MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±°...

158

Transcript of MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±°...

Page 1: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

����������� ���������� �������������������������� �"!#��$%��&'�($

)+*-,/.103242457698�51*;:<24=?>@>3A4BDC;E�>GFIH/,JA�57KLHMK30GE�57H'A�57H/2/N�>O*;HP.7>@>3Q�2R6�>3ES03*-51*LA4E�51*;2T51,P=?0GC�A�>UC;E�>GFIH/,'A�5VKLHP2TCW03,'H3XY B;H-*�0GA�Z�E[03.\57*�A4E451*;2457,-.157*;H�]�Z;*;^;.7H/2_0GE�H`A�B;H�KG0GE�57>OZ;2aA�H/*;2T>3E<C(>�bcH'E42<>O6ed fgNc03*;^h24>i>O*;H-512a.1H/^jA�>,/>O*;2457^;H'EDA�B;H"C�.1Z�E�57,k03*;>O*;51,k03.S.751*;Hk0GED24HJE�51H/2ml nDo_f?lpX Y B;Hq>3]�K�57>OZ;2DrsZ;H/2TA�57>O*t0GE45124H/2'NubuB�0GA�576MA4B;H/24H24H'E451H/2a0GE�HD03.1.vH'=<C;Aw8�x Y B;H�03*;2TbcHJEa572g2TA4E�5VQ�51*;:;Ny>O*;H`>O6\A�B;HDC;E451*;,/5VCW03.\03,/,/>O=<C�.75124B;=?H'*�A�2#>O6Rzq>3E�5|{}2C;E�>O:3E[03=-~�W�1�m�#� �s���%��� �I�����������@���y�������+�y���s�#�W������������� ����� ���������W��� ���%� �@��¡�¢%�D£ ¤J¥ ¦ §¨¤#©<ªJ«?¬�¬�¥®­¯±° ¬+²k¤[³J¥|´�µ3¤Mµ3© ° ´¶¤'¥®·D¬+¸º¹G´»«?¤J¼;ª¨´½¬�¼¾©G¥¿«?¬%ª¨¥v¥®­ ° ¤¨¤kÀ

Á ­;¤'¼ l n�o_f_l ´�ª#¤J« ¯ ¥®·e¸k¬ ° ©GÂ� nÄàŠ´ÇÆ ¦ ´�ªg³[¬�µ3¤ ° ¤�¹`§'·<´�«<©%È�¤¨ª#¬+¸\É�ÊLÀË»Ì H<2�0�8 ¦ 512#,/>�KLH'E�H/^Í]�8Í51=?03:OH/2P>O6 É�Ê 516\6�>3E#H'KLHJE48�C(>O57*�AuÎ�>O6 ¦ N�bcH_=?0�8ÐÏ�*;^j0�=?>3E4C�B;512T=

Ñ ~ É�Ê<Ò±Ó ¦ 24Z;,[BÍA�B�0GAPA�B;HaC(>O51*LAeÎÍ]±H/.1>O*;:O2ÔA�> Ñ Ë É�ÊJÕ N beB;H'E4H?B;H'E�H3Ny032P51*�H'KLHJE48�>3A�B;HJEº^;H'Ï�*;5VA�51>O*51*LKL>O.7K@51*;:a0a=?>3ETC�B;5124=Ö69E�>O=×0a,'Z�E4KLHÔA�><0a24Z�E46�03,/H3N�bvHME�H'r@Z;57E4H Ñ A�>a]±HP*;>O*@ؽ,'>O*;2TA[03*LAkX Õ)+*DA4B;512cCW0GC(H'ERbcHM,/>O*;2457^;H'EuA4B;HÔ03*�03.7>O:O>OZ;2\r@Z;H/2TA451>O*-6�>3ERrsZ�03245VØ|C;E�>GFIH/,'A�5VKLH Ë >3Eu=<>3E�HS:OH/*;H'E[03.7.78`.7>O: Õ

KG0GE�51H'A451H/2/Xº)+6\ÙÚ572Ô0D24=?>s>3A�Bqr@Z�03245ÛضC;E�>GFIH/,'A457KLHgK30GE�57H'Aw8LN�A�B;H/*�N�6�>O.1.1>�bu51*;:`)I5VA[0GQG0�N�>O*;HgC�51,�Q@2P0`24=?>s>3A�B,/>O=<CW03,JA�57Ï�,k0GA451>O*<ÙÝÜ ¦ 24Z;,[BUA�B�0GA�A�B;Hc,/>O=<C�.7H/=?H/*LAyÞàß ¦âá Ù�512y0ã^;57K@5124>3E be5VA�Bg*;>3E�=_03.@,JE�>O242457*;:O2/XY B;H#.151*;H/0GES24H'E�57H/2_l n Ë o_f ähÞ Õ lsA�Z�E�*q>OZ�ASA�>_^;H'C±H/*;^i>O*;.V8�>O*�ÙgN�*;>3Aã>O* ¦ >3EãÞ"N(03*;^Ð572eA�B�Z;2SA�B;H*�0GA�Z�E[03.�03*�03.1>O:OZ;H\>O6ål n�o_f_læXel n Ë o_f`ä?Þ Õ l�572å,/03.1.1H'^UA�B;H\.7>O:ãC�.7Z�E�51,/03*;>O*;51,k03.;24HJE�51H/2'Ns03*;^gA�B;HcC;E�>3]�.7H/=512\A�>a,¨B�0GE�03,'A�H'E�5724HPA�B;>O2THP24=?>s>3A�BDr@Z�03245ÛضC;E�>GFIH/,'A457KLHãK30GE�57H'A�57H/2u6�>3EubeB;57,[B-A�B;HP.7>O:aC�.7Z�E�51,k03*;>O*;57,k03.�24H'E�57H/20GE�HÔ03.1.�H/=<C;Aw8LXÌ B;H/*-Ùç512¿0P,/Z�E4KLHuA�B;H�24>O.7Z�A�51>O*?572¿H/.7H/=?H/*LA[0GE48LN�l n Ë o_fÐä�Þ Õ lG512¿H'=<C;Aw8<6�>3Ev03.1.WnÄàÅP57èÐÙéßëê Ê

>3E É�Ê X)+*�^;51=<H/*;2451>O*�Awbc>�A�B;H<C;E�>3]�.7H/=ì572º03.7E4Hk03^�8¾2TZ�E4C;E�512T51*;:O.78¾24Z�];A�.7H3N�03*;^ÍB�032PE�H',/H/57KLH'^j,'>O*;2451^;H'E�0G]�.1H

0GA4A�H'*�A�57>O*�X¿íS*�57=<C(>3ETAu2IC(H/,/5103. ,/0324HÔb\032u24H'A4A4.1H/^-]�8�zÐ5V8�03*;5124B;5�03*;^ Y 24Z;*;>s^�0�N�î}ï�ð/ñ|N�îòïLó�ñ¶N;03*;^�6�Z�ETA�B;H'EE�H/2TZ;.7A�2cB�0kKLH�](H/H'*D>3];A�0351*;H/^_]�8Dô(B�03*;:;N�î}ïOõGñ|X�öSH'E�H�>OZ�E\=_0357*?:O>L03.±572c0º,/>O=<C�.7H'A�H3N@03*;^`24H/.161ض,/>O*LA[0351*;H/^24>O.7Z�A�51>O* Ë A�B�E�>OZ;:OB;>OZ�ARA�B;HÔCW0GC±H'EkN�H'KLH'ET8@A�B;57*;:aA[0GQLH/2RC�.903,/HM>�KLH'E�÷ Õ ~�W�®�ë�#� �@�W�%���h�D£ ¤J¥ Ù §¨¤"©Ðª¨«?¬%¬�¥»­âø'ù;©Gª¨´�ú ¯±° ¬+²k¤[³'¥®´�µO¤?µG© ° ´¶¤J¥|·j¬+¸-¹G´�«?¤'¼;ª¨´¶¬�¼ë©3¥Ô«?¬�ª¨¥Ô¥|ûv¬OÀ Á ­�¤J¼l n Ë o_f�ä�Þ Õ l ´�ª#¤J« ¯ ¥®·�¸k¬ ° ©GÂ� nÄÃëÅ ´ÇÆ Ù ´�ªº¹s¬�«g´�¼±©3¥w¤�¹D§'·?´�«<©�È�¤Jª#¬+¸ ê Ê;ÀÌ H?240�8�Ùà512 � ���Í�®� �����@�Ýü����®����ýW��¡q��þU�tÿL� �%�W��� N�516cA�B;HJE�H_512#0"^;H/*;2THD>3C±H/*m24Z�]�24H'A�� >O6

Ù 03*;^h6�>3E?H'KLHJE48mC(>O51*LAãΠ>O6��<N�bvH-,k03*�Ï�*;^h0¾*;>O*@ؽ,/>O*;2IA[03*�A<=?>3E4C�B;5724= Ñ ~ � Ò�Ó Ù 24Z;,[BhA�B�0GAÎ�� Ñ Ë �ºÕ X Ì HÔ2�0k8qÙÝ512R^;>O=?57*�0GA�H/^�]�8`E[0GA�57>O*�03.�,/Z�E4KLH/2/NW516 57Au512R^;>O=?51*�0GA4H/^�]�8D51=_03:OH/2\>O6 É�Ê X

������ ��������������������� ������! "�$#����&%'�(�$�*),+�-/.10�0�2.

Page 2: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

) ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

Ì Ha*;>3A�HaA�B�0GAÔA�B;HaE4H'KLH'E�24H<^;57E�H/,JA�51>O*�>O6�A�B;H<57=<C�.157,k0GA�51>O*Ð51* Ë ðOX1ð Õ 512Ô6�0357E�.V8i2IA4E[0351:OBLA�6�>3E4bc0GE�^�N�03*;^B;>O.1^;2<51* 03.1.R^;51=<H/*;2451>O*;2'NR2TH/H Ë�� X7ðOð Õ X Y B�Z;2 Ë ðOX1ð Õ ,k03*h]±H�K�51HJbcH/^ 032?2�0k8�57*;:;NcH/57A4B;H'E-Ù B�032_0�.7>O:C�.1Z�E451,k03*;>O*;57,k03.�24H/,'A�57>O*�N�>3ERA�B;H'E4HP512u0a,'.1Hk0GEu:OH/>O=?H'ATE�51,SE�Hk032T>O*-beBL8D57Au,k03*;*;>3AkXY B;H<>3A�B;H'EP=_0351*ÐE�H/24Z;.VA�2º>O6¿A4B;512ÔCW0GC±H'E#0GE4H<KLH'E48Ð2TA4E4>O*;:-CW0GE4A�5103.å,'.90324245VÏ�,k0GA�57>O*;2º>O6v.1>O:�^;H/.���H����/>

24Z�E�6�03,'H/2/N�A�B�0GAM512SC;E�>GFIH/,'A�5VKLHg24Z�E�6�03,/H/2Mbe5VA�BÐr@Z;>3A�57H/*�Aã2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457A�57H/2M03*;^ Ò o���03=<C�.1HGX Y B;512ã51*;,/.7Z;^;H/20a,'.90324245VÏ�,k0GA�57>O*�>O6�03.7.�]�Z�Ae0a]±>OZ;*;^;H/^�6�03=?57.78`>O6�.7>O:a^;H/.���H����'>?24Z�E�6�03,/H'2�>O6��¿57,k0GE�^�*sZ;=#](HJE�>O*;H3X Ì Hbu51.1.åH �@C�.90351*iA�B;512º,'.90324245VÏ�,k0GA�57>O*Í0GAPA�B;H<H/*;^m>O6vA�B;512Ô51*LA4E�>@^;Z;,JA�51>O*�X Ì H<]±H/.157H'KLHaA�B�0GAÔbe5VA�BÍ24Z"!<,/51H/*LAH'è±>3E4AuA4B;HP=?H'A4B;>@^;2R>O6 A�B;HMCW0GC(H'ERbc>OZ;.1^�8�51H'.1^�0U,/>O=<C�.7H'A�Hã,/.9032T2457Ï�,k0GA451>O*�X

#�>O:-^;H/.���H����/>-24Z�E�6�03,/H/2g0GE4H<>O6¿57*�A4H'E�H/2TAº6�>3Eº24H'KLHJE[03.�E�Hk0324>O*;2/N 51*;^;H'C±H/*;^;H/*LA�.78¾>O6 Ë ðOX1ð Õ X Y B;H'8¾0GE�H>3]�K�51>OZ;2T.78D51=<C±>3E4A[03*LAe6�>3EuA�B;HP2IA�Z;^�8->O6 >3C(H/*"24Z�E46�03,/H/2/X%$cH'8L>O*;^-A4B;512/N�A�B;HP.7>O:<,k0GA4H/:O>3E48�512R51=<C±>3E4A[03*LAH'KLH/*Ð6�>3ESA�B;H#2TA4Z;^�8">O6åC;E4>3FIH','A�57KLHºKG0GE�57H'A�51H'2ebe5VA�B�N(6�>3EMH �;03=<C�.1H3N�.1>O:_24Z�E46�03,/H/2 Ë 24Z�E�6�03,/H'2ãbu57A4Bq]±>OZ;*;^@Ø0GE48 Õ C�.10�8@51*;:�03*¾57*�A�HJE�=?H/^;510GE48�E'&>O.7HU]±H'AwbcH/H/*�2TZ�E�6�03,/H/2P03*;^¾A�B�E�H/H'6�>O.1^;2/X)(M>s>@^ÐH ��03=aC�.1H/2ã>O6�A4B;512Ô0GE�H*Ô0�b\03=?0GA[0�{æ2#C;E�>s>O6e>O6uA4B;H�í�]�Z;*;^�03*;,/H-,/>O*�FIH/,'A�Z�E4H3N\03*;^�+@B;>3Q@Z�E�>%K±{æ2gC;E�>O:3E[03= 6�>3E),�.157C�2'X-#�>O:¾^;H'.��H����'>O2�03.12T><>@,',/Z�ES032\A�B;HP,'H/*�ATE�H/2e>O6 .Gؽ6�>O.1^�.1>O:0/�57C�2/X)+*?03^;^;5VA�51>O*U.1>O:Ô^;H/.1��H����/>O2åC�.90k8U03*<H/242TH/*�A45903.�E'&>O.1HR51*UA�B;Hu,'>O=<CW03,'A�5VÏ�,k0GA�51>O*U>O6�A4B;Hu=?>s^;Z;.15;2TCW03,'He>O6

24Z�E�6�03,'H/2e>O6�:OH/*;H'E[03.(Aw8sC(H3X Y B;H'8`>@,/,'Z�E�0GAcA�B;HS]±>OZ;*;^�0GE48`>O6�A4B;HÔ=?>s^;Z;.15�2TCW03,/HM>O6 24Z�E46�03,/H/2e>O6�:OH/*;H'E�03.Aw8@C±H Ë FIZ;2IAS032\E[0GA�51>O*�03.�,/Z�ETKLH/2e>s,/,/Z�ES0GARA�B;Hã](>OZ;*;^�0GE48�>O6 A4B;HP=?>s^;Z;.15�2TCW03,/HÔ>O6�,/Z�E4KLH'2 Õ NW03*;^"0GE�HMA�B;H=_0357*�>3]�FIH/,'Aa>O6e2IA�Z;^�8j51*�A4B;HDC;E�>s>O6�2<>O6uíS.1H ��H/H'K({}2#](>OZ;*;^;H/^;*;H/2T2?A�B;H/>3E�H/=<2-î}ó�ñ¶N�Z;24H/^�A�>Ð24B;>�bÖA�B;H=?>s^;Z;.15�2TCW03,/HÔ512\C;E�>GFIH/,'A�5VKLH3XÌ H�bu51.7.(Z;24HSA�B;Hã6�>O.1.7>%bu51*;:#A�H'E4=?51*;>O.7>O:38LX2(M5VKLH/*D0gKG0GE�51HJA+8 ¦ N�.1H'A ¦43 ^;H/*;>3A�HSA�B;Hã24=<>@>3A�B_.7>@,/Z;2\>O6

¦ X�W�6587D�:9y�����%���±�¿� #�H'A ¦ ](H�0ãK30GE451H'Aw8LN � 0M,/Z�E4KLH�57* ¦ 03*;^<ÞÚ0Ô2TZ�]�24H'Ac>O6 ¦ X Ì HR2�0k8aA4B�0GA � =?H/HJA�2Þ<;?A�51=?H'2R576 A�B;HÔ51*LKLH'E�24HÔ51=_03:OHã>O6 Þ >O*�A�B;HÔ*;>3E�=_03.7512�0GA�57>O*`>O6 � 512u0a24H'Ae>O6�;<C(>O51*LA�2/X

,W>3EcH ��03=aC�.1HS0º24=<>@>3A�B?C±>O51*LAc>3ER0ºZ;*;57];E[03*;,[B�2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8?>O6 � ,'>OZ;*�A�2\>O*;,/HGN;03*;^�=<>3E�H�:OH/*;H'E�03.1.780a2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457Aw8_be5VA�B>=#];E[03*;,[B;H/2e,/>OZ;*�A42?=#A�51=?H'2/N�E�H/:L0GE�^;.7H/242u>O6 A�B;HÔ>3E�^;H'Eu>O6�,/>O*LA[03,'AkXÌ HU*;>3A�Ha03.124>`A�B�0GAMA�B�E�>OZ;:OB;>OZ�AMA�B;HUCW0GC±H'EkN�]s8i0_E[0GA�51>O*�03.�,'Z�E4KLH3N�bcH<=?H/03*¾0D,/>O=<C�.1HJA�H#E[0GA�51>O*�03.

,/Z�E4KLHGNWA�B�0GAR572�03*-57=_03:OHã>O6 É�Ê X@$c8`Z;*;5VE�Z;.1H'^�NWbcHÔ=?Hk03*D^;>O=?51*�0GA4H/^�]�8`E[0GA�51>O*�03.�,/Z�ETKLH/2/XA ÀCB�À AED ¤J«<© °GF ª/À )+6�0<,/>O=aC�.1H'A�HSKG0GE�51HJA+8D572e^;>O=?57*�0GA�H/^`]s8DE[0GA�57>O*�03.�,/Z�E4KLH/2/N�A�B;H/*"5VAR512e57*-6�03,'Ae,/>�KLH'E�H/^]�8?E[0GA�57>O*�03.�,/Z�ETKLH/2 Ë A�B�0GAv572vA�B�E�>OZ;:OB`H'KLH'ET8<C(>O57*�AcA4B;H'E�HS512v0PE[0GA�51>O*�03.�,/Z�E4KLH Õ N�2451*;,'H�A�B;HS^;H/:OH/*;H'E�0GA�51>O*>O6�0gE[0GA�57>O*�03.�,'Z�E4KLHP572e03:L0357*DE[0GA451>O*�03.|X)+*_A�B;HS^;H'Ï�*;57A451>O*D>O6�^;>O=<51*�0GA�57*;:;N@>O*;HS,k03*DH/r@Z;5VK303.7H/*LA�.78aE�H/r@Z;5VE�HSA�B�0GAvA�B;Hã=_0GC�2 Ñ ~ � ÒWÓ Ù 6�>3E4=

00/W0GAu6�03=?57.78 Ë 24H'H Ë )IHgX7ðOXpï�X � Õ >O6cîæó3õGñ Õ XJ ����� �@ÿ3�%�»���×üå�s�J�#�@�@� �¨�W�»��¢j�W���LK»�WýÚ� �MKON��MPQPL�Ú¡k� �%þ½�WÿL�@¡3� )+*tC;E�>�K�57*;: Ë ðOX7ð Õ >O*;HÐA4E451H/2`A�>2457=<C�.157698UA4B;He245VA�Z�0GA�51>O*a]s8<0Ô]�57E�0GA�51>O*�03.�,/>O*LA4E[03,'A451>O*SRM~ ¦ìÒ�Ó T >O6�03*?57ETE�H/^;Z;,/5V]�.1H�,/Z�ETKLH?U Ü ¦ X�)+*

Page 3: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � �

>3E�^;H'EyA�>SC;E�H'24H'E4KLH\A�B;H\^;51=?H'*;2451>O*g>O6yl n Ë o_f`ä?Þ Õ lpNL5VAy512�24Z"!<,/51H/*LAåA�B�0GA Ë o_f`ä?Þ Õ�� U�� Å�X��S*;^;H'EåA�B;H,/>O*LA4E[03,'A451>O*�NOA�B;H%�¿57,k0GE�^g*sZ;=#]±H'Eå:O>@H/2y^;>�be*g]s8º>O*;H3N�03*;^a69E�>O=�A4B;512�C(>O57*�Ay>O6�K�57H'bPN T 572å2T51=<C�.7H'E�A�B�03*¦ X Y B;Hu,/>O=<C�.751,k0GA�57>O*a572�A�B�0GA T ,/03*_B�0�KLHur@Z;>3A�57H/*�A�2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2 Ë 576 UÝB�032�24H/.161ض51*LA�H'E�2TH/,'A�57>O*`0GA¿=?>O2IAÒ ó Õ X Ì HvE�H'C�.103,/H Ë ¦�� Þ Õ ]�8 Ë T�� Þ! jß R�" Ë Þ Õ4Õ NL03*;^U,/>O*�A451*�Z;H3NO]s8#.7>@>3Q@51*;:S6�>3Eå0 Ë o# Mä<Þ$ Õ Ø½*;H/:L0GA�5VKLH,/>O*LA4E[03,'A451>O*�X@+@Z;,[B�0º2TH'E�51H'2v>O6�,/>O*LA[03,'A�57>O*;2v512v,/03.1.1H'^?A�B;H Ë o_fÐä"Þ Õ Ø½=<51*;51=?03.W=<>@^;H/.;C;E�>O:3E[03= Ë zqz �6�>3Eu24B;>3E4A Õ X)+6c0GAMA�B;H?2TA[0GETA�l n Ë o_fëäëÞ Õ lWß&%-6�>3E#03.7.yn à Å�N A�B;H'*�A�B;H�#�>O:�í�]�Z;*;^�03*;,/H Y B;H/>3E�H'=ì51=aC�.151H'2

A�B�0GAuH/57A4B;H'E ¦ B�032�0UÏ;];E�0GA�51>O* ¦ìÒ�Ó � buB;>O24HP:OH/*;HJE[03.�Ï;];E�HP572 É�Ê 03*;^-=?H/H'A�2RÞ 0GAu=?>O2TAR>O*;,/HGNW>3E/NbcH#B�0kKLHg0<]�57E[0GA451>O*�03.�=?>3E4C�B;512T= RM~ ¦ Ò�Ó ' N(0?,/>O=<C(>O2T57A�57>O*�>O6y,/>O*�ATE[03,'A�57>O*;2S032ã0G](>�KLH3N�bu57A4B ' >O6�¿57,k0GE�^Ð*sZ;=#]±H'EP>O*;HGN 03*;^io��aä ÞS��03*LA�5Vؽ03=<C�.1HU03*;^i.1>O:_A�H'E�=<51*�03. Ë ^;5724,/Z;242TH/^�](H/.7>%b Õ XP)+*ÐA�B;HUÏ;E42TA,k0324HP>O6�,/>OZ�E�24HÔbcHÔA[0GQLHãA�B;Hº:OH'*;H'E[03.�Ï;];E�H3Xv)+*-A�B;HÔ24H/,/>O*;^",k032TH3N ¦ 572e^;>O=?57*�0GA�H/^D]s8DE[0GA�57>O*�03.�,'Z�E4KLH/2=?H/HJA�51*;:#Þ×0GA\=?>O2TA¿>O*;,/H3N;5Vè ' 572c^;>O=?51*�0GA4H/^_]s8?E�0GA�51>O*�03.W,/Z�E4KLH/2\=?H'H'A�51*;:ER Ë Þ Õ 0GA\=?>O2TAc>O*;,/HGX Y B;H>O*;HP^;57=?H/*;2457>O*�03.�CW0GE4Ae>O6 R Ë Þ Õ 572eÞ���N;A�B;H��/H'E�>?^;57=?H/*;2457>O*�03.(CW0GE4AkN �?N�512u0aZ;*;51>O*->O6�,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*�A42e>O6Þ ,'>O*�A4E�03,'A�H/^�]�8�RåX�)+*-A�B;572Rbc0�8LN Ë ðOX7ð Õ 512uE4H/^;Z;,/H/^ Ë 03*;^�51*�6�03,'A�H/rsZ;57KG03.1H/*LA Õ A�>;~�W�)(��#� �s���%���h�`£ ¤J¥�' §J¤ã©º¼�¬ ° «<©3 ¯±° ¬+²k¤[³J¥|´�µ3¤\ªJù ° ¸/©�³[¤Ô¬+¸+*\´¶³�© ° ¹P¼�ù@«<§¨¤ ° ¬�¼(¤-,�ûy´»¥»­`ø'ù�¬G¥®´¶¤'¼�¥ ª¨´�¼@ÈGù@úÂ7© ° ´�¥®´½¤¨ª/À/.Wù ¯L¯ ¬%ªk¤ Þ Ü '�´�ªã© ° ¤�¹GùW³[¤�¹<³Jù ° µ3¤0,�ª¨ùW³¨­<¥®­�©G¥ o��\ä"Þ ´�ªeÂ1¬�È#¥+¤ ° «g´�¼±©GÂ1,�©G¼±¹#Ò Ë o��\ä"Þ ÕS´�ª©G« ¯ Â1¤kÀS£ ¤J¥ � Ü '�§¨¤U©G¼�·32å¼W´�¥w¤Pªk¤J¥u¬+¸ ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥®ª/À Á ­;¤'¼4'�´�ª#¹�¬G«g´�¼±©G¥+¤�¹�§'· ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼(©GÂ�³Jù ° µ3¤Jª5,¿«?¤¨¤J¥®´»¼@ÈÞ76 � ©3¥¿«_¬%ª¨¥R¬�¼(³[¤kÀíS*DH/.1H/=<H/*�A�0GE48_^;512T,/Z;242457>O*->O6 A4B;HM*;>3A451>O*D>O6 .7>O:gA4H'E�=?57*�03.(512\:O57KLH'*�57*�í�C;C±H/*;^;5 ��#åX Ì HM*;>3A�HãB;H'E�H

Ë 24>"A�B�0GA#A4B;H`E4Hk03^;H'Ea=_0�8¾B�0�KLH`24>O=<H_51^;Hk0">O6\A�B;H_A�H'E�=�{}2º=?Hk03*;57*;: Õ A�B�0GAg516RÞ 512g57ETE�H/^;Z;,/5V]�.1H_A�B;H/*o��#ä�Þ 572e.1>O:aA�H'E�=?57*�03.�57èÐA�B;HÔCW035VE Ë '�� Þ Õ B�032er@Z;>3A451H/*LA�2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2/N;A�B�0GA�572e.1>s,k03.1.V8D03*�03.78sA�51,k03.7.78A�B;H�rsZ;>3A�51H'*�A�>O6�0P24=?>s>3A�BaCW035VE Ë '98�� Þ 8�Õ ]�8<0ÔÏ�*;57A�He:3E�>OZ�C�X2,�>3EåA�B;H Ë o��\ä�Þ Õ Ø¶zÐz ��Ns.1>O:ÔA4H'E�=?57*�03.W572A�B;Hã,/>3E4E4H/,'AR:OH/*;H'E[03.7512�0GA451>O*`>O6�*;>3E�=_03.(,'E4>O242451*;:O2'N;51*_A�B;Hã24H/*;24HãA�B�0GA\5VA\512cC;E�H/24HJE4KLH/^�]�8?A�B;HS]�5VE[0GA�51>O*�03.,/>O*LA4E[03,'A451>O*;2uA4B�0GAu>s,/,/Z�Ee51*�A4B;H Ë o��ºä�Þ Õ Ø½=?57*;51=_03.�=?>@^;H/.�C;E�>O:3E�03=�X)+*i6�03,JAP57* Ë ðOXæï Õ 57AM512ãH/*;>OZ;:OBÐA�>D,/>O*;2451^;HJEÔA�B;HU,k0324H��Úß +@51*;: Ë 'åÕ X Y B;Ha=?0351*"C(>O57*�AM](H/B;57*;^iA�B;572

E�H/^;Z;,JA�51>O*Í572ºzq>3E�5|{}2P>3]�24H'ETK30GA�57>O*�A�B�0GAº>O*m0�24=?>@>3A4B¾2TCW03,/HGN�A�B;H?:OH/*;H'E�03.¿=?H/=#]±H'EP>O6\0�^;>O=?51*�0GA�57*;:6�03=?57.78`>O6 57=_03:OH/2\>O6 ê Ê ^;H/6�>3E4=?2e69E�H'H/.78 Ë 032u03*�51=?03:OHM>O6�ê ÊGÕ 03*;^�24>a51*-CW0GETA�51,/Z;.10GEe=<512424H'2e03*L8`Ï"�;H/^,/>s^;51=?H/*;2T51>O*�Awbc>i24Z�]�24H'A/Nc24H/H Ë � X � Õ 03*;^ Ë�� X1: Õ X Y B�Z;2 Ë ðOXæï Õ ,/03*�](H�H/r@Z;5VK303.7H/*�A4.78 Ë 03*;^h2T>O=?H'buB�0GA=?>3E�HM03H/2IA�B;H'A�57,k03.1.V8 Õ 2TA[0GA�H'^"032/~�W�)(��®� �#� �@�W���@�h��£ ¤'¥;' §¨¤Ð©�¼(¬ ° «<©G ¯±° ¬+²k¤[³J¥|´�µ3¤`ªJù ° ¸/©�³[¤i¬+¸<*\´¶³�© ° ¹¾¼�ù@«<§¨¤ ° ¬�¼�¤0,Uûy´�¥®­âø'ùW¬�¥|´¶¤J¼�¥ª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ª/À=.�ù ¯L¯ ¬%ªk¤ Þ ´�ª#© ° ¤�¹3ù�³[¤[¹D³Jù ° µ3¤0,yªJù�³¨­-¥»­;©G¥ o��Pä�Þ ´�ªMÂ1¬�È?¥w¤ ° «g´�¼±©3Â1,\©G¼±¹<Ò Ë o��Ôä�Þ Õ´�ªº©3« ¯ Â1¤kÀ Á ­;¤J¼>' 3 ´�ªº¹s¬�«g´�¼±©3¥w¤�¹D§'· ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼±©3 ³Jù ° µ3¤¨ªPû�­�´¶³¨­�«?¤[¤J¥ Þ ©G¥v«?¬%ªJ¥R¬G¼(³[¤kÀíS2\bcHPbu51.1.�H �@C�.90357*-24B;>3E4A4.78LN;A�B;Hº=_0357*Dbv>3E4Q-572uC;E�>�K�57*;: Ë ðOXæï Õ 57*-A�B;HÔ,k0324HPbuB;H/*"Þ 572eH/=<C;Aw8LN�03*;^

512RA�B�Z;2eA�>?24B;>�b A�B�0GAeA�B;HP24=?>@>3A4B-.1>s,/Z;2e>O6y0a.1>O:<^;H'. ��H����'>_24Z�E�6�03,/Hº572eZ;*;5VE�Z;.1H/^ Ë A4B�0GAe572�^;>O=?51*�0GA4H/^

Page 4: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

]�8�,'>O=<C�.1H'A4HME[0GA451>O*�03.�,/Z�E4KLH'2 Õ X� Z�E�C;E�>@>O6@>O6 Ë ðOXpï Õ C;E�>@,'H/H/^;2 E�>OZ;:OB;.V8º032 6�>O.1.1>�bu2/~�,W>3E�>O*;H¿,/.903242 >O6�E[03*�QÔ>O*;H¿.1>O:e^;H/.M��H����/>S24Z�E�6�03,/H'2/N

A�B;>O24Hgbu57A�B¾0`A�57:OH'E Ë ^;H'Ï�*;H/^¾]±H/.1>�b Õ N�bcH<:O5VKLHa0D24B;>3E4AP03*;^¾H/.7H/:L03*LAP^;H/6�>3E4=_0GA�51>O*qA�B;H/>3E4H'A�51,gC;E�>s>O6¿>O6Ë ðOXæï Õ N�24H/H Ë õ�X7ð Õ X%$c>OZ;*;^;H/^;*;H/242�E4H/24Z;.7A42S>O6�íS.1H ��H/H'K-03*;^ *Ô>O.7.��0GEe51=<C�.V8DA4B�0GAeE[03*�Q�>O*;Hº.1>O:a^;H/. ��H����/>O2bu57A�B;>OZ�A�0MA451:OH'E�0GE�Hc](>OZ;*;^;H'^�N@24H/H Ë ó3ï�X1ð Õ X Ì HR,/>O=<C�.7H'A�HcA�B;H\C;E�>@>O6W]s8U,/>O*;2TATE�Z;,'A�57*;:º03*<HG��C�.157,/57AyÏ�*;5VA�H.1572TAM>O6�6�03=<51.157H/2S>O6�E�03*�Qq>O*;Ha.7>O:D^;H'.���H����/>O2ãbeB;57,¨Bi51*;,/.7Z;^;H/2º03*L8"bu57A�BÐ*;>�A�57:OH'EM03*;^ibuB;>O24HU24=?>s>3A�B.1>s,/Z;2¿B�032�A4E�57K@5903.�03.7:OH'];E[0351,u6�Z;*;^�03=?H/*LA[03.±:3E4>OZ�C Ë 57A¿512�Hk032T8UA�>PE�H/^;Z;,'H Ë ðOX1ð Õ A�>ÔA4B;512v,k032TH3N@24H'H ��� Õ X ,W>3EHk03,[B�>O6 A4B;HÔ24Z�E46�03,/H/2�57*�A�B;572e.1572TAkN�bcHÔ^;57E�H','A�.78`,'>O*;2TA4E�Z;,'AS0a^;>O=?57*�0GA�51*;:g6�03=?57.78`>O6 E�0GA�51>O*�03.�,/Z�ETKLH/2/XÌ H<bu51.7.�HG��C�.90357*m03.1.åA�B;512º57*Í=gZ;,¨Bm:3E�H/0GA�H'E#^;H'A�0351.�]±H/.1>�bÔN ]�Z�A#Ï;E�2TA#bcHaC;E�H/24H/*LAU24>O=?H_03^;^;5VA�51>O*�03.

E�H/2TZ;.7A�2\beB;57,[B�0GE�HM>O6 57*;^;H'C(H/*;^;H'*�AS57*�A4H'E�H/2TA/X�zq>O2TAe0GE�Hã,/>3E�>O.7.90GE�57H/2\>O6 Ë ðOX7ð Õ X ��E�>s>O6�2e0GE4HM:O5VKLH/*-57* � ó3Å�XÌ HMbe57.1.�Z;24HMA�B;HÔ6�>O.7.1>�be57*;:<*;>3A[0GA451>O*�Xê Ê" ßëê Ê�á�� Å�LX )+*ºK�57H'bj>O6 Ë�� X7ðOð Õ NG5VA�512 *�0GA�Z�E[03.LA�>eA�B;57*�QP>O6�ê Ê 03*;^ºê Ê" 032 A�B;H¿>3C(H/*g03*�03.7>O:OZ;H/2�>O6 É�Ê

03*;^-H'.1.15VC;A�51,ã,/Z�ETKLH/2/NW2451*;,/HãA�B;HMH �;572TA�H/*;,'HP>O6 ^;>O=<51*�0GA�57*;:gE�0GA�51>O*�03.®N�>3EeH'.1.15VC;A�51,ã6�03=?57.157H/2cB�032e03*�03.7>O:O>OZ;251=aC�.151,/0GA�51>O*;2\>O*->3E4^;51*�0GE48�*M>@^�0357E�0a^;51=<H/*;2451>O*�X

�W���NÔ�%� ����¡k���%�����¿��£ ¤'¥�� Ü ' §¨¤?© ° ¤�¹GùW³[¤�¹q³Jù ° µO¤`¬�¼�©-¼(¬ ° «<©G ¯(° ¬+²k¤¨³J¥®´»µ3¤#ª¨ù ° ¸/©�³[¤?©3¼±¹Dªk¤J¥ Ù ß'�á Ë � 6 +@51*;: Ë 'åÕ4Õ�À��¿¬�¼�ª¨´|¹�¤ ° ¥»­�¤å¸k¬�Â�Â1¬�ûå´�¼@È�³¨¬�¼±¹G´�¥|´¶¬�¼�ª��

Ë ð Õ Á ­;¤��a¬k¹�©G´ ° ©_¹3´�«?¤J¼;ªJ´¶¬�¼�¬+¸ o��Pä � ´�ªM¼(¤½È�©G¥®´»µ3¤kÀË ó Õ o��ºä � ´�ªM¼Wùs«?¤ ° ´¶³�©3Â� ·_¥ ° ´�µ�´|©GÂ1,\§'ùs¥v¼(¬G¥�Â1¬�È-³�©G¼(¬G¼�´¶³�©GÂ7ÀË ï Õ o��ºä � ´�ªM¼Wùs«?¤ ° ´¶³�©3Â� ·_¥ ° ´�µ�´|©GÂ1,\©G¼±¹����ß % ÀË . Õ o�� ´�ªq¼�ùs«_¤ ° ´¶³[©GÂ� ·h¥ ° ´�µ�´|©GÂ1,�� ß % ,D©3¼±¹�' ­�©Gª¾©�ª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|·�û�­s´¶³¨­ ´�ª`� ���t©âø'ùW¬�¥|´¶¤J¼�¥

ª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|·OÀ� ¸M©3¼�·_¬+¸S¥®­;¤º©L§¨¬Gµ3¤S­;¬�Â7¹ ,奮­;¤J¼ Ù ´�ªÔ¹�¬�«g´�¼(©G¥w¤[¹<§/·U´�«<©%È�¤¨ªP¬+¸ ê Ê" ,v©3¼±¹_§'·g´�«?©�È�¤¨ªº¬+¸ ê Ê_´Ç¸�� A�� ¬ °

��B � ­;¬�Â7¹�ª/À

Ì HR*;>3A�HR>O*;He51*LA�H'E4H/2TA�57*;:º51=<C�.751,k0GA451>O*g>O6 Ë ðOX .;X ó Õ 03*;^ Ë � X1ðOð Õ ~ Y B;Hu,/>O=<C�.1H'=?H/*LA�>O6(0Ô51*LA�H/:3E�03.�C�.103*;H,/Z�]�57,3N � N�572M^;>O=<51*�0GA�H/^q]�8q51=_03:OH/2S>O6åê Ê 57è � B�032Ô0D,/Z;2IC�N >3E � 572SA�B;HgZ;*;51>O*¾>O6¿0D2T=?>@>3A�Bq,/>O*;57,03*;^"0gA[03*;:OH/*LAe.751*;H3N�>3E � 512RA�B;HÔZ;*;57>O*�>O6 A�B�E4H/HÔ.751*;H/2u=?H/H'A451*;:a0GA�0gC(>O51*LA Ë 51*;^;H/H/^�A�B;512R512�FIZ;2TAã0U.1512IA>O6 A4B;HP*;>O*�.7>O:a,k03*;>O*;57,k03.�C(>O24245V]�51.757A�57H/2 Õ X

�SH �@ARbvHPB�0kKLHP0gKLH'E�2457>O*�>O6 Ë ðOXæï Õ 6�>3ES03*L8D]±>OZ;*;^�0GE48(~

�W� � J �W���K K����%�y��.Wù ¯�¯ ¬%ªk¤u¥®­;¤ ¯ ©3´ ° Ë '���!<ÕS³[¬G¼;ª¨´�ª¨¥®ª�¬+¸e© ¯(° ¬+²k¤¨³J¥®´»µ3¤cª¨ù ° ¸/©�³[¤ ' ©G¼±¹#§¨¬Gùs¼±¹�© ° ·"!<, ª¨ùW³¨­¥®­�©G¥ o��ºä ! ´�ªÔÂ1¬�È�³�©3¼(¬�¼�´¶³[©GÂ7À Á ­;¤'¼�¤J´�¥®­;¤ °

Ë ð Õ l n Ë o��ºä !aÕ l ´�ªM¼(¬�¼Wú4¤J« ¯ ¥|·e¸k¬ ° ªk¬�«?¤ nÄàŠ,\¬ °Ë ó Õ Á ­;¤ ° ¤Ô´�ª#©�³[¬�µO¤ ° ´�¼�ÈR¸/©G«g´� ·�¬+¸ ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼±©3Â�³Jù ° µ3¤¨ª�� ,¿ª¨ù�³J­D¥»­;©G¥ Ë o��ºä !<Õ���� ��Å À

Page 5: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � �

Ë ðOX � Õ A�BsZ;2å2�0k8�2�A�B�0GAåH/5VA�B;H'Eå24>O=?H\=gZ;.7A�5VC�.1Hc>O6Wo��¿ä ! B�032�0ã24H/,JA�51>O*�N�>3EyA�B;H'E�H\512�0ã:O>@>@^g:OH/>O=<H'A4E�57,E�Hk032T>O*-beBL8D57Au^;>@H/2R*;>3AkX)wA =?0�8S]±HåA�H'=<C;A�51*;:RA�>u]±H/.157H'KLHyA�B�0GA Ë ðOX � Õ 6�>O.1.7>%bu2 03Z�A4>O=_0GA�51,/03.1.78�69E�>O=éA�B;H¿zqz �e~ � *;H�,k03*#03242TZ;=?H

A�B;H Ë o��gä !<Õ Ø¶zÐz � :O5VKLH/2M0_,/>O=<C(>O2T57A�57>O*">O6å,'>O*�A4E�03,'A�51>O*;2 Ñ ~ 'tÒ�Ó ' 8 24Z;,[BiA�B�0GA Ò Ë o 8� ä ! 8 Õ 57203=<C�.7H3X���KLH'E48�,/Z�E4KLHg=?H/H'A42 Ë o����;ä ! 8 Õ Ø½*;H/:L0GA457KLH/.V8LXSöS>%bcHJKLH'EkN�516�A�B;Hg,/Z�E4KLHg=?H'H'A�2�A�B;HgH ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03..1>s,/Z;2M>O6 Ñ N�57A�2M2TA4E�57,'AãA4E[03*;246�>3E4= =_0k8"](H Ë o��Uä !aÕ Ø¶C±>O2457A�5VKLH3X Y B�Z;2P57*¾>3E�^;HJEPA�>`C;E�>�KLH Ë ðOX � Õ 03.7>O*;:A�B;H/2TH<.157*;H/2P2T>O=?HUE4H/24Z;.7AP24Z;,[Bm032 Ë ðOXpï Õ 512ME�H/r@Z;5VE�H/^�XS+@Z;,¨Bm03*�0GA4A�H/=<C;A Ë 57*¾^;57=?H/*;2457>O*iA�B�E�H'H�� Õ b\032A�B;HÔ>3E�51:O57*�03.�51=<C±H'A�Z;2\6�>3EeA�B;572RCW0GC±H'EkX

�W��� J ���%�K K����%�y� � ¸ Ë '���!<Õu´�ª�©ÔÂ1¬�È�©G¼(¬Ôª¨ù ° ¸/©�³[¤R¥®­;¤J¼!' 3 ´�ª ° ©G¥®´½¬�¼±©GÂ� ·a³[¬�¼W¼(¤[³J¥+¤�¹ ,�©G¼(¹ Ùéß 'Ôá�� !� ´�ª#³¨¬�¼�¼(¤[³'¥w¤�¹D§'·a´»«<©�È�¤¨ªg¬+¸ ê Ê" À � ¼ ¯ © ° ¥®´½³JùsÂ7© ° , R Ê Ë ' 3 ÕÔ´�ª 2å¼�´�¥+¤0,c©3¼±¹ R Ê Ë Ù ÕP´�ªº©G «_¬%ª¨¥��㧨¤J ´¶©G¼±À

Ë íS.7=?>O2TAu0G](H/.75903*"572�^;H'Ï�*;H/^Ð51* ��� X Õ Y B;Hº=_0357*�51242TZ;H#51* Ë ðOXæõ Õ 572eA�B;H#Z;*;57E4Z;.1H/^;*;H/2T2M>O6�A4B;Hº24=?>s>3A�B.1>s,/Z;2S>O6å0?E[03*�Q">O*;H#.1>O:`^;H/. ��H����/>;X Y B;512�b\032S,/>O*�FIH','A�Z�E�H/^i]s8"zq5V8�03*;5124B;5�03*;^ Y 24Z;*;>@^�0�NåîòïOÅGñ¶X Y B;HÏ�*;57A4H/*;H/242�>O6ÔA�B;H�6�Z;*;^�03=?H/*LA[03.M:3E�>OZ�C R Ê Ë ' 3 Õ B�032�](H/H/*tH/2TA[0G]�.75124B;H/^ C;E4H'K�57>OZ;24.78ë51* îÛð�.3ñ7Ø[îVð � ñã03*;^24H'CW0GE�0GA�H/.78�51*éî :Gñ¶X Y B;H�24=<>@>3A�B�.1>@,'Z;2<>O6ã0¾.7>O: ,�03*;>¾A�B�E�H/H'6�>O.1^ Ë >3Ea24Z�E�6�03,/H Õ B�032aÏ�*;57A�H-03.1:OH'];E[0357,6�Z;*;^�03=?H/*LA[03.�:3E�>OZ�C-]�8-0U](>OZ;*;^;H'^;*;H/242�E�H/2TZ;.7Au>O6\î}õGñ|X

�W��� J �W���K K»�����y� .Wù ¯L¯ ¬�ªk¤ o��`ä ÞÖä ! ´�ª`Â1¬�Èi¥+¤ ° «U´�¼±©GÂ(¸k¬ ° ªk¬�«?¤Ð¤»ÆS¤[³J¥|´�µ3¤��Mú4¹G´�µ�´�ª�¬ ° !"À Á ­�¤J¼¤Jµ3¤ ° ·<³[¬�ú�¤��O¥ ° ¤J«<©3 ° ©3· �T³»¸/À������ � ´�ªuª ¯ ©G¼�¼�¤�¹U§'·<³'Â7©�ª[ªk¤¨ª î � ñ ,@¸k¬ ° �८­;¤uÈ�¤J¼(¤ ° ©GÂW«_¤J«<§¨¤ ° ¬+¸ã©<³¨¬�µ3¤ ° ´�¼@ȸ/©G«U´� ·"¬+¸ ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼±©GÂ�³Jù ° µO¤¨ª5,S³[¬�¼W¥½©G´»¼(¤�¹D´�¼Í¥®­;¤gª¨«?¬�¬G¥»­qÂ1¬�³'ù�ª5,ã©G¼±¹�«?¤[¤'¥®´�¼�È Þ ´»¼�©G¥R«?¬�ª¨¥S¬�¼�¤ ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥wÀ� ¼ ¯ © ° ¥|´¶³Jù@Â7© ° ´Ç¸PÒ Ë o��aähÞ ä !<Õ#´�ªa©G« ¯ Â1¤-,R¥»­;¤'¼¾¥®­;¤g¼(¤»¸a³[¬�¼�¤<¬I¸ 'Ý´�ª ¯ ¬G ·%­;¤[¹ ° ©GÂå©G¼(¹?ª ¯ ©G¼�¼(¤�¹�§'·ª¨ùW³¨­q³'Â7©�ª[ªk¤¨ªkÀ

Y B;H?6�03,'AºA�B�0GAÔA�B;H?*;H/6\,/>O*;H_57* Ë ðOX � Õ 512ÔC(>O.78@B;H/^�E[03.yb\032PC;E�>�KLH/^m51*�î � ñ¶N >OZ�E#,/>O*LA4E�57]�Z�A451>O*Í512ÔA�B;H^;H/24,JE�57C;A�57>O*¾>O6åA�B;Ha:OH'*;H'E[0GA�>3E�2'X Ë ðOX � Õ 24B;>OZ;.7^¾](HU,/>O=<CW0GE�H'^ÐA�>DA�B;HU,/>O*;HUA4B;H/>3E�H/=�N�buB;51,[B¾^;H'24,'E�5V](H/2:OH/*;H'E�0GA�>3E�2e6�>3ERA�B;HÔ,/>O*;HP>O6 H'è(H/,JA�57KLHÔ,/Z�E4KLH/2/X

Ë ðOX � Õ 57*�A�Z�E4*-:O57KLH'2/~

�W��� J �W�%��K K»�����y��.Wù ¯L¯ ¬�ªk¤ Ë '�� Þ ä !<Õã´�ªeÂ1¬�È��©G¼(¬LÀ Á ­;¤J¼ � � Ë Ò .7>O:�Þ ÕS´�ªRÈ�¤J¼(¤ ° ´¶³�©GÂ� ·ºª�¤J«g´�ú ¯ ¬%ª¨´�¥|´�µ3¤0,´�¼h¬G¥»­;¤ ° ûv¬ ° ¹�ª\¸k¬ ° ©_È�¤J¼(¤ ° ©GÂ�«?¤'«<§¨¤ ° � ¬I¸<©�ª¨ù"!�³J´½¤J¼�¥| ·"©G« ¯ Â1¤< ´�¼�¤�© ° ª�¤ ° ´¶¤Jª5,R¥»­�¤aµ3¤[³J¥+¬ ° §/ùs¼±¹�Â1¤� � Ë Ò .7>O:�Þ Õ l # ­�©�ªÔ¼�¬_ø'ùW¬�¥®´½¤J¼�¥v ´�¼(¤#§/ùs¼±¹�Â1¤¨ªg¬+¸Ô¼(¤½ÈL©G¥|´�µ3¤g¹�¤½È ° ¤[¤kÀ

Y B;HÔ6�03,'AuA�B�0GA Ë ðOX : Õ 512R51=aC�.151H'^D]�8 Ë ðOX � Õ b\032RC(>O51*LA�H/^->OZ�AuA�>aZ;2R]�8�zÐ>3E45|XÌ HR*;>3A�H\A�B�0GAå6�>3E¿A�H'E4=?51*�03.",�03*;>ÔA4B�E�H/H/6�>O.7^;2/NsA�B;Hu03*�03.1>O:OZ;HR>O6 Ë ðOXpõ Õ 51=aC�.151H'2yA4B;H�03*�03.1>O:OZ;H\>O6 Ë ðOX : Õ X

Y BsZ;2c576�>O*;He,/>OZ;.1^_C;E�>�KLH�A�H'E�=<51*�03. ,±03*;>ºA�B�E4H/H/6�>O.1^;2cB�0kKLHSZ;*;57E4Z;.1H/^`24=?>s>3A�B?.7>@,/Z;2/N@57A¿bv>OZ;.1^`6�>O.1.7>%bt03251*�îæó3ÅGñ�A�B�0GARA�B;HÔ24H'Au>O6 A�H'E�=<51*�03. ,�03*;>aA�B�E�H'H/6�>O.1^;2u512\](>OZ;*;^;H/^�X

Ë ðOX1: Õ 5VA�24H/.76 B�032u24>O=?Hã51*LA�H'E�H'2TA�51*;:<,/>3E�>O.1.10GE�51H'2/~

Page 6: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

�W�����®� J �W���K K»�����y�-£ ¤J¥ Ë '�� �UÕ"§¨¤q©¾Â1¬[È �©3¼(¬ ¯ ©3´ ° �½ûå´�¥»­�' © ¯±° ¬+²�¤[³J¥|´�µ3¤`ª¨ù ° ¸/©s³[¤0,a©G¼±¹ � Ü 'Ä©° ¤[¹Gù�³¨¤�¹D³Jù ° µ3¤ � À �

���������� �������= � Ò ð

= � � óRä�� Ë '�Õ Ò�������� Ë �UÕû�­;¤ ° ¤ = � ´�ªy¥»­�¤R¬ ° ¹�¤ ° ¬I¸å¥»­�¤�Â1¬�³�©GÂ[¸¨ùs¼(¹L©G«?¤J¼W¥½©GÂ3È ° ¬�ù ¯ ,�������� Ë �UÕ¿´�ªå¥®­;¤�¥+¬ ¯ ¬�Â1¬[ÈG´¶³�©GÂ! \ù@Â1¤ ° ³J­�© ° ©s³J¥w¤ ° ´�ª¨¥|´¶³¬+¸ �<,c©G¼±¹ � ´�ªã¥®­;¤;*\´¶³�© ° ¹a¼�ù@«<§¨¤ ° À

�S>3A�HvbuB;H/* � 512�H/=aC;A+8#A4B;H/* Ë ðOX :�X1ð Õ 57=<C�.157H/2�A�B�0GAy.7>O:M^;H'. ��H����/>M24Z�E�6�03,/Hu,k03*aB�0kKLHu0GAy=?>O2TA2.�äDó � �2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2'X�íS2R6�0GE�032RbcHãQ�*;>�bPN�*;><2TZ;,¨B�]±>OZ;*;^�B�032u]±H/H/*-C;E4H'K�57>OZ;24.78D>3]�24H'ETKLH/^�X

,W>3E"�ëß ðONRbvHqC;E4>%KLHi0Í2TA4E�>O*;:OH'E`KLH'E42451>O*�>O6 Ë ðOX :�X1ð Õ Ë 57A`0GC;C�.751H/2`A�>j03*L8â.1>O:ÍA�H'E4=?51*�03.�2TZ�E�6�03,/H'åÕ N¿6�>O.7.1>�be57*;:�03*h0GE4:OZ;=?H/*LA<>O6gî}ó3ÅGñ¶N�24H/H Ë$# X ó Õ X Y B;H�C;E�>s>O6�512U51*;^;H'C±H/*;^;H/*LA`>O6 Ë ðOX7ð Õ Ë 03*;^h51*;^;H'H/^�N03*L8@A�B;57*;:_H/.124HP51*�A�B;HºCW0GC±H'E Õ X Ì H#,k03.7.�A�B;572�51*LA�H'E4=?H/^;590GA4HÔE�H/2TZ;.7ASA�B;H&% �Wý������K»��� % �±��� � 03*;^"Z;24H57A�E�H'C±Hk0GA�H/^;.V8<57*<A�B;HeC;E�>s>O6(>O6 Ë ðOXæï Õ X Y B;H $c>O:O>O=?>O.1>�K0$c>OZ;*;^?B�032c03*_51*LA�H'E4H/2TA�57*;:º,/>3E�>O.7.90GE48LNL24H/H Ë$# Xpï Õ X)+*iîæó�ñ¶NsZ;2451*;:g^;5Vè(H'E�H'*�A\=?HJA�B;>@^;2/NsíS.1H ��H/H'K<>3];A[0351*;2vE�H'24Z;.7A�2vE4H/.90GA�H'^`A4> Ë ]�Z�Ac=gZ;,[BD^;H'H'C(H'E\A�B�03* Õ Ë$# Xpï Õ X)+*�A�B;HÔ.157:OB�AR>O6 Ë ðOXæÅ Õ 03*;^ Ë ðOX1ð Õ N@bcHÔC;E4>3C(>O24HMA�B;HÔ6�>O.7.1>�be57*;:;~

�W�(' J ���*)k�@ÿO�%� �����`£ ¤J¥ Ù §¨¤#©?ª¨«?¬�¬G¥»­qø'ù;©Gª¨´�ú ¯±° ¬+²k¤[³'¥®´�µO¤Sµ3© ° ´¶¤'¥®·LÀ Á ­;¤'¼ ,\¤J´�¥®­;¤ °Ë ð Õ�+, Ë Ù Õ.- Å ,\¬ °Ë ó Õ Ù ´�ªº¹�¬G«g´�¼±©G¥+¤�¹�§'·a´»«<©�È�¤¨ªg¬+¸ ê Ê À

�S>3A�HSA�B�0GA Ë ðOX # Õ 572uH/rsZ;57KG03.1H/*LAeA4>UA�B;HÔ6�>O.1.7>%bu51*;:;~�W�®�s� J �±��)k��ÿ3�%� �%�±�D£ ¤J¥a¥»­;¤ ¯ ©G´ ° Ë ¦�� Þ Õ�³[¬G¼;ª¨´�ª¨¥<¬I¸¾©jª¨«?¬�¬�¥®­âµG© ° ´¶¤J¥|·q¦ ,D©G¼±¹ ° ¤[¹Gù�³¨¤�¹j¼(¬ ° «?©G³ ° ¬%ª[ª¨´�¼�È�ªP¹G´�µ�´�ªk¬ ° Þ À Á ­;¤J¼ ,R¤J´�¥®­;¤ °

Ë ð Õ l n Ë o_f�ä�Þ Õ l ´�ªM¼(¬�¼Wú4¤J« ¯ ¥|·e¸k¬ ° ªk¬�«?¤ nÄàŠ,\¬ °Ë ó Õ¾¥®­;¤ ° ¤P´�ªº©D¹s¬�«g´�¼±©3¥®´�¼�Èu¸/©G«g´»Â ·D¬I¸ ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼(©G ³Jù ° µ3¤¨ªÔ«?¤[¤J¥|´�¼@È Þ ´�¼�©G¥¿«?¬%ªJ¥R¬G¼(¤ ¯ ¬G´�¼�¥wÀ

$v8 Ë�� X7ðOð Õ N Ë ð Õ 03*;^ Ë ó Õ >O6 Ë ðOX1ð�Å Õ 0GE�Hg=gZ�A�Z�03.7.78"H ��,/.1Z;2T57KLH3N 03*;^¾>O*;HU,k03*iK@51H'bÝA�B;Ha,'>O*�FIH/,'A�Z�E�H<0322�0k8�57*;:_H/57A�B;HJE ¦ B�032S0?.1>O:aC�.1Z�E�57,k03*;>O*;51,k03. 24H/,'A451>O*�N±>3EeA�B;H'E�H#572�0?,/.7Hk0GES:OH/>O=?HJA4E�51,ME�Hk0324>O*�buBL8�*;>O*;H,k03*�HG�;512IAkXY B;H'E�H"0GE�H�*�0GA�Z�E[03.u03*�03.1>O:OZ;H/2a>O6 Ë ðOX .GØ � Õ 51*hB;57:OB;H'E_^;51=<H/*;2451>O*;2'N\03*;^h2451=<51.90GEa51=aC�.151,/0GA�51>O*;2#bu51.1.

B;>O.1^D](H'AwbcH'H/*-A�B;H/=-N;516�>O*;HÔB�032RA�B;HÔzqz ��X Ì Hãbe5724B-B;>�bcH'KLHJEuA�>a*;>3A�Hã>O*;HÔ^;5Vè(H'E4H/*;,/H�/�51*D^;51=?H/*;2T51>O*Awbc> Ë ðOX7ð Õ 51=aC�.151H'2 Ë ðOXpõ Õ X Y B;512#6�>O.7.1>�be2º69E4>O= ^;H/6�>3E�=_0GA451>O*¾A�B;H'>3E48LNy03*;^�A�B;H_6�03,'A#A�B�0GAº.1>O:-A�HJE�=?51*�03.24Z�E�6�03,'H#2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2S0GE�HPr@Z;>3A�57H/*�A�2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2/NW24H/H#í�C;C±H/*;^;5 � #�03*;^ � � X Y B�E4H/HJؽ6�>O.7^q.1>O:<A�HJE�=?51*�03.2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2R*;H/H/^-*;>3Au]±HPr@Z;>3A451H/*LAe2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457A�57H/2/X)+*-B;57:OB;H'Ee^;57=?H/*;2457>O*;2RA4B;H'E�HM512R*;>3Ae=gZ;,[B-H'K@51^;H/*;,'HP6�>3E Ë ðOX # Ø4ð�Å Õ X Ì HM,k03*-C;E�>�KLH Ë ðOX # Õ 51*DA�B;HM,k0324H

Ò Ë o_f ähÞ Õ 512ã03=aC�.1H3NW24H/H Ë�� X . Õ N(03*;^q0<KLHJE�2451>O*q>O6 Ë ðOXæï Õ 6�>3EM0<A�B�E4H/H/6�>O.1^ ¦ 51*�A4B;H#,k0324H#ÞÄB�032�Awbc>,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*LA�2/N�24H/H Ë õ�X � Õ X

Page 7: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � 2

�S*;^;H'EÔA�B;H?03242TZ;=<C;A�51>O*;2M>O6 Ë ðOX # Õ N�516 ¦ B�032P^;57=?H/*;2457>O*�0GAÔ=?>O2TAMA�B�E�H/H3N�A�B;H/*¾A4B;H<zqz �Ý03*;^�.7>O:í�]�Z;*;^�03*;,/H<îæóOó�ñ±51=<C�.V8aA�B�0GA ¦ 572c,/>�KLH'E�H/^`]s8 Ë *;>3A\*;H/,/H/2T2�0GE�51.V8?E[0GA�57>O*�03. Õ ,'Z�E4KLH/2 � bu57A�B Ë o_f�ä¾Þ Õ�� � Å�X Y B�Z;2e>O*;HP572u=<>%KLH/^DA�><,'>O*;2451^;H'E/~

�W�®�W� J �±�*)k�@ÿ3�%� �������¿��ý % �����t�W��� % ���s�W��� �½¼(¬�¥w©G¥|´¶¬�¼�©Gªº´»¼ A À A�� � À � ¸ Ë o_f ähÞ Õ ��� �éÅ ,R©3¼±¹� �ÜâÞ ¥®­;¤J¼i¥»­ ° ¬�ùLÈ�­�©aÈ�¤J¼(¤ ° ©G ¯ ¬�´»¼�¥\¬I¸ � ¥»­;¤ ° ¤P´�ªº© ° ©3¥®´¶¬G¼±©GÂ�³Jù ° µO¤Ô«?¤[¤J¥|´�¼@È Þ ©G¥v«?¬%ª¨¥u¬�¼�³[¤kÀ

zq>3E�5|{}2y6�03=?>OZ;2å]±H/*;^?03*;^a];E�Hk0GQU0GE�:OZ;=?H'*�AåC;E�>�KLH/2 Ë ðOX1ðOð Õ 51*gA�B;HR,k0324HeÞ H/=<C;Aw8LX Ì HR^;>O*�{}Aå24H'H�03*L8b\0k8�A�>_H �@A�H/*;^qA�B;HºC;E�>s>O6yA4>`A4B;H#,k0324H#beB;H'*iÞ 512S*;>3AãH'=<C;Aw8LXe)+*Ðzq>3E�5®{æ2ã0GE�:OZ;=<H/*�A/N(o_f � � �çÅ`572Z;24H/^�A�>a2TB;>%bçA�B�0GA Ë =?>s^gÎ Õ 24>O=?Hã=gZ;.7A457C�.1Hã>O6 � =<>%KLH/2cbu57A�B-0gÏ"��H/^-C±>O51*LAkXå)+6 0U,/Z�ETKLHP=?>�KLH/2cbe5VA�B0DC±>O51*LAÔÏ"��H/^�N�A�B;H/*¾E�57:O51^;5VA+8q57=<C�.157H/2SA�B;H'E�HU512Ô0DE�0GA�51>O*�03.�,/Z�ETKLHaA�B�E�>OZ;:OBÐA�B;HaÏ"��H/^iC±>O51*LAkXUöS>%bcHJKLH'E57Ae512u*;>3A�,/.7Hk0GE Ë 0GAu.1H/032TAeA�><Z;2 Õ B;>�b�A4>?,/>O*LA4E�>O.�B;>%bçA�B;Hº:OH'*;H'E[0GA�H/^�E�0GA�51>O*�03.�,/Z�E4KLHÔ51*LA�H'E�2TH/,'A�2SÞ"Xv)+*Ë õ�X # Õ bvHP:O57KLHãH �;03=<C�.1H'2u57*;^;51,k0GA�57*;:<24>O=<HÔ>O6�A�B;HP^;5 !?,/Z;.VA�51H/2'X)+*Í03*L8�,k0324HGN A�B;H<E[0GA451>O*�03.y,/Z�E4KLH/2ºbvH?Z;24H<A�>�C;E�>%KLH Ë ðOX1ð Õ 0GE�H?>3];A[0357*;H/^¾]�8Í03*ÍH/*LA�5VE�H/.78i^;57è±H'E�H/*LA

C;E�>s,/H/^;Z�E�H3N�buB;51,[B"bcHg^;5124,'Z;242S](H/.7>%bÔXSöS>%bvH'KLH'EkN�>O*;,/HºbvHUB�0kKLH Ë ðOX7ð Õ bcH#>3];A[0357*q0_KLHJE�2451>O*q>O6 Ë ðOX7ðOð Õ032u0�~

�W�®� 5 J ���%��K K��W�������ãª[ª¨ù@« ¯ ¥|´¶¬�¼;ªÔ©�ªã´»¼ � A À A�� � À � ¸c¦ ­�©�ªÔ¹G´�«_¤J¼;ª¨´¶¬G¼"©G¥�«?¬%ª¨¥å¥®ûv¬ ,c¬ ° ¦ ­�©�ªP¹G´�«_¤J¼�úª¨´¶¬G¼�¥®­ ° ¤¨¤Ô©3¼±¹U¥»­;¤ �<¬k¹L©G´ ° ©a¹3´�«?¤J¼;ªJ´¶¬�¼i¬+¸ o_f�äiÞ �»¡?¼(¬�¼�ú+¼(¤½ÈL©G¥|´�µ3¤-, ¥®­;¤J¼�¥»­�¤ ° ¤ã´�ªÔ© ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼(©GÂ�³'ù ° µ3¤¥®­ ° ¬�ùLÈ�­q©gÈ�¤J¼(¤ ° ©G ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥R¬+¸ � ,�«?¤[¤'¥®´�¼�È Þ ©G¥v«?¬%ªJ¥R¬G¼(³[¤kÀ

� � � K»�®� �-��þe�%� � �������Wþe�Wþa�¨�W�)(±¢%��S>�b bcHãA�Z�E�*�A4><03*�>OZ�A�.157*;HM>O6�A�B;HãC;E�>@>O6 >O6 Ë ðOXæï Õ N@](>3A4BDA�>a51*;^;57,k0GA�Hã57A�2R.1>O:O57,k03.(2TATE�Z;,'A�Z�E�HGN�03*;^DA�>

B;51:OB".751:OBLA�=_03*L8D>O6�51242TZ;H/2�beB;57,[Bq0GE�5124HÔA�B�0GAS0GE�HÔ>O6�51*;^;H'C±H/*;^;H/*LAM51*LA�H'E�H/2IAkX Y B;Hº.7>O:O51,k03.�>3E�^;H'E�>O6�A�B;HC;E�>s>O6 512e03.124>U51*;^;57,k0GA�H/^�]s8`A�B;H /�>%bc,[B�0GE4A Ë ðOX1ð : Õ ]±H/.1>�bPXY B;HDC;E�>s>O6�^;57K@51^;H/2U51*LA�>ÐA+bv>¾,k0324H'2/X Ì H`bu51.1.cZ;2TH�A�B;H�*;>3A[0GA�51>O*j>O6 Ë ðOXæï Õ X Y BsZ;2 ' 512a0i*;>3E�=_03.

C;E�>GFIH/,'A457KLH#24Z�E�6�03,'Hgbu57A4B �¿51,/0GE�^"*sZ;=#]±H'Eã>O*;Hºbe5VA�B"r@Z;>3A451H/*LAS2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2'X�ÞÄ512ã0?,/Z�ETKLH3N(24Z;,[BqA�B�0GAo��ºä�Þ 572u.7>O:UA4H'E�=?57*�03.�03*;^ Ò Ë o��ºä�Þ Õ 572e03=aC�.1H3X� 0324HÐ)¨~\Þ �ß %�X Y B;Hi,k0324Hi>O6P*;>O*@ؽH'=<C;Aw8tÞ 512�C;E4>%KLH/^t51* Ë õ�X ó Õ N�Z;2T51*;:h^;H/6�>3E4=_0GA�51>O* A�B;H/>3ET8

03*;^-*Ô>O.7.��0GEk{}2 $\Z;:GØ ��8LH/^m,/>�KLH'EkXÐöSH'E�H`572a0"2TQLHJA�,[B�~S,�>3Eg2T51=<C�.751,/5VA+8LN 24Z�C;C(>O24HDÞ 512#57ETE�H/^;Z;,/5V]�.1H3X $c803^�FIZ;*;,'A�57>O*<Þ 57A�2TH/.16W512å0ã24=?>@>3A4BºE[0GA�51>O*�03.@,/Z�E4KLH3Ns03*;^UbvHR>3];A�0351*a0M,/>�KLH'E�57*;:Ô6�03=<51.78P>O6WE�0GA�51>O*�03.�,'Z�E4KLH/2]�8-^;H/6�>3E4=?51*;:<0aB;51:OB-=UZ;.VA�57C�.7Hã>O6�Þ"X Y B;HP^;5 !?,/Z;.VA+8�>O6�,/>OZ�E424HP572uA�B;HMC;E�H/24H/*;,'Hº>O6�2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2'X@,W>3EA�B;572gbvHDZ;2THDA�B;H�$cZ;:GØ��å8LH/^j,/>%KLHJEk~O(M5VKLH/*�0Ð*;>3E�=?03.¿24Z�E�6�03,'H ' bu57A4B�rsZ;>3A�51H/*LAg2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2'NyA4B;H'E�HH ��512TA�2y0SZ;*;57r@Z;H\24=?>s>3A�B Ë ]�Z�Ay*;>O*@ؽ2TH'CW0GE[0GA�H/^ Õ 03.1:OHJ];E[0351,v2ICW03,/H�@~ '�¿Ò�Ó ' 24Z;,[BaA�B�0GA�� 572y0SZ;*;57KLH'E�2403.B;>O=?H/>O=<>3E4C�B;5124=-N 03*;^m03*¾5124>O=?>3ETC�B;5124= >�KLH'E ' 3 X�+@H/H � .;X ,W>3E Ë ðOXpï Õ A�B;H?57=<C(>3E4A�03*�AãC(>O57*�AP512MA�B�0GA51*iA�H'E�=?2Ô>O6vöS>O= Ë� �-' Õ N 6�>3Eg0DC;E�>3C(H'Eº,/Z�E4KLH N ' ]±H/B�0kKLH/2ºH �;03,'A�.78Ð.757QLH?0�24=?>@>3A4BiKG0GE�51H'Aw8LX Y B;H51^;H/0<A�B;H/*"512RA�>?.75169AeA4B;HPC;E�>3]�.1H'= A�> ' X Y B;Hº,/>O*;^;5VA�51>O*�A4B�0GA�o��#ä�ÞÄ512e.1>O:aA4H'E�=?57*�03. 572eH/rsZ;57KG03.1H/*LA

Page 8: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

A�>?A�B;H#,'>O*;^;57A�57>O*�A�B�0GA ��� Ê Ë Þ Õ Ü '� 572S24=?>@>3A4B�N±03*;^"A�B;H#,/>O*;^;5VA�51>O*"A�B�0GA�o��UähÞ 512�03*�A�5ÛØw03=<C�.7H3N±572H/rsZ;57KG03.1H/*LAuA4>aA�B;HÔH �;572TA�H/*;,/HÔ>O6�0UH/*;^;>O=?>3E4C�B;5724= Ñ ~ É Ê Ò±Ó Þàß É Ê 03*;^"0a,/>O=<=UZ�A�0GA�57KLHS^;5103:3E[03=

É Ê �ÒkÒ;Ò;Ò¨Ó '

����� ���Þ ÒkÒ;Ò;Ò¨Ó '��

24H/H Ë .;X7ð�. Õ X"�S>�b�^;H/6�>3E4=_0GA�51>O*"A�B;H'>3E48"51=aC�.151H'2ebcH#,k03*Ð^;H/6�>3E�=��0�bc0�8"69E4>O= A�B;H#2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A451H/2S>O6 ' N=_0357*�A[0357*;51*;:a0a2457*;:O.1HãC(>O57*�Au>O6 Ë *;H/,'H/242�0GE�57.78DB;51:OB->3E�^;H'E Õ ,/>O*LA[03,'ARbe5VA�B-Þ"XY B;H_,k0324H`>O6\Þ *;>O*@ضH/=<C;Aw8ÍB�032º](H'H/*jC;E4H'K�57>OZ;24.78�C;E4>%KLH/^m]�8Ízq578�03*;512TB;5c03*;^ Y 24Z;*;>s^�0�îòï�ð/ñc03*;^

î}ïLó�ñ|X Y B;H'57E�C;E�>s>O6�512R]W0324H/^q>O*q0<,/.103242457Ï�,/0GA�51>O*">O6�CW035VE�2 Ë '�� Þ Õ X�ãH/6�>3E�=?0GA�51>O*DA�B;H/>3E48�A�>O:OH'A�B;H'Eube5VA�BA�B;H $\Z;:GØ ��8LH/^�,/>�KLH'E�:O5VKLH/2e0U2451=aC�.1H3N;A4E[03*;2ICW0GE�H/*LAeC;E�>s>O6½N�032RbcH/.7. 032u24>O=?Hã:OH/*;H'E�03.151240GA�51>O*;2RA�><B;57:OB;H'E^;51=<H/*;2451>O*;2'X� 0324HPAwbc>;~ Ì B;H/*qÞÄ512�H'=<C;Aw8LNWA�B;HP51^;Hk0<572eA�><E4H'C�.903,/H ' ]�8 ' Ê N�]�5VE[0GA�57>O*�03.�A4> ' NWbeB;57,[B",/>O*�A�0351*;2

0_*;>O*@ؽH/=aC;A+8qÞ"N�57*i2TZ;,¨B¾0?b\0�8-A�B�0GA Ë ðOXpï Õ 6�>3E Ë ' Ê � Þ Õ 57=<C�.157H/2 ' 3 512ãZ;*;57E�Z;.7H/^�X Ë ' Ê � Þ Õ be57.1.�,/>O=<H69E�>O= H ��A4E�03,'A�51*;:�0-^;57K@5124>3E U K�510�0�]�.1>�b Z�C Ñ ~ �ÖÒ�Ó ' N�03*;^�A�B;H/*�]�.7>%bu51*;:"^;>�be*Í57*m0-^;57è±H'E�H/*LA^;57E4H/,'A�57>O* RÔ~ �çÒ�Ó ' Ê NWÞÖß R Ë U Õ X Y >aÏ�*;^ Ë ' Ê � Þ Õ H/2424H'*�A�5103.1.V8DE4H/^;Z;,/H/2�A�>UÏ�*;^;51*;: U_X@,�>3EuA�B;512RbcH51*LA4E�>s^;Z;,/HÔA4B;HP6�>O.1.7>%bu51*;:;N�A4B;HP=?>O2TAR57=<C(>3E4A�03*�AcA�H',¨B;*;57,k03.�^;H'Ï�*;57A�57>O*�>O6 A4B;HÔCW0GC(HJEk~

�W�®� (47D�:9y� ���%���±��� #�H'A ¦ ](HeC;E4>3C(H'EkN@*;>3E�=_03.�K30GE�57H'Aw8LX # HJA ! ](Hã03*_HJè(H/,'A457KLH � Ø Ì H/57.�^;57K@5124>3Ev>O* ¦ Xí ¡����@ÿL�»� KR�%��ýW�@� 6�>3EÔo_f�ä ! 572ã03*ÐHJè(H/,'A457KLH � ض^;57K@5124>3E �h24Z;,[BiA4B�0GAão_f�ä ! ä�� 572S*sZ;=<H'E�51,/03.1.78A4E�5VK�5103.|N@]�Z�Ae*;>3A *Ô0�bc03=_0GA[0g.1>O:gA�H'E�=?57*�03. Ë Q�.VA Õ X

,W>3Eº24>O=?H<niN�n�� 512#0-KLHJE48�2457*;:OZ;.90GE#H'.1H/=?H'*�A#>O6ºl Ò n Ë o_ftä !<Õ l(03*;^m24>q0�24>3ETA#>O6R03*�A�5VA�B;H/24572A�>��eH'51^�{æ2S:OH'*;H'E[03.�H/.7H'C�B�03*LAkXÔöSH'*;,/HºA�B;H#A�H'E�=<51*;>O.1>O:38LX $v8q0?2TC±H/,/5903. A�51:OH'Eã6�>3E ¦ N(>3EM0?2IC(H/,/5103. A�57:OH'EË bu57A�B;>OZ�Au6�Z�E4A�B;HJEeE�H/6�HJE�H/*;,/H Õ N�bcHÔ=?Hk03*�0a2TC±H/,/5903.�A�57:OH'ER6�>3E�o_f#X

�S>3A�HcA�B�0GAå516WbcHRB�0�KLHu0M2IC(H/,/5103.;A�51:OH'EyA�B;HJE�Hu572¿0GAå.7Hk032TAå>O*;Hu^;5VK�5724>3E�U�>O6�^;5124,'E4H'CW03*;,'8 Ë be5VA�BgE�H/2TC±H/,'AA�>?o��#ä�� Õ 0GA�=<>O2TA Ò ðOX Ì HPbu51.7.�,k03.1.�03*L8�24Z;,[B Uà0 �%��ýW�@� X¿)+*�6�03,'A�bcHº0GE�HP=gZ;,[B�=?>3E�HÔ51*LA�H'E�H'2TA�H/^51* U Ë 03*;^�A�B;HUE�H/24Z;.VA�51*;:-*;H'b .7>O:-zq>3E�5yÏ;];E�H?2TCW03,'H?2TA4E�Z;,JA�Z�E�H Õ A4B�03*�51*���X�+@>O=?H'A�57=?H/2SbcH<bu51.7.y]±H0_.15VA4A�.1H#2T.1>3C;C�8q51*q>OZ�EM*;>3A[0GA�51>O*Ð03*;^ÐZ;24HgA�B;H#bc>3E�^qA�51:OH'ESA4>D=<Hk03*qH/57A�B;HJE�UÖ>3E��¿X Y B;572ã24B;>OZ;.1^Ð*;>3A,k03Z;24H?03*�8ÐB�0GE�=�N�](H',k03Z;24H?*;>3E�=?03.1.78"bvH?0GE�Ha>O*;.78Ð51*LA�H'E�H'2TA�H/^Í57*ibuB;H/* ¦ ^;>@H'2P>3EÔ^;>@H/2º*;>3AÔB�0kKLH?0A�57:OH'EkN U_N;beB;57,[B�512RH/r@Z;5VK303.7H/*LAuA�>UA�B;HMH �;572TA�H/*;,/HÔ>O6�0a2IC(H/,/5103.�A�51:OH'E/N���XÌ Hãbe57.1.�^;H'Ï�*;HÔQ�.7A/N�03*;^�H ��C�.10351*DA�B;HÔ=<>3A�57KG0GA�51>O*_]±H/B;51*;^ Ë ðOX1ð�ï Õ 51* Ë ðOX1ð � Õ ](H'.1>�bPXY B;HÔ*;H �@AuAwbc>aE�H/24Z;.VA�2e57*;^;51,k0GA�HãA�B;HMZ;24H/6�Z;.7*;H/242S>O6 A�57:OH'E�2R6�>3E Ë ðOXpï Õ ~

�W�®� NÔ�%� ����¡k���%�����¿� � ¸ ' ´�ª`© ¯±° ¬+²k¤[³'¥®´�µO¤Uª¨ù ° ¸/©�³¨¤<ûy´�¥®­jø'ù�¬G¥®´¶¤'¼�¥�ª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ª?©G¼(¹#' ­�©�ª`©"¥|´1È�¤ ° ,¥®­;¤J¼4'�3_´�ªMù@¼�´ ° ùsÂ1¤�¹�À

Page 9: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � 0

�W�®� � NM��� �å�±¡k���%�»���¿� Á ­;¤S³[¬�Â�Â1¤¨³J¥®´½¬�¼�¬+¸ ° ©G¼ F ¬�¼�¤RÂ1¬�Ⱥ¹�¤JÂ�*e¤�����¬�ª¨ù ° ¸/©�³[¤Jªvûy­�´¶³¨­a¹�¬ã¼(¬�¥�­�©Gµ3¤e©ãª ¯ ¤¨³J´|©GÂ¥|´1È�¤ ° ´�ªº§¨¬�ù@¼±¹�¤[¹LÀ

�S>3A�H Ë ðOX7ð�. Õ 572u57=<C�.157H/^�]�8 Ë õ�X1ð Õ XË ðOX7ð � Õ 6�>O.1.7>%bu2_69E�>O= Ë # Xæï Õ 03*;^ërsZ;57A�H":OH'*;H'E[03.�](>OZ;*;^;H'^;*;H/242�C;E451*;,/5VCW03.12/X Ì H"C;E�>�KLHi0m2TA4E4>O*;:OH'E

2TA[0GA4H/=?H/*LAg51* � ó3ï�X � 6u,'>OZ�E�24H3NyA�>O:OH'A�B;HJE � 0324H_)P03*;^ Ë ðOX1ð�.GØ�ð � Õ 51=<C�.V8 Ë ðOXæï Õ 57*�03.7.�]�Z�AU0�](>OZ;*;^;H/^,/>O.7.1H/,'A451>O*º>O6�,/0324H/2/X Ì Håbe57.1.OA�Z�E�*ºA4>eA�B;H¿rsZ;H/2TA�57>O*º>O6;,/.103242451698@51*;:eA4B;H/24Hv,k032TH/2 Ë A�B�0GA 512 24Z�E�6�03,/H'2�be5VA�B;>OZ�AA�57:OH'E Õ 51*"0U=?>O=?H/*LAkX2$cZ�ARÏ;E�2TA�2T>O=?Hã:OH/*;H'E[03.�E�H/=_0GETQ�2\>O*�A�57:OH'E�2/X

,W>3E�A�B;HcE�H/2TAå>O6�A�B;H\51*LA4E�>@^;Z;,JA�51>O*�NLZ;*;.1H'242�>3A4B;H'E4bu5124H\*;>3A�H/^�N ' be57.1.�57*;^;51,k0GA�HR0S.1>O:ã^;H/. ��H����/>P2TZ�E�6�03,/H>O6 E�03*�Q�>O*;HGX

+@B;>3Q�Z�E4>%K-B�032�51*;^;H'C±H/*;^;H/*LA�.78q,'>O*;2451^;H'E4H/^ÐA451:OH'E�2'N±51*�E4H/.90GA�57>O*-A�>_,/>O=aC�.1H/=?H'*�A�2'XuöSHºB�032S>3]�2TH'E4KLH/^A�B�0GA\576 ' B�032R0ºA�51:OH'E/NsA�B;H/*Do��D572SðON�ó@N;ï�N".#>3ERõ�ض,/>O=<C�.7H/=?H/*LA�H/^ Ë o��`512��±Ø½,'>O=<C�.1H/=<H/*�A4H/^_516�A�B;H'E4HM5720_=?H/=#](HJE�� �tl Ò ��o���l;2TZ;,¨BqA�B�0GAão×äéð���� 572S.1>O:_,k03*;>O*;57,k03. Õ X Ì H#51*;,/.7Z;^;H�+@B;>3Q@Z�E�>�K({æ2�C;E4>@>O6>O6cA�B;512#57* � óOó@X �S>3A�H +@B;>3Q�Z�E�>�K({}2ºE�H/24Z;.VAkNå03*;^ Ë ðOX1ð � Õ 57=<C�.78ÐA�B;H'E4H_512g0�Z;*;516�>3E4=�� ÃÚÅ�24Z;,[BmA�B�0GAl Ò �qo���l;512ã*;>O*@ؽH'=<C;Aw8"6�>3EÔ03.1. ' X Y B;572�E�H/24Z;.VAÔ572ã51*LA�H'E�H/2IA�51*;:D51*"K�57H'b�>O6yA�B;H#6�03,'AãA�B�0GASA4B;H'E�Hg512ã*;>](>OZ;*;^->O*-A�B;HM51*;^;H �->O6 o���X� >O=<C�.1H/=<H/*�A42 51*#^;57=?H/*;2457>O* �`:O57KLHv57*;6�>3E�=_0GA�57>O*º>O*#H ��ATE�H/=_03.�*;H/51:OBL](>OZ�E4B;>@>@^;2�57*g^;51=?H/*;2T51>O* ��ä<ó

Ë 24H'H?î}ó � ñ Õ X Y B;H'8`C�.90k8D03*�57=<C(>3ETA[03*�AcE4>O.1Hã51* +@B;>3Q�Z�E�>�K({}2\C;E4>O:3E[03=à6�>3Ee.7>O:0/�5VC�2/X Y B;H/2THÔ>3]�24HJE4K30GA451>O*;2bcH'E4HÔC(>O57*�A4H/^�>OZ�ARA�><Z;2\]s8�íS.1H'242451> � >3ETA�5|XY 51:OH'E�2åB�0kKLHeA�B;He6�>O.7.1>�be57*;:ÔE�H'.90GA�57>O*aA�>PA4B;He*;>3A�57>O*?>O6�0'!?*;H¨Ø¶E�Z;.7H/^ Ë 032å^;H'Ï�*;H/^_]s8azq578�03*;5724B;5 Õ X Y B;H

C;E�>s>O6 512u:O57KLH/*�51* Ë ó@ðOX . Õ X

�¿�@�Í����� � ¸ ' ´�ª<©�!h¼(¤Jú ° ùsÂ1¤�¹ �½¥»­;©G¥u´�ª?³[¬�¼�¥w©G´�¼;ª<© ¯±° ¬k¹3ù�³J¥e¼(¤J´9È�­�§¨¬�ù ° ­�¬�¬k¹ Ù��qê Ê � ¥»­�¤J¼ ' ­;©�ª<©¥|´1È�¤ ° À

Y B;H'E�HM0GE�H ' bu57A�BD2457=<C�.78<,/>O*;*;H/,'A�H'^-24=?>s>3A�B`.1>s,/Z;2 Ë ,/6½X � ó@ð Õ N@]�Z�AR*;>gA�51:OH'E/X Y B;H/24Hã:O5VKLHM,'>OZ;*�A�HJETØH �;03=<C�.1H/2ºA4>Ðzq5V8�03*;5124B;5®{æ2#,/>O*�FIH/,JA�Z�E�H Ë 24H/HiîVð � ñ Õ A�B�0GA#A�B;H`24=?>s>3A�BÍ.1>s,/Z;2g>O6u03*L8ÍE[03*�QÍ>O*;H`.7>O:Ð^;H'.��H����'>?B�032�0gÏ�*;57A�H �H'A[03.7HÔ,/>�KLH'EkN;A�B�0GAu512e0'!?*;HJØ|E�Z;.1H'^�X)wAM512Ô0�6�0357E4.78q2457=<C�.1Hg=_0GA4A4H'EãA�>DE4H/^;Z;,/H<A�B;HgC;E�>s>O6¿>O6 Ë ðOXpï Õ A�>�A4B;Ha,k032THabuB;H/* R���� �Ê Ë ' 3 Õ 512ãA4E�57K@5903.

Ë ,/6½X � � Õ X Ì Hebe57.1.�032424Z;=?HuA�B;512v6�>3E¿A�B;H�E�H/2TAv>O6(A�B;H�51*LA4E�>s^;Z;,'A�57>O*�X Ì Hebe57.1.W24>O=?H'A451=?H/2¿0G]�Z;24HS*;>3A[0GA�57>O*03*;^"2�0k8-A�B�0GA ' 3 Ë >3ESH'KLH/* 'åÕ 512e2451=<C�.V8-,'>O*;*;H/,'A�H/^�X � 6y,/>OZ�E424H3N�0<C±>O2TA�H'E�57>3E�5|NW]s8 Ë ðOXpõ Õ NWA�B;HÔA+bv>`0GE�HH'KLH/*-H/r@Z;5VK303.7H/*�A/XíS2uE4H/=_0GE4QLH/^�0G](>�KLH3N�*;>3AeH'KLH'E48 ' B�032S0aA�57:OH'EkXv)+* � ð � Ø�ð # bcHP:OH/*;HJE[0GA�H#0<Ï�*;5VA�HP24HJAS>O6�6�03=?51.751H/2R>O6

24Z�E�6�03,'H/2��mbuB;51,[BÐ51*;,/.7Z;^;H/2M03.1. Ë 2451=<C�.V8�,/>O*;*;H','A�H/^ Õ;' bu57A4B;>OZ�A�A�51:OHJE�2/X ,W>3EãHk03,[B ' ����bvH#B�0�KLHU03*H �@C�.151,'57Ay^;H/24,JE�57C;A�57>O*<>O6�A�B;HR=?51*;57=_03.s^;H'2451*;:OZ;.10GE�512�0GA451>O*�N��' NO57*aA�HJE�=?2�>O6�]�.1>�bâZ�C�2�>O6 É�� N�03*;^UbcHR,[B;H/,�Q51*`Hk03,[B�,k0324HSA�B�0GA ' 3 512\Z;*;57E�Z;.7H/^�N�]�8_H ��C�.751,/5VA�.78<H �;B;5V]�57A�57*;:U0g^;>O=<51*�0GA�57*;:#6�03=?51.V8?>O6�E[0GA�57>O*�03.±,/Z�E4KLH'2/XÌ Hg*;>3A�HgB;H'E�HgA�B�0GAM57Aã572ãr@Z;57A4HºC(>O24245V]�.1HgA�B�0GA��h572SA�>@>_]�51:;N�57*ÐA4B;Ha24H'*;24HUA4B�0GAã24>O=?Hg>O6åA4B;HU2TZ�E�6�03,/H/2

Page 10: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

.1+ ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

51* �m03,'A�Z�03.7.78`B�0kKLHÔA�57:OH'E�2/N;>3Eu*;>O*@ؽ2T51=<C�.V8`,/>O*;*;H/,'A�H'^"24=?>@>3A4B�.7>@,/Z;2/X (M5VKLH/*�03*-H ��C�.751,/5VAu2TZ�E�6�03,/Hº5VAu572Z;24Z�03.7.78qHk032457H'Eº6�>3EÔZ;2ãA�>�,[B;H/,�QÐA�B�0GAMA�B;Ha2T=?>@>3A�Bq.7>@,/Z;2M512MZ;*;57E�Z;.7H/^�N A4B�03*iA�>D,[B;H/,�Q¾H/5VA�B;H'EMA�B�0GAMA�B;H24=?>s>3A�BÍ.1>s,/Z;2#512#2T51=<C�.V8¾,/>O*;*;H','A�H/^�Nå>3E#A�B�0GA#A�B;H_24Z�E46�03,/H`B�032U*;>"A�57:OH'EkNy032ºbcH_B�0kKLH?E[0GA�B;HJE#E�>3]�Z;2TAA�>s>O.12P6�>3E#A4B;H<Ï;E�2TAkNy03*;^Í>O*;.V8¾E[0GA4B;H'Eg03^@ؽB;>s,?A�H/,[B;*;51rsZ;H/2#6�>3E#A�B;H?2TH/,/>O*;^j03*;^ÍA�B;57E�^�X � 6\,/>OZ�E424H_6�>3EË ðOXæï Õ A4B;512u0GC;C;E�>L03,[B�512u24Z"!?,/57H/*LAkX)wA�512�C±H'E�B�0GC�2y24Z�E4C;E4512457*;:;N3A�B�0GAyH'KLH/*#bu57A�Bg03*gH �@C�.151,'57A�^;H/2T,'E�57C;A451>O*U>O6 �' N35VAy,k03*g2TA�51.7.�]±HcKLH'E48º^;5 !?,/Z;.VA

A�>q24B;>�b ' 3 512#^;>O=?57*�0GA�H/^�]�8�E[0GA�57>O*�03.¿,/Z�E4KLH'2/X Y 8@C�57,k03.1.V8¾A�B;H_2TATE�51,'A#ATE[03*;246�>3E�= >O6cA�B;H/2THD,'>%KLH'E451*;:,/Z�E4KLH'2eB�0kKLHÔE[0GA�B;HJEeB;57:OB�^;H/:3E�H/HÔ51* É � N�>O69A�H'*�>%KLHJE�0UBsZ;*;^�E�H'^�XY >�C;E�>�KLHqZ;*;57E�Z;.7H/^;*;H/242D51*�0Í2TC±H/,/57Ï�,Ð,k0324HGNRbcH"A4ET8�A�>ÍÏ�*;^ E[0GA�51>O*�03.u,/Z�E4KLH/2'N�� Ü ' N\bu57A�B�03*

H/*;^;>O=?>3ETC�B;5124= .75169A�57*;:mA4> '�� Xç)+*�C;E[03,JA�51,k03.e2457A�Z�0GA451>O*;2?A�B;572_512`>O*;.78hC±>O24245V]�.1H"beB;H'*��Ä=?H/H'A42?A�B;H2457*;:OZ;.90GES.7>@,/Z;2ã0GAS=<>O2TAeAwbu51,/H3N�24H/H Ë .;X # X . Õ X Y B;H/*"bcHºA4E48�A�>_^;H/6�>3E�= A4B;H#.15169A4H/^"H/*;^;>O=?>3E4C�B;5724=�X Ì HB�0kKLHÔA�B;HM6�>O.1.7>%bu51*;:a24Z"!?,/57H/*LA�,/>O*;^;5VA�51>O* Ë õ�X � Õ ~

+@Z�C;C(>O2TH�� =?H/HJA�2MA4B;H<2457*;:OZ;.90GEº.7>@,/Z;2MAwbe57,/H3N 03*;^�A�B;H<.7>@,k03.y03*�03.V8@A�57,a57*;^;H ��>O6¿57A�2ãAwbc>-];E[03*;,[B;H/2Ë =?H'H'A�51*;:qA�B;HD2451*;:OZ;.10GE<.7>@,/Z;2 Õ 0GE�H�� 03*;^WX Y B;H/*�A4B;H'E�HD512a0i24Z�E®FIH','A�51>O* Ñ ~ É Ê Ò±Ó � >O6e^;H':3E�H/H� � n Ë � � Õ .15769A�51*;:UA�> ' � NW03*;^�516

Ò o�� � � - ð����gäëð���

A�B;H/* Ñ ^;H/6�>3E�=<2 A�>u,/>%KLHJE ' 3 X Ì H�Z;24Z�03.1.V8PZ;24HåA�B;H¿,JE�57A�HJE�51>O*MbeB;H/*��jB�032 Awbc>u];E�03*;,¨B;H'2�=?H/H'A�57*;:e0GA >O*;HC(>O57*�A/N@03*;^��Dß�WX�)+*?A�B;512�,k0324H����t512 � 0GETA�51H'E/N@03*;^?2T>PA�B;H�,'E457A�H'E451>O*<>O*;.V8<6�0357.12åbeB;H/* Ò o�� � ��ß�ð���� X���;03=<C�.1H Ë õ�X1: Õ 51*;^;51,/0GA�H/2\A�B�0GAuA4B;HP,'E�5VA�H'E�57>O*-572uH/2T24H/*LA�5903.7.78D24B�0GE4C�X)+*g>3E�^;H'E�A�>M0GC;C�.78ÔA�B;H\,'E�5VA�H'E�57>O*ºA�>M0eCW0GE4A�51,'Z;.90GEy,k0324HGNLbvHcB�0�KLHvA�>SÏ�*;^gE[0GA�57>O*�03.@,/Z�E4KLH'2å=<H/H'A�57*;:�A�B;H

2457*;:OZ;.90GER.1>s,/Z;2cA+bu51,'H3X Y B;H��ébvHMZ;2THÔ>s,/,k032457>O*�03.1.78<,/>O=?HS69E�>O=à57*�A4H'E�H/2TA451*;:<:OH'>O=?H'A4E�57,�,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA451>O*;2Ë 24H'H_6�>3EgH ��03=<C�.7H-ð � X � X1ð'Øwï Õ X>,W>3E#,/>O*;,'E�HJA�H_H ��03=aC�.1H_0GC;C�.751,k0GA�57>O*;2º>O6cA�B;H_,'E�5VA�H'E�57>O*�N�24H/H Ë õ�X7ð�Å Õ 03*;^Ë :�X7ð Õ XY B;H'E�H_0GE�H<0GE�>OZ;*;^Í245 ��Aw8¾2TZ�E�6�03,/H/2#57* �åX Y B;H<:OH'*;H'E[0GA�57>O*Í>O6 � 512P>O*;H<=_0351*i6�>@,/Z;2º>O6vA4B;H<CW0GC(H'E/N

03*;^"03,/,'>OZ;*�A�2u6�>3E�=?>O2IAu>O6 57A�2\KL>O.1Z;=<H3X�#� �¾��� ����� � Z�EP,'>O*;2TA4E�Z;,'A451>O*Ð>O6 ��512�]W0324H'^¾>O*i0`2T51=<C�.7H#51^;Hk0�X Y >`H ��C�.10351*q57A Ë 03*;^qA4B;HU*;>3A451>O*

>O6 A451:OH'E Õ bcHÔZ;24HÔA�B;HM6�>O.1.7>%bu51*;:;~

�W�®��� 7�� 9y�����%�»���¿� # HJA ¦ ]±Ha0_*;>3E�=?03. 24Z�E�6�03,'H3N�03*;^ ! 03*ÐH'è±H/,'A�5VKLH � Ø Ì H/51.v^;5VK�5724>3E Ë A�B�0GAS572 ! ß����� Þ � bu57A�B ��� � � N ��� Ã�Å Õ X�#�H'A RÔ~ T Ò�Ó ¦ ]±Ha03*L8"]�57E�0GA�51>O*�03. =?>3E4C�B;512T=�X # H'A �! ß ����� �Þ �](HãA�B;Hã2TA4E451,'A\A4E[03*;2T6�>3E�=�X Y B;HJE�HP572u0gZ;*;51rsZ;H � Ø Ì H/51.�^;5VK�512T>3E�� 2TZ�C;C(>3E4A�H'^�>O*DA4B;HÔH ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.�.1>s,/Z;224Z;,[B�A�B�0GA

o# Ðä �! ä���ß R " Ë o_fâä !aÕ �

!¾ß �! ä� 572e,k03.7.1H/^�A4B;H K���ý ����K K»ü ��ÿ%� >O6 ! X Y B;H ÿO����"jÿ������(�&� Ë U � o_fhä !<Õ >O6y03*�8�57ETE�H/^;Z;,/5V]�.1H^;57K@5124>3E)U >O* T 572SFIZ;2IA<A�B;H�,/>@H�!<,/51H'*�A?032a5VA<0GC;C±Hk0GE�2a51*!åNv5VAa^;HJC(H/*;^;2?>O*;.V8j>O* Ë ¦���!aÕ 03*;^�A�B;H

Page 11: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � . .

^;512T,'E�H'A�H?KG03.1Z�0GA451>O*m032424>s,/590GA4H/^�A�> U_X Y B;H ÿO����"jÿL�����(� � Ë ¦���!aÕ >O6vA�B;H?CW035VE Ë ¦���!<Õ 512PA4B;H?.90GE�:OH'2TA,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LA\>O6 03*L8?^;5VK�5724>3E Ë >3Ec^;5724,'E�HJA�HSK303.7Z�0GA�51>O* Õ X Ì H�be57.1.�buE�5VA�H � Ë ¦iÕ 6�>3EcA�B;HS,'>@H�!<,/51H/*LA\>O6 Ë ¦�� % Õ XD ¤J«<© °GF ú��g¤�2å¼W´�¥®´½¬�¼±À � Ë U � o_fÐä !aÕ 512�FIZ;2TAcA�B;HS*;H/:L0GA�5VKLH�>O6�57A42v^;5124,JE�H'CW03*;,'8LXy)+*?CW0GE4A�51,'Z;.90GEkNso_f�ä !512_.7>O:m,k03*;>O*;51,k03.e57è A�B;Hq,/>sH�!?,'51H/*LAD>O6 Ë ¦���!aÕ 572�0GA`=<>O2TA_>O*;H3Ne03*;^�.7>O:ÍA�H'E�=?57*�03.e5Vèé51*�03^;^;57A451>O*A�B;H#,/>sH�!?,'51H/*LAM>O6åHJKLH'E48qH ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03. ^;57K@5124>3Eã572S.1H/2T2�A�B�03*i>O*;HGXã)wAS572 *P0kb\03=_0GA�0?.1>O:_A�H'E�=<51*�03.�57èÍ5VA�2,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LA�512R.1H'242uA�B�03*�>O*;H3XÌ HM*;>3A�HP>O*;HãA4E�5VK�5103.|N@]�Z�AeZ;24H/6�Z;.|NW6�03,'Ak~ ³[¬�¤ !�³J´½¤J¼�¥®ªP© ° ¤º´�¼�µG© ° ´|©G¼�¥�ùs¼(¹�¤ ° Â1¬�È ¯ ù@Â�Â7§[©�³ F X�S>�bÖ.1H'AaZ;2<H �@C�.90357*�A�B;HD=?>3A�5VK30GA�57>O*Í](H/B;57*;^â^;H'Ï�*;57A�57>O* Ë ðOX7ð�ï Õ N�2IC(H/,/5VÏ�,k03.1.V8mA�B;H-^;H'Ï�*;5VA�51>O*�>O6�0

2TC±H/,/5903.�A�51:OH'Ev6�>3E ' X�)+*_K�57H'bt>O6�,k032TH�)JNsbeB;H/*`ÞÖ51* Ë ðOXpï Õ 572vH/=<C;Aw8LN@>O*;HS*�0GA4Z�E[03.1.V8abc>O*;^;HJE�2\516�A�B;H'E�HS57224>O=?HR,/Z�E4KLH � >O* ' be5VA�B<o��¿ä � 03*LA�5Vؽ03=<C�.1HR03*;^?.7>O:MA4H'E�=?57*�03.|X )wAåA�Z�E�*;2¿>OZ�AåA�B;572¿6�0351.72�6�>3E�51*�Ï�*;5VA�H/.V8=_03*L8?6�03=?57.157H/2c>O6 ' N;24>g>O*;Hã.1>s>3Q�2c6�>3EcbcH/0GQLH'ER,/>O*;^;57A�57>O*;2/X �S>3A�H�A�B�0GA\516�o��ãä � 512R03*LA�5Vؽ03=<C�.1H3N�A�B;H/*bcH\,k03*U03^;^U>O*a24>O=<HvH'è(H','A�57KLH � Ø Ì H'51.�^;57K@5124>3E���24>ãA�B�0GAyo���ä � ä��q512�A4E457K�5103.|X í�:OH'*;H'E[03.�C�B;51.7>O24>3C�BL8>O6¿A�B;Ha.1>O:D,k0GA�H/:O>3ET8i572ÔA�>DA4E�Hk0GAÔH ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.å^;5VK�5724>3E�2Ô03*;^�^;57K@5124>3E�2M>O* ' Z;*;576�>3E�=?.78LXUí�C;C�.78@51*;:DA�B;HC�B;51.7>O24>3C�BL8"A�> ��ß � ä��åN�.7Hk03^;2SA�>`A�B;Hg*;>3A�51>O*q>O6v0_2TC±H/,/5103.�A�51:OH'E Ë 6�>3EÔo�� Õ beB;57,[B¾,k03*q](Hg^;H'Ï�*;H/^032#03*ÍH'è±H/,'A�5VKLH �ëbu57A�B¾o��?ä �ë*�Z;=?H'E451,k03.7.78ÐA4E�57K@5903.®N�bu57A�BÍ,'>@H�!<,/51H/*LAg0GAP.1Hk032TAº>O*;H3X Ì H_*;>3A�H?03.724>A�B;H`6�>O.1.7>%bu51*;:qH/rsZ;57KG03.1H/*LAU6�>3E�=gZ;.90GA�57>O*Í>O6RA4B;HD^;HJÏ�*;57A�57>O*�>O6\A�51:OHJE Ë beB;57,[B�6�>O.7.1>�be2#E�Hk03^;57.78Í69E4>O= A�B;H^;H'Ï�*;5VA�51>O*;2 Õ ~�¿�@�Í�����D£ ¤J¥ U §¨¤-©G¼ë¤��@³[¤ ¯ ¥®´¶¬G¼±©GÂv¹3´�µ�´�ªk¬ ° ¬�µO¤ ° 'eÀi£ ¤J¥ � Ò�Ó 'Ö§¨¤`¥®­;¤-¤��O¥ ° ©�³J¥|´¶¬�¼ �T¬I¸ ° ¤JÂ7©G¥|´�µ3¤*\´¶³�© ° ¹a¼�ùs«?§¨¤ ° ¬�¼(¤ � ¬+¸ U À U ´�ªº©_¥®´9È�¤ ° ´ ÆçÒ Ë o��Dä U ÕÔ­�©�ªM¼(¬G¼�úw¼(¤½È�©G¥®´»µ3¤"�a¬k¹�©G´ ° ©D¹G´�«?¤J¼�ª¨´¶¬�¼±À

+@51*;,'Hc0eA�51:OHJE�512�0u^;57K�5724>3E�>O6;,/>sH�!?,'51H/*LAy0GA�.7Hk032TA�>O*;H3NG51*#B�Z;*�A�57*;:ã6�>3Eå0uA�51:OHJEkN357A 512�*�0GA4Z�E[03.sA�>SHG��A4E[03,JAA�B;HMH �;,'H'C;A�51>O*�03.�^;5VK�5724>3ER69E�>O=àA�B;HÔ=<51*;51=?03.±^;H/2457*;:OZ;.90GE�572�0GA�57>O*�buB;51,[B-B�032R=_0 �;57=_03.W,/>@H�!<,/51H'*�AkX Y B;572512�A�B;Hv57^;Hk0u](H'B;51*;^ºA�B;H�BsZ;*LAkX Ì H�bu51.7.LZ;24H¿A�B;H¿A451:OH'E�GB�Z;*LA�=?H'A�0GC�B;>3E�51*ÔK30GE�57>OZ;2 *;>3A[0GA451>O*;2 A4B�E�>OZ;:OB;>OZ�AA�B;HMCW0GC(H'EkN�>s,/,k032457>O*�03.1.78_A4>?0UA457E�H/2T>O=?Hã^;H/:3E�H/H3X

$cH/:O51*;*;57*;:Dbu57A4B Ë ' 3 ��! 3 Õ ß Ë '�� % Õ N(bcHU51*;^;Z;,JA�57KLH/.V8q,/>O*;2TA4E4Z;,'Aº0`24H/rsZ;H/*;,/Ha>O6�CW0357E42 Ë ' � ��! � Õ >O6�0E[03*�QD>O*;HP.7>O:a^;H'.���H����/><bu57A�B�0U]±>OZ;*;^�0GE48LN�24Z;,[B�A�B�0GAk~

Ë ð ÕÐÒ Ë o����ä ! � Õ 512u03=<C�.7H3XË ó Õ )+6 Ë ' � ��! � Õ B�032u0aA�57:OH'EkN�A�B;H/*-24><^;>sH/2 ' XY B;Hå,'>O*;2TA4E�Z;,'A451>O*P572�]s8Ô0\24H/r@Z;H'*;,/H¿>O6s0Ro"ضC±>O2457A457KLHyH ��ATE[03,'A�57>O* Ë A�B�0GA�512�0\]�.7>%b�Z�C Õ Ñ � ~ � � � Ê ÒWÓ ' �

6�>O.1.7>%bvH/^_]s8`0ºo"ؽ*;H':L0GA�57KLH�,'>O*�A4E�03,'A�51>O*�NMR ��� Ê N@Hk03,[BD>O6�E�H'.90GA�5VKLH?�¿57,k0GE�^`*sZ;=#]±H'E\>O*;H3X2R ��� Ê 572vH/5VA�B;H'ER0É�Ê Ø¶Ï;];E[0GA451>O*�N�>3ER0P]�.7>%bt^;>%bu*8R � � Ê ~ � ��� Ê Ò�Ó ' � � Ê X�)+*_A�B;H�Ï;E�2TA\,k032THãbvHS2�0�8 � � � Ê 512\0 � ��� 03*;^`A�B;HC;E�>s,/H/242c2TA4>3C�2/X Ì H�:O57KLHeA4B;H�^;H'A[0357.12v57* � :�X@+@Z;,¨BD24H/rsZ;H/*;,/H/2R0GE�He69E�H/r@Z;H'*�A�.V8_2TA�Z;^;57H/^`51*?A�B;HezÐz ��Ns24H/H6�>3E�HG��03=<C�.7H<îòï .3ñ¶X Y B;HP>O*;.78D,[B;>O51,'HP51*�A�B;HP24H'r@Z;H/*;,/HP512\beB;57,¨B-^;57K�5724>3Eu512RH ��A4E�03,'A�H/^-]�8 Ñ � X Y B;HÔBsZ;*LA512e0<24H/rsZ;H/*;,/H#:O5VKLH/*-]�8-H �@A4E[03,'A451*;:_03*�HG�;,/H'C;A451>O*�03.�^;57K�5724>3E?U � � Ê N�>O6 A�B;Hº=?57*;51=_03.(^;H'2451*;:OZ;.10GE�512�0GA451>O*>O6 ' � N�6�>3ERbeB;57,[B-A�B;HP,'>@H�!<,/51H/*LA � Ë U � � Ê � o����ä ! � Õ 512R=_0 ��51=_03.®X

Page 12: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

.$) ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

Y >º:OH'*;H'E[0GA�HeA4B;H�,/>O.1.7H/,'A�57>O* � Ë 03*;^`,/>O=<C�.7H'A�HRA�B;HeC;E�>s>O6�>O6 Ë ðOXpï ÕåÕ bcH�,'.903242457698_03.7.�C±>O24245V]�51.15VA�51H'2v6�>3EA�B;HãB�Z;*�AR6�>3E\beB;57,[BDbcHM0GE�HãZ;*�0G]�.7HãA4>gÏ�*;^�0#A�51:OH'E/X # H'ARZ;2\:O57KLHã0#6�H'btE�H/=_0GE4Q@2vA�>gH ��C�.10351*_buB�8_2TZ;,¨B0a,'.90324245VÏ�,k0GA�57>O*-512\C(>O2T2457]�.7H3~)+6WA4B;HR,'>@H�!<,/51H/*LA � Ë '�Õ 572å2TZ"!?,/57H/*�A4.78g,/.7>O24HcA�>ã>O*;H Ë ,/6½X Ë ó@ðOX1ð Õ4Õ NGA�B;H/*g]s8 Ë � X . Õ >O6 îæó � ñ¶N'U Ê 512å0ãA451:OH'EkX

$v8 Ë # Xæï Õ A�B;Hg,/>O.7.1H/,'A451>O*q>O6 ' bu57A�B � Ë 'åÕ � ð Ò�� 512�]±>OZ;*;^;H/^�X Y B�Z;2M57*¾03.7. ]�Z�AÔ0?](>OZ;*;^;H/^Ð*�Z;=g]±H'E>O6¿,/0324H/2/N�A�B;HgBsZ;*LAPÏ�*;^;2P0`A451:OH'EÔ0GASA�B;HgKLH'E48"Ï;E�2IAP2TA4H'C�N 03*;^ÐbeB�0GAM572M*;H'H/^;H/^�572P03*ÐH�!?,'51H/*LAP=<Hk03*;2>O6¿^;H/03.151*;:`bu57A�BÐA�B;HaHG�;,/H'C;A451>O*;2/X � Z�Eº,[B;>O51,'Ha6�>3EMA�B;HUBsZ;*LAkN A4B�0GAÔ572M03.7b\0k8�2ãH �@A4E[03,'A�57*;:-0D^;57K@5124>3EM>O6=_0 ��51=_03.y,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LA Ë beB;57,[B�572g0q*�0GA4Z�E[03.v,[B;>O51,/HGNå69E4>O= A�B;H?C(>O57*�Ag>O6cK�57H'bÚ>O6cA�57:OH'E�2 Õ A4Z�E�*;2#>OZ�A#A�>B�0kKLHgE4H/=_0GE4QG0G]�.78-2TA4E�>O*;:D:OH/>O=?H'ATE�51,#,/>O*;2TH/r@Z;H/*;,'H/2/X Ì H#bu51.7.�H ��C�.10351*qA�B;512S57*i,'>O*;2451^;H'E�0G]�.1HU^;H'A[0351. 51*A�B;HM51*LA4E�>s^;Z;,'A�51>O*DA�> � :�Xå)wAR512\A�B;H/24HÔ,/>O*;24H/rsZ;H/*;,/H/2ubeB;57,¨B-=_0GQLHã6�Hk032457]�.7Hº03*�H ��C�.751,/5VAu,'.90324245VÏ�,k0GA�57>O*->O6A�B;H?HG�;,/H'C;A451>O*�03.¿,/0324H/2/X-)+* Ë :�X .;X � Õ bcH_:O57KLH<0�^;H'A[0351.7H/^�];E�Hk0GQ@^;>%bu*m^;H/24,'E457]�51*;:qC(>O2T2457]�57.157A451H/2Ô6�>3E#A�B;HB�Z;*�AkX Ì HÔA4B;H/*�,/>O=<C�.7H'A�HSA�B;HMC;E�>@>O6�]s8-03*�03.78@2451*;:UHk03,[B�>O6 A�B;HãC(>O2T2457]�57.157A451H/2/X

�W�®� � J K���¡k¡k� 9yÿO�;�%�»���h�Wþ�� K K¿ü�� �<�¾ü�������� �@�âÿO��K K»�@ÿ3�%�»���â��þ;'c�íS2å^;5124,/Z;2T24H/^`0G](>�KLH3Ns0P^;H'A[0357.1H/^<03*�03.78@24512å>O6±A�B;HRBsZ;*LAv8@51H/.7^;2¿0M,/>O.1.7H/,'A�57>O* �",/>O*LA[0357*;51*;:#03.7. ' Ë be5VA�B

' 3 2451=<C�.V8M,/>O*;*;H/,'A�H'^ Õ bu57A4B;>OZ�A A�57:OH'EkX Ì Hc57*�ATE�>@^;Z;,/H'^gA4B;HvBsZ;*LAå6�>3E�H �;03,'A�.78MA�B;572 C�Z�E4C(>O2TH3X@+@>O=?H'buB�0GA24Z�E4C;E4512457*;:O.78LN;A�B;HMBsZ;*LAS512u03.12T>?0aZ;2TH/6�Z;.�A4>@>O.�6�>3E�,'.90324245VÏ�,k0GA�57>O*�0GARA�B;HÔ>3A4B;H'E�H �@A4E�H/=<H3~)+* � ó3ï-bcH_,/.103242451698¾E[03*�Q�>O*;H`.1>O:-^;H/. ��H����'>O2 ' ß ' 3 Ë *;>Ð03242TZ;=<C;A�51>O*Í>O*m6�Z;*;^�03=?H'*�A[03.¿:3E�>OZ�C Õ

24Z;,[B"A�B�0GA U Ê Ë >O6�A�B;HPÏ;E42TASB�Z;*�Aã2TA4H'C Õ 512�0aA�51:OHJEkX\íS2ebcHPE�H'=_0GE4QLH/^"0G]±>%KLHGN�A�B;572�51*;,/.7Z;^;H/2ã03.1. ' be5VA�B24Z"!<,/51H/*LA�.V8-.10GE�:OHã,/>@H�!<,/51H'*�A � Ë '�Õ N;buB;51,[B�57*�A�Z�E�*-51*;,/.7Z;^;H/2�03.7.�]�Z�Ae0U]±>OZ;*;^;H/^",/>O.7.1H/,'A451>O*->O6 ' X

� Z�E�,/.103242457Ï�,/0GA�51>O*�N;buB;51,[B�512R51*;^;HJC(H/*;^;H/*LAS>O6 A4B;HÔB�Z;*�AS03*�03.78�2T512 � ð�.���ð # N;512R>O6 A�B;HÔ6�>O.1.7>%bu51*;:a24>3E4Ak~,�57E42TAgbcH�,'.903242457698j0G]�2TA4E[03,JAUCW035VE�2 Ë ' Ê ��� Ê Õ >O6�0"E[03*�Qm>O*;HD.1>O:Ð^;H/. ��H����/>¾24Z�E�6�03,/HD,/>O*LA[0351*;57*;:�03*

51*LA�H/:3E�03.yE�0GA�51>O*�03.y,/Z�E4KLH � Ê 24Z;,[B�A�B�0GAÔo�����ä � Ê 512Ô03*LA�5Vض*;H/6½N�03*;^�.7>O:�A�H'E4=?51*�03.y0GAÔ2451*;:OZ;.10GEPC±>O51*LA�2>O6 ' Ê X Y B;H'8"6�03.1.�57*�A4>�0_24B;>3ETAÔ*�Z;=#](H'EM>O6å24H'E�57H/2/X Ì Hg*;>3A�H#A�B�0GAM0_2451=?57.90GES,'.90324245VÏ�,k0GA�57>O*Ð>O6yCW0357E42M572>3];A[0357*;H/^¾57*âî}ï�ð/ñå03*;^âî}ïLó�ñ¶X � Z�E#0GE4:OZ;=?H/*LAÔ572M]W032TH/^�>O*¾rsZ;57A�HU^;57è±H'E�H/*LAº57^;Hk032/N 03*;^�512M,/>O*;2457^;H'E[0G]�.V82457=<C�.1H'E/XÌ HS0GC;C�.V8aA4B;512v,/.10324245VÏ�,k0GA�51>O*?A4>ºA�B;HeÏ;E�2TAvBsZ;*LAR2TA�H'C�X2#�H'A � Ê Ü ' Ê ]±H�A�B;H�57=_03:OHu>O6 U Ê Ë 032424Z;=?57*;:

R Ê 572º]�57E[0GA451>O*�03. Õ Xq)wAg572UH/032T8�A�>q24B;>�bÚA�B�0GAU516%U Ê 572a0�A�57:OH'EkN�A�B;H/*jH/5VA�B;H'E � Ê 512U0 É�Ê Ø¶Ï;];E[0GA451>O*�Ny>3EË ' Ê ��� Ê Õ 572g032#51*ÍA�B;H?C;E�H',/H/^;51*;:qCW0GE[03:3E[0GC�B�X Y B;H?Ï;E�2TAg,k032THD572#Hk032T8�A4>",/.903242T51698LX Y >",/.103242457698 ' Ny5VAE�H/=?0351*;2PA�>",'.903242457698�C(>O2T2457]�57.157A451H/2º6�>3EPA�B;H?A4E[03*;246�>3E4=_0GA�51>O* ' Ê���� ' X Y B;512g03=<>OZ;*�A�2ÔA�>",/.9032T2451698@51*;:C(>O2T2457]�57.157A451H/2g6�>3E)R Ê ~ � Ê Ò�Ó ' Ê 2TZ;,¨B�A�B�0GA0U Ê Ë A�B;H�2IA4E�51,JAaA4E�03*;246�>3E�= >O6 � Ê Õ 512g,/>O*LA4E[03,JA�57]�.7H3Nv03*;^,/>O*LA4E[03,'A42uA�>a0a.7>O:UA�HJE�=?51*�03.�2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457Aw8LX Ì HÔ57*;^;51,k0GA4HÔB;>�béA�B;512R,k03*-]±HÔ^;>O*;HÔ51* � ó3ï�Xå)wAu512RHk032T8D03*;^H/.7H/=?H/*LA[0GE48LNO]�Z�AåbcHu^;>Ô*;>3Av03,JA�Z�03.1.V8g.1512IAåA4B;HRC±>O242457]�57.15VA�51H/2'N@032å57Aybc>OZ;.7^a](HR*;>3A[0GA�57>O*�03.1.V8ºA�>@>M51*LKL>O.7KLH'^�X

� ]�24H'E4KLHeA4B�0GA�A�B;HeH �;572TA�H/*;,/Hu>O6(24Z;,[BD0Ô,/.10324245VÏ�,k0GA�51>O*<512v0GA�.1H/032TA¿A�>Ô24>O=?Hu^;H/:3E�H/H�,'>OZ;*�A�HJETؽ57*�A�Z;5VA�57KLHGX� *;Hu=?57:OB�A�B�0�KLH\H �@C(H/,'A4H/^<0S2457=<C�.1Hc,'.90324245VÏ�,k0GA�57>O*U>O6 ' bu57A4BU=<51.1^g2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2/N3be5VA�BU0�C;E�>O:3E�H/242T57KLH/.V8.1H'242#A4E[03,'A[0G]�.7H_.1572TA#>O6\C(>O24245V]�51.757A�57H/2g032#=?>3E�H_,/>O=aC�.151,/0GA�H/^Í2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2g0GE4H`03.1.1>�bcH/^�Xq)+*;^;H/H/^�N É � 572

Page 13: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � . �

A�B;HÔ>O*;.78�24=?>@>3A4B ' N�(ã>3E�H/*;2TA4H/51* ' 0GE�Hº,'.90324245VÏ�H/^"51*ÍîVðOð/ñ¶NW03*;^�.7>O:<^;H/.���H����/>O2ube5VA�B�51*;^;HG� Ë >O6 o Õ 0GA=?>O2TAãAwbc>-0GE�Ha,'.90324245VÏ�H/^�57*âîVð/ñ|X#öS>%bvH'KLH'EkN�,/>O=<CW0GE�5724>O*¾>O6�>OZ�EÔAwbc>�=_0351*Ð,/.103242457Ï�,/0GA�51>O*ÐE�H/24Z;.VA�2ãØ|A�B;H,/>O.7.1H/,'A451>O* �åN;03*;^�>OZ�ER,/.10324245VÏ�,k0GA�51>O*`>O6 ' bu57A�B`.10GE�:OHS,/>@H !?,/57H/*�AIؽ:O57KLH'2u03*D51*;^;57,k0GA�57>O*D57*_A�B;Hã>3C;C(>O245VA�H^;57E4H/,'A�57>O*�~�+@Z�E�6�03,/H/2c>O6�24=?03.1.�,/>@H !?,/57H/*�A/N@A�B;>OZ;:OB<]±>OZ;*;^;H/^�N�0GC;C(Hk0GE Ë 0GA¿.7Hk032TAvA4>ºZ;2 Õ E�0GA�B;H'Ec2TC±>3E[03^;51,GNbuB;51.1HM24Z�E�6�03,'H/2ebu57A�B�24Z"!?,/57H/*LA�.78�.90GE�:OHM,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LAeH ��B;57]�5VAuE�H'.90GA�5VKLH/.78`Z;*;576�>3E�=×]±H/B�0kK�51>OZ�E/X

(M5VKLH/*ÍA�B;H`H'è(H','A�57KLH'*;H/242g>O6u>OZ�E#A4H/,[B;*;51r@Z;H'2<0GAgH/5VA�B;H'Eg2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8ÍH ��ATE�H/=?H3N�bvH?](H/.751H'KLH_A�B�0GAºE4HJØC(H/0GA�H/^D0GC;C�.157,k0GA�51>O*_>O6(A4B;HS2�03=?He=<H'A�B;>@^;2�bc>OZ;.1^`H'KLH/*LA�Z�03.7.78<8@51H/.7^`0º,/>O=<C�.7H'A�He,'.90324245VÏ�,k0GA�57>O*D>O6(E�03*�Q>O*;HP.7>O:a^;H'.���H����/>?24Z�E�6�03,'H/2/X

+@H'KLH'E�03.�C(H/>3C�.7HuB�0kKLHe032IQLH/^aA�B;H\6�>O.7.1>�be57*;:ÔrsZ;H/2TA�57>O* /s572�5VA�A4E�Z;H\A�B�0GA � o �� � Ë >�KLH'E�03.1.;.1>O:M^;H/. ��H����/>O2 Õ2�0GA�572TÏ�H/2ví � � 6�>3E�](>OZ;*;^;H/^`24Z�]�24H'r@Z;H/*;,/H'2�x Y B;H�r@Z;H'2TA�51>O*<512v24Z;:O:OH'2TA�H/^_]�8?03*�03.7>O:38Ubu57A4B`0ÔE�H/24Z;.VAc>O6îæó�ñ±A�B�0GA\A�B;HÔ,'>3E4E�H/2TC±>O*;^;51*;:?2TH'AR>%KLH'Eu=?57*;51=_03.W.1>O:gA�H'E�=<51*�03.(24Z�E46�03,/H/2e>O6�:OH/*;H'E�03.�Aw8sC(Hã2�0GA�572TÏ�H/2� � � XY B;Hº03*;2TbcHJEeA�>UA�B;512Rr@Z;H/2IA�51>O*�512u0UE�H/2T>OZ;*;^;51*;:_*;>;N�24H/H Ë óOó@X � Õ X

Y B�03*�Q�2/~ Ì H`bc>OZ;.7^�.15VQLH_A�>ÐA4B�03*�Qmí#X2$R0GE�03:L0GEkNyí#X � >3E4A45|N UX�zq>3E4E45124>O*�N +±X�zÐ>3E45|N ��X MH'.151:O*;HGNgXvöSZ�8@];E4H/,[B�A�2'N Y X¿öS24Z�NRzmX # Z;2IA�51:;N��PX¿zÐ>3E4H/.1.75|N��UX ��H'ATE�51^;572`03*;^�HgX +@B;>3Q�Z�E�>�Kâ6�>3ED03^�K�57,/H"03*;^24Z;:O:OH/2IA�51>O*;2/X Ì Hebv>OZ;.1^_.15VQLHeA�>PCW0GETA�51,/Z;.10GE�.78UA�B�03*�Q����03*;>O2 *Ô>O.7.��0GEkN�beB;>#24Z;:O:OH'2TA�H/^ Ë ðOX � Õ 032c0º*�0GA�Z�E�03.,/>O=<CW03*;57>O*�A�>0#�>O:?í�]�Z;*;^�03*;,/H3N�03*;^-buB;><B�032�032T24512TA4H/^�Z;2e,'>O*;2451^;H'E�0G]�.78`A�B�E�>OZ;:OB;>OZ�Ae>OZ�EuE�H'24Hk0GE�,[B�X

Page 14: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

. � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

���»�������������� &q�±�(±���±������q ���� �" ��¨���»� �� $�$������ , Ë o_f ä �aÕ ß Ò�� ���a���&�� Ë ¦�� �aÕ &��� ���������&L���

�eZ;* Ë o_fhä �UÕ Ø¶*;H/:L0GA�5VKLHÔzqz �

Ë ¦�� �UÕ¿Ò�Ó Ë '9� Þ Õ N ' E�03*�Q�>O*;HM.1^�C�� (M>L03.|~ Ë '�� Þ Õ .1>O:Z;*;57E�Z;.7H/^ /WAwbc>a,k0324H/2'~���� )+6�Þ �ß %�~ Ë '�� Þ Õ .1>O:

Z;*;5VE�Z;.1H/^ Ë õ�X ó Õ � � � $\Z;:GØ ��8LH/^�,/>�KLH'EkN � .;N�03*;^

MH'6½X Y B;H/>3E48 � ��� )+6�Þàß %�~ (M>L03. ' 3

Z;*;57E4Z;.1H/^ / Y bv><,k0324H'2/~"!# �)+6 o��"B�032u0UA451:OH'EkN1U_~ATE[03*;246�>3E�= Ë '�� % Õ � ��� Ë ' Ê � U Õ' 3Ê á U ^;>O=?51*�0GA4H/^D]�8Dê Ê"%$� ' 3 Z;*;57E4Z;.1H/^�X Ë õ�X1ð Õ � � &'''( ''')

$cZ;:GØ��å8LH/^ � >�KLH'EkN

ãH/6½X Y B;H/>3ET8LN�03*;^(ã>3E�H/*;2TA�H'51*�.7^�C�2/N � ï�

)+6 o���B�032R*;><A�57:OH'Ek~�uZ;*-A�B;HMöSZ;*�A�' � �* 2TC(H/,'5903.�E[0GA � Ü ' � ' 3 ^;>O=?57*�0GA�H/^`]s8DE[0GA�2�+tn � � � &'''( ''')

ãH/6½X Y B;H'>3E48LN$cZ;:GØ��å8LH/^-,/>�KLH'EkNW03*;^,'E�5VA�H'E�510 Ë õ�X � Øwõ Õ X,

íS*�03.V8�24572R>O6 öSZ;*�AkN � :�Ø4ð #+@H/H /�>%bç,[B�0GE4A3:�XpÅ�X7ð�õ

�.-/�a&L $�$k��10h �q�� �������� ���������( �32 �����(�� ��$)+6 ' 572y0�*;>3E�=_03.�24Z�E�6�03,/HcbcHc57*;^;51,k0GA4H¿]s8 �' 5VA�2�=?57*;51=_03.O^;H/2T51*;:OZ;.90GE4512�0GA�57>O*�X�)+6 � Ü ' 512�03*gH'è±H/,'A�5VKLH

^;57K@5124>3E/N�A�B;H/* �� Ü �' bu51.1.�57*;^;51,k0GA�HM57A42u2TATE�51,'ARA4E[03*;2T6�>3E�=�X4�5�ß É Ë7698:6�Ë � Õ4Õ ^;H'*;>3A�H/2\A�B;HãZ;*;51r@Z;Hã=?57*;51=_03.�E[0GA�57>O*�03.�E�Z;.7H/^-2TZ�E�6�03,/H3N;bu57A�BD0#,/Z�E4KLH<;3=àÜ:4>5>O6º24H'.161ؽ57*�A4H'E�24H/,JA�51>O* Ò ��Nã03*;^ 4?5t^;H/*;>3A4H/2-A�B;Hi.1>O:�^;H'.���H����/>h24Z�E�6�03,'H�>O6PE[03*�Q�>O*;H3Nã>3];A[0357*;H/^t]�8

Page 15: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � .��

,/>O*LA4E[03,'A451*;:�A4B;512ã,/Z�E4KLH3X #�H'A ; 5�Ü 4>5�57*;^;51,k0GA4Ha0D24H/,'A451>O*Ð^;512»FI>O57*�AP69E�>O= ;3= Ë 03.7.�24Z;,[B�24H/,'A451>O*;2Ô0GE�H.157*;Hk0GE�.V8`H/r@Z;5VK303.7H/*�A/N�03*;^-B�0�KLHÔ24H/.161ض51*LA�H'E�2TH/,'A�57>O* � Õ XÌ B;H'E�HP*;><,/>O*;6�Z;2451>O*�0GE�5124H'2/NWbvHÔbu51.1.�Z;2THÔA�B;HÔ2�03=?HM*;>3A[0GA�51>O*`A�>a51*;^;51,/0GA�Hº0U^;57K�5724>3EkN�03*;^�5VA�2R2TA4E�57,'A

A4E[03*;2T6�>3E�= Z;*;^;H'E_0q]�57E[0GA�57>O*�03.vA4E[03*;246�>3E4=_0GA�51>O*�X ,�>3Ea0i2T51*;:OZ;.90GEUC(>O57*�ASÎ � ' N¿.7H'A � Ë Î Õ ,'>OZ;*�AaA�B;H*�Z;=g]±H'ES>O6�H ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03. ^;5VK�512T>3E�>O6 �'âÒ±Ó ' .V8�51*;:<>%KLH'E�Î�X � *�A�B;Hº>3A�B;HJESB�03*;^q.1H'A �_]±HºA�B;HPE�H'.90GA�5VKLH�¿57,k0GE�^�*sZ;=#](HJE�>O6 �'�Ò�Ó ' X � .1Hk0GE�.V8

�gß �� � �

� Ë Î Õ �

$v8D0a,/Z�ETKLH ���W�@� 0gC(>O51*LAyÎ�� ' N;bcHP=?H/03*-0U,/Z�E4KLHP57*�A�B;HÔH �;,'H'C;A�51>O*�03.�.7>@,/Z;2R>O6 �'�Ò�Ó ' >�KLH'EyÎ�X$v8`0�;

�ÿL� �%��� >O*�0g*;>3E�=_03.±2TZ�E�6�03,/H � bcHã=?Hk03*D0U,'>O=<C�.1H'A4HM,'Z�E4KLHSbeB;>O24HM2TA4E451,'AcA4E�03*;246�>3E�=Ö>O* ��

B�032M24H/.161ض51*LA�H'E�2TH/,'A�57>O* ;WX��S>3A�HUA4B�0GAÔ576�A�B;HU,/Z�E4KLHa512Mo���ض*;H/:L0GA�5VKLH3N 03*;^ ; � Å�N�A�B;H/*Ð]s8i03^�FIZ;*;,'A�57>O*�N57A42u2TATE�51,'ARA4E[03*;2T6�>3E�= 572e0U24=?>s>3A�BDE�0GA�51>O*�03.�,/Z�ETKLH3Xí � Ø Ì H/57.�^;57K@5124>3E � ��� Þ � 512c,k03.7.1H/^`0 ¡k� ü ü�������� ����� 516 ��� � ðON�03*;^�0 üå������� ����� 516�Å �

���� ðOX

)wAe572u,/03.1.1H'^ ��� �%� 516 ��� �çðOX � ��� Þ � 572u,k03.7.1H/^DE�H/^;Z;,/H'^"516�03.7.(A�B;HP*;>O*@Ø��/H'E�> ��� 0GE�HÔH'r@Z�03.�A�><>O*;HGXÌ B;H/*ÐbvHUHG��C;E�H/2T2P0 � Ø Ì H/57.c^;57K@5124>3EM032 � ��� Þ � bcHU03242TZ;=?H3N(A�B�0GAãA�B;H#Þ � 0GE�H#^;512TA451*;,'AÔ03*;^Ð57E4E�H¨Ø

^;Z;,/5V]�.1H3X$v8D0a,/>O=aC(>O*;H/*LAe>O6 A�B;H � Ø Ì H/51.å^;57K@5124>3E ! ß � ��� Þ � N;be5VA�B ��� - Å�N�bcHP=?H/03*�0aÞ � be5VA�B ��� ÃëÅ�X

Y B;HP24Z�C;C±>3E4A�>O6 ! N+@Z�C;C Ë !<Õ N�572RA�B;HÔZ;*;51>O*�>O6�57A�2R,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*LA�2 Ë be5VA�B�E�H'^;Z;,/H/^"2TA4E4Z;,'A�Z�E�H Õ X$v8qÃç>3E � bcHÔ=?Hk03*�2TA4E�57,'Ae57*;H/r@Z�03.757Aw8LXÌ H<bRE�5VA�H � ��� Þ � - ��� � Þ � 576 ��� - � � 6�>3EU03.1.��4X Ì H?bRE�5VA�H � ��� Þ � à ��� � Þ � 576\51*m03^;^;57A451>O*

��� à � � 6�>3Eu24>O=?H��4Xí .1>O:aE4H/24>O.1Z�A451>O*->O6 0UCW035VE Ë ¦�� Þ Õ >O6�0gK30GE451H'Aw8 ¦ 03*;^"0gE�H/^;Z;,/H'^"^;57K�5724>3ERÞ 512u0U]�5VE[0GA�57>O*�03.�=_0GC

Ñ ~ T Ò�Ó ¦ bu57A�Bm^;57K@5124>3E45903.¿HG�;,/H'C;A451>O*�03.c.1>s,/Z;2 U_N�24Z;,[B�A�B�0GA T Nå03*;^�03.1.v,/>O=aC(>O*;H/*LA�2g>O6 UÝä �Þ0GE�HD24=?>s>3A�B�Nå03*;^ U ä �Þ B�032a*;>3E4=_03.c,'E�>O242T51*;:O2/Xmí×.1>O:qE�H/24>O.7Z�A�51>O*j>O6 Ë ¦���!aÕ 512a0Ð.7>O:ÐE4H/24>O.1Z�A451>O*>O6 Ë ¦�� +@Z�C;C Ë !<ÕTÕ X Ë ¦�� Þ Õ 512S,k03.7.1H/^Ð.1>O:`24=?>s>3A�B�N(576 ¦ 03*;^iHJKLH'E48q,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*LAÔ>O6åÞ 512S24=?>s>3A�B�N�03*;^Ë ¦�� Þ Õ B�032e*;>3E4=_03.�,'E�>O242T51*;:O2/XY B�E�>OZ;:OB;>OZ�A�A�B;HPCW0GC±H'EkN(Z;*;.7H/242S>3A�B;HJE4be5724Hº*;>3A�H'^�N±]s8�0?^;57K@5124>3EkN�bcH#=?H/03*"0 � Ø Ì H/57.¿^;57K@5124>3E/N±03*;^

]�8-0U,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*�AubcHM=?Hk03*�03*�57E4E4H/^;Z;,/57]�.7HP,/>O=aC(>O*;H/*LAkXÌ H#bu51.1. =_0GQLH#69E�H/rsZ;H/*LAkN�03*;^¾>@,',k032451>O*�03.7.78-Z;*�E�H/=_0GE4QLH'^iZ;24HU>O6yA�B;Hg,/.903242T57Ï�,k0GA�57>O*q>O6åAwbc>D^;51=?H'*@Ø

2457>O*�03.¿r@Z;>3A451H/*LA#2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2'N�24H/H � B�0GC;A�H'EUï">O6Ôîæó � ñ¶X�,W>3EºA�B;H?E�Hk03^;HJE�2g,/>O*�KLH'*;51H/*;,/H_bcH?E4H/,k03.1.�A�B;H=?>O2TAã57=<C(>3ETA[03*�A�6�03,'A�2M51*qí�C;C(H/*;^;5 � #�X Ì H<03.724>`=_0GQLH#69E�H/rsZ;H/*�AÔZ;24HU>O6åA4B;HU6�>3E4=UZ;.1032ã>O6 � B�0GC;A�H'EÔï>O6Mîæó � ñ¿6�>3EºA�B;H_57*;^;H �m03*;^m^;512T,'E�H'CW03*;,/57H/2/X Ì H?be57.1.å>O69A�H/*ÍE�H/6�H'E#A4>q0�,'8�,/.751,?2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457Aw8�032º0 ÿG� �W�»�2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8LNW032eA4B;HÔE�H/2T>O.1Z�A�57>O*":3E[0GC�B�512u51*�A�B;572e,k032TH#0<,[B�0351*�X%,W>3ES0<*;>O*@ض,'8�,/.751,º2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457Aw8LN;A�B;H'E�Hº572H �;03,'A�.78D>O*;HPKLHJE4A�H �-51*�A�B;HME�H/24>O.7Z�A�51>O*":3E�0GC�B�=?H/H'A451*;:<A�B�E4H/HºH/^;:OH/2'X Ì Hº,k03.1.�A�B;572uA�B;Hº,'>3E4E�H/2TC±>O*;^;51*;:H ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.å^;5VK�5724>3EÔA4B;H ÿO���(���%�Ke���»���»¡/�W� X Y B�E�H'H<,[B�0351*;2Ô=?H/H'AMA�B;512ãKLH'E4A4H ��X Ì HUE4H/6�H'EºA�>DA�B;H/24H<032

Page 16: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

. � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

A�B;H ü����W��ÿ�� ��¡ Xå)+*"0U];E[03*;,[B�N±bvHP,k03.7.�A4B;Hº,/Z�E4KLHÔ=?H/H'A�57*;:aA�B;HÔ,/H/*LA4E[03. ^;57K�5724>3EkN;A�B;H ����)k��ÿO�@��� ,/Z�E4KLHGN03*;^-A�B;HM>3A�B;H'EeH/*;^�>O6�A�B;HP,[B�0351*�N�A�B;H ��� ����¡k����� ,'Z�E4KLH3XÌ HMbe57.1.�2�0�8DA�B�0GA�0<,[B�0351*"2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8D572 � K®����¡'�O7-���Ô� K 516 57A�2RE�H/24>O.7Z�A�51>O*�:3E�0GC�B"B�032�>O*;.78�>O*;H

KLH'E4A4H �?>O6(bvH/51:OBLAc>3A�B;H'E¿A�B�03*Dó@NsA�B�0GAv>O6(bcH/51:OBLA\ïº03*;^_>s,/,/Z�E4E451*;:U0GA¿A�B;HeH/*;^`>O6(A�B;H�,[B�0351*�N@A4B�0GAv512�A�B;H,[B�0351*�B�032u6�>3E�= Ë ó � ó � ó � � � �5� ï Õ Ë buB;H'E�HÔbvHP03.724>?03.7.1>�b Ë ï Õ4Õ X

$v8_A�B;HM51*;^;H �->O6�0Ur@Z;>3A�57H/*�Au2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8LN�bvHP=?Hk03*DA�B;HM>3E�^;H'E�>O6�A�B;HP.7>@,k03.�6�Z;*;^�03=<H/*�A�03. :3E�>OZ�C�XÌ Hebu51.7.�=?0GQLHu69E�H'r@Z;H/*LARZ;24H�>O6(A�B;HS=_0357*aE�H'24Z;.7A�2c>O6(A4B;H Ë .1>O: Õ zq51*;51=?03.Wzq>s^;H/.��åE�>O:3E[03=�~ A4B;H�,/>O*;H

A�B;H/>3E4H/=�N(A�B;HU,/>O*LA4E[03,'A�57>O*ÐA4B;H/>3E�H/=�N�03*;^ÐA�B;Hg.1>O:D0G]�Z;*;^�03*;,/HUA�B;H/>3E�H/=-X Y B;HUÏ;E�2IAÔAwbc>D>O6åA4B;H/24Ha0GE�HQ�*;>�bu*�51*�03.1.c^;57=?H/*;2457>O*;2/Nv03*;^jA�B;HD.9032TAUZ�C�A4>i^;57=?H/*;2457>O*�A�B�E�H'H3XmöS>%bcHJKLH'EgbcH->O*;.V8ÍZ;24H�A4B;H/= 51*^;51=<H/*;2451>O*ÍAwbc>;X ,W>3EºC;E�>s>O6�2U57*ÍA�B;512#,k032THD2TH/HÐî}ïOÅGñ|X ,�>3Eg>�KLH'E4K@51H'bu2#>O6cA�B;H_:OH/*;H'E�03.vA�B;H/>3E48 Ë 032ºbcH/.7.032�6�Z�E4A4B;H'ESE�H/6�H'E4H/*;,/H/2 Õ 24H'HDîVð�õGñ¶N îæó � ñ|N�î}ó@ð/ñ¶X Ì HPbu51.7. 03.724>?=_0GQLHÔZ;24H#>O6�A�B;Hº2IA[03*;^�0GE�^q^;H'Ï�*;57A451>O*;2S03*;^*;>3A[0GA�57>O*;2u>O6�A�B;HÔC;E4>O:3E[03=�N�032R51*Íî}ó � ñ¶XÌ HSbu51.1.±2�0�8D0#CW0357E Ë ¦�� Þ Õ >O6 0g*;>3E�=_03.±KG0GE�57H'Aw8`03*;^�0#E�H/^;Z;,/H'^-^;57K@5124>3ER572 K��WýÍ�������G� K»�@� 516 ¦ 3 572

,/>�KLH'E�H/^_]�8<E[0GA451>O*�03.�,/Z�E4KLH/2c=<H/H'A�57*;:ºÞÖ0GAv=?>O2IAv>O*;,/H Ë A�B�0GAv572¿A�B�E�>OZ;:OB`0P:OH'*;H'E[03.�C±>O51*LAc>O6��DA�B;H'E�H�5720ã,/>O=<C�.1HJA�HcE[0GA�51>O*�03.;,'Z�E4KLH3N�,/>O*�A�0351*;H/^a51*aA4B;Hu24=<>@>3A�Bg.1>s,/Z;2/Ns03*;^<=?H'H'A�51*;:ãÞ 0GA�=<>O2TAå>O*;,/H Õ X Ì H\bu51.1.2�0k8 ¦ 512R.1>O:UZ;*;57E4Z;.1H/^�576 Ë ¦�� % Õ 572\.1>O:<Z;*;5VE�Z;.1H'^�NW>3EuH/rsZ;57KG03.1H/*LA�.78LN@516 ¦ 3 512RZ;*;57E�Z;.7H/^�N;A�B�0GAu512\A�B�E�>OZ;:OB0a:OH'*;H'E[03.�C(>O57*�Ae>O6 ¦ N�A�B;H'E�HÔ512u0a,/>O=aC�.1H'A�HãE[0GA�57>O*�03.�,/Z�E4KLH3NW,/>O*LA[0351*;H'^�51*DA�B;HP24=<>@>3A�BD.1>s,/Z;2/X

���/�a �����$k������������& �������O��±����'���(��$

)+*iA�B;572P24H','A�51>O*ibcH<,/>O.7.1H/,JA#0�*�Z;=#](H'EP>O6¿E�H/2TZ;.7A�2Ô>O* (M>3E�H'*;2TA�H/57*Í.1>O:-^;H'.@��H����/>�24Z�E�6�03,'H/2PA�B�0GAÔbcHbu51.1. Z;24H?0GAãKG0GE�51>OZ;2SC(>O57*�A42Ô57*ÐA�B;HgCW0GC(HJEkX��¿2TC±H/,/5103.1.78�Z;24H/6�Z;.ybe57.1.�](H Ë ï�Xæõ�Ø : Õ buB;51,[BiA�>O:OHJA�B;H'EM:O57KLHU0,/>O=<C�.7H'A�HÔ03*;^�2457=<C�.1HãC�51,'A4Z�E�HP>O6 E�03*�Q�>O*;H (M>3E�H'*;2TA�H/57*�.1>O:a^;H/.���H����/>?24Z�E46�03,/H/2ebuB;>O24Hº24=<>@>3A�BD.1>s,/Z;2512u03.1:OHJ];E[0351,k03.7.78`2457=<C�.78`,'>O*;*;H/,'A�H/^�X �������%����� �e�#� ����� ý�� �±���e�%� �a¡/��ÿ3�%���±� 'j� �@� ������¡u�`�%�W� ����� ��D�W���@��¡'�����»�4K»�Wý-� �"K N��MPQPL� �)+*`îVðOð/ñ�C(>O2T2457]�.7Hv2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A451H/2 >O6 ' 0GE�H�,/.9032T2457Ï�H/^�X Ì H¿be57.1.�=_0GQLHå69E�H/r@Z;H'*�AyZ;24Hc>O6�A4B;512 ,'.90324245VÏ�,k0GA�57>O*�N

buB;51,[BDbvH�E�H/6�H'EcA�>U032 �%� �8K»�®¡'� X Ì H�bRE�5VA�H�6�>3E\H �;03=<C�.1H ' Ë � Ê ä � � ä ���/Õ 6�>3ER0PE[03*�Q_>O*;H (ã>3E�H/*;2TA4H/51*^;H/.���H����/>Ube5VA�B�A4B;>O24HP2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2/NW03*;^-6�>3E�HG��03=<C�.7H �' Ë � Ê ä � � ä ���/Õ 6�>3E�57A42u^;H/2T51*;:OZ;.90GE4512�0GA�57>O*�X

,W>3ERA4B;HÔE�Hk03^;HJEk{æ2u,/>O*�KLH'*;51H/*;,/HGN±B;H'E�HÔ512u0a,/>3C�8D>O6 A�B;HÔ.1512IAk~

� Ê � � Ê ä � � � ��� � ó � Ê ä � � � Þ � � � Ê ä ��� � ï � � � U�� �ï � Ê ä�Þ � � ��� � � Ê ä�Þ�� � U � � � Ê äâó � � � � � ä ��� �Þ�� � ó � Ê äjÞ�� � U�� � � Ê ä U � � � Ê ä ��� � ó ��� � � � �� Ê ä � � ä ��� � � � ä U�� � � � ä�Þ � � . � � � ó � Ê äâó � � � óGÞ � �

Ë ï�X7ð Õ

Page 17: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � .�2

$v8"îòïOïGñ¶N�A�B;HS6�>O.1.7>%bu51*;:#0GE4H�A�B;HS24Z�]�24H'A\>O6�C±>O242457]�57.15VA�51H/2�be5VA�B ' 3 03.7:OH'];E[0357,k03.1.V8a2T51=<C�.V8<,/>O*;*;H','A�H/^�N�03*;^03*L8"E[03*�Qq>O*;HS(ã>3E�H/*;2TA4H/51*i^;H/.2��H����/>Dbe5VA�BÐA4B;H/24HU2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2ãB�032P03.7:OH'];E[0357,k03.1.V8�2457=<C�.78",'>O*;*;H/,'A�H/^24=?>s>3A�BD.1>@,'Z;2/~

Ë ï�Xpó Õ � Ê � � Ê ä � � � ��� � Þ � � U�� � U � � U�� �

Ì HMbe57.1.�0G]�Z;24HÔ*;>3A[0GA�51>O*-03*;^-,k03.7.�A�B;512\A�B;H ¡k�»� � K��âÿO����� ��ÿ3���@��K®�»¡'� XÌ H_*;>3A�H_A�B�0GAg57*�:OH'*;H'E[03. ' 572g*;>3Ag^;H'A�H'E�=<51*;H/^m]s8m5VA�2#2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2'XiöS>�bcH'KLH'E/N�6�>3E#A�B;H`2457=<C�.78

,/>O*;*;H/,JA�H/^".1572TAkN�A�B;572u572�03.7=?>O2TAcA�B;HÔ,k0324H3X +@H/H Ë ï�X7ð�Å Õ ](H/.7>%bÔXY B;HRo"ؽ*;H':L0GA�57KLH\zqz �j6�>3E (ã>3E�H/*;2TA�H'51*<2TZ�E�6�03,/H/2�512å03.1=?>O2IAå032å2T51=<C�.7H\032yA4B�0GA�6�>3E�24=?>s>3A�Bg24Z�E�6�03,/H'2/X

(��)( �¿�@�Í�����D£ ¤J¥ �v~ � Ò�Ó � §¨¤?©q§'´ ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼±©G o�� ú4³[¬�¼�¥ ° ©s³J¥®´½¬�¼ ,S¬+¸ ° ¤JÂ7©G¥|´�µ3¤ *\´¶³�© ° ¹�¼�ùs«?§¨¤ ° ¬G¼(¤0,ûy´�¥®­ �w´ °¨° ¤�¹GùW³J´|§'Â1¤ � ¤ �@³[¤ ¯ ¥|´¶¬�¼(©GÂ�¹G´�µ�´�ªk¬ ° , ª¨ùW³¨­<¥»­�©3¥ ��´�ª��S¬ ° ¤J¼�ª¨¥w¤'´�¼-©GÂ1¬�¼�È À���Â1¬�¼@È , � ´�ªS¤'´�¥»­�¤ °ª¨«?¬%¬�¥»­ ,c¬ ° ­�©GªP©aùs¼�´¶ø'ù�¤ãªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´»¥®·LÀ � ¼q¥»­�¤ÔÂ7©G¥|¥w¤ ° ³�©�ªk¤M¥®­;¤ãª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|·a´�ªM©3¼ ���aªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´»¥®· ,åûy´�¥®­o��Sä Â1¬�ÈP¥+¤ ° «g´»¼±©GÂ1,y©3¼±¹º¥®­;¤Rª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥|·P´�ª ° ¤J«_¬�µ3¤�¹g§/·P¥®­;¤ã³¨¬�¼�¥ ° ©�³J¥|´¶¬�¼(À �ù ° ¥»­;¤ ° «?¬ ° ¤�¥®­;¤u´»¼±¹GùW³[¤�¹«<© ¯ R ��� �Ê Ë � 3 ÕvÒ�Ó R ��� �Ê Ë � 3 Õº´�ª#©G¼q´�ªk¬G«?¬ °¶¯ ­�´�ª¨«<À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ � *¾A�B;Ha=?51*;57=_03. ^;H'2451*;:OZ;.10GE�512�0GA451>O*�N 572P0 Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLH3X � >O*LA4E[03,'A457]�51.757Aw8",/>O*;2T51^;H'E[0GA451>O*;2P:O5VKLHA�B;HÔ^;H/24,'E�5VC;A�51>O*->O6 A�B;HMC(>O24245V]�.1HM2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A451H/2/X Y B;HP.9032IAu,'.90351=Ö6�>O.7.1>�be2R69E�>O= Ë � Xpï Õ X �

(M>3E4H/*;2TA�H/57* É�Ê Ø¶Ï;];E[0GA�57>O*;2 Ë >O6�E�H/.10GA�57KLH �¿51,/0GE�^`*sZ;=#](HJE\>O*;H Õ 0GE�Hã03.724>ºr@Z;5VA�H�2457=<C�.1HGXåöSHJE�HebcHS2TA�0GA�HA�B;HMC(>O24245V]�51.757A�57H/2/X Ì HÔbu51.7.(C;E�>�KLHº0a=<>3E�HSC;E�H/,/5724HÔE�H'24Z;.7Ae51* � ðOðONW2TH/H Ë ðOðOX � X . Õ X

(��� �����Í����� .Wù ¯L¯ ¬%ª�¤ Ri~ �çÒ�Ó �×´�ªP©ãÉ Ê ú 2v§ ° ©3¥®´¶¬G¼ ,v¬+¸ ° ¤JÂ7©G¥|´�µ3¤3*\´¶³�© ° ¹U¼�ù@«<§¨¤ ° ¬G¼(¤0,v©G¼±¹�� Ü �´�ªº© 2v§ ° ¤-,\³[¬�¼�¥w©G´�¼�¤�¹<´�¼q¥®­;¤ �Ôù��W©GÂ�Â1¬�³Jùsªg¬I¸��gÀ�c¼(¤U¬I¸M¥»­�¤å¸k¬�Â�Â1¬�ûå´�¼@È<­�¬�Â7¹�ª��

Ë ð Õ �à´�ªãª¨«?¬%¬�¥»­"©GÂ1¬�¼@È�_ÀË ó Õ Á ­;¤ ° ¤#© ° ¤U¤��@©�³J¥| ·<¥|ûv¬<ª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥®´½¤¨ª5, � Ê ¯ ¬�´»¼�¥»ª0,v©GÂ1¬�¼@È�_À o��_ä � ´�ªÔ ¥½ÀË ï Õ Á ­;¤ ° ¤Ô´�ª#©?ù@¼�´|ø'ùW¤Ôª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥|· ,c© Þ 5 ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥\©GÂ1¬�¼�È��`À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ #�H'A ��çÒ±Ó � ](HRA�B;He=<51*;51=?03.�^;H/2457*;:OZ;.90GE�572�0GA�51>O*�Ns03*;^?.7H'A �v~ �� Ò±Ó � ](H�0ãE�H/.10GA�57KLHR=?51*;57=_03.=?>s^;H/.¿>O6 �� ÒWÓ � N�A�B�Z;2 � Ò�Ó � 512#24=?>s>3A�B�N�03*;^��m572#0",/>O=<C(>O2T57A�57>O*Í>O6\]�.7>%b Z�C�2U0GA#24=?>s>3A�BC(>O57*�A42/X�$\H',k03Z;24H?R"B�032¿E4H/.90GA�5VKLH ��51,k0GE�^<*sZ;=#](HJEc>O*;H3N@H/03,¨B_]�.7>%b�Z�C`51*��<512¿0GAc0ÔC±>O51*LA\03.1>O*;:ÔA�B;H Ò ð'Ø,/Z�E4KLHM>O6 A4B;HãC;E4H'K�57>OZ;2R]�.7>%béZ�C�X �S>�bé>O*;HÔ,[B;H/,�[email protected]?A4B�0GARA4B;HMC;E�>3C±>O2457A451>O*D:O57KLH/2R03.1.�C(>O24245V]�51.757A�57H/2bu57A�B�MZ8Hv03.�2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2/X2,�>3Eu=?>3E�Hã^;H'A[0357.12R24H/H Ë ðOðOX � Õ X �(�� � �¿�@�Í����� � ¸��à´�ªº©���¬ ° ¤J¼;ª¨¥+¤J´�¼i¹�¤' *e¤�����¬gª¨ù ° ¸/©s³[¤0,�¥®­;¤J¼ l R���� �Ê Ë � 3 Õ l � : À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ �S>3A4Hi576 � 8 Ò±Ó � 512�0�^;H':3E�H/H ��,/>�KLH'EkN �H'A[03.7Hq51*t,'>@^;51=<H/*;2451>O*ë>O*;H3N�A�B;H/* � 8 512�03:L0351*ë0(M>3E4H/*;2TA�H/57*g^;H/."��H����'>;NL03*;^Uo �� � ß ��o �� � :�X2+@57*;,/Hco �� 572�0eC(>O245VA�57KLH¿51*LA�H/:OH'EkN3A4B;HvE�H/24Z;.VA�6�>O.1.7>%bu2/X �

Page 18: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

. � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

�eH',k03.1.�A�B�0GAyA�B�E4>OZ;:OB;>OZ�A�A�B;H\CW0GC(HJEkN�0MC;E�>3C±H'E¿o���ؽ*;H':L0GA�57KLH\,/Z�E4KLHR>O*?0ã*;>3E�=_03.@24Z�E�6�03,/H � 512y,k03.1.7H/^0 Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�ETKLH3N±576��� Ü �� 512e0 Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�E4KLHP51*-A�B;HÔZ;24Z�03.�24H/*;24H3X �S>3A�HãbuB;H/* � 512 (ã>3E�H/*;2TA4H/51*�N�24Z;,[Bq0 � 5720 Ò ð'ؽ,'Z�E4KLHP5Vè � 512\E[0GA�57>O*�03.|N;o�� � � ß Ò ð#03*;^ �� 512R24=?>s>3A�B�X(���� �¿���Í������£ ¤J¥ ' ß ' Ë U�� Õ�À=' ³[¬�¼�¥w©G´�¼;ª#©?ù@¼�´|ø'ùW¤PÒ ð ú4³Jù ° µ3¤ Þ À �ÞÄÜ �'Ý«?¤[¤J¥®ª#©_ùs¼�´¶ø'ù�¤<¤��@³¨¤ ¯ ú¥|´¶¬�¼±©GÂ�³Jù ° µ3¤0,�¥®­;¤Ô¬ ¯L¯ ¬%ª¨´»¥w¤Ô¤J¼±¹?¬+¸e¥®­;¤ ���_³¨­�©3´�¼ ,�ûy´�¥®­<¼(¬ ° «<©GÂ�³[¬�¼W¥½©�³'¥½À l Ò o���l ´�ªã¬�¼(¤Ô¹G´�«_¤J¼;ª¨´¶¬G¼±©GÂ1,©G¼±¹D­;©�ª<©�ùs¼W´|ø'ùW¤?§[©�ªk¤ ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥�,e©�ª¨«?¬�¬G¥»­ ¯ ¬G´�¼�¥�¬+¸ '�À Á ­�¤ ° ¤?© ° ¤U¥®ûc¬ ¯ ¬%ª[ª¨´¶§'´� ´�¥|´¶¤¨ª�¸k¬ ° ¥®­;¤_³[¬�Â�Â1¤¨³J¥®´½¬�¼¬+¸ ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼±©GÂ�«?¤J«<§¨¤ ° ª#¬+¸ l Ò o���l À c´»¥»­;¤ °

Ë ð Õ l Ò o�� l ­�©�ªM¤��s©�³J¥| ·g¥®­ ° ¤¨¤ ° ©3¥®´¶¬G¼±©GÂ�«?¤'«<§¨¤ ° ª5, Þ ©G¼±¹g¥®ûc¬º´�¼W¥w¤½È ° ©GÂ�¼�¬k¹L©G ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼±©3Â(³Jù ° µ3¤¨ª � Ê ,� � Ü ' 3 ,\¬ °

Ë ó Õ l Ò o���l ­�©Gª�¤ �s©�³J¥| ·i¥|ûv¬ ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼±©G¿«?¤J«?§¨¤ ° ª0, Þ ,g©3¼±¹Í©iùs¼W´|ø'ùW¤�´�¼�¥+¤½È ° ©GÂ\³'ù�ª ¯ ´|¹L©G ° ©3¥®´¶¬G¼±©G³Jù ° µ3¤-, � Ü ' 3 À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ #�H'A ' ß ' Ë U�� Õ ](Hg03*L8�24Z;,[Bi24Z�E�6�03,/H3X � ]�K�51>OZ;2T.78 ' ,/>O*�A�0351*;2S24>O=?H Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLH3N�Þ"XSo �� ß ðON24>Íl Ò o���l;512ã>O*;H#^;57=?H/*;2457>O*�03. ]s8 �e51H'=_03*;*@Ø �u>@,[B�N�03*;^iH'KLHJE48"=?H/=#]±H'ES>O6ãl Ò o���l�512�E�H/^;Z;,'H/^�03*;^57ETE�H/^;Z;,/5V]�.1H3X`l Ò o���l;03*;^ÐB�032Ô0_24=<>@>3A�B"H/.7.15VC;A�51,º=<H/=#](H'E U×Ü '23 ]�8jîÛð � ñ¶X 6��eË U Õ ß 6���Ë�� Õ 6�>3EM0Z;*;51rsZ;H � � U_X +@51*;,/H�� Ê Ë 6 � Õ ß Å�N � � ' 3 572uA�B;HMZ;*;51rsZ;HÔ]W0324HJC(>O51*LAS>O6Rl Ò o��ylpX�#�H'A �çÒ�Ó ' ]�.7>%bZ�C � X�l Ò o���l/8@51H/.7^;2y03*aH/.7.15VC;A�51,vÏ;];E[0GA451>O* �c~ �çÒ�Ó É�Ê X #�H'A ��¿~ ��çÒ±Ó É�Ê ](HcA�B;H\51*;^;Z;,/H'^<=_0GC�X2+@57*;,/H' 3 572ã2451=<C�.V8",/>O*;*;H/,JA�H/^�N 03*�8 Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�ETKLHa>O* ' 512M0_=?H/=#]±H'Eã>O6Ml Ò o���lpX +@51*;,/HU03*L8 Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLHU=gZ;2TACW03242ºA�B�E4>OZ;:OB�A�B;H?2457*;:OZ;.90GEºC±>O51*LAkN�03*;^ �iB�032#57E4E4H/^;Z;,/57]�.7H<Ï;];E�H/2'NåÞ 572PA�B;H?Z;*;57r@Z;H Ò ð'ؽ,'Z�E4KLH3X Y B;HÏ;];E�Hu>O6 ��g,/>O*LA[0351*;57*;:ºÞ B�032 # 5VE4E�H/^;Z;,/5V]�.1H�,'>O=<C(>O*;H/*LA�2/NLA�B�Z;2�]�8�*M>@^�035VE[0�{æ2å,/.103242457Ï�,/0GA�51>O*a>O6(2451*;:OZ;.10GEÏ;];E�H/2'N 24H'HUCW03:OHDð � ÅD>O6eî .3ñ|N(A�B;HgÏ;];E�Ha,'>O*�A[0357*;51*;:�Þ 572 �U���N�A4BsZ;2MÞì=?H'H'A�2SA�B;Hg>3C;C(>O245VA�HUH/*;^¾>O6åA�B;H��� ,[B�0351*q032RE�H/rsZ;57E�H/^�X �S>3A�H � Ë ��ãÕ Ë A�B;HMA�>3C(>O.7>O:O51,k03. �¿Z;.7H'E�,[B�0GE[03,JA�H'E�572TA�51, Õ 512Pð%ó@X $v8-6�>3E�=gZ;.10 Ë ðOðOX . Õ>O*?CW03:OH # � >O6åî .3ñ¶NLA�B;HS03^;^;5VA�51>O*�03.W2451*;:OZ;.10GEvÏ;];E�H/2 Ë beB;57,¨B?bvHeQ�*;>�b 0GE4HeE�H/^;Z;,/H'^�03*;^`5VE4E�H/^;Z;,/5V]�.1H Õ 0GE�HH/5VA�B;H'E�HG��03,'A�.V8_Awbc><*;>s^�03.�E�0GA�51>O*�03.�,/Z�ETKLH/2/NW>3EeH �;03,'A�.V8`>O*;HP,/Z;2TC�57^�03.�E�0GA�51>O*�03.�,/Z�ETKLH3X �(���� �����Í����� Á ­;¤ ° ¤i© ° ¤i¤��s©�³J¥| ·Í¥|ûv¬�´�ªk¬�«?¬ °½¯ ­�´�ªJ« ³JÂ7©�ª[ª�¤¨ªq¬+¸ ' Ë U�� Õi³[¬ °¨° ¤¨ª ¯ ¬G¼±¹G´�¼@È�¥w¬�¥»­;¤"¥|ûv¬¯ ¬%ª¨ª¨´|§'´� ´»¥®´¶¤Jª�´»¼ ���sÀ� � À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ #�H'A ' ß ' Ë U�� Õ X #�H'AãÞ ](HÔA�B;H#Z;*;51rsZ;H Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLHg>O6 Ë ï�Xæõ Õ X%# H'A � Ü '�3 ]±Hg03*�8-=?H/=#](HJE�>O6l Ò o���lpX2#�H'A � � � 3 ]±HãA4B;HMZ;*;57r@Z;HS]W0324H'C±>O51*LAe>O6\l Ò o���lpN�2TH/H Ë ï�Xpõ Õ X #�H'A��](HãA�B;H Ò ó%ؽ,/Z�E4KLHM>O6�A�B;H� Ê ];E[03*;,[Bi>O6yA�B;HEU��#2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8LX?# HJA ��Ò±Ó ' H �@A4E[03,'A�eX � B�032M03* ��� 2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8LN(03*;^ÐÞìÜ �,/>O*LA4E[03,'A42?RÔ~ � Ò�Ó É�� N�A�B;Hº57=_03:OHã>O6 ë572�00/�HG�".157*;HÔA�>UA�B;Hº,/Z�]�57,º,/Z�E4KLH � Ü É � 0GA Ë A�B;HÔ51=_03:OHM>O6A�B;H Õ � X Y B;Hº57*;^;Z;,/H/^Ð=_0GC��'�ÒWÓ É � 572�>3];A[0351*;H'^q]�8-]�.7>%bu51*;:_Z�C :<A451=?H/2e03.1>O*;: � >�KLH'E � X � Ü É �512SH'=g]±H/^;^;H/^q]s8-A�B;Hg6�Z;.1.�.751*;Hk0GEã2T8@2TA�H/= lÇï � læN±A�B�Z;2 ' ^;H'C±H/*;^;2Ô>O*;.V8�>O* Ë �<� � Õ X Y B;HU03Z�A�>O=<>3E4C�B;5124=:3E�>OZ�C">O6 � 03,'A�2RA4E[03*;245VA�57KLH'.78`>O* � 3 N�24> ' ^;HJC(H/*;^;2�>O*;.V8D>O* � X $v8 Ë ï�Xæõ Õ bvHP,k03*-A�0GQLHÔ6�>3E � H/57A4B;H'E0a,'Z;2TC�51^�03.�E[0GA�57>O*�03.�,/Z�E4KLH � N�>3E�0U*;>@^�03.�E[0GA�57>O*�03.�,/Z�E4KLH �mX �

Page 19: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � .10

(���� �¿���Í����� �Sª¨ª¨ùs«_¤ ' 3 ­�©�ªº¥ ° ´�µ�´|©3 ©GÂ}È�¤k§ ° ©G´¶³�¸¨ùs¼(¹L©G«?¤J¼W¥½©GÂ�È ° ¬�ù ¯ À � ¸ '�´�ªÔ¼(¬�¥ É��Ь ° 4 � ¥®­;¤J¼>'³[¬�¼W¥½©G´»¼;ªº©?ù@¼�´|ø/ù�¤ºÒ ð ú4³'ù ° µ3¤0, Þ À �Þ ­�©GªÔ¼(¬ ° «<©GÂy³ ° ¬%ª¨ª¨´�¼@È�ªãûå´�¥»­-¥»­�¤U¤��@³¨¤ ¯ ¥|´¶¬�¼±©GÂ�Â1¬�³Jùsªg¬+¸ �'�Ò�Ó ' ,©G¼±¹�«?¤[¤J¥®ª_¤��s©s³J¥®Â ·i¬�¼�¤_¤��@³[¤ ¯ ¥®´¶¬G¼±©G¿³Jù ° µ3¤ �T¬+¸g¥®­;¤a«g´�¼W´�«<©G¿¹s¤¨ª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© ° ´�ª/©G¥|´¶¬�¼ � ¬Gµ3¤ ° ¤[©�³¨­"ª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© °¯ ¬�´»¼�¥`¬I¸4'eÀ � ¸>' �ß É�� ¥®­;¤J¼ç¥®­;¤ ° ¤i´�ª�©hÒ ó ú4³Jù ° µO¤0, U ,-¬I¸ �' ,`ª¨ùW³¨­�¥®­�©G¥D¤��O¥ ° ©s³J¥®´»¼@È U ÈG´�µO¤¨ª¾©É�Ê�ú 2c§ ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼ ,Pûy´�¥®­ U ©¾ªk¤[³J¥|´¶¬�¼ ,a©G¼±¹ Þ �½´�¼ ³[©�ªk¤$' �ß 4 � � ¥»­�¤q¬�¼� ·Í«gù@ ¥|´ ¯ Â1¤ 2v§ ° ¤�À U ,U©3¼±¹¾¥®­;¤ª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ªº¬+¸ Þ © ° ¤U©�ªy¸k¬GÂ�Â1¬�û�ª��

Ë ð Õ � ¸ ' ß ' Ë � Ê Õ ß 4 � ¥®­;¤J¼ U ´�ªM¥®­;¤Pù@¼�´|ø'ùW¤ÔÒ ó ú4³Jù ° µ3¤g©G¼±¹?¥®­;¤ 2c§ ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼Ð´�ªãª¨«?¬%¬�¥»­;ÀË ó Õ � ¸ ' ß ' Ë � Ê ä � � Õ0,\¥®­;¤J¼ o��gä Þ ´�ª#Â1¬�ÈD¥w¤ ° «g´�¼±©3Â1, U ´�ª#¥®­;¤gÒ ó ú�³Jù ° µ3¤?¬�µ3¤ ° ¥®­;¤ � � ¯ ¬�´�¼W¥

û�­�´½³¨­D´�ªº¹3´�ª�²k¬�´»¼�¥�¸ ° ¬�« �Þ ÀË ï Õ � ¸ ' ß ' Ë ����Õaûy´�¥®­"ª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥®· Ë ó � ó 8 � ó � ó Õ0,R¥®­;¤J¼ Þ «_¤[¤J¥®ªg¥»­;¤ ¯(° ´�«?¤[¹�³'ù ° µ3¤?©G¼±¹ U ´�ª#¥®­;¤

ù@¼±¹�¤ °  ´�¼(¤�¹D³'ù ° µ3¤kÀË . Õ � ¸ ' ß ' Ë Þ �kÕ_¥»­�¤J¼ Þ «?¤[¤'¥»ª�¬�¼(¤�¬+¸<¥»­;¤ Ë ó ÕD§ ° ©G¼(³¨­;¤Jª5,P©G¼±¹ U ´�ª?¥»­�¤�¬ ¯�¯ ¬%ª¨´�¥+¤ � ¸ ° ¬�«ì¥®­;¤

³[¤J¼W¥ ° ©G ³Jù ° µ3¤ � ¤J¼±¹D¬I¸M¥»­�¤ � � ³¨­�©3´�¼±ÀË�� Õ � ¸ ' ß ' Ë U�� Õ � : - ; - õ � ¥®­;¤J¼ Þ «?¤[¤J¥®ªº¥»­;¤?¬ ¯�¯ ¬%ª¨´�¥+¤U¤'¼±¹"¬+¸g©3¼ � � � �q³¨­�©3´�¼ �w¥»­�´�ªU³¨­;©G´�¼

´�ªUù@¼�´|ø/ù�¤�¤��@³[¤ ¯ ¥uû�­�¤J¼ ;qß õ � ,ã©G¼±¹ U ´�ªU¥®­;¤D¬ ¯�¯ ¬%ª¨´�¥+¤`¤J¼(¹Ð¬+¸?©G¼ � � ³¨­�©G´»¼ ,ã¹G´ ÆS¤ ° ¤'¼�¥ ,e´�¼¥®­;¤g³�©�ª�¤ ;gß õ ,�¸ ° ¬�« ¥»­�¤ � � ³¨­�©G´»¼qû�­�´¶³J­ Þ «?¤[¤'¥»ª/À

(ù ° ¥®­;¤ ° «?¬ ° ¤0,e©�ª[ª¨ù@«?¤ ð �ëo �� � : ÀM£ ¤J¥ �ÝÒ�Ó �' §'Â1¬�û ù ¯ © ¯ ¬�´»¼�¥u¬+¸ Þ ¼(¬�¥e¬G¼Í©G¼W·_Ò ó ú4³'ù ° µ3¤kÀÁ ­;¤'¼ �Ý´�ª\¥®­;¤u«U´�¼�´�«<©3Â�¹�¤¨ª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�ª/©3¥®´¶¬G¼-¬+¸e© ° ©3¼ F ¬�¼(¤RÂ1¬[Èg¹�¤JÂ�*�¤�����¬ , ' 8 ûy´�¥®­<©GÂ}È�¤k§ ° ©G´¶³[©GÂ� ·MªJ´�« ¯  ·³[¬�¼W¼(¤[³J¥+¤�¹_ª¨«?¬�¬�¥®­"Â1¬�³Jùsª5,�©G¼±¹ o ���� ßÝo �� Ò ð À � ¸#ûv¤ ° ¤ ¯ ¤�©G¥c¥®­�´�ª ¯±° ¬�³[¤¨ª¨ª o �� Ò ð ¥|´�«?¤¨ª0,cûc¤_¬O§'¥w©G´�¼' Ë U�� Õ�À Á ­;¤?´�¼±¹GùW³[¤�¹"«<© ¯ �' Ë U�� Õ#Ò�Ó �' ´�ª`³[©G¼(¬�¼�´½³�©GÂ1,M³¨¬�¼�¥ ° ©�³J¥|´�¼@ÈЩG¥Ô¤�©�³¨­qªJ¥½©�Ès¤<¥®­;¤<ù@¼�´|ø'ùW¤aÒ ð ú³Jù ° µ3¤�À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Ì Habu51.1.�C;E4>%KLHUA�B�0GAÔA4B;H'E�H<HG�;512IA�2º0 Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLH3N Þ"N =?H/HJA�51*;:`A�B;H<2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457A�57H/2P032MC;E�H/24,JE�57]±H/^�XY B;HvÏ�*�03.@E�H/=_0GETQ�2�0GE4HvA�B;H/*g51=?=<H/^;590GA�H�69E�>O=�A4B;Hc2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8º^;H'24,'E�5VC;A�51>O*�NL03*;^U51=<C�.V8ãA�B;HcZ;*;51rsZ;H/*;H/242>O6�A�B;H Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLHã]s8 Ë ï�Xæõ Õ X � *;HP03.724>g,¨B;H',[Q@2uH/032451.V8_A�B�0GA\H ��ATE[03,'A�57*;:gA4B;HM57*;^;51,k0GA4H/^ Ò ó%ؽ,'Z�E4KLH�U :O5VKLH/2A�B;HME�H/r@Z;5VE�H/^ É Ê Ø|Ï;];E[0GA�57>O*�X�öSH/*;,'HP57Au512RH/*;>OZ;:OB-A4>aC;E�>�KLHÔA�B;HMH ��512TA�H'*;,/HP>O6�Þ"XÌ HM,k03*"03242TZ;=?HM]�8 Ë ï�Xpõ Õ A�B�0GAuo �� - ó@X�S>3A�Hu516 � Ü ' 572c03*�8 Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLH3N�A4B;H/* Ë o��eä �ºÕ �&� � Å#03*;^_A�BsZ;2 � 512v24=<>@>3A�B�Ns03*;^`24>g=?H/H'A�2¿0GA

=?>O2TA�>O*;HRHG�;,/H'C;A451>O*�03.�^;5VK�512T>3Ey>%KLH'EåHk03,[BU2451*;:OZ;.10GE�C(>O57*�AkN�03*;^gA�B;Hc,/>O*LA[03,'Aå512�*;>3E4=_03. Ë 2TH/H\6�>3E�HG��03=<C�.7HË õ�X7ðOð Õ4Õ X

#�H'A Ñ ~ �éÒ�Ó ' H ��A4E�03,'A\0 Ò ó%ؽ,/Z�E4KLHSbuB;51,[BD03,/,/>3E�^;57*;:#A�>ºA�B;HS2TA[0GA4H/=?H/*LAv>O6�A�B;HS.7H/=?=_0M512vA�>#B�0kKLH,/>O*LA[03,'AÔbe5VA�B�Þ"X<)+*�A�B;Ha,k0324H?>O6 ' Ë � Ê ä � � Õ .1HJA � ]±HaA�B;H Ò ó%ض,/Z�E4KLH_>O6¿A�B;H � Ê C(>O57*�A/N >3A�B;H'ETbe5724H,[B;>@>O24H�03*L8Í>O6RA4B;HDC±>O242457]�.7H`,/Z�E4KLH/2/NåA�B�0GAg512g>O* ' Ë Þ �kÕ H/5VA�B;H'EU>O6\A�B;H � Ê ];E[03*;,[B;H/2'N¿>O* ' Ë U�� Õ A�B;H>3C;C(>O2T57A�H`H/*;^h>O6RH/5VA�B;H'E � � ,[B�0351*�N¿03*;^�>O* ' Ë ����Õ H/57A�B;HJE<>O6\A�B;HD51*LA�H'E�57>3E Ò ó%ؽ,'Z�E4KLH/2 Ë 51*mA�B;H�>3A4B;H'E,k0324H'2��Ä512gZ;*;57r@Z;H Õ X +@Z�C;C(>O2THDÏ;E�2IAUA4B�0GA � B�032U0 É Ê Ø|Ï;];E[0GA�51>O*�X $v8 Ë ï�X . Õ A�B;512#572g>O*;.78�C±>O242457]�.7H`516

Page 20: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

),+ ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

' ß ' Ë U�� Õ X�)+*jA�B;512g,k0324HD>O*;HD,¨B;H',[Q@2aA�B�0GAUA�B;H_Ï;];E�HDA�B�E�>OZ;:OB�A4B;H�Þ � C±>O51*LA<>O6 � 512U0 Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLH=?H/HJA�51*;:ÐA�B;H-2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2<032UC;E�H/24,'E457](H'^ Ë 6�>3E<^;H'A�0351.12a24H/H Ë ðOðOX � X . ÕTÕ X +@>¾bcH-,/03*â032424Z;=?H � B�032?0]�57E�0GA�51>O*�03.å,/>O*LA4E[03,'A�57>O* RÔ~ � Ò�Ó ' Ê >O6R0 Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�E4KLHGNåÞ"X>�S2451*;: Ë ï�Xæï Õ 03*;^ÍA�B;H_.7512TAkN >O*;H_,¨B;H',[Q@2g51*Hk03,[B�,k032THÔA�B�0GAuÞ =?H'H'A�2\A�B;HP2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2e032\C;E�H/24,JE�57]±H/^�~)+6 ' ß ' Ë Þ �kÕ N � B�032Ô03* ��� 2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8LXE$v8 Ë ï�Xæï Õ 03*;^iA�B;HU2457=<C�.78",'>O*;*;H/,'A�H/^¾.1512IA ' Ê 512MH/57A4B;H'E

É � N�ÞÄÜ � ,'>O*�A[0357*;2eA�B;H ��� C(>O51*LAkN�03*;^"o���ä�ÞÄ512�.7>O:<A�H'E�=<51*�03.|N�>3E ' 8 ß ' Ë ����Õ 03*;^"ÞÄÜ �?3 Xc)+*A�B;H#24H',/>O*;^i,/0324HgÞ Ü ' B�032�A�B;HºC;E�H/24,JE�57]±H/^¾2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2/Xe)+*"A�B;H#Ï;E�2TAãH/5VA�B;H'ESA�B;H#2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2ã0GE�H032cE�H/rsZ;57E�H/^�N�>3ERÞ×=?H/H'A�2vA4B;HÔ>3C;C±>O2457A�HãH/*;^�>O6�A4B;H � � ,[B�0351*�X@$cZ�ARA4B;HÔ.10GA4A�H'E\572R57=<C(>O2T2457]�.7H3N�6�>3E\A�B;H/*Þ � ß ÅU>O* ' X)+6 ' ß ' Ë ����Õ X � B�032#2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A451H/2 � Ê ä � � X ��57A�B;HJEgÞ Ü � 3 Ny03*;^ ' Ê ß ' Ë � Ê ä � � Õ N�>3EgÞ

=?H/HJA�2Ô>O*;HUH/*;^�>O6�A�B;H � � ,[B�0351*�N�03*;^ ' Ê ß ' Ë � Ê Õ Xg)I*ÐA�B;HaÏ;E42TAP,/0324H3N H'57A�B;H'EÔA�B;HU2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2Ô0GE�H032uC;E4H/24,'E�5V](H/^�N�>3E�Þ Ü ' =?H/HJA�2�03*�H'*;^�>O6�A�B;H ��� ,[B�0351*�X%$cZ�AuA4B;HP.90GATA�H'E�572u57=<C(>O2T2457]�.7H3N�6�>3E�51*�A�B�0GA,k0324HÔÞ � ��ÅU>O* ' X)+6 ' ß ' Ë ����Õ N � B�032ã0_2457*;:O.1Hº2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8LN(03* � � C(>O57*�AkXeÞ �Ü � 3 N±69E4>O= A�B;H#.1572TAkN�24>`Þ Ü ' B�032

A�B;HMC;E�H/24,'E457](H'^�2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A451H/2/X)+*�A�B;H_,k0324H'2/N ' Ë U�� Õ N ' Ë U �JÕ N � B�032g0�2T51*;:O.1H<2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8LN�0�*;>O*@ض,'8�,/.751,_2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8LN 24>"]�8 Ë ï�Xæï Õ

Þ Ü � 3 NW03*;^�A�B;HÔ2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A451H/2u0GE�HÔ032uC;E�H/2T,'E�57]±H/^�X �(��(' J ���%�K K����%�y�-£ ¤J¥ � §¨¤<© ��¬ ° ¤J¼;ª¨¥+¤J´�¼�Â1¬�È�¹�¤'Â�*�¤����%¬<ª¨ù ° ¸k©�³[¤?¬+¸ ° ©G¼ F ¬G¼(¤0,\û�­�´¶³J­i³¨¬�¼�¥w©G´�¼;ª#¥|ûv¬¹G´�ªJ¥®´�¼�³J¥ ° ©G¥®´½¬�¼±©GÂ�³'ù ° µ3¤¨ª Þ Ê ©G¼±¹ Þ � ûy´�¥®­ o�� � Þ � ß Ò ð À Á ­�¤�¸k¬�Â�Â1¬Gûy´�¼@È<´»« ¯  ´¶³�©3¥®´¶¬G¼;ªã­;¬�Â7¹ �

Ë ð Õ � ¸ � ´�ªaª¨´�« ¯  ·¾³¨¬�¼�¼(¤[³'¥w¤�¹�¥»­;¤'¼ � ß ' Ë U�� Õ-,P¬�¼(¤-¬+¸a¥®­;¤ Þ � ´�ªD³[¬�¼�¥w©G´�¼(¤[¹�´�¼ � 3 ,Ô©G¼±¹q´�ª© ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼±©G¿³'ù ° µ3¤D¬+¸_© ° ´�¥®­�«?¤'¥®´¶³gÈ�¤J¼�ùsª_¬�¼(¤�À Þ Ê�� Þ � ´�ª?©-ªJ´�¼@ÈGÂ1¤UªJ«?¬�¬�¥®­ ¯ ¬�´»¼�¥ã¬I¸ � ,e¥®­;¤ù@¼�´|ø'ùW¤g§[©Gªk¤ ¯ ¬�´»¼�¥c¬+¸Ô¥»­;¤ºÂ ´�¼(¤�© ° ªk¤ ° ´¶¤¨ª l Ò o���l À

Ë ó Õ � ¸ o �� - . ,c¥®­;¤J¼ o �� ß . , � ß ' Ë ó � Ê ä � �kÕa©G¼±¹ Þ Ê ©3¼±¹ Þ � ¤�©�³J­ ¯ ©�ª¨ªÔ¥®­ ° ¬�ùLÈ�­i¬�¼(¤<¬+¸¥®­;¤ � Ê ¯ ¬�´»¼�¥»ª#©G¼±¹�¬ ¯L¯ ¬%ª¨´»¥w¤#¤J¼(¹�ª#¬+¸M¥®­;¤ � � ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥wÀ

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Ë ð Õ 572u57=?=?H/^;510GA�HS69E�>O= Ë ï�Xpõ Õ N Ë ï�X � Õ 03*;^ Ë ï�X1: Õ X�S>�b 24Z�C;C(>O2TH<o �� - .;X $c8 Ë ð Õ�� 572ã*;>3AP2457=<C�.78�,/>O*;*;H/,'A�H'^�N�03*;^¾2T>�69E�>O=ÄA�B;H Ë 6�Z;.7. Õ .1572TAkN ' ß

' Ë ó � Ê ä � ��Õ X�o��jäaÞ Ê äaÞ � 512�03*LA�5Vؽ03=<C�.1HGX )+*gCW0GETA�51,/Z;.10GE�Þ � 512�24=<>@>3A�B�X $c8º03^�FIZ;*;,'A�57>O*�NLA4B;H'8#=?H/HJA0GAc>O*;.V8_>O*;H�C(>O57*�AkN�03*;^D*;H'57A�B;H'ER,k03*`,/>O*LA[0357*�03.7.�A�B�E4H/Hã2451*;:OZ;.10GEcC(>O51*LA�2/X Y BsZ;2\Hk03,[BDÞ � =UZ;2IA\,/>O*�A�0351*H �;03,'A�.78DAwbc>_2457*;:OZ;.90GE�C±>O51*LA�2/N(03*;^�A4B;H'8�,k03*;*;>3AS]±>3A�B�](H � Ê N±6�>3Eã>3A�B;HJE4be5724HºÞ �� � Å�X Y BsZ;2SH/03,¨BqÞ �,/>O*LA[0351*;2c>O*;He>O6�A4B;H � Ê C(>O57*�A�2'N;03*;^_A�B;H'8<]±>3A�B_,/>O*LA[0351*_A�B;H � � C(>O51*LAkX Y B;HS^;H/24,'E�5V](H/^D,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA451>O*512ã*;>�b A�B;HU>O*;.78�C±>O242457]�57.15VA+8LN�032M>O*;Hg,[B;H/,�Q�2ÔA4B�0GAÔ>3A4B;H'E4bu5124Ha0369A�H'EÔH ��ATE[03,'A�57*;:�03*¾0GC;C;E�>3C;E�510GA�Hg,/Z�E4KLH>�KLH'E`A�B;H � � C(>O51*LAkNR](>3A�B B�0kKLHÐ*;>O*@Ø|C(>O245VA�57KLHq24H'.161ؽ57*�A4H'E�24H/,JA�51>O*�NS03*;^ë0GA`.1H/032TA`>O*;Hq512_,/>O*LA4E[03,'A457]�.1HGNK�57>O.90GA�57*;:#A�B;H ��51,k0GE�^�*sZ;=#]±H'EkX �

Page 21: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � )�.

(��®�s� J ���%��K K��W���y�-£ ¤'¥ '맨¤�© ° ©G¼ F ¬G¼(¤���¬ ° ¤J¼;ª¨¥+¤J´�¼?Â1¬�ÈU¹�¤JÂ�*e¤�����¬Sª¨ù ° ¸/©�³¨¤0, ûy´�¥®­<©GÂ}È�¤�§ ° ©G´½³�©GÂ� ·ãªJ´�« ¯  ·³[¬�¼W¼(¤[³J¥+¤�¹`ª¨«?¬�¬G¥»­qÂ1¬�³'ù�ª/À ' ´�ªgù@¼�´|ø'ùW¤J ·q¹�¤J¥+¤ ° «U´�¼(¤�¹�§'·-´�¥®ªPªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´»¥®´¶¤Jª �T©G¼±¹�¥®­�ù�ª<§/· o �� � ¤ �@³[¤ ¯ ¥´�¼q¥®­;¤a³�©�ªk¤g¬I¸ ' Ë U�� Õ �w¥»­�©3¥�´�ª o �� ßÝð � û�­;¤'¼q¥»­�¤ ° ¤#© ° ¤P¥|ûv¬ ¯ ¬%ª[ª¨´¶§'´� ´�¥|´¶¤¨ª5,�©�ªº¹s¤¨ªk³ ° ´|§¨¤�¹a´�¼ ���sÀ�� � À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Ì HPbe57.1.�buE457A�H ' Ë �PÕ Ë E4H/2TC ' Ë � Õ4Õ 6�>3E�A4B;H ' Ë U�� Õ >O6 Ë ï�Xpõ�Ø � Õ bu57A�B"0?,'Z;2TC�51^�03. =?H/=#](H'E Ë E�H/2IC�X*;>@^�03.�=?H'=g]±H'E Õ X' Ë � Ê Õ 512uZ;*;51r@Z;Hã]�8 Ë ï�X1: Õ XyíS2424Z;=?HUð �âo �� � :�X$v8aA4B;HeÏ�*�03.±E�H/=?0GE4Q�2�>O6 Ë ï�X : Õ A�B;H'E�Hã0GE�Hã0GA¿=?>O2TA�A+bv>gC±>O24245V]�51.15VA�51H'2¿6�>3E �' ~�+sA[0GE4Avbu57A�B_H'57A�B;H'E ' Ë �PÕ

>3E ' Ë � Õ 03*;^_,/>O*�ATE[03,'AvE�HJC(Hk0GA�H'^;.78UA�B;H�Z;*;51rsZ;H Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�ETKLH3N�o �� Ò ðuA�51=?H'2/X Ì Hebu51.7.W2TB;>%b�A�B�0GAåA�B;HeAwbc>C(>O2T2457]�57.157A451H/2R:O57KLHãA�B;HP2403=?HÔ2TZ�E�6�03,/H3X +sA[0GETAubu57A�B ' Ë �PÕ X � *;Hº>3];A�0351*;2 ' bu57A4B � Ü ' 3 N � ��l Ò o��ylpX#�H'A Ñ ~ É�Ê`Ò�Ó � ]±H?A�B;H_*;>3E�=_03.7512�0GA�57>O*�X�öS>O= Ë É�Ê �-'åÕ B�032#^;51=<H/*;2451>O*m0GAº.1Hk032TA .q0GA Ñ ]s8 Ë )4)¨X1ðOX ó Õ>O6Ôîæó3õGñ|Ny03*;^mA4BsZ;2g^;H/6�>3E�=<2ºA�>":O57KLH`0"^;>O=?57*�0GA�51*;:�6�03=<51.78i>O6cE[0GA�57>O*�03.¿,/Z�E4KLH'2/X4$c8 Ë )4)¨Xpï�X7ð�. Õ >O6Ôîæó3õGñA�B;Hº:OH'*;H'E[03. =<H/=#](H'EuB�032�>O*;.78�*;>@^;H'2/N(03*;^"24>_:O5VKLH/2�0a*;>@^�03. E�0GA�51>O*�03.�,/Z�E4KLH � �âl Ò o��ylæN � Ü ' 3 X� B;>@>O2457*;:-A�B;HaC±>O51*LA � N >O6¿A�B;HaÏ�*�03.åE�H'=_0GE4Q�2M51* Ë ï�X : Õ N�A�>-]±H Ë E�HJC(Hk0GA�H'^;.78 Õ � � Þ"N bvH?24H/H<bvH?,k03*03.12T><>3];A[0357* ' 2TA[0GETA�51*;:gbe5VA�B ' Ë � Õ X �

�����Ô� ��� 0 �����ã32 ���$1�% �G���@þ/�(���%������ÿ3�%�»���¿�íS2S51*;^;57,k0GA�H/^q57*qA4B;HU57*�ATE�>@^;Z;,'A451>O*�N�0?QLH'8�A4>@>O. 57*"A�B;HºC;E�>@>O6å>O6 Ë ðOX1ð Õ 512 *M>O.1.��0GE/{æ2e]�Z;:GضH'8LH/^¾,'>%KLH'E/X

,W>3E_0ÐE�03*�Q�>O*;H�.1>O:�^;H/. ��H����'> ' N¿A4B;512<572?0ÐZ;*;57KLH'E�2403.eB;>O=?H/>O=<>3E4C�B;5124= �@~ '�_Ò±Ó ' N¿bu57A�B '� 0*;>O*@ؽ2T51*;:OZ;.90GE Ë ]�Z�Aº576 ' 512P2T51*;:OZ;.90GE/N *;>O*@ؽ2TH'CW0GE[0GA�H/^ Õ 03.1:OH'];E[0357,<2TCW03,'H3X?)+*;6�>3E�=_03.1.V8LN '� 03.1.7>%bu2PZ;2MA�>^;>_^;H/6�>3E�=?0GA�51>O*DA�B;H/>3E48->O* ' N ©�ªP´Ç¸ 'Ýûv¤ ° ¤ÔªJ«?¬�¬�¥®­ X\zq>3E�HPC;E�H/,'5124H/.V8LN�bcHPB�0�KLH#0a:O>@>@^-^;H/6�>3E�=_0GA�57>O*A�B;H/>3ET8�6�>3Ee0g=_0GC Ñ ~ � Ò�Ó ' Ë 69E4>O= 0#C;E�>3C±H'E�24=<>@>3A�B`,/Z�E4KLH Õ C;E�>�K�57^;H/^ Ñ 6�03,'A�>3E�2\A�B�E�>OZ;:OB �JX�öSHJE�H>OZ�E?=?0351*�:O>L03.\572aA�>¾C;E4H/24H/*LA_,'E�5VA�H'E�510¾6�>3E<A4B;H�H �;572TA�H/*;,'H�>O6�24Z;,[B 0¾.75169A�57*;:;X Ì H�bu51.7.u,'>O*;2451^;H'E<A�B;Hr@Z;H'2TA�51>O*�>O6�B;>�béA�><^;H/6�>3E4= Ñ 51* � � 03*;^ � õ�XÌ Hg*;>3A�Hg0GAãA�B;Hg>OZ�A�24HJASA�B�0GAÔ03.1.�>O6yA�B;Hg51=<C±>3E4A[03*LAS51^;H/032M57*"A�B;512ã24H/,JA�51>O*i0GE�Hg^;Z;HUA4>�*M>O.1.��0GEkN�03*;^

=?>O2TA�>O6�A4B;H�2TA[0GA�H'=?H/*LA�2å]±H/.1>�b�,k03*<]±He6�>OZ;*;^_51=aC�.151,'57A�.V8#>3E¿HG��C�.157,/57A4.78U51*�îæó3ïGñ¶X Ì HuC;E�H/2TH/*�A¿A�B;H/= B;H'E�HE[0GA�B;HJEPA�B�03*ÍrsZ;>3A�H)*M>O.1.��0GEº^;5VE�H/,'A�.V8LN 032Ô57AÔbe57.1.�](Ha,/>O*�KLH'*;51H/*LA#A�>-B�0kKLH<A�B;H'= 57*Í0-24.751:OBLA�.78Ð^;57è±H'E�H/*LA6�>3E�=�X � Z�EU>O*;.V8�>3E�57:O51*�03.å,/>O*�ATE�57]�Z�A�57>O*ÍA�>"A�B;H_:OH/*;H'E[03.åA�B;H/>3E48�512PA�B;H_Z;*;57r@Z;H/*;H'242a>O6cA�B;H?]�Z;:GضH'8LH/^,/>�KLH'ES>O6å0<KG0GE�51H'Aw8Dbe5VA�B"512T>O.90GA�H/^-r@Z;>3A�57H/*�A�2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2/N Ë .;X . Õ X Y B;512�572�2TA[0GA4H/^q51*jîæó3ïGñ|NW]�Z�Aebe5VA�B;>OZ�AC;E�>s>O6½XY B;H\E4Hk03^;H'EåbeB;>M512�6�03=?57.1510GE�be5VA�B0*Ô>O.7.��0GEk{}2�,/>O*;2TA4E�Z;,JA�51>O*�Ns03*;^Ubu51.7.157*;:ãA4>ãA�0GQLHRZ;*;57r@Z;H/*;H'242�>O*U6�0357A4B�N

,k03*�2IQ�57C-^;57E�H','A�.78`A�> Ë .;X � Õ X� *;HÐC±>O51*LA�>O6Ô*;>3A[0GA�57>O*�~�>3EDZ;2-0j,/Z�E4KLHÐ512D032424Z;=?H'^ëA�>Í](Hi0m24H'CW0GE[0GA�H'^tK30GE451H'Aw8LX �uH/,k03.7.�A�B�0GA

H'KLH'ET8@A�B;57*;:<51*DA�B;512RCW0GC(H'ERA[0GQLH/2RC�.903,/HM>�KLH'ES÷vXÌ Hã](H/:O57*-]�8DE4H/,k03.1.751*;:)*Ô>O.7.��0GEk{}2R^;HJÏ�*;57A�57>O*�~

Page 22: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

) ) ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

��1�-7�� 9y�����%�»���¿� # H'A Ñ ~ T Ò±Ó ¦ ](H#0a=_0GC-]±H'AwbcH/H/*Ð03.1:OHJ];E[0351,M2TCW03,/H/2'X #�H'APÙ�Ü T ](HÔA4B;Hº.1>s,/Z;2buB;H'E�H Ñ 512 �HJA[03.1H3XuíS2424Z;=?HUÙ 512�2TH'CW0GE[0GA�H/^�X Y B;H ü�� ý

����±�@�tÿO���W�@����þ㦠�W¡k¡/��ÿ����;����� ��� Ñ 572�A�B;H

03.1:OHJ];E[0351,g2TCW03,/H T ��� � Ò�Ó ¦ N(beB;HJE�H�� � 512SA�B;HgH/r@Z;5VK303.7H/*;,/HgE�H/.10GA�51>O*�� � ß Ë Ù��f Ù á !���Õ 6 ! uX#�H'A � ß Ù��/X� À A D ¤J«?© ° F À )+*;6�>3E�=?03.1.78LN T ��� � Ò�Ó ¦ 512a>3];A[0351*;H'^h69E�>O= T Ò±Ó ¦ ]s8�:O.1Z;57*;:iA�>O:OHJA�B;H'E?57*�KLHJE�24H51=?03:OHDC±>O51*LA�2<buB;H'E�H Ñ 572 �H'A[03.7H3Xâ)+*hCW0GE4A�51,'Z;.90GEkNv576 Ñ 512 �H'A[03.1H-0GA?H'KLHJE48h57*�KLH'E424H�51=?03:OH�>O6�� NvA�B;H/*T ��� � Ò�Ó ¦ 512c03*`512T>O=?>3E4C�B;512T= >�KLH'E\0º*;H/57:OB�]±>OZ�E�B;>@>s^`>O6 � X�)wAv512\0M]�57Ac24Z�ETC;E�512457*;:#A�>#Z;2vA�B�0GAv2TZ;,¨B0a2T51=<C�.7HÔ57^;Hk0UA�Z�E4*;2e>OZ�ARA�>a]±HÔ24><Z;24H/6�Z;.|X��65 �¿���Í�����-£ ¤'¥ �v~ T 8 Ò�Ó T §J¤D©�ªk¤ ¯ © ° ©G¥+¤�¹¤'¥½©GÂ1¤<ª¨ù ° ²k¤[³'¥®´¶¬G¼ ,�ûy­�´¶³¨­¾´�ª`¬�¼�¤?¥+¬i¬G¼(¤�¬G¼â³JÂ1¬%ª�¤�¹¯ ¬�´»¼�¥»ªg¬�µ3¤ ° �-À Á ­;¤'¼

Ë ð Õ � ��� � ß � � � �� Ë T 8 � T 8 Õ-,Ë ó Õ¾¥®­;¤Ô´�¼±¹3ù�³[¤[¹<«<© ¯ T 8 ��� ��� �

Ò�Ó T ��� ´�ªº©G¼Ð´�ªk¬�«?¬ °½¯ ­�´�ªJ« ,v©G¼±¹Ë ï Õ¾´Ç¸¿¸¨ù ° ¥®­;¤ ° Ñ ´�ªU©3¼¾´�ªk¬�«?¬ °½¯ ­�´�ªJ« ¬�¼ Ù ©G¼±¹ Ñ ´�ªa§'´ ²k¤[³J¥|´�µ3¤g¬G¼j³'Â1¬%ªk¤�¹ ¯ ¬�´»¼�¥»ª0,v¥®­;¤J¼ TÖÒ±Ó ¦

´�ªM¥®­;¤#§/ùOÈGú�¤J·L¤[¹�³[¬�µO¤ ° ©�ª¨ªk¬�³J´|©3¥w¤�¹U¥+¬ Ñ�� � ,�T 8 ��� ��� � À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ #�H'A��â57*;^;51,k0GA�H\0�^;572»FI>O51*LAyZ;*;51>O*g57*�A�>S>3C±H/*U03*;^g,/.1>O24H'^U2TZ�]�24H'A�2/X �S>3A�HRÙ 8 ß � � Ê Ë Ù Õ Ë Ù 8 � � 8 ÜT 8 0GE�Hã^;H'Ï�*;H'^�bu57A�B_E�H/2IC(H/,'A\A�> Ñ�� �<51*_A�B;Hã>3]sK@51>OZ;2vb\0k8 Õ X +@57*;,/H �_572c24H'CW0GE[0GA�H'^-03*;^ �H'A[03.7H3N@A�B;H'E4HM5720º^;H/,/>O=aC(>O245VA�51>O* T 8 � T 8 ß � � ! �wX�$v8?032T24Z;=<C;A�57>O* � 8 � � 8 Ü ! �wN@03*;^`24><Ù 8 � Ù 8 ß � � !�� �wXY BsZ;2RbcHPB�0kKLH

� � � �� Ë T 8 � T 8 Õ ß Ë Ù 8 �f Ù 8 á Ù 8 � Ù 8 Õ � T 8 � T 8

ß Ë Ù 8 �f Ù 8 á !�� � Õ � ! �(ß��� � �

öSH/*;,/H Ë ð Õ X@+@51*;,'H �`512u03* �H'A�03.1Hã24Z�E®FIH/,JA�51>O*�N Ë ó Õ 6�>O.1.1>�bu2/X�S>3A�HcA�B�0GAåbeB;H'* Ñ 572¿03*?5724>O=?>3E4C�B;5724= >O*DÙé03*;^ Ñ 512y]�5 FIH/,'A457KLHe>O*a,/.1>O2TH/^<C(>O57*�A42/N�� � ß ! eX Y B;572

:O57KLH'2 Ë ï Õ X ��S>�bhbcH\A�Z�E�*aA4>ÔZ;*;57r@Z;H/*;H/2T2/X Ì H\Ï;E42TA¿,'>O*;2451^;H'E�beB�0GAåB�0GC;C±H/*;2¿.7>@,k03.7.78LX �S>3A4H\A4B�0GAåbuB;H/* ¦ 512�Awbc>

^;51=<H/*;2451>O*�03.®N(A�B;Hg,k0324H#A�B�0GAM=?>O2TAã57*�A4H'E�H/2TA42MZ;2'N�A4B;Ha.7>@,k03. 03*�03.78@A451,ºC(>O2T2457]�57.157A451H/2ã6�>3E Ñ 0GE�Hg,/.903242T57Ï�H/^51*�î � ñ|X��)( �¿���Í������£ ¤J¥ Ë ¦�� � Õ_§¨¤_© ¯ ¬�´�¼W¥w¤�¹�¼(¬ ° «?©GÂåµG© ° ´¶¤J¥|·i¬+¸?¹G´»«?¤J¼;ª¨´½¬�¼ � - ó À�£ ¤J¥ Ñ ~ Ë �����ãÕPÒ�ÓË ¦�� � Õ�§J¤�©Íø/ù;©�ªJ´�ú 2å¼�´»¥w¤?ª¨ù ° ²k¤[³'¥®´¶¬G¼�¸ ° ¬�« ©qª¨«?¬�¬G¥»­�©GÂ}Ès¤k§ ° ©3´¶³_ª ¯ ©�³[¤-,Mûy´�¥®­�� ß Ñ � Ê Ë � Õ �T©�ª?ªk¤J¥®ª � ,¤J¥w©GÂ1¤g©3û¿©G·e¸ ° ¬G«��aÀR£ ¤'¥ � §¨¤P¥»­;¤PÂ1¬�³�©GÂO¸Jùs¼±¹�©G«?¤J¼�¥w©GÂ�È ° ¬�ù ¯ ¬+¸u¦ ©G¥ Î À

Ë ð Õ � ¸ � ´�ªº©<ª�¤ ¯ © ° ©G¥w¤[¹aµG© ° ´½¤J¥®· ,�¥®­;¤J¼qÂ1¬%³�©GÂ� ·�©G¼±©3 ·�¥|´¶³�©GÂ� ·�© ° ¬�ù@¼±¹ � ©G¼±¹�� ,

Ñ ~ � á"��� � Ò�Ó ¦Úá"� � �

Page 23: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � )0�

´�ªM¥®­;¤Ôù@¼�´�µO¤ ° ª/©3Â�³[¬�µ3¤ ° ÀË ó Õ Á ­;¤Ð¤��O¥+¤J¼;ª¨´¶¬G¼t¬+¸��#¤J¼;ª¨´� ´�ª/©G¥|´¶¬�¼;ª 6��f�� � Ü 6����� � ´�¼(¹Gù�³¨¤¨ª-©��e©3Â1¬�´�ª�¤��O¥+¤J¼;ªJ´¶¬�¼t¬+¸-ø'ùW¬�¥|´¶¤J¼�¥

2c¤JÂ7¹Gª5,�ûy´�¥®­?È ° ¬�ù ¯ � ,\©G¼±¹ 6��f� � ß Ë76���� � Õ���À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ �uH'C�.903,'51*;: � ]�8Í03* �H'A[03.7H?,/>�KLH'E#be5VA�Bm0�2457*;:O.1H?C(>O57*�Aº.78�57*;:">%KLHJE � N Ë buB;51,[Bm^;>@H/24*�{òA#H'è±H/,'A6 ��� � Õ bcHg=_0k8"03242TZ;=?H � 512ã03*i0'!?*;H#KG0GE�51H'Aw8LX #�>@,k03.7.78q03*�03.V8@A�57,k03.1.V8 Ñ ~ � á���� � Ò�Ó ¦×á�� � �a5720?,/>�KLH'EkN�03*;^q2457*;,/H � á ��� �g512S2457=<C�.78�,/>O*;*;H/,JA�H/^ Ë .1>s,k03.1.V8�03*�03.V8@A�57,k03.1.V8 Õ N�57A�512�A�B;H#Z;*;5VKLH'E�2�03.�,'>%KLH'E/XöSH/*;,/H Ë ð Õ X Y B;H#03*�03.7>O:O>OZ;2e2TA�0GA�H/=?H/*LA�A�> Ë ó Õ NW6�>3Eã03*�03.78sA�51,Ô.1>@,/03.�E�57*;:O2�6�>O.1.7>%bu2/X Ë ó Õ *;>%b�6�>O.1.7>%bu2e]�8Ë .;X7ðOð Õ >O6vî}ïGñ|X ���� NÔ�%���å��¡k���%���±����£ ¤J¥¿¦ §¨¤_©-¼�¬ ° «<©3ÂåµG© ° ´¶¤J¥|·�ûå´�¥»­i´�ªk¬�Â7©G¥+¤�¹qø/ù�¬�¥|´¶¤J¼W¥Rª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ªkÀ Á ­;¤J¼m¥®­;¤ ° ¤´�ª?©�ùs¼�´¶ø'ù�¤aª¨«?¬�¬�¥®­Í©3Â}È�¤k§ ° ©G´¶³gª ¯ ©s³[¤ Ñ ~ � Ò�Ó ¦ ª¨ùW³¨­Ð¥®­�©G¥ Ñ ´�ª<©G¼�´�ªk¬�«_¬ °¶¯ ­s´�ª¨«ì¬�µ3¤ ° ¦ 3 ,ã©3¼±¹¬�¼(¤M¥+¬`¬�¼�¤#¬�¼�³JÂ1¬%ª�¤�¹ ¯ ¬�´�¼W¥»ª/À Á ­;¤Ô«<© ¯ ¬+¸ �#¤J¼;ª¨´� ´�ª/©G¥|´¶¬�¼;ªS´�ªP¹�¤Jªk³ ° ´¶§¨¤�¹<§'· � � À �sÀCB � À Ñ ´�ªP©aùs¼W´�µ3¤ ° ª/©G­;¬�«_¤[¬�«?¬ °½¯ ­�´�ªJ«<À � ¼ ¯ © ° ¥®´½³JùsÂ7© ° ,¿ûy­;¤J¼_¦ ´�ª#³[¬�« ¯ Â1¤J¥w¤-, � ´�ªMù@¼�´�µ3¤ ° ª/©GÂ� ·-³JÂ1¬�ªk¤�¹LÀ

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ $v8D^;H'Ï�*;5VA�51>O*-A4B;H'E�HP572�0U24Z�E®FIH/,'A451>O* T Ò�Ó ¦ N �H'A�03.1HM>OZ�A�2451^;HMA�B;HP2T51*;:OZ;.90GEe.1>s,/Z;2/N;beB;HJE�H T 5720#24=?>s>3A�B_K30GE�57H'Aw8LX2$v8_^�E�>3C;C�51*;:gC(>O57*�A42R>O6 T bcHã,k03*�032424Z;=?HSA�B;Hã=_0GCD512c>O*;HSA�>g>O*;Hã>O*`C(>O51*LA�2\>�KLH'EA�B;HÔ2451*;:OZ;.10GEe.7>@,/Z;2/X�,W>3EuA�B;HMH ��512TA�H'*;,/HP>O6 � bcHMA[0GQLHSA�B;Hº032T24>@,/510GA�H/^D]�Z;:GؽH'8LH/^",'>%KLH'E/X�S*;51rsZ;H/*;H/242M,k03*Ð](HU,¨B;H',[QLH'^mô�0GE�512TQ@5�.1>s,k03.1.V8">O* ¦ X Y B�Z;2P6�>3EMA�B;H#E�H/2TAÔ>O6�A4B;HUC;E�>s>O6åbvHUbc>3ETQq51*

A�B;Ha,k0GA�H/:O>3E48q>O6åC(>O57*�A�H'^�2TCW03,/H/2'X +@Z�C;C(>O2TH Ñ � ~ Ë � � ��� � ÕPÒ�Ó Ë ¦�� � Õ N �Rß×ð � ó@N 0GE4HUAwbc>�,k03*;^;51^�0GA�H'2/X$v8 Ë .;X ó Õ A�B;HJE�Ha572P0D24=?>s>3A�BÐ0'!?*;HaKG0GE�57H'Aw8 Ë �����ãÕ 03*;^�0DCW035VEP>O6 �H'A[03.7Ha24Z�E»FIH/,'A�57>O*;2RÎ � ~ Ë �����ãÕMÒ�ÓË � � ��� � Õ X ãE4>3C;C�51*;:?,/.7>O24H/^�C±>O51*LA�2/N;bcHº,k03*�032424Z;=?H � ß�Î � Ê� Ë � � Õ X +@57*;,/H ¦ 572u2TH'CW0GE[0GA�H/^�N Ñ Ê � Î Ê ßÑ � � Î � X $v8 Ë .;X ó@Xæï Õ N � � ß � ��� � � � 4X

+@51*;,'H Ñ 512M0_24H'Aã]�5ÇFIH/,'A�57>O*�N�A4>�24B;>�b 5VAÔ572M0`Z;*;5VKLH'E�2�03.�B;>O=<H/>O=?>3E4C�B;5724=�N(5VAã512ãH/*;>OZ;:OBiA4>D2TB;>%b 5VA512RZ;*;57KLHJE�2�03.1.V8D>3C(H/*�X Y B;572e512e0a.7>@,k03."�H'A[03.7Hãr@Z;H/2TA451>O*�>O* � 03*;^ ¦ N�A�B�Z;2ebcHME�H/^;Z;,/HÔA�>aA�B;HM,k0324HÔ>O6�0r@Z;>3A451H/*LAe]�8"0aÏ�*;5VA�Hº:3E�>OZ�C�N�buB;H'E�HºA�B;HME�H/24Z;.VAS512RQ�*;>�be*�X\íS.7A4H'E�*�0GA�5VKLH/.78LN�>O*;HP,/03*q0GC;C�.78 � B;H'KG03.1.7H'8({}2,'E�5VA�H'E�57>O*�N�24H/H Ë ð � X . Õ >O6cîÛð�ïGñ¶X ��� � 7�� 9y�����%�»���¿� Ì HPbu51.7.�^;H'*;>3A�HÔA�B;HPZ;*;51r@Z;H � >O6 Ë .;X . Õ ]s8 �R~ ¦ ¿Ò�Ó ¦ N�03*;^�E�H/6�H'E�A4>?57Ae032 �%� �ü�� ý����±�@� ÿL�@���s�_��þ ¦ X

Ì Hãbe57.1.(]±HÔC;E�57*;,/57CW03.7.78D51*LA�H'E�H'2TA�H/^�57*�A�B;HM]�Z;:GؽH'8LH'^�,/>�KLH'E�>O6�0U.1>O:U^;H/.���H����/>?2TZ�E�6�03,/H3N ' X�SH �@ARbvHÔA�Z�E�*DA�><.75169A�57*;:<,'E457A�H'E4590�X

���� �����Í������£ ¤'¥ � ~ � 8 Ò�Ó �ħ¨¤P©Uª¨ù ° ²�¤[³J¥|´�µ3¤eÈ�¤J¼(¤ ° ´¶³ã´�ªk¬G«?¬ °¶¯ ­�´�ª¨«t¸ ° ¬�« ©a¼(¬�¼�úwª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ¬�¼�¤º¹G´�ú«?¤J¼�ª¨´¶¬�¼±©3Â�©3Â}È�¤k§ ° ©G´¶³cª ¯ ©�³¨¤R¥w¬º©Mª¨«_¬�¬�¥®­?³Jù ° µ3¤kÀ ¬ ° ¤�©�³J­�� � � 8 ª¨ù�³J­g¥»­�©3¥ � ´�ªc¼(¬�¥y©G¼_´�ªk¬�«_¬ °¶¯ ­s´�ª¨«¬�µ3¤ ° Î��mß � Ë �#Õ0,�Â1¤J¥ =�� §¨¤S¥®­;¤ ° ©G«g´ 2\³�©G¥|´¶¬�¼D´»¼±¹�¤��sÀ Á ­;¤J¼-´�¼�¥®­;¤S¼(¬�¥w©G¥|´¶¬�¼Ð¬+¸ � B � �5, � 8 ß � � =�� � Î�� � À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ #�H'APÞìß � � =�� � Î�� �LX Y B;H'E�H<572P03*i>3]sK@51>OZ;2Ô24H'AM]�5 FIH/,'A451>O*¾]±H'AwbcH/H/*�Þ 03*;^ � 8 03*;^�>O*;Ha,k03*

Page 24: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

) � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

,[B;H/,�Q".1>s,k03.1.V8`A�B�0GAeA�B;572�512e03*"5124>O=<>3E4C�B;5124=-X Y B�Z;2S>O*;Hº,k03*"^�E4>3C"C(>O51*LA�2�69E4>O= Ï;];E�H/2'N�03*;^q032424Z;=?H �512u0a2TH'Ae]�5ÇFIH/,'A�57>O*�Xå)+*-A�B;572u,/0324HÔA�B;HME�H/24Z;.VAe6�>O.7.1>�be2R69E�>O= Ë .;X ó@Xæï Õ 0G](>�KLH3NW03*;^ Ë .;Xæï Õ >O6vîæó3ïGñ|X �Ì HM*;>%bçC;E�H'24H/*LA?*M>O.1.��0GE/{æ2\]W032451,Ô.15169A451*;:U,'E�57A4H'E�51>O*�51*"0U,/>O*LKLH/*;51H/*LA�57*�ATE�51*;2457,P6�>3E�=-~

���� �¿���Í������£ ¤J¥ � ~ � 8�Ò�Ó � §¨¤Ô©�ª�´�¼ � � À� � Àc£ ¤J¥ Ñ ~�Þ Ò�Ó � §¨¤Ô© 2�¼�´�¥+¤�«<© ¯ ,yûy´�¥®­ Þ ©ºªJ«?¬�¬�¥®­³Jù ° µ3¤�À Á ­;¤J¼ Ñ ¸/©�³J¥+¬ ° ªu¥®­ ° ¬�ùLÈ�­ � ´ÇÆ륮­;¤ ¸�¬�Â�Â1¬�ûy´�¼�ÈP­;¬�Â7¹Gª���¸k¬ ° ¤�©�³¨­ ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥�� ��Þ ,�¥»­;¤ ° ¤e´�ªS©G¼�´�¼�µ3¤ ° ªk¤´�«<©%È�¤ ¯ ¬G´�¼�¥ � � � � Ê Ë Ñ Ë �;ÕTÕÔª¨ùW³¨­-¥»­�©3¥c¥»­;¤ ° ©G«U´ 2c³�©G¥|´¶¬�¼i´�¼±¹�¤ � = � Ë � ÕU¹3´�µ�´|¹�¤JªM¥»­�¤ ° ©G«g´ 2c³[©G¥®´½¬�¼q´�¼±¹s¤��= � Ë �;Õ�À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ )+=?=<H/^;590GA�Hã69E�>O= Ë .;Xæõ Õ N�03*;^ Ë .;Xpó@X ó Õ >O6vîæó3ïGñ¶X ����� �¿�@�Í������£ ¤J¥'� 8 §¨¤<©Dª¨«_¬�¬�¥®­�¬�¼(¤<¹G´�«?¤'¼;ª¨´¶¬�¼(©G �½¼(¬�¥\¼�¤[³[¤¨ª[ªk© ° ´� ·`ªk¤ ¯ © ° ©G¥+¤�¹ � ©GÂ}È�¤k§ ° ©G´¶³ºª ¯ ©s³[¤kÀ£ ¤'¥ � §¨¤g© ¯±° ¬ ¯ ¤ ° ª¨«?¬�¬�¥®­"³Jù ° µO¤0,\©G¼(¹<Â1¤J¥ � ~ � 8 Ò�Ó � §¨¤g©UÈ�¤J¼�¤ ° ´¶³[©GÂ� ·?´�ªk¬�«?¬ °¶¯ ­�´½³ãª¨ù ° ²k¤[³J¥|´¶¬�¼(À

� ¸ o # � ­;©�ª`¼(¤½ÈL©3¥®´�µO¤�¹�¤½È ° ¤[¤D¥»­�¤J¼ � ß É�ÊÍ©G¼±¹�¥»­;¤ ° ¤"¤��O´�ª¨¥»ª-©3¼ ¤J¼±¹�¬G«?¬ °¶¯ ­�´�ª¨« Ñ ¬+¸ � û�­s´¶³¨­¸/©�³'¥w¬ ° ªM¥®­ ° ¬�ùLÈ�­ � À

� ¸W¸¨ù ° ¥®­;¤ ° � ´�ª\©�ªk¤'¥�§/´Ç²k¤[³J¥|´¶¬�¼ ,(¥®­;¤J¼a¥»­;¤e³[¬�¼Wµ3¤ ° ª�¤�­;¬�Â7¹Gª/À � ¸!� ß É Ê ©G¼(¹S¥®­;¤ ° ¤¿´�ªR©G¼_¤'¼±¹�¬�«?¬ °¶¯ ­�´�ª¨«Ñ ¸/©�³'¥w¬ ° ´�¼@È<¥®­ ° ¬�ùOÈG­ � ,v¥»­�¤J¼ o # � ­�©�ªM¼�¤½ÈL©G¥|´�µ3¤#¹s¤½È ° ¤¨¤kÀ* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ $v8 Ë .;Xpõ Õ N � 8 ß ��� = � � Î � �LX?o # �vB�032º^;H':3E�H/H Ò óãä � � � Ê� ]s8iA�B;H<öSZ�ETbe5VA �<6�>3E�=gZ;.10�X �S>%b0GC;C�.78 Ë .;X .;X ó Õ 03*;^ Ë õ�X � Õ >O6\îæó3ïGñ Ë *;>3A�HMA4B;HÔE�H/=?0GE4Q`0GARA�B;HPH/*;^->O6 A�B;HMC;E�>@>O6 >O6 Ë õ�X � ÕTÕ X �� À�� D ¤J«?© ° F ªkÀ

Ë ð Õ �S>3A[0GA451>O*g032y51* Ë .;X1: Õ X Ì H\*;>3A�HcA�B�0GA�]�8 Ë .;Xpõ Õ 0G](>�KLH3N Ë .;X .;Xpó Õ 03*;^ Ë õ�X � Õ >O6 îæó3ïGñ�A4B;H'E�H\512y03.Vb\0�8@20?rsZ�03245VØ|Ï�*;57A�Hg24Z�E®FIH','A�51>O*���~�Þ Ò±Ó � 8 be5VA�B"Þ 0_C;E4>3C(H'EM24=?>s>3A�B�,/Z�ETKLH3N�03*;^ÐA4B;H#^;H/:3E�H/Hg>O60U.151*;Hã]�Z;*;^;.1H �>O* � 8 ,k03*-]±HP^;H'Ï�*;H'^ Ë 032e0gE[0GA�57>O*�03.�*sZ;=#](HJE Õ 032R^;H/: Ë � " Ë Õ4Õ ��^;H/: Ë � Õ X

Ë ó Õ � 6\,/>OZ�E�24H_57* Ë .;X � Õ A�B;H?,/>O*;^;5VA�51>O*Í>O* Ñ Ë ��Õ B;>O.7^;2º516cA�B;H'E4H?512#0-C±>O51*LA#>�KLH'E Ñ Ë ��Õ buB;H'E�H � 572�H'A�03.1H3X Y B�Z;2e>O*;HÔ>O*;.78`*;H/H'^;2eA�><,'>O*;2451^;H'EuC(>O57*�A�2R51* � >�KLH'EubeB;57,¨B � 572 ¼(¬<û�­�¤ ° ¤ ¤'¥½©GÂ1¤ X

Ë ï Õ Ë .;X � Õ 57=<C�.157H/2P57*�CW0GE4A�57,/Z;.90GEÔA�B�0GAº576 � ß É�Ê 03*;^�A�B;H'E4H`0GE�H_0GAº=<>O2TAÔAwbc>�C±>O51*LA�2º57* � >�KLH'EbuB;51,[B � 512R*;><buB;H'E�H �H'A[03.1HGN�A�B;H/*-A�B;HJE�HP572e03*�H'*;^;>O=?>3E4C�B;512T= Ñ >O6 � 6�03,'A�>3E�57*;:aA�B�E4>OZ;:OB � X

Ë . Õ )+*#A�B;HvÏ�*�03.sCW0GE�03:3E[0GC�Bg>O6 Ë .;X : Õ N%beB;H/* � ß É�Ê N3>O*;Hc,k03*gH ��C;E4H/242�A�B;Hc*;H/,/H'242�0GE48U03*;^g24Z"!<,/51H/*LA,/>O*;^;5VA�51>O*_6�>3EcA4B;HMHG�;512IA�H/*;,/HS>O6�0º.15769A�51*;:#H'*;^;>O=?>3E4C�B;512T=à032/~ Y B;HJE�HM0GE�Hã0GAc=?>O2TA�A�B�E�H/HSC±>O51*LA�257* � 8 beB;H'E4HãA4B;HM=?0GC�572\*;>3A �HJA[03.1Hã03*;^�516 = Ê N = � N = � 0GE�H�A�B;HãE[03=?57Ï�,/0GA�51>O*_57*;^;51,/H/2 Ë buB;51,[B�0GE�H03.7.1>�bcH/^"A�>_](Hg>O*;H Õ N(A4B;H/*ÐA4B;H'E�HgH �;572TA�2ã0`.15769A�51*;:_H/*;^;>O=<>3E4C�B;5124=Ä5VèjóDà � � � Ê� X ,�>3ESA4B�E�H/HE[03=<57Ï�,k0GA�57>O*_C(>O51*LA�2/N�A4B;HMC±>O242457]�.7H Ë = Ê � = � � = �kÕ 0GE�HSA�B;HM24>U,k03.1.7H/^ *cÂ7©3¥w¬�¼W´¶³M¥ ° ´ ¯ Â1¤¨ª N;Z�]�57r@Z;5VA�>OZ;257*�A�B;HÔ2TA�Z;^�8D>O6�.7AR24Z�E46�03,/Hº2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2'X

��®�s� �¿���Í������£ ¤J¥ Ñ ~ � Ò�Ó '秨¤M© ¯±° ¬ ¯ ¤ ° «<© ¯ ,�©G¼±¹<©PÈ�¤J¼(¤ ° ´¶³M¤'«<§¨¤�¹L¹3´�¼@È ,�û�­;¤ ° ¤ �à´�ªã©ºªJ«?¬�¬�¥®­³Jù ° µ3¤U©G¼±¹ '�´�ªº© ° ©G¼ F ¬�¼(¤ºÂ1¬�ÈD¹�¤' *e¤�����¬gª¨ù ° ¸/©s³[¤kÀR£ ¤J¥!� 8 §¨¤P¥»­;¤º¼(¬ ° «<©G ´�ª/©3¥®´¶¬G¼�¬+¸ � � Ê Ë Ñ Ë �ºÕTÕ �p¸�¬ °¥®­;¤g³[¬�¼�ª¨¥ ° ù�³'¥®´¶¬G¼Í¬+¸ � 8vªk¤[¤ � ¯L¯ ¤J¼±¹G´ ��� � À

Page 25: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � ) �

� A�� Á ­;¤ ° ¤Ô´�ª#©D³[¬�«g«Uùs¥w©G¥|´�µ3¤a¹G´|©�È ° ©G«� 8 ÒkÒ;Ò;Ò¨Ó '�

� ��� ���� �ÒkÒ;Ò;Ò¨Ó ' �

��B � � ¸ Þ Ò�Ó � ´�ªa©D«<© ¯ ¸ ° ¬�« ©`ª¨«?¬�¬G¥»­¾³Jù ° µ3¤gªJù�³¨­"¥®­�©G¥ Þ Ò�Ó 'h¸/©�³'¥w¬ ° ªP¥®­ ° ¬�ùOÈG­ �v~±Þ Ò±Ó ' ,¥®­;¤J¼ � ¸/©�³J¥+¬ ° ªMùs¼W´|ø'ùW¤J ·?¥»­ ° ¬�ùLÈ�­ � 8 À£ ¤'¥ Î � '�©3¼±¹ �v~ Ë Ù � ��Õ¿Ò±Ó Ë � � Î ÕP¤�� ¯±° ¤¨ª[ªÔ©UÂ1¬�³�©GÂ�©G¼(©G ·�¥|´¶³M¼(¤'´1È�­�§¨¬Gù ° ­;¬�¬k¹ � ¬+¸ Î ©GªM©?ø'ùW¬�¥|´¶¤J¼�¥

¬+¸�ª¨«?¬%¬�¥»­ Ù §'·j¥®­;¤ 2å¼�´»¥w¤�È ° ¬�ù ¯ � �¶ªk¬�� ©s³J¥»ª¾¬�¼ Ù ¸ ° ¤¨¤J ·â¬�ù@¥®ª¨´|¹�¤�¬+¸ � ,`©G¼±¹ � ´�ª"¥»­;¤ÐÂ1¬%³�©G¸¨ù@¼±¹L©G«_¤J¼�¥w©GÂ�È ° ¬�ù ¯ � À��´ � � � Ñ � Ê Ë Î Õ�ÀM£ ¤J¥ � §¨¤#¥»­;¤?³[¬ °¨° ¤Jª ¯ ¬�¼±¹3´�¼@È<Â1¬�³[©GÂå©G¼±©G ·G¥®´½³U§ ° ©G¼(³¨­¾¬+¸ Ñ Ë �PÕ¥®­ ° ¬�ùLÈ�­ Î À?£ ¤J¥ � §J¤U¥»­;¤<¼�ùs«?§¨¤ ° ¬+¸<©G¼±©G ·G¥|´¶³_§ ° ©G¼(³¨­;¤Jª?¬+¸ � � Ê Ë � Õ�À?£ ¤J¥ n §J¤a¥»­�¤a´�¼±¹�¤ �i¬+¸ ' ©G¥ Î�½¥®­�©G¥ ´�ªR¥®­;¤ã¬ ° ¹�¤ ° ¬+¸ � � ©G¼±¹ºÂ1¤J¥ � §¨¤e¥»­;¤eÂ1¬�³�©G±©3¼±©G ·G¥®´¶³e´�¼±¹�¤��?¬+¸ � Àc£ ¤'¥ � � � 8 §J¤S© ¯ ¬�´»¼�¥y¬I¸ � � Ê Ë� Õ�À

��� � � ´�ªU¥®­;¤?¼�ùs«?§¨¤ ° ¬+¸ ¯ ¬G´�¼�¥®ªU´�¼ � � Ê Ë� ÕkÀ �vl n ©G¼±¹ =Dß n �� ´�ªU¥®­;¤ ° ©G«g´ 2c³�©G¥|´¶¬�¼m´»¼±¹�¤��¾¬I¸ � ©G¥ � À��l = À � ¸ n ´�ª ¯±° ´�«_¤Ô¥»­�¤J¼ �#ß =Ôßtn ùs¼WÂ1¤¨ª[ª � ´�ª ��© ° ¥®´½¤ ° ©G¥ Î À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Ë ð Õ 03*;^ Ë ó Õ 0GE4HÔ57=?=?H/^;510GA�HS69E�>O= Ë �#Xpï Õ NsA�B;HPZ;*;5VKLH'E�2�03.�C;E�>3C(HJE4Aw8�>O6 *;>3E�=_03.7512�0GA�57>O*�XË ï Õ ,/03* ]±H",/>O*;2457^;H'E�H/^t0GA?A�B;Hq.1H'KLH'.e>O6ã2TA4E�57,'A`öSH/*;2457.1572�0GA�51>O*;2`03*;^ 24>Í]�8 Ë .;Xæï Õ bcH",k03*âE�H'C�.103,/H

�@~ ' Ò±Ó ' ]s8 �v~ Ë Ù � ��Õ¿Ò±Ó Ë � � Î Õ 03*;^ � 8 ]s8`A�B;HÔ*;>3E�=_03.1572�0GA�57>O*D>O6 � � Ê Ë � Õ X$v8 Ë�� X �eXòK�5 Õ >O6uîæó :Gñ � 03,'A�2�A4E[03*;2T57A�5VKLH/.78�>O*"A�B;H#];E[03*;,[B;H/2ã>O6 � � Ê Ë � Õ N�03*;^q24> �vl nÐX � .1Hk0GE�.V8�Hk03,[B

];E[03*;,[B->O6 � 8 B�032\^;H/:3E4H/Hãn ��Ð>%KLHJE � N�A�B�Z;2 =Ôßtn ���N;2451*;,'H � B�032R0#Z;*;51rsZ;HÔ57*�KLHJE�24Hã51=_03:OHe>O*�Hk03,[B];E[03*;,[B�X

#�H'A �a](HS0Ô.1>@,/03.�H/rsZ�0GA�51>O*<6�>3Ec>O*;He];E[03*;,[B_>O6 ��� Ê Ë � Õ X@+@51*;,/H � 03,'A�2åA4E[03*;245VA�57KLH/.V8<>O*aA�B;He];E[03*;,[B;H/2>O6(Þ"N � � Ë � Õ Ë A�B;H\C;E�>@^;Z;,'A¿>O6±A�B;HRA4E[03*;24.10GA�H/2 Õ N�512�0P^;H'Ï�*;57*;:ºH/rsZ�0GA�51>O*a6�>3E = � � � Ê Ë � Õ X�+@51*;,/H � � Ë � Õ 572� 51*LK30GE45903*LAkNs5VAk{æ2å0ã^;H'Ï�*;51*;:PH/r@Z�0GA�57>O*<6�>3E@= �éÜ �?X Y B�Z;2 = � 572 � 0GE4A�57H'EkN�03*;^<24> ��l =�]s8gA�B;HR^;H'Ï�*;5VA�51>O*>O6 A4B;HP51*;^;HG��X

,�51*�03.7.78LN�576 n 512\C;E�57=?H3N�03*;^ � �ßtnÐN;A�B;H/* �gßÝðON�03*;^ �ç512 � 0GE4A451H'EkX �)wA<bu51.7.R]±H",/>O*�KLH'*;51H/*LA`6�>3ED0GC;C�.157,k0GA�51>O*;2aA�>�B�0kKLHq0�,'E�57A4H'E�51>O*�6�>3E_beB;H/* � >O6 Ë .;X7ð�Å Õ 6�0357.12<A�>�]±H

� 0GE4A�51HJEkX��®�W� �¿�@�Í�����D£ ¤J¥ Ë � � n Õa§¨¤<©"¬�¼(¤<¹G´�«?¤'¼;ª¨´¶¬�¼(©GÂ�Â1¬�³[©G �º¬%¤J¥»­�¤ ° ´|©3¼ �g¬�«?©G´�¼ ,e© ; úT©GÂ}È�¤�§ ° © ,\ûy´»¥»­ ;´�ªk¬G«?¬ °¶¯ ­�´¶³M¥+¬ � �Gn À �ãª[ª¨ù@«?¤Ô¥®­;¤P¼(¬ ° «<©G ´�ª/©G¥|´¶¬�¼ ��×´�ª92å¼�´�¥+¤U¬�µO¤ ° � ©G¼(¹?Â1¬�³�©3Â7À Á ­;¤J¼

^;51= � nn � � =?57*

� ��� � 3 ^;57= ���ßt^;51= � ��

n � ���

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ $v8`A�B;HãC;E�>GFIH/,'A�57>O*�6�>3E�=gZ;.90�î # ñ� �¶n � �

�ßt^;57= � ��

� � ���

Page 26: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

) � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

+@51*;,'H �� 572e0U.1>s,k03. H �ÔNWA�B;HM24H/,'>O*;^"H/r@Z�03.757Aw8`6�>O.1.7>%bu2/X

� �¶n � nn � � � �¶n � nn � ä � ätð � � �¶n � n

�äëð�ßt^;51= � �

buB;51,[B�:O57KLH'2RA�B;HMÏ;E�2TAu51*;H/rsZ�03.15VA+8LX ���®� 5��¿�@�Í�����D£ ¤J¥ Ë '�� Î Õ\§¨¤\©\Ès¤ ° « ¬+¸c©e¼�¬ ° «<©3ÂLª¨ù ° ¸/©s³[¤0,�ûy´�¥®­º© ° ©G¥®´½¬�¼±©GÂOªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´»¥®· ,�©3¼±¹ �c~ �'�Ò�Ó' ¥»­;¤�«g´�¼�´»«<©GÂ�¹s¤¨ª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© ° ´�ª/©G¥|´¶¬�¼ ,ºûy´»¥»­ ° ¤�¹3ù�³[¤[¹j¤��@³[¤ ¯ ¥®´½¬�¼±©GÂe¹3´�µ�´�ªk¬ ° U Àt£ ¤J¥ Î � � Ü 'ħ¨¤Ð©G¼©G¼±©3 ·�¥|´¶³�©GÂ� ·¾´ °J° ¤�¹GùW³J´|§/Â1¤-³'ù ° µ3¤0,ÔªJù�³¨­m¥®­�©G¥Ô¥»­�¤`ª¨¥ ° ´¶³J¥ã¥ ° ©3¼;ª�¸k¬ ° « �� Ü �'à´�ª?ª¨«_¬�¬�¥®­�À �ãª[ª¨ù@«?¤ U ´�ª� ú4©G¼�¥|´�úw¼(¤»¸kÀ

Ë ð Õ ^;51= � � Ë �ºÕ � �� � U ÀË ó Õ � ´�ªãª¨«_¬�¬�¥®­D´ÇÆ �� � U�ßÝð À � ¼ ¯ © ° ¥®´½³JùsÂ7© ° ´Ç¸ �� � UÝßÝð ¥®­;¤J¼ � ´�ªÔ¼(¬�¥ ��© ° ¥®´¶¤ ° ÀË ï Õ � ¸ �� � U ßÖó ¥»­;¤'¼ � ­�©�ª`©�­s· ¯ ¤ ° ª¨ù ° ¸/©s³[¤Uª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|·OÀ � ¸R¸¨ù ° ¥®­;¤ ° «?¬ ° ¤ � Ü ' ´�ª ��© ° ¥®´¶¤ ° ,

¥®­;¤J¼ '�´�ª �Ôù ��©GÂ7À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ +@57*;,/H U 512\03*LA�5Vض*;H/6½N;A�B;H'E�Hã512\0#24Z;=à>O6�03*�03.V8@A�57,�^;5124,'2 � N�=?H/H'A451*;:EU *;>3E�=_03.7.78LNs03*;^D^;572»FI>O51*LA69E�>O= �� 24Z;,[B�A�B�0GA Uëä � 512R,/Z�Ae>OZ�Au]�8 � � Ê Ë � Õ 6�>3Ee24>O=?H�� ��n>� � � X Ë ð Õ 6�>O.7.1>�be2R69E�>O= Ë .;X7ðOð Õ X

�S>�bé24Z�C;C(>O2TH � 572u2T=?>@>3A�B�X Y B;H/*�576 bcHMA[0GQLH��0U:OH/*;H'E[0GA4>3E�>O6 n # � � N;A�B;H'*ðSß � Ë � Õ�� �� - U � ��

Ë buB;H'E�H � Ë � Õ Ü �' 512\A�B;HM24,[B;H/=?HÔ,/Z�A�>OZ�AR]s8 � " Ë � Õ4Õ buB;51,[B�:O5VKLH/2 Ë ó Õ X,W>3E Ë ï Õ 24Z�C;C±>O24H �� � U ß ó@X Y B;H'*�]s8 Ë ð'Øwó Õ N � B�032aAwbc>�^;57=?H/*;2457>O*�03.\A�03*;:OH/*�A<2TCW03,/H"03*;^�51*

CW0GE4A�57,/Z;.90GE � 512?(M>3E�H/*;2IA�H/51*�X��S>%bç576 � 512 � 0GETA�51H'E/N�A�B;H/* ' 572?(ã>3E�H/*;2TA�H'51*�X¿öSH'*;,/H Ë ï Õ X �� À A � D ¤'«<© ° F ª/À �S>3A�H\A�B;He,'>O*;^;57A�57>O*;2�>O6 Ë .;X1ð%ó Õ B;>O.1^a6�>3Ec03*L8a,J8�,/.751,Rr@Z;>3A�57H/*�A�2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8LN�03*;^a6�>3Ec03*L8*;>O*@ؽ,J8�,/.751,�rsZ;>3A�51H/*LAc2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8<6�>3EvbuB;51,[B?A�B;He,/H/*LA4E[03.±,'Z�E4KLHSB�032v24H/.761ؽ57*�A�HJE�24H/,'A451>O*D0GAc=?>O2TA Ò ï�X Y B;H51=aC�.151,/0GA�51>O* � 24=?>@>3A4Bìß � �� � U ß ð Ë 03*;^q5VA�2eC;E�>s>O6 Õ B;>O.7^;2S6�>3EM03*�8",'Z�E4KLH#>O*Ð0?*;>3E�=_03. 2TZ�E�6�03,/H:OH'E�=-N3A�B�0GAå512ybe5VA�B;>OZ�Aå032424Z;=?57*;:�U 512 ��Øw03*LA�5Vض*;H/6½X Y B;H\E�H'KLHJE�24HR51=<C�.751,k0GA�57>O*�N3B;>�bcH'KLH'EkN�^;>@H'2�*;>3AkX � *;H,/>OZ;*LA�H'EeH ��03=<C�.7Hã512uA4B;HÔZ;*;57r@Z;H Ò ð'ؽ,'Z�E4KLHP>O* ' Ë U�� Õ N;24H/H Ë ï�X : Õ X

� À A � D ¤'«<© ° F À Y B;H?,/>O*;^;5VA�51>O*;2Ô6�>3E#0DCW035VE Ë '�� Þ Õ >O6c03*�5VE4E�H/^;Z;,/5V]�.1H Ë *;>O*@ؽH/=<C;Aw8 Õ ,/Z�ETKLH?>O*Í0DE�03*�Q>O*;HU.1>O:`A�H'E�=?57*�03.�24Z�E�6�03,/HUA�>`](H<.7>O:8,�03*;>DB�0�KLHa0�*;57,/HaHG��C;E�H/2T2451>O*�57*iA�HJE�=?2ã>O6�A�B;Hg]�Z;:GؽHJ8LH/^Í,/>�KLH'E�@~ '�åÒ±Ó ' ~

Ë ð Õ íS* 5VE4E�H/^;Z;,'57]�.1H¾,/Z�E4KLH�Þ >O*ç0j.1>O:�A4H'E�=?57*�03.M2TZ�E�6�03,/H ' 512�.1>O:�A4H'E�=?57*�03.S57è A�B;H¾C�Z;.1.V]W03,�Q� " Ë Þ Õ Ü ' 572u*;>O*@ض2451*;:OZ;.10GEkX

Ë ó Õ )+6�Þà512�.1>O:PA4H'E�=?57*�03.�03*;^ ' B�032¿E[03*�Q<>O*;H3NsA4B;H/*_o��eä"Þà512c03*LA�5ÛØw03=<C�.7Hu5Vè�Þàß É Ê 03*;^?A4B;H'E�HH ��512TA42e03*�H/*;^;>O=?>3E4C�B;5724= >O6 Þ buB;51,[B�6�03,'A�>3E42RA�B�E4>OZ;:OB �JX

Page 27: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � )�2

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ ,W>3E Ë ð Õ 24H/Hgí�C;C±H/*;^;5 �4#åX Ë ó Õ 6�>O.1.7>%bu2ã69E�>O= Ë .;X1: Õ Ë >3E Ë .;X # Xæï Õ4Õ 03*;^qA�B;HU03^�FIZ;*;,'A�57>O*¾6�>3E�=gZ;.90�N24H/H Ë .;X1ð � Õ ]±H/.1>�bPX �� À A � D ¤'«<© ° F À ,W>3EP.7>O:�A�HJE�=?51*�03.y2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2/N�+@B;>3Q@Z�E�>�K({æ2Ô^;57è±H'E�H/*LA Ë 24H'H<í�C;C(H'*;^;5 � # Õ 03.124>�B�032º0*;51,'H-51*LA�H'ETC;E�H'A[0GA�57>O*h51*jA�H'E�=<2a>O6eA4B;H�]�Z;:GؽHJ8LH/^â,/>�KLH'EkX +@Z�C;C±>O24H-bcH�B�0�KLH-03*h.7AUCW0357E Ë '��,�ºÕ Nåbe5VA�B� E4H/^;Z;,/H/^�03*;^ 57E4E4H/^;Z;,/57]�.7H3X +@Z�C;C(>O24H�A�B;H-2451*;:OZ;.10GE<C(>O57*�A42?>O6 ' 03.1>O*;: � 0GE�HaÎ Ê � Î � � � � �-� Î>5h03*;^= Ê � = � � � � �-� = 5h0GE�H�A�B;H�,/>3E4E4H/2TC(>O*;^;57*;:Í>3E�^;H'E�2_>O6�A4B;H�.1>s,k03.u6�Z;*;^�03=<H/*�A�03.e:3E�>OZ�C�2/X � 8 ß � � Ê Ë �ºÕ 572*;>O*@ؽ2T51*;:OZ;.90GE_032 � 572?.7AkNv03*;^ � ~ � 8 Ò�Ó � 572_0¾24H'A<]�5 FIH/,'A451>O*�NcA�>3A[03.7.78mE[03=?5VÏ�H/^â0GA?H/03,¨B¾Î � be5VA�BE[03=?5VÏ�,k0GA�57>O*"51*;^;H � = � XS)I*qA�B;H#*;>3A[0GA451>O*q>O6uîæó3ïGñ¶N � 8 ß � � = � � Î � �LX #�H'A � � ](H#A�B;H#Z;*;57r@Z;H#C(>O57*�Aã>O6åÞ>�KLH'EåÎ � X +@57*;,/H �@~ '�¿Ò�Ó ' 572 �H'A[03.7HÔ57*-,/>s^;51=?H'*;2451>O*�>O*;H

�" Ë o��#ä �ºÕ l # ��ß Ë o ��� ä � 8 Õ l # �(ßto # �

ß � " Ë o # Õ ä � Ë = � Ò ð Õ � �

ß � " Ë o #�ä � = � Ò ð= � Î � Õ �

Y BsZ;2RA�B;H'E�HÔ512u0a,k03*;>O*;57,k03. 57^;H/*LA�57Ï�,k0GA451>O*->O6 � Ø Ì H/51.y^;5VK�512T>3E�2

Ë o��ºä �ºÕ l #Íßto #"ä � = � Ò ð= � Î � �

��� �¿����<���L ��e���(�� �������� 10íS2¿57*;^;51,k0GA4H/^`51*?A�B;H�57*�ATE�>@^;Z;,'A451>O*�N@A�B;HuC;E�>@>O6�>O6 Ë ðOXæï Õ 57*�KL>O.VKLH/2v^;H/6�>3E�=<51*;:#0PE[0GA451>O*�03.W,/Z�E4KLH3N@buB;51.7H

=_0357*�A[0357*;51*;:#24>O=<HeC;E�H/24,JE�57]±H/^-,/>O*LA[03,'Acbu57A4B�0#^;5VK�512T>3EkX�öSH'E�HSbcH�]±H/:O51*`]s8?^;H'KLH/.1>3C�57*;:#A�B;Hã*;H/,/H/24240GE48^;H/6�>3E�=?0GA�51>O*gA�B;H/>3E48LN Ë�� X7ð'Øwõ Õ NL0ã2TA4E�0351:OBLA�6�>3E4b\0GE�^aH ��A4H/*;2451>O*a>O6�A�B;H\E�H/2TZ;.7A�2å>O6�îÛð # ñ¶X Y B;H/*abvHRbu51.7.;^�E[0�b0a*�Z;=#](H'Ee>O6 ,/>3E4>O.1.90GE451H/2/NW03.7.�>O6 buB;51,[B-bcHM](H/.751H'KLHÔ0GE�HP>O6 24>O=?HM51*;^;H'C±H/*;^;H/*LAS51*LA�H'E4H/2TAkX)+*PA�B;H¿0GC;C�.151,/0GA�51>O*;2/N%bcH¿bu51.7.�>O69A4H/*P](H�bc>3E4Q�57*;:e>O*#0R]�Z;:GؽH'8LH/^#,'>%KLH'E/NO0e*;>O*@ؽ2T51*;:OZ;.90GE/NG]�Z�A Ë Z;24Z�03.7.78 Õ

*;>O*@ؽ2TH'CW0GE[0GA�H/^q03.7:OH'];E[0357,P2TCW03,/HGX +@><bcHÔbv>3E4QD51*-A�B;572e.7H'KLH/.�>O6�:OH/*;H'E�03.157Aw8 Ë buB;51,[B�51*-6�03,'A�^;>sH/2e*;>3Ae51*03*L8Dbc0�8D,/>O=<C�.751,k0GA4HãA4B;HÔA4E�H/0GA�=?H/*LA Õ X

$cH/.1>�bÔNs]�8`0#2TCW03,/H3N�bcHã=?H/03*`0 Ë *;>3Ac*;H/,/H/2T2�0GE�51.V8`24H'CW0GE[0GA4H/^ Õ 03.1:OH'];E�0351,S2TCW03,/HGXå)+*�03.1.±>O6�A�B;HSöS>O=a2bcHº,'>O*;2451^;H'E/N�A�B;HÔ^;>O=_0351*�512�03.Vb\0k8�2�032T24Z;=?H/^-A4><](H#0UC;E�>GFIH/,'A�5VKLHP24,[B;H/=?HGX +@H/H`îæó3ïGñ�6�>3Eã0a^;5124,/Z;2T2451>O*>O6 öS>O=Ö57*�A�B;572e,/>O*LA�H �@AkX

,�57E42TA?0Ð6�H'bÖE�H/=_0GETQ�2g>O*�C�Z;.7.7]W03,�Q�2<03*;^h*;>3A[0GA�57>O* Ë 03.7.\>O6ubuB;51,[Bâ0GE�H�2TA[03*;^�0GE�^ Õ X (M5VKLH/*â0Ð=_0GCÑ ~ ¦ Ò±Ó T NR03*;^ 0¾24Z�]�2ICW03,/Hqo Ü T N Ñ � Ê Ë o Õ Ü ¦ 51*;^;57,k0GA�H/2aA�B;H�24,[B;H/=?H¨Ø¶A�B;H/>3E4H'A�51,"57*�KLHJE�24H51=?03:OH Ë ^;H'Ï�*;H'^D]�8<C�Z;.7.151*;:º]W03,�Q?A4B;HS^;H'Ï�*;51*;:gH/rsZ�0GA�51>O*;2 Õ Xy)+6�o 512c03*`H'è±H/,'A�5VKLH � 0GETA�51H'E¿^;57K@5124>3EkN�A�B;H/*Ñ � Ê Ë o Õ Ü ¦ 512v0g.7>@,k03.7.78UC;E�51*;,'57CW03.(24Z�]�2ICW03,/H Ë A�B�0GA\512¿57A�2c57^;Hk03.±24B;H/036 572c.1>@,/03.1.78UC;E�57*;,/57CW03. Õ N;03*;^`516 ¦512S57*�A4H/:3E[03.�03*;^ Ñ Ë ¦iÕ 572S*;>3AM0_24Z�]�24H'AM>O6�A�B;H#24Z�C;C±>3E4AM>O6åojN±A�B;H'* Ñ � Ê Ë o Õ Ü ¦ 512ã03:L0351*Ð0 � 0GE4A�57H'E^;57K@5124>3E/NåbuB;51,[B�bvH`bu51.7.v>O69A�H/*�^;H/*;>3A�H`]s8mA�B;H`=?>3E4HD,'>O*�KLH/*LA�57>O*�03.c*;>3A[0GA�51>O* Ñ " ojX¾)+*�03*L8j,k0324H`bcH

Page 28: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

) � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

,k03*q03.Vb\0�8@2eC�Z;.1.V]W03,�Q-A�B;Hº.751*;HP]�Z;*;^;.7H 6 Ë o Õ X (M5VKLH/*�Awbc>_24Z�]�2TCW03,/H'2��mN�o >O6y0?2ICW03,/H T N � Üto=?Hk03*;2vA4B�0GAvA�B;Hã2TCW03,/H � 512c0#24Z�]�2TCW03,'HÔ>O6�o Ë 032c>3C;C(>O24H/^`A�>ºA�B;HSbcH/0GQLH'E\,/>O*;^;57A451>O*`>O6�24H'ATØ|A�B;H/>3E�H'A451,51*;,'.1Z;2457>O* Õ X�±�®�-7�� 9y�����%�»���

��¿���Í�����_£ ¤J¥ Þ Ü ¦ ©G¼±¹ UÄÜ T §¨¤`¤»Æã¤[³J¥|´�µ3¤ ��© ° ¥®´¶¤ ° ¹G´�µ%´�ªk¬ ° ª/À��ãª[ªJùs«?¤Ô¦ ´�ª

¯ ù ° ¤J ·-¬G¼(¤#¹G´�«_¤J¼;ª¨´¶¬G¼±©GÂ7ÀÁ ­;¤ ° ¤�´�ª-©�ª ¯ ©�³¨¤ öS>O= Ë ¦�� T�� Þ ÜLU Õ-ûy´�¥®­j¥»­�¤M¸k¬�Â�Â1¬�ûå´�¼@Ⱦù@¼�´�µ3¤ ° ª/©G ¯±° ¬ ¯ ¤ ° ¥|·OÀ � �ºú ¯ ¬�´�¼W¥ �ë~

� � ¦ Ò±Ó T ¬+¸ öS>O= Ë ¦�� T#Õº´�ªP© ¯ ¬G´�¼�¥R¬+¸ öS>O= Ë ¦�� T�� ÞàÜ�U ÕP´ÇÆ � ��Þ Ü � � Ê Ë U Õ�À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ #�H'A

;¿~uöS>O= Ë ¦�� T#Õ � ¦ìÒ�Ó T

](HMA�B;HãA[03Z�A�>O.1>O:O57,k03.�=_0GC�X2#�H'A� ß R�"�; " 6 Ë U Õ �

� 512R>3]sK@51>OZ;24.V8D0UKLH/,'A4>3Eu]�Z;*;^;.7Hº>O6 E[03*�QD^;H/:¿Þ"X Y B;HP,/>O=aC(>O245VA�51>O*

; " 6 Ë Ò U ÕcÒ�Ó 6�� ��� f�� � �@f�� 6�� ��� f�� � ���51*;^;Z;,'H/2S0a,/03*;>O*;51,k03.�24H/,JA�51>O*�>O6 � X�# HJA

öS>O= Ë ¦�� T � Þ×Ü�U Õ ÜâöS>O= Ë ¦�� T#Õ

](HgA�B;H �/H'E4>-.1>s,/Z;2/X Y B;HUZ;*;57KLH'E42�03.�C;E�>3C(H'ETA+8q>O6yA�B;H0�/H'E�>D.1>s,/Z;2M>O6åA�B;572ã24H/,'A�57>O*¾572M>3]�K�57>OZ;2ã69E�>O=ÄA�B;H,/>O*;2TATE�Z;,'A�57>O*�X �

#�H'A� ](Hm0â,/>O.1.7H/,'A�57>O*é>O6aHJè(H/,'A457KLH � 0GE4A�51HJEq^;57K�5724>3E�2�Þ Ê � Þ � � � � � � Þ 5é>O* ¦ 03*;^�à0â,/>O.7.1H/,¨ØA�57>O*�>O6UH'è(H','A�57KLH � 0GE4A�51HJEi^;5VK�5724>3E�2 U Ê � U � � � � � � U 5é>O* T X Ì Hj.1HJA U ß U Ê ä � � � U 5(X Ì Hm.7H'A� ß öS>O= Ë ¦�� T � � Ü� Õ ^;H/*;>3A�H`A�B;HD24,[B;H/=?HJØ|A�B;H/>3E�H'A451,-57*�A4H'E�24H/,JA�51>O*h>O6\A�B;H�öS>O= Ë ¦�� T � Þ � Ü U � Õ51*;2T51^;HPöS>O= Ë ¦�� T#Õ X � A�B;H'*�51*;B;H'E457A�2u03*�>3]�K�51>OZ;2RZ;*;57KLHJE�2�03.�C;E�>3C(H'ETA+8D69E�>O= Ë�� X7ð Õ X�±�65 �¿�@�Í������.Wù ¯�¯ ¬%ªk¤ T×´�ªuª¨«?¬�¬G¥»­�©G¼±¹g¥®­;¤M¹3´�µ�´�ªk¬ ° ª U Ê � U � � � � � � U 5 ­�©Gµ3¤�¼(¬ ° «<©GÂ�³ ° ¬%ª¨ª¨´�¼@È�ªkÀ Á ­;¤ªk¤�ø/ù�¤J¼�³[¤¨ª

Ë ð Õ Å Ò�Ó � Ë Ò .1>O:�U ÕvÒ±Ó � Ò�Ó 8 6�� Ë U � ÕcÒ±Ó Å

©G¼±¹

Ë ó Õ Å Ò±Ó 6�� � Ò�Ó � Ë Ò .7>O: U Õ l � � Ò�Ó � � � Ë Ò .1>O:�î U Ê � Ë U Ò U Ê Õ ñ ÕvÒ±Ó Å

© ° ¤g¤��s©�³'¥½À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ ,W>3E Ë ð Õ 2TH/H #�H/,'A�Z�E4H#óU>O6cîVð%ó�ñ¶X Ë ó Õ 6�>O.7.1>�be2R69E�>O= Ë ð Õ X �

�SH �@ARbvHPH �@A�H/*;^ Ë ðOXpó Õ 03*;^ Ë ðOXæï Õ >O6cîVð # ñ¶X

Page 29: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � ),0

�±�)( NÔ�%���å�±¡k���%���±�¿�D£ ¤J¥e¦ ß � §¨¤"©�ª¨«?¬�¬G¥»­ ¯(° ¬+²k¤¨³J¥®´»µ3¤�³Jù ° µ3¤kÀ � Ü×öS>O= Ë � � T#Õ-´�ª�³Jù@¥a¬�ùs¥U§'·^;H/: Ë Þ Õq¤�ø'ù�©G¥®´½¬�¼;ª/À Á ­;¤�¹G´�«?¤'¼;ª¨´¶¬�¼t¬I¸D©3¼�·i´ °¨° ¤[¹Gù�³'´|§'Â1¤�³[¬�« ¯ ¬�¼(¤J¼�¥g¬+¸ � ©G¥#© ¯ ¬�´�¼W¥ � ´�ª-©G¥ÔÂ1¤�©�ª¨¥� Ë � " � Õ�Ò ^;H/: Ë Þ Õ�À

� ¸�¸¨ù ° ¥»­�¤ ° «?¬ ° ¤ Ë T�� U Õc´�ª\Â1¬�ÈMªJ«?¬�¬�¥®­ ,y©3¼±¹ Þ � ß � � Ê Ë U � Õ�¸k¬ ° ©3Â� � , ¥»­�¤J¼`¥®­;¤���© ° ´�ª F ´�¥w©G¼@È�¤'¼�¥�ª ¯ ©�³[¤©G¥ î �sñ ´�ª � 3 Ë � " � Ë Ò .1>O:�U Õ4Õ�À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Ì H_*;>3A�H<Ï;E�2TA#A4B�0GA Ë ðOX ó Õ 03*;^ Ë ðOXpï Õ >O6ÔîVð # ñ¿03*;^�A�B;H/57E#C;E4>@>O6�2ºB;>O.7^mbuB;H/*ÍA�B;H<A�0GE�:OH'A#572º*;>3A24H'CW0GE�0GA�H/^�X � Ü�öS>O= Ë � � TºÕ 572Ô,/Z�AP>OZ�AÔ]�8Ð^;H/: Ë Þ Õ H'r@Z�0GA�57>O*;2M]�8 Ë�� X1ð Õ X Y B;H<^;57=?H/*;2457>O*¾H/2IA�51=_0GA4H*;>�b�6�>O.7.1>�be2R69E�>O= Ë ðOXpó Õ >O6cîVð # ñ¶X

�SH �@Au,'>O*;2451^;H'EuA�B;HP,'>O=?=gZ�A[0GA�57KLHS^;5103:3E[03=

Å Ò'ÒWÒ;Ò�Ó � 3 Ë � " � Ë Ò .7>O:@U � Õ4ÕqÒkÒ;Ò;Ò¨Ó � 3 Ë � " � Õ Ò/Ò�Ò;Ò[Ó � 3 Ë � " 6�� Ë U � Õ4Õ���

� ������

Å Ò'ÒWÒ;Ò�Ó � 3 ËTË � l � Õ " � � Õ ÒkÒ;Ò;Ò¨Ó � 3 Ë4Ë � l � Õ " � Õ �Ò/Ò�Ò;Ò[Ó � 3 Ë4Ë � l � Õ " 6�� Ë U � Õ4Õ �

Ë Y B;HÐÏ;E42TA`E�>%b 572_C�Z;.1.1H'^ë]W03,�Q�69E�>O= Ë�� X ó@X7ð Õ 03*;^ëE�H'=_0351*;2`H �;03,'A�032�U � C�Z;.1.12`]W03,�QâA�>�0 � 0GE4A�57H'E^;57K@5124>3E Õ X�$v8"A�B;HaZ;*;57KLH'E42�03.�C;E�>3C(H'ETA+8LN�A�B;HgA[03*;:OH/*LAº2TCW03,/HUA�>-öS>O= Ë � � T � Þ � Ü U � Õ 572MA�B;HUQLH'E�*;H/.å>O6A�B;HS,/>O=aC(>O245VA�51>O*�� � =P03*;^_A�BsZ;2c]�8<A�B;HS^;5103:3E[03=ÚH/rsZ�03.�A�> � 3 Ë � " � Ë Ò .7>O: U � Õ4Õ X Y B;H�A[03*;:OH/*LA\2TCW03,/HA�> � 512eA4B;H#51*LA�H'E�24H','A�51>O*q>O6�A�B;HºA[03*;:OH'*�AS2ICW03,/H/2ã>O6yöS>O= Ë � � T�� Þ � Ü U � Õ 03*;^q24>_]�8 Ë�� Xpó@X1ð Õ 572�H/rsZ�03.A�> � 3 Ë � " � Ë Ò .7>O:@U ÕTÕ X ��OZ;:O:O.157*;:UA�H',¨B;*;57r@Z;H/2e>O6�zq>3E�5�bcHÔ>3];A�0351*�A4B;HP6�>O.1.7>%bu51*;:;~

�±�� J �W�%��K K»�����y� � ¸�¦ ´�ªS©#ª¨«?¬%¬�¥»­?µG© ° ´¶¤J¥|·a©G¼±¹ºÒ Ë o_fÐä�Þ Õã´�ªS©G« ¯ Â1¤0,y¥»­;¤'¼ Ë ¦�� Þ Õe´�ª�Â1¬�È#ù@¼�´ ° ùsÂ1¤[¹LÀ� ¸PÒ o_f Ò Þ ´�ª ¯ ª�¤Jù;¹s¬�ú4¤»ÆS¤¨³J¥®´»µ3¤0,\©3¼±¹g¦ ´�ªºù@¼�´ ° ù@Â1¤�¹ ,\¥®­;¤J¼¾¥»­ ° ¬�ùLÈ�­i©?È�¤J¼(¤ ° ©G ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥e¬+¸e¦ ¥»­;¤ ° ¤g´�ª© ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼±©G ³'ù ° µ3¤P«?¤¨¤J¥®´»¼@È Þ ©G¥¿«?¬%ªJ¥¿¥|ûy´¶³¨¤kÀ

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ #�H'A � ]±H�0 �'H'E�>�^;57=?H/*;2457>O*�03.c24,[B;H/=?H->O*h0i,/Z�E4KLH � X Ì H�240�8 � B�032 ¡k� PL� $ N¿516 $ 512UA�B;H=_0 ��51=gZ;=Ö.1H/*;:3A�Bq>O6å0_24Z�]�24,[B;H/=?H��DÜ � 24Z�C;C(>3ETA�H/^i0GAã0_2451*;:O.7HPC(>O57*�AkX ,�5 �q0<C±>O.90GE�572�0GA�51>O* � 03*;^0�:OH'*;H'E[03.yC(>O51*LA��m>O6 ¦ XaíS=?>O*;:`E[0GA�57>O*�03.�,/Z�E4KLH/2 Ñ ~ � Ò�Ó ¦ A�B�E4>OZ;:OB �mbe5VA�B � �(� =?57*;51=gZ;=�N,[B;>@>O24HÔ>O*;HP24Z;,[B-A4B�0GA Ñ " Þ B�032u:3E�Hk0GA�H'2TAe2T5C�/H $ X

+@Z�C;C(>O2THÔA�B;HME�H/24Z;.VA�6�0351.72/X Y B;H/*-51*�A4B;HÔC�24H/Z;^;>GضH'è(H','A�57KLHP,k0324H3N $ � � � Þ Ò ó@NW03*;^ $ � � � Þ Ò ð51*�A4B;H#03=<C�.1HÔ,k0324H3X # HJA��?](H#0?24Z�]�2T,¨B;H'=?Hg>O6 Ñ " ÞÄ>O6�.1H/*;:3A�B $ N±.7H'A¿Îq]±HPA�B;Hº24Z�C;C±>3E4Aã>O6��N�03*;^".7H'A� ]±Hº0UC±>O51*LA�=_0GC;C�57*;:UA4>�� X �S>3A�HM516 Ò o_f Ò Þ 512\C�24H/Z;^;>GضH'è(H/,JA�57KLH3N � � Þ � Ò o_f � � N;bu57A�B�2TA4E�57,'A51*;H'r@Z�03.15VAw8q516 Ò o_f Ò Þ 512Ô03=<C�.7H3X Y B�Z;2º51*Í03*L8Ð,k0324HaöS>O= Ë � ��¦�� ��Ü�Þ Õ B�032Ô^;51=?H/*;2T51>O*�0GAÔ.1H/032TAÒ o_f �$� ä � Ò $ - �MäÐóÔbeB;HJE�H���512�A�B;H�^;51=<H/*;2451>O*_>O6 ¦ X Y BsZ;2 Ñ =?>%KLH'2/N�Ï"��51*;: �-03*;^�aÜ Ñ " Ë Þ Õ N51*D0ºAwbc>g^;51=?H'*;2451>O*�03.�6�03=?51.V8LN@03*;^D24>g57A�2c57=_03:OH�=gZ;2TAc=<>%KLH3X Y BsZ;2cbcHã,k03*_Ï�*;^�0ºC;E�>GFIH/,'A�5VKLHM2TZ�E�6�03,/H' N�0a24=?>@>3A4BDC;E�>GFIH/,JA�57KLHÔ,/Z�E4KLH � NW03*;^"0aÏ�*;5VA�HP=?0GC '�Ò�Ó � � ¦ 24Z;,[B�A�B�0GARA�B;HP=_0GC �c~ '�Ò�Ó ¦

Page 30: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� + ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

512U:OH/*;H'E451,k03.7.78ÍÏ�*;57A4H3N ' Ò�Ó � B�032a:OH'*;H'E[03.cÏ;];E�H É�Ê N¿03*;^�6�>3Ea24>O=?H`>3C(H'*�24H'A`ÙìÜ � N �j:O57KLH/2U0Ù�Ø|C(>O51*LAS>O6yöS>O= Ë � ��¦�� �?ÜtÞ � � Ü � Õ N(03*;^ � � ~ É Ê Ò�Ó ¦ 512�A�B;HP=_0GC Ñ X +@57*;,/H � � � 512�=<51*;51=?03.|NR Ê B�032ÔE�H'^;Z;,/H/^m57E4E4H/^;Z;,/57]�.7H?Ï;];E�H/2/N�03*;^�A�BsZ;2P512º0�24=?>@>3A4B É Ê Ø¶]�Z;*;^;.7H3X8#�H'A �×Ü ' ](H<A4B;H<,/.7>O24Z�E�H>O6�Î �ÍÙgX Y B;H/* � 512Ô0�2TZ�]�24,[B;H/=?H<>O6 � " Þ 03*;^�0�24H/,JA�51>O*i>O6 R Ê X0#�H'A � ](HUA�B;Ha,'.1>O24Z�E�Ha>O6 � �ÍÙ#X$v8Ð032424Z;=<C;A451>O*iA4B;H'E�H<572P03*;>3A4B;H'EP,'>O=<C(>O*;H/*LA�U >O6 � " Þ"N *;H',/H/242�0GE451.78i^;512�FI>O51*LAP69E�>O= � 6 � X � B�032*;H/:L0GA�5VKLHº24H/.761ؽ57*�A�HJE�24H/,'A451>O* Ë 032�� Ë �SÕ ß � Õ X Y BsZ;2 Ë 2457*;,/HºA�B;H#,/>O*;Hg>O6 ' 512�Awbc>`^;51=?H'*;2451>O*�03. Õ N ��03*;^U B�0�KLHMC(>O245VA�57KLHM24H/.76�51*LA�H'E�2TH/,'A�57>O*�N�03*;^ � � UÝß Å�NW0a,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�51>O*�X �

Ë�� X . Õ :O5VKLH/2¿24>O=<HuH'K@51^;H/*;,'HS6�>3E Ë ðOX7ð�Å Õ NO]�Z�Ac57A¿512¿*;>3A�KLH'E48aZ;24H/6�Z;.�6�>3EvC;E�>�K�51*;: Ë ðOX1ð Õ Øw03242TZ;=?51*;:P]±>3A�BA�B;HM24=?>s>3A�B;*;H/242\6�>3E ¦ 03*;^�03=aC�.1H/*;H/2T2u>O6 Ò Ë o_f�ä�Þ Õ 572RA�>s>g2TA4E�>O*;:;X Y B;HM*;H �@AuAwbc>U,/>3E�>O.7.90GE�57H/2/N;>O*A�B;HÔ>3A�B;H'EuB�03*;^�NWbu51.7.(C;E�>%KLHMA�>g](HÔQLHJ8(~

�±� � J ���%��K K��W���y��£ ¤J¥ �c~ ¦ ß � ß É�ÊeÒ±Ó T §¨¤º©<«_¬ °¶¯ ­s´�ª¨« ,åû�­�¤ ° ¤ TÄ´�ªSª¨«?¬�¬�¥®­-©G¼±¹?¥»­;¤g¹G´�µ�´�ª�¬ ° ªU Ê � U � � � � � � U �<­�©GµO¤P¼(¬ ° «<©GÂ�³ ° ¬%ª[ªJ´�¼@È�ª/À��ãª[ªJùs«?¤ Þ � ß � � Ê Ë U � Õ�À Á ­�¤å¸k¬�Â�Â1¬�ûå´�¼@È<­�¬�Â7¹ �

Ë ð Õ � ¸ Þ ´�ªDª¨ù ¯L¯ ¬ ° ¥+¤�¹Í´»¼ ©G¥#«?¬�ª¨¥g¥|ûv¬ ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥®ª5,<©G¼±¹ � ´�ª�´�¼ç©�³¨¬�« ¯ ¬�¼�¤J¼�¥ � ¬I¸ � ª¨ùW³¨­�¥®­�©G¥� � É Ê Ò�Ó T ´�ª�¹�¬�«U´�¼±©G¥|´�¼@È ,g¥®­;¤J¼ Ñ " � Ë Ò .7>O:@U Õ-´�ªDªk¤'«g´ ¯ ¬%ªJ´�¥®´»µ3¤ã¸k¬ ° ©iÈ�¤'¼(¤ ° ©3 ¯ ¬�´�¼W¥Ñ � � À

� ¸ � " � Ë Ò .1>O:�U ÕP´�ªãª�¤J«g´ ¯ ¬�ª¨´�¥|´�µ3¤M¥®­;¤J¼ �½¼�¤�© ° � �Ë ó Õ � � � Î � Ò�Ó T ´�ªãªJ«?¬�¬�¥®­ã¸k¬ ° ©G¼�· Î ��-Þ ©G¼±¹Ë ï Õ � � � Î � Ò�Ó U�� ´�ªãªJ«?¬�¬�¥®­M¸k¬ ° Î��-Þ�� á 6 ���� ��Þ �

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Ë ð Õ 6�>O.1.7>%bu2v69E�>O= Ë�� Xpï Õ 032v57*?A�B;HeC;E�>s>O6�>O6 Ë ðOXpï Õ >O6åîVð # ñ|X Ë ó Õ 03*;^ Ë ï Õ 0GE�H�,/.7Hk0GEv69E4>O= Ë�� Xæï Õ X �Y B;HÔ6�>O.7.1>�be57*;:a,/>3E4>O.1.90GET8_B;>O.1^;2Rbe5VA�B-03*L8D*sZ;=#]±H'Ee>O6 ,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*�A42/N;]�Z�AubcHãC;E�H/2TH/*�A�57AR6�>3E�0GAR=?>O2IA

Awbc><,'>O=<C(>O*;H/*LA�2/NW032RA�B;512R2451=aC�.157�H'2u*;>3A[0GA451>O*�03*;^�512R24Z"!?,'51H/*LAS6�>3Eu>OZ�Ee*;H/H'^;2/X

�±��� J ���%��K K��W���y��£ ¤J¥ �c~ ¦ ß � ß É�ÊeÒ±Ó T §¨¤º©<«_¬ °¶¯ ­s´�ª¨« ,åû�­�¤ ° ¤ TÄ´�ªSª¨«?¬�¬�¥®­-©G¼±¹?¥»­;¤g¹G´�µ�´�ª�¬ ° ªU Ê � U � ­�©3µ3¤P¼(¬ ° «<©GÂ�³ ° ¬%ª¨ª¨´�¼@È�ªkÀ=.Wù ¯�¯ ¬%ªk¤g¤'´�¥»­�¤ °

Ë 5 Õ � Ë É�Ê¨Õ Ü U Ê , � � Ê Ë U � Õ ß×Þ � , ^;H': �" 6 Ë U Ê Õ ß ^;H/: Ë Þ Ê Õ0,º©3¼±¹ �

" � � � Ë Ò .7>O: Ë U Ê � U � ÕTÕD´�ªªk¤J«U´ ¯ ¬%ª¨´»¥®´�µO¤kÀ/.�¤J¥

�ÐßtöS>O= Ë � � U Ê � Þ � Ü�U � � U Ê Õ �

¬ °Ë 515 Õ � Ë É Ê Õ Ü�U Ê � U � , ^;H/: �

" 6 Ë U � Õ ßt^;H/: Ë Þ � Õ-,c©G¼±¹ � " � � ��� � ´�ªãªk¤J«U´ ¯ ¬%ª¨´»¥®´�µO¤kÀ/.�¤J¥

�ÐßtöS>O= Ë � � U Ê � Þ � Ü�U � � U Ê Õ 6DöS>O= Ë � � U � � Þ Ê Ü�U Ê � U � Õ �

Page 31: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � � .

Á ­;¤'¼ � ´�ªMÂ7À»³kÀ1´v©G¼±¹ ° ¤�¹GùW³[¤�¹`©G¥ � ©G¼±¹ � ´�ªP©?¼(¬�ûy­;¤ ° ¤g¹�¤J¼;ªk¤Ôª¨ù;§'ª ¯ ©�³[¤�À (ù ° ¥®­;¤ ° «?¬ ° ¤ �½¼(¤�© ° � �Ë ð Õ � á � � � Î � Ò�Ó T ´�ªSª¨«?¬%¬�¥»­Ô¸k¬ ° ©G¼�· Î ���Þ ÀË ó Õ � á � � � Î � Ò�Ó U Ê ´�ªãª¨«?¬�¬G¥»­ã¸�¬ ° ©G¼W· Î���Þ Ê á Þ � � Þ Ê À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Ì H`bu51.7.¿>O*;.V8Í^;Hk03.¿bu57A�Bm,k032TH Ë 5 Õ N�,k032TH Ë 515 Õ 512#KLH'E48¾2451=<51.90GE Ë 03*;^m*;>3AgZ;24H/^�57*ÍA�B;H?C;E�>@>O6R>O6Ë ðOX7ð Õ4Õ XË�� Xpó@X1ð Õ 03*;^ Ë�� X ó@Xpó Õ 24B;>�bÄA�B�0GA � " � Ë Ò .7>O:@U Õ Ne03*;^ � " � ×0GE�H"](>3A4Bë24H'=?57C±>O2457A�5VKLH3X #�H'A � ß

öS>O= Ë É�Ê � T#Õ X � ]�2TH'E4KLHºA�B�0GA �Ðß � � öS>O= Ë É�Ê � U Ê Õ Ü �mX Ë ð'Ø+ó Õ 0GE�Hº51=<=?H/^;590GA4HM69E4>O= Ë�� X � X ó%Øwï Õ X%$c8Ë�� Xæï Õ N �Ö03*;^ �_0GE�H¿2T=?>@>3A�BP0GA �M>O6�^;57=?H/*;2457>O* � Ë � " � Õ NG03*;^ � Ë � " � � � Ë Ò .7>O: Ë U � � U Ê Õ4Õ4Õ E�H/2TC±H/,'A�5VKLH/.78LX$v8 Ë�� Xæï Õ H'KLH'ET8_,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*�Av>O6 � B�032\^;51=?H/*;2T51>O*`0GA\.1H/032TA � Ë � " � Õ(Ò ^;H/: Ë � " U Õ ßt^;57= Ë � Õ ä�ðOX Y B�Z;2��512ã*;>%buB;H'E�HU^;H/*;24HGX0+@>D]�8 Ë ð'Ø+ó Õ N � Ü � B�032MC�Z�E�HU,/>s^;51=?H/*;2T51>O*Ð^;H/: Ë Þ Õ X +@51*;,/HU57AM512ã,/Z�AM>OZ�Aã]�8^;H/: Ë Þ Õ H/r@Z�0GA�57>O*;2/N�57Av572c0P,/>O=aC�.1H'A�Hu51*LA�H'E�2TH/,'A�57>O*�Xå)+*<CW0GE4A451,/Z;.10GEc57A¿512 � >OB;H/*@ضzi03,/03Z;.90k8LN�03*;^`24>º2457*;,/H57Au512R:OH/*;H'E451,k03.7.78_E�H/^;Z;,'H/^�N±5VAe572RE�H'^;Z;,/H/^�X ��±��� ��� �W� � K���¡3� íS2�0Ô2T51=<C�.7HRHG��03=<C�.7HR>O6 Ë�� Xpõ�X}5 Õ NO.7H'A �UH/=#](H/^ É Ê 032¿0M24=?>s>3A�Ba,'>O*;51, U�ß U Ê 51* É � X#�H'A¿ÞÚß .Wî Î�ñ¶NL6�>3E¿0MÏ"��H/^ÔÎ�� É Ê X Ë � Xpõ�X1ð Õ 240�8@2åbcHu,k03*?^;H/6�>3E4= �g57*?0M6�>OZ�Ev^;51=<H/*;2451>O*�03.;6�03=<51.78LN3buB;51.7H=_0357*�A[0357*;51*;:º6�>OZ�ETA�B`>3E�^;H'E\,/>O*LA[03,'A\0GA Î�X Y B�Z;2\bvH�B�0�KLH�A4B;HSH/.1H/=<H/*�A�0GE48<>3]�2TH'E4KG0GA�51>O*_A�B�0GAc:O5VKLH/*`03*L8,/>O*;57,P51* É�� A�B;H'E4HÔ572�0UAwbc>a^;51=?H'*;2451>O*�03.�6�03=?57.78`>O6 ,/>O*;51,/2RbeB;57,[B�=?H/H'A42RA�B;HÔ:O57KLH/*�,/>O*;51,M>O*;,/H3XíS2�03*;>3A4B;H'E"2457=<C�.1H�HG��03=<C�.7Hi>O6 Ë�� Xæõ�Xæ5 Õ NS24Z�C;C(>O2TH � Ü ' 3 512"0�.7>O:h,k03*;>O*;57,k03.|NãE�H/^;Z;,/H'^�NP]�Z�A

*;>3A_5VE4E�H/^;Z;,/5V]�.1H3NR=?H/=#]±H'E?>O6?l Ò o���l Ë B;H'E4H3NR032`03.7b\0k8�2/N ' 512?0¾E[03*�Qh>O*;H".7>O:�^;H/.?��H����/> Õ X Y B;H/*03^�FIZ;*;,'A�57>O*�2TB;>%bu2#A�B�0GA#H'KLH'ET8Í57E4E4H/^;Z;,/57]�.7H`,/>O=<C(>O*;H'*�A U Ê >O6 � N�512º0q2T=?>@>3A�B�E�0GA�51>O*�03.å,/Z�E4KLH3Nå03*;^U Ê =<H/H'A�2 U � ß �ÝÒ U Ê *;>3E�=_03.7.78�0GAeAwbc>?C±>O51*LA�2/N±240�8UÎi03*;^ � X # H'A �c~ É�ÊMÒWÓ U Ê ](HºA4B;Hº51^;H/*LA�5VA+8LX� " � � � Ë Ò .1>O:@U Ê � U � Õ 512uATE�57K@5903.(]�8�03^�FIZ;*;,'A451>O*�N±2T><bcHº=_0k8D0GC;C�.78 Ë�� Xæõ�Xæ5 Õ N�be5VA�B�Þ Ê ß Ë U �Ê Õ Î�N�Þ � ßÎÔä � NsA�>g,/>O*;,/.1Z;^;HãA�B�0GA '23 512c^;>O=?57*�0GA�H/^_]s8<E[0GA�51>O*�03.±,/Z�E4KLH/2 Ë 57*D6�03,JAu^;H'6�>3E�=_0GA�57>O*;2c>O6�U Ê Õ =?H/H'A�57*;:� Awbe57,/H3Xv)+*�A�B;572e,k0324HRÎqbe57.1.�](H#0U]W0324H'C(>O57*�A�>O6�A�B;HP^;>O=?57*�0GA�51*;:a6�03=?51.V8LX � *;Hº,k03*">3];A[0357*-A�B;Hº2�03=<HE�H/2TZ;.7Ae]�8D,/>OZ;*LA�51*;:?^;57=?H/*;2457>O*;2u57*�l U Ê lpN�2457*;,/Hº03*L8D^;H/6�>3E�=_0GA451>O*->O6�U Ê 512�03:L0357*�2T=?>@>3A�B`E[0GA�57>O*�03.|XÌ Hãbe57.1.�69E�H'r@Z;H/*LA�.78�Z;24HMA�B;HP6�>O.7.1>�be57*;:a,/>O*;2TH/r@Z;H/*;,'H#>O6 Ë�� X � Õ Ë 24>O=?H'A�57=?H/2cbu57A�B;>OZ�A\E�H/6�HJE�H/*;,/H Õ ~

�±��� J ���%��K K��W���y��£ ¤J¥ � Ü ¦ §¨¤�© ° ¤�¹3ù�³[¤[¹i¹G´»µ�´�ªk¬ ° ¬�¼ ©Ð¼(¬ ° «<©GÂR©GÂ}È�¤k§ ° ©G´¶³<ª ¯ ©�³¨¤kÀ �ãª[ª¨ù@«?¤g¦ ´�ª©`ªk¤ ¯ © ° ©G¥+¤�¹`µG© ° ´½¤J¥®·D´�¼j©`¼�¤J´1È�­�§J¬�ù ° ­;¬�¬k¹�¬+¸ +@51*;: Ë �UÕ 6 +@51*;: Ë ¦iÕ�ÀP£ ¤J¥ �ÖÜ � §¨¤<©"³JÂ1¬%ªk¤�¹`ª¨ù�§Jªk¤'¥�¬+¸³[¬k¹3´�«?¤J¼;ªJ´¶¬�¼i©G¥vÂ1¤�©�ªJ¥�¥|ûv¬ ,R¹G´�ª�²k¬G´�¼�¥�¸ ° ¬�« +@51*;: Ë �UÕ 6 +@51*;: Ë ¦iÕ�À

� ¸\¦ ´�ª#¹�¬�«g´�¼(©G¥w¤[¹`§'·D©e¸/©3«g´� ·�¬+¸ ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼±©G ³'ù ° µ3¤¨ªÔ«_¤[¤J¥|´�¼@È�� 6 +@57*;: Ë ¦¾Õº©G¥v«?¬�ª¨¥ � ¥|´�«?¤¨ª0,�ûy´�¥®­� � ó ,v¥»­�¤J¼Ð´�¥v´�ª#¹�¬�«g´�¼(©G¥w¤[¹D§'· ° ©G¥®´½¬�¼±©GÂ�³'ù ° µ3¤¨ª#¹3´�ª�²k¬�´»¼�¥�¸ ° ¬�« � ,¿«?¤[¤'¥®´�¼�È�� 6>+@51*;: Ë ¦iÕg©G¥c«?¬�ª¨¥ �¥|´�«?¤¨ª5,\©G¼±¹`©GÂ}Ès¤k§ ° ©3´¶³�©GÂ� ·�¤�ø'ù@´�µG©3Â1¤J¼�¥v¥w¬<«?¤J«<§¨¤ ° ªg¬I¸M¥»­�¤U¬ ° ´1ÈG´�¼±©3Â3¸/©G«g´� ·LÀ

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ íS69A4H'EPCW03242T51*;:�A�>-0�.1>O:DE�H/24>O.7Z�A�51>O*¾>O6 Ë ¦�� �UÕ N�E�H'C�.103,/51*;: � ]s8i57A�2MA�>3A[03.�A4E�03*;246�>3E�= 03*;^�A�B;H^;>O=?57*�0GA�51*;:a6�03=?51.V8D]�8-A4B;Hº2TA4E�57,'A�A4E�03*;246�>3E�=�N�bcH#=_0k8�032424Z;=?H Ë ¦�� �aÕ 512e.1>O:?24=<>@>3A�B�X%$v8 Ë�� X � X7ð'Øwï Õ N

Page 32: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

��) ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

A�B;H�:OH'*;H'E[03.(=?H'=g]±H'Ev>O6(A4B;H�6�03=?51.V8<^;H'6�>3E�=?2/Ns=_0351*LA[0351*;57*;:PA�B;H�*�Z;=#](H'E\>O6(C±>O51*LA�2v>O6�,/>O*LA[03,'Avbu57A4B � Nbu57A�B�*;>a]W0324H'C±>O51*LA�2e>OZ�A42451^;HÔ>O62+@51*;: Ë �UÕ X �

�SH �@Ae0U=?H'A�B;>s^->O6�C;E�>%K@51*;: ¦ 3 512uZ;*;57E�Z;.7H/^�X Ì HÔZ;24HMA�B;HP6�>O.7.1>�be57*;:;~7�� 9y�����%�»���¿� Ì Hº2�0k8-0aCW0357E Ë ¦����MÕ >O6�0aE�H/^;Z;,/H'^i^;5VK�512T>3Ee>O*q0<*;>3E4=_03.�K30GE�57H'Aw8-B�032�� � ���%�»�@���?¡k�®�

ý���K»�������%����¡ 516±A4B;H'E�H�572c0Pr@Z�032T5VضÏ�*;5VA�H�24Z�E»FIH/,'A�57>O* � ~(Ù Ò�Ó ¦ N �H'A[03.7He57*_,/>@^;57=?H/*;2457>O*?>O*;H3Nsbu57A4B�Ùç03*;^� � Ê Ë �MÕ 24=?>s>3A�B�X�±�(' J ���%�K K����%�y��£ ¤J¥¿¥»­�¤ ¯ ©G´ ° Ë ¦����MÕº³¨¬�¼;ª¨´�ªJ¥v¬+¸Ô©a¼(¬ ° «<©GÂ�µG© ° ´¶¤J¥|·?©G¼(¹_©_¹G´�µ�´�ª�¬ ° �<À .Wù ¯L¯ ¬%ª�¤S¥®­;¤ ° ¤´�ªq©j¹�¬�«U´�¼±©G¥|´�¼@Èa¸k©G«g´� ·�¬+¸ ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼(©GÂ�³Jù ° µ3¤Jª�«?¤[¤'¥®´�¼�È +@51*;: Ë ¦iÕ 6 � ©G¥#«?¬%ªJ¥ � ¥|´�«?¤¨ª5,\¸�¬ ° � � ó À.Wù ¯L¯ ¬%ª�¤0,\¤J´�¥®­;¤ °

Ë ð Õ Ë ¦����MÕã­;©�ªºø'ùW¬�¥|´¶¤J¼�¥�ª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ª5,c¬ °Ë ó Õ�¦ ­�©GªM¥w¤ ° «g´�¼(©GÂ1,y£ � ��� ª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ª �¶ª�¤[¤�� B � � � ,v©G¼±¹ �×´�ª#¤J« ¯ ¥®·LÀ

Á ­;¤'¼h¦ 3 ´�ª¾¹�¬�«g´»¼±©G¥+¤�¹h§'· ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼±©GÂÔ³Jù ° µO¤¨ªq«?¤[¤J¥|´�¼@È � ©G¥<«?¬%ªJ¥ � ¥|´�«?¤Jª/À � ¼ ¯ © ° ¥®´½³JùsÂ7© ° ¦ 3 ´�ªù@¼�´ ° ù@Â1¤�¹LÀ* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ $v8 Ë .;XæÅ Õ NG032 51*PA4B;H¿Ï;E�2TA CW0GE[03:3E[0GC�Bº>O6@A4B;H�C;E�>s>O6;>O6 Ë .;X . Õ N%A�B;HJE�H¿572�0u]�Z;:GضH'8LH/^#,/>�KLH'E��@~ ¦ �Ò�Ó¦ 24Z;,[BÐA4B�0GAS51*",k032TH Ë ó Õ N ¦ 512�.®Xæ,3X}5|N(03*;^q57*",k0324H Ë ð Õ N ¦ 03*;^ � 8 ß � � Ê Ë �MÕ 0GE�Hº*;>O*@ؽ2T51*;:OZ;.90GE/X $c8Ë .;X # Xpï Õ N ¦ 572u^;>O=?57*�0GA�H/^D]s8`E[0GA�57>O*�03.�,/Z�E4KLH/2u=?H/H'A451*;: � 8 0GAR=?>O2TARAwbe57,/H3X

,W>3E Ë ð Õ NW0GC;C�.78 Ë�� X1: Õ A4> Ë ¦ ��� 8 Õ bu57A�B �Ýß � � Ê Ë +@51*;: Ë ¦iÕ4Õ X)+* ,k0324H Ë ó Õ NR.1H'A �é]±H�A�B;Hq^;51=?H/*;2T51>O* >O6 ¦ X #�H'A � ß É Ê 03*;^ � Ò±Ó ¦ A�B;H":OH/*;H'E�03.S=_0GC

51*�0Í^;>O=?57*�0GA�51*;:Í6�03=?57.78LNvbu57A�B Ñ ~ � Ò�Ó ¦ A4B;H"51*;^;Z;,/H/^ë=_0GC�X $v8 Ë ó@X7ð�Å Õ >O6<îæó3ïGñ|NRöS>O= Ë � ��¦¾ÕB�032g^;51=?H'*;2451>O*�0GAg.1Hk032IA Ò Ñ Ë �PÕ/� o_f ä �ë0GA-î Ñ ñ¶X # HJA�î Ñ ñ � � ÜÚöS>O= Ë � ��¦iÕ ]±H�03*j57ETE�H/^;Z;,/5V]�.1H,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*LAº>O6vA�B�0GAP^;51=?H/*;2T51>O*�XO# HJA T Ò�Ó ¦ ](H?0-E4H/24>O.1Z�A451>O*�X Ì H?=?0�8Ð.15769A Ñ A4> Ñ 8 ~ � Ò�Ó T X#�H'A � 8 ](HºA4B;Hº57E4E4H/^;Z;,/57]�.7Hg,/>O=<C(>O*;H'*�AS>O6yöS>O= Ë � � TºÕ ,/>O*LA[0351*;57*;: Ñ 8 X +@57*;,/Hg=_0GC�2e57* � 8 ^;>O=?51*�0GA4HT N�� 8 B�032-^;57=?H/*;2457>O* Ò Ñ 8 Ë �PÕ3� o# ëä ��Ne]s8 Ë�� Xæï Õ 03*;^ Ë�� X � Õ X +@51*;,/H � 8 Ò�Ó � 512D^;>O=?57*�03*�AkNÑ 8 Ë �ºÕ � o# �

Ñ Ë �ºÕ � o_fºX �S>%b�]s8ÔA�B;Hc^;H'Ï�*;57A451>O*g>O6;A�H'E�=?57*�03.|N�57A�6�>O.7.1>�be2�A�B�0GA�o# � Ñ 8 Ë �PÕ ßto_f � Ñ Ë �PÕ03*;^ Ñ Ë �PÕ Ü ¦ 3 X �D ¤J«<© °GF À ,W>3E\,k0324H/2cbuB;H'E�H Ë�� X # Õ 0GC;C�.151H'2/N�bcHS*;>3A�HSA�B�0GA\0#.7>O:gA4H'E�=?57*�03.�CW0357E Ë '9� �UÕ >O6 03*`57ETE�H/^;Z;,/5V]�.1H,/Z�E4KLHi>O* 0j24Z�E�6�03,/HiB�032-r@Z;>3A451H/*LA-2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457A�57H/2/N�24H'H¾í�C;C(H'*;^;5 � #�NR03*;^tA4B�0GADA4H'E�=?57*�03.�A�B�E�H/HJض6�>O.1^2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2u0GE�H # � )��gNW24H/H?îæó3ïGñ|X

,W>3Eu2TZ�E�6�03,/H/2/NWbcHPB�0kKLHãA�B;HP6�>O.7.1>�be57*;:<,/>O=#]�51*�0GA451>O*D>O6 Ë�� X1:�Ø # Õ ~�±�('��)( J ���%��K K��W���y��£ ¤J¥ Þ Ü '�§J¤#© ° ¤[¹Gù�³¨¤�¹�³Jù ° µO¤g¬�¼�©?Â1¬�È?¥+¤ ° «U´�¼±©GÂ�ªJù ° ¸/©�³[¤kÀR£ ¤J¥ � §¨¤U©G¼�· 2å¼�´�¥+¤ªk¤J¥e¬I¸ ¯ ¬�´»¼�¥»ªg©G¥cû�­�´½³¨­ Ë '�� Þ Õº´�ª ¯ ù ° ¤J ·`Â1¬[È_¥+¤ ° «U´�¼±©G �T¬ ° ¤�ø'ù@´�µG©GÂ1¤'¼�¥®Â · ,v­�©�ª#ø/ù�¬�¥|´¶¤J¼W¥vª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥®´½¤¨ª � À� ¸ '�´�ªg¹�¬G«g´�¼±©G¥+¤�¹-§'· ° ©G¥®´½¬�¼±©GÂå³Jù ° µ3¤¨ªº«?¤[¤'¥®´�¼�È Þ 6 +@51*;: Ë 'åÕ<©G¥\«?¬%ªJ¥ � ¥®´»«?¤¨ª5,cûy´�¥®­ � � ó ,c¥»­�¤J¼�'´�ªº¹s¬�«g´�¼±©3¥w¤�¹D§'· ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼±©3 ³Jù ° µ3¤¨ªg¹G´�ª�²k¬G´�¼�¥�¸ ° ¬�« � ,R©G¼±¹<«_¤[¤J¥|´�¼@È Þ 68+@51*;: Ë '�Õ#©3¥�«?¬�ª¨¥ � ¥|´�«?¤¨ªkÀ

Page 33: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � �-�

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ #�H'A � ]±H\0ã:OH'*;H'E[03.�=?H'=g]±H'E�>O6W0S^;>O=?51*�0GA451*;:S6�03=?57.78Ô>O6�E�0GA�51>O*�03.s,/Z�E4KLH/2y=?H/HJA�51*;:SÞ 6?+@51*;: Ë 'åÕ0GAM=?>O2TA ��A451=?H/2'XÔíS69A�HJEÔ]�.7>%bu51*;:DZ�CiC±>O51*LA�2Ô0�b\0k8q69E�>O= �<N�A[0GQ@51*;:_A�B;HU2TA4E�57,'ASA4E[03*;246�>3E4= >O6 � N�03*;^A�B;H/*_E�H'2TA4E�57,'A�51*;:#A�>g0º*;H'51:OBL](>OZ�E�B;>s>@^`>O6 � N@bcHS,/03*�032T24Z;=?H Ë '�� Þ Õ B�032crsZ;>3A�51H'*�A\2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2/X �S>%b0GC;C�.78 Ë�� X # Õ X ��±�®�s� J �W���K K����%�y� Á ­;¤Ôª¨«_¬�¬�¥®­�Â1¬�³Jùsªg¬I¸º©�ÔúÛ¸/©�³J¥+¬ ° ´¶©G ¯±° ¬I²k¤[³J¥|´�µ3¤M¥+¬ ° ´½³ÔµG© ° ´¶¤J¥|·<´�ªãùs¼�´ ° ù@Â1¤�¹LÀ* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀR¦ B�032\r@Z;>3A�57H/*LAu2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457A�57H/2\03*;^ ¦ 3 512\>3]�K�57>OZ;24.78_^;>O=<51*�0GA�H/^_]�8_,/>3C�57H/2u>O6�ê Ê" X��S>�bé0GC;C�.V8Ë�� X # X1ð Õ X �Y B;H¾H ��512TA�H'*;,/H¾>O6º^;>O=<51*�0GA�57*;:�6�03=?57.151H'2D>O6ÔE[0GA�51>O*�03.ã,/Z�ETKLH/2�B�032-57=<C�.157,k0GA�57>O*;2D6�>3E�A�B;H *M>@^�035VE[0

^;51=<H/*;2451>O*�~�±�®�W� �¿���Í�����-£ ¤'¥@T §¨¤`©-µG© ° ´¶¤J¥|·OÀ#.Wù ¯L¯ ¬%ª�¤a¥»­;©G¥ o# ¾ä � ´�ªgªk¤'«g´cÂ1¬�Èi³[©G¼(¬�¼�´½³�©GÂå©G¼±¹-¥®­�©G¥ � ´�ª¥®­;¤ºÈ�¤J¼(¤ ° ©GÂ�«?¤J«?§¨¤ ° ¬+¸<©q³¨¬�µ3¤ ° ´�¼@Èã¸/©G«g´»Â ·"¬+¸ ° ©G¥®´½¬�¼±©GÂ�³Jù ° µ3¤Jª/ÀU£ ¤J¥ � §J¤U¥»­;¤U¼Wùs«<§J¤ ° ¬+¸g¥|´�«?¤¨ªg¥®­�©G¥� «?¤[¤J¥®ªM¥®­;¤Pù@¼�´¶¬G¼Í¬+¸ �Öûå´�¥»­�¥»­;¤ºÂ1¬�³Jùsªg¬+¸ ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥®ªMû�­�¤ ° ¤ T ´�ªM¼(¬�¥R³�©G¼�¬�¼�´¶³�©3Â7À

Ë ð Õ � ¸ � � ó ¥®­;¤J¼ Ë o# Ðä �MÕ�� � � Å À � ¼ ¯ © ° ¥|´¶³Jù@Â7© ° o# Ðä �×´�ªã¼(¬G¥\§/´1ÈLÀË ó Õ � ¸ � � ð ,㥻­�¤J¼ Ë o# mä �MÕ�� � � Å À � ¼ ¯ © ° ¥®´¶³'ùsÂ7© ° ¥®­;¤ �a¬k¹L©3´ ° ©i¹G´�«?¤J¼�ª¨´¶¬�¼ ¬+¸ o# mä �ì´�ª

¼(¬�¼Wúw¼(¤½ÈL©3¥®´�µO¤kÀ

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ �y032T2451*;:ºA�>ÔA�B;H�*;>3E�=_03.7512�0GA451>O*U>O6 T NsbcH�=?0�8a032424Z;=<HuA�B�0GA T 512¿.7>O:º,k03*;>O*;57,k03.|X2#�H'A RM~ � Ò�ÓT ](HU0D.7>O:_E�H/24>O.7Z�A�51>O*Ð>O6�A�B;H#CW035VE Ë T����MÕ X $v8�A�B;Hg^;H'Ï�*;57A451>O*;2M>O6�,k03*;>O*;57,k03.y03*;^¾.7>O:`,k03*;>O*;51,k03.®N�bcH=_0k8_buE457A�H

o# qä � ß R " Ë o��_ä �MÕ ä U

buB;H'E�H U 512cHJè(H/,'A457KLHã03*;^`H �;,'H'C;A�51>O*�03.®N � 512vE�H'^;Z;,/H/^�N�03*;^OR Ë �UÕ 512c,'>O*�A[0357*;H/^D51*?A�B;HSZ;*;57>O*D>O6 � 03*;^A�B;HU.1>s,/Z;2MbuB;H'E�H T 512M*;>3AÔ,/03*;>O*;51,k03.®X Y B�Z;2ÔA�B;HU2TA4E451,'AãA4E[03*;2T6�>3E�= >O6 � =?H/HJA�2 � 0GAM=?>O2TA ��A�57=?H/2/X�eHJC�.903,/57*;:¾A�B;H`CW0357E Ë T����MÕ ]�8jA4B;HDCW035VE Ë � � �UÕ bcH�=_0k8m032424Z;=?HDA�B�0GA Ë T����MÕ 572a.7>O:i24=<>@>3A�B�X #�H'AÑ ~ É Ê Ò�Ó T ](HãA�B;HM*;>3E�=_03.1572�0GA�57>O*D>O6 � X@$v8 Ë�� X � X7ð Õ N;0369A�H'ERC(>O2T2457]�.V8DE4H'C�.903,/57*;: Ñ ]s8�0U^;H/6�>3E�=_0GA�57>O*Ë bu57A�BDA�B;HM2�03=?HM,/>O*�A�03,'Aubu57A4B �MÕ N Ñ " � Ë Ò .1>O: �MÕ 512R24H/=?5VC(>O245VA�57KLH3X Y B;512\C;E�>�KLH/2 Ë ð Õ X

�S>�bà24Z�C;C(>O2TH �mßìð Ë A�B;H`,k0324H �mß Åq512UHk032457H'E<03*;^�bcH/.7.vQ�*;>�be* Õ X # H'A � ß ^;H/: Ñ � Ê Ë �MÕ X $c8032424Z;=aC;A�51>O*�N(A�B;HJE�Ha572M0D,/>O=aC(>O*;H/*LA � >O6åöS>O= Ë É�Ê ��¦�� � Î�Ü �MÕ buB;51,[B¾,'>O*�A[0357*;2 Ñ buB;>O24HUZ;*;57KLH'E�2403.6�03=?57.78a^;>O=?51*�0GA�H'2 T X Y B;HãZ;*;57KLH'E42�03.�6�03=?51.V8<B�032\>O*;HS^;57=?H/*;2457>O*�03.±Ï;];E�H/2R>%KLHJE��PN@]�Z�AR57A\B�032\0GA\.1H/032TAAwbc>?^;57=?H/*;2457>O*�03.�Ï;];E�H'2�>%KLHJE T N�2T51*;,/HPê Ê B�032e0<A+bv>?^;51=?H'*;2451>O*�03.�6�03=?57.78D>O6�03Z�A�>O=?>3ETC�B;5124=?2'X Y B�Z;2A�B;Huô�0GE�512IQ�5@A[03*;:OH'*�Aå2TCW03,/HR0GAuî Ñ ñ;B�032y^;51=?H/*;2T51>O*a0GAy.1Hk032TAy^;57= Ë TgÕ ä�ðOX Ë ó Õ 6�>O.1.7>%bu2�Hk032457.78º]�8 �e57H/=_03*;*�e>s,[B"03*;^ Ë�� Xæï Õ X ��LÀ A B D ¤J«<© °GF À �S>3A�HÔ]�8 Ë � X # X1ð Õ NW576�A�B;H#24=?>s>3A�B-.7>@,/Z;2e>O6y0?.1>O:<A�HJE�=?51*�03.�24Z�E�6�03,'H ' 572�^;>O=?51*�0GA4H/^-]�851=?03:OH/2g>O6eê Ê" A�B;H/*â51*�6�03,'A<A4B;H-24=?>s>3A�Bj.1>@,'Z;2<512UZ;*;57E4Z;.1H/^�NvA�B�0GAa512 ' 512U^;>O=?51*�0GA4H/^�]�8�,'>O=<C�.1H'A4HE[0GA�57>O*�03.�,/Z�E4KLH/2RA�B�0GAu=?51242\A�B;HM2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A451H/2RH/*LA�57E�H'.78LX

Page 34: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

� *ÐA�B;HU>3A�B;H'EMB�03*;^�N�57Aã572MH/032T8"A�>D,/>O*;2TA4E�Z;,JAÔE[0GA451>O*�03. 2TZ�E�6�03,/H/2Mbe5VA�BirsZ;>3A�51H'*�AM2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2S2TZ;,¨BA�B�0GA�o��?512v03=aC�.1H Ë 6�>3E¿HG��03=<C�.7HRA�B;Hu24Z�E�6�03,/He51* Ë ð # Xæï�X ó@Xpó@X1ð Õ bu57A�BO; - ð�Å Õ X � ]sK@51>OZ;24.V8aA4B;H/24He2TZ�E�6�03,/H/20GE�HaZ;*;57E�Z;.7H/^�N�]�Z�AP]�8 Ë�� X7ðOð Õ 03*�8i^;>O=?51*�0GA451*;:-6�03=<51.78Ð>O6¿E�0GA�51>O*�03.y,/Z�E4KLH'2º=?H/H'A42ÔA�B;H?2T51*;:OZ;.90GEP.1>s,/Z;20GAÔ.1Hk032TAÔA�B�E�H/HUA�51=<H/2/X +@57=?51.10GE�.78LN(A4B;Ha]�Z;:GؽHJ8LH/^Í,/>�KLH'E�2P>O6�A�B;H/24H?2TZ�E�6�03,/H/2#,k03*;*;>3AÔ](Ha^;>O=?51*�0GA�H'^i]�851=?03:OH/2\>O6 É�Ê N�6�>3E�H �;03=<C�.1HS]�8 Ë � X1ðOð Õ 03*;^-A�B;HãC;E�>@>O6 >O6 Ë�� X # Õ X

��� ��9������9�h�L �������g�������&��������W$�$

% �G���@þ/�(���%������ÿ3�%�»���¿�)+*ÍA�B;512º2TH/,'A�57>O*jbcH_^;HJKLH/.1>3Cj>OZ�Eg=_0357*�A�H/,[B;*;51rsZ;H/2g6�>3E#C;E�>%K@51*;:".7>O:"Z;*;57E�Z;.7H/^;*;H/242/X4,�57E42TA#bcH?bu51.1.

C;E�>�KLH Ë ðOXæï Õ 51*ÐA�B;H<,k032THUbuB;H/*¾A�B;HU](>OZ;*;^�0GE48ÐÞ 572Ô*;>O*@ضH/=<C;Aw8LX Y B�Z;2P6�>3E Ë ðOXæï Õ bvH<0GE�HUE�H/^;Z;,/H'^¾A�>24B;>�be57*;:�A�B�0GA#0DE[03*�Q�>O*;H?.7>O:�^;H/.���H����/>qB�032ÔZ;*;57E�Z;.7H/^m24=?>@>3A4B¾.1>s,/Z;2/X_)+*�A�B;512P24H/,'A�57>O*�bcH<C;E�>�K�57^;HAwbc><2T>3E4A�2e>O6 ,'E�5VA�H'E�510�X

,�57E42TAubvHMbu51.7.(C;E�>%KLHMA�B;HP:OH'*;H'E[03.�51=<C�.751,k0GA451>O*H �;572TA�H/*;,'HP>O6�0gA�51:OH'E � ' 3 Z;*;57E�Z;.7H/^ �

íS2å51*;^;51,/0GA�H/^<57*UA4B;Hu57*�A4E4>@^;Z;,'A�57>O*�NOA�B;512ybe57.1.�,'>O=<C�.1H'A4H\A4B;HRÏ;E�2IA¿B�03.76±>O6�A4B;HRC;E�>s>O6�>O6 Ë ðOXpï Õ NL03*;^aC;E�>�KLH/2Ë ðOXæï Õ 57*�03.7.�]�Z�Ae0U]±>OZ;*;^;H/^",/>O.7.1H/,'A451>O*->O6 ,k0324H/2'X

+@H/,/>O*;^;.V8 Ë õ�X � Õ 03*;^ Ë õ�Xpõ Õ :O57KLHM,'E�5VA�H'E�510<6�>3EebuB;H/*q0<=gZ;.7A457C�.1HM>O6�0aE�0GA�51>O*�03.�,/Z�E4KLH ��Ü ' ^;H/6�>3E4=?2Ë 032Ô0�E[0GA�57>O*�03.�,/Z�E4KLH Õ A�>-^;>O=<51*�0GA�H '23 X Ì HUbe57.1.�Ï�*;512TB¾A�B;HaC;E4>@>O6v>O6 Ë ðOXpï Õ 51* � :�Ø�ð :`]s8i:OH/*;H'E[0GA451*;:0aÏ�*;5VA�Hº24H'A��m>O6 Ë 6�03=?51.751H/2R>O6 Õ ' N�,/>O*LA[0351*;57*;:_03*�8-2451=aC�.78D,/>O*;*;H/,'A4H/^ ' bu57A4B;>OZ�A�A�51:OHJEkN±03*;^�A4B;H/*"6�>3EHk03,[B ' � �åN;Ï�*;^;51*;:?0UE[0GA�57>O*�03.�,/Z�E4KLH � Ü ' A�>gbeB;57,[B�bcHÔ,/03*"0GC;C�.78D>O*;HM>O6 Ë õ�X � Õ >3E Ë õ�Xpõ Õ Xí\A¿A�B;HuH/*;^`>O6±A�B;512¿24H/,'A�57>O*?bcHe:O5VKLH�0º*�Z;=#](H'Ec>O6±H ��03=<C�.7H/2/X Ë õ�X1: Õ 2TB;>%bu2vA�B�0GAv>OZ�E¿=_0351*a,'E�5VA�H'E�57>O*�N

Ë õ�X � Õ NL512å51*?24>O=<Hu24H'*;24H�>3C;A�57=_03.|X Ë õ�X1ð�Å Õ ,/>O*LA[0351*;2¿0P^;H'A[0357.1H/^aH ��03=aC�.1Hu0GC;C�.151,/0GA�51>O*a>O6 Ë õ�X � Õ X�)+* Ë õ�X7ðOð ÕbcH\Ï�*;^aA�B;H\=?57*;51=_03. Ë ^;H/:3E4H/H Õ ^;>O=?51*�0GA�57*;:ã6�03=?51.V8º>O6�E[0GA�51>O*�03.@,/Z�E4KLH/2å51* ' 3 51*a03*U51*LA�H'E�H/2IA�51*;:Ô2TC(H/,'57Ï�,,k0324HGX�)+* Ë õ�X # Õ bcHÔ:O5VKLHÔ2T>O=?HãH ��03=<C�.7H/2\A�>a,'>O*�K@51*;,/HMA�B;HÔE�H/03^;H'EuA4B�0GAe>O*;HÔ,k03*;*;>3AuC;E4>%KLH Ë ðOX1ð Õ ]�8 Ë 0GA.1H/032TAã0?^;57E4H/,'AS*�035VKLH#0GC;C�.157,k0GA�51>O*">O6 Õ A�B;H ³JÂ7©�ª[ª¨´½³�©G =?HJA�B;>@^">O6�,/>O*;2IA4E�Z;,'A�57*;:_E[0GA�51>O*�03.�,/Z�E4KLH'2/N(zq>3E�5|{}2](H'*;^i03*;^�];E4Hk0GQ�A4H/,[B;*;51r@Z;H Ë bcHPbc>3E4ET8�A�B;HÔE�Hk03^;H'ES=<51:OBLA�^;Z;,�Q-A�B;HÔE[0GA�B;H'ES57*�KL>O.VKLH/^"03*�03.V8�24572�03B;Hk03^516�A�B;H'8`](H'.151HJKLH/^-A�B;H'E4HÔb\032e0UC;E�>O=?572451*;:a03.7A4H'E�*�0GA�5VKLH Õ X��� �»¡'������ÿO�"�Wþ��i�%��ý��s�`�®� ��K®����¡a�������G��K���� � ��¡k¡3�Y B;HÔ=_0357*DE4H/24Z;.7Ae>O6 A�B;572e24Z�]�2TH/,'A�57>O*�512RA�B;HÔ6�>O.7.1>�be57*;:;~

���®�8NÔ�%���å��¡k���%���±����£ ¤J¥�' §¨¤Ô©#¼�¬ ° «<©3Â�ªJù ° ¸/©�³[¤Ô©G¼±¹ � ©G¼Ð¤»ÆS¤¨³J¥®´»µ3¤ �Ôú��q¤J´�Ây¹G´�µ�´�ªk¬ ° ¬�¼<' ,�ª¨ù�³J­?¥®­�©G¥o��gä�� ´�ªº¼�ù@«?¤ ° ´½³�©GÂ� ·D¥ ° ´»µ�´|©GÂ1,e©G¼±¹D¼(¬G¥ F  ¥wÀÔ£ ¤J¥ � §¨¤g¥»­�¤ºªJù ¯L¯ ¬ ° ¥�¬I¸ � � WÀ Á ­;¤J¼�'�´�ªU¹�¬�«g´»¼±©G¥+¤�¹§'· ° ©3¥®´¶¬G¼±©G ³Jù ° µ3¤JªÔ«?¤[¤'¥®´�¼�È�� 6 +@51*;: Ë 'åÕg©G¥¿«?¬%ª¨¥v¥|ûy´¶³[¤�À

�S>3A�HcA�B�0GAåbeB;H'* ' 51* Ë õ�X1ð Õ 572�.7>O:MA�HJE�=?51*�03.®N3A�B;H/*�N�]s8 Ë�� X7ð%ó Õ N3A�B;He,'>O*;,/.1Z;2457>O*<57=<C�.157H/2y51*aCW0GETA�51,/Z;.10GEA�B�0GA '�3 512RZ;*;57E�Z;.7H/^�X Y B�Z;2 Ë õ�X7ð Õ 57=<C�.157H/2 Ë ðOX1ð�. Õ >O6 A4B;HÔ57*�A4E4>@^;Z;,'A�57>O*�X

Page 35: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � �"�

Ì Hãbe57.1.�>3];A[0357*�0U2TA4E�>O*;:OH'Ee6�>3E�=Ö>O6 Ë õ�X7ð Õ 57* � ó3Åa032e0U,/>3E�>O.7.90GE48`>O6 Ë ðOX1ð Õ N;24H'H Ë ðOX . Õ XY B;HÔ=_0357*DC±>O51*LA�6�>3E Ë õ�X1ð Õ 572RA�B;HÔ6�>O.1.7>%bu51*;:;N�A�B;HÔ*;>O*@ؽH/=aC;A+8`]±>OZ;*;^�0GE48D,k0324HP>O6 Ë ðOXpï Õ X

���65 �¿���Í������£ ¤J¥+'২¤`© ° ©G¼ F ¬�¼(¤?Â1¬�Èйs¤JÂ�*�¤�����¬�ª¨ù ° ¸/©�³[¤�À � ¸ � ´�ª?©�¼(¬G¼�ú4¤J« ¯ ¥®· ° ¤�¹GùW³[¤�¹Ð³Jù ° µO¤0,ª¨ùW³¨­�¥®­�©G¥ o��#ä � ´�ªÔÂ1¬�È<¥+¤ ° «g´»¼±©G ©G¼(¹<Ò Ë o��ºä �UÕP´�ªº©3« ¯ Â1¤0,v¥»­;¤'¼ Ë '�� �UÕP´�ªãÂ1¬�ÈGú+ùs¼�´ ° ù@Â1¤�¹LÀ* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ �S>3A4Hº]s8Ð03^�FIZ;*;,'A451>O*i03*;^ÐA�B;Hg,/.10324245VÏ�,k0GA�51>O*q>O6å.7Aã2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2/N � B�032Ô0GAã=<>O2TA�Awbc>D,/>O=<C(>GØ*;H/*LA�2/N;03*;^_576 � 512¿E4H/^;Z;,/57]�.7H3N@A�B;HuA+bv>#,/>O=<C(>O*;H'*�A�2�=?H/H'A¿H ��03,JA�.78a>O*;,/H3N�*;>3E4=_03.1.V8U0GAc0º24=?>s>3A�BaC±>O51*LA>O6 ' X

#�H'A �@~ '�cÒ�Ó ' ]±HPA�B;Hº]�Z;:GضH'8LH/^q,/>�KLH'ES>O6 ' N Ë .;X � Õ X $c8 Ë .;X7ð�.;X1ð Õ A�B;HPCW0357E Ë '�5� � 8 ß ��� Ê Ë �UÕ4Õ 572.1>O:a24=?>s>3A�B�X

#�H'A � ]±H�0q,/>O=<C(>O*;H'*�Aa>O6 � 03*;^�.1H'A � 8 ](H`A�B;H�,/>3E4E�H/2IC(>O*;^;51*;:¾,/>O=<C(>O*;H'*�Aa>O6 � 8 X-$v8 Ë .;X1: Õ03*;^ Ë .;X1ð�. Õ N � 8 512`*;>O*@ؽ2457*;:OZ;.90GEkNSo # �PB�032D*;H/:L0GA�57KLHÐ^;H/:3E�H'H3N � ß É�Ê 03*;^tA�B;HJE�Hi572-0j24Z�E®FIH/,JA�51>O*�c~ É�Ê�Ò�Ó � 8 X��S>3A4H � � àÅU2451*;,/H ' B�032 ��51,k0GE�^�*sZ;=#]±H'E�>O*;H3X Y B;H'E�H#0GE�HãAwbc><,/0324H/2/X)+6 � ß � B�032�>O*;Hc,/>O=aC(>O*;H/*LA�bcHc,k03*U0GC;C�.78 Ë 5 Õ >O6 Ë � Xpõ Õ bu57A�BEUÝß � 8 03*;^UÞ H/r@Z�03.�A�>S^;H/: Ë � " � 81Õ Î

6�>3E�Îg0\:OH/*;H'E[03.OC(>O57*�A�>O6 É Ê X $v8 Ë�� Xpõ�X7ð Õ �ã^;H/6�>3E�=?2�A�>u:O57KLHå0\^;>O=?51*�0GA�57*;:\6�03=?51.V8S>O6@=_0GC�2 �D~ É Ê Ò�Ó ' 24Z;,[B�A�B�0GA

� � Ê Ë � 8 Õ ß Ë � � � Õ � Ê Ë �UÕ�� Ë ^;H/: Ë � � � Õ � Ê Ë �UÕ4Õ Î �+@51*;,'H?A�B;H?Awbc> � 0GE4A451H'E#^;5VK�5724>3E�2#0G]±>%KLH_B�0kKLH?A�B;H?2�03=<H?^;H/:3E�H/HGNybvH_B�0�KLH_H/rsZ�03.15VA+8LN�03*;^mA4BsZ;2 � Ë É�ÊJÕ=?H/HJA�2 � 8 HG��03,'A�.V8m>O*;,/H3N¿0GA � Ë Î Õ X-$v8 Ë�� Xæõ�X1ð Õ A�B;HD:OH/*;H'E�03.R=<H/=#](H'EU=?572424H/2U03*L8�,'>@^;51=<H/*;2451>O*mAwbc>24Z�]�24HJAkN�51*iCW0GE4A�51,'Z;.90GE ��� Ê Ë +@51*;: Ë 'åÕ4Õ N 03*;^¾A�B�Z;2PbcH<>3];A�0351*�0D6�03=?51.V8q>O6¿E[0GA�57>O*�03.y,/Z�E4KLH/2Ô^;>O=?51*�0GA�57*;:' 3 03*;^-=<H/H'A�57*;: � H �;03,'A�.V8`>O*;,/H3X

� A�B;H'E4bu5124H � B�032ÔH ��03,'A4.78"Awbc>-,'>O=<C(>O*;H/*LA�2/X0#�H'A � ß � Ê ä � � N�buB;H'E�H � ß � Ê X � � =?H'H'A�2 �*;>3E�=_03.7.78-0GAã0?2457*;:O.1HºC(>O57*�A/N � � ' 3 N(03*;^qA4B;H'E�Hg512 Ë ]s8q03^�FIZ;*;,JA�51>O* Õ 0GAS=<>O2TAS>O*;H#2457*;:OZ;.90GE�C±>O51*LAkN � N>O6 ' 03.1>O*;: � X�$v8 Ë .;X # Xpï Õ NWbcHg,k03*�03242TZ;=?H�� � �-512M03*ÐH/*;^;>O=?>3E4C�B;5724=Ä>O6 É�Ê A�>3A[03.7.78�E[03=?57Ï�H'^i0GA��03*;^ � X�#�H'AåÎ�](HMA�B;HMZ;*;51r@Z;HMC(>O57*�Au51*�� � Ê Ë � Õ X �S>%bébcHÔ0GC;C�.78 Ë�� Xæõ�Xæ5 Õ bu57A4B

U Ê ß � 8Ê � U � ß � 8� � Þ Ê ß ^;H/: Ë � " � 8Ê Õ Î � Þ � ßt^;H/: Ë � " � 8� Õ Î_ß � � Ê Ë � 8� Õ �

Y B;HPH ��512TA�H'*;,/HP>O6 0a^;>O=?57*�0GA�51*;:U6�03=?51.V8_6�>O.1.7>%bu2�032\](H'6�>3E�H3X �Y B;Hv*;H ��A # H'=?=_0RE4H/^;Z;,/H/2 Ë õ�X7ð Õ A4>S0er@Z;H'2TA�51>O*g0G]±>OZ�A E[03*�QÔ>O*;H%(ã>3E�H/*;2TA�H'51*#.1>O:e^;H/.:��H����/>ã24Z�E�6�03,/H'2/N

Z;2457*;: Ë õ�Xpó Õ 03*;^�2T>O=?HS2TA[03*;^�0GE�^�0GC;C�.157,k0GA�57>O*;2c>O6�A�B;Hãzqz ��X ,�57E�2IAR0U.757A4A�.7H�*;>3A[0GA�57>O*�X�)I*`A�B;Hã*;>3A[0GA�57>O*>O6 Ë õ�X1ð Õ N�.1HJA �â]±HUA4B;Ha.10GE�:OH/2TAã](>OZ;*;^�0GET8LN ,/>O*LA[0357*;H/^�51*;2T51^;H �¿X��S>3A�HUA4B�0GA ��03*;^ �âB�0kKLHgA�B;H<2�03=<H24Z�C;C±>3E4AkN�03*;^�03:3E�H/HÔ>O*�A�B;HÔ,/>O=<C�.7H/=?H/*LAR>O6 � X���)( �¿�@�Í����� Á ¬ ¯(° ¬�µ3¤ � �3À A � ûv¤Ô«<©G·�©Gª[ª¨ù@«?¤0,

Ë ð Õ Á ­;¤ ° ¤Ô´�ªÔ¼(¬<«?¬ °¶¯ ­�´�ª¨« RM~ '�Ò�Ó ,¿ûy´�¥®­?È�¤'¼(¤ ° ©3 2v§ ° ¤uÉ Ê ,

Page 36: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

Ë ó Õ o��ºä � ´�ªÔÂ1¬�È�³�©3¼(¬�¼�´¶³[©GÂ1,Ë ï Õ � ´�ªÔ¼(¬�¼�ú4¤'« ¯ ¥|· ,Ë . Õ 'ç´�ªº© ° ©G¼ F ¬�¼�¤PÂ1¬�È`¹s¤J *�¤�����¬UªJù ° ¸/©�³[¤0,Ë�� Õ o��ºä � ´�ªMÂ1¬[È?¥+¤ ° «g´»¼±©G ©G¥¿ª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© °v¯ ¬G´�¼�¥®ª5,Ë õ Õ � ß � �T¬ ° ¤[ø'ùs´»µG©GÂ1¤J¼�¥| · , o��#ä � ´�ªM¼Wùs«?¤ ° ´¶³�©3Â� ·_¥ ° ´�µ�´|©G � ,Ë � Õ � ��l Ò o���l , � Ü ' 3 ©G¼±¹ ' ´�ª �S¬ ° ¤J¼�ª¨¥w¤'´�¼ ,Ë : Õ '23_´�ªãª¨´�« ¯  ·D³¨¬�¼�¼(¤[³'¥w¤�¹ ,v©G¼±¹Ë # Õ � ´�ªÔ´ °¨° ¤�¹GùW³J´|§'Â1¤kÀ

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ +@Z�C;C±>O24HÔA4B;H'E�HM512R0a=?>3ETC�B;5124= RM~ '�Ò�Ó N;be5VA�BD:OH/*;H'E[03.(Ï;];E�HGN �aN;5124>O=<>3E4C�B;51,SA�> É�Ê X Y B;H/*� .157H/2e57*�A�B;HÔ24=?>@>3A4B-.1>s,/Z;2u03*;^�2451*;,'H Ë o��ºä �UÕ 512R*;>O*@ضC(>O2T57A�5VKLHP>O* �aN � =?H'H'A�2 � 0GAe=?>O2IARAwbu51,/HGXöSH/*;,/HMbcHPB�0kKLHM6�>OZ;*;^">OZ�Ee^;>O=?57*�0GA�51*;:U6�03=?57.78`>O6 E�0GA�51>O*�03.�,/Z�ETKLH/2/X Y B�Z;2ebcHM=_0�8D032T24Z;=?H Ë ð Õ X

#�H'A Ñ ~ � Ò�Ó ' ](Hg0?.7>O:<A�H'E4=?51*�03.�=?>@^;H'. >O6�A�B;HºCW035VE Ë '�� � Õ N(24H/H Ë ð � X1ð�Å Õ >O6Rî}ó � ñ¶X $c8�^;H'Ï�*;5VA�51>O*>O6�0U.1>O:UA�H'E�=?57*�03.�=?>@^;H'.(bcHP=_0k8?bRE�57A4HMA�B;HÔ.1>O:gC�Z;.1.V]W03,[Q Ë 24H'H Ë ðOX7ð�õ ÕRÕ 032

o��Dä ��Dä UÝß Ñ " Ë o��`ä � Õ �

buB;H'E�H � U 572åA�B;HR6�Z;.1.;E�H'^;Z;,/H/^_H ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.W.7>@,/Z;2'N ��"572åA4B;Hu2TATE�51,'AåA4E[03*;2T6�>3E�= >O6 �åN@03*;^<o��Sä ��ãä � U 512e.1>O:<A�HJE�=?51*�03.®XvíS2�^;5724,'E�H'CW03*;,'51H/2ã0GE�HP*;>3ASH'è(H','A�H/^"]�8-.7>O:<C�Z;.1.V]W03,[Q±N�bcHº0GE�Hº69E�H/HºA4><E�H'C�.103,/H Ë '�� � Õ N]�8 Ë � � Uëä ��Dä Ñ " Ë � Ò � ÕTÕ X��S>�bço��#ä �m572u.7>O:aA�H'E4=?51*�03.®N�51*-CW0GETA�51,/Z;.10GE Ë ó Õ B;>O.7^;2/X

+@Z�C;C(>O2TH � 572SH/=<C;Aw8LX Y B;H/* �h03*;^ ��0GE�H#H/rsZ�03.|NWbeB;57.12TAão��gä ��572�Q�.VAkN(0_,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�51>O*�XeöSH/*;,/HË ï Õ X

+@Z�C;C(>O2TH Ñ ~ 'ÝÒ�Ó ' 8 572#03*L8¾,/>O*LA4E[03,JA�51>O*�XO#�H'A � 8 ]±H<A�B;H?>O*;Ha^;51=?H'*;2451>O*�03.yCW0GE4A#>O6 Ñ Ë �aÕ XO$c8Ë�� X1: Õ N�0GC;C�.751H/^_bu57A�B �Ýß Ñ Ë �aÕ�á � 8 N�5VAc512cH/*;>OZ;:OB`A�>#Ï�*;^�0g^;>O=<51*�0GA�57*;:º6�03=?51.V8<>O6�E[0GA�57>O*�03.±,/Z�ETKLH/2 �buB;51,[B�=?H/HJA�2 � 8 68+@51*;: Ë ' 81Õ 0GAe=?>O2IARAwbu51,/HGXY B;H?*Ô>s^�0357E[0º^;57=?H/*;2457>O*_>O6�o��eä Ë � Ò �UÕ 572v*;H/:L0GA�5VKLH3N�24>º]�8 Ë ð Õ NsA�B;HezÐz ��bu57A4B?E�H/2TC±H/,'AcA�>ºA�B;572

^;57K@5124>3E :O57KLH'2 0\]�57E[0GA�57>O*�03.L,/>O*�ATE[03,'A�57>O* Ñ ~ 'jÒ±Ó ' 8 A�>e0RE[03*�QM>O*;H�.1>O:R^;H/.:��H����/>ebu57A�BÔo����¶ä Ñ " Ë � Ò �UÕ.1>O:aA�H'E�=?57*�03.�03*;^i03*LA�5ÛØw03=<C�.7H3X �S>3A�H'KLHJE48�,/>O=aC(>O*;H/*LAS>O6 � ,k03*�]±H#,/>O*�ATE[03,'A�H/^�]�8 Ñ N�6�>3ES>3A�B;H'ETbe5724HË 2457*;,/H � Ò ��572e24Z�C;C±>3E4A�H/^q>O* �UÕ o��#ä �j512eA4B;HP.1>O:aC�Z;.1.7]W03,�Q->O6�o�����ä Ñ " Ë � Ò �aÕ N�,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�57>O*�X�eHJC�.903,/57*;: Ë '�� � Õ ]s8 Ë ' 8 � Ñ " Ë � Õ4Õ bcHÔB�0�KLH Ë ð'Ø�. Õ X

�S>�bà24Z�C;C(>O2TH � 512U*;>3Aa.1>O:iA4H'E�=?57*�03.\0GAa2T51*;:OZ;.90GEaC(>O57*�A�2'X Y B;H/*�bcH�=_0k8ÍH ��ATE[03,'A<0i^;57K@5124>3Ea>O6A�B;H"=?57*;51=_03.R^;H/2457*;:OZ;.90GE�572�0GA�57>O*�>O6ã,/>sH�!?,'51H/*LAD>O*;H Ë 6�>3E`o��-ä �aÕ Ñ ~ � Ò�Ó ' 03*;^�,'>O*�A4E�03,'A`A�B;Ho���ؽ*;H/:L0GA�5VKLHeE[0k8SRM~ �çÒ�Ó '98 Ë E�H'C�.903,'51*;:ºA�B;He]±>OZ;*;^�0GE�51H'2v]s8aC�Z;.1.7]W03,�Q?03*;^`C�Z;2TB;6�>3E4b\0GE�^�032c0G](>�KLH Õ XY B;512\C;E�>@,/H'242�51=aC;E�>%KLH'2\A4B;HP2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2R24>aH'KLH/*LA�Z�03.1.V8DA4H'E�=?57*�0GA�H/2/N�bu57A�B Ë ð'Ø � Õ X

�S>�b�2TZ�C;C(>O24H � �ß �¿X Y B;H/*qo��#ä � 512�03*�A�5ÛØw03=<C�.7H3NW03*;^q24><]�8"03^�FIZ;*;,'A�57>O*Ð03*;^ Ë�� Õ NWo��#ä � 572.1>O:UA�H'E�=<51*�03.|X Y B�Z;2ubcHÔ=_0�8D0GC;C�.V8 Ë õ�X ó Õ XyöSH/*;,'H Ë ð'ؽõ Õ X

Page 37: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � ��2

Y B;H'E�H�572_0�,/>O*;*;H/,'A4H/^ë,'>%KLH'E/N��v~ � ÒWÓ ' �H'A[03.7H�51*â,'>@^;51=<H/*;2451>O*â>O*;HGNR2TZ;,¨BâA�B�0GA?o���ä � 8 ß� " Ë o��vä �UÕ 572�A4E457K�5103. Ë 57*aCW0GE4A�57,/Z;.90GE � 0GE4A�51HJE Õ X $v8 Ë ó3Å�X . Õ >O6�îæó � ñ¶N�03*;^ Ë � Õ NLo��ãä � 8 572�.7>O:Ô,/03*;>O*;51,k03.®N03*;^¾.7>O:_A�H'E�=?57*�03.�0GAã2457*;:OZ;.90GEãC(>O57*�A�2'XP)wAÔ6�>O.7.1>�be2'N(]s8qA�B;Hg,/.103242457Ï�,/0GA�51>O*Ð>O6�.7>O:DA4H'E�=?57*�03. CW0357E42/N�A�B�0GA� 8 Ü � 3 X Y B�Z;2 � 572�0 (M>3E�H'*;2TA�H/57*<.1>O:M^;H/. ��H����/>;X Y 0GQ�57*;:Ô0ã6�Z�E4A�B;HJEv,/>�KLH'EåbcHu=?0�8g032T24Z;=?H3NO]�8 Ë ï�X � Õ NA�B�0GA � 3 B�032ºA4E�5VK�5103.¿03.7:OH'];E[0351,<6�Z;*;^�03=?H/*LA[03.v:3E�>OZ�C�X �uZ;*;*;51*;:qA�B;H?o���ؽzqz �ÝA�>�E�H'A4Z�E�*ÍA�> �¿57,k0GE�^*�Z;=g]±H'E�>O*;HGN�bvHP>3];A[0357* Ë ð'Ø : Õ ]�8 Ë ï�Xpï Õ X

,�51*�03.7.78LN@]�8 Ë�� X � Õ bcHÔ=_0k8D032424Z;=?HãA�B�0GA � 512R57E4E4H/^;Z;,/57]�.7H3X¿öSH'*;,/H Ë # Õ X �Ì Hãbe57.1.�Z;24HMA�B;HP6�>O.7.1>�be57*;:aE[0GA4B;H'E�03^�B;>@,ME�H/24Z;.VAe57*-A�B;HãC;E�>@>O6�>O6 Ë õ�X1ð Õ ~

���� �¿�@�Í�����-£ ¤J¥ 'Ú§¨¤?©Dª¨ù ° ¸/©s³[¤Uûy´�¥®­¾ø'ùW¬�¥®´½¤J¼�¥uª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥®´½¤¨ª5,�©G¼±¹�Â1¤'¥ Ñ ~ É�ÊgÒ�Ó ' §J¤?©_È�¤J¼(¤ ° ´¶³¤J«<§J¤�¹L¹G´�¼�Èiûy´�¥®­m´�«<©�È�¤ � À�£ ¤'¥ � Ü ' 3 §¨¤�© ° ¤�¹3ù�³[¤[¹m³Jù ° µ3¤kÀ �ãª[ª¨ù@«?¤ � «?¤[¤'¥»ª�� ¤��@©�³J¥| ·m¬�¼�³[¤©G¼±¹ +@57*;: Ë 'åÕ`©G¥�«?¬%ª¨¥Ô¬�¼�³[¤0,Ô©G¼±¹ Ñ � Ê Ë �aÕU­;©�ª_¹�¤wÈ ° ¤[¤`©G¥�Â1¤�©�ª¨¥�¥|ûv¬OÀ � ¸ Ë o��<ä �UÕ � � � Å ¥®­;¤J¼ ' 3´�ªU¹�¬�«g´»¼±©G¥+¤�¹�§/· ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼±©3Â�³Jù ° µ3¤Jª5,R©3Â}È�¤k§ ° ©G´¶³�©GÂ� ·"¤�ø'ù@´�µG©GÂ1¤J¼W¥c¥w¬�©D«gùs ¥|´ ¯ Â1¤?¬+¸ � ,\«?¤[¤J¥|´�¼@È�� ©3¥\«?¬%ª¨¥¥|ûy´¶³[¤kÀ* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ #�H'A � ß É�Ê X #�H'A�jß � � � 03*;^�516 � =?H'H'A�2�+@51*;: Ë '�Õ A�B;H/*â.7H'AÔÎtß � � +@51*;: Ë 'åÕ 03*;^>3A�B;H'ETbe5724Hã,¨B;>s>O24HÔ03*�8`24=<>@>3A�B_C(>O57*�A�Î�>O6 �é>3A�B;H'E\A�B�03* ��X Ì Hã6�>O.7.1>�b A�B;HM*;>3A[0GA�51>O*`>O6 Ë .;X1ð�Å Õ X �S>3A�HA�B�0GA Ñ ~ � Ò�Ó �PN � 8 Ò�Ó �PN�03*;^ '�¿Ò�Ó ' 0GE�HM03.1.�24H'A\]�5 FIH','A�51>O*;2\57*�0#*;H/57:OB�]±>OZ�E�B;>@>s^�>O6 ��N�03*;^`bcHbu51.1.�03.724>?Z;24H �<A�><^;H/*;>3A�HPA�B;HP57A�2uZ;*;51r@Z;HP51*LKLH'E�24Hº57=_03:OHMZ;*;^;H'EM03*�8�>O6�A�B;H/2THº=_0GC�2/X +@57=?51.10GE�.78LN�bcHG{æ.1.Z;24HMA�B;HP2�03=<HM*;>3A�0GA�51>O*�6�>3E � Ü ' 3 03*;^�57A�2R51*LKLH'E�2THP51=?03:OHM>O* '� X

#�H'A �\~ É Ê Ò�Ó � ](HS>O6�^;H/:3E�H/H = Ë =P032R57* Ë .;X1ð�Å�Xæï Õ NsbuB;51,[BD512Sðã516 � Ü '23kÕ A�>3A[03.7.78aE[03=?57Ï�H'^D>�KLH'E �03*;^ÔÎ�X�$v8 Ë .;X � Õ N �a6�03,'A�>3E42�A�B�E�>OZ;:OB?0Ô=_0GC �c~ É Ê Ò�Ó � 8 X2#�H'A �Dß � � Ê Ë � Õ 03*;^ � ß � � Ê Ë Î Õ X �S>3A�H �512 �H'A[03.7HP0GA � 03*;^-A�>3A�03.1.78<E[03=?57Ï�H'^�0GA � X Ì HP03.124>U51*;^;57,k0GA�HÔ]�8 �`A�B;HP57*;^;Z;,/H/^"=_0GC É�Ê�Ò�Ó '� X �S>3A�HÑ � Ê Ë �UÕ ß $ î �Gñ¶N � � Ê Ë �UÕ ß = $ î �Wñ¶N;6�>3Eu24>O=?H $ - ó@X

#�H'A�ÄßtöS>O= Ë É Ê �-' � Ë = $ Ò ð Õ î �Wñ�Ü �UÕ �

$v8 Ë�� X1: Õ 57Aå512yH/*;>OZ;:OBUA�>Ô2TB;>%bâA�B�0GA � :O57KLH/2�0M^;>O=<51*�0GA�57*;:M6�03=<51.78P>O6�E[0GA451>O*�03.�,/Z�ETKLH/2 Ë *;H/,/H/24240GE�51.V8LN]�8Í^;H/:3E�H/HD,/>O*;2457^;H'E[0GA�57>O*;2/Ny=?H/H'A451*;: � 0GAg=?>O2TAºAwbu51,/H Õ X +@Z�C;C±>O24H`A�B;512#6�0357.12/Ny>3EgH/rsZ;57KG03.1H/*LA�.78LN A�B�0GA=_0GC�2R51* � B�0�KLHMÏ"�;H/^�51=_03:OH ��� Ê Ë � Õ X Y B;H/*-]�8 Ë .;X1ð�Å�X ó Õ 6�>3E

�"ß öS>O= Ë É Ê �,� 8 � Ë = $ Ò ð Õ î �Wñ�Ü $ î �Gñ Õ �A�B;HÔ*�0GA�Z�E[03.�r@Z�03245ÛضÏ�*;5VA�HÔ=?0GC � Ò±Ó � 572u24Z�E»FIH/,'A�5VKLHº*;Hk0GEºî �sñ¶X

� ]sK@51>OZ;24.V8LNs6�>3E\03*L8a*;>O*@ؽ,/>O*;2TA�03*�A\=_0GC��ã~ É�Ê�Ò�Ó � 8 N�A�B;H�.7H/*;:3A�B_>O6�� � Ê Ë $ î �Gñ Õ 0GAv03*�8UC(>O57*�Av51*?5VA�224Z�C;C±>3E4Ay512�^;5VK�512T57]�.1H�]s8 $ X Y B�Z;2/NL2451*;,/H $ - ó@NL0GA�.1Hk032TA�24H'A�A�B;H/>3E4H'A�51,/03.1.78 �ÐßtöS>O= Ë É�Ê �,� 8 � =;î ��ñ(ÜÝî �Gñ Õ X$v8 Ë�� Xpï Õ A�B;HÔ.90GA4A4H'ERB�032Sô�0GE�512IQ�5(A[03*;:OH/*LA�2ICW03,/H

� 3 Ë � " � # � Ë Ò .7>O: � ÕTÕ ß � 3 Ë ��� � Ë Ò .1>O: � ÕTÕ ß � 3 Ë76 � � Ë ð ÕTÕ

Page 38: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

0GA�î �sñ±03*;^aA�BsZ;2�B�032¿^;57=?H/*;2457>O*_0GA¿=<>O2TAyA+bv>;X2$\Z�Aå]�8 Ë�� Xæï Õ A�B;He^;57=?H/*;2457>O*<>O6 � 572¿0GA�.1H/032TA Ò = Ë o��cä�UÕ � ��ä�ï - ï<0GAºî �sñ¶N�0U,/>O*�ATE[03^;51,'A451>O*�N �

�S>3A�HRA�B�0GA Ë õ�X . Õ ,k03*;*;>3A¿](H�H �@A�H/*;^;H/^_A�>ÔA�B;H�,k0324H�� � � ß�ðOX ,W>3EvH �;03=<C�.1HRA[0GQLHe6�>3E � 0 Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLH>O*�0U24=?>s>3A�B�2TZ�E�6�03,/H3N±03*;^-6�>3E � 24>O=?Hã,/Z�E4KLHÔ=?H/H'A�57*;:��ç*;>3E�=_03.1.V8`0GAu>O*;HÔC(>O57*�A/X

* ° ¬�¬+¸º¬I¸ � �3À A � À $v8 Ë õ�Xpï Õ N�bcHP=_0k8`03242TZ;=?HÔbcHMB�0kKLHÔC;E�>3C±H'E4A�57H/2 Ë õ�Xæï�X1ð'Ø # Õ X�S>3A�H<A4B�0GA � 572#H/57A4B;H'Ea0�24=?>@>3A4BÍH/.1.757C;A�57,?,/Z�E4KLH3Nå>3EU0-E[0GA�57>O*�03.¿,/Z�ETKLH`bu57A4B�0"*;>s^;H3X�)+6 ' ß É��

A[0GQLHUA[03*;:OH/*LAº.157*;H/2ÔA4> � X � A�B;H'E4bu5124H<.1H'A Rë~ �àÒ�Ó É�Ê ](HaA�B;H É�Ê Ø|Ï;];E[0GA�51>O*Í>O6 Ë ï�X : Õ N�>3];A[0357*;H/^¾]�8H �@A4E[03,'A�57*;:<A�B;H Ò ó%ؽ,/Z�ETKLHEU_X � Ü � 3 512�0?^;>OZ�]�.1H#,/>�KLH'EkX $c8DA�B;HºöSZ�ETbe5VA �º6�>3E�=gZ;.90�N�2451*;,'HERÍB�032S0GA=?>O2TA\>O*;HÔ=gZ;.7A�5VC�.1H�Ï;];E�H3N�A�B;H'E4HÔ572u0U24=?>s>3A�B_Ï;];E�H�� Ü � 3 =?H'H'A�51*;: � HG��03,'A�.V8_>O*;,/H3N;bu57A�B�� 03*;^ �2457=<C�.78?A�03*;:OH/*�A Ë 0GAu0#C(>O57*�AR>O6 �03/Õ X@#�H'A � Ü ' ](HãA�B;Hã51=?03:OHS>O6 �aX +@57*;,/H�U 572u0g24H/,JA�51>O*�N � =?H/HJA�2+@51*;: Ë 'åÕ >O*;,/H3X �S>�b 0GC;C�.78 Ë õ�X . Õ X �7��sþ½�����Í�»� ým¡����@ÿL�»� K¿�%�;�%�»��� � KvÿL� �%���@¡ � Ü 'c�öSH'E�H�bcHc:O57KLHv2T>O=?Hv,'E�5VA�H'E�510e6�>3E�buB;H/*U0�=UZ;.VA�57C�.7Hv>O6�0eE[0GA�57>O*�03.@,/Z�ETKLH �çÜ ' ^;H/6�>3E�=?2/NL032�0eE[0GA�51>O*�03.

,/Z�E4KLHGN�A�>a^;>O=?51*�0GA�H '23 X Y B;HP51^;Hk0<572uA�><.15169A Ë 03*�H'*;^;>O=?>3E4C�B;512T= >O6 Õ � A�>aA�B;HÔ]�Z;:;N±03*;^-A�B;H/*q0GC;C�.V8^;H/6�>3E�=?0GA�51>O*DA�B;H/>3E48LXöSH'E�HM512\A�B;HÔ=_0351*D,'E�5VA�H'E�510�N;^;5124,/Z;2T24H/^q51*DA�B;HÔ57*�ATE�>@^;Z;,'A451>O*�X

��� � �¿���Í������£ ¤J¥ '맨¤�©M¼(¬ ° «<©GÂ�ª¨ù ° ¸/©s³[¤\ûy´�¥®­<ø'ù�¬G¥®´¶¤'¼�¥�ª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ª/À¿£ ¤'¥ Ñ ~ � Ò�Ó 't§¨¤e©SÈ�¤J¼(¤ ° ´¶³¤J«<§J¤�¹L¹G´�¼�È , ûy´»¥»­ � ß É�Ê�,�ª¨ù�³J­<¥®­�©G¥ Ñ � Ê Ë +@51*;: Ë 'åÕ4Õ�´�ªe¥®ûc¬ ¯ ¬G´�¼�¥®ª5, Î , � Àc£ ¤J¥ � , �¾§¨¤�¥»­;¤�Â1¬�³�©G±´�¼±¹3´¶³[¤¨ª¬+¸ � ß Ñ Ë �ºÕ?©3¥ Ñ Ë Î Õ-, Ñ Ë� Õ �½ûy­;¤J¼ Ñ Ë Î Õ ß Ñ Ë�� Õa¥»­�´�ªU«?¤�©G¼�ªU¥»­�¤a´�¼±¹G´½³[¤¨ª?¬+¸g¥®­;¤a¥|ûv¬q§ ° ©G¼(³J­;¤¨ª � À � ¸Ò o�� � � - ð�� �Uä�ð�� �¾¥»­�¤J¼4' 3 ´�ªMù@¼�´ ° ù@Â1¤�¹ ,\¹�¬�«g´�¼(©G¥w¤[¹`§'· ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼(©G ³Jù ° µ3¤¨ª#©GÂ}È�¤k§ ° ©G´¶³�©3Â� ·D¤[ø'ùs´»µG©GÂ1¤J¼�¥¥+¬`©<«gù@ ¥|´ ¯ Â1¤<¬+¸ � À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ #�H'A��h03*;^ Ð](H?A�B;H_E[03=?5VÏ�,k0GA�57>O*�51*;^;57,/H/2g>O6 � ~ � 8 Ò±Ó � >�KLH'E�Î�03*;^ � N�buB;H'E�H � 8 572ºA�B;H*;>3E�=_03.7512�0GA451>O*�>O6 � � Ê Ë � Õ X4$c8 Ë .;X1ð�Å�Xæï ÕUÒ o�� � � - ð����`äÝð���WX4#�H'A �c~ É Ê Ò�Ó � ](HD0"=_0GCj>O6^;H/:3E�H'H � WN�A4>3A[03.1.V8ÍE[03=?57Ï�H'^h0G](>�KLHUÎ�N � X $v8 Ë .;X1: Õ N�A�B;HJE�H-572?0i.75169A�57*;: � 8 ~ É Ê Ò�Ó � 8 X�$v8 Ë � Xpï Õ NöS>O= Ë É�Ê �,� 8 Õ 512�2T=?>@>3A�B-0GAUî � 8 ñ >O6�^;51=<H/*;2451>O* �UäMä ðOX $v8 Ë � Xpï Õ NWöS>O= Ë É�Ê �-'�wÕ B�032�^;57=?H/*;2457>O*"0GA.1H/032TA Ò � so�� � � äâó@X Y B;HãE�H/2TZ;.7A�*;>�bç6�>O.1.7>%bu2e69E4>O= Ë .;X1ð�Å�X ó Õ 03*;^ Ë�� X � Õ X �Ì HS*;>3A�H�A4B�0GAc51*_A�B;H�C;E�>s>O6�>O6 Ë õ�X � Õ bcHã03,JA�Z�03.1.V8?>3];A[0357*�0º]�5VAc=?>3E�H3X�)wAk{}2cH/*;>OZ;:OB`A�>#:OH'A\o�� � � -

ð��'= Ë Î Õ äÐð��'= Ë�� Õ beB;HJE�H =ã512å032å51* Ë .;X1ð�Å�Xæï Õ Ë *;>3A�H\]s8 Ë .;X7ð�Å�Xpï Õ N � � � ^;57K@51^;H = Ë Î Õ N = Ë� Õ Ns03*;^UA�B;H'8a0GE�HR*;>3A51*q:OH/*;HJE[03.�H/rsZ�03. Õ Xe)+*Ð0GC;C�.157,k0GA�57>O*;2ebcHºbu51.1.�Q�*;>�b�B;>�b �� Ü �' =<H/H'A�2eA4B;H#H �;,/HJC;A�51>O*�03.�.7>@,/Z;2'X?,WE4>O=A�B;572 Ë 03*;^DA4B;HS^;H/24,'E�5VC;A�51>O*D>O6�A�B;HãH �;,'H'C;A�51>O*�03.±.1>@,'Z;2 Õ 57Ac572cHk032T8?A4>U,'>O=<C�Z�A�H�A�B;Hã.1>s,k03.(03*�03.V8@A�57,�51*;^;HG�>O6 Ë 2T>O=?HS];E[03*;,[B">O6 Õ �PX Y B;HP*�Z;=#](H'E�2 = Ë Î Õ 03*;^ = Ë� Õ ,k03*"03.724>a]±HP,/>O=aC�Z�A�H/^-69E4>O=×A�B;572u^;H'24,'E�5VC;A�51>O*Ë buB;51,[BU0369A�H'Ey03.7.s^;HJA�H'E�=?57*;H/2�A�B;H¿CW035VE Ë '�� � Õ .7>@,k03.7.78P03*�03.78sA�51,k03.7.78 Õ Nk]�Z�A�A�B;Hc03*�03.78@24512 512�=?>3E4H¿51*LKL>O.7KLH'^�XÌ HÔZ;24HÔA�B;HãbcHk0GQLHJE�,'E�5VA�H'E�57>O*�NW03*;^-57A42RCW0GE4A4*;H'Ee]±H/.1>�bPNW032\A�B;H'8`A�Z�E�*->OZ�AuA�>a24Z"!?,'H3X

Page 39: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � � 0

)+*`=?>O2TA\0GC;C�.751,k0GA�57>O*;2c>O6 Ë õ�X � Õ N �"03*;^ � bu51.7.�](HSH'r@Z�03.|N�03*;^�Hk03,[B`];E[03*;,[B�>O6 � be57.1.�B�0�KLH�A�B;Hã2�03=<H51*;^;HG��N�A�B;Hã51*;^;HG�D>O6�A�B;Hã2457*;:OZ;.90GE\C(>O57*�A Ë 6�>3ERH �;03=<C�.1HuA�B;512\B;>O.1^;2cbuB;H/*-H/03,¨BD];E[03*;,[B-572R.7>O:#A�H'E�=?57*�03.|N>3Ev]�8 Ë .;X1ð�Å�Xpï Õ 516�*;H'57A�B;H'Ec];E�03*;,¨B`572 � 0GE4A�51HJE\03*;^?A�B;H�2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8<B�032¿C;E451=?Hu51*;^;H � Õ X�)I6(A4B;H�51*;H/rsZ�03.15VA+851* Ë õ�X � Õ 6�0351.12'N@bcHãbe57.1.±.7>@>3Q_6�>3Eu0g24H/,/>O*;^�,/Z�E4KLHã>O6 A4B;HM2403=?HS24>3E4AkN;57*�>3E4^;H'E\A�>U0GC;C�.78_A�B;Hã*;H �@ARE4H/24Z;.7A/~

����� �¿���Í������£ ¤J¥ ' §J¤�©¾¼(¬ ° «<©GÂcª¨ù ° ¸k©�³[¤Dûy´�¥®­hø'ùW¬�¥|´¶¤J¼�¥Ôª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ª/À�£ ¤'¥ Ñ ~ � ß É�ÊqÒ±Ó ' ,�c~�ÞÚß É�Ê�Ò�Ó ' §¨¤ã¥®ûc¬ºÈ�¤J¼(¤ ° ´¶³P¤J«<§¨¤�¹�¹G´�¼@È�ª0,�ªJù�³¨­_¥®­�©G¥ Ñ Ë �ºÕ � +@51*;: Ë 'åÕ ß � Î � , � Ë Þ Õ � +@51*;: Ë 'åÕ ß� � � , � Ê ß Ñ Ë �ºÕ �ß � Ë Þ Õ ß � � ©G¼(¹�ª¨ùW³¨­h¥»­;©G¥ Ñ � Ê Ë Î Õi©G¼(¹ � � Ê Ë� Õi© ° ¤¾¤�©�³¨­�© ¯ ©G´ ° ¬+¸ ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥®ª/À.Wù ¯L¯ ¬%ª�¤R¸¨ù ° ¥®­;¤ ° ¥®­�©G¥M¤�©�³J­�¬+¸g¥»­�¤aÂ1¬�³�©GÂv§ ° ©G¼�³¨­;¤¨ª?¬+¸ � Ê � ° ¤¨ª ¯ À � � � ­�©Gµ3¤U¥®­;¤Uª/©3«?¤a´�¼±¹s¤�� � � ° ¤Jª ¯ Àn � ©G¥ Î � ° ¤¨ª ¯ À � � û�­;¤ ° ¤ � � ° ¤Jª ¯ À n � ´�ª�¥»­�¤S´»¼±¹�¤��`¬+¸�¥»­;¤Sª¨ù ° ¸k©�³[¤Ô©G¥ Î � ° ¤¨ª ¯ À � � À��ãª[ªJùs«?¤ã¥®­;¤ ° ¤M© ° ¤¯ ¬�´»¼�¥»ª � ©G¼±¹ �j¬I¸cÉ�ÊUª¨ùW³¨­�¥®­�©G¥ Ñ Ë � Õ ß � Ë ��Õ � ' 3 À

Á ­;¤'¼ ' 3 ´�ªÔùs¼�´ ° ù@Â1¤�¹LÀ* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ $v8 Ë õ�X � Õ bcHã=_0k8_032T24Z;=?H � Ñ Ë �ºÕ� o��_ßtn�� Ë �PÕ�� o��_ß Ò ðOX�íS2c57*DA�B;HSC;E�>s>O6�>O6 Ë õ�X � Õ NsA4B;H'E�H0GE�H �H'A[03.7Hg=_0GC�2S>O6¿^;H/:3E4H/H �j03*;^iniN � 8 ~ É Ê Ò�Ó � 8 03*;^�� 8 ~ É Ê ÒWÓ Þ 8 N�buB;H'E�H � 8 03*;^ÐÞ 8 0GE�H#A�B;H*;>3E�=_03.7512�0GA451>O*;2e>O6�� � Ê Ë � Ê Õ 03*;^ ��� Ê Ë � � Õ X #�H'A � ](HºA�B;HºZ;*;57>O* Ë be5VA�B�*;>3E�=?03. ,'E4>O242451*;: Õ >O6 � 8 03*;^Þ 8 0GA�� 8 Ë � Õ 03*;^�� 8 Ë ��Õ X # HJA � ](H#A�B;HgZ;*;51>O*i>O6åAwbc>D,/>3C�57H/2ã>O6 É�Ê FI>O51*;H/^¾03.1>O*;: �m03*;^ � X Y B;HJE�Ha57203*"51*;^;Z;,'H/^q=?>3E4C�B;512T= �O~ � Ò±Ó � X%# HJA�� Ò�Ó � ]±H#0?>O*;Hº^;57=?H/*;2457>O*�03. ^;H/6�>3E4=_0GA�51>O*->O6 � A�>_024=?>s>3A�B�E�0GA�51>O*�03.�,/Z�E4KLHGX $v8�îVð # ñ�öS>O= � Ë � �-' � �UÕ B�032�^;51=<H/*;2451>O*�0GA�.1H/032TA � N�beB;57.1HÔöS>O= Ë � � � ÕB�032S^;51=<H/*;2451>O*q6�>OZ�EkN�2T51*;,/HU0?^;H/6�>3E�=?0GA�51>O*">O6��c512S:O5VKLH/*�]s8 �HJA[03.1Hº=?0GC�2 É�ʺÒ�Ó � 03*;^ É�ÊÔÒ±Ó Þ Nbu57A�BDA�B;HP57=_03:OHS>O6 �Ð03*;^ � Ï"��H/^�X Y BsZ;2 '�3 512RZ;*;57E�Z;.7H/^�X �íS*-HG��03=<C�.7HÔ0GC;C�.751,k0GA451>O*->O6 Ë õ�X � Õ 572Rbc>3ETQLH/^�>OZ�Au51* Ë õ�X1ð�Å Õ XÌ HãC;E�H/24H'*�Aã0gA�B�E�H/HÔ^;51=?H'*;2451>O*�03.(KLH'E42451>O*�>O6 Ë õ�X ó Õ Ë ^;.VAe572u^;HJÏ�*;H/^"51*�îæó � ñ Õ ~

����� �¿���Í�����-£ ¤J¥¿¦ §¨¤_© ¯(° ¬+²k¤¨³J¥®´»µ3¤a¥®­ ° ¤[¤®¸k¬�Â7¹-ûy´»¥»­m©Ð¹@ ¥Ô¹G´»µ�´�ªk¬ ° o_ftä U Ê ä�U � û�­�¤ ° ¤ U Ê ©3¼±¹U � © ° ¤º´ °J° ¤�¹3ù�³J´¶§'Â1¤g©G¼(¹?¼(¬ ° «<©GÂ7À㣠¤J¥ � ß U Ê � U � À � ¸ � � U � ©G¼(¹?Ò � � Ë o_fâä U Ê ä U � Õa© ° ¤U§¨¬�¥®­¯ ¬%ªJ´�¥®´»µ3¤M¥»­�¤J¼ Ë ¦�� U Ê ä U � ÕP´�ªÔÂ1¬�È?ù@¼�´ ° ùsÂ1¤�¹�À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ $v8ÍíS^�FIZ;*;,JA�51>O* � ßLU Ê�� U � 512g0q24=?>s>3A�B�E[0GA�57>O*�03.v,/Z�E4KLH3XiíÖ.1>@,/03.c03*�03.78sA�51,?^;H'24,'E�5VC;A�51>O*03.1>O*;: � 512º:O5VKLH/*Í51* Ë ð�õ�X1ð � X ó Õ >O6Mîæó � ñ|X_)I*ÍCW0GE4A451,/Z;.10GE ¦ B�032ºr@Z;>3A451H/*LA#2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2º03.1>O*;: � X>#�H'A�@~ ¦ PÒ�Ó ¦ ]±H_0�24=?>s>3A�B¾]�Z;:GؽHJ8LH/^m,/>%KLHJEkX Y B;H/*m516vbcH<24H'AEU 8� ß ��� Ê Ë U � Õ A�B;H/* U 8Ê 03*;^ U 8� 0GE�H24=?>s>3A�B"03*;^q,'E�>O2T2M*;>3E4=_03.1.V8-03.7>O*;: � 8 ß � � Ê Ë �PÕ X�íS^�FIZ;*;,'A451>O*q24B;>�be2SA�B�0GASo # ��512S*;H/:L0GA�5VKLH#03*;^q24>A�B;H'E4HU572M0`2TZ�E®FIH/,'A�57>O* �v~ É�Ê#ÒWÓ � 8 X �S>�b 0GC;C�.V8 Ë�� Xpõ Õ N(,[B;H/,�Q�51*;:D24H/=<57C(>O2T57A�5VK�57Aw8-032ã51*"A�B;H#C;E�>@>O6å>O6Ë õ�Xpó Õ X �� � �%�»���K»���J����þg����� �W¢%�)wA#512ÔC(>O24245V]�.1H?A�>"B�0kKLH Ñ ~ É Ê Ò�Ó ' N�24Z;,[BmA�B�0GAg*;>"=gZ;.7A�5VC�.1H?>O6 Ñ ^;H/6�>3E4=?2ºA�>",/>�KLH'E ' X�öSHJE�H

]�8Ð0`=gZ;.VA�57C�.7HºbcHg=?Hk03*Ð0_,/>O=<C(>O2T57A�57>O* �Dß Ñ � �(N�6�>3E�Ð03*ÐH/*;^;>O=?>3ETC�B;5124=Ä>O6 É Ê X Y BsZ;2ã5VAÔ572S*;>3A

Page 40: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

��+ ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

24Z"!<,/51H/*LA\6�>3EcC;E�>�K�57*;:ºZ;*;57E�Z;.7H/^;*;H/242\A�>PÏ�*;^D0PE[0GA451>O*�03.W,/Z�E4KLHS.15769A�51*;:ÔA�> '� NsbvHS*;H/H/^`24>O=?HS03^;^;5VA�51>O*�03..1>s,k03.�51*;6�>3E4=_0GA�51>O*�X2,W>3EeHG��03=<C�.7H3~����� ��� �W� � K��±�>.�ù ¯L¯ ¬%ªk¤ � ´�ªP© ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼(©G ³Jù ° µ3¤0,åªJ«?¬�¬�¥®­-©Gû¿©G·u¸ ° ¬�« +@57*;: ' ,¿«?¤[¤J¥|´�¼@È +@51*;: '祮ûy´½³[¤0,ûy´�¥®­�¤�©�³J­¾§ ° ©G¼�³¨­�¬+¸��ìÂ1¬�È-¥+¤ ° «g´»¼±©GÂ1,S©G¼(¹�ª¨ùW³¨­q¥»­;©G¥ã¤[©�³¨­�¬+¸g¥®­;¤gª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© °�¯ ¬�´»¼�¥»ªa©GÂ1¬G¼@È�� ­�©�ªg¥®­;¤ª/©G«_¤º´�¼(¹�¤�� , n À㣠¤J¥ Ñ ~ É�ÊÔÒ�Ó '�g§¨¤#¥»­�¤ n ¥+¬�¬�¼�¤ºÂ ´Ç¸J¥¿¥+¬`¥»­�¤g§'ùLÈGú4¤J·�¤�¹�³[¬�µ3¤ ° �I©GªP´�¼i¥»­�¤ ¯±° ¬�¬+¸a¬+¸� �3À � � � À

� ¸ � �3À�� � ¸/©G´�Âpª0,奻­�©3¥¿´�ªM´Ç¸SÒ o�� � � ßÝð��Gn ¥®­;¤J¼i¼(¬a«gù@ ¥®´ ¯ Â1¤a¬I¸ Ñ ¹�¤»¸k¬ ° «#ªM¥+¬D³¨¬�µ3¤ ° '�'À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ � � Ê Ë �PÕ B�032c24=?>s>3A�B<];E[03*;,[B;H/2'N�A�BsZ;2 �å~ � ¿Ò�Ó '� 512cZ;*�E[03=?5VÏ�H/^�N�03*;^ � # � 572c0º24Z�];]�Z;*;^;.1HM>O6�" Ë � ��� Õ X Ñ 6�03,'A�>3E42ãA4B�E�>OZ;:OB�03* �H'A[03.7HU=?0GC É�Ê#Ò±Ó � A�B�Z;2 � � � 572M0D24Z�];]�Z;*;^;.7H<>O6 Ñ " Ë � � � Õ XE+@57*;,/HÑ " Ë � ��� Õ B�032u^;H/:3E4H/H?ðON�A�B;HÔr@Z;>3A�57H/*�ARA�B;HMr@Z;>3A�57H/*LAe572 6�Ë Ò ð Õ 03*;^-A�B�Z;2

Ñ " Ë � � � Õ ß 6DË ó Õ 8 6�Ë Ò ð Õ �#�H'A�"](HU03*ÐH/*;^;>O=?>3E4C�B;5724=Ä>O6 É�Ê >O6y^;H/:3E�H/H ��N�03*;^i.7H'A �-ß Ñ � �±X Y B;Haô�0GE4512TQ@5 A[03*;:OH/*LAM2TCW03,/H#A�>öS>O= Ë É�Ê �-'�wÕ 0GA��`572

� 3 Ë � " Ë � � � Õ4Õ ß � 3 Ë76�Ë ó � Õ 8 6�Ë Ò � Õ4ÕbuB;51,[B�B�032"^;57=?H/*;2457>O*�ó ��äÚðOXÄöS>O= Ë É�Ê � ��� Ê Ë �ºÕTÕ B�032"^;51=?H/*;2T51>O* 0GA �ç0GA�.1Hk032TA"A4B;HÍ^;51=?H/*;2T51>O*>O6SöS>O= Ë É Ê �4É Ê Õ 0GA �±NcbeB;57,[Bâ512_03.724>mó �aä ðOX Y BsZ;2_öS>O= Ë É Ê �-' Õ 512?24=<>@>3A�B�0GA �(Nv03*;^âH/r@Z�03.\A�>öS>O= Ë É Ê � � � Ê Ë �ºÕ4Õ X �

� *;HP51*;2IA[03*;,/HP>O6 Ë õ�X : Õ 572uA�B;HM,/Z�E4KLH� ��� � 51* Ë ð � X ó Õ X���(' ��� �W� � K���¡ �Ô�v����� ü K��q�?���%� % �@���â��� � % �%�@�����

Ë ð Õ )+6 � 512y0S,/Z�E4KLH\57*gA4B;Hc24=?>@>3A4B#.1>@,'Z;2�>O6 4�A4B;H/* Ò o

���� � - � ä_ó@X �S>3A�Hc57*U,'>O*�A4E�032TAyA�B�0GA�516 ¦

572�0<24=<>@>3A�BDC;E�>GFIH/,'A�5VKLH �±Ø½^;57=?H/*;2457>O*�03. ,±03*;><KG0GE�57H'Aw8LN�A4B;H/*�A�B;HP]±H/*;^q03*;^-];E�Hk0GQ�A�H/,[B;*;51rsZ;H/2:O5VKLHMA�B�0GA ¦ 572u,'>%KLH'E4H/^-]�8�E[0GA451>O*�03.�,/Z�E4KLH'2 � be5VA�B � �OÒ o_f � �<äëðOX

Ë ó Õ #�H'A ' ]±H`A4B;H�,/>O*;H`>�KLH'Ea0"24=?>@>3A4BjH'.1.15VC;A�51,_,'Z�E4KLH3X Y B;H/* ' 512U0q.1>O:q,k03*;>O*;57,k03.c24Z�E�6�03,/HD>O6��51,k0GE�^m*�Z;=#](H'EU>O*;H3N�bu57A�B Ò o���03=<C�.1HGN�]�Z�A ' 3 ,/>O*LA[0351*;2g*;>"E[0GA�57>O*�03.¿,/Z�E4KLH'2/X �S>3A�HaA�B�0GA>O*;HÔ,k03*",[B;>@>O24H � Ü ' 3 03*�8D,/Z�E4KLHGN(03*;^-A�B;H'*q0GC;C�.78�zÐ>3E45|{æ2 $cH/*;^"03*;^ $vE�Hk0GQ�0GE�:OZ;=?H'*�ARA�>C;E�>s^;Z;,/Hã0ÔE[0GA451>O*�03.W,/Z�E4KLH3N@]�Z�Av*;>#=_0GA4A�H'E�B;>�bt:OH/*;HJE[03.1.V8<>O*;H�,[B;>s>O24H/2 � NsA�B;HeE[0GA�57>O*�03.�,/Z�E4KLHbu51.7.�=?H/H'A\A�B;HÔ2451*;:OZ;.10GEuC±>O51*LAkX

Ë ï Õ ��51,�QM03*�8ãA�B�E4H/H/6�>O.1^ T N�03*;^#03*L8M24=?>@>3A4BÔ,/Z�ETKLH � 51* T X $c.1>�bÍZ�C T 03.7>O*;: � X Y B;H¿H ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.^;5VK�512T>3Ev512v0ÔE�Z;.1H'^_24Z�E�6�03,/H RM~ '�ÒWÓ � X �S>�b ]�.1>�btZ�CD03:L0357*�N�03.1>O*;:º0º24H/,'A�57>O*_>O6 R�be5VA�B<KLH'ET8B;57:OB"24H/.161ض51*LA�H'E�2TH/,'A�57>O*�N±A�>?>3];A[0357*"0?24=?>s>3A�B�A4B�E�H/H/6�>O.7^ �PX%#�H'A U ]±HPA�B;Hº2IA4E�51,JA�A4E[03*;246�>3E4= >O6' N�03*;^�� ](HeA�B;He:OH/*;H'E[03.WÏ;];E�HS>O6 U�>�KLH'E � X Y B;H�,/>O*;H�>O6 �t>�KLH'E T 572¿Awbc>º^;57=?H/*;2457>O*�03.±03*;^�Ú:OH'*;H'E[0GA�H/2ã>O*;HgH/^;:OH3X�+@57*;,/H Ë o��-ä U Õ � � ß Ò ó@N(bcHg=_0�8LNW]s8-A�B;Hg,/>O*�ATE[03,'A�57>O*qA4B;H/>3E�H/=�N

Page 41: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � ��.

,/>O*LA4E[03,JA U×^;>%bu*iA4> � A�>D>3];A[0351* ¦ N�0 � ؽ6»03,'A�>3E45903.vA�B�E�H'H/6�>O.1^�>�KLH'E T X0+@51*;,/HUo�� � �àß Å�N¦ 512 (ã>3E�H/*;2TA4H/51*i03*;^q,k03*;>O*;51,k03.®X �S>%b�A�B;H#H ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.�^;57K@5124>3ES>O6 ¦ >%KLHJE T 572S^;>O=?51*�0GA4H/^]�8`o_f�ؽ*;H/:L0GA�5VKLHã,/Z�E4KLH/2u,/>O*�A�0351*;H/^�51* ¦43 N�]�Z�Au516 T 5VA�24H/.76 ,/>O*LA[0357*;2u*;>gE[0GA�57>O*�03.�,/Z�E4KLH/2\A�B;H/*H'KLHJE48`E[0GA�51>O*�03.�,'Z�E4KLHP57* ¦ =?H'H'A�2 +@51*;: Ë ¦iÕ X

Ë . Õ )+*Öîòï � ñaô�B�03*;:t:O57KLH/2iH ��03=<C�.7H/2Ð>O6?.1>O:�A�H'E�=?57*�03. É�Ê Ø¶Ï;];E[0GA451>O*;2 Ñ ~ � Ò�Ó É�Ê 24Z;,[B�A�B�0GA, Ë Ò o�� Õ ßÄó"]�Z�A � 3 572 ¼�¬�¥ 2457=<C�.78¾,/>O*;*;H/,'A4H/^�X�)+*�CW0GE4A�57,/Z;.90GE � 3 512g*;>3AgE[0GA�51>O*�03.7.78¾,/>O*@Ø*;H/,JA�H/^�X4$v8 Ë )IHgXpï�X7ð�Å�Xpï Õ >O6Ôîæó3õGñ¿A4B;H?Ï;];E�H/2g>O6 Ñ 0GE�H?A�B;H_Z;*;51rsZ;H_6�03=?51.V8¾>O6cE[0GA451>O*�03.¿,'Z�E4KLH/2^;>O=?57*�0GA�51*;: � 3 N�buB;51.7H�03*L8mAwbc>iC±>O51*LA�2a>O6 � 3 0GE�HD,/>O*;*;H/,'A4H/^�]�8�0Ð24=?>s>3A�Bm,/>O=<C�.1HJA�H�o��*;H/:L0GA457KLHM,/Z�E4KLHP,'>O*�A[0357*;H/^�57* � 3 Ë A[0GQLHÔ0aB;57:OB-=gZ;.7A457C�.1Hã>O6�03*-03=<C�.1Hã^;5VK�512T>3E Õ X

� �®��������������&�� �ã �������s���(�� �öSH'E�HSbcHãbc>3E4Q_A4B�E�>OZ;:OB�>O*;HMH �;03=<C�.1Hã0GC;C�.751,k0GA�57>O*�>O6 Ë õ�X � Õ 51*D,/>O*;2451^;HJE[0G]�.1HÔ^;H'A[0351.®X Ì HÔB;>3C±HSA�B�0GA

0369A�H'EM^;57:OH/2TA�57*;:DA�B;572ãH ��03=<C�.7H3N±A�B;H#E�H/03^;H'EÔbu51.7.�B�0kKLHU.757A4A4.1HºA4E�>OZ�]�.7Hg6�>O.1.1>�bu51*;:_A�B;HU03*�03.1>O:O>OZ;2/N(]�Z�AÔ>O6*;H/,/H'242457Aw8?E�0GA�B;H'EvA�HJE�24H3N;03*�03.V8�24572¿>O6 � ð � 03*;^ � ð # N�beB;HJE�H�bcHS0GC;C�.V8 Ë õ�X � Õ A�>ºH/03,¨B`>O6(A�B;HuE�>OZ;:OB;.78<245 �@A+824Z�E�6�03,'H/2 ' � �åX� B;>@>O24Hi0�,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E�0GA�51>O* 57* É � >O6P0�,/>O*;57, � NS0j24H/,k03*LA�.751*;H � Nã03*;^é0jA[03*;:OH'*�A�.157*;H � X #�H'A

� � � � �eß � � � 03*;^ � ß � � � Ë 2TH/H ,�57:OZ�E�HPï�N Ë :�X7ð Õ4Õ X#�H'A �'�Ò�Ó É�� ](HÔ>3];A[0351*;H'^-]s8`]�.7>%bu51*;:?Z�C"ïUA�57=?H/2R0GA � NW03.1>O*;: � N Ë A�B�0GAu512e6�Z�ETA�B;H'Ee]�.7>%b Z�C�2e0GE�H

0GAPA4B;H<C(>O57*�AP>O6vA�B;H?2TA4E451,'AÔA4E[03*;246�>3E�=ì>O6 � .V8�51*;:->%KLH'E � Õ � A�51=?H'2º0GA � 03.1>O*;: � 03*;^ � A�51=?H'2P0GA �03.1>O*;: � X #�H'A �'éÒ�Ó ' ,'>O*�A4E�03,'AÔA4B;HU,'Z�E4KLH/2P>O*ÐbeB;57,[B¾o��� 512ã*;>O*;*;H/:L0GA457KLH3X Y B;HUE4H/24Z;.7A451*;:-2TZ�E�6�03,/HB�032eAwbc>_2457*;:OZ;.90GEuC(>O51*LA�2/~ ��ß Ë ó # � �� � ó � ó � ó � ó Õ N�51*;^;H � � � N±03*;^ � ß Ë ó � ó � . � � ó � ó � ó � ó � ó � ó Õ N�51*;^;HG�� ó@N�beB;H'E4H<6�>3EºHG��03=<C�.7H?ó # 57*;^;51,k0GA�H'2ÔA�B�0GAMA�B;512 Ò ó%ؽ,/Z�E4KLH<512ÔA4B;Ha2TATE�51,'AÔA4E[03*;246�>3E4= >O6 � Ë A4B;H<51*;^;HG�,k03*-]±HÔ,/03.1,/Z;.10GA�H/^�Z;2457*;: Ë ï�X7ðOX : Õ >O6cî}ó � ñ Õ XÌ H#Z;24HE#�H/=?=?0 Ë õ�X � Õ A�>`0GE�:OZ;HºA�B�0GA ' 3 512�Z;*;5VE�Z;.1H'^�X Ì H#.1>@>3Q�6�>3ESE[0GA�57>O*�03. ,/Z�ETKLH/2 � Ü ' N±2TZ;,¨B

A�B�0GA�� � +@51*;: Ë 'åÕ 572�0?2457*;:O.1HMC(>O51*LAkNLÎ�N �ÝB�032eAwbc>?03*�03.78@A451,ã];E[03*;,[B;H/2M0GAeA�B;572uC(>O57*�A/N Ë bcHMbe57.1. 0G]�Z;24H*;>3A[0GA�57>O*-03*;^�2�0k8�� B�032u0U*;>s^;HP0GA�Î�N�H'KLH/*DA�B;>OZ;:OB-H/5VA�B;H'Eu>O6�A4B;H/24HÔ];E�03*;,¨B;H'2e=_0k8?](HM2457*;:OZ;.90GEkN�03*;^24>gA�B;HM2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8`=_0k8?*;>3Ae03,'A�Z�03.7.78?]±HP0g^;>OZ�]�.1HãC(>O57*�A Õ 03*;^DHk03,[B-];E[03*;,[B-B�032\A�B;HM2�03=?HS57*;^;H ��N�nÐX)+6 � 572c24Z;,[B-0#,/Z�E4KLHGN�A�B;H/* Ë õ�X � Õ ,/03*�>O*;.V8?6�0351.±516 Ò o�� � �ëßÝð��Gn Ë *;>3A�HSn 512c51*_A�B;572\,k0324H�A�B;Hã:O.1>3]W03.51*;^;HG�->O6 �PN�A4B�0GAe572un 512\A�B;HM24=_03.7.1H/2TA\C±>O2457A�5VKLHÔ57*�A4H/:OH'E�2TZ;,¨B�A�B�0GAen ��572 � 0GE4A�57H'E Õ XY B;H'E�Hg0GE�Hg24H'KLHJE[03.�*�0GA�Z�E[03. ,¨B;>O57,/H/2ã6�>3E �PX Ì H#6�>O.1.7>%b�A�B;H#*;>3A[0GA�57>O*q>O6 Ë .;X1ð�Å Õ X Y B�Z;2 �àÒ�Ó � 572

A�B;HÔ*;>3E�=_03.1572�0GA�57>O*�X � *;HP,'>OZ;.1^-A4ET8DA4B;HP2TA4E451,'ARA4E[03*;246�>3E4= >O6 A4B;HÔA[03*;:OH/*LAu.151*;HMA�> � 0GA � X Y B;512R,/Z�E4KLHB�032u0U*;>s^;HP0GA � N;>O*;HM];E[03*;,[B�512R.7A Ë 24>a51*;^;H � � � Õ N�]�Z�AuA�B;Hã>3A�B;HJEu];E[03*;,[B�512 Ë ó � � � ó � ó 8 � ó � ó Õ N�03*;^�>O*;H,[B;H/,�Q�2\A�B�0GAvA�B;Hã57*;^;H �`>O6�A�B;512c];E[03*;,[BD512Sð # X � *;HM,'>O=<C�Z�A�H/2vA�B�0GA Ò o�� � �tßéó � � � N;03*;^`24>gbcHS,k03*�{òA0GC;C�.78 Ë õ�X � Õ XíS*;>3A�B;H'EeE�Hk0324>O*�0G]�.7H#,¨B;>O57,/Hºbc>OZ;.7^�](HPA�>?A�0GQLH ��A�B;Hº2TATE�51,'AeA4E[03*;246�>3E�= >O6�A�B;Hº24H/,/03*�Aã.751*;H#69E�>O= �

Page 42: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

��) ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

A�> � X Y B;H/* �çB�032R0#*;>@^;HM0GA � N�be5VA�BD>O*;HS.7Ac];E[03*;,[B Ë 03*;^D2T>UA�B;Hã57*;^;H �`512 � ó Õ 03*;^`A�B;Hã>3A�B;H'E\];E[03*;,[B

Ë ó � ó � . � ó 8 � ó � ó � ó � ó � ó Õ ß Ë � � � . � ó 8 �����/Õ �

� *;Hº,[B;H/,�Q�2�A�B�0GAuA�B;Hº51*;^;HG��>O6 A4B;512�*;>O*�.VAe];E[03*;,[Bq512�ó3õ�X � *;HP,/>O=<C�Z�A�H/2 Ò o�� � �éß ó � � óU24>`03:L0357*bcHÔ,k03*�{}Ae0GC;C�.78 Ë õ�X � Õ X

�S>�bÝA[0GQLHg51*;2IA�Hk03^¾6�>3E�� A�B;Hg24=?>@>3A4BÐ,'>O*;51,gbeB;57,¨BiB�032SA�B;57E�^i>3E�^;H'EM,/>O*LA[03,'AMbe5VA�B � 0GA � 03*;^¾572A[03*;:OH/*LA�A�> � 0GA � X�� 572S0S�/H'E4>_,/Z�E4KLH#>O* ' N±be5VA�B�Awbc>?];E[03*;,[B;H/2M0GA � ~\>O*;Hº512 Ë � � � . � ó � ó 8 ������Õ 03*;^A�B;HD>3A�B;H'EU512g2457*;:OZ;.90GEkN Ë ó � ó 8�� . 8 ��� � Õ X $v8ÍA�B;572U.1032TAU*;>3A[0GA�57>O*mbvH�=?H/03*�N �à=?H/H'A42gAwbc>ÐH ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.^;57K@5124>3E42c>O6 �'�Ò�Ó ' NsA�B;HSA+bv>U=?0GE4QLH/^`,/Z�E4KLH/2'N�0GAcA�B;H/57EcC±>O51*LA\>O6 57*�A4H'E�24H/,JA�51>O*�X � *;Hã,[B;H/,�Q�2\A�B�0GA\Hk03,[B>O6 A4B;H/24HP];E[03*;,[B;H/2eB�032u57*;^;H � � ó@XyíS.724><>O*;HÔ,/>O=<C�Z�A�H/2\A�B�0GA

Ò o�� � �tßéó Ò .�ó � � ó Ò ó : � � ó Ò ïOÅ � � óÔß . � � ó

03*;^-A�B�Z;2 ' 572u.7>O:<Z;*;5VE�Z;.1H/^�]s8 Ë õ�X � Õ X

���®�W���`�;�%���±� �K¿ÿ�� ���W��¡U�®� ' 3 Ë U�� ÕJ�öSH'E�H�bvHãbv>3E4Q?A�B�E�>OZ;:OB�03*D51*LA�H'E�H/2IA�51*;:U03*;^D*;>O*@ضA4E�5VK�5103.(H ��03=aC�.1H3X�)+*D6�03,'A\>OZ�E\C;E�>@>O6�>O6 Ë õ�X1ð Õ ^;>sH/2

*;>3AS:OH/*;HJE[0GA�HºA�B;H#^;>O=?57*�0GA�51*;:<6�03=?51.V8->O6�=?57*;51=_03. Ò o��;ض^;H/:3E�H/H3XSöSHJE�HPbcH#^;H'A4H'E�=?57*;H#24Z;,[B¾0?6�03=?57.786�>3E ' Ë U�� Õ X Y B;572Rbu51.7.�*;>3AR](HMZ;24H/^"57*�A�B;HMC;E�>@>O6 >O6 Ë ðOX7ð Õ XÌ H"6�>O.7.1>�b A�B;H"*;>3A�0GA�51>O*â>O6 Ë ï�Xæõ�Ø � Õ X Ì H"51*;^;51,/0GA�H�A�B;H�Awbc>m24Z�E�6�03,/H'2D>O6 Ë ï�X � Õ ]�8 '�� 03*;^ ' #\N

,/>3E4E4H/2TC(>O*;^;57*;:aA�>a0g*;>@^�03.�03*;^�,/Z;2TC�51^�03.�,/Z�]�57,3N;E�H/2TC±H/,'A�5VKLH/.78LX2#�H'A � � � ��l Ò o����SlG](HãA�B;HSE[0GA�51>O*�03.,/Z�E4KLH'2�� Ê N � � >O6 Ë ï�Xpõ Õ XY B;HÔ6�>O.7.1>�be57*;:aE�H/2TZ;.7A�2TB;>OZ;.1^-]±HÔ,/>O=aCW0GE�H/^�bu57A4B Ë õ�Xæõ Õ X

���®�W���»� NM��� ����¡k���%�»���¿� Á ­;¤ ° ¤M´�ªÔ©`¹�¬G«g´�¼±©G¥|´�¼@È\¸/©3«g´� ·D¬+¸ ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼(©G ³Jù ° µ3¤¨ª � Ü ' 3� ûy´�¥®­� � o����mßÒ ó À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ #�H'A ' ß '�� X #�H'A�� Ò�Ó Þ ](H�0Ô>O*;HuCW0GE[03=?HJA�H'E�^;H/6�>3E�=_0GA�57>O*?>O6�0PZ;*;57>O*?>O6±Awbc> É�Ê 2�=?H/H'A�57*;:0GAP0�C(>O57*�AkN�A�>�0�24=?>@>3A4B É�Ê N bu57A4B¾2457*;:OZ;.90GEPÏ;];E4H� 3 X�# H'A Ñ ~� 3 Ò�Ó ' ](HaA4B;H<=_0GC¾:O57KLH/*¾]�8ÐA�B;H*;>3E�=_03.7512�0GA451>O*;2M>O6�� 03*;^ � X Y B;H_^;51=<H/*;2451>O*Í>O6cöS>O= Ë � 3 �-'�Õ 0GADî Ñ ñå572º6�>OZ�E Ë *;H/5VA�B;H'Eº];E[03*;,[Bj,k03*=?>�KLH_0kb\0�8�69E�>O=�� 6 � N�A�B�Z;2#A�B;H_*;>@^;H_=gZ;2TAg:OHJA#24H/*LAgA�> � ß � � � Ny03*;^mA4B;H/*jbvH_,k03*ÍA[0GQLH03*L8Í03Z�A�>O=?>3ETC�B;5124= >O6cH/57A�B;HJE#];E[03*;,[BjÏ"��51*;:�A�B;H<C;E4H/51=_03:OH<>O6 � Õ X>$\Z�A#03,/,/>3E�^;57*;:qA4> Ë ðOX ó Õ >O6MîVð # ñ¶N����n � Ë � � Þ � 'åÕ B�032u^;57=?H/*;2457>O*-0GAR.7Hk032TA � Ë Ñ " Ë � � Õ4Õ äm^;51= Ë Þ Õ ß � X Y BsZ;2 Ñ ^;H'6�>3E�=?2\A�>U0U=_0GC�>O60a2T=?>@>3A�B É Ê 57*�A�> ' 3 X �

,�5 �q0O/�H �ÐC±>O51*LA � � � 3 A�>�03*Ð51*LA�H/:3E[03.�C�.103*;Ha,/Z�]�57, � X #�H'A� ](H#A�B;H /�H �i.157*;H3XE$c.1>�be57*;:`Z�C :A�57=?H/2S0GA � 03.7>O*;: � :O5VKLH/2 �' Ë U�� Õ�Ò±Ó É � N�24H/H#A�B;H#C;E�>s>O6�>O6 Ë ï�X � Õ X # HJA ' Ë �UÕ ]±HgA4B;HU,'>3E4E�H/2TC±>O*;^;51*;:,/>3C�8Í>O6 ' Ë U�� Õ X $v8¾A�B;H`,/>O*;2IA4E�Z;,'A�57>O* � Ü ' Ë �UÕ 3 X Ì H`*;>3A�H?A�B�0GAg516 � � 512g0 /W0GAg6�03=?57.78i>O6R2TZ;,¨B

Page 43: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � � �

H/.7.157C;A451,ã,/Z�E4KLH/2'NWA�B;H ' Ë � �wÕ 6�>3E4= 0 /W0GAR6�03=?51.V8LX � B;>s>O24HÔ2TZ;,¨Bq0g6�03=?57.78?bu57A�B � � *;>@^�03.�6�>3E � �ß Å�N�03*;^� 3 ß � ,/Z;2TC�57^�03.|X Y B;H/*¾A�B;H'E4Ha572P0D6�03=?51.V8"Þ � >O6¿=?H'=g]±H'E�2ã>O6Ôl Ò óGo����/l�be5VA�BÐÞ � ß�� � ä � � 6�>3E� �ß Å�NW03*;^-Þ 3 ßéó � X

���®�W��� 5 NÔ�%���å�±¡k���%���±�¿�D£ ¤J¥ ' ß ' Ë U�� Õ�À Á ­;¤ ° ¤º´�ªº©�¹s¬�«g´�¼±©3¥®´�¼�Èe¸/©G«U´� ·�¬+¸ ° ©G¥®´½¬�¼±©GÂy³Jù ° µ3¤¨ª �ÍÜ '23ûy´�¥®­ � � o��_ß Ò ó À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ $v8 Ë õ�X1ðOðOX1ð Õ bcH\,k03*a032424Z;=?H ' ß ' #\X Ì H\,/>O*;2451^;HJEåA4B;HR6�03=<51.78 ' � ^;HJÏ�*;H/^_0G](>�KLH3X $v8 Ë õ�X1ðOðOX1ð ÕbcHºB�0kKLHº6�>3ESH/03,¨B � �ß�Å_0a>O*;Hº^;51=?H'*;2451>O*�03.�6�03=?51.V8�� � Ü l Ò óGo�����ls>O6�E[0GA�57>O*�03. ,'Z�E4KLH/2�,/>O*LA[0357*;H/^q51*A�B;Hg24=?>s>3A�Bq.1>s,/Z;2/N�beB;57,[B¾51*;,'.1Z;^;H/2�� � ä � � XºíS69A�HJEP0_C(>O2T2457]�.7Hg]W032THa,[B�03*;:OH3N�A�B;H/24HU.157Hg51*i0D6�03=?57.786�>3EP03.1. � X Y B;H/*iA�B;HU.157=?57A/N�� 3 ÜÖl Ò óGo����vl�:O5VKLH/2M0D>O*;HU^;51=<H/*;2451>O*�03.�6�03=<51.78->O6�E[0GA451>O*�03.�=?H'=g]±H'E�2/N,/>O*LA[0351*;57*;:_ó � X +@57*;,/H � Ü ' 3# N;A�B;H/2THP^;>O=?57*�0GA�H ' 3# X �

�S>3A�H�A�B;HJE�HM0GE�Hã>O*;.78?Ï�*;5VA�H/.78?=_03*�8aE[0GA�57>O*�03.(=?H/=#](HJE�2c>O6cl Ò o � ��� � lO24>gA�B;Hã6�03=?51.V8?51* Ë õ�X7ðOðOX ó Õ 572>3]�K�51>OZ;2T.78D>O6 =?57*;51=_03.�^;H/:3E�H/HGX

�"!#�������±���� �j�� R��� �Ê Ë '�3/Õ ß � ð � �� Z�Ev=_0357*a:O>L03.;572�A�>ME�H/^;Z;,/HRA�B;HuC;E�>s>O6(>O6�A4B;HeH/=<C;Aw8#]±>OZ;*;^�0GE48<,/0324He57* Ë ðOXpï Õ A�>MA�B;HR,k0324HubuB;H/* ' 3

B�032ãA4E�57K@5903.�03.7:OH'];E[0357,U6�Z;*;^�03=<H/*�A�03.�:3E�>OZ�C�N Ë � Xpó Õ X Ì Ha03.124>`C;E�>�KLH3N Ë � X1ð�Å Õ N(A4B;H)��51,k0GE�^i*sZ;=#]±H'EP>O*;HGN*;>O*@ؽH'=<C;Aw8D]±>OZ;*;^�0GE48LN�,k0324HÔ>O6 Ë ðOXæõ Õ XíS^;^;57A451>O*�03.1.V8LN�bcH\57*;,/.1Z;^;HR24>O=?HcHk032I8g.1H/=?=?032�^;H/24,'E457]�51*;:MB;>�b�R��� �Ê 512yH'è±H/,'A�H'^a]�8#]�57E[0GA�57>O*�03.@A4E[03*;2+Ø

6�>3E�=_0GA451>O*;2/NW03*;^�24>O=<HP51=aC�.151,/0GA�51>O*;2\6�>3E?R Ê >O6 A4B;HPH ��512TA�H'*;,/Hº>O6�,/HJE4A[0351*�E�0GA�51>O*�03.�,/Z�E4KLH'2/X Y B;H'24HPbu51.1.](HaZ;24H/6�Z;.�51*¾A�B;HaBsZ;*LAg03*�03.V8�24572/X Y B;HaE�H'24Z;.7A�2P0GE�HabvH/.1.�Q�*;>�bu*�N bcH?57*;,/.1Z;^;HUC;E�>@>O6�2Ô6�>3EPA�B;HUE�Hk03^;H'E/{æ2,/>O*LKLH/*;51H'*;,/H3XÌ HM2TA[0GE4ARbu57A�B-03*-Hk032T8�#�H/=?=_0�X

�±�®� �¿�@�Í�����D£ ¤J¥ ¦ §¨¤#©��Ôú �S¬ ° ¤J¼�ª¨¥w¤'´�¼ �©3¼(¬<µG© ° ´¶¤J¥|·D¬+¸º¹G´�«_¤J¼;ª¨´¶¬G¼ � À� ¸ o 5f à � 5 ¥®­;¤J¼D¦ ­�©�ª#©aª ¯ ¤[³'´|©GÂ�¥|´1È�¤ ° À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ $v8 �u51H/=_03*;*@Ø �e>s,¨B�03*;^�+@H'ETE�HDKG03*;512TB;51*;:;N�A4B;H�^;57=?H/*;2457>O*�>O6\A�B;HD.151*;H/0GEa2I8�2TA�H'= l Ò nDo_f_l:3E�>�be2¿.157QLHen 5 o 5 �� �1X � *_A�B;HS>3A�B;H'EvB�03*;^�N;516@Î�512v2T=?>@>3A�BaC(>O51*LAc>O6 ¦ N�A4B;H/*`57Ac572c0GAc=?>O2TA�� � � � 5 � Ê5 �,/>O*;^;5VA�51>O*;2\>O*�0U.751*;Hk0GER2T8@2TA�H/=ÚA�>gB�0kKLHM0U=?H'=g]±H'E\>O6�=UZ;.VA�57C�.751,/5VAw8_0GA\.1H/032TARn8=g0GA�Î�X +@>a576�A4B;HM:O5VKLH/*51*;H'r@Z�03.15VAw8?B;>O.1^;2'N�A�B;H'E�HSbu51.1.W](HM0#=?H/=#](HJE\Þ ��l Ò n�o_f?lGbe5VA�B`=UZ;.VA�57C�.751,/5VAw8 ��n 0GA�Î�X Y B;H/*�576 U 572A�B;HÔH �;,/HJC;A�51>O*�03.�^;57K@5124>3ER>O6 A4B;HM]�.7>%b Z�C"0GAyÎ�N � Ë U � o_f�ätð��Gn�Þ Õ - ðOX ��±�65�NM��� �å�±¡k���%�»���¿� � ¸S¤'µ3¤ ° · ° ©G¼ F ¬�¼(¤eÂ1¬�ÈU¹�¤'Â�*e¤�����¬Mûy´�¥®­ R �� �Ê Ë '�3kÕ ß � ð � ´�ªRÂ1¬�Ⱥùs¼�´ ° ù@Â1¤�¹º¥®­;¤J¼�¤'µ3¤ ° ·° ©3¼ F ¬�¼(¤ºÂ1¬�È`¹�¤' *e¤�����¬a´�ªÔÂ1¬�È<ù@¼�´ ° ù@Â1¤�¹LÀ

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ +@Z�C;C±>O24H ' 572-03*L8 E[03*�Q�>O*;Hi.7>O:�^;H/. ��H����'>;X )+6 R �� �Ê Ë '23kÕ �ß � ð �LNeA�B;H/*tA4B;H'E�H¾572-0j,/>�KLH'E

Page 44: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

��� ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

RM~ ' 8 Ò�Ó ' N�buB;H'E�Hao ���� - óGo �� X �uZ;*;*;51*;:-A�B;HUzqz ��N�bvH<=_0k8q032424Z;=<H ' 8 512Ô0DE[03*�QÐ>O*;HU.1>O:-^;H'.��H����'>;N±032Ro ���� bu51.7.�>O*;.78`51*;,JE�Hk0324H3X�zq>3E�H/>�KLH'E ' 572u.7>O:<Z;*;57E4Z;.1H/^�5Vè ' 8 512R.1>O:aZ;*;57E�Z;.7H/^�X)+6�A�B;512¿C;E4>@,/H/2T2R^;>sH/2c*;>3AcA�H'E4=?51*�0GA�HGN�A�B;H'*�H'KLH'*�A�Z�03.7.78<o �� Ã�.#ßéó � N;03*;^_bcHS=?0�8?0GC;C�.78 Ë � X1ð Õ �Ì HÔ03.124>a>3];A[0351*�24>O=?HMHk032T8D.1H'=?=_032c^;H/24,JE�57]�57*;:?B;>%b R �� �Ê 572�0Gè(H','A�H/^-]�8`A�B;HPB�Z;*LAkX

�±�)(��¿���Í������£ ¤J¥ �c~ �çÒ�Ó 'h§¨¤\©M§'´ ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼±©GÂ3«<© ¯ §¨¤J¥|ûv¤[¤'¼g¼(¬ ° «<©GÂLªJù ° ¸/©�³[¤¨ª0,±ûy´�¥®­g¤ �@³[¤ ¯ ¥|´¶¬�¼(©GÂOÂ1¬�³JùsªU À Á ­�¤ ° ¤Ô´�ªº©?¼±©3¥®ù ° ©GÂ�ª¨ù ° ²k¤[³J¥|´¶¬�¼ R �� �Ê Ë '23kÕcÒWÓ R �� �Ê Ë �?3�Õ0,¿û�­�´¶³¨­�´�ªº©G¼q´�ªk¬�«?¬ °½¯ ­�´�ªJ«Ö´Ç¸ � Ë U Õ Ü '�3

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Ì Hc*;>3A�HvA�B�0GAy516(Ù�Ü ¦ 512y03*g>3C(H'*U2TZ�]�24H'Aå>O6W0ã*;>3E4=_03.�KG0GE�57H'Aw8 ¦ NGA�B;H/* R��� �Ê Ë Ù ÕvÒ±Ó R��� �Ê Ë ¦iÕ512\24Z�E»FIH/,'A�5VKLH Ë 2451*;,/HÔ0#,/>O*;*;H/,'A4H/^-,/>�KLH'ER,k03*;*;>3A\](H',/>O=?Hã^;5124,'>O*;*;H/,'A�H/^DbeB;H'*�E�H/2IA4E�51,JA�H/^`A�>`Ù Õ N;03*;^D516¦ 512u24=?>s>3A�B�03*;^¾Ù��uB�032�,/>@^;57=?H/*;2457>O*"0GA�.7Hk032TAuA+bv>;NR��� �Ê Ë ¦iÕ ß R��� �Ê Ë Ù Õ Ë ]s8DC�Z�E�57Aw8->O6 A�B;HP];E[03*;,[B.1>s,/Z;2 Õ X ��±�)(��®� J ���%��K K��W���y� � ¼i¥»­�¤Ô­�ù@¼�¥�,¿´Ç¸ R �� �Ê Ë ' � ÕP´�ªÔ¥ ° ´�µ�´|©GÂ1,\©G¼±¹ R Ë ��� Ê Õ � ' 3��� Ê ¥®­;¤J¼

R��� �Ê Ë � ��� Ê Õ ß R��� �Ê Ë ' � � Ê Õ ß � ð � �

�±�� �����Í������£ ¤'¥�T Ê , T � §¨¤Ð¥|ûv¬ë³[¬�« ¯ Â1¤'¥w¤ �Pú���© ° ¥®´½¤ ° ¹G´»µ�´�ªk¬ ° ª"´�¼Ý©G¼ç´»¼�¥w¤wÈ ° ©GÂÔø/ù;©�ªJ´�ú ¯±° ¬+²k¤[³J¥|´�µ3¤µG© ° ´¶¤J¥|·M¦ ¬+¸º¹G´�«_¤J¼;ª¨´¶¬G¼¾©G¥vÂ1¤�©�ª¨¥¿¥|ûv¬OÀ � ¸ T � l T � ´�ªM¼(¤»¸º©3¼±¹`§'´1È , � ßÝð , ó ¥®­;¤J¼8T Ê � T � �ß % À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ � Z�A4A�57*;:�]�8çBL8@C(HJE4C�.903*;H/2'NU,'>O=<CW03,'A�57698�51*;:�03*;^�^;H/2451*;:OZ;.10GE�512T51*;:;NºbcHj=_0k8é032424Z;=<H ¦ 512Ð024=?>s>3A�B`C;E�>GFIH/,'A�5VKLHÔ24Z�E46�03,/H3X Y B;HÔE�H'24Z;.7Au*;>%b 6�>O.7.1>�be2R69E�>O=àA�B;HPöS>s^;:OHÔ57*;^;H � Y B;H'>3E�H/=�X ��±����®� J �W���K K»�����y�-£ ¤J¥�TÖ§J¤�©G¼�¤»ÆS¤¨³J¥®´»µ3¤�³[¬�« ¯ Â1¤'¥w¤u´»¼�¥w¤wÈ ° ©G �q¤J´»Â1, �Mú���© ° ¥|´¶¤ ° ¹3´�µ�´�ªk¬ ° ´�¼�©U³[¬�¼W¼(¤[³J¥+¤�¹´�¼�¥+¤½È ° ©GÂåø'ù�©�ª¨´�ú ¯(° ¬+²k¤¨³J¥®´»µ3¤PµG© ° ´¶¤J¥|·g¦ ¬+¸<¹3´�«?¤J¼;ªJ´¶¬�¼j©G¥RÂ1¤[©�ª¨¥R¥|ûv¬OÀ � ¸g¥®­;¤U¼(¬ ° «<©GÂ�§'ù@¼±¹@Â1¤D¬+¸ Tì´�ª<§'´1È©G¼±¹?¼(¤»¸5,�¥®­;¤J¼ R �� �Ê Ë TgÕvÒ�Ó R �� �Ê Ë ¦iÕÔ´�ªãªJù ° ²k¤[³J¥|´�µ3¤kÀ

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ )wA�2åH/*;>OZ;:OBUA�>Ô2TB;>%b�0ã,/>O*;*;H/,'A4H/^<Ï�*;57A4H �H'A�03.1H\,/>�KLH'E¿>O6 ¦ E4H/2TA4E�57,'A�2yA�>Ô0M,/>O*;*;H','A�H/^?,'>%KLH'E�>O6 T X#�H'A Ñ ~ ¦ 8 Ò�Ó ¦ ](HP24Z;,[Bi0?,'>%KLH'E/X Y B;H/* Ñ " Ë TgÕ B�032e]�51:?*;H'6å*;>3E4=_03.�]�Z;*;^;.1H3N�03*;^"2T>_512e,'>O*;*;H/,'A�H/^]�8 Ë � X . Õ X ��±� � �¿�@�Í������£ ¤J¥ 'ק¨¤�©Ð¼(¬ ° «<©G ¯±° ¬I²k¤[³J¥|´�µ3¤?ª¨ù ° ¸/©�³¨¤�¬+¸!*\´¶³�© ° ¹�¼�ù@«<§¨¤ ° ¬�¼(¤kÀ � ¸ ' 3 ´�ª?ù@¼�´ ° ùsÂ1¤[¹ ,¥®­;¤J¼Ð´»¥�´�ª ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼±©3Â� ·D³¨¬�¼�¼(¤[³'¥w¤�¹ ,v©G¼±¹ R Ê Ë ' 3 ÕP´�ª 2å¼�´»¥w¤kÀ

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ �OZ;2TA¿,/>3C�8aA�B;HRC;E�>@>O6�>O6 Ë ï�X . Õ >O6�îVð :Gñ|NLA4>P^;H/^;Z;,/HuA�B�0GA ' 3 572�E[0GA451>O*�03.1.V8#,/>O*;*;H/,JA�H/^�X �S>%b�0GC;C�.V8Ë � X1: Õ ]±H/.1>�bÔX ��±��� 7�� 9y�����%�»���¿� # HJA � N ¦ ](HuK30GE�57H'A�57H/2/X Ì H�240�8UA�B�0GA ¦ 512 � ؽ,/>O*;*;H','A�H/^�N;576(:O57KLH/*?03*�8UAwbc>º:OH/*;H'E�03.C(>O57*�A42 � � � � ¦ N�A�B;H'E�HÔ512u0a:OH/*;HJE�51,k03.7.78`Ï�*;57A4HÔ=_0GC � Ò±Ó ¦ buB;>O24HM51=_03:OHã,/>O*LA[0351*;2 �Ð03*;^ � X

Page 45: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � � �

�±��� 7D�:9y� ���%���±��� íÄB;>O=?>O=<>3E4C�B;5124= >O6ã:3E�>OZ�C�2?572?,k03.7.1H/^ � K»���±¡'��¡k� � )k��ÿ3�%�»�W� 516�A�B;H"57=_03:OH�572_024Z�]�:3E�>OZ�C�>O6�Ï�*;57A4Ha57*;^;H ��X#í :3E�>OZ�C�572ã,k03.1.7H/^ � K»���±¡'���Düå�"K»�»�W� 576¿5VAÔB�032Ô03*¾í�]±H/.15103*i2TZ�]�:3E�>OZ�CÍ>O6Ï�*;57A4HP51*;^;HG��X

�±��� �¿�@�Í����� � ¸<¦ ©G¼(¹ � © ° ¤iø'ù�©�ª¨´�ú ¯(° ¬+²k¤¨³J¥®´»µ3¤0,a©G¼±¹q¦ ´�ª��<ú4³[¬�¼W¼(¤[³J¥+¤�¹ ,U¥®­;¤J¼t¥»­�¤ ° ¤"´�ªÐ©m«?© ¯Ñ ~ � Ò�Ó ¦ ª¨ù�³J­D¥»­;©G¥v¥»­;¤P´�¼±¹GùW³[¤�¹<«?© ¯ Ñ ~R Ê Ë �PÕ\Ò�Ó R Ê Ë ¦¾ÕÔ´�ªº©G «?¬%ªJ¥�ªJù ° ²k¤[³J¥|´�µ3¤kÀ* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ #�H'A�� � ¦ ]±H¾0m:OH/*;H'E[03.�C±>O51*LAkX $v8 r@Z�032T5VضC;E4>3FIH','A�57K@57Aw8â>O6 Ë A�B;HÐ,/>O*;*;H/,'A4H/^ ,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*LA�2>O6 Õ öS>O= Ë � ��¦iÕ N A�B;HJE�H_512#0-KG0GE�57H'Aw8jÙgN�0�^;>O=?51*�03*LA#=_0GC �j~�Ù � � ÒWÓ ¦ N�03*;^�0�=gZ;.VA�5Vض24H/,'A�57>O* ÜtÙ � � Ë 6�>3ERA�B;HãÏ;E�2TARC;E�>GFIH/,'A�57>O* Õ 24Z;,[B-A4B�0GA�� Ë Õ ß � X �eH'C�.103,/51*;:`ÙÝ]�8 Ë 03*;^�C�Z;.7.157*;:U]W03,�Q Õ NbcHã,k03*D032424Z;=<H 512\0#24H/,JA�51>O*�X@$v8Ðîæó'.3ñ(0g^;>O=<51*�03*LA\=_0GC`>O6�KG0GE�57H'A�51H'2c51*;^;Z;,/H/2u03*D03.1=?>O2IAc24Z�E®FIH/,JA�51>O*>O*"6�Z;*;^�03=?H/*LA[03.�:3E4>OZ�C�2/X?R Ê Ë Ù � �PÕ 512�:OH'*;H'E[0GA�H/^"]�8�A�B;Hº57=_03:OH/2�>O6 R Ê Ë Õ 03*;^ R Ê Ë �ºÕ Ë beB;H'E4HºA�B;H.90GATA�H'ER512u51*;,/.7Z;^;H/^-K�510a03*L8DÏ;];E�H Õ X � .7Hk0GE�.V8DA4B;HÔ57=_03:OHã>O6 R Ê Ë ÕvÒ�Ó R Ê Ë ¦iÕ 512\A4E�5VK�5103.|X ��±�(' J ���%��K K��W���y� � ¸S¦ ´�ª ê ÊLú4³[¬�¼�¼�¤[³J¥+¤�¹ � ° ¤¨ª ¯ À ê Ê" ú�³[¬�¼�¼(¤¨³J¥w¤[¹ � ¥®­;¤J¼ R Ê Ë ¦iÕ#´�ª+2å¼W´�¥w¤ � ° ¤¨ª ¯ À_©3 «?¬%ª¨¥�㧨¤' ´|©G¼ � À�±�®�s� NM��� ����¡k���%�»���¿��£ ¤J¥ Ë '9� �UÕU§¨¤a©_Â1¬�È ©G¼(¬ ¯ ©G´ ° ,u¬+¸ *\´¶³�© ° ¹?¼�ù@«<§¨¤ ° ¬�¼�¤0,vûå´�¥»­ � ©`¼�¬�¼�ú4¤J« ¯ ¥®·³Jù ° µ3¤�À�£ ¤J¥ Ùàß '�á Ë � 6 +@57*;: Ë '�Õ4Õ � Á ­�¤J¼ Ù ´�ª ê Ê" ú�³[¬�¼�¼(¤¨³J¥w¤[¹ ,u´�¼ ¯ © ° ¥|´¶³Jù@Â7© ° ,Ô§/· ����À�� � , R Ê Ë Ù Õ?´�ª©G «?¬�ª¨¥��㧨¤J ´|©3¼±À(ù ° ¥®­;¤ ° «?¬ ° ¤0,ã´Ç¸ Ù ´�ª<¼(¬�¥ ê Ê�ú�³[¬�¼�¼(¤¨³J¥w¤[¹ ,e¥®­;¤J¼ � " Ë � � Ë Ò .7>O: �UÕ4Õ ß 6�Ë ð Õ 8 6 ¸k¬ ° �v~ É�Ê_Ò�Ó �

¥®­;¤`¼(¬ ° «?©G ´�ª/©G¥|´¶¬�¼ë¬+¸_¥®­;¤<È�¤J¼(¤ ° ©G¿«?¤J«<§J¤ ° ¬+¸�©G¼�·U¸/©G«g´� ·Í¬+¸ ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼±©3Â\³Jù ° µO¤¨ª�¹�¬�«g´�¼(©G¥®´»¼@È#' 3 ©3¼±¹«?¤[¤'¥®´�¼�È�� ¬�¼(³¨¤kÀ* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ $v8 Ë õ�X ó Õ N '23 512P^;>O=?51*�0GA�H'^i]�8Í0-6�03=?57.78Ð>O6vE[0GA�57>O*�03.y,/Z�E4KLH/2º=<H/H'A�57*;: � H ��03,JA�.78Ð>O*;,/H3X�#�H'A�i~ É�ÊUÒ�Ó � ](HaA4B;Ha*;>3E�=?03.151240GA�51>O*q>O6v0`:OH/*;H'E�03.�=?H'=g]±H'Eã>O6v03*L8Ð24Z;,[BÍ6�03=?51.V8LXE+@Z�C;C±>O24H�Ù 512M*;>3Aê Ê Ø½,/>O*;*;H/,JA�H/^�X Ì H?B�0�KLH � � Ê Ë Þ Õ ß �±î � ñ�6�>3E#24>O=?HUC(>O51*LA � � É Ê 03*;^Í24>O=?H ��à Å�X � >O*;2451^;HJE#A�B;H^;51=<H/*;2451>O*�N���N�>O6 � ß öS>O= Ë É�Ê �-'�� ��î � ñ�Ü �UÕ 0GA_î �@ñ|X0$c8 Ë � X � Õ 03*;^ Ë�� Xæï Õ N �hß � Ë � " � � Ë Ò .7>O: �UÕ4Õ X#�H'A $ � É�Ê ](HÔ0a:OH/*;HJE[03.�C±>O51*LAkNW03*;^-.7H'A ��ß � Ë $ Õ X Y B;HP24Z�]�2TCW03,'H

� 8 ßtöS>O= Ë É Ê �-'�� �±î � ñ�Ü �<� $ Ó � Õ Ü �

Ë buB;H'E�HãA�B;HM03^;^;57A�57>O*�03.(*;>3A[0GA�57>O*`=?Hk03*;2cA�B�0GA $ 572\E4H/r@Z;5VE�H/^`A�>a=?0GCDA4> � Õ 512\,/Z�AR>OZ�A\]s8�óºH/rsZ�0GA�51>O*;2'X$v8Í03242TZ;=<C;A�51>O*ÍA�B;H_57=_03:OH?>O6R0"=_0GCm51* � 8 572ºÏ"�;H/^ Ë H/rsZ�03.¿A�> �PÕ X Y B�Z;2 � 8 B�032g^;51=?H/*;2T51>O*m>O*;HË A�B;HJE�H<572º0->O*;Ha^;51=?H/*;2T51>O*�03.y6�03=?51.V8Ð>O6v=_0GC�2ãbe5VA�B¾Ï"�;H'^�51=_03:OHGN 2457*;,/H?57* � 8 A4B;H?51=_03:OH'2M>O6 � 03*;^$ 0GE�H<Ï"�;H'^ Õ Ny03*;^Í24> � � ï�X $v8 Ë�� X � Õ N � " Ë � � Ë Ò .1>O: �UÕ4Õ 572º24H/=?5ÛضC±>O2457A�5VKLH3X8$c8¾032424Z;=aC;A�51>O*Í5VA#B�032C(>O2T57A�5VKLHÔ^;H/:3E4H/H3X Y B�Z;2uA�B;HM]�Z;*;^;.1HP572 6DË ð Õ 8 6 XíS2424Z;=<H � - ó@X Y B;H'*�öS>O= Ë É Ê �-'9� Ë � Ò ð Õ î � ñSÜ �UÕ B�032g^;51=<H/*;2451>O*j0GAg.7Hk032TA .i0GA�î �sñ¶Ny03*;^mA�B;H

24Z�]�2TCW03,'H3N � 818 N�bu57A�B $ Ó � N ^;57=?H/*;2457>O*�0GAÔ.1Hk032TAºó@X Y B�Z;2 Ë 2457*;,/H<57* � 818 bcHUÏ"�¾A4B;Ha57=_03:OH/2ã>O6¿Awbc>

Page 46: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

C(>O57*�A42/N � � $ Õ A4B;HS51=_03:OH/2¿>O6�=?0GC�2v51* � 818 512v*;>3AcÏ"��H/^�X�$c8<,/>O*;2TA4E4Z;,'A�51>O*_A�B;HJ8_=?H/H'A � 0GAv=?>O2TA¿Awbu51,/HGXY BsZ;2ãÙ�572uê Ê" ؽ,/>O*;*;H/,JA�H/^�XY B;HgÏ�*�03.�C±>O24245V]�51.15VAw8"512�A�B�0GA �`ßÚðOX #�H'A � Ê N � � Ü ' 3 ](H#Awbc>`:OH/*;H'E�03.�=?H/=#](H'E42S>O6åA�B;Hg6�03=?57.78LX

� Ê � � � �ß %�N@2457*;,/HeA�B;H �¿51,/0GE�^_*sZ;=#]±H'Ec512�>O*;H3XyíS2v51*?A4B;HeC;E�>@>O6±>O6 Ë õ�X1ðOðOX7ð Õ NObcH�,k03*_^;H/6�>3E4= � Ê ä � �A�>g:OH'AR0#^;>O=?57*�0GA�51*;:#6�03=?57.78<>O6�57*�A4H/:3E[03.±E[0GA451>O*�03.(,/Z�ETKLH/2\Þ Ü ' 3 bu57A4B � � ÞÚßéó@N Ò o � ÞÚß .;X Y B;HE�Hk032T>O*;51*;:`0G](>�KLHº24B;>�bu2�A�B�0GA�ÞÄ^;H/6�>3E4=?2ebu57A�B"0?:OH'*;H'E[03. C±>O51*LAeÏ"��H/^ Ë *;>_,/>O*;^;5VA�51>O*">O*�A�B;HP,/>O*�A�03,'Abu57A�B �UÕ �s516\5VAg^;51^j*;>3AkN�A�B;H/*mA�B;H_C�Z;.1.V]W03,[Q�>O6 � � Ë Ò .1>O:¿Þ Õ A4>�A�B;H`*;>3E�=_03.1572�0GA�57>O*�>O6uÞ bc>OZ;.7^j]±H6 8 6�Ë ó Õ X +@51*;,'HPÞ � � ßéó@N�Þ � Ù�:O5VKLH/2e0U,/>O*;*;H/,'A451*;:?6�03=?57.78`>O6 51=_03:OH/2\>O6 ê Ê" X �

�S>3A�H`Ùà51* Ë � X1ð�Å Õ 512P*;>3Aº51*�:OH/*;HJE[03.�ê Ê Ø½,'>O*;*;H/,'A�H/^�X8,�>3EPH ��03=aC�.1HaA�0GQLH Ë '�� �UÕ ß Ë É�� � Ê ä � Õ6�>3ESAwbc>`.157*;H/2 Ê N � XPÙ�ß�ê Ê �"ê Ê" N±buB;51,[BiB�032S57*�Ï�*;57A�H#6�Z;*;^�03=<H/*�A�03.�:3E�>OZ�C�N�03*;^qA�BsZ;2S,/03*;*;>3AM]±Hê Ê Ø½,/>O*;*;H/,JA�H/^�]�8 Ë � X # Õ

�.���\&L��$ ������$%$g����� ���� �G��(������ ���L m� �����g�����

���1� /�(���%������ÿ3�%���±�¿�Ì H�*;>%bmA[0GQLHåZ�CºA�B;H�24H/,/>O*;^gB�03.16s>O6@A�B;HåC;E�>@>O6�>O6 Ë ðOXpï Õ X íS2 >OZ�A�.751*;H/^P51*ÔA4B;H¿51*LA4E�>s^;Z;,'A�57>O*�NGA�B;H�C;E4>@>O6

03=?>OZ;*LA�2uA4>_H ��C�.751,/5VA�.78D^;H'A�HJE�=?51*;57*;:`0aÏ�*;57A4H#24H'A �j>O6 ' N�buB;51,[B"51*;,/.7Z;^;H/2ã03.1. ' be5VA�B R��� �Ê Ë '�3kÕ ß � ð �]�Z�Av*;>ÔA�51:OH'E/N@03*;^_6�>3E¿Hk03,[B ' � �åN@H �@C�.157,/57A�.V8gH �;B;5V]�57A�57*;:º0P6�03=<51.78g>O6�E[0GA�51>O*�03.�,/Z�ETKLH/2v^;>O=?57*�0GA�51*;:MA�B;H24=?>s>3A�Bq.1>s,/Z;2/X � *;,/H ' 512ã51*ÐB�03*;^�N�A�B;Hg^;>O=?51*�0GA451*;:`6�03=?51.V8-bu51.7. ](HU>3];A[0351*;H'^Ð]�8"Ï�*;^;51*;:-0D2TC±H/,/5103.E[0GA�57>O*�03. ,/Z�ETKLH�� Ü ' beB;57,[Bi2�0GA4512TÏ�H/2�A4B;H#,'E�57A4H'E�590?>O6 Ë õ�X � Õ >3E Ë õ�Xæõ Õ X Ì HºÏ�*;^ �Ý51*qHk03,[BÐ,k0324Hº]�8q02TA4E�0351:OBLA�6�>3E4b\0GE�^g]�Z�AåE[0GA�B;H'E�03^@ؽB;>s,R03*�03.78�2T512/X�öSH'E4H\bvHR,'>O*;2451^;H'EåA�B;HcC;E�>3]�.7H/= >O6WÏ�*;^;57*;: �åX�íS2�*;>3A�H/^51*qA�B;HU51*LA4E�>s^;Z;,'A�51>O*�N�A�B;572M572Ô^;>O*;Hg]�8Ð03*�03.78�2T51*;:`C(>O24245V]�51.757A�57H/2ã6�>3Eº0`24H'E�57H/2M>O6¿2457=<C�.157698�51*;:_]�5VE[0GA�51>O*�03.A4E[03*;2T6�>3E�=_0GA�57>O*;2/NObeB;57,¨B?bvHe,k03.7.�A4B;HeB�Z;*�AkN�03*;^<beB;57,[B<bcHe*;>�b�^;H/24,'E457](HGXå)+*<A�B;HuBsZ;*LAc^;H'Ï�*;5VA�51>O*aA�B�0GA6�>O.1.7>%bu2ãA�B;H'E�H<0GE�H?0D6�H'b ,¨B;>O57,/H/2PA4>�](HU=_03^;H3N 03*;^Í0D6�H'b C(>O51*LA�2MA�B�0GAÔE4H/r@Z;5VE�HaC;E�>s>O6½X Ì Habu51.1.�:O5VKLHA�B;HMC;E�H/,/5724HP^;H'A�0351.12R51* Ë :�X ó Õ XY B;HeB�Z;*�Ac:OH'*;H'E[0GA�H/2¿0P24H'E451H/2�>O6±CW0357E�2 Ë ' � ��! � Õ >O6±E[03*�Qa>O*;He.7>O:P^;H/. ��H����/>P24Z�E�6�03,/H/2�be5VA�B<](>OZ;*;^�0GET8

bu57A�BDA�B;HÔC;E�>3C±H'E4A�57H/2\A�B�0GAË ð ÕÐÒ Ë o����ä ! � Õ 512u03=<C�.7H3XË ó Õ )+6 o�� �� ��ä ! ��� Ê B�032e0gA�51:OHJEkN;A�B;H/*�24>a^;>@H/2uo���±ä ! � XY B;HMC;E�>s,/H/242e512u032u6�>O.7.1>�be2/~(M5VKLH/* Ë ' � ��! � Õ NybcH`H ��ATE[03,'Aa03*�HG�;,/H'C;A451>O*�03.c^;57K@5124>3E U � � Ê >O6 �' � K�510 Ñ � ~ � ��� Ê Ò�Ó ' � X Ì H_bu51.1.

^;512T,/Z;242�A�B;Hº,[B;>O57,/H#>O6 U � � Ê ]±H/.1>�bPX%#�H'A�! � � Ê ](HºA4B;Hº.1>O:<C�Z;.7.7]W03,�Q�>O6 ! � Ë 2TH/H � ó Õ X � ��� Ê B�032?�¿57,k0GE�^*�Z;=g]±H'EyAwbc>;X�)wAå03^;=?57A�2y0 Ë Z;*;57r@Z;H Õ o"ؽ*;H/:L0GA457KLHc,/>O*LA4E[03,'A451>O*0R ��� Ê X MHJÏ�*;H�! 8 à !�24>ãA�B�0GAyo����� �Lä ! 8512�R ��� Ê Ø|A4E�5VK�5903. Ë A�B;HJE�H�512<24>O=?H�,[B;>O51,'H"51*â^;H'Ï�*;57*;:�! 8 Õ X �¿5VA�B;H'E R � � Ê 572`0 É Ê Ø¶Ï;];E[0GA�57>O*�N\>3E_57A_572_0]�57E�0GA�51>O*�03.�,/>O*LA4E[03,JA�51>O*8R ��� Ê ~ � ��� Ê Ò�Ó ' ��� Ê A�>a0UE[03*�QD>O*;HM.1>O:<^;H'.���H����/>;Xy)I*�A�B;HMÏ;E42TAe,/0324HÔbcHÔ,k03.1.

Page 47: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � �"2

� ��� Ê 0 � �s� 03*;^-A�B;HÔC;E4>@,/H/2T2e2TA�>3C�2'Xå)+*-A�B;HÔ24H/,/>O*;^�bcHP^;H'Ï�*;H ! � � Ê ß R ��� Ê Ë ! 8 Õ X(M5VKLH/* ' bcHº57*;^;Z;,'A�5VKLH/.78D,k0GE4ET8->OZ�AuA�B;H#0G](>�KLH3NW2TA[0GE4A451*;:<bu57A�B Ë ' 3 ��! 3 Õ ß Ë '9� % Õ X Y ><C;E4>%KLH Ë ðOXpï Õ N

bcHã03242TZ;=?H ' 3 B�032c*;>ºA�51:OH'E/N�03*;^OR �� �Ê Ë ' 3 Õ 572¿A4E�5VK�5103.|Ns03*;^D>OZ�E\:O>L03.W512vA4>#:O57KLHS03*_H �@C�.157,/57Ac^;H'24,'E�5VC;A�51>O*>O6 �' 032�0U]�.1>�b�Z�C�>O6 É�� X � Z�E�=?H'A�B;>s^-512RA�>_0GAu24>O=?HM2TA[03:OHÔ^;H'A�H'E�=<51*;H ' � Ë >3EebuB;H/*�A�B;HJE�HP572�0<*;H'A/N� � Õ 03*;^DA�B;H'*�E�H/,'>%KLH'E ' ]�8`,/.103242451698@51*;:#C(>O2T2457]�57.157A451H/2\6�>3E\A�B;Hã51*LKLH'E�24HSA4E�03*;246�>3E�=_0GA�57>O* ' � � ��� ' 3 X Y B;HE�H/=?0351*;^;H'E¿>O6 Ë :�XpÅ Õ 512�^;H'KL>3A�H/^aA�>#0P^;H'A�0351.1H'^?^;5124,'Z;242451>O*_>O6�A�B;HeA�H/,[B;*;57r@Z;H/2¿buB;51,[B`03.7.1>�b Z;2¿A�>P,'>O*�A4E4>O.A�B;H�C±>O242457]�57.15VA�51H/2'X � Z�ER0357= 512�A�>#:O57KLHeA4B;HeE�Hk03^;H'ER0º6�H'H/.157*;:U6�>3EvB;>%b 03*;^`buBL8<A�B;H/2TH�A�H/,[B;*;51rsZ;H/2cbc>3E4Q(XY B;H/24H?A�H/,[B;*;57r@Z;H/2#bu51.1.yC;E�>�KLH<KLH'E48¾H�!?,'51H/*LAg6�>3E#,/.103242457Ï�,/0GA�51>O* /�bcH?bu51.7.�*;H'KLHJEg*;H/H/^ÍA�>",/>O*;2457^;H'E ' 5](HJ8L>O*;^ ' � N�03*;^�51*�6�03,JAuA�B;HMK3032IAe=_0�FI>3E�5VAw8_>O6 A�B;HP03*�03.78@24512\be57.1.(]±HÔ>O* ' Ê 03*;^ ' � X)+*�A�B;H_^;512T,/Z;242457>O*�NybvH?be57.1.åZ;24H?A�B;H_6�>O.1.7>%bu51*;:-*;>3A[0GA�51>O*�N Ï"�;H/^m6�>3E#A�B;H<E4H/=_0351*;^;HJEg>O6vA�B;H?CW0GC(H'E/X

#�H'A � ß R Ë U Ê Õ N ' Ê�� � ß R Ë Ê Õ X?#�H'A � ]±HºA�B;H#,/>@H !?,/57H/*�Aã>O6 � 57* ! Ê N�A�B�0GAã572 ! Ê ß � � X Ì H#.7H'A� Ü ' � ](HÔA4B;HP51=?03:OHS>O6�U � NW03*;^�.7H'A � ]±HMA�B;HÔ,/>@H !?,/57H/*�Ae>O6 � 57* ! � X

J � �±�»ÿO�"��þ U � �Y B;HuB�Z;*�A¿512�0Ô24HJE�51H/2�>O6±oÄ*;>O*@ض*;H/:L0GA�57KLHR]�.1>�b Z�C�2¿6�>O.7.1>�bcH/^a]�8Uoqض*;H/:L0GA�5VKLHR]�.7>%b ^;>�be*;2'Nsbu57A�BUA�B;H

]�.1>�bçZ�C"03*;^DA�B;Hã]�.1>�bé^;>%bu*-H/03,¨B->O6 E�H/.10GA�57KLH ��51,k0GE4^-*�Z;=g]±H'Eu>O*;H3X +@Z;,[B�2TH/r@Z;H/*;,'H/2�>O6�A4E[03*;246�>3E�=?0�ØA�57>O*;2u0GE4HM69E4H/r@Z;H/*LA�.V8�2IA�Z;^;51H/^�51*DA�B;HãzÐz ��N;24H'HÔ6�>3EuH ��03=aC�.1HUî}ï .3ñ|X Y B;HM>O*;.78`,[B;>O57,/HÔ57*�^;HJÏ�*;51*;:<2TZ;,¨B0<24H'r@Z;H/*;,/H#>O6 A4E[03*;246�>3E�=?0GA�51>O*;2R512RbeB;57,¨B"^;5VK�5724>3E?U ��� Ê A�>?HG��A4E[03,JAkX Y B;HºBsZ;*LAS572uA�B;HÔ24H'E�57H/2�>O6�A4E[03*;2+Ø6�>3E�=_0GA451>O*;2\^;H'Ï�*;H/^-]�8D,[B;>@>O2457*;:�U ��� Ê >O6 =?0 �;51=?03.�,/>sH�!?,'51H/*LA Ë 57*�o�� �ä ! � Õ X Y B;512R,[B;>O51,/H3N�*�0GA�Z�E�03.69E�>O= A�B;H#C±>O51*LAÔ>O6yK�57H'b�>O6yA�57:OH'E�2/N(A�Z�E4*;2Ô>OZ�ASA�>DB�0kKLHgE4H/=_0GE4QG0G]�.78-2TA4E�>O*;:D:OH/>O=?H'ATE�51,#,/>O*;2TH/r@Z;H/*;,'H/2/N03*;^�5VAe572uA�B;H/2THº,/>O*;24H/rsZ;H/*;,/H/2'N(=?>3E�HãA�B�03*"03*L8@A�B;57*;:;N;beB;57,¨B"=?0GQLH/2u5VAuC±>O24245V]�.1HÔA4>?,/.9032T2451698D>OZ�A�,/>O=<H/2>O6 A4B;HPB�Z;*�AkXå)+*�>3E�^;H'ERA�><HG��C�.90357*�A�B;H'24HP:OH/>O=<H'A4E�57,M,'>O*;24H/r@Z;H'*;,/H/2/N±bvHÔ57*�A4E4>@^;Z;,/HÔ24>O=?HM^;H'Ï�*;57A�57>O*;2/~

���1���®�¾�#� ��� K»��¡k� J �±��� ���%���±���`£ ¤J¥y¦ §¨¤U©D¼(¬ ° «?©GÂ�ø/ù;©�ªJ´�ú ¯±° ¬+²k¤[³J¥|´�µ3¤Mµ3© ° ´¶¤'¥®·�©G¼(¹ ! ß � ��� Þ � ©§¨¬�ù@¼±¹L© ° ·LÀ\£ ¤J¥ n ßtn Ë !aÕP§¨¤�¥®­;¤S«g´�¼�´»«gùs« ¬I¸u¥®­;¤ã¼(¬�¼�ú �%¤ ° ¬ ��� À � ¸ ! ´�ªÔ¤J« ¯ ¥®· ,yûv¤�Â1¤'¥ n Ë !<Õ ßÝð À

���1���65 7�� 9y�����%�»���¿� # HJA U ]±H?03*L8ÐH �;,/HJC;A�51>O*�03.å^;57K@5124>3EÔ>%KLHJE ¦ X Ì H<2�0k8iA4B�0GAPo_fëä ! N 03*;^Í03.724>A�B;HMCW0357E Ë ¦���!<Õ 572/~

Ë ð Õ��y� ¡k� Ë E�H/2TC�X K»�s���MK½¢ 0GA U 516 � Ë U � o_f�ä !<Õ �ân Ë E�H/2TC � Õ XË ó Õ��y� ¡k� Ë E�H/2TC�X K»�s���MK½¢ 516 � Ë U � o_f�ä !aÕ �ân Ë E�H/2TC�X � Õ 6�>3E�03.7.�H �;,/HJC;A�51>O*�03.�^;57K@5124>3E42 U_X

Ì He03.124>ºB�0kKLH�.7>@,k03.;KLH'E�2T51>O*;2/~ £ ¤'¥ � §¨¤M©ºªJù;§Jª�¤J¥¿¬+¸¿¦hÀ �q¤eª/©3· o_fÐä !Ä´�ª��vùsª[­ � ° ¤Jª ¯ ÀRÂ1¤Jµ3¤J � ©G¥�,¬ ° © ° ¬�ù@¼±¹ , � ,R´Ç¸#¥®­;¤ ° ¤#´�ªPª�¬�«?¤U¼(¤J´9È�­�§¨¬�ù ° ­�¬�¬k¹ Ù ¬+¸ � ,\ªk¬D¥®­�©G¥ o � ä ! l ��´�ª��cùsª[­ � ° ¤¨ª ¯ ÀUÂ1¤Jµ3¤' � À�q¤Mª/©3· o_fhä ! ´�ª�cù�ª[­q©Gû¿©G·e¸ ° ¬�« ,\¬ ° ¬�ù@¥»ªJ´|¹�¤U¬I¸5, � ´Ç¸ o_fhä !ì´�ª�cù�ª[­q©G¥ ¦Úá � À

� À � À � �"© ° ¼�´�¼@ÈGú D ¤J«?© ° F À �SH/57A�B;HJE Ë ð Õ *;>3E Ë ó Õ 57* Ë :�XæÅ�X ó Õ ,k03*Í51*�:OH'*;H'E[03.�]±H?,[B;H/,�QLH/^m.1>s,k03.1.V8LN 2457*;,/Hn ,k03*q51*;,'E�H/0324HPbuB;H/*"8L>OZ"24B�E�51*�Q ¦ Ë 516�bvHPA�B�E�>�b�0kb\0k8"03.7.�A�B;HP,/>O=<C(>O*;H'*�A�2e>O6�,/>@H�!<,/51H'*�Aãn Õ X � 6

Page 48: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

,/>OZ�E�2TH Ë ð Õ ,k03*Í](H_,[B;H/,�QLH/^�0GE�>OZ;*;^mA�B;H_,/H/*LA�H'EkN��aN�>O6 UÄ>O* ¦ N�576\A4B;H'E�H_512g0",/>O=aC(>O*;H/*LA#>O6 ! >O6,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LA�nÄbeB;57,[B�=?H/H'A42��aXÌ H?bu51.7.¿24B;>�bÚA�B�0GAg57*jA�B;H_B�Z;*LAkN Ë ' Ê ��! Ê Õ 512 /�Z;2TB Ë 03*j03.1=<>O2TA#51=<=?H/^;590GA4H<,/>O*;24H'r@Z;H/*;,/HD>O6\A�B;H

,[B;>O51,/Ha>O6 U Ê Õ 03*;^¾A�B�0GAM24>O=<H'A�B;51*;:�24.157:OB�A4.78"bcHk0GQLHJEkN ]�Z�AÔbe5VA�BÐA4B;H<2�03=?HU:OH/>O=?HJA4E�51,g,/>O*;2TH/r@Z;H/*;,'H/2/NB;>O.1^;2u6�>3E�03.7.�BsZ;*LA�2TA�03:OH/2/N�24H/H Ë :�X .;X � Øwõ Õ XY B;H /�Z;24BD,/>O*;^;57A�57>O*_,/>O*LA4E�>O.12�](>3A�B?A�B;HS2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457A�57H/2¿>O6 ¦ 03*;^`>O6�� !�� Ns51*`0º=_03*;*;H'E¿bcH�be57.1.W*;>%b

^;512T,/Z;242/X@��E�>s>O6�2�0GE�HM:O57KLH/*�51* Ë :�Xpï Õ X�������qý��s�±�������G�»ÿ�ÿO�±� ¡/� � � �@��ÿO��¡3�� >O*;2451^;H'EgÏ;E�2IAaA�B;H`.7>@,k03.v2T57A�Z�0GA�57>O*�Nå0 /�Z;24BjCW0357E Ë '���!<Õ NybuB;H'E�H#Î � ' 512U0q24Z�E�6�03,/HD:OH'E�=-X #�H'A

� ß�� !�� X���1���� �¿�@�Í����� � ¸ Î ´�ªMª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ,�¥»­�¤J¼ o��ºä �Ö´�ªMÂ1¬[È?¥+¤ ° «g´»¼±©G ©G¥ Î ÀY BsZ;2M69E�>O=ÄA�B;HU,/.903242T57Ï�,k0GA�57>O*i>O6�.1>O:`A�H'E�=<51*�03. CW035VE�2/N�E�H/,k03.7.1H/^i51*ií�C;C(H/*;^;5 � uN�Î�572P0`,'8�,'.151,g2457*@Ø

:OZ;.90GE457Aw8LN � 512º0q2T=?>@>3A�B¾,/Z�E4KLH_:OH'E�= 03*;^ �� =<H/H'A�2º>O*;.V8�>O*;H_H ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.¿^;5VK�512T>3E#>O6cA�B;H_=?51*;57=_03.^;H/2457*;:OZ;.90GE�572�0GA�57>O*->�KLH'E�Î�N�>O*;HM>O6 A�B;HMH/*;^;2�>O6 A4B;HP,[B�0351*�XÌ Ha51*LA4E�>@^;Z;,'H?24>O=?HU,/>O*LKLH/*;51H/*LAg*;>3A[0GA�57>O*¾6�>3EP^;H/24,'E�5V]�51*;:�A�B;572º245VA�Z�0GA�51>O*�X Y B;H<*;>3A[0GA�51>O*i512MÏ"�;H/^

A�B�E�>OZ;:OB;>OZ�AuA�B;HãCW0GC(H'Ek~���1��� � �����;�%�»���hþ½��� �y� ¡k� � ������¡a�;�?� �����®�(�L�Ì H�57*;^;51,k0GA4H�A�B;H�2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8ëAw8@C(H¾>O6ºA�B;H�A4E�5VC�.1H�Î � � Ü ' ]�8ç0�KLH/,'A4>3E">O6#51*LA�H/:OH'E42 � ß

Ò Ë U �Ê � U �� � � � � � U �5 Õ NåbuB;H'E�H`A�B;H�U � 0GE�H_A�B;HDH �;,/HJC;A�51>O*�03.c^;5VK�512T>3E�2a>O6 �' Ë >�KLH'EãÎ Õ 03*;^ �� =?H/H'A�2 U Ê XÌ H-bu51.7.\2�0�8 Ë '���!<Õ NvB�032_0¾2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8�>O6 �¨� �å� �Ý0GAÔÎ�X�#�H'A � ](H�A4B;H�,/>@H !?,/57H/*�A?>O6 � N¿A�B�0GA?572! ß � � X � 6v,/>OZ�E424H Ë '���!<Õ 572PZ;*;51rsZ;H/.78Ð^;H'A4H'E�=?57*;H/^ Ë .7>@,k03.7.78q03*�03.V8@A�57,k03.1.V8 Õ ]�8 �ë03*;^ � X Ì Ha*;>3A�HA�B�0GA#A�B;572#KLH/,'A�>3Eg*;>3A[0GA451>O*m512ºA�B;H`2TA�03*;^�0GE�^jbc0�8m>O6\^;H/24,JE�57]�57*;:�0",'8�,'.151,`2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8LN�A�B;H`>O*;.78�*;HJb6�Hk0GA�Z�E4HPB;H'E�HÔ512R>OZ�E�2TC±H/,/5VÏ�,k0GA�51>O*->O6 A�B;H ©�¹I²/©�³[¤'¼�¥c³Jù ° µO¤ N;A�B�0GAu512/N;A�B;HÔ,/Z�E4KLHM=?H/H'A451*;: �� XY B;H�/�Z;24B",/>O*;^;5VA�51>O*-51=<C�.751H/2R=gZ;,¨B"=<>3E�HMA4B�03*�.1>O:UA�H'E�=?57*�03.15VA+8`>O6 � NWA�B;HÔ24=_03.7.1H'ERA�B;HP,'>@H�!<,/51H/*LA

� 512/N;A�B;HM=?57.1^;H'ERA�B;HM2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8LX Y B;HMC;E�H/,/5724HP2IA[0GA�H/=?H'*�Au51*LKL>O.7KLH/2u0a^;HJÏ�*;57A�57>O*�~���1����� 7�� 9y�����%�»��� ��� �å��ÿ3����� K �M� K®� �W¢%� Ì Habu51.7.å240�8i0DKLH','A�>3Eº>O6�C(>O245VA�57KLHU51*LA�H/:OH'E42 � Ë 03*;^Í03.12T>�0/�Z;24B"CW0357E Ë '���!<Õ4Õ B�032 ¡��å��ÿ3����� Kc��� K»� � ;D516 Ë 57*-A�B;Hº*;>3A[0GA451>O*�>O6 Ë :�XæÅ�X � Õ4Õ A�B;Hº,'>@H�!<,/51H/*LAS>O6 U Ê Ë 6�>3Eo�� Õ B�032RA�B;HP6�>3E�= ; �'=sN�beB;H'E4H =#512RA�B;HÔ57*;^;H �->O6 Ë A�B;HM,'8@,/.157,Ô2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8�^;HJÏ�*;H/^�]s8 Õ ��X���1����� �¿�@�Í����� .Wù ¯L¯ ¬�ªk¤Ô¥®­;¤ ¯ ©3´ ° Ë '���!<ÕM´�ª�cù�ª[­;À Á ­;¤J¼

Ë ð Õ Á ­;¤ ° ¤S´�ªã©gù@¼�´|ø'ùW¤º¤��@³[¤ ¯ ¥®´¶¬G¼±©GÂ(¹3´�µ�´�ªk¬ ° ¬+¸�«<© �O´»«<©G ³[¬�¤ !ë³J´¶¤'¼�¥ �½ûy´�¥®­ ° ¤¨ª ¯ ¤¨³J¥�¥w¬ o��uä ! � À � ¥´�ªM¥®­;¤g¤ �@³[¤ ¯ ¥|´¶¬�¼(©G ¹G´�µ�´�ªk¬ ° ©�¹I²/©�³[¤'¼�¥å¥+¬ � ,�¥®­�©G¥¿´�ª U Ê ¬+¸ � � À � À � � À

Ë ó Õ � ¸P¥®­;¤ ¯ ©G´ ° Ë '9��!aÕP­�©GªMª ¯ ¤¨³J¥ ° ©GÂ�µ3©G ù�¤ ; ©3¥ Î ,c¥®­;¤J¼¾¥»­;¤a³[¬�¤ !ë³J´¶¤'¼�¥ �Ь+¸º¥»­�¤ ¯ ©G´ ° Ë '���!<ÕU©G¥ δ�ªº©3¥�Â1¤�©Gª¨¥ ; � Ë ;ãäëð ÕkÀ � ¼ ¯ © ° ¥|´¶³Jù@Â7© ° � à ; � Ë ;�ätð Õ�À

Page 49: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � ��0

+@51*;:OZ;.10GE�57A451H/2�bu57A�Bq24=?03.1. 2IC(H/,'ATE[03.�K303.7Z;HU0GE�HºKLH'E48"E�H'2TA4E�57,'A�H/^�X ,�>3EãA�B;Hg*;H �@Aã.1H/=<=_0�N�bcH#bu51.7.�,k03.1.A�B;HºKLH/,JA�>3E �jA�B;H ¡k��¡��å����¡k���±� >O6 ��516 ��512�>3];A[0357*;H/^q69E�>O= ��]�8�2TZ;,/,/H/242T57KLH/.V8Ð03^;^;51*;:D0<Awbc>_>O*"A�B;H.1H'69AkX���1����� �¿���Í����� � ¸ �ëß Ë � � � Õ?¥®­;¤J¼�¥»­�¤`¹G´ÇÆ㤠° ¤J¼�³[¤D¬+¸<¥»­�¤<ª ¯ ¤[³J¥ ° ©GÂ�µG©G ùW¤�¬+¸ � ©G¼±¹ � ´�ª Ë � Ò ó Õ = ,û�­;¤ ° ¤ = ´�ªP¥»­�¤P´�¼±¹s¤���¬+¸ � À � ¼ ¯ © ° ¥|´¶³Jù@Â7© ° ¥»­;¤Pª ¯ ¤[³'¥ ° ©GÂ�µG©G ùW¤#´�ªM´�¼�µ3© ° ´|©3¼�¥�ù@¼±¹�¤ ° ªJù�ª ¯ ¤J¼;ª¨´¶¬G¼ ,c©G¼±¹_´Ç¸� ­�©�ªMª ¯ ¤[³J¥ ° ©3Â�µG©G ùW¤ ; ,�¥®­;¤J¼ � ´�ªM¥®­;¤Mª¨ùsª ¯ ¤J¼�ª¨´¶¬�¼�¬I¸

Ë 0 Õ¾¥®­;¤g¤J« ¯ ¥®·?ª¨¥ ° ´»¼@È ,奮­�©G¥v´�ª �¾ß Ë ó � � � �-� ó Õ0,åûy­;¤J¼ ;Uß Å ÀË ] Õ Ë ï Õ-,奻­�©3¥¿´�ª �iß Ë ó � � � �-� ï Õ �T¬ ° Ë ï Õ � ,�û�­;¤J¼ ;gßÝð ÀË , Õ Ë . ÕU¬ ° Ë ï � ó Õ-,åû�­;¤J¼ ;#ßéó À

�S>3A�HcA�B�0GAybu57A�B;>OZ�AyA�B;H%/�Z;24B_03242TZ;=<C;A�51>O*�NOA�B�0GAå572å576(03.7.@bcH\Q�*;>�b 512�A�B�0GAåo��¿ä � � 512å.1>O:ãA�H'E�=?57*�03.|NA�B;H/*q,/>O=aC�.1H'A�H'.78-A4B;H#>3C;C(>O245VA�HºB;>O.1^;2'~uA�B;Hº2T=_03.1.7H'E � 572/N±A�B;H#=<>3E�HPC(>O2T2457]�57.157A451H/2eA4B;H'E�Hg0GE�H#6�>3EvÎi03*;^� X)+6 A�B;HÔ,/Z�E4KLH � 512R2451*;:OZ;.10GES0GAyÎ�NWA�B;H'*-]s8 Ë :�XæÅ�X � Õ N ' 572e24=?>s>3A�B�0GAyÎ�X Y B;Hº245 �/HP>O6 A�B;HP,/>sH�!?,'51H/*LA�2

>O6 ! be57.1.�,/>O*LA4E�>O.�A4B;HU2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457A�57H/2ã>O6 � X�,�>3Eã2457=<C�.157,/57Aw8">O6åH �@C(>O245VA�51>O*�N�24Z�C;C±>O24H ! ß � � Ë A�B�0GAã572Hk03,[B�,/>O=aC(>O*;H/*LAe>O6 ! B�032RA�B;HM2�03=?HM,/>@H�!<,/51H'*�A Õ X���1���(' �¿�@�Í����� �ãª[ª¨ù@«?¤ Ë '9� � �MÕÔ´�ª�cùsª[­�©G¥ Î À

Ë ð Õ � ¸ �Ö­�©�ªÔ«gùs ¥|´ ¯  ´½³J´�¥|· n ¥®­;¤J¼ Ë n Ò ð Õ � �éð ÀË ó Õ � ¸ �Ö­�©�ªÔ¥®ûv¬<ª¨«?¬�¬G¥»­�§ ° ©G¼(³J­;¤¨ªM«?¤¨¤J¥®´»¼@È<¥+¬D¬ ° ¹�¤ ° � ,c¬ ° ©?ù@¼�´|§ ° ©G¼(³¨­`ªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´»¥®·D¬+¸�È�¤'¼�ù�ª �

¥®­;¤J¼ � � �� � � Ê�p¸k¬ ° ¥»­�¤g¹�¤�2�¼�´�¥|´¶¬�¼¾¬+¸M¥®­;¤¨ª�¤Ôª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ªSªk¤¨¤ � AQA À A � ©G¼±¹ � AQA ÀCB � � À

Ë ï Õ � ¸ � - . � � ¥®­;¤J¼ �à­;©�ªM¼(¬ ° «<©GÂy³ ° ¬%ª¨ª¨´�¼@È�ªÔ©G¥ Î À

�S>�bé,/>O*;2457^;H'EeA�B;HM:O.1>3]W03.�2T57A�Z�0GA�57>O*�N�0gCW035VE Ë '9���MÕ N�>O6�0g,/Z�E4KLHÔ>O*�0g24Z�E�6�03,/H3NW24Z;,[B�A�B�0GA Ë '�� � �MÕ 572/�Z;24B Ë 032ãbu51.7. ](HgA�B;Hg,k0324HU51*ÐA�B;HgBsZ;*LAº6�>3E Ë ' Ê ���MÕ4Õ X Y B;HgAwbc>�,k0324H/2Ô0G](>�KLHg,k03*i]±HUC�.10�8LH'^¾03:L0357*;2TAHk03,[B?>3A�B;HJEkX�)+6 � B�032�03*L8a2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457A�57H/2/NOA�B;H/*<A4B;H/24He2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457A�57H/2�C�Z�A¿](>OZ;*;^;2�>O* � ]�8 Ë :�XpÅ�X # Õ X Y B;H/24H](>OZ;*;^;2Ô,/>O*LA4E�>O.�A�B;HU2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2M>O6 ' 03.7>O*;: � N�]s8 Ë :�XæÅ�X � Ø : Õ Xºzq>3E�HU,/>O*;,'E�H'A4H/.78LN�24Z�C;C(>O2TH � B�032Ô02457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8º>O6±=gZ;.7A�5VC�.157,/57Aw8ºnÖ0GAy2T>O=?HcC(>O51*LAkN�03*;^<.7H'A ;º]±HcA�B;Hu2IC(H/,'ATE[03.�K303.7Z;Hu>O6 Ë '���!<Õ 0GA�0ã2451*;:OZ;.10GEC(>O57*�A � X Y B;H/*-]�8 Ë :�XæÅ�X � Õ 03*;^ Ë :�XpÅ�X # Õ

; � Ë ;ãätð Õ �éð�� Ë n Ò ð Õ �

Y BsZ;2�576�n - ï�N ;UßçÅ�N�24>;N�]�8 Ë :�XæÅ�X : Õ N ' 572 ãZ>H¿03.�03.1>O*;: � X +@51=?57.90GE�.V8LN@516 � B�032�0U^;>OZ�]�.1HPC±>O51*LA�>O60GE�5VA�B;=?H'A�57,ã:OH/*sZ;2��(N�A4B;H/*

; � Ë ;�ätð Õ � � � Ë ó � Ò ð Õ24>�6�>3EÔHG��03=<C�.7HU576 � - ï�N ; � ðOX Y BsZ;2ã]s8 Ë :�XæÅ�X : Õ A�B;HU2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2M03.7>O*;: � 0GE�Ha0GAMbv>3E�2TAM>O6�Aw8@C±HË ó � � � �-� ï Õ X

Page 50: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

�,+ ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

+@51*;:OZ;.10GE�57A451H/2�>O6 � 03.724>ã,/>O*�ATE�>O.sA�>ã0S.7H/2424H'EyHG��A�H/*;^gA�B;Hc2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2�>O6 ' >3è � NO2T51*;,/H � ]±>OZ;*;^;2�A�B;H,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LA¿>O6 ' 0GA�03*�8U2457*;:OZ;.90GEyC(>O57*�AkN�03*;^a2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2�be5VA�BU24=_03.1.@,/>@H�!<,/51H'*�A¿0GE�HR6�0357E�.V8#E�H/2TA4E451,'A�H'^�X,W>3EeH �;03=<C�.1HGN�bcHÔ.7512TARA�B;HMC(>O24245V]�51.757A�57H/2cbe5VA�B � Ë 'åÕ � ï � � 51* Ë ð�Å�X1ð Õ X

� 6�,/>OZ�E�24HMbcHPB�0kKLHãA�B;HP2�03=<HM,'>O*�A4E4>O.�buB;H/*;H'KLH'EubcHPB�0kKLHº03*�Z�C;C(H'Eu](>OZ;*;^�>O* � X

/� ��K®�»ÿO���%������¡Uþ½�W�<�%� ����� ���L� )+*DA�B;HMB�Z;*�AkN Ò Ë o����ä ! � Õ 512R03=<C�.1HGX Y B�Z;2uA�B;H Ë *;Hk0GE Õ /�Z;24B;*;H'242�>O6Ë ! � �-' � Õ 24H'A42eZ�Cq0UZ;24H/6�Z;. ^;57,[B;>3A�>O=#8(~

Á ­;¤eª¨«<©GÂ�Â1¤ ° ¥»­;¤Ô³[¬�¤ !ë³J´¶¤'¼�¥»ªã¬+¸ ! � ,�¥®­;¤eªJ¥ ° ¬�¼@È�¤ ° ¬�ù ° ³[¬�¼�¥ ° ¬�Â�¬�¼�¥®­;¤ ¯ ©G´ ° Ë ' � ��! � Õ���¥®­;¤�Â7© ° È�¤ ° ¥®­;¤³[¬�¤ !�³J´½¤J¼�¥®ªº¬+¸ ! � ,�¥®­;¤a³JÂ1¬%ªk¤ ° ûv¤g© ° ¤Ô¥+¬`©_¥®´1Ès¤ ° À

íS2ã*;>3A�H/^¾0G](>�KLH3N�>O*;Hgbc0�8"A�>D>3];A[0357*Ð]±>OZ;*;^;2P>O*qA�B;Ha,'>@H�!<,/51H/*LA�2M512ã69E�>O= 2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2ã>O6 � ! � � XY BsZ;2#bcH`B�0kKLH?A�B;H_:OH/*;H'E[03.vC�B;57.1>O24>3C�BL8(~ Ì B;H'* � >3E � ä � 572#r@Z;5VA�H_2451*;:OZ;.10GEkN�bcH`H �@C(H/,'Ag2IA4E�>O*;:,/>O*LA4E�>O.®X�íS2u03*-Hk032I8-H �;03=<C�.1HG~

���1���®�s�j���W� � K�� �¿���Í����� � ¸0,å´�¼�¥»­;¤ã­sùs¼�¥�, � ­�©�ªP©gª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|·_¬+¸S«gù@ ¥®´ ¯  ´¶³J´�¥|·`©G¥yÂ1¤�©�ªJ¥ . ,奮­;¤J¼<' 3´�ª �Ôù ��©3Â7À �e¼�·��Ôù ��©3 'é­;©�ªº©?¥|´1È�¤ ° À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ �S>3A4H?]s8ÍA�B;H`^;H'Ï�*;5VA�51>O*j>O6\A�B;H`BsZ;*LA � à � 3 ß � Ë ' 3 Õ X Y BsZ;2#]�8 Ë :�XpÅ�X # X1ð Õ N � 3 � ð��3ï�XqíS*Hk032T8¾,/>@H !?,/57H/*�Ag,/03.1,/Z;.10GA�51>O*Í24B;>�bu2 ' 3 =gZ;2TAP](H ãZ Hv03.®N�24H/H Ë ð�Å�X1ð Õ X Y B;H_.1032TAPE4H/=_0GE4Qi512g03*ÍHk032I8,/>O*;24H'r@Z;H/*;,/HP>O6 �e57H/=_03*;* �u>@,[B�N�24H/H Ë ð�Å�X . Õ X �Ì B;H/* ! � B�032aAwbc>�,'>O=<C(>O*;H/*LA�2/NåA�B;H�C±>O24245V]�51.15VA�51H'2a6�>3E Ë ' � ��� � ä � � Õ bu51.7.c^;57K@51^;HD51*LA�>�0¾2T=_03.1.

*�Z;=g]±H'Eã>O6y6�0357E�.V8-2T51=<C�.7Hº:OH/>O=?H'ATE�51,Ô,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*;2/N(beB;57,[BqbvH#*;>%b�51*LA4E�>s^;Z;,/H3X Ì H#^;H'Ï�*;H#A�B;HP,/>O*@ØÏ�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*;2u57*�:OH/*;H'E�03. Ë A�B�0GAe572u>OZ�A42451^;HMA�B;HÔ,'>O*�A�HG��Au>O6 A�B;HMBsZ;*LA Õ X

£ ¤'¥ � ©3¼±¹�� §¨¤#¥|ûv¬ ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼(©GÂ�³Jù ° µO¤¨ª<¬�¼�' ,cª¨ùW³¨­"¥»­�©3¥ o��gä � ä � ´�ªºÂ ¥e©G¥e©3¼�·`ª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© °u¯ ¬�´�¼W¥¬+¸ '�À �q¤g¤J« ¯ ­�©�ª¨´ ��¤Ô¥®­�©G¥u¤J´�¥®­;¤ ° � ¬ ° � «<©G·<­�©Gµ3¤Ôª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥®´½¤¨ª �I©G¥�ª¨«?¬%¬�¥»­ ¯ ¬�´�¼W¥»ªº¬+¸ ' � À

Y B;HÔ6�>O.7.1>�be57*;:aÏ�:OZ�E�HMbe57.1.�B;>3C(H'6�Z;.1.78�,/.10GE�51698`24>O=<HÔ>O6�A�B;HP*;>3A[0GA451>O*�~

Page 51: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � ��.

B

B

B

A

A Tacnode

B

A

A Banana A Fence

A

A

,�57:OZ�E�HUð

���1���®�W� 7D�:9y�����%���±�¿� Ì H\2�0k8#A�B�0GA Ë '���� ä �UÕ 572å0 ü��W� �W� � N3576 � 03*;^ � =?H/HJAy51*UH ��03,'A4.78ºAwbc>ãC(>O57*�A�2'N03*;^-A�B;HJE�HP*;>3E�=?03.1.78LX

���1���®� 5-7D�:9y�����%���±�¿� Ì H#2�0k8�A�B�0GA Ë '9��� ä �aÕ 512ã0 þ½����ÿO� 516 � 03*;^ � =?H'H'Aã0GASH �;03,'A�.V8�>O*;HºC(>O57*�A/N03*;^-A�B;HJE�HP*;>3E�=?03.1.78LX

���1���®� ( 7D�:9y�����%���±�¿� Ì HM2�0k8?A�B�0GA Ë '���� ä �UÕ 512R0 ���WÿL� ��� � 516 � � � 572\0GAu=<>O2TAvAwbc>gC(>O51*LA�2/N�A4B;H'E�H512e>O*;HºC(>O51*LA � � � � � 24Z;,[BqA�B�0GA � ä � B�032ã0?*;>s^;H#>O6å:OH'*sZ;2 � - ó?0GA ��Ë 6�>3E�A�B;H#^;H'Ï�*;5VA�51>O*�N±24H/HË ðOðOX7ð Õ4Õ N;03*;^�576 A�B;HJE�HP572e0U24H/,/>O*;^�C±>O51*LAe57* � � � N�A�B;H/* � 03*;^ � =?H/HJARA4B;H'E�HP*;>3E4=_03.1.V8LX

íS*;>3A�B;H'E�A�>@>O.;buB;51,[B_bcHeZ;2TH�E�H'C(H/0GA�H/^;.78a512¿0PCW0GE4A�5103.W,'.90324245VÏ�,k0GA�57>O*?>O6(A�B;H�,/>O*LA4E[03,JA�51>O*;2@R � ~ � � Ò�Ó' � Ë .1>s,k03.1.V8�03*�03.V8@A�57,k03.1.V8�0GE4>OZ;*;^ � Õ X Y B;H#,/.9032T2457Ï�,k0GA451>O*Ð512SHk032T8"03*;^iH/.7H/=?H/*LA[0GE48LX Ì H#,k0GE4E48"5VAã>OZ�A51* � ðOðOX Ì 57A�B"A�B;572M,'.90324245VÏ�,k0GA�57>O*�N�>O*;,/H#bcH#B�0�KLHg57^;H/*�A457Ï�H/^ Ë ' � ��� ä �UÕ >3E Ë ' Ê ���MÕ N�bcHg,k03*qE�H'KLHJE�24HA�B;HMC;E�>@,/H'242uA�>UE�H/,/>�KLH'E ' 3 X

Page 52: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ) ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

���1���®� �_�±� ý�� �������%ÿG�â�Wþu�%� � ���%���Wþ��Y B;HP:OH/*;H'E�03. 57^;Hk0<>O6 A4B;Hº24H/,/>O*;^"B�03.76�>O6 A4B;HPC;E�>@>O6 >O6 Ë ðOXæï Õ 572�032R6�>O.1.1>�bu2 Ë 24H'Hº03.12T>aA�B;H /�>�b ,[B�0GE4A

](H'.1>�b Õ XcíS2T24Z;=?51*;: ' ß ' 3 B�032e*;>?A451:OH'E Ë 03*;^"2457=<C�.78D,/>O*;*;H/,JA�H/^q24=?>s>3A�B-.7>@,/Z;2 Õ NWbcHÔE�Z;*-A�B;HºB�Z;*LAkX)+6 � 572#24Z"!?,/57H/*LA�.78m2457*;:OZ;.90GEkN�bcH_HG��C(H','AkN�]s8ÍA4B;H`0G](>�KLH`C�B;57.1>O24>3C�BL8LN�KLH'E48Í2IA4E�>O*;:q,/>O*LA4E�>O.|X")+*j6�03,'AbuB;H/* � Ë �MÕ - ó Ë A�B;H?0GE�5VA�B;=?H'A451,g:OH/*�Z;2 Õ bcH<0GE�H?0G]�.7HaA�>DE�Z;.1Ha>OZ�Aº03.7.�]�Z�Aº>O*;H<,/0324H3N buB;51,[B�bcHa,k03*H �@C�.151,'57A�.V8�,/>O*;2TATE�Z;,'AkN Ë ð � Xpó Õ X Ì B;H'* � Ë �MÕ ß ðD>3E � 572#24=?>@>3A4B�bcH_,/>O*;2457^;H'EaA4B;H_*;H ��AgB�Z;*�Aa2TA�HJC�XíS:L0351*ibcH<H �@C(H/,JA#2TA4E�>O*;:-,/>O*�ATE�>O.¿576 � � ä � � B�032#0-2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457Aw8Ð>O6\0GE�57A�B;=<H'A�51,U:OH/*�Z;2#0GAº.7Hk032TAÔA+bv>;N03*;^m51*Í6�03,'A#bvH_,k03*ÍE�Z;.1H_>OZ�Ag03.7.�C±>O242457]�57.15VA�51H/2PH �;,/HJC;A Ë ' � ��� � ä � � Õ H/57A4B;H'EU0�24=?>s>3A�B $\03*�03*�0�N�>3EË ' � ��� � ä � � Õ 0D6�H/*;,'HUbu57A�B � � 2T=?>@>3A�BÐ03*;^ � � >O6¿0GE�57A4B;=?H'A�57,º:OH/*�Z;2<ðON�be5VA�BÐ0D2T51=<C�.7HU*;>s^;H3X ,W>3E24Z;,[B<CW035VE�2åA4B;H?$c>O:O>O=?>O.1>�KE$c>OZ;*;^ Ë # X ó Õ :O57KLH'2yKLHJE48U2TA4E�>O*;:Ô:O.1>3]W03.;,/>O*LA4E�>O.®N@03*;^UbcHe0GE4He0G]�.7HRA�>Ô:O57KLHR0,/.103242457Ï�,/0GA�51>O*�N�03*DH ��C�.751,/5VA\,/>O*;2TA4E4Z;,'A�51>O*D>O6�Hk03,[B�C(>O2T2457]�.7HM,/0324H3N�24H/H Ë ð�ï�Xpó Õ 03*;^ Ë ð�ï�X � Õ X Ì HM03.12T>aB�0kKLH0g,/.903242T57Ï�,k0GA�57>O*`6�>3ERA4B;HÔ57*�KLH'E424HSA4E[03*;246�>3E�=?0GA�51>O* ' � ���� ' 3 Ë 24H/H � ðOð Õ 03*;^�2T>a,k03*`E�H/,'>%KLH'Ee03*DH ��C�.751,/5VAH �@C;E�H/242457>O*�6�>3ES03.7.(C(>O242T57]�.1H ' 3 XÌ Ha*;>3A�H3N 57*�,k0324HaA�B;HaE�H/03^;H'E#512ãC�Z ���/.7H/^Í]s8ÐA�B;Ha>@,/,/Z�ETE�H/*;,/H_>O6c0�*;>@^;H3N�]�Z�A#*;>3A#0D,/Z;2TC�N�51*iA�B;H

C;E�H/,'H/^;51*;:-CW0GE�03:3E[0GC�B�N�A�B�0GAãA�B;HUATE�[email protected]�>O6 R��� �Ê Ë ' 3 Õ 03.1.7>%bu2ãZ;2P0GAãKG0GE�51>OZ;2ãC(>O57*�A�2SA�>D2457=<C�.157698"A�B;H03*�03.78@24512'N@03*;^`51*aCW0GE4A�51,'Z;.90GE¿A4>PE�Z;.1He>OZ�A\0P6�H/*;,/H�buB;H'E�H � � B�032c0P:OH/*�Z;2Sð�,/Z;2TC�X Ì H�2TB;>OZ;.1^D03.124>P*;>3A�HA�B�0GAkNO6�>3Eå2457=<C�.157,/57Aw8P>O6�H �@C(>O245VA�51>O*�NO57*UA4B;Hu0G]±>%KLHc2IQLH'A�,[BabcH\B�0kKLH\.1H/69Aå>OZ�A�0S6�H'bâC(>O242T57]�51.757A�57H/2/X �ã03=<H/.78� Ê >3E � � ,/>OZ;.1^"]±Hg0`*;HJAkN(>3E � =?57:OB�Au](H#,/>O*LA4E[03,'A4H/^Ð]�8 R � Ë 24> ! � B�032S>O*;.78�>O*;H#,'>O=<C(>O*;H/*LA Õ X � 6,/>OZ�E�2THÔ57*DA�B;HM03,'A4Z�03.±C;E�>@>O6�bcHM03*�03.78@24H�A�B;H/24HM,k0324H'2/NW03*;^-032\51=aC�.151,'57A�.V8<57*;^;51,k0GA�H'^-51*`A�B;Hã2TQLH'A4,¨B�N;E�Z;.7HA�B;H/=×>OZ�AkX

���1���®� � J ���(�����(�U�����s�������@� þ½�W� � ��5;���

Y B;HME�H'=_0351*;^;H'Eu>O6 � :U512R^;57K@51^;H/^"032R6�>O.1.7>%bu2/X)+* Ë :�X7ð Õ bcHa:O5VKLH<0D,/>O*;,'E�HJA�H<H �;03=<C�.1Hg>O6åA�B;H<B�Z;*�A/Xa)+* Ë :�Xpó Õ bcHa=?0GQLHgC;E4H/,/512TH<A�B;HU^;H'Ï�*;57A�57>O*�>O6

A�B;H#B�Z;*�A�/(A�B;H'E�Hg0GE�Hg0?6�HJb�,[B;>O51,/H'2ãA4>?](H#=_03^;H3N±03*;^Ð0?6�H'b 03242TH'E4A�57>O*;2�A�B�0GA�E�H/rsZ;57E�HºC;E4>@>O6½Xu)+* Ë :�Xæï ÕbcH?2IA�Z;^�8�A�B;H?:OH'*;H'E[03.�C;E4>3C(H'E4A451H/2º>O6vA4B;HS/�Z;24Bm,/>O*;^;57A�57>O*�XD)+* Ë :�X . Õ bcH<^;H'A�H'E�=<51*;H<A�>�beB�0GA#^;H':3E�H/H/�Z;24B;*;H/2T2U572PC;E�H/2TH'E4KLH/^Í]�8¾A�B;H?B�Z;*LAkX Y B;H/*ÍbcH?:O5VKLH?0�C;E4>3C(>O245VA�51>O* Ë :�X .;X � Õ buB;51,[Bm:O57KLH/2P0�^;H'A[0351.7H/^^;H/24,JE�57C;A�57>O*">O6 A�B;HMC(>O24245V]�51.757A�57H/2e6�>3EuA�B;HÔÏ;E�2IA�Awbc>?B�Z;*�AS2IA�H'C�2/X Y B;HPC;E�>s>O6�>O6 Ë ðOXæï Õ A�B;H'*-C;E�>@,'H/H/^;2�]�803*-HG��C�.157,/57Ae03*�03.78@24512R>O6 A4B;H/24HÔC±>O24245V]�51.15VA�51H'2/X Y B;512R512R,k0GE4E451H/^�>OZ�Au51*�24H/,'A451>O*;2 � ð�.GØ4ð # X

�SH �@AcbcHã:O57KLHM03*�>�KLH'E4K@51H'bt>O6�A4B;HÔ24H','A�51>O*;2'N�03*;^�A�B;H/*�0E/�>%bc,[B�0GE4ARbuB;51,[B-24B;>�bu2RA�B;Hã.7>O:O51,k03.(>3E4^;H'E>O6 A4B;HÔC;E�>s>O6½X � ð�Å�Ø4ð�ïUA4E4Hk0GA�0U,/>O.1.7H/,'A�57>O*->O6 H/2424H/*LA�5103.1.78D57*;^;H'C(H/*;^;H'*�ASA�H',¨B;*;57,k03.�512424Z;H'2/~)+* � ð�Å`bcHg:O5VKLHg0`CW0GE4A45903.�,/.10324245VÏ�,k0GA�51>O*Ð>O6 ' be5VA�BÐ*;>DA�57:OH'EkN�03*;^Ð24=_03.7. ,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LAkX Y B;HUE�H'24Z;.7A�2'N

03*;^Í*;>3A[0GA�57>O*�N 0GE4H?Z;24H/^�E�HJC(Hk0GA�H'^;.78i51*�A�B;HaBsZ;*LAU03*�03.78@24512/X Y B;572Ôbu51.1.y](H<0-=_0357*iA�>s>O.å57*¾A�B;H?,/0324H/2� Ë �MÕ - ó@X)+* � ðOðDbcH-:O5VKLH_CW0GE4A�5903.c,'.90324245VÏ�,k0GA�57>O*;2<6�>3EUA�B;H-,/>O*LA4E[03,JA�51>O*;20R � Nv03*;^�CW0GETA�5903.c,/.10324245VÏ�,k0GA�51>O*;2a6�>3E

É Ê Ø¶]�Z;*;^;.7H/2/X Y B;H'24HPbu51.1.�]±HP24Z"!<,/51H/*LAS6�>3Ee,/.903242T51698�57*;:<A�B;HÔ51*LKLH'E�24HPATE[03*;246�>3E�=_0GA451>O*;2 ' � ÒWÓ ' 3 51*�A�B;H

Page 53: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � �0�

,/5VE�,/Z;=?2TA�03*;,/H/2ubvHÔbu51.1.�H'*;,/>OZ;*�A4H'ES51*DA�B;HMBsZ;*LAã03*�03.78@24512'X)+* � ð%ó#bcHP2TA4Z;^�8�A�B;HÔ.157*;Hk0GEe2I8�2TA�H'= l o�����ä � l�51*-A�B;HÔ,k0324HMbeB;H/* � 512u*;>3Ae24=<>@>3A�B�Xy)+*-A�B;HP,/0324H/2

buB;H/* �iß ð � ó`A4B;H<2T8@2TA�H/= A�Z�E�*;2º>OZ�AÔA�>-,/>O*LA[0357*m0-24Z�E4C;E�572451*;:q03=<>OZ;*�AÔ>O6c:OH/>O=?H'ATE�51,U51*;6�>3E�=?0GA�51>O*�X,W>3E �aßéóP5VAv^;H'Ï�*;H/2\0 É�Ê Ø|Ï;];E[0GA�57>O*�N�03*;^`6�>3E �UßÝðã0M]�57E[0GA�57>O*�03.WATE[03*;246�>3E�=_0GA451>O*aA4>g0E(M>3E�H'*;2TA�H/57*D.7>O:^;H/.���H����/>;X)+* � ð�ïqbcHD:O57KLHD0ÐCW0GE4A45903.c,/.103242457Ï�,/0GA�51>O*�>O6?$\03*�03*�032<03*;^ ,�H'*;,/H/2/X Y B;H'24H�bu51.7.v](H-2TZ"!?,/57H/*�A<6�>3E

,/.103242451698@51*;: Ë ' � ��� � ä � � Õ N�51*�A4B;HP,k0324H'2ubcHMbe57.1.�*;H/H/^�A�><,/>O*;2T51^;H'EkX)+* � ð�.GØ�ð # bcHD03*�03.78�2TH`A4B;HDC±>O242457]�57.15VA�51H/2#6�>3EUA�B;H`B�Z;*�AkN¿03,/,/>3E�^;57*;:iA�>"A�B;H`];E�Hk0GQ@^;>%bu*�>O6 Ë :�X .;X � Õ X

Y B;H/24HP2TH/,'A�57>O*;2�0GE�HÔH/2424H/*LA�5103.1.78D57*;^;H'C(H/*;^;H'*�AkN±03*;^�,k03*D](HÔE4Hk03^�51*-03*�8D>3E�^;HJEkX,�51*�03.7.78Ð51* � ó3Å�bcH?6�>3E4=_03.1.V8"C;E�H/24H/*LAºA�B;HaC;E�>@>O6v>O6 Ë ðOX1ð Õ N�beB;57,[B�be57.1.�](H?*;>3A4B;51*;:-]�Z�Ag0�24H'E�57H/2º>O6

E�H/6�HJE�H/*;,/H/2ÔA�>DA4B;HUC;E�H',/H/^;51*;:-24H/,'A�57>O*;2/X Y B;572ã24H/,'A�57>O*�03.724>�57*;,/.1Z;^;H'2ÔC;E�>s>O6�2Ô>O6åA�B;Ha,'>3E�>O.1.10GE�51H/2ã2TA�0GA�H/^51*DA�B;HP57*�ATE�>@^;Z;,'A451>O*�X

Page 54: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���� � � �®� � �\��������� � � � � $�$%����� ' ����$<��h��� � �WÍ����� R �� �Ê Ë ' 3 Õ ß � ð � ��a���&>� �\����� ' �����h$ �W���(�9��&`(������ ��� &-�(���2 � � Ü '

�eZ;*"öSZ;*LARbe5VA�B Ë ' 3 ��! 3 Õ ß Ë '�� % Õ(MH'*;H'E[03.�];E�Hk0GQ�^;>�bu*�51*LA�><,/0324H/2e57* Ë :�X .;X � Õ � � (MH/>O=<H'A4E�57, � >O*;24H/rsZ;H/*;,/H/2e>O6�,�.1Z;24B�N � :�������� ,�57E42TAeöSZ;*LA +sA4H'C�~

� Ê 512u*;>3A�0U*;H'AkN � ð�.ã57K@51^;HM6�Z�E4A�B;H'Eã03*�03.V8�24572R03,/,/>3E�^;57*;:

A�> � Ë � Ê Õ

!�������#� � � .10324245VÏ�,k0GA�51>O*�>O6 É Ê Ø¶Ï;];E�0GA�51>O*;2/N Ë ðOðOX � Õ

�)+6 � Ë �MÕ - ó@N � ð �

' :O5VKLH/*�]�8 Ë ð � X ó Õ* � Ü ' � � &( )� .103242/X ' be5VA�B-2T=_03.1. � � ð�Ål o��ºä � l � ð%ó� �

)+6 � Ê 24=?>s>3A�B�N � ð :�+@H/,/>O*;^"öSZ;*LA?+sA�H'C�~

�eZ;.7HP>OZ�Ae03.1.�]�Z�Au>O*;HP,k0324HG~

+@=?>s>3A�B>$\03*�03*�0�X � .103242457698DCW035VE�2

Ë ' � ��� � ä � � Õ N Ë ð�ï�Xpó Õ�� .903242457698 ' N � ð #* � Ü ' �,� .903242'X@R Ê � R � N Ë ðOðOX1ð'Øwó Õ

)+6 � Ë � Ê Õ ßÝðON � ð�õ�Ø4ð �

)+6 � Ê B�032u2T51=<C�.7HÔ*;>s^;H3N � ð � � &''''( '''')�S> � Z;2TC�N � ð�õ

l o��#ä � l � ð%ó

ãZ>H¿03.�.1^�C�2/N � ï�+@H/,/>O*;^�öSZ;*LA +sA�HJC�~

�eZ;.1HÔ>OZ�A�03.7.(]�Z�A�>O*;HM,k0324H3~

,�H/*;,'H3X � .903242T51698`CW0357E�2

Ë ' � ��� � ä � � Õ N Ë ð�ï�X � Õ�� .103242451698 ' N Ë ð � X � Ø4ð�. Õ* � Ü ' �,� .903242/X�R Ê � R � N Ë ðOðOX1ð'Ø+ó Õ

���®� �D� � � �W� � K»�"�Wþe�%� �q�����(�L�

Page 55: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � � �

,�5 �¾0D,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*�51* É � >O6c0�A[03*;:OH/*LAº.751*;H3N 03*;^Í0�2TH/,k03*LA#.157*;H3N Þ 03*;^ � N A�>-0�,/>O*;57, � X�#�H'A�?ßÝÞ � � N±03*;^ � � � � �Ôß � � � X #�H'A��c~ �'ëÒWÓ É � ]±H#:O57KLH/*�]�8�]�.7>%bu51*;:_Z�C¾ï<A�51=<H/2S0GA ��N(03.Vb\0�[email protected]>O*;:MA�B;He2IA4E�51,JA�A4E�03*;246�>3E�= >O6(Þ"N � A�57=?H/2�0GA � Ns03.Vb\0k8�2�03.1>O*;:ÔA4B;He2TA4E451,'AåA4E[03*;246�>3E4= >O6 � Ns03*;^ � A�51=?H'20GA � N�03.7b\0k8�2u03.1>O*;:UA�B;HP2TATE�51,'AuA4E[03*;246�>3E4= >O6 � X@# HJA Ê N � N�03*;^ � ](HÔA4B;H Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�E4KLH'2�>O6 �' >%KLHJE � N� NW03*;^ �<E�H/2TC±H/,'A�5VKLH/.78LXöSH'E�HGN 032SA�B�E4>OZ;:OB;>OZ�AMA4B;HgCW0GC±H'EkN�bcH#be57.1.�>O69A4H/*¾Z;24HgA�B;Hg2�03=?Hg*;>3A[0GA451>O*"A�>D^;H/*;>3A�H#](>3A�Bi0`,/Z�E4KLH

03*;^�5VA�2u2IA4E�51,JAuA4E�03*;246�>3E�=ÖZ;*;^;H'ES24>O=<HM]�5VE[0GA�51>O*�03.(ATE[03*;246�>3E�=_0GA451>O*�X#�H'A �'�Ò�Ó ' ,'>O*�A4E�03,'AyA�B;Huo �� *;>O*@ؽ*;H/:L0GA�5VKLH\,/Z�E4KLH/2/X Y B;H/* ' 512å0SE[03*�Qg>O*;H\.1>O:ã^;H/. ��H����'>P24Z�E�6�03,'H3N

03*;^ �' 572u5VA�2u=<51*;51=?03.±^;H/2457*;:OZ;.90GE�572�0GA�57>O*�X ' B�032RA+bv><2457*;:OZ;.90GERC(>O51*LA�2/N

�`ß � 3 ß Ë ó � � � � � ó � ó � ó � ó Õ ß Ë ó � � � � �����kÕ

03*;^

� ß Ë � � � .� ������Õ

buB;H'E�H_6�>3E#H �;03=<C�.1H � � 51*;^;57,k0GA�H/2ÔA�B;H Ò � ؽ,/Z�E4KLH_>O6 �' buB;51,[BÍ512PA4B;H?2TA4E�57,'AºA4E�03*;246�>3E�=ì>O6vA4B;H?24H/,k03*LA.157*;H � X �qB�032e57*;^;H �-ï � 03*;^ � B�032u51*;^;H �-ï :�XåöSH'E�HM512e0UC�51,JA�Z�E�HP>O6�A�B;HP^;Z�03.�:3E[0GC�B->O6 �' >�KLH'E �

A

-2 -5 -2

D

-2 -2 -2

-1

,�57:OZ�E�HPó

Ì HMB�0�KLHÔ,[B;>O24H/*�A�B;HM*;>3A[0GA�57>O*�A�>U,/>3E4E�H'2TC(>O*;^�bu57A�BDA�B;HP>OZ�A4,/>O=?Hã>O6 A�B;HÔBsZ;*LAkXÑ 3 ~ � Ê Ò�Ó ' 3 ß ' H ��ATE[03,'A�2 U Ê ß � NåA�B;H Ò � ؽ,'Z�E4KLH->�KLH'E � 3 X R Ê ~ � Ê Ò�Ó ' Ê ,/>O*�ATE[03,'A�2UA�B;H

Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�E4KLH Ê X � Ê Ü ' Ê 572a0q24=?>s>3A�B É�Ê N�o�� �cä � 512#C�Z�E�H'.78j.1>O:"A�H'E4=?51*�03.®Ny03*;^�A�B;H'E4H�0GE4H`A4B�E�H/H2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2R>O6 ' Ê 03.1>O*;: � N

Ë ó Õ � Ë ó � ó � ó � ó Õ 03*;^ Ë ï � ó � ó Õ

buB;H'E�H`A�B;H�Z;*;^;HJE�.157*;H-51*;^;57,k0GA�H/2gA�B;H`,/Z�E4KLH`buB;51,[B � =?H/H'A�2g>O*mA�B;HD=?51*;57=_03.¿^;H/2T51*;:OZ;.90GE4512�0GA�57>O*�X�íC�51,JA�Z�E�HP>O6 ' N �' 03*;^-A4B;HME�H'.1H'KG03*�Ae.1>s,/5�51* É � 512u:O57KLH/*D]s8±~

Page 56: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

S P2

A

B

D

d

ba

A

DB

-2

-2

-1

-2

-5

-1

-2

-2

-2-2

-2 -2

-2

-2

-1

-4

.

.

x

y

~S

,�57:OZ�E�HÔï

� Ê � � 512\A�B;H Ë ï � ó � ó Õ C(>O57*�A/N�03*;^ Ñ Ê ~ � � ÒWÓ ' Ê HG��A4E[03,JA�2RA4B;H Ò ï�ؽ,/Z�ETKLH3NU � N;beB;57,¨B�512\A�B;HM2TA4E�57,'AA4E[03*;2T6�>3E�= >O6 � X@R � ,/>O*LA4E[03,JA�2 � Ü � � X � =<H/H'A�2 U � 0GAu0<2T=?>@>3A�B`C(>O57*�A/N�03*;^�=?H/H'A42 � 0GAuA�B;H ���C(>O57*�A Ë 03*;^ � 03*;^ � =?H'H'A��T>3C;C±>O2457A4H��<H/*;^;2u>O6 A�B;H ��� ,[B�0351* Õ XY B;Hv,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O* Ë ' � ��� ä �UÕ 572�0�24=?>s>3A�BP]W03*�03*�0 Ë A4B�0GA�512�0R]W03*�03*�0ã57*ºbeB;57,[Bg]±>3A�B#,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*LA�2

0GE�Hå24=?>s>3A�B Õ X +@Z;,¨BP,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*;2�0GE�Hy,/.103242457Ï�H'^º51* Ë ð�ï�X ó Õ X ' � 572 0�ãZ�H¿03.O24Z�E�6�03,/H3N�be5VA�BMAwbc>u2451*;:OZ;.10GEC(>O57*�A42 � Ê � � 03*;^ � � � � X

Page 57: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � ��2

� � 512RA�B;H � � C(>O51*LAS03.7>O*;: � NW03*;^ U � 572uA�B;H Ò ó%ض,/Z�E4KLH#=?H'H'A�51*;: � X R � ~ ���PÒ�Ó ' � � ,'>O*�A4E�03,'A�2 �#�H'A � ](HMA�B;HP57=_03:OHã>O6�U � X ' � ß 4 � 03*;^ � ä � ä � Ü ' � 512u0<,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*�>O6 Awbc>a24H/,'A�57>O*;2�03*;^0UÏ;];E4H3N�=<H/H'A�57*;:a*;>3E�=?03.1.78LXD ¤J«<© °GF À )+6\51*;2TA�H/03^j>O* ' � bcH_,[B;>O24H Ñ � ~ � ��Ò�Ó ' � A�>�]�.1>�bÚZ�CmA�B;H � Ê C(>O51*LAU03.1>O*;: � N A�B;H/*mbcHbc>OZ;.7^i](HUH �@A4E[03,'A�57*;:OU � ß Þ"X#íS:L0357* � 512ã,/>O*LA4E[03,'A�5V]�.1H3N�03*;^ R � bc>OZ;.1^i,/>O*LA4E[03,'AMA�> É�� N 03*;^ÐA�B;H,/>O=<C±>O2457A451>O*D>O6�R Ê N1R � NW03*;^ R � bc>OZ;.1^�HG��03,'A�.V8_E�H'KLH'E424Hº>OZ�E�,'>O*;2TA4E�Z;,'A451>O*�>O6 ' XvöS>�bcH'KLH'EuA�B;512R512u*;>3AB;>�b A4B;HÔB�Z;*�AeC;E�>@,/H'H/^;2/N�032u>O*;HÔ,k03*�,[B;H/,�Q�]�8D,/>O=<C�Z�A�57*;:<,/>sH�!?,'51H/*LA�2/NW24H/H Ë ð�ï�X ó Õ XÌ Hã*;>�bçZ;24HMA4B;HÔ,'E457A�H'E451>O*D>O6 � õ#A�>gC;E�>%KLH ' 3 572RZ;*;5VE�Z;.1H'^�X Ì Hã*;H/H/^�A�>UÏ�*;^DE[0GA�57>O*�03.(,/Z�E4KLH/2u>O* '

bu57A�B"Awbc>D03*�03.78sA�51,P];E�03*;,¨B;H'2MA�B�E4>OZ;:OBÐ>O*;Hg>O6�A�B;Hg2457*;:OZ;.90GESC(>O57*�A42/N�03*;^Ð>3A�B;H'E4bu5124Hg,/>O*LA[0357*;H/^i57*"A�B;H24=?>s>3A�B¾.7>@,/Z;2'X�,W>3EPA4B;512º.7H'A � � Ü É � ](HaA�B;H<A[03*;:OH/*LAº.751*;H<A4> � 0GA � X � * ' N � � =?H/H'A�2 +@51*;: Ë 'åÕAwbe57,/H3N;bu57A�BDA+bv>?03*�03.78sA�51,S];E[03*;,[B;H/2�0GA � ~

Ë ó 8 � � �����kÕ 03*;^ Ë ó � � � ó � ó 8 ��� � ÕbuB;H'E�HD6�>3EaHG��03=<C�.7H Ë ó � � � ó � ó 8���� � Õ 51*;^;57,k0GA�H/2gA�B;H`2TA4E451,'AgA4E[03*;2T6�>3E�= >O6RA�B;H_];E[03*;,[Bh=<H/H'A�2#>O*;.V8ÍA�B;H=_0GE4QLH'^ Ò ó%ض,/Z�E4KLH3Nå03*;^m=?H/H'A42º57A#*;>3E4=_03.1.V8LX �S>3A�HaA�B;H?];E[03*;,[Bjbu57A4BÍ2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8 Ë ó 8 � � �����/Õ 512PA�B�Z;2C�Z�E�H/.V8-.7>O:aA�HJE�=?51*�03.®X �¿03,[B-];E[03*;,[B"B�032e57*;^;H �"ï � ~�2451*;,'HÔA�B;HÔ51*;^;H �->O6 �Ð512RC;E�51=?HGN�A�B;512u,k03*�>O*;.78D6�0357.516�A�B;H#];E[03*;,[Bi512 � 0GE4A�51HJEkN�03*;^qA�B;512ã,k03*;*;>3AãB�0GC;C±H/*�032�A�B;H#Awbc>`.1>s,k03. ];E[03*;,[B;H/2Ô0GE�Hg51*q6�03,'AM24=<>@>3A�B�N24H/H Ë .;X1ð�Å�Xæï Õ 03*;^ Ë .;X7ð%ó@X ó Õ X � *;HP,/>O=aC�Z�A�H/2

Ò o�� � � � ß . �3ï �03*;^gA�BsZ;2�]�8ºA�B;H\,'E�5VA�H'E�57>O* Ë õ�X � Õ�' 3 512�Z;*;5VE�Z;.1H/^ Ë 03*;^U^;>O=?51*�0GA4H/^º]s8#E�0GA�51>O*�03.s^;H/6�>3E�=_0GA�57>O*;2�>O6Wï � � � Õ X���65 D��� �@�%�K ���%�W���@�#�W����þ½�����"���(�%¡3�öSH'E�HãbcHÔ=_0GQLHSC;E�H/,/5724HÔA�B;HÔ^;H'Ï�*;57A451>O*�>O6�A�B;HPB�Z;*�A/X¿íÝ:O5VKLH/*-2IA�H'C"B�032\A�B�E�H/HÔ2�03.157H/*LA�6�Hk0GA�Z�E4H/2/~Ë ð Õ Y B;H ùs¼(¹�¤ °  ·G´�¼@È_¥ ° ©G¼;ª�¸�¬ ° «<©3¥®´¶¬G¼;ª Ñ ~ �çÒ�Ó ' N1RM~ �çÒ�Ó ' Ê XË ó Õ Y B;H ªk³�©G ´»¼@È N�A�B�0GAu512\A�B;HM^;H'Ï�*;57A�57>O*�>O6 ! 8 Ë 6�>3EubuB;51,[B-A4B;H'E�HP572u2T>O=?HÔ,[B;>O57,/H Õ XË ï Õ Y B;HP,[B;>O51,'HP>O6 ^;5VK�5724>3E U H �@A4E[03,'A�H'^-]s8 Ñ X)wA�bu51.7.;](He,'>O*�KLH/*;57H/*LAcA�>PB�0kKLHS0Ô69E�03=?H'bc>3E4QUA�B�0GA�24H'CW0GE[0GA4H/2¿A�B;HRÏ;E�2TAvAwbc>Ô6�Hk0GA�Z�E�H/2c69E4>O= A�B;HRA�B;57E4^�X

���65±�� ��ÿO� K»�®� ý����S¤½ÈG´�¼Íûy´»¥»­�© ¯ ©G´ ° Ë '���!<Õ_¬I¸?© ° ©G¼ F ¬�¼(¤UÂ1¬�Èй�¤J *�¤�����¬`ª¨ù ° ¸k©�³[¤0,S©3¼±¹"©G¼h¤»Æã¤[³J¥|´�µ3¤�MúT¹3´�µ�´�ªk¬ ° ! �½ûv¤#¹s¬<¼(¬�¥R©�ª¨ª¨ùs«_¤ !ì´�ªº©`§¨¬Gùs¼±¹�© ° · � À£ ¤'¥ Ñ ~ �çÒ±Ó '�§¨¤P©G¼¾¤ �O¥ ° ©�³J¥|´¶¬�¼i¬+¸ ° ¤JÂ7©G¥|´�µ3¤ *c´½³�© ° ¹U¼�ù@«<§¨¤ ° ¬�¼(¤0,c¬I¸M©3¼"´ °¨° ¤�¹GùW³J´|§'Â1¤P¹G´�µ%´�ªk¬ ° U ¬+¸

¥®­;¤¿«g´»¼�´�«<©GÂ;¹�¤¨ª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�ªk©G¥®´½¬�¼±À Á ­�ù�ª �é­�©�ª9*\´¶³�© ° ¹u¼�ù@«<§¨¤ ° ¥|ûv¬ , ©G¼±¹�ªk¬e´»¥»ªR³[¬�¼(¤u¬+¸\³Jù ° µO¤¨ª � U Ê Ë ��Õ­�©�ªÔ¥®ûv¬�¤�¹�È�¤Jª/À��c¼(¤U¤�¹�È�¤Ô´�ª�È�¤J¼(¤ ° ©G¥+¤�¹`§'· U Àc£ ¤J¥ � È�¤'¼(¤ ° ©3¥w¤M¥®­;¤U¬G¥»­;¤ ° ¤�¹�Ès¤kÀ\£ ¤'¥ ��ß Ñ Ë U Õ�À£ ¤'¥ ! §¨¤P¥®­;¤ÔÂ1¬[È ¯ ù@Â�Â7§[©�³ F ¬+¸ ! �p¸k¬ ° ¥®­;¤#¹�¤�2�¼�´�¥|´¶¬�¼ ,yªk¤¨¤ � A À A � � � À�q¤MÂ1¤J¥ !��åß�!_ä � U À �D­�¤J¼ o��ºä ! ´�ªã¼�ùs«_¤ ° ´¶³[©GÂ� ·_¥ ° ´�µ�´|©3Â1,åûv¤P¥w© F ¤ � ß Å À �D­;¤'¼"Ò Ë o��ºä !aÕ

´�ªº©3« ¯ Â1¤Pûc¤g©�ª[ªJùs«?¤ Å � � � �çð ,\§'ùs¥vûv¤ºûy´�Â�Â�¼�¤Jµ3¤ ° ª ¯ ¤[³J´ ¸¨·a¥®­;¤g¤ �s©�³J¥vµG©G ùW¤kÀ

Page 58: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

���65±� � 7D�:9y�����%���±���¿���Í����� �ãª[ª¨ù@«?¤PÒ Ë o��#ä !aÕº´�ªP©3« ¯ Â1¤ � ° ¤¨ª ¯ Àu¼�ù@«?¤ ° ´½³�©GÂ� ·_¥ ° ´�µ�´¶©G � À Á ­�¤J¼

Ë ð Õ � ´�ª o�� úw¼�¤½ÈL©G¥|´�µ3¤0,v©3¼±¹D³[¬�¼W¥ ° ©�³J¥|´|§'Â1¤kÀ\£ ¤J¥ R §¨¤Ô¥®­;¤U©�ª[ªk¬�³'´|©G¥+¤�¹a«<© ¯ ÀË ó Õ o��`ä!�� ´�ªº©3¼�¥®´»úT©G« ¯ Â1¤ � ° ¤Jª ¯ Àu¼�ù@«?¤ ° ´¶³�©GÂ� ·_¥ ° ´�µ%´|©G � ÀË ï Õ !�� ´�ª U ¼(¤½ÈL©G¥|´�µ3¤ � ° ¤¨ª ¯ Àe¼(¬�¼�ú ¯ ¬%ª¨´�¥|´�µ3¤ � ÀË . Õ Á ­;¤ ° ¤u´�ªS©ºù@¼�´|ø'ùW¤ ° ©3¥®´¶¬G¼±©GÂ�¼�ù@«<§¨¤ °�� ª¨ùW³¨­a¥®­�©G¥ ûy´�¥®­ ! 8 ß � ! � , o��Sä�! 8 ´�ª � ¥ ° ´�µ%´|©GÂ7À � Ãéð

� ° ¤¨ª ¯ À � ßÝð � ÀË�� Õ o��`ä! 8c´�ª U ¼�¤½ÈL©G¥|´�µ3¤ � ° ¤¨ª ¯ À�¥ ° ´�µ�´|©G � ÀË õ Õ R ´�ªg¤J´�¥®­;¤ ° §/´ ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼(©GÂ1,c¬ ° ©MÉ�Ê�ú 2v§ ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼±ÀË � Õ � ¸ RM~ � ÒWÓ ' Ê ´�ª¾§'´ ° ©3¥®´¶¬G¼±©GÂ1,�©G¼±¹ ! Ê ß R Ë ! 81Õ-,`¥®­;¤J¼ o�����ä ! Ê ´�ª¾©G¼�¥|´�úT©G« ¯ Â1¤ � ° ¤Jª ¯ À

¼�ù@«?¤ ° ´¶³�©GÂ� ·_¥ ° ´�µ%´|©G � ©G¼(¹ ' Ê ´�ª#© ° ©G¼ F ¬�¼(¤ºÂ1¬�ÈD¹�¤' *e¤�����¬OÀË : Õ � ¸ o��gä ! ¹�¬�¤¨ªº¼(¬�¥\­�©Gµ3¤a©?ª ¯ ¤[³J´|©3Â�¥|´1È�¤ ° ,v¥®­;¤J¼ o��gä !#, o���ä ! 8 ,e©G¼±¹ o�����ä ! Ê © ° ¤a©GÂ�Â

F  ¥ �½´�¼ ¯ © ° ¥|´¶³Jù@Â7© ° ûv¤M­�©3µ3¤ ¯ ù ° ¤U§¨¬�ù@¼±¹L© ° ´¶¤¨ª � ©3¼±¹<¼(¬�¼�¤U¬+¸M¥®­;¤Ô¥®­ ° ¤[¤M­�©�ªg©aª ¯ ¤¨³J´|©GÂ�¥|´1È�¤ ° À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Ì H-C;E�>�KLH�A�B;H"03*LA�5Vؽ03=<C�.1H�,k0324H3X Y B;H"*�Z;=?H'E451,k03.7.78mA4E�5VK�5903.\,k032TH"512?2457=?51.10GEkN�]�Z�A?Hk032451HJEkXë)+6o�� � � - Å�N�A�B;H/*_o��i03*;^_B;H/*;,/HSo��`0GE�He*;H/6½N�0º,/>O*�ATE[03^;51,'A451>O*�N@B;H'*;,/HSo�� � � � Å�X �ç512v,'>O*�A4E�03,'A�57]�.7H]�8jA4B;H-,/>O*LA4E[03,'A451>O*�A4B;H/>3E�H/=�Nå24H/H�îæó@ð/ñ|XjöSH'*;,/H Ë ð Õ X Ë ó Õ 512U,/.1Hk0GEU]�8�57*�A�HJE�24H/,'A451*;:ibu57A4B U 03*;^ �aN6�>3EgH �;03=<C�.1H<]�8 *M.1H/57=_03*�{æ2º,JE�57A�HJE�51>O*m6�>3EU03=<C�.7H/*;H/242/X Ë ï Õ 6�>O.7.1>�be2P69E�>O= Ë ó Õ N�2457*;,/H`o�� � U - Å�]�8032424Z;=aC;A�51>O*�X $v8 Ë ï Õ N ! �g512 �ÄC(>O2T57A�5VKLH Ë 2457*;,/H�57A/{æ2?H'è±H/,'A�5VKLH Õ N �S>�b Ë . Õ 6�>O.1.7>%bu2?69E�>O= Ë ó Õ X Ë õ Õ 572>3]�K�51>OZ;2'N�69E�>O= Ë ð Õ X Ë � Õ 6�>O.1.7>%bu2P69E4>O= Ë ó Õ 03*;^ Ë ï Õ N�03*;^m51=aC�.151H'2 Ë � Õ N 2451*;,'H ' Ê B�032E�¿51,/0GE�^�*�Z;=g]±H'E>O*;H3X Ë : Õ 512R,/.1Hk0GEu69E�>O=ÖA�B;HM,/>O*;2TA4E�Z;,JA�51>O*�X �� ÀCB�À� D ¤J«?© ° F ªkÀ Ì Hã57*�A4E4>@^;Z;,/H ! �¿6�>3E\A�H',¨B;*;57,k03.�E�Hk0324>O*;2'Xå)+*�A4B;HMB�Z;*LAkN�516�o��Ôä ! 512 /�Z;24B�N;bcHãb\03*LAo��¾ä ! 8 A�>i](H>/�Z;24B�Nc]�Z�A_576�bcH�24,/03.1H�^;5VE�H/,'A�.V8LN¿bu57A�B;>OZ�A<51*LA4E�>@^;Z;,'51*;: � NvbcH�,/03*â>O*;.78�51*â:OH/*;H'E�03.:OZ�0GE[03*LA�H/H#.7H'KLH/.|X +@H/HºA�B;HºC;E�>s>O6å>O6 Ë :�X .;X1ð Õ X Y B;H#^;57è(HJE�H/*;,/H#](HJA+bvH/H/*qA�B;H#:OH/>O=?H'ATE�51,º57=<C�.157,k0GA�57>O*;2e>O6/�Z;24Bq03*;^�.1H'KLH/.�0GE�HGN�bvHÔ](H'.151HJKLH3N�24Z"!?,/57H/*LAeA�>SFIZ;2TA�51698DA�B;572e03^;^;5VA�51>O*�03.�A�H/,[B;*;57,k03.15VA+8LN;2TH/H Ë :�Xæï�Xpõ�Xæï Õ XY B;H?C;E�>@,/H'242g>O6R]�.7>%bu51*;:"Z�C�Nå24,k03.751*;:;Ny03*;^m]�.1>�be57*;:Ð^;>�bu*j,/03*j]±H_,k0GE4E�57H/^�>OZ�Ag57*m=UZ;,[Bm:3E�Hk0GA4H'E

:OH/*;H'E�03.157Aw8LN�03*L8`A�51=?Hã>O*;HÔB�032e0U.1>O:<=<51*;51=?03.±=?>s^;H/.�C;E�>O:3E[03=�X�+@H/H Ë ó@X1ð Õ >O6\î}óOó�ñ¶X

���65±��� �"���(�%�»� ý¾þ½�W�`�¾�%��ý��s�s�

���65±���87��:9������%�������_�������%��� Ì HRbu51.7.�,k03.1.�A4B;H\ATE[03*;246�>3E�=_0GA451>O*;2 Ñ � R Ë be5VA�BgA�B;HR032424>@,'590GA�H/^a^;57K@5124>3E�2 Õ

0 � � � �m�����(�¾¡'���� 6�>3E Ë '9��!aÕ 516 � Ë U � o��?ä !aÕ 572a=_0 ��51=_03.¿03=?>O*;:ÐH �;,/HJC;A�51>O*�03.\^;57K@5124>3E42U>O6uA�B;H=?57*;51=_03.�^;H/2451*;:OZ;.10GE�51240GA�51>O*�X

�S>3A�H3N(A4B;H'E�H<=?0�8�]±Ha2TH'KLH'E[03.y,[B;>O51,/H'2P>O6�U_Xº)I6 �Í512Ô0`,'8�,/.751,U2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8LN(bcHa03.1.7>%b 03*�8q,[B;>O51,'H<>O6=_0 ��51=_03.U_N�buB;51,[B"572u*;>3A�0 Ò ó%ؽ,/Z�E4KLH Ë A�B;512u512e03.7b\0k8�2\C(>O242T57]�.1HM]s8 Ë ð�Å�X7ðOð Õ4Õ ]�Z�A�516 �q512�0a*;>O*@ؽ,[B�0351*2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8LN�bvHME�H'r@Z;57E4HÔA�B�0GA U ]±HÔA�B;HM,/H/*LA4E[03.�,/Z�E4KLHGNWbuB;51,[B�B�032R=_0 �;57=_03.±,'>@H�!<,/51H/*LAe]�8 Ë :�Xpï�X # Õ XY B;H�=_0351*aBsZ;*LAvbcHube57.1.W,/>O*;2451^;HJEc512¿A4B;He24H'E451H/2c>O6±ATE[03*;246�>3E�=_0GA451>O*;2¿^;H'24,'E�5V](H/^`51*aA�B;H�51*LA4E�>s^;Z;,'A�57>O*�N

Page 59: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � �,0

](H':O51*;*;51*;:?bu57A4B Ë ' 3 � % Õ N;beB;HJE�HºbcH#03242TZ;=?H ' 3 ^;>sH/2S*;>3A�B�0kKLH#0aA�57:OH'EkN�03*;^">OZ�ES:O>L03.�512uA4>?H ��C�.751,/5VA�.78^;H'A�HJE�=?51*;H ' 3 X Ì H<bu51.7.�,k03.1.yA�B;572 �%� �������(���<���%� ! 3 ß %�X?öS>�bcH'KLH'EP>@,/,/032451>O*�03.7.78qbcHabu51.7.�E�Z;*Í0B�Z;*�A�FIZ;2TA#A�>":OH'*;H'E[0GA�H`0"24H'E451H/2#>O6 Ë 2457=<C�.157698�57*;: Õ ]�5VE[0GA�51>O*�03.åA4E[03*;246�>3E4=_0GA�51>O*;2'N�24H/H_6�>3EgH �;03=<C�.1HaA�B;HC;E�>s>O6 >O6 Ë ó3ï�X � Õ X Y B;HÔÏ;E�2TAe,k0324HMbe57.1.�2�0GA�5724698D24>O=?HÔ03^;^;57A�57>O*�03.�Z;24H/6�Z;. 032424Z;=<C;A�57>O*;2/~

���65±�(' 7�� 9y�����%�»���¿� Ì HPbu51.7.�2�0�8DbcHP0GE�H �����(�%�»� ý�þ½�W���¾�%��ýW�@� 516 Ë 51*�03^;^;5VA�51>O*�A�><A�B;HP032424Z;=<C;A�57>O*;2>O6 Ë :�X ó@X . ÕTÕ A4B;HÔ6�>O.7.1>�be57*;:<B;>O.1^�~

Ë ð Õ o��ºä ! [email protected]*;^"03*LA�5Vؽ03=<C�.1H3XË ó Õ Ë '���!aÕ 572 /�Z;2TBq0GAe2457*;:OZ;.90GERC(>O57*�A�2R>O6 ' .V8�51*;:U51*DA�B;HP2TZ�C;C(>3E4Ae>O6 ! X

Y B;HÔB�Z;*�Aebe5VA�B ! 3 ß %gbe57.1.�51*;^;H'H/^"2�0GA�5724698 Ë :�X ó@X # Õ N�24H/H Ë :�X .;X � Ø � Õ XÌ H#bu51.1.�Z;2THa2TA451.1.�6�Z�ETA�B;H'EÔ*;>3A[0GA�51>O*Ð6�>3EãA�B;HUBsZ;*LAPbu57A�B ! 3 ß %�X +@57*;,/HUbvHaB�0kKLHa*;>�b 51*LA4E�>s^;Z;,/H/^

*;>3A[0GA�57>O*P57*º24H'KLH'E�03.�C�.103,/H/2/N3bcHåbe57.1.OE�H'C±Hk0GA�5VA�03.7.�B;HJE�H3N324>uA�B;H¿E�Hk03^;HJE bu51.1.LB�0kKLHc0e,/>O*LKLH/*;57H/*�A E�H/6�H'E�H'*;,/H3X)wAe572RÏ"��H/^�6�>3ERA�B;HÔE4H/=_0351*;^;HJEe>O6�A�B;HÔCW0GC±H'EkX

���65±�®�s� 8K»��¡k¡/���%�h��þS� �W���;�%���±�hþ½�W�_�%� �q�����(�a�<���%� ! 3 ß % �Ñ � � R ��� Ê ^;H'Ï�*;HPA4B;HÔ*;H �@AeB�Z;*LAS2TA�H'C�6�>3E Ë ' � ��! � Õ X

' ��� � ß Ñ � Ë U ��� Ê Õ � ' � � Ê � � � � Ê ß R � � Ê Ë � � Ê Õ �

! � � Ê 512R^;H'Ï�*;H/^�]�8o�� �� � ä! � � Ê ß Ñ " Ë o���±ä ! � Õ �

!��åß�! � � Ê ä � U ��� Ê X�! 8 à ! �y512c^;H'Ï�*;H/^D51* Ë :�X ó@X � Õ X )wAc512 R � � Ê Ø|A4E�57K@5903.®X ! � � Ê ß R ��� Ê Ë ! 89Õ 03*;^`2�0GA�572TÏ�H/2

o����� � ä! 8 ß R "� � Ê Ë o����� � ä ! ��� Ê Õ �

' Ê � � ß R Ê Ë U Ê Õ � ' � � � ß R � Ë U � Õ ' � ��� ß R � Ë U �kÕ �

)+6�A�B;HJE�H<24H'H/=?2º0`C(>O242T57]�51.757Aw8q>O6v,/>O*;6�Z;2T51>O*�N bcHUbe57.1.�Z;24H<0�24Z�]�2T,'E�57C;A42/N � � � � � �,� � A4>-51*;^;57,k0GA�HUA�B;H2TA4E451,'ARA4E[03*;246�>3E4= >O6 � � �#�,� >O* ' � X

#�H'A � � � � � ]±HgA4B;HU,'>@H�!<,/51H/*LA�2ã>O6 � � �#�,� 51* ! Ê ��! � ��! � X Y B;H/2THa0GE4Ha03.724>_A�B;H#,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LA�2Ô>O62U Ê NU � N1U � 51*�! 8 Ê N ! 8 � N ! 8 � X�#�H'A ��� � � � � � � ]±HÔA�B;HM,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LA�>O6 � � � � � �,� � 51* ! � X

�S>3A�HeA4B�0GAv](H/,/03Z;24HÔ>O6�A�B;HS2T,k03.157*;:;N@A�B;HS,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LA�2 ��� � � � � � � Hk03,[BD2TA4E�57,'A�.V8<57*;,'E�Hk0324HSbu57A�B �4X2,�.7Z;24B@Ø*;H/242e03*;^�24,k03.751*;:a51=<C�.V8 ��� à � � à � � XRX

#�H'A � � ]±H#A�B;Hg,/>@H�!<,/51H'*�AÔ>O6@U � � Ê 51* Ë ' � ��! � Õ X Y B;572M572M03.124>_A�B;HU,/>@H !?,/57H/*�AM>O6yA�B;H#CW0357E Ë ' � ��! � Õ N24H/H Ë :�Xpï�Xpó@X ó Õ 03*;^ Ë :�Xpï�X � X . Õ XÌ HM.1H'A � � ]±HMA4B;HP,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LA�>O6 o�� (ä ! � XÌ HM.1H'A U Ê ](HP0 Ò ;Oؽ,/Z�E4KLHº03*;^>U � 0 Ò �Oض,/Z�E4KLH3X

Page 60: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� + ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

)+6 � CW032T24H/2<A�B�E4>OZ;:OBâ0i,[B�0351*�2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8 � >O6 � � N�A�B;H-*;>3A[0GA451>O* Ë � Ê � � � � � � � � � 5 Õ ^;H/*;>3A�H/2aA�B;H*;H/:L0GA�5VKLH->O6eA4B;H-24H/.761ؽ57*�A�HJE�24H/,'A451>O* >O6eA�B;H�,/Z�E4KLH/2?57*�A�B;H�=?51*;57=_03.vE�H/24>O.7Z�A�51>O*�>O6 � Nc0iC;E451=?H�0G](>�KLHË E�H'2TC�XÔZ;*;^;HJE�.157*;H Õ ��� =?H/03*;2�A�B�0GA � Ë E�H/2TC�XãA�B;Hg2TA4E451,'ASA4E�03*;246�>3E�=Ä>O6 ! � Õ =?H/H'A�2�A4B;HU,'>3E4E�H/2TC±>O*;^;51*;:,/Z�E4KLHÔ>O* �� � X Ì HÔ.7H'A � ](HMA�B;HP57=_03:OHS>O6 � >O* ' � � Ê X Ì Hãbe57.1.�bRE�57A�H 6�>3E Ê X���)( NÔ�%� ���s�%�%����¡g��þu�%� � �y��¡k� ÿO�±� �����%�����¿�)+*"A�B;512S24Z�]�ض24H/,'A451>O*qbcHgB�0�KLHºAwbc>`=_0357*":O>L03.12/X Ì Hºb\03*�ASA4>D>3];A�0351*�A�B;Hg:OH/>O=?HJA4E�51,P,/>O*;24H/rsZ;H/*;,/H/2

>O6�A�B;H?/�Z;24BD,/>O*;^;57A451>O*`^;5124,'Z;2424H/^�51* Ë :�XæÅ Õ N�03*;^_A�>g^;H'A�HJE�=?51*;HeB;>%bëA�B;H?/�Z;24BD,/>O*;^;57A�57>O*`512cH'è±H/,'A�H/^`]�8A�B;HÔ>3C(H'E[0GA451>O*;2R>O6 A�B;HÔBsZ;*LAkNW*�03=?H/.78`HG��A4E[03,JA�51*;:U>3Ee,'>O*�A4E�03,'A�51*;:<0a^;5VK�512T>3EkNW03*;^-24,k03.751*;:<0U](>OZ;*;^�0GET8LX���)(��1� �����;�%�»��� � Á ­ ° ¬�ùOÈG­;¬�ù@¥ � � À � � ûc¤U³[¬�¼�ª¨´|¹�¤ ° ©D§¨¬�ù@¼±¹L© ° ·�!<,¿ûy´�¥®­`ª¨ù ¯L¯ ¬ ° ¥ Þ ÀÌ Hã](H/:O57*-bu57A�BD24>O=?HM2451=aC�.1HãC;E�>3C(H'ETA�51H/2\A�B�0GAuB;>O.1^�57*�03*L8D^;51=?H/*;2T51>O*�X

���)(��®� �¿���Í�����-£ ¤'¥"! 8 - ! - Å ,Uûy´»¥»­ ! 8 ©�§¨¬�ù@¼±¹L© ° · ,`¬G¼ ©m¼(¬ ° «?©G �MúÛ¸/©�³J¥+¬ ° ´¶©GÂMµG© ° ´¶¤J¥|·-¦hÀ.Wù ¯L¯ ¬%ª�¤ Ñ ~ TÄÒWÓ ¦ ´�ª?©Ð§'´ ° ©3¥®´¶¬G¼±©GÂ�«?¬ °½¯ ­�´�ª¨« ûy´�¥®­Ð´ °¨° ¤�¹GùW³J´|§'Â1¤?¹3´�µ�´�ªk¬ ° ´|©GÂ�¤���³[¤ ¯ ¥|´¶¬�¼±©3 Â1¬%³Jù�ª0, U À�ãª[ª¨ù@«?¤ � ß � Ë U � o_f�ä !<Õ - Å Àu£ ¤J¥ ! §¨¤P¥®­;¤ºÂ1¬�È ¯ ù@Â�Â7§[©�³ F ¬+¸ !<,v¥»­�©3¥¿´�ª !iß � Uéä �!"À �ãª[ª¨ù@«?¤ !´�ªº©D§¨¬�ù@¼±¹L© ° ·OÀ

Ë ð Õ � ¸ o_fhä ! ´�ªMÂ1¤'µ3¤J ©G¼(¹ U ­�©�ªÔ«<© �O´�«?©GÂ�³[¬%¤ !�³'´¶¤J¼�¥ �p¸k¬ ° Ë ¦���!<Õ � ¥»­�¤J¼ o# Ðä�! ´�ªMÂ1¤Jµ3¤'Â7ÀË ó Õ � ¸ o# ¾ä! ´�ª �cùsª[­ ,¿¥®­;¤J¼ o_f ä ! ´�ªÔ¼�¬�¥ �cù�ª¨­M¸k¬ ° � ´ÇÆ ��ß U ,\©3¼±¹_¥®­;¤<³[¬�¤ !ë³J´¶¤'¼�¥\¬I¸ U

´�¼ ! ´�ªº©3¥¿Â1¤[©�ª¨¥\©�ªMÂ7© ° È�¤g©�ªÔ¥»­;¤a³[¬�¤ !ë³J´¶¤'¼�¥c¬+¸Mªk¬�«?¤º¼(¬�¼�¤���³[¤ ¯ ¥|´¶¬�¼±©3 ³[¬�« ¯ ¬G¼(¤J¼�¥u¬+¸ ! ÀË ï Õ � ¸\¦ ´�ªM¥+¤ ° «g´�¼±©GÂ�©G¼±¹ o_fhä ! 8 ´�ª �vùsª[­D¥®­;¤J¼ o_fhä ! ´�ª�cùsª[­�À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Ë ð Õ 03*;^ Ë ó Õ 0GE4HÔ>3]�K�57>OZ;2/XÌ HMC;E�>%KLH Ë ï Õ ]�8-57*;^;Z;,'A�57>O*">O*-A�B;Hº*�Z;=#](H'ES>O6 57E4E�H'^;Z;,/57]�.7Hº,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*�A42�51*-A4B;Hº24Z�C;C(>3ETAS>O6 ! Xc)+6

A�B;572c512%�/H'E�>;N�A4B;H�E�H/24Z;.VAuB;>O.7^;2c]s8_A�B;HS^;HJÏ�*;57A�57>O*�>O6�A�H'E�=<51*�03.|X�)+6�A�B;H'E�Hã572c=?>3E�H�A�B�03*`>O*;Hã,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*�A/NA�B;H/*D^�E�>3C;C�57*;:a0#,/>O=aC(>O*;H/*LA\,/.1H/0GE�.78aC;E�H/24H'ETKLH/2 /�Z;2TB;*;H/242/N�2457*;,/Hãn Ë >O6 Ë :�XæÅ�X1ð Õ4Õ be57.1.±>O*;.V8?:O>gZ�C�N;03*;^A�B;HÔ,/>@H�!<,/51H'*�Ae>O6�03*�8D^;5VK�512T>3Eubu51.7.�>O*;.78D:O><^;>�be*�X Y B�Z;2ubcHÔ=_0k8D032424Z;=?H ! 8 03*;^ ! B�0�KLHMA�B;HP2�03=<H24Z�C;C±>3E4AkN±]�Z�Aã0GE4Hº*;>3ASH/rsZ�03.|X%# HJA�� ]±HPA�B;Hº](>OZ;*;^�0GET8 ! 8 Ò ! N±03*;^ ! Ë � Õ A4B;Hº^;57K@5124>3E ! ä � �#X #�H'A�à](Ha03*�8qHG�;,/H'C;A451>O*�03.y^;57K@5124>3EkX Y B;H/* Ñ Ë � Õ ß � Ë � � o��Uä ! Ë � Õ4Õ 03*;^ � Ë � Õ ß n Ë ! Ë � Õ4Õ N�A�B;HU24=_03.7.1H/2IA,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LAe>O6 03*�8?,/>O=<C(>O*;H'*�AR>O6 ! Ë � Õ N�0GE�HS]±>3A�BD0'!?*;HM6�Z;*;,'A�51>O*;2R>O6 � X � >O*;2451^;HJEuA�B;Hã24=?03.1.1H'2TAcK303.7Z;H>O6 � N � 3 N 24Z;,[B�A�B�0GA ! Ë � Õ 572º0D]±>OZ;*;^�0GE48LX � 3 � Å�2457*;,/H_Å ���gX ! ��� B�032Ô24=_03.1.7H'EÔ24Z�C;C(>3E4AÔA�B�03* ! NA�B�Z;2#]s8Í57*;^;Z;,'A�57>O*�N�03*;^mA�B;H_^;H'Ï�*;5VA�51>O*j>O6 /�Z;24B�NybcH_B�0�KLH � Ë � 3 Õ Ã Ñ Ë � 3 Õ 03*;^�� Ë ð Õ Ã Ñ Ë ð Õ X Y B�Z;2� Ë Å Õ Ã Ñ Ë Å Õ N;>3EuH/r@Z;5VK303.7H/*LA�.78LN;o_f�ä ! 512%/�Z;24Bq0GA��aX ������_�%� �"�%��¡'�<��þg������((¢º�#�"�#���%�h��� �%� �"ý��s�G� �Wþe� K»�Wý����@���Í�®� �K¿¡k� ��þ½�WÿO� Î�� 'c��eH',k03.1.�A�B�0GARA�B�E�>OZ;:OB;>OZ�A Ë :�Xpï Õ N;Þàß � !�� N;A�B;HM24Z�C;C±>3E4A�>O6 ! X

���)(��65 �¿�@�Í�����Ë ð Õ � ¸ Ë '�� Þ Õ<­;©�ª_¼(¬ ° «?©GÂ\³ ° ¬%ª[ªJ´�¼@È�ª �½´�¼ ¯ © ° ¥|´¶³Jù@Â7© ° , Î ´�ª<ª¨«?¬%¬�¥»­ � ¥®­;¤J¼ o��?ä ! ´�ª?Â1¤Jµ3¤JÂ1,º©3¼±¹

Page 61: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � � .�cù�ª¨­D´Ç¸ !ì´�ªº© ¯ ù ° ¤g§¨¬Gùs¼±¹�© ° ·LÀ

Ë ó Õ �ãª[ª¨ù@«?¤ Ë '�� Þ Õ-¹�¬%¤¨ª<¼�¬�¥S­�©GµO¤_¼�¬ ° «<©3Â\³ ° ¬%ª[ª¨´»¼@È�ª �½¥»­;©G¥ã´�ª�¤J´�¥®­;¤ ° Î ´�ª?ª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ,#¬ ° Þ ­;©�ªûv¬ ° ªk¤Ð¥®­�©G¼�©jª¨´�« ¯ Â1¤Ð¼(¬k¹�¤ � À £ ¤'¥ Ñ ~ � Ò±Ó ' §¨¤¾©�Â1¬�È ° ¤¨ªk¬G ùs¥|´¶¬�¼Ý¬+¸ Ë '���!<Õ � ¸k¬ ° ¥®­;¤¹�¤�2�¼�´�¥|´¶¬�¼�ªk¤[¤ � B � À �ãª[ª¨ù@«?¤ � Ë � � o��Ôä !<Õ � ð ¸k¬ ° ©G¼�· Ñ ú4¤��@³¨¤ ¯ ¥|´¶¬�¼±©GÂ�¹G´»µ�´�ªk¬ ° � À Á ­;¤J¼g¸�¬ °©G¼�·�¤���³[¤ ¯ ¥|´¶¬�¼±©3 ¹G´�µ�´�ª�¬ ° � ¥®­;¤ ° ¤P´�ª#©G¼ Ñ ú4¤ �@³[¤ ¯ ¥|´¶¬�¼(©GÂ�¹G´�µ�´�ª�¬ ° � ª¨ùW³¨­�¥®­�©G¥ � Ë � � o��ºä !aÕ �� Ë � � o��Uä !aÕ�À � ¼ ¯ © ° ¥®´¶³'ùsÂ7© ° o��Uä ! ´�ª �vùsª[­ � ° ¤¨ª ¯ ÀaÂ1¤JµO¤J � ´ÇÆ ´�¥\´�ª �cùsª[­ � ° ¤¨ª ¯ ÀUÂ1¤Jµ3¤J � ©G¥©GÂ�Â�¤ �@³[¤ ¯ ¥|´¶¬�¼(©G ¹G´�µ%´�ªk¬ ° ªÔ¬I¸ Ñ À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ ,W>3E Ë ð Õ 57AR512\,/>O*LKLH/*;51H'*�AuA�>aC;E�>�KLHÔ0a.15VA4A�.7HS=?>3E�H3X Ì HM,/>O*;2457^;H'E�>O*;.V8_A�B;HÔ.7H'KLH/.�,k032TH Ë A�B;H /�Z;24B,k0324HU512ã*;Hk0GE4.78q51^;H'*�A�57,k03. Õ X Ì Hg24B;>�b A�B�0GAM516 Ë '���� ä �UÕ B�032ã*;>3E�=_03.�,JE�>O242457*;:O2/N � � � � ðON(buB;H'E�HUbcH03.1.7>%bt*;H/:L0GA�5VKLHM*�Z;=#](H'E42/N;A�B;H/* � Ë � � o��Mä � � ä � �UÕ � =<51* Ë � � � Õ 6�>3Eu03*�8DH ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.(^;57K@5124>3ER>�KLH'EÎDß � � � X

� ,k03*Í](H<>3];A[0351*;H/^Í]�8Í0�24H'r@Z;H/*;,/H`>O6c24=<>@>3A�B¾]�.7>%b Z�C�2/X Ì H_51*;^;Z;,'Ag>O*�A�B;H_*�Z;=#](H'Eg>O6vA4B;H/24H]�.1>�bçZ�C�2/X@# H'A Ñ ~ �çÒ�Ó ' ](HMA�B;HM]�.7>%b Z�C�0GAåÎ�N;bu57A�B�H �;,/HJC;A�51>O*�03.�^;57K@5124>3E U_X Ì HPB�0kKLH

o��Dä � �� ä � �� ä Ë � ä � Ò ð Õ UÝß Ñ " Ë o��#ä !<Õ �

Y BsZ;2 � ß � Ë U � o��#ä � � ä � �aÕ ß Ë � ä � Ò ð Õ � =?51* Ë � � � Õ XR)+6 �Ú.151H'2�>O*Ð0?6�Z�E4A�B;H'ES]�.7>%bÝZ�C�N±A�B;H/*�Ú512�,'H/*�A4H'E�H/^i>%KLH'E�24>O=?HPC±>O51*LA��¾>O62U_X +@57*;,/H � 03*;^ � 0GE4H#24H'CW0GE[0GA�H'^q]�8 Ñ NWbcH#=_0k8�03242TZ;=?H Ë ]�82Tbu57A�,[B;57*;:?*;>3A[0GA�57>O*�576 *;H/,/H'242�0GE48 Õ A�B�0GA � �� � X Y B;H/*-]�8D51*;^;Z;,'A451>O*

� Ë � � o��ºä � � ä � �UÕ ß � Ë � � o��?ä � �� ä � �� ä � U Õß � Ë � � o��?ä � �� ä � U Õ � � � =?51* Ë � � � Õ �

,W>3E Ë ó Õ X Ì E�57A�Ho��Dä�!Ðß Ñ " Ë o��Pä !<Õ �

öSH'E�H !Í512\57*-:OH/*;H'E�03.�>O*;.V8D0U2TZ�];](>OZ;*;^�0GE48 Ë 6�>3E\A�B;HÔ^;HJÏ�*;57A�57>O*�NW2TH/H � ó Õ XåíS2T24Z;=?H � 512\,/H'*�A�HJE�H/^">�KLH'E24>O=?HºC±>O51*LA���>O*Ð03*Ð57E4E�H'^;Z;,/57]�.7HU,'>O=<C(>O*;H/*LAkN � >O6@U_X #�H'A � ]±H#A�B;H#,/>@H !?,/57H/*�AM>O6 �Ú51* !åX $c8-A�B;HC;E�>s>O6 >O6 Ë ð Õ N

� Ë � � o��Pä !<Õ ß � Ë � � o��`ä�! Õ � � ß � Ë � � o��Ôä !<Õ ����)(��)( �¿���Í����� �ãª[ª¨ù@«?¤ Î ´�ªqªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° À � ¸Ð¥®­;¤m³[¬�¤ !�³J´½¤J¼�¥?¬+¸m¤Jµ3¤ ° · ¤���³[¤ ¯ ¥|´¶¬�¼±©3Âã¹3´�µ�´�ªk¬ ° ¬+¸q¥®­;¤«g´�¼W´�«<©G ° ¤¨ª�¬� ùs¥|´¶¬�¼ RM~ �'�Ò�Ó 't´�¼ o��RäqÞ ´�ªeª¨¥ ° ´¶³'¥®Â ·#Â1¤¨ª¨ªe¥®­�©G¼Ð¬�¼(¤0,y¥®­;¤J¼ o��RäqÞ ´�ª�Â1¬�Èg¥w¤ ° «g´�¼(©GÂ7À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ +@Z�C;C±>O24H Ë '�� Þ Õ 572�*;>3A�.1>O:uA�H'E�=?57*�03.|X Þ 572�*;>3A�H'=<C;Aw8LN32451*;,'H ' 572�.1>O:�A4H'E�=?57*�03.L]�8g03242TZ;=<C;A�51>O*�X#�H'A U ]±HSA�B;H Ë E�H/^;Z;,/H'^ Õ H ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.(.1>s,/Z;2\>O6�RyX�$v8 Ë :�Xæï�X ó@X ó Õ N Ñ 512\*;>3AR0g.1>O:ºE�H'24>O.1Z�A�57>O*�6�>3E Ë '�� Þ Õ X$v8qA�B;H<,/.10324245VÏ�,k0GA�51>O*¾>O6v.7AP2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2/N�U B�032º*;>3E4=_03.�,'E�>O242T51*;:O2/N A4BsZ;2ºÞì^;>@H/2Ô*;>3AºB�0kKLH<*;>3E�=_03.

Page 62: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ) ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

,'E�>O2T2451*;:O2åbe5VA�B�U_X�íS2åA�B;Hu,'>O=<C�Z�A[0GA�57>O*<>O6±,'>@H�!<,/51H/*LA�2v572åC�Z�E4H/.78a*sZ;=<H'E�51,/03.|NLbcHe=_0k8#E�H'C�.103,/H �Þ ]s8a0^;512�FI>O51*LAuZ;*;57>O*�>O6 03*�03.78sA�51,e^;5124,/2'N;Hk03,[B-=?H/HJA�51*;:EU *;>3E�=_03.7.78LNs03*;^�2TZ;,¨BDA�B�0GAR0GA\.1H/032TAcAwbc>g^;5124,/2R=?H/HJAA�B;HR2�03=?H\57ETE�H/^;Z;,/5V]�.1HR,/>O=<C(>O*;H'*�A�>O6�U_N3bu57A�B;>OZ�Aå,[B�03*;:O51*;:ÔA�B;Hu,'>@H�!<,/51H/*LA�2å>O6(03*L8g>O6�A�B;HRH ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.^;57K@5124>3E42/X $\Z�A`A�B;H'*�NS69E�>O= A4B;Hi,/.10324245VÏ�,k0GA�51>O*ë>O6P.7>O:jA�HJE�=?51*�03.S2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457A�57H/2`51*tí�C;C±H/*;^;5 � eNuA�B;HC�Z;24B;6�>3E4bc0GE�^_>O6±A�B;HR*;H'b�,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O* Ë 6�>3EåbeB;57,[B Ñ 572¿0M.1>O:ÔE4H/24>O.1Z�A451>O* Õ 512å*;>3A¿.7>O:ÔA�H'E4=?51*�03.®NL03*;^?24>]�8 Ë :�Xpï�X ó@Xpó Õ NGA�B;HR,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LAv>O6±2T>O=?H\H �;,/HJC;A�51>O*�03.;^;5VK�512T>3E�=gZ;2TAå](Hu0GAå.1Hk032IA¿>O*;H3Ns0ã,/>O*�ATE[03^;51,'A451>O*�X �� À �@À � D ¤J«<© ° F À )+6y>O*;Hg>O*;.78q032T24Z;=?H/2ã51* Ë :�Xæï�Xpï Õ A4B�0GASA�B;Hg,/>@H�!<,/51H'*�A�2Ô0GE�Hg0GAã=?>O2IAS>O*;H3N�>O*;Hg,k03*;*;>3A51*i:OH/*;H'E[03.�,'>O*;,/.1Z;^;HUA�B�0GAMo ä Þ 572Ô.7>O:�,k03*;>O*;57,k03.y0GAM2451*;:OZ;.10GEÔC±>O51*LA�2/XE,W>3EMH ��03=<C�.7H#A[0GQLHU0D,'8@,/.157,2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8#bu57A4B<H �;03,'A�.78U>O*;HRH �;,'H'C;A�51>O*�03.W,/Z�E4KLHGN:U_N�03*;^_03242TZ;=?H �Þ 512å2451=<C�.V8#A[03*;:OH/*LA¿A�>�U /s*�Z;=?H'EIØ51,/03.1.78"A4B;512P572P57*;^;512TA�57*;:OZ;5124B�0G]�.7H<69E�>O= 0-.7>O:-,k03*;>O*;57,k03.�*;>s^;H3X?öS>�bcH'KLH'EPZ;2451*;:�A�B;H<2�03=<HUC;E�>s>O6½N�03*;^A�B;H?,'.90324245VÏ�,k0GA�57>O*�51*�í�C;C±H/*;^;5 � �>O*;H<,k03*�Hk032457.78i,/.9032T2451698ÐA�B;H?H ��,/H'C;A�57>O*;2/X Ì H<*;>3A4H?51*¾CW0GETA�51,/Z;.10GEA�B�0GAS576yo ähÞ 512S*;>3A�.1>O:_,k03*;>O*;57,k03.�0GA¿Î�N(A�B;H'*qA4B;H'E�Hg0GE�Hg0GAã=?>O2IAeAwbc>`H �;,'H'C;A�51>O*�03. ^;57K@5124>3E�2S57*"A�B;H=?57*;51=_03.WE�H/24>O.7Z�A�51>O*�>�KLH'EyÎ�X���)(�� � �¿�@�Í�����D£ ¤J¥ Ñ ~ �àÒ�Ó 'à¤��O¥ ° ©�³J¥�¥®­;¤<´ °¨° ¤[¹Gù�³'´|§'Â1¤_¹G´»µ�´�ªk¬ ° U À �ãª[ª¨ù@«?¤ � Ë U � o��aä !<Õ&- Å©G¼±¹?Â1¤J¥ ! §¨¤º¥»­�¤ÔÂ1¬�È ¯ ùsÂ�Â7§[©s³ F ¬+¸ !�Àu£ ¤J¥ R¾~ �'�ÒWÓ '�§¨¤Ô¥®­;¤P«g´»¼�´�«<©GÂ�¹�¤¨ª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�ª/©3¥®´¶¬G¼±À

Ë ð Õ � ¸ Î ´�ªMª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ,u©G¼±¹ o��#ä ! ´�ª �vùsª[­Ð©G¥e¤Jµ3¤ ° · R ú4¤ �@³[¤ ¯ ¥|´¶¬�¼(©G ¹G´�µ�´�ªk¬ ° � ¥»­;¤'¼ o×ähÞ ´�ªÔ ¥©G¼±¹ o��#ä !ì´�ª �vùsª[­�À

Ë ó Õ � ¸ o��aäâÞ ´�ª# ¥�©3¼±¹ o��Uä ! ´�ª#Â1¤Jµ3¤JÂå©G¥ã¤Jµ3¤ ° · R ú4¤ �@³[¤ ¯ ¥|´¶¬�¼(©GÂ�¹G´»µ�´�ªk¬ ° � ¥®­;¤J¼ o��aä $ ! ´�ª�cù�ª¨­ã¸k¬ ° ©G¼�· $ Ãé𠪨ùW³¨­�¥®­�©G¥ $ ! ´�ªº©D§¨¬�ù@¼±¹L© ° ·OÀ

Ë ï Õ .Wù ¯L¯ ¬%ª�¤ Î ´�ªeª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© ° À � ¸ Ñ ´�ªM© o�� ú4³¨¬�¼�¥ ° ©�³J¥|´¶¬�¼"©G¼±¹ o��gä ! ´�ª �cù�ª[­D©G¥v¤'µ3¤ ° ·`¤��@³[¤ ¯ ¥®´½¬�¼±©G¹G´�µ%´�ªk¬ ° ¬I¸M¥»­�¤P«g´�¼W´�«<©G ¹s¤¨ª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© ° ´�ª/©G¥|´¶¬�¼¾¬I¸�� ,�¥®­;¤J¼ o��ºä ! ´�ª�vùsª[­�À

Ë . Õ .Wù ¯L¯ ¬%ª�¤ Î ´�ª#ª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© ° ,S©G¼±¹ o��<äâÞ ´�ªgÂ1¬�Èг�©G¼�¬�¼�´¶³�©3Â7À Á ­;¤'¼_¸k¬ ° ©3¼�·q¤ �@³[¤ ¯ ¥|´¶¬�¼(©GÂå¹G´�µ�´�ª�¬ ° ,� ,�¥®­;¤ ° ¤P´�ªSªk¬G«?¤ R ú�¤��@³[¤ ¯ ¥®´¶¬G¼±©G � ûy´�¥®­ � Ë � � o��Pä !<Õ � � Ë � � o��Pä !<Õ�À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Ì HDÏ;E�2IAaC;E�>�KLH Ë ð Õ X +@Z�C;C±>O24H�A�B;HD24=_03.7.1H/2IAg,/>@H�!<,/51H'*�Aa>O6 ! 512 � X � >O*;2457^;H'EUA�B;H�6�Z;*;,JA�51>O*Ñ Ë � Õ ß � Ë o��uä � Þ � � Õ X �S>�b Ñ Ë Å Õ.- ź03*;^`032¿A�B;He,/>@H�!<,/51H'*�Ac>O6�o��Rä � Þà512v0GAv=?>O2TAåA�B;H�,'>@H�!<,/51H/*LA>O6 o��#ä ! N

Ñ Ë � Õ � � Ë � � o��Pä !aÕ � � �buB;H'E�H<A�B;HUÏ�*�03.�57*;H/r@Z�03.757Aw8Ð512Ô69E�>O= A�B;Ha^;H'Ï�*;57A451>O*�>O6 /�Z;24B�X_íS2 Ñ 512P03*Í0'!?*;Ha6�Z;*;,'A�57>O*�N Ñ Ë � Õ � � N6�>3EÔ03.1. � - � XM)+*qCW0GE4A�57,/Z;.90GE � Ë � � o��UäâÞ Õ � ðON�2T>�o��gäâÞ 572M.7>O:_A�H'E�=?57*�03. ]�8 Ë :�Xpï�Xæï Õ X Y BsZ;2/N�]�8A�B;HS,/.10324245VÏ�,k0GA�51>O*_>O6�.7>O:ºA�H'E�=<51*�03.�2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A451H/2/Nsí�C;C(H/*;^;5 � eN:Rq512c0º.7>O:PE�H/24>O.7Z�A�51>O*`>O6 Ë '���!aÕ 03*;^`24>o��ºä ! 512 /�Z;24B-]�8 Ë :�Xpï�Xpó@X ó Õ X�öSH/*;,'H Ë ð Õ X

�S>�b bcH_C;E�>�KLH Ë ó Õ X Y B;H`=?57*;51=_03.y^;H/2457*;:OZ;.90GE�572�0GA�57>O*j572g0".1>O:�E�H/2T>O.1Z�A�57>O*j>O6\o��_ä � ! NyA4BsZ;2#]�8Ë :�Xæï�X ó@X ó Õ N�bcHU*;H/H/^i>O*;.78"C;E�>�KLHE/�Z;24B;*;H/242#0GAãH/03,¨B �<X �S>3A�HgÞ 572M5VE4E�H/^;Z;,'57]�.1HGN 2�0k8 ! ß � Þ"X ãH'Ï�*;HÑ Ë � Õ 032u57* Ë ð Õ X Ñ Ë Å Õ - Å�N Ñ Ë � Õ �

� N�03*;^ Ñ Ë ð Õ �éðOX Y BsZ;2 Ñ Ë � Õ � � 6�>3EÔð - � à � XyöSH/*;,/H Ë ó Õ X

Page 63: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � � ��S>�bébcHPC;E�>�KLH Ë ï Õ X $v8 Ë ð Õ bcHÔ>O*;.78�*;H/H/^�A�>?,[B;H/,�Q8/�Z;24B;*;H/242M0GA�H/03,¨B"HG�;,/H'C;A451>O*�03.�^;57K@5124>3EkN �<NW>O6

RyX +@57*;,/H U 512e*;>3Ae03*�H ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.�^;57K�5724>3E�>O6�R Ë 5VAe572eo���ؽ*;H/:L0GA�5VKLH Õ N � 512u03*�H �;,'H'C;A�51>O*�03.�^;57K@5124>3Eu>O6A�B;HÔ=?51*;57=_03.±^;H/2T51*;:OZ;.90GE4512�0GA�57>O*->O6 � X Y B�Z;2

n Ë !<Õ - n Ë ! Õ Ã � Ë � � o��`ä�! Õ ß � Ë � � o��ºä !aÕ03*;^�o��`ä ! 572 /�Z;24B�X¿öSH/*;,/H Ë ï Õ X

,�51*�03.7.78"6�>3E Ë . Õ N�2T51*;,/HaÞì512ã.7>O:�,k03*;>O*;57,k03.|N�R�572M0�.1>O:_E�H'24>O.1Z�A�57>O*�X Y B�Z;2MA4B;HUE�H'24Z;.7AÔ6�>O.1.7>%bu2Ô69E4>O=Ë :�Xæï�X ó@X ó Õ X �öSH'E�HÔ0GE�HÔ0a6�H'b ,/>O*;,JE�H'A�HºHG��03=<C�.7H/2/~

���)(���� ��� �W� � K���¡3� #�H'AyÎ�� � Ü ' ]±Hº0a,'Z�E4KLHP:OH'E4=×>O* ' XË ð Õ )+6 � B�032u03*D>3E�^;51*�0GE48`,'Z;2TCq0GA�Î�N�03*;^UÎ-512R0g24=?>@>3A4B`C±>O51*LAe>O6�A�B;HM24Z�E�6�03,/H ' N�A4B;H/*-o��Mä � �

572 /�Z;24B-57è � ��. � � N�03*;^�.1H'KLH'.�5Vè �� . � � X

Ë ó Õ +@Z�C;C±>O24H#o��#ä � 512u.7A�0GA�Î�N(03*;^<Î"B�032eAw8@C(H Ë ï Õ Ë 57*-A�B;Hº2TH/*;24H#>O6 Ë :�XæÅ�X � Õ4Õ X Y B;H/*"o��#ä � �572 /�Z;24B�0GAåÎq5Vè � Ãéð��Oóa03*;^-.7H'KLH/.�57è � - ð��Oó@X

Ë ï Õ +@Z�C;C±>O24H_o��<ä � Ê ä � � 572º.1,<0GAuÎ�N�6�>3EÔA+bv>"57E4E�H'^;Z;,/57]�.7H?,/Z�E4KLH/2 � Ê �,� � X_íS242TZ;=?H � � � à Å�XY B;H/*Ðo��Uä � � Ê ä � � � 572?/�Z;24B�0GA�Î�5Vè�ξ512ã0?24=?>s>3A�B�C(>O57*�AM03*;^Ð=_0 � Ë � � � Õ � ðON�03*;^Ð57AS572.7H'KLH/.;]�Z�A¿*;>3A@/�Z;24B_0GA�Î_5Vè�H'57A�B;H'E�Î_572¿24=?>s>3A�Ba03*;^?=_0 � Ë � � � Õ ßÝðONs>3E�Î_572 ãZ�H¿03.�03*;^ � ß � N>3E � ß � ßÝðOX

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ ,W>3E Ë ð Õ X $v8 Ë :�Xpï�X ó@Xpó Õ bcHR*;H/H/^a>O*;.78#,'>O*;2451^;H'E�,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LA�2�>O*a0S.1>O:SE�H/2T>O.1Z�A�57>O*a>O6 Ë '��,�ºÕ X +@Z;,¨B0#E�H/24>O.7Z�A�51>O*`512\>3];A[0357*;H/^`]s8_]�.7>%bu51*;:UZ�C�ï#A�57=?H/2v>�KLH'E�Î�N�03.7b\0k8�2c>O*`A�B;Hã2TA4E451,'A\A4E[03*;2T6�>3E�=à>O6 � X � *;H,/>O=<C�Z�A4H/2RA4B;HP,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LA�>O6 H/03,¨B-H �;,/HJC;A�51>O*�03.�^;57K@5124>3EkX Y B;HP^;H'A4H'E�=?57*;51*;:U,/>@H�!<,/51H'*�Ae512

� Ë� � � o��Pä � �ºÕ ß õ � Ò .

buB;H'E�H � 572RA4B;HPH ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.�^;5VK�5724>3ER>O6 A�B;HãÏ�*�03.�]�.7>%bçZ�C Ë 24>aA�B;HÔZ;*;51rsZ;H Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�ETKLHº>%KLHJEåÎ Õ X,W>3E Ë ó Õ X Ì Hc*;H/H/^U>O*;.78#,/>O*;2T51^;H'E � Ë U � o���ä � �ºÕ NGbuB;H'E�H%Uç512 A�B;H Ò ï�ض,/Z�E4KLH\>%KLHJE(Î�X � *;H\,/>O=<C�Z�A4H/2

� Ë U � o��Pä � �ºÕ ßÝð��3ïuä � �3ï�X,W>3E Ë ï Õ X Y B;H /�Z;24B_,/0324H�6�>O.1.7>%bu2v69E�>O= Ë :�Xæï�X � X1ð Õ 03*;^ Ë :�Xæï�X ó@X1ð Õ X Y B;H�24=?>s>3A�BaCW0GE4Av>O6±A�B;H�.7H'KLH/.W,k0324H

512\Hk032I8LN;Z;2451*;: Ë :�Xpï�Xpó@X1ð Õ X�+@>U24Z�C;C(>O2THRÎ"572\2451*;:OZ;.10GEkX $v8 Ë :�Xæï�X � X . Õ bcHM*;H/H/^�>O*;.V8_,/>O*;2457^;H'E�,/>sH�!?,'51H/*LA�2>O6cH ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.�^;5VK�512T>3E�2P69E�>O= A�B;H?=?57*;51=_03.�^;H'2451*;:OZ;.10GE�512�0GA451>O*�XO# HJAEU ]±H?24Z;,[Bj0�^;57K�5724>3EkX_íS242TZ;=?H� - � X # H'A Ñ Ë � � $ Õ ß � Ë U � o��gä � � Ê ä $ � � Õ X Ñ Ë Å � Å Õ - Å�N�03*;^ �/H'E�>�57è�ÎÍ572 MZ4Hv03.®X Ñ Ë ð � ð Õ ß×ðOXÑ Ë � � � Õ �

Ñ Ë � � � Õ bu57A4BD2IA4E�51,JA\51*;H/rsZ�03.157Aw8<Z;*;.1H/242 � ß � X�$v8`0'!<*;H/*;H/242/N Ñ Ë � � � Õ - � N@bu57A�B`H/rsZ�03.157Aw8_5Vè<Î512�ãZ>H¿03.|N;>3E � ßÝðOX Y B;HÔE�H'24Z;.7Au6�>O.1.7>%bu2/X �D ¤J«<© °GF À Ë :�Xæï�Xpõ�X1ð Õ 2TB;>%bu2ÔA�B�0GAMbuB;H/*¾bcHa24,k03.1Ha51*ÐA�B;H<B�Z;*�A/N�/�Z;24B;*;H/2T2#=?51:OBLAã](H<.7>O2TAkX#)wAÔbu51.7.�A�Z�E�*>OZ�AMA�B;512M,k03*�>O*;.V8iB�0GC;C±H/*Í0GAÔ24=?>s>3A�BÐC±>O51*LA�2P>O6 ' X Y B;H<>3A�B;H'EMb\0k8qA�B�0GA�/�Z;2TB;*;H/242#,k03*¾]±Ha.7>O2TAÔ51*A�B;HÔBsZ;*LAkNW512R516�0GAu24>O=?HM2TA[03:OHÔ0a,'>O=<C(>O*;H/*LAu>O6 ! � 512R,/>O*LA4E[03,'A4H/^�N Ë :�Xpï�X1ðOXpó Õ X

Page 64: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

���)(���� �¿�@�Í����� .Wù ¯L¯ ¬�ªk¤ Î ´�ªMª¨«?¬�¬�¥®­"©3¼±¹<¥®­;¤ ¯ ©3´ ° Ë '���!<ÕÔ´�ª�cù�ª[­;À\£ ¤J¥ ! ß � ��� Þ � À Á ­;¤J¼Ë ð Õ � ¸ � � ´�ªR¥®­;¤�«gùs ¥|´ ¯  ´½³J´�¥|·<¬+¸ Þ � ¥®­;¤J¼ � ��� � � Ò ð �ân À � ¼ ¯ © ° ¥|´¶³Jù@Â7© ° n �éð�� Ë � Ò ð Õeû�­;¤ ° ¤

� ´�ªM¥®­;¤Ô«gù@ ¥®´ ¯  ´¶³J´�¥|·-¬+¸ Þ ÀË ó Õ � ¸ Þ ­�©�ª_©q¼(¬k¹s¤D¬+¸UÈ�¤J¼�ùsª_©3¥SÂ1¤�©�ª¨¥S¥|ûv¬i©G¥ Î �¶ª�¤[¤ � A A À A � � ,ã©G¼±¹q¥®­;¤D³[¬%¤ !�³'´¶¤J¼�¥Ô¬+¸<¥»­;¤_¥|ûv¬

§ ° ©G¼(³¨­;¤Jª#¬+¸ �ì©3¥ Î © ° ¤ � - � ,�¥®­;¤J¼ ó � ä � ��ó ÀË ï Õ � ¸ Î ´�ª_©¾³Jù�ª ¯ ¬+¸ Þ �¶ª�¤[¤ � A A ÀCB � � ©G¼±¹ � ´�ªa¥®­;¤D³¨¬�¤ !ë³J´¶¤J¼�¥Ô¬+¸<¥»­�¤D§ ° ©G¼(³¨­j¬+¸ Þ ©G¥ Î ,㥻­�¤J¼

� ��. � � ÀË . Õ � ¸ n - . � � ,奮­;¤J¼ Þ ­�©�ªM¼(¬ ° «<©GÂ�³ ° ¬%ª¨ª¨´�¼@È�ªkÀ

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ #�H'A RÔ~ � Ò±Ó ' ]±HMA�B;HS]�.7>%bçZ�C�>O6 ' 0GA�Î�X Y B;H/*�A�B;HM,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LAe>O6�A�B;HMH �;,/HJC;A�51>O*�03.�^;5VK�512T>3E512 � ��� � � Ò ðON;buB;51,[B�512R.1H'242uA�B�03*�nÄ]s8-032424Z;=<C;A451>O*�XyöSH/*;,/H Ë ð Õ X

Ë ó Õ 03*;^ Ë ï Õ =_0k8�](H_C;E�>�KLH/^j2451=<51.90GE4.78LX Ë . Õ 512#57=?=?H/^;510GA�H?69E�>O= Ë ð'Øwï Õ Ny2457*;,/H Ë ó%Øwï Õ 0GE�H_A�B;H_Awbc>C(>O2T2457]�57.157A451H/2R6�>3EeÞ >O6 =gZ;.7A�5VC�.157,/57Aw8?Awbc>;N�24H/H Ë )4)¨X : Õ >O6\î .3ñ¶X �* ° ¬�¬+¸P¬+¸ � � À � À ��� À #�H'A $ ]±HSA�B;Hã51*;^;H �D>O6 �Í03*;^�= � A�B;Hã51*;^;H �D>O6�A�B;Hã,[B�0351*D>3];A[0351*;H/^`]�8`^;H/.1H'A451*;:gA�B;H.1H'69A�=?>O2TAR51*LA�H/:OHJE�69E�>O= �¿X �S>%b $ ß �Q= Ò = � N�03*;^-A�B;HÔ,/>@H !?,/57H/*�Ae>O6 A�B;HÔH �;,'H'C;A�51>O*�03.�^;5VK�512T>3Ee>O6 ��>O*A�B;HÔ.1H/69Au512 Ë = Ò = � Ò ð Õ �'=@X Y B;HP,/>sH�!?,'51H/*LAe>O6 U Ê 572 Ë4Ë � Ò ó Õ =\ä = Ò = � Ò ð Õ � $ X �* ° ¬�¬+¸e¬+¸ � � À � À�� � À o�� äaÞ 572�.1>O:�A4H'E�=?57*�03.s]�8 Ë :�Xpï�X � X1ð Õ X�#�H'A2U ](HvA�B;Hc^;5VK�5724>3E�>O6�=_0 �;57=_03.L,/>@H !?,/57H/*�A/N03*;^-.7H'A R¾~ �çÒ�Ó ' HG��A4E[03,JA U_X�$v8 Ë :�Xæï�X � X . Õ 03*;^ Ë :�Xpï�X7ðOX1ð Õ Nso��`ä�!Ðß R " Ë o��ºä !<Õ 512R.1H'KLH'.|X2,WE4>O=A�B;Hg,/.103242457Ï�,/0GA�51>O*Ð>O6�.7>O:_A�H'E�=?57*�03. 2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2/N�57Aã572MH'*;>OZ;:OBÐA�>D24B;>�b � ß ��! � 512ã.1>O:_A�HJE�=?51*�03. 0GAA�B;HSC(>O57*�A�Î`ß U � �Þ"X@$v8 Ë :�Xpï�X � X7ð Õ bcHã*;H/H/^->O*;.78_24B;>�béo��<ä !¾512 /�Z;24B�0GA�Î�X Y B;Hã,/>sH�!?,'51H/*LAe>O6 �Þ51*�!m512R2TA4E�57,'A�.78`=<51*;51=?03.|N@2T51*;,/H Ë '���!<Õ 512%/�Z;24B�NWA4BsZ;2uo��Dä�!m512%/�Z;24Bq0GA�Î"]s8 Ë :�Xæï�Xpõ�Xæï Õ X�öSH/*;,/H Ë ð Õ X

,W>3E Ë ó Õ X�+@Z�C;C±>O24HvÎDB�032c51*;^;H �S=@N@03*;^ ! ß � Þ"Xyo��eäÐÞÖ572v.1>O:PA4H'E�=?57*�03.|NL]s8 Ë :�Xpï�X � X1ð Õ 03*;^_24>#A�B;H^;57è±H'E�H/*LAå>O6�o���äaÞ 512 Ë = Ò ð Õ �'=@N324H'H Ë #�Xpó Õ X �S>�b�A�B;Hc,'>@H�!<,/51H/*LAy>O6�o���ä � Þ 572 Ë ; �'= Õ ä � Ë = Ò ð Ò ; Õ �'=@NbuB;51,[B�512R.1H'242uA�B�03* � X Y B�Z;2 � à � à � N;beB;HJE�H �q572RA�B;HÔ24>O.1Z�A451>O*�A4>aA�B;HãE�H/,/Z�E42457KLHÔH/r@Z�0GA�57>O*

��ß Ë ;ãä � Ë = Ò ð Ò ; Õ4Õ �'= �

buB;51,[B�512 ; � Ë ;Sätð Õ XyöSH/*;,/H Ë ó Õ X �Ì HM*;>3A�HÔA4B�0GARA4B;HÔC;E�>s>O6 >O6 Ë :�XæÅ�X � Õ 03.724><:O5VKLH/2

���)(���� �¿�@�Í����� �½´»¼q¥»­�¤Ô¼(¬�¥w©G¥|´¶¬�¼�¬+¸ � � À � À�� � �

� Ë U Ê � oÚä � Þ Õ ß Ë ; �'= Õ ä � Ë = Ò ð Ò ; Õ �'=Mß � Ë = Ò ð Õ �'=\ä Ë ð Ò � Õ Ë ; �'= Õ �

Page 65: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � � ����)(��(' �¿�@�Í������£ ¤J¥ � §¨¤?©-¼(¬�¼Wú4³¨­�©G´»¼iªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´»¥®·�ûy´�¥®­�§ ° ©3¼(³¨­;¤¨ª � Ê � � � � � ��À��ãª[ª¨ù@«?¤a¥®­;¤_³[¤'¼�¥ ° ©G³Jù ° µ3¤º´�ªº©aÒ � ú4³'ù ° µ3¤kÀ

� Ë � Õe´�ªu¥»­;¤M³[¬�¤ !ë³J´¶¤J¼W¥�¬+¸R¥®­;¤ã³¨¤J¼�¥ ° ©GÂ(³'ù ° µ3¤0,y©3¼±¹P´�ª�© ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼±©3Â;¼�ùs«?§¨¤ ° ¬+¸R¥®­;¤ ¸k¬ ° « �

� � Ê ,s¸�¬ ° ªk¬G«?¤¯ ¬%ªJ´�¥®´»µ3¤M´�¼�¥+¤½È�¤ ° ; À

� ¬ ° ¤¨¬�µ3¤ ° ´Ç¸ � Ê ß � � ß Ë ó Õ-,c©G¼(¹ �iß Ë � � � �/ÕP¥®­;¤J¼ ; ´�ªM¥®­;¤Ôª ¯ ¤[³J¥ ° ©GÂ�µG©3 ù�¤a¬+¸ � �¶ªk¤¨¤ 2�ÈGù ° ¤ � �

-l

β

β

β

1

2

3

,�57:OZ�E�H .

öSH'E�HM>�K303.72u^;H/*;>3A4HP,[B�0351*;2/N�032R51* � B�0GC;A�H'Eeïa>O6\î}ó � ñ¶X* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Ì H�24B;>�b Ï;E�2IA?A�B;H�,/H'*�A4E�03.e^;57K@5124>3E<B�032?=_0 ��51=_03.v,'>@H�!<,/51H/*LAkX�# HJA Ñ ~ � Ò�Ó ' HG��A4E[03,JA_0^;57K@5124>3E U >O6 A�B;HM=?57*;51=_03.�E�H/24>O.7Z�A�51>O*�>O6 =_0 ��51=_03.W,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LAkN � X Ì HÔ032424Z;=?H U 512R*;>3AR,/H/*LA4E[03.|N;A�B�Z;257Ay,'>O*�A[0357*;2å0GAy=?>O2TA�>O*;H\*;>O*@ؽ,[B�0357*a2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8 � X�o��uä�Uç512y*;>3Ay.7>O:�A�H'E�=?57*�03.�0GA � X $v8ºA�B;Hc,[B;>O51,/HR>O6U_NGo��vä � Ué572 .1HJKLH/.�0GA H �;,/HJC;A�51>O*�03.s^;57K�5724>3E�2 >O6�A�B;Hv=?57*;51=_03.3E�H'24>O.1Z�A�57>O*�X�#�H'A Ñ Ë � Õ ß � Ë � � o��¿ä � U Õ%Ò �6�>3E�� 03*#HG�;,/H'C;A451>O*�03.�^;5VK�512T>3E�>O6;A�B;Hc=?57*;51=_03.3E�H'24>O.1Z�A�57>O*g>%KLH'E � X Ñ Ë Å Õ - Å�N Ñ Ë ��Õ ß Å�X Y B�Z;2 Ñ Ë ð Õ � Å�X�S>�b ]�8 Ë :�Xpï�Xæï Õ N Ñ Ë ð Õ ß Å Ë 6�>3Eg24>O=<H�� Õ N�A�B�Z;2 Ñ Ë Å Õ ß×Å�Nå03*;^j2T> � 512 ãZ Hv03.®X�íS.124>"]�8 Ë :�Xæï�X . Õ No���ä Uà572�.1>O:_,/03*;>O*;51,k03.�0GA � X Y BsZ;2S]�8"í�C;C(H'*;^;5 � tAwbc>_>O6�A�B;H#];E[03*;,[B;H/2M0GA � N�0GE�H Ë ó Õ X?# HJASA�B;HA�B;5VE�^-];E[03*;,[B�](H Ë ó � � � �-� ó Õ ß � � be5VA�B-A�B;HÔ,/H/*LA4E[03.�,/Z�E4KLHP=<H/H'A�57*;:aA�B;HÔ.1H/69Ae=?>O2TA Ò ó%ض,/Z�E4KLH3X #�H'AuA�B;H,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LA�2a>O6\A�B;HD,/Z�E4KLH/2U>�KLH'E � ](H � Ê � � � � ��� � X #�H'A � ß � � � Ê X #�H'A � 3 ](H_A�B;HD,/>@H !?,/57H/*�AU>O6RA�B;H,/H/*LA4E[03.�,/Z�E4KLHGN � N � A�B;Hº,'>@H�!<,/51H/*LA�2u>O6 A�B;HPAwbc> Ò ó%ض,/Z�E4KLH/2S57*-A�B;H Ë ó Õ ];E[03*;,[B;H/2'X � *;HºB�032 Ë 69E�>O=ÖA�B;H^;H'Ï�*;5VA�51>O*�>O6�A�B;HP,'>@H�!<,/51H/*LA Õ

� ß � ß � 3 �OóÒ ó � 3 ä � ä � ä � Ê ß Å

Ò ó ��� ä ��� � Ê ä ��� � Ê ß Åa6�>3E � - $ - ð

Y BsZ;2 � 3 ß � Ê ß ����� ß � � ß � X�SH �@AcbcHã24B;>%b � Ë � Õ B�032cA�B;HSC;E�H/24,JE�57]±H/^�6�>3E�=�X Ì HãZ;24HãA�B;Hã*;>3A[0GA�57>O*D03*;^DE�H'24Z;.7A�2R>O6 � B�0GC;A�HJEeïg>O6

îæó � ñ|X

Page 66: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

��� ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

#�H'A � � B�0�KLHP51*;^;H � =?03*;^q.1H'A $ ]±HPA�B;H#57*;^;H �">O6�A�B;HP,¨B�0357*q2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8�>3];A[0351*;H/^�]�8"^;H/.7H'A�57*;:?A�B;HÏ;E�2TAe51*LA�H/:OH'Eu>O*-A�B;HM.1H'69A�69E�>O= � � X

,�57E42TAe2TZ�C;C(>O24H � Ê 03*;^ � � ]±>3A�B�B�0kKLHÔ57*;^;H �-Awbc>;X Y BsZ;2

! ßéó � ó � = � � Ò ó � = Ò ó � = Ò ó � ó � $ ß . Ë = � Ò = Ò $ Õ03*;^�24>UA�B;HP.7>O:a^;5724,'E�HJCW03*;,'8�>O6 �q512

ó � ó � =!

Ë ð��OóRäëð��Oóuätð��'= Ò ð Õ ßÝð�� Ë = � Ò = Ò $ Õ �$cZ�AuA4B;HÔ57*;^;H ��>O6 �¾ß = � Ò $ 03*;^�2T>aA�B;HÔ2TC(H/,JA4E[03.�K303.7Z;HP>O6 ��512RH �;03,'A�.78O= � Ò = Ò $ Ò ðOXY BsZ;2ebvHº=_0k8-24Z�C;C±>O24H � Ê B�032�57*;^;H ��Awbc>;N � � B�032�51*;^;H �-A�B�E�H/HGN(03*;^qï � = �

� X � *;,/Hg03:L0351*�A�B;H.1>O:a^;5124,JE�H'CW03*;,'8�512

ó � ï � =!

Ë ð��Oó\ätð��3ïeäëð��'= Ò ð Õ ß õ Ò =!

Y B;512e^;H/03.12ubu57A4B-A�B;HP,/0324H =Pß � X � A4B;H'E4bu5124HMbcHRFIZ;2TAe*;H/H/^�A�><C;E4>%KLHMA�B�0GA ! 512u^;57K@51245V]�.1HÔ]�8`A�B�E�H/HP51*A�B;HÔ,k0324H =Pß ïa03*;^-Awbc><57*�A�B;HÔ,k0324H�=Mß .;X Y B;H'E�HP0GE�HMAwbc><,k0324H/2/N �iß Ë ï Õ >3E �iß Ë ó � ó Õ X)+*�A�B;HÔ6�>3E�=?H'E/N

! ßéó � ï � = � � Ò � = Ò õ $ ß õ = � Ò � = Ò õ $ �03*;^�57*�A�B;HÔ.90GA4A�HJE

! ßéó � ï � = � � Ò . = Ò õ $ ß õ = � Ò . = Ò õ $ �Y B;HÔE�H/2TZ;.7Au*;>%b 6�>O.1.7>%bu2RHk032451.V8LX ����� � K®��¡k� �������»¡/����¡?�»���Í�����(�L�������®�W�-£ ¤'¥ �২¤Ô©Uª¨ù ° ¸/©�³¨¤kÀv£ ¤J¥ � §¨¤Ô© ° ¤�¹3ù�³[¤[¹<³Jù ° µO¤P¬G¼ � ,yûy´�¥®­ o��#ä �× ¥½Àu£ ¤J¥ ! §¨¤M©_§J¬�ùs¼(¹L© ° ·ûy´�¥®­`ª¨ù ¯L¯ ¬ ° ¥ �_À Á ­;¤å¸�¬�Â�Â1¬�ûy´�¼�È?´�« ¯  ´¶³�©G¥|´¶¬�¼;ªM­;¬�Â7¹ �

Ë ð Õ �ãª[ª¨ù@«?¤ o���ä ! ´�ª�Â1¤JµO¤JÂ1,_©G¼±¹ ! ­�©�ªq©Íù@¼�´|ø'ùW¤¾³[¬�« ¯ ¬G¼(¤J¼�¥�, U ,Uû�­;¬%ª�¤Ð³[¬�¤ !�³J´½¤J¼�¥�, � ,a´�ª«g´�¼W´�«<©GÂ7À �Sª¨ª¨ùs«_¤ � �àð ÀD£ ¤J¥ !��Sß !"ä � U À Á ­;¤J¼ o���ä !�� ´�ª �cùsª[­g¸k¬ ° ©GÂ�Â媨ù !ë³J´¶¤'¼�¥®Â ·ª¨«<©3Â� � àŠÀ

Ë ó Õ �ãª[ª¨ù@«?¤i©G¼�·�ª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|·�¬+¸ �  ´¶¤¨ª"©3Â1¬�¼@È�©�³[¬G« ¯ ¬�¼(¤'¼�¥<¬+¸ � ¬+¸�«g´»¼�´�«<©GÂã³[¬�¤ !ë³J´¶¤'¼�¥½À � ¸o��gä ! ´�ª��cùsª[­�©G¥¿©GÂ� ¤���³[¤ ¯ ¥|´¶¬�¼±©3Â(¹G´�µ%´�ªk¬ ° ªã¬+¸S¥®­;¤ã«g´�¼�´�«?©GÂ�¹s¤¨ª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© ° ´�ª/©G¥|´¶¬�¼ ,�¥®­;¤J¼ o ä � !´�ª�cùsª[­ã¸k¬ ° ©G¼�· � Ãé𠪨ùW³¨­�¥®­�©G¥ � ! ´�ªº© ¯ ù ° ¤g§¨¬Gùs¼±¹�© ° ·LÀ

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ ,W>3E Ë ð Õ X�# HJA � ßtn Ë ! Õ ]±HMA4B;HÔ,/>sH�!?,'51H/*LAe>O6�U_X2# H'A � 8 ß � ä � X � 6�,/>OZ�E�24H � 8 ßén Ë !�� Õ X�#�H'A� ]±Hº03*L8DH �;,/HJC;A�51>O*�03.�^;57K@5124>3E/Xå)+6 � ^;>@H/2R*;>3A�.751Hã>%KLHJE?U A�B;H/*

� Ë � � o��`ä�!�� Õ ß � Ë � � o��`ä! Õ � � � � 8

Page 67: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � � 2+@51*;,'H � 8 ßtn Ë ! � Õ 5VA\512cA�B�Z;2uH'*;>OZ;:OB�A�>g,[B;H/,�QO/�Z;24B;*;H/242u.1>@,/03.1.78_0GA\Hk03,[B�C(>O57*�AR03.7>O*;:)U_X�í\AR2451*;:OZ;.10GEC(>O57*�A42MA�B;572Ô6�>O.7.1>�be2M69E�>O= Ë :�Xæï�X � X ó Õ N±beB;57.1Ha0GAM24=?>@>3A4BÐC±>O51*LA�2 Ë >O6 ��Õ bvHa,k03*�0GC;C�.78 Ë :�Xæï�X ó@X1ð Õ X Y B�Z;2Ë ð Õ X

,W>3E Ë ó Õ X # HJAãn ß�n Ë ! Õ X �S>3A�H � n ß n Ë � ! Õ X?#�H'A � ](Hg03*"HG�;,/H'C;A451>O*�03.�^;5VK�512T>3EkN±>�KLH'E�A�B;HºC±>O51*LA�Í57* � X +@Z�C;C(>O24HUÏ;E�2TA �m512M0`2451*;:OZ;.10GEãC(>O51*LAkX Ì Ha,k03*¾032424Z;=?H �Ö512M03*iHG�;,/H'C;A451>O*�03.�^;57K@5124>3EM>O6åA�B;H=?57*;51=_03.�^;H/2451*;:OZ;.10GE�51240GA�51>O*�>�KLH'E � N;]�8 Ë :�Xpï�X � X . Õ X #�H'A

� Ë � Õ ß � Ë � � oÚä � ! Õ�Ò n � �

Ì HÔB�0�KLH � Ë Å Õ - Å�N � Ë ð Õ � Å�N�24> � Ë � Õ � Åa6�>3E � - ðOX�S>�bÝ24Z�C;C±>O24H ��572S0?24=?>s>3A�B-C±>O51*LAkXe)+6 � 512e24=?>@>3A4B"0GA��¾A4B;H/* � Ë � � oÖä � ! Õ �éÅ�X?+@>D032424Z;=?H �

512ã0_*;>s^;HU>O6 � X Y B;H/*Ðn 512�A4B;H#,/>@H�!<,/51H'*�AM>O6y>O*;Hg>O6yA4B;HU,'>O=<C(>O*;H/*LA�2S>O6 � A�B�E�>OZ;:OB � N�24>_bcHg,k03*,[B;H/,�Q8/�Z;2TB;*;H/242S.1>s,k03.1.V8D0GE�>OZ;*;^ � N�03*;^"0GC;C�.78 Ë :�Xæï�X ó@X7ð Õ X �������65 7�� 9y�����%�»���¿� ,�>3Ee0a]±>OZ;*;^�0GE48 ! >O*"0<24Z�E46�03,/H ' NWbcHP.1H'A�� Ë !<Õ ](HPA4B;HP24H'A�>O6�24=?>s>3A�B�C±>O51*LA�2>O6 ' buB;H'E�H � !�� Ë A�B;HP2TZ�C;C(>3E4Ae>O6 !<Õ 512R2457*;:OZ;.90GEkX

������)( �¿�@�Í����� � �º¬G¥½©G¥|´¶¬�¼ë©Gª`´�¼ � � ÀCB�À � � , � � ÀCB@À ��� � À .�ù ¯L¯ ¬%ªk¤ o��`ä ! ´�ª-©G¼W¥®´�ú4©G« ¯ Â1¤0,U©G¼±¹ �cùsª[­©Gû¿©3·u¸ ° ¬�« � Ë !<Õ�À\£ ¤'¥ Þ Ü 'ݧJ¤Ô¥»­�¤Ôª¨ù ¯L¯ ¬ ° ¥\¬I¸ !"À£ ¤'¥ Ñ ~ �çÒ�Ó '�§¨¤P¥®­;¤Ô¼�¤��O¥¿ª¨¥+¤ ¯ ¬+¸M¥®­;¤ o��Pä ! ­�ù@¼�¥wÀ �ãª[ª¨ù@«?¤ ! 8 ´�ªº© ¯ ù ° ¤#§¨¬�ù@¼±¹L© ° ·OÀ Á ­;¤J¼Ë ð Õ o��`ä!�� ©G¼±¹ o��`ä! 8 © ° ¤ �vùsª[­�©3û¿©G·e¸ ° ¬G« � Ë !aÕ�À

� ¸ � ´�ªM¼(¬�¥R©<¼(¤'¥ ,vÂ1¤J¥ ß Ñ Ë Õ Ü 'eÀ Á ­;¤�¸k¬GÂ�Â1¬�ûy´�¼@È?­;¬�Â7¹ �Ë ó Õ � ¸ ´�ªÔ©?³[¬�« ¯ ¬�¼(¤J¼�¥c¬+¸ Þ ,奮­;¤J¼ o����±ä ! Ê ´�ªe¼�¬�¥yÂ1¤Jµ3¤'Â�©G¥ � , � ´�ªM©gª¨«?¬�¬G¥»­ ¯ ¬�´»¼�¥¿¬+¸+' Ê , Þ Ê

¹�¬�¤JªR¼(¬�¥ ­�©Gµ3¤e¼(¬ ° «?©GÂ(³ ° ¬%ª[ª¨´�¼�È�ªe©G¥ � ,å©G¼±¹ o����sä ! Ê ´�ª �cù�ª[­_©Gû¿©G·¿¸ ° ¬�« � Ë ! Ê Õ�À �´�¼±©3Â� · ,�´Ç¸o��yä ! ´�ª �cùsª[­?© ° ¬�ùs¼(¹ ¥®­;¤J¼ ´�ª\¥»­;¤S¬G¼� ·a¤��@³[¤ ¯ ¥®´¶¬G¼±©GÂW¹G´�µ�´�ªk¬ ° ¬�µ3¤ ° � ©3¥�û�­�´½³¨­ o����Lä ! ʸ/©G´»ÂpªM¥w¬`§¨¤PÂ1¤JµO¤JÂ7À

Ë ï Õ � ¸ ´�ªe¼(¬G¥¿©_³[¬�« ¯ ¬G¼(¤J¼�¥v¬I¸ Þ ,¿©G¼(¹ ´�ªM¹3´�ª�²k¬�´»¼�¥@¸ ° ¬�« � Ë !<Õ㥮­;¤J¼ o����±ä ! Ê ´�ª �cùsª[­�©Gû¿©G·¸ ° ¬�« R Ë � Ë !aÕ4Õ-,v©G¼±¹ o��`ä �ÞÝä U ´�ªMÂ1¬[È<¥w¤ ° «g´�¼(©GÂ�´�¼Í©<¼(¤J´1ÈG­�§¨¬�ù ° ­;¬%¬k¹D¬+¸ À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ �S>3A4HPA�B;HPÏ�*�03.�E�H/=_0GE4Q�51* Ë ï Õ 6�>O.1.7>%bu2�69E�>O=×C;E�H'K@51>OZ;2S2TA[0GA4H/=?H/*LA�2e>O6 Ë ï Õ N�]�8 Ë :�XæÅ�X . Õ 03*;^"A�B;H^;H'Ï�*;5VA�51>O*q>O6 � Ë !aÕ X �S>3A4H#03.124>?A4B�0GAeA�B;Hg03242TZ;=<C;A�51>O*;2�03*;^",/>O*;,/.1Z;2T51>O*;2ã51* Ë ð Õ >3E Ë ï Õ 0GE4Hº24Z;,[B"A�B�0GAbcHÔ,k03*-24B�E451*�Q ' NW03*;^�032T24Z;=?H�� Ë !<Õ 512uH/=<C;Aw8LN@A�B�0GAu512\A�B�0GAuÞ � ' 3 572u2T=?>@>3A�B�Xo�� �yä !�572S.1H'KLH/. ]s8 Ë :�Xpï�X � X . Õ 03*;^ Ë :�Xpï�X7ðOX1ð Õ X $v8-A�B;H#^;H'Ï�*;5VA�51>O*Ð>O6 /�Z;24B�N � N(A�B;Hg,/>@H�!<,/51H'*�Aã>O6�U

51* !�N 512M2TA4E�57,'A�.V8i2T=_03.1.7H'EãA�B�03*iA�B;Ha,/>@H !?,/57H/*�AP>O6c03*L8i>3A4B;H'Eº,/>O=aC(>O*;H/*LAP>O6 !�X�+@> Ë ð Õ 6�>O.1.7>%bu2P69E4>O=Ë :�X .;X1ðOX1ð Õ 6�>O.7.1>�bcH/^-]�8 Ë :�X .;X7ðOX ó Õ Ë 0GC;C�.751H/^DA�> !�� Õ XË ï Õ 512R51=<=?H/^;590GA4HS69E�>O= Ë :�Xpï�X1ðOXpó Õ X

Page 68: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

��� ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

,W>3E Ë ó Õ X�+@Z�C;C±>O24H 572c0º,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*LAc>O6�Þ"X�#�H'A � N � 8 ]±H�A�B;H�,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LA�2c>O6 03*;^ U 57*�! 8 X Y B;H/*

� ß � Ë � o���� ä ! Ê Õ Ã � 8 ß � Ë R Ë U Õ � o�����ä ! Ê Õ �

Y BsZ;2go����¿ä ! Ê 512#*;>3A#.7H'KLH/.c0GA � X�o��Ðä ! 8 512 /�Z;2TB�0GAg03*L8�HG�;,/H'C;A451>O*�03.v^;5VK�512T>3E#>O6cA�B;H_=?51*;57=_03.^;H/2457*;:OZ;.90GE�572�0GA�57>O*P>O6 � N�A4BsZ;2 � 572 *;>3A 0u24=<>@>3A�BSC(>O57*�A�]�8 Ë :�Xæï�X � Xæï Õ X�Þ Ê ,k03*;*;>3A�B�0kKLH�*;>3E4=_03.O,'E�>O242T51*;:O20GA � N;]s8 Ë :�Xæï�X ó@X7ð Õ X Y B;HMÏ�*�03.�E�H/=_0GE4Q`6�>O.7.1>�be2R69E�>O= Ë :�Xpï�X7ðOX ó Õ X �� À � À �>D ¤J«<© °GF ª/À

Ë ð Õ Ì B;H/*ºbcHc0GE4H¿B�Z;*�A�57*;:S6�>3E�0uA451:OH'EkN%bcHv,k03*º03.7b\0k8�2 032424Z;=?H ! 8 512 0uC�Z�E�H¿]±>OZ;*;^�0GE48Ô]�8 Ë :�X ó@X � X1: Õ XË ó Õ $v8º^;HJÏ�*;57A�57>O*U>O6;A�B;HcB�Z;*LAkN Ñ Ë U Õ 572�0S2451*;:OZ;.10GE�C(>O51*LAkNGbuB;51.7H � Ë !<Õ 512�,/>O*LA[0351*;H'^U57*#A�B;Hc24=?>s>3A�B

.7>@,/Z;2/N@24>#bcHã,k03*DA4B;51*�Q_>O6 � Ë !aÕ 032\0g2TZ�]�24H'Au>O6 � X �S>3A�Hã03.12T>gA4B�0GA\51*_A�B;HS,/>O*;,/.7Z;2451>O*`A�> Ë ï Õ N� �� R Ë � Ë !aÕ4Õ X

Ë ï Õ ,�57*�03.1.78LN�51* Ë ï Õ A�B;H?,'>O*;^;57A�57>O* � � Ë !<Õ ß %�572º2�0GA�572TÏ�H/^�buB;H/*;H'KLH'E#A4B;H?=gZ;.7A�5VC�.151,'57Aw8Ð>O6 !Ë A4B�0GA\512vA�B;Hã24Z;=à>O6�A�B;Hã,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LA�2/N;bcH/57:OB�A�H'^D]�8_A�B;HS=gZ;.7A�5VC�.157,/57A�57H/2v>O6�A�B;HS,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*LA�2\24H/HË ó@ðOXpó Õ4Õ 572ã0GAã.1Hk032TAã>O*;HU0GAãHk03,[BqC(>O57*�Aã>O6 � Ë !<Õ X Y B;512Sbu51.7.�03.7bc0�8@2�](H#A�B;Hg,k0324Hg51*Ð03*L8qBsZ;*LAbcHM,/>O*;2457^;H'EkX

������ � �����Í����� � ¼D¥®­;¤u­�ù@¼�¥�ûy´�¥®­�! 3 ß % , o�� �@ä � U Ê ´�ª �cù�ª[­;À � ¸���´�ªu¼(¬�¥å©º¼(¤'¥ ,�¥»­;¤'¼ o����@ä � Ê � Ê´�ª�cùsª[­�À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ ,W>O.1.7>%btA�B;HÔC;E�>s>O6 >O6 Ë ð Õ 03*;^ Ë ï Õ >O6 Ë :�X .;Xæï Õ X ��������� J ���%��K K��W���y� � ¼m¥»­�¤U­�ù@¼�¥�ûy´�¥®­ ! 3 ß % ,ã©Gª[ª¨ù@«?¤a¥®­�©G¥ � Ë ! � Õ � � � Ê ß % ¸k¬ ° ©3Â� �SÃÝÅ �½ªk¤[¤� � À � À � À � � � À Á ­;¤J¼ o����ä ! � ´�ª�cù�ª[­q©Gû¿©G·e¸ ° ¬�« � Ë ! � Õ¿¸k¬ ° ©GÂ� ��àŠÀ

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ )+=?=<H/^;590GA�Hã69E�>O= Ë :�X .;Xpï Õ 03*;^ Ë :�X .;X � Õ N�]s8D51*;^;Z;,JA�51>O*�X ��������� NM��� �å�±¡k���%�»��� � D��� �@�%�KUÿO�±��9�ý±� ���;�%���±�Ú�Wþ��%� � 9��G¡'�j�J�#��¡'�����¡m�Wþ��%� �é�����(�m�?���%�! 3 ß % � �#¬�¥½©3¥®´¶¬G¼�©�ªM´»¼ � � ÀCB�À A�� � À ¬ ° ¥®­;¤ 2 ° ª¨¥¿­�ù@¼�¥¿ª¨¥w¤ ¯ �o�� � ä U Ê ´�ªÔÂ1¬�È<¥+¤ ° «g´»¼±©GÂ1, o�����ä�! 8c´�ª�cùsª[­�©G¼(¹�¬�¼(¤U¬+¸M¥®­;¤�¸k¬GÂ�Â1¬�ûy´�¼@È?­;¬�Â7¹�ª��Ë ð Õ � Ê ´�ªº©?¼�¤J¥½À

¬�¥®­;¤ ° ûy´�ªk¤ o���� ä � Ê � Ê ´�ª�cù�ª¨­"©G¼±¹�¬�¼(¤g¬+¸P¥»­�¤å¸k¬�Â�Â1¬�ûå´�¼@È<­�¬�Â7¹�ªË ó Õ � Ë � Ê Õ Ãéð �I© ° ´�¥®­�«?¤J¥|´¶³SÈs¤J¼�ùsª � ÀË ï Õ � Ë � Ê Õ ßÝð ©G¼(¹ � Ê ­�©�ª#©G¼Í¬ ° ¹G´�¼±© ° ·<¼(¬k¹�¤#©3¥ � ß � Ê ÀË . Õ � Ë � Ê Õ ßÝð ©G¼(¹ � Ê ­�©�ª#©G¼Í¬ ° ¹G´�¼±© ° ·D³Jù�ª ¯ ©G¥ � ß � Ê ÀË�� Õ � Ë � Ê Õ ß Å ©G¼(¹ o���� ä � Ê ´�ªMÂ1¬�È_¥w¤ ° «g´�¼(©GÂ7À

Page 69: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � � 0 ¬ ° ¥®­;¤Mªk¤¨³[¬�¼±¹a­sùs¼�¥¿ª¨¥+¤ ¯ ¬G¼(¤g¬+¸P¥»­;¤�¸k¬�Â�Â1¬�ûy´»¼@È<­;¬GÂ7¹�ª��Ë õ Õ � � ´�ªº©?¼�¤J¥Ë � Õ � ´�ªM³[¬G¼�¥ ° ©�³J¥+¤�¹<§'· R � �½¥®­�©G¥�´�ª � ß � � , o�� ä ! 8 ´�ª �cù�ª[­ , o�����ä � Ê ´�ª�Â1¬�ÈU¥w¤ ° «g´�¼±©3Â1, � � ´�ª

©<ªJ«?¬�¬�¥®­ ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥u¬+¸3' � , � � ´�ªMª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ©G¥ � � ,cûy´�¥®­"©`ù@¼�´|§ ° ©G¼(³¨­�ª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥®· ,\©3¼±¹ o�� ä ! �´�ª �vùsª[­q©Gû¿©G·�¸ ° ¬�« � � ,R§'ùs¥c´�ªÔ¼(¬�¥vÂ1¤JµO¤JÂ�©G¥ � � À � ´�ªÔ¥®­;¤U¬G¼� ·-¤��@³[¤ ¯ ¥®´½¬�¼±©G ¹3´�µ�´�ªk¬ ° ©G¥cû�­s´¶³¨­o�� ä ! � ¸k©G´�ÂpªM¥+¬`§¨¤ �vùsª[­�À

Ë : Õ ! � ­�©�ªM¥|ûv¬D³¨¬�« ¯ ¬�¼�¤J¼�¥®ª/À.Wù ¯L¯ ¬%ª�¤Ô´�¼ � ��� ¥»­;©G¥ � � ä � � Ãéð À Á ­;¤J¼ �

� � À A � � � � +@51*;: Ë � Ê Õ ß % , o�� ä ! 8#´�ª �cùsª[­â©Gûv©G· +@57*;: Ë � Ê Õ�À o�� ä ! � ´�ª �cùsª[­â©3û¿©G·?¸ ° ¬�«R � Ë +@51*;: Ë � Ê ÕTÕ-,�©G¼±¹ ©3¥UÂ1¤�©�ªJ¥`¬�¼�¤Í¬+¸"Ò Ë o�� ä �MÕm¬ ° Ò Ë o�� ä �UÕi´�ª¾©G« ¯ Â1¤kÀ �eÂpªk¬ ,"¬G¼(¤Í¬+¸q¥®­;¤¸k¬�Â�Â1¬Gûy´�¼@È?­;¬�Â7¹�ª��

Ë # Õ Ë ' � ��� ä �UÕP´�ªº©�¸k¤J¼(³¨¤kÀË ð�Å Õ Ë ' � ��� ä �UÕP´�ªº©�§[©G¼±©3¼±© , o�� ä � ´�ª ¯  ¥ ,\©G¼±¹ � Ê � �<ÀË ðOð Õ Ë ' � ��� ä �UÕe´�ªe©º¥w©�³J¼(¬�¹�¤0, ûy´»¥»­<¥½©�³'¼(¬k¹�¤S©3¥ � � À o�� ä � ´�ª ¯  ¥wÀ � ¸ � Ê � � , � � � ß � � Ê � � � � À

� ¸ � Ê �� �Ö¥»­;¤'¼ � � � ß � � � � À

D ¤J«<© °GF À )+* Ë :�X1ð Õ N +@51*;: Ë � Ê Õ Ë beB;57,¨Bq572�H/57A4B;H'EãH/=<C;Aw8LN±>3E � Ê Õ 512ã0?24=<>@>3A�B-C±>O51*LAã>O6 ' Ê 03*;^q24> Ñ Ê 57203*-5724>O=?>3E4C�B;5724=×0GE�>OZ;*;^ +@57*;: Ë � Ê Õ N�A�B�Z;2ubcHÔ,k03*-A�B;57*�Q�>O6�+@51*;: Ë � Ê Õ 032e0U24Z�]�24H'A�>O6 � � X

* ° ¬�¬+¸º¬I¸ � � À � À A � � À ��KLH'E48sA�B;51*;:UA�B�E�>OZ;:OB Ë � Õ 572u,'.1Hk0GEkN�Z;2457*;: Ë :�X .;Xpï Õ X� >O*;2451^;H'ERA�B;HÔ24H/,/>O*;^"B�Z;*�Ae2TA�H'C�N�03*;^-2TZ�C;C(>O24H � � 572u*;>3Ae0<*;H'AkX)+6 � 512S,/>O*LA4E[03,'A4H/^�N(A�B;H/*q>3]�K�51>OZ;2T.78 � ß � N�03*;^qbcH#B�0kKLH#,k0324H Ë�� Õ >O6�A�B;HºÏ;E42TAãBsZ;*LAM2TA�H'C�X Y B;H

E�H/2IA�6�>O.1.7>%bu2R69E�>O= Ë :�X .;Xæï�X ó Õ X�S>�b 24Z�C;C(>O2TH ! � B�032ãA+bv>-,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*LA�2/N 03*;^ � � ä � � - ðOXº)+*iCW0GE4A451,/Z;.10GE � � à ð��Oó@N�03*;^i24> �

,k03*;*;>3Au=?H/H'Au0U2451*;:OZ;.10GEuC±>O51*LAu>O6 � X�íS.7.(A�B;H /�Z;24B-E�H/=?0GE4Q�2\6�>O.1.7>%b 69E�>O= Ë :�X .;Xæï�Xpï Õ X � � ä � � ,k03*;*;>3AB�0kKLH�0�A4E457C�.1HaC(>O51*LAa0GA � � N�]�8 Ë :�Xpï�X � Õ X +@> � � U Ê � � ß %�N�03*;^ � � � N�U Ê�� � 0GE�H_Hk03,[B�0GA=?>O2TAv>O*;H�C(>O51*LA Ë 03*;^_A�B;HS24H',/>O*;^�,/03*;*;>3Ac](HãH/=<C;Aw8_032 � � Ã Å Õ X�$v8 Ë :�Xæï�X � X7ð Õ Nso�� ä � ä � 512c.VA\0GA2457*;:OZ;.90GESC(>O57*�A42S>O6 ' � X�)+6 ¦ 572�A�B;Hg24=_03.1.7H'ES>O6 � 03*;^ � N±A4B;H/* Ò Ë o ä Ë � � ä � � ÕI¦iÕ 572Ô03=aC�.1H3X Y B;HE�H/2IA�6�>O.1.7>%bu2R69E�>O=ÖHk032T8D24H'AuA�B;H/>3E�H'A451,M,/>O*;2451^;HJE[0GA�51>O*;2'X �

��� �M�� �� &�32��M �����Y B;512�24H/,'A�57>O*P572 .7>O:O51,k03.7.78S57*;^;H'C(H/*;^;H'*�A�69E4>O=çA4B;H�E�H/2IA >O6�A�B;HåCW0GC±H'E�03*;^Ô512 Ë bcHåB;>3C(H Õ >O6�57*;^;H'C(H/*;^;H'*�A

51*LA�H'E4H/2TAkXÌ HãE�H/6�H'EuA�> � B�0GC;A�H'EPð�Åa>O6vîæó � ñ�6�>3EeA4B;HÔ^;H'Ï�*;5VA�51>O*�03*;^-]W032451,MC;E�>3C(HJE4A�51H'2u>O6��\ض24B;Hk0kKLH/2S03*;^ &� Ê� XY B;HÔ=_0357*DE4H/24Z;.7Ae>O6 A�B;572e24H','A�51>O*�512RA�B;HÔ6�>O.7.1>�be57*;:;~

Page 70: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

2&+ ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

'��®�t�#� �@�W���@�h�>.Wù ¯L¯ ¬%ªk¤ � Ü 'Ö´�ª�© ° ¤�¹GùW³[¤�¹�³Jù ° µ3¤Ð¬G¼t©¾ª¨ù ° ¸k©�³[¤q¬+¸<*c´¶³[© ° ¹i¼�ù@«<§¨¤ ° ¬�¼�¤0,U©3¼±¹o��ºä � ´�ªMÂ1³�À Á ­;¤'¼ &� � Ë &� Ê� Ë .1>O: �UÕ4Õ.- Å ,�ûå´�¥»­Dª¨¥ ° ´¶³J¥¿´�¼(¤�ø/ù;©G ´»¥®·?û�­;¤'¼ o��#ä � ´�ªº©3« ¯ Â1¤kÀ* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ $v8 Ë ð�Å�X1ð�. Õ >O6åîæó � ñWbcH�,/03*`032424Z;=?H�o��Rä � 572c03*LA�5Vؽ03=<C�.1H3X Ì HS24.157:OB�A4.78U=?>@^;57698?03*?0GE�:OZ;=?H/*LA^;Z;HSA�> *P0kb\03=_0GA�0`îæó3ÅGñ¶X Ì HS=?0�8?032424Z;=?H &� Ê� Ë .7>O: �UÕ 572c*;>3Au2TH/=?5Vض2TA[0G]�.7H3X Y B�Z;2cA�B;H'E�Hã512\0g2�0GA�Z�E�0GA�H/^^;H/2TA�0G]�51.1572451*;: � 24Z�]�2TB;Hk036 � N�,/6½XºA4B;HgC;E4>@>O6å>O6 Ë ð�Å�X7ðOð Õ >O6Sî}ó � ñ¶X +@Z�C;C(>O24H � Ê Ë � Õ ß � Ë o��Uä �UÕ X Y B;H,'E�Z;,'5903.�>3]�24HJE4K30GA451>O*q512�A�B�0GA�� 3 Ë '�� � � Õ � � �m6�>3EÔ2T>O=?Hº,/>O*;2TA�03*�A � N±,/6½XSA�B;HºC;E�>@>O6å>O6 Ë ð�Å�X1ð�. Õ >O6uîæó � ñ¶XY BsZ;2 � 572u*;>3A�03=<C�.1H3N�03*;^ � � Å�X �S>%béC;E�>s,/H/H/^�NWH �;03,'A�.78D032R51*Íîæó3ÅGñ¶X �'��65 J ���%�K K����%�y�-£ ¤J¥ 'ק¨¤D©ÐÂ1¬�Èq¥+¤ ° «g´»¼±©GÂ�ª¨ù ° ¸/©�³[¤-¬+¸!*\´¶³�© ° ¹�¼�ù@«<§¨¤ ° ¬G¼(¤-©G¼±¹ � Ü 'ש ° ¤�¹GùW³[¤�¹³Jù ° µ3¤Pª¨ùW³¨­D¥®­�©G¥ o��ºä � ´�ªMÂ1³kÀu£ ¤J¥ Ù ß '�á �-À

���� �

= � Ò ð= � � ������� Ë 'åÕ�Ò ������� Ë �UÕ

� ¸ ' ´�ª ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼(©GÂ1,c©G¼±¹��Ä­�©�ªº© ° ´�¥®­�«?¤J¥|´¶³SÈs¤J¼�ùsª Å ©G¼±¹ $ ´ °J° ¤�¹3ù�³J´¶§'Â1¤g³[¬�« ¯ ¬�¼(¤J¼W¥»ª5,¿¥»­;¤'¼���� �

= � Ò ð= � &''( '')

� ï ´ ¸ $ ßéÅ

� ð ´ ¸ $ ß�ðß Å ´ ¸ $ ßçó �

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Y B;HeÏ;E�2IAv51*;H'r@Z�03.15VAw8a6�>O.7.1>�be2�69E�>O= Ë ð�Å�X � Õ 03*;^ Ë ð�Å�X : Õ >O6yî}ó � ñ¶X�)+6 ' 512åE[0GA�57>O*�03.|NLA�B;H/* ������� Ë 'åÕ ßï�X � 572�0<,'>O*;*;H/,'A�H/^�ATE�H/HP>O6 É�Ê $ X¿)+6 � 572e*;>3AeH/=<C;Aw8LN;A�B;H/* ������� Ë �UÕ ß ðvä $ X�öSH/*;,/HPA4B;HP24H/,'>O*;^Ð2TH'A>O6 57*;H/r@Z�03.757A�57H/2R6�>O.1.1>�bu2u69E�>O=ÖA�B;HãÏ;E�2TAe51*;H/rsZ�03.157Aw8LX �'��)( J ���%�K K����%�y���´ � � à Š,?©G¼±¹�©�§/´ ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼(©GÂe¤�ø'ù@´�µG©GÂ1¤'¼(³[¤Ð³'Â7©�ª[ª � ¬I¸ ¯±° ¬+²k¤[³J¥|´�µ3¤�ª¨ù ° ¸/©�³[¤Jª/À Á ­;¤³[¬�Â�Â1¤¨³J¥®´½¬�¼

¦ ß �9' � �`l � Ë 'åÕ ßÝð ��� Ë 'åÕ � ð Ò � �

´�ªº§J¬�ùs¼(¹�¤�¹LÀ* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ �S>3A4Hº51*"CW0GE4A�57,/Z;.90GEeA�B�0GA � Ë 'åÕ �ÝðON±24> ' B�032Sr@Z;>3A�57H/*�AM03*;^"A�B�Z;2�E[0GA�57>O*�03. 2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2/X ,W>3E' � �ibe5VA�B�E[0GA451>O*�03.�2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2'N ������� Ë 'åÕ ^;H'C(H/*;^;2S>O*;.V8D>O* � Ë '�Õ X Y BsZ;2 Ë # X ó Õ 51=aC�.151H'2e03*L8-2TZ�E�6�03,/H' � ¦ B�032D0GA`=?>O2TA`ó ������� Ë '�Õ 2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2/X $c8�A�B;H",/.9032T2457Ï�,k0GA451>O*�>O6MrsZ;>3A�51H'*�AD2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2'Nu5VA512gH/*;>OZ;:OBmA�>"](>OZ;*;^ � Ë �'åÕ 6�>3E ' � ¦ N�03*;^mA�B�Z;2UA4>q]±>OZ;*;^ ��Ò o � �� l ' � ¦ ��69E�>O= 0G](>�KLH3N�buB;H'E�HÑ ~ �'�Ò�Ó ' 572RA�B;HÔ=?51*;57=_03.±^;H'2451*;:OZ;.10GE�512�0GA451>O*�XÌ E�5VA�H Ñ " o��_ßto��� ä � � � U � NW03*;^�.7H'A = � ß Ò U �� X Ì HPB�0kKLH

Ò o � �� ß Ò o �� ä � � � o��� � U �

�� � � Ë = � Ò ó Õ

+@51*;,'H � � � ðON�5VA�512uH/*;>OZ;:OB�A�><]±>OZ;*;^"A�B;HP*�Z;=#](H'ES>O6 U � bu57A�B>= � - ï�X Y B;572�512R](>OZ;*;^;H/^q57*-A�H'E�=<2e>O6� ]�8 Ë ï�X1ðOX7ð%ó Õ >O6\îæó � ñ�03*;^�2T51=<C�.7HM,'>@H�!<,/51H/*LA�,/03.1,/Z;.10GA�51>O*;2/X �

Page 71: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � 2".

�D���»�(���@�%��¡'�%�»� ý¾� � �W� � K»�Ð�»� � �±��PL�@�%�mÿG� ���%�WÿO���s�G�»¡'�%�»ÿ��

�S>3A�HS57*DCW0GE4A451,/Z;.10GEkN�A�B;H $c>O:O>O=?>O.1>�K<]±>OZ;*;^-51=aC�.151H'2\0gE[03*�Q`>O*;Hã.7>O: ãH/. ��H����/>a,/03*-B�0kKLHÔ0GAR=?>O2IAÏ;KLHº2457*;:OZ;.90GE�C±>O51*LA�2 Ë A�B;H'E�Hº572�*;><E[03*�Q->O*;Hº.1>O:<^;H/.���H����/>_be5VA�B�H �;03,'A�.V8�2T5 � � Ê 2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A451H/2 Õ XRöSHJE�HbcHÔ24B;>%bçA�B;HJE�HÔ572e*;>U](>OZ;*;^�>O*-A4B;HÔ*�Z;=#](H'Ee>O6 2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2R51*�,[B�0GE[03,'A�H'E4512TA�57,ÔAwbc>;XY 0GQLHS0º2IA4E[03*;:OHS,/>O*;57,�51* É�� N�03*;^_]�.1>�b Z�C`A�B;H�C±>O51*LAvbuB;H'E�Hã03.1.WA�B;H�A[03*;:OH/*LA�2c=?H'H'AkX �S>�btbcHSB�0kKLH

0a,'Z�E4KLH � 51* 4 Ê N�buB;51,[B�572RC�Z�E4H/.78�51*;24HJCW0GE[0G]�.1HÔ>%KLH'ERA�B;HM]W0324HP>O6 ^;H/:3E�H/HPAwbc>;X�¿57,�Q`03*�8_Ï;];E4HP03*;^DC(H'E�6�>3E4=ÖA4B;HM6�>O.7.1>�be57*;:g>3C(H'E[0GA451>O*�X@$\.7>%btZ�C"03.7>O*;: � Awbu51,/HM03*;^D,/>O*�ATE[03,'ARA�B;H

Awbc> Ò ó%ض,/Z�E4KLH/2'XM)+6ybcHºC(H'E46�>3E�= A�B;512S>3C±H'E[0GA�57>O* ;�A451=?H/2'N � bu51.1. *;>%b�B�0�KLH#24H'.161ؽ57*�A4H'E�24H/,JA�51>O* . Ò ó ;WN03*;^�bu51.7.(.157Hã51*`A�B;Hã24=?>@>3A4BD.7>@,/Z;2'X � >O*�ATE[03,'A�57*;: � bcHã:OH'Au0g.1>O:U^;H/. ��H����/>a>O6�E�03*�Q`>O*;H3N;be5VA�B�ó ;eäâð2457*;:OZ;.90GERC(>O51*LA�2/XåíS2�0U2TC(H',/5903.�,k0324H Ë ;#ß ï Õ bcHÔ:OH'Ae0S(M>3E4H/*;2TA�H/57*�.1>O:a^;H/. ��H����/>abe5VA�B-24HJKLH/*�*;>@^;H'2/X

�����i!#�����e������!M � ���������±����J���(��$��?�9� ���±�e��&L& �S ���@�s���(�������Ì H"0GE4H-24H/HJQ�51*;:�A4>¾CW0GE4A�5103.1.78j,/.103242457698�A�B;>O24H�E[03*�Q�>O*;H-.1>O:�^;H/. ��H����/>m24Z�E46�03,/H/2?bu57A�Bh,'>@H�!<,/51H/*LA

.1H'242PA�B�03*mó �3ï`beB;57,[BÍ^;>�*;>3AºB�0kKLHaA�57:OH'E�2/X � Z�Eº=<H'A�B;>@^¾512P2T51=<C�.V8"A�>�Z;24H �u51H/=?03*;* �e>s,[Bm03*;^�A�B;H$c>O:O>O=?>O.1>�KÐ](>OZ;*;^�Xi)+*m6�03,'AU6�>3EU>OZ�EU,/.903242T57Ï�,k0GA�57>O*Íbe57.1.¿E�H'r@Z;57E4HD=gZ;,[Bm.1H/2T2UA�B�03*ÍA�B;HD0G]�24H'*;,/H�>O6u0A�57:OH'EkN;24H/H Ë ð�Å�X : Õ X)wA¿bu51.7.W]±H�,/>O*LKLH/*;51H/*LA Ë 0GA�K30GE�57>OZ;2�C±>O51*LA�2v51*?A4B;HeCW0GC(H'E Õ A�>ºB�0kKLHeA�B;H�6�>O.7.1>�be57*;:º.1572TAv>O6�2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457A�57H/2

>O6 2T=_03.1.�,/>sH�!?,'51H/*LAk~

�s���»� NÔ�%���å��¡k���%���±���-£ ¤J¥ � §¨¤?©G¼Í ¥uª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥®· ,Rûy´�¥®­ � ß � Ë � Õ�À � ¸ Å � � ��ï � � ,R¥®­;¤ ¯ ¬%ª[ªJ´|§'´� ´�¥|´¶¤¨ª¸k¬ ° � © ° ¤#©�ªå¸k¬�Â�Â1¬�û�ª��

� A�� � �éð��Oó � Ë ï ��� � Õ�À � ß � � Ê� � � � À

��B � � ßÝð��Oó �

�I© � Ë . Õ�I§ � Ë ï ��� � � ï Õ�T³ � Ë ó � ï � ó Õ�I¹ � � ´�ªº©_¼�¬�¼�ú4³¨­;©G´�¼"ª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥|· ,¿ûy´�¥®­q³¨¤J¼�¥+¤ ° Ë ó ÕU©G¼(¹D§ ° ©G¼(³¨­;¤Jª Ë ó Õ0, Ë ó Õ0,\©G¼±¹ Ë � � � ï Õ0,¿ûy´�¥®­�¥®­;¤³[¤J¼W¥ ° ©GÂc³Jù ° µO¤�©3¼±¹Ð¥»­;¤_ù@¼�´|ø'ùW¤_Ò ï ú4³Jù ° µO¤_«_¤[¤J¥|´�¼@È�¬ ¯L¯ ¬%ªJ´�¥w¤-¤J¼±¹GªD¬+¸_¥®­;¤ � � ³¨­�©G´�¼(À Á ­�´�ª<´�ª?¥®­;¤¬�¼� ·?¼(¬G¼�ú4³¨­�©3´�¼�ª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|·<ûå´�¥»­ � ��ó �3ï À

��� � ð��Oó � � � ï � � �

�I© � Ë ó � ï ��� � Õºûy´»¥»­ ó � � � . À � ß � � � �� � � � À�I§ � Ë . � ó Õ-, � ß . � � À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Ë #�X7ð Õ E�H'^;Z;,/H/2eA�B;HãE�H/2TZ;.7AeA4><2TA4E�0351:OBLA�6�>3E4b\0GE�^�,[B;H/,�Q�51*;:;X �

Page 72: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

2,) ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

�s��� 5¾�#� �"þ½��K K����?�»� ým� �����;�%�»���â�®¡09 � ���h�%� �%�±� ý±� ��� �U�%� �q¡/��ÿ3�%���±���' ´�ªM© ° ©G¼ F ¬�¼�¤SÂ1¬[È<¹s¤JÂ�*e¤�����¬ ,�©G¼±¹ �'�Ò�Ó ' ´�ªS¥®­;¤ã«g´�¼�´»«<©GÂ�¹�¤¨ª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�ª/©3¥®´¶¬G¼±À � ´�ªS¥»­;¤ ° ¤JÂ7©G¥|´�µ3¤

*\´¶³�© ° ¹a¼�ùs«?§¨¤ ° ¬+¸ �'�Ò�Ó 'eÀ ¬ ° ©-ªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© °�¯ ¬�´�¼�¥ Î � ' , � Ë Î Õ<´�¼±¹G´¶³[©G¥w¤Jªg¥»­;¤D³[¬�¼�¥ ° ´|§/ùs¥|´¶¬�¼h¬I¸ Î ¥w¬ � ,�¥»­�©3¥u´�ªa¥»­;¤<¼�ùs«?§¨¤ ° ¬+¸

¤��@³¨¤ ¯ ¥|´¶¬�¼±©G ¹3´�µ�´�ªk¬ ° ªã ·G´�¼@È�¬Gµ3¤ ° Î À£ ¤'¥ =�~ 'çÒ�Ó ' §¨¤a¥®­;¤a«U´�¼�´�«<©3 ° ¤¨ª�¬� ùs¥|´¶¬�¼â¬+¸ 'Ú¬�µO¤ ° ¥®­;¤a¼(¬G¼ �Ôù ��©GÂyÂ1¬%³Jù�ªkÀ Á ­�ùsª = ° ¤¨ªk¬G µ3¤¨ª

¯±° ¤[³J´�ªk¤' ·a¥®­;¤Ô¼(¬G¼ �Ôù ��©GÂ�ª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥®´½¤¨ª/À � ¼ ¯ © ° ¥®´½³JùsÂ7© ° , ' ­�©�ª �S¬ ° ¤'¼;ª¨¥+¤J´�¼"ª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ªkÀ£ ¤'¥ Þ Ü ' §¨¤U¥®­;¤ � ° ¤�¹GùW³[¤�¹ � ª¨ù@« ¬+¸#¥®­;¤ = ú�¤��@³[¤ ¯ ¥®´¶¬G¼±©GÂy¹G´�µ�´�ª�¬ ° ª5,e©G¼(¹ � ¥®­;¤U¼�ù@«<§¨¤ ° ¬+¸#¼(¬�¼ �Ôù

��©GÂ�ªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´»¥®´¶¤Jª/Àº£ ¤J¥ !�ß�o � � � Ë ð Ò � � Õ U � ,Rû�­;¤ ° ¤g¥»­;¤gªJùs«Ä´�ª?¬Gµ3¤ ° ¥®­;¤ = ú�¤��@³[¤ ¯ ¥®´¶¬G¼±©GÂ�¹3´�µ�´�ªk¬ ° ª5,©G¼±¹&� � ß � Ë U � � o�� Õ�À.W´�¼�³[¤ � 3 Ë óGo � ä�Þ Õ ß Å ûv¤P­�©Gµ3¤#§/· D ´½¤J«<©G¼�¼ D ¬�³J­

� 3 Ë Ò o � Ò Þ Õ.- � Ë Ò o � Ò Þ Õ ßÝð Ò �aä�o �� ä�!ßÝð Ò �aä�o � �� ä�o � � ÞË ð�Å�Xæï Õ

¬ ° © �w¼(¬�¼ �Ôù ��©3 � ª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© °v¯ ¬�´»¼�¥ � ûv¤ÔÂ1¤J¥ ! Ë � Õ0,�� Ë � Õ-,c©G¼(¹�� Ë � ÕU§¨¤Ô¥®­;¤g³[¬�¼W¥ ° ´|§'ù@¥®´¶¬G¼�¬+¸ � ¥w¬ ! ,Ò o � �� ,c©G¼(¹ o � � Þ ° ¤Jª ¯ ¤[³J¥|´�µ3¤' ·OÀ Á ­sù�ª

! Ë � Õ ß � Ë ð Ò � � Õ o �� � U �eß � Ë ð Ò � � Õ Ë Ò ó Ò U �� Õ� Ë � Õ ß � � � Ë Ò ó Ò U �� Õ� Ë � Õ ß � o �� � U��eß � Ë Ò ó Ò U �� Õ

û�­;¤ ° ¤U´�¼h¤[©�³¨­�³�©�ª�¤#¥®­;¤UªJùs« ´�ª?¬�µ3¤ ° ¥®­;¬%ª�¤ � ûy´�¥®­ U��  ·G´�¼@ÈЬ�µO¤ ° � À �q¤?©GÂpªk¬ ° ¤»¸k¤ ° ¥w¬ � Ë � Õ_©�ªg¥®­;¤�#����ý�����¬I¸ � À £ ¤'¥�� §¨¤-¥»­;¤-ª¨ù@« ¬+¸`¥®­;¤-ûc¤J´1È�­�¥®ª�¬+¸D¥®­;¤DªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© °g¯ ¬�´�¼�¥®ª5,U©G¼±¹ � §¨¤�¥®­;¤�ûv¤'´1È�­�¥+¤�¹©Gµ3¤ ° ©�È�¤U¬+¸M¥®­;¤g³[¬�¤ !�³J´½¤J¼�¥®ª5,奻­;©G¥�´�ª

� � �qß � � Ë � Õ � Ë � Õ ��u§Jª�¤ ° µ3¤

� �Ë ð�� �ãÕ � � Ë � Õ � Ë 'åÕ ß � Ë 'åÕ �

�q¤ÔÂ1¤J¥ ! Ë � Õg§¨¤Ô¥®­;¤P´�¼(¹�¤��-¬+¸ � �½¥®­�©G¥¿´�ªM¥®­;¤U¬ ° ¹�¤ ° ¬+¸M¥®­;¤ÔÂ1¬�³[©GÂO¸¨ù@¼±¹L©G«_¤J¼�¥w©GÂ(È ° ¬�ù ¯ � À� ¼q¥»­�¤ã­�ùs¼W¥�ûy´»¥»­!' ß ' 3 ,¿ûv¤ÔÂ1¤J¥ � §J¤Mª¨ù@« ¬+¸�� Ë � Õå¸�¬ ° � �� À D ¤[³�©GÂ�Â3¸ ° ¬�« � � ÀCB@À A���� ¥®­�©G¥ Ü ' 3

´�ªM¥®­;¤Ô´»«<©�È�¤a¬+¸ Ê Ü � Ê À�s��� �¿���Í����� �½¼(¬�¥w©G¥|´¶¬�¼¾©GªÔ´�¼ � A�� ÀCB ��� � ¸ � � ð ,R¬ ° ��ßçó ©G¼(¹ � Ë 'åÕ � ð��Oó ,�¥»­�¤J¼ l Ò o � Ò Þ�l ´�ª¼(¬�¼Wú4¤J« ¯ ¥|· ,�´�¼ ¯ © ° ¥|´¶³Jù@Â7© ° ©3¼�·�¤��@³[¤ ¯ ¥®´¶¬G¼±©G ¹G´�µ%´�ªk¬ ° ¬�µ3¤ ° ©<¼(¬�¼ �Ôù��W©G ¯ ¬G´�¼�¥¿´�ªº©<¥|´1È�¤ ° À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ $v8 Ë ð�Å�X7ð Õ N ! Ë � Õ - ð��Oó@Ns576 � � ð��Oó@X�+@57*;,/Heo �� Ã�Å�N�l Ò o � Ò Þ�lG512¿*;>O*@ضH/=<C;Aw8LNL]s8 Ë ð�Å�Xpï Õ X �

Page 73: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � 25�

)wAã512ã,/>O*LKLH/*;51H'*�AÔA�>`.1512IAP03.7.�6�>OZ�ETØ|A�Z�C�.1H/2M>O6¿57*�A4H/:OH'E�2M0GAM.1Hk032IAPï�N(buB;51,[Bi,k03*i>s,/,/Z�EP032ã51*;^;51,'H/2Ô>O*i0E[03*�Q_>O*;HM.1>O:g^;H/. ��H����/> Ë A�B�0GA\512\57*�A�H':OH'E�2\2�0GA�5724698�57*;:UA�B;H $c>O:O>O=?>O.7>%KU](>OZ;*;^ Õ X Ì Hã*;>3A�Hã51*DHk03,[BD,k0324HA�B�0GAR]s8`A�B;H $c>O:O>O=?>O.1>�K<]±>OZ;*;^-A�B;H'E�HÔ,k03*-]±HÔ*;>?>3A4B;H'Ee2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457A�57H/2u>O*DA�B;HP2TZ�E�6�03,/H3X�s��� �

Ë 0 Õ Ë ï � ï � ï � n Õ Nsn - ï�NW>3EË ] Õ Ë ï � ï � . � n Õ N:. � n � ð%ó@N;>3EË , Õ Ë ï � ï � � � n Õ N � � n �

� N�>3EË ^ Õ Ë ï � ï � õ � õ Õ Ns>3EË H Õ Ë ï � . � . � n Õ . � n � õ�NW>3EË 6 Õ Ë . � . � . � . Õ X

�s��� � �¿���Í����� �º¬G¥½©G¥|´¶¬�¼�©�ªM´�¼ � A�� ÀCB � Àc£ ¤J¥�'ݧ¨¤g© ° ©G¼ F ¬�¼(¤ÔÂ1¬[ÈD¹�¤J *�¤����%¬gª¨ù�³J­D¥»­;©G¥ l Ò o � Ò Þ�l´�ª#¤'« ¯ ¥|·OÀ3.Wù ¯�¯ ¬%ªk¤ ' ­�©�ª n ª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ªg¬+¸M´�¼±¹s¤���©G¥vÂ1¤�©�ªJ¥�¥®­ ° ¤¨¤kÀ

� ¸ nÄàï ,�¥®­;¤J¼Ð¥®­;¤MªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´»¥®´¶¤Jª#¬+¸ '�© ° ¤0,R¤J´�¥®­;¤ °Ë ð Õ Ë ï Õ-, Ë ï Õ-, Ë ó � ó � ó Õº©G¼±¹ Ë ï � ó � ó � ó � ó Õ-,å¬ °Ë ó Õ Ë ï Õ-, Ë ï Õ-, Ë ï � ó Õ#©G¼±¹`©3¼ � � ú ¯ ¬�´»¼�¥ ,R¬ °Ë ï Õ¾¥®­;¤Ô´�¼±¹3´¶³[¤¨ªP© ° ¤ãÈG´»µ3¤J¼i§'· � A�� À��LÀ�© � À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ +@Z�C;C±>O24Hº*;>3AkX�S>3A�H#Ï;E�2TAÔA�B�0GAM]s8qA�B;Ha,/.903242T57Ï�,k0GA�57>O*¾>O6vrsZ;>3A�51H'*�AÔ2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A451H/2<î � ñ�A�B;HJE�H<572Ô>O*;.V8i>O*;HU*;>O*�,'8@,/.157,

2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8LN;Þ � N�>O6 57*;^;H � Ë A�B�0GAR512e>3E4^;H'Ee>O6 .1>@,/03.�6�Z;*;^�03=?H/*LA[03. :3E4>OZ�C Õ .7H/242uA4B�03*¾ð�õ�X�S2457*;: Ë #åX1ð Õ 5VAu572u2T51=<C�.7HãA4>a,/.103242457698�2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457A�57H/2u>O6 24=_03.7.(51*;^;H �(X@,W>3ERH ��03=aC�.1HSA�B;HM>O*;.78`*;>O* ãZ

H¿03.�2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2R>O6 51*;^;HG�"0GAu=?>O2TA � 0GE4H

Ë ð�Å�X � Õ Ë � Õ-� Ë õ Õ � Ë�� Õ � Ë . Õ � Ë ï Õ-� Ë . � ó Õ � Ë ï � ó Õ � Ë ï � ó � ó Õ �

Ì HMbe57.1.�Z;24HMA�B;512/NW032\bcH/.7. 032 Ë ð�Å�X7ð Õ N�E�H'C±Hk0GA�H/^;.V8-03*;^�be5VA�B;>OZ�AuE4H/=_0GE4Q±X� .1Hk0GE�.V8�n ß .;N�Z;2457*;:DA�B;H0$c>O:O>O=?>O.7>%KD](>OZ;*;^�X Ì Hg,/>O*;2451^;HJEMA4B;Ha0G]±>%KLHg.7512TAã>O6�C(>O2T2457]�.7HU57*;^;51,/H'2/X

#�H'A �<]±HÔA�B;Hº6�>OZ�ETA�B"2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8D51*�A�B;HP.7512TAkX Ì HÔÏ;E�2IAS24B;>�b A4B�0GA�,k0324H'2 Ë ^ Õ Ø Ë 6 Õ 0G](>�KLHP^;>?*;>3Ae>@,/,/Z�E/X�S>3A�H � - ð�Å�N�6�>3Ee>3A4B;H'E4bu5124HÔo � �� - Å<03*;^�l Ò o � Ò Þ�l �ß %g]s8 Ë ð�Å�Xæï Õ X)+*",k0324H Ë ^ Õ N±>O*;Hº>O6�A4B;H#51*;^;H ��245 ��C(>O57*�A�2e=UZ;2IA�](H ��� Ë >3E � � õ Õ A4B;Hº>3A�B;H'E�Aw8sC(H Ë õ Õ Ë >3A�B;H'ETbe5724H

� � ó_03*;^ � 3 � ð��3ï<K@51>O.10GA�51*;: Ë ð�Å�X . Õ4Õ X $cZ�A�A�B;H/*"]±>3A�Bq51*;^;H �"A4B�E�H/HºC(>O57*�A42S0GE�H ãZ Hv03. Ë >3E � �# Õ

03*;^ �-ßÝðON�,/>O*�ATE[03^;51,'A451*;: Ë ð�Å�X . Õ X)+*i,/0324H Ë H Õ N(A�B;H#C±>O51*LA�2ã>3A�B;H'EãA�B�03* �D,k03*;*;>3AÔ03.7. ](H ãZ4H¿03. Ë >3E � � ð#K@51>O.90GA451*;: Ë ð�Å�X . Õ4Õ X Y B�Z;2

� Ë � Õ - ï�X Y BsZ;2��"512 ãZ Hv03.®X +@57*;,/H � - ó@N � �# Z;*;.1H/2T2gA4B;H_2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2#0GE�H Ë ï Õ N Ë . Õ N � � 03*;^

�ºß ��� X Y B;512\K�51>O.10GA�H/2 Ë ð�Å�X . Õ X

Page 74: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

2 � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

)+*-,k032TH Ë 6 Õ N � - ïg]s8 Ë ð�Å�X . Õ N@A�B�Z;2 � � õ�N�0a,'>O*�A4E�03^;51,'A�57>O*�X)+*`,k0324H Ë ] Õ N@,/>O*;2451^;HJE � Ë � Õ X�)+6�5VAc512 �'H'E�>;N@A�B;H'*�>O*;HS,[B;H/,�Q�2 Ë � Ò ð Õ±Ò ! � Å�N�,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�57*;: Ë ð�Å�Xpï Õ X

+@> � - ðOX �¾ÃéðÔ]�8 Ë ð�Å�X . Õ X +@> � Ò � Ë � Õ 572e0GAu=?>O2TAuõ�X Y B�Z;2 � Ë � Õ - .;X@,�E�>O= ! Ë � Õ � ð%ó#57Au6�>O.1.7>%bu2A�B�0GA �ºß Ë ï ��� � Õ X Y BsZ;2R]s8 Ë ð�Å�X . Õ N � - ï�X Ë ð Õ 512\A�B;HP>O*;.V8_C(>O242T57]�51.757Aw8`be5VA�B � - ð�Å�X)+*i,/0324H Ë , Õ N�24Z�C;C±>O24HUÏ;E42TA �`512ã*;>O* MZ H¿03.|X +@51*;,/H � - ó@N � Ò � Ë � Õ �

� N(A�B�Z;2 � Ë � Õ - ï�N(buB;51,[B51=aC�.151H'2�#ß Ë ï � ó � ó Õ X�)wA�6�>O.7.1>�be2yA�B;H\2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2å0GE�H Ë ï Õ N � � N ��� 03*;^ Ë ï � ó � ó Õ X Y B;512yK�57>O.90GA�H/2 Ë ð�Å�X . Õ XY BsZ;2 �<512�ãZ>Hv03.®X Y B;H/*->O*;HP,[B;H/,�Q�2 Ë � Ò ð Õ�Ò ! � ÅUZ;*;.1H/2T2ebcHMB�0�KLH Ë ó Õ X ��s��� � �¿�@�Í����� �#¬�¥w©G¥|´¶¬�¼�©GªP´�¼ � A�� ÀCB � À �ãª[ª¨ù@«?¤ � Ë 'åÕ � ó �3ï ©G¼±¹ l Ò o � Ò Þ�lLß % À �q¤º­�©GµO¤P¥®­;¤¸k¬�Â�Â1¬Gûy´�¼@È ¯ ¬%ª[ª¨´¶§'´� ´�¥|´¶¤¨ª/À \´�¥»­�¤ °

Ë ð Õ �-ß . , � - . ,�¥®­ ° ¤¨¤U¬+¸M¥®­;¤MªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´»¥®´¶¤Jªº© ° ¤ Ë ï Õ-,c¬ °Ë ó Õ o � �� ß Ò ï , �-ß ï , � ß � , ï � � ��� � � Ë '�Õ-,\¬ °Ë ï Õ o � �� ß Ò ó , �-ß ï , � ß . , ð��Oó ��� � � Ë '�Õ-,\¬ °Ë . Õ o � �� ß Ò ð , �-ß ï , � ß ï , ð��3ï ��� � � Ë '�Õ-,\¬ °Ë�� Õ o � �� ß Ò ð , �-ßéó , � ßéó , ð��Oó ��� � � Ë '�Õ�À(ù ° ¥®­;¤ ° «?¬ ° ¤0,\´Ç¸ � Ë '�Õ ��ð��Oó ¥®­;¤J¼ o � �� ß Ò ð , � Ã�ð��3ï ,e©G¼±¹�¤J´�¥®­;¤ ° � � � ­;¬GÂ7¹�ª5,e¬ ° � A � ­;¬�Â7¹�ª0,u©3¼±¹

¥®­;¤ÔÂ7©�ª¨¥¿ª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥|·?´�ª Ë ï ��� � ÕkÀ* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ $v8ÐA�B;HS$c>O:O>O=?>O.7>%K-](>OZ;*;^�N � � .;X $v8 Ë ð�Å�Xpï Õ 03*;^�A�B;H<^;H'Ï�*;5VA�51>O*;2ÔbcH?B�0kKLHaA�B;H?6�>O.7.1>�be57*;:6�>3E�=gZ;.903HG~

Å!� Ò o � �� �ëó � �3ï � � - �� � � - � � � o � � U � ßéo �� Ò o �� Ã Ò o ��

!Íà � �3ï � � � � � ! � � Ò ð � Ò o � �� - � Ò �aätð �)+6 ��ß .abcHÔB�0�KLH Ë ð Õ ]s8 Ë ð�Å�Xæõ Õ X+@Z�C;C(>O2TH �"ßéó@X Y B;H/* � �3ï � ! �éðOX Y B�Z;2 � ßéóa03*;^�o � �� ß Ò ðOX+@Z�C;C(>O2TH �qß�ï�X � �3ï � ! � óa24> � �ëõ�X Y B;H#,'>3E4E�H/2TC±>O*;^;51*;:?KG03.1Z;H/2e>O6�o � �� N�03*;^ ��6�>O.7.1>�bÝ69E4>O=

A�B;HÔ6�>3E�=gZ;.903HM0G](>�KLH3X,�51*�03.7.78"2TZ�C;C(>O24H � Ë 'åÕ � ð��Oó@X Y B;H/*¾]�8 Ë ð�Å�X1ð Õ N � ß � � .;N 03*;^ÍÅ � Ò o � �� � � �Oó � ó@X Y B�Z;2

o � �� ß Ò ðON�03*;^ � � � �çð��Oó@X@+@><516�bcHP^;>a*;>3AeB�0kKLH Ë . Õ N�A�B;H/* �-ß � ß .;X Y B;HP.1032TAR2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8DB�032�#ß � NW03*;^-A�B�Z;2u]�8 Ë ð�Å�X1ð Õ 572 Ë ï ��� � Õ X �öSH'E�HãbcHÔB;>OZ;24HP24>O=<HÔ2457=<C�.1HSE�H'24Z;.7A�2'NWbuB;51,[B�=?57:OB�AR>3A�B;HJE4be5724Hã](HP>O*DA�B;HP2IA4E�H/H'A42/X

�s��� ' �¿���Í����� �#¬�¥½©3¥®´¶¬G¼¾©�ªÔ´»¼ � � ÀCB�À A�� � À

o �� � ßË o�� �/� Õ �

Page 75: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � 2 �

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ )+=?=<H/^;590GA�Hã2457*;,/H ' 3 B�032RE[03*�QD>O*;H3X ��s���»�@� �¿�@�Í�����D£ ¤J¥ Ë '�� Î Õ�§¨¤¾©m ¥ºÈ�¤ ° « ,`©G¼±¹ � Ü ' ©G¼ ©G¼±©G ·G¥®´½³�©GÂ� ·j´ °¨° ¤[¹Gù�³'´|§'Â1¤�³Jù ° µ3¤-È�¤ ° «©G¥ Î À .�ù ¯L¯ ¬%ªk¤ Î ­�©�ªaûv¤J´1È�­s¥S¬�¼(¤-,S©G¼±¹ ��ì«?¤[¤J¥®ª_¬�¼W ·q¬�¼�¤`¤��@³[¤ ¯ ¥®´½¬�¼±©GÂå¹G´�µ%´�ªk¬ ° , U ,M¬+¸g¥»­�¤a«g´�¼�´»«<©G¹�¤¨ªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�ª/©G¥|´¶¬�¼<¬�µ3¤ ° Î ,�¥»­�¤¿ù@¼�´|ø'ùW¤�Ò ï ú4³Jù ° µ3¤u¬�µ3¤ ° Î ,�©3¼±¹�«?¤¨¤J¥»ª U ¼(¬ ° «<©GÂ� ·LÀ Á ­;¤J¼a¥»­;¤R³[¬�¤ !ë³J´¶¤J¼W¥¬+¸ U ´»¼q¥»­�¤ ¯ ù@Â�Â7§[©�³ F ¬+¸ � ´�ª � Ë Î Õ�À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ ,W>O.1.7>%bu2å2451*;,/H �� 03*;^ Ò o �� B�0�KLHRA�B;He2403=?Hu57*�A4H'E�24H/,JA�51>O*<bu57A4B<Hk03,[B_H ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.W^;5VK�5724>3E¿>O6�A�B;H=?57*;51=_03.�^;H/2451*;:OZ;.10GE�51240GA�51>O*�>�KLH'EyÎ�X ��s���»��� �����Í������£ ¤'¥ � � 'Ö§¨¤�©Í³J·�³J ´¶³_¼(¬�¼ �Ôù ��©GÂ�ª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|·OÀ Á ­;¤J¼�¥®­;¤ ° ¤_´�ªD©G¼ë¤��@³[¤ ¯ ¥®´½¬�¼±©G¹G´�µ%´�ªk¬ ° U Ü �'ç¬+¸u¥®­;¤e«U´�¼�´�«<©3Â(¹�¤¨ªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�ª/©G¥|´¶¬�¼�¬�µO¤ ° � ¬+¸e«<© �O´�«?©GÂ�³¨¬�¤ !ë³J´¶¤J¼�¥ �p¸k¬ ° o�� � ª¨ùW³¨­a¥®­�©G¥U � � Ò ï À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ íS*-Hk032T8D,/>@H !?,/57H/*�Ae,k03.1,'Z;.90GA�57>O*�X �

�%�;� � �G��s���9��& �ã&O��$%$����s���±������ �h � o���� �( ���((���±���� ��$

Y B;Hº:O>L03. >O6�A4B;512�24H','A�51>O*"572eA�>?:O5VKLH#0aCW0GE4A45903.�,/.903242T57Ï�,k0GA�57>O*"6�>3E�A�B;Hº,'>O*�A4E�03,'A�51>O*;2 R � 51*�A�B;HºB�Z;*LAkXÌ HMÏ;E�2TAu,/>O*;2451^;HJEe]�57E�0GA�51>O*�03.�,/>O*LA4E[03,'A451>O*;2/N Ë ðOðOXæÅ�Ø�. Õ N;03*;^�A�B;H/* É�Ê Ø¶Ï;];E�0GA�51>O*;2R51* Ë ðOðOX � Õ X�W���7� % ���%���%����� � K J ���(�����Wÿ3�%�»����¡3�

� Z�E�=_0357*�>3]�FIH/,'A457KLHM512u0a.1>s,k03.�03*�03.78sA�51,ã,/.103242457Ï�,/0GA�51>O*�>O6 A�B;HMC(>O24245V]�51.757A�57H/2u6�>3E

R � ~ Ë � � � � ä�Þ � ÕcÒ±Ó Ë ' � � Ê � Þ � � Ê Õ

6�>3EUA�B;HDÏ;E42TAaAwbc>ÐB�Z;*�A<2TA�H'C�2/N �ºß ðON¿ó@X $c8m.7>@,k03.\03*�03.V8@A�57,3N�bcHD=?Hk03*j.1>@,/03.1.78Í03*�03.78@A451,k03.7.78Í0G]±>OZ�A� ��� Ê � ' � � Ê XíS2�24Z;,[Ba0M,/.10324245VÏ�,k0GA�51>O*#bu51.7.s](H\Z;24H'6�Z;.�0GAy>3A�B;H'E�C(>O57*�A42å57*#A�B;HcCW0GC(H'EkN3bvH\bu51.7.sbc>3ETQ#51*#A�B;HR0G]�2TA4E�03,'A

Ë >OZ�A�2T51^;HãA�B;HP,/>O*LA�H �@Ae>O6 A�B;HÔB�Z;*LA Õ XAQA À � À A �q¤ 2 �Ôªk¬G«?¤\¼(¬�¥w©G¥®´½¬�¼±À¿£ ¤J¥ RÔ~ �çÒ�Ó '�§¨¤R© ¯±° ¬ ¯ ¤ ° §'´ ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼±©3Â;³[¬�¼W¥ ° ©�³J¥|´¶¬�¼D¬+¸\© o�� ú4¤��O¥ ° ¤'«<©G° ©3·OÀ � ¼ ¯ © ° ¥|´¶³Jù@Â7© ° � Ë � � 'åÕ ß ð À�£ ¤J¥ ¹�¤J¼�¬�¥w¤º¥»­�¤U¤��@³¨¤ ¯ ¥|´¶¬�¼±©GÂ�¹G´�µ�´�ª�¬ ° ¬+¸ R ,¿ûy­�´¶³¨­-´�ª#©_Ò ð ú4³'ù ° µ3¤kÀ£ ¤'¥ � §J¤e¥®­;¤�´»«<©�È�¤Ô¬+¸ À �q¤uûy´�Â�Â�¬�¼� ·a§¨¤Ô³[¬�¼(³¨¤ ° ¼(¤[¹Pûy´�¥®­<¥®­;¤�Â1¬�³�©GÂ�©G¼±©G ·G¥®´½³M¹�¤Jªk³ ° ´ ¯ ¥®´½¬�¼-¬+¸ � ©L§J¬�ùs¥ ,奮­�ùsª Î�� ' ´�ªº¬�¼� ·`©G¼¾©3¼±©G ·G¥®´¶³ãªJù ° ¸/©�³[¤�È�¤ ° «<À\£ ¤J¥ � Ü �Ö§¨¤º©�³Jù ° µ3¤Mûy´�¥®­`ª¨«_¬�¬�¥®­�³[¬�« ¯ ¬G¼(¤J¼�¥®ª³ ° ¬%ª[ª¨´�¼�ÈÔ¼(¬ ° «?©GÂ� ·OÀ �q¤S©�ª[ªJùs«?¤ � ­�©�ª�©G¥�«?¬�ª¨¥�¥®ûv¬º´ °¨° ¤�¹GùW³J´|§'Â1¤M³[¬�« ¯ ¬G¼(¤J¼�¥®ªå¦�� T � Tà´�ª�©GÂ�Â1¬�ûv¤[¹#¥+¬§¨¤º¤J« ¯ ¥®· � À �q¤Ô©�ª[ª¨ù@«?¤ o��gä � ¦ ä�� T ´�ª R úw¥ ° ´�µ�´|©3Â(©G¼±¹ �cùsª[­ ,�ûy´�¥®­ Å!� � � �!�éð À Á ­�ù�ªP§/· � � À � À � � ,o��Dä ¦ ä T ´�ªMÂ1¬�È?¥+¤ ° «g´�¼±©GÂ7À � ¼ ¯ © ° ¥|´¶³Jù@Â7© ° ¦ ©G¼±¹ETì³�©G¼�¼�¬�¥v«?¤[¤J¥\©G¥R©G¼�·<ª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© °c¯ ¬G´�¼�¥R¬+¸��gÀ

�q¤c©�ª¨ª¨ùs«_¤ Rcl � ´�ª 2å¼�´�¥+¤ �½¥®­�©G¥(´�ª ´�ª�¼(¬�¥�©Ô³[¬G« ¯ ¬�¼(¤'¼�¥ ¬+¸ � � À Á ­�ùsªc§'·�� � À �sÀ A À B � , o��(ä � ¦ ä � T´�ª �cù�ª[­;À �q¤Ô©Gª[ª¨ù@«?¤c¦ ©G¼(¹ T ­�©GµO¤M©G¼(©G ·�¥|´¶³�©3Â� ·U´ °J° ¤�¹GùW³J´|§/Â1¤�´�«?©�È�¤¨ªÔ©G¥ � ,¿©G¼±¹g¥»­sù�ªP¤�©�³J­ �w´�ªM¤'´�¥»­�¤ °¤J« ¯ ¥®·�¬ ° � «?¤[¤'¥»ª ©G¥R¤��s©�³'¥®Â ·-¬�¼�¤ ¯ ¬�´�¼W¥½À

Page 76: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

2 � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

£ ¤'¥ Þ Ü 'ݧJ¤Ô¥»­�¤P´�«<©%È�¤ �½ûy´»¥»­ ° ¤�¹GùW³[¤�¹aªJ¥ ° ù�³J¥|ù ° ¤ � ¬+¸ �àÀ�e¥¿©?³¨­�©3´�¼DªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´»¥®· Ë � Ê � � � � � � �

ÕÔ© ¯(° ´�«?¤ � ° ¤¨ª ¯ ÀRù@¼±¹�¤ °  ´�¼(¤ � ´�¼(¹G´¶³�©G¥+¤¨ªR¼�¬ ° «<©3Â�³¨¬�¼�¥w©�³J¥�ûy´�¥®­ � ° ¤¨ª ¯ À � � À �#¬�¥+¤Ô¥®­�´�ªM´�ªM¥»­�¤Mª/©G«?¤º¼(¬�¥w©G¥|´¶¬�¼qûv¤ºù�ª�¤P´�¼q¥®­;¤M­sùs¼�¥�,�ª�¤[¤ � � À B@À A�� � À�q¤uÂ1¤J¥ �c~ �� Ò±Ó �'駨¤e¥®­;¤S´�¼±¹GùW³[¤�¹º«<© ¯ §¨¤J¥|ûv¤[¤J¼�¥»­;¤S«g´�¼W´�«<©GÂ�¹�¤¨ª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�ª/©3¥®´¶¬G¼;ª5,�©<³[¬�« ¯ ¬�ª¨´�¥|´¶¬�¼

¬+¸ãªJ«?¬�¬�¥®­"§'Â1¬Gû�ù ¯ ª/ÀÌ Hgbe57.1.å03.12T>-Z;24H<A4B;H<2T8@=g]±>O.12 ¦ N T A�>-57*;^;51,k0GA�HUA�B;H<57=_03:OH/2ã>O6¿A�B;H'24H<,/Z�ETKLH/2º>O* ' X Y B;512M512Ô51*

QLH/H'C�57*;:<bu57A�B�>OZ�Ee,/>O*LKLH/*�A451>O*">O6�>s,/,k032457>O*�03.1.78DZ;2457*;:<A�B;HÔ2�03=?HM2T8�=#](>O.�A�>a^;H/*;>3A�H#0a^;57K�5724>3EkNW03*;^�5VA�22TA4E451,'ARA4E[03*;246�>3E4= Z;*;^;H'E�0U]�5VE[0GA�51>O*�03.�=?0GC�XY B;HÔ2TA�0GE4A�51*;:UC(>O57*�Au6�>3E�>OZ�Eu,/.9032T2457Ï�,k0GA451>O*-572RA4B;HP6�>O.1.7>%bu51*;:a2451=aC�.1Hã>3]�24H'E4KG0GA�57>O*�~

�W���7��� 5 �¿�@�Í����� Á ­�¤#³[¤J¼�¥ ° ¤#¬+¸º¤[©�³¨­�§'Â1¬�û ù ¯ ¬+¸ �  ´½¤¨ªº¬�¼"¥®­;¤#¤��@³[¤ ¯ ¥®´½¬�¼±©GÂ�¹G´�µ%´�ªk¬ ° ¬+¸ã¥®­;¤ ¯±° ¤Jµ�´¶¬�ùsª§'Â1¬�ûëù ¯ À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ � 572uA�B;HM>O*;.78 Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�ETKLHP.78@51*;:a>%KLH'E � X �Ì H`,/.103242451698m,'>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�51>O*;2#]�8m,/>O*;2457^;H'E�51*;:ÐC(>O242T57]�51.757A�57H/2#6�>3EUA�B;H`24H/r@Z;H'*;,/H�>O6R]�.1>�bÚZ�C�2 �(X Ì H

A�B;57*�Q�>O6 Ë �=� �ÝÕ 032R]±H/51*;:<>3];A[0351*;H/^�69E�>O= Ë '�� Þ Õ ]�8DA�B;HÔ2TH/r@Z;H/*;,'Hº>O6 ]�.7>%b Z�C�2 �±XÌ H?*;>3A4H?*;H ��A#A4B�0GA Ë Z;*;^;H'EU24>O=<H<=?57.1^�,/>O*;^;5VA�51>O*;2 Õ A�B;H?,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LA�2 � N �q^;>"*;>3A#^;H/,'E4Hk0324H_be5VA�B

03^;^;57A451>O*�03.(]�.1>�b Z�C�2/~�W���7����( �¿�@�Í����� � ¸ Ë � 8 ��¦ 8 � T 8 � 8 ÕU´�ª<¬O§'¥w©G´�¼(¤�¹S¸ ° ¬�« Ë � ��¦�� T � Õg§'·ã¸¨ù ° ¥®­;¤ ° §/Â1¬�ûéù ¯ ª5,\¥»­�©3¥\´�ª#´Ç¸� 8 ~ �� 8 Ò�Ó �'m¸k©�³J¥+¬ ° ªã¥®­ ° ¬GùOÈ�­ �v~ ��çÒ�Ó �'�¥®­;¤J¼

Ë � 8 ¦ ä � 8 TgÕ�� - Ë � ¦ ä � T#Õ�� � ¼ ¯ © ° ¥®´½³JùsÂ7© ° ´Ç¸ � ß � ©G¼(¹ � 8 ß � 8 ,\¬ ° � 8 � � ,�¥»­�¤J¼ � 8 - � À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ #�H'A Ñ ]±H#A�B;Ha57*;^;Z;,/H/^�=?0GC �� 8 Ò�Ó �� X #�H'A\Î�N;Î 8 ]±HgA4B;Ha=?57*;51=_03. ^;H/2457*;:OZ;.90GE�572�0GA�51>O*Ð=_0GC�2/X�S>3A�HãA�B�0GA

Î�" Ñ "wÎ 8 " Ë o�� �@ä �-8 ¦ 8 ä � 8 T 8 Õ ßto��`ä �-8 ¦ ä � 8 T ä�� 6�>3Eu24>O=?H � - Å�NW03*;^�A4B�0GAuA�B;HP0G](>�KLHÔ^;5VK�5724>3Ee572RC�Z;.7.1H/^�]W03,[QD69E�>O= ' N�03*;^DA�B�Z;2e512 A4E�5VK�5903.®X�öSH/*;,/H

Ë � 8 ¦ ä � 8 TgÕ9� ß Ò � � Ò o�� � ß Ò � � ä Ë � ¦ ä � T#Õ�� �

íS2 B�032e*;H/:L0GA�5VKLHÔ2TH/.161ض51*LA�H'E�24H','A�51>O*�NWA�B;HãE�H/24Z;.VA�6�>O.1.7>%bu2/X �Ì B;H/*"ÞÄ512�2T=?>@>3A�B-0GA � NWA�B;H'*"o��Uä�ÞÄ572e.7>O:<A�H'E�=<51*�03.�0GA � N�]�8 Ë :�XæÅ�X . Õ X Ì HPbu51.1.�,/>O*;2T51^;H'ESA�B;572

,k0324Hu51* Ë ðOðOX . Õ X +@Z�C;C(>O24HuÞÚ512å2451*;:OZ;.10GEv0GA � X@$v8 Ë :�XæÅ�X . Õ N ' 572�2T=?>@>3A�B�X # H'A �#]±HuA�B;HR.1>s,k03.�0GE�57A4B;=?H'A�57,:OH/*�Z;2`>O6MÞ"X Ì H�Ï;E�2TA`,/.103242451698�A�B;>O24H"Þ be5VA�B 0Í^;>OZ�]�.1H�C±>O51*LAkN Ë ðOðOX1ð'Ø+ó Õ XtöS51:OB;HJE_=gZ;.7A�5VC�.151,'57Aw8�572,/>O*;2457^;H'E�H/^-51* Ë ðOðOXpï Õ X ã>OZ�]�.1HãC(>O57*�A42R6�>3Eu,/Z�E4KLH'2u>O*-0U24=<>@>3A�B`24Z�E�6�03,'HP:OH'E�=×0GE�Hã,/.10324245VÏ�H/^�51*`)4)¨X :g>O6î .3ñ|X Y B;H'E4Hº0GE�HMA+bv>aC(>O2T2457]�57.157A451H/2/N�03*;^�bcHP,/>O*;2T51^;H'EeHk03,[B�51*DA�Z�E�*�X

Page 77: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � 2 2

�W���»� Þ � �W¡U�J�#�Í¡k�������%�ëü��%�W��ÿG� ��¡g��� � �

)+*ÐA4B;512M,k0324H3N�Þ B�032ãbuB�0GAP572M,/03.1.1H'^�03* � � �ض2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8LX ¦ Ü ' 03*;^ T Ü ' 0GE4HU]±>3A�B¾24=<>@>3A�B�N

03*;^"=?H/HJAeA�>?>3E4^;H'E ��0GA � X Ì Hº,k03.7.�A�B;572�0 � ��� �Ð�WþS�W�G� �s� � � � >O*;2451^;HJE �c~ ��ÝÒWÓ ' Xv)+6 � - ó@NWbcH=gZ;2TAvÏ;E�2IAc]�.1>�btZ�C`E�H'C±Hk0GA�H/^;.V8_0GA ¦ � T Z;*LA�57. ¦ 03*;^ T ,'E�>O242c*;>3E�=?03.1.78LN�6�>3Ec>3A�B;HJE4be5724HSo ä � bu51.1.*;>3AR](HM.7AkX Ì HM,k03.1.(A4B;512 ÿO�±��9�ý±� �%�;�%�»��� Å � öSH'E�H ¦ 03*;^ T =?H/HJAu*;>3E4=_03.1.V8_0GAe0U24=<>@>3A�B`C(>O57*�AR>O6 �03.1>O*;: X ,/>O*LA[0357*;2�0aZ;*;57r@Z;HM2451*;:OZ;.10GEuC±>O51*LAkN Ë ó 8 � � � � � ó Õ ß �

� � �Ë 03*;^ � - ó Õ X � .1H/0GE�.78 � ä �ºß ðOX

D ¤J«<© °GF À �S>3A�HeA4B�0GAc51*?A�B;572v,k0324H � 512v2T51*;:OZ;.90GE/N@24>#,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E�0GA�51>O*Dź,k03*;*;>3Ac>s,/,/Z�E\6�>3E � ß � Ê >O6�A�B;HB�Z;*�AkN�bu57A�B � ß U Ê N�2451*;,/H�U Ê 512e2T=?>@>3A�B�X

)+6WA4B;H'E�HR512å0S6�Z�E4A�B;H'E�]�.1>�bâZ�C<5VAå=UZ;2IA�](Hu0GA ¦ � T NL>3Eå>3A�B;H'ETbe5724H ¦ 03*;^ T bu51.7.�=?H/H'A�0GAå0ã2451*;:OZ;.10GEC(>O57*�A\>O6 � X Ì HM,/03.1.±A�B;572 ÿO�±��9�ý±� �%�;�%�»��� �� öSH'E�H ¦ 03*;^ T Hk03,[BD=?H/H'A 0GAR0#24=?>@>3A4B?C(>O51*LAkN@A4B;H'E�H512R>O*;HP2T51*;:OZ;.90GERC(>O57*�A Ë ó 8 � ó � � � �-� ó Õ ß �

� � Ê 03*;^�>O*;,/HÔ03:L0351* � ä �gßÝðOX

� >O*;2451^;H'EeA�B;H#*;H ��Ae]�.1>�bÝZ�C�Xe)wAS=gZ;2TAe](Hg0GAeA4B;HºC(>O51*LA�buB;H'E�H =?H/H'A42�H/57A4B;H'E ¦ >3E T N(6�>3ES576�bcH]�.1>�béZ�C-0GAu03*�8_>3A4B;H'EuC±>O51*LAkN@A�B;H'* ¦ 03*;^ T be57.1.(=<H/H'AR0GAR0g2451*;:OZ;.10GERC±>O51*LA\>O6 � X@+sbe5VA�,[B;51*;: ¦ 03*;^T 576�*;H/,/H'242�0GE48LN;bcHÔ=_0�8D032T24Z;=?HãA�B;HP*;H �@Au]�.7>%bçZ�C�512u0GAuA�B;HãC(>O57*�Ae>O6 ¦ X

Ì H#,k03.7. A�B;572 ÿL����9�ý�� �%�;�%�»��������� öSH'E4HºA�B;H'E�Hg512M0_Z;*;51rsZ;H#2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8LN ��03.1>O*;: N ¦ =?H/H'A�2

0GAã0_24=?>s>3A�B-C±>O51*LAkX � * �� N T 03*;^ 0GE�H#^;572»FI>O51*LAkN±]�Z�AM=?H/HJA�A�B;H#2�03=?H Ò ó%ض,/Z�E4KLHg>O6�A�B;H ��,[B�0357*�N

03*-H'*;^">O6 A�B;HÔ,¨B�0357*�X Y B;H ��C(>O51*LAuB�032uAw8@C±H Ë ó 8 � � � � � ó Õ X � *;HP,'>O=<C�Z�A�H/2 � �eä Ë �Mätð Õ � ß �MätðOX

�S>�b 0GAPHJKLH'E48Ð6�Z�E4A�B;H'EP2TA�H'C¾A�B;H'E�H<0GE�HUAwbc>DC(>O242T57]�.1HgC(>O57*�A42ÔbcHU,/>OZ;.1^i]�.1>�b Z�C�N H/5VA�B;H'EÔA�B;HUC±>O51*LA� � Ü �� .78@51*;:?>�KLH'E � ¦ � � N±>3EuA�B;HPC(>O57*�A � � Ü �� .78�57*;:?>�KLH'E � T � � Ë 516 bcHº]�.7>%b Z�C0GAe03*�8�>3A�B;H'ERC(>O57*�AkN�A�B;H/* ¦ 03*;^ T bu51.7.�=?H/H'Ae0GA�0U2451*;:OZ;.10GEeC±>O51*LAe>O6 ��Õ X Ì HÔ,/03.1.�A�B;H/24HÔA�B;HÔC±>O51*LA�2� �s�W�%��¡'�Ô¦ 03*;^ T E4H/2TC(H','A�57KLH'.78LX Ì HP51*;^;51,/0GA�HÔA�B;HÔ24H/rsZ;H/*;,/H#>O6 ]�.7>%b Z�C�2�]�8�0<2IA4E�51*;:a>O6 �±2e03*;^ � 2/X,W>3EgH ��03=<C�.7H Ë ��� � � � � � �;Õ =?Hk03*;2PA4B;HD,'>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�51>O*m>3];A[0357*;H/^j69E�>O= ��� ]�8Í]�.1>�be57*;:"Z�C�Awbu51,/H`0GA �03*;^�>O*;,/HP0GA � X

+@Z�C;C(>O2TH � - ó@X �S>3A4HºA�B�0GAS516å03*L8�>O6�A�B;Hº]�.7>%b�Z�C�2ã512ã0GA�A�B;HºC±>O51*LAS*;Hk0GE�H'2TA ¦ NWA�B;H/*qo���ä T 572*;>3AM.1>O:_A�H'E4=?51*�03.®X Y BsZ;2Ô6�>3E � - ó?A�B;Hg>O*;.78�C±>O24245V]�51.15VA�51H'2Ô0GE4H Ë ����� � � � � �5� ��Õ N±buB;51,[BibcHU51*;^;57,k0GA�H#]�8Ë ��� � � � Õ N;beB;HJE�H $ 572RA�B;HÔ*sZ;=#]±H'Ee>O6 � $ 57*�A�B;HÔ2TA4E�57*;:;X

,�51:OZ�E4H � :O57KLH/2u0UC�57,'A�Z�E�HÔ>O6 24>O=?HãC(>O2T2457]�.7HP,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA451>O*;2/~

Page 78: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

2 � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

II

-1

-2

-2

-2 Σ

−3−1 −2

ΣΣ−3

−2 −1

−2

−2

−1

Σ

-2

I

g-1

gY

XY

X

YX

YX

II IIx y

yx

,�57:OZ�E�H �

AQA À A À ��D ¤J«?© ° F À Y B;Hã0G](>�KLHS,/.103242457Ï�,/0GA�51>O*`>O6�,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA451>O*;2 Ë 51:O*;>3E451*;:ºA�B;HeKG03.1Z;H'2 � 03*;^ � Õ E4H/r@Z;5VE�H/2>O*;.78PA�B;HR032424Z;=<C;A�57>O*UA4B�0GAyo���ä ¦ ä T 572y.7A Ë A�B�0GAy572y57AyB;>O.1^;2�bu57A�B;>OZ�Aå032T24Z;=?51*;:MH/5VA�B;H'Eåoëä � ¦ ä � T512 /�Z;2TB�NW>3E R�Ø|A4E�5VK�5903. Õ Ns032vA�B;512\512\03.7.�bcHSB�0kKLHãZ;24H/^`A�>#A�B;512vC±>O51*LAkX �S2451*;:#A�B;HM03^;^;5VA�51>O*�03.±032424Z;=<C;A�57>O*;2bcHÔ,k03*-6�Z�E4A4B;H'E�E�H/2IA4E�51,JAuA�B;HMC(>O242T57]�51.757A�57H/2/~�W���»���»� �¿���Í����� .Wù ¯�¯ ¬%ªk¤ Þ ­�©�ª#©?¼(¬k¹�¤g¬I¸g¬ ° ¹�¤ ° � À�c¼(¤U¬+¸Ô¥®­;¤å¸k¬GÂ�Â1¬�ûy´�¼@È?­;¬�Â7¹�ª��Ë ð Õ �Ú­�©�ªM¥|· ¯ ¤ � ¬ ° � ,c©G¼±¹ � ä �ºßÝð ,R¬ °Ë ó Õ � - ó , �Ú­�©�ªM¥|· ¯ ¤ � � ,R©G¼±¹ � �eä Ë �Mä�ð Õ � ß Ë �Mäëð Õ0,R¬ °

Page 79: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � 2&0

�aßÝð , o��`ä ä ¦ ä T ´�ªãÂ1¬[È�³�©G¼�¬�¼�´¶³�©3 ©G¼±¹�¤'´�¥»­�¤ °Ë ï Õ � ­;©�ª`¥®· ¯ ¤ Ë ����� � � � Ê Õ-,Pûå´�¥»­ = - ð �p¸k¬ ° =¾ß ð ¥®­�´�ª`«_¤�©G¼;ª�³[¬G¼�2�ÈGù ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼ ��� � ¥®­;¤ ° ¤D´�ª-©

ù@¼�´|ø'ùW¤PªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´»¥®· ,\©G¼ ��� ¯ ¬�´»¼�¥ ,R¬�¼ , ¦ «?¤[¤J¥®ª ©G¥u©?ª¨«?¬�¬�¥®­ ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥�, T «?¤[¤J¥®ª ©G¥v¥®­;¤��� ¯ ¬�´�¼W¥ ,�ûy­�´¶³¨­`­;©�ªM¥|· ¯ ¤ Ë ó � � � �-� ó 8 Õ-,c©3¼±¹ � ä �� � Ê ßÝð ,R¬ °

Ë . Õ «?¤[¤'¥»ªv¦ ©G¼±¹ T ¤�©�³¨­�©G¥¿©UªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© °�¯ ¬�´»¼�¥v¬+¸ � ,v©G¼(¹g¥®­;¬%ª�¤Ô© ° ¤ã¥»­�¤P¬G¼� ·U¥|ûv¬#ª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ª©GÂ1¬�¼�È À

� ¬ ° ¤¨¬�µ3¤ °Ë�� Õ

� Ë � ä � Ò ð Õ �â=?57* Ë � � � Õ � �ó � Ò ð �

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ #�H'A2U ]±HvA�B;H Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLH\>O6�,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*#)JX � *;H\,/>O=aC�Z�A�H/2 � Ë U � o ä � ¦ ä � TºÕ ß � Ë � ä � Ò ð Õ XË�� Õ A�B;H/*�6�>O.1.1>�bu2e69E�>O=àA�B;H /�Z;24B�,/>O*;^;5VA�51>O*�XY B;HÔH/rsZ�03.15VA�51H/2R51*DA�B;HP.7H/=?=_0g0GE�HÔ03*-H/032T8-,'>O=<C�Z�A[0GA�57>O*�X+@Z�C;C(>O2TH�� - ó@X )I*a,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*;2 Ë ����� � � Õ N T B�032y2TC(H','A4E[03.�KG03.1Z;HR0GAy.1H/032TAyA+bv>;Ns03*;^U24> � � � - ó �3ï�N

]�8 Ë :�XpÅ�X � Xpó Õ N@buB;51,[B�,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�2 Ë�� Õ XY B;HME�H'2TA�572uHk032I8LX �

�W��� 5 Þ � �W¡a��������ü����W��ÿ��â� ��� ü K�� �����®�(�a�;� � �Ì HD^;H/24,'E457](HDA�B;512a032a0 � � � ����� �@�jÿL��¡��v� )+*jA�B;512U,k0324H T 572aH/=aC;A+8j03*;^ � ß ¦ X Ì H�03:L0357*

,/>O*;2457^;H'E��±X Y B;HPÏ;E�2IAS24H'E�57H/2�>O6�]�.7>%b Z�C�2S=gZ;2TAeE4H/=?>�KLHÔA�B;HÔ2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8�>O6�Þ Ë 2451*;,'Hºo��Dä ¦ 512�.7>O:A�H'E4=?51*�03. Õ X Ì Hã,k03.7.�A�B;572 ÿL����9�ý�� �%�;�%�»��� �� öSH'E�H B�032c>O*;HS2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8LN Ë ó 8 � � � �-� ó Õ ß �

� � Ê N;03*;^ ¦512R2457=<C�.78_A[03*;:OH'*�AuA�> 0GAe0a2T=?>@>3A�B`C(>O57*�A/XY B;HÐ*;HG��A_]�.1>�bÄZ�Cë=gZ;2TA_](HÐ0GA ¦ � X � 03.7.eA�B;512 ÿO����9�ý�� �%���%����� �� öSH'E�H"A�B;H'E�Hq572`03* �

�2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8`>O6 A+8sC(H Ë ó 8 � ó � � � � ó Õ XY B;Hv*;H ��A ]�.1>�bjZ�Ca572�03:L0357*#03.1>O*;: ¦ X � 03.7.�A�B;572 ÿO����9�ý�� ���;�%���±� G� Y B;H/* B�032 Awbc>�2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457A�57H/2

Ë �� � Ê � ï 89Õ 03*;^-03* � Ê C(>O57*�A/N;03*;^ ¦ =?H/H'A42 0GAR0U2T=?>@>3A�B?C±>O51*LAkX�# H'A ��N WN � ]±HSA�B;HSC(>O51*LA�2cbuB;H'E�H

=?H'H'A�2�A�B;H Ò ï�ض,/Z�E4KLH3N ¦ N�03*;^qA�B;H Ò ó%ؽ,'Z�E4KLH3X Y B;Hg*;H ��Aã]�.1>�b Z�Ci512M0GAM>O*;Hg>O6åA�B;H'24HUC±>O51*LA�2/N�03*;^bcHÔ,k03.1.(A�B;HME�H/24Z;.VA�51*;:a,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*;2���N `03*;^ � X)+* ��A�B;HJE�Hº0GE�HMAwbc><2457*;:OZ;.90GERC(>O57*�Ae03.1>O*;: N Ë �

� � Ê � . 8 Õ 03*;^Ë ó 8 � ó Õ X

)+* DA4B;H'E�Hg512S0?2T51*;:O.1HP2451*;:OZ;.10GESC(>O51*LA Ë �� � Ê � ï � ó 8 � ó Õ 03.1>O*;:

N�03*;^ � ¦ 512S0?2T=?>@>3A�B�C(>O51*LAã>O6� X)+* � A�B;H'E�HP0GE�HãA+bv>?2451*;:OZ;.10GEuC±>O51*LA�03.7>O*;: N Ë �

� � Ê � ï � ó 8 Õ 03*;^Ë ï 8 Õ X

$cH'8L>O*;^`A�B;H/24HãA�B;H'E�HM0GE�HSAwbc>gC(>O242T57]�.1HãC(>O57*�A42\A4>g]�.7>%b Z�C�X Ì Hã51*;^;57,k0GA�HS]�8D0U2TATE�51*;:U>O6 � $ 03*;^ Ñ $buB;H'A�B;H'EubcHM]�.7>%bçZ�C�0GAuA4B;HMC±>O51*LAe*;Hk0GE4H/2TAkN�>3Eu6�0GE4A�B;H/2TAu69E�>O= ¦ Ë A�B�0GAe572R0GA�0#C(>O57*�Au>O6 �� .V8�51*;:U>�KLH'E¦ � Ü � N�>3Ee0UC±>O51*LAe>O6 *;>3Au.78@51*;:U>%KLHJE ¦ Ü ��Õ X

Page 80: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� + ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

,�51:OZ�E4HPõU:O57KLH/2u0UC�57,'A�Z�E�HÔ>O6 24>O=?HãC(>O2T2457]�.7HP,/>O*LA4E[03,'A451>O*;2/~

u-2

I

Σ-2

-2

-1-1

-2 -2 -2

g-1

-2-2

-3

u

w

v-1

-2

IIII

I

-2

-2-4

-1

-2

-2

g-1

g-1

Σ

-2

-3-2

-2

-1

g-1

Σ

-2-3

-2-2

-1

-3

g-1

Σ

vw

ΣX

XX

XX

X

,�57:OZ�E�HÔõ

AQA À B@À �)D ¤J«?© ° F À Y B;Hg0G](>�KLH#,/.103242457Ï�,/0GA�51>O*"E�H/rsZ;57E�H'2S>O*;.78-A4B;Hg032424Z;=<C;A�57>O*"A�B�0GASo���ä ¦ 572�.7A Ë A4B�0GA512u57AeB;>O.1^;2ebu57A�B;>OZ�A�032424Z;=?57*;:<H/5VA�B;H'ESo×ä � ¦ 512 /�Z;24B�N±>3E R�Ø|A4E�5VK�5903. Õ N�032uA4B;512�572�03.1.�bcHPB�0�KLHºZ;2TH/^�A�>A�B;572RC±>O51*LAkX �S2T51*;:aA4B;Hº03^;^;57A451>O*�03.�032424Z;=aC;A�51>O*;2\bcHP,/03*�6�Z�E4A�B;H'EuE�H/2TATE�51,'ARA�B;HMC(>O24245V]�51.757A�57H/2/~�W��� 5(�»� �¿���Í����� .Wù ¯�¯ ¬%ªk¤ Þ ­�©�ª#©�³Jù�ª ¯ ¬+¸#¬ ° ¹�¤ ° � À Á ­;¤J¼ ,\¤'´�¥»­�¤ °

Ë ð Õ �Ú­�©�ªM¥|· ¯ ¤ � ,c©G¼±¹ � ß�ð��Oó ,c¬ °Ë ó Õ �Ú­�©�ªM¥|· ¯ ¤ � � ,R©G¼±¹ � ß Ë �Mätð Õ � Ë ó �ãäëð Õ0,R¬ °Ë ï Õ �Ú­�©�ªM¥|· ¯ ¤ � � � ,\©G¼(¹ � ß Ë �ãätð Õ � Ë ó �Sätð Õ-,\¬ °

Page 81: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � � .

Ë . Õ �aßÝð , �Ú­�©�ªM¥|· ¯ ¤ � ©3¼±¹ � ßéï �'. ¬ ° �aßéó ©G¼±¹ � ß # �@ð�. ,\¬ °Ë�� Õ �aßÝð , �Ú­�©�ªM¥|· ¯ ¤ ©3¼±¹ � ß � � � ¬ ° �aßéó ©G¼±¹ � ß � �@ðOð ,c¬ °Ë õ Õ �aßÝð , �Ú­�©�ªM¥|· ¯ ¤�� ©G¼±¹ � ß � � # ,c¬ °Ë � Õ �aßÝð , �Ú­�©�ªM¥|· ¯ ¤ Ë � / � Õ#©G¼±¹ � ßÝðOð��@ð�. ,c¬ °Ë : Õ �aßÝð , �Ú­�©�ªM¥|· ¯ ¤ Ë / Ñ Õº©G¼±¹ � ßÝð�Å �@ð�ï ,c¬ °Ë # Õ �aßÝð , �Ú­�©�ªM¥|· ¯ ¤ Ë / Ñ �'Õg©G¼±¹ � ßÝð � �@ð # ,R¬ °Ë ð�Å Õ �aßÝð , �Ú­�©�ªM¥|· ¯ ¤ Ë / � Õ#©G¼±¹ � ß ï �'. ,\¬ °Ë ðOð Õ �aßÝð , �Ú­�©�ªM¥|· ¯ ¤ Ë / � �'Õg©G¼±¹ � ß � � # À

� ¬ ° ¤¨¬�µ3¤ °Ë ð%ó Õ � � �� � � ÊË ð�ï Õ � ¸ �aßÝð , � � . � � À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Y B;HD2TA[0GA�H/^jK303.7Z;H/2U>O6 � 0GE�HDH/.1H'=?H/*LA[0GE48Í,k03.7,/Z;.90GA451>O*;2/X Y BsZ;2U516RbcHDB�0�KLH`Aw8@C(H_)¨N�)4)#>3Eg)4)T)JNA�B;H/*DbcHPB�0kKLHãA�B;HÔH'r@Z�03.15VA�51H'2R>O6 Ë ð Õ Ø Ë ï Õ X2# HJA U ](HMA�B;H Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLHP>O6 ,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*�)¨X � *;HP,/>O=<C�Z�A4H/2� Ë U � oÖä � ¦iÕ ß � Ë ó � Ò ð Õ N�24> Ë ð%ó Õ 6�>O.7.1>�be2�69E4>O= A�B;H /�Z;24BÐ,/>O*;^;57A451>O*�X Ë ð�ï Õ 6�>O.1.7>%bu2e]�8",/>O=<C�Z�A�57*;:A�B;HÔ,/>@H�!<,/51H'*�Ae>O6 A�B;H Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLHP>O6 ,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O* ����� X

+@Z�C;C(>O2THDbcHDB�0kKLHDAw8@C±H�� XÐ)I6�� - ï�NyA�B;H/*�bvHDB�0kKLH�0Ð2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8m0GAU.1Hk032TA Ë . � ó � ó Õ beB;57,¨B�B�032,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LAPï � � N(buB;51,[Bi,/>O*�ATE[03^;51,'A42 Ë ð%ó Õ X ,�Z�E4A4B;H'EÔ]�.7>%bÝZ�C�2P0GE4HU>O6å6�>3E�= Ë � / � � Õ Ë >3Eão ä ¦ 512ã*;>3A.7A Õ Xå)+6 � - ó@N;A�B;H'*-bcHPB�0kKLH#0U2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8�0GAe.7Hk032TA Ë ó � . � ó Õ buB;51,[B�B�032e,'>@H�!<,/51H/*LAMó �3ï�Xy)+6 �aß�ðº03*;^= - ógbcHM:OH'Ae0a2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8�>O6 2TC(H','A4E[03.�K303.7Z;HÔ6�>OZ�E/N�57=<C(>O242T57]�.1HGN�]s8 Ë ð�ï Õ N�03*;^ Ë :�XpÅ�X � X ó Õ X

+@Z�C;C(>O2TH�bcHDB�0�KLHDAw8@C(H � XÍ)+6 � - ó@NyA�B;H/* U B�032<0Ð2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8m>O6u2TC(H/,JA4E[03.cK303.7Z;H-0GAa.1H/032TA_ó@N51=aC(>O24245V]�.1H`]s8 Ë ð%ó Õ X-,WZ�E4A�B;H'E?]�.7>%bÖZ�C�2?0GE�H->O6eA4B;H-6�>3E�= Ë � / � � Õ X Y B;H/* ¦ B�032<0¾2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8j>O62TC±H/,'A4E[03.�KG03.1Z;HP0GAe.7Hk032TAu6�>OZ�EkN;K�51>O.10GA�51*;: Ë ð�ï Õ X

+@Z�C;C(>O2THºbcH#B�0�KLHÔA+8sC(H WX\)I6 � - ï<A4B;H/*"bcHºB�0kKLHg0?2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8-0GA�.1H/032TA Ë ó � ó � ï � ó � ó Õ buB;51,[BqB�032,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LAãï � � N�,'>O*�A4E�03^;51,'A�57*;: Ë ð%ó Õ X ,W>3E Ë / � Õ >3E Ë / Ñ Õ >3Ee](H'8L>O*;^�N�516 � - óaA4B;H/*�A�B;H'E�HP512S0aC±>O51*LA>O6å,/>@H�!<,/51H'*�AÔ0GAã.1H/032TAPó �3ï�N�,/>O*�ATE[03^;51,'A451*;: Ë ð%ó Õ X +@>��DßàðOX � Ë / Ñ Õ ßÚð�Å �@ð�ï�X � Ë / Ñ �'Õ ßÚð � �@ð # XM)+*Ë / Ñ � � Õ N Ë / Ñ � � � Õ N Ë / Ñ � Õ N Ë / � � Ñ Õ N Ë / � � � Ñ Õ N(>3E Ë � � Õ N Ñ B�032ã,/>sH�!?,'51H/*LAº0GAM.7Hk032TA . � � N�24>DA4B;H/24H03*;^�6�Z�E4A4B;H'Ee]�.7>%bçZ�C�2S0GE4HÔ*;>3Ae03.1.7>%bcH'^�X Y B;H'E�HP0GE�HÔ*;>aE�H/=_0357*;51*;:U,k0324H/2RA�><,/>O*;2T51^;H'EkX ��W����( Þ � �W¡S�Ð��K��%� � K»�®ÿL���J�-�%� ���s�±� � Z�Eå>O*;.78#0GC;C�.151,/0GA�51>O*#bu51.1.s](HcA�>SA�B;HcÏ;E�2TAåB�Z;*�A�2TA�H'CabeB;H'* � B�032=gZ;.7A�5VC�.157,/57Aw8-A4B�E�H/H3X Ë»Ì Hg^;>�*;>3AM*;H/H'^iA�>`,/>O*;2457^;H'EÔB;51:OB;H'EÔ=gZ;.7A�5VC�.151,'57A�57H/2�51*qA�B;HgB�Z;*�AkN�]�8 Ë :�XpÅ�X7ð�Å Õ4Õ Xí C;E�51>3E�5 � =?57:OB�AMB�0kKLHUA�B�E4H/H<03*�03.V8@A�57,º];E[03*;,[B;H/2#0GA � X#öSH'*;,/H �q¤?§ ° ¬k©�¹�¤J¼Í¥®­;¤gªk¤J¥eù ¯ ¬+¸ � AQA À � À A �©G¼±¹-©GÂ�Â1¬�û�� ¥+¬<­�©3µ3¤g©`¥»­s´ ° ¹-³[¬�« ¯ ¬G¼(¤J¼�¥�, � ,u©G¼±¹-³[¬�¼;ª¨´¶¹�¤ ° ¥»­;¤ºÂ1¬�È-¹G´�µ�´�ª�¬ ° o��Dä � ¦ ä � T ä Ñ � ,û�­�´½³¨­`ûv¤#©�ª¨ª¨ùs«_¤Ô´�ª R úw¥ ° ´�µ%´|©GÂ�©G¼±¹ �cùsª[­-©�ªº§¨¤®¸k¬ ° ¤�À )+*-6�03,'A\bcHãbe57.1.(2TB;>%bç24B;>3ETA�.78?A4B�0GA �é512\H/=aC;A+8LX

#�H'A � ](H<A4B;H_24=_03.1.7H/2TAÔ*;>O*@Ø��/HJE�>q,/>@H�!<,/51H'*�Ag57* � ¦ ä � T ä Ñ �PX � �Öð��OóD]s8 Ë :�Xpï�X � Õ X Y B�Z;2º]�8Ë :�XæÅ�X � X ó Õ 03*;^ Ë :�XpÅ�X1: Õ N � 512R,/>O*LA[0351*;H/^-51*�A4B;H ãZ>H¿03.�.1>@,'Z;2u>O6 � X

Page 82: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ) ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

�W����(��7� �����Í����� �Mùs¼W¥\¼(¬�¥w©G¥|´¶¬�¼�©GªP´�¼ � � À B@À A�� � À .�ù ¯L¯ ¬%ªk¤3' 3 ¹�¬�¤JªP¼(¬G¥v­�©Gµ3¤U©_¥|´1È�¤ ° ,R©3¼±¹ � Ü ' Ê­�©�ªg«Uùs ¥|´ ¯  ´¶³'´�¥®·q©G¥uÂ1¤�©�ª¨¥e¥»­ ° ¤[¤kÀ Á ­;¤J¼ ð��3ï>� � � ð��Oó À�(ù ° ¥®­;¤ ° «?¬ ° ¤-,u´Ç¸ U Ê Ü � Ê ³¨¬�¼�¥w©G´�¼;ªa©G¼ � �

¯ ¬�´»¼�¥ ,¿¥»­;¤'¼ � 3 ß Ë ï ��� � Õ-, U Ê ´�ªM¥®­;¤MÒ ï ú4³Jù ° µ3¤0,\©G¼±¹&� 3 ß Ë ;Säëð Õ � Ë ó ;�ähï Õ�À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ ' 3 572¿*;>3A ãZSH¿03.|N�6�>3EvH �;03=<C�.1HR]s8 Ë :�XpÅ�X # Õ X � 3 � � �éð��OóM]�8 Ë :�Xpï�X � Õ X �S>%b A�B;HuE�H/24Z;.VAc6�>O.1.7>%bu269E�>O=ÖA�B;HM.1512IAe>O6 2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2R>O6 24=_03.7.�,/>@H !?,/57H/*�A/N Ë ð�Å�X7ð Õ X �)+*�K@51H'bç>O6 Ë ðOðOXpï�XæÅ Õ bvHÔ=_0GQLHSA�B;HP03^;^;57A�57>O*�03.�032424Z;=<C;A451>O*�~Á ¬aª¨´�« ¯  ´Ç¸¨·?¥®­;¤g³JÂ7©�ª¨ª¨´ 2c³�©3¥®´¶¬G¼qûv¤Pûå´�Â�Â�©�ª¨ª¨ùs«_¤P¥®­�©G¥ � Ãçð��3ï ©G¼±¹�¸¨ù ° ¥»­�¤ ° «?¬ ° ¤P´ ¸ � ³[¬�¼�¥w©G´�¼;ª#©G¼

� � ¯ ¬�´�¼W¥ ,�¥®­;¤J¼"� Ã Ë ;ãäëð Õ � Ë ó ;�ähï Õ�ÀÌ H¿03:L0351*P2IA�Z;^�8ÔA4B;H¿,/>O=<C±>O2457A451>O*M>O6@]�.1>�bjZ�C�2 �c~ ��çÒ�Ó �' X Ì HåbuE457A�H � A�>�57*;^;51,k0GA4H�A�B;H Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLH

>O6 A4B;H � � � ]�.7>%b Z�C�X�W����(��»� �¿���Í����� � ´�ª#¤J« ¯ ¥®· ,¿¥®­�©G¥¿´�ª Þ ­�©�ªº©G¥v«?¬�ª¨¥v¥®ûv¬D§ ° ©3¼(³¨­;¤¨ªkÀ* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ íS2ubcH#B�0�KLH#*;>3A4H/^�N � 572�,/>O*LA[0351*;H'^Ð57*�A�B;H ãZ Hv03. .1>s,/Z;2/X +@Z�C;C±>O24H#Þ B�032eA�B�E�H'Hº];E[03*;,[B;H/2/X ,k03*�,/>O*LA[0351*�0GAR=?>O2TA\>O*;H�MZOH¿03.±C(>O57*�A Ë >3E\57A\bu51.7.(*;>3A\](HM,/>O*�ATE[03,'A�5V]�.1H Õ A�B�Z;2 =?H/H'A�2 � 0GA\Awbc>24=?>s>3A�B`C(>O51*LA�2/NW03*;^"03* � �gC±>O51*LAkX@$\Z�ARA�B;H/*

ð ��ó � ä � � Ë ;Mäëð Õ � � Ë � ¦ ä � T ä Ñ � Õ ß Ò � o�� � ð

0a,'>O*�A4E�03^;51,'A�57>O*�X �� ¼Ðµ�´¶¤'û ¬+¸ � A A À �sÀ A�� ,yûv¤ ° ¤J¥®ù ° ¼i¥w¬?¥»­�¤Ô¼(¬�¥w©G¥|´¶¬�¼�¬+¸ � AQA À � À A � À

�W����(�� 5 �¿�@�Í����� � ¸ Þ ­;©�ªD¥|ûv¬m§ ° ©G¼(³¨­�¤¨ª�©G¥ � ,#¥®­;¤J¼ç¬�¼(¤"§ ° ©G¼(³J­m­�©�ªq©j¹�¬�ù�§'Â1¤ ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥�,a©¾ª¨´�« ¯ Â1¤³Jùsª ¯ ,S©3¼±¹�¥»­�¤_¬�¥»­�¤ ° ´�ªºª¨«?¬%¬�¥»­;À � ¸ã¦ ´�ªg¥»­�¤?§ ° ©G¼�³¨­"ûy´�¥®­q¥»­;¤_³'ù�ª ¯ ,u¥»­�¤J¼ «?¤[¤'¥»ªS¦ ¼(¬ ° «<©GÂ� ·Ð©G¥¬�¼(¤gªJ«?¬�¬�¥®­ ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥�, ³[¬�¼W¥½©G´»¼;ª#¥®ûv¬`ªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´»¥®´¶¤Jª Ë ó Õ?©G¼±¹ Ë ï Õ0,�©3¼±¹0Tì«_¤[¤J¥®ªg¥»­;¤#Ò ó ú4³Jù ° µ3¤0,�©3¼±¹�´�ª¹G´�ª»²k¬�´�¼�¥�¸ ° ¬�« ¬�¼ ��UÀ � ¼j¥w¤ ° «#ª_¬+¸a¥»­;¤D³JÂ7©�ª[ª¨´ 2c³�©G¥|´¶¬�¼�¬+¸ � AQA ÀCB � ,R¥»­�´�ªU´�ª?³[¬�¼ 2�ÈGù ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼ � � � ¸�¬ ° ¥®­;¤È�¤J¼Wù�ªU¬�¼(¤g³Jùsª ¯ ¦hÀ* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ +@Z�C;C±>O24H�ÞÚB�032åAwbc>P];E[03*;,[B;H/2/X +@51*;,'H�ÞÚB�032¿=gZ;.VA�57C�.751,/5VA+8PA�B�E�H/H3Ns>O*;HeB�032¿0P^;>OZ�]�.1HRC(>O51*LAkN�2�0k8¦ N�*;H/,/H'242�0GE�57.78D0 � � � >3E�^;H'ER,/Z;2TC�NW03*;^`A�B;Hã>3A�B;H'EkN T N@512\24=?>s>3A�B�X Y B;Hã,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E�0GA�51>O*`be5VA�B`E�H/2TC±H/,'A\A�>A�B;HÔ,/Z;2TC ¦ ]±H/.1>O*;:O2\A�>UA�B;HP,/.10324245VÏ�,k0GA�51>O*-0GAuA4B;HÔ2TA�0GE4Ae>O6 Ë ðOðOX ó Õ N�]s8`E�H/=?0GE4Q Ë ðOðOX ó@XæÅ Õ X)+6 ¦ 03*;^ T ](>3A�Bq=?H'H'A 0GA�24=?>@>3A4B�C(>O51*LA�2/N(A4B;H/*q69E�>O= � à ð��3ï_57A�6�>O.1.1>�bu2�A�B�0GAãHk03,[Bq=?H/H'A�2

*;>3E�=_03.7.78LX�$cZ�AMA4B;H/*iA�B;H'57EM51=_03:OH'2ã0GA � 0GE�HU03*�03.V8@A�57,k03.1.V8�512T>O=?>3E4C�B;51,GN�0D,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�57>O*�X0+@>-0GAM.1H/032TA>O*;HP,'>O*�A[0357*;2e03* � �gC±>O51*LAkXå)+6 Hk03,[B�=?H/H'A42 >O* �� A4B;H/*

Ë � ¦ ä � T#Õ�� - � ä � ä � � Ë ;Sätð Õ Ãéð

0a,'>O*�A4E�03^;51,'A�57>O*�X

Page 83: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � � �

�S>�bé,/>O*;2457^;H'E�A�B;HM,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*�6�>3ERA�B;HP,/Z;2IC ¦ X)+6 A�B;HÔ,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*-572u)¨N T ,/>O*LA[0351*;2\A�B;H � �gC±>O51*LA�03*;^-bvHÔB�0kKLH

ð - ó � ä � � Ë ;�ätð Õ - � Ë ó ;Sähï � ;Säëð Õ Ãéð

0_,/>O*LA4E[03^;51,JA�51>O*�XS)+6åA4B;HU,'>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�51>O*q572ã)T)JNWA�B;H/* Ë 2457*;,/H ¦ 03*;^ T 0GE�H#^;512»FI>O57*�AM>O* ��Õ N T =?H/H'A�2 *;>3E�=_03.7.78`0GAe0a2T=?>@>3A�B`C(>O57*�A/X Ì HMB�0kKLH

ðeß �Sä � ä � � Ë ;Säëð Õ Ãçð

0a,'>O*�A4E�03^;51,'A�57>O*�X+@51*;,'H"o��Íä ¦ ä T 512?C�.VAkN ¦ ä T >O*;.78�,/>O*LA[0351*;2 ãZ�Hv03.RC(>O57*�A�2'Nu03*;^ T 572_24=?>@>3A4Bâ0GA � 5VA

6�>O.1.7>%bu2�A�B�0GAãA�B;H#,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E�0GA�51>O*Ð512S)4)4)¨N T =?H'H'A�2�A�B;H Ò ó%ؽ,/Z�E4KLHa03*;^Ð512S^;512�FI>O51*LAÔ69E4>O= >O* �� X Y B�Z;2� ä �

�ä �� �

� Ê ßÝðON�03*;^<24>M69E�>O= A�B;H%/�Z;24B?,/>O*;^;5VA�51>O*�N �aßÝðOX Y B;512y572åA�B;HR,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA451>O*<^;H'24,'E�5V](H/^�X ��W����(���( �¿���Í����� .Wù ¯�¯ ¬%ªk¤?TÄ´�ª#¤J« ¯ ¥®·LÀ Á ­�¤J¼Í¤J´»¥»­;¤ °

Ë ð Õ ­;©�ªMª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ª Ë ï � ó 8 Õ-� Ë ï Õ#©G¼±¹<«_¤[¤J¥®ªR¦ ¼(¬ ° «<©GÂ� ·�©3¥\©<ª¨«?¬�¬�¥®­ ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥�,c¬ °Ë ó Õ ­�©�ªUªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´»¥®´¶¤Jª Ë ï Õ-� Ë ó Õ_©G¼±¹¾¬�¼�¥®­;¤?«g´�¼�´�«?©G¿¹�¤¨ªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�ª/©G¥|´¶¬�¼"¦ «?¤[¤J¥®ª ¼(¬ ° «<©GÂ� ·

©G¥v¥®­;¤Ô´�¼�¥+¤ ° ªk¤[³J¥|´¶¬�¼¾¬+¸ ©G¼(¹<¥»­�¤ÔÒ ó ú�³Jù ° µ3¤kÀ

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ � >O*;2457^;H'EeA�B;HÔ=gZ;.7A�5VC�.151,'57Aw8LN@nÐN�>O6�A�B;HP2IA4E�51,JAuA4E�03*;246�>3E�=Ö>O6�Þ >O*�A�B;HMÏ;E42TAe]�.7>%bçZ�C">O6 � X+@Z�C;C(>O2TH`Ï;E42TAgn 572PA�B�E�H/HGX Y B;H/*Í]�8�A�B;HS/�Z;24Bj,/>O*;^;5VA�51>O*�N�]�8Í,/>O*;2457^;H'E�57*;:qA4B;H_,/>@H�!<,/51H'*�AU>O6 N

� � ó � � X Y B�Z;2/N±]�8->OZ�E�2451=<C�.751698@51*;:a032424Z;=<C;A�57>O*;2/N ¦ .151H'2e51*�A4B;HP24=?>s>3A�B-.7>@,/Z;2'XRíS.724>a]�8 Ë ð�Å�X1ð Õ A�B;H2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2R>O6 � 0GE�HÔH/57A�B;HJE ãZ>H¿03.|N�>3EuAw8sC(H Ë ï Õ X ,WZ�E4A�B;H'E/N±032 � à ð��3ï�N;A�B;HJE�HP,k03*�](H#0GAu=?>O2TAu>O*;HAw8@C±H Ë ï Õ 2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8LN(03*;^ �%¦ � ó@Xe)+6 572eA[03*;:OH/*LASA�> ¦ N�A4B;H/* � 512 ãZ H¿03. 03*;^"A�B�Z;2S]s8 Ë ï�Xpï Õ N� B�032�>O*;H ãZ Hv03.�2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8-03.1>O*;: X $cZ�AeA�B;H'*ÐÞÄB�032�0<^;>OZ�]�.1HºC±>O51*LAkN±032uA�B;512�572�,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA451>O*� 6�>3EºA�B;Ha,/Z;2TC�N�,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�51>O*�X�+@> ¦ =<H/H'A�2 *;>3E4=_03.1.V8LX � ,k03*;*;>3Aº]±H ãZ Hv03.y>3E#Þì512º24=<>@>3A�B�X+@>_A�B;H'E�Hg572ã0`Z;*;57r@Z;Hg*;>O* ãZ4H¿03. 2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8"03.1>O*;: N�0 Ë ï Õ C±>O51*LAkX $c8 Ë ðOðOXpï�X . Õ A�B;H#2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457A�57H/203.1>O*;: 0GE�H Ë ï Õ 03*;^ Ë ó Õ X Y B;572v512c,'>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�51>O*_)4)T)y6�>3ER0º:OH/*sZ;2\>O*;HS,/Z;2IC�N;24>#ÞÖB�032\0º^;>OZ�]�.1H�C(>O57*�A/N0a,'>O*�A4E�03^;51,'A�57>O*�X)+6�n 572¿>O*;H3N�A�B;H/* ¦ 512åA4E�5VC�.78UA[03*;:OH/*LAvA�> Ê 03*;^?bcH�=gZ;2TA�]�.1>�btZ�CD0GA¿.1Hk032IAvAwbe57,/He=?>3E4H�03.1>O*;:PÞ"X

í\A�A�B;512uC(>O51*LA � B�032ã0?2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8�>O6�A+8sC(H Ë ï 8 Õ N±03*;^ � ß ð��Oó@N±0?,/>O*LA4E[03^;51,JA�51>O*�X $c8 Ë ðOðOX7ð Õ N�6�Z�ETA�B;H'E]�.1>�bçZ�C�2ubu51.7.�>O*;.78`51*;,JE�Hk0324H � XY BsZ;2Sn ßÝó@XRíS2�Þ � Ê ß ï�N ¦ =gZ;2TASB�0kKLH#03*">3E�^;57*�0GE48�,'Z;2TCÐ>O* '\Ê X Y B;H#*;HG��A�]�.7>%b�Z�Cq=gZ;2TA

](Hã03.7>O*;: ¦ X Y B;512c,'>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�51>O*`572c*;>3AR03.1.1>�bcH/^�N�032 � ßéó � � N�03*;^ ;gßÝðOX Y B;H�Awbc>g24Z�]�24H'r@Z;H/*LAu]�.7>%bZ�C�2#=gZ;2TA#](H?03.1>O*;: ¦ 03*;^m:O57KLH Ë ó Õ 03*;^ Ë ð Õ X � *j03*�8Í6�Z�ETA�B;H'E#]�.1>�bÚZ�CmA�B;HJE�H_512g0�2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8�>O6,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LAS0GAu.1Hk032TAÔð��Oó@N�buB;51,[B�512R*;>3Ae03.1.1>�bcH/^�032 � �éð��Oó@X �

Page 84: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

�W����(�� �¿�@�Í����� � ¸ ³¨¬�¼�¥w©G´�¼;ª\©Sù@¼�´|ø'ùW¤c¼(¬�¼ �Ôù ��©GÂsª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥®· , © Ë ï Õ ¯ ¬G´�¼�¥�, ©3¼±¹ R Ë� Õ¿´�ªåª¨«_¬�¬�¥®­ ,¥®­;¤J¼m¥®­;¤ ° ¤<´�ª?¤��@©�³J¥| ·¾¬�¼(¤R¸¨ù ° ¥®­;¤ ° ª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|· ,Ô©G¼ � Ê ¯ ¬G´�¼�¥�,ã©GÂ1¬�¼�È ,S¥»­;©G¥u´�ª � ´�ªg¥»­;¤<ª¨ù ° ¸/©�³¨¤`¬+¸³[¬�¼ 2�ÈGù ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼ � � � ¸k¬ ° ©aÈ�¤J¼�ùsª#¬�¼�¤U³Jùsª ¯ À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Ì HP,/>O*;2457^;H'E�A�B;HÔ24H/rsZ;H/*;,/H#>O6 ]�.7>%bçZ�C�2��v~ ���Ò�Ó ' X +@Z�C;C(>O24HºA�B;HMÏ;E�2TA = - ó#]�.1>�b�Z�C�2�0GE�H>�KLH'Eg24=?>s>3A�B�C(>O57*�A�2#>O6 � X")I*ÍA�B;H?E4H/24Z;.7A451*;:q,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*jA4B;H_2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8�572 Ë ó 8 � � � �-� ó Õ ß ��� � Ê XY B;HS*;H ��Ac]�.7>%bëZ�C Ë ]s8<A�B;HS,[B;>O51,/HS>O6 = Õ 512c0GAvA4B;HS51*LA�H'E�24H','A�51>O*`>O6 03*;^`A4B;HS=_0GE4QLH/^ Ò ó%ؽ,/Z�ETKLH3X Y B;HE�H/2TZ;.7A�57*;:?,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*"B�032uAwbc>?2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457A�57H/2/N Ë ï 8 ����� � � Õ 03*;^ Ë ó 8 Õ X � *q03*�8�6�Z�E4A�B;H'ES]�.7>%b Z�C�A4B;H'E�H512u0a*;>O* MZ8Hv03.�2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8LN�*;>3A�>O6�A+8sC(H Ë ï Õ X Y BsZ;2ebvHPB�0kKLHMA�B;572e,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E�0GA�51>O*Dbe5VA�B>=Mßçó@X ��W��� o��ºä�Þ K���ýÍ���s�G�Í�»� � K¿�;� � �öSH'E�H T ß %�Ne03*;^�Þ ß ¦ X Ì H"=_0GQLHq03*ë03^;^;57A451>O*�03.e2T51=<C�.751698�57*;:m032424Z;=<C;A451>O*�~ �q¤Ð©Gª[ª¨ù@«?¤

�Þ � à �� � ,S¬ ° ¤�ø'ù@´�µG©GÂ1¤'¼�¥®Â · ,u¥®­�©G¥u¥»­;¤/2 ° ª¨¥S§'Â1¬�ûéù ¯ ´�¼ �v~ �� Ò�Ó �' ´�ªa©G¥u¥»­�¤ ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥ã¬+¸ �ÞìÜ �'  ·�´»¼@Ȭ�µ3¤ ° � À �S>3A4HaA�B;572ºB;>O.1^;2º6�>3E � ß U � 51*m0�2TA�H'Cj>O6¿A�B;H<BsZ;*LAkN�2457*;,/H Ë 51*iA�B;H?B�Z;*�Ag*;>3A[0GA451>O* Õ �Þ � 572o"ؽ*;H/:L0GA�5VKLH3N;beB;57.1H �U � 512Ro *;>O*@ؽ*;H/:L0GA457KLH3XY B;H'E�H\0GE�Hc57*�Ï�*;57A�H/.V8º=_03*L8PC±>O24245V]�.1Hc,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA451>O*;2/N3bcHc*;>�bh57*;^;51,k0GA4HcB;>%b�A�B;H'8º,/03*g]±Hc:OH/*;H'E[0GA4H/^�X

�q¤Sûy´�Â�±¼(¬�¥�©�ª[ªJùs«?¤ã´�¼-¥®­;¤M©3¼±©G ·�ª¨´�ªM§¨¤JÂ1¬�ûh¥®­�©G¥ o��#ä � ¦ ´�ªÔ¤J´�¥®­;¤ ° �cù�ª¨­D¬ ° R úw¥ ° ´�µ�´|©3Â7À �q¤Sûy´�Â�Â�¬�¼� ·ùsªk¤U¬�ù ° ©�ª[ª¨ù@« ¯ ¥|´¶¬�¼�¬G¼ �Þ � ,c©G¼(¹<¥»­;©G¥ o��Dä � ©G¼(¹ o��#ä�Þ © ° ¤ºÂ1¬�È<¥+¤ ° «U´�¼±©GÂ� >O*;2451^;H'EeA�B;HÔC±>O242457]�57.15VA�51H/2u6�>3E �c~ ���Ò�Ó �' X $v8�032424Z;=aC;A�51>O*�N�A�B;HÔÏ;E42TA�]�.1>�b Z�Cq>O6 �c~ �� Ò±Ó �' 572

03.1>O*;: ¦ ßtÞ"X +@Z�]�2TH/r@Z;H/*LAR]�.1>�btZ�C�2R0GE�HS>O6�A�B�E�H'HS24>3E4A�2/X ��57A�B;H'EcbvH�]�.1>�b Z�C�0GAvA�B;HSC(>O57*�Av>O6 Ü ��.78@51*;:M>%KLHJE � ¦ N3buB;51,[BabvHu,k03.7.�A�B;H � �@���%��¡'� C(>O57*�AkNL>3E�0GA�0ãC±>O51*LAkN�.78�57*;:ã>%KLH'E¿0ã2451*;:OZ;.10GEåC±>O51*LA¿>O6 � N^;57è±H'E�H/*LAS69E�>O=àA�B;HÔ*;Hk0GEeC±>O51*LAkN;beB;57,[B�bcHP,k03.7.�A�B;H þ½�����%� ��¡'� C(>O57*�A Ë A�B;H'E4HÔbu51.1.(]±Hº0GAu=?>O2TAu>O*;HÔ2TZ;,¨BC(>O57*�A Õ N�>3ES0GAS0aC±>O51*LAS>O* NW*;>3Aã03.7>O*;: ¦ N�.V8�51*;:<>%KLH'ES0<24=?>s>3A�B-C(>O57*�Ae>O6 � X Ì HP,k03.1.�A�B;512e.9032TAe,k0324H03* �»�����s�G���W�ºü K����×� � X Ì H�57*;^;51,k0GA4HS0P24H'E451H/2v>O6�*;>O*@ض51*LA�H'E�57>3E¿]�.7>%bëZ�C�2¿]�8_0P24H'r@Z;H/*;,/HGN Ë � / Ñ / � �'Õ 6�>3EH �;03=<C�.1H3N�buB;H'E�H �Í51*;^;57,k0GA�H/2S0<]�.7>%bÝZ�Ci0GAeA�B;H#*;Hk0GE4H/2TASC(>O57*�AeA�> ¦ N(03*;^ Ñ 51*;^;57,k0GA�H/2ã0<]�.7>%b�Z�Ci0GAA�B;H#6�0GE4A4B;H/2TA�C±>O51*LAkX Ì H#,'>OZ;*�ASA�B;HÔÏ;E�2TAS]�.1>�b�Z�Ci>O6 �"032S0<]�.1>�b�Z�CÐ0GAeA�B;H#*;Hk0GE�H/2IASC(>O51*LAkX Ì Hºbu51.1.51*;^;57,k0GA�HP03*"51*LA�H'E�57>3Eu]�.7>%b�Z�C�]�8 �4XcíS69A�HJES03*�57*�A�HJE�51>3Eu]�.1>�b�Z�C�NWA�B;H'E�HP512e>O*;.V8D>O*;Hº2451*;:OZ;.10GEeC±>O51*LA�>O6� >O* Xyíç6�Z�E4A�B;H'E\57*�A�HJE�51>3Ec]�.7>%bëZ�CD512c51=aC(>O24245V]�.1H3Ns6�>3EcA�B;H/*`o��gä � 512v*;>3A\.VAkN�03*;^`24>#A�B;HeC±>O24245V]�.1H24H/rsZ;H/*;,/HÔ>O6�]�.7>%bçZ�C�2R512\Z;*;51rsZ;H3X Ì HMbRE�5VA�H � � 576�A4B;H'E�HÔ0GE�H ;_6�Z�E4A�B;HJEu]�.7>%béZ�C�2'X �S>3A�Hão��<ä ¦ ä

512u.1,Ô57èÐA�B;H'E�Hº572e*;>?57*�A4H'E�51>3Eu]�.1>�b Z�C�N±03*;^�A�B�0GA ¦ � 572�0a2T=?>@>3A�BDC(>O57*�Ae>O6 � 5Vèi03.1.�A�B;HÔ]�.7>%b Z�C�20GE�HÔ0GAuA4B;HP*;Hk0GERC(>O57*�AkN;A�B�0GAu512R57èqA�B;HÔ,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*-572 Ë � � Õ 6�>3Ee24>O=?H = - Å�X

,W>3ESH ��03=aC�.1H#516�A�B;Hg2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8"0GA � 572 Ë ó � ï Õ N(03*;^qbcHg=_0GQLHPA4B;Hg]�.7>%bÝZ�C¾2TH/r@Z;H/*;,'H Ë � � / Ñ / � / � Õ NA�B;HÔ2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2\>O* � 03.1>O*;: 0GE�H Ë ó � ï 8 � ï � ï � ï Õ 03*;^ Ë ó 81Õ XöSH'E�HM512u0UC�57,'A�Z�E�HG~

Page 85: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � � �

S~

.q

S

~

-2

-3

DD

X X

-1

-3-3

-3

-3

-2

-2-1

Σ

Σ

ΤΤ∼

,�57:OZ�E�H �

�W��� �ÐÉ�Ê�9�ü��%�;�%�»����¡3�

AQA À �LÀ A �#¬�¥w©G¥|´¶¬�¼ �y£ ¤J¥ Ë Î �,�PÕ\§¨¤c©�ª¨«?¬�¬G¥»­U³Jù ° µ3¤yÈs¤ ° « , ©G¼±¹SÂ1¤J¥ RM~ �çÒ±Ó � §¨¤c©�� ¯±° ¬ ¯ ¤ ° � É�Ê%ú 2v§ ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼¬+¸ ° ¤JÂ7©G¥|´�µ3¤ *\´¶³�© ° ¹a¼�ù@«<§¨¤ ° ¬�¼�¤0,�ûy´�¥®­�� ©<¼(¬ ° «<©GÂ�ª¨ù ° ¸/©�³[¤�Àc£ ¤J¥ �R §¨¤P¥»­;¤a³[¬�« ¯ ¬%ª¨´�¥|´¶¬�¼

�Ri~����Ó � �Ò Ó �

�½û�­�¤ ° ¤0,v©GªM¥»­ ° ¬�ùLÈ�­;¬�ù@¥v¥»­�¤ ¯ © ¯ ¤ ° , ��éÒ�Ó � ´�ªÔ¥»­;¤P«g´�¼�´�«?©G ¹�¤¨ª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�ªk©G¥®´½¬�¼ � Àc£ ¤J¥�� Ü �� , ��Ü �§¨¤Ô¥®­;¤Pªk³¨­;¤J«_¤Júw¥®­;¤[¬ ° ¤J¥®´½³�2c§ ° ¤¨ª �T¬�µ3¤ ° Î � ,�ûy´»¥»­ ° ¤�¹GùW³J¥|´¶¬�¼;ª � � �`À

Page 86: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

��� ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

�W��� �(� 5 �¿���Í����� Á ­;¤�¸�¬�Â�Â1¬�ûy´�¼�È`© ° ¤a¤�ø'ù@´�µG©GÂ1¤'¼�¥ �Ë ð Õ R ´�ªMª¨«?¬�¬�¥®­�ÀË ó Õ �à´�ªãª¨«?¬%¬�¥»­;ÀË ï Õ � ´�ªSÈ�¤J¼(¤ ° ´¶³�©GÂ� · ° ¤[¹Gù�³¨¤�¹LÀ

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Y B;HRH/r@Z;5VK303.7H/*;,/HR>O6 Ë ð'Øwó Õ 512�bcH/.7.�Q�*;>�be*�N�03*;^a>3]sK@51>OZ;24.V8 Ë ð Õ 51=<C�.751H/2 Ë ï Õ X�íS2424Z;=<H Ë ï Õ X ��Ü �512 � 0GE4A�57H'EkN±03*;^ÐB;H'*;,/H � >OB;H/*@ضzi03,/03Z;.90k8LX Y B�Z;2ã57ASB�032ã*;>_H/=#]±H/^;^;H/^qC(>O51*LA�2/N�03*;^q24>`572�51*LA�H/:3E[03.®Xe)wA6�>O.1.7>%bu2\A�B�0GA

� Ê Ë 6 � Õ ßÝð Ò � Ë 6 � Õ ßÝð Ò � Ë 6 � � Õ ß Å

A�B�Z;2 � ß É�Ê X +@57*;,/H �j512 � 0GE4A451H'EkN Ë ó Õ 6�>O.7.1>�be2'X � ° ¬�«Ö¼(¬Gû ¬�¼"ûv¤#©Gª[ª¨ù@«?¤�� ´�ªSªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° À )+*�K�57H'b >O6 Ë ðOðOX � X ó Õ bcHSbu51.1.±24>O=?H'A�57=?H/2\0G]�Z;24HM*;>3A[0GA�57>O*

03*;^�,k03.7. � 0 «gù@ ¥®´ ¯ Â1¤ >3E ªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° Ï;];E�H?>O6 � Ë H'KLH/*�A�B;>OZ;:OB � 512M]s8¾032424Z;=aC;A�51>O*¾E4H/^;Z;,/H/^�Ny03*;^�572512T>O=?>3E4C�B;51,SA�> É�ÊMÕ X

�W��� �(��( �¿���Í����� �� Ü � ´�ªM¥®­;¤Ôù@¼�´|ø'ùW¤ÔÒ ð ú4³Jù ° µ3¤º´�¼q¥®­;¤ 2v§ ° ¤kÀ* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Y B;512uB;>O.1^;2R2451*;,'HPA�B;HMH �;,/HJC;A�51>O*�03.�.1>s,/Z;2e>O6 ��çÒ�Ó � 572uo �� *;H/6½X �AQA À �LÀ � (ù ° ¥®­;¤ ° �#¬�¥w©G¥|´¶¬�¼ �\£ ¤J¥

�� �Ò/Ò;Ò�Ò[Ó �

�� ��� ������ �

§¨¤�© ° ¤'Â7©G¥®´»µ3¤R«g´�¼�´»«<©GÂ�«?¬k¹�¤'±¬�µ3¤ ° Î ,�ª�¬ Ñ ´�ªu©Mª¨«_¬�¬�¥®­�É�ÊGúT§'ù@¼±¹@Â1¤0,y©G¼±¹ � ´�ªu©g³[¬G« ¯ ¬%ª¨´»¥®´¶¬G¼D¬I¸¿ªJ«?¬�¬�¥®­§'Â1¬�ûëù ¯ ª/ÀR£ ¤J¥ � §¨¤º¥»­;¤�2v§ ° ¤g¬+¸ Ñ ¬Gµ3¤ ° Î À � ¼¾¥®­;¤g³�©�ª�¤Ôû�­;¤ ° ¤P¥®­;¤g¹3ù;©GÂ(È ° © ¯ ­q¬+¸M¥®­;¤º´�¼�µ3¤ ° ªk¤M´�«<©%È�¤¬+¸ � ´�ªM©_³¨­�©G´»¼ ,yûv¤ãûy´�Â�Â(ù�ª�¤S¥®­;¤�¸k¬�Â�Â1¬Gûy´�¼@ÈU¼(¬�¥w©G¥|´¶¬�¼�¥+¬a¹s¤¨ªk³ ° ´|§¨¤e¥®­;¤Sªk³¨­�¤J«?¤Júw¥®­;¤[¬ ° ¤J¥|´¶³�2v§ ° ¤ � � Á ­;¤ªk¤�ø/ù�¤J¼�³[¤ ; Ë Ò � Õ ä � Ë Ò � Õ ä ����� ä"n Ë Ò � Õ-,y´�ª�¥½© F ¤J¼-¥w¬#«?¤�©G¼�¥®­�©G¥�¥®­;¤�2 ° ª¨¥ ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼±©GÂ�³Jù ° µ3¤S´�¼-¥»­�¤Ô³¨­;©G´�¼­�©�ªºªk¤' ¸¨úw´�¼�¥+¤ ° ªk¤[³J¥|´¶¬�¼iÒ � ©3¼±¹D­�©�ª#«gù@ ¥®´ ¯  ´¶³J´�¥|· ; ´�¼�ª¨´|¹�¤g¥®­;¤+2v§ ° ¤-,R¥»­;¤#ªk¤¨³[¬�¼±¹`­�©�ªºªk¤' ¸¨úw´�¼�¥+¤ ° ªk¤[³J¥|´¶¬�¼Ò � ©G¼(¹<«gù@ ¥®´ ¯  ´¶³J´�¥|· � ©G¼(¹<ªk¬`¬G¼±À� >O*;2451^;H'EåA�B;H\C(>O242T57]�51.757A�57H/2å6�>3E �±X Y B;H\Ï;E�2TA�]�.1>�bâZ�C_512�0GAå24>O=?H\C(>O57*�A¿03.1>O*;:ãA�B;H\Ï;];E�H3N�0369A4H'E�buB;51,[B

A�B;HãÏ;];E�HM512 Ë Ò ð Õ ä Ë Ò ð Õ X � *;HM>O6 A�B;HM,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*LA�2u572 Ë A�B;HM2TA4E�57,'A\A4E[03*;246�>3E�=Ö>O6 Õ �mN�A�B;HM>3A�B;H'E/N �_N;572��ؽH ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.|XY B;H'E�H?=gZ;2TAÔ](H?0�6�Z�E4A�B;H'E#]�.7>%b Z�C�X �SH/,/H/2T2�0GE�51.V8LN ]�8 Ë ðOðOX � Xpï Õ N�0GAÔA�B;H?51*LA�H'E424H/,'A�57>O*�C(>O57*�AP>O6vA�B;H

Awbc> Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�ETKLH/2/Nå0369A�H'EÔbeB;57,¨BÍA�B;HaÏ;];E�H?512 Ë Ò ó Õ äëó Ë Ò ð Õ ä Ë Ò ó Õ X`íS.1.y24Z�]�24H/rsZ;H/*LAU]�.7>%b Z�C�2g0GE�H<0GA24>O=?HRC(>O57*�Av03.1>O*;:ÔA4B;H�Z;*;51rsZ;H Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�E4KLHGN@]s8 Ë ðOðOX � Xæï Õ X í\AvH/03,¨B_2IA[03:OHe>O*;H�H'57A�B;H'E�]�.1>�be2¿Z�C`0GAc0ÔC±>O51*LAbuB;H'E�HãA�B;H Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLHM=?H/H'A�2R03*;>3A�B;HJERÏ;];E�03.�,'>O=<C(>O*;H/*LAkN�>3Eu0GAu0#C(>O51*LAR>O6�A4B;H Ò ð'ؽ,'Z�E4KLHMbuB;51,[B�512\*;>3A>O*h03*L8j>3A�B;H'Ea,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*�A/X Ì HD,k03.7.vA�B;H-.10GA4A�H'Ea03* �»�(���@���»�W�mü K���� � � X �S>3A�HD51*�CW0GETA�51,/Z;.10GEgA�B�0GA

Page 87: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � � 2

buB�0GA�H'KLH'ESA�B;Hg24H'r@Z;H/*;,/HU>O6�]�.1>�b�Z�C�2SA�B;H'E4Ha0GE4H#H ��03,'A4.78-Awbc>_E�H'^;Z;,/H/^¾,'>O=<C(>O*;H/*LA�2ã51*"A�B;HºÏ;];E4H3N�A�B;H2TA4E451,'ARA4E[03*;246�>3E4=?2u>O6!� 03*;^ �mX Ì HP,'>O.1.1H','AuA4B;H/24HP>3]�2TH'E4KG0GA�51>O*;2e032/~�W��� �(� � �¿�@�Í����� �#¬�¥w©G¥|´¶¬�¼�©�ªe´�¼ � AQA À��LÀ A � , � AQA À �LÀ � � À �×­�©GªS¤��s©�³'¥®Â ·º¥|ûv¬ ° ¤�¹GùW³[¤�¹U³[¬G« ¯ ¬�¼(¤'¼�¥»ªkÀ Á ­;¤³[¬�Â�Â1¤¨³J¥®´½¬�¼m¬I¸P«gù@ ¥|´ ¯ Â1¤_³[¬�« ¯ ¬�¼(¤J¼W¥»ªº´�ªg³¨¬�¼�¥ ° ©�³J¥|´|§'Â1¤�À㣠¤J¥ � 8 ~ ��ÒWÓ � 8 ³[¬�¼�¥ ° ©s³J¥c¥»­�¤¨ªk¤<³[¬�« ¯ ¬G¼(¤J¼�¥®ª/À� 8M´�ª<ª¨«?¬�¬�¥®­ ,#©3¼±¹ Ñ 8 ~ � 8�Ò�Ó � ­�©Gª 2v§ ° ¤ Ë Ò ð Õ ä Ë Ò ð Õ�À � 8 ~ � Ò�Ó � 8P§'Â1¬�û�ª-¹s¬�ûy¼ �I©G¥º¤[©�³¨­ª¨¥w©�È�¤ � ¥®­;¤�ù@¼�´|ø/ù�¤SÒ ð ú�³Jù ° µ3¤kÀ Ñ 8�­;©�ªe¥|ûv¬ ° ¤'Â7©G¥®´»µ3¤�«U´�¼�´�«<©3Â�«?¬�¹�¤JÂpª � Ê , � � ÈG´�µO¤J¼"§/·?³[¬�¼�¥ ° ©s³J¥®´»¼@È<¬G¼(¤0,¬ ° ¥»­;¤D¬�¥»­�¤ ° Ò ð ú4³Jù ° µ3¤kÀ �R ­�©�ª_¤��@©�³J¥| ·-¥|ûv¬ ° ¤JÂ7©G¥|´�µ3¤U«U´�¼�´�«<©3Ây«?¬k¹�¤'Âpª � Ê � � 8 ©G¼±¹ � � � � 8 ,ã©3¼±¹-¥®­;¤° ¤'Â7©G¥®´»µ3¤u«g´�¼W´�«<©GÂ�«_¬k¹�¤JÂ�´�ª�¹�¤J¥+¤ ° «U´�¼(¤�¹g§/·U³J­;¬�¬%ª¨´»¼@ÈÔû�­�´¶³J­ ° ¤�¹3ù�³[¤[¹U³[¬�« ¯ ¬�¼(¤J¼�¥�¬+¸ � ¼�¬�¥ ¥+¬U³¨¬�¼�¥ ° ©�³J¥wÀÁ ­�´�ªg³[¬�« ¯ ¬�¼(¤J¼W¥¿´�ªM¥»­�¤Ôª¨¥ ° ´¶³'¥¿¥ ° ©3¼;ª�¸k¬ ° « ¬+¸ � ,¿¥®­;¤U¬G¥»­;¤ ° ³[¬G« ¯ ¬�¼(¤'¼�¥v´�ªM¥®­;¤Ôª¨¥ ° ´½³J¥v¥ ° ©G¼;ª�¸k¬ ° «Ä¬I¸ � À�Ú­�©�ª ° ©G¥®´½¬�¼±©GÂ(ª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ª0,v©G¼±¹D©3¥�«?¬�ª¨¥v¥®ûv¬<ª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© °\¯ ¬�´»¼�¥»ª#©GÂ1¬�¼@È �`À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Y B;H?.1032TAPAwbc>"2TA�0GA�H/=?H/*LA�2P0GE�H<A�B;Ha>O*;.78i*;H'b >3]�2TH'E4KG0GA�51>O*;2/Ny03*;^Í6�>O.7.1>�b Hk032451.V8¾69E4>O= A�B;H<^;HJØ24,'E457C;A�57>O*->O6 A�B;HM=?>3E4C�B;5724= � 8 X �

��>O24245V]�.1H Rë0GE�H_,/.103242457Ï�H'^�]�8�A�B;H`,[B;>O51,/H/2U>O6cA�B;H_]�.1>�bÚZ�C�2U51*��±X �S2457*;:"A�B;H`,/.903242T57Ï�,k0GA�57>O*m>O6u.VA2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2'N±>O*;H#,k03*q6�Z�E4A�B;HJEÔ,'.903242457698�C(>O2T2457]�57.157A451H/2ebuB;H/* � 572�.1>O:?A4H'E�=?57*�03.|X � *;HgHk032457.78-,¨B;H',[Q@2ã51*CW0GE4A�57,/Z;.90GERA�B;HÔ6�>O.1.1>�bu51*;:;~�W��� �(� � �¿�@�Í����� �#¬�¥w©G¥|´¶¬�¼i©�ªã´»¼ � AQA À���À A � À o��<ä � ´�ª�Â1¬[È<¥w¤ ° «g´�¼(©GÂ�´ÇÆ祮­;¤ ° ¤º© ° ¤M¼(¬U´�¼W¥w¤ ° ´¶¬ ° §/Â1¬�ûù ¯ ª/À

�S>3A�HP0369A�H'EeA4B;HPÏ;E�2TAS57*�A4H'E�51>3Ee]�.1>�b�Z�C�N � ,/>O*;2T512TA�2e>O6�A�B;H Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�E4KLHGN�03*;^q0<,[B�0351*">O6�o���ضC±>O2457A�5VKLH,/Z�E4KLH'2/X Ì HS,k03.1.WA�B;512c,[B�0351* Ë 03*;^`5VA�2c2TA4E�57,'AvA4E�03*;246�>3E�=à0369A�HJE\6�Z�E4A�B;H'E\]�.1>�b Z�C�2 Õ N@A�B;H �����»��ÿL� ��� K ,[B�0351*>O6 A4B;HÔÏ;];E�H3Xå)wA�2RAwbc>aH/*;^;2S0GE�HãA�B;HMA+bv>aE�H/^;Z;,'H/^",/>O=<C±>O*;H/*�A42e>O6 A4B;HÔÏ;];E�H3X�W��� �(� � �u��ü��%�;�%�»����¡g�?���%� ��¡/��ÿ3�%�»���¿���¹L¹G´�¥|´¶¬�¼(©G �#¬�¥w©G¥|´¶¬�¼ �c£ ¤J¥ U Ü �২¤P© ° ¤�¹GùW³[¤�¹`³Jù ° µ3¤�Ès¤ ° « , 2å¼W´�¥w¤#¬Gµ3¤ ° � ,媨ùW³¨­`¥»­;©G¥ o��Uä U ´�ªS ¥�,©G¼±¹ �U � � ßÝð À

�SH/,/H'242�0GE�57.78 U×512Ô0�24H/,JA�51>O*i>O6 RyN �U×=?H/HJA�2M0�Z;*;51rsZ;Ha,'>O=<C(>O*;H/*LA�2Ô>O6 � N 0`E�H/^;Z;,/H'^�,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*�A/N03*;^ �U B�032ã*;>3E�=_03. ,/>O*�A�03,'AkX $v8 Ë ðOðOX � X � Õ A�B;H'E�HU512M0`Z;*;51r@Z;Hg,[B;>O51,'Ha>O6 �qbeB;57,[B¾512M03*Ð5124>O=<>3E4C�B;5124=51*i0`*;H/51:OBL](>OZ�E�B;>s>@^i>O6 �U_X Y B;H'E4Ha,k03*Ð](HU0GAM=?>O2TAã>O*;Hg51*LA�H'E451>3Eã]�.1>�b Z�C Ë >3A�B;H'E4bu5124H U×,/>O*LA[0351*;2M0*;>O*@ؽ,[B�0357*¾2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8 Õ X #�H'A��iß U � � � � Xã)+6åo���ä � 572ã.7A�A�B;H'* � Ë 03*;^iB;H/*;,'H � Õ 512SZ;*;57r@Z;H/.V8^;H'A�HJE�=?51*;H'^h]s8�A�B;H�=_0GE4QLH'^h2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8 Ë � � U Õ Nc03*;^â>3A�B;H'ETbe5724H�57A?512<^;HJA�H'E�=?57*;H/^â]s8�A�B;H�=_0GETQLH/^2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8 Ë � � UÝä �PÕ X Ì H�51*;^;57,k0GA�H�A4B;H-2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2<032<57* Ë ðOðOXæÅ�X1ð Õ Nybe5VA�Bâ03*hZ;*;^;HJE�.157*;H Ë E�H/2IC�XC;E�57=?H Õ 51*;^;57,k0GA�51*;:a*;>3E�=_03.�,/>O*LA[03,'Aube5VA�B �U Ë E�H'2TC�X�bu57A�B ��ºÕ XD ¤J«<© °GF À � 6�,/>OZ�E�24HÔ>O*;HÔ,/03*-,/.103242451698D:O.7>3]W03. É�Ê Ø¶Ï;];E[0GA�57>O*;2 RM~ �çÒ�Ó � NW6�>3Ee0g24=?>@>3A4BDC;E�>3C±H'Eu,/Z�E4KLH� N3]�8#Z;2457*;:SA�B;H\0G](>�KLHv.1>s,k03.@,'.90324245VÏ�,k0GA�57>O*�N324>ã.1>O*;:ã032�>O*;HcB�032y0�,/.10324245VÏ�,k0GA�51>O*g>O6;24=<>@>3A�B É Ê Ø|]�Z;*;^;.1H/2� ÒWÓ � X@,W>3EeHG��03=<C�.7HM>O*;HÔ,k03*-,/0GE4E48`A�B;512u>OZ�Ae6�>3E � ß É Ê X

Page 88: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

��� ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

AQA À �LÀ � �s©3« ¯ Â1¤kÀ +@Z�C;C±>O24H � ß É�Ê N U Ü � 512 0 Ò ;Oض,/Z�E4KLH3NL03*;^U0e2TH/,'A�57>O*�N3be5VA�Bºo��cäEUé.1>O:uA�H'E�=?57*�03.|N03*;^ UÚ,/>O*LA[0351*;2ã0?2T51*;:O.1HP2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8��qß Ë ó � ó � ó Õ X # HJA � ](HºA4B;H Ë E�H/^;Z;,JA�51>O*q>O6�A�B;H Õ Ï;];E�H#A�B�E�>OZ;:OB� XY B;H/*aA�B;He0G](>�KLHe03*�03.V8�24572y24B;>%bu2/~2R-572�2T=?>@>3A�Ba0kb\0�8U69E�>O= � X Y B;H'E4He512�0ÔZ;*;57r@Z;H\E�H/.10GA�57KLHR=?51*;57=_03.

=?>s^;H/. �v~ �� Ò�Ó � beB;57,[Bi572ã03*i5724>O=?>3E4C�B;5724= 57*i0_*;H/57:OB�]±>OZ�E�B;>@>s^i>O6 �U×Ü �� X � ß 4 �q03*;^ Ë A�B;H51=?03:OHM>O6 Õ U Ü � 512RA�B;HP*;H':L0GA�57KLHÔ24H/,'A�57>O*�Xv)+6�o��Dä � 572e.7>O:aA�H'E4=?51*�03.®N�A4B;H/* � 512 Ë Ò ó Õ äâó Ë Ò ó Õ äï Ë Ò ó Õ ä . Ë Ò ð Õ ä Ë Ò . Õ XÔ)I6åo��-ä � 512ã*;>3AM.7A/N(A�B;H/* ��512SA�B;HgC;E�51*;,/5VCW03.�,[B�0351*�N�A�B;Hg>O*;.78q2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+803.1>O*;: � NW03*;^-A�B;HM=_0GE4QLH'^�Ï;];E�HÔ512 Ë Ò ó Õ äâó Ë Ò ó 8 Õ ä Ë Ò ó Õ XöSH'E�HM512u0UC�57,'A�Z�E�HG~

T~

T~

x

yG

E

T

-4

-1

-2-2

-2E

C

F

x

G

ET

C

-2

-2

-2E

F-1

,�57:OZ�E�H :

Page 89: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � � 0

�W��� �(� ' �����Í����� �#¬�¥w©G¥®´½¬�¼â©Gªa´�¼ � AQA À���À A � À �Sª¨ª¨ùs«_¤�Ä´�ªaÂ1¬[È"¥+¤ ° «U´�¼±©GÂ1, � ´�ª_©q«gù@ ¥®´ ¯ Â1¤ 2c§ ° ¤-¬+¸R ,Ô¬+¸U«gù@ ¥®´ ¯  ´¶³J´�¥|· n ,Ô©G¼±¹ � ³[¬�¼�¥w©G´�¼;ª_©i³J·�³J ´¶³UªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´»¥®· ,Ô¤'´�¥»­�¤ ° �Ôù ��©3Âv¬ ° ©G «?¬%ª¨¥ �Ôù ��©3Â7À � ¸� Ë ��Õ ��ó �3ï ,奻­�¤J¼ � ´�ª#¬G¼(¤g¬+¸M¥®­;¤¿¸k¬�Â�Â1¬�ûy´»¼@È �� ¸ o��`ä � ´�ªM¼(¬�¥¿Â ¥u©G¥\©G¼�·<ª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© °c¯ ¬G´�¼�¥ �

Ë ð Õ Ë ó � ó 8 � ó Õ-, n×ßéó ¬ °Ë ó Õ Ë ï � ó 8 � ó � ó Õ-, n×ß ï À

� ¸ o��`ä � ´�ªMÂ1¬�È<¥+¤ ° «g´�¼±©GÂ�©G¥u¬�¼(¤Mª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© °c¯ ¬�´�¼�¥�,c§'ù@¥v¼(¬�¥¿Â ¥ �Ë ï Õ Ë ó 8 / � Õ-, n ß . À � ´�ªa©`¼�¬�¼�ú4³¨­;©G´�¼iª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥®· ,Rûy´�¥®­¾³[¤J¼�¥ ° ¤ºÒ ó ©G¼(¹-§ ° ©G¼(³J­;¤¨ª Ë ó Õ-, Ë ó Õ-,u©3¼±¹

Ë ó � � � �-� ï 89Õ �4¬ ° Ë ï 8�Õ � ÀË . Õ Ë ó � ï 8 � ó*/¨ó 8 Õ n×ß . À

� ¸ o��`ä � ´�ªMÂ1¬�È<¥+¤ ° «g´�¼±©GÂ��9úË�� Õ Ë � ��/ Ë ;ãä�ð Õ 8�Õ-, ; � . , n ß ;Sätð À Á ­�¤ 2v§ ° ¤P´�ª

Ò Ë ;Sätð Õ ätî ;Sätð/ñ Ë Ò ð Õ ä�; Ë Ò ó Õ ätî ; Ò ð/ñ Ë Ò ó Õ ä ����� ä Ë Ò ó Õ �

Ë õ Õ Ë ó � ï 8 /¨ó 8 � ï Õ0, n×ß � À Á ­;¤ 2c§ ° ¤Ô´�ª Ë Ò ó Õ ähó Ë Ò ï Õ ä �;Ë Ò ð Õ ä�ï Ë Ò ó Õ ä Ë Ò ï Õ�ÀË � Õ Ë ï � ó � ó 8 / . 8�� ó Õ n×ß � À Á ­;¤ 2v§ ° ¤Ô´�ª Ë Ò ï Õ ähï Ë Ò ó Õ ä �;Ë Ò ó Õ ä � Ë Ò ð Õ äâó Ë Ò . Õ ä Ë Ò ó Õ�ÀË : Õ Ë . � ó 8 /[ï 8 � ó � ó Õ0, n×ß � À Á ­;¤ 2v§ ° ¤Ô´�ª Ë Ò . Õ ä . Ë Ò ó Õ ähï Ë Ò ð Õ ä � Ë Ò ï Õ äâó Ë Ò ó Õ ä Ë Ò ó Õ�À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ � *;H<,[B;H/,�Q@2PA�B�0GAMHk03,[B�>O6 Ë ð'Ø : Õ 512Ô03*�03.7.1>�bcH/^¾,'>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�51>O*�X)+@Z�C;C±>O24H<o���ä � 512M.7AkX � *;H,[B;H/,�Q�2PA4B�0GAº6�>3EºH/03,¨BÍ,'>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�51>O* Ë � Ø : Õ N 03*;^ÍH/57A4B;H'Eº>O6¿A4B;HaAwbc>-C±>O242457]�.7H?*;>O*@ؽ57*�A4H'E�51>3EÔ]�.1>�b Z�C�2/NA�B;H\E�H/24Z;.VA�51*;:Ô,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*<572�H/5VA�B;H'E�>O*;He>O6 Ë�� Ø : Õ NL>3Eå^;512403.1.1>�bcH/^U]s8gA�B;HuB�8sC(>3A�B;H'24H/2/X@+@51*;,'HuA�B;H\Ï;];E�HË Ò ó Õ äâó Ë Ò ð Õ ä Ë Ò ó Õ 512 Ë�� Õ N�;gßÝðON�bvHÔB�0kKLHP,/>O*;2T51^;H'E�H'^q03.1.(C(>O2T2457]�57.157A451H/2/X

�S>�b 24Z�C;C(>O2THao ä � 572M*;>3AÔ.7A/X Y BsZ;2MA�B;H'E�HU512ã24>O=?Hg57*�A�HJE�51>3Eã]�.1>�b Z�C�X � >O*;2451^;H'EMA�B;Hg24H/rsZ;H/*;,/H>O6�]�.1>�b�Z�C�2/X Ì HÔ](H/:O57*qbu57A4B"0?24H/rsZ;H/*;,/Hg>O6�*;>O*@ؽ57*�A�HJE�51>3E�]�.7>%b�Z�C�2/N(:O5VK�57*;:?>O*;Hº>O6�A�B;HºÏ;];E�H'2 Ë�� Ø : Õ X� 03.1.(A�B;572e,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA451>O* �åX Y B;H/*-bcHÔ=_0GQLHM0a2TA4E451*;: � � >O6 = - ðÔ51*LA�H'E�57>3Eu]�.7>%bçZ�C�2/X

+@Z�C;C(>O2THPA�B;H'E�Hº0GE�HPAwbc>?2457*;:OZ;.90GE�C±>O51*LA�2�03.7>O*;: � X Y B;H/*�bcHº=?0GQLHÔ57*"03^;^;57A�57>O*"0GA�.7Hk032TAe>O*;Hº*;>O*@Ø51*LA�H'E451>3Eã]�.1>�b Z�C�X � Ë �SÕ - ó �3ïDZ;*;.7H/242 �â512ã:O5VKLH/*i]�8 Ë�� Õ be5VA�B ;-ßÖðOXE= - ó`:O5VKLH/2 Ë ï Õ N�03*;^ =_ßàð:O57KLH'2 Ë . Õ XåíS*L8D6�Z�E4A�B;H'Ee]�.1>�bçZ�C"B�032 � Ë ��Õ.- ó �3ï�X

+@Z�C;C(>O2TH`A4B;H'E�H_512#>O*;.V8�>O*;H`2457*;:OZ;.90GEºC±>O51*LAU03.1>O*;: � Ny,'8@,/.157,`03*;^ MZ H¿03.¿>3EU03.7=?>O2TA ãZ H¿03.�]�8032424Z;=aC;A�51>O*�X Y B;H'*�=jß ð Ë >3A�B;H'E4bu512TH-A�B;H"2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8�,k03*;*;>3A?]±H",'8�,'.151, Õ X � :O57KLH/*h]�8 Ë�� Õ be5VA�B;¾ßÄð � ó�0GE�H<A�B;H_>O*;.V8¾C(>O2T2457]�57.157A451H/2º57*ÍbeB;57,¨BÍA�B;H_2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457Aw8�572 ãZ H¿03.¿>3E#03.1=?>O2TA ãZ H¿03.|X Y B;572:O57KLH'2 Ë ð Õ 03*;^ Ë ó Õ X �S>_6�Z�E4A�B;H'Eã]�.7>%b�Z�CÐ512�C(>O2T2457]�.7H Ë A�B;Hº*;H �@AS]�.1>�bÝZ�CÐB�032�A�>?]±H#*;>O*@ؽ57*�A�HJE�51>3E Õ N�032A�B;HÔ2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8_bu51.1.�*;>3AR](H ãZ>Hv03.�>3Ee03.1=<>O2TA�ãZ>Hv03.®X �

Page 90: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

0 + ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

�W��� �(�»�s� �¿���Í������.Wù ¯L¯ ¬%ª�¤ Þ Ü:4>5 ´�ªP©3¼q´ °¨° ¤�¹GùW³J´|§'Â1¤#³'ù ° µ3¤g¬+¸P¹�¤wÈ ° ¤[¤ � - ó ,v© ° ´�¥®­�«?¤J¥|´¶³SÈs¤J¼�ùsª � À� ¸ � � ð ,�¥®­;¤J¼�¤J´»¥»­;¤ °

Ë ð Õ �aß Å , �-ß Å ©G¼±¹ Þ � ßéó � ,\¬ °Ë ó Õ �aß Å , �#ßéó , ��ßÝð ©G¼±¹ Þ � ß . ,\¬ °Ë ï Õ �aßÝð , �#ß ï ©G¼±¹ ��ßÝð ,\¬ °Ë . Õ �aßÝð , �#ßéó ©G¼±¹ � � ó À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Ë o�� ä#Þ Õ � Þ � Å�X $cZ�A Ë o�� ägÞ Õ � � - Å�NGbeB;HJE�H �t572�0e24=<>@>3A�BPÏ;];E4H3NL03*;^ Ë o���ägÞ Õ � U =àÃëÅ�NZ;*;.1H'242 � � ó@N�beB;HJE�H�U = :OH/*;H'E[0GA�H'2ÔA�B;H?>3A4B;H'EºH �@A4E�H/=?03.yE�0�8LX Ì E�57A�HUÞ *�Z;=?H'E�57,k03.1.V8¾032 � U ä�=��<X� *;HP,/>O=<C�Z�A4H/2 =gZ;2457*;: Ë oÖä�Þ Õ�� ÞÚßçó � Ò ó@NW03*;^-A�B;H'*�,[B;H/,�Q�2uA4B;HÔE�H/2TZ;.7AkX ��W��� �(�»�W� �¿���Í������.Wù ¯L¯ ¬%ªk¤ RM~ � Ò�Ó É�Ê_´�ªa©DÂ1¬�È �©G¼�¬;2v§ ° ©3¥®´¶¬G¼m¬+¸ ° ¤JÂ7©G¥|´�µ3¤ *c´¶³[© ° ¹`¼�ù@«<§¨¤ ° ¬G¼(¤0,È�¤J¼�¤ ° ©G 2v§ ° ¤\É�Ê�, � ´�ªP©Uªk¤¨³J¥®´½¬�¼ , Þ ´�ª ° ©G¥®´½¬�¼±©GÂ1,v©G¼Ð´ °¨° ¤�¹GùW³J´|§'Â1¤P¹�¬�ù�§'Â1¤Mª�¤[³J¥|´¶¬�¼ ,v©G¼(¹ �Ä©G¼(¹ Þ «?¤[¤J¥©G¥P¬�¼W ·"ª¨«?¬�¬G¥»­ ¯ ¬�´�¼W¥»ªD¬+¸ �UÀq£ ¤'¥ � Ê ©G¼±¹ � � §¨¤?¥»­;¤32v§ ° ¤¨ª5,ãû�­;¤ ° ¤ Rcl � ­�©�ªD© ° ©G«g´ 2c³�©G¥|´¶¬�¼ ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥wÀ£ ¤'¥ � §J¤P¥®­;¤ºù@¼�´|ø/ù�¤º«g´�¼�´�«?©GÂ�«?¬�¹�¤J �c~ �� Ò�Ó � ß 4>5 ,e¬+¸ � AQA À���À�� � , � A A À��LÀ�� � ,媨ùW³¨­�¥®­�©G¥ � ´�ªg©G¼´�ªk¬G«?¬ °¶¯ ­�´�ª¨«Ö´»¼¾©?¼(¤'´1È�­�§¨¬Gù ° ­;¬�¬k¹`¬+¸ ��_À � ¸ o��Dä�Þ ´�ªM ¥ ,v¥»­�¤J¼

Ë ð Õ �e¼�·?«gù@ ¥|´ ¯ Â1¤ 2v§ ° ¤º´�ªº¤J´�¥®­;¤ ° � Ê ¬ ° � � �w¥»­;¬GùOÈ�­q¤J´�¥®­;¤ ° � � «g´1ÈG­�¥R§¨¤Mª¨«?¬%¬�¥»­ � ÀË ó Õ �#¤J´�¥®­;¤ ° � ¼�¬ ° Þ ³¨¬�¼�¥w©G´�¼;ªM«_¬ ° ¤º¥»­�©3¼q¥®ûc¬aª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ª#¬I¸��gÀË ï Õ � l � ´�ªº©G¼q´�ªk¬�«?¬ °½¯ ­�´�ªJ«<À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ #�H'A � ](Ha0D=gZ;.7A457C�.1H#Ï;];E�HGX�+@Z�C;C±>O24H � 572Ô*;H'57A�B;H'E � Ê *;>3E�� � X Y B;H/*iHk03,[B¾C(>O57*�AM>O6 � � �03*;^ � � Þ 512u0a2457*;:OZ;.90GEuC(>O51*LAkN;,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�57*;: Ë ðOðOX � X � Õ X�öSH/*;,/H Ë ð Õ X

Ë ó Õ 6�>O.1.7>%bu2RHk032451.V8LN;Z;2451*;: Ë ðOðOX � X � Õ X+@Z�C;C(>O2TH Ë ï Õ ^;>@H/2º*;>3APB;>O.1^�X Y B;H/*Í>O*;Ha>O6¿A�B;H<E[03=<57Ï�,k0GA�57>O*ÐC±>O51*LA�2P>O6¿Þ 512P2T=?>@>3A�BÐ>O* � N�03*;^

B�032#0�,/Z;2IC�>O* � X � >O*;2457^;H'E�57*;:�A�B;H<Ï;E�2TAPA+bv>-]�.1>�b Z�C�2#>O6 �±N bcH<24H/H?A�B�0GAPÞ ^;>@H/2º*;>3Aº=?H/H'AÔA�B;HH ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.�.7>@,/Z;2\>O6 ��çÒ±Ó � A4E[03*;2IKLH'E�2�03.7.78LN�0g,/>O*�ATE[03^;51,'A451>O* Ë 2451*;,/HãbcHÔ032424Z;=?HMo��`ämÞ 512R.7A Õ X ��W��� �(�»� 5 �¿���Í����� �#¬�¥½©3¥®´¶¬G¼�©�ªR´»¼ � AQA À��LÀ A � ,�� AQA À���À � � À+.Wù ¯L¯ ¬%ªk¤ Ri~ �çÒ±Ó �Ú´�ªS©uÉ�ÊGú 2v§ ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼ ,�©3¼±¹� Ü �à´�ªº©G¼Ð´ °¨° ¤�¹GùW³J´|§'Â1¤ 2c§ ° ¤g³¨¬�¼�¥w©G´�¼(¤�¹?´�¼q¥®­;¤ �Ôù ��©GÂ�Â1¬�³Jùsªg¬+¸��UÀ�c¼�¤U¬+¸M¥®­;¤å¸�¬�Â�Â1¬�ûy´�¼�È<­;¬�Â7¹Gª��

Ë ð Õ �à´�ªãª¨«?¬%¬�¥»­"©GÂ1¬�¼@È�_ÀË ó Õ Á ­;¤ ° ¤i© ° ¤i¤��s©�³J¥| ·m¥|ûv¬�ª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥®´½¤¨ª5, � Ê ¯ ¬G´�¼�¥®ª5,?©GÂ1¬�¼@È��`À o��¾ä � ´�ª- ¥½À Á ­;¤ 2c§ ° ¤"´�ª

Ë Ò ó Õ ähó Ë Ò ð Õ ä Ë Ò ó Õ �½¼(¬�¥w©G¥|´¶¬�¼¾©�ªÔ´�¼ � A A À��LÀ � � � ÀË ï Õ Á ­;¤ ° ¤Ô´�ª#©?ù@¼�´|ø'ùW¤Ôª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥|· ,c©G¼ � � ¯ ¬G´�¼�¥\©GÂ1¬�¼@È� , Ë ó � ó 8 � ó ÕkÀË . Õ Á ­;¤ ° ¤Ô´�ª#©?ù@¼�´|ø'ùW¤Ôª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥|· ,c© Þ 5 ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥�,v©GÂ1¬�¼�È � ,�´�¥®ªº§ ° ©3¼(³¨­;¤¨ª#© ° ¤ Ë ó Õ-, Ë ó Õg©G¼±¹

Ë ó � � � � � ó 8 Õ0,¿û�­;¤ ° ¤Ô¥»­�¤g³[¤J¼�¥ ° ©3Â�³Jù ° µ3¤º«?¤[¤J¥®ªM¥®­;¤Pù@¼±¹�¤ °  ´�¼(¤�¹-³Jù ° µ3¤0,\©G¼±¹ � «?¤[¤'¥»ªP¥»­;¤ ¯±° ´�«_¤�¹³Jù ° µ3¤�À

Page 91: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � 0 .

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Y B;HM>O*;.78?C±>O242457]�57.15VA�51H/2\6�>3E �_buB;51,[B�8@51H/.7^�ãZOHv03.(2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457A�57H/2R0GE�H Ë Ò ó Õ ä�ó Ë Ò ð Õ ä Ë Ò ó Õ N;>3EA�B;572u,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E�0GA�51>O*�6�>O.7.1>�bcH/^-]�8�0a24H'r@Z;H/*;,/HP>O6 51*LA�H'E451>3ER]�.1>�b�Z�C�2'X �Ì Hãbe57.1.�Z;24HMA�B;HP6�>O.7.1>�be57*;:?03^@ضB;>@,ãE�H/24Z;.VA�51* � ð�.;X

�W��� �(�»� ( �¿���Í����� �#¬�¥½©3¥®´¶¬G¼m©Gªº´»¼ � AQA À��LÀ A � À � ¸ � ´�ªg©�«Uùs ¥|´ ¯ Â1¤=2c§ ° ¤?¬+¸#«gù@ ¥®´ ¯  ´¶³J´�¥|· n ß ï ,u©3¼±¹¥®­;¤g³[¬�¤ !�³J´½¤J¼�¥�� Ë ��Õ ��ó �3ï ¥®­;¤J¼ � ´�ª#¬�¼(¤g¬I¸M¥»­�¤ 2v§ ° ¤¨ªM´�¼Ð¥»­;¤a³JÂ7©�ª[ªJ´ 2c³�©G¥|´¶¬�¼ � AQA À��LÀ � � À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ � >O*;2457^;H'EãA�B;HºC(>O242T57]�51.757A�57H/2�6�>3E���032�](H/.7>%b Ë ðOðOX � X . Õ X\)+A�512SHk032T8�A�>_24H/H#A�B�0GAeA�B;H#>O*;.78�b\0�8�A�>:OH'AR0#Ï;];E�Hã>O6 =gZ;.VA�57C�.751,/5VA+8UA�B�E�H'HÔ572vA�>#](H/:O57*Dbu57A�B Ë Ò ï Õ äÍï Ë Ò ð Õ äjó Ë Ò ó Õ ä Ë Ò ó Õ 03*;^D=_0GQLHã0#24H'E�57H/2>O6 = - Å?51*LA�H'E�57>3Ee]�.7>%b�Z�C�2/XeíS69A4H'E�Awbc>_51*LA�H'E451>3E�]�.7>%b Z�C�2�A�B;H'E4H#512S0<*;>O*@ض,[B�0351*"C(>O57*�AS>O6�,'>@H�!<,/51H/*LAó �3ï�X2,�>3E = � ðON�A�B;HÔÏ;];E4H/2�0GE�HÔ51* Ë ðOðOX � X # Õ X �

�%� - � ���¾&L�����;� j$ 0 $��(�W� l o���ä � l

�#� �ëþ½��K K»�@�?�»� ý�� �����;�%�»���Ú�»¡ 9 � ��� �%� �%��� ý±� �±� �Í�%� � ¡/��ÿ3�%���±���D£ ¤'¥3'ħ¨¤Ð© ° ©3¼ F ¬�¼�¤-Â1¬�È�¹�¤JÂ*�¤�����¬#ª¨ù ° ¸/©s³[¤kÀc£ ¤'¥ � Ü '�© ° ¤�¹3ù�³[¤[¹_©G¼±¹a´ °J° ¤�¹GùW³J´|§/Â1¤Ô¹3´�µ�´�ªk¬ ° ,�ª¨ùW³¨­`¥»­;©G¥yÒ Ë o��Ôä Ë ð��Oó Õ �MÕã´�ªÔ©G« ¯ Â1¤©G¼±¹ o��gä � ´�ªºÂ ¥e©G¥cªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© °u¯ ¬�´»¼�¥»ªa¬+¸ 'eÀ �º¬G¥w¤g´�¼ ¯ © ° ¥®´¶³'ùsÂ7© ° � ­�©�ª ¯ Â7©G¼(© ° ª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ª5,R©G¼±¹D´�ª¥®­�ù�ª �S¬ ° ¤'¼;ª¨¥+¤J´�¼±À��ãª[ª¨ù@«?¤U¥®­;¤<© ° ´»¥»­�«_¤J¥®´½³ÔÈs¤J¼�ùsª � ¬I¸ � ´�ªa©G¥uÂ1¤�©�ª¨¥S¬�¼(¤kÀ =D~ �'tÒ�Ó ' ¹�¤J¼(¬�¥+¤¨ª#¥®­;¤«g´�¼W´�«<©GÂy¹�¤¨ª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�ªk©G¥®´½¬�¼Í¬+¸ ' ,e©G¼(¹_¥|´�Â7¹�¤¨ªU¹�¤J¼�¬�¥w¤#ª¨¥ ° ´½³J¥c¥ ° ©G¼;ª�¸�¬ ° «#ªkÀ㣠¤J¥ Þ ß �tä � ¬+¸ � A B�À � �§¨¤JÂ1¬Gû¿À\£ ¤'¥ Þ §¨¤M¥®­;¤ ° ¤[¹Gù�³'¥®´¶¬G¼Ð¬I¸ Þ À\£ ¤J¥ T Ò±Ó 'ݤ �O¥ ° ©�³J¥\¤��s©�³J¥| ·<¥»­;¤#¤ �@³[¤ ¯ ¥|´¶¬�¼(©GÂ�¹3´�µ�´�ªk¬ ° ª��T¬+¸S¥®­;¤«g´�¼W´�«<©G ¹s¤¨ª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© ° ´�ª/©G¥|´¶¬�¼ � ©L¹I²/©�³¨¤J¼�¥¿¥w¬ �<À

�S>3A�HSA�B;HP032424Z;=<C;A�57>O*;2u57=<C�.78O=Wl ��512u03*�512T>O=?>3E4C�B;512T=�X

� 5(�7� 7��:9������%�������¿�@�Í����� � Ê Ë d �� Õ ß � 3 Ë d �� Õ ß Å ©G¼±¹ � 3 Ë d �� Ë ��ãÕ4Õ + � 3 Ë d � Õ�À Á ­�¤ ° ¤?© ° ¤U´�¼�¥+¤Jú

È ° ©GÂ1,\¤»ÆS¤¨³J¥®´»µ3¤0, �q¤J´� ¹3´�µ�´�ªk¬ ° ª � � � Ü '+, U Ü �' ûy´�¥®­�¥®­;¤å¸k¬GÂ�Â1¬�ûy´�¼@È ¯±° ¬ ¯ ¤ ° ¥|´¶¤¨ª��Ë ð Õ ���ä �� ä U ��l o �� ä �� l , ��ä � ��l o��ºä � l ÀË ó Õ Á ­;¤Pª¨ù ¯L¯ ¬ ° ¥\¬+¸ U ´�ª �'�Ò�Ó '�¤��@³¨¤ ¯ ¥|´¶¬�¼±©GÂ7ÀË ï Õ l ��`l ­�©�ªM¼�¬ 2 �@¤[¹D³[¬�« ¯ ¬�¼(¤J¼�¥®ª/À �#¬�³[¬�« ¯ ¬G¼(¤J¼�¥R¬+¸ �� «?¬�µ3¤Jª/À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Y B;H_Ï;E�2TAUH/rsZ�03.157A451H/2#B;>O.7^�2457*;,/H �' 512ºE�0GA�51>O*�03.®X Y B;H`24H/,/>O*;^�6�>O.1.7>%b 69E�>O= A�B;H_Ï;E�2TAa03*;^mA�B;HH �;03,'Ae2TH/r@Z;H/*;,'H

Å Ò�Ó d �� Ò�Ó d �� Ë ��MÕvÒ�Ó d � Ò�Ó Å �

$v8g032424Z;=aC;A�51>O*�N(l d � lk572y*;>O*@ؽH/=<C;Aw8LX Y B�Z;2Ml o �� ä �� lk572y*;>O*@ؽH/=<C;Aw8LX Ì HR,/03*UbRE�57A4Hu0S:OH/*;HJE[03.;=?H/=#](HJE032 ��çä �� ä U_N buB;H'E�H �� 512MA�B;H?=?>�K�57*;:�CW0GE4A/N �� ä U 572ÔA�B;HaÏ"�;H/^�CW0GE4A/N�03*;^ U 512MA�B;H �'ÝÒ�Ó 'H ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.åCW0GE4A/X �S>%b .7H'A � � � ](H<A4B;H<51=?03:OH/2Ô>O6 �� � �� X �S>3A�H �� 03*;^ �� 0GE�H<57*;^;H/H/^ÍA�B;Ha2TA4E�57,'AA4E[03*;2T6�>3E�=?2R>O6 � 03*;^ � N;]�8D,/>O*;2TA4E�Z;,JA�51>O*�X �

Page 92: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

0�) ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

� 5(�»� �¿���Í����� �#¬�¥½©3¥®´¶¬G¼¾©�ªÔ´»¼ � A B@À � � ÀË ð Õ o��ºä�Þ ´�ªM¼�¤½ÈL©G¥|´�µ3¤ �½¥®­�©G¥v´�ª#©G¼�¥|´�úT©G« ¯ Â1¤ � ©G¼±¹ Þ ­�©�ªº© ° ´�¥®­�«?¤J¥|´¶³SÈs¤J¼�ùsª ��¤ ° ¬OÀË ó Õ � ¸ Þ ´�ª ° ¤�¹GùW³J´|§/Â1¤0, ¥®­;¤J¼`¥®­;¤�ùs¼�´½¬�¼"¬+¸u¥»­;¤ ¯ ©G´ ° ûy´�ªk¤R´»¼�¥w¤ ° ªk¤[³'¥®´¶¬G¼-¬+¸ã³[¬G« ¯ ¬�¼(¤'¼�¥»ªã¬+¸ Þ ³[¬G¼;ª¨´�ª¨¥®ª

¬+¸º©?ª¨´�¼@È3Â1¤ ¯ ¬�´�¼W¥ � ÀË ï Õ � �ß % ´ÇÆ � - ó À l����l ´�ªº§[©�ªk¤ ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥�¸ ° ¤[¤kÀË . Õ Þ � +@57*;: Ë 'åÕ<³[¬G¼�¥½©3´�¼;ª#©3¼�·D¼(¬G¼ �Ôù ��©G ª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥®·"¬+¸3'+,e©G¼±¹�©G¼�·_ªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´»¥®·�¬I¸3'�û�­s´¶³¨­

 ´¶¤¨ªg¬�¼ �<ÀË�� Õ � ¸ Þ ´�ª ° ¤�¹GùW³J´|§'Â1¤-,�¥»­�¤J¼ o��ºä Þ ´�ª ¯  ¥u©Gû¿©G·e¸ ° ¬�« � ÀË õ Õ ��Ö´�ªº¹3´�ª�²k¬�´»¼�¥�¸ ° ¬�« �� ©G¼±¹ U ÀË � Õ Á ­;¤gªJù ¯L¯ ¬ ° ¥ã¬+¸ �� ´�ªa©"¹G´�ª�²k¬�´�¼W¥\ùs¼W´¶¬�¼�¬+¸ºÒ ð ú�³Jù ° µ3¤¨ª/À �� Ü T ´�ª?³¨¬�¼�¥ ° ©�³J¥|´|§'Â1¤<§'·"©Dªk¤ ° ´¶¤¨ª

¬+¸ o ú+¼(¤½ÈL©G¥|´�µ3¤<³[¬�¼W¥ ° ©�³J¥|´¶¬�¼;ª5,�©3¼±¹D¥»­;¤U¼Wùs«<§J¤ ° ¬+¸#´ °J° ¤�¹3ù�³J´¶§'Â1¤?³[¬�« ¯ ¬G¼(¤J¼�¥®ª?¬+¸ � ´�ªa©G¥u«?¬%ª¨¥¥®­;¤Ô¼�ù@«<§¨¤ ° ¬+¸Mª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥®´½¤¨ªP©GÂ1¬�¼@È �<À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ o��#äjÞàßéó Ë o��ºätð��Oó �MÕ 572u*;H/:L0GA457KLH3X Ë ð Õ N Ë ó Õ 03*;^ Ë�� Õ 6�>O.7.1>�bé]s8�03^�FIZ;*;,'A�57>O*�X� 3 Ë d � Õ - ðM57è � Ë �MÕ - ó@X Ë ï Õ 6�>O.1.1>�bu2/N;2451*;,'HP0U=?>%K@51*;:g24=?>s>3A�B_E[0GA�57>O*�03.(,/Z�E4KLHM>O*�0g24Z�E�6�03,/HMbe5VA�B

� Ê Ë76 � Õ ß ÅU512\]W0324H'C±>O51*LA�69E�H/HGXË õ Õ 6�>O.1.7>%bu2R69E�>O= Ë ð%ó@X � Õ X,�E�>O= o �� ä ��tÒ �� Ò �� ß U_NWbcH#24H/H#A�B�0GA UÖ572�*;H/6½N�03*;^qB;H/*;,/H#]s8 Ë ó@X1ð # Õ >O6uî}ó � ñ¶N±H'=<C;Aw8LN±>�KLH'E

03*L8DC±>O51*LAe*;>3Au,/>O*LA[0351*;H'^"51* � ä�<X Ë . Õ 6�>O.1.1>�bu2/X,W>3E Ë � Õ bcHÔZ;24HÔA4B;HÔ6�>O.7.1>�be57*;:;~

J K��W�®�h�D£ ¤J¥ �Ð~ T Ò�Ó � §¨¤ ¯±° ¬ ¯ ¤ ° §/´ ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼(©GÂW«<© ¯ ,åû�­�´¶³J­?´�ªã©G¼�´�ª�¬�«?¬ °½¯ ­�´�ª¨«Ú´�¼Ð©U¼(¤J´9È�­�§¨¬�ù ° ­�¬�¬k¹¬+¸ �� Ü T�À<£ ¤J¥ � §¨¤?©G¼h¤»Æã¤[³J¥|´�µ3¤<¹G´�µ�´�ªk¬ ° ¬�¼ T$,ã¹G´�ª�²k¬G´�¼�¥�¸ ° ¬�« �� ,RªJù�³¨­q¥®­�©G¥ � ©3¼±¹)T Ò�Ó ' © ° ¤2å¼�´»¥w¤g¬G¼ � À Á ­;¤J¼

Ågà � Ë � Õ � Ë o��Dä � Ë ��ãÕTÕ ßto�� � � Ë � Õ �

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ +@57*;,/H Ò o��`512c03=aC�.1H3N�A�B;H'E�HS572c03*_H'è(H','A�57KLH � ؽ^;5VK�5724>3E �Ð24Z�C;C(>3ETA�H/^`>O*_A�B;HSH �;,'H'C;A�51>O*�03.�.1>s,/Z;2>O6 T Ò�Ó ' 24Z;,[B�A�B�0GA Ò Ë o# Ðä � Õ 572e03=aC�.1H3X Ì HMB�0�KLH

ÅaÃ Ë o��Dä � Ë � Õ4Õ � � Ë � Õ - o�� � � Ë � Õ ß Ë o��`ä � Ë ��ãÕ4Õ � � Ë � Õ � ��S>�bé.1H'A �Ð~ T Ò�Ó �ç,/>O*�ATE[03,'AR24>O=?Hã,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*LA�2u>O6 �� Ë bcHM03.7.1>�b �"A�>g](HãA�B;Hã51^;H/*LA�5VA+8 Õ X�# H'A �

](HMA�B;HãE�H/^;Z;,'A�57>O*�>O6�24>O=<HM,'>O=<C(>O*;H/*LA�>O6 � beB;57,¨B-512R*;>3Ae,/>O*LA4E[03,JA�H/^�X $v8 Ë õ Õ 03*;^�A4B;HP,/.10351=

Ågà � Ë � Õ � Ë o��_ä � Ë ��ãÕ4Õ ß � Ë � Õ � o��iß � Ë � Õ � � Ë �� ä ���ä U Õ.- � Ë � Õ �

Y BsZ;2 � Ë � Õ ,k03*<]±Hu,'>O*�A4E�03,'A�H/^�Ns51*U6�03,'A¿]�8a0Mo���ض*;H/:L0GA�5VKLHu,/>O*LA4E[03,JA�51>O*�X Y BsZ;2'N � ,k03*<]±Hu,'>O*�A4E�03,'A�H/^]�8-0U24H'E�57H/2e>O6 oqض*;H/:L0GA�57KLHM,/>O*LA4E[03,'A451>O*;2/X Ë � Õ 6�>O.1.1>�bu2/X �

Page 93: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � 0-�

� 5(� 5 �¿���Í����� .Wù ¯L¯ ¬%ªk¤ ' ß ' Ê ¬+¸M¥®­;¤P­�ùs¼W¥½À � ¸3' 3 ¹�¬�¤JªM¼(¬�¥�­�©Gµ3¤U©<¥|´1È�¤ ° ,�¥»­�¤J¼Í¤JµO¤ ° ·D³[¬�« ¯ ¬�¼(¤J¼�¥¬+¸ � ³[¬�¼W¥½©G´»¼;ªº©G¥vÂ1¤�©�ªJ¥�¥|ûv¬aªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´»¥®´¶¤Jªº¬+¸ '�À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ +@Z�C;C±>O24H � 572?0¾,/>O=aC(>O*;H/*LA<>O6�� CW03242T51*;:¾A�B�E4>OZ;:OBâ0¾Z;*;51rsZ;H-2457*;:OZ;.90GEaC(>O51*LA�� Ë 57Aa=gZ;2TA,/>O*LA[0351*?0Ô2457*;:OZ;.90GEåC(>O51*LAkN�>3Ev5VAåbv>OZ;.1^<]±He,/>O*LA4E[03,'A457]�.1Hu>O* 'åÕ X�íS2 �� 572�^;572»FI>O51*LAv69E�>O= �� NL]s8 Ë ð%ó@X7ðOXpõ Õ N��512º0�C(>O57*�A#>O6 � X � ,k03*;*;>3A#=?H'H'A Ê >O* � Ê N�6�>3E#>3A�B;H'ETbe5724H��"ß R Ë Ê Õ N�0�2T51*;:OZ;.90GEÔC(>O57*�A#>O6 � XY BsZ;2 � =<H/H'A�2 U Ê 0GA�0U2451*;:OZ;.10GEuC±>O51*LA�>O6 � Ê 03*;^ � 3 572RA4B;HÔ>O*;.V8�2T51*;:OZ;.90GERC(>O57*�Au>O6 ' 3 03.7>O*;: � X

#�H'AcÞà](H�A�B;HSZ;*;57r@Z;HSH ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.(,/Z�E4KLHS>O6 �' 3 buB;51,[B�=<H/H'A�2 � Ë A�B;H'E4HS512\0ºZ;*;51rsZ;HSÞà]s8 Ë .;X1ð%ó@X ó Õ03*;^ Ë ð%ó@X7ðOX1ð Õ4Õ NO03*;^?.1HJA �`~ � 8 Ò�Ó ' 3 ]±HuA�B;HRH �@A4E[03,'A�57>O*<>O6�Þ"X Y B;H/* � 572¿0 Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLHe57*<A�B;HR24=?>s>3A�B.1>s,/Z;2R>O6 � 8 NW03*;^�bcHÔ=_0�8`,'>O*�A4E�03,'A�� >O* � 8 A�><>3];A�0351* ' 8 X@#�H'A�Þ 8 ]±HÔA�B;HM51=_03:OHã>O6�Þ 51* ' 8 X

$v8`A�B;HP,/.10324245VÏ�,k0GA�51>O*->O6�.7ARC(>O57*�A�2'N�576�o�����ä�Þ 8 512u.1,ãA�B;H/*"5VAe572�03*LA�5Vض*;H/6y03*;^-bcHÔB�0�KLH#0gA�51:OHJEkX%+@>bcHÔ,k03*�03242TZ;=?HÔA�B�0GA � 3 572e0<*;>O*@ض,[B�0351*�2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8-03*;^�>O*;HP>O6�A�B;HP2457*;:OZ;.90GERC(>O57*�A�2e03.1>O*;:0U Ê >3A4B;H'EA�B�03* �UB�032\57*;^;H ��0GA\.1Hk032IAcA�B�E�H/H3X Y BsZ;2 �UB�032\57*;^;H ��0GA\=?>O2TA � XåíS2�� � àÅ�N�5VA\6�>O.1.1>�bu2\A4B�0GA �ºß ���Ë FIZ;2TA�,/>O*;2451^;HJESA�B;HPC(>O2T2457]�57.157A451H/2/NW24H/HP6�>3ESH ��03=aC�.1HÔA4B;HPC;E�>@>O6�>O6 Ë ð�Å�Xpõ Õ4Õ N�03*;^qÞ 572eA�B;HPC;E451=?H/^-,/Z�E4KLHË ó � ó 8�� ó � ó Õ X�$\Z�A�A4B;H/* Ë o���ä �MÕ � � � Ò ð;ä?ï � � � Å�NL03*;^ Ò Ë o���ä �MÕ 512å03=<C�.1HGNO0S,/>O*�ATE[03^;51,'A451>O*�X �� 5(��(�� �º¬G¥½©G¥|´¶¬�¼�©�ªM´�¼ � A B@À ��� À=.Wù ¯L¯ ¬%ªk¤ �Ußéó À Á ­;¤J¼

Ë ð Õ �� ´�ªM¥®­;¤ 2v§ ° ¤g¬+¸#© ° ù@ ´�¼@È-¬�¼ �'+, ��×´�ªº©D¹�¬�ù�§'Â1¤Ôªk¤¨³J¥®´½¬�¼±ÀË ó Õ �� ´�ªº¹G´�ª»²k¬�´�¼�¥W¸ ° ¬G« �� ©G¼±¹ U ¬�¼ �'eÀË ï Õ � ¸ Î�� � ´�ªã©Pª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© °å¯ ¬�´�¼�¥�, ¥®­;¤J¼q¤J´�¥®­;¤ ° � «?¤[¤J¥®ªu¥®­;¤uªk©G«?¤M³'ù ° µ3¤Ô¬Gµ3¤ ° Î ©�ª � ,¿¬ ° � «?¤[¤J¥®ª

©D³Jù ° µO¤U¬+¸ãª�¤J ¸¨úw´�¼W¥w¤ ° ªk¤[³J¥|´¶¬�¼Ð©G¥v«?¬�ª¨¥¿Ò ï À� ¸ Î � � á � � � ´�ªº©?ª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© °c¯ ¬�´�¼W¥ ,�¥®­;¤J¼ U ´�ª#¤J« ¯ ¥®·-¬�µO¤ ° Î ©3¼±¹

Ë . Õ � ¸ Î � �×¥®­;¤J¼ Î ´�ª �Ôù ��©GÂ�©G¼±¹ � «?¤¨¤J¥»ªÔ¥»­;¤Pª/©G«?¤U¤��@³[¤ ¯ ¥®´¶¬G¼±©G ³Jù ° µ3¤U©G¥ Î ©�ª �<ÀË�� Õ � ¸ Î �� �×¥®­;¤J¼ Î ­�©�ªMûc¤J´1È�­�¥R¬�¼(¤-,c©G¼±¹ � «?¤¨¤J¥»ªP¥»­�¤Ôùs¼W´|ø'ùW¤ÔÒ ï ú�³Jù ° µ3¤kÀ

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ $v8 Ë ð%ó@X7ðOXpï Õ 03*;^ Ë ð%ó@X7ðOXpõ Õ bcHÔB�0�KLH

Å � �� � �Ë ��âä �� ä U Õ � ���ß Ë o �� ä ��MÕ � �� � Ò óRä �� � ��

ß Ò óRä �� � Ë o �� ä ��ãÕ ßéó Ë � Ò ó Õ �

Ë ð'Øwó Õ 6�>O.7.1>�bPX,W>3E Ë . Õ 03*;^ Ë�� Õ N Ë ó Õ 03*;^�A�B;H<H/r@Z�03.757Aw8¾o �� ä ��çÒ �� ß U >%KLHJEuÎj51=aC�.784U 572º*;H/6c>�KLH'EeÎ�N A�B�Z;2

H/=<C;Aw8LN�]�8 Ë ó@X1ð # Õ >O6cî}ó � ñ¶X Ë . Õ 03*;^ Ë�� Õ 6�>O.1.7>%bÔX Ë ï Õ 512R2451=?57.90GEkX �� 5(� �¿���Í���

�7��:9������%�����¿� �º¬G¥½©G¥|´¶¬�¼ç©�ª�´�¼ � A B@À ��� À .Wù ¯�¯ ¬%ªk¤ �tß ð À �R· � A B@À A À�� � �� Ü T ´�ª

³[¬�¼W¥ ° ©�³J¥|´|§'Â1¤0,gÂ1¤J¥ RÔ~ T Ò�Ó � §J¤-¥®­;¤i³¨¬�¼�¥ ° ©�³J¥|´¶¬�¼(Àë£ ¤J¥ � ß � � � §¨¤-¥®­;¤¾¤��@³[¤ ¯ ¥®´¶¬G¼±©GÂ\Â1¬�³'ù�ªi¬+¸

Page 94: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

0 � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

Ñ ~ TÖÒ�Ó '�À �R·D¥»­;¤<¹�¤ 2å¼�´�¥|´¶¬�¼m¬+¸ T$, � ´�ªP¥®­;¤#ùs¼W´¶¬�¼�¬+¸#¥»­�¤a¤���³[¤ ¯ ¥|´¶¬�¼±©3Â�¹G´»µ�´�ªk¬ ° ª �T¬I¸ �' � ©L¹T²/©�³[¤J¼W¥¥+¬ �<À\£ ¤J¥ Þ � ß R Ë � � Õ�À\£ ¤J¥ �� Ü Tì§J¤Ô¥»­�¤Ôª¨¥ ° ´¶³'¥�¥ ° ©G¼�ª�¸k¬ ° « ¬+¸ �<À �q¤Ô­�©Gµ3¤

Ë ð Õ Á ­;¤ ° ©3¼ F ¬+¸ � ´�ªM¬�¼�¤�«?¬ ° ¤ã¥»­;©G¼�¥»­;¤Ô¹G´ÇÆ㤠° ¤J¼�³[¤ã§¨¤'¥®ûv¤¨¤J¼�¥®­;¤ã¼�ù@«<§¨¤ ° ¬I¸uª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© °å¯ ¬�´�¼�¥®ªÔ¬�¼� ©G¼±¹_¥»­�¤Ô¼�ù@«<§¨¤ ° ¬+¸Ô´ °¨° ¤[¹Gù�³'´|§'Â1¤#³[¬�« ¯ ¬�¼(¤J¼W¥»ª#¬I¸ � À

Ë ó Õ R ´�ª#©G¼q´�ªk¬G«?¬ °¶¯ ­�´�ª¨«Ö´»¼¾©?¼(¤'´1È�­�§¨¬Gù ° ­;¬�¬k¹`¬+¸ ��aÀË ï Õ � ��l Ò o���l , � Ü � 3 ,c©G¼(¹� ´�ª ��¬ ° ¤J¼;ªJ¥w¤J´»¼±ÀË . Õ Þ � �� ßÝð ÀË�� Õ � ¸ �ij[¬�¼W¥½©G´»¼;ªº¬�¼� ·-¬�¼�¤Mª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© °\¯ ¬�´»¼�¥ ,¿¥»­;¤'¼ � ­�©�ª ° ©G¼ F ¬�¼�¤g©G¼±¹ ���� - ð À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Y B;H�E�H/.10GA�57KLH �¿51,/0GE�^_*sZ;=#]±H'E\>O6 Ñ ~ T Ò�Ó ' 512¿A4B;HS*sZ;=#](HJE\>O6�2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457A�57H/2c03.1>O*;: � N;03*;^?A�>:OH'Au69E�>O= T A�> � N�bcHÔ,/>O*�ATE[03,'A � XåöSH/*;,/H Ë ð Õ X

Ë ó Õ 512R51=<=?H/^;590GA4HS69E�>O= Ë ð%ó@X1ðOXpõ Õ X$v8 Ë ð%ó@X1ðOXæï Õ 03*;^ Ë ð%ó@XæÅ�X1ð Õ N�o# Ðä �� ß �� X Ë ï Õ 6�>O.1.7>%bu2u69E4>O=ÖA4B;512/NW03*;^ Ë ó Õ XË . Õ 6�>O.1.7>%bu2R69E�>O= Ë ï Õ 2T51*;,/H � � � �� ßÝðONW032Ro��#ä � 572u.VA�0GAu2457*;:OZ;.90GERC(>O51*LA�2���� ßto �� N�]�8 Ë ó Õ 03*;^ Ë ï Õ X�)+6 � B�032RE�03*�Q�>O*;HGN�o �� Ã�Å�XåöSH'*;,/H Ë�� Õ X �

D ¤J«<© °GF A B@À � À�3À +@Z�C;C(>O24H ' ß ' Ê N � ß � Ê >O6�A4B;H"BsZ;*LAkNR03*;^ � Ë �MÕ ß ðOX Y B;H-A4E�03*;246�>3E�=_0GA�57>O*' Ê �� � � >O6 Ë ð%ó@X . Õ 572S*;>3AS51*q:OH/*;H'E�03. A�B;H#*;H �@AãBsZ;*LAM2TA�H'C�XSöS>�bcH'KLH'E/N�2451*;,/H � 512 (M>3E4H/*;2TA�H/57*�N�57AS572>O69A�H/*�0aZ;24H/6�Z;. 03.7A4H'E�*�0GA�5VKLH3N�H/2TC(H',/5903.7.78`516 >O*;HÔ,k03*�0GE�:OZ;HÔA�B�0GA � B�032RE�03*�Q�>O*;HGX

� 5(� � �¿�@�Í����� �#¬�¥w©G¥|´¶¬�¼m©�ªº´�¼ � A B@À ��� À � ¸ � ­�©�ªMÈ�¤J¼�ùsª<¬�¼(¤a©G¼±¹ o��gä ó �3ï � ´�ªº¼(¤½ÈL©G¥|´�µ3¤º¥»­�¤J¼�¼(¬´ °J° ¤�¹GùW³J´|§/Â1¤g³[¬�« ¯ ¬�¼(¤J¼�¥R¬+¸ � ¯ ©�ª¨ªk¤¨ªM¥®­ ° ¬GùOÈ�­-«?¬ ° ¤Ô¥»­;©G¼Ð¥|ûv¬aªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© °v¯ ¬�´�¼�¥®ª#¬+¸ '�À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ +@Z�C;C±>O24HS*;>3AkX2#�H'A��Ä](HeA4B;HeE�H/^;Z;,'A451>O*_>O6�03*_57ETE�H/^;Z;,/5V]�.1HS,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*LAv>O6� ,'>O*�A[0357*;51*;:PA4B�E�H/H2457*;:OZ;.90GE\C(>O57*�A�2'N;2�0�8`>O6�51*;^;HG�UÎ�N � 03*;^8=@XyíS2\o��Ôä Ë ó �3ï Õ � 572R*;H':L0GA�57KLH3N;o��Mäjó�ì512\*;H/:L0GA457KLH3X�$cZ�A]�8-03^�FIZ;*;,JA�51>O*

Ë o��ºäâó� Õ � � - Ë Î Ò ð Õ �¨Î#ä Ë� Ò ð Õ � � ä Ë = Ò ð Õ �'= Ò óuä � �- Ë Î Ò ð Õ �¨Î#ä Ë� Ò ð Õ � � ä Ë = Ò ð Õ �'= Ò óuä Ë Ò ð¿ätð��¨Îgäëð�� � ätð��'= Õ ß Å �

0a,'>O*�A4E�03^;51,'A�57>O*�X �� 5(� � J �W� �����®ÿO� K¿��� ����þe��� �»�(���@ýW��� K D�W���@��¡'�����»� ÿL� ���W�±�öSH'E�HãbcHMC;E�>%KLHãA�B;HÔ6�>O.1.1>�bu51*;:;N�032ubvHMbcHJE�HPZ;*�0G]�.7HÔA�>UÏ�*;^�57Au51*DA�B;HP.757A�H'E�0GA�Z�E�H3~

� 5(� � �����Í������£ ¤'¥ �ħ¨¤g© ¯±° ¬ ¯ ¤ ° ,¿´�¼�¥+¤½È ° ©3Â1, ��¬ ° ¤J¼;ªJ¥w¤J´»¼�³Jù ° µ3¤kÀ � ¸ � �ß É Ê ¥®­;¤J¼ l d � l ´�ªº§[©�ª�¤ ¯ ¬�´�¼W¥¸ ° ¤[¤kÀ

Page 95: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � 0"�

� 5(� � �¿�@�Í������£ ¤J¥ � §J¤�© ¯±° ¬ ¯ ¤ ° ,_´�¼�¥+¤½È ° ©GÂ1, ��¬ ° ¤J¼;ª¨¥+¤J´�¼�³Jù ° µ3¤�À Á ­�¤ ° ¤i´�ª¾©â¹G´ÇÆS¤ ° ¤J¼�¥|´|©G ¸k¬ ° «� � � 3 Ë d � ÕPû�­�´½³¨­�¹�¬�¤JªM¼(¬�¥vµG©G¼W´�ª[­�©G¥\©G¼�·<ª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© °c¯ ¬�´�¼�¥R¬+¸ �<À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ #�H'A RM~ �� Ò±Ó � ]±Hº57A�2e*;>3E�=_03.1572�0GA�57>O*�X�ãH'Ï�*;H#A�B;H � 0GE4A451H'ES^;5VK�5724>3ESÞ ]�8-d �

�Ë Þ Õ ß R " Ë d � Õ

Ë A�B�Z;2ãÞ 512S,/Z�AM>OZ�AS]�8�A�B;H#,/>O*;^;Z;,'A4>3EÔ57^;Hk03.�>O* ��MÕ X Ì HgB�0kKLHg0_,/>O=?=gZ�A[0GA�5VKLHP^;5903:3E�03= be5VA�B"H �;03,'AE�>�be2

Å Ò/Ò;Ò�Ò[Ó R�" Ë d ��ÕÐÒkÒ;Ò;Ò[Ó R�" Ë d �

�Ë Þ Õ4ÕÐÒkÒ;Ò;Ò¨Ó R�" Ë d � Õ Ò/Ò;Ò�Ò[Ó Å

������ � ���

Å Ò/Ò;Ò�Ò[Ó d � ÒkÒ;Ò;Ò[Ó d ��� 6 ��

ÒkÒ;Ò;Ò¨Ó d ��� Ë76 ��Õ � Ë 6 � ÕiÒ/Ò;Ò�Ò[Ó Å �

Y B;512R51*;^;Z;,/H/2�0a24B;>3E4AeH ��03,JAe24H'r@Z;H/*;,/H

Å Ò Ó � 3 Ë d ��ÕcÒ Ó � 3 Ë d � ÕcÒ Ó QLH'E Ë � Õ¿Ò Ó Å �

,�5 �Í0Ð2T51*;:OZ;.90GE#C±>O51*LA � � � 03*;^�0q.7>@,k03.�:OH/*;H'E[0GA4>3E ��� �ëd � ���GX4,�5 �m0q*;H/57:OB�]±>OZ�E�B;>@>s^ � �çÙ=?57242451*;:`A�B;HU>3A�B;H'EÔ2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A451H/2/N�03*;^�.7H'A �Öß R � Ê Ë Ù Õ X Y B;HUC±>O.90GEM^;57K@5124>3EM>O6 ���3N�A�B;>OZ;:OB�AÔ>O6v032Ô0E[0GA�57>O*�03.y6�>3E�= >O* �<N 512ÔH ��03,JA�.78ÐÞ�l �<N 03*;^¾A�B;Ha51=_03:OHU>O6 ���U51*id �Ul �×572º03*�H/.7H/=?H/*LA � � ��QLH'E Ë � Õ XíS*L8�.75169A�57*;:<>O6 � �MA4> � 3 Ë d � Õ B�032\C(>O.10GEe^;5VK�5724>3EeÞ�l � >O* �_N�03*;^-24>?512u0a:OH'*;H'E[0GA�>3Eu6�>3Eed � ����X �* ° ¬�¬+¸Ð¬+¸ � A B@À�� � À $v8 Ë ð%ó@X : Õ bcH"*;H'H/^ë>O*;.V8h24B;>�b A�B;HJE�Hq0GE�H"*;>m24=?>s>3A�Bh]W0324H'C±>O51*LA�2/X $v8�ãZ�03.15VA+8Îç572�*;>3A"0�]W032TH'C(>O57*�A"6�>3E�l d � l¿5VèÝöS>O= Ë n � � 6 � Õ 572->O*;H�^;57=?H/*;2457>O*�03.|XÚ)+6uÎ 512-0�24=?>s>3A�BëC±>O51*LAöS>O= Ë n � � 6 � Õ ß � 3 Ë 6�Ë Î Õ4Õ N�24>-516�A4B;H<^;51=<H/*;2451>O*i512P0GAÔ.7Hk032TAÔA+bv>;N�A�B;H'*tl ÎylW512ã]W0324H'C±>O51*LAº69E�H'H3N�03*;^^;H'Ï�*;H/2�0U]�57E�0GA�51>O*�03.�=_0GC�A�> É�Ê NW03*;^�2T>?03*-5724>O=?>3E4C�B;5724=�X �

�%��� �S&O� $�$����@���������� �� � �ã� ��������$a����� �\�W���(��$

� (��7� �W���;�%���±�¿��9 � ���â�%� �%�±� ý�� ��� � � � ( � 'ç´�ªg© ° ©G¼ F ¬�¼�¤PÂ1¬�È�¹�¤JÂ*�¤����%¬gª¨ù ° ¸/©�³[¤�À¿¦�� T Ü '�© ° ¤´ °J° ¤�¹GùW³J´|§/Â1¤ ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼(©G ³Jù ° µ3¤¨ªÔª¨ùW³¨­D¥®­�©G¥ o��ºä ¦ ä T ´�ªÔÂ1¬�È<¥+¤ ° «g´»¼±©G ©G¥¿ª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© °c¯ ¬�´�¼�¥®ªº¬+¸ '�À

,W>3ERA4B;HP^;H'Ï�*;5VA�51>O*;2u>O6 ,WH/*;,/H#03*;^>$R03*�03*�0U24H/H Ë :�XpÅ�X7ðOð'Ø�ð%ó Õ X� (��»� �¿���Í����� �#¬�¥½©3¥®´¶¬G¼�©�ªg´�¼ � A �@À � � À � ¸ã¦ ©G¼(¹)T © ° ¤gª¨«?¬%¬�¥»­i¥»­;¤'¼�¤�©�³¨­�¬+¸S¦ ,�T ³[¬�¼�¥w©G´�¼;ªa©G¥«?¬%ªJ¥\¬�¼�¤ãª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© °¿¯ ¬�´�¼�¥\¬+¸/'eÀ � ¸�¸¨ù ° ¥®­;¤ ° «_¬ ° ¤Ô¥®­;¤ ° ¤ã´�ªP©Uª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|·`¬+Æ⦠6 T$,奮­;¤J¼#' ß 4�5 ,v©3¼±¹¦�� T ��l ;>5 l �¶ªk¬a´�¼ ¯ © ° ¥|´¶³Jù@Â7© ° , ¦ ä T Ü '23 � À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Ì Hº0GE�:OZ;HãÏ;E�2TAuA�B�0GAeH/03,¨B->O6 ¦�� T ,'>O*�A[0357*;2e0GAu=?>O2TAR>O*;HÔ2451*;:OZ;.10GEuC±>O51*LAkX

#�H'A � ](HDH/5VA�B;H'E ¦ >3E T X $v8 Ë # X ó Õ N 'Íá�� ,/>O*LA[0351*;2UH/5VA�B;H'E<0ÐZ;*;57r@Z;HD2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8LNå>3EUAwbc> � ÊC(>O57*�A42/X@+@51*;,/HeA4B;H'E�H�572¿*;> ' Ë . � Ê Õ 57*<A�B;H�.7512TA Ë ï�X7ð Õ N�A4B;H'E�H�572v0GAv.7Hk032TA¿>O*;H�,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*�A�beB;57,[B_,/>O*�A�0351*;20aZ;*;57r@Z;HÔ2451*;:OZ;.10GEuC±>O51*LAkXY BsZ;2�bcHc,k03* Ë 2Ibe5VA�,[B;51*;:ã516�*;H/,/H'242�0GE48 Õ 032T24Z;=?H ¦ ,/>O*LA[0351*;2y0SZ;*;51rsZ;Hc2451*;:OZ;.10GE�C(>O57*�AkNL03*;^ Ë 0GE4:OZ;51*;:

]�8i,'>O*�A4E�03^;51,'A�57>O* Õ N T ,/>O*LA[0351*;2ÔH ��03,'A4.78"Awbc>-2T51*;:OZ;.90GEMC(>O57*�A42/N Hk03,[B � Ê C(>O57*�A�2'X �S>3A�HUo��<ä ¦ 03*;^o��ºä T 0GE�HÔ]±>3A�B�03*LA�5Vؽ03=<C�.1HGN�]s8�03^�FIZ;*;,'A�57>O*�X

Page 96: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

0 � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

� >O*;2451^;H'EeA�B;HºB�Z;*�Aãbu57A�B-E4H/2TC(H','ASA�>_o��#ä ¦ NWbuB;51,[Bq512�,'.1Hk0GE�.V88/�Z;2TB�X � ]sK@51>OZ;24.V8 � N±6�>3E�A�B;HºÏ;E42TAB�Z;*�Ae2TA�H'C�NW512\A�B;HPZ;*;57r@Z;HÔ2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8D03.1>O*;: ¦ X �S>3A4HMA�B�0GAe0369A�H'ERA�B;572RbcHMbe57.1.�*;>3AuZ;24H�/�Z;2TB;*;H/242/X

�S>3A�H ¦ Ü � 3 X+@Z�C;C(>O2TH � 572�0h*;H'AkXÖ)+6 ¦ 512-Ï;];E�03.|NSA�B;H/*ç57A-512"0�24=?>@>3A4BtÏ;];E�HÍ03*;^é]�8 *;H/:L0GA�5VK�5VA+8 T 572"0

24H/,JA�51>O*�N�buB;51,[BD=?H/H'A�2 ¦ >O*;,/H3X@$cZ�AcA�B;H/* � B�032cAwbc>#Ï;];E�H/2\beB;57,¨B`](>3A4B�,/>O*LA[0357*�>O*;H � Ê 2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8LN51=aC(>O24245V]�.1H3X Y BsZ;2/N±2451*;,/H#o��gä ¦ 512e*;H/:L0GA�57KLHGN ¦ 512�0?24H/,'A�57>O*�N±57*qA4B;Hº24=?>s>3A�B�.1>s,/Z;2�>O6 � X Y BsZ;2 �512R24=?>s>3A�B�N�0a,'>O*�A4E�03^;51,'A�57>O* Ë A4B;H'E�Hº0GE4HMAwbc>a2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2u03.1>O*;: TgÕ XöSH/*;,/H\bcHRB�0�KLHe0M,'>O*�A4E�03,'A�51>O*)RÔ~ �éÒ�Ó ' Ê X�+@51*;,/H ¦ Ü � 3 N@03*;^ao��¿ä ¦ 512å*;H/:L0GA�57KLHGN � ¦ ß %�N

03*;^ ¦ Ü ' 3Ê X �S>3A�Hco����Oä T 572�*;H/:L0GA�5VKLH3NL24> � T ,k03*;*;>3Ay,'>O*�A[0357*U]±>3A�Bg>O6WA4B;H � Ê C±>O51*LA�2 Ë >3A�B;H'ETbe5724HT Ü ' Ê B�032P0`2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8Ð0GA � Õ X Y B�Z;2Ô]�8 Ë ð�ï�X � Õ N ' Ê ß 4 � N � ä ¦ Ü ' 3Ê N ¦ 03*;^ � 0GE�HU.157*;Hk0GE�.78H/rsZ;57KG03.1H/*LA�03*;^ ¦ � ß � � ßéó@N�beB;HJE�H � ß R Ë U Õ X�íÝ,'>O*�A4E�03^;51,'A�57>O*�N�2451*;,/H ¦ � � ßÝðOX

+@>#Hk03,[B`>O6 ¦ N T ,/>O*LA[0351*;2\0GAc=<>O2TAv>O*;HS2457*;:OZ;.90GEcC±>O51*LAc>O6 ' X �S>�bt2TZ�C;C(>O24HSA�B;H'E4HS512\0º2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8�º>3è ¦ ä T N�03*;^`0º2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8 � >O* ¦ ä T X Y B;H'*`]�8 Ë$# X ó Õ NL](>3A�B_>O6 �U03*;^ � 0GE�H � Ê C±>O51*LA�2/X Y B�Z;2' B�032c0GAv.7Hk032TAvAwbc>P2451*;:OZ;.10GEvC(>O57*�A�2'N�03*;^`03.1.�>O6�5VA�2¿2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2v0GE�H � Ê C(>O51*LA�2/X Y B;512v,'>O*�A4E�03^;51,'A�2�A�B;H.1572TA Ë ï�X1ð Õ X �S>�b 0GC;C�.78 Ë ð�ï�X � Õ X �� (�� 5 NÔ�%���å�±¡k���%���±� �I�#� �����������%� % �W� �W� �(¢%� � ¸ o���ä ¦ ä T ´�ªÐ©�§¨©G¼±©G¼±© ,aûy´�¥®­i¦ ©G¼±¹ Tª¨«?¬%¬�¥»­ ,Ô©3¼±¹4' ´�ªUª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ©G¥�ªk¬�«?¤ ¯ ¬�´»¼�¥P¬+¸P¦ 6 T$,M¥»­;¤'¼ ¤�©s³¨­j¬I¸M¦ ©G¼±¹OT ³[¬�¼W¥½©G´»¼;ª`©qù@¼�´|ø'ùW¤ª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© °�¯ ¬�´�¼�¥wÀ � ¬ ° ¤¨¬�µ3¤ ° ¬�¼�¤P³¨¬�« ¯ ¬�¼�¤J¼�¥y´�ªM© ó ú4³Jù ° µ3¤P©G¼(¹?³¨¬�¼�¥w©G´�¼;ªM©G¼ Ë =Rätð � ó Õ ¯ ¬�´�¼W¥ ,�¥»­�¤P¬G¥»­;¤ °´�ª`© ð ú4³'ù ° µ3¤`©G¼(¹¾³[¬G¼�¥½©3´�¼;ª_©3¼ ���qªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´»¥®·LÀ �y¸¨¥w¤ ° ¤ �O¥ ° ©�³J¥|´�¼@È"¥»­;¤?Ò Ë =ãäÝð Õ'ú4³Jù ° µ3¤-, U ,S¥»­�¤ ° ¤_´�ª© o ú+¼(¤½ÈL©G¥|´�µ3¤-³[¬�¼W¥ ° ©�³J¥|´¶¬�¼ ¹�¬�ûy¼â¥+¬ 4 � ,g©G¼(¹q¥®­;¤D´�«?©�È�¤�¬+¸#¦ ä T ä U ´�ª_¥|ûv¬qªk¤[³J¥|´¶¬�¼�ª �½´»¼ l ; � l �©G¼±¹�©;2v§ ° ¤kÀ���¸J¥w¤ ° ¤��L¥ ° ©�³J¥|´�¼@ÈD¥»­�¤a©�¹I²/©�³[¤'¼�¥vÒ ó ú4³'ù ° µ3¤0, U 8 ,�¬+¸#¥®­;¤ ��� ¯ ¬�´�¼W¥ ,\¥®­;¤ ° ¤g´�ªU© o úw¼�¤½ÈL©G¥|´�µ3¤³[¬�¼W¥ ° ©�³J¥|´¶¬�¼ ¹�¬�ûy¼�¥w¬?É�� ,º©G¼(¹"¥®­;¤`´�«<©�Ès¤�¬+¸?¥®­;¤ �4³[¬�« ¯ ¬G¼(¤J¼�¥P¬+¸P¦ ä T û�­�´½³¨­i´�ªD© � ó ú4³Jù ° µ3¤_´�ªD©³[¬�¼W´¶³0,R¥®­;¤U´�«<©�Ès¤_¬+¸#¥»­;¤ ð ú�³Jù ° µ3¤U´�ª<©Dªk¤¨³�©G¼�¥\ ´»¼(¤U¥w¬-¥»­;¤_³¨¬�¼�´¶³0,e©G¼(¹�¥»­;¤<´�«<©�È�¤?¬+¸ U 8 ´�ªa©�¥½©3¼@È�¤J¼�¥Â ´�¼(¤P¥w¬?¥»­;¤a³[¬�¼�´½³kÀ

� ¬ ° ¤¨¬�µ3¤ ° ´Ç¸ o��Uä � ¦ ä � T ´�ª��cù�ª[­Ð©G¼±¹�©G¼�¥|´�úT©G« ¯ Â1¤U©3¼±¹�¹s¬�¤¨ªº¼(¬�¥v­�©GµO¤U©`¥®´9È�¤ ° ,v¥»­�¤J¼i¥®­;¤#¼(¤��O¥­�ù@¼�¥¿ª¨¥+¤ ¯ ¸k¬ ° o��#ä � ¦ ä � T ¤ �O¥ ° ©�³J¥®ª U ,c©G¼(¹ ' Ê ß 4 � À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ +@Z�C;C±>O24H T 572å,'>O*�A[0357*;H/^U51*gA�B;H\24=?>@>3A4B#.1>@,'Z;2/X Y B;H'* Ë o��yä ¦ ä TUÕ�� T ß Å�NL03*;^ao��åä ¦ ä T512u*sZ;=<H'E�51,/03.1.78DA4E�5VK�5103.|X $cZ�AeA4B;H/* Ë o��#ä ¦ ä TgÕ9�k¦ ß ÅabuB;51,[B"57=<C�.157H/2 ¦ Ü ' 3 N�0<,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�57>O*�X� 6c,/>OZ�E�24HUA�B;H<2�03=<H?0GC;C�.157H/2ÔA4> ¦ N�A4BsZ;2ºH'57A�B;H'EP,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*�AP,/>O*LA[0351*;2P0�2457*;:OZ;.90GEPC±>O51*LAkX $v8 Ë ð�ï�X7ð ÕHk03,[B�,/>O*LA[0357*;2�0aZ;*;57r@Z;HÔ2451*;:OZ;.10GEuC±>O51*LAkNW03*;^ ' 512u24=?>s>3A�B�>3è ¦ ä T X

+sbu57A�,[B;51*;:`,/>O=aC(>O*;H/*LA�2ã516å*;H/,/H/2T2�0GE48LN(bcHg,k03*i032424Z;=?H ¦ ,/>O*LA[0351*;2SA�B;Hg2457*;:OZ;.90GESC±>O51*LAÔ>O6yB;57:OB;H/2TA51*;^;HG��X �S>3A�H Ò Ë o��#ä ¦iÕ 03*;^ Ò Ë o��#ä TgÕ 0GE�HM]±>3A�B�03=aC�.1H3N�]�8�03^�FIZ;*;,'A�51>O*�X� >O*;2451^;H'E¿A�B;H�B�Z;*�Acbu57A�B?E4H/2TC(H','AcA�>ºo��Rä ¦ X � ]sK@51>OZ;24.V8�� N@6�>3EvA�B;HuÏ;E�2TA\B�Z;*�A\2TA4H'C�N�512åA�B;H�Z;*;57r@Z;H

2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8U03.7>O*;: ¦ X Ì HR*;>3A�HuA4B�0GAv0369A�HJE¿24,/03.151*;:Ô24>O=?HR,/>@H !?,/57H/*�A¿,/>OZ;.1^U](Hu:3E�Hk0GA�H'EåA�B�03*?>O*;H Ë 2457*;,/H

Page 97: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � 0�2

bcH_0GE4H<*;>3A#032T24Z;=?51*;:�A�B;H'E�H?572º*;>-A�57:OH'E Õ X Y B;512Mbe57.1.å*;>3AºH'è±H/,'A#>OZ�Eº0GE�:OZ;=?H/*LAkN�beB;57,¨BÍbu51.7.å*;>3APZ;24H/�Z;24B;*;H/2T2ã0GA�03.7.|X� ,k03*;*;>3AR](HP0a*;H'AkNW032u51*�A4B;HMC;E�>s>O6�>O6 Ë ð�ï�X1ð Õ XöSH/*;,/H\bcHRB�0�KLHe0M,'>O*�A4E�03,'A�51>O*)RÔ~ �éÒ�Ó ' Ê X�+@51*;,/H ¦ Ü � 3 N@03*;^ao��¿ä ¦ 512å*;H/:L0GA�57KLHGN � ¦ ß %�N

03*;^ ¦ Ü '23Ê X Y B;H'*q]�8"03^�FIZ;*;,JA�51>O*qo�����ä ¦ ä T 512u*sZ;=<H'E�51,/03.1.78DA4E�5VK�5103.|X Y BsZ;2 ¦ ä T Ü '23Ê N±03*;^' Ê 572 ãZ>H¿03.|X�$v8 Ë ð�ï�X � Õ/' Ê 572uH'57A�B;H'E É�� >3E 4 � X

#�H'A � Ü ' Ê ]±HÔA�B;HM51=?03:OHM>O6 U_X)+6 ' Ê ß 4 � N � 572ã0_Ï;];E4H3N(A�B�Z;2 � ,'>O*�A[0357*;2ã0_2451*;:OZ;.10GESC(>O51*LAkN�03*;^Ð24> Ë 2457*;,/H Uà,/>O*LA[0351*;2M0GAS=?>O2IA

>O*;H<2T51*;:OZ;.90GEÔC(>O57*�A Õ N =?H/H'A42�UÄ0GAP0-24=<>@>3A�BqC(>O57*�AkN 03*;^ T 0GAP0-2451*;:OZ;.10GEPC±>O51*LAkX T ä � B�032#03*>3E�^;57*�0GE48D*;>@^;Hº0GA � X Y B;HP:O5VKLH/*-^;H/2T,'E�57C;A451>O*�*;>�b 6�>O.1.1>�bu2u69E�>O= Ë ðOðOX7ðOXpÅ Õ X)+6 ' Ê ß É � NåA�B;H/* ¦ 03*;^ � 0GE�HD.157*;H/2U03*;^ T 0q,/>O*;57,DA[03*;:OH'*�AUA�> � 0GA � X �S>�bà,/>O*;2T51^;H'EaA�B;H

,/>O=<C±>O2457A451>O*�>O6u]�.1>�b Z�C�2��v~ �� ÒWÓ ' Ê Nc032?57* � ðOðOX Y B;H�Ï;E�2TA<A+bv>¾]�.1>�b×Z�C�2?=gZ;2TA<]±H"0GA T Ë A�>24H'CW0GE�0GA�H T 03*;^ �ºÕ Xy)+*-A4B;512R,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*�N � 572u0 Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLH3X +@51*;,/H �� � � Ò ó@N;A�B;HM*;H ��AR]�.1>�béZ�C"57203.12T>�0GA � X �S>�bÝA4B;H'E�Hg512ã>O*;.78�>O*;HºC(>O24245V]�.1Hg,[B;>O51,/HU6�>3EM03*L8q6�Z�E4A�B;H'EM]�.1>�b�Z�Ci24Z;,[BiA�B�0GAão��-ä T 572C�.7A/X Y B;512\8�57H/.1^;2\A�B;HP:O5VKLH/*-^;H'24,'E�5VC;A�51>O*�X

�S>�b 24Z�C;C(>O2TH?o��aä � ¦ ä � T 572 /�Z;2TBÍ03*;^Í03*LA�5Vؽ03=<C�.1H3N�bcHU^;>�*;>3AMB�0kKLH?0DA451:OH'EkN�03*;^¾A4B;Ha*;H �@AB�Z;*�AP2TA�H'C�8@51H/.7^;2 É�� X Ì HU=_0k8q032424Z;=<H Ë ]�8Ð2Tbu57A�,[B;51*;:�,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*�A42Ô576¿*;H/,/H'242�0GE48 Õ A�B�0GA�� � ¦ X#íS2bcHU:OH'AÔ0`A�03,/*;>@^;H3N � �Ýó �3ï`]�8 Ë ðOðOX1ðOX7ð Õ X Y B;H/*Ð]s8 Ë :�XæÅ�X � X ó Õ N±A�B;Hg2TC(H','A4E[03.�KG03.1Z;Hg>O6 Ë =Rä�ð � ó Õ 512M0GA=?>O2TAu>O*;H3N�A�B�Z;2?=Ôß ðON��q512e03* � Ê C±>O51*LAS03*;^-A4B;HP2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8D>O* T 512�03* � � C(>O57*�A/X $v8-03^�FIZ;*;,JA�51>O*� Ãtï �'. Ë >3ESo��gä ¦ ä � T 512�03*�A�5Ûؽ*;H/6 Õ 03*;^q24>;N�]�8 /�Z;24B;*;H/2T2/N � �Oó#ß � Ã Ë ï �'. Õ Ë ó �3ï Õ ß ð��Oó@X Y B�Z;2� ÃéðONW0a,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�57>O*�X �� (���( NÔ�%� ����¡k���%����� � ���@��ÿO���?���%�Ý�ë¡k�����W�%� ¡k�»� �W¢%�`£ ¤J¥/'Ö§¨¤`©qÂ1¬�Ⱦ¹�¤J *e¤�����¬�ª¨ù ° ¸k©�³[¤D¬I¸ ° ©3¼ F¬�¼(¤g©G¼±¹<ªJù ¯L¯ ¬%ªk¤R¦ ä T ´�ªº©u¸�¤J¼(³[¤0,åûå´�¥»­�T ª¨«?¬�¬G¥»­�À

� ¸\¦ ´�ªãªJ«?¬�¬�¥®­ ,�¥®­;¤J¼ÐÒ Ë o��ºä ¦ ä TgÕº´�ªº©3« ¯ Â1¤0,c©3¼±¹ ' ´�ªãª¨«?¬%¬�¥»­q©Gû¿©G·e¸ ° ¬�« ¦ ä T�À� ¸�¦ ´�ª�ª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ,�¥®­;¤J¼ T ´�ªc©SÒ ð ú�³Jù ° µ3¤u©G¼±¹Ô³¨¬�¼�¥w©G´�¼;ª\©G¥�Â1¤�©�ª¨¥�¥|ûv¬�ª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© °�¯ ¬G´�¼�¥®ª/À � ¸�¸Jù ° ¥»­;¤ ° «?¬ ° ¤

T ³[¬G¼�¥½©3´�¼;ªP©G¥vÂ1¤�©�ªJ¥ ï ªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© °\¯ ¬�´�¼�¥®ªã¥®­;¤J¼Í¤'´�¥»­�¤ °Ë ð Õ o��ºä ¦ ´�ªº©3« ¯ Â1¤g©3¼±¹ o��ºätð��Oó Ë ¦ ä TgÕP´�ªM¼(¤®¸5,\¬ °Ë ó Õ ' ß ' Ë � Ê ä � � ä ���/Õ-,�¦ Ü ' 3 ´�ªP©#È�¤J¼�ùsª#¬�¼�¤g³Jù ° µ3¤Mûy´»¥»­�©UªJ´�« ¯ Â1¤Ô¼�¬k¹�¤0,v©G¼(¹ o��Mä TÄ´�ª

¼�ù@«?¤ ° ´¶³�©GÂ� ·_¥ ° ´�µ%´|©GÂ7À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ )+6 ¦ 572#24=?>s>3A�B�N�A�B;H/* Ë ð�ï�X1ð Õ 0GC;C�.151H'2/XÐ)+*mCW0GE4A�57,/Z;.90GE Ò Ë o��_ä ¦ ä TgÕ 572g03=<C�.1H`03*;^ ' 57224=?>s>3A�B�0�b\0k8D69E�>O= ¦ ä T X

�S>�bh24Z�C;C±>O24H ¦ 512y2457*;:OZ;.90GEkX�)+6�A�B;H'E�HR512å0GAy=?>O2TAy>O*;H\2457*;:OZ;.90GEyC(>O57*�A�03.7>O*;: T NOA�B;H'*<o��åä ¦ ä T 572*;H/:L0GA�5VKLHR]�8a03^�FIZ;*;,'A�57>O*�N�0Ô,'>O*�A4E�03^;51,'A�57>O*�X�)I6 �T =?>�KLH/2yA�B;H/*<]�8 Ë�� X1ðOð Õ N , Ë o �� ä �¦¾Õ ß Ò�� XyöS>%bcHJKLH'E2457*;,/H � Ê Ë o �� Õ ß � 3 Ë o �� Õ ßéÅ�N � 3 Ë o �� ä �¦iÕ ß � 3 Ë o �f Õ Ã Å�X Y B�Z;2 T 512u0 Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�ETKLH3X

Page 98: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

0 � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

+@Z�C;C(>O2THUo��gä ¦ 512ã03=<C�.7H#03*;^io��gä ð��Oó Ë ¦ ä TgÕ 572S*;H/:L0GA�57KLHGX $c8 Ë ð%ó@X1ðOX . Õ o��Uä ¦ ß�Þ 6�>3E24>O=?HãH'è±H/,'A�5VKLHPÞ ,/>O*�A�0351*;51*;:<03.1.(A�B;HÔ2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A451H/2\>O6 ' 03.7>O*;: ¦ N�03*;^-B�0kK�57*;:?0U*;>O*@ؽH/=<C;Aw8D=?>�K�57*;:CW0GE4A�516 � Ë ¦¾Õ - ó@X�)wAå6�>O.1.7>%bu2yA�B�0GAyA�B;Hu2TZ�C;C(>3E4A�>O6±Þ 512å*;>3A�,'>O*�A[0357*;H/^<57* T X�o���ä T äDÞ 572�*;H':L0GA�57KLH3N24>U]s8-03^�FIZ;*;,'A�57>O*�N T ,k03*�,/>O*LA[0351*-0GAe=<>O2TA\A+bv><2457*;:OZ;.90GERC(>O51*LA�2/X

,�51*�03.7.78LNW516yo��gä ¦ 572S*sZ;=?HJE�51,k03.7.78�A4E�57K@5903.®NWA�B;H'*q]�8q03^�FIZ;*;,'A451>O* Ë 2451*;,'H ¦ 572S2451*;:OZ;.10GE Õ N ¦ Ü ' 3 N¦ B�032M:OH'*sZ;2UðON�03*;^ ' 512�(M>3E4H/*;2TA�H/57*�XÔ)+6 ¦ B�032M0_,/Z;2TC�N�A�B;H/* ' 3 572M2T51=<C�.V8�,/>O*;*;H/,JA�H/^i]�8 Ë � X .;X1ð Õ N03*;^j24>q69E�>O=ìA�B;H`.1572TA Ë ï�Xpó Õ N T ,/>O*LA[0351*;2gH �;03,'A�.78iAwbc>q2451*;:OZ;.10GE#C(>O51*LA�2/X � A�B;H'E4bu512THDo��_ä ¦ 512#.7>O:,k03*;>O*;57,k03.|NW03*;^-]�8 Ë # X ó Õ N � ��� �

��� � Ê��� � ó@X+@Z�C;C(>O2TH T ,/>O*LA[0351*;2U0GAg.1H/032TAgA�B�E�H/H`2457*;:OZ;.90GEgC(>O57*�A�2'XÐ)wAU6�>O.1.7>%bu2 Ë 2457*;,/H�69E4>O= A�B;H`.1512IAkN Ë ï�X1ð Õ N '

,k03*;*;>3AR,/>O*LA[0351*O.g51*;^;HG�`A+bv>gC±>O51*LA�2 Õ A�B�0GA T ,/>O*LA[0357*;2RHG��03,'A�.V8<A�B�E4H/Hã2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2/N;03*;^ ' 572c24=?>s>3A�B>3è T X��S>3A4H

o �� ß ðT �

ß ðÒ ð¿ä � ��� � Ê���

)wAã6�>O.1.7>%bu2 Ë 2451*;,'HUo �� 512M03*i57*�A4H/:OH'E Õ A�B�0GA � ��� � Ê��� ß ó@N�o �� ßÚðON�03*;^ � = � ßÚðOðOX Y B�Z;2 Ë 69E4>O= A�B;H.1572TA Õ/' ß ' Ë � Ê ä � � ä ���'Õ X �������ÿO��¡U�?���%�h�±� �i¡k�������%�t¡k�»� �����W���â�±� �Сk�»� �"�Wþ�ý��@����¡ ð �NÔ�%� ����¡k���%�����ç� (�����-£ ¤J¥ o��Ôä ¦ ä T §¨¤º©u¸�¤J¼(³[¤0,yûy´»¥»­ T ª¨«_¬�¬�¥®­�©G¼±¹ � Ë ¦¾Õ ßÝð À .Wù ¯L¯ ¬%ªk¤\¦ ­;©�ª©G¼j¬ ° ¹3´�¼±© ° ·-³Jù�ª ¯ ,R©3¼±¹ o��#ä ð��Oó ¦ ´�ªº¼(¤½È�©G¥®´»µ3¤kÀ (ù ° ¥®­;¤ ° ©Gª[ª¨ù@«?¤?¤J´�¥®­;¤ ° ¥»­�©3¥�¦ ³[¬G¼�¥½©3´�¼;ª#©3¥\«?¬%ª¨¥¬�¼(¤Ôª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© °\¯ ¬�´�¼W¥ ,\¬ ° o��#ähó �3ï ¦ ´�ªM¼�¤½ÈL©G¥|´�µ3¤kÀÁ ­;¤'¼º¦ Ü ' 3 ,' ß ' Ë � Ê ä � � Õ-,y©G¼(¹P¥»­�¤S³[¬�¼�2�È3ù ° ©G¥®´½¬�¼`´�ª�¬O§/¥½©G´»¼(¤�¹å¸ ° ¬�«tÉ��<§'·P¥½© F ´�¼@È#© �e¤��ºÂ ´»¼(¤

¥+¬D©�³Jù�§'´¶³0,u§'Â1¬�ûy´»¼@È_ù ¯ ¥w¬?ªk¤ ¯ © ° ©G¥+¤P¥®­;¤# ´�¼(¤a©G¼±¹`¥»­;¤<³Jù�§'´¶³0,c¥®­;¤J¼m§'Â1¬�ûy´�¼�È�¹�¬Gûy¼Í©3Â� ¥®­;¤ºÒ ó ú4³Jù ° µO¤¨ª/À� ¼ ¯ © ° ¥®´¶³'ùsÂ7© ° ¦ � ß õ ,@T ³[¬�¼�¥w©G´�¼�ªg¥®ûv¬�ª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥®´½¤¨ª5,�©G¼ � Ê ©G¼(¹q©G¼ � � ,ã©3¼±¹�¥»­�¤ ° ¤_© ° ¤U¼(¬q¬G¥»­;¤ °ª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ª#¬G¼4'eÀ � ¬ ° ¤[¬Gµ3¤ ° ,¿´Ç¸ !ì´�ªº©G¼W·D¤®ÆS¤[³J¥|´�µ3¤#¹3´�µ�´�ªk¬ ° ª¨ù ¯L¯ ¬ ° ¥w¤[¹D¬�¼`¦ ä T$,c©G¼(¹ o��#ä !ì´�ª©G¼�¥|´�úw¼�¤»¸5,奮­;¤J¼ o��#ä ! ­�©�ªº©_¥®´9È�¤ ° À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Ì HÐ]±H/:O51*�]s8�24B;>�be57*;:�A�B�0GA ¦ Ü ' 3 X +@Z�C;C(>O24Hi*;>3AkX Ì HÐ,/>O*;2457^;H'E�A4B;HÐA4E�03*;246�>3E�=_0GA�57>O*' ���� � >O6 Ë ð%ó@X . Õ Ë A4B;512R512\beB;H'E4HÔbcHÔZ;24HÔA�B;HP032424Z;=<C;A451>O*�A4B�0GAuo��#ätð��Oó ¦ 512R*;H/:L0GA�5VKLH Õ XJ K��W�®�h� � ­�©�ª ° ©G¼ F ¬�¼(¤kÀ* ° ¬�¬+¸?¬I¸ ��Â7©G´�«?À �S>3A�HgA�B�0GAP]�8 Ë # X ó Õ N�H'57A�B;H'E ¦ ,/>O*LA[0351*;2P0�2457*;:O.1Ha2451*;:OZ;.10GEÔC±>O51*LAº>O6 ' N >3EÔH �;03,'A�.78Awbc> � Ê C(>O57*�A�2M03*;^ ' 572S24=?>s>3A�B">3è ¦ ä T X �S>%bÝ24Z�C;C(>O2THUA�B;H#,'.90351= 6�0351.72/X Y B;H/*q]�8 Ë ð%ó@X .;X7ð Õ N �512e57E4E�H'^;Z;,/57]�.7H3N(03*;^ ¦ ,/>O*LA[0357*;2eAwbc> � Ê C(>O57*�A42/X +@51*;,/H T 572�0 Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�ETKLH3N ' 512u*;>3A ãZ Hv03.�03.1>O*;: T XY BsZ;2R]s8 Ë ð%ó@X1ðOX . Õ N � ,/>O*LA[0357*;2�0GAu.1Hk032TARA�B�E�H'HP2457*;:OZ;.90GERC(>O51*LA�2R>O6 ' X Y B;512R,/>O*LA4E[03^;51,JA�2 Ë ð%ó@X � Õ X �

#�H'A � ](Hi03*ëH ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.S^;57K@5124>3ED03^�FT03,/H'*�ADA�> ¦ X � 512D0ÍE[03*�Q >O*;H (M>3E�H'*;2TA�H/57*t^;H/. ��H����'>;N¦ Ü � 3 N�03*;^_o�� � � ßto�� � T ß Ò ðOX � 3 572¿2457=<C�.78U,/>O*;*;H','A�H/^`]s8 Ë � X .;X1ð Õ X Y B�Z;2 � ß ' Ë U�� Õ ]�8

Page 99: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � 0 0

Ë ï�X # Õ NW03*;^ ¦ N � N T 0GE�HP03.1.�=?H/=#](HJE�2u>O6�l Ò o���læX%$\Z�A�03*�8DAwbc>?=?H'=g]±H'E�2u>O6el Ò o � � � � ls51*LA�H'E�2TH/,'A51*�0�2457*;:O.1HaC±>O51*LAkN�A�B;H<Z;*;57r@Z;Ha]W032TH'C(>O57*�A#>O6åA�B;H<.751*;Hk0GEP2T8�2IA�H/=�N�]s8 Ë ï�Xæõ Õ X)$\Z�AÔ,/.7Hk0GE�.78 � � ¦ 03*;^¦ � T 0GE�HÔ^;57è±H'E�H/*LAeC±>O51*LA�2u>O6 � X Y B�Z;2ubcHÔB�0�KLHÔ0a,'>O*�A4E�03^;51,'A�57>O*�X

+@>ºbcHã=_0k8?032T24Z;=?H ¦ Ü ' 3 X ' 3 572c2451=aC�.78a,/>O*;*;H/,'A�H'^�]�8 Ë � X .;X7ð Õ X $v8 Ë ð�ï�Xpï Õ A4B;H'E�HM0GE�H�Awbc>#,[B�0351*2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2�>O* T Ns2T>#69E�>O= A4B;H�.1572TA ' ß ' Ë � Ê ä � � Õ X�$c.1>�bu51*;:PZ�C_A4B;H � Ê C(>O57*�Av03*;^?]�.1>�be57*;:º^;>�be*T :O5VKLH/2\A�B;HP^;H/2T,'E�57]±H/^",/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA451>O*-57* É�� X

,W>3EuA�B;HMÏ�*�03. 2IA[0GA�H/=?H'*�AkNW.1HJA ! ß � ¦ ä � T X�)+6 � - � �3õ�N;A�B;H'*-A�B;H'E�HP512�0gA�51:OHJE�>�KLH'EeA�B;HÔ2451*;:OZ;.10GEC(>O57*�A�>O6 ¦ Ë A�B;H Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLHe>O6 Ë ðOðOX ó Õ ,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E�0GA�51>O*<)T)4) Õ NOH/.12TH T 57A�24H'.16(572¿0SA�51:OHJEkN@032åo_f-ä Ë�� �3õ ÕI¦ ä T512R*�Z;=?H'E�57,k03.1.V8_A4E�57K@5903.®X �NÔ�%� ����¡k���%����� � (�� �±��£ ¤'¥ o���ä ¦ ä T §¨¤S©¿¸k¤J¼(³[¤-, ûy´�¥®­ TÚª¨«?¬%¬�¥»­ , � Ë ¦iÕ ßÝð ©G¼(¹u¦ Ü ' 3 À��ãª[ª¨ù@«?¤¦ ­�©Gªº©G¼Í¬ ° ¹G´�¼(© ° ·<¼(¬k¹�¤�À Á ­;¤J¼m¬�¼(¤g¬I¸M¥»­�¤�¸k¬�Â�Â1¬Gûy´�¼@Èa­�¬�Â7¹�ª��

Ë ð Õ ' ß ' Ë � Ê ä � � Õºûå´�¥»­�¥®­;¤a³¨¬�¼;ª¨¥ ° ùW³J¥|´¶¬�¼�©GªÔ´�¼ � A �sÀ � � À Á ­�´�ªP´�ªÔ¥®­;¤<¬�¼� · ¯ ¬�ª[ª¨´|§'´»Â ´�¥®·?ûy´»¥»­ ' 3ª¨´�« ¯  ·�³[¬�¼�¼(¤¨³J¥w¤[¹LÀ

Ë ó Õ ' ß ' Ë � Ê ä ���kÕkÀ Á ­;¤ã³[¬�¼ 2�ÈGù ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼`´�ªS¬O§'¥w©G´�¼(¤[¹å¸ ° ¬�«à©P¼(¬k¹�©GÂ(³Jù�§'´¶³å¦ ©G¼±¹g©ÔªJ«?¬�¬�¥®­`³[¬G¼�´¶³� «?¤¨¤J¥®´»¼@È?¦ ¥+¬¾¬ ° ¹�¤ ° õ ©G¥P© ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥ Î À �RÂ1¬�û�ù ¯ õ ¥®´»«?¤¨ª�©G¥ Î ,º©GÂ1¬�¼�È �`À T ´�ª?¥»­�¤32�¼±©G¤��@³¨¤ ¯ ¥|´¶¬�¼±©G ¹3´�µ�´�ªk¬ ° ¬�µ3¤ ° Î À

Ë ï Õ ' ß ' Ë ï � � ÕkÀ �S¤½ÈG´»¼Íûy´�¥®­¾©-¼(¬k¹L©3¿³Jù;§/´¶³ã¦ ©G¼±¹�¥|ûv¬ �e¤��� ´�¼�¤¨ª ©G¼(¹ � ,R«_¤[¤J¥|´�¼@È �ì©G¥ �©G¼±¹ n À �RÂ1¬�ûéù ¯ ï ¤�©�³J­�¥|´�«?¤Jªg©G¥ � ©3Â1¬�¼@È ,e©G¼(¹ n ©GÂ1¬G¼@È � À T ´�ªº¥®­;¤�2�¼±©GÂ�¤��@³[¤ ¯ ¥®´½¬�¼±©G¹G´�µ%´�ªk¬ ° ¬�µ3¤ ° � À Á ­;¤eªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´»¥®´¶¤JªS©GÂ1¬�¼�È TÄ© ° ¤ � � ©G¼±¹ Ë ó � � ó�� Õ�À Á ­;¤ ° ¤S´�ªS©L¹�¹G´�¥|´¶¬�¼±©GÂ� ·<¬G¼(¤� � ¯ ¬�´»¼�¥c©3û¿©G·e¸ ° ¬G« ¦ ä T�À

Ë . Õ ' ß ' Ë � � ä ���kÕ�ÀË�� Õ ' ß ' Ë � Ê ähó � ��Õ-, ó � � � T�ÀË õ Õ ' ß ' Ë ó � Ê ä � ��Õ-, � Ê ä � � � T�ÀË � Õ ' ß ' Ë � Ê ä � � ä ���kÕ-, � Ê ä � � ä ��� � T�À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ íS2T24Z;=?H_bcHD^;>i*;>3AUB�0kKLH Ë � Õ X Y B;H/*�]�8 Ë ð�ï�Xæï Õ A�B;H'E�H�0GE�H`H �;03,'A�.78¾A+bv>i2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2a03.7>O*;:T N�2�0k8 � � 03*;^ � � X ' 512�ãZ H¿03.|X Ì HUB�0kKLH�ð<��o �� ß Ê ß � � Ê � � � Ê �� � � Ê X��S>�b >O*;Ha:O>sH/2ãA�B�E�>OZ;:OBA�B;HÔ.1512IA Ë ï�X7ð Õ A�><,[B;H/,�Q-A4B;H/24Hº0GE4HÔA�B;HÔ:O57KLH/*DC(>O24245V]�51.757A�57H/2u6�>3E $ N � X�)wARE�H/=_0357*;2u*;>�bçA�><2TB;>%bçA�B�0GAuA�B;H,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA451>O*;2u0GE�HM032R^;H'24,'E�5V](H/^�X@,�>3E Ë ð'Øwó Õ >O*;HS]�.7>%bu2uZ�CDA�B;H � Ê C(>O51*LAu03*;^-,/>O*LA4E[03,JA�2 T FIZ;2TAe032\51*A�B;HMC;E�>@>O6 >O6 Ë ð�ï�X . Õ X

,W>3E Ë ï Õ ~@+@Z�C;C(>O24HMÏ;E�2TA ' 512R03*L8 ' Ë ï � � Õ Xy)I6 Ñ ~ �çÒ�Ó ' H �@A4E[03,'A�2R0 Ò ó%ض,/Z�E4KLH3N U_N@A�B;H'*�]�8 Ë ï�Xpï Õ NË ï�X . Õ N@03*;^?A4B;HS.1512IAkN�A4B;HSo���ض*;H/:L0GA�57KLHuE[0�8a:O57KLH'2c0P]�57E[0GA451>O*�03.W,/>O*�ATE[03,'A�57>O* RÔ~ �çÒ�Ó ' Ë � Ê ä � � Õ X2#�H'A ](HPA4B;H Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLH#,/>O*LA4E[03,JA�H/^�]�8>RyXv)wA�6�>O.7.1>�be2eA4B�0GA�o��Dä 512e.7>O:<A�H'E4=?51*�03.®N ,/>O*LA[0357*;2eAwbc> � �C(>O57*�A42/NW03*;^�=?H/H'A42 U_X

�S>�b 0GC;C�.78-A�B;HU0G](>�KLHgbu57A4B4UÖ>O*;Hg>O6yA�B;H Ò ó%ض,/Z�E4KLH/2M51*qA�B;H � � C(>O51*LAã>3èm>O6 T X +@57*;,/HUo � ß ï�N

Page 100: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

.1+�+ ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

oÄä T ä 572#03*LA�5Vؽ03=<C�.1H3Xa)+AP6�>O.1.7>%bu2PA�B�0GA T � 512º0�2T51*;:O.1HUC(>O57*�AkN >O*;H?>O6¿A�B;H � � C(>O51*LA�2#03.7>O*;:T X +@Z�C;C±>O24H T 03*;^ =?H/H'AuA�B;H#2�03=?H Ò ó%ؽ,'Z�E4KLH3X Y B;H'*qbuB;H/*qbcH#H �@A4E[03,'A�A4B;512S,/Z�E4KLHGN±](>3A�B T 03*;^ 0GE�HU,/>O*LA4E[03,'A�5V]�.1H3N 0�,'>O*�A4E�03^;51,'A�57>O*�X Y B�Z;2Po��aä T ä 572ã.1>O:-,/03*;>O*;51,k03.®X �uH/24>O.VKLHUA�B;H � � C±>O51*LAT � � NW03*;^�,/>O*LA4E[03,JA T 03*;^ � Ë buB;51,[B"0GE4HÔ^;572»FI>O51*LA�>O*-A4B;HÔE�H/2T>O.1Z�A�57>O* Õ X Y B;512u:O57KLH/2RA�B;HM^;H/24,'E�5V](H/^,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA451>O*�X �D ¤J«<© °GF À � *;HM,/03*-03.724>g:O57KLHSH �@C�.151,'57Ac,/>O*;2IA4E�Z;,'A�57>O*;2u57* Ë .GØwõ Õ N�03.1>O*;:ºA�B;Hã.157*;H/2\>O6 Ë ó%Øwï Õ X Ì HSB�0kKLHã*;>3A^;>O*;HP2T>?032ubvHMbu51.7.�*;>3A�*;H/H/^-57AkX)wA#be57.1.v]±HD,'>O*�KLH/*;57H/*LA<A�>qB�0kKLH-0"KLH'E�2457>O*�>O6RA�B;H_Ï�*�03.\2TA[0GA�H/=<H/*�Ag>O6 Ë ð�ï�X . Õ 6�>3E?0q24.157:OB�A4.78Í=?>3E4H

:OH/*;H'E�03.�2T57A�Z�0GA�57>O*�~

� (�� ���-£ ¤J¥±¦ , T Ü '秨¤u¥|ûv¬#´�¼�¥+¤½È ° ©G ° ©3¥®´¶¬G¼±©GÂ(³Jù ° µO¤¨ªRª¨ùW³¨­<¥»­�©3¥(¦ Ü '�3#­�©�ªã© ° ´�¥®­�«?¤'¥®´¶³\È�¤J¼�ùsªM¬G¼(¤0,©G¼±¹<©G¼i¬ ° ¹G´�¼±© ° ·<³Jùsª ¯ ,�©G¼±¹ T «?¤¨¤J¥»ª¿¦ ©G¥¿¬�¼� ·?¬G¼(¤ ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥�,å©3¼±¹U¼(¬ ° «?©GÂ� · �I§/ùs¥�ù@¼� ´ F ¤ã´�¼ � A �@À � � ,�ûv¤¹�¬`¼(¬�¥S©�ª[ª¨ù@«?¤ o��gä T ´�ª# ¥�©G¥Rª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© °u¯ ¬G´�¼�¥®ª � À Á ­;¤J¼ o��aä ! ­;©�ªa©�¥®´1Ès¤ ° ¸k¬ ° ©G¼W·"¤»ÆS¤¨³J¥®´»µ3¤ !ûy´�¥®­`ª¨ù ¯L¯ ¬ ° ¥u³[¬�¼�¥w©G´�¼�¤�¹<´�¼_¦ ä TĪ¨ùW³¨­D¥®­�©G¥ o��ºä !ì´�ªP©G¼�¥|´�úw¼(¤®¸/À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀR¦ ��l Ò o���lpN324> ' 5722(M>3E4H/*;2TA�H/57*�X ' 3 512 2T51=<C�.V8Ô,'>O*;*;H/,'A�H/^g]�8 Ë � X .;X1ð Õ X�o�� � T ß Ò ð�ß ÒR¦ � T X� ]�24H'E4KLHeA4B�0GA T 512åA�B;H�Z;*;57r@Z;H Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�ETKLH�>O6 Ë ï�X : Õ X )+*;^;H/H/^`516�o �� - óMA4B;H/*_o��uä T 572v03*LA�5Vؽ03=<C�.1H3N

24> T 572\24=?>@>3A4B�03*;^`A�B�Z;2e0 Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�E4KLHGX � A�B;H'E4bu5124HGN�]�8_A�B;Hã.1572TAkN ' ß ' Ë U�� Õ N T ��l Ò o���læN�03*;^�2457*;,/H¦ B�032Ô0`,/Z;2TC�N T 512SA�B;HUZ;*;51rsZ;H Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�E4KLHU>O* ' N�]s8 Ë ï�Xæõ Õ X Ì HU*;>3A�HgA�B�0GAM51*ÐA�B;512M,k0324H3N T 57A�24H'.16¿572*;>3Au24=?>@>3A4B�X

�S>�b bvHº,/>O*;2457^;H'ESA�B;HPC±>O242457]�57.15VA�51H/2u51* Ë ï�X : Õ Xv)+* Ë ï�X1:�X1ð'Ø+ó Õ NWo��gä T 572�.1>O:UA�H'E�=?57*�03.|NW24> ¦ ä T 5720a6�H'*;,/H#03*;^ Ë ð�ï�X . Õ 0GC;C�.157H/2/X)+*UA4B;H\E4H/=_0351*;57*;:S,k0324H/2'N Ë ï�X1:�X ó%Ø � Õ N T =?H/H'A�2y0ãZ;*;51rsZ;H\,/Z�E4KLH3N �é>O6WA�B;H\=?57*;51=_03.�^;H/2457*;:OZ;.90GE�572�0GA�57>O*�X

#�H'A Ñ ~ �çÒWÓ ' HG��A4E[03,JA �<X T Ü � 3 572e0 Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLH3X@# HJA RM~ �éÒ�Ó ' Ê ,'>O*�A4E�03,'A T X�# HJA T Ê ß R Ë � Õ X� ]�24H'E4KLH Ë ' Ê � T Ê ��¦iÕ 03:L0351*�2�0GA�512IÏ�H/2<A�B;H-032424Z;=<C;A�57>O*;2a>O6 Ë ð�ï�Xpõ Õ Xjo ���� ß o �� Ò ðOX +@,k03.157*;:�032a51*Ë :�Xpó@X . Õ N�bcHP,k03*�Ï�*;^ ! Ê 2TZ�C;C(>3E4A�H'^"51* ¦ ä T Ê Ü ' Ê N�24>aA�B�0GAS0aA451:OH'Ee6�>3E�o�����ä ! Ê 51=<C�.751H/2u0aA�57:OH'E6�>3Euo��#ä ! X Y B�Z;2ubcHÔ=_0k8_51*;^;Z;,'Ae>O*�o �� X �� (�� � �����Í������.Wù ¯L¯ ¬�ªk¤ � Ü ' 3 ´�ª?©-ªJ«?¬�¬�¥®­ ° ©G¥®´½¬�¼±©G¿³Jù ° µO¤kÀ Á ­�¤J¼â¤J´»¥»­;¤ ° ' ß É�� ,M¬ ° ' ß 4�5©G¼±¹ � �hl ; 5�l À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ )+6 ' 572u24=<>@>3A�B�N ' ß É � X � A�B;H'ETbe5724Hº.1HJA Ñ ~ �çÒ�Ó ' H �@A4E[03,'Ae03*�8�H ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.�^;5VK�5724>3Ee>O6 A�B;H=?57*;51=_03.WE�H/24>O.7Z�A�51>O*�X +@51*;,/HÔo��ºä ¦ 512R*;H/:L0GA�5VKLH3NW03*;^ ¦ Ü � 3 N � =gZ;2TAu]±HP0U24=?>s>3A�B�*;HJAkN±03*;^ ¦ 024H/,JA�51>O*�X �

��� � � Ê �������

öSH'E�HãbcHMC;E�>%KLH

Page 101: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � .1+ .

� �»�4NÔ�%���å�±¡k���%���±�¿� � ¸ � Ê ´�ªº©_¼(¤J¥�,c©G¼±¹ R �� �Ê Ë ' 33 Õ ß � ð � ,奻­;¤'¼4' 3 ­�©Gªº©?¥|´1È�¤ ° À

� �i�W¡k¡k�����i�%� �%��� ý±� �±� � � � m�%� �;� ' 3 � ����¡_� �W�D� �s���Ð�Í�%�»ýW�@���å��� � R �� �Ê Ë ' 33 Õ ß � ð � � Ì Hbu51.1.�^;HJE�57KLHP0a,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�51>O*�XÌ Ha6�>O.1.1>�b A�B;Ha*;>3A[0GA�51>O*¾>O6 Ë :�X ó@X7ð�Å Õ X�+@51*;,/HUA�B;H'E�H_0GE4H<*;>�6�Z�E4A4B;H'E#B�Z;*�A#2IA�H'C�2PbcHa^�E�>3CÍA�B;Ha24Z�]�Ø

24,'E457C;A�2/N�bRE�57A�57*;:a6�>3EuH �;03=<C�.1H �=�-'9� U ��� 6�>3E � Ê �-' 3 � U Ê ��� 3 XÌ HgB�0kKLHUA�B;H É�Ê Ø¶Ï;];E�0GA�51>O* RÔ~ � ÒWÓ É�Ê X �eH/,/03.1.�51*ÐCW0GE4A�57,/Z;.90GEãA�B�0GA � 572ãA4B;Ha,/>sH�!?,'51H/*LAP>O6�U×51*

! 8 N;A�B�0GAu512Ro��Dä � U 512 R�Ø|A4E�5VK�5903.®Xo��`ä � U 572 /�Z;24B�N�Q�.VAkN�03*;^"03*LA�5Vض*;H/6 ]�8 Ë :�X .;X � Õ X

� � 5 �¿�@�Í����� R �� �Ê Ë � 3 Õ ß � ð � À U ´�ª#¼(¬G¥�2v§ ° ©GÂ7Àº£ ¤J¥ � §J¤#´»¥»ªU¹�¤½È ° ¤[¤kÀ � - ï À � � � ß ó � � À��e¼�·ª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|·D©GÂ1¬�¼@È U ­;©�ªMª ¯ ¤[³J¥ ° ©GÂ�µG©3 ù�¤U©G¥v«?¬%ª¨¥R¬�¼(¤kÀ

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Y B;HÔÏ;E42TA�,/.10351=à6�>O.7.1>�be2R69E�>O= Ë � Xpï Õ X2U � ��Å�N;24>SU ,k03*;*;>3Ae]±HMÏ;];E�03.|X#�H'A �ç](HS0Ô24=?>@>3A4BaÏ;];E�H3X �S>3A�H��Ý03*;^ U�:OH/*;H'E[0GA�HuA�B;HeAwbc>ºH/^;:OH'2v>O6(A�B;He,'>O*;H�>O6�,/Z�E4KLH � U Ê Ë �SÕ X

Ë o��Dä U Õ � U�� Ë o��Dä � U Õ�� U�ß Ñ " Ë o�� Õ�� U�ß Å

2457*;,/H U � � Å�XË o��`ä U Õ � ��ß Ò óuä �

buB;H'E�H �?572RA4B;HP^;H/:3E�H'HP>O6�U_X Ò Ë o��Dä U Õ 512u*;>3Ae*;H/6 Ë >3A�B;H'E4bu512TH�U 512u0UA�57:OH'E Õ N;24> � - ï�X

Åºß Ë o��`ä � U Õ � ��ß Ò óeä � � �

Y BsZ;2 � ßéó � � � ó �3ï�X �S>�b ]s8 Ë :�XpÅ�X � X ó Õ 03*L8<2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8?03.7>O*;: UÝB�032v2IC(H/,'ATE[03.�KG03.1Z;He0GAv=?>O2TAuðOX �Ì HM:OH'Au24>O=?HM,/>O*�ATE�>O.�69E�>O=àA�B;HÔA4E457K�5103.15VA+8?>O6 A�B;HP03.1:OH'];E[0357,Ô6�Z;*;^�03=<H/*�A�03.�:3E4>OZ�C�~

� ��( �����Í����� � ¸ Ñ ~ �àÒ�Ó É�Ê�´�ª_©aÉ�Ê�ú 2c§ ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼Íûå´�¥»­¾´ °¨° ¤�¹GùW³J´|§'Â1¤/2c§ ° ¤¨ª_©G¼±¹�ûå´�¥»­i¥»­ ° ¤[¤`¬ ° «?¬ ° ¤«gù@ ¥®´ ¯ Â1¤�2c§ ° ¤¨ª0,c¬ ° ¥|ûv¬?«gùs ¥|´ ¯ Â1¤ 2v§ ° ¤¨ª#¬+¸Ô¼(¬�¼�ú ° ¤JÂ7©G¥|´�µ3¤J · ¯±° ´�«?¤P«Uùs ¥|´ ¯  ´¶³'´�¥®· ,¿¥®­;¤J¼ R �� �Ê Ë � 3 Õ��ß � ð � À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ )+6eAwbc>ÐÏ;];E�H/2?B�0kKLH-*;>O*@Ø|E�H/.10GA�57KLH/.V8ÍC;E�51=<H�=gZ;.7A457C�.157,/57Aw8LN�A�B;H/*�A�B;H'E�H�512a0i*;>O*@ضATE�[email protected]�>3E�2T51>O*Ì H/57.±^;5VK�512T>3EkN�03*;^_B;H/*;,'HÔ0MÏ�*;57A�H �H'A�03.1H�,/>�KLH'Ec>O6 � 3 X�)+6�A4B;H'E�HS0GE�H�0GAc.1Hk032IAvA�B�E�H/HS=gZ;.VA�57C�.7HuÏ;];E�H/2'N@A�B;H/*A�B;H'E4HU572M0_];E�03*;,¨B;H'^¾,/>�KLH'E �×ÒWÓ É�Ê N(be5VA�B"E[03=?57Ï�,/0GA�51>O*"=_0GA4,¨B;57*;:_A�B;H#=gZ;.7A�5VC�.151,'57A�57H/2�>O6yA�B;H#Ï;];E�H/2Ë 24H'H Ë õ�X � Õ >O6ãîæó3ïGñ Õ X Y B;Ha*;>3E�=_03.7512�0GA�57>O*q>O6�A�B;HgC�Z;.1.V]W03,[Qi>O6 � :O5VKLH/2Ô0�,/>�KLH'EkN��H'A[03.1Hg57*¾,/>s^;51=?H/*;2T51>O*>O*;H Ë 24H/H Ë )4)4)¨X # X7ð Õ >O6cî .3ñ Õ X �

+@>"]s8 Ë ð�.;Xpï Õ N�RëB�032g0GAº=?>O2TAºAwbc>q=gZ;.7A�5VC�.1HUÏ;];E�H/2/N�03*;^m516cA�B;H'E�HD0GE�H?Awbc>"=gZ;.VA�57C�.7H<Ï;];E�H/2/NyA�B;H/5VE=gZ;.7A�5VC�.157,/57A�57H/2R0GE�HãE�H/.90GA457KLH/.V8_C;E�51=?HGX

Page 102: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

.1+�) ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

� � �¿���Í����� � - ð��Oó À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ íS2T24Z;=?H � � ð��Oó@X $v8-A�B;HºÏ�*�03. E4H/=_0GE4Q->O6 Ë ð�Å�X : Õ N ' B�032ã0GAS.7Hk032TASA�B�E4H/H#*;>O* ãZ H¿03. 2457*;:OZ@Ø.90GE457A�57H/2/N�03*;^ ð��3ï � � � ð��Oó@X Y BsZ;2#]�8 Ë ð�Å�X7ð Õ N ��ß Ë ï �����kÕ 6�>3E =¾ÃÖð`03*;^ UÄ,/>O*�A�0351*;2#0�Z;*;57r@Z;H2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8LN � N 03* ��� C(>O51*LAkX � ß � � Ê

� � � � - ó � � X Y B�Z;2P]�8 Ë ð�.;X ó Õ N � � .;XS#�H'A � Ê ]±H<A�B;H<=gZ;.VA�57C�.7HÏ;];E�Hg,/>O*LA[0351*;57*;: � X $v8 Ë ðOðOX � X � Õ N�A�B;H'E4H#512SH �;03,'A�.78->O*;H#>3A�B;H'EM=gZ;.7A�5VC�.1HMÏ;];E�H3N � � N�03*;^q5VAã,/>O*�A�0351*;2ã0*;>O* ãZ8H¿03.(C(>O57*�A/XY B;H�C(>O2T2457]�.7H�*;>O*�ãZ H¿03.vÏ;];E�H/2'Nv]s8 Ë ðOðOX � X # Õ N�0GE�H Ë ðOðOX � X # Xpó Õ N Ë ðOðOX � X # Xpõ Õ Nå03*;^ Ë ðOðOX � X # X � Õ be5VA�B

;Ußéó@N;buB;51,[B�B�0kKLHME4H/2TC(H','A�57KLHÔ=gZ;.7A�5VC�.151,'57A�57H/2cA�B�E�H/H3N;Ï;KLH3N�03*;^�A4B�E�H/H3XË ðOðOX � X # Xpõ Õ 572e*;>3ARC(>O242T57]�.1HGN�6�>3E U =gZ;2TA�=<H/H'Au24Z;,[Bq0UÏ;];E�H#0GAe0<2457*;:OZ;.90GEuC(>O51*LA Ë >3A�B;H'E4bu512TH �_512u0GA

.1H/032TA � Õ N�0_,/>O*LA4E[03^;51,JA�51>O*�N�032�A�B;572SÏ;];E�Hg,/>O*�A�0351*;2ã*;>�ãZ Hv03. 2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8 Ë 03*;^qA4B;HU>O*;.V8"2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8>O*>U 512�ãZ>Hv03. Õ XY BsZ;2M03*L8q*;>O* ãZ Hv03.�Ï;];E�HaB�032ã=gZ;.7A457C�.157,/57Aw8�A�B�E�H/H3Xã)+*ÐCW0GETA�51,/Z;.10GESA�B;512ãB;>O.7^;2M6�>3E � � X Y BsZ;2ã]�8

Ë ð�.;Xæï Õ N � Ê 512 ãZ Hv03.®X � � A�B;H/*#=gZ;2TA ,/>O*LA[0351*PAwbc>e*;>O* MZ�Hv03.OC(>O57*�A42/N3,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�51*;:uA�B;H¿^;H/2T,'E�57C;A451>O*;2Ë ðOðOX � X # X ó Õ 03*;^ Ë ðOðOX � X # X � Õ X �

$v8 Ë ð�.;X ó Õ 03*;^ Ë ð�.;X . Õ N �ºßçï�XÌ Ha.1H'A �c~ ��ÚÒ±Ó � ](H_0�E4H/.90GA�5VKLHa=<51*;51=?03.�=?>@^;H'.|N 032P51* Ë ðOðOX � X . Õ XS$v8 Ë ðOðOX � X � Õ A�B;H'E�H_0GE4HaAwbc>

,[B;>O51,/H'2e6�>3E��-0GARHk03,[B�=gZ;.7A457C�.1HãÏ;];E�H3X� � � �����Í������£ ¤'¥ � §¨¤�©i«gù@ ¥®´ ¯ Â1¤ 2v§ ° ¤"¬+¸ R À �q¤D«<©3·m³¨­�¬�¬%ªk¤ � ª�¬Ð¥»­�©3¥ � Ë U ÕD´�ª_ª¨«?¬�¬G¥»­�©G¥¥®­;¤U´�«<©�Ès¤ 2c§ ° ¤0,�©3¼±¹ �U �?Ès¬�¤¨ª#ù ¯ §/·�©G¥u«?¬%ª¨¥ . À (ù ° ¥®­;¤ ° ´Ç¸ �U �"³¨­;©G¼@È�¤¨ªa§'· . ,R¥»­�¤J¼ � ´�ª#ù@¼�´|ø'ùW¤J ·¹�¤J¥+¤ ° «g´�¼(¤�¹�À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Ì HeZ;24HeA4B;He,/.103242457Ï�,/0GA�51>O* Ë ðOðOX � X # Õ X Ì He,[B;H/,�QaÏ;E�2TA¿A4B�0GA¿5VAv0GC;C�.751H/2/X�$v8 Ë ð�.;X ó Õ NLA4B;He2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5ÛØA�57H/2¿03.7>O*;:�U�B�0�KLHR2TC±H/,'A4E[03.;KG03.1Z;Hu0GA¿=<>O2TARðON�2T>P516 � =<H/H'A�2�U�57*?0M2451*;:OZ;.10GE�C±>O51*LAkNOA�B;H/*<]�8 Ë :�XpÅ�X1:�X}] Õ NË ðOðOX � X # Õ 0GC;C�.157H/2/X � A4B;H'E4bu5124H � =<H/H'A�2 U 57*�0U2451*;:O.7HÔ24=<>@>3A�B`C(>O57*�AkN�03*;^-24>aA�B;HM=gZ;.7A�5VC�.157,/57Aw8_>O6 � 572A�B�E�H'H3N±03*;^DbcHP,/03*"0GC;C�.78 Ë ðOðOX � X1ð�ï Õ XÌ HRbe57.1.W51*;^;51,/0GA�HeA�B;HRA+8sC(H�>O6(A4B;HeÏ;];E�H Ë Z;2T51*;:ºA�B;H�*;>3A�0GA�51>O*?>O6 Ë ðOðOX � X . Õ4Õ NOA�B;H�,[B�03*;:OHS51*��U � Z;*;^;H'E

�±N(03*;^q.1Hk0kKLHPA�B;HP,¨B;>O57,/H#>O6 ��A�><A�B;HºE�H/03^;H'EkX Ì Hº.1HJA � ]±HPA�B;Hº,[B�03*;:OH#51* �U � Ë 6�>3ES>3C;A�57=_03.�,¨B;>O57,/H#>O6� Õ Xå)+6 � =?H'H'A�2 U 51*DAwbc><2457*;:OZ;.90GERC(>O57*�A�2'N�A4B;H/*-A�B;HMÏ;];E�HP572

Ë Ò ï Õ ä Ë Ò ð Õ ä Ë Ò ó Õ ä Ë Ò ó Õ � � ßéó �

)+6 � =?H/H'A42 U 51*�>O*;HM2457*;:OZ;.90GEeC±>O51*LAkN�03*;^�>O*;HÔ24=?>@>3A4BDC±>O51*LAkN;A�B;H/*�A4B;HÔÏ;];E�HÔ512

Ë Ò ó Õ ä Ë Ò ð Õ ä Ë Ò ó Õ � � ßéó �

>3E#:O5VKLH/*�]s8 Ë ðOðOX � X # X1ð Õ 03*;^ � ß×ï�X_)+6 � =?H/HJA�2 UÄ57*Í>O*;H<C(>O57*�AkN�0�2451*;:OZ;.10GEºC(>O57*�AkN�03*;^ �UÄ03*;^ ��=?H/HJAkN�A4B;H/*?A�B;HuÏ;];E4H�512¿03:L0351* Ë Ò ó Õ ä Ë Ò ð Õ ä Ë Ò ó Õ N � ßéó@X�)+6 � 03*;^ UÝ=?H'H'Av>O*;.V8a>O*;,'H3N;0GA¿0P24=?>s>3A�B

Page 103: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � .1+-�

C(>O57*�A/N�A�B;H'*<n×ßéï�N�03*;^aA�B;HRÏ;];E�He572�:O5VKLH/*U]�8 Ë ðOðOX � X # X ó Õ >3E Ë ðOðOX � X # X � Õ N�be5VA�B � ß .;NL>3EvïãE�H/2TC±H/,'A�5VKLH/.78LX,�51*�03.7.78a516 �U 03*;^ �� 0GE�HS^;572»FI>O51*LAkN;03*;^ � =?H'H'A�2 U 57*`0g2T51*;:O.1He2451*;:OZ;.10GEcC(>O51*LAkN@A4B;H/*_A�B;H�Ï;];E�Hã512v:O5VKLH/*]�8 Ë ðOðOX � X # X � Õ be5VA�B4;gß ï�N�>3E Ë ðOðOX � X # Xæõ Õ N�03*;^�57*-H/5VA�B;H'Ee,k0324H � ß ï�X �* ° ¬�¬+¸º¬I¸ � A � À A � À íS2RE4H/=_0GE4QLH/^D](H/.7>%b Ë ð�.;Xpï Õ N RiB�032�0GAu=?>O2TA\Awbc><=gZ;.7A457C�.1HSÏ;];E�H'2/N±03*;^-,k03*;*;>3A�B�0kKLHAwbc>`>O6�A�B;H#2�03=?Hº=gZ;.VA�57C�.751,/5VA+8LX Y BsZ;2S]�8 Ë ð�.;X � Õ bcH#=_0k8-,[B;>@>O2TH ��24>_A�B�0GA � Ë U Õ 572ã0`2T=?>@>3A�B�A4E�57C�.7H24H/,JA�51>O*i>O6�24H'.161ؽ57*�A4H'E�24H/,JA�51>O*Í0GAM=?>O2IA �iË ,'>3E4E�H/2TC±>O*;^;51*;:DA�>DA4B;HU,/0324HUbuB;H/* �U � ß Ò ó@N�A�B;H'E�Ha0GE�H#Awbc>=gZ;.7A�5VC�.1H�Ï;];E�H'2/NW03*;^�NWZ;*;^;HJE��±N �U � :O>sH/2\Z�C-]�8_A�B�E�H/HÔ0GAR>O*;HÔ=gZ;.VA�57C�.7H�Ï;];E�H3NW03*;^�6�>OZ�Ee0GA\A�B;Hã>3A�B;H'E Õ X$cZ�Au]�8 Ë ðOðOX � X7ð Õ Å�N � Ë U Õ � ßéó �#ß õ�X Y B�Z;2ubcHÔB�0�KLHP0a,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�57>O*�X �

�%� � � Ë �MÕ Ã ð �öSH'E�HãbcHMC;E�>%KLH

� �(�7� NM��� ����¡k���%�»���¿� � ¸ ' ß ' 3 ¹�¬%¤¨ªU¼(¬�¥�­;©Gµ3¤_©"¥®´1Ès¤ ° ©3¼±¹ � Ë � Ê Õ&- ó ,S¥®­;¤J¼ ' ´�ªU¥®­;¤<ª¨ù ° ¸/©�³[¤<´�¼� A ��ÀCB � ,v©G¼(¹ ' 3 ´�ªMùs¼W´ ° ù@Â1¤�¹LÀ

�#� �%�±� ý±� ��� � � � �¾�#�"�W¡k¡k����� ' ß ' 3 � �W¡<� ���%��ý��s�s�ð��3ï � � 3 � � N�]�8 Ë ð�Å�X : Õ N�03*;^"2T>a]�8 Ë :�Xæï�X � Õ � H/5VA�B;H'EeB�032e=gZ;.7A�5VC�.157,/57Aw8_A�B�E�H'H3N�>3Ee0<^;>OZ�]�.7HÔC(>O57*�A/X

$v8 Ë :�X .;X � Õ N�o�� ��ä � Ê U Ê 512%/�Z;24B�X Y B;HMC(>O24245V]�.1HÔ,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*;2u6�>3E � Ê Ò±Ó ' Ê Ë 57*�0U*;H/51:OBL](>OZ�E�B;>s>@^>O6 Ê Õ 0GE�HÔ,'.90324245VÏ�H/^"51* Ë ðOðOX1ð'ؽï Õ XÌ H?bu51.7.�E�H'C±Hk0GA�H/^;.V8ÍZ;24H_A�B;H_B�Z;*�Aa*;>3A[0GA�57>O* Ë :�X ó@X7ð�Å Õ N A�B;H_*;>3A�0GA�51>O*Í>O6 Ë ðOðOXpÅ�X7ð Õ A�>"^;H'24,'E�5V](H`A�B;H

,/>O*LA4E[03,'A451>O*>RM~ � Ê Ò�Ó ' Ê NW03*;^-A�B;HM*;>3A[0GA�57>O*->O6 Ë ð�Å�X ó Õ XÌ Hã](H/:O57*-]�8DE4Z;.151*;:a>OZ�Ae=gZ;.VA�57C�.751,/5VA+8<A�B�E�H/H3~

� �(�»� �¿���Í������ Ê ³�©G¼�¼�¬�¥å­;©Gµ3¤P«Uùs ¥|´ ¯  ´¶³'´�¥®·?¥®­ ° ¤¨¤kÀ

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ +@Z�C;C±>O24H � Ê B�032u=UZ;.VA�57C�.751,/5VAw8_A�B�E�H/H3X Y B;HÔC±>O242457]�.7Hº.1>s,k03.�C�51,'A4Z�E�H/2�6�>3E R�0GE�HP:O5VKLH/*"51* Ë ðOðOXpï Õ Nbu57A�B � ß U Ê X $v8 Ë :�XpÅ�X # X7ð Õ N � 3 � ð��Oó@NR24> � 3 ß Ë ï ��� �JÕ 6�>3ED24>O=?H $ NR]�8 Ë ð�Å�X7ð Õ X $v8 Ë ð�Å�X : Õ No � �� � ß Ò ðOX� >O*;2451^;H'EcbuB�0GA\B�0GC;C(H'*;2\buB;H/*�Ri572v:O57KLH'*`]�8 Ë ðOðOXæï�X ó Õ >3E Ë ðOðOXpï�Xæï�X ó Õ Ë *sZ;=?HJE�51,k03.7.78UA�B;H/24Hã,k032TH/2R0GE�H

51*;^;572TA�57*;:OZ;5124B�0G]�.7H Õ Xe)+*"A�B;Hº*;>3A[0GA451>O*">O6 Ë ðOðOXpÅ�X7ð Õ N ¦ N T 0GE�HºA�B;HºAwbc>`03*�03.V8@A�57,P^;5724,/2�buB;H'E�H UÚ=?H/HJA�2 X�,�E�>O= A�B;HS^;H/24,'E457C;A�57>O*�>O6�A�B;HS,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E�0GA�51>O*�N � 3 ß Ë ï � ó Õ X $v8 Ë ð�Å�X1: Õ A�B;HJE�Hã512\0º*;>O*�ãZOH¿03.�C±>O51*LA0kb\0�8D69E�>O= Xy)+*-CW0GETA�51,/Z;.10GE � - ð��3ï Ë �j>O6 Ë ð�Å�X ó Õ4Õ X2$c8 Ë ð�Å�X # Õ

o �� � ß Ò ðvätð��3ïuähó � � ä��Ðß Ë o�� �=� Õ � �

ß Ë Ò ðvä�ð��3ïeähï � � Õ �Ë Ò ð¿ätð��3ïRä � � � Õ �

03*;^�24> �¾ß ï �@ðOð �éð��3ï�N�0a,'>O*�A4E�03^;51,'A�57>O*�X

Page 104: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

.1+�� ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

�S>�bÝ,/>O*;2T51^;H'E Ë ðOðOXæï�Xpï�X1ð Õ X +@51*;,/H#A�B;HJE�H#512ã0GAã.7Hk032TAM0 Ë ó � ï Õ 2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457Aw8LN � 3 ß Ë ï ��� �[Õ bu57A�B $ - ðOX$v8 Ë ð�Å�Xpõ Õ A�B;H'E�Hg0GE�HP*;>_2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2�0kb\0k8�69E�>O= XRíS2 �Uß ð�Å�N $ ß õ�X $\Z�AeA�B;H/*�A�B;Hº2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457A�57H/203.1>O*;: 0GE�HMH ��03,'A4.78 Ë ï 89Õ N Ë ó 8 � ï Õ 03*;^ Ë ï 8 ��� � Õ 03*;^�24>ao�� �+� ß Å�NW0a,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�57>O*�X �Ì HM*;>%bçA�Z�E4*�A�>a^;>OZ�]�.1HÔC±>O51*LA�2e>O6 :OH/*�Z;2 � - ó@XÌ H?,'>O*;2451^;H'EU57*�A�Z�E�*mHk03,[BjC±>O24245V]�.1H_,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA451>O*Í>O* � Ê 69E�>O= A�B;H_,/.9032T2457Ï�,k0GA451>O* Ë ðOðOX7ð'Ø+ó Õ X Ì H

*;>3A�HMA�B�0GA�,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E�0GA�51>O*qÅ<6�>3E�0<*;>@^;HP,k03*;*;>3AS>@,',/Z�E Ë 2T51*;,/H U 512e2T=?>@>3A�B Õ X�)+*�A�B;Hº,k032THP>O6�A�B;HÔ*;>@^;HbcH_0GC;C�.V8iA4B;H?,/.9032T2457Ï�,k0GA451>O*¾bu57A�B ¦ 03*;^ T Ë 51*iA�B;H?*;>3A[0GA�57>O*�>O6 Ë ðOðOXæÅ�X1ð Õ4Õ A�B;HaA+bv>-];E[03*;,[B;H/2g>O6 �0GA ��Ë A4B�0GAº512MA�B;HaAwbc>�];E[03*;,[B;H/2#>O6 U 03.7>O*;: Õ N�03*;^ � ß �"ß � XS,W>3EMA�B;H<,/Z;2IC�N�bcHaA[0GQLH ¦ ß � N� ß � X Ì HÔ*;>3A�HPA�B�0GAuA�B;Hº*;>s^;H#03*;^",/Z;2TCÐ,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA451>O*;2�.10G](H/.7H/^�]s8DA�B;Hº2403=?HÔE�>O=?03*�*sZ;=<H'E[03. 0GE�H*�Z;=?H'E�57,k03.1.V8`51*;^;512IA�51*;:OZ;5724B�0G]�.1H3XJ ����9�ý�� �%�;�%�»��� ��� )I*?A4B;512¿2TZ�]�24H/,'A�57>O*?bcHS03.724>º03.7.1>�b��aßÝðON@2457*;,/He=<>O2TA¿>O6�A�B;HS03*�03.78@24512å51*aA�B;512�,k0324H512\A�B;HÔ2�03=?H Ë 03*;^-A�B;572Rbu51.7.�2�0kKLHº0a.757A4A4.1HSbc>3E4QD51* � ð�õ�Ø�ð � Õ X

$v8 Ë ðOðOX7ð'Ø+ó@X1ð Õ N � ßÖð��Oó@X Y B�Z;2að��3ï � � 3 � ð��Oó@XE$v8 Ë ð�Å�X1: Õ N�o � �� � ß Ò ðON � 3 à ð��3ï�X $c8 Ë ð�Å�X1ð Õ N� 3 ß Ë ï �����/Õ bu57A�B = - ðON(03*;^ � 3 ß � � Ê

� � � � - ó � � X $c8DA�B;Hº^;H'24,'E�5VC;A�51>O*q>O6 � >O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�51>O*�)¨N � Ê Ü ' Ê,/>O*LA[0351*;2e0aZ;*;57r@Z;HP2T51*;:OZ;.90GERC(>O57*�A/N�03* ��� C±>O51*LAkX@$c8 Ë ð�Å�X # Õ bcHPB�0kKLH

Ò ð¿ä � 3 ä��ÐßË o�� �+� Õ �

�ß Ë Ò ðvähó � 3 Õ �

. � 3 ä � � Ê� Ò ð

24>?A�B�0GA �Íß �� �� � Ê�

��� � Ê

X $v8 Ë ð�Å�X : Õ N � - ï�N±2T><A�B;H'E�Hg0GE4Hº0GA�.7Hk032TA�Awbc><*;>O* MZ H¿03.�2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2e>3è XY BsZ;2 � - ó �3ï�X +@51*;,/H � 3 ß � � Ê

� � � � - ó � � N � ��� ��

�� �� � ó �3ï�X Y BsZ;2RbcHP=gZ;2TAuB�0kKLHPH/rsZ�03.157Aw8`57*-Hk03,[B">O6

A�B;HM51*;H/rsZ�03.15VA�51H/2'N =Mß �aßÝðº03*;^DA�B;HÔ*;>O*�ãZ8H¿03.�2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2\>O6 ' 3 0GE�HÔHG��03,'A�.V8 Ë ó � ï Õ � Ë ï Õ-� Ë ï Õ X�$c8Ë ð�Å�Xæõ�X ó Õ A�B;H'E�He512¿HG��03,'A�.V8U>O*;H�>3A�B;H'E¿2451*;:OZ;.10GE¿C(>O57*�A/N@03* � �\C(>O51*LAkX �S>�b ,/>O*;2451^;HJEcA�B;HuA4E�03*;246�>3E�=_0GA�57>O*' Ê � ��� � >O6 Ë ð%ó@X . Õ X � B�032ÔE�03*�Q¾>O*;H<]�8 Ë ð%ó@X .;X1ð Õ X Y B;H Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLH � Ë >O6 Ë ð%ó@XpÅ Õ4Õ 512Ô57E4E�H'^;Z;,/57]�.7H3No����yä � 512ã*;H/:L0GA457KLH3N�03*;^�� ,/>O*�A�0351*;2ãA�B;Ha2T51*;:OZ;.90GEãC±>O51*LA�2 Ë ï Õ � Ë ï Õ � Ë ó Õ >O6 ' Ê N�]�8 Ë ð%ó@X1ðOXæï�Ø�. Õ X $c803^�FIZ;*;,'A�57>O* � ,k03*;*;>3A\,/>O*LA[0351*D03*L8_>3A�B;H'E\2T51*;:OZ;.90GEcC±>O51*LA�2/N;03*;^`o����(ä � 512v.7>O:ºA�H'E�=?57*�03.|N�beB;H'E4H �512�A�B;H�E�H/^;Z;,'A451>O*`>O6 � X Y BsZ;2 � ß ' Ë � � ä � � Õ X�$cZ�AvA�B;H'E4HS512v*;>g24Z;,[BD24Z�E�6�03,/Hã51*?A4B;HS.1512IA Ë ï�X7ð Õ X �J ����9�ý�� �%�;�%�»��� ���W�

$v8 Ë ðOðOX1ðOX7ð Õ 03*;^ Ë ðOðOXpó@X1ð Õ � 3 � � ß �� Ê� �� Ê � ï � � N�03*;^�24>�]�8 Ë ð�Å�X1ð Õ H/5VA�B;H'E�� 3 ß Ë ó � ï � ó � ó Õ 03*;^

�aßéó@N�>3E � 3 ß Ë ��� ï Õ X

+@Z�C;C(>O2TH � 3 ß Ë ï ����Õ X � 3 �Ýð��Oó@N�24>?A�B;HºÏ�*�03.�E�H/=_0GE4Q�>O6 Ë ð�Å�X1: Õ B;>O.1^;2'X #�H'A � ](HPA4B;H Ò ó%ض,/Z�E4KLH

buB;51,[B¾=?H'H'A�2 X � *;HU,[B;H/,�Q�2 B�032M,/>@H�!<,/51H'*�A ��� �� � >O* � 03*;^ � �

� Ê� �� � >O*4U_XPíS.724> � 3 ß �

� � �� � X $c8

Ë ð�Å�X # Õ bvHÔB�0kKLHÒ ðvä �Mäëð

ó �ãähï ä��ÐßË Ò ð¿ä � �

� Ê� �� � Õ �

��� Ê

� �� � Ò ð

Page 105: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � .1+"�

24>?A�B�0GA �mß �� � � ÊX +@51*;,'H � - ï�N � - ó �3ï�N�24>_57A�6�>O.1.1>�bu2eA�B�0GA �_ßÝó?03*;^ �mßÝó �3ï�X Y B�Z;2�A�B;H'E4Hg0GE�H

H �;03,'A�.78`Awbc>?>3A4B;H'ES*;>O*@Ø ãZ H¿03.�C(>O51*LA�2/N�Hk03,[B Ë ï Õ X%+@57*;,/H �Uß ð�ÅaA�B;H'E�HP512�03*;>3A4B;H'E�2457*;:OZ;.90GE�C±>O51*LAkN ��NA�B;H?>O*;.V8Ð>3A�B;H'Eº2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457Aw8LN ]�8 Ë$# X ó Õ X Y B�Z;2 � Ë � Õ ß � XO$cZ�AMA�B;H/* ��B�032º57*;^;H ��0GAº.1H/032TA#õ�N 03*;^�bcHB�0kKLHP2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2R>O6 57*;^;H �-0GAe.7Hk032TA Ë ï � ï � õ � � Õ N�beB;57,¨B�K�51>O.10GA�H/2 Ë # Xpó Õ X

�S>�b 2TZ�C;C(>O24H � 3 ß Ë ó � ó � ï � ó Õ XO$v8 Ë ð�Å�X1ðOð Õ N�U 512PA4B;H Ò ï�ض,/Z�E4KLH3X Y B;H/*�N�]�8¾A�B;H_^;H'24,'E�5VC;A�51>O*m>O6,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA451>O*â)4)¨N � ,/>O*LA[0351*;2`0ÍZ;*;57r@Z;Hq2451*;:OZ;.10GE?C(>O57*�A/N � NR>O6 ' Ê Nu03* � Ê C(>O57*�A/X � Ë >O6 � ð%ó Õ 57257ETE�H/^;Z;,/5V]�.1Hº>3EeH/=<C;Aw8`]s8 Ë ð%ó@X1ðOX � Õ X¿o�� ��ä � ä� 512u*;H/:L0GA�5VKLH3N±03*;^-24><]�8 Ë ð%ó@X7ðOX . Õ 03*;^"03^�FIZ;*;,'A�57>O*�N� ��.;X � 3 ß õ �@ðOðON;2T><bcHMB�0�KLHÔ>O*;HP>O6 Ë ð�Å�X :�Xpï�Ø � Õ X�)+*-CW0GE4A�57,/Z;.90GE/N;o � �� � ß Ò ðP>3E Ò ó@X Ì HMB�0�KLH

o � �� � ähõ �@ðOð�ä��iß Ë Ò ð¿ähõ �@ðOð�ä . �@ðOð Õ �Ò ðcäâó'. �@ðOð

A�B�Z;2 �iß õ �@ð�ï �éð��Oóg>3E �ißÝð¿ä�õ �@ð�ï�N�^;H'C(H/*;^;57*;:?>O*-buB;H'A�B;H'Eeo � �� � 512 Ò ðÔ>3E Ò ó@X+@Z�C;C(>O2TH<bcH<B�0kKLHaA4B;H<24H/,'>O*;^�C(>O24245V]�51.757Aw8LX Y B;H/*�]�8 Ë ð�Å�X : Õ N ��ß ï�N � ß .;N A�B�Z;2ÔA4B;H'E�H?0GE4HaAwbc>

=?>3E�HU2457*;:OZ;.90GEºC±>O51*LA�2/N�>O*;H3N � >O6vbvH/51:OBLA#>O*;H3N�03*;^�A4B;H<>3A�B;H'E/N ��N�>O6vbcH/57:OB�APA+bv>;X Y B;H?>O*;.V8ibvH/51:OBLAAwbc>?2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2�>O6�,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LAM0GA�=?>O2TA � 3 ß õ �@ðOðº0GE�Hº:O57KLH'*-]s8 Ë ð�Å�X1ðOXpó Õ X¿)+*�CW0GE4A�57,/Z;.90GE/N � Ë � Õ ß ðOXöSH/*;,/H � Ë �;Õ ß � Ë �;Õ ß õ �@ð�ï�X�$v8 Ë ð�Å�X1ð Õ N � ß Ë ï �����JÕ X +@51*;,/H �`ßÚðOðON � Ë � Õ ß ðON �_ß Ë . Õ N�03*;^ÐA4B;H'E�H0GE�HÔ*;>_>3A�B;H'E�2T51*;:OZ;.90GEuC(>O57*�A�2'X%$c8 Ë ð%ó@Xæï�X � Õ � Ü ' Ê 572e*;>O*;H/=<C;Aw8LNW03*;^"=gZ;2TAeCW032T2uA�B�E�>OZ;:OB Ë ó Õ 03*;^Ë . Õ X�$v8�03^�FIZ;*;,'A�57>O* � 512R24=?>@>3A4B�X@$cZ�ARA�B;H/* � ,'>O*�A4E�03,'A�2e>O* ' Ê N�0U,/>O*LA4E[03^;51,JA�51>O*�XY BsZ;2�bcHåB�0�KLHåA�B;HåÏ;E42TA C±>O24245V]�51.15VAw8LX �SH/,'H/242�0GE�57.78SA�B;HJE�H¿572�HG��03,'A�.V8ã>O*;H�=<>3E�Hy*;>O* ãZ�H¿03.32457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8LN

� N�03*;^ � Ë �;Õ ßÝðOX +@>�¾ß � Ë �;Õ ß � Ë �;Õ ß õ �@ð�ï

03*;^-A�B�Z;2 � ß Ë ï �����'Õ ]s8 Ë ð�Å�X1ð Õ X +@51*;,'H �gß ð�Å�N;A�B;HJE�H#0GE�HÔ*;>?>3A�B;H'Ee2451*;:OZ;.10GEeC(>O57*�A42/X Ì HP*;>�b 24B;>�bA�B;H'E4HP512RH �;03,'A�.78`>O*;HMC(>O242T57]�51.757Aw8`6�>3E ' ß ' 3 X �������%����� � ¬ ° ©m³[¬�¼W´¶³g¦ Ü É���©G¼±¹ ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥®ª � � � � Î � ¦ ,ºûv¤DÂ1¤J¥ �

�©3¼±¹ � � ´»¼±¹G´¶³�©3¥w¤`¥®­;¤

ªk¤[³[©G¼�¥¿¥»­ ° ¬�ùLÈ�­ � � � ,c©G¼(¹<¥»­�¤P¥w©G¼@È�¤J¼W¥� ´�¼�¤P¥®­ ° ¬�ùLÈ�­ Î À� �(� 5 7D�:9y�����%���±�

��¿���Í�����`£ ¤J¥ �שG¼±¹ � §¨¤ã¥|ûv¬gª¨«?¬%¬�¥»­�³¨¬�¼�´¶³¨ªS«?¤¨¤J¥®´»¼@ÈU¥w¬_¬ ° ¹�¤ ° ¸k¬Gù ° ´»¼UÉ � ©G¥c©

¯ ¬�´»¼�¥ � À/*c´½³ F © ¯ ¬G´�¼�¥ � �ß � ¬+¸ �-À+*\´¶³ F © ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥ � ¬+¸ � � � � À\£ ¤J¥ � 8v§¨¤ã¥®­;¤#¬�¥®­;¤ °�¯ ¬G´�¼�¥v¬+¸ � � � �-À£ ¤'¥ � 8 §¨¤#© ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥R¬+¸ � � � � � À£ ¤'¥ Ñ ~ �'�Ò�Ó É���§'Â1¬�û�ù ¯ ¬G¼(³[¤#©G¥ � , � 8 , � 8 ,¿¥®ûy´½³[¤#©GÂ1¬�¼�È � � ©3¥ � ,c©G¼(¹ 2åµ3¤P¥®´�«_¤¨ªº©GÂ1¬�¼�È � ©G¥ � À�q¤M­�©3µ3¤Ë ð Õ �'ç´�ªM¥»­�¤P«g´�¼W´�«<©G ° ¤¨ªk¬� ù@¥|´¶¬�¼�¬+¸3'eÀË ó Õ �eÂ�Ây³[¬�¼�2�È3ù ° ©G¥®´½¬�¼;ª Ë � � �<� � ÕP© ° ¤ ¯±° ¬+²k¤[³J¥|´�µ3¤' ·a´�ª�¬�«?¬ °½¯ ­�´¶³kÀ � ¼ ¯ © ° ¥|´¶³Jù@Â7© ° 'ç´�ªMù@¼�´|ø/ù�¤kÀË ï Õ � � � «_¤[¤J¥®ª �tá � � � � 8 � � � ´�¼q¥|ûv¬`¹3´�ª¨¥|´�¼(³J¥ ¯ ¬�´�¼W¥»ª/ÀË . Õ � � � ´�ªM¼�¬�¥v¥½©G¼�È�¤J¼�¥¿¥w¬ �<À eø'ùs´»µG©GÂ1¤J¼�¥| · � ´�ªM¼(¬�¥\©?ù@¼�´|§ ° ©G¼(³J­`ª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|·D¬I¸ � Ê ÀË�� Õ '23_´�ªMùs¼W´ ° ù@Â1¤�¹LÀ

Page 106: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

.1+ � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ #�H'A�� Ò�Ó ' Ê H �@A4E[03,'ARA�B;HÔ^;57K�5724>3E�2e03^�FT03,/H/*LA�A�> � Ë >O6 � ð%ó Õ X Y B;H/* � 512RA�B;HP:OH'*;H'E[03.�Ï;];E�Hº>O60 É Ê Ø|Ï;];E[0GA�51>O*�>O* �PN�]s8 Ë ð%ó@Xæï Õ XÌ HM0GE�:OZ;HãÏ;E�2TARA�B�0GA � N � � �<X � A�B;H'E4bu512TH � B�032 �¿57,k0GE�^D*sZ;=#]±H'EuAwbc>;NW03*;^ � Ò�Ó ' Ê H ��ATE[03,'A�2R0

Z;*;51rsZ;Hg^;57K�5724>3E U_N�0_24H/,JA�51>O*Ð>O6åA4B;HºÏ;];E[0GA�51>O*�X UÖ,k03*;*;>3AS](Hg>�KLH'E � ß � Ê N�6�>3EÔ>3A4B;H'E4bu5124H U×Ü � 3 N03*;^-2T> Ë 2T51*;,/H U 512\0g24H/,'A�57>O* Õ U 572R2T=?>@>3A�B�N@0U,'>O*�A4E�03^;51,'A�57>O*�N�032 � � �PX Y B;H/*D]s8 Ë ð%ó@Xæï�Xpï Õ N:U 572cA�B;HÒ ï�ؽ,/Z�E4KLHÔ>O6 � N;2T>�� 572 ãZ>H¿03.|N�03*;^�B�032�03* ��� 2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8LN;,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�57*;: Ë ðOðOX � X . Õ X

�S>�bébcHº,/.10351= � 572uH'=<C;Aw8(~¿íS2RbcHPB�0kKLHº>3]�24HJE4KLH/^�N±5VAeB�032�0GAe=?>O2IAe>O*;HÔ57E4E�H'^;Z;,/57]�.7Hº,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*�A/X+@51*;,'H � N � � �aNu03*;^�o����\ä � ä � 512_*;H':L0GA�57KLH3N � ,k03* >O*;.78h,'>O*�A[0357* >O*;HÐ2T51*;:OZ;.90GE<C(>O51*LA_]�803^�FIZ;*;,'A�57>O*�N(03*;^"24>a]s8 Ë ð%ó@X1ðOXæõ Õ N � � � X $cZ�AeA�B;H'* � ,'>O*�A4E�03,'A�2�>O* ' Ê N�0<,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�51>O*�X +@> � 572H/=<C;Aw8LX Y B;H/*-]�8 Ë ð%ó@Xpï Õ N U 512uH/=<C;Aw8D032RbvH/.1.®N�03*;^-oÖä �� ß ��aX

� Ò�Ó ' Ê H �@A4E[03,'A42 Ë ]s8 Ë ð%ó3ï�Xpï Õ4Õ A4B;HU^;5VK�5724>3E�2�� � N(A�B;H Ò ó%ض,/Z�E4KLHg>O6 � N�03*;^ � N(A�B;H Ò ï�ؽ,/Z�E4KLHU>O6� X � B�032��¿57,k0GE�^¾*�Z;=#](H'EÔA�B�E�H/HGX Y B;HJE�H<572P0DZ;*;51r@Z;HUE�H/^;Z;,/5V]�.1H<Ï;];E4H � Ê ä � � N�03*;^ � Ü � 3 X�� 572ãZ Hv03.®NWbu57A4B"Z;*;51r@Z;HP2451*;:OZ;.10GE�C(>O57*�A�<ß ��� � � X � Ê 03*;^ � � 0GE�Hº,'>O*�A4E�03,'A�57]�.7H Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�E4KLH'2/N�03*;^"24>A�B;Hã2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2\03.7>O*;:gH/57A�B;HJEe0GE4HM^;H'24,'E�5V](H/^-]�8 Ë ï�Xæï Õ Xyo��aä � ß �aN�24> � =?H/H'A�2\Hk03,[B � � *;>3E�=_03.7.7851*Ð0_2457*;:O.1H Ë 2T=?>@>3A�B Õ C(>O51*LAkX �,k03*;*;>3Aã.157H#>O*Ð03*Ð5VE4E�H/^;Z;,'57]�.1H#Ï;];E�HGN(]s8 Ë ï�X . Õ X"�S>�b � � 512S*;>3Aã57*"A�B;H24=?>s>3A�B�.7>@,/Z;2/N�>3Eã0369A�H'Eã,'>O*�A4E�03,'A�51*;:_5VAkN�D.157H/2�>O*q03*q57ETE�H/^;Z;,/5V]�.1HºÏ;];E�H3XR)wAS6�>O.1.7>%bu2eA�B�0GA�?ß � Ê � � �03*;^�o��`ä�� Ê ä� � 512R.1,Ô0GA�WX

#�H'A � Ê ]±HMA4B;HM,'>O=<C(>O*;H/*LAR=?H/H'A451*;: � � Ë A�B;H'E4HM,/03*�](HM>O*;.78?>O*;HP032 � � 572u0g24H/,JA�51>O*�,/>O*�A�0351*;H/^�51*� 3 Õ XP)+6ybcHU,/>O*�ATE[03,'A � � bvHa>3];A[0357*4 � N � � ]±H/,/>O=?H'2<; = 03*;^ � N�032Ô5VASE�H/=_0357*;2ã^;512»FI>O57*�AÔ69E�>O= � � N](H',/>O=?H/2 ; � Xy)wAe6�>O.7.1>�be2\A�B�0GARo��`ä � ä� Ê 572e.1,Ô0GA �NW03*;^ � � 03*;^ � =?H/H'A\A�B;HÔ2�03=?Hã,/Z�E4KLHÔ>%KLH'E�WX

#�H'A � � 4 � ](HãA�B;HÔ51=_03:OHã>O6 � � X Y B;H/* � 03*;^ � =?H'H'Ae>O*;.V8D0GA � N;bu57A�BDÏ�69A�B�>3E�^;H'Ee,/>O*LA[03,'AkX� >O*;2451^;H'EeH ��ATE[03,'A�57*;: �<N�A�B;H Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�ETKLHº>O6�A�B;HP2TH/,/>O*;^�]�.1>�b Z�Cq0GA � 03.1>O*;: � NW03*;^�]�.1>�be57*;:<^;>�be*

A�B;HMÏ;];E�H Ë A�B�E4>OZ;:OB � Õ X Y B;HME�H/24Z;.VA�51*;:?2TZ�E�6�03,/Hº572 É�Ê � É�Ê N�beB;HJE�H � � ](H',/>O=?H/2e0)�/H'E4>_,/Z�E4KLH3N�03*;^ �0g24H/,'A�57>O* Ë 57*DA4B;HÔ^;5VE�H/,'A�57>O*�6�>3ERbuB;51,[B � � 572R0gÏ;];E�H Õ X #�H'A�h](HãA�B;HMZ;*;51r@Z;HM,/Z�E4KLHM^;512�FI>O51*LAe69E�>O= � �CW03242457*;:DA4B�E�>OZ;:OB � X 572ã0�ó%ض,/Z�E4KLHg>O* 4 � A4B�E�>OZ;:OB � 03*;^ � N�03*;^q^;512»FI>O57*�AM69E�>O= � � X � =?H/H'A�2 tA�>>3E�^;H'E¿6�>OZ�Ec0GA � X � 03*;^ j0GE�HRATE[03*;2TKLH'E�2THS0GA � Ë 032�572�,'.1Hk0GE¿>O* É�Ê � É�Ê/Õ A�B�Z;2 � =?H'H'A�2 mATE[03*;2TKLH'E�2403.1.780GA � 032RbvH/.1.®X

#�H'A � � �(]±HuA�B;Hu=_0GE4QLH/^<,/Z�E4KLH Ë ó � ó ����� � � ï � � ó Õ >%KLH'E � 3 03*;^ � � A�B;H�=_0GETQLH/^<,/Z�ETKLH Ë ï� ����� � ó ����� Õ

0GA � X2# HJA � ](HMA�B;HMÏ;];E4Hº>O6 A�B;HME�Z;.157*;: Ë >O* � Õ A4B�E�>OZ;:OB � XY B;H/* Ñ 572R:O5VKLH/*_]s8`,'>O*�A4E�03,'A�51*;: N � N � Ê N � � N â03*;^�03.1.(H ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.(,/Z�E4KLH'2u>�KLH'E ' N@>3A�B;H'E\A�B�03*

� N � N � � �½N � � N � � X�öSH/*;,'H Ë ð Õ X�y0357E42 Ë � � Î Õ >O6�0\C(>O51*LA >O*º0u2T=?>@>3A�BM,/>O*;57,¿0GE�HyC;E�>GFIH/,'A457KLH/.V8ÔH'r@Z;57KG03.1H'*�AkN�24>ubvH�=_0k8M032424Z;=<H � 512�A�B;H

,/>O*;57, � �Pß � � 03*;^ � 572�A�B;Hc>3E�57:O51* Ë Å � Å � ð Õ X Y B;H'* � 512�57*UA�B;HvC±H/*;,/57.;>O6W,'>O*;51,/2�bu57A�B . � � >3E4^;H'Eå,/>O*�A�03,'A0GA � N � � Ò � � ä � � � ßÝÅ�N±6�>3E � �ßÝÅ � � X Y B;Hg03Z�A�>O=?>3ETC�B;5124=?2 Ë � � � � � ÕuÒ�Ó Ë � � � � � � � � Õ Ë 6�>3E � �ßÝÅ Õ03,'AåA4E[03*;245VA�57KLH'.78g>O*aA4B;HuC(H'*;,/51.�H/.7H/=?H/*LA�2ybe5VA�B � �ß Å � � X Y B�Z;2�bcHu=_0k8U032424Z;=?H � ~ � � Ò � � ä � � ßçÅ�X

Page 107: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � .1+�2

Y B;Hº03Z�A�>O=?>3ETC�B;5124=?2

��~ Ë � � � � � Õ¿Ò�Ó Ë �Uä �

ó � � � � � � � �Uä� �. � � ä � Õ

6�>3E � �Úê Ê C;E�H/2TH'E4KLH � 03*;^ � X íS,'A�57*;:h>O*é0�:OH/*;HJE[03.MC±>O51*LA�>O6 � :O57KLH/2-0�*;>O*@ؽ,/>O*;2IA[03*�A�=_0GCê ÊPÒ�Ó �ëá"� � �ãßëê Ê N;buB;51,[B�512R*;H/,/H'242�0GE�57.78-0a24Z�E®FIH','A�51>O*�X�öSH/*;,/H Ë ó Õ X

$v8 Ë ó Õ bvHº,k03*"03242TZ;=?H � 512RA�B;HPC(>O57*�A Ë Å �kÒ ð � ð Õ X��S>�b Ë ï Õ 03*;^ Ë . Õ 0GE4HP2TA4E�0351:OBLA�6�>3E4b\0GE�^",/03.1,/Z;.10�ØA�57>O*;2/N;beB;57,¨B�bcHÔ.7Hk0kKLHÔA�>UA�B;HME4Hk03^;H'EkX

$v8 Ë ï Õ 03*;^ Ë . Õ N 03*;^ ��� � 0GE�HãHk03,[B Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�E4KLH'2e>O* ' N�=<H/H'A�57*;:�+@57*;: Ë '�Õ Awbu51,/H3X B�032c];E[03*;,[B;H/2Ë ó � ó 8 � ï � ó Õ 03*;^ Ë ó � ó � ï 8 � ó Õ N�]±>3A�Bj0GA � N�buB;51.7H ��� �RB�032#Awbc>"];E[03*;,[B;H/2/N�Hk03,[B Ë ��� � ï 8 Õ 0GA � X ��KLH'ET8];E[03*;,[B;H/2M512�2T=?>@>3A�B�]�8 Ë .;X7ð%ó@X ó Õ X Y B;H#51*;^;51,'H/2ã>O6 ��03*;^ � 0GE�H_ðOðg03*;^mð�ï�X Y BsZ;2 ' 3 512SZ;*;5VE�Z;.1H/^q]�8Ë .;X7ð�Å�Xpï Õ 03*;^ Ë õ�Xæõ Õ X �A �LÀ B@À� D ¤J«<© °GF À )wA?512UA�H/=<C;A451*;:iA4>¾A�B;51*�QjA�B�0GA Ë ð � X ó@Xpó Õ 6�>O.7.1>�be2a51=?=?H'^;590GA�H/.V8Í69E�>O= A�B;H�6�03,'AaA�B�0GA� ä � 572e,k03*;>O*;57,k03.1.V8DH/=#](H/^;^;H/^�X\öS>�bcH'KLH'E/N�A�B;HÔ24,[B;H/=?Hº2TATE�Z;,'A�Z�E�HP>O* � ä � 572e*;>3A�2T>_>3]sK@51>OZ;2/Xv)+6>O*;HP,'>O*;2TA4E�Z;,'A42S0<24,[B;H/=?H � Ë � Õ ]s8�:O.1Z;57*;:<A�>O:OH'A�B;HJEeAwbc><,'>3C�51H/2�>O6 É�Ê 03.1>O*;:_03*-03Z�A�>O=?>3E4C�B;5724= � >O6A�B;Ha.1H/*;:3A�B .-,/Z�[email protected]*;Hk0GEÔ24,[B;H/=?H?2TZ�C;C(>3E4A�H'^m0GAP24>O=<HUC±>O51*LAkN�A4B;H/*¾A�B;Ha5124>O=?>3ETC�B;5124= ,/.103242P>O6 � Ë � Õ^;H'C±H/*;^;2º51*i:OH/*;H'E[03.y>O* � X),W>3EMH ��03=aC�.1Hg516�>O*;HaA[0GQLH/2SA�B;Ha51^;H/*LA�5VA+8Ð6�>3E � N�A�B;H/*¾A�B;HU,k03*;>O*;57,k03.y=_0GC6�>3EeA4B;HÔE�H/2TZ;.7A�57*;: (M>3E4H/*;2TA�H/57*",/Z�E4KLH Ë >O6�0GE�5VA�B;=?H'A�57,ã:OH/*sZ;2�ï Õ 572RA�B;HMAwbc><A�>a>O*;HP=_0GCDA�> É�Ê buB;51,[B�572A�B;HÔ51^;H/*LA�57Aw8�>O*�Hk03,[B",/>O=<C±>O*;H/*LAkX Ë ð � Xpó@X ó Õ ,k03*-]±HPK�57H'bcH/^�032e2�0k8�57*;:aA�B�0GA�03*�8DAwbc>�� Ë � Õ 6�>3EebuB;51,[BA�B;HÔ,k03*;>O*;51,k03.�=_0GC�512u03*�H/=#]±H/^;^;51*;:;NW0GE�HM5124>O=<>3E4C�B;51,3X

�S>3A�Hq]s8 Ë ðOðOX7ð'Ø+ó Õ A�B�0GA�6�>3E�6�Z�E4A�B;HJE",/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*;2/N � � � 512�0�Z;*;57];E�03*;,¨Bé2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457Aw8LX Y B;HC(>O2T2457]�57.157A451H/2u0GE�HM,/.903242T57Ï�H/^�57* Ë ðOðOXpó@X1ðOXpï�Ø � Õ X Ì HÔ,/>O*;2457^;H'E�Hk03,[B�57*�A�Z�E4*�X

J ����9�ý�� �%�;�%�»��� �������#�H'A � ]±HMA�B;H Ë �

� � Ê � ï Õ C±>O51*LA�03.7>O*;: X Ì HPB�0kKLHÔ]�8 Ë ð�Å�X1ðOX1ð Õ 03*;^ Ë ðOðOX ó@X7ðOXpï Õ

� Ë ��Õ ß �ó �ãätð � � 3 � � ß �ãäëð

ó �ãäëð � ï � � �

Y BsZ;2ó �

ó �ãäëð � � 3 ä ��� �éð �

� *;H�Hk032457.78gE�Z;.1H'2¿>OZ�A Ë ð�Å�X :�X7ð Õ N Ë ð�Å�X :�Xpó Õ 03*;^ Ë ð�Å�X :�X � Õ X2+@>PbvHe=_0k8U032424Z;=?H\A�B;H'E4H�512åH ��03,JA�.78U>O*;He>3A4B;H'E*;>O* ãZ8H¿03.�2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8LN ��NW>O6 ' 3 N�>O6 bvH/51:OBLA�>O*;HÔ>3EuAwbc>;NW03*;^ � � .;X

+@Z�C;C(>O2TH �_B�032�bcH'51:OBLA�Awbc>;X Y B;H/*"bcH#B�0�KLH Ë ð�Å�X :�Xpï Õ XuíS2 ��Ã�ð��Oó@N ð��Oó � � Ë � Õ � ï � � X Y BsZ;2S]�8Ë ð�Å�X7ð Õ N �#ß Ë . � ó Õ X � Ë � Õ ß . � � � � ß �

� Ê� �� Ê N;A�B�Z;2 �<ßçó@X $v8 Ë # Xpó Õ A�B;HJE�Hº0GE�HÔ*;>?>3A�B;H'Ee2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A451H/2/X

+@51*;,'H ��ß ðOðON�� Ë � Õ ß õ�X �mB�032MbcH/51:OBLAÔ>O*;H3N�03*;^�ð��Oó�� � Ë � Õ ��ï � � N�24>�]�8 Ë ð�Å�X1ð Õ N �Íß Ë ó � ï �����'Õ

Page 108: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

.1+ � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

buB;51,[B¾B�032M51*;^;H �jð � X $\Z�AM*;>�b bcHgB�0�KLHU2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2Sbu57A�BÐ51*;^;57,/H/2 Ë ó � � � � � ð � Õ N�beB;57,[B¾,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�2Ë # Xpó Õ XY BsZ;2 �-B�032SbcH/57:OB�AÔ>O*;H3X)+@Z�C;C(>O24HUÏ;E�2TA��ÍB�032ãbcH/51:OBLAMA+bv>;XE,WE�>O= ð��Oó � � Ë � Õ ��ï � � N�57AM6�>O.1.7>%bu2

69E�>O= Ë ð�Å�X7ð Õ A�B�0GA �âß Ë . � ó Õ X �2��03,'A4.78Í032#57*jA4B;H`C;E4H'K�57>OZ;2ºCW0GE[03:3E[0GC�B�N �mß ó-A�B;HJE�HD0GE�H_*;>i>3A4B;H'E2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2'N 03*;^�� Ë � Õ ßÚõ�XS$cZ�AÔA�B;H/* ��B�032Ô51*;^;H ��0GAP.7Hk032TA<ð�ï�N 03*;^�bcHaB�0�KLHa51*;^;57,/H/2º>O6c0GAÔ.1H/032TAË ó � � � � � ð�ï Õ NLbuB;51,[B�,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�2 Ë$# X ó Õ XY BsZ;2��iB�032ãbvH/51:OBLAã>O*;Hg032�bcH/.7.|N�03*;^"bcH#B�0kKLH Ë ð�Å�X :�X . Õ Xeo � �� � ß Ò ðON�03*;^ �?ß ð�Å�X?$c8 Ë ð�Å�X # Õ bcH

B�0kKLHÒ ð¿ä � 3 ä ��� ä��iß Ë Ò ð¿ä ��� ä � 3 Õ �

Ò ðvä ��� ä � 3 ätð��Oó

24>ºA�B�0GA��Ðß Ê � � � � ���� � � � � ��� � Ê XyíS2 � - ð��3ï�N@5VAc6�>O.1.7>%bu2¿A�B�0GA � 3 ä ��� � . � � X Y B�Z;2��¾ßÝð��3ï�N � 3 ß ��� ßéó � � N

03*;^-A�B�Z;2uA4B;HÔ*;>O* ãZ>H¿03.�2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2u0GE�HMH ��03,JA�.78

� � � � �Mß Ë ó � ï Õ � Ë ó � ï Õ � Ë ï Õ �

$v8 Ë$# X ó Õ A4B;H'E�HS512\0GAv=?>O2TAv>O*;He>3A�B;H'E\2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8LNs03*;^D03*�8?03^;^;57A�57>O*�03.±2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8<,k03*`B�0kKLHS51*;^;H �_0GA=?>O2TAuï�X@$cZ�AuA�B;H'* � �

� NW0a,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�57>O*�X �J ����9�ý�� �%�;�%�»����¡ � ��� �Y B;HjÏ�*�03.#C(>O2T2457]�57.157A451H/2Ð0GE�HmA�B;Hj:OH/*sZ;2ÐAwbc>ëZ;*;5V];E[03*;,[B 2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A451H/2q:O57KLH'* ]�8 Ë ðOðOX ó@X7ðOX . Õ 03*;^

Ë ðOðOXpó@X1ðOX � Õ Xi)+*�A�B;H`Ï;E�2TAa,k0324HGN¿,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA451>O*��N�A4B;H'E�H�0GE�HDAwbc>Ð2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2a03.1>O*;: Ü � N Ë ó � . 8 Õ03*;^ Ë ó 8 � ó Õ X )+*`A4B;HS24H/,/>O*;^D,k0324H3N;,'>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�51>O*�WN@A�B;HJE�HS512c>O*;HS2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8_03.1>O*;: N Ë ó � ï � ó 8 � ó Õ N@03*;^U =?H/H'A�2 *;>3E�=_03.7.78D0GAu0a2T=?>@>3A�B`C(>O57*�A/X

� �(��( �¿�@�Í����� � ¸ãûv¤ã­�©GµO¤P³¨¬�¼�2�ÈGù ° ©3¥®´¶¬G¼ � ¬ ° ¥»­�¤J¼#' Ê ­�©�ªÔ©G¥åÂ1¤[©�ª¨¥y¥|ûv¬gª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© °¿¯ ¬�´�¼W¥»ªM©GÂ1¬�¼@È �� � ¬+¸ � A B@À � � � À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ �� Ü �' 512e0UÏ;];E�HGN±24>a>3]sK@51>OZ;24.V8�� �Ü ' 3Ê X +@Z�C;C±>O24HPA�B;H'E4Hº512u0aZ;*;57r@Z;HP2T51*;:OZ;.90GEuC(>O57*�AkN � >O6 ' Ê03.1>O*;: �<X

#�H'A Ñ ~ � Ò±Ó É�Ê ](HgA�B;H É�Ê Ø|Ï;];E[0GA�51>O*¾>O6 Ë ð%ó@Xæï Õ >3];A�0351*;H/^Ð]s8ÐH �@A4E[03,'A�57*;:�A�B;HUZ;*;51rsZ;H<^;5VK�512T>3E�U_N03^�FT03,/H/*LA?A�> �<X �S>3A�H�Uì512a0i2TH/,'A�57>O*�Nc03*;^�]�8 Ë ð%ó@Xæï�X1ð Õ � 512a0¾^;>OZ�]�.1H�24H/,'A�57>O*�X�íS2 � Ë ' 3 Õ - ð�Å�N� Ë � Õ.- .;N�03*;^�24><A�B;HJE�HP572e0GAu.1Hk032IAe>O*;HM=gZ;.7A�5VC�.1HSÏ;];E�H � 8 X

#�H'A !�](H#A�B;H#Ï;];E�H#CW03242T51*;:`A�B�E�>OZ;:OBqA�B;Hg2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8 � >O6 � N ! �PA�B;Hg.1>@,/03.�03*�03.78sA�51,P];E�03*;,¨Bi>O6 !0GA � NW03*;^ !

�A4B;HÔ.7>@,k03.(];E[03*;,[B�buB;H'E�H !j=<H/H'A�2%U_X

Y B;H/* !Í512u0a2T=?>@>3A�B`Ï;];E�H#03*;^ � 572e0gE[03=?5VÏ�,k0GA�51>O*`C(>O57*�Au>O6 Ñ l � X+@51*;,'H � � !Íß�ó@N�! �º03*;^ � 0GE�Hº2TH'CW0GE[0GA�H/^"]�8-A�B;HÔÏ;E�2TA�]�.7>%b�Z�CÐ>O6 ��ÝÒ�Ó ' Ê 0GA � X � 3 �� ! �º03*;^

]�8 Ë ðOðOXpó@X1ð Õ A�B;He2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457Aw8<>O6�! �e572�E�H'2TC(H/,JA�57KLH/.V8 Ë ó 8 � . Õ 6�>3E ��N�03*;^ Ë ó 8 � ï � ó � ó Õ 6�>3E WX Y B�Z;2co�� � ä ! �

Page 109: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � .1+ 0

512P.7AkX !�03*;^ ! �<CW03242ºA�B�E�>OZ;:OBm^;5Vè(H'E�H'*�AgC(>O57*�A42#>O6 ' 3 Ny03*;^j0GE�H?A4B;H_>O*;.78¾];E�03*;,¨B;H'2U>O6 !�A�B�E�>OZ;:OB

2457*;:OZ;.90GERC(>O51*LA�2u>O6 ' 3 X Y B�Z;2eo�� � ä�!�572u*;>3Au.1,GNW6�>3Eu>3A�B;H'ETbe5724H�!Í572�0UA451:OH'EkX

+@Z�C;C(>O2TH � �� � X Y BsZ;2Ro�����ä !�512\*;>3A\.7,Ô0GA � X�íç=gZ;.7A457C�.1H�Ï;];E4HM=<H/H'A�2 � 51*D>O*;.78_>O*;HSC±>O51*LAkN;6�>3E

>3A�B;H'ETbe5724H\57A�bu51.1.s,/>O*LA[0351*gA�B�E�H/H\2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2 Ë A�B;HvAwbc>SC(>O57*�A�2�buB;H'E�H\57Ay=<H/H'A�2 � 03*;^gA�B;HcC(>O51*LA�buB;H'E�H57A¿=?H/H'A42 U Õ N�,/>O*LA4E[03^;51,JA�51*;: Ë ðOðOX � X � Õ X íS2 Ñ l � E[03=?5VÏ�H/2v0GA¿>O*;.78UA+bv>ºC(>O51*LA�2/N � 572�A�B;H�Z;*;57r@Z;H�=gZ;.VA�57C�.7HÏ;];E�H3N�03*;^-A�B;HJE�HP572�0aZ;*;57r@Z;HÔ2451*;:OZ;.10GEuC±>O51*LA � 8 >O*8U_X Y BsZ;2 � 572u*;>3A�0a,[B�0351*-2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8 Ë >3A�B;H'ETbe5724Ho�����ä!

�572e.7A Õ X $v8 Ë ð%ó@Xæï�Xpï Õ U 572e*;>3AS0 Ò ó%ض,/Z�E4KLH3N�03*;^q032 � 3 �tó �3ï�N � 512e:O5VKLH/*-]�8 Ë ð�Å�X1ðOX ó@X}^ Õ N;03*;^

� =?H/H'A�2cA�B;HÔZ;*;51rsZ;H Ò ï�ؽ,/Z�E4KLHGX $cZ�AuA4B;H/*�o���� ä!�512R.1, Ë 24H/HÔí�C;C(H/*;^;5 � Õ N�0a,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�57>O*�X

+@Z�C;C(>O2TH � � � X�� 3 512M0_,¨B�0357*i2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457Aw8-]�8 Ë ð�Å�X1ð Õ 2451*;,/H`ð��Oó<� � 3 ��ó �3ï�X Y B�Z;2 !�^;>sH/2ã*;>3A

=?H/HJAã03*"H/*;^Ð>O6�A�B;H#,[B�0351*Ð0GA�� 3 XeíS2 � �çó �3ï�NW]s8 Ë :�XpÅ�X � X ó Õ N�03*L8�2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8�03.1>O*;: � B�032S2TC±H/,'A4E�03.KG03.1Z;Hã0GAc=?>O2IA�ð Ë bu57A�B?E�H'2TC(H/,JARA4> �MÕ N�03*;^`24>#]�8 Ë :�XpÅ�X1: Õ 03*;^ Ë ð%ó@Xæï�Xpï Õ N�o����±ä ��572vC�.7A\0GA � X Y B�Z;2%U512\03*DH/*;^D>O6�A�B;Hã,¨B�0357*-0GA � N;03*;^D*;>3AR0GA � 3 X Y BsZ;2 � � U 572R0g2T=?>@>3A�B?C±>O51*LA\>O6 �PNsA�B;H'E�Hã512\0#Z;*;57r@Z;H2457*;:OZ;.90GE�C±>O51*LA � 8 >O*4U_N±03*;^ � 512uA�B;H#Z;*;51rsZ;H#=UZ;.VA�57C�.7HÔÏ;];E�HGX�íS2 � 8 512S0?,[B�0351*q2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8LN�ãZ Hv03.>3Eu03.1=?>O2IA�MZ�Hv03.®N � 512\^;H/24,JE�57]±H/^-]�8 Ë ðOðOX � X # Õ X�)I6�n �ßéó@N;2451*;,'H � 512u0U^;>OZ�]�.7HÔ2TH/,'A�57>O*�N�]�8 Ë ðOðOX � X � Õ N� =?H/H'A�2 � 0GAe0<Z;*;51rsZ;HPC(>O57*�AkN � 8 8 �ß � N�24> � ,/>O*LA[0357*;2eAwbc>?,[B�0351*"2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2/N�Hk03,[B"H/57A�B;HJE ãZ>Hv03.>3ES03.7=?>O2TA�ãZ>H¿03.|X Y B;512RE�Z;.1H'2e>OZ�A�,/0324H/2 Ë ó%Ø�. Õ N Ë � Ø : Õ N�03*;^ Ë�� Õ 6�>3E�; - ï�X � =?H'H'A�2u0<,/Z�E4KLHÔ>%KLH'E � 8 8>O6¿=gZ;.VA�57C�.751,/5VA+8"Awbc>�51*ÐA�B;HaÏ;];E�HGN A�B�Z;2P57* Ë õ Õ A�B;HU=_0GE4QLH/^i2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8 Ë � � � 8 8 Õ 572 Ë ï 8 � ó Õ N�buB;51,[BÍB�0322TC±H/,'A4E[03.åK303.7Z;H`ó@Ny0�,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�51>O*�X`)+*ÍA�B;H<E�H/=?0351*;51*;:-,k0324H/2/N�buB;51,[Bj0GE�H Ë ð Õ N�03*;^ Ë�� Õ bu57A4B ; � ó@N� Ë � Õ � ï�N�0U,/>O*LA4E[03^;51,JA�51>O*�X �� �(� �¿���Í����� � ¸Pûv¤M­�©3µ3¤Ô¥|· ¯ ¤ � ¬ ° ¥»­;¤'¼ ' 3 ­�©Gªº©?¥|´1È�¤ ° À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ $v8 Ë ð � Xæï Õ bcHP=_0k8`24Z�C;C±>O24H � CW032424H/2RA�B�E�>OZ;:OB"0GAu.1H/032TAuAwbc>a2451*;:OZ;.10GEuC±>O51*LA�2/XÌ Hg24B;>�b�Ï;E�2TAãA�B�0GA�� Ë >O6 � ð%ó Õ 572SH/=<C;Aw8LX +@Z�C;C±>O24H<*;>3A/X Y B;H/*i]�8 Ë ð%ó@X7ðOX ó Õ N � � �Ú512M0`2451*;:O.7H

C(>O57*�A � X +@>aA4B;H'E�HP572e0U2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8�03.1>O*;:�� á � X�# H'A =#](HMA�B;HÔ57*;^;H �->O6 >O*;HP2TZ;,¨B"2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457Aw8LX#�H'A � ](H�03*â57E4E�H'^;Z;,/57]�.7H�,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*�A?>O6 � X �S>3A�HDA�B�0GA_032?o��Dä Ë � �@ðOð Õ � 572?*;H/:L0GA�5VKLH3Nv24>Í572

o��_ä Ë � �'. Õ Ë � ä�� Õ X # H'A�� ](H_A�B;HD,/Z�E4KLH_buB;51,[B�Ä=?H'H'A�2g0GA � Nå03*;^�.7H'A���ß � Ë � � o���� Õ X �S>3A�H� Ë � � o���� ä �àä� Õ.- ðP03*;^�24>aA4B;HP,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LA�>O6 � 51* �Úä� 512u0GAe.7Hk032TAÔð Ò ��XÌ HMB�0�KLH

ÅgÃ Ë oàä Ë � �'. Õ Ë �Úä � Õ4Õ�� � -éÒ óeä = Ò ð=

äëð¿ähï �'. Ë � ä� Õ�� � -éÒ ð��'=Rähï �'. Ë ð Ò �Pä�ð��'= Õ �

)wAR6�>O.1.1>�bu2uA�B�0GAeó �3ïaà � Ã��`à � � � Ê� � - � �3õ�N�0a,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�51>O*�XöSH/*;,/H � 512aH/=<C;Aw8LX Y B;H�2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A451H/2a03.1>O*;: � Nv032gbcH/.1.R032a03*�8j*;>O*�ãZ H¿03.c2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2U>O6

' Ê 0kb\0k8¾69E�>O= � N�0GE4Ha^;H/2T,'E�57]±H/^Í]s8 Ë ð%ó@X7ðOX . Õ 03*;^ Ë ð%ó@Xæï�Xpï�Ø�. Õ X0#�H'A = Ê � � � � � = � ](HaA4B;H<51*;^;57,/H/2º>O6�A�B;H2457*;:OZ;.90GE\C(>O57*�A�2R>O6 � � � Ë beB;H/*DA�B;H'E�HÔ0GE�Hã*;><2T51*;:OZ;.90GE\C±>O51*LA�2/N�A[0GQLH � ßÝðON = Ê ßÝð Õ X@+@51*;,/HMo���� ä �

Page 110: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

. .$+ ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

512R.7Ae0GAu2451*;:OZ;.10GEuC±>O51*LA�2 Ë ]s8 Ë :�X .;X � Õ 03*;^ Ë :�XæÅ�X . Õ4Õ N@03*;^ � 572u57*�A�B;H ãZ>Hv03.�.7>@,/Z;2

� � ��ßéóuä � = � Ò ð= � �

�S>3A�HSA�B�0GAuo � � ß Ò óRä�� Ë ��032R51* Ë ð�Å�X ó Õ4Õ X$v8 Ë ðOðOX ó@X7ðOX .GØ � Õ

Ë ð � X .;X1ð Õ Ò óRä��Dä � �@ðOð Ë ó\ä � = � Ò ð= � Õ ß Ë o��ºä � �@ðOð �MÕ � � � Å �

+@Z�C;C(>O2THMÏ;E�2IA � - ó@X Y B;H/* Ë ð � X .;X7ð Õ 51=aC�.151H'2 � ßéó@N"= Ê ß = � ßéó#03*;^��¾ß Å�X Y BsZ;2 ' Ê 572 ãZ�H¿03.(03*;^Ë ]�8"A�B;Hg,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*i>O* ��Õ �Íß ó@XÔöSH'*;,/H#]s8 Ë ð�Å�X1: Õ N � ß ó@X +@57*;,/H � 3 B�032SbcH/51:OBLAÔ0GAã.1Hk032IAÔ>O*;HGNA�B;Hg,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA451>O*Ð,k03*;*;>3Aã](H�� Ë buB;51,[B¾B�032M0 Ò .Gض,/Z�E4KLHa0�bc0�8"69E4>O= � 3 Õ N(A4BsZ;2ãA�B;Hg,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*i572WNMU 512v0 Ò ï�ض,/Z�E4KLH3N;03*;^ � 3 512c0º*;>O*@ض,[B�0351*`2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8abe5VA�B<];E[03*;,[B;H/2 Ë ó � ó Õ N Ë ó Õ 03*;^ Ë ó Õ X2$cZ�AvA�B;H/*� 3 - ï �'.;N�0U,/>O*�ATE[03^;51,'A451>O*�X

�SH �@A¿24Z�C;C±>O24H�A�B;H'E4HS0GE�H�0GA¿.1Hk032IA¿Awbc>º2457*;:OZ;.90GE�C(>O51*LA�2c03.7>O*;:�� á � � � X Y B;H/* Ë ð � X .;X1ð Õ 03*;^ Ë ð�Å�X7ð Õ51=aC�.78"A�B�0GAMA�B;H'E�H<0GE�H<HG��03,'A�.V8"Awbc>�2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2M>O* �aN Hk03,[BÍ>O6¿Aw8sC(H Ë ï Õ X Y B�Z;2 ��ß .;N 03*;^¾24>-]�8Ë ð�Å�X1: Õ N@A�B�E�H'HP>O6 A�B;HM2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2R>O* ' 3 0GE4H Ë ï Õ N;,/.1Hk0GE4.78D51=<C±>O24245V]�.1H3XY BsZ;2<bvH",k03* 032424Z;=?H�A�B;H'E�H�572?H �;03,'A�.78j>O*;H"2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8LNc03.1>O*;: � Ë *;H/,/H/24240GE�51.V8h51* � � � Õ 03*;^

H �;03,'A�.78�>O*;Hº*;>O* ãZ Hv03.�2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8LN �<Ë *;H/,/H/2T2�0GE�51.V8�57* � á � � �MÕ >O6 ' Ê X Ë ð � X .;X1ð Õ 51=aC�.151H'2 = Ê ßÝó@N03*;^ � ß Ë ï Õ >3E Ë ï � ó Õ X�� 3 ,k03*;*;>3A`B�0kKLH-bcH/57:OB�A`>O*;H Ë >3E?A�B;H'E�H"572_03*;>3A�B;H'E?2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8h>O6ãB;57:OB;H'E,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LA Õ X_)+6vA�B;H<,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E�0GA�51>O*Í572���N A�B;H/* � 3 - � Ë ó � ó � . � ó Õ Ã ó �3ï�N�0�,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�51>O*�X Y B�Z;2ºA�B;H,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA451>O*¾572 �N�03*;^ � 3 ß Ë ó � . Õ X Y B�Z;2 �Íß ïD03*;^ � ß .;N�03*;^¾2T>D]�8 Ë ð�Å�X : Õ N � Ë ' 3 Õ ßÖðOðOX $c8Ë # Xpó Õ A�B;H'E�H_572g0GAg=?>O2TA#>O*;H_>3A4B;H'Eg2451*;:OZ;.10GE#C(>O57*�AkX4+@57*;,/H"� Ë ' Ê Õ ß � Ë ' 3 ÕvÒ � ß õ�N�A�B;H'E4HD=gZ;2TA#]±HH �;03,'A�.78`>O*;HÔ=?>3E�HM2451*;:OZ;.10GEuC±>O51*LAkN ãZ>Hv03.®N;>O6�51*;^;HG�"0GAu.1Hk032IA .;X $\Z�Au*;>�b bvHPB�0kKLHP51*;^;57,/H/2u>O* ' 3 >O60GAu.1Hk032TA Ë . � ï � � � ðOð Õ NLbuB;51,[B-K�57>O.90GA�H'2 Ë$# X ó Õ X �

�%� � � Ê ����$U�h$�������&L�i�(��$ �

Y B;512R24H/,'A�57>O*�512R^;H'KL>3A�H'^-A�>gC;E�>%K@51*;:;~

�����»�4NÔ�%���å�±¡k���%���±�¿� � ¸ � Ê ­;©�ªº©�³'ù�ª ¯ ¬+¸�È�¤J¼Wù�ªU¬�¼(¤0,c©3¼±¹ R �� �Ê Ë '�3kÕ ß � ð � ,奮­;¤J¼4'ç­�©�ªº©_¥®´9È�¤ ° À�#� �%�±� ý±� ��� � � � �é�#� ��¡k¡k� ��� 'à� �W¡�� �ç�%�»ýW�@���P�W��� R��� �Ê Ë ' 3 Õ ß � ð � � � Z�E?:O>L03.vbu51.7.v](H`A�>>3];A[0357*�0a,'>O*�A4E�03^;51,'A�57>O*�Xo�� �yä � 03*;^qo����åä � � 0GE�H /�Z;24Bq]s8 Ë :�X .;X � Õ X Y B;HºC(>O242T57]�.1H#,'>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�51>O*;2ã6�>3E � Ê Ò�Ó ' Ê 0GE�H

:O57KLH'*<]s8 Ë ðOðOXpó Õ X�íS2 � 0324He)�B�032¿](H/H'*?E�Z;.1H/^_>OZ�A�51* Ë � ð � Õ NObcH�=_0k8U032424Z;=<He]s8 Ë ðOðOXpó@X1ð Õ A�B�0GA � - ó �3ï�X�S>3A�HM]s8 Ë � Xpï�X7ð Õ N;2451*;,'H � ß � Ê ß R Ê Ë Ê Õ 572�0<2T=?>@>3A�B�C(>O51*LA�>O6 ' Ê NR ��� �Ê Ë ' 3Ê Õ 512RA4E�5VK�5903.®X � �Ü ' 3Ê N�6�>3E>3A�B;H'ETbe5724HPo���� ä � 512R*sZ;=<H'E�51,/03.1.78_ATE�57K@5903.|N�03*;^ � 572e0gA�51:OH'E/X

Page 111: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � . . .

$v8 Ë ðOðOX ó@X1ð Õ N�ó �3ï �� Ê � . � � X $v8 Ë :�Xpï�X1: Õ N � Ê - ð��3ï�N�24> � Ê ä � Ê - ðOX +@51*;,/H � �ß � Ë � 572

24=?>s>3A�B Õ 57AR6�>O.1.7>%bu2R69E�>O= Ë :�X .;X � Õ A4B�0GAk~A �3À B@À Y B;HÔC(>O2T2457]�57.157A451H/2\6�>3EeA4B;HÔ*;H �@A�B�Z;*�Ae2TA�H'C"0GE�H3~

Ë ð Õ � � ä � � 572�0gA[03,/*;>@^;HË ó Õ � � ä � � 572�0g]W03*�03*�0Ë ï Õ � � ä � � 572�0U6�H/*;,/HË . Õ � � 512u0a*;HJA�eH',k03.1.�A�B�0GA U Ê 512u0 Ò ;Oؽ,/Z�E4KLHGN(03*;^>U � 512u0 Ò �3ؽ,/Z�E4KLHGX,W>3ERA4B;HP*;H �@Ae.7H/=?=_0 Ë 03*;^�5VA�2cC;E�>@>O6 Õ bvHPZ;24HMA�B;HP*;>3A[0GA451>O*D>O6 � ð%ó@X

������( �¿���Í����� Á ­;¤¿¸k¬�Â�Â1¬�ûy´»¼@Èa­;¬�Â7¹ �Ë ð Õ ' � ´�ªÔ¼(¬�¥R©u¸k¤J¼�³[¤0,Ë ó Õ � �T¬+¸ � A B@À � � � ­;©�ª ° ©G¼ F ©G¥vÂ1¤�©Gª¨¥�¥|ûv¬ ,Ë ï Õ ' Ê ´�ªMª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ©GÂ1¬�¼@È �Ö´�¼¾©G¥vÂ1¤�©Gª¨¥�¥|ûv¬ ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥®ª5,Ë . Õ ' Ê ´�ª �Ôù ��©GÂ�¬�ù@¥®ª¨´|¹�¤ � ,Ë�� Õ ' Ê ´�ªÔ¼(¬�¥���¬ ° ¤J¼;ª¨¥+¤J´�¼ ,v©G¼±¹Ë õ Õ ' � ´�ªÔ¼(¬�¥R©<¥w©�³J¼(¬k¹s¤kÀ

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ +@Z�C;C±>O24H ' � 572g0"6�H/*;,/H3X Y B;H/*j]�8 Ë :�X .;X � X1:�X1ð Õ N Ò Ë o�� ä �aÕ 572#03=<C�.7H3N�24> � 512#24=?>s>3A�B�]�803^�FIZ;*;,'A�57>O*�X $cZ�ARA�B;H/*-]�8 Ë ð�ï�X . Õ N�A4B;H'E�HP572e0gA�51:OHJEkN�0a,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�57>O*�X

+@Z�C;C(>O2TH � B�032uE[03*�QD>O*;H3XíS2 � 512R2457=<C�.78`,/>O*;*;H','A�H/^�N � 512�03.724>;N�]�8 Ë � X .;X1ð Õ X� .90351=-~ Y B;H'E�H<512P>O*;.V8Ð>O*;H<2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8i03.7>O*;: � ~ � A�B;H'E4bu512TH<]s8 Ë ð%ó@X . Õ 03*;^ Ë ï�X # Õ N � ß ' Ë U�� Õ N

Ë 6�>3Eu24>O=?H�� Õ Þ � Ü � 3 N�Þ � �hl Ò o���lpX@$cZ�A�032 � �hl Ò o���lsB�032e0a,/Z;2IC�NWA�B;572u,'>O*�A4E�03^;51,'A�2 Ë ï�Xpõ Õ X�S>�b � 512R57E4E�H'^;Z;,/57]�.7HP]s8 Ë ð%ó@X .;X1ð Õ X�S>�bç^;H'Ï�*;H !Í]s8�o# Ðä!iß Ñ " Ë o��#ä � �MÕ N�03*;^�^;HJÏ�*;H ! 8 ß � !j24Z;,[B�A�B�0GAuo# iä! 8 512 RiA4E�57K@5903.

Ë 032#57*�A�B;H_^;H'Ï�*;57A451>O*m>O6cA�B;H_BsZ;*LA Õ Nå.1HJA ! 8 ß R Ë ! 89Õ X-o�� ä ! 8 B�032U0-A�51:OHJEº]s8 Ë ð�ï�Xpõ Õ X>$cZ�AºA�B;H/*o��ºä � � B�032u0UA�57:OH'EkNW0a,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�57>O*�X

Ë ï Õ 6�>O.1.7>%bu2R69E�>O= Ë ó Õ 03*;^ Ë ð%ó@X .;X7ð Õ X)+6�A�B;H'E�HS572c0#*;>O* ãZ H¿03.�2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8?>OZ�A�2457^;H � N@A�B;H/* � CW032424H/2cA�B�E�>OZ;:OB_A�B�0GA¿C(>O51*LAc]�8 Ë ð%ó@X7ðOX . Õ X

+�0k8SA�B;H'E�H�0GE�H � 2457*;:OZ;.90GE�C(>O57*�A�2 03.1>O*;: � X Y B;H/*M]s8 Ë ó Õ 03*;^ Ë ð%ó@X .;X7ð Õ N � B�032 0GA =<>O2TA � Ò ðå,/>O=<C(>O*;H'*�A�2'N03*;^Í,/>O*LA[0351*;2g0GAº.1Hk032TA � ä�ð?C±>O51*LA�2/X8$c8 Ë ð%ó@X7ðOX ó Õ 24>O=?H?,/>O=aC(>O*;H/*LA#>O6�� ,/>O*�A�0351*;2g0GA#.7Hk032TAPA4B�E�H/H2457*;:OZ;.90GERC(>O51*LA�2/N�,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�57*;: Ë ð%ó@X � Õ X�öSH/*;,/H Ë . Õ X

+@Z�C;C(>O2TH ' Ê 572 ãZ8H¿03.|X@$v8 Ë ï Õ 03*;^DA�B;HP,'.90324245VÏ�,k0GA�57>O*->O6�2457=<C�.78`,'>O*;*;H/,'A�H/^4(ã>3E�H/*;2TA4H/51*�2TZ�E�6�03,/H/2' Ê ß ' Ë � Ê ä � � Õ X Y BsZ;2

�� � Ê ßto �� Ãâo � ß o ���� ß õ �

Page 112: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

. .�) ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

buB;51,[B�,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�2 Ë ð�õ�X . Õ ](H/.7>%bÔXåöSH/*;,/H Ë � Õ XY BsZ;2 ' Ê B�032e0U*;>O* ãZ>H¿03.(C(>O57*�Ae03.1>O*;: � Ê X Ë õ Õ 6�>O.7.1>�be2RH �;03,'A�.78D032R51*DA�B;HM24H/,/>O*;^-CW0GE�03:3E[0GC�B�>O6

A�B;HMC;E�>@>O6 >O6 Ë ð :�X � Õ X ������ �¿���Í����� � ¸ ���� Ê - � ,�¥®­;¤J¼ �Ö­�©�ªM¥®­ ° ¤[¤Mª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ªº©3Â1¬�¼@È<´�¥wÀ

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ $v8 Ë ðOðOX ó@X7ð Õ A4B;Hº24H/.761ؽ51*LA�H'E424H/,'A�57>O*q>O6 UÚ,k03*">O*;.78�:O>?Z�Cq]�8-*;57*;H Ë ,/>3E4E�H'2TC(>O*;^;57*;:?A�> Ë � � �/Õ4Õ XY BsZ;2 ;Uß Ò ó<03*;^ � 3 572u*;>3A�0a,[B�0351*�2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457Aw8LN@]�8 Ë ð�Å�X7ðOð Õ X ������ � �¿���Í����� � A �3À B@ÀCB � ¹�¬%¤¨ªM¼(¬�¥u¬�³¨³Jù ° À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ +@Z�C;C±>O24Hº*;>3AkX� �Ü ' 3� Ë >3E � 572g0-A�51:OH'E Õ N�24>"A�B;H'E�H_572g0�2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8 � � � X � Ê � � Ë A4B;H_>O*;.78¾bc0�8iA�>q:OH'Ag0

$\03*�03*�0 Õ N 2T>�A�B;H'E�H?572º0-Z;*;57r@Z;H?2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457Aw8�03.7>O*;: U � N ]s8 Ë :�XpÅ�X � X1ð Õ N 03*;^ =?H/H'A42 UÄ0GAº0-24=?>s>3A�BC(>O57*�A/X +@51*;,/H � Ê ä � Ê - ðON =gZ;2TA�=?H/H'A � 0GAM0_2457*;:OZ;.90GE�C±>O51*LA ��X Y B;Hg,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*Ð03.1>O*;: � 572:O57KLH'*�]�8 Ë ðOðOX7ðOX1ðOXæï Õ X )+*-CW0GE4A�57,/Z;.90GE �a572�0 MZ�Hv03.(C±>O51*LAkXíS2¿A�B;HJE�Hã512c>O*;.78<>O*;HS2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8?03.1>O*;: � N � 512v*;>3AR0 Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�E4KLHGX � *DA4B;HS>3A�B;H'E\B�03*;^ Ò o�� � � �� � � ßéó@Xy)+Au6�>O.1.7>%bu2\A�B�0GA � 512u0<Å�ؽ,'Z�E4KLH3X+@Z�C;C(>O2TH ' � 512R2457*;:OZ;.90GEe03.1>O*;: � � X Y B;H/* � 512R*;>3A�0 ãZ>Hv03.(C±>O51*LAkN � 3 512R*;>3AS0U,¨B�0357*�2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8

Ë 032eA4B;H'E�Hg0GE�H#0GA�.1Hk032TASï?2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2S03.7>O*;: � Ê N(03*;^qB;H/*;,/HU03.7>O*;:SU Ê Õ X � Ê 572S0GAS.7Hk032TA Ë ó � ï Õ X +@57*;,/H� 3 ��. � � NW>O*;HÔ,[B;H/,�Q�2SZ;2457*;: Ë :�Xpï�X # Õ A4B�0GAuA�B;HP>O*;.78`C(>O242T57]�51.757Aw8D512RA�B�0GA�;aß �Ußçó@N±03*;^�A4B;HÔ];E[03*;,[B;H/2>O6 � 3 0GE�H Ë ó Õ N Ë ó Õ 03*;^ � Ê ß Ë ��� � ï Õ NQ= - ðOX Y B;H'*�ºß � Ê N � � ,/>O*LA[0351*;2c03* � Ê C(>O57*�A/N � ß Ë ��� � Ê � ï Õ N03*;^g]s8 Ë$# X ó Õ A�B;HJE�H\0GE�H\*;>ã>3A�B;H'Ey2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2'X�# HJA@RM~ �çÒ�Ó ' � H �@A4E[03,'A�A4B;H Ò ó%ؽ,'Z�E4KLH3NQU � NL03^�FT03,/H/*LAA�> � Ë A�B;512Ô512Ô51*�6�03,'APA�B;H<*;H �@AºB�Z;*�Ag2IA�H'C�N ]�Z�APbcHabu51.7.�*;>3APZ;24H<A�B;572 Õ X � 512P0-*;H'AkN � 512P0-24=?>s>3A�BÏ;];E�H3N 03*;^ U � 572P0`24H/,'A451>O*�N�,/>O*�A�0351*;51*;:-0DZ;*;57r@Z;Ha2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8LN Ë ��� � � � ï Õ Ë ]�8"beB;57,[B¾bcHU=?Hk03* Ë ï Õ 516= � ó Õ X Y BsZ;2\A�B;H�Ï;];E�HSA�B�E�>OZ;:OB`A�B;H Ë ��� � � � ï Õ C±>O51*LA\512vA�B;HãZ;*;57r@Z;HS=gZ;.7A�5VC�.1H�Ï;];E�HGN�03*;^�24>#A�B;572vÏ;];E�H,/>O*LA[0351*;2RA�B;H � Ê C(>O57*�Ae032\bcH/.1.®X $cZ�ARA�B;H'E�HÔ512R*;><24Z;,[B"*;H'Au]s8 Ë ðOðOX � X # Õ XY BsZ;2 � � .157H/2R51*�A4B;HP24=?>s>3A�BD.1>@,'Z;2�03*;^ ' � 572?(ã>3E�H/*;2TA4H/51*�X�íS2 � 512u0<,[B�0351*-2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8D03*;^ ' � 572

2457=<C�.78P,/>O*;*;H/,'A�H'^�N�A�B;HcC±>O242457]�57.15VA�51H/2�6�>3E ' � 0GE�H ' Ë � Ê Õ N ' Ë � Ê ä � � Õ NO>3E ' Ë ����Õ X�zq>3E�H/>�KLH'E � Ê ß Ë � � �;Õ N�Uß � � � Ê Ë 2457*;,/H � 512�0?Å�ؽ,/Z�ETKLH Õ 03*;^ ���� Ê ßéo �� Ò ðOX �S>�b � - ï�N�]s8 Ë ð�õ�Xpï�X � Õ X%+@51*;,'HPA�B;Hº2TC±H/,'A4E�03.KG03.1Z;HU512Ô0GAP=?>O2IAMA4B�E�H/Ha]�8 Ë :�XpÅ�X � X ó Õ N � ß Ë ó Õ >3E Ë ó � ó Õ 03*;^ ��ß ï�N�]�8 Ë :�XpÅ�X1: Õ Xº)+6 � ß Ë ó � ó Õ N(A�B;H/*� Ê Ã ï �'.<03*;^ � �3ïuä � ÃéðON�24> Ë o�� ä! 8 Õ�� � àÅ�N�,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�51>O*�XY BsZ;2 � ß Ë ó Õ 03*;^i]s8 Ë ð�õ�X . Õ N 03*;^¾A4B;H<2457=<C�.78Ð,/>O*;*;H/,JA�H/^m.1572TAkN ' � ß ' Ë � Ê ä � � Õ X $cZ�AÔA�B;H'*Í516

Ñ ~ � Ò�Ó ' � 572�A�B;Hº]�.1>�bÝZ�C¾0GA � N � 572S0 ãZ4H¿03.�*;H'AkN±bu57A�B"HG��03,'A�.V8�>O*;H#2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8LN(03* � � C(>O57*�A/N,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�51*;: Ë ï�X . Õ X �

,W>3EuA�B;HP*;H ��A # H/=<=_0�N;bcHº03.7.1>�b A4B;HÔC(>O2T2457]�57.157Aw8`A�B�0GA � B�032S0<*;>s^;H Ë 032uA4B;Hº03*�[email protected].�](HÔA�B;H2�03=?HM51*DA�B�0GAu,k0324H Õ X

Page 113: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � . . �

����� � �¿���Í����� � A �3À B@À � � ¹�¬%¤¨ªM¼(¬�¥u¬�³¨³Jù ° À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ +@Z�C;C±>O24H � � 512�0a*;H'AkXcíS2 � Ê - ó �3ï�NW*;H',/H/242�0GE451.78>U � 572�0<24H','A�51>O*�03*;^ � 512e0<^;>OZ�]�.1Hº2TH/,'A�57>O*�X$v8 Ë ðOðOX � X1ðOðOXpó Õ N Ué,/>O*�A�0351*;2y0GA�=<>O2TA Awbc>ã2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2 03*;^g24>�� Ê 572y0�,[B�0351*g2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8LX�)I*ºCW0GETA�51,/Z;.10GE� - ï�X�$cZ�Au]�8 Ë ðOðOX � X1ð�Å Õ NMU � 512u0 Ò ó%ؽ,/Z�E4KLHGN±0U,/>O*�ATE[03^;51,'A451>O*�X �íS2\bcHÔB�0kKLHPH'.151=<51*�0GA�H/^DH'KLH'ET8�,/0324HP>O6 Ë ð�õ�X ó Õ N@A4B;512R,/>O=<C�.1HJA�H/2\A�B;HÔC;E�>s>O6 >O6 Ë ð�õ�X1ð Õ X

�%� � Ê ����$g�h$�������&L�i�� � �

� Z�E�:O>L03.�512\A�>UC;E�>%KLHG~

� �(�»�4NÔ�%���å�±¡k���%���±�¿� � ¸ R �� �Ê Ë ' 3 Õ ß � ð � ©3¼±¹ � Ë � Ê Õ ß ð ,c©G¼±¹ � Ê ­�©�ªº©_¼(¬k¹�¤0,¿¥»­;¤'¼Í¤J´�¥®­;¤ ° ' 3 ­�©Gªº©¥|´1È�¤ ° ,\¬ ° Ë ' � ��� � ä � � Õº´�ªº©u¸k¤J¼�³[¤0,åûy´�¥®­ � � ª¨«?¬�¬�¥®­�À � ¼�©3¼�·�³�©�ªk¤ ' 3 ´�ªMÂ1¬�È_ùs¼�´ ° ù@Â1¤�¹LÀ

,W>3EÔA�B;HU,k0324H'2PbeB;H'* ' 3 ^;>@H'2P*;>3AºB�0kKLH?0`A�51:OHJEkN�bvHabu51.1.�H'2424H/*LA�5903.7.78i,/.9032T2451698qA�B;HUC(>O24245V]�.1Ha6�H/*;,/H/2Ë ' � ��� � ä � � Õ N@24H/H Ë ð � Xpï Õ N�032cbcH/.7.�032cA�B;Hã>3E�51:O57*�03. ' 3 N;24H/H Ë ð � X � Ø�ð�. Õ /�bcHSbe57.1.(2TA4>3CDA4B;HÔ03*�03.V8�24572c>O*;,/HbcH?B�0kKLH_H/*;>OZ;:OBÍ57*;6�>3E�=_0GA�57>O*¾A�>"0GC;C�.V8¾A�B;H?,JE�57A�HJE�590->O6 � õ�N ]�Z�A#6�Z�E4A�B;HJEU03*�03.78�2T512º>O6vA�B;H<2�03=?H<2T>3E4Abc>OZ;.7^?8�51H'.1^`03*_H �@C�.151,'57Av,'.90324245VÏ�,k0GA�57>O*�X Y B;HS6�H/*;,/H'2 Ë ' � ��� � ä � � Õ 0GE�He51*?A�B;H�,'.90324245VÏ�,k0GA�57>O*_>O6 Ë ð�ï�X � Õ Nbu57A�B�>O*;HPH ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�N Ë ð � Xpï�X ó Õ N@beB;57,[B�512\CW0GE4A�5103.1.78`,'.90324245VÏ�H/^�57*�A�B;HMC;E�>@>O6 >O6 Ë ð � Xæï Õ X

� �q�W¡k¡k�����"�%� �%�±� ý±� ��� � � � �i�%� ��� ' 3 � ���@¡<� ���<� �@�W�"�¾�%��ý��s�s���W��� R��� �Ê Ë ' 3 Õ ß � ð � �o�� �åä � Ê U Ê 512 /�Z;24BÐ]s8 Ë :�X .;X � Õ X � >O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*;2M>O* � Ê 0GE�Hg,/.9032T2457Ï�H/^i51* Ë ðOðOX1ð Õ X Ì Hg24B;>�bcH/^¾51*

� ð � A4B�0GAPA�B;H'E4H?512P0�A�51:OHJEP576¿A�B;H?,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E�0GA�51>O*�572Ô)¨X�)I6 � Ê Ü ' 3Ê A�B;H/*Ío�� ��ä � Ê 572ÔA4E�5VK�5103.y03*;^�bcHB�0kKLHP0#A�51:OHJEkN;0g,/>O*�ATE[03^;51,'A451>O*�X Y B�Z;2 � Ê ,/>O*LA[0351*;2u0g2451*;:OZ;.10GERC±>O51*LAkN�03*;^`A�B;HÔ,'>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�51>O*�>O* � Ê 572)4)c>3EuB;51:OB;HJEkX��S>3A4HP03.724>aA�B�0GA '23Ê 512R2457=<C�.78`,/>O*;*;H','A�H/^-]�8 Ë � Xpï�X7ð Õ X

� �(�»���7� �����;�%�»��� �P£ ¤'¥��ì©G¼±¹ Þ §¨¤#¥»­�¤#¥|ûv¬�§ ° ©G¼(³¨­�¤¨ªU¬I¸ � Ê ©G¥\¥®­;¤g¼(¬k¹�¤-,u©3¼±¹ � , � ¥®­;¤ ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥®ª¬+¸ � Ê û�­;¤ ° ¤U¥»­;¤?§ ° ©G¼(³J­;¤¨ª#«?¤[¤J¥ U Ê À �q¤g«<©G·q©�ª[ªJùs«?¤ �I§'·`ªJûy´�¥+³¨­�´�¼@È � ©G¼±¹ Þ ´Ç¸g¼(¤¨³[¤¨ª[ª/© ° · � ¥®­�©G¥¥®­;¤/2 ° ªJ¥\¥®ûc¬�§'Â1¬�ûéù ¯ ª?¬+¸ �c~ �� Ê Ò±Ó ' Ê © ° ¤<©GÂ1¬�¼@È �`Àg£ ¤'¥ =�äéð � = - ð � §¨¤U¥®­;¤g¼�ù@«<§¨¤ ° ¬+¸#´�¼�´�¥|´|©G§'Â1¬�ûëù ¯ ª#©GÂ1¬�¼�È �`À �#¬�¥w¤ � ´�ªÔ¼(¤[³[¤¨ª¨ª/© ° ´»Â ·Uª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° À

� �(� 5 �¿���Í�����Ë ð Õ o�� ��ä Ê ä U Ê ´�ªMÂ1¬�È-³�©G¼(¬G¼�´¶³�©GÂ7ÀË ó Õ ­;©�ªÔ¥|ûv¬aªJ«?¬�¬�¥®­�§ ° ©G¼(³¨­;¤JªM¥»­ ° ¬�ùLÈ�­ � 3 ©G¼±¹<«_¤[¤J¥®ªÔ¼(¬`¬G¥»­;¤ ° ª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ªkÀË ï Õ � ¸ � ´�ªãª¨«?¬%¬�¥»­ ,�¥»­�¤J¼ � ´�ªº©G¼ ��� ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥�, = - ð ©G¼(¹ � Ê ß

� � Ê� � � ÀË . Õ � Ê ´�ªãª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ©G¥¿ªk¬G«?¤ ¯ ¬�´»¼�¥\¬I¸ U Ê á U Ê � Ê ÀË�� Õ 'é­;©�ªg¤��@©�³J¥| ·<¥|ûv¬?¼(¬�¼ �Ôù ��©3 ¯ ¬�´�¼W¥»ªº©3¼±¹ � 3 Ãéð��Oó ÀË õ Õ � Ê - ó �3ï ,c©G¼(¹ � - . � � ,åù@¼�Â1¤¨ª[ªPûv¤Ô­�©3µ3¤ ��� � ûy´�¥®­ = � ó ÀË � Õ � ³[¬�¼W¥½©G´»¼;ª#¤��s©s³J¥®Â ·�¬�¼�¤Ôª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|·OÀ

Page 114: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

. . � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Ë ð Õ Ø Ë ï Õ 0GE�HÔ51=?=<H/^;590GA�HS69E4>O= Ë ðOðOX1ðOX1ð Õ Ë 2451*;,/HMbcHPB�0kKLHÔE4Z;.1H/^�>OZ�Au,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA451>O*;2�Åa03*;^�) Õ XË . Õ B;>O.1^;2'NW6�>3Ee>3A�B;H'E4bu512TH � Ü '�3Ê X,W>3E Ë�� Õ N >O*;H_24B;>%bu2ºA�B;H'E4H_512#0GA#=<>O2TAº>O*;H_*;>O* ãZ Hv03.yC(>O57*�AU0kb\0k8�69E�>O= � 032º51*ÍA�B;HaC;E�>@>O6\>O6

Ë ð�õ�Xæï�X . Õ X�+@>P]s8 Ë ó Õ NLA4B;H'E�H�0GE4He0GA�=?>O2TAyAwbc>P*;>O* MZ)Hv03.�C±>O51*LA�2�>O* ' 3 X �S>�b Ë�� Õ 6�>O.1.7>%bu2å69E�>O= Ë ð�Å�X : Õ X,W>3E Ë õ Õ N�24Z�C;C±>O24HabcHU0GE�Hg*;>3AM51*qA�B;HU2457A4Z�0GA�51>O*q>O6 Ë ï Õ X � - . � � ]�8 Ë ï Õ 03*;^ Ë ðOðOXpÅ Õ Z;*;.7H/242 =?ßÚð

>3E =Mßéó@X $v8 Ë ðOðOXæÅ Õ 57Ak{}2RH'*;>OZ;:OB-A�>U,/>O*;2451^;HJEeA�B;HM,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*;2�0369A�HJEe>O*;HM=?>3E�HS]�.1>�bçZ�C�X +@Z�C;C(>O24H=`ßÖðOXaíS69A�HJEPA�B;HU*;H ��AM]�.1>�b Z�C � ß Ë ó Õ 03*;^ ��ß Ë ï Õ X � *;Ha,/>O=<C�Z�A�H/2 � ß . � � X)+@Z�C;C±>O24HS=`ßÚó@XíS69A�H'ERA�B;HÔ*;H ��AR]�.1>�bçZ�C � ß Ë ó Õ 03*;^ �gß Ë ó � ï 8 Õ X � *;HP,/>O=<C�Z�A�H/2 � ßéõ � � XyöSH/*;,/H Ë õ Õ X

,�51*�03.7.78`24Z�C;C±>O24H Ë � Õ 6�0357.12/X Y B;H'*�NW2T51*;,/H RÐE�H/=?>�KLH/2R>O*;HP>O6�A�B;HP2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2e03.7>O*;:)U_N � ,/>O*�A�0351*;2Awbc>g2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A451H/2/N � 3 512R0#*;>O*@ؽ,[B�0357*-2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8LN@03*;^DbvHMB�0kKLH Ë ï Õ X Ì HSbu51.7.±Z;24H Ë :�Xpï�X # Õ A�>g,/>O=aC�Z�A�H� 3 Xº)+6 U Ê 512ã*;>3AÔ0 Ò ó%ؽ,/Z�ETKLH3N�A4B;H/* � 3 - � � Ê� � � N 0`,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�51>O*�X Y B�Z;2ÔbcHU=_0k8q032424Z;=?HS;-ß ó@X#íS2� 3 Ãéð��Oó@N Ë ]�8 Ë�� Õ4Õ N � 3 - ó �3ï�N�]�8`A�B;HM,/.903242T57Ï�,k0GA�57>O*�>O6 *;>O*@ض,[B�0351*"2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2'N�03*;^ = - ó@X

� *;H?,[B;H/,�Q�2#A�B�0GA � 3 - � � Ê� � � Z;*;.1H/242E=-ßÖó-03*;^�A�B;H_>3A�B;HJEPAwbc>"2457*;:OZ;.90GEºC±>O51*LA�2#0GE�H Ë ó Õ 03*;^ Ë ï Õ XY BsZ;2 �� � Ê ß .;XuíS2 ' Ê B�032S0?*;>O* ãZ Hv03.�C(>O57*�AS>OZ�A42451^;H � Ê N � 512eE�H'^;Z;,/57]�.7Hº]s8 Ë ð%ó@X � Õ X Y B�Z;2 � >O6Ë ð%ó@X . Õ B�032RE[03*�Q->O*;HGN±03*;^"o �� ß ���� ß .;X R Ë >O6 Ë ð%ó@X . ÕTÕ B�032RA+bv>?H �;,'H'C;A�51>O*�03.�^;57K@5124>3E42/X � Ê 03*;^ � �>O6 Ë ð%ó@X . Õ 0GE�H#A�B;H Ò ó`03*;^ Ò ï�ض,/Z�E4KLH/2Ô03^�FT03,/H/*LAMA�> � N�03*;^ � � Ü TE3 X $c8 Ë ï�X # Õ � ß ' Ë ó � Ê ä � ��Õ N03*;^�Hk03,[B"Þ � ß R Ë � � Õ ,'>O*�A[0357*;2uAwbc>?2T51*;:OZ;.90GEuC(>O57*�A�2'NWA�B�Z;2eH/03,¨B � � =gZ;2TAu=?H/H'AR](>3A4B R�H ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.^;57K@5124>3E42/X $cZ�ARA�B;H/*�Þ Ê � Þ � ,/>O*LA[0351*;2\Awbc><C(>O57*�A42/N�,/>O*�ATE[03^;51,'A451*;: Ë ï�X # Õ X �

$v8 Ë ð � Xpó Õ N�A4B;H'E�HR0GE�HvAwbc>ã*;>O* MZ H¿03.sC(>O57*�A42/N � 3 03*;^ � NO>O6 ' 3 03*;^ ' Ê B�032�H �;03,'A�.V8º>O*;Hc2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8LN��NL03.1>O*;: � X # H'A $ ](H�A�B;Hc51*;^;H �º>O6 ��X Ì Hvbe57.1.LÏ;E�2TAy24B;>�bjA�B�0GA ' � 512y0�6�H/*;,'H Ë ð � Xpï Õ NG03*;^gA4B;H/*#CW0GE4A�5903.7.78,/.103242451698iHk03,[B�C(>O2T2457]�.7H ' 3 N�03*;^Í24B;>�b 57*�Hk03,[BÍ,k0324HGN�Z;2451*;: � õ�N A�B�0GA ' 33 572PZ;*;5VE�Z;.1H/^�X Ë»Ì 57A4BÍ0-.15VA4A�.7H=?>3E�H?03*�03.78�2T512#>O*;H_,k03*j,/>O=<C�.7H'A�H/.V8¾,/.103242457698�A�B;H_C(>O242T57]�51.757A�57H/2/N�]�Z�AgbcH_2TA4>3C�>O*;,'H`bvHDB�0kKLH_H/*;>OZ;:OB51*;6�>3E4=_0GA�51>O*`A�><0GC;C�.78`A�B;HM,'E�57A4H'E�590U>O6 � õ Õ X�eH',k03.1.�69E�>O= Ë :�Xpó@X1ð�Å Õ A�B�0GA U � 572e0 Ò �3ؽ,'Z�E4KLH3N�03*;^ U Ê 512�0 Ò ;Oض,/Z�E4KLH3X

� �(��( NM��� ����¡k���%�»��� � � � �%ÿO�±���ë��þ?�%� �t�����(�3¢%� Ë ' � ��� � ä � � Õ-´�ª�© ¤J¼(³¨¤kÀ � Ë � � Õ ß ð , � � ´�ªª¨«?¬%¬�¥»­;À

Ë ð Õ � ¸ � Ê � � Ê ¥»­;¤'¼ � «?¤[¤J¥®ª U � ©G¥M©-ªJ«?¬�¬�¥®­ ¯ ¬G´�¼�¥�,ã©G¼±¹¾³[¬�¼�¥w©G´�¼�ª?©�ù@¼�´|ø'ùW¤?ª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© °ã¯ ¬�´�¼W¥Ë � � � ï ��� � � � Õ �p¸k¬ ° ªk¬�«?¤ � � À o���ä � ´�ªgÂ1¬�È-¥+¤ ° «U´�¼±©GÂ1,M©G¼±¹ «_¤[¤J¥®ªU¥»­�¤_¤J¼±¹Ð¬+¸g¥®­;¤ � � � �³¨­�©3´�¼±À Ë ' � ��� � ä � � ÕP´�ª�È3´�µ3¤J¼¾§/· � A �sÀ�� � À � � ´�ªP©G¼ � � � Ê ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥wÀ

Ë ó Õ � ¸ � Ê �� � Ê ,\©G¼±¹ � � �Ü '23� ,�¥®­;¤J¼4'233 ´�ªÔùs¼�´ ° ù@Â1¤�¹LÀË ï Õ � ¸ � Ê �� � Ê ©G¼±¹ � � Ü ' 3� ,�¥®­;¤J¼ Ë ' � ��� � ä � � Õº´�ªeÈG´�µ3¤'¼¾§'· � A �sÀ �LÀ A � ,¿©G¼(¹ � � õ � � À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ íS2 � ä � Ê - ó �3ï�ä � Ë �;Õ - ðON�bcH#B�0�KLHºA4B;H#2�03=?HÔC±>O24245V]�51.15VA�51H'2S6�>3E�A�B;H#>OZ�A�,/>O=<Hº>O6�A�B;H#BsZ;*LA032R51* Ë ð�õ�Xpó Õ X

$v8 Ë ð�õ�Xpõ Õ � � 512R*;>3Ae0a*;H'AkX

Page 115: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � . .��

+@Z�C;C(>O2TH � Ê � � Ê X Y B;H/* ' � ß � >O6 Ë ð%ó@X . Õ N�03*;^ � ß X¿íS2�� 512R^;512�FI>O51*LAS69E�>O= � Ë >O* � ß T>O6 Ë ð%ó@X . ÕTÕ bcHS=gZ;2TAc:O>#A�>g0º6�H'*;,/H3N;be5VA�B � 24=?>@>3A4B<]s8 Ë ðOðOX1ð Õ N�2457*;,/H � � ä � � ÃéðOX�$c8 Ë ð�ï�Xpï Õ Ë bu57A�B �C�.90k8�57*;:PA�B;HRE'&>O.1Hu>O6 T >O6 Ë ð�ï�Xæï Õ4Õ A�B;H'E�He0GE�H�0GA¿.1Hk032TA�Awbc>º2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2¿03.1>O*;: � Ns03*;^ � 572v0 Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�ETKLH3XY BsZ;2 � =?H/HJA�2 Uì0GAa0q24=?>@>3A4BmC±>O51*LAkN�03*;^�,/>O*LA4E[03,'A42UA�>i0q,'8�,/.751,�ãZ H¿03.v2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8LX �S>%b Ë ð Õ6�>O.1.7>%bu2RHk032451.V8`]s8 Ë ðOðOX . Õ XY BsZ;2ybcH\=_0k8#24Z�C;C(>O2TH � Ê �� � Ê X�+@Z�C;C(>O24H � � 6 � � B�032å0ã*;>@^;HR>O6�:OH'*sZ;2 � - ó@X�+@51*;,'H � � ä � � à ðON

A�B;HÔ,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*->O* � � 512R:O57KLH'*�]�8 Ë ðOðOX1ðOX1ðOXpó Õ X)+6 � �� NLA�B;H/*_o�� ä � � 512�*;>3A¿A4E�5VK�5103.�03*;^ � � ð��OóS]s8 Ë ðOðOX7ðOX1ðOX ó Õ X Y BsZ;2 � Ê ß Ë ï ���

�Õ N�]�8 Ë ð�Å�X1ð Õ X

$cZ�A�A�B;H/* � 512S,'>O*�A[0357*;H/^q51*"A�B;H#24=<>@>3A�B�.7>@,/Z;2ã03*;^Ð032 � 572S*;>3Aã0<A�51:OHJEkN�� - ï�X Ë ðOðOX7ðOX1ðOX ó Õ 51=aC�.151H'2�

� . � # X � *-A4B;HP>3A�B;H'EuB�03*;^�N � Ê - � Ë ï ��� �/Õ ß . � # N�0a,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�57>O*�X)+6 ��� � N;A�B;H/* � � 512u,/>O*LA[0351*;H/^-51*�A4B;HP24=?>s>3A�BD.1>@,'Z;2/N±03*;^ ' � 512R2451=aC�.78`,/>O*;*;H/,JA�H/^4(M>3E4H/*;2TA�H/57*�X

íS2 �`ß ��N � Ê - � � � Ë �Päéð Õ 03*;^Ð]s8 Ë ðOðOX7ðOX1ðOXpó Õ ó � � � Ë �#äéð Õ N�A�B�0GAM512Pó �3ï �

� � ð��OóSäçð�� Ë ó � Õ XY BsZ;2 � ß�ó �3ï�N��`ß�ó@X $v8 Ë ð � Xpó@Xpõ Õ N =Uß ðON(03*;^ � 3 512ã0_,[B�0351*q2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8LXe)+*"CW0GE4A�57,/Z;.90GE ; - ï?]�8Ë ð�Å�X7ðOð Õ X Y B�Z;2

' �� ß � �� ß =Rä .eä � Ò ; � . �

$cZ�A � ,/>O*�A�0351*;2u0a,[B�0351*�2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457Aw8 Ë 57AR512R*;>3Ae0UA�57:OH'E Õ N;buB;51,[B�,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�2\A�B;HP.7512TA Ë ï�X ó Õ XY BsZ;2SbcH#=gZ;2TAS:O>_A�>`0_6�H/*;,'H3X � 572S24=?>s>3A�B�N(03*;^"]�8 Ë ð�ï�Xpï Õ ,/>O*�A�0351*;2ã0GAS.7Hk032TASAwbc>`2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A451H/2/N

03*;^�572e0 Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLH3X)+6 � � Ü ' 3� NsA4B;H/* ' � 572%(M>3E4H/*;2TA�H/57*�N;03*;^ ' 3� 572v2457=<C�.78U,/>O*;*;H/,JA�H/^�N�]�8 Ë � Xpï�X7ð Õ NL2451*;,'H � � 512c24=<>@>3A�B�X

Y BsZ;2 Ë ' � ��� � ä � � Õ 512v:O5VKLH/*?]�8 Ë ð�ï�X � X7ð Õ X $c.1>�bu51*;:ºZ�C`A�B;H � Ê C±>O51*LA\03*;^`,/>O*LA4E[03,'A�57*;: � :O57KLH/2c0 /�HG�.157*;HMA4>?0a*;>s^�03.�,/Z�]�51,3N�03*;^�A4B;HP51*;H'r@Z�03.15VAw8 � �OóRä�ï � � ï�X +@57*;,/H � à � N Ë ï Õ 6�>O.7.1>�be2'X

�S>�b 24Z�C;C(>O2TH � � �Ü ' 3� X Y B�Z;2 � =?H/HJA�2 � 0GAº0D24=?>s>3A�BÐC±>O51*LAkXUíS2 � ä � Ê - ðON�]s8 Ë ðOðOX1ð Õ �=?H/HJA�2 U � 0GAM03* � � C(>O51*LAkN�6�>3EM24>O=?H $ - ðOX U � 512M0 Ò ó%ض,/Z�E4KLH3N�24> � Ê 572ã0D*;>O*@ض,¨B�0357*iC±>O51*LAkX +@57*;,/H� Ê ,/>O*LA[0351*;2c>O*;.V8?>O*;HS2457*;:OZ;.90GEcC±>O51*LAkN ���� Ê - ðON@]s8 Ë ð%ó@X .;Xæõ Õ Ns03*;^D2T> Ë 69E�>O= A�B;HS,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E�0GA�51>O*`>O* � � Õ N����� ß ���� Ê äëð¿ä $ X

+@Z�C;C(>O2TH �� �� - . Ë 6�>3EuH ��03=<C�.7Hã516 $ - ó@N�>3E �� � Ê - ó Õ XÌ HD0GC;C�.78 Ë ð%ó@X . Õ A�> Ë ' � ��� � Õ X +@51*;,/H � � ,'>O*�A[0357*;2<0qZ;*;51rsZ;H�2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457Aw8LN � B�032UE[03*�Qm>O*;HGN�]�8

Ë ð%ó@X .;X1ð Õ Xvo �� ß ����� - .;N�24> � 512e:O57KLH/*-]�8 Ë ï�X # X ó Õ X � Ë >O6 Ë ð%ó@X . Õ4Õ 512e57E4E�H'^;Z;,/57]�.7H3N�A�B;HP,/Z�E4KLH#>�KLH'E �03^�FT03,/H/*LA�A�> � � X � 572e5VE4E�H/^;Z;,/5V]�.1H3X\Þ×ß R Ë �ºÕ 03*;^ � Ü � 0GE�HPHk03,[B"24=?>@>3A4B Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�E4KLH'2/N(03*;^�A�B�Z;2A�B;H/5VEP,'>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�51>O*¾512M:O57KLH/*¾]�8 Ë ï�X # Xpó Õ X#)+*iCW0GE4A�57,/Z;.90GEMA�B;H'8i=?H/HJAÔHG��03,'A�.V8q>O*;,/H3N 0GAP>3C;C±>O2457A�HaH/*;^;2>O6�A4B;H � � C±>O51*LAkN�beB;57,¨B¾512M*;H/,/H/24240GE�51.V8 R Ë � Õ N�03*;^¾Hk03,[BÍ,/>O*LA[0357*;2Ô57*�03^;^;57A451>O*�03* � Ê C±>O51*LAkXS+@57*;,/H� ,'>O*�A[0357*;2�0GAe=?>O2TAu>O*;Hº2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8LN � =?H/H'A�2 � 0GA�0<24=?>s>3A�B�C±>O51*LAkX �S>�b�,'>O*;2451^;H'ESA4B;HP24H/rsZ;H/*;,/H>O6¿]�.7>%b Z�C�2 �v~ �TÄÒ�Ó �� X Y B;HaÏ;E42TAP]�.7>%b Z�Cm572P03.7>O*;:-Þ Ë 2T51*;,/HaÞ 512Ô0 Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�ETKLH3N�03*;^ � 512Mo# *;>O*@ؽ*;H':L0GA�57KLH Õ X�íS.1.@6�Z�ETA�B;H'Eå]�.1>�bâZ�C�2y=UZ;2IAå03.124>S](HR03.7>O*;: � NL6�>3E�>3A4B;H'E4bu5124H � =?H'H'A�2 � 0GAå0S2451*;:OZ;.10GEC(>O57*�A/X +�0k8 � 572�0 Ò Oؽ,/Z�E4KLHGX Y B;H'*-A�B;H'E�HÔ512u0<Z;*;51rsZ;HP2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8 Ë ó � ó � ï ����� � � Õ >O* � N�0GA�� � � N

Page 116: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

. . � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

� =?H'H'A�2yA�B;HeZ;*;^;H'E4.151*;H'^_,/Z�E4KLH3N@03*;^?o ä � ä � 512å.1>O:Ô,k03*;>O*;51,k03. Ë 2T> � =?H/H'A�2yA�B;HuH/*;^?>O6±A�B;H ��� � �,[B�0351* Õ X Y BsZ;2cA�B;HS];E[03*;,[B;H/2u>O6 � Ê 0GE�H � � N Ë ó Õ 03*;^ Ë ó � ó � ï ����� � � Õ X +@57*;,/HãA�B;512c.1032TAc];E[03*;,[B-B�032\51*;^;HG�0GAu.1Hk032TA � N $ � ðOX �S>3A�HP03.724>gA�B�0GA �ºß Ë � ó Õ XöSH/*;,/H $ ß ðOX Y B;H/* � � ä � � �OóaßàðOX $v8 Ë ð�Å�X1ð Õ N � � à � Ê - ð��Oó@N(A4BsZ;2 �

� ï �'.;X�+@>D]�8 Ë ð � Xpó@Xpõ Õ N� ßÚó �3ï�N�=Dß ðOX Y B;H/* � � ó �3ïD24> � Ê 572P:O57KLH'*¾]s8 Ë ð�Å�X7ðOX ó@Xæ^ Õ XUíS2 � Ë ó � . � ó Õ ßÚó �3ï�N ;qß ï�X Y B�Z;2���� Ê ß .Mä�= Ò ;�ß ó@X Y B�Z;2ÔA4B;HU2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457A�57H/2M0GE�HU032Ô57*ÐA�B;H#C;E�HJK�51>OZ;2ãCW0GE[03:3E[0GC�B�XE+@51*;,/H � Ê ßÖð��Oó@N;�ß ó@N�]s8 Ë :�XpÅ�X � Xpó Õ X Y BsZ;2 � 3 ß Ë ó � ï � � ó �+� ó Õ X Y B;HD57*;^;H �j>O6 � 3 512#H'.1H'KLH/*�X B�032#Awbc>q24=?>s>3A�B];E[03*;,[B;H/2/N Ë ó 8 � ï � ó � ó Õ 03*;^ Ë ó � ï 8�� ó � ó Õ X � *;H#,/>O=<C�Z�A�H'2 Ò o�� � � ßÝó �@ðOðOX\öSH/*;,/H '�33 572�Z;*;57E4Z;.1H/^"]�8Ë õ�X � Õ X �� �(� �¿���Í����� c´»¥»­;¤ ° � 3 ´�ªº©D³¨­�©3´�¼"ª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|· ,u¬ ° ' 33 ´�ªMù@¼�´ ° ùsÂ1¤�¹�À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ +@Z�C;C±>O24H � 3 572<0q*;>O*@ؽ,[B�0357*h2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8LN�03*;^ ' 33 572a*;>3AUZ;*;57E4Z;.1H/^�X Ì H`be57.1.cZ;24H Ë :�Xpï�X # Õ A�>,/>O=<C�Z�A4H � 3 X

$v8 Ë ð � X ó Õ � 03*;^ �_0GE�HM2457*;:OZ;.90GERC(>O51*LA�2/X+@Z�C;C(>O2TH � B�032RAw8sC(H Ë ó Õ X�$v8 Ë ðOðOX1ð Õ NsA�B;HÔAwbc>gC(>O57*�A�2R>O6�U Ê � Ê 0GE�H � ß Ë ó 8 Õ 03*;^ �#ß Ë ó � � � � � ï 8 Õ

Ë buB;H'E�HeA4B;H'E�HS0GE�H = Ò ðON Ò ó%ؽ,'Z�E4KLH/2 Õ X�)+*?A�B;572¿,k0324He>O*;H�,[B;H/,�Q�2vA�B�0GA � E�H'24,k03.1H'2¿A�> � � � �� � � � X � *?A�B;H�>3A4B;H'E

B�03*;^�NW516�U Ê 512e0 Ò ï�ؽ,/Z�E4KLHGN�A�B;H/* � 3 - � � � �� � � � X Y BsZ;2?U Ê 512u0 Ò ó%ؽ,/Z�ETKLH3XcíS2 � 3 Ãçð��Oó@N�57Au6�>O.1.7>%bu2\A�B�0GA

A�B;HSA�B;5VE�^D];E�03*;,¨B-512c*;>3Au03* � Ê Ø¶2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8LX Y BsZ;2 Ë ]�8_A�B;Hã,/.9032T2457Ï�,k0GA451>O*D>O6 *;>O*@ض,¨B�0357*�2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2 ÕH/5VA�B;H'E =Mß�ðS03*;^?A�B;He.9032TA�C(>O51*LAcB�032v57*;^;H �`0GA¿=?>O2TA � N@>3E =Ôßéó@N@03*;^?A�B;H�.9032IA¿C(>O57*�AvB�032v51*;^;H �<A�B�E�H/HGX� *;HP,[B;H/,�Q�2eA4B;HP>O*;.78`,/0324HP572 =ÔßÝðON � 3 ßéó �3ï�N �� � ß ï�N � ß . � � 03*;^ � ,'>O*�A[0357*;2e03* � � ؽ2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8LX

+@Z�C;C(>O2THºÏ;E�2TA�� Ê �� � Ê X # H'A � ß ��� U � X Ì HºB�0�KLH Ë ð � Xpï�Xpï Õ X $v8 Ë ðOðOX1ð Õ N�576 � 512�24=<>@>3A�B�N�A�B;H/*2457*;,/H � 512M0 Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLH3N �Dß ó_03*;^ � 3 512 ãZ4H¿03.|N�0_,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�57>O*�X Y B�Z;2 � 572ã2451*;:OZ;.10GEkN�03*;^ � Ê 5720�*;>O*@ض,[B�0351*�C(>O57*�AMbu57A�B¾];E�03*;,¨B;H'2 Ë ó Õ N Ë ó � ó Õ 03*;^ � X �-ß � � � X +@57*;,/H ����� ß õ�N�A�B;HgÏ;E�2TAPA4B�E�H/H]�.1>�bçZ�C�2�>O6 �c~ �� � ÒWÓ �' � 0GE�HP03.1>O*;: � X Y BsZ;2R]s8 Ë ðOðOX1ð Õ N � ß Ë . 8 � ó Õ N � ß Ë . 8 � ó Õ N;beB;57,¨B-B�032e51*;^;HG�:3E�Hk0GA4H'EuA4B�03*-Ï;KLH3NW0a,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�57>O*�XÌ Hg,/>O*;,/.7Z;^;H�� Ê ß ��N 03*;^ Ë ' � ��� � ä � � Õ 512M:O57KLH'*Ð]�8 Ë ð � Xpï�X7ð Õ X � � ,/>O*�A�0351*;2Ô03* � Ê C(>O57*�AkN�03*;^

���� ß�ï�X�)wAS6�>O.1.7>%bu2S69E�>O= Ë ð�ï�X � Õ A�B�0GA ' � 572S:O57KLH/*"]�8 Ë ð�ï�X � Xpó Õ X #�H'A � 8 ]±H#:O57KLH/*"]�8 Ë ð � X � Xpó Õ X Y B;H/*� 8 B�032Ô0�*;>s^;H?0GA�� 3 X � *;H<,/>O=aC�Z�A�H/2PH/03,¨Bi];E[03*;,[B�B�032P57*;^;H �i*;51*;H?03*;^ Ò o�� � � � 8 ß×ð��3ï�à ó � # XöSH/*;,/H ' 33 512RZ;*;57E�Z;.7H/^-]�8 Ë õ�X � Õ X

�S>�bm24Z�C;C(>O24H � ^;>sH/2 *;>3A B�0�KLHåAw8@C(H Ë ó Õ X Y B;H'*º](>3A�B � 03*;^ ��B�0kKLH¿57*;^;H �º0GA .7Hk032TA ï�N303*;^PA�B;H�51*;^;57,/H/2>O6W2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2y03.1>O*;: U Ê 0GE�HRó � ï � �?bu57A�B � �

� X � >O*;2457^;H'EyA�B;HcC(>O242T57]�51.757A�57H/2y6�>3E �� Ê Ò±Ó �' Ê NL,/.903242T57Ï�H/^51* Ë ðOðOX7ð Õ X�)+*;^;H �Í,/>O*;2451^;HJE[0GA�51>O*m24B;>�bu20=�ß ðONy03*;^ÍbcH`0GE�H_HG��03,'A�.V8�>O*;H?]�.7>%b Z�Cj]±H'8L>O*;^ � ß Ë ó Õ03*;^ �-ß Ë ï Õ X Y B;H'E4H?0GE�HUA+bv>�C(>O2T2457]�57.157A451H/2/N � ß Ë ó � ó 8 Õ N ��ß Ë . Õ N � ß õ � � >3E � ß Ë ï Õ N ��ß Ë ï � ó 8 Õ N� ß � � :�X�$cZ�Au576 � 3 B�032u,'H/*�ATE�HM0 Ò ó%ؽ,/Z�ETKLHP03*;^`];E[03*;,[B;H/2 Ë ó Õ N Ë ó � ó Õ 03*;^ Ë . Õ N@A4B;H/* � 3 ß õ � � 03*;^D24>A�B;HÔ6�>3E�=?H'ER,k0324HÔ512R51=<C±>O24245V]�.1H3X � 3 - ð�õ �@ð � N�57*-A�B;HM.90GA4A�HJEe,k032TH3NW03:L0351*-57=<C(>O2T2457]�.7H3X �

Page 117: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � . .�2

Y BsZ;2Ô69E�>O= *;>%b >O*¾bvHUbu51.7.y032424Z;=?H � 3 512Ô0�,[B�0351*¾2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8LXº)+*iCW0GE4A451,/Z;.10GE0; - ï�N 03*;^iA4B;H'E�H0GE�HMH ��03,JA�.78_Awbc>?2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457A�57H/2e03.7>O*;:)U Ê N �?03*;^ ��� X

� � ����32 ��� � '233��$U������±��&L�W�

Ì Ha*;>%b ,/.9032T2451698ÐC(>O242T57]�51.757A�57H/2P6�>3E ' 3 .1Hk03^;57*;:-A�> Ë ' � ��� � ä � � Õ :O57KLH'*Í51* Ë ð � Xæï�X1ð Õ 03*;^ Ë ð � Xæï�Xpï Õ X)+*-Hk03,[B�,/0324HMbvHÔ24B;>�bçA�B�0GA ' 3 512\Z;*;5VE�Z;.1H/^-Z;2451*;:UA�B;HÔ=<H'A�B;>@^;2R>O6 � õ�X Y B;512R51*LKL>O.7KLH/2cÏ�*;^;57*;:?,/H'E4A�0351*E[0GA�57>O*�03.�,/Z�E4KLH/2u>O* ' 3 X � *;HÔ,k03*;^;51^�0GA4H3N;]s8 Ë ð � Xpó@X ó Õ 512 X Y B;HÔ>3A4B;H'E�2\bcHÔbu51.7.(Z;24Hº0GE4HÔ:O5VKLH/*�]�8`A�B;H6�>O.1.7>%bu51*;:<.1H/=?=?032/X Ì HºH/*;,/>OZ�E�03:OHºA�B;HºE�Hk03^;H'EeA�>?Ï;E�2TAS:O>?A4B�E�>OZ;:OB"H ��03=aC�.1H Ë õ�X1ð�Å Õ N�032eA�B;H#03*�03.V8�24572A�>a6�>O.1.1>�bç512\KLH'E48D2457=?51.10GEkN@]�Z�Au.1H/2T2e^;H'A[0357.1H/^�XY B;HÔ*;>3A[0GA451>O*-6�>3ERA�B;HME[0GA�51>O*�03.�,'Z�E4KLH/2u]±H/.1>�b 512\Ï"�;H/^�6�>3EeA�B;HME�H/=_0357*;^;H'Eu>O6 � ð � X

� �(� �(�»� �����Í������£ ¤'¥ � Ü É �q§¨¤a©`¼(¬k¹L©GÂå³Jù�§'´¶³0,cûy´�¥®­�¼(¬k¹�¤a©G¥ � ©G¼(¹�© �e¤�� ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥u©G¥ Î ÀÔ£ ¤J¥ = �ßâΧ¨¤Ô¥®­;¤ºùs¼�´¶ø'ù�¤ ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥u¬+¸ � 3 ,¿û�­;¬%ªk¤º¥½©3¼@È�¤J¼�¥¿Â ´�¼(¤P«?¤[¤J¥®ª Î À

Ë ð Õ Á ­;¤ ° ¤S´�ªÔ©#¼(¬�¹L©GÂ�³Jù;§/´¶³ � ¥®­ ° ¬�ùOÈG­ Î ©G¼±¹ � ,�ªJ«?¬�¬�¥®­�©G¥ Î ©G¼±¹ � ,yûy´�¥®­?ªk¤Jµ3¤'¼�¥»­�¬ ° ¹�¤ ° ³[¬�¼�¥w©�³J¥ûy´�¥®­ � ©3¥ Î À

Ë ó Õ Á ­;¤ ° ¤a´�ª<©�¼(¬k¹L©GÂc³Jù;§/´¶³ � ¥®­ ° ¬GùOÈ�­ Î , � ,ã©G¼±¹ = ,RªJ«?¬�¬�¥®­�©G¥e¥»­�¤¨ªk¤ ¯ ¬G´�¼�¥®ª5,uûy´�¥®­g¸k¬ ° ¥®­�¬ ° ¹�¤ °³[¬�¼W¥½©�³'¥�ûy´»¥»­ � ©G¥ Î ,c©G¼±¹<¥®­�´ ° ¹D¬ ° ¹�¤ ° ³[¬�¼�¥w©�³J¥¿ûy´�¥®­ � ©G¥ = À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Ì HÔC;E�>�KLHPA�B;HMÏ;E�2TA�,/0324H3N�03*;^�A�B;HP.7Hk0�KLHMA�B;HP2TH/,/>O*;^�A�>UA�B;HPE�Hk03^;HJEkNWbuB;51,[B"572e03*�03.7>O:O>OZ;2/X #�H'A' ß ' Ë � Ê ä U �/Õ X@$c.1>�béZ�C">O*;,/HP0GA � 03*;^�24H'KLH/*-A451=?H/2R0GAyÎq03.7>O*;: � N�A�>a>3];A[0351* �' Xy)wAu572uH'*;>OZ;:OB-A�>24B;>�b�A�B;H'E4H#512ã0_*;>@^�03. H/.1.757C;A�57,#,/Z�E4KLH �ÚÜ ' 3 X ,W>3ESA�B;512�bcH#2IA�Z;^�8�A�B;H#H/.7.15VC;A�51,ºC±H/*;,/51.ul Ò o���lpXUîVð � ñ51=aC�.151H'2eA�B;H'E�HU512ã0_24=<>@>3A�Bq=?H/=#]±H'E � �tl Ò o���lpN(bu57A�B � Ü ' 3 N�03*;^Ð516 �à512SA�B;H Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLHg>�KLH'E �A�B;H/*�� ��l Ò o���lpXY BsZ;2ºbcH`B�0kKLH`03*mH/.1.757C;A�57,<Ï;];E[0GA�57>O*-RM~ � ÒWÓ É�Ê 0369A�H'E#]�.1>�bu51*;:"Z�CmA�B;H_]W0324H'C±>O51*LAg>O6gl Ò o��ylpX

Y B;H/*-]�8 Ë ð�õ�X . Õ >O6\î .3ñ�bvHPB�0kKLH

� Ë ���Õ ß � Ë É � Õ ä # ß � Ë � � Õ ä � Ë �U �/Õ ä �buB;H'E�H � 512#A�B;H �¿Z;.7H'EU,[B�0GE[03,'A�H'E4512TA�57,3N ��512#A�B;H`,/>O*LA4E�5V]�Z�A�51>O*jA�>qA�B;H`24Z;= 69E�>O= A�B;HD>3A�B;H'EU2451*;:OZ;.10GEÏ;];E�H/2Ô03*;^ �U � N � � 0GE�HU032S>O*qCW03:OH_ð � Å`>O6eî .3ñ Ë Y B;H#Ï;];E�H#A�B�E4>OZ;:OBÐA�B;H � Ê C(>O57*�Aã,'>O*�A[0357*;2 �×03*;^Ð24>bcHÔ:OH'AuA4B;HÔ:3E[0GC�B � � Õ X Y B�Z;2���ßÝðº03*;^�>O*;HãÏ;];E�Hº>O6�R�512u0a*;>s^�03.�,/Z�]�51,��aX �A ��À �LÀ A À A�D ¤J«<© °GF À $c8Ð0D^;51=?H'*;2451>O*i,/>OZ;*�AÔ>O*;H<HG��C(H','A�2P57* Ë ð � X � X1ðOX7ð Õ 0D>O*;Ha^;51=?H/*;2T51>O*�03.�6�03=?57.78q>O6H/.7.157C;A451,g,/Z�E4KLH/2ãCW03242457*;:�A�B�E4>OZ;:OBDÎ�03*;^ � =?H/HJA�51*;: � A4>�>3E�^;HJE � 0GAcÎ�XºöS>%bvH'KLH'EMÏ�*;^;51*;:�0 ° ©3¥®´¶¬G¼±©GÂH/.7.157C;A451,e,'Z�E4KLHS51*?A�B;HS6�03=<51.78LNL24=<>@>3A�B_0GA Î�03*;^ � N@572v=?>3E�Hu24Z�];A�.1HGX@,W>3EcH �;03=<C�.1HRA�B;HeC;E�>s>O6�>O6 Ë ð � X � X1ð Õ24B;>�be2RA�B�0GARA�B;H'E�HÔ512R*;><24Z;,[B",/Z�E4KLHÔ516 � B�032�03*->3E4^;51*�0GE48D,/Z;2TC�X

Page 118: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

. . � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

� �(� �(� 5 �¿���Í�����-£ ¤J¥ � , � Ü É��-§¨¤U©?¼(¬�¹L©GÂ�³Jù�§'´¶³-,�ûy´�¥®­�¼(¬�¹�¤ � ,c©G¼±¹�©<ª¨«_¬�¬�¥®­q³[¬�¼W´¶³0,�«?¤¨¤J¥®´»¼@È �¥+¬<¬ ° ¹�¤ ° ª¨´ �`©G¥¿© ¯ ¬�´»¼�¥ Î �ß � À Á ­;¤J¼�¥»­�¤ ° ¤M´�ªM©a¼(¬k¹�©GÂ�³'ù;§'´½³ � 8åû�­�´½³¨­_«?¤[¤J¥®ª �ש3¥ Î ¥w¬?¬ ° ¹�¤ ° ªk¤JµO¤J¼±À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ )+6vbcHU]�.1>�b Z�Cjï�A�51=<H/2P0GARÎj03.1>O*;: � 03*;^¾A�B;H/*�]�.7>%b ^;>�be*�A4B;HaA[03*;:OH/*LA#.751*;H?03*;^�A4B;HaAwbc>Ò ó%ؽ,/Z�E4KLH'2/NWA4B;H/* � ](H/,/>O=<H/2RA4B;H�/�H ��.157*;HMA4>MÎ�NW03*;^-A�B;HãE�H/24Z;.VA�6�>O.7.1>�be2R69E�>O= Ë ð � X � X7ðOX ó Õ X �� �(� �(��( �¿���Í������£ ¤J¥ � , � Ü É � §¨¤#©?¼�¬k¹L©G ³Jù�§'´¶³-,�ûy´�¥®­D¼(¬k¹s¤ � ,\©G¼±¹D©<ª¨«?¬�¬�¥®­q³¨¬�¼�´¶³0,å«_¤[¤J¥|´�¼@È<¥+¬¬ ° ¹�¤ ° ª¨´ �i©G¥ã© ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥ Î �ß � À Á ­;¤'¼m¥»­�¤ ° ¤U´�ª<© ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼±©3Â�ø'ù;© ° ¥|´¶³ � 818�,eûy´�¥®­�©G¼�¬%ªk³'¼(¬k¹�¤?©G¥ Î �½¥®­�©G¥e´�ª¥|ûv¬<ªJ«?¬�¬�¥®­q§ ° ©G¼(³J­;¤¨ªÔ«_¤[¤J¥|´�¼@È?¥+¬-¬ ° ¹�¤ ° ï � ,¿ª¨ùW³¨­-¥®­�©G¥e¬G¼(¤U§ ° ©G¼(³J­q¬+¸ � 818 ©3¥ Î «?¤[¤'¥»ª �×¥+¬�¬ ° ¹�¤ ° � ,©G¼±¹?¥»­;¤a¬�¥®­;¤ ° «_¤[¤J¥®ª �Ö¥+¬D¬ ° ¹�¤ ° ï ,\©G¼±¹<ªJù�³¨­�¥»­�©3¥ � 8 8 «?¤[¤'¥»ª#¬G¼(¤g§ ° ©G¼(³¨­q¬+¸ � ©G¥ � ¥w¬D¬ ° ¹�¤ ° ï À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ íS69A4H'EÔ0_]�5VE[0GA�57>O*�03. A4E[03*;2T6�>3E�=_0GA�57>O* Ë ,/6½XSA�B;HºC;E�>s>O6å>O6 Ë ð � X � X ó Õ4Õ Îi]±H/,/>O=?H'2ã0 /�HG�"C(>O57*�AM03*;^A�B;HMC;E�>3]�.1H/= 512\A�><Ï�*;^q0U24=?>@>3A4B-,/>O*;57, � A�03*;:OH/*�AuA�> � 0GAåÎ"bu57A4B-A�B;HP^;H'24,'E�5V](H/^q,/>O*LA[03,'A�0GA � XvíS203.1.(CW035VE�2 Ë � �,�ºÕ 0GE�HãC;E�>GFIH/,'A�5VKLH/.78D512T>O=?>3E4C�B;51,GN;57Au512RH/*;>OZ;:OB-A�>a,/>O*;2TA4E�Z;,JA � 6�>3Ee24>O=<HMCW035VEkX

$cH/:O51*"bu57A�Bi0`24=?>@>3A4Bi,/>O*;57, U Ü É � N�Awbc>`A[03*;:OH/*LA�2 � 03*;^ � 0GA � 03*;^ �±N�03*;^�0`24H/,k03*LAP.751*;H �A�B�E�>OZ;:OB � N � �� � X #�H'A � ~ � Ò�Ó É�� ](H`>3];A[0351*;H'^m]�8¾]�.7>%bu51*;:qZ�C�ï�A�51=<H/2º0GA � 03.1>O*;: � Nå03*;^jïA�57=?H/2c0GA%U 03.1>O*;: �±X2# HJA � ](HSA�B;H Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLHã>�KLH'E �(N@03*;^ ��A�B;H Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�E4KLHM>�KLH'E � X�# HJA �c~ �çÒ�Ó É��](HU:O57KLH'*i]�8i,'>O*�A4E�03,'A�51*;:�03.1.�A4B;H � ضH �;,'H'C;A�51>O*�03.y,/Z�ETKLH/2PH ��,/H'C;A � 03*;^ �<N�A�>O:OH'A�B;H'EMbu57A�B4U 03*;^ �Ë buB;51,[B"0GE�Hã](>3A4B Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�E4KLH'2�>O* ��Õ X � 572RA�B;HME�H/rsZ;57E�H/^-,/>O*;51,3X �� �(� �(� 7��:9������%�����¿�4.Wù ¯�¯ ¬%ªk¤ Ë ' � ��� � ä � � ÕD´�ª<È3´�µ3¤J¼�§'· � A �sÀ �LÀ A � ÀÍ£ ¤J¥ � � � Ü ' §¨¤D¥®­;¤`ª¨¥ ° ´¶³'¥¥ ° ©G¼;ª»¸k¬ ° «gª_¬+¸a¥®­;¤a¥w©G¼@Ès¤J¼�¥� ´�¼(¤¨ª<¥w¬�¥»­�¤a¥®ûc¬Ð§ ° ©G¼(³¨­�¤¨ª�� , Þ ,P¬+¸ � A ��À A À ��� ,ã¬+¸ � Ü É � ©G¥�¥®­;¤a¼(¬�¹�¤� À �#¬�¥+¤� ­�©�ª�©Ðùs¼W´|§ ° ©3¼(³¨­¾ª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥®·�©G¥ � 3 ¬+¸�¸k¬ ° « Ë ��� � Ê � ó 8 � ; 8 � � � ��Õ �T¬�¼ �� Ê , �� «?¤[¤'¥»ª_¥®­;¤´�¼�¥+¤ ° ªk¤[³J¥|´¶¬�¼�¬+¸ �U Ê ûy´�¥®­q¥»­�¤=2 ° ªJ¥\Ò ó ú�³Jù ° µ3¤`¬+¸g¥®­;¤ ��� ¯ ¬�´»¼�¥ � À �#¬�¥+¤U´Ç¸ = - ó , � ´�ª#ªJ«?¬�¬�¥®­¾©G¥ � 3 ,©G¼±¹�­�©�ª\¸�¬ ° « Ë ��� � � � ó 8 � ó � ; � � � �+Õ-,�û�­s´�Â1¤a´Ç¸ =Dß ð , � «?¤[¤J¥®ª Ê ©G¥ã©-ª¨«?¬%¬�¥»­ ¯ ¬�´�¼W¥ ,S©3¼±¹Ð¹�¬%¤¨ªU¼(¬�¥¯ ©�ª¨ªM¥»­ ° ¬�ùLÈ�­ � 3 À

�S>3A�H Ò ;Mä =\ä .ºß ���� Ê X Ì HPB�0kKLH

Ë ð � Xæõ Õ ÅaÃ Ë oàä � � Ê Õ�� � Ê ß$ Ò ð$ Ò ��� Ê

=Räâó+@Z�C;C(>O2TH �<B�032RA+8sC(H !�5�X Y B;H/* ��� Ê ß ���� Ê ä

� � Ê � 5� 03*;^�>O*;HÔÏ�*;^;2u69E�>O= Ë ð � Xpõ Õ

Ë ð � Xæõ�X1ð Õ �� � Ê Ã Ë $ Ò ð Õ Ë ; Ò ï Õ ä �

)+*qð � X � Ø�ð%óÔbvHS,/.903242T51698?C±>O242457]�57.15VA�51H/2vbuB;H'E�H�� Ê � � Ê X Ë ð � Xpï�X1ð Õ ^;H/24,'E457](H'2\A4B;HS,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*;2R>O* ' �03*;^ � � X Ì HM,/>O*;2457^;H'E�H/03,¨B�C±>O24245V]�51.15VAw8`6�>3E ' � 57*-A�Z�E�*�Xy)+*"03*L8�,/0324H $ - ï�X �S>3A�H �� � Ê ßto �� X� �(� � ' � ß ' Ë � Ê ä � � ÕJ� Y B;H/* �� � Ê ßÝõ�N=gß ;ãä�ó@X �S>3A�H U � B�032eH/57A�B;HJEM03* � Ê C(>O51*LAS>3E � � C±>O51*LA03.1>O*;:a57AkX

Page 119: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � . .10

� �(� �(�»� 'þ U � � ��¡���� � � �å�±�»�(�L� Y BsZ;2 �tß Ë � � ó � ó Õ N � ß Ë � � � � � ï Õ N � 3 ß Ë ó � ó � � � ; ��� � � � Õ X$ ßéï � Ò ó@X �-ß ï � Ò õ�X�$c8 Ë ð � Xæõ�X1ð Õ N �$��.;X� �(� �(�»�W�®� 'þ �jß ï � Ë ð � Xpõ�X7ð Õ :O5VKLH/2 ;�ß ï�X ! Ë � 3 Õ ß � ï�X Ò o�� � � ß ï � � ï�X # >O:iZ;*;57E�Z;.7H/^h]�8Ë õ�X � Õ X �� �(� �(�»�W�65 'þ �#ßéó � Ë ð � Xæõ�X1ð Õ :O57KLH'2 ;gß ï�N .;N ! Ë � 3 Õ ß ï . � õ � X � *;HP,[B;H/,�Q�2uA�B;HÔ2T=?>@>3A�B`];E[03*;,[B">O6 B�032e57*;^;H �ið � 57*�A�B;HMÏ;E�2TAu,k0324H3X Ò o�� �/� ßéõ �3ï . � ï �3õ � X�#�>O:<Z;*;5VE�Z;.1H'^�]s8 Ë õ�X � Õ X �� �(� �(� 5 'þ U � � �W¡\��� � Ê �å�±�»�(�L� Y BsZ;2 �#ß Ë � � ó Õ N � ß Ë � � � � � ï � ó Õ N � 3 ß Ë ó � � � ; ��� � � � Õ X $ ßéó � Ò ðON�-ß ó � Ò .;X Ë ð � Xpõ�X1ð Õ :O5VKLH/2 �$� � X� �(� �(� 5±�®� 'þ �#ß . � Ë ð � Xæõ�X1ð Õ :O57KLH/2 ;#ß ï�X ! Ë � 3 Õ ß � # X Ò o�� �=� ßéó � � # X �� �(� �(� 5±�65 'þ �#ß ï � Ë ð � Xæõ�X1ð Õ :O57KLH/2 ;#ß ï�X ! Ë � 3 Õ ß � ï�X Ò o�� �=� ß . � � ï�X �� �(� �(� 5±�)( 'þ �#ßéó � Ë ð � Xæõ�X1ð Õ :O57KLH/2 ;gß ï � . � � X ! Ë � 3 Õ ßéó � N � ó@N :Oï�X �S>3A�HeA�B;H�Awbc>#];E[03*;,[B;H/2\>O6 � 0GA� 3 0GE�H Ë ó 8�� � � ; ��� � � � Õ 03*;^ Ë ó � � � ; � ó � ó 8���� � Õ X � *;H<,[B;H/,�Q�2MA�B;Ha2T=?>@>3A�B"];E[03*;,[B�>O6 � B�032M51*;^;HG�Íó � N� óU57*�A�B;HMÏ;E�2TARAwbc><,k032TH/2/X Ò o�� �/� �tß # �Oó � N : � � ó@N � � :Oï�X �� �(� ��Jþ=' � ß ' Ë � Ê ä ���/ÕJ� Y B;H/* �� � Ê ßéï�N:=Pß ; Ò ðOX �S>3A�H U � B�032cH/57A4B;H'ER03* � Ê C(>O57*�A\>3E ��� C±>O51*LA03.1>O*;:a57AkX� �(� ���»� 'þ U � � �W¡��W� ��� �����»���L� Y B�Z;2 � ß Ë � �����/Õ N � ß Ë � � � � � ï Õ N�� 3 ß Ë ��� � � � ; ��� � � Ê Õ X$ ßàõ � Ò � N �âßàõ � Ò ð%ó@X Ë ð � Xpõ�X1ð Õ :O57KLH'2 �qßÖó@N@;Ðßàï�X ! Ë � 3 Õ ßàï�ðON Ò o�� �;� ßàï �3ï�ðON 24>".7>O:Z;*;57E4Z;.1H/^-]�8 Ë õ�X � Õ X �� �(� ��� 5 Jþ U � � �W¡?�W� � Ê �å�±�»�(�L� �Uß Ë � � ó Õ N � ß Ë � � � � � ï �����'Õ N � 3 ß Ë ó � � � ; ��� � � Ê Õ X $ ß�ó � Ò ðON�-ß ó � Ò .;X Ë ð � Xpõ�X1ð Õ :O5VKLH/2 �#ßéï � ó@X� �(� ��� 5±�®� 'þ �#ß ï � Ë ð � Xæõ�X1ð Õ :O5VKLH/2 ;Uß ï�X ! Ë � 3 Õ ßéó # N B�032cAwbc>g24=?>@>3A4B<];E[03*;,[B;H/2u0GA � 3 X � 8 8 N Ë >O6ð � X � Xæï Õ B�032RAwbc>a24=?>@>3A4BD];E[03*;,[B;H/2ã0GA � 3 X Y B�Z;2e.1>O:aZ;*;57E�Z;.7H/^-]�8 Ë õ�X � Õ N;Z;2T51*;: � 8 8 03*;^ X� �(� ��� 5±�65 'þ �Ußçó � Ë ð � Xæõ�X1ð Õ :O57KLH'2 ;aßéï � .;X@,�>3E ;aßéï�N ! Ë �;Õ ß ðOðOX � 818 B�032eAwbc>a24=?>@>3A4B�];E[03*;,[B;H/20GA � N Ë ��� � ï 8 Õ 03*;^ Ë � � � ó 8 � ó � ï Õ X Ò o�� � � � 8 8 ß ï �@ðOðOXå.7>O:#Z;*;57E�Z;.7H/^`]s8 Ë õ�X � Õ X ,W>3E?;Uß .;N ! Ë � 3 Õ ß ï�ðOX� 8 B�032å>O*;He2T=?>@>3A�B�N�03*;^a>O*;He2457*;:OZ;.90GEå];E[03*;,[B`0GA � 3 X Y B;He2457*;:OZ;.90GEå];E[03*;,[B_512 Ë ó � ó � . 8 � ó 8 ��� � Õ NLbuB;51,[B>O*;HP,[B;H/,�Q@2eB�032e57*;^;H �-ï�ðOX Y B�Z;2 Ë bu57A�B � 8 03*;^ Õ .1>O:aZ;*;57E�Z;.7H/^-]�8 Ë õ�X � Õ X �� �(� ' 'þ ' � ß ' Ë ï � � ÕJ� ���� Ê ß ï�X�=aß ; Ò ðOX � ß Ë ó � ï ��� � � � Õ N�� 3 ß Ë � � � � � ; ��� � � Ê Õ X $ ß ï � Ò ó@N��� Ê ß ïuä �

� � � � X Y B;H/* Ë ð � Xæõ Õ :O57KLH/2 �#ßçó@N�;#ßçï�X ! Ë � 3 Õ ßÝð # N�03*;^ Ò o�� ��� ßéï �@ð # N�.1>O:UZ;*;57E4Z;.1H/^]�8 Ë õ�X � Õ X �� �(�»�@� Jþ;' � ß ' Ë � � ä ���kÕJ� �� � Ê ßéó@X Y B�Z;2e]�8 Ë ð � Xpõ�X1ð Õ N;Uß ï�N1=MßÝðON �#ßçó@N�03*;^ �<572 ãZ>H¿03.�X

�S>3A�H U � ,/>O*�A�0351*;2eH'57A�B;H'Ee03* � � >3E�03* ��� C±>O51*LAkX

Page 120: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

.$) + ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

� �(�»�@���»� Jþ U � ÿO�±�(���W�®� ¡Ð�W� � � �å���®�(�L� Y B�Z;2 � ß Ë ��� � ï Õ 03*;^ � 3 ß Ë ó � ï ��� �/Õ X ! Ë � 3 Õ ßìð�.;X� *;Ha,[B;H/,�Q�2MA�B;HU24=?>@>3A4Bq];E�03*;,¨Bi>O6 B�032ã57*;^;H ��ð�.;N�03*;^ Ò o�� � � ß ó �@ð�.;N(A�B�Z;2Ô.7>O:�Z;*;5VE�Z;.1H'^i]�8Ë õ�X � Õ X �� �(�»�@��� 5 'þ U � ÿO���(�����»��¡c�W� ��� �å���®�(�L� � ß Ë ó � ï Õ N � 3 ß Ë ó � ï ��� � Õ X ! Ë � 3 Õ ßéó3ï�X Ò o�� ��� ßéó �Oó3ï�NA�B�Z;2e.7>O:<Z;*;57E4Z;.1H/^-]�8 Ë õ�X � Õ X �� �(�»��� 'þ=' � ß ' Ë � Ê äió � �kÕJ� $v8 Ë ð�ï�X � X � Õ U � ,/>O*�A�0351*;2c03* � � C±>O51*LAkX�íS2c51* Ë ð � X7ð�Å Õ ���� Ê ßéóP51=aC�.151H'2;Ußéï�N1=PßÝðON �gßçó@X Ì HPB�0kKLH � ß Ë � � � ï Õ 03*;^ � 3 ß Ë ó � ï �����'Õ X ! Ë � 3 Õ ß�ð � N Ò o�� �/� ßçó �@ð � N�24>.1>O:aZ;*;57E�Z;.7H/^-]�8 Ë õ�X � Õ X �� �(�»�15 'þ ' � ß ' Ë ó � Ê ä � ��Õ¨� �S>3A�H U � ,/>O*LA[0351*;2SH/5VA�B;H'Eã03* � � >3Eã03* � Ê C(>O57*�AkX Ì HºB�0kKLH ���� Ê ß .;X=DßL; � .-]�8 Ë ð � Xpõ�X7ð Õ X +@Z�C;C±>O24H>;Ðß .;X Ë ð � Xæõ�X1ð Õ :O57KLH'2 �âßÚÅ�N 03*;^ � à $ N A�B�Z;2 �qßàó@N 03*;^ U �,/>O*LA[0351*;2�03* � Ê C±>O51*LAkN � ß Ë � � � ï Õ N � 3 ß Ë ��� � . ��� � Õ N ! Ë � 3 Õ ßçï :�N�>O*;Hº,[B;H/,�Q�2eA4B;Hº24=?>s>3A�B�];E[03*;,[B>O6 B�03^�51*;^;H ��ï :<03*;^ Ò o�� �/� ßéó �3ï :�N;24>a.1>O:aZ;*;57E�Z;.7H/^-]�8 Ë õ�X � Õ X

�S>�bç032424Z;=?H ;gß =Mß ï�X� �(�»�15±�»� 'þ U � ÿL���(���W�®��¡��W� � � �å�±�»�(�L� $v8 Ë ð � Xpõ�X7ð Õ N � ��.Ô57=<C�.157H/2 �#ßçó@X Y B�Z;2 � 3 ß Ë � � � ï �����kÕ N! Ë � 3 Õ ßéó # N Ò o�� � � ß . �Oó # N;.1>O:<Z;*;5VE�Z;.1H'^-]s8 Ë õ�X � Õ X �� �(�»�15±� 5 'þ U � ÿO�������W�»��¡?�W� � Ê �å�±�»�(�L� �aß Ë � � ó Õ NWbuB;51,[BÐB�032eAw8@C±HUó � Ò .;X Y B�Z;2 Ë ð � Xpõ�X7ð Õ :O5VKLH/2�#ßçó � ï�X�,�>3E �#ßéó@N � 3 ß Ë � � � ï ��� � Õ N ! Ë � 3 Õ ßÝð # N Ò o�� � � ß . �@ð # X�,W>3E �gß ï�N � 3 ß Ë � � � ï � � ï � ó Õ N! Ë � 3 Õ ß ï � N Ò o�� � � ßéó �3ï � X �)+*Íð � X1ð�ï�Ø4ð�.?bcH#,/.9032T2451698�C±>O24245V]�51.15VA�51H'2ebeB;HJE�H � Ê �� � Ê X Y B�Z;2SbcH#B�0kKLHºA�B;H#24H'A�Z�Ci>O6 Ë ð � Xæï�Xpï Õ X Ì H

^;57K@51^;HeA4B;HS03*�03.78@24512v57*�A4>ºA+bv>#,k0324H/2c^;H'C±H/*;^;51*;:g>O*?buB;H'A�B;H'E\>3Ev*;>3A � � U � 572c0º24=?>s>3A�B<C(>O57*�A/X �S>3A�H� ß � Ê X� �(�»� ( Jþ � ���@���%¡ U � �;�-�h¡k�����W�%� �����»���L� +@> �D512Ô0 ãZ H¿03. C±>O51*LAkN � � N ��ß � ä�ó@N����� Ê ß � N=Mß ;ãä�ðON � 3 ß Ë � �5� ; ��� � � Ê Õ N � Ê ß Ë ó � � äâó � ó � ó Õ X $ ß � ätðON;24> Ë ð � Xæõ�X1ð Õ :O57KLH'2

Ë ð � X7ð�ï�X1ð Õ � à � Ë ; Ò ï Õ

)+*�CW0GE4A451,/Z;.10GE ; � :�X� �(�»� (�� 5 Jþ ;gß ï � � *;He,¨B;H',[Q@2 � ßÝð Ë >3E � Ê Ã � 3 Õ X � 3 ß Ë ó � ï �����kÕ N ! Ë � 3 Õ ß�ð � X Ò o�� � � ß � �@ð � X' 3 572u.7>O:<Z;*;57E4Z;.1H/^-]�8 Ë õ�X � Õ X �� �(�»� (���( 'þ ;Ðß . � ð�õ�X7ð�õ�X1ð?:O5VKLH � ß ð � ó � ï � .;X ! Ë � 3 Õ ßàïLó � . � � � : � � ðOX � *;H_,[B;H/,�Q�2#57*ÍHk03,[BÍ,k0324HA�B�0GA\A�B;HÔ2451*;:OZ;.10GER];E�03*;,¨B">O6 �aNsbeB;57,¨B-512 Ë � � � Ê � ó 8 � .

� �����'Õ B�032u51*;^;H � ! Ë � 3 Õ N�03*;^-A�B�0GA\A�B;HM24=?>s>3A�B];E[03*;,[B�N buB;51,[Bi512 Ë � � � . � ó 8 ������Õ N�B�032M51*;^;H � ! Ë � 3 Õ H ��,/H'C;AÔ51*iA4B;Ha,k032TH � ß ó`buB;H/*iA�B;HU51*;^;HG�¾572 # X� *;HP,/>O=<C�Z�A4H/2 Ò o�� �/� � ß � � � � �

Ê � � � Ê�� X Y B�Z;2 ' 3 512R.1>O:<Z;*;5VE�Z;.1H'^-]s8 Ë õ�X � Õ 51*�H'KLHJE48D,k0324H3X �

Page 121: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � .$)�.

� �(�»� (�� Jþ ;Íß � � ð�õ�X1ð�õ�X7ð_:O57KLH/2 � ß ð � ó@X ! ß � ð � � ï�X � *;HD,¨B;H',[Q@2<57*mA4B;HDÏ;E�2IAa,/0324H_A�B�0GAgA�B;H24=?>s>3A�B�];E[03*;,[B B�032S51*;^;H � � ðON(03*;^ Ò o�� � � ß ï � � ðOX�)+*"A�B;Hg24H/,/>O*;^i,k0324H � B�032SAwbc>_];E[03*;,[B;H/20GA � 3 N�>O*;HS24=?>s>3A�B`03*;^`>O*;Hã2451*;:OZ;.10GEkX � *;Hã,[B;H/,�Q�2cA�B;HS2457*;:OZ;.90GEc];E[03*;,[BDB�032\51*;^;H � � ï�X Y B;HS2451*;:OZ;.10GE];E[03*;,[B"512 Ë � � � � � � ó 8 � ó Õ X Y B;HP24=?>@>3A4BD];E[03*;,[B"572 Ë ��� � ó 8 � � � ó � ó Õ X � *;Hº,/>O=<C�Z�A�H'2 Ò o�� �=� � ß � � � ï�X+@><.7>O:<Z;*;5VE�Z;.1H/^�]s8 Ë õ�X � Õ X �� �(�»� (�� � 'þ ;Ýß õ � � ß ðOX ! Ë � 3 Õ ß � .;X � *;HÍ,[B;H/,�Q�2"]±>3A�Bt];E[03*;,[B;H/2q>O6 � B�0�KLHÍ57*;^;H � � .;XÒ o�� �/� �çßÝð�õ � � .;X �� �(�»� (�� � 'þ ;qß � � � ß ðOX ! Ë � 3 Õ ß ð�Å�ðOX � *;H?,[B;H/,�Q�2ºA�B;Ha2451*;:OZ;.10GEP];E[03*;,[BÍ>O6 �àB�032º57*;^;H �hð�Å�ðOXÒ o�� �/� �çß # �@ð�Å�ðOX �� �(�»� 'þ � ���@���%¡ U � ���?��¡k�»� ý���K��W� �å���®�(�L� #�H'A � ß U � � � X � Ê 572e*;H/,'H/242�0GE�57.78�0?*;>O*@ؽ,[B�0351*C(>O57*�A/NLbu57A4BU];E[03*;,[B;H/2 � � Ë ó Õ � Ë ó � ó Õ X ,WE�>O= 03*aHk032T8g,/.10324245VÏ�,k0GA�51>O* Ë 2457*;,/H � Ê 512y*;>3A ãZ)H¿03. Õ N � Ê - ó �3ï�X� >O*;2451^;H'E �c~ �� � Ò�Ó �' � X

� �(�»� ��»� 'þ#�%� ��¡/��ÿO�±� �Ýü K���� � � �Wþ � �»¡"�K���� ý �#� �S>3A4H �ÐßÖó@X Y B;H?>O*;.78iC(>O242T57]�51.757Aw8i6�>3E �Ë bu57A�B � Ê � õ � � N�03*;^ � Ê *;>O* MZ H¿03. Õ 512 Ë ï Õ X Y B;H/* �_ß Ë ó Õ N ���� Ê ß .;X�� Ë >O* �' 3 Õ 572ã0�ï�ض,/Z�E4KLH3XM)wA�22457*;:OZ;.90GEe];E�03*;,¨BÐ0GA � 3 572 Ë ó 8�� ; � ��� � Õ 03*;^"57A42e24=?>s>3A�B�];E�03*;,¨Bq572 Ë ó � ; � ó 8 ��� � � Ê Õ XcíS.724>_0369A�H'Ee24,k03.751*;:� ß ó Ò ï �Oó � X Y B;H/*i69E�>O= A�B;HU,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*¾57* É � 57Aã6�>O.1.7>%bu2SA�B�0GA � � : � # X Y B�Z;2 =<ß ; � õ�XP)+6;"ß ïDA�B;H'* � 3 � � Ê ßÚó �3ï�X Y BsZ;20;"ß .;N � N�õ�X ! Ë � 3 Õ ßÚó � N�. .;N�õ � X),�>3E ;qß .->O*;H<,[B;H/,�Q@2ºA�B;H24=?>s>3A�B?];E[03*;,[B->O6 B�032\57*;^;H �-ó � N;03*;^ Ò o�� � � ß ï �Oó � X2,�>3E?;gß � >O*;Hã,[B;H/,�Q�2\](>3A4B`];E�03*;,¨B;H'2e>O6� B�0�KLHº57*;^;H � . .`03*;^ Ò o�� � � �Ýß ð%ó �'. .;X ,�>3E ;?ß õ<A�B;H#2451*;:OZ;.10GE�];E[03*;,[Bq>O6�� B�032�57*;^;H �mð�ï�NWA�B;H24=?>s>3A�Bq];E[03*;,[BÍB�032P51*;^;HG��õ � N�buB;51.1H Ò o�� � � � ß � �3õ � ÃÚð��@ð�ïãäçð��3õ � X�+@> Ë õ�X � Õ 0GC;C�.157H/2P57*¾Hk03,[B,k0324HGX �� �(�»� �� 5 Jþe�%� �q¡/��ÿO�����âü K���� � �ë�Wþ � �»¡a� K»��� ý U � � �S>3A�H � - ï�Xå)+6 � - .aA�B;H'* � Ê - õ � � X�íS.724>516 � - ïD03*;^ � B�032Ô57*;^;H �i0GAM.1Hk032IAºï�N � Ê - õ � � X Ì Hg,/>O*;,/.1Z;^;H � ß Ë ó Õ N �Dß ï�N �Dß Ë ï Õ N �� � Ê ß � N=aß ;PäçðON � Ê ß ï �'.;N�� 3 ß Ë ï � ; ��� � � Ê Õ X $v8 Ë ð � Xæõ�X1ð Õ ; � .;XM)+6%;`ß ï?A�B;H/* � 3 ß ó@ð��Oó : � ï �'.;N�0,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�51>O*�X +@>8;<ß .;X ! Ë � 3 Õ ß � ðOX � B�032e];E[03*;,[B;H/2 Ë ï 8 � . � �����/Õ 03*;^ Ë ï � . � ó 8 ������Õ X � *;Hº,[B;H/,�Q�2Hk03,[B�B�032u51*;^;H � � ðOX Ò o�� �/� �çß . �@ð � X �

����� � Ê $��� �� �

)+*�A�B;572e03*;^�A�B;HP6�>O.7.1>�be57*;:a24H','A�51>O*�bcHÔC;E�>�KLH

�����»��NÔ�%� ����¡k���%�����¿� � ¸ � Ê ´�ªUª¨«?¬%¬�¥»­ ,S¥®­;¤J¼�¤J´�¥®­;¤ ° ' ­�©�ªD©�¥|´1È�¤ ° ,P¬ ° Ë ' � ��� � ä � � Õ?´�ª`©�ªJ«?¬�¬�¥®­§[©G¼(©G¼±© ,\³'Â7©�ª[ª¨´ 2\¤�¹a´�¼ � A �sÀCB � À � ¼m¤J´�¥®­;¤ ° ³[©�ªk¤ ' 33 ´�ªMù@¼�´ ° ù@Â1¤�¹LÀ

� �q�W¡k¡k�����"�%� �%�±� ý±� ��� � � ������� '��%� �;� ' � �W¡a� ���%��ýW�@���

Page 122: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

.$)�) ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

)+*¾A�B;572Ô24H','A�51>O*ibcH<bu51.1.�,'>O*;2451^;H'E#03.1.�C(>O242T57]�51.757A�57H/2M6�>3EPA�B;Ha*;H ��APBsZ;*LA#2TA�HJC�N�03*;^¾E�Z;.7H<>OZ�Aº03.1.�]�Z�AA�B;HÔ24=?>@>3A4BD]W03*�03*�0�X Y B;HÔ24=?>s>3A�BD]W03*�03*�0Ube57.1.(](HM,/>O*;2457^;H'E�H/^"57* � ð #�eH',k03.1.�69E�>O= Ë :�Xpó@X1ð�Å Õ A�B�0GA U Ê 512c0 Ò ;Oؽ,/Z�ETKLH3N�03*;^OU � 512v0 Ò �3ؽ,/Z�ETKLH3X Ì HeÏ;E�2TAcC�Z�AvA4>O:OH'A�B;H'E\24>O=<H

H/.7H/=?H/*LA[0GE48`>3]�24HJE4K30GA451>O*;2/Xoàä � � 572 /�Z;24B�03*;^�o�����ä � 572u.VAu]�8 Ë :�X .;X � Õ X

����� 5 �¿���Í����� Á ­;¤¿¸k¬�Â�Â1¬�ûy´»¼@Èa­;¬�Â7¹ �Ë ð Õ �Ö´�ªº©3« ¯ Â1¤g©3¼±¹ ���� -éÒ ð ÀË ó Õ � ³[¬�¼W¥½©G´»¼;ª#¤��s©s³J¥®Â ·?¥®­ ° ¤¨¤Mª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ª/ÀË ï Õ Á ­;¤ ° ¤Ô´�ª#©<ª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|·`¬I¸Ô´�¼±¹s¤���©G¥¿Â1¤�©�ª¨¥±¸k¬Gù ° ©GÂ1¬�¼@È �<ÀË . Õ � Ã�ó �3ï , � Ê Ãéð��Oó À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Ë ð Õ 6�>O.7.1>�be2/N�2457*;,/HPo�� � � � ��Å�X�SH �@AºbcH`,/>O*;2457^;H'E Ë ó Õ XqíS2 � 572U*;>3AU0"A�57:OH'EkN � =UZ;2IAg,/>O*�A�0351*�0GAg.1Hk032TAgA�B�E4H/H`2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2/N�]�8

03^�FIZ;*;,'A�57>O*�X +@Z�C;C(>O2THD5VA#,/>O*LA[0351*;2º0GA#.1Hk032IAE.;X +@57*;,/H UÄ,k03*Í,/>O*LA[0351*j0GA#=<>O2TAPA�B�E4H/H3Ny03*;^ÍA�B;H_>O*;.7803^;^;57A451>O*�03.±2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457Aw8<,/03*`]±Hã0GA � Ê N@bvHS,/>O*;,/.1Z;^;H�� 3 512\0º*;>O*@ض,[B�0351*D2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8LN � U 572c0º24=?>s>3A�BC(>O57*�A/N�03*;^ÍA�B;H'E�H_0GE4H_H ��03,'A4.78Ð6�>OZ�Eg2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A451H/2#03.7>O*;: � X8$c8¾03^�FIZ;*;,'A�57>O*�>O*;H<B�032º51*;^;H �m0GAº.1H/032TAA�B�E�H'H3X

� 3 - ð��Oóã]s8 Ë ð�Å�X1ð Õ X � Ê - ó �3ï � Ë 2451*;,'HeA�B;H'E�Hu512¿0P2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8<03.1>O*;: � >O6�51*;^;H �?0GAv.7Hk032TA�A�B�E�H/H Õ Ns]�8Ë :�Xæï�X : Õ X )+6 � 3 - ó �3ï�NsA4B;H/* � � ä�ï � � Ã�ó@X�)+6 � 3 ��ó �3ï�NsA�B;H'*�� 3 512v:O5VKLH/*_]s8 Ë ð�Å�X7ðOXæ^ Õ Ns03*;^ � ,/>O*�A�0351*;20_*;>O*@Ø ãZ Hv03.�2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457Aw8LN±24> � 3 - � Ê - ð��Oó?]�8 Ë :�XæÅ�X � Õ X Y B�Z;2Ô03:L0357* � � ä ï � � à ó@XS)+*qCW0GETA�51,/Z;.10GE� � ä � � ÃéðOX� >O*;2451^;H'ERA�B;HÔ*;H ��Au2TA�H'C�>O6 A�B;HMBsZ;*LA�/�A�B;HÔC±>O242457]�57.15VA�51H/2u0GE�HM:O57KLH/*D]s8 Ë :�X .;X � Õ X+@Z�C;C(>O2TH � � 572v0P*;HJAkX � 512�*;>3A¿Ï;];E[03.�]s8 Ë ðOðOX � X � Õ X � ä U�B�032v^;H/:3E�H'HS0GA¿.7Hk032TA�A�B�E�H/H3Ns6�>3Ec>3A�B;H'ETbe5724H

Ò Ë o��Dä � ä U Õ 512R*;H/6y03*;^-bvHPB�0kKLHº0UA451:OH'EkX +@51*;,/H � � ähï � � Ãtó@N�5VAe6�>O.7.1>�be2\A�B�0GA�>O*;HÔ>O6 � >3E U 5720g24H/,'A�57>O*�NW03*;^�A�B;Hã>3A�B;H'Eu512R0g^;>OZ�]�.1HM24H/,'A451>O*�X Y B;572u,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�2 Ë ðOðOX � X7ðOðOX ó Õ X Y B�Z;2 R � 512c]�57E[0GA451>O*�03.|XY B;HRC±>O242457]�57.15VA�51H/2å6�>3E Ë ' � ��� � ä � � Õ 0GE�HR:O57KLH/*U]s8 Ë :�X .;X � Õ X � � =gZ;2TA¿,'>O*�A[0357*_0GAå.1Hk032IA¿Awbc>P2T51*;:OZ;.90GEIØ

57A451H/2/X Y B�Z;2 � 572u*;>3Ae24=?>s>3A�B�N�]s8 Ë ð�ï�X7ð Õ XyöSH/*;,/HPbcHÔB�0�KLHP0a6�H/*;,'H3X � � ,/>O*LA[0357*;2uA�B�E�H'Hº2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A451H/2/NA�B�Z;2c]s8 Ë ð�ï�Xpï Õ N ' � ß ' Ë � Ê ä � � ä ���/Õ N � Ü ' 3� N � B�032R0GE�5VA�B;=?H'A451,e:OH'*sZ;2R>O*;H3N;03*;^�0º2451=aC�.1HS*;>@^;HGN03*;^ � � ßÝðOX $v8 Ë ðOðOX7ðOX1ð Õ N � � 572u24=<>@>3A�B�03.1>O*;: � á � � U � NW03*;^ � � 572e03* ��� C(>O57*�A/N�03*;^

ðeß � �� ß =Rätð Ò � �

Y BsZ;2 =tß �WX � Ê ß Ë � ��� � Õ X ' Ê 572-24=<>@>3A�Bt0�b\0k8ë69E�>O= � Ê Nã03*;^é5VA�2D2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2�0GE4H¾H �;03,'A�.78� Ê ��� Ê ��� � ����� X ' Ê ,k03*;*;>3Ag](H8(M>3E�H'*;2TA�H/57* Ë 2457*;,/H �' Ê B�032 ��51,k0GE�^j*�Z;=g]±H'Ea0GAg.1Hk032IAa*;57*;H Õ X � *;HD>O6A�B;HÔ2451*;:OZ;.10GEeC(>O57*�A42e512 � Ê X Y B;512u,k03*;*;>3Ae]±H � Ê Ë >3E � 3 B�032R];E[03*;,[B;H/2S>O6�51*;^;HG� Ë ó � ï � õ ÕTÕ X Y B�Z;2 � Ê B�032

Page 123: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � .$)0�

51*;^;HG�j0GA#=?>O2TAÔÏ;KLH3NyH/57A4B;H'E � Ê ß Ë ï Õ N � Ê ß Ë . Õ >3E � Ê ß Ë ï � ó Õ X Y B;512#,'>O*�A4E�03^;51,'A�2#>OZ�EgHG��C;E�H/2T2451>O*� Ê ß Ë � ��� � Õ XåöSH/*;,/H Ë ó Õ X

Ë ï Õ 6�>O.1.7>%bu2R51=?=?H'^;590GA�H/.V8?69E�>O= Ë ó Õ 03*;^�03^�FIZ;*;,'A451>O*�X�S>�b bcHÔC;E4>%KLH Ë . Õ X Y B;HÔ24H/,/>O*;^-51*;H/rsZ�03.157Aw8D6�>O.1.7>%bu2R69E�>O=àA�B;HÔÏ;E�2IAkNW03*;^ Ë ï Õ ]s8 Ë :�Xæï�X : Õ X+@Z�C;C(>O2THuÏ;E�2TA � 3 512�0Ô,[B�0357*<2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8LX Y B;H/* =?H/H'A�2 � 0GAv0ã24=?>s>3A�BUC±>O51*LAv03*;^ � Ê 572¿0M2451*;:OZ;.10GE

C(>O57*�A/X Y B;Hº,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA451>O*">O* � 512e>O6�6�>3E4= Ë � � Õ >O6 Ë ðOðOX . Õ X Y B;HJE�H#512S0aZ;*;51r@Z;H#2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457Aw8LN � N(03.7>O*;: N±03*;^"o���ä 512e.VAkX ; - ï�N±24><A4B;Hº24H/.761ؽ51*LA�H'E424H/,'A�57>O*q>O6 UÚ:O>@H/2uZ�C"]s8�0GA�.7Hk032TAeAwbc>;N±03*;^�A�B�Z;2 � 572>O6�A�B;H#6�>3E�= Ë ó 8 � $ � � � �IÕ Ë 6�>3Eã24>O=?H $ - ï Õ buB;H'E�H � Ê B�032�Aw8@C(H Ë $ Ò ð � � � �TÕ X?#�H'A �D](HºA�B;H#,'>@H�!<,/51H/*LA>O6�A�B;H Ò $ ض,/Z�E4KLH3X Y B;H/*"A�B;H#=_0GETQLH/^ Ò ó%ض,/Z�E4KLHgB�032S,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LA � �Oó@N�03*;^ � ä � �Oó#ß ðOX�o���ä � UÚ572/�Z;24B�]�8 Ë :�X .;X � Õ N@A�B�Z;2 � à �±N;24> � Ãëó �3ï�X

�S>�b×032424Z;=?H�� 3 572<*;>3A?0¾,[B�0351*h2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8LNc03*;^ � 3 �Äó �3ï�X Y B;H/*h]�8 Ë ð�Å�X7ðOX1ðOX}^ Õ NåAwbc>¾>O6�A�B;H2457*;:OZ;.90GERC(>O51*LA�2u03.1>O*;:)U 0GE�HM51*;^;HG�-Awbc>;N U 512u0 Ò ó%ؽ,/Z�ETKLH3N±03*;^ � ßÝð��Oó@X Ì HÔ=_0k8D032424Z;=<H � U 572>O*;HU>O6åA�B;H Ë ó Õ C(>O57*�A42/N�6�>3EP>3A�B;HJE4be5724H#A�B;HU51*;^;51,'H/2P03.7>O*;: � 0GE�H Ë ó � ó � n Õ 6�>3EP2T>O=?H#niN 03*;^ibvHaB�0kKLH0?A�51:OHJES]s8q03^�FIZ;*;,JA�51>O*�X Y B;Hg,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E�0GA�51>O*Ð>O* � 512 Ë � � � Ñ Õ >O6 Ë ðOðOX . Õ N±6�>3EM24>O=?H $ - ð Ë 51*q*;>�>3A4B;H'E,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA451>O*D^;>@H/2 =<H/H'A%U 0GAR03* � Ê C±>O51*LA Õ X Y B;HJE�Hã512c>O*;Hã2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8 � 03.1>O*;: á � � X2# H'A �](HÔA�B;HP,/>sH�!?,'51H/*LAS>O6 A�B;HP,/Z�E4KLHº>�KLH'E � buB;51,[B"=?H/H'A42 X Ì HPB�0kKLH � �OóRä �?ß�ðOXcí�E�:OZ;51*;:_032R](H/6�>3E4H3N� Ã�ó �3ï�XåöSH/*;,/H Ë . Õ X �ãH'Ï�*;H � ÃÄž24>iA�B�0GA?o����\ä � � 572?*�Z;=?H'E�57,k03.1.V8jATE�57K@5903.|X�o����Rä � � 5120/�Z;24Bâ]s8 Ë :�Xæï�X ó@X1ð Õ 03*;^

Ë :�Xæï�X � X ó Õ X������( �¿�@�Í������.Wù ¯�¯ ¬%ªk¤ � ´�ªa© Ë � Ò ó Õ'ú4³Jù ° µ3¤0,e©G¼(¹ � ­�©�ª<¬�¼W ·��Ôù ��©G ª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ªa©GÂ1¬�¼@È �<À � ¸� ß Ë o��ºä �MÕ�� � ,奮­;¤J¼

Ë ð Õ � ß � � Ë � ä �[Õ-, � ß � Ë ð Ò � Õ � � ß � � Ò �Ë ó Õ ' Ê ´�ªÔ¼(¬�¥���¬ ° ¤J¼;ª¨¥+¤J´�¼(À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Ì HPB�0kKLH

ÅÔß Ë o��#ä � �MÕ�� � ßto�� � � ä � � �

ß Ò � ä � Ë � ä �[Õ ß Ò � ä � � ä � �

Ë ð Õ 6�>O.1.7>%bu2/X+@Z�C;C(>O2TH ' Ê 512E(ã>3E�H/*;2TA4H/51*�X8$v8 Ë ð :�Xpó@X ó Õ N � ,/>O*LA[0357*;2PA�B�E�H/H MZ H¿03.å,¨B�0357*Í2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A451H/2/N 2�0k8�>O6

51*;^;HG� $ ätðON SäëðON1=RäëðOX $v8�03^�FIZ;*;,'A�57>O*$$ ätð ä

Säëð ä=

=Räëð Ã�ó �

� *;H_,¨B;H',[Q@2º69E�>O= A�B;H?.1572TA Ë ï�X1ð Õ A�B�0GAº*;>�E[03*�Qi>O*;HO(ã>3E�H/*;2TA�H'51*Í.1>O:-^;H/.@��H����/>",/>O*LA[0351*;2ÔA�B�E�H/H?2TZ;,¨B2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2'X �

Page 124: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

.$) � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

A � À �>D ¤'«<© ° F À +@57*;,/H � Ê ä � Ê ÃéðON�]�8 Ë :�X .;X � Õ >O*;HÔ>O6 A4B;HÔ6�>O.7.1>�be57*;:<>@,',/Z�E�2/XË 0 Õ Ë ' � ��� � ä � � Õ 512u0UA[03,'*;>@^;H3XË ] Õ ' � 572e0U6�H/*;,/H3XË , Õ ' � 572e0g]W03*�03*�0�XË ^ Õ � 512R,/>O*�ATE[03,'A�H/^�N�A�B�0GAu512 � ß � XË H Õ � � 512u0a*;HJAkX

,WZ�E4A�B;H'E�=<>3E�Hão�� ä! 8 572 /�Z;2TB�N(03*;^-o�� ä � � � � ä � � � � 512%/�Z;24B"51*�,k0324H/2 Ë 0�ؽ, Õ X����� � �¿���Í����� � A � À � À�© � ¼(¤'µ3¤ ° ­�¬�Â7¹�ª/À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ +@Z�C;C±>O24H Ë ð :�X .;Xp0 Õ B;>O.1^;2/X2$v8 Ë ðOðOX7ðOX1ð Õ A�B;H\,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E�0GA�51>O*a>O* � � 572yAw8sC(H ��� NL03*;^_ó � � ä`ï � � � ï�X

+@Z�C;C(>O2TH ' Ê B�032e0a*;>O* ãZ8H¿03. ��>O51*LAS03.7>O*;: � X Y B;H/*-]�8 Ë :�Xpï�X : Õ

� � à � Ê - Ë ð��'= Õ ä Ë = Ò ó �'= Õ Ë ó �3ï Õ

03*;^ =#Ã�ó@N;buB;H'E�H =g572RA�B;HÔ51*;^;H ��>O6 A4B;512\C(>O51*LAkX Y B�Z;2

ó � � ä�ï � � Ãëó Ë ó �3ï Õ ä Ë ó'= Ò ð Õ �'=Mßéóuä . �3ï Ò ð��'= - ï �

0a,'>O*�A4E�03^;51,'A�57>O*�X+@> ' Ê 572�ãZ�Hv03.�03.7>O*;: � X�#�H'A � ß � Ë U � � o�����ä � �MÕ X Y B;H/* � à � à � Ê N�03*;^�o�� ä � � ä � U 572

R � ضA4E457K�5103.|N�2T>?ó � ämï � � ïg032\51* Ë ðOðOX7ðOX1ðOX ó Õ X Y B�Z;2 � � ï �'.U]�8 Ë ð :�Xpó@X . Õ X $v8 Ë ð :�Xæï�X1ð Õ N � à � �3ï - ð��3ï�Xí�C;C�.78@51*;:"A�B;H�$c>O:O>O=?>O.1>�Kq](>OZ;*;^�NybcH`^;H/^;Z;,/H`A�B�0GAgH/5VA�B;H'E ' Ê 572#24=?>s>3A�Bm0�bc0�8Í69E4>O= � Nå>3Eg5VAgB�032H �;03,'A�.78a>O*;HS2457*;:OZ;.90GEvC±>O51*LA\0�bc0�8<69E�>O= � N@0PC(>O51*LAc>O6�51*;^;HG�Dó Ë A�B;He,/>O*�ATE�57]�Z�A�57>O*_A�>ºA�B;H�24Z;= 51* Ë # Xpó Õ6�>3E#A�B;H?2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457A�57H/2#0kb\0�8¾69E�>O= � 572º.1H/2T2ºA�B�03*�ó �3ï Õ X>$cZ�AºA4B;H/* ' Ê 572 (M>3E4H/*;2TA�H/57*�Ny,/>O*�ATE[03^;51,'A451*;:Ë ð :�Xæï�X ó Õ X ������ � �¿���Í����� � A � À � À�§ � ¹�¬%¤¨ªM¼(¬�¥�­;¬�Â7¹�À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ +@Z�C;C±>O24H Ë ð :�X .;Xò] Õ B;>O.1^;2/X $v8 Ë ð�ï�Xæï Õ N � � 512g2451*;:OZ;.10GEkNå03*;^ � � 572g0 Ò ð'ؽ,'Z�E4KLH3X +@57*;,/H � � 5722457*;:OZ;.90GEkN � Ê � � Ê X $v8 Ë :�XpÅ�X � X1ð Õ 03*;^ Ë :�XæÅ�X . Õ N�A4B;H'E�HP572e0GAu=?>O2TAR>O*;HÔ2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8D>O6 ' � 03.7>O*;: � � X $c8Ë ð�ï�X . Õ 03*;^ Ë ð :�X ó@X . Õ N�516 � B�032R:OH/*sZ;2e>O*;H3N;A�B;H/* � B�032u0<*;>s^;H3X

+@Z�C;C(>O2TH � � .151H'2#51*�A�B;H ãZ Hv03.å.1>s,/Z;2/X Y B;H/* Ë o ä �aÕ�� � � ß×Å�N�24> � Ü ' 3� N � B�032#0":OH/*�Z;2>O*;H3N 03*;^ ' � 512�(M>3E�H'*;2TA�H/57*�X $c8 Ë ðOðOX1ðOX1ð Õ bcHaB�0kKLHa0D,/>O*LA4E[03,JA�51>O*i>O6åAw8@C±H Ë )4)¨N � � � Ê¨Õ XPíS2 ' Ê 512ã*;>3A(M>3E4H/*;2TA�H/57*�N±]�8 Ë ð :�Xæï�X ó Õ N�� Ê B�032�A+8sC(H Ë � �����/Õ N � - ï�NWbeB;57,¨BqB�032�2IC(H/,'ATE[03. KG03.1Z;H#0GAS.7Hk032TA =�ätðOX $c8Ë :�XæÅ�X � Õ A�B;572e,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�2 Ë ðOðOX1ðOX1ðOXæï Õ XY BsZ;2�bcHR=_0k8#032424Z;=<H � � B�032å0GAy.1H/032TAy>O*;Hu*;>O* ãZ0H¿03.sC±>O51*LA�03.1>O*;:ã57AkX Y B�Z;2 � Ê Ãéð��Oó�]�8 Ë :�XæÅ�X � Õ X

)+6 � B�032S:OH/*sZ;2S>O*;HGN�A�B;H/*q5VASB�032S0?*;>@^;Hg03*;^"^;>sH/2S*;>3AS.751HP57*�A�B;H#24=?>s>3A�B�.7>@,/Z;2 Ë >3E ' � 512 ãZ H¿03. Õ XY BsZ;2 � =?H/H'A�2 UÚ0GAR24=<>@>3A�B`C(>O57*�A�2'N�03*;^�bcHPB�0kKLHº0U*;>@^;HM>O6 Aw8@C(Hã)¨X Y B;572u,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�2 Ë ðOðOX1ðOX7ðOX1ð Õ X

Page 125: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � .$) �

Y BsZ;2MA�B;Ha:OH'*sZ;2Ô>O6 � 572 � - ó@X0$v8 Ë ðOðOX7ðOX1ðOX � Õ 03*;^ Ë ðOðOX1ðOX7ðOX1ð%ó Õ N(03*;^ Ë :�XæÅ�X � Õ A�B;Ha2TC(H/,JA4E[03.�K303.7Z;H>O6 ! Ê 512#0GAÔ=?>O2TAÔ>O*;H3X Y BsZ;2P]�8 Ë :�XpÅ�X1: Õ N � Ê B�032 ãZ Hv03.y>3Eº03.1=?>O2TA ãZ H¿03.yC±>O51*LA�2#03.7>O*;:-57A/X Ì H,/>O*;2457^;H'EeA4B;HÔC(>O2T2457]�.7HÔAw8@C±H/2u>O6 ,/>O*LA4E[03,'A�57>O*�N�24H/H Ë ðOðOX7ð Õ 03*;^ Ë ðOðOXpó Õ X

$v8 Ë ð :�X ó@X . Õ N � Ê Ã×ð��Oó@N�24>�bcH_,k03*;*;>3A#B�0kKLH`0�,/>O*LA4E[03,'A451>O*m>O6vAw8@C(H?)¨X�+@Z�C;C(>O24H?bcH_B�0kKLH_>O*;H_>O6Aw8@C±HM)4)¨X Y B;H/*

� Ê � � � �Ë �Mätð Õ � Ë ó �ãä�ð Õ � ó �3ï

03*;^�24>DA�B;HaC±>O51*LAÔbvHa]�.1HJb Z�CÍ=gZ;2TAÔ]±H<03* ��� Ê Ë >3A�B;H'E4bu512TH � Ê B�032Ô2TC(H/,JA4E[03.�K303.7Z;H?0GAÔ.1Hk032IAÔAwbc> Õ X

$cZ�A � B�032g0"2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8¾bu57A4Bj2IC(H/,'ATE[03.¿KG03.1Z;H_>O*;H3X4+@57*;,/H_bcH_2TA�57.1.¿^;H',/51^;H/^mA�>�]�.7>%b Z�C�A�B;H ��� Ê

C(>O57*�A/N�bvHÔB�0kKLHÔA�B�0GA � 512u0GAe.7Hk032TARA�B;HM24>O.1Z�A�57>O*�A�>UA�B;HP6�>O.7.1>�be57*;:aH'r@Z�0GA�57>O*-51*��

ð��3ïeä � �3ïPß � Ë �ãäëð Õ � Ë �ãähó Õ �

Y BsZ;2 � - Ë �Mäâó Õ � Ë ó �ãätð Õ 03*;^ � Ê - Ë �Mätð Õ � Ë ó �Sätð Õ N�0U,/>O*�ATE[03^;51,'A451>O*�X)wA�6�>O.7.1>�be2R]s8 Ë ðOðOX1ðOX7ð Õ A4B�0GA � � B�032S0aZ;*;57];E[03*;,[Bq2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8LX �S>�bçA+8sC(HM)4)4)\512u51=<C±>O24245V]�.1H3N�032 ' Ê

bc>OZ;.7^-K�57>O.90GA�H�A�B;H $c>O:O>O=?>O.1>�K<]±>OZ;*;^ Ë # X ó Õ XY B;512R>O*;.78D.1Hk0kKLH/2\Aw8@C(H'2��q03*;^ WX)+*"A+8sC(H ��N � Ê ß Ë � � ó � ó Õ N�03*;^qA�B;H'E�H#572S51*Ð03^;^;57A�57>O*Ð0_C±>O51*LA Ë . � ó Õ Ë 51*;^;H � � Õ 0�b\0k8"69E�>O= � Ê X $c8

2TC±H/,'A4E[03.�KG03.1Z;H3N Ë :�XæÅ�X : Õ N �ºßéó@X)+*�Aw8@C±H ?A4B;H'E�HP572e0 Ë ó � ï � ó � ó Õ C±>O51*LA Ë 57*;^;H �¾ðOð Õ 0kb\0k8D69E�>O= � Ê X�S>�bé,/>O*;2457^;H'EuA4B;HMC±>O242457]�.7HÔ57*;^;51,/H'2u>O6�A�B;Hã2451*;:OZ;.10GEuC±>O51*LA�2R03.1>O*;: � Ê X@#�H'AyÎ-]±HMA4B;HÔ.10GE�:OH/2TAR51*;^;HG�

>O6y0?*;>O* ãZ Hv03.�C(>O57*�A�03.1>O*;: � � Ë bcHºB�0kKLH#03.7E�H/03^�8-*;>3A�H'^qA4B;H'E�Hº572S0GA�.7Hk032TAS>O*;Hº*;>O* ãZ H¿03.�C±>O51*LA03.1>O*;: � � Õ N(.1HJA � ]±HºA�B;H#51*;^;H �">O6�A�B;H#>3A�B;H'ESC±>O51*LAS>O* � � X $v8 Ë :�Xpï�X : Õ A�B;H#51*;^;HG�">O6 � Ê 572ã0GAS.1H/032TA¿ÎË >3ERA�B;HMBsZ;*LA�bc>OZ;.7^-*;>3A�,[B;>s>O24H � Ê Õ X

+@Z�C;C(>O2TH � 572R0GA\.1Hk032TAcA4B�E�H/H3X Y B;H'*�bcHãB�0kKLHM6�>OZ�ER2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2c>O6 57*;^;H ��0GA\.1Hk032IAcA�B�E�H/Hã>O* ' Ê 03*;^24>_bcHg=_0k8�Z;24H#A�B;H#.7512TA Ë ð�Å�X � Õ X +@57*;,/H#bcHgB�0�KLHU0?C(>O57*�Aã>3è � Ê >O6�57*;^;H �Ð0GAã.1H/032TA � N(57Aã6�>O.7.1>�be2S69E4>O=A�B;HM.1572TA\A�B�0GA�Î"03*;^ � ]±>3A�BDB�0�KLHM51*;^;H ��H �;03,'A�.V8?A�B�E�H/HGX $cZ�A\A�B;H/*�2T51*;,/H � � 572R0 Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�ETKLH3N ���� � Å�N�0,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�51>O*�XY BsZ;2 � B�032Ô57*;^;H �ÐA+bv>;XºíS2 � � 512ã*;>3AÔ,/>O*LA4E[03,'A�5V]�.1H3N�Î�N 03*;^¾B;H/*;,'H�� Ê N B�0kKLHU51*;^;H �i0GAÔ.1Hk032IAMÏ;KLHGX

Y BsZ;2ebvHPB�0kKLHP,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA451>O* � Ë 57* ?A�B;HÔ51*;^;H �->O6 � Ê 512R6�>OZ�E Õ 03*;^ ' Ê B�032e2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2u>O6�57*;^;H �-0GA.1H/032TASó � � � � � ðOðON�beB;57,[B-K�57>O.90GA�H/2 Ë # Xpó Õ X ������ � �¿���Í������Ö´�ªM¼(¬G¥R³¨¬�¼�¥ ° ©�³J¥+¤�¹LÀ* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ +@Z�C;C±>O24H � 512R,/>O*�ATE[03,'A�H/^�NW51*�>3A�B;H'Eubc>3E�^;2 � ß � X

$v8 Ë :�Xæï�X1ðOXpó Õ 03*;^ Ë :�Xpï�X � X7ð Õ N � � 572\0U2T=?>@>3A�B?C±>O51*LAR>O6 ' � N � � B�032R0gZ;*;5V];E[03*;,[B-2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8`03*;^ �512vA4B;HS>O*;.78?^;5VK�5724>3EcbeB;>O2THS,/>@H�!<,/51H'*�AR51*`o�� ä � � 572c:3E�Hk0GA�HJEcA�B�03* � X �S>%b � ,/03*;*;>3Ac](HS51*_A�B;H ãZH¿03.�.1>@,'Z;2/N�>3E � � bv>OZ;.1^�]±HP24=<>@>3A�B�X Y BsZ;2 � Ê Ãéð��Oó@X

Page 126: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

.$) � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

+@Z�C;C(>O2TH � � B�032-0mA4E�57C�.7H"C(>O51*LAkX �S>3A�H"A�B�0GA`A�B;HqÏ;E�2TADH ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.ã^;57K�5724>3ED.78@51*;:m>%KLHJE � � B�032,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LAãï � Ò ðãß Ë ó � Ò ð Õ ä � à � X Y B�Z;2 � =gZ;2TAR](HÔA4B;512e^;5VK�5724>3EkN�03*;^�51*-CW0GETA�51,/Z;.10GE � .751H/2u51*A�B;HÔ24=?>@>3A4B�.7>@,/Z;2/NW0U,/>O*�ATE[03^;51,'A451>O*�XY BsZ;2 � � B�032U=UZ;.VA�57C�.751,/5VAw8�Awbc>�0GA � � X +@51*;,/H � � B�032aH �;03,'A�.V8ÍA+bv>¾2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2U03.7>O*;: � Nv03*;^

=?H/HJA�2 U � 0GAe0a24=<>@>3A�B`C(>O57*�AkN;bcHÔ=gZ;2TARB�0�KLHMA+8sC(Hã)4)4)c>O6 Ë ðOðOX ó Õ X+@Z�C;C(>O2TH � - ó@X Y B;H/* � à ó �3ï�N¿2T51*;,/H � Ê B�032U2TC(H','A4E[03.cKG03.1Z;H�0GAU.7Hk032TAUA+bv>;X $cZ�Aa516RbcHD]�.7>%b

Z�C � � A+bu51,'HgA4B;H/*ÐA4B;HºE�H/24Z;.VA�51*;:DH �;,'H'C;A�51>O*�03. ^;57K�5724>3EkN±buB;51,[BÐ512S*;>3A � N�B�032S,/>@H !?,/57H/*�APó Ë ó � Ò ð Õ ß� ä Ë ï � Ò ó Õ Ã � N�0U,/>O*LA4E[03^;51,JA�51>O*�XY BsZ;2 �aßÝðOX ���;03,'A�.V8U032å57*aA�B;H\C;E�>s>O6±>O6 Ë ð�õ�Xpï�X1ð Õ N3bcHu2TH/HuA�B�0GA ' B�032�0ãA451:OH'EkNs0ã,/>O*�ATE[03^;51,'A451>O*�X �

����� � �¿���Í����� R � ´�ªÔ¼(¬�¥R©<¼(¤J¥wÀ

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ +@Z�C;C±>O24H R � 572e0U*;H'AkX�# H'A �<](HãA�B;HP^;H':3E�H/HP>O6 U � >�KLH'E É�Ê X+@Z�C;C(>O2TH � 572º0`Ï;];E�H<>O6 R � X �ià ó Ë >3EMo�� ä � ä�U � 512P03*�A�5Ûؽ*;H/6 Õ 03*;^�2T> � Ê � ó �3ï�X Y B�Z;2 �

03*;^ U B�0kKLH?2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2P>O6c2TC±H/,'A4E[03.yKG03.1Z;H?0GAP=?>O2TAÔ>O*;H3X � ,/>O*LA[0351*;2ÔA+bv>�2451*;:OZ;.10GEPC±>O51*LA�2º>O6 � � X+@51*;,'H � Ê - ð��Oó@N �"ßàï�X?)wAº6�>O.7.1>�be2MA�B�0GA � 512º:O5VKLH/*¾]�8 Ë ðOðOX � X # X � Õ bu57A4B ;ÐßÖó@X Y BsZ;2P]�8 Ë ð :�X ó@Xpï Õ� Ê B�032_51*;^;H �â0GA?.7Hk032TA .;X +@51*;,'H�A�B;H�2TC±H/,'A4E[03.RK303.7Z;H�512?0GA_=?>O2TA�ðON U =gZ;2TA<]±H"0 Ò ó%ض,/Z�E4KLH3NR03*;^,/>O*LA[0351*�0qZ;*;51r@Z;HD2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8 ��N¿H/5VA�B;H'E ãZ H¿03.v>3Ea03.1=?>O2TA MZ-Hv03.®X #�H'A �c~ �� � Ò�Ó � ](H�0Ðo��E�H/.10GA�57KLHg=?57*;51=_03.�=?>s^;H/.|N�03*Ð5124>O=<>3E4C�B;5124= 0GAãA�B;Hg:OH/*;HJE�51,gC(>O57*�AM>O6�A4B;H Ò ï�ؽ,/Z�ETKLHa=?H'H'A�51*;: � X �Ð572^;H'A�HJE�=?51*;H'^�]s8i24H/.7H/,'A�57*;:�beB;57,¨B�E4H/^;Z;,/H/^j,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*�AP>O6cHk03,[BÍ=gZ;.7A�5VC�.1HaÏ;];E4H<](H/,'>O=?H/2PA�B;HUÏ;];E�H_>O6� N�24H'H Ë ðOðOX � X � Õ X

� 03*;^ � N±A�B;H#Ï;];E�H#A�B�E4>OZ;:OB ��N�0GE4HºA�B;Hg>O*;.78�=gZ;.VA�57C�.7HPÏ;];E�H/2/~ U ÒWÓ É�Ê 572S*;H/,/H/2T2�0GE�51.V8�E[03=?5VÏ�H/^>�KLH'E#A�B;H_51=?03:OH?>O6R03*�8Í=gZ;.VA�57C�.7H<Ï;];E�H3Nå51*�CW0GE4A451,/Z;.10GEg57A#572ºE[03=?57Ï�H'^�0GA ��N¿03*;^ÍA�>3A[03.7.78ÐE[03=?5VÏ�H/^m0GAU � � Xy)+6 A�B;H'E4HÔbcH'E4HP03*;>3A�B;HJE�=gZ;.7A�5VC�.1HSÏ;];E�H3N;A�B;H'*�57ARbc>OZ;.1^�=?H/H'A U 0GA�0U24=?>s>3A�BDC±>O51*LAkN�03*;^�24>)Ubc>OZ;.7^-](HãA�>3A[03.7.78?E[03=<57Ï�H/^DA�B;H'E�HP032RbcH'.1.|NW0U,/>O*�ATE[03^;51,'A451>O*�XÌ HR,/>O*;2457^;H'Ev57*aA�Z�E�*aA�B;HRAwbc>MC(>O242T57]�51.757A�57H/2/NLH/5VA�B;H'E U =?H/HJA�2 � >O*;.V8<0GA ��Ns>3E¿0GA �º03*;^<03.124>P0GA¿24>O=<H

24=?>s>3A�B`C(>O51*LA � X)+*�A�B;HDÏ;E�2TA_,k032TH>U =?H'H'A�2a0¾,/Z�E4KLH�>�KLH'E ��>O6�=gZ;.7A�5VC�.151,'57Aw8jï¾51*�A�B;H�Ï;];E�HGX�,�E�>O= Ë ðOðOX � X # Õ A�B;H

C(>O2T2457]�57.157A451H/2M6�>3E � 0GE�H Ë�� Õ N�be5VA�B-;"ß ï�N�>3E Ë õ Õ X � B;>s>O24H �Ð]�8i2TH/.1H/,JA�51*;:�57*iA�B;HUÏ;E�2TAP,k0324HaA4B;H Ò .GØ,/Z�E4KLHGN\03*;^â51*�A�B;H�24H/,/>O*;^hA4B;H Ò ï�ض,/Z�E4KLH�>�KLH'E ��X Y B;H/* � Ë U Õ Ü � 572?0¾2T=?>@>3A�BmE[0GA�57>O*�03.cA4E�57C�.7H24H/,JA�51>O*�NW03*;^ � Ë U Õ � ß .;N;,/>O*LA4E[03^;51,JA�51*;: Ë ðOðOX � X1ð�Å Õ X)+*UA4B;Hu24H',/>O*;^<,k032TH3Ns*;H',/H/242�0GE451.78Un Ë �ºÕ ßéó@X Y B;HR>O*;.V8#C(>O242T57]�51.757Aw8#572 Ë ðOðOX � X # X7ð Õ Ë 57* Ë�� Õ bu57A�B ;#ß ðON

� Ê B�032M51*;^;H �iï Õ X � B;>s>O24H �"]s8Ð24H'.1H/,'A451*;:`A�B;H Ò ó%ؽ,'Z�E4KLH<=?H'H'A�51*;:OU 0GA � X � Ë U Õ Ü � 512M0`24=?>s>3A�BA4E�5VC�.1HM24H/,'A451>O*�>O6 24H/.161ض51*LA�H'E�2TH/,'A�57>O* .;NW,'>O*�A4E�03^;51,'A�57*;: Ë ðOðOX � X1ð�Å Õ XY BsZ;2 � ^;>O=?57*�0GA�H/2 É Ê X2#�H'A � ]±H�A�B;HS^;H/:3E�H'HS>O6 � >�KLH'E É Ê X �vä � Ã�ó Ë >3A�B;H'E4bu5124HSo�� ä � ä U 572

03*LA�5Vض*;H/6y03*;^-bcHÔB�0�KLHP0aA�51:OHJE Õ X@$c8 Ë ð :�Xpó@X . Õ N;>O*;HÔ>O6�U >3E � 572e0<2TH/,'A�57>O*"03*;^-A�B;HÔ>3A�B;H'E�572�0U^;>OZ�]�.1H

Page 127: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � .$)�2

24H/,JA�51>O*�X Y B�Z;2 � Ê � � ]�8 Ë ðOðOX � X1ðOðOXpó Õ X Y B;HP2TC±H/,'A4E[03.�KG03.1Z;HM>O6 � Ê 512RH/5VA�B;H'Eu>O*;HP>3E �/H'E�>;X+@Z�C;C(>O2TH?UÝ572¿0P2TH/,'A�57>O*�X��¿03,[B?2451*;:OZ;.10GE�C±>O51*LAv>O6 � .157H/2¿>O*<0P^;57è±H'E�H/*LAc=gZ;.7A�5VC�.1HcÏ;];E�H3N�]s8 Ë ðOðOX � X � Õ N

2457*;,/H_Hk03,[BÍ=gZ;2TA#=?H/HJA UÄ0GAº0�2451*;:OZ;.10GEºC(>O57*�AkX Y BsZ;2ºA4B;H'E�H`0GE�H_0GAP.1Hk032IAºAwbc>�=gZ;.7A�5VC�.1HUÏ;];E�H/2/Ny03*;^24>-0GAP.7Hk032TAMA+bv>�2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A451H/2Ô03.1>O*;:8U_N 0D,/>O*LA4E[03^;51,JA�51>O*�X Y B�Z;2 � 512Ô0-24H/,'A451>O*�N 03*;^ U 572P0D^;>OZ�]�.1H24H/,JA�51>O*�X Y B;HJE�Hº0GE�HÔH ��03,JA�.78_Awbc>a=UZ;.VA�57C�.7HSÏ;];E�H/2e]�8 Ë ðOðOX � X7ðOðOX1ð Õ X

+@Z�C;C(>O2TH�UÄÜ � 3 X Y B;H'* U 572P0 Ò ï�ض,/Z�E4KLH Ë ]s8Ð2TC±H/,'A4E[03.�KG03.1Z;H � � ï�N 03*;^iA�B;HaB�Z;*LAºbc>OZ;.1^i*;>3A,[B;>@>O24HM03* � Ê C(>O51*LAR032cA�B;H'E�Hã572\0#C±>O51*LAR>O6�57*;^;H ��.U03.1>O*;: � N@]�8 Ë ð :�X ó@Xæï Õ4Õ X $c>3A�B`=gZ;.7A457C�.1HuÏ;];E�H/2u0GE�H>O6�=gZ;.7A457C�.157,/57Aw8_Awbc>;N�Hk03,[B":O57KLH'*�]�8 Ë ðOðOX � X # X7ð Õ Ë 516 H'57A�B;H'Ee512 Ë ðOðOX � X # X � Õ N@bu57A4B ;Uß�ðON�A�B;H/*-A�B;HÔ51*;^;57,/H/2>O6 ' Ê 03.1>O*;: � 0GE�H#0GAS=?>O2IA Ë ó@Næï�N . Õ 03*;^"o�����ä � 572e*;H/:L0GA457KLH3N±0?,/>O*�ATE[03^;51,'A451>O* Õ X Y B;H/* � Ë U Õ Ü � N>O6 Ë ðOðOX � X . Õ N@572\0#24=?>@>3A4B_^;>OZ�]�.1Hã24H/,'A451>O*D>O6�2TH/.161ض51*LA�H'E�24H','A�51>O*-ï�N�,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�51*;: Ë ðOðOX � X1ð�Å Õ X Y B�Z;2\A4B;H'E�H512u0aZ;*;57r@Z;HÔ2451*;:OZ;.10GEuC±>O51*LAkN ��N±03.7>O*;:)U_N�03*;^ U 512u0 Ò ó%ؽ,/Z�ETKLH3X

#�H'A�� Ê N � � ](HãA�B;HMA+bv><=gZ;.7A�5VC�.1HãÏ;];E�H/2u>O6 Ë ðOðOX � X7ðOð Õ X �v03,[B�=?H/H'A�2 � 0GAe0a2T51*;:OZ;.90GERC(>O57*�A/X � *;Hº>O6A�B;H � � NW2�0k8�� � =?H/H'A42 U 0GA ��X U =?H/H'A42�0a,'Z�E4KLHº>O6 =gZ;.VA�57C�.751,/5VA+8_Awbc>?0GA ��X $v8D2TC±H/,'A4E[03.�KG03.1Z;H Ë be5VA�BE�H/2IC(H/,'AuA�>a]±>3A�B � 03*;^ U Õ A�B;HP>O*;.V8_C(>O242T57]�51.757Aw8LN;69E�>O= Ë ðOðOX � X # Õ 512

Ë Ò ï Õ ähï Ë Ò ð Õ äâó Ë Ò ó Õ ä Ë Ò ó Õ �

Y BsZ;2 � Ê ß � � Nå03*;^j>O*;H`>3A�B;H'EU2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8Í>O6 � 512 Ë ï Õ X Y BsZ;2gA�B;H`.9032IAg2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8ÍB�032g51*;^;HG�j0GA.1H/032TA`ï�X�� Ê B�032_=gZ;.VA�57C�.751,/5VA+8mAwbc>;X +@57*;,/H"57A?=?H/H'A�2 � 0GA`0�C(>O51*LA_>O6ã51*;^;HG� 0GA_.7Hk032TADï�NcA�B;H">O*;.78C(>O2T2457]�57.157Aw8U69E�>O= Ë ðOðOX � X # Õ 572 Ë ð Õ Ns03*;^_24>PA4B;HeA�B;57E4^?2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8<03.1>O*;: � 512 Ë ó � ó � ó Õ X �S>�b�516±bcHe,¨B;>s>O24H�c~ �� � Ò�Ó � 03*�5724>O=?>3E4C�B;5724= 03.1>O*;: � N � Ë U Õ 512º0D24=?>s>3A�B¾^;>OZ�]�.7H<24H/,JA�51>O*�>O6¿24H/.161ض51*LA�H'E�2TH/,'A�57>O*�ï�NK�57>O.90GA�57*;: Ë ðOðOX � X7ð�Å Õ X �

��� � � ���¾$��� � � � ���������

öSH'E�HãbcHMC;E�>%KLHG~�*'��»�4NÔ�%���å�±¡k���%���±�¿� � ¸ ' � ´�ªº©<ªJ«?¬�¬�¥®­�§[©G¼(©G¼±©?¥®­;¤J¼4' 3 ´�ªMÂ1¬�È_ùs¼W´ ° ù@Â1¤�¹LÀ

� �q�W¡k¡k�����"�%� �%�±� ý±� ��� � � �*'��%� ��� ' 3 � ���@¡<� ���<� �@�W�"�¾�%��ý��s�s�+@=?>s>3A�B�]W03*�03*�032<0GE4HD,'.90324245VÏ�H/^h57* Ë ð�ï�Xpó Õ N�buB;H'E�H`bcHDÏ�*;^ ' � ß 4 � N � � ß Ë =Räëð � ó Õ X Ì H_bu51.1.

H �@C�.151,'57A�.V8Í,/.9032T2451698mA�B;H`C(>O242T57]�51.757A�57H/2/X �S>3A4H Ê =<H/H'A�2 U Ê 0GAa0Ð24=<>@>3A�BmC(>O57*�AkN�03*;^�2T>i]�8 Ë ðOðOX1ðOX1ð Õ=?H/HJA�2 � Ê 0GAe0 ãZ>H¿03.(C(>O51*LAkN�2�0k8 � � X

� ä � ä � Ü 4 � 512\0º,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA451>O*_>O6�Awbc>#24H/,'A451>O*;2\03*;^D0PÏ;];E�H3N�A�B�Z;2c2457*;,/HSo � ä � � ä � � ä � �512R*;H/:L0GA�5VKLH

Ë�� Õ ó � � ähó � � ä � ��. �

)+*-CW0GE4A�57,/Z;.90GE � � ��. � � N�24>U]s8 Ë :�XæÅ�X � Xpó Õ N � � B�032e2IC(H/,'ATE[03.�K303.7Z;HP0GAu=?>O2TA\A�B�E�H'H3X Y BsZ;2 = � ó@X

Page 128: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

.$) � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

�*'�� 5 �¿���Í����� Á ­;¤ ° ¤#© ° ¤P¥|ûv¬ ¯ ¬�ª[ª¨´|§'´»Â ´�¥®´½¤¨ª��J �W¡/�m� � � � � � ,�¥®­;¤Pª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥®´½¤¨ª#¬+¸ ' Ê ©GÂ1¬�¼@È � Ê © ° ¤ � Ê ß Ë $ Ò ð � =\ätð � ó Õ-, � ��, ��� , $ - ï ,c©3¼±¹� Ê ´�ªº© Å ú4³Jù ° µ3¤�À Ë $ � = ÕÔ´�ª#¤'´�¥»­�¤ ° Ë ï � ó Õg¬ ° Ë . � ð Õ�ÀJ �W¡/� 5 � � � � � ,S¥®­;¤?ª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ª_©3Â1¬�¼@È � Ê © ° ¤ � Ê ß Ë $ �����kÕ0, � � , Ë =Räëð � ó Õ-, � Ê ´�ª`© ð ú�³Jù ° µ3¤� $ - ó � À Ë $ � = ÕÔ´�ª#¤J´»¥»­;¤ ° Ë ï � ó Õ-, Ë . � ð Õg¬ ° Ë . � ï Õ�À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Y B;HM^;H/24,'E�5VC;A�51>O*;2R>O6 A4B;HÔ2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2c6�>O.1.1>�bé69E�>O= Ë ðOðOX7ðOX1ð Õ 03*;^�>OZ�ER^;H/24,'E�5VC;A�51>O*�>O6 Ë ' � ��� ä� ä �ºÕ X Y B�Z;2MbvHU*;H'H/^¾>O*;.V8"^;H'A�H'E4=?51*;H $ 03*;^4=@X Ì HU,/>O=<C�Z�A�HºA�B;Hg2TC±H/,'A4E�03.�K303.7Z;HU>O6 � Ê 03*;^ÐZ;24HË�� Õ ~)+* � 032TH?ðO~ +@Z�C;C(>O24HºÏ;E42TA =#ß ðOXc)I6 $ ß ï<A4B;H/*qo�����ä � Ê 512�*�Z;=?H'E�57,k03.1.V8`A4E�57K@5903.�03*;^"bcHºB�0kKLH#0

A�57:OH'EkX#)+6 $ - � A4B;H/* � Ê B�032M2TC(H/,JA4E[03.�K303.7Z;H?0GAM.1H/032TAºõ�N�03*;^�2T> � � à � � - õ � � 03*;^ � - ó �3ï � õ � � NbuB;51,[B�,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�2 Ë�� Õ X�)I6 $ ß ïUA�B;H'*�o�����ä � 572u*�Z;=?H'E451,k03.7.78`A4E�5VK�5903.®N;03*;^ � 512e0UA�57:OH'EkX

�S>�bé24Z�C;C(>O2TH =#512\Awbc>;N;bcHÔ2TB;>%b $ 512u0GAR=?>O2TAuï�Xy)I6 $ - .aA4B;H/* � Ê B�032R2TC(H/,JA4E[03.�K303.7Z;HP0GAu.1H/032TA � N� � à � � - � � :�NW03*;^ � - . � � � � � :UbuB;51,[B"03:L0351*`K�57>O.90GA�H'2 Ë�� Õ X)+* � 0324HUó@~ +@Z�C;C(>O2THUÏ;E�2IA =Uß�ó@X $ ,k03*;*;>3AS]±HºAwbc>;N Ë >3ESA�B;H#B�Z;*LAMbv>OZ;.1^q,[B;>@>O24H � Ê ß Ë ï � ó Õ4Õ Xe)+6$ - .aA4B;H/* � Ê B�032u2TC(H/,JA4E[03.�K303.7Z;HP>O6 0GAe.7Hk032TAeõ�NW,'>O*�A4E�03^;51,'A�57*;: Ë�� Õ 032u0G](>�KLH3X�öSH'*;,/H $ ßéï�X)+6 =`ßÖðaA�B;H'* $ ,k03*¾]±H?0GAM=?>O2TA .;N�6�>3Eº>3A�B;H'ETbe5724HUA4B;H<2TC±H/,'A4E[03.�KG03.1Z;Ha>O6 � Ê 512Ô0GAÔ.1Hk032TAPõDbuB;51,[B

:O57KLH'2e0U,/>O*�ATE[03^;51,'A451>O*�032R](H/6�>3E4H3X�)+6 $ ßéó#A�B;H/*�o�� � ä � Ê 512R*�Z;=?H'E�57,k03.1.V8_A4E�57K@5903.®X �Ì Hgbe57.1.�*;>�b ,/.903242T51698qA�B;HaC±>O24245V]�.1H<2TZ�E�6�03,/H/2 ' 3 03*;^¾51*¾Hk03,[B�,k0324HUC;E�>%KLHU.1>O:�Z;*;57E�Z;.7H/^;*;H/242#Z;2T51*;:

� õ�X

�*'���( 'þ � 3 �»¡<�¾ÿG� �W�»��¡k�»� ý���K��W�����J�y�

�*'���(��»� �����Í����� � ¸ � 3 ´�ªu©g³¨­�©G´»¼?ª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥®· , ¥®­;¤J¼_¥®­;¤ ° ¤c´�ª�¬�¼(¤\ª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|·#¬+¸ � Ê ¬�¼ Ê , Ê «?¤[¤J¥®ªU Ê ©G¥R©aª¨«?¬%¬�¥»­ ¯ ¬�´�¼W¥ ,v©G¼(¹ o�� � ä Ê ´�ªMÂ1¬�È_¥w¤ ° «g´�¼(©GÂ7À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ +@57*;,/HPA�B;HJE�H#0GE�HÔ>O*;.78DA+bv>?2451*;:OZ;.10GEeC±>O51*LA�2�03.7>O*;:SU Ê N Ê =UZ;2IAe=?H'H'A?U Ê 0GAS0<2T=?>@>3A�B`C(>O57*�A/XY B;HÔE�H/2IAe*;>�b 6�>O.1.1>�bu2u69E�>O=ÖA�B;HM6�03,'AeA4B�0GA � Ê 512R24=?>s>3A�B�N;24H/H Ë ðOðOX . Õ X �

$v8 Ë ð # Xæï�X1ð Õ A�B;H'E�Hg0GE�HºAwbc>`2457*;:OZ;.90GESC±>O51*LA�2��iß � 3 03*;^ � >O* ' ß ' 3 X � 512�A�B;H#Z;*;57r@Z;Hg2451*;:OZ;.10GEC(>O57*�Aa>O* ß Ê X Ì H-2�0k8mA�B�0GAabvH�0GE�H�� 03^;^;51*;:;{�A�B;H�2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8 � X �eH',k03.1.cA�B�0GA�U ß U Ê 512a0Ò ;Oؽ,/Z�E4KLHGX

#�H'A�_]±HÔA�B;HÔ,/>@H�!<,/51H'*�Ae>O6 A�B;HM,/Z�E4KLHº=?H'H'A�51*;: 0GA � X@#�H'A � ß � 3 X Y B;H'*"o�� � ß Ò ðvä � ä�WXY BsZ;2 ' 512�0U.1>O:U^;H/.���H����/>?5Vè � ä �éðOXÌ HD*;>3A�H-57*h03.7.c,k0324H/2UA�B;H'E�H�512a0i=_0GC ��~ �'ÚÒ�Ó É � Nv0Ð,/>O=<C(>O2T57A�57>O*�>O6u24=?>@>3A4Bj]�.7>%b×Z�C�2/X Y >

^;H/24,JE�57]±HP:OH'E�=<2u>O6�,'Z�E4KLH/2e>O* ' bcHÔbu51.7.�6�>O.1.7>%béA�B;HÔ*;>3A[0GA�57>O*�>O6 H ��03=<C�.7H Ë õ�X # Õ X

Page 129: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � .$),0

�*'���(�� 5 J �W¡/���W� ,�5 ��0?,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*"51* É�� >O6y0?,/>O*;57, � N±0?24H',k03*�Aã.751*;H � N�0<A[03*;:OH/*LAS.751*;H � X #�H'A� � � ß � N � � � ß � N;03*;^ � � � ß � � � � �LX�#�H'A� �

�51*;^;57,k0GA�HSA�B;Hã.157*;HS51* É � 69E�>O= � A�> ��NW03*;^ � �

A�B;HMA[03*;:OH/*LAe.751*;HãA�>aA�B;HÔ,/>O*;51,Ô0GAyÎ�X

�*'���(�� 5±�®� J �W¡/�Í� � Ë $ � = Õ ß Ë ï � ó ÕJ�

�*'���(�� 5±�®�W�®� �D��� Ë ó � ï � ó ÕJ� � ß Ë � � � Ê � ï 8 � ï � ó Õ X � 3 ß Ê � � � � �Ê � � � Ê � gß �� � � � X � Ë ï 89Õ ß � �

� � � � X�,W>3E ' A�>º]±H^;H/.���H����/>;N�03*;^"A�B;572eA�><]±H#0?2TA�HJCi>O6�A4B;HºBsZ;*LAãbcHºB�0kKLH � ä >��ð#03*;^ � - � Ë ï 8 Õ X Y B;HÔC(>O24245V]�51.757A�57H/20GE�H ;aß . � � X �_512u:O57KLH/*-]�8D]�.1>�be57*;:?Z�CqïaA�57=?H/2u0GA � 03.1>O*;: � N�03*;^">O*;,/HP=?>3E4HÔ>�KLH'E � N±0GAuA�B;HÔC±>O51*LAbuB;H'E�H�A4B;H Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�E4KLH-=?H/H'A�2a03*�HG�;,/H'C;A451>O*�03. Ò ó%ض,/Z�E4KLH3N .ÐA�51=?H'2a0GA � 03.1>O*;: � Nv03*;^�;ÍA�57=?H/2U0GA �03.1>O*;: � X �mß Ë ó � ó # � ; � � ó � ó � ó Õ X � ß Ë ó � ï � ï � ��� � � Ê Õ XUöSH'E�H<6�>3EPH ��03=aC�.1HS; � 51*;^;57,k0GA�H/2MA�B�0GAMA�B;H2TA4E451,'A�ATE[03*;246�>3E�= >O6�A�B;Hº.157*;H � >O*��' 512S0 Ò ;Oؽ,'Z�E4KLH3X ! Ë � Õ ß�ï�ð � .Lï�X ! Ë �;Õ ß ï � � . � X%# H'A � ß � �Ë >O* '�Õ X � 512a0 Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�ETKLH"03*;^�B�032UA+bv>¾24=?>s>3A�Bm];E[03*;,[B;H/2`0GA � N�A4B;H'8�0GE�H Ë � � � � � ó 8 � ï � ï � ó Õ 03*;^Ë � � � Ê � ï � ï � ó 8 Õ X%,W>3E ;<ß .;N Ò o�� � � ß ï �3ï � NWA�B�Z;2So��"512�.7>O:?Z;*;57E�Z;.7H/^"]s8 Ë õ�X � Õ X #�H'A �éß � � X��512R0 Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLH3N�03*;^DB�032RAwbc>U24=?>s>3A�B_];E[03*;,[B;H/2�0GA � X Y B;H'8D0GE�H Ë ó � ó 8 � ; � ó � ó � ó Õ 03*;^ Ë ó � ó � ; � ó � ó 8)� ó Õ XÌ B;H/* ;gß � >O*;HP,/>O=aC�Z�A�H/2 Ò o�� � � ßÝð��'. � N Ò o�� � �tßÝð��'.Lï�X ' 512R.1>O:aZ;*;57E�Z;.7H/^-]�8 Ë õ�X � Õ X

�*'���(�� 5±�®�W�65 ����� � �3� � ß Ë � � � Ê � ï � ó � ó Õ X � 3 ß � � � � � �� � � � � Ê _ß �

� � � � X ;?ßÝï � .;X ��~ $c.7>%b�Z�C4.?A�51=?H'20GA � � � N .DA�51=?H'2P0GA �<� � A�B;H/* ;�A�51=?H'2 Ë 0G](>�KLH � Õ 03.7>O*;: � X0# HJA � ß � � X Ò o�� � � ß # �'.;ðOX0#�>O:Z;*;57E4Z;.1H/^Í]�8 Ë õ�X � Õ X ,�>3E0;Ðß .".1HJA � ß � � X � B�032PAwbc>�];E[03*;,[B;H/2g0GA � X � *;H_,[B;H/,�Q@2ºA�B�0GAºHk03,[B];E[03*;,[B"B�032R51*;^;H ��õ � ß ! Ë � Õ X Ò o�� � � ß � �3õ � N;.7>O:<Z;*;5VE�Z;.1H/^�]s8 Ë õ�X � Õ X

�*'���(�� 5±�®�W�)( ����� � � � � ß Ë � � � Ê � ï � ó Õ X � ß � � � � � �� � � � � �gß �� � � � X � ä �çðã:O57KLH/2 ; ��.;N�;gßéó#*;>3AR0

B�Z;*�Ae2TA�H'C�N;24>O;Uß ï�X �?~1$c.1>�b Z�C>.UA�57=?H/2R0GA �<� � NM.UA�51=<H/2\0GA � � � 03*;^DA�B;H/*�ï#A�57=?H/2R0G](>�KLH � 03.7>O*;:� X ! Ë � Õ ß � ó@X2# H'A��ëß � � X � B�032vA+bv>g];E�03*;,¨B;H'2e0GA � N�>O*;HS.VAkX � *;Hã,[B;H/,�Q�2cA�B;Hã*;>O*`.7Av];E�03*;,¨B�B�03251*;^;HG� � ó@X Ò o�� � �tß . � � ó@X

�*'���(�� 5±�65 J �W¡/�Í� Ë $ � = Õ ß Ë . � ð Õ¨�

�*'���(�� 5±�65±�®� ����� Ë ï � ó � ó ÕJ��� ß Ë � � � Ê � . 8 � ó � ó Õ X � ß Ê 3 � � �'ÊÊ 3 � � Ê � Ðß �� � � � X � ä �×ð<:O57KLH/2);�� # X

� - � Ë . 8 Õ ß � �� � � � :O57KLH/2 ; - � X>;Ðß � � õ � � � :�X � >3ETE�H/2TC±>O*;^;51*;:"51*;^;57,/H/2#0GE4H ! Ë � Õ ßÚï � � . � � � � � õ � X

! Ë �;Õ ß ï : � . � � � ó � ��# X �<~ $c.1>�bçZ�C � A�51=<H/2e0GA �<� � N�ïgA�51=<H/2R0GA � � � N�;?A451=?H/2R0GA � � � X #�H'A ��ß � � XÒ o�� � �àß � � �Ê 3 � � Ê � X #�H'A � ß � � X Ò o�� � � ß � � �� � � � X �ÚB�032ºAwbc>"];E[03*;,[B;H/2a0GA � N�>O*;H`.VAkN�>O*;H24=?>s>3A�B / � Awbc>?0GA � N;>O*;HÔ.VAkN;>O*;HÔ2T=?>@>3A�B�Xyí�C;C�.V8 Ë õ�X � Õ A�> � 6�>3E ; �ß � � :�N;03*;^ Ë õ�X � Õ A�> �mä � 6�>3E;Uß :�X ,W>3E ;gß � .1HJA �Ä](HRA�B;H�,/>O*;57,�>O6 Ë õ�X # X7ð Õ NLB�0�K@51*;:#ï � � >3E4^;H'Ec,/>O*LA[03,'A�be5VA�B � 0GA � 03*;^?A[03*;:OH/*LAA�> � 0GA � X � B�032ãA+bv>�];E[03*;,[B;H/2g0GA � N�>O*;HU2451*;:OZ;.10GEkN >O*;Ha24=?>s>3A�B�N�03*;^¾>O*;H<,[B;H/,�Q@2PA�B�0GAMHk03,[BÍB�032.1>s,k03.�51*;^;HG� � ó@X Ò o�� � � ß . � � ó@N;24>abvHP,k03*"0GC;C�.V8 Ë õ�X � Õ X ��*'���(�� 5±�65±�65 �D��� � Ê �å�±�»�(�L�

Page 130: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

. ��+ ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

� ß Ë � � � Ê � ï Õ X � ß � � � � � �� � � � � � �ß Ê� � � Ê X � ä� � ðD:O57KLH/2 ; � .;X ;�ßÄï � .;X ! Ë � Õ ß õLó � # � X

! Ë �;Õ ß � � # X �j~ � A451=?H/2º0GA �<� � Nyï-A�57=?H/2#0GA � � � N ;ÐA�51=<H/2#0GA � � � X ,W>3E�;�ß ï�A[0GQLH � 24=?>s>3A�B,/>O*;57,eA[03*;:OH/*LAcA�> � 0GA � 03*;^?bu57A�B`ï � � >3E�^;HJE\,/>O*�A�03,'Avbu57A�B � 0GA � X �ÄB�032vA+bv>º];E[03*;,[B;H/2R0GA � N Ë Hk03,[B2457*;:OZ;.90GE Õ H/03,¨Bq>O6y51*;^;HG�qõLó@X Ò o�� � �ìß�ó@ð��3õLó@X ,�>3E�;_ß ._.1H'A �çß � � X Y bc>?];E[03*;,[B;H/2M0GA�� N(>O*;H.7A/N;>O*;HP24=?>s>3A�B�X Ò o�� � �tß ï � # � X ��*'���(�� 5±�65±�)( �D��� ��� �å�±�»�(�L� � ß Ë � � � Ê � ï � ó � ó � ó Õ N � ß Ê � � � � �Ê � � � Ê � N Uß

�� � � � X � ä<�çðP:O57KLH'2 ; �

� N;aßéï � . � � � õ � � X ! Ë � Õ ß ó # � .Lï � � � � � ð � : � X ! Ë �;Õ ß ð # � ó'. � ó # � ï . � ï # X �W~¿ïUA�57=?H/2u0GA � � � N � A�57=?H/2R0GA�<� � A�B;H'* ;UA�57=?H/2v>�KLH'E � 03.7>O*;: � X ��ß � � N � ß � � X��¿03,[B�B�032vAwbc>#];E[03*;,[B;H/2u0GA � N�>O*;Hã>O6�buB;51,[B512M2457*;:OZ;.90GEkX Ò o�� � � ß � � � ���Ê � � � Ê � X Ì B;H/* ! Ë � Õ 512ãC;E�57=?H3N�A�B;H<2T51*;:OZ;.90GEM];E[03*;,[B�>O6 � 512M*;>O*@Ø � 0GE4A�57H'E]�8 Ë .;X1ð%ó@Xpó Õ N�03*;^DbcHã,k03*�0GC;C�.V8 Ë õ�X � Õ X � *;HM,¨B;H',[Q@2uA�B�0GAcA4B;HÔ*;>O*D.7A\];E[03*;,[B->O6 � B�032\57*;^;H � � � buB;H/*;�ß � 03*;^ÐA4B;Ha*;>O*Ð.7AS];E[03*;,[Bi>O6 � B�032ã51*;^;HG� : � buB;H/* ;�ß � X +@57*;,/H Ò o 572S*;>3AP0`:OH/*;H'E�0GA�>3EãbcH,k03*"0GC;C�.V8 Ë õ�X � Õ X �� �*'���(��)( J �W¡/�85±� öSH'E�HRÏ"�UA�B;He,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E�0GA�51>O*<032¿51* � 032THPðONL]�Z�A¿bu57A�B � A�B;Hu,/>O*;51,u03*;^ � A�B;Hu24H/,k03*LA.157*;H3X

�*'���(���(��®� Ë = � $ Õ ß Ë ó � ï Õ¨��*'���(���(��®�W�®� ��� � Ë ï � ó � ó Õ �å�±�»�(�L� � ß Ë � � � . � ó � ó Õ N � ß �'Ê � � � �

�'Ê � � � � N gß�

� � � Ê 3 X � ä <�çðS:O5VKLH/2 ; � ï�X$cZ�Ac6�>3E ; ��.ºA�B;512v572v*;>3A\0ºB�Z;*�AR2TA4H'C Ë A�B;H Ò .Gؽ,/Z�ETKLHSB�032cB;51:OB;H'E\,/>sH�!?,'51H/*LA Õ X@+@>ºA�B;572c,k0324H�^;>sH/2c*;>3A>@,',/Z�EkX

�*'���(���(��®�W�65 ����� Ë ï � ó Õ �å�±�»�(�L� � ß Ë � � � . � ó Õ N � ß � � � � � �� � � � � � N iß

�� � � � X � ä �Öð_:O57KLH/2 ; � ï�X

;ÐßÖó�*;>3Aº0�BsZ;*LAg2TA�HJCm24> ;Ðßàï�X ! Ë � Õ ß � ðON ! Ë �;Õ ßÖóOó@X �¾~�. Y 51=?H/2Ô0GA �<� � N .-A�57=?H/2P0GA � N�A�>:OH'AeH �;,/HJC;A�51>O*�03. .1>@,'Z;2e>�KLH'E � N Ë Ò ó �kÒ ï �kÒ ð �kÒ ó Õ N�bu57A4B � 0 Ò ó%ؽ,'Z�E4KLH3N±A�B;H'*�]�.1>�bÝZ�C .<A451=?H/2e0G](>�KLH� 03.1>O*;: � X ��ß Ë ó � ó # � ï � � ï � � ó � ó � ó Õ X�#�H'A � ß � � X � B�032\Awbc>g];E[03*;,[B;H/2e0GA � N Ë ó � ó 8 � ï � ï � ó � ó � ó Õ03*;^ Ë ó � ï � ï � ó � ó 8 � ó Õ N�Hk03,[B�>O6�57*;^;H � � ðOX Ò o�� � � ß � � � ðOX ��*'���(���(��®�W�)( ����� � � �å���®�(�L� � ß Ë � � � ï � ó � ó Õ N � ß � � � � � Ê� � � � � � N iß

�� � � � X � ä �Öð_:O57KLH'2); � ó@X

;Ußéóg*;>3A�0UBsZ;*LA�2IA�H'C�X +@>UA�B;512u,k0324HÔ^;>@H/2R*;>3Ae>s,/,/Z�EkX ��*'���(���(��65 J �W¡/� 5±� Ë = � $ Õ ß Ë ð � . ÕJ��*'���(���(��65±�®� ����� Ë . � ó Õ �å�±�»�(�L� � ß Ë � � � � � ó Õ N � ß Ê � � � � 3Ê � � � � � N iß

�� � �

�X � ä �Öð_:O57KLH/2 ; �

� X� - � Ë�� Õ ß � � � �

� � ��:O57KLH/2E;�ß � X ! Ë � Õ ß � ï�X �i~�õDA451=?H/2M0GA � � � Næï_A451=?H/2M0GA � � � N � A�51=?H'2Ô0GA �<� � X

�tß � � X � B�032RAwbc><];E�03*;,¨B;H'2S0GA � N�>O*;HP.VAkN;>O*;HP2T=?>@>3A�B�X Ò o�� � �tßéó � � ï�X ��*'���(���(��65±�65 �D��� � � �å�±�»�(�L� � ß Ë � � � ï � ó Õ N � ß � � � � � 3� � � � � �

N Uß �� � � � X � ä<�çðP:O5VKLH/2 ; � ï�X%;Ußçó*;>3AºB�Z;*LAg2TA�H'Cm24> ;qßàï�X ! Ë � Õ ßàõ � X ��~ � A�57=?H/2º0GA �<� � N ï-A�51=?H'2P0GA � � � A�B;H/* .�A�57=?H/2Ô0GA � � � X��ß Ë ó # � . � � ï � ������Õ X � ß � � X Y bv>a];E[03*;,[B;H/2S0GA � NW>O*;HM.7A/NW>O*;HM24=?>s>3A�B�X Ò o�� � � ß : �3õ � X �

Page 131: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � . � .

�*'���(���(��65±�)( �D��� ��� �����»���L� � ß Ë � � � ï ��� �/Õ N � ß �'Ê � � � 3�'Ê � � �'Ê N��ß �

� � ��X � ä� � ð`:O57KLH/2�; � .;X

;Dß�ï_*;>3AM0_B�Z;*�AÔ2TA�H'Ci24> ;Dß .;X ! Ë � Õ ß�õ .;X �W~uï_A�51=?H'2S0GA � � � N � A�51=?H'2S0GA �<� � A�B;H/* � 0GA � � � X� ß � � X � B�032PAwbc>"];E[03*;,[B;H/2U0GA � N >O*Í.7AkN�>O*;H_2T51*;:OZ;.90GE/X Y B;H_2451*;:OZ;.10GEº];E[03*;,[B�B�032P51*;^;H �jõ .;XÒ o�� � � ß . �3õ .;X ��*'���(���(��)( J �W¡/� 5 Ë = � $ Õ ß Ë ð � ï ÕJ��*'���(���(��)(��®� ����� Ë ï � ó Õ �å�±�»�(�L� � ß Ë � � � . � ó Õ N � ß Ê � � � � �Ê � � � Ê � N iß

�� � � � X � ä �Öð_:O57KLH/2 ; � :�X

� - � Ë . Õ ß � � � �� � � � :O5VKLH/2 ;Uß . � � � õ � � � :�X ! Ë � Õ ßéï�ð � .Lï � � � � õ � � � # X �W~yïPA�57=?H/2¿0GA � � � N1;väjð�A451=?H/2¿0GA

� � � N .SA�57=?H/2å0GA �<� � X � ß � � X � B�032yAwbc>ã];E[03*;,[B;H/2¿0GA � NL>O*a.VAkNO>O*;HR24=?>@>3A4B�X Ò o�� � � ß � � �Ê � � � Ê � X� *;HP,[B;H/,�Q�2RbeB;H/* ;Uß õ�N�A�B;HM24=?>s>3A�B_];E[03*;,[B�>O6 � B�032R51*;^;HG� � � X Y BsZ;2 Ë õ�X � Õ 0GC;C�.751H/2\buB;H/* ; �ß :�X,W>3E ;Dß7:_.7H'A ��ß � � X ��B�032�Awbc>_];E[03*;,[B;H/2Ô0GA � N±>O*;H#.7AkN(>3A4B;H'Eã24=?>s>3A�B�X ! Ë �;Õ ß . � Ë 24>_C;E�57=?H Õ XÒ o�� � � ß ð��'. � X �S>�b 0GC;C�.78 Ë õ�X � Õ X ��*'���(���(��)(��65 ����� � � �å���®�(�L� � ß Ë � � � ï � ó � ó Õ N � ß Ê � � � � �Ê � � � Ê � N âß �

� � � � X � ä � ð":O57KLH/2O; ßï � . � � � õ � � X ! Ë � Õ ßìó # � . . � ��# � � . � : # X ��~�ïiA451=?H/2<0GA � � � N .iA�51=?H'2?0GA �#� � A�B;H'* ;<ä ð"0GA � � � X�çß � � X��ÝB�032�Awbc>?];E[03*;,[B;H/2M0GA�� N±>O*;H#.VAkN±>O*;H#2T51*;:OZ;.90GE/X Y B;H#2451*;:OZ;.10GES512S*;>3A � 0GE4A451H'Eu]s8 Ë .;X1ð%ó Õ XÒ o�� � �tß � � � ���Ê � � � Ê � X � *;HÔ,[B;H/,�Q�2�6�>3E ;Uß .;NWõUA4B�0GAuA�B;HM2457*;:OZ;.90GER];E[03*;,[B"B�032e51*;^;HG�>. . � � .;X ��*'���(���(��)(��)( �D��� � � �����»���L� � ß Ë � � � ï � ó Õ N � ß �'Ê � � � �

�'Ê � � � � N Uß �� � � � X � ä<� ðÔ:O57KLH/2 ;Ußéï � . � � � õ�X! Ë � Õ ß ï � � � � � � � � # � X ��~@.<0GA �#� � N�ï<0GA � � � A�B;H'* ;ãätðP0GA � � � X �tß � � X �çB�032uAwbc>a];E�03*;,¨B;H'2S0GA� N;>O*-.7A/N�>O*;HÔ2T51*;:OZ;.90GE/X Y B;HÔ2T51*;:OZ;.90GE\];E[03*;,[B�572 Ë ó # � ï � � ; 8 � ó 8 � ó � ó Õ X2$v8 Ë .;X7ð%ó Õ A�B;HM2451*;:OZ;.10GEu];E[03*;,[B512�*;>3A � 0GE4A�57H'EkX ,W>3E ;#ß .º>O*?,[B;H/,�Q�2�A�B;He57*;^;H �?>O6�A�B;He2457*;:OZ;.90GE�];E[03*;,[B_512vï � � � � X Ò o�� � �tß � � � ���

�'Ê � � � � XY BsZ;2 Ë õ�X � Õ 0GC;C�.151H'2?6�>3E8; �ß � X�,W>3EO;âß � .1HJA � ß � � X � B�032a>O*;H�.7Aa];E[03*;,[B�Nc>O*;H�2451*;:OZ;.10GE];E[03*;,[B�N�0GA�� X � *;Hg,¨B;H',[Q@2SA�B;Hº2457*;:OZ;.90GES];E[03*;,[BqB�032S51*;^;H � � � X +@51*;,'H#o��Ð512e*;>3Aã0_:OH/*;H'E[0GA�>3E/N Ë õ�X � Õ0GC;C�.157H/2/X �� �*'�� 'þ � 3 �»¡a��� �±�

�ÿG� ���»�â¡k�»� ý±� K»�������¨�y�

Y BsZ;2ãA�B;H'E�HU0GE�H#A�B�E4H/Hg2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2M03.1>O*;:OU_N�03*;^i03.1>O*;: � Ê XM)+6 =?H/HJA�2 U 0GAM0`24=?>s>3A�B�C(>O57*�A/NA�B;H/*�R Ë U Õ 572c24=?>@>3A4B�Xy)wA\6�>O.7.1>�be2 Ë 2T51*;,/H � Ê 512\24=?>s>3A�B Õ N�A�B�0GA 512c57*DA4B;H MZOH¿03.(.1>s,/Z;2/N�A�B�Z;2 � ß ðON0a,'>O*�A4E�03^;51,'A�57>O*�X

+@>`bcHa,/03*�032424Z;=<H)U×=?H/H'A42 0GAP0D2451*;:OZ;.10GEãC(>O51*LA ��X��S>%b�A4B;HUC±>O242457]�57.15VA�51H/2ã6�>3E �� Ò�Ó �' Ê 0GE�H:O57KLH'*¾51* Ë ðOðOX . Õ X)+@57*;,/Ha]�8 Ë .;X1ð%ó@Xpï Õ A4B;H'E�H<=gZ;2TAM](H<0�*;>O*@Ø MZ H¿03.�2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8i03.7>O*;: á � U_N 5VA6�>O.1.7>%bu2 Ë 51*ÐA�B;H<.103*;:OZ�03:OHa>O6 Ë ðOðOX . Õ4Õ A�B�0GAMA�B;H'E4H<0GE�Ha*;>-57*�A�HJE�51>3EM]�.1>�b Z�C�2/N�03*;^¾o��"ä�U ä 512M.7AkX#�H'A � ](HãA�B;HP>3A4B;H'Ee2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457Aw8�03.1>O*;: X

�*'�� �»�W�®� J �W¡/����� Ë $ Ò ð � =�äâð Õ ß Ë ó � ï ÕJ� $v8?A�B;Hã,/.10324245VÏ�,k0GA�51>O*D>O6�.7A\2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2'N�*;H/,/H/2T2�0GE�51.V8`A�B;H2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2u03.1>O*;:)U 0GE4H � � N � � 03*;^ �ºß � Ê X Y B�Z;2 Ë 2T51*;,/H�� 3 512R*;>3A ãZ8H¿03. Õ N�; - ï�X@$v8 Ë ðOðOX . Õ N� ß Ë ï 8 ��� � � � � ï � ï � ó Õ X � 3 ßÄÊ � � � � �Ê � � � � � X � *;HPHk032451.V8`,[B;H/,�Q�2eA�B�0GAuo�� �+� àÅ�NW0a,'>O*�A4E�03^;51,'A�57>O*�X �

Page 132: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

. ��) ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

�*'�� �»�W�65 J �W¡/�Í�W� Ë $ Ò ð � =\ä�ð Õ ß Ë ï � ó Õ¨� Y B;HP2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2e03.7>O*;: � Ê 0GE�H Ë ï � ó � ó Õ N ��� NW03*;^ � Ê X+@Z�C;C(>O2TH�Ï;E�2TA"A�B�0GA Ë ï � ó � ó Õ 572�*;>3Aq03^;^;H/^�X Y B;H/*ç*;H/,/H'242�0GE�57.78 A�B;HÍ2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457A�57H/2"03.1>O*;: U 0GE�H

Ë ï � ó � ó Õ N � Ê Ny03*;^ �Ðß � Ê Ny03*;^ � ß Ë ï 8 ��� � � � � ï � ó � ó � ó Õ N�; - ó@X � *;H_,¨B;H',[Q@2#A�B�0GA#516?; - ï-A�B;H/*o�� � 572S03=<C�.7H3X Y B�Z;2E;?ß�ó@~ Y B;H#2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2�0GE�Hg0?*;>O*@ؽ,[B�0351* �ibe5VA�B",/H/*LA�H'E Ë Ò ó Õ 03*;^"];E[03*;,[B;H/2Ë ï 8 � ó � ó Õ � Ë ó Õ � Ë ó Õ N�03*;^ � ß � ß Ë ï � ï � ó � ó � ó Õ X Y B;HR=_0GC �' 3 Ò�Ó É � 512y>3];A[0357*;H/^<69E4>O= 0ã,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA451>O*bu57A�BÍ,/>O*;57, � N�24H/,k03*LAg.157*;H � 03*;^�A[03*;:OH/*LAg.157*;H � X>$c.1>�b Z�C�ï-A�57=?H/2º0GA � 03.1>O*;: � N � A�57=?H/2#0GA �03.1>O*;: � 03*;^-A�B;H'*qïa=?>3E�HãA�57=?H/2R>%KLH'E � A�><:O5VKLHMA�B;HMC;E�H/24,JE�57]±H/^q,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O*�X � ]±H/,/>O=?H/2 U_N � 5720 Ò ó%ؽ,'Z�E4KLH3N�>O*;H<>O6�A4B;HU];E[03*;,[B;H/2'N�03*;^ � 512SA�B;H Ò ï�ؽ,'Z�E4KLH<>O6åA�B;H Ë ï � ó � ó Õ ];E[03*;,[B�X)#�H'A � ](HUA�B;HA[03*;:OH/*LA�.751*;HÔ0GA � X � 512e0a>O*;HÔ,/Z�E4KLHP>O* ' 3 be5VA�B-Awbc>U];E[03*;,[B;H/2ã0GA � X � *;HP=<H/H'A�2 � N�03*;^�B�032e.7>@,k03.51*;^;HG� Ë >O*;HÔ,/>O=<C�Z�A�H'2 Õ ð�õ�N;A�B;HÔ>3A�B;H'Ee512\A[03*;:OH/*LAeA�> � 03*;^-A4E[03*;2IKLH'E�2�03.�A�> � Ë 0GA � Õ Xå)+A42u.7>@,k03.�51*;^;HG�512 :�X � *;HÔ,/>O=<C�Z�A�H/2

Ò o�� �/� � ß ï Ò ï � : Ò ó � ï �'. Ò ï �'.ºß ï � : �

Y BsZ;2 ' 3 512u.1>O:UZ;*;57E�Z;.7H/^-]�8 Ë õ�X � Õ X�S>�btbcHM032424Z;=<H Ë ï � ó � ó Õ 512R03^;^;H/^�X Y B;H'* �aB�032\57*;^;H �DH/57A4B;H'Eeóg>3Euï�X@+@Z�C;C(>O24HãÏ;E�2TAu57A\572uó@X Y B;H/*

; - ï�NW03*;^ � ß Ë ï 8 ��� � � � � . � ó � ó Õ X � 3 ß � � � Ê 3� � � �X � *;Hº,[B;H/,�Q@2eo�� � 512u03=<C�.1HGX

+@Z�C;C(>O2TH �aß Ë ó � ó Õ X Y B;H/* ; - ï�N � ß Ë . 8 ��� � � � � . � ó � ó Õ N�03*;^ � 3 ß � 3 � � � 3� 3 � � � �X � *;Hº,[B;H/,�Q�2ão�� � 572

03=<C�.7H3X,�51*�03.7.78Í2TZ�C;C(>O24H �mß Ë ï Õ X Y B;H/* ; - ó@N � ß Ë ó 8 � ï ��� � � � � . � ó � ó Õ Ny03*;^�A4B;H�,/>sH�!?,'51H/*LA?>O6RA�B;H

Ò ï�ؽ,/Z�E4KLHP0GA � 3 572 �'Ê� � � �� 3 � � � �

X Y B;HP,/>sH�!?,'51H/*LA�>O6�ó 8 572 � � � ��'Ê � � � X � *;HP,[B;H/,�Q�2eo�� � 512e*;H'6½X �

�*'�� � 5±�®� J �W¡/� 5 � Ë = � $ Õ ß Ë ó � ï Õ¨� +@51*;:OZ;.10GE�57A451H/2a03.1>O*;: � Ê 0GE�H Ë ï � ó � ó Õ ��� ��� Ë ï � ó Õ X Y B;512a,k0324H-572E�Z;.7H/^�>OZ�AR]s8D51*;^;HG��,/>O*;2T51^;H'E[0GA451>O*�X ��*'�� � 5±�65 J �W¡/� 5 � Ë = � $ Õ ß Ë ð � . ÕJ� +@51*;:OZ;.90GE457A�57H/2�03.7>O*;: � Ê 0GE4H Ë . 8 � ó Õ ����� � Ë ó � ó Õ X �SH/,/H/24240GE�51.V8 Ë . � ó Õ512u03^;^;H/^�N �#ß Ë ó Õ N�; - ï�N�03*;^ � ß Ë ï 8 ��� � � Ê � � � ó Õ X � 3 ß � 3 � � � 3� 3 � � � �

X � *;HÔ,[B;H/,�Q�2�o�� � 572�03=<C�.7H3X ��*'�� � 5±�)( J �W¡/� 5 � Ë = � $ Õ ß Ë ð � ï ÕJ� +@57*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2-03.7>O*;: � Ê 0GE�H Ë ï 8�� ó Õ ��� � � Ë ó � ó Õ XÝ)+*é03*L8�,k0324H�ºß Ë ó Õ X

+@Z�C;C(>O2TH<Ï;E�2TAºA4B�0GA Ë ï � ó Õ 512P03^;^;H/^�X Y B;H/* ; - ï�03*;^ � ß Ë ï 8���� � � Ê � . � ó Õ X � 3 ß Ê � � � � �Ê � � � � � X � *;H,[B;H/,�Q�2�o�� � 572�03=<C�.7H3X �

� - ����± �q � [���®� �Ô�����h�( � &L&O������W$

Ì Hã](H/:O57*-bu57A�B`A�B;HP6�>3E4=_03.(C;E�>@>O6 >O6 Ë ðOX7ð Õ X

5����»� �#� �@�W�%���h�D£ ¤J¥='קJ¤D© ° ©3¼ F ¬G¼(¤?Â1¬[Ⱦ¹s¤JÂ9*�¤����%¬-ª¨ù ° ¸k©�³[¤kÀ �ãª[ªJùs«?¤ ' 3 ­�©Gª<¥ ° ´�µ%´|©GÂv©3Â}È�¤k§ ° ©G´¶³¸¨ù@¼±¹L©G«_¤J¼�¥w©GÂWÈ ° ¬�ù ¯ À � ¸/' ¹�¬�¤¨ªS¼(¬G¥�­�©Gµ3¤P©U¥|´1È�¤ ° ¥®­;¤J¼<'23<´�ªSù@¼�´ ° ù@Â1¤�¹LÀ � ¬ ° ¤[¬�µO¤ ° ,v¤��s©s³J¥®Â ·`¬�¼(¤º¬+¸S¥®­;¤

Page 133: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � . �-�

¸k¬�Â�Â1¬Gûy´�¼@È?­;¬�Â7¹�ªy¸�¬ ° ¥®­;¤Ô­sùs¼�¥vûy´»¥»­ Ë ' 3 ��! 3 Õ ß Ë '�� % Õ �Ë ð Õ � Ê Ü ' Ê ´�ªPª¨«?¬�¬�¥®­ ,R©G¼±¹ Ë ' � ��� � ä � � Õ#´�ªg©?ªJ«?¬�¬�¥®­���©3¼±©G¼±©�©G¼±¹`´�¼(³J ù�¹�¤�¹`´�¼Ð¥®­;¤<³JÂ7©�ª[ªJ´ 2åú

³�©G¥|´¶¬�¼ � A �sÀCB � ÀË ó Õ � Ë � Ê Õ ßéó ©G¼(¹ 'ç´�ªM¥»­�¤Ôª¨ù ° ¸/©s³[¤�ÈG´�µ3¤'¼q´�¼ � A �LÀCB � ÀË ï Õ � Ë � Ê Õ ß ð ©G¼(¹ � Ê ­�©�ªa©_ª¨´�« ¯ Â1¤g¼(¬�¹�¤kÀ Ë ' � ��� � ä � � ÕU´�ªg©ã¸k¤'¼(³[¤Pûå´�¥»­ � � ª¨«?¬�¬G¥»­�À \´�¥»­�¤ °

Ë ' � ��� � ä � � Õº´�ªã´�¼�³J ù;¹s¤�¹?´�¼Ð¥»­;¤a³JÂ7©�ª[ªJ´ 2c³�©G¥|´¶¬�¼ � A �sÀ�� � ,c¬ ° ûv¤P­�©Gµ3¤ � A ��À �@ÀCB � À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Y B;HcC(>O242T57]�51.757A�57H/2y6�>3EyA�B;HvÏ;E�2TAåAwbc>ãBsZ;*LA¿2IA�H'C�2�0GE�Hc^;H/24,'E457](H'^<51* Ë :�X .;X � Õ X $c8 Ë ð�.;X1ð Õ N � Ê ,k03*;*;>3A](HP0a*;H'A/X��S>�b 0GC;C�.78 Ë ð � X7ð Õ N Ë ð�õ�X7ð Õ N Ë ð � X1ð Õ N Ë ð � X1ðOX7ð Õ 03*;^ Ë ð :�X7ð Õ X �B � À B * ° ¬�¬I¸M¬+¸�� A À A � À �S>3A[0GA�57>O*_032c0G](>�KLH Ë ðOX7ð Õ X�íS2\0G](>�KLH Ë ðOXæï Õ NLA�B;H Ë o_fiäÐÞ Õ Ø¶zqz4�hE4H/^;Z;,/H/2 Ë ðOX7ð ÕA�> Ë ðOXpï Õ X $v8 Ë õ�X ó Õ 03*;^ Ë � Xpó Õ N�bcH�=_0k8j032424Z;=?H�Þ 512UH/=<C;Aw8LN ' B�032a*;>¾A�51:OHJEkNv03*;^ ' B�032UA4E�[email protected]:OHJ];E[0351,M6�Z;*;^�03=?H/*LA[03.�:3E�>OZ�C�X��S>�b 0GC;C�.78 Ë ó3Å�X7ð Õ X �öSH'E�HRbcH�:O5VKLHRC;E�>s>O6�2v>O6±A�B;He,/>3E�>O.1.10GE�51H'2�57*<A�B;H�57*�A4E4>@^;Z;,'A�57>O*�N@57*<A�B;>O24Hu,k0324H/2¿buB;H'E�H�A4B;HuE�H/2TZ;.7Av^;>sH/2

*;>3Au6�>O.1.1>�bç51=<=?H/^;590GA4H/.78<69E�>O= Ë ðOX1ð Õ 03*;^ Ë ðOXæï Õ X

* ° ¬�¬+¸U¬+¸ � A À � � À Ë ï Õ 03*;^ Ë . Õ 0GE�Hº57*;2TA[03*;,/H'2M>O6 Ë õ�X7ð Õ X � 0324H Ë ó Õ E�H/^;Z;,'H/2SA�>_,k0324H Ë ð Õ 0369A�H'E�CW03242T51*;:_A�>0?.1>O:?A4H'E�=?57*�03. =?>s^;H/.|N±032S51*�A�B;HºC;E4>@>O6y>O6 Ë õ�Xpï Õ X Y BsZ;2ã57A42�H/*;>OZ;:OBqA�>_,/>O*;2457^;H'E Ë ð Õ X"�S>�b CW03242�A�>`0.1>O:UE�H/24>O.7Z�A�51>O*�N�E4H'C�.903,/H � ]�8DA4B;HÔA�>3A[03.(ATE[03*;246�>3E�=�N�03*;^�0GC;C�.78 Ë ðOX1ð Õ X �* ° ¬�¬+¸�¬+¸ � A À� � À #�H'A � ß � ! X")+6 ' B�032E�¿51,/0GE�^�*�Z;=#](H'Eg>O*;H_A�B;H_E�H'24Z;.7AU6�>O.1.7>%bu2#69E�>O= Ë � X � Õ 03*;^Ë � X7ð�Å Õ X � A�B;H'E4bu5124HGN@E�Z;*;*;51*;: Ë o��Rä !aÕ Ø½zqz ��bcH�=?0�8U03242TZ;=?H ' B�032 �¿57,k0GE�^?*�Z;=#](H'E¿A+bv>;N@03*;^_Hk03,[BH/^;:OHº:O5VKLH/2�0 É�Ê Ø¶Ï;];E[0GA�57>O*�N±03*;^ � B�032u^;H/:3E�H/Hº0GA�=?>O2TAu>O*;HP6�>3E�H/57A�B;HJEeÏ;];E[0GA�57>O*�XcíS2e57*-A�B;HÔC;E4>@>O6�>O6Ë � X7ð�Å Õ N@bcHã,k03*D^;H/6�>3E�=àA�B;HMZ;*;51>O*D>O6�A4B;HMAwbc>U:OH/*;H'E[03.(Ï;];E4H/2�� Ê ä � � A�>g:OH'Au0g^;>O=?51*�0GA�57*;:g6�03=?51.V8?>O651*LA�H/:3E�03. E[0GA�57>O*�03. ,'Z�E4KLH/2SÞ Ü ' 3 beB;57,[BÐ^;H'6�>3E�= bu57A�Bq0<:OH'*;H'E[03. C±>O51*LA�Ï"�;H/^�XuÞ � � � ó@N±2T>DÞ � Ù:O57KLH'2e0U,/>O*;*;H/,'A�57*;:?6�03=?57.78`>O6 57=_03:OH/2\>O6 ê Ê" X �* ° ¬�¬+¸U¬+¸ � A À�� � À Y B;512e6�>O.1.1>�bu2�69E�>O= Ë ï�Xpï�Øwï�X . Õ >O6Rî � ñ¶X $\0GAw8@E�H'KDbc>3E4Q@2ebu57A�B-A4H'E�=?57*�03.�A�B�E4H/Hº6�>O.1^;2'N±]�Z�AB;512ã0GE4:OZ;=?H/*LA�2S0GC;C�.78�be5VA�B;>OZ�AS,[B�03*;:OHºA�>_.7>O:_24Z�E�6�03,/H/2'X Y B;H#^;H/2T,'E�57C;A451>O*q>O6�A�B;H#H/^;:OH/2S6�>O.7.1>�be2S69E4>O=B;512u^;H'Ï�*;57A451>O*->O6 A�>3A[03.(C�Z;.1.V]W03,�Q(NW03*;^�>OZ�E Ë ðOXpï Õ X �* ° ¬�¬+¸º¬I¸ � A À � � ,v¹GùW¤Ô¥+¬ � ¬ ° ´¶À $v8 Ë ó@X1ð Õ 03*;^ Ë ï�X1ð Õ >O6\î}ó # ñ�57Au512RH/*;>OZ;:OB-A�>a24B;>%bçA�B�0GAu516

� � Ë Ò .7>O: Ë Þ Õ4ÕvÒ�Ó

512¿0P:OH/*;H'E451,k03.7.78a24Z�E®FIH/,'A457KLH�=_0GC<A�>#0P.751*;Hu]�Z;*;^;.7H�eN�A�B;H/* � Ê Ë Õ � � - Å�Ns6�>3E\03*L8<03=<C�.1H��mX@$v8 Ë ðOX � Õ57Au512RH/*;>OZ;:OB-A4><24B;>�b � Ê Ë Õ�� î � ñ - Å�N�6�>3E � 032R51* Ë ðOX � Õ X Y B;512u6�>O.1.7>%bu2u69E4>O= Ë � X � X1ð Õ X �* ° ¬�¬+¸º¬I¸ � A À � À A � À )+=?=?H/^;510GA�Hã69E�>O= Ë ðOX : Õ N�03*;^ Ë ð�Å�X : Õ N Ë ð�Å�X1ð%ó Õ >O6cî}ó � ñ¶X �

Page 134: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

. ��� ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

* ° ¬�¬+¸º¬I¸ � A À A B � À Ì HM,k03*"032424Z;=<H � 512R*;>3AuE�0GA�51>O*�03.®X+@Z�C;C(>O2THDÏ;E�2IA<^;57= Ë ¦iÕ ßÄó@X-+@51*;,/HDo_f �/� �×Å�NåbvH�B�0kKLH � � ÃÖÅ"]s8�03^�FIZ;*;,'A451>O*�X Y BsZ;2UA�B;H

*M>@^�0357E�0`^;57=?H/*;2457>O*i>O6åo_f�äâÞ 572M*;H':L0GA�57KLH3N�03*;^Ð24>`]s8 Ë ðOX1ð Õu¦ 512ã^;>O=?57*�0GA�H/^"]s8"E�0GA�51>O*�03.�,'Z�E4KLH/2=?H/HJA�51*;:DÞ 0GAM=?>O2TAM>O*;,/HGX Y B;H<^;>O=<51*�0GA�57*;:D6�03=<51.78�=?H/H'A�2 � ]�8ÐA4B;HaöS>s^;:OHU)+*;^;H � Y B;H/>3E�H/=�N�03*;^B�032e*;>U]W0324H'C±>O51*LA�2�03.7>O*;: � ]s8 Ë�� X � Õ X

�S>�bm24Z�C;C(>O24Hc^;57= Ë ¦iÕ ß ï�X #�H'A � �hl n Ë o_fgäºÞ Õ l'6�>3E 24>O=?H�nÄàÅ�X�# HJA �� ]±H�A�B;H¿*;>3E�=_03.1572�0GA�57>O*>O6 � XyíS2v57*`A4B;H�C;E�>@>O6�>O6 Ë ó@X7ð�ï Õ >O6�îæó3ïGñ|N�A�B;HJE�HS512\0PC;E�>3C±H'E\24=?>s>3A�B?=_0GC Ñ ~ �çÒ�Ó � 69E4>O=à0º24=?>s>3A�B24Z�E�6�03,'H<A�>�0D24=?>s>3A�Bi,'Z�E4KLH3N bu57A4B �� 0DÏ;];E�Ha>O6 Ñ N�03*;^Í0�=_0GC �c~ �ÚÒ�Ó ¦ bu57A�BÐAwbc>�^;51=<H/*;2451>O*�03.51=?03:OH3Ns2TZ;,¨B`A�B�0GA � l �# 512�A�B;HS*;>3E�=_03.7512�0GA�57>O*?=_0GC Ë 51*`24B;>3E4A � 2TbcH/H'C�2\>OZ�AR0º24Z�E46�03,/H Õ X�# HJA ' ß � Ë ��Õ X+@51*;,'H ' 512�,'>%KLH'E4H/^U]�8 � *;H/:L0GA�57KLHc,'Z�E4KLH/2/N ' 512y0S,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*�A�>O6 � NL03*;^ ' � � � Å�X Y B�Z;2yo�� � � �ëÅ�X

#�H'A¿Îu~ '98 Ò�Ó ' ](HºA�B;HP*;>3E�=_03.1572�0GA�57>O*�X ��.75169A�2eA4> � 8 ~ �ÝÒWÓ ' 8 X #�H'A � 8 ß � 8 Ë ��PÕ N�RM~ '9818�Ò�Ó '98](HuA�B;H�=?57*;51=_03.�^;H'2451*;:OZ;.10GE�512�0GA451>O*�N � 818 Ü '9818 ](HeA�B;He2TA4E�57,'A¿A4E�03*;246�>3E�= >O6 � 8 N �ÝßtÞ�l ' N � 8 ß�Î " Ë � Õ N03*;^ � 8 8 ß R " Ë � 8 Õ XY B;H'E�H?572#03*ÍH'è(H','A�57KLH<51*LA�H/:3E[03. Ì H/51.å^;57K@5124>3E !ë24Z;,[BÍA�B�0GA#o�� ��ä !tßÝÎ " Ë o�� Õ X��eH/,k03.7.�A�B�0GAPA�B;H

51*LA�H'E424H/,'A�57>O*-C;E�>s^;Z;,'Aebu57A�B � ؽ,k>@H !?,/57H/*�A42º512R^;H'Ï�*;H/^">O*-03*�8�*;>3E�=_03.(2TZ�E�6�03,/H3X Ì HÔB�0kKLHË o�� � ��ä � 818 Õ9�"� 8 8 �

Ë o�� �@ä � 8 Õ � � 8

�Ë o�� �@ä�!Dä � 8 Õ � � 8 ß Ë o��#ä � Õ�� � � Å

buB;H'E�HÔA4B;HÔA�B;5VE�^-57*;H/r@Z�03.757Aw8`B;>O.1^;2u2451*;,/H � 8 2TbcH'H'C�2�>OZ�A ' 8 XY BsZ;2c]�8?A�B;HS24Z�E�6�03,'HÔ,k032TH�A�B;H'E�Hã512\0PE�0GA�51>O*�03.�,/Z�E4KLHSA�B�E�>OZ;:OBD0#:OH/*;H'E[03.�C(>O51*LA\>O6 � 8 8 N�=?H/HJA�51*;: � 8 8

0GAº=<>O2TAP>O*;,'H3X � 6c,'>OZ�E�24H_57A42Ô57=_03:OHUCW032T24H/2ºA�B�E�>OZ;:OB�0-:OH/*;H'E[03.åC(>O57*�AP>O6 � 03*;^�=<H/H'A�2ÔÞ 0GAº=?>O2IA>O*;,/H3X �

� -±� � $�����'���(� �_�9��� R��� �Ê Ë ' 3 Õ ß � ð � � ���m��h��� ����� Z�EcÏ;E�2TA\:O>L03.±572¿A�>#:O5VKLHS03*`H ��03=<C�.7He>O6 ' bu57A4B;>OZ�AvA�51:OHJEkX Ì Hã03:L0351*_Z;2THãA4B;HSBsZ;*LAkN�]�Z�Ac>O6�,/>OZ�E�2TH3N

*;>�b bcH_,k03*;*;>3AU032T24Z;=?H ' ß ' 3 ^;>@H'2#*;>3AgB�0�KLH`0-A�57:OH'EkX �S>O*;H?A4B;H?.1H/2T2/Ny6�>O.1.1>�bu51*;: Ë :�Xpó Õ N Ë :�Xpó@X � Õ N03*;^ Ë :�X ó@X1: Õ NsbvHS,/>O*;2TA4E�Z;,JA Ë ' � ��!<Õ 2IA[0GE4A�57*;:ºbe5VA�B Ë ' 3 ��! 3 Õ ß Ë '�� % Õ N�]s8_HG��03,'A�.V8<A�B;HS2403=?HeC;E�>s,/H/^;Z�E�HZ;24H/^-51*�B�Z;*�A451*;:?6�>3Ee0aA�57:OH'EkX Ì HP,'>O*�A�57*sZ;HMA�><Z;2THÔA�B;HÔ*;>3A[0GA�51>O* Ë :�Xpó@X1ð�Å Õ X

$v8 Ë :�Xpó@X � X : Õ Nc516Mo����� � ��� �� ��B�032-0�A�57:OH'EkNe2T>�^;>sH/2`o���X Y >m:OH'A�03*ë57=<C�.157,k0GA�51>O*â57*�A4B;HÐ>3A4B;H'E^;57E4H/,'A�57>O*�N�bvHP*;H/H/^�A�><.7>@>3QD0GAe0a24=_03.7.1H'E\]±>OZ;*;^�0GE48LX5±���»�<�#� �Uüå������� �����»�@¡ � � � Ì Hc51*LA4E�>@^;Z;,'Hc24>O=?Hv=?>3E4Hv*;>3A[0GA�57>O*�X Ì HvE�H',k03.1.s>OZ�Ey,/>O*�KLH'*�A�57>O*g>O6WZ;2T51*;:A�B;HU2�03=?H#2T8@=#](>O.�6�>3EÔ0`,/Z�E4KLH3N 03*;^i5VA�2ã2TA4E�57,'AãA4E[03*;246�>3E4= Z;*;^;HJEP24>O=<Hg]�5VE[0GA�57>O*�03.�=_0GC�XÔ)+*;^;Z;,'A457KLH/.V8^;H'Ï�*;H� � ß � ��� � n ��U �Ð03*;^ n ��� Ê ß � Ë U � � Ê � o���yä � � Õ X Ì H".1H'A�� 3 ß %�X Y B�Z;2 � Ê ß � 3 � Ê NRn � ß� Ë U � � o�� � ä � 3 � Ê Õ NW03*;^ � � ß � 3 � äjn � � X

Page 135: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � . �"�

,W>3ERA4B;HP*;H �@Ae.7H/=?=_0�N;032T24Z;=?H � �Ô512u*;>3A�0U*;H'Au6�>3E � � �4X5±���»���»� �¿���Í����� � ¸ o�� ­�©Gªº©?¥|´1È�¤ ° ,奻­�¤J¼qªk¬`¹�¬�¤¨ª o���±ä � � À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Ì HÔC;E�>�KLHP57*;^;Z;,'A�57KLH'.78`A�B�0GAR516�o�� ±ä � � B�032u0UA451:OH'EkN;A�B;H'*�24><^;>sH/2eo�� �� � ä � � � Ê X

+@Z�C;C(>O2THPo���(ä � � ä��m512R*sZ;=<H'E�51,/03.1.78_ATE�57K@5903.|NsbeB;H'E4H ��572uHJè(H/,'A457KLH3X ãH'Ï�*;HºH'è±H/,'A�5VKLH ��]�8

Ñ "� Ë o����ä � � ä � Õ ßto�� �� � ä � � ä�n � � Ê U � � Ê ä �ß R "� � Ê Ë o����� � ä � � � Ê ä R � � Ê Ë � Õ4Õ �

Y B;H/*�o����ä � � ä �j512\Q�.VAu5VèÐo����� � ä � � � Ê ä R ��� Ê Ë � Õ 512\Q�.VAkX �B A À A ÀCB@À Ì H<*;>3A4HaA�B�0GA Ë ó@ðOX1ðOX7ð Õ N�03*;^�57A�2MC;E�>@>O6½N B;>O.1^�6�>3Eº03*�8i24H/rsZ;H/*;,/H?>O6�E�H/.90GA457KLH���51,k0GE4^¾*�Z;=g]±H'E>O*;HgH ��ATE[03,'A�57>O*;2S03*;^i,'>O*�A4E�03,'A�51>O*;2 Ñ � ~ � � � Ê Ò�Ó ' � 03*;^ R � � Ê ~ � � � Ê Ò�Ó ' � � Ê N±bu57A�B Ñ � oqØ|C(>O245VA�57KLH3X)+*;^;H/H/^�N�03.1.�bcHÔZ;24HP57*�A�B;HãC;E�>@>O6 512\A�B�0GA �m572uHJè(H/,'A457KLH3X5±��� 5 � ÿL���������%���±�h���Í��� ¡k� �����%� �@�%�q�®¡a� ���%��ý��s�s�

#�H'A !â](H?03*�H'è(H','A�57KLH � Ø Ì H/51.R^;57K@5124>3E/X ,�>3EP0�C(>O57*�ARÎj>O*Í0-24=<>@>3A�Bi24Z�E�6�03,/H3N�.7H'Aºn � Ë ! Õ ](HaA�B;H,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LAº>O6¿A�B;H<H �;,/HJC;A�51>O*�03.y^;57K@5124>3EÔ>O6¿A�B;HU]�.1>�b Z�Cm>O6 Îm51*ÐA�B;H<57*�KLHJE�24H?57=_03:OHa>O6 ! Ë beB;H/* !�572E�H/^;Z;,'H/^�A�B;512R512RA�B;HMZ;24Z�03. =gZ;.VA�57C�.751,/5VA+8 Õ X5±��� 5(�»� �¿���Í������£ ¤J¥�¦ ©G¼(¹�T §¨¤_¹G´»µ�´�ªk¬ ° ª#«?¤[¤J¥|´�¼@È-¼�¬ ° «<©3Â� ·i©G¥S©-ª¨«?¬�¬�¥®­ ¯ ¬G´�¼�¥ Î ¬+¸?©�ª¨ù ° ¸k©�³[¤'eÀ � ¸

=_0 � Ë � � � Õ ä�n � Ë �PÕ �é𥮭;¤J¼ o��ºä � ¦ ä � T ä � ´�ª F  ¥R©G¥ Î À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Ì HÐ=?0�8h032424Z;=?H � - � X $c.1>�b Z�C ' 0GAºÎ�X Y B;HÐHG�;,/H'C;A451>O*�03.�^;5VK�512T>3EOU B�032D,'>@H�!<,/51H/*LA� ä � ähn � Ò ð � � N±03*;^�A�B;H#2TA4E�57,'AeATE[03*;246�>3E�= >O6 ¦ 03*;^ T Z;*;57>O*4U B�032S*;>3E�=_03.�,'E�>O242457*;:O2/X +@57*;,/Hn � ^;>@H/2R*;>3A�:O>UZ�C"Z;*;^;H'E�]�.7>%bçZ�C�2'NWA�B;HME�H/24Z;.VAe6�>O.7.1>�be2\]�8-57*;^;Z;,'A�51>O*�X �5±��� 5(� 5 NM��� ����¡k���%�»���¿��£ ¤J¥"� , � ,�� §¨¤"©�³¨¬�¼�´¶³0,U©¾ªk¤¨³�©G¼�¥P ´�¼(¤"©3¼±¹j©Í¥½©G¼�È�¤J¼�¥P ´�¼(¤�´�¼�É�� ,gûy´�¥®­� � � � � ß % À o � ä Ë õOÅ �3õ � Õ � ä Ë ï :�ð��'.Lõ # Õ � ä Ë ïOÅ �3õ � Õ$� ­�©�ªM¼�¬<¥|´1È�¤ ° À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ #�H'A �m]±Hº03*-HJè(H/,'A457KLH � Ø Ì H/51.y^;57K@5124>3Eu24Z;,[B�A�B�0GA

oÖä ! ßto � ä Ë õOÅ �3õ � Õ � ä Ë ï :�ð��'.Lõ # Õ � ä Ë ïOÅ �3õ � Õ ä��

512R*�Z;=?H'E�57,k03.1.V8_A4E�57K@5903.®X#�H'A�Îa](He0ãC±>O51*LA¿>O6 É�� N@03*;^a.1H'A �](Hu0Ô.751*;H3X �S>3A4H\A4B�0GA¿n � Ë � Õ � � � mß ï Ò õOÅ �3õ � Ò ó � ï :�ð��'.Lõ # Ò

ïOÅ �3õ � ßÝð � �'.Lõ # X�#�H'A � ](HãA�B;H Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLHP>O6 A�B;H � � � ]�.1>�b�Z�C�>O6 É�� 0GA �ºß � � � 03.1>O*;: � X Y B;H/*

� Ë Ê � oàä !aÕ � ð�ï � �'.Lõ # �� Ë � � oàä !aÕ � ó � . �'.Lõ # �

Page 136: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

. � � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

�S>�b�]�.7>%bÝZ�CÐAwbu51,/Hg0GA �D03.7>O*;: � X�í�C;C�.78@51*;: Ë ó@ðOXpó@X1ð Õ N�A�>?A�B;HºA�>3A�03.�A4E�03*;246�>3E�=�N±buB;51,[BqB�032S*;>3E�=_03.,'E�>O2T2451*;:O2/N�bcHM,/>O*;,/.7Z;^;HPA�B�0GAuoÖä ! 512\Q�.7A/X �D ¤J«<© °GF À Y B;Hc,/>@H�!<,/51H'*�A�2 51* Ë ó@ðOXpó@X ó Õ =_0�8Ô24H/H'= 0u]�57A ]�5C�k0GE4E4H3X Ì Hc,[B;>O24HvA�B;H'=�A�>�=?0GQLH�A�B;Hc03*�03.V8�2457251*DA�B;HP*;HG��Au24H/,'A�57>O*"032R2451=<C�.7HM032uC(>O2T2457]�.7H3X5±����( ���â� � �W� � K��q��þu�Í¡k�������%� % �W� �W� �¾�<���%� � ���%��ý��s�s�Y B�E�>OZ;:OB;>OZ�A Ë ó@ðOXpï Õ .1H'A ' ß ' 3 X

5±����(��»� �¿���Í����� � ¸3' � ´�ªº©?ª¨«?¬�¬�¥®­�§[©3¼±©G¼±© ,¿¥»­;¤'¼ R Ê Ë ' 3 Õº´�ª �㧨¤J ´|©3¼±À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ $v8 Ë ð�ï�X ó Õ Nå0369A�H'Ea0"]�.1>�bàZ�C�03*;^�]�.1>�bÚ^;>�bu*�>O6 ' � bcH`>3];A[0357* 4 � X Ì HDbu51.7.vZ;24H_A�B;HDBsZ;*LA*;>3A[0GA�57>O* Ë 03.7A�B;>OZ;:OBq5VAS512SC(>O2T2457]�.7HºA�B;512ã.9032IASA4E[03*;246�>3E�=?0GA�51>O*"572S*;>3ASCW0GE4AM>O6yA4B;HUB�Z;*LA Õ X Ì HgB�0�KLH#]�8Ë ð�ï�Xpó Õ 0ãE[0GA�57>O*�03.W=?0GC �D~ ' � ��� 4 � N@03*;^<A4B;HeH ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.W.7>@,/Z;2�>O6 ��� Ê 512¿,'>O*�A[0357*;H/^?57* � ä � ä � Ü4 � N�6�>3E � N � Awbc>g24H/,'A�57>O*;2R03*;^ � 0ºÏ;];E�HGNW2TZ;,¨B`A�B�0GA � ä � ä � B�032\*;>3E�=_03.±,JE�>O242457*;:O2/X $c.7>%bu51*;:#Z�C0?C(>O57*�AS>O6�Î � � � � 03*;^"]�.1>�be57*;:D^;>�bu*qA4B;HºÏ;];E�H#A�B�E�>OZ;:OB_Î�N(:O57KLH/2ã0<E�0GA�51>O*�03. =_0GC �"~ ' ���� É��24Z;,[B<A�B�0GAyA�B;HRH ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.;.1>@,'Z;2�>O6 � � Ê 512å,/>O*�A�0351*;H/^a51* � Ü É � N�0ÔZ;*;57>O*<>O6W6�>OZ�Ev.751*;H/2/NObu57A�BU*;>3E�=_03.,'E�>O2T2451*;:O2/X Y B;H/*mÙ ß É��\á � 572ã03*i>3C±H/*Ð24Z�]�24H'AM>O6 ' 3 N(A4BsZ;2 R Ê Ë Ù Õ � R Ê Ë ' 3 Õ X R Ê Ë Ù Õ 572Sí�](H/.75903*]�8�ô�0GE�572TQ�5®{æ2\,/>O*�FIH/,JA�Z�E�H3X �5±����(�� 5 �¿���Í����� � ¸3' � ´�ªº© ��©G¼±©G¼±©�¬+¸M¥|· ¯ ¤MÈG´�µ3¤'¼q´�¼ � A �LÀ �sÀCB�ÀCB@À A � ,�¥®­;¤J¼>' 3 ´�ªãªJ´�« ¯  ·�³[¬�¼W¼(¤[³J¥+¤�¹LÀ* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ $v8 Ë ó@ðOXpï�X1ð Õ N'R Ê Ë ' 3 Õ ß � Ê Ë ' 3 ���\Õ X�)+6�Þ 572�A�B;H\H �;,/HJC;A�51>O*�03.�.7>@,/Z;2�>O6 �'�Ò�Ó ' N3A�B;H/*a03,/,/>3E4^;51*;:A�> Ë ó@X1ð Õ >O6cîòïOïGñ�A�B;H'E�HÔ512u03*�H �;03,'Ae2TH/r@Z;H/*;,'H

Å Ò�Ó =#~ ��51, Ë �'åÕvÒ�Ó � � Ë Þ ���\ÕyÒ�Ó � Ê Ë ' 3 ���\ÕåÒ�Ó Å

#�H'A�� ]±HÔA�B;HM,/>3QLH'E�*;H'.|X)+6�bcH#.1H'A � Ü ��51, Ë �'�Õ ]±H#A�B;H#24Z�]�:3E�>OZ�Ci:OH/*;H'E[0GA4H/^Ð]�8�Þ"N(A4B;H/* Ë 2451*;,'H �¾03*;^ � 0GE�H#,[B�0351*q2457*;:OZ@Ø

.90GE457A�57H/2 Õ N�bcHMB�0kKLH

Å Ò�Ó � Ò�Ó � � Ë Þ ���\ÕåÒ�Ó �! Ë � Õ ��� 8 �

! Ë �;Õ ��� Ò�Ó Å

bu57A�B�H/57A�B;HJEeH/*;^",'>O=<C(>O*;H/*LAu=_0GC;C�51*;:gA�>aA4B;HP:OH/*;H'E�0GA�>3Ee57* �� � ��� � Ë 6�>3EåÎ`ß � N �;Õ X#�H'A%U � N"U � ]±HãA4B;H Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLHM>%KLH'E � N �#Ë 57*_A�B;HS*;>3A[0GA�57>O*D>O6 Ë ð # Xæï�X ó Õ4Õ X � *;HMHk032457.78<,¨B;H',[Q@2RA4B�0GAcA�B;H

51=?03:OHM>O6�U � 57* � 512 Ë ð � ï Õ 03*;^�A4B;HP51=?03:OHM>O6�U � 57* � 512 Ë ð � ó Õ X Y BsZ;2 =#512e2TZ�E®FIH/,'A�5VKLH3X �5±����(���( ��� �W� � K��±� � ¸+' ´�ªe¥®­;¤Sª¨ù ° ¸/©s³[¤ ¸ ° ¬�« � A ��À �sÀCB@À B@À A � ûå´�¥»­ ;Uß : ¥®­;¤J¼ '23<´�ªeª¨´�« ¯  ·?³[¬�¼�¼�¤[³J¥+¤�¹ ,©G¼±¹ 'ç­�©GªM¼(¬<¥|´1È�¤ ° À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ #�H'A Ñ Ê 03*;^ Ñ � ](H Ë 032MZ;24Z�03. Õ A�B;HaÏ;E�2IAPAwbc>-B�Z;*LA#2TA�H'C�2'X Ë ' � ��� ä �UÕ 512Ô0-24=?>s>3A�Bq]W03*�03*�0�X#�H'A Ñ � ]�.7>%b Z�CiA�B;H � Ê C(>O57*�AÔ03.7>O*;: � Ü ' � Ë A�B;572ã512M*;>3Aº0`BsZ;*LAº2IA�H'C Õ N�24> Ë ' � � � ä � ä �ºÕ 512Ô032

Page 137: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � . ��2

51* Ë ó@ðOXpó@X ó Õ X"n Ê ß � 3 ß � 3� � X � Ê B�032#A�B;H`6�>3E�= Ë bu57A�BÍE�H'2TC(H/,JAaA�> � Ê Õ Ë ï � ó � ó Õ X Y B�Z;2U]�8 Ë :�Xæï�X : Õ Nn � ß ï � � ä�ï � 3 � � ß ï :�ð��'.Lõ # N�03*;^in � ß Ë ð��Oó Õ Ë õOÅ �3õ � Õ ß ïOÅ �3õ � X $v8 Ë ó@ðOXpó@X ó Õ N�o����cä � � B�032M*;>A�57:OH'EkX Ì HP,'>O*;,/.1Z;^;H ' B�032R*;><A�57:OH'E\]s8 Ë ó@ðOX7ðOX1ð Õ X '23 572u2457=<C�.78`,'>O*;*;H/,'A�H/^�]�8 Ë ó@ðOXpï�Xpó Õ X �5±��� J �����(���@�

���� �W� � K������Í��ÿO�±��)k��ÿ3�%� �%�"��þe�������W���»¡k���+�

5±��� �»� 7D�:9y� ���%���±��� Ì H<2�0�8ÐA�B�0GAg0�24Z�E�6�03,/H � 572 � "j� ������K���� 516vA�B;HJE�H?512P03*Í>3C(H/*Í2TZ�]�24H'Ag>O6 �buB;51,[B�512R512T>O=?>3E4C�B;51,ãA�>a0aC;E�>s^;Z;,'AMÙ �-ê Ê X

íS,/,/>3E4^;51*;:_A�>ÐîVð � ñ|N±zq578�03*;5724B;5�B�032S,/>O*�FIH','A�Z�E�H/^ÐA�B�0GAã:O57KLH'*q03*�8�E�03*�Q">O*;H#.1>O:_^;H/. ��H����/> ' A4B;H'E�H512Ô0DÏ�*;5VA�H �HJA[03.1Hg,/>�KLH'Eº>O6 ' 3 beB;57,[B�512Ô0'!?*;HgE�Z;.1H'^�X Ì HU24B;>�b B;HJE�HaA�B�0GAP03*L8ÐA451:OH'ETض69E�H/H ' be5VA�B ' 32457=<C�.78`,/>O*;*;H','A�H/^ Ë 6�>3EuH �;03=<C�.1HSA�B;HÔ24Z�E�6�03,/HÔ>O6 Ë ó@ðOXpï�Xæï ÕcÕ 572e0U,/>OZ;*LA�H'ETضH ��03=<C�.7H3X

5±��� � 5 �����Í������£ ¤'¥ ' §¨¤g© ° ©G¼ F ¬�¼�¤ºÂ1¬�È�¹�¤'Â*�¤�����¬ ,R©G¼±¹ �ÚÜ ' 3 ©G¼j¬ ¯ ¤'¼Ðª¨ù�§Jªk¤'¥u¹�¬�«g´�¼(©G¥w¤[¹�§'·´�«<©%È�¤¨ª#¬+¸ ê Ê�À � ¸Ô¥®­;¤g³[¬G« ¯ Â1¤J«?¤'¼�¥e¬+¸ � ³¨¬�¼�¥w©G´�¼;ªP©�¹G´�µ�´�ª�¬ ° ,奮­;¤J¼ 'ç­�©�ªg©<¥®´9È�¤ ° À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ íS2T24Z;=?HaA4B�0GAPA�B;H'E4H?512P0�^;>O=?51*�03*LAP=?0GC Ñ ~�Ù �iê Ê Ò±Ó �?N�03*;^�A�B�0GAPÞ Ü � � Ü ' 572º03*57ETE�H/^;Z;,/5V]�.1HM,/Z�E4KLH3X@# H'A � ](HãA�B;Hã,/.7>O24Z�E�HM>O6 A�B;HM51=_03:OHe>O6�0g:OH/*;H'E[03.�ê Ê Xå)+6 � =?H/H'A�2\Þ 0GAe0g:OH/*;H'E�03.C(>O57*�Au>O6�Þ"N;A�B;H/* Ë o��ºä�Þ Õ9��� ��ÅU]�8 Ë � X1ðOð Õ N;03*;^�A�BsZ;2uÞ 512u0UA451:OH'EkX

� A�B;H'E4bu5124H�H'KLH'E48 � CW032424H'2 A�B�E�>OZ;:OBº0u,/>O=?=<>O*ãC±>O51*LAWÎ`ß � � Þ"X�#�H'A ' 8�Ò�Ó ' H ��A4E�03,'A�A�B;H¿^;5VK�512T>3EU×>%KLH'EcÎ�N�24>`A�B�0GA � 8 ,/Z�A�2M>OZ�A U_X Y B;H/* � 8 03*;^¾Þ 8 0GE�HU^;512»FI>O57*�AÔ>O* � Ë B;H'E�HgA�B;HgC;E�51=<HU57*;^;51,k0GA4H/22TA4E451,'AåA4E[03*;246�>3E4= Õ X ãH'Ï�*;H � 2T>ÔA�B�0GA�o��ãä8Uiä � Þ 8 ß Ñ " Ë o��vä � Þ Õ X �S>3A�H � Ã�Åã2451*;,'H ' 512å.7A/X �S>%b� 8 =?H/HJA�2@U�51*_0M2451*;:O.7He24=<>@>3A�BUC(>O51*LAkNs03*;^?24>P]�8 Ë�� X1ðOð Õ N Ë o��Mä>U Õ ��� 8 ß Ë o��cä � Þ Õ ��� ��Å�X Y B�Z;2o��ºä � Þ 512u03*�A45VØw03=aC�.1H3X�)wAe572u*;>3ARQ�.VA\]s8�,/>O*;2TA4E4Z;,'A�51>O*�NW03*;^�2T> � Þ 512u0a2TC±H/,/5903.�A�57:OH'Eu6�>3E�o���X �5±��� ��( J �W���K K»�����y����¼�©�!h¼(¤ ° ùsÂ1¤�¹ ° ©G¼ F ¬�¼(¤PÂ1¬�ÈD¹�¤' *e¤�����¬gª¨ù ° ¸/©s³[¤M­�©�ª#©?¥|´1È�¤ ° À

5±��� � ��-£ ¤J¥9'ݧ¨¤º© ° ©G¼ F ¬�¼(¤ÔÂ1¬[È`¹�¤J *�¤����%¬OÀ � ¸ 'ݹ�¬�¤JªM¼(¬�¥�­�©Gµ3¤g©<¥®´9È�¤ ° ©G¼(¹ R �� �Ê Ë ' 3 Õ ß � ð � ,奻­�¤J¼¼(¬�¬ ¯ ¤J¼"ªJù;§Jª�¤J¥\¬I¸ 'ç­;©�ªº© 2�¼�´�¥+¤ ¤J¥w©GÂ1¤g³[¬�µO¤ ° û�­s´¶³¨­D´�ª#©�!�¼�¤ ° ù@Â1¤�¹LÀ

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ #�H'A ' ]±Hº0<2457=<C�.78D,/>O*;*;H','A�H/^�E[03*�Q�>O*;Hº.7>O:<^;H/.���H����/>;NWbe5VA�B�*;><A451:OH'EkX +@Z�C;C(>O24H � Ü ' B�0320"Ï�*;57A�H �H'A[03.7HD,'>%KLH'EgbuB;51,[B�572<0'!<*;H_E�Z;.1H/^�X�SE�>3C;C�57*;:iC±>O51*LA�2g69E�>O= �?NåbcHD=_0k8Í03242TZ;=?H � Ü ' 3 X$v8 Ë ó@ðOX .;X ó Õ � � B�032�,/>s^;51=?H'*;2451>O*q0GAe.1Hk032TAuAwbc>;N(03*;^�A�B�Z;2 � 512e2451=<C�.V8D,/>O*;*;H/,'A�H'^ Ë 24H/HºA�B;HPC;E4>@>O6�>O6Ë � Xæï Õ4Õ X Y BsZ;2 ' 572e0'!<*;HÔE�Z;.7H/^�N�,/>O*LA4E[03^;51,JA�51*;: Ë ó@ðOX .;Xpï Õ X �D ¤J«<© °GF À ãH'Ï�*;57A451>O* Ë ó@ðOX .;X1ð Õ 512-^;Z;H�A4>hzq578�03*;512TB;5|X *M>O.1.��0GE-B�032�24Z;:O:OH/2IA�H/^éA�B�0GA�57* K�57H'b >O6ºA�B;H^;H'Ï�*;5VA�51>O*">O6 E4Z;.1H/^�N Ë 24H/Hº6�>3E�H ��03=<C�.7H Ë ) HgX7ðOX1ð Õ >O6\îæó3õGñ Õ 5VA�572uC(HJE�B�0GC�2S=?>3E�HM*�0GA�Z�E[03.�A�>_03242TZ;=?Hº>O*;.78A�B;HaH �;572TA�H/*;,/Ha>O6c0D]�5VE[0GA�57>O*�03.�=_0GC Ñ ~�Ù �Ðê Ê Ò�Ó ' 3 X Ì Ha^;>�*;>3AMQ�*;>�b 576 Ë ó@ðOX .;Xpï Õ B;>O.1^;2ÔZ;*;^;H'EA�B;572RbcH/0GQLH'ES03242TZ;=<C;A�51>O*�X

Page 138: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

. � � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

� -�- � � �����$�

�( ����&L�W�e�W����$g�������� ���� �G�����$

Y B;H?6�>O.1.7>%bu51*;:"24H','A�51>O*�C;E4H'CW0GE�H/2#A�B;H<bc0�8¾6�>3EºA�B;H_,/.103242457Ï�,/0GA�51>O*�A�B�0GAº0GC;C(Hk0GE42#51* � ó3ï�X�,�57E�2TAPbcH51*LA4E�>s^;Z;,/HÔA4B;HÔ*;>3A�57>O*->O6 ,/>O=<C�.1H'=?H/*LA�2e03*;^�:O57KLHãA�B;HM,/>O*;*;H/,'A�57>O*-](HJA+bvH/H/*�A�57:OH'E�2R03*;^�,/>O=<C�.7H/=?H/*LA�2/XÌ HãÏ;E�2TAuE�H/,k03.7.�A4B;HÔ^;H'Ï�*;5VA�51>O*->O6�0a,/>O=aC�.1H/=?H'*�AkN@,/6½X � B�0GC;A�H'EPð # >O6cî}ó � ñ¶N;6�>3Eu=?>3E�HM^;H'A[0357.12/X

5 5(�»�47��:9������%�����¿� #�H'A ¦ ](HÔ0a*;>3E4=_03.(K30GE451H'Aw8D03*;^ ! ß ÞÝä � 0U]±>OZ;*;^�0GE48LN;beB;HJE�HPÞ 512\E�H/^;Z;,/H/^03*;^ � 572\0ºC�Z�E�HS](>OZ;*;^�0GE48LX Ì Hã2�0k8_o_fÍä ! 512��±Ø½,'>O=<C�.1H/=<H/*�A4H/^�N�6�>3ER0ºC(>O245VA�57KLHS57*�A4H/:OH'E ��N�576�A4B;H'E�H512u0a^;5VK�5724>3EeÞ 8 N�24Z;,[B�A�B�0GA

Ë ð Õ ��Þ 8 �hl Ò ��o_f?læNË ó Õ ��Þ 8 -çÒ ��Þ Ò � Ë �aätð Õ � 03*;^Ë ï Õ o_f�ä�Þ 8 512R.1,3X

� *m0�Ï;E�2TA#H'*;,/>OZ;*�A4H'EkN Ë óOó@X1ð Õ =_0k8¾2TH/H/= 0-]�5VAP]�5 �k0GE4E�H3X�,W>3Eº>OZ�E#,/.10324245VÏ�,k0GA�51>O*¾51* � ó3ï�N bvH?*;H/H/^>O*;.78�0U2451=<C�.7Hã6�>3E�=�X2,�>3ERA�B;HME�Hk03^;H'E�2u,/>O*LKLH/*;51H/*;,'H3N�bcHME�H/2TA�0GA�HMA4B;HP^;H'Ï�*;5VA�51>O*�51*-A�B;572u,/0324H3~5 5(�»��� 7�� 9y�����%�»��� � ð

�ÿL��� � K������@���j�Wþ������@����ÿO���à� �»���»¡/���O¢%� Ë ¦�� Þ Õ 032?51* Ë óOó@X7ð Õ X Ì H"2�0k8

o_f�ä�Þ 512Uð'ؽ,/>O=aC�.1H/=?H'*�A�H'^i576�A�B;H'E4Ha572P0_E�H/^;Z;,/H'^Í^;57K�5724>3E T 24Z;,[B¾A4B�0GAÔo_fëäâÞ ä T 512 � 0GE4A451H'EkNA4E�5VK�5103.|N;03*;^�.7>O:a,/03*;>O*;51,k03.®Xå)+*-A�B;HM*;>3A[0GA�57>O*->O6 Ë óOó@X1ð Õ N;Þ 8 ßtÞÝä T XY B;Ha6�>O.7.1>�be57*;:�E�H/2TZ;.7AkN 03*;^�57A42MC;E�>s>O6½N 0GE4H<^;Z;HaA4> +@B;>3Q@Z�E�>%K±X Ì H<.1H/0GE�*;H/^�>O6åA�B;H/= 69E�>O= íS.1H/242T51>

� >3E4A�5|~5 5(� 5 �¿�@�Í������£ ¤J¥/'Ú§J¤`© ©G¼(¬�ª¨ù ° ¸/©�³¨¤`¬+¸ *\´¶³�© ° ¹-¼�ù@«<§¨¤ ° ¬G¼(¤0,Ô©G¼±¹ ! ©G¼�¤»ÆS¤¨³J¥®´»µ3¤ �MúT¹3´�µ�´�ªk¬ ° ,ª¨ùW³¨­i¥®­�©G¥ o��?ä ! ´�ªUÂ1¬�Ⱦ³�©G¼(¬�¼W´¶³�©GÂ7À � ¸ o��aä ! ­�©�ª`©�¥|´1È�¤ ° ,e¥®­;¤J¼ o��<ä ! ­�©�ª_© ð , ó , ï , . ,Ô¬ °õ ú4³[¬G« ¯ Â1¤J«?¤'¼�¥½À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ íS69A4H'E�24,k03.751*;:ã03*;^g0GC;C�.V8�51*;: Ë ð # X ó Õ >O6�îæó � ñ�bcHv=_0k8º032T24Z;=?Hvo���ä ! 512�03*LA�5Vض*;H/6W03*;^#=_0 �;57=_03.1.V8.1>O:�,k03*;>O*;51,/03.|X Y B;H'E4H<512Ô03*¾HG��A4E[03,JA�51>O* RÔ~ �ÚÒ�Ó ' 24Z;,[B�A�B�0GAÔo���ä ! ß R " Ë o��Uä !<Õ 512M.1,GN 03*;^Þ ß � ! 512P*;>O*@ؽH/=<C;Aw8LN�03*;^m,/>O*LA[0357*;H/^�57*�A�B;H_24=?>s>3A�B�.7>@,/Z;2/X $c8 Ë ð # X ó Õ >O6Mîæó � ñ¿57A#572ºH/*;>OZ;:OBÍA�>24B;>�b o��`ä!Ðßto��Dä�Þ ä � B�032�0DðONWó@N�ï�N1.a>3E�õ�ض,/>O=<C�.1H'=?H/*LAkX

#�>@>3QD0GARA�B;HÔ*�0GA4Z�E[03.�E�H/2TA4E451,'A�57>O*-H �;03,'Au24H/r@Z;H'*;,/H

Å Ò±Ó 6 � Ë Ò ��o�� Ò Ë �<ätð Õ Þ Ò � Ë �?ätð Õ � OÕ¿Ò�Ó 6 � Ë Ò ��o�� Ò ��Þ Ò � Ë �<äëð Õ � OÕvÒWÓÒ�Ó 6 � Ë Ò ��o � Ò � Ë �<äëð Õ � l � OÕcÒ�Ó Å �

�S>�b o �hä � l ��512 �±Ø¶,/>O=<C�.7H/=?H/*LA�H/^�N 6�>3Eº24>O=?H � � � ð � ó � ï � . � õ�#]�8 Ë ð # X . Õ >O6ãîæó � ñ|X Ì H<0GE�:OZ;H*;H �@AuA�B�0GA

� Ê Ë � � 6 � Ë Ò ��o�� Ò Ë �<ätð Õ Þ Ò � Ë �<äëð Õ � OÕ4Õ ß � Ê Ë �=� o��`ä � Ò Ë �<ätð Õ Ë o��_ä! Õ �OÕ ß Å �

Page 139: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � . � 0

)+6 o��Mä ! 512R03*LA�5Vؽ03=<C�.1H3NsA�B;512\B;>O.1^;2\]�8O*P0kb\03=_0GA[0�Ø Hã51H/BLbcH/:#KG03*;5124B;57*;:�î}ó@ð/ñ¶N�2T>UbcHã=_0k8`03242TZ;=?Ho��eä ! 512¿*sZ;=?HJE�51,k03.7.78UA4E�5VK�5903.®X�#�H'A � ß o��#ä � Ò Ë �Ôäjð Õ Ë o��#ä ! Õ � X�� Ê R�" Ë �ºÕ ß ÅP]s8�*P0kb\03=_0GA[0�ØHã51H'B�bcH':<K303*;5724B;51*;:;XåöSH/*;,/HMbcHº0GE4HME�H'^;Z;,/H/^�A�>a24B;>%bu51*;: � Ê Ë '�� R�" Ë �PÕ4Õ ßéÅ�X

�S>�b R�" Ë �ºÕ ß 6 � Ë o��Mä � Ò Ë �aäâð Õ Ë o��Mä !<Õ �OÕ X@+@51*;,/HMA�B;H �¿51,/0GE�^-*�Z;=#](H'Eu>O6 ' 512R>O*;H3N � Ò Ë �<äð Õ Ë o��#ä !aÕ � 512S03=aC�.1H3N±03*;^4*Ô0kb\03=_0GA[0�Ø Hã51H/BLbcH/:?KG03*;5124B;57*;:D0GC;C�.151H'2/N(Z;*;.1H'242 Ò Ë �`ä ð Õ Ë o��#ä !<Õ 57251*LA�H/:3E�03.|N;51*�beB;57,¨B-,k0324H Ë óOó@X ó@X1ð Õ 0GC;C�.751H/2'XY BsZ;2<bvH-=_0k8ÍÏ�*;^ 0¾^;57K@5124>3EaÞ 8 >O* � Nc2TZ;,¨BhA4B�0GA ��Þ 8 �Öl Ò ��o��\l 03*;^ho���äéÞ 8 512U.1,-57*â0

*;H/57:OB�]±>OZ�E�B;>@>s^�>O6�Þ"X��S>�btA4B;HM^;5VK�5724>3E\o��?ä Ë ð Ò �[Õ Þ 8 ä � Ë Þçä �UÕ 512\*;>3AcQ�.VA\51*�0#*;H/51:OBL](>OZ�E�B;>s>@^>O6�Þ"X $v8aA�B;Hã,/>O*;*;H/,'A�H'^;*;H/242 Y B;H/>3E�H'=�N Ë ð � X . Õ >O6�îæó � ñ¶Ns57A\6�>O.7.1>�be2vA�B�0GAcA4B;512c^;57K@5124>3Ev512cQ�.VA\0�bc0�8_69E4>O=Þ"X Y B�Z;2�o��`ä�Þ 8 512R.1,Ô03*;^�o��Dä�!mB�032u0<,/>O=<C�.7H/=?H/*LAkX �5 5(� 5(�»� �¿�@�Í�����-£ ¤J¥�¦ §¨¤<© �Ôú ¸k©�³J¥+¬ ° ´|©3Â�Â1¬�È ©G¼(¬DµG© ° ´¶¤J¥|·-©G¼±¹ � ©D¼�ù@«?¤ ° ´¶³�©GÂ� ·-¥ ° ´�µ�´|©3Â�´�¼�¥+¤½È ° ©GÂ�q¤J´� ¹3´�µ�´�ªk¬ ° ¬�¼`¦âÀ Á ­;¤J¼ � � Ë ¦�� 6 f Ë o_f�ä � Õ4Õ ß Å ¸k¬ ° ©3Â� �åÃ�Å À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ � 57*;^;Z;,/H/2ã0<,'8@,/.157, (Ô03.7>O512u,/>%KLHJEkN �H'A�03.1HP57*",/>@^;57=?H/*;2457>O*�>O*;H3N �c~ TÚÒ�Ó ¦ 24Z;,[B"A�B�0GA�o# âß� " Ë o_fâä � Õ X\)I*�CW0GETA�51,/Z;.10GEkN T 512�.7>O:S,±03*;>;N±03*;^"24> � � Ë76 Ë o# Õ4Õ ß�Å�X 6 f Ë o_fâä � Õ 572S0?^;57E�H','A24Z;=?=?03*;^�>O6 ��" Ë76 Ë o# Õ4Õ X �Y B;HÔ6�>O.7.1>�be57*;:)#�H/=?=_0�NsE�H'Ï�*;H/2 Ë óOó@X ó Õ N�57*�0g2TC(H',/5903.�,k0324HGX¿íS.1.(bvHÔ*;H/H'^�6�>3EuA4B;512\CW0GC(H'Eu512\A�B;HM,k0324H

Ë óOó@Xæï�X1ð Õ N@buB;51,[B-bu51.7.(](HÔZ;24H/^�57* Ë ó3ï�X � Õ X

5 5(��( �����Í������£ ¤'¥ 'Ú§¨¤_©-Â1¬[Èй�¤J *�¤����%¬q¬+¸ ° ©G¼ F ¬�¼�¤kÀ .Wù ¯L¯ ¬%ªk¤ o��aä � ´�ª ¯  ¥M©G¼(¹�Ò Ë o��<ä �MÕ´�ªa©G« ¯ Â1¤0,uû�­;¤ ° ¤ �Ä´�ª#´�¼�¥+¤½È ° ©3Â�©G¼(¹`¼�¬�¼�ú4¤J« ¯ ¥®·LÀ �ì³[¬�¼W¥½©G´»¼;ªa©G¥\«?¬%ªJ¥R¥®­ ° ¤[¤#ª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ª<¬+¸;'�Àg£ ¤J¥Î - � - = §J¤Ô¥»­�¤P´�¼±¹3´¶³[¤¨ªº¬+¸Ô¥»­;¤Jªk¤Mª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ª �½ûc¤g©GÂ�Â1¬�ût´�¼±¹s¤�� ð � À

Á ­;¤'¼ o��#ä �Ö­�©�ªº©3¼ � ú4³[¬�« ¯ Â1¤J«?¤J¼W¥ ¦âÀ � ¬ ° ¤[¬Gµ3¤ °Ë ð Õ �jßàð ,ã©G¼±¹ o��aä �ì´�ª ¯  ¥ ¸k¬ ° ©3¼�·q³¨¬�« ¯ ¬�¼�¤J¼�¥'� ¬+¸ã¦ ,R´�¼Í¥»­�¤`³�©�ªk¤ =_ßàð �w¥»­�©3¥R´�ªgû�­�¤J¼

¥®­;¤ ° ¤g© ° ¤#©3¥¿«_¬%ª¨¥v¥®ûc¬aª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ªP©GÂ1¬G¼@È � � À�c¥®­;¤ ° ûy´�ªk¤ � ­�©�ªg¥®­ ° ¤[¤gª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ª5,y¦ ­�©Gª?¬�¼(¤_¬�¥®­;¤ ° ³¨¬�« ¯ ¬�¼�¤J¼�¥ � , o��aä � ä � ´�ªgÂ1³<´�¼�©

¼(¤J´9È�­�§¨¬�ù ° ­�¬�¬k¹`¬+¸ � ,v©G¼±¹ �Ö«_¤[¤J¥®ª �ì©G¥u¬�¼�¤ ¯ ¬�´�¼W¥½À � ¬ ° ¤[¬�µ3¤ °Ë ó Õ �-ß ó ©G¼±¹Ô¦ ß � ä � ,¿û�­;¤J¼ � ß =Ôßéó À

�c¥®­;¤ ° ûy´�ªk¤R¦ ß � ä Ë � �� Õ�À � ¬ ° ¤[¬�µ3¤ °Ë ï Õ �-ßçï ,�û�­;¤J¼ Î`ß � ß ï ÀË . Õ �-ß . ,�û�­;¤J¼ Î`ß . ©3¼±¹ � ß ï ,Ë�� Õ �-ßçõ ,�û�­;¤J¼ Î`ß � ©3¼±¹ � ß ï À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ � ,k03*_,/>O*LA[0351*`0GA¿=?>O2TAåA�B�E�H/H�2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457A�57H/2�]�8_03^�FIZ;*;,'A451>O*�X�$v8aA�B;HuC;E�>@>O6(>O6 Ë óOó@X ó Õ NObcHeQ@*;>%bA�B�0GAã576åo � ä ã5Vè � Ë % Õ Ë 24H/H Ë #åX ó ÕTÕ B�032ã03* �±Ø½,/>O=<C�.7H/=?H/*LAkN±A4B;H/*i2T>D^;>sH/2So��Uä � XSzq>3E�H'>%KLH'EM2457*;,/H

Page 140: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

. ��+ ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

bcH<0GE�H<.75169A�57*;:�03*¾H'.1H/=?H'*�AP>O6Pl Ò ��o � lpN�bcH<B�0kKLH?0D.1>@,/03.yC�57,'A�Z�E�H<0GE�>OZ;*;^ � X �S>%b � 572º0D,/>3Cs8i>O6É Ê N�03*;^ÐA4B;HU^;H'24,'E�5VC;A�51>O*Ð>O6 ¦ 6�>O.1.7>%bu2S69E�>O= A�B;Hg^;5VK�512T51>O*q51*LA�>`,k0324H/2ã57*ÐA�B;H#C;E�>s>O6�>O6 Ë ð # X . Õ >O6uîæó � ñ¶X�S>3A�HU51*ÐCW0GE4A�51,'Z;.90GEãA�B�0GAÔ516 � ß ¦ Ò � N�A4B;H/* � � � ß×ð��¨Î¾beB;H'* �jß óD03*;^ � � � ß×ð�� $ �jbuB;H/*� - ï�N�beB;HJE�H $ 572¿A�B;HS51*;^;HG�`>O6�A�B;H�C(>O57*�AvbuB;H'E�H � =?H'H'A�2 � X � *_A�B;HS>3A4B;H'EcB�03*;^ � ��� - ð�� $ N�be5VA�BH/rsZ�03.157Aw8D51*DA�B;HP,/0324HPA�B�0GAuo��#ä � ä � 512R.1,P57*"0a*;H'51:OBL](>OZ�E�B;>s>@^">O6 � 03*;^ � ß Ë ; �� Õ � N;6�>3E�24>O=<H; - ðOX Y B;HUE�H'24Z;.7AÔ*;>%b 6�>O.7.1>�be2'N�H �;,/HJC;AP57*ÐA�B;HU,k0324H �mß ó@XºöSH'E�HgbcHU=_0GQLHºA�B;HU03^¾B;>s,U0GE�:OZ;=?H/*LAA�B�0GARbcHPB�0kKLHÔ0a,/.103242457Ï�,/0GA�51>O*�,'6½X Ë ó3ï�Xæõ Õ 03*;^-A�B�0GA � 512RA�B;HM51=_03:OHã>O6 A4B;HP>3]�K�51>OZ;2\Ï;];E�H3X ��v�W�G�»ÿ N��W�»��¡3�Ì Hº*;>�b E�H/,k03.7.�A�B;HP^;H'Ï�*;57A�57>O*q>O6y0aA�>3E�57,PK30GE451H'Aw8LXcíS2ebcHP24B�03.1. 24H/Hº57* � ó3ï�NWA�B;HJ8"0GE�Hº6�Z;*;^�03=<H/*�A�03.

A�>gA�B;HM,/.903242T57Ï�,k0GA�57>O*->O6 03.1.�.1>O:U^;H/. ��H����'>O2/X¿íS.724>abcHãC;E�H/2TH/*�A�0UE�H'24Z;.7Ae0G](>OZ�A\A�>3E�57,MKG0GE�57H'A�51H'2\buB;51,[B�572E[0GA�B;HJEe24Z�ETC;E�512457*;:;N�57*-.751:OBLAe>O6 A4B;HM]±>OZ;*;^;H/^;*;H/242�E�H'24Z;.7A�2u>O6 íS.7H �;H/HJK�î}ó�ñ¶X

5 5(� 7D�:9y� ���%���±��� ítCW035VE Ë '���¦iÕ 512v2�0357^?A�>P]±HeA�>3E�57,3Ns576 'gá ¦ 512c0P,'>3Cs8<>O6�0ÔA�>3E�Z;2/N@03*;^?A�B;H�*�0GA�Z�E�03.03,'A�57>O*->O6�A�B;HÔA�>3E4Z;2u>O*�5VA�24H/.76½N�H ��A�H'*;^;2uA�><03*�03,'A�57>O*->O* ' X

Y >3E�57,¿CW0357E42y0GE�HcKLH'E48#Hk032T51.78PZ;*;^;H'E�2TA4>@>@^�X ��57A�B;HJE�>O*;Hc=?0�8PZ;24HcA�B;H\0GC;C;E�>L03,[B<>O6�6�03*;2/NL51*#buB;51,[BU,k0324H0�CW035VE Ë '���¦iÕ 512PH'2424H/*LA�5903.7.78i2TC(H',/57Ï�H/^�]�8ÐA+bv>-CW0357E�2P>O6¿E�H/.10GA�57KLH/.V8"C;E�51=<H<51*LA�H/:OHJE�2 Ë 2TH/H?6�>3EºHG��03=<C�.7HîVð�ÅGñ Õ >3E<>O*;HD=_0k8mZ;*�Awbu512TA<0ÐA�>3E451,`CW0357EkNåZ;2451*;:�0i24H'E451H/2a>O6uA4E[03*;2T6�>3E�=_0GA�57>O*;2U>O6RAw8@C(H Ë 0 Õ 03*;^�A�B�Z;2,'E�H/0GA�H Ë '���¦¾Õ 51*;^;Z;,'A�5VKLH/.78LN�2TH/H Ë ó3ï�X # Õ 03*;^qA�B;H#C;E�>@>O6å>O6 Ë ó3ï�X1ð%ó Õ X Y B;HUE4H/24Z;.7A42ã]±H/.1>�b 57.1.1Z;2IA4E[0GA�HºA�B;57251^;H/0�X

+@H'KLH'E�03.�C±H/>3C�.1HÔB�0�KLHÔ032TQLH/^�A�B;HP6�>O.7.1>�be57*;:arsZ;H/2TA�57>O*�~ ã>@H'2uA�B;HM24H'A

� o �� l ' 512u0a.7>O:a^;H'.���H����/>?24Z�E�6�03,'Hº>O6 E[03*�QD>O*;H �

2�0GA�5724698Dí � � 6�>3Ee]±>OZ;*;^;H/^�24H'r@Z;H/*;,/H'2MxÌ HãC;E�>�KLH

5 5(� � NÔ�%���å�±¡k���%���±�¿�Ë ð Õ Á ­;¤Pªk¤J¥

� o �� l 'é´�ªº©?¥+¬ ° ´½³Mª¨ù ° ¸/©�³¨¤g¬+¸ ° ©G¼ F ¬�¼�¤0,�ûy´�¥®­�¥|ûv¬<ª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥®´½¤¨ª �

´�ªº¹s¤J¼;ªk¤Ô´»¼q¥»­�¤Mªk¤J¥u¬+¸ ° ¤�©GÂ�¼Wùs«<§J¤ ° ªº©3¥¿Â1¤[©�ª¨¥±¸k¬�ù ° ,c©3¼±¹Ë ó Õ Á ­;¤Pªk¤J¥

� o �� l 'ç´�ªP©_¥w¬ ° ´¶³Mª¨ù ° ¸k©�³[¤g¬+¸ ° ©G¼ F ¬�¼(¤ �

´�ªº¹s¤J¼;ªk¤Ô´»¼q¥»­�¤Mªk¤J¥u¬+¸ ¯ ¬%ª¨´�¥|´�µ3¤ ° ¤�©GÂ�¼�ù@«<§¨¤ ° ª/À

Page 141: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � . ��.

5 5(� � �¿�@�Í������£ ¤J¥ 'ë§J¤�©Ô¥w¬ ° ´¶³\ª¨ù ° ¸/©s³[¤�¬+¸�*c´½³�© ° ¹ã¼�ù@«<§¨¤ ° ¬�¼(¤0, ûy´�¥®­g¥»­ ° ¤[¤cª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© °�¯ ¬�´�¼W¥»ªe¬+¸c´�¼±¹s¤��Î , � ©G¼±¹ = À

Á ­;¤'¼o �� ß Ë Îgä � ä = Õ �

Ë Î � = Õ �

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ �S>�b A�B;H'E�H�0GE�HeA�B�E�H'HeA�>3E�57,e^;57K@5124>3E42/NsÞ Ê N@Þ � 03*;^_Þ � NsbuB;51,[B_6�>3E�= 0ÔA4E�5103*;:O.1H3N�24Z;,[B_A�B�0GAvHk03,[BKLH'E4A4H ��512R>O*;HP>O6 A4B;HÔ2457*;:OZ;.90GEuC(>O51*LA�2/Xåzq>3E�H/>�KLH'Euo��#ä�Þ Ê ä�Þ � ä�Þ � 572u.7,P03*;^�.751*;Hk0GE4.78`H/rsZ;57KG03.1H/*LAA�>)�/H'E�>;X Y B�Z;2

o �� ß Ë Þ Ê ä�Þ � ä�Þ ��Õ � �$cZ�Au032eo��ºä�Þ Ê ä�Þ � ä�Þ � 512R.7AkN

� Þ � � Þ �\l[ð � � � � � ï ��ß � Î � � � =�� �

Y B;HME�H'24Z;.7Ae512R*;>%b�03*-H/032T8D,/>O=<C�Z�A[0GA�57>O*�X �5 5(� � �¿���Í�����

Ë ð Õ Á ­;¤Pªk¤J¥�Ë �Uätð Õ ��

l � ´�ªº© ¯ ¬%ª¨´�¥|´�µ3¤ ° ¤�©GÂ�¼�ù@«<§¨¤ ° �

´�ªº¹s¤J¼;ªk¤Ô´»¼q¥»­�¤Mªk¤J¥u¬+¸ ° ¤�©GÂ�¼Wùs«<§J¤ ° ªº©3¥¿Â1¤[©�ª¨¥±¸k¬�ù ° ÀË ó Õ �´ � ¯ ¬%ª¨´�¥|´�µ3¤M´�¼W¥w¤½Ès¤ ° ª � ©G¼±¹ = À Á ­�¤Ôªk¤J¥

� � � � ß �Î 8�l � ©3¼±¹ � à � © ° ¤U³¨¬ ¯±° ´»«?¤Ô´�¼�¥+¤½È�¤ ° ª5, Î 8 ß = Ë � ätð Õ�Ò � àŠ�

´�ªº¹s¤J¼;ªk¤Ô´»¼q¥»­�¤Mªk¤J¥u¬+¸ ¯ ¬%ª¨´�¥|´�µ3¤ ° ¤�©GÂ�¼�ù@«<§¨¤ ° ª/À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Ë ð Õ 572uH/.7H/=?H/*LA[0GE48`,/03.1,/Z;.7Z;2�03*;^ Ë ó Õ 512R,/.7Hk0GEkX �* ° ¬�¬+¸º¬I¸ * ° ¬ ¯ ¬�ª¨´�¥|´¶¬�¼±À �¿57,�Q-0gC(>O245VA�57KLHM51*LA�H/:OHJE =U03*;^�,/>3C;E451=?HM51*LA�H/:OH'E42 � 03*;^ � X Y B;HÔA�B�E�H'HÔKLH/,'A4>3E�2� Ë ð � Å Õ � Ë ð � = Õ � Ë Ò � � � Õ �c2IC(H/,/57698`0#6�03*`51*?A�B;HS.10GA4A�51,'H � � N;03*;^`:O57KLHeE�5724H�A�>g0ºA�>3E�57,�24Z�E�6�03,'H ' >O6 �¿57,k0GE�^*�Z;=g]±H'E�>O*;HGN�bu57A4B-51*;^;57,/H/2yÎDß = � Ò � N � 03*;^>=@X

$v8 Ë óOó@Xpõ Õ

o �� ß Ë Îgä � ä = Õ �Ë Î � = Õ

ß Ë ð��'= Õ Ë4Ë Î � � Õ ätð¿ä Ë = � � Õ4Õ �Ë Î � � Õ

ß Ë ð��'= Õ Ë4Ë Î 8 � � Õ ätð Õ �Ë Î 8 � � Õ

Ë ðvä �[Õ

buB;H'E�H�l � lGß � Ë ð Õ Ë beB;HJE�HÔbcHMA�B;51*�Q�>O6 Ï"��51*;:S=U03*;^�.7H'A � :O>UA�><57*�Ï�*;57Aw8 Õ 03*;^aÎ 8 ß�Î#ä =@X Y B;HME�H/24Z;.VA*;>�b�6�>O.7.1>�be2RHk032457.78`69E�>O= Ë ð Õ 03*;^ Ë ó Õ >O6 Ë óOó@X � Õ X �

Page 142: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

. �") ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

� - � �ã&O��$%$����s���±������ �� �"��&L& � ���Í� � ����������'������& 0ë �"(�����â ���i&��� � ��& �e� ���O�$%����'�(�(��$

öSH'E�HSbcHSbu51.7.±:O57KLHM0#,/.103242457Ï�,/0GA�51>O*D>O6 03.7.±]�Z�Au0º](>OZ;*;^;H/^�6�03=<51.78a>O6�E[03*�Q`>O*;Hã.1>O:g^;H/. ��H����'>O2/X Y B;HC;E�>s>O6�2#Z;24H?A�B;H_=?H'A4B;>@^;2P>O6cA�B;H<BsZ;*LAkNy51*LA4E�>s^;Z;,/H/^j51* � :�N�]�Z�AU032PbvH_H ��C±H/,'AºA�B;HJE�H?be57.1.y](H?E�H/03^;H'E�2buB;>-0GE�Hg57*�A�HJE�H/2TA�H'^¾51*qA�B;HU2TA[0GA�H'=?H/*LAã>O6åA�B;HU,/.103242457Ï�,/0GA�51>O*�N�57*;^;H'C(H/*;^;H'*�AP>O6�A�B;H#E�H/2IAÔ>O6yA�B;HgCW0GC(H'E/NbcHãbe57.1.�2TA�0GA�HMA4B;HME�H'24Z;.7A�2u51*-0a24H/.76 ,/>O*LA[0357*;H/^-b\0k8LX Y B;572ubu51.1.±51*LKL>O.7KLHM24>O=?HSE�H'C±H'A�57A451>O*->O6 ^;H'Ï�*;57A451>O*;269E�>O= � :�X Y B;HM03*�03.78�2T512\>O6�A�B;512\24H/,JA�51>O*D512c57*;^;H'C(H/*;^;H'*�Ae69E�>O=à=?>O2TA\>O6�A�B;HSCW0GC(HJEkXå)wARZ;24H/2cE�H'24Z;.7A�2R03*;^*;>3A[0GA�57>O*;2u69E4>O= � ó%ؽï<03*;^ � :�Ø�ð�ïg>O*;.78LX

� Z�E<,/.10324245VÏ�,k0GA�51>O*�512U>O6uA�B;H�6�>O.1.7>%bu51*;:Ð24>3E4AkX +sA[0GETA�51*;:qbe5VA�Bh0qE[03*�Qm>O*;H-.7>O:i^;H'. ��H����/>¾bcH`bu51.1.=_0GQLH<03*ÍH/2424H/*LA�5103.1.78¾,k03*;>O*;51,/03.�]�57E�0GA�51>O*�03.yA4E[03*;246�>3E4=_0GA�51>O* Ë A�B;H<Ï;E�2IAgBsZ;*LAg2TA�H'C Õ 69E4>O= ' A�>"H/57A4B;H'E0 É Ê Ø¶Ï;];E[0GA451>O*Í>3EºA�>q0�2TH/,/>O*;^mE[03*�Q�>O*;H_.7>O:�^;H/. ��H����/>;X Ì H?bu51.7.�H �@C�.157,/57A�.V8¾,'.903242457698¾A�B;H?E4H/24Z;.7A451*;:24Z�E�6�03,'H/2/X Ì Hãbu51.1.�03.724><57*;^;51,k0GA4HÔB;>�bçA�B;HÔ57*�KLHJE�24HPA4E�03*;246�>3E�=_0GA�57>O*;2\,k03*-](HM,/.103242457Ï�H'^�NWA�B;HãC;E�>s,/H/^;Z�E�H512�Hk032T8?03*;^_H/.1H/=<H/*�A�0GE48LN�]�Z�A¿bcH�^;>º*;>3AvbRE�5VA�He^;>�be*`03*_HG��C�.157,/57A�.1572TAc032¿57A¿bv>OZ;.1^<]±H�*;>3A[0GA�57>O*�03.1.78gA�>s>51*LKL>O.7KLH'^�X

5 (��7�"�#� ���R�»��¡'� �"� ���#����� �v� (ã57KLH/*?0ME[03*�QU>O*;He.7>O:P^;H/.1��H����/> ' Ns.7H'A U ](He03*<H ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.�^;5VK�512T>3E>O6cA�B;H_=?57*;51=_03.y^;H/2457*;:OZ;.90GE�572�0GA�57>O*mbu57A4BÍ=_0 �;57=_03.y,/>@H�!<,/51H'*�A Ë A4B�0GA#512#=?57*;51=_03.y^;5724,'E�H'CW03*;,J8 Õ X #�H'AÑ ~ � Ò�Ó ' ]±H?A�B;H_H ��ATE[03,'A�57>O* Ë >O6vE�H/.10GA�57KLHS��51,k0GE4^j*�Z;=#](H'Eg>O*;H Õ >O6 U_X Ì H`032424Z;=<H UÄ512º,[B;>O24H/*24>¾A4B�0GA?o��¾ä U 512<.7>O:iA�HJE�=?51*�03. Ë 2TZ;,¨B�0Ð,¨B;>O57,/H�572?03.7bc0�8@2aC(>O2T2457]�.7H3Nc24H/H Ë :�Xpï Õ4Õ � B�032?0¾Z;*;57r@Z;Ho���ؽ*;H/:L0GA�5VKLHe,/>O*LA4E[03,JA�51>O* RyX R�572¿H/5VA�B;H'E\0 É�Ê Ø|Ï;];E[0GA�57>O*�N@>3E¿]�5VE[0GA�57>O*�03.|X�)+*<A�B;H�2TH/,/>O*;^_,k0324HubcHe.7H'A ' Ê](HÔA�B;H#51=_03:OHGN�03*;^q.7H'A � Ê Ü ' Ê ]±HºA�B;Hº57=_03:OH Ë bu57A4B-E�H/^;Z;,/H'^i2TATE�Z;,'A�Z�E�H Õ >O6 U_X ' Ê 572S03:L0351*"0<E�03*�Q>O*;HP.7>O:a^;H'.���H����/>;X@,W>3Eu^;H'A[0351.72u2TH/H Ë :�Xæï Õ X

5 (��»� �¿�@�Í����� � �º¬G¥½©G¥|´¶¬�¼Ð©�ªS´�¼ �IB �sÀ � ��� ¬ ° ©GÂ� §'ù@¥v©_§J¬�ùs¼(¹�¤�¹\¸/©G«g´»Â ·`¬+¸ ° ©G¼ F ¬�¼(¤MÂ1¬�È_¹s¤JÂ�*e¤�����¬%ª5,¥®­;¤ �<¬k¹L©G´ ° ©U¹3´�«?¤J¼;ªJ´¶¬�¼"¬I¸uÒ Ë o��ºä U Õ�´�ªe¼(¬�¼�ú+¼(¤½ÈL©G¥|´�µ3¤M©G¼±¹?¤J´�¥®­;¤ ° R ´�ªS©�É Ê ú 2v§ ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼"¬ ° o����Wä � Ê´�ªMÂ1¬[È�³�©G¼�¬�¼�´¶³�©3 ©G¼±¹`©G¼W¥®´�ú+¼(¤»¸/À

5 (�� 5��#� �@�W�%���h� � �#¬�¥w©G¥®´½¬�¼j©�ªg´�¼ ��B �@À � � � £ ¤'¥�' §J¤?© ° ©G¼ F ¬G¼(¤UÂ1¬�È"¹�¤J *�¤����%¬?ªJù ° ¸/©�³[¤0,\ªJù�³¨­q¥®­�©G¥¥®­;¤ �a¬�¹L©G´ ° ©`¹G´�«?¤'¼;ª¨´¶¬�¼�Ò Ë o��Dä U ÕM´�ªÔ¼(¬�¼�úw¼�¤½ÈL©G¥|´�µ3¤kÀ �\¼(¤U¬+¸Ô¥»­;¤¿¸k¬�Â�Â1¬�ûå´�¼@Èa­;¬GÂ7¹�ª��

Ë ð Õ R ´�ª_©UÉ�Ê�ú 2v§ ° ©G¥|´¶¬�¼ ,ã©G¼±¹�Ò Ë o��qä�U ÕU´�ªU¼(¤»¸5, U ´�ª<©�«Uùs ¥|´�ú½ªk¤¨³J¥®´½¬�¼h¬+¸?¹s¤½È ° ¤¨¤?©G¥�«?¬%ª¨¥�¥|ûv¬©G¼±¹<Ò Ë o��Dä U ÕM´�ªº©G« ¯ Â1¤#´Ç¸ U ´�ª#©<ªk¤[³'¥®´¶¬G¼±À

Ë ó Õ o�����ä � Ê ´�ªe ¥¿©3¼±¹a©3¼�¥®´»úT©G« ¯ Â1¤Ô©G¼±¹ � Ê ³[¬�¼�¥w©G´�¼;ªã©G¥y«?¬�ª¨¥�¥®ûc¬ºªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© °å¯ ¬�´�¼W¥»ª/À+*�¬%ª[ªJ´|§'´� ´�¥|´¶¤¨ª¸k¬ ° Ë ' Ê ��� Ê ÕU© ° ¤g³JÂ7©Gª[ª¨´ 2c¤[¹a´�¼ ��B �sÀ A B � À

Ë ï Õ o�����ä � Ê ´�ªe ¥�©G¼±¹U©3¼�¥®´»úT©G« ¯ Â1¤M©G¼±¹ � Ê ³[¬�¼�¥w©G´�¼�ªS¤��s©�³'¥®Â ·#¥®­ ° ¤¨¤Rª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ª/À *e©G´ ° ª Ë ' Ê ��� Ê Õ© ° ¤S³JÂ7©�ª[ª¨´ 2c¤�¹M´�¼ ��B �sÀ �LÀ A � À Á ­;¤'·º© ° ¤R´�¼�¬�¼(¤R¥+¬#¬�¼(¤S³[¬ °J° ¤¨ª ¯ ¬�¼±¹�¤'¼(³[¤cûy´�¥®­g¼(¬�¼-³J·�³J ´¶³�ø'ùW¬�¥|´¶¤J¼�¥ª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ª �T¬I¸º¹G´�«?¤'¼;ª¨´¶¬�¼Ð¥®ûv¬ �

Page 143: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � . � �

�c¥®­;¤ ° ûy´�ªk¤ ' Ê ´�ª �Ôù ��©GÂ1,R©G¼±¹�¬G¼(¤g¬+¸M¥®­;¤¿¸k¬�Â�Â1¬�ûy´»¼@È<­;¬GÂ7¹�ª��Ë . Õ � Ê Ü ' 3Ê ´�ª`© ° ©G¥®´½¬�¼±©GÂ\³Jù ° µ3¤D¬I¸_© ° ´�¥»­s«?¤J¥|´¶³gÈ�¤'¼�ù�ªD¬�¼(¤kÀ *�¬%ª[ª¨´¶§'´� ´�¥|´¶¤¨ªv¸k¬ ° ' ª¨ùW³¨­i¥®­�©G¥ � Ê

­�©�ª#©�³Jùsª ¯ © ° ¤g§¨¬Gùs¼±¹s¤�¹LÀË�� Õ o����vä � Ê ´�ª_ ¥º©G¼(¹q¼Wùs«?¤ ° ´¶³�©3Â� ·i¥ ° ´�µ%´|©GÂ1,#©G¼(¹ � Ê ³[¬G¼�¥½©3´�¼;ª�¤��s©�³J¥| ·¾¥»­ ° ¤[¤_ª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© °Ô¯ ¬�´�¼�¥®ª/À

*e©G´ ° ª Ë ' Ê ��� Ê Õ�¸/©GÂ�Â�´�¼�¥+¬ � ¸/©G«U´� ´¶¤¨ª5,å ´�ª¨¥w¤[¹<´�¼ ��B �sÀ��LÀCB�ú � � À

5 (���( �¿���Í�����-£ ¤'¥ Ë ' Ê ��� Ê ÕU§¨¤#© ¯ ©G´ ° ¬+¸º© ° ©G¼ F ¬�¼(¤ºÂ1¬�ÈD¹s¤J *�¤�����¬aûå´�¥»­q© ° ¤�¹GùW³[¤�¹ ° ©G¥®´½¬�¼±©GÂ�³'ù ° µ3¤ª¨ùW³¨­�¥»­�©3¥ o�����ä � Ê ´�ª#©3¼�¥®´»úw¼(¤»¸/À � ¸ RÍ~ ��Ò�Ó ' Ê ´�ªg©-³[¬G¼�¥ ° ©�³J¥|´¶¬�¼�¬I¸ ° ¤'Â7©G¥®´»µ3¤;*\´¶³�© ° ¹?¼�ù@«<§¨¤ ° ¬G¼(¤0,ª¨ùW³¨­�¥®­�©G¥ U ,v¥»­;¤Pª¨¥ ° ´¶³J¥¿¥ ° ©G¼;ª»¸k¬ ° « ¬+¸ � Ê ,u³[¬�¼�¥ ° ©�³'¥»ª Ñ ~ � Ò�Ó '�¥w¬D©?Â1¬�È_¥w¤ ° «g´�¼±©3Â�ª¨ù ° ¸/©s³[¤0,�¥®­;¤J¼>'´�ªº© ° ©G¼ F ¬�¼(¤ÔÂ1¬[ÈD¹�¤JÂ*e¤�����¬OÀÌ HM*;>%b =_0GQLHSE�H'=_0GE4Q�2cE�H':L0GE�^;51*;:UA�B;Hº0G]±>%KLH3~

B �sÀ �>D ¤'«<© ° F ª/ÀË ð Õ �e03*�Qg>O*;H ãZ)H¿03.�^;H/.1��H����/>P24Z�E46�03,/H/2v0GE4H\]±>OZ;*;^;H/^�N�03*;^UA�B;H'E�HR512�0ã24B;>3E4Aå.1572TAå>O6�C(>O2T2457]�57.157A451H/2/X

+@H/H � ï�N�>3E#îòïOïGñ¶XË ó Õ )wA�572y0ã2T51=<C�.7Hv=_0GA4A�HJE A�>S,/.103242457698ºC(>O242T57]�.1H É�Ê Ø|Ï;];E[0GA�51>O*;2�57* Ë ó3ï�X ó@X7ð Õ N303.7>O*;:�A�B;H\.151*;H'2�>O6 Ë ðOðOX � Õ X

� *;H<,k03*¾,/.903242T51698qCW0357E�2M51* Ë ó3ï�X ó@X . Õ ]s8Ð,/>O*;2457^;H'E�57*;:-A�B;H?03*LA�5Ûؽ,k03*;>O*;57,k03.y24H'E�57H/2�l Ò o����GlpN�24H/H6�>3EuH ��03=aC�.1H Ë ï�Xpõ Õ X

Ë ï Õ (ã57KLH/*Ð0<CW0357E Ë ' Ê ��� Ê Õ ,/>O*LA4E[03,'A�57>O*;2 RÔ~ � Ò�Ó ' Ê 24Z;,[BÐA�B�0GA�o��-ä�Uà512e.7Aã0GE�H#,'.90324245VÏ�H/^Ð51*Ë ðOðOX . Õ X��S2457*;:PA�B;H�,'.90324245VÏ�,k0GA�57>O*?>O6�.1>O:MA�H'E�=?57*�03.�2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2/Ns>O*;H�,k03*<A�B;H'*_6�Z�E4A�B;H'E\,/.103242457698C±>O242457]�57.15VA�51H/2¿24Z;,[B�A�B�0GA%U ,/>O*LA4E[03,JA�2cA�>g0#r@Z;>3A�57H/*�A\2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457Aw8LX�)+*`A4B;512c24H/*;2TH Ë ó3ï�X7ð'Øwï Õ :O5VKLHS0,/.10324245VÏ�,k0GA�51>O*�>O6�03.7.�]�Z�A�0U]±>OZ;*;^;H/^�6�03=?57.78`>O6 .7>O:<^;H/. ��H����/>?24Z�E�6�03,'H/2/X

Ë . Õ �S>3A�HRA�B;HS03242TZ;=<C;A�51>O*<51* Ë ó3ï�Xpó Õ N�512¿HG��03,'A�.V8aA4B�0GA U�572v0ÔA�57:OH'EkX Ì HR](H/.751H'KLH�5VA¿bc>OZ;.7^?](HeC±>O24245ÛØ]�.7H3N;Z;2451*;:UA�B;Hã=?H'A�B;>s^;2\>O6 A�B;572\CW0GC±H'EkN;A�>g,/>O=<C�.7H'A�H/.V8_,/.103242451698`A�B;>O2THM.7>O:a^;H'. ��H����/>O2 ' N�2TZ;,¨BA�B�0GA UÚ512u*;>3AS0<A�57:OH'EkXv)+*;^;H/H/^�N±51*-A�B;HÔ](>@^�8�>O6�A�B;HPCW0GC±H'E�bcHPB�0�KLH#03.VE�Hk03^�8�,/>O*;2TA4E4Z;,'A�H/^Ð03*H �@C�.157,/57Ac,'>O.1.1H','A�51>O* �ÐbeB;57,[B�57*;,/.1Z;^;H/2R03.7. ' bu57A4BD*;>#A�57:OH'EkN�Z;*;^;HJERA4B;HÔ03^;^;5VA�51>O*�03.±032424Z;=<C;A451>O*A�B�0GA R �� �Ê Ë ' 3 Õ ß � ð �LX

NÔ�%���Wþw¡?��þg� 5 (��®��(±¢%�

* ° ¬�¬+¸?¬I¸ ��B �sÀ A � À $v8 Ë # Xpï Õ N�5VAP572ÔH'*;>OZ;:OB¾A�>`Ï�*;^ � 8 � ð<2TZ;,¨B�A4B�0GAP576 � ß � Ë 'åÕ Ã � 8 N�A�B;H/* U Ê 512Ô0A�57:OH'EkX � ]�K�57>OZ;24.78DbcHM=_0k8D032424Z;=?H � Ë >O6 A�B;HMBsZ;*LA Õ 512e.7H/242\A�B�03*�>O*;H3X)+6 � 572å0M*;H'A/N@03*;^ � Ã�ó �3ï�N3A�B;H/*SUçB�032å^;H/:3E�H/Hu0GAå=?>O2TA�ó@NOA�B�Z;2¿o���äOU 512å03*LA�5Vض*;H/6½X �S>%bâ2TZ�C;C(>O24H

Rm512e]�5VE[0GA�57>O*�03.|XRo����yä � � Ê 512 /�Z;2TBÐ]�8 Ë :�X .;X � Õ Xc)+6 � à . � � A�B;H/*qo�����ä � Ê 512�.7,P]s8 Ë :�XpÅ�X # Xpï Õ 03*;^�N]�8 Ë � Xpï Õ >O6\îæó � ñ|N;516 � Ã�.;ð��'.�ó@N�A�B;H/*�o�� ��ä � Ê 512u03*LA�5Vض*;H/6½X �* ° ¬�¬+¸º¬I¸ ��B �sÀ � � À +@Z�C;C(>O2TH ' 572u*;>3Au0g.1>O:U^;H/. ��H����/>;X Y B;H/*�o��-512R*;H/6½NW03*;^�C�Z;.7.151*;:UZ�Cq03*;^DC�Z;24B;51*;:^;>�be*�o�� � ä � � Ê 512R*;H/6½X +@57*;,/H ' 572e.VAkN � �éðONW03*;^-bcHM:OH'Ae0a,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�51>O*�XåöSH/*;,/H Ë ó Õ X �

Page 144: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

. � � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

* ° ¬�¬+¸<¬+¸ �IB �sÀCB � À � .1Hk0GE4.78 Ë ð Õ B;>O.7^;2Ô576 � 572Ô0D*;H'AkX0+@>�032424Z;=?H0R�572S]�57E[0GA�57>O*�03.|X Ì HUbu51.7.�24B;>�b A�B�0GAo���� ä � Ê 512R03*�A45Vؽ*;H'6½NW.7>O:UA4H'E�=?57*�03.�0GAR2451*;:OZ;.10GERC±>O51*LA�2/N�03*;^�N�H ��,/H'C;Au6�>3Ee0#](>OZ;*;^;H'^�,/>O.1.7H/,'A�57>O*�>O6 ' N.1>O:a,k03*;>O*;51,/03.|X Y B;HM^;57K@512457>O*-51*LA�>a,k0324H/2RA�B;H/*�6�>O.7.1>�be2RHk032457.78`]s8�03^�FIZ;*;,'A451>O*�X

$v8?032T24Z;=<C;A�57>O*?A�B;H *Ô>s^�0357E[0º^;57=?H/*;2457>O*_>O6 Ò Ë o�� �±ä4U Õ 512c*;>O*@ؽ*;H':L0GA�57KLH3NsA�BsZ;2co�� �±ä � Ê 512c03*LA�5ÛØ*;H/6½XO+@Z�C;C±>O24H � Ë 69E�>O= A�B;HaBsZ;*LA Õ 572º0GAÔ.1Hk032IAP>O*;H3X Y B;H'*Ío�����ä�U Ê 512 Rh*;>O*@Ø|C(>O245VA�57KLH3N�A�B�Z;2/N 2457*;,/Ho�� ��ä-U Ê 572u.7>O:UA�HJE�=?51*�03.®N;24><572uo�� ��ä � Ê X

+@>�bvH<=_0k8Ð032424Z;=?H � �ÚðOXao�����ä � � Ê 572�/�Z;24B�]�8 Ë :�X .;X � Õ N�A�BsZ;2Po�����ä � Ê 512M.1>O:DA�H'E�=?57*�03.y0GA2457*;:OZ;.90GE\C(>O57*�A�2'N�]�8 Ë :�XæÅ�X . Õ X�)+6 � Ã�. � � A�B;H'*-o���� ä � Ê 512\.1,ã]s8 Ë :�XpÅ�X # Xæï Õ X $cZ�AR516 � ��. � � A4B;H/* ' 572](>OZ;*;^;H'^�]s8 Ë # Xæï Õ X �5 (�� � NM��� �å�±¡k���%�»���¿��£ ¤J¥ Ë ' Ê ��� Ê ÕÔ§¨¤Ô© ¯ ©G´ ° ¬+¸M© ° ©G¼ F ¬�¼(¤SÂ1¬�È<¹�¤J *e¤�����¬Ôª¨ù ° ¸k©�³[¤0,�' Ê ©3¼±¹a© ° ¤�¹GùW³[¤�¹´ °J° ¤�¹GùW³J´|§/Â1¤P³'ù ° µ3¤ � Ê Ü ' Ê ª¨ùW³¨­`¥®­�©G¥ o����(ä � Ê ´�ªÔ©G¼W¥®´�ú+¼(¤»¸Ô©G¼±¹UÂ1¬�Èa¥+¤ ° «U´�¼±©GÂ7À �ãª[ªJùs«?¤M¥®­;¤ ° ¤º© ° ¤P©G¥Â1¤�©�ªJ¥¿¥®­ ° ¤[¤Mª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ªº¬+¸ ' Ê ©GÂ1¬�¼�È � Ê À

� ¸ãÒ Ë o�����ä � Ê ÕP´�ªº©G« ¯ Â1¤º¥®­;¤J¼� A�� ' Ê á � Ê ­�©Gªa¤ �s©�³J¥| ·"¬�¼�¤ºªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© °e¯ ¬G´�¼�¥�,u©D¼(¬G¼�ú4³J·�³J ´¶³#ª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|· , � À � ¸ � Ò±Ó ' Ê ¤��O¥ ° ©�³'¥»ª#¥®­;¤

³[¤J¼W¥ ° ©GÂ�¤��@³¨¤ ¯ ¥|´¶¬�¼±©GÂ�¹G´�µ�´�ª�¬ ° ¬+¸ � ,v¥®­;¤J¼ � ´�ªg©ÔÉ Ê ú 2v§ ° ©3¥®´¶¬G¼¾©G¼±¹ U ©G¼±¹ � © ° ¤Ôªk¤[³'¥®´¶¬G¼;ª/À Ë ' Ê ��� Ê Õ´�ªUù@¼�´|ø/ù�¤J ·i¹s¤J¥w¤ ° «g´�¼�¤�¹q§'· � ,Ô©G¼±¹Ð©3Â�Âå¼(¬�¼Wú4³J·�³J ´¶³Uª¨´»¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥|´¶¤¨ª0, � ,P¬�³[³Jù ° ´»¼m¥»­s´�ªUû¿©G·º¸�¬ ° ªk¬G«?¤¯ ©G´ ° Ë ' Ê ��� Ê ÕkÀ

� ¸ o�����ä � Ê ´�ªM¼�ù@«?¤ ° ´¶³�©GÂ� ·_¥ ° ´�µ%´|©GÂ�¥®­;¤J¼4' Ê ´�ª �Ôù ��©GÂ1,R©G¼±¹ Ë ' Ê ��� Ê Õº´�ªM´»¼�¬�¼(¤g¬I¸ 2åµ3¤¿¸/©G«g´� ´½¤¨ª����B � ' ß ' Ë � Ê äâó � �kÕ�À Ë ' Ê ��� Ê ÕP´�ª�ÈG´�µO¤J¼¾§'· � A �LÀ B � , ��©�ª�¤ A ,�ûå´�¥»­ $ ß ï ©G¼±¹ =MßÝð À��� � ' ß ' Ë ï � � Õ�À Ë ' Ê ��� Ê Õº´�ª�ÈG´�µ3¤'¼i§'· � A �LÀCB � , ��©�ªk¤ B ,�ûy´»¥»­ $ ßéó ©3¼±¹ =MßÝð À� � � o ���� ß ð , � Ê ´�ª¾©jÒ ð ú4³'ù ° µ3¤Í©G¼±¹ ' Ê ´�ª�¬�¼(¤Í¬+¸ ' Ë � Ê ä � � ä ���kÕ-, ' Ë ó � Ê ä � �kÕ0, ' Ë . � Ê Õ�À

Á ­;¤ ¯ ©3´ ° ªa© ° ¤_¬O§'¥w©G´�¼(¤�¹S¸ ° ¬�« � A �sÀ �LÀ A � , � A �@À��LÀ � � ©G¼±¹ � A �sÀ��LÀ � � ° ¤¨ª ¯ ¤¨³J¥®´»µ3¤J · ,u§/·D¥®­;¤g´�¼�µ3¤ ° ªk¤?¬+¸a©¥ ° ©G¼;ª»¸k¬ ° «?©G¥®´½¬�¼¾¬+¸M¥|· ¯ ¤ � AQA À A À A � À

D ¤J«<© °GF ª/ÀË ð Õ ,W>3E�0U,/>O*;2TA4E4Z;,'A�51>O*�N�57* Ë ð Õ N�>O6 Ë ' Ê ��� Ê Õ 69E�>O= ��N�24H'HÔA�B;HMC;E�>@>O6 >O6 Ë ó3ï�X � X7ðOX1ð ÕË ó Õ Ë ó3ï�X � Õ 512\0#,/.10324245VÏ�,k0GA�51>O*`>O6 0G]�2TA4E[03,JAcCW0357E�2 Ë ' Ê ��� Ê Õ N@]�Z�AR>OZ�E\C;E�51*;,/5VCW03.(51*LA�H'E4H/2TAR,/>O=?H/2c69E4>O=

Ë ó3ï�Xpó Õ N�beB;H'E4H<A�B;H<CW035VE Ë ' Ê ��� Ê Õ 512PA4B;H<Ï;E�2TAPBsZ;*LAg2TA�H'C�N�03*;^�A�B;512Ô512PbuB�8ÐbcH?Z;2TH<A�B;512P24Z�]�Ø24,JE�57C;A�H'^Í*;>3A[0GA�51>O*�X_)+*Í6�03,'AkN 57Aº572ºHk032T8ÐA�>�,[B;H/,�QÍZ;2T51*;: Ë ó3ï�Xæï Õ 03*;^ Ë ðOðOX . Õ A�B�0GAPHk03,[Bm>O6vA�B;HCW035VE�2 Ë ' Ê ��� Ê Õ 03,JA�Z�03.1.V8`>@,/,/Z�E42�032uA4B;HMÏ;E�2IA�B�Z;*�Ae2TA�H'C"6�>3Ee24>O=?H ' X

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ $v8 Ë ó3ï�X � X1ðOX7ð Õ ](H/.7>%bÔN �¾57*�,k032TH Ë ð Õ ^;H'A�HJE�=?51*;H'2 Ë ' Ê ��� Ê Õ Nv03*;^ho�� �\ä � Ê 572a*;H':L0GA�57KLH3XÍ)+*Ë ó%Ø�. Õ >O*;H_,k03*m,/>O=<C�Z�A�H_^;5VE�H/,'A4.78¾A4B�0GA#o����vä � Ê 512#*�Z;=?H'E451,k03.7.78¾ATE�57K@5903.|X Ì H_*;>�bÚ24B;>�b Ë bu57A4B;>OZ�A^;512IA�51*;:OZ;5724B;51*;:U](H'AwbcH/H'*"*;H/:L0GA�57KLHM03*;^�*�Z;=?H'E451,k03.7.78_A4E�5VK�5103. Õ A�B�0GAu03*L8DCW035VE Ë ' Ê ��� Ê Õ 6�03.7.12R51*LA�>U>O*;HP>O6A�B;HÔ,k0324H/2 Ë ð'Ø�. Õ X

Page 145: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � . � �

#�H'A =#]±HÔA�B;HM=_0 �;57=_03.±57*;^;H ��>O6�03*L8�2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457Aw8D03.1>O*;: � Ê X� B;>@>O24HM0g2451*;:OZ;.10GERC±>O51*LA � � ' Ê 032R6�>O.1.7>%bu2/X�)+6�A4B;H'E�HM512R0gC±>O51*LA � �� � Ê be5VA�B � Ë ��Õ.- � � Ê� N;,¨B;>s>O24H

24Z;,[B"0 � >O6�=_0 �;57=_03.�,'>@H�!<,/51H/*LA Ë 6�>3ERo���� Õ X � A�B;H'E4bu5124HãA[0GQLH � 0#C(>O57*�AR>O6 � Ê >O6 51*;^;H ��=sN�beB;57,¨B�B�032=_0 ��51=_03.�2TC(H','A4E[03.�KG03.1Z;H Ë 03=?>O*;:SC(>O57*�A42å>O6�51*;^;H �)= Õ X � *;Hu,[B;H/,�Q�2�Z;2451*;: Ë :�Xpï�X1: Õ N3A�B�0GA � 572 Ë >O*;H\>O6WA�B;HC(>O2T2457]�.7HÔ,[B;>O51,'H/2u6�>3E Õ ��6�>3ERA4B;HÔ*;H �@ARBsZ;*LAe2IA�H'C-bu57A4BDE�H'2TC(H/,JAuA�>go�����ä � � 6�>3Ee03*L8qð Ò � � - � � ðON6�>3ESÏ"�;H'^ � à Å?24Z"!?,/57H/*LA�.78q24=?03.1.|X Ë �S>3A�HÔA�B�0GAS24>O=?H#,/0GE�H#512�*;H'H/^;H/^iA4>_^;H'Ï�*;H � N±A4>_H/*;24Z�E�H#A�B�0GAã5VA512R51*;^;HJC(H/*;^;H/*LAã>O6 � X Õ

�S>�b bcHSE�Z;*�A4B;HÔB�Z;*�Aube5VA�B`E�H/2TC±H/,'ARA�>ao�� � ä � � 6�>3E � ,/.7>O24HSA�>a>O*;HGN�03*;^��Dß � 032u0G](>�KLH3X �S>3A�Ho�����ä � � 512%/�Z;24B�XöSH'E�H?A4B;H_2457A�Z�0GA451>O*m512#24.751:OBLA�.78¾^;57è±H'E�H/*LAgA�B�03*m51* Ë :�X .;X � Õ X Ì H`,k03*;*;>3AU032T24Z;=?H?A�B�0GA#A�B;HJE�H`512#*;>

A�57:OH'EkN�51*;^;H'H/^ � 572#>3]sK@51>OZ;24.V8Í0�A�51:OHJEkX �S>O*;H_A�B;H_.1H'242/N�A�B;H_^;57K@512457>O*m51*LA�>",k0324H/2 Ë :�X .;X � Õ be57.1.�]±H_A�B;H2�03=?HGN;Z;2451*;:?H'2424H/*LA�5903.7.78`A�B;HÔ2�03=?HM0GE�:OZ;=?H/*LAkX Y B;572Rbu51.7.�E�H/r@Z;5VE�HÔ0U]�57Au>O6 C;E4H/.157=?51*�0GE48D03*�03.V8�24572/XY >�0�KL>O57^iB�0kK�57*;:�03*L8Ð,/>@H�!<,/51H'*�A�2Ô.90GE�:OHJEMA4B�03*¾>O*;H3N�bcH?03.VA�H'EM24.751:OBLA�.78"A�B;HU24,k03.751*;:�,/>O*�KLH'*�A�57>O*�>O6

Ë :�Xpó@X . Õ X�ãH'Ï�*;H � - � Ê 24Z;,[BÍA�B�0GA#o��qä � � Ê ä � U 572 �ãØ|A4E�5VK�5903. Ë �Ö572ºA�B;H?o���ؽ*;H/:L0GA�5VKLH_H ��ATE�H/=_03.E[0k8 Õ X2#�H'A ! 8 ß � � Ê ä � U_XJ K��W�®�h� � � � ,�ù@¼�Â1¤¨ª[ª �Ú´�ªº©<¼(¤J¥�, oÖä � Ê ´�ªM¼�¤½ÈL©G¥|´�µ3¤º©G¼(¹ � �� � Ê ,�´�¼qû�­s´¶³¨­"³�©Gªk¤ � ßéó Ò � À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ )+6�o�����ä � Ê 572¿*�Z;=?H'E�57,k03.1.V8aATE�57K@5903.|NOA�B;H'* � ß � Ê � � Ns24>ºbcH�,k03*`032T24Z;=?HeoÝä � Ê 512v*;H':L0GA�57KLH3X�S>�b�24Z�C;C±>O24H � 512M0_*;H'AkN�03*;^ � �� � Ê X +@51*;,/H Ë 6�>3E � ßÚð Õ � Ê - ð��Oó@N � 03*;^4U×0GE�Hg24H/,'A�57>O*;2/N�24>

,/.7Hk0GE�.78 � ßéó Ò � XÌ Hãbe57.1.�24B;>�b 51*DA�B;HÔE�H'=_0351*;57*;:a,k032TH/2uA�B�0GA � � � X�)wAe572eH/*;>OZ;:OB�A�>a,[B;H/,�Q-6�>3E � ßÝðOX)+6 � � U �ß %UA�B;H/*-2451*;,/H � Ê Ü � ,'>O*�A[0357*;2�0GAu.1Hk032IAuAwbc>a2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2/NW03^�FIZ;*;,'A�57>O*�:O57KLH'2

ÅUÃ Ë o��_ä � ä � �UÕ � � -çÒ ðvä � �

+@>`bcH#,k03*i032424Z;=?H � �� � Ê X Y B;H/* � 512S*;>3AM0_*;H'AkXMo�� ä � ä � � 512S*;H':L0GA�57KLH3N�2T>-03:L0357* � � ð#]�803^�FIZ;*;,'A�57>O*�X �

,W>3ERA4B;HÔ57*;H/r@Z�03.757A�57H/2R03*;^-H/rsZ�03.157A451H/2\6�>3Eu,/>@H�!<,/51H'*�A�2\](H'.1>�bPNW032cbcH/.7. 032cA�B;HÔ03*�03.78@24512\57*�A�B;HMH �;,'H'C�ØA�57>O*�03.�,k0324HP>O6 A�B;HÔ,'.90351=-N�bcHMA�0GQLH � ß�ðOX

J K��W�®�h� � � À � À��GÀ�%ú AQA�� ­�¬�Â7¹

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ o��"ä � Ê U�ä � � Ê 512Ô.1H'KLH/.y]�8 Ë :�Xæï�X � X . Õ X +@57*;,/H � �� N�bcH<,/03*Í,¨B;H',[Q /�Z;24B;*;H/242g>O6vo���ä ! 8

.1>s,k03.1.V8a0GAvHk03,[B?C(>O57*�A¿>O6 U_N�buB;H'E�He57Av6�>O.7.1>�be2�]s8 Ë :�Xpï�X � X ó Õ X Ë :�X .;X � Xpõ�Ø�ðOð Õ *;>�b�6�>O.1.1>�b�H ��03,JA�.78<032¿57*?A�B;HC;E�>s>O6 >O6 Ë :�X .;Xpï Õ X �

�S>3A�HSA�B�0GA � Ê - ð��Oó@N�03*;^ � Ê - ó �3ïUZ;*;.1H/2T2 � Ê ,'>O*�A[0357*;2 .a2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2\>O6�51*;^;HG�"ó@X

Page 146: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

. � � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

� >O*;2451^;H'ERA�B;HÔ*;H ��AuBsZ;*LAS2TA4H'C�X@#�H'A��#ß Ò �U � Ë 032R51*�A4B;HPZ;24Z�03.�BsZ;*LA Õ XíS2eó � ä � Ãëó@N�bcHP,k03*;*;>3AeB�0�KLHÔ0UA�03,/*;>@^;H3NW>3Ee0UA4E�5VC�.1HãC(>O57*�AkN�]�8 Ë :�Xpï�X � Õ X+@Z�C;C(>O2TH�� �� � XU)+6¿bvH<:O>�A4>�0�.7>O:-^;H/.2��H����/>;N A�B;H'* � 512M.7AP03*;^�24=<>@>3A�B�N�2457*;,/H � ä � ,k03*;*;>3A

B�0kKLHº0UATE�57C�.7HMC±>O51*LAkX�öSH'*;,/HÔbcHM=gZ;2TAu:O>aA�><0a6�H/*;,/HGX $cZ�A�032 � Ü ' � ,/>O*�A�0351*;2�0GAu.1H/032TAuAwbc>a2451*;:OZ;.10GEC(>O57*�A42/N;o�� ä � ä � 512c*;H'6 ]�8`03^�FIZ;*;,'A�57>O*�N�buB;51,[BD,/>O*LA4E[03^;51,JA�2 Ë ð�ï�Xpï Õ X�)+6 � 512\0#*;H'A/N�A�B;H/* � 03*;^�U0GE�HÔ24H/,'A�57>O*;2/NW6�>3E�>3A�B;H'ETbe5724H3NW2451*;,/H#ó � ä � Ãëó@NW>O*;HP572�0a2TH/,'A�57>O*�N±03*;^�A�B;HÔ>3A�B;H'Ee512�0U^;>OZ�]�.1Hº2TH/,'A�57>O*�NbuB;51,[Bm,/>O*�ATE[03^;51,'A42 Ë ðOðOX � X1ðOðOXpó Õ X Y B;HJE�HD0GE�H_0GA#.7Hk032TAUï�=gZ;.7A�5VC�.1H<Ï;];E4H/2/Ny24> ��572g0�*;>O*@ؽ,[B�0351*mC(>O57*�A/X�S>�b Ë ð Õ 6�>O.1.1>�bu2e69E�>O= Ë ó3ï�X .;X1ðOX1ð Õ X

+@Z�C;C(>O2TH � � � X Ì HM,/>O*;2451^;HJE�A�B;HãK30GE�57>OZ;2RC±>O24245V]�51.15VA�51H'2/N Ë :�X .;X � Xpõ�Ø�ðOð Õ X)+6 bcHÔB�0�KLHP0�$\03*�03*�0�N�A�B;H/*-69E�>O=×A4B;HÔ,/.10324245VÏ�,k0GA�51>O* Ë ð�ï�X ó Õ N Ë ó%Øwï Õ 6�>O.1.7>%bÔX�S>�b 2TZ�C;C(>O24H ' � 512_0�6�H'*;,/H3X +@57*;,/H � Ê ,/>O*LA[0351*;2`0GA<.1Hk032TA<A+bv>j2T51*;:OZ;.90GE<C(>O51*LA�2/Nc]�8 Ë ð�ï�Xæï Õ N �

512�2451*;:OZ;.10GEkN�� � � Ê 03*;^ � Ê 512�0 Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLH3X +@Z�C;C±>O24H � � ^;>sH/2-*;>3A-.151Hi51*tA4B;H ãZ H¿03.M.7>@,/Z;2'X$v8j,/>O*;2451^;HJE�51*;:�A�B;HDC(>O242T57]�.1H�51*;^;57,/H/2?6�>3E<2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2?03.7>O*;: � Ê Nc03*;^�Z;2451*;:�A�B;H�6�03,'A<A4B�0GA���B�032=_0 ��51=_03.s51*;^;H �(Ns5VA�6�>O.7.1>�be2yA�B�0GA � � ,/>O*LA[0357*;2�H/5VA�B;H'E Ë ï Õ >3E Ë . Õ X � *;Hu,¨B;H',[Q@2v51*<03.1.;,k032TH/2�A�B�0GA � �� � Å�N0<,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�57>O*�X Y B�Z;2 � Ü '�3� N � Ë �UÕ ß ðONW03*;^ ' � 512 ãZ H¿03.|X �S>�béA�B;HPC±>O24245V]�51.15VA�51H'2�0GE�HÔ,/.903242T57Ï�H/^51* Ë ð�ï�X . Õ 03*;^ Ë ð�ï�X � Õ X)+6 � B�032M0`,/Z;2TC�N�A�B;H/*q]s8 Ë ð�ï�X . Õ A4B;HU2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457A�57H/2ã0GE�H � Ê ä � � X � >O*;2457^;H'E�c~ �� Ò±Ó ' Ê X +@57*;,/H

�U �� � Ò ó@N A4B;HUÏ;E�2IAPÏ;KLHg]�.1>�b Z�C�2P=gZ;2TAM](H?03.7>O*;: � X Y B;512P:O5VKLH/2M,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E[0GA�57>O* Ë / � Õ >O6 Ë ðOðOXpó@X1ð Õ N03*;^���ß Ë ó Õ X2$\Z�A�A�B;H/*S=Ôßéó@Ns03*;^ � � ,/>O*LA[0357*;2¿A�B�E�H/H � Ê C(>O57*�A42/N@,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�57*;: Ë ð�ï�Xpï Õ X $v8 Ë ðOðOX ó@X1ð ÕA�B;H_,/>O*�Ï�:OZ�E�0GA�51>O*Í>O* � 512 Ë / � �'Õ N �hß Ë ï Õ 03*;^-=-ßÖï�X>$cZ�AºA�B;H'*mA4B;H'E�H_512º0-C(>O51*LA#>OZ�A�2T51^;H � >O6,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LAãó �3ï�N�0a,'>O*�A4E�03^;51,'A�57>O*�N�2451*;,/HM]s8�>OZ�Eu,/>O*�KLH'*�A�57>O*;2eA�B;HMBsZ;*LA�bc>OZ;.7^-,[B;>@>O2THÔA�B�0GARC(>O57*�AkX

+@Z�C;C(>O2TH � B�032y0e*;>@^;H3X Y B;H/* U ,/>O*LA[0357*;2�03* ��� C(>O57*�A/NO03*;^#516 U 572�0 Ò �Oض,/Z�E4KLH3N Ò �±äE=;äE.Ußto �� XË . Õ 6�>O.1.7>%bu2R]�8D,/>O=<CW0GE�57*;:UA4B;HÔC(>O2T2457]�.7HP51*;^;57,/H/2/N;bu57A�BDA�B;HÔC±>O24245V]�51.15VA�51H'2u>O6 Ë ð�ï�X � Õ X

+@Z�C;C(>O2TH � � � N�03*;^ � 512e0<*;H'AkX Y B;H/* � =gZ;2TAu](H#0aÏ;];E4H Ë >3A�B;H'ETbe5724HÔ]�8 Ë ðOðOX � X1ðOðOXpó Õ N�032�0G]±>%KLHGN](>3A4B � 03*;^-U 0GE�H_24H','A�51>O*;2'N�03*;^ � ,/>O*LA[0351*;2g0GAº.1Hk032TA#Awbc>q2457*;:OZ;.90GE#C±>O51*LA�2/N�buB;51.1H UÄ,'>O*�A[0357*;2g0GA=?>O2TAR>O*;H Õ X $v8 Ë ðOðOX � X � Õ N � Ê ,/>O*LA[0351*;2uH ��03,'A4.78_A�B�E�H'HP2457*;:OZ;.90GERC(>O51*LA�2/N�24> � Ê - ó �3ï�X

+@Z�C;C(>O2TH U B�032�^;H/:3E�H/H¾0GA-.7Hk032TA-A4B�E�H/H3X Y B;H/* U B�032-^;H/:3E4H/H�H �;03,'A�.78âA4B�E�H/H3N � 572�0mÏ;];E�H�>O6=gZ;.7A�5VC�.157,/57Aw8`A�B�E�H/HGN � Ê ßÝó �3ï?03*;^ =gßçï�X � Ü � 512eA�B;HÔÏ;];E�H Ë ðOðOX � X # X � Õ N�bu57A4B ;<ßÝó@X\)I*�CW0GETA�51,/Z;.10GE� Ü � ,/>O*LA[0351*;2\2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H'2 � � 03*;^ Ë ï Õ X�)wAc6�>O.1.7>%bu2c69E�>O=Ú>OZ�E\,/>O*LKLH/*LA�51>O*`6�>3E � N@A�B�0GA �Dß Ë ï Õ N�03*;^U Ü � 3 XP)+6åbvHUHG��A4E[03,JAMA4B;H Ò ï�ؽ,'Z�E4KLH<03^�FT03,'H/*�AÔA�> � 03*;^Ð,/>O*LA4E[03,'A � N U � ](H/,'>O=?H/2 �/H'E�>;N�A�B�Z;2ãbcH>3];A[0357* 4 3 X Y B;572e,/>O*LA4E[03^;57,'A�2 Ë ðOðOX � X1ð�Å Õ N�2451*;,'H U E�H/=_0357*;2u24=<>@>3A�B�03*;^�B�032R^;H/:3E�H/HMA�B�E�H/H3X)wAg6�>O.1.7>%bu2EU 512U0"^;>OZ�]�.1HD24H/,'A�57>O*�03*;^mA�B;H`2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2#>O6 � 03.7>O*;: � 0GE�H_H/03,¨B � Ê X � >O*;2457^;H'E

�c~ ��çÒ�Ó � N�6�>3E � 0Ô24=<>@>3A�BgE�H/.10GA�57KLHR=?51*;57=_03.@=<>@^;H/. Ë 2TH/H Ë ðOðOX � X . Õ4Õ X �S>3A�HRo��Mä8U¾ä � ��512yA4E�[email protected]�>3Eu24>O=?H � àÅ�X Y B�Z;2 Ë o�� ä U Õ�� U � ÅU03*;^>U E�H/=?0351*;2R0U2T=?>@>3A�B`^;>OZ�]�.7HÔ24H','A�51>O*�X@$v8 Ë ðOðOX � X1ð�Å Õ NU � ß .a>O* � N�03*;^ � ß 4 Ê >3E 4 3 X@#�H'AåÎ�N � � � ](HMA�B;HÔE�03=?57Ï�,k0GA451>O*`C(>O51*LA�2R>O6�U Ò±Ó É Ê N�bu57A4BUÎ

Page 147: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � . �"2

A�B;HMC(>O51*LAu>O*�A�B;HMÏ;];E�HP,/>3ETE�H/2TC±>O*;^;51*;:<A�> � X � .1H/0GE�.78`>�KLH'E�Î�N �D572e:O57KLH'*�]�8D]�.7>%bu51*;:aZ�C�Awbe57,/Hº03.7>O*;:U_X Y B�Z;2 Ë 2451*;,'H �U � � Ò óg>O* ��Õ � =gZ;2TA\,'>3E4E�H/2TC±>O*;^�A�>U0g2451*;:OZ;.10GEcÏ;];E�H3N � N;>O6 � X Y B;H'E�HM,k03*`](Hã*;>>3A�B;H'E�2451*;:OZ;.10GE�Ï;];E�H/2/X Y B;HºÏ;E42TA �ãä óU]�.1>�b�Z�C�2S>O6 ��>�KLH'E � =UZ;2IA�](H#03.7>O*;:SU_XRíRAuA�B;512eC±>O51*LA � 57251*_A�B;H ãZOHv03.W.1>s,/Z;2/N�03*;^`B�032\0#Þ��ã2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57Aw8LX Y B;HS*;H ��Ac]�.7>%btZ�C Ë 576�57A\H ��512TA42 Õ 512vA4B;HS*;>O*@ؽ51*LA�H'E451>3E]�.1>�b�Z�C¾0kb\0�8�69E�>O= U Ë 24H/H Ë ðOðOX � X . Õ4Õ N(03*;^Ð24Z�]�24H/rsZ;H/*�AM]�.1>�b�Z�C�2Ô0GE�H#*;>O*@ض51*LA�H'E�57>3EkN�^;H'A�H'E4=?51*;H/^q]�8� X ' Ê B�032g0"*;>O*@ض,¨B�0357*�2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457Aw8 ��N�bu57A�BÍ,/H'*�A4E4H Ò ó@Nå03*;^ÍA+bv>q];E�03*;,¨B;H'2 Ë ó Õ X Y B;H_.9032TA#];E[03*;,[B512ã^;H'A4H'E�=?57*;H/^"]s8 � X�,W>3EãH �;03=<C�.1H#576 �iß Ë ó � ï Õ N±A�B;H/*qA�B;Hg.9032TAS];E�03*;,¨Bi512 Ë ï 8 � ó Õ N±bu57A�B"A�B;Hg=_0GETQLH/^,/Z�E4KLH#=<H/H'A�57*;:<A�B;Hº,/H'*�A4E�03. ,/Z�E4KLHGXu)+6 � Ò±Ó ' Ê H �@A4E[03,'A42eA�B;Hº,/H'*�A4E�03. ^;57K@5124>3E�0GA���N±A�B;H'* �Ý512S0?*;H'A/N� 512u0UÏ;];E�H3N � 03*;^DA�B;HP,'H/*�ATE[03.�^;57K�5724>3Ee0GE�HÔ2TH/,'A�57>O*;2/N±03*;^�bcHÔB�0kKLHP,/0324H Ë ð Õ XY B;H¿E�H/=_0357*;51*;:RC(>O24245V]�51.757Aw8P572 A�B�0GA � ß X Y B�Z;2 � 572�0 Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�E4KLHGNL03*;^gbvHvB�0�KLH Ë :�X .;X � X � Õ X � Ê Ü �

,k03*;*;>3Aã,/>O*LA[0357*�A+bv> � Ê C(>O51*LA�2 Ë >3ES57A�bv>OZ;.1^"*;>3AS,/>O*LA4E[03,JA Õ N(24> � Ãéó �3ï�Xu)wAS6�>O.7.1>�be2�032�51*�A�B;HºC;E4>@>O6>O6 Ë ð :�X � Õ A�B�0GA � 03,/r@Z;5VE�H/2u03*�>3E�^;57*�0GE48D,/Z;2TC�N�03*;^�A�B;HÔ2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2u03.1>O*;: 0GE4H Ë ó Õ 03*;^ Ë ï Õ X)+6 � Ü ' 3� NGA�B;H/* ' � 572 ãZ H¿03.�03*;^ ' 3� 572�2457=<C�.78Ô,/>O*;*;H/,'A4H/^�X �Dß Ë � Õ N � - ï�X Y B;H/* ' �� ßéõ Ò � � ï�X

)wA#6�>O.1.7>%bu2º69E�>O= A�B;H?2457=<C�.78i,/>O*;*;H/,'A4H/^�.7512TAPA�B�0GA ' � ß ' Ë U � � �kÕ X8# HJA � ](H`03*mH/*;^�N�>3C;C±>O2457A4H?A�B;H,/H/*LA4E[03.å^;57K@5124>3E/N 51*¾03* � � � Ê ,[B�0357*�>O6vA�B;H�U � � � C±>O51*LAkX $v8 Ë ï�X : Õ N�A4B;H'E�H?572º0�Z;*;57r@Z;H Ò ð'ؽ,'Z�E4KLH3N � N=?H/HJA�51*;: � Ë 03*;^�*;>m>3A�B;HJE`,/Z�E4KLH/2`>�KLH'E_A�B;H"2457*;:OZ;.90GE_C(>O57*�A Õ X +@51*;,'H � � l Ò o�� lpN � =?H'H'A�2 �*;>3E�=_03.7.78LXD)I6�� Ò�Ó ' Ê HG��A4E[03,JA�2PA�B;H`,/H/*LA4E[03.¿^;57K�5724>3Eg0GA���N�A�B;H/* � 572g0"Ï;];E4H3N � 03*;^ÍA�B;H`,/H'*�A4E�03.^;57K@5124>3Ee0GE�HM24H/,'A451>O*;2/N�03*;^�bcHÔB�0�KLHÔ,k0324H Ë ð Õ X�)+*�A�B;572e,k0324H � 512\A�B;HÔÏ;];E�H Ë ðOðOX � X # Õ be5VA�B4;gß � Ò ðOX

� A�B;H'E4bu5124H � ,'>O*�A[0357*;2yH ��03,'A4.78g>O*;H\2451*;:OZ;.10GEyC(>O51*LA � X �S>3A�Hc]�8U03^�FIZ;*;,'A�57>O*�N � ß � �3õ�X Ì HR,/>O*;2457^;H'EA�B;HÔ*;H ��AuBsZ;*LA�2IA�H'C�bu57A�BDE�H/2TC±H/,'AuA�><o�� ä � � XÌ H`0GE�:OZ;H?A4B�0GA Ë ' � � � ä �PÕ 512#:O5VKLH/*Í]s8 Ë ð�ï�X . Õ X-)+6 � � � � N�A�B;H/* � ß T >O6 Ë ð # X . Õ N � ß N

� Ü ' 3� 03*;^qA�B;HºE�H/24Z;.VAM512S,/.7Hk0GEkX +@>_bcHg,k03*Ð032424Z;=?H � � �� � X +@51*;,/Haó � ä � à ó<bcH#,/03*;*;>3AÔB�0kKLHg0*;H'AkN±>3EkN±]�8 Ë :�Xpï�X � Õ N�0_A�03,/*;>@^;H3X � ä � à ðON(24>?bvHU,/03*;*;>3AãB�0�KLHg0<A4E457C�.1HºC±>O51*LAkX Y BsZ;2 ' � 512ã0_6�H/*;,'H3N03*;^-A�B;HãE�H/2TZ;.7A�6�>O.7.1>�be2R69E�>O= Ë ð�ï�X . Õ X

�S>3A�H �� �� ß õ Ò � � .;NåbeB;57.1H � �� ß o ���� ß õ�X Y BsZ;2UA�B;H`Ï;E�2TA �¾]�.7>%bÖZ�C�2a>O6��c~ �� �¾Ò�Ó ' �0GE�H<03.1>O*;: � Xg)+*¾CW0GE4A�57,/Z;.90GE�� � �� � N 03*;^ � � 572P0D*;>O*@ؽ,[B�0351*Í2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457Aw8qbe5VA�B¾,/H'*�A�HJE Ò ó-03*;^¾Awbc>];E[03*;,[B;H/2 Ë ó Õ 03*;^ Ë ó � ó Õ X�# HJA � ß U � � � X �S>3A4H Ë 24H/H Ë ðOðOX1ð Õ4Õ A�B�0GA � 572vZ;*;51rsZ;H/.78<^;H'A�H'E�=<51*;H/^_]�8 �WN03*;^<A�B;He=_0GE4QLH/^UC(>O51*LA � � � Ns03*;^<A�B�Z;2¿]�8�� � � X ,�>3E¿H ��03=<C�.7Hu576 �Dß � � N�A�B;H/* � ß Ë � ä�ð Õ X �DB�03251*;^;HG��0GAu=?>O2TAuõ�NW03*;^�A4B;H'E�Hº0GE4HP0GAu.1Hk032IASó%ض,/Z�E4KLH/2u>%KLH'E � Ë 2457*;,/H � ,/>O*�A�0351*;2�0U2451*;:OZ;.10GEuC±>O51*LA Õ N�03*;^516 �i572 ãZ>H¿03.�57A�B�032u51*;^;H ��0GA�.7Hk032TA . Ë >3EuA�B;HPB�Z;*�A�,¨B;>s>O24H/2eA4B;H Ë ï Õ C(>O51*LA Õ X Y B�Z;2eA�B;HMC(>O24245V]�51.757A�57H/26�>3E �Ð0GE4H Ë ï � ó Õ � Ë ó � ï Õ 03*;^ � � N;be5VA�B�ï � � �

� X � *;Hº,[B;H/,�Q�2�6�>3EeHk03,[B�C(>O24245V]�51.757Aw8_A�B�0GA � Ë � � Õ - � � Ê� N24>Ube5VA�B->OZ�Ee,/>O*�KLH'*�A�57>O*�N;A�B;HPB�Z;*�Aubc>OZ;.1^-,¨B;>s>O24H � � 57*;2TA�Hk03^->O6 � N�0U,/>O*LA4E[03^;51,JA�51>O*�X �5 (�� �(�»�W�®� �¿���Í������£ ¤J¥ Ë ' Ê ��� Ê Õ�§¨¤�©Gª\´�¼ ��B �sÀ � � À+.Wù ¯�¯ ¬%ªk¤u¥®­;¤ ° ¤R´�ªu©P¼(¬�¼Wú4³¨­�©G´»¼aªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´»¥®· � �� � ʪ¨ùW³¨­#¥»­;©G¥�´Ç¸ Ñ ~�� ÒWÓ ' Ê ¤��O¥ ° ©s³J¥»ªc¥®­;¤e³[¤J¼�¥ ° ©GÂW³Jù ° µ3¤-, U ,�¥®­;¤J¼ � ´�ªR©S¼(¤'¥ ©G¼±¹ U ©3¼±¹ � Ê © ° ¤cªk¤¨³J¥®´½¬�¼;ª/À

Page 148: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

. � � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

Á ­;¤'¼ �

Ë ð Õ Ë ' Ê ��� Ê ÕÔ´�ªMùs¼W´|ø'ùW¤J ·�¹�¤J¥+¤ ° «U´�¼(¤�¹`§/· � ÀË ó Õ o���� ä � Ê ´�ªM¼(¤wÈL©G¥|´�µ3¤kÀË ï Õ Á ­;¤ ° ¤#© ° ¤U¤��@©�³J¥| ·<¥®­ ° ¤[¤Ô«gù@ ¥®´ ¯ Â1¤�2c§ ° ¤¨ª0,\¤�©�³¨­�Â1¬�È<¥+¤ ° «g´»¼±©GÂ7ÀË . Õ \µ3¤ ° ·<¼(¬�¼Wú4³¨­�©G´»¼"ª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© ° ´�¥|· � ¬�³[³Jù ° ªy¸�¬ ° ªk¬G«?¤ ¯ ©3´ ° Ë ' Ê ��� Ê Õ�À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ +@Z�C;C±>O24H Ñ ~ � Ò�Ó ' Ê 512e032u57*�A�B;HÔ2TA[0GA�H'=?H/*LAkX � .7Hk0GE�.78_A4B;H'E�Hº0GE4HMA�B�E4H/HP=gZ;.7A457C�.1HSÏ;];E�H'2/X #�H'A� ]±Hg0<=gZ;.7A�5VC�.1HMÏ;];E�H3X?$v8 Ë ðOðOX � X � Õ N � ,/>O*LA[0351*;2eH ��03,'A4.78DA+bv>_2451*;:OZ;.10GE�C(>O57*�A�2'N � � Uà03*;^ � � � Ê XY B;HeE�H/^;Z;,/H'^D,'>O=<C(>O*;H/*LA�2v>O6 � Ë 57*<A�B;H�.103*;:OZ�03:OHe>O6 Ë ðOðOX � X1ð Õ 03*;^ Ë ðOðOX � X � Õ4Õ NLHk03,[B_.751He>�KLH'Ec>O*;He>O6(A�B;H2457*;:OZ;.90GERC(>O51*LA�2/Xy)wAe6�>O.7.1>�be2\A�B;H'E4Hº0GE�HÔ*;><51*LA�H'E451>3ER]�.1>�bçZ�C�2e24> � 572u.7>O:aA�H'E4=?51*�03.®X

#�H'A�c~ �� Ò�Ó � ]±Ha0`E�H/.10GA�57KLH#=?57*;51=_03. =?>@^;H'. beB;57,[B�512M03*¾5724>O=?>3E4C�B;5724= 57*�0`*;H/51:OBL](>OZ�E�B;>s>@^>O6 �U Ü ��PX $v8 Ë ðOðOX � X � Õ N �q512ãZ;*;51rsZ;H/.78q^;HJA�H'E�=?57*;H/^q]s8 ��XM)I6@UÖ512M0 Ò �3ؽ,/Z�ETKLH3N�A4B;H/* � ß�4 ��N�03*;^U Ü � :OH/*;HJE[0GA�H/2#>O*;Ha>O6vA�B;H<H �@A4E�H/=?03.yE�0�8@2/N�03*;^ � Ê Ü U 512P03* �Oض,/Z�E4KLH3N ^;512»FI>O57*�A#69E4>O= U_X Y B;HÏ;E�2TAã]�.7>%b Z�Ci>O6 � Ë 6�>3EÔH/03,¨Bi=gZ;.7A�5VC�.1HºÏ;];E�H Õ 512M03.7>O*;: � N�03*;^ÐA�B;H/*qA�B;H'E�HU512M0`24H/r@Z;H'*;,/H<>O6å51*LA�H'E�57>3E]�.1>�bëZ�C�2cZ;*;51r@Z;H'.78a^;H'A�H'E�=<51*;H/^?]�8<A�B;HS=?0GE4QLH/^?2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8<>O6 U 0GA U � � X Y B;H�2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457A�57H/2 � � �03*;^ U � � B�0kKLHºA�B;H#2�03=<Hº51*;^;H �(N±A�B�Z;2ão����yä � Ê 572S*;H/:L0GA�57KLH Ë 2451*;,'HEUà512S,/>O*LA4E[03,'A457]�.1H Õ X�íS*L8-Awbc>�3ؽ,/Z�E4KLHa51* 4 �-^;572»FI>O51*LA#69E�>O=<U 0GE4HaC(HJE�=gZ�A�H/^¾]�8�03*�03Z�A�>O=?>3E4C�B;5724=ÄbeB;57,¨B¾512ÔATE�57K@5903.�>O* U_X Y B�Z;2Ë ' Ê ��� Ê Õ 512RZ;*;51rsZ;H/.78D^;H'A4H'E�=?57*;H/^-]�8 ��X �B �sÀ � D ¤J«<© °GF À )+*qA4B;Hº,k0324H#>O6 Ë ó3ï�X � X1ð Õ buB;H'E�H � ,'>O*�A[0357*;2�Awbc> � Ê 2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A451H/2/N�.1H'A � Ü ' Ê ]±HºA�B;H51=?03:OHa>O6vA�B;HUÏ;];E�H?buB;51,[B�CW032424H/2ÔA�B�E�>OZ;:OB�A�B;H<A4B;57E�^�2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457Aw8�03.7>O*;: � X Y B;H/*Ío����¿ä � ä � 572*�Z;=?H'E�57,k03.1.V8_A4E�57K@5903.®[email protected]>O:U,k03*;>O*;57,k03.|N�03*;^qó Ë o�����ä � ä �aÕ 572R.751*;Hk0GE4.78`H/rsZ;57KG03.1H/*LAuA4>)�/HJE�>;X Y B�Z;2 � 5720UAwbc>a,/>O=<C�.7H/=?H/*LAR6�>3E�o���� ä � N�24H/H Ë óOó@Xpï�Xpó Õ X

5 (�� �-�#� �`ÿO��¡/�¾� 5 (��65±�®�;¢%� +@Z�C;C±>O24H � Ê ,'>O*�A[0357*;2v0GA¿=?>O2TAyAwbc>º2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2'X2$c8 Ë óOó@Xæï�X1ð Õ o�����ä � ÊB�032g0�ð'ؽ,'>O=<C�.1H/=<H/*�A/N ¦ X Y B�0GA#512/N�A4B;H'E�H_512º0-E�H/^;Z;,/H/^j,/Z�E4KLH ¦ N�,/>O*LA[0357*;51*;: � 032g03*Í57ETE�H/^;Z;,/5V]�.1H,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*LAkN;be5VA�B�A�B;HM6�>O.1.7>%bu51*;:UC;E�>3C(HJE4A�51H'2/~

Ë�� Õ o����(ä ¦ 512vA4E�5VK�5103.|N � 0GE4A451H'EkNs.1>O:#,k03*;>O*;57,k03.|N�03*;^Do�� �±ä � 512c.7>O:ºA�H'E�=<51*�03.�03*;^�03*LA�5ÛØw03=<C�.7H�6�>3EH'KLH'ET8�5VE4E�H/^;Z;,'57]�.1HÔ,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*�A � >O6 ¦ XÌ Hãbe57.1.�6�>3E�:OHJAS0G](>OZ�A � Ê N�^�E�>3C�A4B;HÔ24Z�]�2T,'E�57C;A/N(03*;^-,'.903242457698�CW035VE�2 Ë '���¦¾Õ N�2�0GA�5724698�57*;: Ë�� Õ X

B �sÀ �)D ¤'«<© ° F ª/À Y B;HP,/>O*;^;5VA�51>O*;2R51* Ë�� Õ N;A�>O:OH'A�B;HJEubu57A�B-03^�FIZ;*;,'A�57>O*�N�57=<C�.78?A4B;HP6�>O.1.7>%bu51*;:;~Ë ð Õ Y B;H<>O*;.V8"C(>O24245V]�.1Ha2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A�57H/2M>O6 ' 03.1>O*;: ¦ 0GE�H<0GAÔA�B;HU51*LA�H'E424H/,'A�57>O*¾C(>O57*�A42P>O6�Awbc>-57E4E�H¨Ø

^;Z;,/5V]�.1HÔ,/>O=<C(>O*;H'*�A�2'XË ó ÕD¦ 572P*;H/,/H'242�0GE�57.78¾E4H/^;Z;,/57]�.7H3Ny03*;^ÍB�032ºH/5VA�B;H'EÔA+bv>"57E4E�H'^;Z;,/57]�.7H?,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*�A42/N�=?H/HJA�51*;:�57*¾Awbc>

C±>O51*LA�2/N�>3EeB�032RA�B�E�H/HM57ETE�H/^;Z;,/5V]�.1Hº,/>O=aC(>O*;H/*LA�2R6�>3E�=?51*;:a0UATE�5903*;:O.7H3XË ï Õ>'�ác¦ 572 ãZ>H¿03.|X

Page 149: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � . ��0

Ì H?Ï;E�2IAa57*�ATE�>@^;Z;,/H_Awbc>ÐZ;24H/6�Z;.v]�5VE[0GA�51>O*�03.�A4E[03*;246�>3E�=?0GA�51>O*;2/X Ì HD2IA[0GE4A#bu57A�Bj0�CW0357E Ë '���¦iÕ 03*;^>3];A[0357*"0a*;H'bçCW035VE Ë '98 ��¦ 87Õ X '98 512e>3];A�0351*;H/^-]�8�>O*;HÔ]�.1>�b Z�Cq03*;^">O*;HÔ]�.7>%b ^;>�be*�N�03*;^ ¦ 8 ,/>O*;24572TA�2>O6 A4B;HÔC�Z;24B;6�>3E4bc0GE�^">O6 A�B;HãA�>3A[03.(A4E�03*;246�>3E�=×>O6 ¦ XÌ H�E�H'=?51*;^_A�B;H�E�H/03^;H'ER>O6�>OZ�E\2IC(>3E[03^;57,k03.1.V8?H/=<C�.7>%8LH'^D,'>O*�KLH/*LA�57>O*�>O6�Z;2457*;:gA4B;HM2403=?H�*;>3A[0GA�57>O*?A�>

51*;^;57,k0GA�HÔ0a,/Z�ETKLH3N±03*;^-57A�2R2TA4E�57,'ARA4E[03*;246�>3E�=ÖZ;*;^;H'ES0U]�57E�0GA�51>O*�03.(A4E�03*;246�>3E�=_0GA�57>O*�X

5 (�� ' 7��:9������%�������¿�@�Í�����

�I© � .Wù ¯L¯ ¬%ª�¤g©�³¨¬�« ¯ ¬�¼�¤J¼�¥�, � ,R¬+¸u¦ ´�ªº©_Ò ð ú�³Jù ° µ3¤kÀe£ ¤J¥ ��ÒWÓ ' ¤��O¥ ° ©s³J¥R©�¹G´»µ�´�ªk¬ ° , U ,\©L¹T²/©�³[¤J¼W¥�¥+¬�`À � Ü �Ö´�ªU³¨¬�¼�¥ ° ©�³J¥|´|§'Â1¤�ÀM£ ¤'¥ �ÝÒ±Ó ' 8 §J¤º¥®­;¤<³[¬�¼�¥ ° ©�³'¥®´¶¬G¼m¬+¸ �`ÀÔ£ ¤J¥ � � ' 8 §¨¤#¥»­�¤º´�«?©�È�¤?¬+¸�`À

�I§ � .Wù ¯L¯ ¬%ª�¤Ô¥»­�¤ ° ¤#©?Ò ð ú4³'ù ° µ3¤ ûy´�¥®­D¥»­�¤�¸k¬�Â�Â1¬Gûy´�¼@È ¯(° ¬ ¯ ¤ ° ¥|´¶¤¨ª��Ë ð Õ � ¦ ´�ª`©ÐªJ´�¼@ÈGÂ1¤ ¯ ¬�´»¼�¥ , Î ,g©Ðª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© °Ô¯ ¬G´�¼�¥º¬+¸ '+,#©G¼±¹ «?¤[¤'¥»ª-©Ðù@¼�´|ø'ùW¤"³Jù ° µ3¤�¬+¸_¥®­;¤

«g´�¼W´�«<©G ¹s¤¨ª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© ° ´�ª/©G¥|´¶¬�¼¾¬Gµ3¤ ° Î ÀË ó Õ Á ­;¤Pª¨¥ ° ´¶³J¥¿¥ ° ©G¼;ª»¸k¬ ° «gª#¬+¸ ©G¼±¹P¦ ¬�¼q¥®­;¤P«g´»¼�´�«<©GÂ�¹�¤¨ª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© ° ´�ª/©3¥®´¶¬G¼i© ° ¤#¹3´�ª�²k¬�´»¼�¥½ÀË ï Õ ³[¬�¼�¥w©G´�¼�ªã©G¥å«?¬%ª¨¥v¬G¼(¤Ô¬G¥»­;¤ ° ªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© °�¯ ¬�´»¼�¥¿¬+¸+' ,¿©G¼±¹ o��uä ´�ªeÂ1¬�ÈU¥w¤ ° «g´�¼±©3Â�©Gûv©G·c¸ ° ¬�«

Î À£ ¤'¥ � Ò±Ó ' ¤ �O¥ ° ©�³J¥u¥»­;¤?¹3´�µ�´�ªk¬ ° , U ,S¬�µ3¤ ° Î û�­�´¶³¨­"´�ª<©�¹I²/©�³[¤'¼�¥\¥+¬ À Ü � ´�ª<³[¬G¼�¥ ° ©�³J¥|´|§'Â1¤kÀa£ ¤J¥�çÒ�Ó '98R§¨¤P¥®­;¤g³[¬G¼�¥ ° ©�³J¥|´¶¬�¼�¬I¸ À\£ ¤J¥ � � '98R§¨¤P¥®­;¤Ô´»«<©�È�¤g¬I¸ À

� ¼q§J¬�¥»­-³�©Gªk¤¨ªS¥»­�¤S¼�¤Jû ¯ ©G´ ° Ë ' 8 ��¦ 8 Õ#©GÂpªk¬#ª/©3¥®´�ª�2c¤¨ª���� � À � ¼¾³�©�ªk¤��I© � ,(¦ 8 ­�©�ªS¥®­;¤Sª/©G«?¤M¼�ù@«<§¨¤ ° ¬+¸³[¬�« ¯ ¬�¼(¤J¼W¥»ªº©GªR¦ ,v§'ù@¥v´�¼�³�©Gªk¤ �I§ � ¥»­;¤º¼�ù@«<§¨¤ ° ¬+¸#³[¬G« ¯ ¬�¼(¤'¼�¥»ªSÈ�¬�¤¨ªMù ¯ §/·D¬G¼(¤kÀ

Y B;HÔ57*�KLH'E424HÔA4E�03*;246�>3E�=_0GA�57>O*;2 Ë ' 8 ��¦ 8 Õ � ��� Ë '9��¦iÕ 0GE�HMHk032T8DA�>U^;H/24,'E457](HG~

5 (��»�@� 7�� 9y�����%�»���������Í�����`£ ¤J¥ Ë ' 8 ��¦ 8 Õaª/©3¥®´�ª»¸¨· ��� � ÀD£ ¤J¥ � � ¦ 8 §¨¤`©�ª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© °ã¯ ¬�´�¼W¥�� ° ¤¨ª ¯ Ài©

ª¨«?¬%¬�¥»­ ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥ � ¬+¸#¦ 8 ,P ·G´�¼@È�¬�¼ë©G¼ ´ °¨° ¤[¹Gù�³'´|§'Â1¤"³[¬�« ¯ ¬�¼(¤J¼W¥ U ¬+¸g¦ �w¥»­;¤ ° ¤�© ° ¤�¥®ûc¬m³¨­;¬�´½³[¤¨ª-¬+¸ Uû�­;¤'¼ � ´�ª`©"ª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© °Ô¯ ¬�´�¼�¥�,º©G¼±¹�¬�¼� ·m¬�¼(¤-³¨­;¬�´½³[¤?ûy­;¤J¼ � ´�ªD©�ªJ«?¬�¬�¥®­ ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥ � Ài£ ¤J¥ �' Ò�Ó �' 8 §¨¤©m³[¬�« ¯ ¬%ª¨´�¥|´¶¬�¼t¬I¸D§/Â1¬�û ù ¯ ª5,#ûy´�¥®­m¥»­;¤"³¨¤J¼�¥+¤ ° ¬+¸�¤�©s³¨­�§'Â1¬�û ù ¯ ©G¥Ô¥»­�¤Dùs¼�´¶ø'ù�¤ ¯ ¬�´�¼�¥g¬+¸ �½¥®­;¤`ª¨¥ ° ´¶³'¥¥ ° ©G¼;ª»¸k¬ ° « ¬+¸ � U ,P ·�´�¼�È�¬Gµ3¤ ° � À �RÂ1¬�û ù ¯ ©G¥ãÂ1¤�©�ªJ¥#¤J¼(¬GùOÈ�­Í¥|´�«?¤¨ª?ªk¬q¥®­�©G¥Ô¥»­;¤_ªk¤' ¸¨úw´�¼�¥+¤ ° ªk¤[³J¥|´¶¬�¼�¬+¸U Ü �' ´�ª`©G¥ã«?¬%ªJ¥�Ò ó ÀУ ¤J¥ � Ü �' � ° ¤Jª ¯ À Ü �' � §¨¤_¥»­;¤_ù@¼�´|ø'ùW¤<Ò ð ú4³Jù ° µ3¤-¬�µ3¤ ° Î ,㥮­�©G¥ã´�ªa¥®­;¤¤��@³¨¤ ¯ ¥|´¶¬�¼±©GÂ�¹G´�µ%´�ªk¬ ° ¬+¸S¥®­;¤MÂ7©�ª¨¥c§'Â1¬�û ù ¯ À\£ ¤J¥ �'�ÒWÓ 'ݳ[¬G¼�¥ ° ©�³J¥¿©3Â�Â�¥»­;¤ o ¼�¬�¼�úw¼(¤wÈL©G¥|´�µ3¤º³Jù ° µ3¤¨ª0,¿¬G¼(¤¬+¸?û�­�´¶³J­ ,M§/·�³[¬�¼;ªJ¥ ° ù�³J¥|´¶¬�¼ ,S´�ª U Àq£ ¤J¥ Î � 'Ö§¨¤_¥»­;¤_´�«<©%È�¤D¬+¸ U Ü �'�À Ë '���¦iÕ<ª/©G¥|´�ª 2\¤¨ª ��� � ,Ô©3¼±¹Ë '98 ��¦ 87ÕM´�ªM¬L§'¥½©3´�¼(¤�¹\¸ ° ¬�« Ë '9��¦iÕM§'·U«?© F ´�¼@È<©U¥ ° ©G¼;ª�¸�¬ ° «<©3¥®´¶¬G¼Ð¬I¸e¥|· ¯ ¤ �I© � � ° ¤¨ª ¯ �I§ � � ¤��O¥ ° ©�³J¥|´�¼@È U ,©G¼±¹?ù�ª¨´»¼@È Î�� � Ü ' � ° ¤¨ª ¯ À Î � Ü ' � À

* ° ¬�¬+¸¨ªº¬+¸ ��B �@À��Gú A���� À Y B;H/24HP0GE�HPHk032I8LN;24H/HP6�>3EeH ��03=aC�.1H Ë ðOðOX . Õ X �Ì Hãbe57.1.(E�H'6�H'E�A�>gA�B;HÔATE[03*;246�>3E�=_0GA451>O*;2\>O6 Ë ó3ï�X # Ø�ð�Å Õ 032u]±H/51*;:a>O6 Aw8@C±H Ë 0 Õ N Ë ] Õ N Ë 0 Õ � Ê 03*;^ Ë ] Õ � Ê X

Page 150: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

.�� + ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

5 (��»��� �¿�@�Í�����D£ ¤J¥ 'çÒ�Ó 'Ú§¨¤a¥®­;¤a«g´»¼�´�«<©GÂ�¹s¤¨ª¨´�¼@È3ùsÂ7© ° ´�ª/©G¥|´¶¬�¼Í´»¼�©-¼(¤J´1ÈG­�§¨¬�ù ° ­;¬%¬k¹q¬+¸ã¦ �½¥®­�©G¥´�ª ° ¤¨ªk¬� µ�´»¼@È_¬�¼� ·?¥»­�¤ãª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥®´½¤¨ªÔ©GÂ1¬�¼@ÈÔ¦ � À � ¸ ' ­�©�ªP© o � úw¼(¤½È�©G¥®´»µ3¤P§'´ ° ©3¥®´¶¬G¼±©G ³[¬�¼�¥ ° ©s³J¥®´½¬�¼ ,y¥»­�¤J¼Ë '���¦iÕM­�©�ªº©_¥ ° ©G¼;ª�¸�¬ ° «<©3¥®´¶¬G¼�¬+¸M¥|· ¯ ¤ �I© � ¬ ° �I§ � À

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ �S>3A4Hg]�8 Ë ó3ï�X1:�Xpï Õ N ' 512 ãZ H¿03.|X +@Z�C;C(>O24H ' B�032M0Do � ؽ*;H/:L0GA�5VKLH#]�57E[0GA�57>O*�03.�,/>O*LA4E[03,'A451>O*�XP)+6A�B;HM032424>s,/590GA4H/^ Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�ETKLHÔ572u0g,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*LAkN � >O6 ¦ N@A�B;H'*-,/.7Hk0GE�.78_bvHMB�0kKLHÔ0gA4E�03*;246�>3E�=_0GA�57>O*`>O6�Aw8@C±HË 0 Õ X � A�B;HJE4be5724H\,k03.1.�A�B;H Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLH X2$c8 Ë ï�Xpï Õ N3o � ä 572�.1>O:�A�H'E4=?51*�03.®NO03*;^ ,/>O*LA[0351*;2y0GAy=?>O2IA�>O*;H2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA+8LX2#�H'A ¦ 8 Ü ' ]±HMA4B;HMA�>3A�03.(A4E[03*;246�>3E�=Ö>O6 ¦ Xyo � ä ¦ 8 ß R " Ë o��Pä ¦iÕ N@A�B�Z;2eo � ä ¦ 8 572*�Z;=?H'E�57,k03.1.V8<A4E�5VK�5103.|X Y BsZ;2 ¦ 8 � ÞÚß Ò o �� � � ßÝðOX Y BsZ;2 =<H/H'A�2\0#Z;*;51rsZ;HÔ5VE4E�H/^;Z;,'57]�.1Hã,/>O=aC(>O*;H/*LA>O6 ¦ 8 X Y B;512R=gZ;2TAu]±Hº03*�H �;,/HJC;A�51>O*�03.�,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*LAkN�>3E Ü ' 572u,/>O*LA4E[03,JA�57]�.7H3X �5 (��»�15 NM��� ����¡k���%�»���¿��£ ¤J¥ Ë '���¦iÕÔª/©3¥®´�ª»¸¨· ��� � À��c¼(¤a¬+¸M¥®­;¤å¸k¬GÂ�Â1¬�ûy´�¼@È?­;¬�Â7¹�ª��

� A�� Á ­;¤ ¯ ©G´ ° Ë '���¦¾Õ�´�ªe¥+¬ ° ´¶³ �¶ªk¤[¤���BQB@À � � � ,¿¬ ° ¬O§'¥w©G´�¼(¤�¹c¸ ° ¬�«à©U¥+¬ ° ´½³ ¯ ©3´ ° §'·<©gª¨´�¼@È3Â1¤�¥ ° ©G¼�ª�¸k¬ ° «<©G¥|´¶¬�¼¬+¸M¥|· ¯ ¤ Ë � Õ � ÊGÀ

��B � ' ß 4�5 ,�¦ ³[¬G¼;ª¨´�ª¨¥®ªº¬+¸º©32v§ ° ¤Ôùs¼W´¶¬�¼�©<ªk¤[³J¥|´¶¬�¼"û�­s´¶³¨­ ¯ ©Gª[ªk¤¨ªM¥®­ ° ¬�ùOÈG­D¥»­�¤Ôª¨´�¼�ÈGùsÂ7© °v¯ ¬�´»¼�¥½À�� �㪺©ª ¯ ¤¨³J´|©G ³�©�ª�¤Ôûv¤ãÈs¤J¥�É���©G¼±¹P¦ ´�ªº©D³[¬G¼�´¶³Ôù@¼�´¶¬�¼Í©< ´�¼(¤�À �

��� � ' ß 4 � ©G¼±¹º¦ ³[¬�¼�ª¨´�ª¨¥®ªº¬+¸M¥|ûv¬aª�¤[³J¥|´¶¬�¼;ªã´�¼i¥»­�¤Mª¨«?¬�¬G¥»­-Â1¬�³Jùsª/À� � � Ë '���¦iÕ�´�ªÔ¬O§'¥w©G´�¼�¤�¹v¸ ° ¬�« ¥»­�¤ ¯ ©G´ ° ´�¼ ��B � §'·<©gªk¤�ø/ù�¤J¼�³[¤Ô¬I¸e¥ ° ©G¼�ª�¸k¬ ° «<©G¥|´¶¬�¼;ªÔ¬+¸�¥®· ¯ ¤ Ë � Õ � Ê�À � ¬ ° ¤Jú

¬�µ3¤ ° ,c¤��s©s³J¥®Â ·�¬�¼�¤U³[¬�« ¯ ¬�¼(¤J¼W¥ , � ,\¬+¸R¦ ´�ªº©aÒ ð ú4³Jù ° µ3¤U©G¼±¹ � ­�©Gªº© A ú4³¨¬�« ¯ Â1¤J«_¤J¼�¥�T �¶ªk¤¨¤ � B B �ª¨ùW³¨­D¥®­�©G¥ Ë '�� T#Õº´�ªã¥+¬ ° ´¶³�À

B �sÀ A � D ¤J«<© °GF ª/ÀË ð Õ )+*D,k0324H Ë . Õ N@A4B;HãC;E4>@>O6�:O57KLH/2R0º]�57A\=<>3E�HS51*;6�>3E�=?0GA�51>O*�X ,W>3EcA�B;HSA4E[03*;246�>3E4=_0GA�51>O*;2'N@A�B;Hã24H/,'A451>O*

572u*;H'KLHJE�,/>O*LA4E[03,'A4H/^�X � 512\A�B;HÔ>3A�B;H'Eu,/>O=<C(>O*;H'*�AkXË ó Õ �S>3A�HM51*DCW0GE4A�57,/Z;.90GERA�B�0GARA�B;HÔ2TZ�E�6�03,/H ' 572RA�>3E451,3N;H ��,/H'C;AuC(>O24245V]�.78D51*DA�B;HP2TH/,/>O*;^",k0324HM>O6 Ë ð Õ X

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ �S>3A4HDA�B;HJE�H-,k03*�>O*;.78m](H-0ÐÏ�*;57A4H-24H/rsZ;H/*;,/H�>O6uA4E[03*;246�>3E�=?0GA�51>O*;2 Ë >O6�03*L8mAw8@C(H Õ Nv2457*;,/H-Hk03,[B51=aC;E�>%KLH'2RA�B;HÔ2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A451H/2/X �S>3A�HP03.124>;N;57*"03*�8D24H'r@Z;H/*;,/H#>O6�A4E[03*;246�>3E4=_0GA�51>O*;2'N�A4B;H'E�HP,/03*-](HP0GAe=?>O2IA>O*;H->O6�Aw8sC(H Ë ] Õ Nc2457*;,/H->3A�B;HJE4be5724H ¦ 8 bc>OZ;.1^�B�0�KLH"0GAa.1H/032TA?6�>OZ�E_,'>O=<C(>O*;H/*LA�2/N�K�51>O.10GA�51*;: Ë ó3ï�X1:�X1ð Õ X,�51*�03.7.78M*;>3A�H¿A4B�0GA�516 Ë ' 8 ��¦ 8 Õ B�032�0uA4E[03*;246�>3E4=_0GA�51>O*Ô>O6�Aw8@C(H Ë ] Õ NGA�B;H'*#24>S^;>@H/2 Ë '���¦¾Õ ß Ë � Õ � Ê Ë ' 8 ��¦ 8 ÕË 03* Ë � Õ � Ê A4E[03*;246�>3E�=?0GA�51>O*Dbe57.1.�*;>3Au^;H/2TA4E�>�8�0a,/Z�ETKLHP>O6 Aw8@C±H 57* Ë ó3ï�X # Õ4Õ X

�S>�b�2TA[0GETASbe5VA�BÐ0`CW035VE Ë '���¦¾Õ X ��H'E�6�>3E�= 0?A4E[03*;246�>3E4=_0GA�51>O*">O6yAw8@C±H Ë ] Õ 516å>O*;HUHG�;512IA�2/X Y B;HU>O*;.786�Z�E4A�B;HJEeC(>O2T2457]�.7HÔA4E[03*;2T6�>3E�=_0GA�57>O*;2e0GE�HM>O6 Aw8sC(H Ë 0 Õ X

�S>�bâ032424Z;=<H\bvHRB�0kKLH Ë '���¦iÕ 03*;^aA�B;HJE�H\512y*;>MATE[03*;246�>3E�=_0GA451>O*#>O6�A+8sC(H Ë 0 Õ >3E Ë ] Õ X Y B;H/*U]s8 Ë ó3ï�X � Õ NH/5VA�B;H'E ' 512R24=?>s>3A�BD03.1>O*;: ¦ N;>3E ' N�A�B;HM=?51*;57=_03.±^;H/2T51*;:OZ;.90GE4512�0GA�57>O*->O6 ' 51*�0a*;H/57:OB�]±>OZ�E�B;>@>s^->O6 ¦ N512U0"*;H'AkNå>O6 ��51,k0GE4^j*�Z;=#](H'EUAwbc>;X +@51*;,/HDo � ä ¦ 8 512#A4E�5VK�5903.®Ny03*;^ ¦ 8 Ü ' 3 Nå57Ag6�>O.7.1>�be2#A�B�0GA ' 57224=?>s>3A�B�X �S>�bÝ576 ¦ B�032eAwbc>_,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*�A42�57Ae512�Hk032I8-A�>?2TH/HºbcHºB�0kKLH Ë ó Õ >3E Ë ï Õ N�03*;^"516 ¦ B�032eA4B�E�H/H

Page 151: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � .���.

,/>O=<C±>O*;H/*LA�2/NW57A�572eHk032I8�A�><,¨B;H',[Q�A�B�0GA ' ß 4?5"03*;^ ¦ 572uAwbc><Ï;];E�H'2�Z;*;51>O*q0<2TH/,'A�57>O*"51*-A�B;HÔ24=?>s>3A�B.1>s,/Z;2 Ë 032e0U2TC(H',/5903.�,k0324HMbcHÔ:OHJA É � 03*;^�A�B�E�H/HÔ.151*;H'2 Õ N;beB;57,[B"0GE�HÔ03.1.(A�>3E�57,3X

�S>3A�H Ë � Õ � Ê A4E[03*;2T6�>3E�=_0GA�57>O*;2UC;E�H'24H'E4KLHDA�>3E�51,`CW0357E42/X +@>�516RbcH�H'*;^�be5VA�B�A4B�E�H/H-,'>O=<C(>O*;H/*LA�2/N�bcH](H':L03*�51*DA�B;HÔ2T57A�Z�0GA�57>O*->O6 Ë ð Õ X

+@>`bcHg,k03*�03242TZ;=?H#bcHaH'*;^ibu57A�B Ë ó Õ >3E Ë ï Õ N�03*;^qbcHU>3];A[0351*qA�B;Hg>3E�51:O57*�03. CW0357Eã]�8Ð0D2TH/r@Z;H/*;,'H<>O6Ë � Õ � Ê A4E[03*;2T6�>3E�=_0GA�57>O*;2/X)+* Ë ï Õ Ns0369A�H'E¿>O*;HeA4E[03*;2T6�>3E�=_0GA�57>O*<>O6±Aw8@C±H Ë � Õ � Ê N�A�B;HJE�H�512¿0P,/Z�E4KLHe>O6±Aw8@C(H çË A�B;H�2TATE�51,'AåA4E[03*;2T6�>3E�=

>O6 A�B;HãÏ;];E�HPA4B�E�>OZ;:OB � Õ N�A4B�0GAe572RA�B;HÔ*;H'bçCW0357Ee03^;=?57A42u0UA4E[03*;246�>3E�=?0GA�51>O*D>O6 Aw8@C±H Ë ] Õ X Ì HME�Z;.1H'^�>OZ�AA�B;572RC±>O242457]�57.15VA+8�0G]±>%KLH3X

+@>"bcH_,k03*j032424Z;=<H_>OZ�Eg>3E�51:O57*�03.�CW0357Eº512#>3];A[0357*;H/^m69E�>O= Ë � Õ � Ê ATE[03*;246�>3E�=_0GA451>O*;2#0GC;C�.751H/^mA�> Ë ó Õ XÌ Hã*;H/H/^�>O*;.78<,¨B;H',[Q`A�B;HãH �@A4E[0#,/>O*;^;5VA�51>O*;2\51* Ë . Õ X�#�H'A ¦ Ê ]±HSA�B;Hã24H/,'A�57>O*�>O6�24H/.761ؽ57*�A�HJE�24H/,'A451>O* �ºä�ó@N03*;^ ¦ � A�B;HMÏ;];E�H3X

#�H'A � � 4>5m](HgA�B;Hg51*LA�H'E�24H','A�51>O*ÐC(>O57*�AM>O6�A4B;Ha2TATE�51,'AãA4E�03*;246�>3E�=?2ã>O6 ¦ Ê 03*;^ ¦ � X # HJA�� � 4>5�]±HA�B;HgC(>O57*�AãbuB;H'E�H ¦ Ê =?H/H'A�2SA�B;HU*;H/:L0GA�5VKLHa2TH/,'A�57>O*�XE# H'A � ](HgA�B;HgÏ;];E�H<>O6 4�5ÐA4B�E�>OZ;:OB � X Y B;HJE�Ha5720�Z;*;57r@Z;HU24H/,'A451>O* 5ÍÜ 4>5jbeB;57,¨B¾512M^;512»FI>O57*�AÔ69E�>O= A�B;Ha*;H':L0GA�57KLHU24H/,'A451>O*�N 03*;^�B�032 Ë �?äëð Õ�� � >3E4^;H'E,/>O*LA[03,'A�bu57A4B ¦ Ê 0GA � X +@,¨B;H'=?HJضA4B;H/>3E�H'A�57,k03.1.V8LN ¦ Ê � 5Dß Ë �<ä ð Õ � X\íS2eE4H/=_0GE4QLH/^q0G]±>%KLHGN�A�B;HPCW035VEË ¦ � ä � ä 5 � 4?5 Õ 512RA�>3E�57,3XÌ Hãbe57.1.�0GE�:OZ;HãA�B�0GAe0369A�H'ES03*L8`]�.1>�bçZ�C��¦ �Ê Ë A4B;HÔ24H'.161ؽ57*�A4H'E�24H/,JA�51>O*">O6 A4B;HÔ2TATE�51,'ARA4E[03*;2T6�>3E�= >O*�A�B;H

=?57*;51=_03.;^;H/2T51*;:OZ;.90GE4512�0GA�57>O* Õ E�H/=?0351*;2¿C±>O2457A�5VKLH3X�)+*_CW0GE4A�51,'Z;.90GEkN ¦ Ê bu51.7.±*;H'KLH'Ec]±H�,[B;>O24H/*�032 U Ë 57*?A�B;H.903*;:OZ�03:OHP>O6 Ë ó3ï�X1ð�Å Õ4Õ X Y BsZ;2ãHk03,[Bq>O6�A�B;HºA4E[03*;246�>3E4=_0GA�51>O*;2e512eA�>3E451,Pbu57A�B�E4H/2TC(H','AãA�> Ë ¦ � ä � ä 5 ÕË 03*;^�57A�2\A4E[03*;246�>3E4=?2 Õ X Ë . Õ A�B;H/*�6�>O.7.1>�be2R51=<=?H/^;590GA4H/.78LX

�S>3A�HqA�B�0GA�Z;*;.7H/242 � Ë 51*ëA�B;H¾.103*;:OZ�03:OH¾>O6 Ë ó3ï�X7ð�Å Õ4Õ ,/>3E4E�H/2IC(>O*;^;2�A�>�H/57A�B;HJE � >3E � N�A4B;H'E�H�572�0*;H/57:OB�]±>OZ�E�B;>@>s^?>O6 �� ä � 5�ä �¦ Ê Ë >O*aA4B;Hu=?57*;51=_03.s^;H/2457*;:OZ;.90GE�572�0GA�51>O* Õ buB;51,[B?512å*;>3A�H'è(H/,JA�H/^�X2,�Z�ETA�B;H'EA�B;H'E4HP512u0a*;H'51:OBL](>OZ�E�B;>s>@^�>O6 �� buB;51,[B"512RH'è±H/,'A�H/^->O*;.78D516 � ß � NW03*;^"03*L8�,[B;>O57,/HP>O6 � B�032RA�B;HP2�03=<HH'è±H/,'A�>O*�*sZ;=#]±H'E�2 �¦ �Ê N � �5 NW03*;^ ¦ Ê � 5 Ë A4B;HÔ>3E�^;HJE�>O6 ,'>O*�A[03,JAS0GA �;Õ X

�S>�bâ516WbcHe,[B;>@>O2TH � ß � N�A�B;H'*?0369A�H'E�A�B;H\A4E[03*;246�>3E�=?0GA�51>O* � 512�0 Ò ð'ؽ,/Z�ETKLH�>O6�Aw8@C±H N�0MC±>O242457]�57.15VA+8bcHÔB�0�KLHãE�Z;.1H'^�>OZ�AkX)+6�0369A�H'ER0º]�.1>�b Z�C Ë 51*_A�B;HS,'>O*;2TA4E�Z;,'A451>O*D>O6 �'�Ò�Ó �' 8 51* Ë ó3ï�X1ð�Å ÕTÕ �¦ Ê ]±H/,/>O=?H/2c*;>O*@Ø|C(>O245VA�57KLHGN@A�B;H/*

� 5"512�24HJCW0GE[0GA�H/^q69E�>O= �¦ Ê N�03*;^">O*"A�B;H#*;H'bÝ24Z�E�6�03,/HGN 5�572ã0 Ò ð'ض,/Z�E4KLH#>O6�Aw8@C±H N(0?,/>O*�ATE[03^;51,'A451>O*032\](H/6�>3E�HGX �� � ������� � � � �¿��â������������ &�$�����J���(�Ð$%��� ����&O����9������$U�����������J�����±���� �Ì HÔ*;>3A�Hº6�>3EeA4B;HPE�Hk03^;H'E42�,/>O*LKLH/*;51H/*;,'H Ë >3E�H/^;5VÏ�,k0GA�57>O* Õ A�B�0GA�0<*;>3E�=_03.�24Z�E�6�03,'H#512e.7>O:aA�HJE�=?51*�03.�5Vè

57AgB�032grsZ;>3A�51H/*LAg2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VA�51H/2'N�03*;^mA�B�0GAg6�>3E � 03*�03*�03.78sA�51,k03.7.78i57E4E4H/^;Z;,/57]�.7H`:OH'E�= >O6u0q,'Z�E4KLHD0GA�Î�NÎ�� � Ü ' N�576 ' 512c:O5VKLH/*`.1>@,/03.1.78<03*�03.78sA�51,/03.1.78<0G](>OZ�A Î"032vA�B;HSrsZ;>3A�51H'*�A � ~ � ÒWÓ ' bu57A4B � 24=<>@>3A�B�N

Page 152: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

.���) ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

A�B;H/*<o��cä � 572¿.7>O:MA�HJE�=?51*�03. Ë E�H/2TC�Xy.1>O:Ô,k03*;>O*;51,/03. Õ 0GA�Î`5Vè � " Ë �ºÕ Ü ��572�2T=?>@>3A�B Ë E�H'2TC�XyB�032¿*;>3E�=_03.,'E�>O2T2451*;:O2 Õ X ,W>3Ee0gC;E�>@>O6 24H/H Ë ó3Å�Xpï Õ >O6cî}ó � ñ¶X

#�H'A�Î�� � Ü ' ]±HP0#C(>O57*�AR>O6 ' >O*DA4B;H Ë *;>O*@ضH/=<C;Aw8 Õ E4H/^;Z;,/H/^�,'Z�E4KLH � X Ì HÔ:O5VKLHãA4B;HM,JE�57A�HJE�590g6�>3E.1>O:UA�H'E�=<51*�03.�03*;^�.7>O:<,k03*;>O*;57,k03.�0GAåÎ�51*DA�B;512R,k0324H3X@,�>3ERC;E�>s>O6�2u24H'Hº,[B�0GC;A�H'ESïU>O6cî}ó � ñ¶X

+@Z�C;C(>O2THÔÏ;E�2TAåÎ"572e0U2451*;:OZ;.10GEeC(>O57*�Au>O6 ' ~o��ºä � 512u.7Au57è_Îq512e0a,'8@,/.157,P2457*;:OZ;.90GE�5VAw8LN�03*;^-A�B;HÔE4H/24>O.1Z�A451>O*�:3E[0GC�B-512�0U,[B�0351*�N�be5VA�B �� =?H/H'A�57*;:

>O*;HMH/*;^->O6�A�B;Hã,¨B�0357*�NW03*;^-*;>3E�=_03.7.78LX�)+*`CW0GE4A�51,'Z;.90GE � 512\24=?>s>3A�B-0GA�Î�X Ì Hãbe57.1.±E4H/6�H'EeA4>UA�B;HãZ;*;57r@Z;HH ��,/H'C;A�57>O*�03.�^;5VK�5724>3EubuB;51,[B �� =?H'H'A�2u032RA�B;HÔ^;57K@5124>3E �W�*)k�WÿL�@�(�#��� � >�KLH'EyÎ�X)+6 � 512S2457*;:OZ;.90GEM0GA¿Î�N(A4B;H/*qo��aä � 572S.1>O:_,k03*;>O*;57,k03. Ë .7, Õ 0GA¿Îi57è � B�032�A+bv>�03*�03.V8@A�57,P];E[03*;,[B;H/2

0GAvÎ�N�Hk03,[BÐ>O6åbuB;51,[BÐ516å24=?>@>3A4B�N�ξ512ã0`,¨B�0357*i2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457Aw8LN±A�B;HºAwbc>`];E[03*;,[B;H/2M>O6 �� 0GE4HU^;572»FI>O51*LAkN�03*;^=?H/HJAe>3C;C±>O2457A�HMH/*;^;2u>O6 A�B;HM,¨B�0357*�N±03*;^-*;>3E�=_03.1.V8LX)+6 � 512M24=?>@>3A4B�0GA\ÎÍA�B;H/*�o��<ä � 512P.7,U]�Z�AP*;>3Aº.VAkN 5VèÐÎÍ512Ô0-*;>O*@ؽ,[B�0351*Í2T51*;:OZ;.90GE457Aw8LN�bu57A4BiAwbc>

];E[03*;,[B;H/2 Ë ó Õ N Ë ó Õ NW03*;^ �� =?H'H'A�2R*;>3E�=_03.1.V8_A�B;HPH'*;^">O6�A�B;57E�^�];E[03*;,[B�N(0GARA�B;HP>3C;C±>O2457A�HPH/*;^�69E�>O=×A�B;H,/H/*LA4E[03.�^;57K@5124>3E/X

�S>3A�HU51*¾CW0GETA�51,/Z;.10GEPA�B�0GAÔA�B;H<,JE�57A�HJE�590�0G]±>%KLH<0GE�H<.7>@,k03.�03*�03.78sA�51,GX Ì B;H/*�Îm512Ô24=?>@>3A4BiA�B;572P512Ô*;>3AA�B;HÔ,k0324H3~o�ä � 512v.VAc0GA ÎD5Vè-H'57A�B;H'E � 512¿24=?>@>3A4B_0GA Î�Ns>3E � B�032¿Awbc>P57E4E�H'^;Z;,/57]�.7HS,/>O=<C(>O*;H'*�A�2 Ë 51*`0#ô�0GE�572TQ�5

*;H/57:OB�]±>OZ�E�B;>@>s^ Õ N�Hk03,[B"24=?>@>3A4B�N�=?H/H'A451*;:<*;>3E4=_03.1.V8`0GAåÎ�Xo×ä � 572�.1,#0GA�Îq]�Z�AS*;>3AS.7A/N±57è � 572�57E4E4H/^;Z;,/57]�.7H Ë 51*q0`ô�0GE�572TQ�5�*;H/57:OB�]±>OZ�E�B;>@>s^Ð>O6±Î Õ N(03*;^qB�032S0

2457=<C�.1HM*;>@^;HÔ0GAåÎ�XY BsZ;2v6�>3E¿H ��03=aC�.1HR516 � 512åA�B;HeZ;*;57>O*_>O6±A�B�E�H/Hu:OH/*;H'E[03.�.157*;H/2¿57* É�� N@o ä � 512¿.VAkNL]�Z�Av516 � 512�0P*;>s^�03.

,/Z�]�57,3N�5VAR512e.7,M]�Z�Au*;>3A�.VAkX$cH/,k03Z;24H�>O6eA�B;572UC±H/,/Z;.1510GE�57Aw8j>O6eA�B;H�^;H'Ï�*;57A451>O*�N¿bcHDbe57.1.\24>O=?HJA�51=?H'2#Z;24H-A�B;HDK30GE�5103*�AUC�Z�E�H/.V8�.7>O:

A�H'E4=?51*�03. Ë C�.VA Õ X),�>3EÔA�B;H<:OH/*;HJE[03.�^;HJÏ�*;57A�57>O*�24H/H?,[B�0GC;A�HJEUó�>O6ãî}ó � ñ¶X0,�>3EP>OZ�EPC�Z�E4C±>O24H/2º5VAP572PH/*;>OZ;:OBA�B�0GA�o ä � 572åC�.VAc0GA¿0Ô2457*;:OZ;.90GE¿C±>O51*LA Î?57è�57A�512å.7A¿0GA Î�Ns03*;^<C�.7Av0GAv0M24=?>@>3A4BaC(>O57*�A�Î`5Vè � 512å24=?>s>3A�B0GAyÎ�Xå)+*-2TB;>3E4AkN�oÖä � 512\C�.7Au57èÐ57AR512R.7Ae03*;^ � 512u24=?>s>3A�B�XÌ HM>O69A�H/*�Z;2THÔA�B;HÔ6�>O.1.1>�bu51*;:U2TA[03*;^�0GE�^-E4H/24Z;.7Ae51=<C�.751,/5VA�.78<51*-A4B;512\CW0GC(H'Ek~

�e�»� �¿���Í������£ ¤J¥ Ë '�� � Õ-, Ë �=� �;Õ<§J¤#È�¤ ° «#ª?¬+¸UÂ1¬�È�¥w¤ ° «g´�¼±©3Â�ª¨ù ° ¸/©�³[¤gªJ´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´»¥®´¶¤Jª5,S©G¼±¹�Â1¤'¥ ! 8 � ! §¨¤¥®­;¤º¹Gù�©GÂ�È ° © ¯ ­LªP¬+¸ã¥®­;¤J´ ° «g´»¼�´�«<©G ° ¤¨ªk¬� ù@¥|´¶¬�¼;ª/À��ãª[ªJùs«?¤ ! ´�ªP¬O§'¥w©G´�¼(¤[¹c¸ ° ¬�« ! 8\¤J´�¥®­;¤ ° §'·U´�¼�³ ° ¤�©Gª¨´�¼@È¥®­;¤Ôûv¤J´9È�­�¥u¬+¸#¬�¼�¤g¬+¸M¥®­;¤PµO¤ ° ¥|´¶³[¤¨ª0,¿¬ ° §'·D©L¹�¹G´�¼@È`©<ª¨´�¼@ÈGÂ1¤Pµ3¤ ° ¥+¤���©G¼±¹D¤�¹%È�¤kÀ Á ­�¤�¸k¬�Â�Â1¬Gûy´�¼@Èa­�¬�Â7¹ �

Ë ð Õ Á ­;¤º´�¼±¹�¤ �-¬+¸ ��´�ªãª¨¥ ° ´½³J¥®Â ·D§'´9È�È�¤ ° ¥®­�©G¼i¥»­�¤Ô´�¼±¹�¤ �-¬+¸ � ÀË ó Õ Á ­;¤M³[¬�¤ !ë³J´¶¤J¼W¥�¬+¸�¤�©s³¨­_¤��@³¨¤ ¯ ¥|´¶¬�¼±©GÂW¹G´»µ�´�ªk¬ ° ¬+¸\¥»­�¤u«g´�¼�´»«<©G ° ¤¨ªk¬� ù@¥®´½¬�¼�¬+¸ ��´�ªcª¨¥ ° ´¶³'¥®Â ·g§'´1È�Ès¤ °

¥®­�©G¼q¥®­;¤g³[¬%¤ !�³'´¶¤J¼�¥v¬I¸ã¥»­;¤U³[¬ °¨° ¤¨ª ¯ ¬G¼±¹G´�¼@È?¹G´»µ�´�ªk¬ ° ¬�µ3¤ ° � ,�ù@¼�Â1¤¨ª[ª ��´�ªP© �Ôù���©GÂ�ª¨´�¼@ÈGù@Â7© ° ´�¥®·�½´�¼Ðû�­�´¶³¨­q³�©�ªk¤#©3Â�Â�¥»­�¤U³[¬�¤ !�³J´½¤J¼�¥®ªP© ° ¤ �%¤ ° ¬ � À

Page 153: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � .��0�

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ Y B;HU,'8�,/.751,U,k0324HU>O6 Ë ð Õ 6�>O.7.1>�be2ã69E�>O= Ë ï�X7ðOX : Õ >O6Sî}ó � ñ¶X Y B;HU*;>O*@ؽ,'8@,/.157,<,k0324H Ë 03*;^i51*;^;H/H/^iA�B;H,'8@,/.157,Ô,k032THº032\bcH/.1. Õ ,/03*-](HM,[B;H/,�QLH/^"69E�>O=ÖA�B;HPH �@C�.157,/57AR.1572TA�2R51*�î � ñ¶X

,W>3E Ë ó Õ bcHMbe57.1.�,/>O*;2457^;H'E�A�B;HÔ,k0324HMbeB;H/*�A4B;HÔbcH/57:OB�Ae:O>@H/2uZ�C�X Y B;HP>3A�B;H'Ee,k0324HÔ512eB�03*;^;.7H/^"03*�03.7>GØ:O>OZ;24.V8LN;>3E�03.VA�H'E�*�0GA�5VKLH/.78LN@6�>O.1.1>�bu2u69E�>O= Ë ï�X7ðOXpï Õ >O6\î}ó � ñ¶X

� 6S,/>OZ�E�24H�bcH-=_0�8�03242TZ;=?H-A�B;H-bvH/51:OBLA_:O>@H'2<Z�C ]s8�H ��03,JA�.78j>O*;H3X +@51*;,/H�A4B;H�2451*;:OZ;.10GE�57A451H/2<0GE�H^;H'A�HJE�=?51*;H'^q]�8-A4B;HºE�H/24>O.7Z�A�51>O*":3E[0GC�B�N�bcH#,k03*Ð032424Z;=?H Ë �=� �;Õ 572S>3];A[0351*;H'^"69E�>O= Ë '�� � Õ ]�8q0?24=?>s>3A�B]�.1>�bhZ�C �v~ ��çÒ�Ó �' 0GAå0eC±>O51*LA�.78@51*;:S>O*U0�Z;*;51rsZ;HcH �;,'H'C;A�51>O*�03.@^;57K�5724>3EkNGA4B;Hc^;57K�5724>3E�,/>3ETE�H/2TC±>O*;^;51*;:SA�>A�B;H¿KLHJE4A�H �ÔbeB;>O2THvbcH/51:OBLA�57*;,'E�Hk0324H'2/X # HJA ]±H¿A�B;H Ò ð'ؽ,'Z�E4KLHvH �@A4E[03,'A�H'^º]s8 �(X �S>3A4H � ß � Ë � o�� Õ � Å2457*;,/H � 512u.1>O:gA�H'E�=<51*�03.|X�#�H'A U ](HP03*�H �;,'H'C;A�51>O*�03.�^;5VK�512T>3E Ë >O6�A�B;HP=<51*;51=?03.(^;H/2457*;:OZ;.90GE�572�0GA�51>O* Õ >�KLH'E� X@#�H'A Ñ ~ � 8 ÒWÓ � N �v~ ' 8 Ò�Ó ' H ��ATE[03,'A U_X Ì HPB�0kKLHº03*-57*;^;Z;,/H/^"=_0GC�� 8 ~ � 8 Ò�Ó ' 8 X

Ë � � � 8 Õ " Ë o�� Õ ß � 8 " Ë o����@ä � Ë U � o�� Õ U Õ ßto�� �@ä � Ë U � o�� Õ Uëä Ë �RÒ ð Õ �

Y BsZ;2/NW,/>O=<C�Z�A451*;:<57*�A4H'E�24H/,JA�51>O*;2u>O* � 8 N

Ò � Ë U � o�� Õ U � ß Ë o�� �'ä Ë ��Ò ð Õ Õ � U � o 8� � U�ß Ë Ñ " Ë o�� Õ@Ò � Ë U � o�� Õ U Õ � U�ß Ò � Ë U � o�� Õ U � � ��e� 5 ����)�����ÿ3�%�»���h�W��� /���W�@��¡k�»�����Wþ �D�*)�����ÿ3�%���±���)+*-,[B�0GC;A�H'E�ïa>O6\îòï .3ñ¶N +@B;>3Q@Z�E�>%KD57*�A4E4>@^;Z;,/H/2RA�B;HP6�>O.7.1>�be57*;:;~

7�� 9y�����%�»�����¿���Í���-�I�#� ��7-�����@�%���(�3¢%� #�H'A ' ](Hå0R*;>3E�=_03.GKG0GE�51HJA+8M03*;^ � Ü ' 0\E4H/^;Z;,/H/^#H'è±H/,'A�5VKLH

^;57K@5124>3E/X?# HJA � ](HºA�B;H#*;>3E�=?03.151240GA�51>O*�N±03*;^ �O~ �àÒWÓ ' A�B;H#51*;^;Z;,'H/^¾=_0GC�X # H'A � ]±Ha03*L8"H'è±H/,'A�5VKLH� Øw^;57K@5124>3EÔ>O* ' XyíS2424Z;=?HÔo��ºä � ä � 512 � Ø � 0GE4A�57H'Ek~Y B;H'E�HP572e0U,k03*;>O*;51,/03.1.78`^;HJÏ�*;H/^qH'è(H/,JA�57KLH � Ø Ì H/57.�^;5VK�512T>3E ã5Vè # Ë �UÕ >O* � 24Z;,[B�A�B�0GA

�" Ë o��#ä � ä �UÕ ß o #-ä M5Vè # Ë �UÕ

Ë Y B;HS032424Z;=aC;A�51>O*<A4B�0GAco��uä � ä � 572 � Ø � 0GE4A�57H'Eã512v*;>3A¿*;H/,/H/2T2�0GE48LN@]�Z�Acbu57A�B;>OZ�A¿57A�A�B;H�^;H'Ï�*;5VA�51>O*>O6 � " 512R=?>3E�HSA�H/,[B;*;51,/03.|X Y B;Hº0G]±>%KLHM512R24Z"!<,/51H/*LAS6�>3Eu>OZ�Ee*;H'H/^;2/X ÕÌ B;H/* Ë '��,�PÕ 512S.1>O:_A�HJE�=?51*�03.�A�B;Hg^;57è±H'E�H/*LAPB�032M0_2457=<C�.1H#57*�A�HJE4C;E�H'A[0GA451>O*qK�590 *M>O.1.��0GEk{æ2 $cZ;:GØ��å8LH/^

,/>�KLH'EkX +@H/H Ë .;X7ð � Õ X+@B;>3Q�Z�E4>%KD>3];A[0357*;H/^�A�B;HÔ6�>O.1.7>%bu51*;:ar@Z;57A4HM2TZ�E4C;E�512T51*;:?E�H/2TZ;.7Ak~

�e� 5(�»�q�#� �s���%��� � /�����s�G¡k����� �Wþ �D�*)�����ÿ3�%���±�y¢%� �Sª¨ª¨ùs«_¤ ^;51= Ë 'åÕ � ï Ào��gä � ä � ´�ª#Â1¬�Èq³[©G¼(¬�¼�´½³�©G � ° ¤¨ª ¯ À ¯  ¥�©G¼(¹�� ´�ªa© ¯ ù ° ¤?§¨¬Gùs¼±¹�© ° · � ´�¼j©D¼(¤J´1È�­;§¨¬�ù ° ­;¬�¬�¹�¬I¸ �

´ÇÆ o #"ä ã57è�# Ë �UÕP´�ªÔÂ1¬�È�³�©3¼(¬�¼�´¶³[©G � ° ¤Jª ¯ À F  ¥ � À,W>3ERA4B;HÔC;E�>s>O6 24H/H Ë ï�X . Õ >O6\îòï .3ñ¶N$v8q03*¾H'.1H/:L03*LAMH ��A�H'*;2451>O*i>O6v03*Ð51^;Hk0D>O6 +@B;>3Q@Z�E�>%K±N�*M>O.1.��0GESC;E�>�KLH/^¾A�B;H#C�.7AÔ,k0324HU>O6 Ë #�Xpó@X1ð Õ 57*�03.1.

^;51=<H/*;2451>O*;2'NW2TH/H Ë ð � Xæõ Õ >O6cîæó � ñ|X

Page 154: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

.�� � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

�e� 5(� 5 �¿���Í������£ ¤J¥*� Ü '秨¤P© ° ¤�¹GùW³[¤�¹g´ °J° ¤�¹GùW³J´|§/Â1¤Ô³Jù ° µO¤P¬G¼q©��MúÛ¸/©�³J¥+¬ ° ´¶©G ¯(° ¬+²k¤¨³J¥®´»µ3¤uª¨ù ° ¸k©�³[¤kÀ � ¸Ë o��ºä �PÕ�� � � Å ,�¥»­�¤J¼ � ß É Ê À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ $v8"A�B;HU24Z�]W03^�FIZ;*;,'A451>O*�6�>3E�=gZ;.10�N Ë � X1ðOX # Õ >O6eîæó@ð/ñ|N�6�>3EÔ2TZ"!?,/57H/*�A4.78Ð^;57K@51245V]�.1Hgn Ã�Å�N�d�� ���# 512M024Z�]�24B;H/036�>O6�A�B;HP.151*;HÔ]�Z;*;^;.1H 6 # Ë n Ë o��#ä �ºÕ4Õ X\íS2eA4B;Hº.90GA4A4H'E�B�032�*;H':L0GA�57KLHº^;H':3E�H/H3N(5VA�6�>O.7.1>�be2RA�B�0GA� Ê Ë76 # Õ ß � 3 Ë d # Õ ß Å�X �D ¤J«<© °GF À Ì HgH �@C(H/,'AãA�B;HJE�Hg512M03.124>D0_.1>s,k03. KLH'E42451>O*q>O6 Ë #�Xpó@X ó Õ N±*�03=?H/.78�A�B�0GA ã57è # Ë Å Õ 512ã0GAM.1H/032TAM032]�51:<032RA4B;HP,/>O*;^;Z;,'A4>3EkNWbuB;51,[B�572uH'57A�B;H'EeH/=<C;Aw8LN�>3EuB�032e^;H/:3E4H/Hº0GAu.1Hk032IAuAwbc>;XY B;HÔ*;H �@AuE4H/24Z;.7Ae512R>OZ�EeC;E�57*;,/57CW03.�0GC;C�.751,k0GA�57>O*->O6 Ë #�Xpó@X1ð Õ ~

�e� 5(��( J ���%�K K����%�y��£ ¤J¥ ' §J¤U©��Ôú ¸k©�³J¥+¬ ° ´|©3 ¯±° ¬+²k¤[³J¥|´�µ3¤Pª¨ù ° ¸/©�³¨¤0,R©3¼±¹ � � ÞÄÜ 'Ý¥®ûv¬�³Jù ° µO¤¨ª5,cûy´�¥®­ �´�¼�¥+¤½È ° ©GÂ7À � ¸ Ë o��Ôä � ä�Þ Õ ��� � Å ,v©G¼±¹ � � Þ ³[¬�¼W¥½©G´»¼;ªP©G¥¿Â1¤�©�ª¨¥¿¥®ûc¬ ¯ ¬�´�¼W¥»ª5,奮­;¤J¼ o��Pä � äjÞ ´�ªÂ1¬�È-³�©G¼(¬�¼W´¶³�©GÂ1,*� � Þ ´�ªg¤��s©�³J¥| ·?¥®ûc¬ ¯ ¬�´»¼�¥»ª0,c©G¼±¹ Ë o��ºä � ä�Þ Õ�� � ß Å À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ�� ß É�Ê ]s8 Ë #åX ó@X ó Õ X $v8 Ë #åX ó@X1ð Õ N�2457*;,/H#o×ä � ä � ÞÄ572�*;>3AS.1,º0GA�Þ � � N±6�>3Eã03*L8 � ÃÝðONWA�B;H,/>sH�!?,/57H/*LAe>O6 � 57*�ã5Vè # Ë Þ Õ 512R0GAR.1H/032TAR>O*;H3N�6�>3E�03*L8 � �"Þ � � Xå)wAR6�>O.1.7>%bu2cA�B�0GARÞ � � 512\H �;03,'A�.78Awbc>"C(>O57*�A�2 � � Ê � � � ��03*;^ ã5Vè # Ë Þ Õ ß � Ê ä � � X")+*mCW0GE4A�51,'Z;.90GEgo #mä ã57è�# Ë Þ Õ 512#.7,3Nå03*;^jA�B�Z;2o��ºä � ä�Þ 572u.7,Ô57*�0U*;H/51:OBL](>OZ�E�B;>s>@^�>O6 � ]�8 Ë #�Xpó@X1ð Õ X �

� �������»� ý � )I*?A4B;512¿CW0GC±H'EcbcH�69E�H'r@Z;H/*LA�.78?Z;24H Ë #åX ó@X7ð'Øwï Õ bu57A4B;>OZ�AvE�H/6�H'E4H/*;,/H3N;>3EcZ;*;^;HJEcA�B;H�,k0GA�,[BD03.1.§'·D©L¹I²Jùs¼(³'¥®´¶¬G¼ X � � ������� � ��� ���g ��e��&L��$k������ �â ��������&1��� � (�����Í$ �G���(�

öSH'E�HÔbcHº:O57KLHP0<,/>O*;2TATE�Z;,'A�57>O*Ð>O6�A4B;Hº*;>3E�=_03.7512�0GA�57>O*�>O6y03*q03.7:OH'];E[0357,º2TCW03,/H3N±032ebcHºB�0kKLHº*;>3A�]±H/H/*0G]�.1HãA�>UÏ�*;^�57Au51*DA�B;HP.757A�H'E�0GA�Z�E�H3X

�S>3A�HMA�B�0GA�A�B;HPC;E4>3C(H'E4Aw8->O6y]±H/51*;:_*;>3E4=_03. 572eC;E�H/2TH'E4KLH/^"]�8 �H'A[03.7HP,/>�KLH'E�2/N(03*;^Ð2T>_=_0GQLH/2e2TH/*;24Hg6�>3E03.1:OHJ];E[0351,M2TCW03,/H/2'X�eH',k03.1.s6�>3Eå0SE4H/^;Z;,/H/^U24,[B;H/=?H ¦ A�B;H'E�Hc572y0�Z;*;51rsZ;H\Ï�*;5VA�Hc=?>3E4C�B;5724= �¦ Ò�Ó ¦ Ë A�B;Hc*;>3E4=_03.1572�0GA�51>O* Õ

buB;51,[B�512RZ;*;57KLHJE�2�03.�6�>3Ee^;>O=?57*�03*�Au=_0GC�2\69E�>O=×*;>3E�=_03.�24,[B;H/=<H/2/X �»� �¿���Í������£ ¤J¥ Ñ ~ T Ò±Ó ¦ §J¤D©¾¹�¬�«g´»¼±©G¼�¥ ¤'¥½©GÂ1¤`«<© ¯ ¬I¸aªk³J­;¤J«?¤¨ª0,Sûå´�¥»­�¦ ° ¤�¹3ù�³[¤[¹LÀ Á ­�¤J¼¥®­;¤ ° ¤P´�ªº©?¼(©G¥®ù ° ©3 2v§ ° ¤#¹G´|©�È ° ©G«

�T ÒkÒ;Ò�Ò[Ó T

��� ����¦ ÒkÒ;Ò�Ò[Ó ¦ �

* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ )+=?=<H/^;590GA�Hã69E�>O=àA�B;HÔZ;*;57KLH'E42�03.�C;E�>3C(H'ETA+8�>O6 A4B;HP*;>3E�=_03.7512�0GA451>O*�X ��S>�bç.1H'A �å~ � Ò�Ó T � T ](Hº03* �H'A[03.1HMH/rsZ;57KG03.1H/*;,/HME�H/.10GA�51>O*�X@$v8_A�B;HPZ;*;5VKLH'E�2�03.�C;E�>3C±H'E4Aw8�A4B;H'E�HP572

03*-57*;^;Z;,/H/^"=_0GC ��å~ �� Ò�Ó �T � �T X

Page 155: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � .�� �

� 5 �¿���Í����� �I©�ª[ªJùs« ¯ ¥®´¶¬G¼;ªº©�ªº©�§¨¬�µ3¤ � �� ´�ªº©3¼ ¤J¥w©GÂ1¤U¤[ø'ùs´»µG©GÂ1¤J¼(³¨¤ ° ¤JÂ7©G¥|´¶¬�¼(À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ $v8aA�B;HS^;H'Ï�*;57A451>O*`>O6�03*_H/r@Z;5VK303.7H/*;,/H�E�H/.10GA�51>O*�NsbcHS*;H/H/^_A�>#24B;>�b A�B�0GA �U572c0#=?>O*;>O=?>3E4C�B;5724=�N03*;^�öS>O= Ë �=� �� Õ ÜâöS>O= Ë �=� �TgÕ �-öS>O= Ë �=� �T#Õ 512e03*-H/rsZ;57KG03.1H/*;,'HÔE�H/.10GA�51>O*D6�>3ES03.7. � X)wA?6�>O.7.1>�be2a69E�>O= Ë �#X1ð Õ A�B�0GA ��Í512<0¾=?>O*;>O=?>3ETC�B;5124=�N¿03*;^�A�B;H-C;E4>3FIH','A�51>O*;2 �� Ò�Ó �T 0GE�H �HJA[03.1H3X

íS.12T>;Nu]�8�A4B;HÐZ;*;5VKLH'E�2�03.SC;E�>3C±H'E4Aw8LNe6�>3E-03*L8 *;>3E�=_03.�24,[B;H/=<H � N�öS>O=�Ë �=� �� Õ ß öS>O=

�Ë �=� � Õ 03*;^

öS>O=�Ë �=� �T � �TgÕ ß öS>O=

�Ë �=� T � TgÕ N buB;H'E�HaöS>O=

�57*;^;51,k0GA�H'2ÔA�B;H?2TZ�]�24H'A#>O6v^;>O=<51*�03*LAP=_0GC�2'Xa)wA

6�>O.1.7>%bu2vA�B�0GAcöS>O=�Ë �=� �� Õ ÜâöS>O=

�Ë �=� �TgÕ �?öS>O=

�Ë �=� �TgÕ 572\03*`H/r@Z;5VK303.7H/*;,/HSE�H/.10GA�51>O*_6�>3ER03*L8_*;>3E�=_03.

� X,W>3E�A�B;HvA4E[03*;2T57A�5VK�57Aw8P0 �;57>O=�X #�H'A � ß �� � � � � � � ��aN3buB;H'E�H Î Ê � Î � ~ �� Ò�Ó �T 0GE�HvA4B;HvA+bv>ãC;E4>3FIH','A�51>O*;2'X

)wAP572ãH/*;>OZ;:OB¾A�>�24B;>%b A4B�0GA Ë Î Ê � Î = Ê � Î � � Î = � Õ �jöS>O= Ë �=� �� Õ X $cZ�AP2T51*;,/H � 512M*;>3E�=_03.®N�03*;^�Î � 0GE�H^;>O=?57*�03*�AkNLA�B;572�6�>O.7.1>�be2�69E�>O= A4B;HuE�H/=?0GE4Q�2å0G](>�KLH3X Y B;He>3A�B;H'Ev0 �;57>O=?2å0GE�He03*�03.7>O:O>OZ;24.78U>3];A[0357*;H/^�X � ��(47D�:9y�����%���±�

��¿���Í��� � �W�����K»�»¡/���%�����¿�D£ ¤J¥ � §¨¤P© ° ¤�¹GùW³[¤�¹<©GÂ}È�¤�§ ° ©G´½³eª ¯ ©�³[¤kÀ Á ­�¤J¼�¥»­;¤ ° ¤ã´�ª

©aù@¼�´|ø'ùW¤ 2å¼�´�¥+¤º¹�¬�«U´�¼±©G¼�¥�«<© ¯ �� Ò±Ó � ¸ ° ¬�« ©a¼(¬ ° «<©G ©3Â}È�¤k§ ° ©G´¶³Sª ¯ ©�³¨¤0,yùs¼�´»µ3¤ ° ªk©GÂG¸k¬ ° ¹�¬�«U´�¼±©G¼�¥«<© ¯ ªå¸ ° ¬�«Ö¼(¬ ° «<©GÂ�©GÂ}È�¤k§ ° ©G´¶³ãª ¯ ©�³[¤¨ª/À* ° ¬�¬+¸kÀ #�H'A Ñ ~ T Ò�Ó � ]±He03* �H'A[03.7H\,/>%KLHJEå]�8a03*<0'!<*;Hu2T,¨B;H'=?H3N�.1H'A��çß T �� T NL24>MA�B�0GA � ß T ���aX#�H'A �� ß �T � ��aN@buB;51,[BD512R03*D03.1:OH'];E�0351,S2TCW03,/Hã]�8 Ë �#X ó Õ N�03*;^D,/.1Hk0GE4.78_*;>3E�=?03.|X2$v8?,/>O*;2IA4E�Z;,'A�57>O*DA4B;H'E�H512�03*U57*;^;Z;,/H/^U=_0GC �� Ò�Ó � X Ë �#X1ð Õ 03*;^#A�B;Hc,/>O*;2TA4E4Z;,'A�51>O*g57=<C�.157H/2 �T ß �� �� T X �S>�b�A4B;HcZ;*;57KLH'E�2403.C;E�>3C±H'E4Aw8D>O6 �T Ò�Ó T 51=aC�.151H'2\A4B;HPZ;*;57KLHJE�2�03.15VAw8`>O6 �� Ò�Ó � X ��ºÀ � D ¤J«<© ° F À �S>3A�HaA�B�0GA # H'=?=_0 Ë �#X1ð Õ B;>O.1^;2º6�>3E#03.1:OH'];E[0357,<2TCW03,'H/2/N�FIZ;2TA#,'>3Cs8ÐA�B;H<C;E�>s>O6c>O6 Ë �#X7ð Õ03*;^�Z;24H Ë �#Xpï Õ X

����� � �

�¿N ��N � �s�03.1=?>O2TA�ãZ8H¿03.|N � 503^�FT03,/H/*LA�A�>;N � 5�� �

]W03*�03*�0�N �����7���»���;¢];E[03*;,[B;H/2/N � 5]�Z;:GؽH'8LH/^",'>%KLH'E/N � ��7��¢,/H/*LA4E[03.�^;57K�5724>3EkN � 5,¨B�0357*�N � 5,/>@H�!<,/51H'*�AkN �¨�W�»� �±¢,/>O=<C�.1H'=?H/*LAkN � 5 5^;>O=?51*�0GA�H'^�]�8LN �¨�W�»��¢

Page 156: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

.�� � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

H'è(H/,JA�57KLH3N � 56�H/*;,/H3N �����7���»�15W¢/�Z;24B�N �����7��� 5�¢6�Z�E4A�B;H/2TA/N�6 �¨�W�W�65W¢%�e�¨���W� �¢4�5±N � 5BsZ;*LAkN �¨�W�»� �W¢51*LA�H'E�57>3EkN�5 � �W�.1H'KLH/.®N �����7��� 5�¢.1512IAkN;2451=aC�.78`,/>O*;*;H/,JA�H/^".1572TAkN � (.1>O:<Z;*;5VE�Z;.1H'^�N � 5*;Hk0GEkNW* � �W�*;H'AkN �¨�W�»� �±¢�WN � 52TC(H/,JA4E[03.�K303.7Z;H3N �����7��� �(¢A[03,/*;>@^;HGN �����7���»� (±¢A�51:OH'E/N �¨�W�»� (±¢�' N � 5A+8sC(H Ò Ë � Ê � � � � � � � � � 5 Õ N �����7��� ��¢A�>3E�51,GN � 5 5¦ N T N � �W� � � �15 � � � (bcH/51:OBLAkN;b � �s�

!#���@��������(��$

îVð/ñ HgX�í#X íS.7H'Q�24H'H'KÍ03*;^ HgX�HgX �S5VQ�Z;.157*�X � .103242457Ï�,/0GA�51>O*Í>O6c^;H/.@��H����/>q24Z�E46�03,/H/2ºbu57A�BÍ.7>O:GضA�H'E4=?51*�03.2457*;:OZ;.90GE4A�57H/2�>O6�57*;^;H � � ó?03*;^q57*�KL>O.7Z�A�51>O*;2u>O*Ðoiï<24Z�E46�03,/H/2/X .�¬�µ�´½¤J¥ � ©3¥»­�À �g¬ F Â7À N�ï # ~ � Å � � � ðOðONð # : # X

îæó�ñ HgXLíS.1H ��H/H'K±X $\>OZ;*;^;H'^;*;H/242\03*;^_o � 6�>3Ev.7>O:P24Z�E�6�03,'H/2/X � ¼�¥+¤ ° ¼(©G¥®´½¬�¼±©G � À � ©3¥»­�À N � ~ � � # � :�ð�Å�N;ð # # .;Xî}ïGñÔzmXví�E4A�57*�XçíS.1:OH'];E[0357,Ð0GC;C;E�> ��51=_0GA451>O*h>O6M2TA4E�Z;,JA�Z�E�H/2D>%KLHJE�,'>O=<C�.1H'A4H".1>@,/03.eE�51*;:O2'X *u§�À � ©G¥®­�À

� À �ºÀ uÀ�. N;ïOõ�~pó � � � :�N�ð # õ # Xî .3ñ Ì X $\0GE4A�B�N � X ��HJA�H'E�2/Ny03*;^mí#X�Hv03*m^;H H¿H'*�X �¿¬G« ¯ ©�³J¥ �¿¬�« ¯ Â1¤�� .Wù ° ¸/©�³[¤Jª X4+sC;E�57*;:OH'EEH�H'E�.903:;N

ð # : .;Xî � ñ HgX�$\0GA+8sE�H'K±X Y B;H<,/>O*;H?>O6vH'è±H/,'A�5VKLH?^;57K@5124>3E42P>O6¿A�B�E4H/H/6�>O.1^;2'X`)+* * ° ¬�³kÀ � ¼�¥|Â7À �¿¬G¼k¸/Àu¬G¼ �eÂ}È�¤�§ ° © N

CW03:OH/2eïOï � �@ï � ó@N(ð # : # X

Page 157: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

� ��������� � ��� ���� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �� �� ��� � � � .���2

î}õGñÔí#X $c>3E�5124>�K(X $\>OZ;*;^;H'^;*;H/242SA�B;H/>3E�H'= 6�>3E?,�03*;>?.7>O:GضA�B�E�H'H/6�>O.1^;2/X � À �eÂ}È�¤k§ ° ©G´¶³ ��¤[¬�«?À N � ~1ðOð # ��ð�ïOï�Nð # # õ�X

î � ñ�eX1$vE�57H/2TQL>3E�*�X ��0GA451>O*�03.1H +@51*;:OZ;.10GE�57A4H/*�QL>O=<C�.7H �;HJE ,�.103,[B;H/*�X � ¼Wµ3¤J¼�¥wÀ � ©G¥®­�À N1.;~pïOïOõ��@ï � :�N(ð # õ :�Xî :GñÔí#X ,WZ�FI57Q@5|N �PX�*M>3]W0�8@5124B;5®N�03*;^ +±X�# Z;>;X � *mA�B;H`6�Z;*;^�03=?H/*LA[03.v:3E�>OZ�Cj>O6R,/H'E4A[0357*m>3C(H/*m*;>3E�=_03.

24Z�E�6�03,'H/2/X .(©G´�¥w©G«<© � ©3¥»­�À � À N�ðOðO~1ð � ��ó3Å�N(ð # # ï�Xî # ñ Ì X ,WZ;.7A4>O*�X � ¼W¥w¤ ° ªk¤[³J¥|´¶¬�¼ Á ­;¤[¬ ° · X +sC�57*;:OH'ETØ�H�H'E�.103:;N�ð # : .;XîVð�ÅGñ Ì X ,WZ;.7A4>O*�X � ¼W¥ ° ¬k¹GùW³J¥®´½¬�¼q¥+¬<¥+¬ ° ´¶³PµG© ° ´½¤J¥®´½¤¨ª X ��E451*;,/H'A4>O* �S*;57KLH'E42457Aw8O��E4H/242/N�ð # # ï�XîVðOð/ñÔzmX ,�Z�E4Z;24B;51=_0�X +@51*;:OZ;.10GE¿^;H/.1��H����/>P24Z�E46�03,/H/2v03*;^?03*�03.78@A451,c,/>O=<CW03,'57A�5VÏ�,k0GA�51>O*;2y>O6±ï�ؽ^;51=<H/*;2451>O*�03.

,/>O=<C�.7H ��0'!?*;HÔ2TCW03,/HP÷ � X �º©�È�¬�·L© � ©G¥®­�À � À N�ð�Å .;~1ð ��ó :�N(ð # :Oõ�XîVð%ó�ñÔzÐ0GE4Q-#�X@(SE�H/H/*�X � ¼�2å¼�´»¥w¤¨ªJ´�«<©GÂc«?¤'¥»­;¬�¹�ª`´�¼ �#¬k¹�È�¤D¥®­;¤[¬ ° · X +sC;E�57*;:OH'ETØ�H�H'E�.103:;Ncð # # .;X # H/,JA�Z�E�H

�S>3A�H/2R51*�zÐ0GA�B�X;KL>O.|X�ð ��# .;XîVð�ïGñÔí#X (ãE4>3A�B;H/*;^;51H',[Q±X ��.��H/= �H'*�A�2R^;HE( �H/>O= �H'ATE�51HMíS.1: �H'];E451r@Z;HGX *cù�§'Â7À � ©G¥®­�À � � . N�ó :�N�ð # õOõ�XîVð�.3ñ �PX:H (ãZ�E®FT0GEu03*;^�gXWô(B�03*;:;X�R Ê >O6�24=?>s>3A�B_C(>O57*�A�2\>O6�0g.1>O:g^;H/. ��H����'>a24Z�E46�03,/HÔ572cÏ�*;57A�H3~ò)4)¨X�z ��)

C;E�H'C;E451*LAkN ð # # ï�XîVð � ñ �PX H (ãZ�E®FT0GE#03*;^�gX ô(B�03*;:;XSR Ê >O6v24=<>@>3A�BqC(>O57*�A�2Ô>O6c0-.7>O:-^;H/.���H����/>-24Z�E�6�03,/H?572ÔÏ�*;5VA�H3~})¨X � À

� ©G¥®­�À .�³J´¶À � ¼�´�µGÀ Á ¬ F ·�¬ N�ðO~1ð�ï � ��ð :OÅ�N(ð # # .;XîVð�õGñÔö#X � .1H'=?H/*;2/N �;X *M>O.1.��0GEkNW03*;^4+±Xæzq>3E�5|XcöS57:OB;H'E�^;57=?H/*;2457>O*�03. ,'>O=<C�.1H ��:OH/>O=<H'A4E48LX �㪨¥ ¤ ° ´�ª/ø'ùW¤0, .�¬�³kÀ

� ©G¥®­�À ° ©G¼(³[¤-, N�ð�õOõ�N�ð # : :�XîVð � ñ�,cXLöS51^�0GQG0P03*;^S*UX Ì 0GA[03*�0G]±H3X �S>3E�=_03.1(ã>3E�H/*;2TA4H/51*_24Z�E46�03,/H/2¿bu57A�B<03=<C�.1Hu03*LA�51,k03*;>O*;57,k03.�^;57K@5124>3EkX

Á ¬ F ·�¬ � À � ©G¥»­;À N .;~pó :Oï��@ïOõOÅ�N(ð # :�ðOXîVð :Gñ �UXåzÐ5V8�03>3Q30 �;X@*Ô>O.7.��0GE_03*;^ +±X�zÐ>3E45|X ��0GA�57>O*�03.u,/Z�ETKLH/2_>O*�,±03*;>�KG0GE�57H'A�51H'2/X � À �Ô´ÇÆ�À�S¤[¬�«<À N

ï�~ � õ � � � � # N±ð # # ó@XîVð # ñ �UX�zq578�03>3QG0��;X*M>O.1.��0GE�03*;^4+±XWzq>3E�5|X �e0GA�51>O*�03.7.78D,/>O*;*;H/,JA�H/^"K30GE451H'A�57H/2/X � À �eÂ}È�¤k§ ° ©G´¶³ ��¤[¬�«_¤J¥ ° · N

ðO~ .�ó # �:. . :�N±ð # # ó@Xîæó3ÅGñ �UX1*P0kb\03=_0GA�0�X $c>OZ;*;^;H/^;*;H/2T2S>O6 � ØI,y03*;>-A�B�E�H'H/6�>O.1^;2/X �¿¬�¼�¥+¤J« ¯ À � ©G¥»­;À ,9*e© ° ¥ � ,��e«?¤ ° À � ©G¥®­�À

.�¬�³�À N�ð�ï�ðON�ð # # ó@Xîæó@ð/ñ �UX"*Ô0�bc03=_0GA[0�N"*UX;zÐ0GA�24Z;^�0�NW03*;^>*UX;zÐ0GA�24Z�Q�5®X�)+*�A4E4>@^;Z;,'A�57>O*�A�>#A�B;HM=?57*;51=_03.W=?>@^;H'.±C;E�>O:3E[03=�X

)+* Y X � ^�0�N@H/^;57A�>3E/N �eÂ}È�¤k§ ° ©G´¶³ �S¤[¬�«?¤J¥ ° · ,9.�¤J¼±¹�©G´ NLCW03:OH/2\ó :Oï��@ïOõOÅ�X *Ô57*;>3Q�Z;*;578�0�Ø �S>3E4A�B@ضöS>O.1.903*;^�Nð # : � XyíS^�K(X +sA�Z;^�X �¿Z�E4HPzÐ0GA�B�N;KL>O.�ð�Å�X

Page 158: MIT Mathematicsmath.mit.edu/~mckernan/Papers/paper.pdf · 2007. 9. 5. · 51* + y ¦ ~ ¸ ' ¯±° ° #', °

.�� � ��������� ��� ��� ����� � � ����� � � � ���

îæóOó�ñ +±X *MH/H/.|N%*UX\zi0GA424Z�Q�5®N\03*;^ �;X\z � *MH'E�*�03*�X #�>O:�0G]�Z;*;^�03*;,/HiA�B;H/>3E�H/= 6�>3EDA�B�E�H/H'6�>O.1^;2/X �Ôù F ¤� ¬Gù ° ¼±©GÂ�¬I¸ � ©G¥»­�¤J«<©G¥|´¶³¨ª N�ð # # .;X

îæó3ïGñ �;X1*Ô>O.7.��0GEkX � >O*;HÔA�B;H/>3E4H/=?2u03*;^-]�Z;:GؽH'8LH'^�,/>�KLH'E�2/X � À �eÂ}È�¤�§ ° ©G´½³ ��¤¨¬�«?¤J¥ ° · N�ðO~ ó # ï��@ïLó3ï�N±ð # # ó@Xîæó'.3ñ �;X1*Ô>O.7.��0GEkX@+@B�036�0GE�H'K@51,[B"=_0GC�2R03*;^"03Z�A�>O=<>3E4C�B;51,ã6�>3E�=?2'X@#�H/,'A�Z�E4H/2S0GA��e57,/H �S*;5VKLH'E�245VA+8±N�ð # # ï�Xîæó � ñ �;X *Ô>O.7.��0GEkXE#�>O:-24Z�E46�03,/H/2P>O6�:OH/*;H'E[03.�Aw8@C±H�/�24>O=?Hg,/>O*�FIH/,JA�Z�E�H/2/X �¿¬G¼�¥w¤'« ¯ À � ©G¥®­�À Nyð�õLó@~ ó3õ�ð ��ó � � N

ð # # .;Xîæó3õGñ �;X1*Ô>O.7.��0GEkX D ©G¥®´½¬�¼±©G ��ù ° µO¤¨ªg¬�¼ �eÂ}È�¤k§ ° ©G´¶³���© ° ´½¤J¥®´½¤¨ª X@+sC;E�51*;:OHJE H�H'E�.903:;N�ð # # õ�Xîæó � ñ �;X1*Ô>O.7.��0GEuH'A�03.®X2,�.157C�2u03*;^"0G]�Z;*;^�03*;,/HP6�>3ES03.1:OHJ];E[0351,ãA�B�E�H/H'6�>O.1^;2/X �㪨¥ ¤ ° ´�ª/ø'ùW¤ NWó@ðOðON�ð # # ó@Xîæó :GñÔö#X;zÐ0GA�24Z;=?=gZ�E[0�X �¿¬�«g«Uùs¥w©G¥|´�µ3¤�eÂ}È�¤k§ ° © X@$\H'*�FT03=?51*@Ø � Z;=?=<51*;:O2/N(ð # :OÅ�Xîæó # ñ HgX�$SX zÐH'B�A[0q03*;^jí#X �e03=_03*�0GA�B�03*�X +@H'=?5 �s2TA�0G]�.1H?24B;H/0�KLH/2g>O*ÍC;E�>GFIH/,'A457KLH?KG0GE�51H'A451H/2g03*;^ÍA�B;H/5VE

E�H/2IA4E�51,JA�51>O*DA�><,/Z�ETKLH/2/X � ©3¥»­�À �e¼�¼±À N±ó � :�~pó@ð�ï���óOó'.;N(ð # :Ló@Xî}ïOÅGñÔzmX3zq578�03*;5724B;5�03*;^S+±X Y 24Z;*;>s^�0�X Y B;H\2TA4E�Z;,JA�Z�E�HR>O6�>3C±H/*<03.7:OH'];E[0357,c24Z�E�6�03,/H/2'NL)T)JX;)+* �yÂ7©�ª[ª¨´ 2\³�©G¥|´¶¬�¼

¬+¸u©GÂ}È�¤�§ ° ©G´½³R©G¼(¹#©G¼±©G ·G¥®´½³c«?©G¼�´Ç¸k¬GÂ7¹�ª�� �U©3¥½©G¥w©LÀ A � � B � N�CW03:OH/2 . # # � � . .;X $\5VE4Q�B�03Z;2TH'EkN@ð # :Oï�XM��E�>O:3EkXzÐ0GA�B�X;KL>O.�ï # X

î}ï�ð/ñÔzmXOzq578�03*;512TB;5�03*;^S+±X Y 2TZ;*;>@^�0�X�#�>O:L0GE�5VA�B;=?51,c^;H'. ��H����/>P2TZ�E�6�03,/H/2v>O6�E[03*�QU>O*;H\be5VA�Ba,'>O*�A4E�03,'A�57]�.7H](>OZ;*;^�0GE451H/2e0GAe57*�Ï�*;57Aw8LX � © ¯ ©G¼ � À � ©G¥®­�À N�ð�Å�~pó � ð �@ï�ð # N(ð # : .;X

î}ïLó�ñÔzmX�zÐ5V8�03*;5124B;5�03*;^ +±X Y 24Z;*;>@^�0�X �S>O*i,/>O=<C�.7H'A�Ha03.1:OH'];E[0357,<24Z�E46�03,/H<bu57A�Bi.1>O:L0GE�5VA�B;=?51,E*M>@^�035VE[0^;51=<H/*;2451>O* Ò � 03*;^<bu57A�Ba*;>O*@ؽ,/>O*;*;H/,JA�H/^?](>OZ;*;^�0GE451H/2c0GAå57*�Ï�*;57Aw8LX � © ¯ ©G¼ � À � ©G¥®­�À N;ð�Å�~1ð #Q� ��ó'.�ó@Nð # : .;X

î}ïOïGñÔzmX�zq5V8�03*;5124B;5 03*;^ gX �#X(ô(B�03*;:;X (ã>3E�H/*;2TA�H'51*".1>O:<^;H/.���H����/>_24Z�E�6�03,'H/2S>O6�E[03*�Q�>O*;H3X � ¬�ù ° ¼±©GÂå¬+¸�eÂ}È�¤�§ ° © N�ðOð :�~æõOï�� : .;N(ð # : :�X

î}ï .3ñ HgX"HgX+@B;>3Q�Z�E�>�K(X�ï��s6�>O.1^�.1>O:0/�57C�2/X D ùsª[ª¨´|©3¼��S³�©L¹LÀ .�³J´|À � �JµGÀ � ©G¥®­�À N .LÅ Ë ð Õ N�ð # # ï�Xî}ï � ñ gX%ô(B�03*;:;X�íS.7:OH'];E[0357,å2TZ�E�6�03,/H/2 bu57A4BÔ*;H/6�03*;^P]�51:u03*�A45Vؽ,/03*;>O*;51,k03.L^;57K@5124>3E/X � ©G¥®­�À�* ° ¬�³kÀ ��©G«?§ ° ´|¹%È�¤

*c­�´�Â1¬%ª/À�.�¬�³kÀ N�ðOð � ~1ð�õ�ð ��ð�õOï�N(ð # #Q� Xî}ïOõGñ �SHJØ �S5uô�B�03*;:;X #�>O:L0GE�5VA�B;=?51,_^;H'. ��H����/>�24Z�E46�03,/H/2<>O6RE[03*�Qm>O*;H`be5VA�B�,'>O*�A4E�03,'A�57]�.7HD]±>OZ;*;^�0GE�51H'2/X

�vª/© F © � À � ©G¥»­;À NWó � ~ .Lõ�ð �:. # � N(ð # : :�X