Comparativa Sistema Frenado Emergencia

Anlisis comparativo de los sistemas avanzados de frenado de emergencia

Pgina 1 de 50

NDICE DE CONTENIDO

0 RESUMEN EJECUTIVO 2

" #$%&'($ 8

2 RESULTADOS ESPECFICOS 9

) #$%&%$$& 21

4 INVESTIGACIN DE ACCIDENTES SOBRE COLISIONES POR ALCANCE 35

* $+#,-.%&($'/$&,(% 37

0 -($ 39

7 CONSEJOS PARA LOS CONSUMIDORES 40

1 ,%-,%(,%,/($&2$3#%#& 41

9 METODOLOGA DE PRUEBAS 43


Pgina 2 de 50

! 454

!6" ,4

! "#$%

&

'%&

(()*"#$'

+ " ,

#(

(

-"#

( ./0,'

"#

-.1-'

$ $-

''

-"'

'-"

(23 -

.

"4*56"3

-"'

7-..28 -

"# -

7--"'1

$

$'"

"


Pgina 3 de 50

/-

9-+-

$---

---

.27- +""#$

$-

47 $ #

$

#+ ,:$

",

! -,

$"#$

$

/$

--'

/

$


Pgina 4 de 50

!6 %44

/

.44

"7

8

45

7

8

45

)7

8

45

94

:7

8

45

4

.47

4

.47

.47

4

3; !1 >! !>) !>" !>"

./48*;7 = ">? ">1 ">0 >" >@ >! !>) !>" !>!

04*! ">@ "> >@ :>0 ">! !>) !>! !>!

(23(>*" ">? >: >* )>? ">* !>) !>! !>!

.284* & >1 >* >* >0 )>1 >* !>" !>! !>"

7-.403 & )>! >@ >0 >0 > :>* !>" !>" !>

!6) &54>4>4

"+1/

-"

"# $

$$

" "#

?4*!1,

@ -/ "#

>*A>" $

#-

"#-$

-


Pgina 5 de 50

?

AB)* AB0* ABC* ABB* >*** >*A*

3

-

"

.

(

=

.

(>7(>(

/ %& - $

"$-/-

$

#!"#

3 -

-$

"# - %& .

6 "#

%'

&

-"#%-

& -

+

"

$1-

/"

" -

'$-

D-'

-/-


Pgina 6 de 50

- **83-

"'$ $

""#$! +-

!6: .485

(()*'$!

"$

?E*56"()*$

""$'-'1

-"

./ 0

(()*F

.'$

-'"(()*-"

$ !'$

"#


Pgina 7 de 50

(23

'$3 '

' " - % &

$"

.28$

-

" -$

-"#

.2-

7-/

-

-

--

"$

$'"

"

-"

$ # "

"#$#

56"


Pgina 8 de 50

" 4

/

.44

"7

8

45

8*G>*

A**G)*

7

8

45

)*G)*G4

)7

8

45

94

8*GE*G4

:7

8

45

>*G*

4*G*

E*G*

0*G*H

4

.47

4

.47

.47

4

3; ! ! A !? *C >A > >> >: >E !>1 *C *C *C A* >! !>) !>" !>"

./48*;7 = ">? ">1 A8 >* ">0 A) >" >A >@ 88 >A >A A* >! !>) !>" !>!

04*! ">@ >B AE "> A> >@ >B :>0 88 EC E4 4* ">! !>) !>! !>!

(23(>*" ">? *C >A >: >E >* >8 )>? >4 >4 88 88 ">* !>) !>! !>!

.284* & >1 >* >E >8 >* >8 >0 >) )>1 44 E4 E4 4* >* !>" !>! !>"

7-.403 & )>! >@ >E 4A >0 >) >0 >) > >> >E >8 A* :>* !>" !>" !>

H

@

== 4A4 *) I A8

= 4 A) I >8

>) I 48

4) I E8

B 4 E) I 88


Pgina 9 de 50

4C

/()*82;9..9. (@4A4

.DC447 >C***

.7 A0**

=5@ A0**

@

7

.$ #%

J&

-7)*K)*0*(0*(C*

47

(()*$,

$

"#

"E*56"

'#

-$

--

/-@/-

"# !

+9""#$

- # - %' $! -

&

/ --

--"#

--

/

% $

&-$


Pgina 10 de 50

$

$#

@

3'

"

E*56"

-

-

-

%--

&


Pgina 11 de 50

-/48*-- (@4

.DC4478BC80

.7 E)EA

3$@ >)0C

3$'@ E)E

8*3@ AEBB

7

.%

&

-7

47

3- . "

!

-

$3-1

'

3- $

'"4*56"

>*AAA

/$ '/

#!

3 -

--"

$

/ --

--.

--


Pgina 12 de 50

/ :

,

-$$

$#

/@

1 Fuente: el fabricante

'

7-'

= -

-

-

3


Pgina 13 de 50

404**

@ AE)*

@ 8**

@

3-%?93&%&@ A4C*

7

.%&

-7 )C

47

-

3,

-

#

3 -

0"

+-''

0 -$ !

-!

"

--"$

"-

$


Pgina 14 de 50

/ --

--0

--

/@

'

-

-

-

-'


Pgina 15 de 50

/E3(>*


Pgina 16 de 50


Pgina 17 de 50

-E84* (@

.DC447 E*48*

.7 8AE*

-@A88*

>**

3-%&@A4B*

7

. #%

&

-7 < 8;


Pgina 18 de 50

-'--

"$

/@

-

-

.#

-

=

-'

-


Pgina 19 de 50

,.403 (@

.DC447 8B)**

.7

- @

7

.3%

&

-7K=K%&

47

7-.40 "

7%

- +

1& # -

/-

-, -8*L

,7--'

7

-/ "

-

=2%-&1$$

$

/#7-%

&$=27

"

-"$1'

"

,>86>%&"

=2


Pgina 20 de 50

7-%'

7-&"

,

7--

" -'

--F

-'--

"$

/@

7

$

!

3$!

-

-


Pgina 21 de 50

) 4

)6" 845

3M

(

"#

N56"O

(

"#

DN56"O

NO

"#

D

N6PO

* >> A* >4* AB

7-.403 >: 4> A* A** 4B

(()*82; !>1 AB A* 4** *)

(23(>*1 >0 A* 4** *)

'-*56"0./

"#%

0A456": ./0Q6"&F

!"#.28

7-

>*56" -

0"#


Pgina 22 de 50

"F 784

5

.44

"!!F0!

: >A A* 4>* AC

.284* >* 4E A* A>* E*

./48*;7 >! >0 A* >>* >B

7-.403 )>" E* >* AA* E>

(()*82; >" >4 A* AB* 44

(23(>*" >C A* >** 4A

$"#A**56",

"$)*56"-0

+"4>56"

AB56">>56"

.(2(.27-

:4*56"

-

"-

-$

)6 845

3M

(

"#

N56"O

(

"#

DN56"O

NO

"#

D

N6PO

0 44 A* >C* >>

7-.403 >0 4* A* AA* E>


Pgina 23 de 50

(()*82;

> 4B A* A0* 48

(23(>*: 4A A* A8* 40

"#

$-

#""

"#-0

'4)56">C56".

/1/--(()*

(23% A056"A856"

& .2 7- 1 +

/AA56"7-

- F

56"

$-%"#

&


Pgina 24 de 50

)6) 84594

3M

(

"#

N56"O

(

"#

DN56"O

NO

"#

D

N6PO

B* >C

.284* >0 40 A* A4* E>

./48*;7 >" >4 A* >8* 4>

7-.403 >0 >4 A* A4* E>

(()*82; >: >E A* A0* 4B

(23(>** >0 A* A8* EA

"# -"

"-

0

$#1

,8*56"

>A56" " / -

1.$>856"

(()*(23A056"A856"

/,A456"

.2 17- +

4*56"-


Pgina 25 de 50

)6: 845

3M

(

"#

N56"O

(

"#

DN56"O

NO

"#

D

N6PO

8* * EAI>8 >EIAB ACIA> AAI*A

:F"784

5

.44

!F!


Pgina 26 de 50

-0

./ +

:F"784

5

.44

)!F!

A A* A8* 4A

7-.403 >: >* A* A** 4B

(()*82; !>1 AB A* 4** *)

(23(>*) A* E* 4** *)

/4*56"

>*56"((27-

,A*56"4*56"

./ -

A856"F0.28-

4*56""#

$0(23

:F"784

5

.44

:!F!

> A* >** 4A

7-.403 >* >4 A* A4* 4B

(()*82; !>1 >E A* E** *)

(23(>** ** 88 ** 88

E*56"(()*+"$

"#;-

./8*L">*56"


Pgina 27 de 50

/7-A456"0.28(2

3-%4*56"&

$4*56"(23

""

:F"784

5

H

.44

?!F!G

4*

./48*;7 ">! >8 A*

7-.403 ">! >8 A*

(()*82; ">! 4* A*

(23(>** ** 88

/ 0*56"

.7-(

-$-

.2(23 +

4

/

-/-

"#AG>%"#

,%)*56"&"#A**56"&


Pgina 28 de 50

0-3

+ %&

-"

$!/--

$

R"$"-

/.28-'

0.2

@ # "# '

--"$

-#-#

50

60

70

80

90

100

110

120

130

3.5 3.0 2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 -0,5 -12

-10

-8

-6

-4

-2

0

2

4

Velocidad (km/h)Deceleracin (m/s)

Alarma visual/acstica

TTC 2.1sec

Sacudida del freno TTC 1.9sec

Frenada parcial 3.8m/s

TTC 1.7sec

Frenada parcial 2 5.3m/s

TTC 1.1sec

Deceleracin completa TTC 0.1sec

Audi A7

de 100km/h a 60km/h

Reduccin de la velocidad: 32km/h

Alarma acstica

50

60

70

80

90

100

110

120

130

3,5 3,0 2,5 2,0 1,5 1,0 0,5 0,0 -0,5-12

-10

-8

-6

-4

-2

0

2

4

Geschwindigkeit (km/h)Verzgerung (m/s)

Teilbremsung 3,0 m/s

TTC 1,7 sec

optische WarnungTTC 3,4 sec

akustische WarnungTTC 1,7 sec

BMW 5er 100 km/h auf 60 km/h

Geschw .-Abbau: 12 km/h

Alarma visual Alarma acstica

Velocidad (Km/h)

Frenada parcial

Acceleracin (m/s)

Reduccin de la velocidad:

de 100km/h a 60km/h


Pgina 29 de 50

!+-,A8


Pgina 30 de 50

/(

"/$

'%'&

+"%'&-

$ 7

"$( -

-

/(230

!+!

3-

-"

$!/--

50

60

70

80

90

100

110

120

130

3.5 3.0 2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 -0,5 -12

-10

-8

-6

-4

-2

0

2

4


Frenada completa TTC 0.9sec

Alarma visual/acstica

TTC 2.3sec

Volvo V60De 100km/h a 60km/h

Reduccin de la velocidad: 19km/h

50

60

70

80

90

100

110

120

130

3,5 3,0 2,5 2,0 1,5 1,0 0,5 0,0 -0,5 -12

-10

-8

-6

-4

-2

0

2

4


Sacudida TTC 2.2sec

Frenada parcial 1.3m/s

TTC 1.9sec

Frenada parcial 2 4.2m/s

TTC 1.3sec

Aviso visua/acstico

TTC 2.8sec VW Passat

de 100km/h a 60km/h

Reduccin de la velocidad 20km/h


Pgina 31 de 50

(23-

)6* 4

*7

4

.4

7

"!!F !

S3

-T

04*** 56"& ,

1-

,46>

--

"#-

-""#

-"

$7-.2 -

$$

- ' -

-

)60

./(()*$

-$

,


Pgina 32 de 50

$0.28(23

$

"$,

'

-

/-7-%

&$-

"

-"$1

"

,>856>%&"$

=27F

- % 7-&

"

,

)6? 34

9-

$

$ / -

$

""-

.2$

#"#$ +

(1-$"

--


Pgina 33 de 50

Prueba de fallo de funcionamiento A1 curvas

("# @ )*56"U456"

("#D@ 4*56"U456"

%("# &@ A**UA*L

"@ 48

F- "#

Prueba de fallo de funcionamiento A2 adelantamiento de coche en movimiento

("# @A4*56"U456"

("#D@B*56"U456"

8*UA*L"#"# A*

"# +

"#

7-%&

-

" " -

7- $'#


Pgina 34 de 50

Prueba de fallo de funcionamiento A3 frenada ficticia

("# @ 8*56"U456"

("#@ 8*56"U456"

"#@4*UA*L

D-8*56"4*56",> %,

46>& B* D

/ - - -

$"#".2

(""#

Prueba de fallo de funcionamiento A4 aproximacin a un objeto esttico

("# @ 8*56"U456"

("#@ *56"

4*UA*L"#"# A*

F- "#


Pgina 35 de 50

: ,

$ #

--"

"#!+!

+;**B>E*L#

"#

#% +

&'E8L

#>*L-

>**BA48A*AA8B8"

Accidentes mortales por tipo de accidente

=

4)L

=

4)L

/

0L

-H

1

Comparativa Sistema Frenado Emergencia

Documents

Transcript of Comparativa Sistema Frenado Emergencia