQWKHMRLQWYHQWXUHWKDQQRWSDUWL.LSDWLQJ+LJKODQGV¶GH.LVLRQQRWWRWDNHOHVVLVWKH

XQUHDVRQDEOHRQHXQOHVVLWIHOWDVWXUQHGRXWWREH.RUUH.WWKDWLW.RXOGXVHWKH&RXUWWR

REWDLQEHWWHUWHUPV%XWQRWHWKLV,QWKHDEVHQ.HRI&RXUWLQWHUYHQWLRQWKHUHLVDQLQ.HQWLYHIRU

WKHHIIL.LHQWEDUJDLQWREHVWUX.N7KHUHLVQRUHDVRQWRUHJDUGWKHVKDULQJRIWKHMRLQWYHQWXUH

SURILWVDVKDYLQJDQ\WKLQJWRGRZLWKDQWLWUXVWDJDLQUHJDUGLQJWKLVDV&DVH,QGHHGWKH

EDUJDLQLQJSRVLWLRQRIHD.KZRXOGEHDIIH.WHGE\WKHLU³WKUHDW´SRLQWWKHRXW.RPHLQWKH

DEVHQ.HRIDJUHHPHQW,QID.WZHNQRZWKDWWKHVKDUHSUHYDLOLQJLQWKHDEVHQ.HRIWKHMRLQW

YHQWXUHZDVIRU+LJKODQGVZKL.KLVORZHUWKDQZKDWLWZRXOGKDYHUH.HLYHGLQWKHMRLQW

YHQWXUHGHDOWKDWLWUHIXVHG

7KH&RXUW¶VSRVLWLRQLVVLPSOH7KH.RQVXPHUVOLNHGWKHIRXUPRXQWDLQSDVVDQGLWKDG

EHHQVROGEHIRUHRQ.HUWDLQWHUPV+HQ.HD..RUGLQJWRWKH&RXUWWKH\NQHZWKDWWKHMRLQW

YHQWXUHZDVIHDVLEOHDQGEHQHIL.LDO6X.KORJL.LV,WKLQNSDUWLDOO\.RUUH.WEXWLQDSSOL.DEOHKHUH

7KDWLVWKH&RXUWLVZDU\WRLPSRVHDQDQWLWUXVWGXW\WRGHDOZKHUHLWPLJKWEHLPSRVLQJKLJK

.RVWVE\IRU.LQJILUPVWRGHDORUE\LQYHQWLQJSUL.HWHUPVLQDQHZVHWWLQJ%XWSUHYLRXVEHKDYLRU

RUEHKDYLRUWRZDUGRWKHUV.DQEHXVHGWRVKRZWKDWWKRVH.RVWVDUHQRWKLJK$OWKRXJK

.RUUH.WVX.KDQDSSURD.KSHQDOL]HV.KDQJHDQGWKHUHIRUH.DQPDNHILUPVUHOX.WDQWWRHQWHU



VX.KDJUHHPHQWVLQLWLDOO\%XWHYHQLIWKHUHLVORJL.WRWKH&RXUW¶VUHDVRQLQJLWLVLQDSSOL.DEOH

KHUHIRUWKHUHDVRQDOUHDG\VWDWHG7KHUHLVQRDQWLWUXVWJDLQIURPLQWHUYHQWLRQ$EVHQW

LQWHUYHQWLRQWKHMRLQWYHQWXUHDJUHHPHQWZRXOGUHPDLQLQIRU.HLILWZHUHHIIL.LHQWWRGRVRMXVW

RQZRUVHWHUPVIRU+LJKODQGV$..RUGLQJWRWKH&RXUW¶VORJL.+LJKODQGV¶UHIXVDOWRD..HSWWKH

ORZHUHGSUL.HWHUPV.RXOGEHUHJDUGHGDVWKHDQWLWUXVWYLRODWLRQ,QVKRUWLWLVKDUGWRVHHDQ\

H.RQRPL.EDVLVWRXVHWKHDQWLWUXVWODZVWR.RPSHOWKHMRLQWYHQWXUHWR.RQWLQXH7KH&RXUW¶V

KROGLQJLQ$VSHQVLPSO\OD.NVH.RQRPL.ORJL.,W¶VEHVWXVHZRXOGEHDYHU\QDUURZUHDGLQJWKDW

HIIH.WLYHO\UHPRYHVLWDVDSUH.HGHQWIRUIXWXUH.DVHV

7KHUHLVKRZHYHURQHDVSH.WWKDWWKH&RXUWSD\VOLWWOHDWWHQWLRQWRWKDWLVDWOHDVWD

WKHRUHWL.DOO\YDOLGDQWLWUXVW.RQ.HUQLQOLJKWRIRXUHDUOLHUDQDO\VLVRIUHIXVDOWRGHDO$EVHQWWKH

MRLQWYHQWXUHWKH$VSHQ.DVHIDOOVLQWR&DVH6XSSRVH6NL.RXOGVRPHKRZLPSRVHH[.OXVLYLW\

RQVNLHUVLH\RX.DQ¶WVNLDWDQ\RI6NL¶VWKUHHPRXQWDLQVLI\RXVNLDOVRDW+LJKODQGV,I

WKHUHZHUHVLJQLIL.DQWV.DOHH.RQRPLHVWKLV.RXOGSUHYHQW+LJKODQGVIURPEHLQJDQHIIH.WLYH

.RPSHWLWRU1RZ6NLGLGQRWLPSRVHDQH[.OXVLYLW\UHTXLUHPHQWEXWGLGXVHDQRQOLQHDUSUL.LQJ

V.KHGXOHGD\SDVV.RVWVOHVVWKDQWLPHVVLQJOHGD\SDVV'LGWKLVV.KHGXOH.UHDWH

HIIH.WLYHH[.OXVLYLW\WKDWKDUPHG.RPSHWLWLRQ",GRQ¶WNQRZEXWDWOHDVWLWLVSHUKDSVDVHQVLEOH

TXHVWLRQWRLQYHVWLJDWHXQGHUDUXOHRIUHDVRQ$UHWKHUHV.DOHH.RQRPLHV":HUHWKHUHHQRXJK

VLQJOHGD\VNLHUVVRWKDW.ULWL.DOYROXPHZDVDYDLODEOH":HUHWKHSUL.HWHUPVVRXQUHDVRQDEOH

UH.DOOWKH.DYHDWLQ&DVHRQWUHDWLQJQRQOLQHDUSUL.LQJDVDQDQWLWUXVWYLRODWLRQWRMXVWLI\

WUHDWLQJLWDVH[.OXVLYLW\"(YHQLI+LJKODQGVLVKDUPHGDUHWKHUHRIIVHWWLQJHIIL.LHQ.LHVWKDW6NL

.RXOG.ODLP"$OWKRXJKWKLVH[.OXVLYLW\.RQ.HUQ.RXOGKDYHEHHQDQLQWHUHVWLQJDQWLWUXVWLVVXHWR

GH.LGHLWZDVQRWRQHWKDWWKH&RXUWGLGGHEDWH

-XGJH3RVQHUTXHVWLRQV³ZKHWKHU$VSHQVWDQGVIRUDQ\SULQLSOHWKDWJRHVEH\RQGLWVXQXVXDOIDWV´)GWK&LU7KHUHLVDQRWKHUDVSHWWKDWLVWURXEOLQJDERXW$VSHQWKRXJKWKH&RXUWSD\VQRDWWHQWLRQWRLW,IDVWKH&RXUWZDVIRUHGWRDVVXPHWKHIRXUPRXQWDLQVRQVWLWXWHDUHOHYDQWPDUNHWWKHQWKHMRLQWYHQWXUHLVDPHUJHUWRPRQRSRO\7KHQHHVVDU\UHYHQXHVKDULQJDJUHHPHQWRIWKHMRLQWYHQWXUHZRXOGUHTXLUHSULHGLVXVVLRQVDQGWKHMRLQWYHQWXUHZRXOGVHHPWRUDLVHWKRUQ\DQWLWUXVWLVVXHVDVLQ%0,7KLVLVVXHZDVWKHVXEMHWRIDQDQWLWUXVWDWLRQE\WKH



%,62Y.2'$.

7KHPRVWUH.HQW6XSUHPH&RXUW.DVHUHJDUGLQJDGXW\WRGHDOLQYROYHVRGDN6LQ.H

WKDW.DVHKDVEHHQDQDO\]HGLQVHYHUDODUWL.OHV ,ZLOOEHEULHIRGDNVHUYL.HVLWVRZQ

SKRWR.RSLHUVDQGVRGRLQGHSHQGHQWVHUYL.HRUJDQL]DWLRQV,62,QRUGHUIRUDQ,62WRVHUYL.H

DRGDNPD.KLQHLWQHHGVUHSDLUSDUWVWKDWRQO\RGDNVXSSOLHVRGDN.KDQJHGLWVSROL.\RI

VXSSO\LQJUHSDLUSDUWVWR,62VZKRLQUHVSRQVHEURXJKWDQDQWLWUXVWD.WLRQ7KHLVVXHWKH

&RXUWGH.LGHGZDVWKLV,IRGDNKDGQRPDUNHWSRZHUDWWKHWLPHRIWKHLQLWLDOVDOHEH.DXVH

WKHUHDUHPXOWLSOHVXSSOLHUVRISKRWR.RSLHUVZKL.KDOVRUHTXLUHVXEVHTXHQWUHSDLUSDUWVDQG

VHUYL.H.DQWKH,62VSUR.HHGWRWULDO"7KH&RXUWGH.LGHGWKDWWKH.DVHVKRXOGSUR.HHGWRWULDO

EH.DXVHWKHUH.RXOGEHHYLGHQ.HWRVKRZDQDQWLWUXVWKDUPWR.RPSHWLWLRQIURPWKHD.WLRQ

7KH&RXUWEHOLHYHGWKDWWKH.ODVVRIOR.NHGLQRGDN.RQVXPHUV.RXOGWKHRUHWL.DOO\EHKDUPHG

E\WKHDOOHJHGGLPLQXWLRQLQ.RPSHWLWLRQ7KLVGH.LVLRQ.RPPLWVWZRHUURUV

7KHILUVWHUURULVWKHIDLOXUHWRUH.RJQL]HWKDWH[DQWH.RPSHWLWLRQSURWH.WV.RQVXPHUV

&RQVLGHUWKH.DVHZKHUHRGDNKDVGHYHORSHGDUHSXWDWLRQDOLNHO\.DVHDERXWEHKDYLQJ

.RPSHWLWLYHO\LQLWVDIWHUPDUNHWD.WLYLWLHV,QWKDW.DVH.RQVXPHUVRIWHQVRSKLVWL.DWHG

EXVLQHVVHVDUHDZDUHRIUHSDLU.RVWVDWWLPHRISXU.KDVHDQGXQOHVVRGDNLVH[LWLQJWKH

EXVLQHVVZKL.KQRRQH.ODLPHGH[DQWH.RPSHWLWLRQ.RPSOHWHO\SURWH.WV.RQVXPHUV%XW

HYHQLIRGDNGLGQRWKDYHDUHSXWDWLRQIRUEHKDYLQJ.RPSHWLWLYHO\LQWKHDIWHUPDUNHWWRWKH

H[WHQWWKHUHDUHRYHU.KDUJHVLQWKHDIWHUPDUNHWWKDWJHQHUDWHVXSUD.RPSHWLWLYHSURILWVH[DQWH

.RPSHWLWLRQDPRQJRGDNDQGLWVULYDOVIRUWKHLQLWLDOVDOHJXDUDQWHHVWKDWVX.KSURILWVZLOOEH

JLYHQED.NWR.RQVXPHUV0RUHRYHUEH.DXVHRIWKHH[DQWH.RPSHWLWLRQRGDNKDVDQ

.RQWLQXHG

&RORUDGR$WWRUQH\*HQHUDO(DVWPDQ.RGDN&RY,PDJH7HKQLDO6HUYLH,Q86

(J&DUO6KDSLUR³$IWHUPDUNHWVDQG&RQVXPHU:HOIDUH0DNLQJ6HQVHRI.RGDN´ $QWLWUXVW/DZ-RXUQDO %RUHQVWHLQ0DNLH0DVRQDQG1HW]³$QWLWUXVW3ROL\LQ$IWHUPDUNHWV´ $QWLWUXVW/DZ-RXUQDO %HQMDPLQ.OHLQ³0DUNHW3RZHULQ$QWLWUXVW(RQRPL$QDO\VLVDIWHU.RGDN´6XSUHPH&RXUW(.RQRPL.5HYLHZ DQG'HQQLV&DUOWRQDQG0LKDHO:DOGPDQ³&RPSHWLWLRQ0RQRSRO\DQG$IWHUPDUNHWV´GUDIW



LQ.HQWLYHWREHKDYHHIIL.LHQWO\LQKRZLWRUJDQL]HVDQGLQWHJUDWHVLWVDIWHUPDUNHWDQGVDOHV

PDUNHWD.WLYLW\7RVWUHVVDVWKH&RXUWGRHVWKDWWKHDIWHUPDUNHWPDUNHWGHYLDWHVIURP

SHUIH.W.RPSHWLWLRQDGGVQRWKLQJWRWKHDQDO\VLV(YHU\PDUNHWGRHV%XWLIWKHJRDORIDQWLWUXVW

LVWRPD[LPL]HVR.LHW\¶VZHOIDUHLQWHUYHQWLRQXQGHUWKHDQWLWUXVWODZVVKRXOGR..XURQO\ZKHQ

VX.KLQWHUYHQWLRQ.DQLPSURYHWKHVWDWHRI.RPSHWLWLRQ:LWKH[DQWH.RPSHWLWLRQ.RPELQHGZLWK

UHSXWDWLRQVDQGVRSKLVWL.DWHGEX\HUVRUVLPSO\ZLWKH[DQWH.RPSHWLWLRQDORQHWKH.RPSHWLWLRQ

VKRXOGSURYLGHHQRXJKSURWH.WLRQVRWKDWWKHDQWLWUXVWODZVDUHOLNHO\WRGRRQO\KDUPZKHQWKH\

DUHXVHGWRLQWHUYHQHLQDPDUNHW7RVD\WKDWHD.K.DVHPXVWSUR.HHGWRWULDOEH.DXVHRID

WKHRUHWL.DOSRVVLELOLW\RIVKRZLQJKDUPZRXOGWXUQWKHDQWLWUXVWODZVLQWRDSRWHQWZHDSRQIRU

SXUVXLQJVSH.LRXV.ODLPV

%XWHYHQLILQRGDNWKH&RXUWPDGHDQHUURUIRUIDLOLQJWRGLVPLVVWKH.DVHIRUOD.NRI

PDUNHWSRZHULW.RPSRXQGHGLWVHUURUE\IDLOLQJWRUH.RJQL]HWKDWRGDNLVLQDSXUHO\YHUWL.DO

UHODWLRQVKLSZLWKLWV,62V7KDWLVDIWHUWKHLQLWLDOVDOHWKHRGDN.DVHLV&DVHD,QDSXUHO\

YHUWL.DO.DVHRGDNKDVWKHPRQRSRO\ULJKWWR.KDUJHZKDWHYHUSUL.HLWIHHOVOLNHIRULWV

PRQRSROL]HGSURGX.WSDUWV%\GRLQJVRLW.DQQRWDIIH.W.RPSHWLWLRQIRUWKHSDUWVVLQ.HE\

DVVXPSWLRQWKHUHDUHQRRWKHU.RPSHWLWRUV7KHLOOXVLRQWKDW,62VUHVWUDLQRGDNLVSUHPLVHG

RQWKHQRWLRQWKDWRGDNLVREOLJHGWR.KDUJHDORZHQRXJKSUL.HWR,62VWROHWWKHP.RPSHWH

:KHUHGRHVVX.KDGXW\DULVH",IWKHDQWLWUXVWODZVSHUPLWDPRQRSROLVWWR.KDUJHDSUL.HDERYH

.RVWWKHUH.DQEHQRDQWLWUXVWOLDELOLW\IURPRGDN¶VEHKDYLRU

.RQWLQXHG.RGDNVXEVHTXHQWO\ORVWWKDWWULDO.LWH

6HH'HQQLV:&DUOWRQDQG0LKDHO:DOGPDQLELGIRUDQDQDO\VLVWKDWVKRZVWKDWDIWHUPDUNHWDWLYLW\WKDWDSSHDUVWRSUHYHQWRPSHWLWLRQDQHQKDQHHIILLHQ\

6RPHRPPHQWDWRUVKDYHH[SODLQHGWKDW.RGDN¶VKDQJHRISROL\PD\KDYHVXUSULVHGXVWRPHUVDOUHDG\ORNHGLQ%XWWKLVZRXOGEHWUXHHYHQLQWKHDEVHQHRI,62RPSHWLWLRQLI.RGDNKDGUDLVHGUHSDLUSDUWSULHV8VLQJDQWLWUXVWWRSXUVXHZKDWLVDEUHDKRIRQWUDWODLPKDVQRHRQRPLIRXQGDWLRQ&RPSHWLWLRQLVQRWLQYROYHG2WKHURPPHQWDWRUVKDYHEHHQRQHUQHGDERXWWKHLQGXHPHQWWRRYHUVHUYLHDSKRWRRSLHULI.RGDNKDUJHVWKHPRQRSRO\SULHIRUUHSDLUSDUWV$JDLQWKLVLVQRWDKDUPDXVHGE\DUHGXWLRQLQRPSHWLWLRQ,WLVLQVWHDGDKDUPDXVHGE\DOORZLQJDPRQRSROLVWRISDUWVWRKDUJHDSULHDERYHPDUJLQDORVWRQGXWWKDWWKHDQWLWUXVWODZVDOORZ0RUHRYHUHYHQDPRQRSROLVWZDQWVWRDYRLGVXKLQHIILLHQLHV7KHUHLVQRUHDVRQWREHOLHYHWKDW



2XUDQDO\VLVKDVVKRZQWKDWWKHUHLVQRDQWLWUXVWLQMXU\WR.RQVXPHUVLQHLWKHU$VSHQRU

RGDNEXWHYHQDVVXPLQJWKDWWKHUHLVVRWKDWDQWLWUXVWOLDELOLW\H[LVWVWKH&RXUW¶VGH.LVLRQV

UHJDUGLQJSURRIVHHPPLVJXLGHG7KH&RXUW¶VGH.LVLRQLQWKHVH.DVHVKDVEHHQLQWHUSUHWHGWR

PHDQWKDWDUHIXVDOWRGHDOE\DILUPZLWKPDUNHWSRZHUUHTXLUHVDQHIIL.LHQ.\GHIHQVH

LQGHSHQGHQWRIVKRZLQJDOLNHO\.RPSHWLWLYHKDUPVHHHJ%DNHU-RQDWKDQ3URPRWLQJ

,QQRYDWLRQ&RPSHWLWLRQ7KURXJKWKH$VSHQRGDN5XOH´ *HRUJH0DVRQ/DZ5HYLHZ

>@%XWXQOHVV.RPSHWLWLRQLVOLNHO\WREHKDUPHGUHTXLULQJDQHIIL.LHQ.\GHIHQVHWRDYRLG

DQWLWUXVWOLDELOLW\ZRXOGEHXQZLVH,WZRXOGLQWKHDEVHQ.HRIDQWLWUXVWLQMXU\JLYHSODLQWLIIVD

.KDQ.HWRZLQDQDQWLWUXVW.DVHEDVHGRQZKHWKHUVRPHMXGJHRUMXU\QRWH[SHUWLQWKHLQGXVWU\

.DQXQGHUVWDQGDSUD.WL.HWKDWPD\EHKDUGWRH[SODLQ7KHQRWLRQWKDWVRPHH.RQRPLVWVKDYH

WKDWWKH\RUEXVLQHVVHV.DQUHDGLO\H[SODLQWROD\PHQWKHEDVLVIRUDQ\EXVLQHVVSUD.WL.HGRHV

QRWVTXDUHZLWKP\H[SHULHQ.H,QGHHGDVWKHOLWHUDWXUHLQH.RQRPL.VVKRZVH.RQRPLVWVRIWHQ

WDNHGH.DGHVWRXQGHUVWDQG.HUWDLQEXVLQHVVSUD.WL.HV8QOHVVWKHLQGXVWU\ID.WVDUHVX.K

WKDWDUHIXVDOWRGHDOKDVDOLNHOLKRRGRIDGYHUVHO\DIIH.WLQJ.RPSHWLWLRQWKHUH.DQRQO\EHHUURU

LQWURGX.HGE\GHPDQGLQJWKDWDGHIHQGDQWRIIHU.RQYLQ.LQJUHDVRQVIRULWVEXVLQHVVSUD.WL.HV

&/25$,1-2851$/$1'0,&5262)7

$OWKRXJK,GRKDYHDJHQHUDOVNHSWL.LVPDERXWWKHDQWLWUXVWYDOLGLW\RIPDQ\UHIXVDOWR

GHDO.ODLPVDQGKDYHH[SODLQHGZK\LWZRXOGEHPLVWDNHIRUWZRUH.HQW6XSUHPH&RXUW.DVHVWR

.RQWLQXHG

RXUW¶VLQWHUYHQWLRQRXOGEHWWHUDYRLGWKHLQHIILLHQ\WKDQRXOGWKHPRQRSROLVW6HH&DUOWRQDQG:DOGPDQVXSUDDWIRUIXUWKHUHODERUDWLRQRIWKLVSRLQW

2QHPLJKWDVNZK\.RGDNHQJDJHGLQLWVEHKDYLRU&DUOWRQDQG:DOGPDQVXSUDDWH[SODLQ

ZK\VXKEHKDYLRULVOLNHO\WREHDQHIILLHQWZD\WRRQWUROWKHLQWHUDWLRQEHWZHHQLQLWLDOVDOHVDQGWKHDIWHUPDUNHW

6HH5RQDOG+&RDVH³'XUDELOLW\DQG0RQRSRO\´ -RXUQDORI/DZDQG(.RQRPL.VVKRZLQJKRZRPPRQSUDWLHVUHJDUGLQJGXUDEOHJRRGVKHUHWRIRUHPLVXQGHUVWRRGDUHHIILLHQW6RWW(0DVWHQDQG(GZDUG6Q\GHU³8QLWHG6WDWHVY8QLWHG6KRH0DKLQHU\&RUSRUDWLRQ2QWKH0HULWV´-RXUQDORI/DZDQG(.RQRPL.VVKRZLQJKRZVRPHRI8QLWHG6KRHV¶VSUDWLHVIURP\HDUVDJRDQQRZEHXQGHUVWRRGDVHIILLHQ\HQKDQLQJDQG'DULXV:*DVNLQV-U³$ORD5HYLVLWHG7KH:HOIDUH,PSOLDWLRQVRID6HRQGKDQG0DUNHW´-RXUQDORI(.RQRPL.7KHRU\ VKRZLQJDERXW\HDUVODWHUKRZWKHRXUWVKRXOGKDYHDQDO\]HGWKH



EHIROORZHGEURDGO\,GLGHDUOLHULQGL.DWHWKDWWKHUH.DQEHV.RSHIRUDQWLWUXVWHQIRU.HPHQWLQ

UHIXVDOWRGHDO.DVHV%XW,WKLQNWKRVH.DVHVWREHUDUH,ZDQWWREULHIO\LQGL.DWHWZR.DVHV

ZKHUHWKHUHIXVDOWRGHDO.RXOGKDYHDGYHUVHO\DIIH.WHG.RPSHWLWLRQDQGZKHUHDQWLWUXVWV.UXWLQ\

ZDVMXVWLILHG

,Q/RUDLQ-RXUQDOWKHRZQHURIWKDWQHZVSDSHUZKL.KZDVWKHPDMRUOR.DODGYHUWLVLQJ

YHKL.OHUHVSRQGHGWRWKHHQWU\RIDOR.DOUDGLRVWDWLRQE\UHIXVLQJWRGHDOZLWKDQ\.XVWRPHU

DGYHUWLVLQJRQWKHUDGLR0RVW.RPPHQWDWRUVWUHDWWKHQHZVSDSHUDQGUDGLRDVVXEVWLWXWHVDQG

VRDSSO\UHDVRQLQJDNLQWRWKDWRIP\&DVH%XWLQLWLDOO\LWLVEHWWHUWRYLHZWKHUDGLRDQG

QHZVSDSHUDV.RPSOHPHQWVIRUVRPHDGYHUWLVHUVZD\VRIUHD.KLQJGLIIHUHQWGHPRJUDSKL.

JURXSV2WKHUZLVHDILUPZRXOGORVHOLWWOHE\EHLQJDEOHWRDGYHUWLVHRQRQO\WKHUDGLR%XW

RYHUWLPHWKHUDGLRGRHVJURZLQWRDVXEVWLWXWHIRUQHZVSDSHUDGYHUWLVLQJ7KDWPHDQV&DVH

LVDEHWWHUZD\RIXQGHUVWDQGLQJ/RUDLQ-RXUQDO7KHEHKDYLRUZKL.KDVIDUDV,.DQWHOOZDV

QRWEDVHGRQDQ\HIIL.LHQ.\GHIHQVHZDVGHVLJQHGWRVROLPLWWKHVL]HRIWKHUDGLRVWDWLRQWKDW

LWZRXOGQRWVXUYLYHDVDYLJRURXV.RPSHWLWRUODWHURQ:KDWLVXQ.OHDUWRPHLVKRZLPSRUWDQW

DUHWKHLQLWLDOV.DOHHIIH.WVLQGHWHUPLQLQJKRZIDVWWKHUDGLRVWDWLRQ.RXOGJURZRYHUWLPHDV

PRUHSHRSOHRZQHGUDGLRVEXWDVVXPLQJWKH\DUHLPSRUWDQWWKH.DVHVHHPVUHDVRQDEO\

GH.LGHGDJDLQVW/RUDLQ

/HWPHILQDOO\WXUQWRWZRDVSH.WVRIWKHUH.HQW0L.URVRIW.DVHV0L.URVRIW¶VHIIH.WLYH

UHIXVDOWRGHDOZLWK2(0VWKDWGHDOWZLWKRWKHURSHUDWLQJV\VWHPVRU1HWV.DSHDQG0L.URVRIW¶V

SURGX.WWLHRI:LQGRZVZLWK,QWHUQHW([SORUHU 7KHUHLV.RQVLGHUDEOHHYLGHQ.HWKDWH.RQRPLHV

RIV.DOHDQGLQVWDOOHGEDVHPDWWHULQWKH.RPSXWHULQGXVWU\,ZLOODVVXPHDVWKH&RXUWIRXQG

WKDW0L.URVRIWKDVPDUNHWSRZHULQRSHUDWLQJV\VWHPV0L.URVRIWGLGQRWXVHH[SOL.LWH[.OXVLYH

.RQWLQXHG

VHRQGKDQGPDUNHWLQ$ORD>86Y$OXPLQXP&RRI$P)GG&LW@/RUDLQ-RXUQDOY8686

6HHHJ86Y0LURVRIW:/''&$XJKHQHIRUWK0LURVRIW,DQG86Y0LURVRIW)6XSSG''&KHQHIRUWK0LURVRIW,KDYHZRUNHGRQDVSHWV



GHDOLQJEXWD.KLHYHGGHID.WRH[.OXVLYHGHDOLQJE\VWUX.WXULQJ.RQWUD.WVVRWKDWWKHSD\PHQWWR

0L.URVRIWWKDWD.RPSXWHUPDQXID.WXUHUPDGHGHSHQGHGQRWRQKRZPDQ\.RPSXWHUVLWVKLSSHG

ZLWK:LQGRZVEXWUDWKHURQKRZPDQ\.RPSXWHUVLWVKLSSHGLQWRWDOZKHWKHURUQRWWKH\KDGD

:LQGRZVRSHUDWLQJV\VWHP6X.KDQH[WUHPHSUL.LQJV\VWHPHDVLO\.RXOG.UHDWHH[.OXVLYLW\LQ

:LQGRZVRSHUDWLQJV\VWHPVVLQ.HWKHPDUJLQDO.RVWRI:LQGRZVLV]HURIRULQ.UHPHQWDOXQLWV,I

HYHU\ODUJH2(0QHHGVWRVKLSVRPH.RPSXWHUVZLWK:LQGRZVWKLVSROL.\.RXOGKDYHWKHHIIH.W

RIIRUH.ORVLQJULYDORSHUDWLQJV\VWHPVIURPREWDLQLQJHIIL.LHQWGLVWULEXWLRQ7KLVVWULNHVPHDVD

VHQVLEOHDQWLWUXVW.RQ.HUQZKL.K.DQEHHYDOXDWHGXQGHUDUXOHRIUHDVRQ,Q0L.URVRIW,WKH

'HSDUWPHQWRI-XVWL.HDWWD.NHGMXVWVX.KD.ODLPDQGXQGHUD.RQVHQWGH.UHH0L.URVRIWDJUHHG

WRGLV.RQWLQXHWKHSUD.WL.H6LPLODUO\LQ86Y0L.URVRIWVHYHUDORI0L.URVRIW¶V.RQWUD.WVZLWK

RULJLQDOHTXLSPHQWPDQXID.WXUHUVDQG,QWHUQHWVHUYL.HSURYLGHUVHLWKHUUHTXLUHGRU.UHDWHG

LQ.HQWLYHVIRUH[.OXVLYLW\LQEURZVHUVDQGZHUH.RQGHPQHGXQGHU6H.WLRQ 7KHWKHRU\ZRXOG

EHDVWUDLJKWIRUZDUGDSSOL.DWLRQRIWKHUHDVRQLQJLQ&DVH

7KH0L.URVRIW.DVHDOVRDOOHJHGDQLOOHJDOWLHEHWZHHQ:LQGRZVDQG,QWHUQHW([SORUHU

$JDLQWKHORJL.ZRXOGEHDVWUDLJKWIRUZDUGDSSOL.DWLRQRI&DVHZLWKWKHG\QDPL.

LQWHUGHSHQGHQ.H.DXVHGE\WKHLPSRUWDQ.HRIDQLQVWDOOHGEDVHRIDSSOL.DWLRQVWKDWZRUNRQ

:LQGRZV$OWKRXJKWKHPH.KDQLVPRIKDUPLV.OHDU,ZDQWWRIR.XVRQWKHWZRGLIIHUHQWWLHLQ

.ODLPV7KHILUVWZDVD.RQWUD.WXDOWLH,I\RXEX\:LQGRZV\RXDOVREX\,QWHUQHW([SORUHU

7KDWLVDW\SHRIWLHWKDW.DQOLNHO\EHEURNHQZLWKRXW.UHDWLQJODUJH.RVWV7KHUHDVRQLVWKH

XVXDORQHWKHWLHR..XUV³RXWVLGHWKHILUP¶VERXQGDULHV´VRWKHUHLVQRWWKHULVNWKDWXQGXH

GDPDJHLVGRQH,Q.RQWUDVWWKHVH.RQGWLHLQ.ODLPLQYROYHGWKHSK\VL.DO.RPPLQJOLQJRIWKH

.RQWLQXHG

RIWKH0LURVRIWDVHVDGYHUVHWR0LURVRIW6HHDOVR&DUOWRQDQG:DOGPDQVXSUDDW:KHWKHUWKHDQWLWUXVWKDUPWKDWDQHIIHWLYHUHIXVDOWRGHDORUH[OXVLYHGHDOLQJDXVHVLVDWLRQDEOHXQGHU6HWLRQV,RU,,LVDOHJDOTXHVWLRQZKLK,GRQRWGLVXVV,Q0LURVRIWWKHRXUWKHOGWKDW0LURVRIWGLGQRWYLRODWH6HWLRQ,E\LWVH[OXVLYHGHDOLQJDQGHIIHWLYHH[OXVLYHGHDOLQJRQWUDWVEXWWKDWWKHVDPHRQGXWGLGYLRODWH6HWLRQ,,86Y0LURVRIW)6XSSG''&



.RGHRI,QWHUQHW([SORUHUDQG:LQGRZVWRJHWKHU,QWHUIHULQJLQWKDWWLHUHTXLUHVWKHMXGJPHQW

WKDWJRLQJLQVLGHDILUPWRUHGHVLJQDSURGX.WZLOOQRWLPSRVHKLJK.RVWV

7KHSUH.HGHQWRILQWHUIHULQJLQSURGX.WGHVLJQXQGHU.XWVWKHEDVL.SROL.\SULQ.LSOH

EHZDUHRI.UHDWLQJLQHIIL.LHQ.\E\LQWHUIHULQJZLWKD.WLYLW\LQVLGHDILUPDQGHVSH.LDOO\EHZDUHRI

LQWHUIHULQJZLWKWH.KQRORJL.DOSURJUHVV,WZRXOGVHHPWKDWWKDWSULQ.LSOHVKRXOGEHDGKHUHGWRLQ

DOOEXWWKHPRVWXQXVXDO.LU.XPVWDQ.HVVRORQJDVWKHJRDORIWKHDQWLWUXVWODZVLVWRSUHYHQW

KDUPWR.RPSHWLWLRQ

9&21&/86,21

5HIXVDOVWRGHDODQGUHODWHGSUD.WL.HVVKRXOGJHQHUDOO\EHKRQRUHGLIWKHJRDORI

DQWLWUXVWLVWRD.KLHYHHIIL.LHQ.\$OWKRXJKWKHUHDUHVRPHOHJLWLPDWH.LU.XPVWDQ.HVMXVWLI\LQJD

GXW\WRGHDOLQRUGHUWRSUHYHQWDKDUPWR.RPSHWLWLRQWKRVH.LU.XPVWDQ.HVDUHUHODWLYHO\UDUH

DQGZHUHQRWSUHVHQWLQHLWKHU$VSHQRURGDN7KH.RQVHTXHQ.HVRI$VSHQDQGRGDNZLOOEH

GHWULPHQWDOWR.RPSHWLWLRQXQOHVVWKRVH.DVHVDUHUHDGVRQDUURZO\WKDWWKH\ORVHWKHLU

SUH.HGHQWLDOYDOXH

1HZH.RQRPL.PRGHOVKDYHJUHDWO\DLGHGWKHXQGHUVWDQGLQJRIVWUDWHJL.EHKDYLRU

LQYROYLQJUHIXVDOVWRGHDODQGUHODWHGSUD.WL.HV7KHVHPRGHOVRIWHQKDYHDPELJXRXVZHOIDUH

SUHGL.WLRQV7KHUHIRUHEHIRUH.RQGHPQLQJDSUD.WL.HLWLVLQ.XPEHQWRQWKHH.RQRPLVWWR

DGGX.HHYLGHQ.HWRHVWDEOLVKWKDWWKHUHLVLQGHHGOLNHO\WREHDVLJQLIL.DQWKDUPWR.RPSHWLWLRQ

IURPWKHSUD.WL.H:LWKRXWVX.KHYLGHQ.HWKHH[SDQVLRQRIDQWLWUXVWLQWR.UHDWLQJDGXW\WRGHDO

ZLOOZLQGXSKDUPLQJ.RQVXPHUZHOIDUH

$QGSHUKDSVWKH0LURVRIWDVHLVRQHRIWKRVHXQXVXDOLUXPVWDQHVEHDXVHRIWKHXQXVXDOO\ODUJHDPRXQWRIYHU\UHYHDOLQJHPDLORQWKHWRSLRIWKHWLHLQ



)LJ

3ULH 33

&&

TV 4XDQWLW\

Análisis General de las conductas exclusorias

Documents

Transcript of Análisis General de las conductas exclusorias