IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE...

32
Pontificia Universidad Católica del Perú IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE BENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE BENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE BENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE GRIDS WITH POLYPROPYLENE GRIDS WITH POLYPROPYLENE GRIDS. WITH POLYPROPYLENE GRIDS. Daniel Torrealva Cecilia Cerron and Daniel Torrealva, Cecilia Cerron and Yvan Espinoza POLYMER BIAXIAL GEOGRID Pontificia Universidad Católica del Perú Departamento de Ingeniería

Transcript of IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE...

Page 1: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE

Pontificia Universidad Católica del Perú

IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE BENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE

WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE GRIDSWITH POLYPROPYLENE GRIDSWITH POLYPROPYLENE GRIDS.WITH POLYPROPYLENE GRIDS.

Daniel Torrealva Cecilia Cerron andDaniel Torrealva, Cecilia Cerron and Yvan Espinoza

POLYMER BIAXIAL GEOGRID

Pontificia Universidad Católica del PerúDepartamento de Ingeniería

Page 2: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE

•POLYMER BIAXIAL GEOGRID

GEOGRID BX 1100GEOGRID BX-1100

Page 3: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE

INSTALLATION PROCEDURE

Page 4: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE
Page 5: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE
Page 6: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE
Page 7: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE
Page 8: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE
Page 9: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE
Page 10: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE

NON REINFORCED MODEL

St f SiPontificia Universidad Católica del PerúDepartamento de Ingeniería

Stefan Simon

REINFORCED MODEL

St f SiPontificia Universidad Católica del PerúDepartamento de Ingeniería

Stefan Simon

Page 11: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE

MODEL BEFORE TESTING

REINFORCED MODEL

Pontificia Universidad Católica del PerúDepartamento de Ingeniería

Page 12: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE

North Wall - Plastered

AFTER TEST

EFFECT OF PLASTER

Non plastered side

Plastered side

Pontificia Universidad Católica del PerúDepartamento de Ingeniería

Page 13: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE

2006 NUBIC VAULTS

REINFORCED

NON REINFORCEDREINFORCED

Pontificia Universidad Católica del PerúDepartamento de Ingeniería

NON REINFORCED VAULT

Pontificia Universidad Católica del PerúDepartamento de Ingeniería

Page 14: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE

REINFORCED VAULT

Pontificia Universidad Católica del PerúDepartamento de Ingeniería

CYCLIC SHEAR TEST – PLAIN WALL

Page 15: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE

CYCLIC SHEAR TEST – PLAIN WALL

REINFORCED AND NON PLASTERED WALL

Page 16: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE

REINFORCED AND NON PLASTERED WALL

REINFORCED AND PLASTERED WALL

Pontificia Universidad Católica del PerúDepartamento de Ingeniería

Page 17: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE
Page 18: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE
Page 19: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE
Page 20: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE
Page 21: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE

REINFORCED AND PLASTERED WALL60

REINFORCED AND PLASTERED WALL

30

40

50

10

20

Fo

rce

(kN

)

-20

-10

0

-100 -80 -60 -40 -20 0 20 40 60 80 100

Sh

ear

F

-50

-40

-30

-50

Displacement (mm)

COMPARATIVE EVOLVEMENT CURVES

Distorsión Angular vs. Esfuerzo Cortante

0.045

0.04

0.03

0.035

MP

a)

0.02

0.025

rzo

Co

rtan

te (

M

Geomalla conTarrajeo

Geomalla sinTarrajeo

0 01

0.015Esf

uer Tarrajeo

Sin Geomalla

0.005

0.01

0

0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.07 0.08 0.09 0.1

Distorsión Angular

Page 22: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE

OUT OF PLANE BENDING TESTS

OUT OF PLANE BENDING TESTS

1ra fase

8

10

12

2

4

6

V(k

N)

0

0 10 20 30 40 50

D1 (mm)

Page 23: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE

1ra fase

8

10

12

2

4

6

V(k

N)

0

0 10 20 30 40 50

D1 (mm)

2da fase

8

10

12

2

4

6

V(k

N)

0

0 10 20 30 40 50

D1 (mm)

Page 24: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE

2da fase

8

10

12

2

4

6

V(k

N)

0

0 10 20 30 40 50

D1 (mm)

3ra fase

8

10

12

2

4

6

V(k

N)

0

0 10 20 30 40 50

D1 (mm)

Page 25: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE

3ra fase

8

10

12

2

4

6

V(k

N)

0

0 10 20 30 40 50

D1 (mm)

4ta fase

8

10

12

2

4

6

V(k

N)

0

0 10 20 30 40 50

D1 (mm)

Page 26: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE

4ta fase

8

10

12

2

4

6

V(k

N)

0

0 10 20 30 40 50

D1 (mm)

5ta fase

8

10

12

2

4

6

V(k

N)

0

0 10 20 30 40 50

D1 (mm)

Page 27: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE

5ta fase

8

10

12

2

4

6

V(k

N)

0

0 10 20 30 40 50

D1 (mm)

6ta fase

8

10

12

2

4

6

V(k

N)

0

2

0 10 20 30 40 50

D1 (mm)

Page 28: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE

6ta fase

8

10

12

2

4

6

V(k

N)

0

0 10 20 30 40 50

D1 (mm)

OUT OF PLANE BENDING TESTS

R i f d ith id N i f d

COMPARATIVE CURVES

Reinforced with geogrid - Non reinforced

12

6

8

10

kN

)

2

4

6

V(k

0

2

0 10 20 30 40 50

D1 (mm)D1 (mm)

Page 29: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE

BENDING TEST OF WALL WITHBENDING TEST OF WALL WITH

SAND/CEMENT MORTAR PLASTER

COMPARATIVE EVOLVEMENT CURVES

CEMENT PLASTER MUD PLASTER AND PLAIN WALLCEMENT PLASTER, MUD PLASTER AND PLAIN WALL

Page 30: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE

CONCLUSIONS

• Biaxial geogrids for its characteristics of• Biaxial geogrids, for its characteristics ofcompatibility with natural soil, high tensilet th d tiff d d bilit istrength and stiffness and durability is very

effective in drastically reducing the seismicvulnerability of earthen buildings.

Pontificia Universidad Católica del PerúDepartamento de Ingeniería

CONCLUSIONS

•Geogrids embedded in the mud plaster of adobe•Geogrids embedded in the mud plaster of adobewalls creates a composite material, where thed b t k th i f d th idadobe takes the compression forces and the grid

the tensile forces additionally providingdisplacement capacity, therefore, it is nowpossible to develop engineering expressions top p g g pcompute shear and bending capacity of adobewalls reinforced with geogridswalls reinforced with geogrids.

Pontificia Universidad Católica del PerúDepartamento de Ingeniería

Page 31: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE

CONCLUSIONS

• Because of its simple construction procedure• Because of its simple construction procedure,this technique can be applied on new and existingb ildi h i hi t i l t lbuildings such as in historical centers, vernacularhousing as part of landscape, and on buildingswere the plaster is not a significant characterdefining feature.g

Pontificia Universidad Católica del PerúDepartamento de Ingeniería

CONCLUSIONS

• By providing a mean to meet current building• By providing a mean to meet current buildingcodes and life-safety standards, this technique

h l l iti i th b ildi t i lcan help legitimize earth as a building materialand allow the tradition of earthen architecture tocontinue in the future in earthquake pronecountries.

Pontificia Universidad Católica del PerúDepartamento de Ingeniería

Page 32: IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING ......2009/01/09  · IN PLANE SHEAR AND OUT OF PLANE BENDING STRENGTH OFADOBEBENDING STRENGTH OF ADOBE WALLS EXTERNALLY REINFORCED WITH POLYPROPYLENE

THANK YOU