BHHMaHHe! CKOpO BbIH.n;eT Ha neqaTH C60pHHK no … · 2017. 8. 21. · BHHMaHHe! CKOpO BbIH.n;eT Ha...
Transcript of BHHMaHHe! CKOpO BbIH.n;eT Ha neqaTH C60pHHK no … · 2017. 8. 21. · BHHMaHHe! CKOpO BbIH.n;eT Ha...
BHHMaHHe! CKOpO BbIH.n;eT Ha neqaTHC60pHHK no MaTepHaJIaM py6pHKH ~MCTOPHHConpOTHBJIeHHH~, 06'be.n;HHHBWHHCTaTbH HaMHorHX HOMepOB raaeTbI ~TYM-6aJIaJIaHKa~ H)KypHaJIa ~AHTH<paWHCTCKHHMOTHB~. Bcex,KTO aaHHTepecyeTcH aTOH KHHrOH, npOCHMHanHcaTb HaM B aHTH<paWHCTCKYIOKOMHCCHIOCaHKT-lleTep6yprcKoro 06m;eCTBa ~MeMO-pHaJI~.
: .• •• BHHMaHHel IIPOCHM nHcaTb HaM no a)J,pecy: 191002, CaHKT- •: n~Tep6ypr, y:!" Pa3'be3'Kaa; 9, a He Ha CTapbIM nO'ITOBbIM 5Im:HK :• ~1yM-6aJIaJIaHKH1>. 11 npO)J,OJI)KaMTe nocem:aTb Ham npe)KHHM •• caHT http://tumbalalaika.memo.ru. •• TA •• .u3)J,aHHe ocym:eCTBJIeHO npH nO)J,)J,ep)KKe¢oH)J,a ~TO'IKa OnOpbI1>. •• •..................................... :
3mom HOMep ZomoeUJlC~ e oKm~6pe 2002 zoaa. MocKea ...J],a He mOJlbKO MOCKea - ece Mbl, ee3ae: «EeaHbuj, 6eaHbte3eepu! BOlom, pblamom, peeym! B Ka){{aOU 6epJloze U e Ka){{-aou ne~epe ... » Y Ka,){{aOZOmeJleeU30pa - OKaMeHeewue om60JlU U cmpaxa 3pUmeJlU U CJlywameJlu.
B KOZOMbl npeepamUJlUCb? flezo Mbl ){{aaJlu? Mbl ttmo -He nOHUMaJlU, ttmo COn11-t~MUtteJlOeetteCKUx ){{U3HeU JleZKO no-,){{epmeYlOm He mOJlbKO Oaep){{UMble meppopucmbl, HO U 1-tawueJlacmu? Pa3ee Mbl He 3HaJlU, ttmo 6yaem UlmypM U 6yaymy6umble? HJlU U aJl~ Hac tteJlOeetteclW~ '){{U3Hby){{e - He ZJlae-Hoe? Pa3ee Mbl He XomeJlU nepezoeopoe? He eepuJlu e Heo6xo-aW.tQcmb npeKpa~eHu~ eOtl1-lblHa KaeKa3e? He nOHUMaJlU eclO6e3Haae){{1-l0Cmb, ece Omttamlue 3mou L~enHou peaK~uu Hacu-JlU~? Kmo omeemum 3a y6uucmea? 3a cMepmb mex, Kmo 6blJlyayweH za30M - on~mb, KaK 60 Jlem 1-la3aa? Mbl?! Hem.Beab eJlacmu maK U CKa3aJlU: «EepeM Ha ce6~ eClO omeemcm-eeH1-l0Cmb». BClO? BClO.
A zae ,){{e 1-lawa omeemcmeeHHocmb? J],a maM ,){{e, zae Ucoeecmb, Mbl CaaJlu ux eJlaCm~M, 1-leaO){{Uaa~Cb, nOKa ttetteH-~bl caaaym opy,){{ue.
3Hattum, He omeettaeJIt 3a CJlyttueUleec~? A 3a mo, ttmo e~ecJlyttumc~? 3a mo, 1lmo npoucxoaum ceuttac? )f(u3Hb mo6ozoU3 Hac y,){{e O~eHe1-ta: eCJlU ttmo, 100 mblC~tt py6Jleu nOJlyttumpoa~. M bl - COZJlaCHbl?
B HOMepe:.c
2
MaTepllaJIbI CeMIIHapa
MHrpaHTbI H 6e)KeHUbI B POCCHHCKOH <De)),epaUHH :3o rrpe)),OCTaBJIeHHH cTaTyca 6e)KeHua
B POCCHHCKOH <De)),epaUHH 11IIOMOIIIb 6e)KeHuaM B 3arra)),HoH EBporre 22,lLBH)KeHHe rrpOTHB HeJIeraJIbHOH HMMHrpaUHH 2HUblraHe-6e)KeHUbI B cOBpeMeHHoH EBporre 42,lLHCKYCCH5IHa ceMHHape 4H
AHTH<pallIHcTCKHH aHaJIH3
AHTHr JI06aJIH3M - HOBa5I TeMa
crropoB aHTH¢anIHcToB 52MCTOPH5I ConpOTHHJIeHH5I
<DpaHIIY3cKHe HHTeJIJIeKTyaJIbI H CorrpOTHBJIeHHe 61IIaM5ITH )KepTH
,lLHH rraM5ITH. IIoe3)),Ka B IIOJIbllIY 67KllH)KHOe oooapeHHe
C. 13eJIHKOB <i:13pHTOrOJIOBble~;
A. BepxoBcKHH <i:focy)),apcTBo rrpOTHB
pa)J,HKaJIbHOrO HaUHOHaJIH3Ma~ ;
B. JIHXaqeB <i:HaIIH3M B POCCHH~ 79KHHopeBlo
<i:AMHHb~ 8/i
AHTH<pallIHcTCKa5I xpoHHKa
KOH¢epeHIIH5I UNITED 92AHTH¢allIHCTcKHH TeaTp '" 9/i
,lLeTH rrpOTHB BOHHbI 95
B 2002 zoay mpaaUZ;UO'HJibltl oCeJiJiUZl CeJl'IU'Hap 6blJl nOC651w,ml
aUC"KpuJvlu'Hau,uu 6e)f(c'HZ;e6 U JvluZpa'Hmo6. B ceJvlu'Hape npurl5lJlU Ylla-
cmue "Ka"K cneu,uaJlUCmbl, "KOmOpble aa6JiO U ZJly6o"KO 3aHUJI'laJomC51
aaHHozl npo6JleJvlou, mal< U umnepecY1Ow,a51C51 3mozl meJvlamU"KOZl JvlO-
JlOae)f{b.
MHrPAHTbI II EE)KEH:QbIB POCCllHCKOH <l>E)1EPA:QHH
KpaTKaH cnpaBKa
B MocKBe cymeCTByeT KOMHTeT <tfpa)K,[laHCKOe cO,[leMCTBHe». ::ho rrepBa5]
B POCCHH o6mecTBeHl-raR opraHH3aJJ;HR, KOTopaR CTaJIa 3aHllMaTbCR BbIHY)K-
,[leHHblMH MHrpaHTaMll. OHa 06pa30BaJIaCb B 1990 ro,[ly, KOr,l(a B MOCKBY
XJlbIHYJI rrOTOK 6e)KeHJJ;eB H3 A3ep6aM,[l)KaHa B CBR3H C Kapa6axcKllM KOH-
cPJIllKTOM II KOr,[la HeCKOJIbl{o LleJIOBeK, rrbITaBllIllXCR JIWIHO rrOMoraTb 3THM
JIIO,[lRM, rrOHRJIH: rocY,[lapCTBO OTKa3blBaeTCR OC03HaTb, 'ITO rrp06JIeMa 3Ta -
60JIee cleM Ha ,[leCRTHJIeTHe, H npe,[lrrOJlaraeT, 'ITO Bce YTpRceTCR caMO C060M.
OCHOBHOM JJ;eJIblO KOMHTeTa 6bIJlO rrOMO'Ib JIIO,[lRM a,[larrTHpOBaTbCR, rrOMO'Ib
HM HaMTH HOBoe MeCTO B )KH3HH.
,l(eRTeJIbHOCTb KOMHTeTa <tfpa)K,[laHCKOe CO,[leMCTBHe» Be,[leTCH rro He-
CKOJIbKHl'1 HarrpaBJIeHHJIl'1. OCHOBHoe H3 HHX - pa60Ta ]\1HOr0cPYHKJJ;HOHaJIb-
Hoit rrpHel'1HOM, 'Iepe3 KOTOpYlO Ka)K,l(blM ro,[l rrpoXo,[lHT 60JIbille 12 TblCJI'l 'Ie-
JIOBeK: 6e)KeHJJ;eB, rrepeCeJIeHJJ;eB H3 Cal'1blX pa3Hblx 'IaCTeM HailleM CTpaHbI.
3,l(eCb ocymeCTBJIReTCJI rrepBWIHoe KOHCYJIbTHpOBaHlle no rJIaBHbll'1 ,[lJIJI 6e-
)KeHl(eB BOrrpOCal'1: cT,nyc, penlcTpaJJ;HJI, rpa)K,[laHCTBO, TPY,[lOYCTPOMCTBO,l'1e-
,l(HJJ;HHCKaJIrr0l'10mb, o6pa30BaHlle. B pal'1KaX OKa3aHHJI opraHH3aJJ;HoHHo-rro-
Cpe,l(HH'IeCKoit rr0l'10mH KOl'1HTeT BblCblJIaCT B pa3Hble HUCTaHJJ;HH ,[l0
1500 pa3JIH'IHblX rrHCel'1 B ro,[l: 06pameHHM, ,[lerrYTaTcKHx 3arrpOCOB, Be,[leT Te-
JIecPouuble rreperOBOpbI. 1-lT06bl rro,[l,[lep)KaTb 6e)KeHJJ;eB, KOl'1HTeT OKa3blBaeT
l'1aTepHaJIbuylO H HHYIO rYl'1,UIHTapHYIO rr0l'10mb.
Me,[lllJJ;HHcKaJI rr0l'10mb - O,[lHO H3 Ba)KHeMIlIHX UanpaBJIeHHM pa60Tbl
KOl'1HTeTa. Be)KeuJJ;bl - 3TO JIIO,[lH, KOTopble ue Hl'1eIOT )KHJIbR, ue l'10rYT 0cPH-
JJ;HaJIbHO o6paTHTbCJI no l'1eCTY npO)KHBaUHJI B nOJIHKJIHHHKH HJIH ,[lpyrHe
JIe'Ie6Hble Y'Ipe)K,l(eUHJI, TaK KaK Y HHX ueT rrOJIHca. Bpa'iH KOl'1HTeTa o6cJIe,[lY-
lOT HY)K,[lalOmHXCR, rrpH Heo6xo,[lHl'10CTH UarrpaBJIJIIOT 60JIbUblX Ha rOCmITaJIH-
3aJJ;HIO, rrocemalOT 60JIbUblX H Bble3)KalOT HUOr,[la B nYUKTbl Bpel'1eUHOrO pa3l'1e-
meHlm 6e)KeUJJ;eB.
I10'ITH 50 l'1GCKOBCKHX CTY,[leUTOB ua 6eClIJIaTHOM OCHOBe pa60T,"lOT B
IJ,eHTpe a,[larrTaJJ;HH H 06Y'IeHHJI ,[lJIJI ,[leTeM 6e)KeUJJ;eB H BbIHY)K,[leUUblX rrepece- 3
JIeliI];eB, CyrrreCTBYIOIIIeM rrpll KOl'lIlTeTe C 1996 rotla. fJIaBHaJI 3atla'-Ia l!,eu-
Tpa - BOCCTaHOBJIeHlle KOMMYHilKaTllBHbIX II Y'Ie6Hblx HaBbIKOB, rrCllXOJIOrl1-
'-IeCKa5I rrOMOrrrb tleT5IM B rrOCJleCTpeCcoBoM cllTyaIIIlIl.
O'IeHb 60JIbiliOe 3Ha'-IeHlle llMeeT rrpaBOBaJI rrOMOrrrb 6e)j(eHIIaM: HeCKOJlb-
KO roPlICTOB II atlBOKaTOB BetlYT KOHcYJIbTaTllBHbIM rrplIeM, rrOMoralOT B COCTan-
JIeHlllI ropIItllI'-IeCKlIX tlOKYMeHToB II BetleHlIll rreperrllCKil C rocYtlapCTBeHHbIMH
OpraHal'Ill, rrpetlCTaBJI5IroT IIHTepeCbI 6e)j(eHIIeB B CYtle.
IOpIItlll'IecKYro rrOtltlep)j(KY 6e)j(eHIIeB ocyrrreCTBJIJIeT TaK)j(e ceTb %JVhI-
rpaIIlI5I II npaB01> rrpaBo3arrrlITuoro IIeHTpa %MeMOpIIaJI1> , COCT05IIIIaJI ceM'lar
1I3 rrJITlitleCJITll roplltllI'IeCKllX rryuKToB nOMOrrrlI 6e)j(eHIIaM rro BCe}1 POCCIllI 11
paCIIIIlpJIIOrrraJICJI Ha BOCTOK.
JIIO,ll,I1 eIaCTO 3a,ll,alOT BO-
rrpoc: ~3aeleM HaM HY)KHbI 6e-
}KeHIJ;bI? ITO'-IeMY MbI ,ll,OJDKHbI
o HHX 3a6oTI1TbC5I, I1X rrpHHI1-
MaTb?~ MO)KHO tJ:aTb OTBeT C
TO'IKH 3peHI15I emCTO rrparMa-
TH'IeCKOH:. Y'IeHbIe YTBep)KtJ:a-
lOT, 'ITO B POCCI1H CeH:elaC
CTpallIHbIH: ,ll,eMOrpaepWleCKI1H:
KpI13I1C 11 eITO MOJIO,ll,OMY rrOKO-
JIeHHlO 6Y,ll,eT He rrpOKOpMI1Tb
rrOKOJIeHI1e CBOI1X pO,ll,HTeJIeH:,
KOr,ll,a Te BbIH:,ll,YT Ha rreHCHlO.
IT03TOMY POCCI1I1 HY)KHbI MH-
rpaHTbI HCXO,ll,5I H3 CaMOH: 'ITO
HI1 Ha eCTb rrpaKTI1'IeCKOH: He-
06XO,ll,I1MOCTH. MHrpaHTbI 3aH:-
MYT 3KOHOMH'IeCKI1e HI1IIIH, KO-
TopbIe He XOT5IT 3aHHMaTb, OCO-
6emro B 60JIbIIIHX ropotJ:ax, KO-
peHHbIe )KHTeJIH. HaM HY)KHbI
JIIO,ll,H, KOTopbIe 6Y,ll,YT TOPro-
BaTb I-Ia pbIHKax, pa60TaTb Ha
Crp0H:KaX, HaM HY)KHbI BOtJ:I1Te-
JIH 06meCTBeHHoro TpaHcrrop-
r<1 (ceH:eElC B MOCKBe 3TO rro'I-
TV! l1CKJIIO'IHTeJIbHO YKpaHH-
IJ;bI). CTpaHe HY)KeH rrpHTOI<
CBe)KHX CI1JI, 3HeprH'IHbIe JIIO-
,ll,H, KOTopble BbIHY)K,ll,eHbI Ka-
pa6KaTbC5I B 3TOj;'I)KH3HH, rrpe,T(-
rrpIIHI1MaTb 60JIbillHe YCI1JIIUI
,ll,JI5I Toro, 'IT06bI BbI)KI1Tb. J;JrrOCT<1HOBKaBorrpoca 0 TOM, eITO
roCY,ll,apCTBO He MO)KeT KOp-
MHTb 3THX 6e)KeHIJ;eB H MH-
rpaHTOB, COBepIlleHHO Herrpa-
BOMepHa: 3TH JIlO,ll,H crroc06Hbi
HaKopMHTb ce65I H Hac. CeM-
'Iac MbI OTrrpaBJI5IeM B Hop Be-
rHIO O,ll,HY apM5IHcKYlO ceMbIO:
MaJIb'IHK TaJIaHTJII1BbIH: MaTe-
MaTHK. POCCH5I He ,ll,aJIa 11M
rrpHlOT H rrbITaJIaCb ero C MaTe-
pblO KaK MO)KHO CKopee BbI-
,ll,BOPI1Tb. Ye3)KaIOT MOJIOtJ:bIC
crroco6Hble JIIO,ll,I1, TaK KaK ro-
CYtJ:aPCTBO Haille Be,ll,eT rrOJIH-
TI1KY OTTOp)KeHI15I 6e)KeHIJ;eB.
Kor,ll,a HaIllI1 BJIaCTI1 rOBO-
p5IT HaM, 'ITO HI1 O,ll,Ha CTpaHa
He rrOCTpOHJIa CBoe 6JIaro-
COCT05IHHe Ha MHrp~HTax, C03-
,ll,aeTC5I Brre'IaTJIeHHe, eITO 3TH
JIIO,ll,H rrpOCTO He YeIHJIHCb B
IllKOJIe 11He 3HaIOT, '-ITOeCTb Ha
tJ:pyroM KOHTI1HeIITe TaKM
CTpaHa - CIliA, Bce 6JIaro-
COCT05IHI1e KOTOPOM CTPOI1JIOCb
H CTPOI1TC5I CeH:elaC Ha MI1rpaH-
Tax.
O,ll,HaKO eCJIH CMOTpeTb
Y)Ke C 'IeJIOBe'IeCKOH:, rrpa-
BI1JIbHOH:, Ha MOH: B3r JI5I,ll" TOLI-
KH 3peHH5I, TO Borrpoc: «3aLIeM
OHH HaM HY)KHbI?» - rrpOCTO
He MO)I(eT CTaBHTbC5I. JIIOtJ:H
cymeCTBYlOT He ,ll,JJ5IToro, eITO
6bI KTO-TO KOMY-TO H tJ:JJ5I ele-
rO-TO 6bIJI HY)KeH, - OHH CY-
meCTBYIOT, rrOTOMY eITO OI-IH
eCTb. 11 rrpHJIWIHa5I CTpaHa
Be,ll,eT TaKym rrOJIHTI1KY, eITo6bI
JIlO,ll,H, KOTOpble OKa3aJII1Cb B
3TOH: CTpaHe, )KI1JII1 tJ:OCTOH:HO.
MI1rpaIJ;IJ5I - 3TO rrepece-
JIeHHe JIIotJ:eH: H3 OtJ:HHX perI10-
HOB B ,ll,PyrI1e. MbI 3aHI1MaeMC5I
TaKOH: ee pa3HOBI1,ll,HOCTblO, KO-
TOpM Ha3bIBaeTC5I BbIHY)KtJ:eH-
HOH:MI1rpaIJ;I1eH:, TO eCTb MbI rro-
MOraeM JIlO,ll,5IM,KOTOpble rrOKI1-
HYJII1 CBOI1 tJ:OMa He rrOTOMY,
eITO OHI1 3aXOTeJII1 rrepeCeJII1Tb-
C5I B ,ll,PyrOH: perI10H pa60TaTb,
I1JII1 113 CeJIbCKI1X )KI1TeJIeH:, Ha-
rrpI1Mep, CTaTb ropOtJ:CKI1MI1
)KI1TeJI5IMI1, I1JII1 ITO tJ:PyrOH: Ka-
KOH:-HI16Y,ll,b JIWlHOM rrpWII1He.
3TI1 JIIO,ll,I1 BbIHY}K,ll,eHbI 6bIJIII
yexaTb rrOTOMY, eITO B I1X pOt!:"
HbIX MeCTax rrp0I130IIIJIO LITO-
TO TaKoe, rrOCJIe 'Iero OHI1 TaM
OCTaBaTbC5I Y)Ke 60JIbille He
MOfJIH.
KaKOBbI )Ke rrpWUIHbI BbI-
HY)KtJ:eHHOH: MI1rpaIJ;I1I1 ceH:'Iac,
rrOCJIe pacrra,ll,a COBeTCKoro
COlO3a? CaMbIH: 60JIbIIIOH: rro-
TOK 6e)KeHIJ;eB - 9TO HaIllI1
COOTe'IeCTBeHHI1KI1 H3 6bIB-
I11I1X COlO3HbIX pecrry6JII1K.
)KHTb BO BHOBb 06pa30BaB-
I11I1XC5IrOCYtJ:apCTBax ,ll,JI5I HHX
'IaCTO OKa3bIBaeTC5I HeB03-
MO)KHbIM ITO rrOJIIITI1LIeCKI1M
rrpI1'IHHaM. OHI1 TaM 'IaCTO or-
paHWIeHbI B rrpaBax. 11x 06-
BI1H5IlOT B TOM, 'ITO POCCI15I OK-
KyrrHpOBaJIa tJ:Pynle CTpaHbI,
ITpI16aJITIIKY HarrpIIMep, He
,ll,aBaJIa CB060,ll,HO )KI1Tb pec-
rry6JII1KaM A3III1 11 KaBKa3a.
Pa3YMeeTC5I, Ka)KtJ:bIH: KOH-
KpeTI-IbIH: PYCCKI1H: LIeJIOBeK B
9TOM He BI1HOBaT, 11 pa3YMeeT-
C5I, 5I MeHbille Bcero tJ:eP)KYCb
KOHIJ;errIJ;I1I1 KOJIJIeKTI1BHOH: HC-
TOpI1LIeCKOH: BI1HbI. Ho 11 )KI1Tb
C omymeHI1eM, 'ITO PYCCKHH:
HapO,ll, 06JIarOtJ:eTeJIbCTBOBaJI
,ll,PyrI1e Hap0,ll,bI, TO)Ke CMeIll-
HO. PYCCKI1e, rrpIIexaBIllIIe 113
6bIBIllI1X COBeTCKITX pecrry6-
JII1K, 6bIBalOT T5I)KeJIbI B o6me-
HI1IT, 06I1)KeHbI, HarrpI1Mep Ha
TO, LITO OT HI1X Tpe60BaJIII
yeIHTb HaIJ;I10HaJIbHbIH: 5I3bIK.
7
PYCCKHX. K Ha1.JaJIY BTOPOM
BOMHbI 60JIbllIHHCTBO PYCCKHX
Y)Ke BbleXaJIO H3 1{e1.JHH, Te-
rrepb oTTy,a:a 6erYT 1.Je1.JeH-
IIbl - 6erYT OT 60M6e)KeK
POCCHMCKHXBoeHHbIX, OT rrpo-
H3BOJIa H MaCCOBblX 6ecrro-
P5l,a:KOB,TaK KaK pa3pYllIaeTC5I
ceJIO 3a CeJIOM, CKpbITbC5I OT
60M6 ,a:a)Ke B ropax Y)Ke He-
B03MO)KHO.
ECTb OCHOBaHH5IrrOJIaraTb,
1.JTOCYlI(eCTByeT YCTaHOBKa He
rrpe,a:OCTaBJI5ITb1.Je1.JeHllaMCTa-
TYC BbIHY)K,a:eHHoro rrepece-
JIeHlla H He perHCTpHpOBaTb
HX rro MeCTY rrpe6bIBaHHH H
)KHTeJIbCTBa, ,a:a)Ke Kor,a:a HMe-
IOTCH Bce 3aKOHHbIe Ha TO OC-
HOBaHHH. I1cKJII01.JefIHe ,a:eJIa-
eTcH JIHlIIb B OT,a:eJIbHbIX CJIY-
1.JMX: ,a:JIHTex, KTO MO)KeT ,a:o-
KYMeHTaJIbHO ,a:OKa3aTb CBOIO
rrpHBep)KeHHOCTb POCCHMCKOM
BJIaCTH H HaJIH1.JHerrpeCJIe,a:o-
BaHHM HMeHHO CO CTOPOHbl MY-
cy JIbMaHCKHX ¢YH,a:aMefITaJIH-
CTOBHJIH 6aH,a:HToB. To, 1.JTO,a:e-
JIaeTCH B 1{e1.JHe - 3TO Y):Kac-
HO. O,a:HH 1.Je'-IeHellCKa3aJI: <i:5I
3,a:eCbKa)K,a:bIM ,a:eHb 60IOCb 3a
CBOIO ceMbIO, eCJIH 6bI Y MeHH
6blJIH ,a:eHbrH, 516bl yexaJI B JIa-
repb B I1HryllIeTHIOi>. He B
AMepHKY, HJIH B fOJIJIaH,a:HIO,
HJIH BO (1)paHIIHIO, He B crro-
KOMHble perHOHbI POCCHH, a B
1.JTOrrpOHcxo,a:51T BoopY)KeH-
Hble KOH¢JIHKTbI.
}KepTBbl 1.Je1.JeHCKOMBOM-
Hbl, oceTHHO-HHrYIlICKoro KOH-
¢JIHKTa IOpH,a:H1.JeCKHHe 51BJI5I-
10TC5I6e)KeHllaMH, rrOTOMY 1.JTO
6e)KeHell - 3TO 06513aTeJIbHO
He rpa)K,a:aHHH CTpaI-IbI. I1 TeM
He MeHee ¢aKTH1.JeCKH 3TO Ha-
IIIH BHYTpeHHHe 6e):KeHllbI. B
rrepBYIO 01.Jepe,a:b,)KHTeJIH 1{e-
1.JeHCKOMpecrry6JIHKH, rrOKH-
HYBIIIHe ee TeppHTopHIO H3-3a
Be,a:YII(HXC5I TaM llIHpOKOMac-
IIITa6HblX BoeHHblX ,a:eMCTBHM,
KOTopbIe HallIH BJIaCTH Ha3bl-
BaIOT <i:KOHTpTeppOpHCTH1.Je-
CKOM orrepaIlHeMi>. 110 O¢HIIH-
aJIbHbIM ,a:aHHbIMTOJIbKOB I1H-
rYlIIeTHH Haxo,a:HTC5I 60JIee
160 TbIC5I1.J)KHTeJIeM 1{e1.JHH,
061I(ee )Ke HX 1.JHCJIO rro
OlleHKaM HerrpaBHTeJIbCTBeH-
HbIX opraHH3allHM - 60JIee
300 TbIC5I1.J 1.JeJIOBeK. focy-
,a:apCTBO ,a:JI5I HHX HH1.JerO He
,a:eJIaeT, TOJIbKO MellIaeT HM. B
OTJIl1'-IHeOT 1991 -1996 ro,a:oB,
TO eCTb rrepHo,a:a rrepBOM BOMHbI
H HeCKOJIbKHX JIeT ,a:o Hee CTa-
TYC BbIHY):K,a:eHHoro rrepece-
JIeHlla )KepTBaM BOMHbl 1999 -2001 ro,a:OB rrpaKTH1.JeCKH He
rrpe,a:OCTaBJI5IeTC5I.,lleJIO B TOM,
1.JTO rrepBa51 BOJIHa )KHTeJIeM
1{e1.JHH, ee rrOKH,a:aBllIHX, CO-
CT05lJIa rrpeHMYlI(eCTBeHHO H3
A3ep6aM,a:)KaHa BO BpeM5I Ka-
pa6axcKoro KOH¢JIHKTa, rrpH-
e3):KaIOT )KepTBbI a6xa30-rpy-
3HHcKoro, oceTHHo-rpY3HHcKO-
ro KOH¢JIHKTa. Hallie rocy-
,a:apcTBo HaCTOJIbKO He )KeJIaeT
HMeTb 06513aTeJIbCTB rro onIO-
lIIeHHIO K 3THM JIIO,a:51M,'-ITO yHac HeT HHKaKoro rrpaBOBoro
aKTa, KOTOPbIM 6bl HX rrOJIO)Ke-
HHe orrpe,a:eJI5IJI, - XOT5I Y)K
3a HHX-TO OHO OTBe1.JaeTB rrOJI-
HOM Mepe: HMeHHO rocy,a:apcT-
BO OTBeTCTBeHHO 3a TO,
"JIIO,a:H, KOTopble C1.JHTaIOTPOC-
CHIO CBoeM PO,a:HHOM,,a:OJI)KHbl
HMeTb B03MO)KHOCTb BepHYTb-
C5I, H 3TO CaMa5160JIbllIM rrpo-
6JIeMa.
ElI(e o,a:Ha rrpH1.JHHa-
B03HHKHOBeHHe rOp5l1.JHX TO-
1.JeK, 60JIbllIHX 01.JarOB Me):K3T-
HH1.JeCKHX H ,a:pymx BOOPY-
):KeHHbIX KOHCI)JIHKTOB. Ap-
M5IHe H pYCCKHe 6e)KaJIH H3
TeM He MeHee, KaKHe OHH HH
eCTb, OHH HallIH, H rrpHHHMaTb
Mbl HX ,a:OJDKHbI. Y HHX He 6bl-
JIO OII(YlI(eHH5I, 1.JTOOHH )KHBYT
B ,a:PyroM CTpaHe, B ,a:Pyroit
pecrry6JIHKe, - OHH )KHJIH B
POCCHH. I1 OHa, POCCH5I, C KO-
TOpOM OHH CB5I3aHbl KYJIbTYP-
HO, KOTOpa51HX Ty,a:a rrOCJIaJIa,
,a:OJI)KHaHX rrpHH5ITb. TaKHx
JIIo,a:eM25 MHJIJIHOHOB, He Bce
OHH 3aXOT5IT BepHYTbC5I B
POCCHIO, KTO-TO CMO)KeT HH-
TerpHpOBaTbC5I B HOBoe 061I(e-
CTBO - HO KTO-TO HeT.
,llpyra51 rrpH1.JHHa - 3KO-
HOMH1.JeCKHe Tpy,a:HOCTH. Bo
MHorHX 6bIBIIIHX COBeTCKHX
pecrry6J1lIKax H3-3a ,a:HCKPH-
MHHallHH TaK Ha3bIBaeMoro
HeKopeHHoro HaCeJIeHH5I JIIO-
,a:H JIHlIIaIOTC5I pa60Tbl, 3apa-
60TKa. 11eHCHH cYlI(eCTBeHHo
HH)Ke, 1.JeMy Hac, )KHTb Ha HHX
HeB03MO)KHO, a 01.JeHb 1.JaCTO
3TO JIIO,a:HY)Ke HeMOJIo,a:ble, H
HeT y HHX TaM KJIaHa rrOTOM-
KOB H po,a:CTBeHHHKOB, KaK y
KopeHHblX ):KHTeJIeM. HallIH
CTapHKH TaM 6YKBaJIbHO YMH-
paIOT C rOJIo,a:y. Mbl ,a:OJI)KHbl
rrOM01.JbHM Bbl)KHTb, eCJIH OHH
XOT5IT )KI'ITb TaM, H ,a:OJI)KHbl
rrOM01.JbHM BepHYTbC5I B POC-
CHIO, HHTerpHpOBaTbC5I B POC-
CHMCKoe 06II(eCTBO, eCJIH OHH
XOT5IT BepHYTbC5I B POCCHIO.6
8
JIarep5:I 11Hrymenm... A
CKOJIbKO HY:>KHO ,Z:(eHer? J(Ba-
,Z:(uaTb Py6JIeH. B qe"lIHe ,Z:(eHer
HeT Bo06Il(e. J(a 11 113 JIarepeH
11HrymeTlIlI, r,Z:(e Y:>Ke YCTaHO-
BlIJIC5:I KaKOH-TO 6bIT, r,Z:(e eCTb
mKOJIbI, 6e)KeHueB nbITaIOTC51
nepeCeJIlITb 06paTHO B qe"lIHIO.
IIocJIe,Z:(H5151 11, KOHe"lIHO,
OqeHb Ba:>KHa51 KaTerOp1I51 MlI-
rpaHTOB - C06CTBeHHO 6e-
:>KeHUbI. 3TO BbIHY:>K,Z:(eHHbIe
MlIrpaHTbI 113 TpeTblIX CTpaH,
TO eCTb CTpaH, He BXO,Z:(lIBmlIX
B COCTaB COBeTCKoro Cor03a.
B nepBYIO Oqepe,Z:(b, KOHeqHO,
aepraHUbI. B POCCIIH :>KlIBeT
nOp51,Z:(Ka 150 TbIC51"lI aepraH-
ueB. (ECTb JIIO,Z:(11113 KOHro,
113 COMaJIlI, 113 11paHa, 11paKa,
HO lIX qlICJIeHHOCTb no cpaB-
HeHlIIO C aepraHuaMlI HWITO:>K-
HO MaJIa.) 113 HlIX np1I3HaHO
6e:>KeHuaMlI 500 (!) qeJIOBeIC
3TlI 150 TbIC51q - Te JIIO,Z:(lI,
KOTopbIe nplIeXaJIlI B CCCP,
Kor,Z:(a MbI ,Z:(PY:>KlIJIlIC Aepra-
HlICTaHOM, Kor,Z:(a MbI nplIr JIa-
maJIlI aepraHueB yqlITbC51 B
BoeHHbIX aKa,Z:(eM1I51X, Kor,Z:(a
MbI B351JIlI 2000 ,Z:(eTeH-clIpoT
11 BOCnJ1TbIBaJIlI lIX JIY"lIIlle,
qeM c06cTBeHHbIx ClIPOT, -
B 3JIlITapHbIX lIHTepHaTax.
Ha MOMeHT na,Z:(eH1I51 pe:>KlIMa
Ha,Z:(:>K1I6YJIbI 3TlI JIIO,Z:(11OKa3a-
JIlICb Ha TepplIToplIlI POCClIlI.
IIplIIlleJI K BJIaCTlI CeBepHblH
aJIb51HC, 11 JIIO,Z:(lI,KOTopbIe no'"
MOraJIlI Ha,Z:(:>K1I6YJIe, 6bIJlfl
Ka3HeHbI BMeCTe C Ha,Z:(:>KH'
6y JIOH. CTOPOHHlIKlI Ha,Z:()Iul"
6y JIbI He Mor JIll BepHYTbC51 TI<1
P0,Z:(lIHY BO BpeM51 CeBepHoro
aJIb51HCa, OHlI He Mor JIll Bep
HYTbC5:I BO BpeM51 MO,Z:(:>KaXC'
,Z:(OB11 TaJI1I60B, 11 OHlI HC MO'
rYT BCPHYTbC5:I CeHqaC, nOTO~
MY qTO OHlI 6e:>KaJIlI OT 3Toro
caMoro CCBepHoro aJIb51HCa,
BJIaCTlI rOBOp51T: 3TlI JIIO,Z:(H
3,Z:(eCb no 3KOHOMlI"lIeCKHiVl
nplIqlIHaM, OI-Ill MorYT no-
exaTb B cBoit AepraHlICTal1.
KOI-IeqHO, MorYT, HO BeJIHK,l
onacHocTb, qTO C I-IIIX :>KlIBblX
c,Z:(epYT UIKYPY. He,Z:(aBHo IIC-
CKOJIbKO aepraHueB BepHY-
JIlICb - 11 6bIJIlI y61ITbl, HX
TpyrrbI no,Z:(6pOClIJIlI Ha rpaHYI-
uy, qT06bI MbI 3HaJIlI, qTO C HHMvl
6y,Z:(eT. 0 KaKlIX 3KOHOMWIC-
CKlIX npelIMYIl(eCTBax :>K1I3HH
3,Z:(ecb MO)I{HO rOBoplITb, CCJIH
qeJIOBeK TaM Y Cc651 6bIJI reHe-
paJIOM, lIMeJI OC06H5IK, a ceHqac
:>KlIBeT C ceMbeH 113 n51TlI qeJIO-
BeK B 8-MeTpOBOH KOMHaTC?
3,Z:(eCb OH HlIIl(lIH, OH Ha pbIHKe
TaCKaeT rpY3bl, nOTOMY qTO 3TO
C,Z:(lIHCTBCHHa51pa60Ta, K KOTO-
pOH era ,Z:(onYCKaIOT. ECTb eIl(c
BaplIaHT ,Z:(JI51HeJICraJIOB: KPlI-
MlIHaJIbHa51 cepepa. TaK pa3Be
HC BbIrO,Z:(HOrocy,Z:(apCTBY, "lITO-
6bI acpraHCKlIH Bpa"ll nOJIY"lJl1JI
npaBOBOH CTaTYC 11 pa60TaJI
BpaqOM, - npWleM OH CorJIa-
ceH exaTb He B IIeTep6ypr, a
Ty,Z:(a,r,Z:(eIi)':>KHbI BpaqlI! To, qTO
npolIcxo,Z:(IIJIO B AepraHHcTaHc,
BO MHorOM eCTb CJIe,Z:(CTBlIeno-
JIIITJ1KlI COBeTcKoro COI03a:
MbI BMemaJIJ1Cb B "lry:>KlIe,Z:(eJIa,a
Tenepb JIIo,Z:(eH, KOTopble no-
mJIlI 3a HaMlI CJIe,Z:(OM,He XOTIIM
nplIHlIMaTb. 11Haqe rOBOp51,
POCCII51, nplIcoe,Z:(lIHlIBIlla5IC51 K
KOHBeHUlIlI OOH ~O CTaTyce
6e:>KeHua» 11 nplIH51Bma51 c06-
CTBeHHbIe 3aKOHbI no MlIrpaH-
TaM, He BbII10JIH51eT CBOHX 0651-
3aTeJIbCTB.
O,Z:(Ha 113 nplIqlIH B TOM,
qTO TaKoe KOJIII"lIeCTBO HeJIera-
JIOB BbIrO,Z:(HO MlIJIlIUlIlI: 'IDa:>K-
,Z:(bIHpa3, OCTaHaBJIJ1Ba51 HeJIe-
raJIbHOrO lIMMJ1rpaHTa, y Hcro
no,Z:( yrp030H ,Z:(enopTaUlIJ1 06-
paulo B cTpaHY npOlICXO:>K,Z:(C-
H1I51 BbIMoraIOT ,Z:(eHbrlI.
IIpHqy,Z:(JIlIBOCTb Hamero
3aKOHo,Z:(aTeJIbCTBa 0 MlIrpaH-
Tax nop0:>K,Z:(aeT IOPlI,Z:(WICCKlIC
Ka3YCbI. HanplIMep, C 1990 ra-
,Z:(a6e)KCHUbI 113 naKY, apM51He,
6bIJIlI 3,Z:(eCb JICraJIbHbIMlI lIM-
MlIrpaHTaMJ1: 11M ,Z:(aBaJIlI y,Z:(O-
CTOBCPCHlIC 6e)KeHua, KOTO-
poe pcry JI51PHO npo,Z:(JIeBaJIOCb.
KTO-TO J13 HlIX nplIH51JI rpa)K-
,Z:(aHcTBo POCClIJ1, [{TO-TO
HCT - no pa3HbIM nplIq1'IHaM:
HeKOTopbIe nOTOMY, qTO B Mo-
CKBe, HanplIMep, HeJIb351 rro,Z:(aTb
,Z:(OKYMeHTbI,He lIMC51 perlICTpa-
UlIlI; ,Z:(pyrlIe HaXO,Z:(lIJIlICb 3a
py6C)KOM 11 He CMor JIll no,Z:(aTb
,Z:(OKYMeHTbI, nOTOMY "lITOB KOH-
cy JIbCTBaX B351TKlI 11 KOJIOC-
CaJIbHbIe Oqepe,Z:(lI Ha rrOJIY"lIe-
HlIe rpa:>K,Z:(aHCTBa; TPCTblI npo-
CTO He XOTCJIlI. B 2000 ro,Z:(y
lIX y,Z:(ocToBepcHlIe 6e:>KeHua
06b51BJIeHO y,Z:(ocToBepeHlIeM
HCYCTaHOBJIeHHOrO 06pa3ua,
TaKlIM 06pa30M Bce 3TlI ap-
M51He-6e:>KeHUbI CTaHOB51TC51He-
JIeraJIbHbIMII lIMMlIrpaHTaMIL
B 2001 ra,Z:(y BHOClITC51 HOBbIH
3aKOHonpoeKT 0 rpa)I{,Z:(aI-ICTBe,
OCI-IOBaHI-IbIH I-Ia HlIKaK He on-
pe,Z:(eJIeHHOM nOH51TJ11I BlI,Z:(a Ha
:>KlITeJIbCTBO. MbI nO,Z:(HlIMaeM
mYM B 06Il(eCTBeHHbIX OpraI-IlI-
3aU1I51X, nlIIlleM Ha npOCKT
, 3aKOHa OTplIuaTCJIbI-IbIe peueH-
31111, 06b51CH51eM, qTO I-ICJIb351
o rrPE~OCTABAEHHHCTATYCA EEJKEHQA
B POCCHMCKOM <l>E~EPAQHH
Om peaaKt~uu. C MOMeHTaHarrHcaHAA 3Toro MaTepHafla CH-
TyaI(H~ pa~HKaflbHo H3MemwaCb K xY~llIeMY H ~e1.IeHCKHe6e-
)KeHI(bI, HaXO~H13llIHec~13flarep~x 11HryllIeTHH, rro~BeprflHcb Mac-
COBOMY BblcefleHHIO 13 l.lelIHIo, lITO rp03HT HM He rrpOCTO
CTpa~aHH~MH, a CMepTblO.
1
Jie 06ocHo8aHHblX onaceHutlcmamb )Kepmeou npeCJleaoea-HUR-no npU3HaKY paCbl, eepo-ucnOeeaal-lUR-, Zpa)Kaal-ICm8a,Ha~U01WJlbHOCmU, npUJ-wa-Jle)KHOCmU K onpeaeJleHHOUCO~UaJlbHOUzpynne UJlU nOJlU-
C. A. F al-mYLUKWW,conpeaceaameJlb KOJ;IUmema
«Fpa)KaaHCKOe coaeucmeuet>,PYK080aUmeJlb cemu «Muzpa-t~UR-u npaeot> npaeo3au~um-HOW t~eHmpa «]VIe/vwpuaJlt>
CeH~ac COI(HaflbHOC H
rrpaBOBoe rrOflO)KeHHe BbIHY)K-
~eHHbIX MHrpaHTOB 13 HallIeH
CTpaHe CTaflO HeCOH3MepHMO
XY)KCrro cpaBHeHHIO CTCM,~TO
6bIflO ~Ba ro~a Ha3a~. Tor~a
6bwa Ha~e)K~a, LITO MbI ~BH-
)KeMC~ 13 HY)KHOM HarrpaBflC-
HHH. CeH1.Iac Y MeH~ TaKoro
OlIWII(eHH~ HeT.
CorflaCHO 3aKOHY PcD~O
6e)KeHI(ax» 0'1' 19 epe13pafl~
1993 ro~a 13 pe~aKI(HH 0'1'
28 HIorm 1997 ro~a, 6e,)/w-Het~ - 3mo Jlut~O, Komopoe HeR-8JlaemCR-Zpa)KaaHUHOM PeDu Komopoe e CWIY enOJI-
13aKY, MO~ pO~HHa COBeTCKHH
COI03, BOT 3Ta 60flbllIa~ CTpa-
Ha POCCH~. 5I 3a Hee KpOBb
rrpOflHBafla, ~ Ha Hee pa6OTafla,
~fl~ MeH~ 3'1'0 KpYllIeHHe BceH
)KH3HH, ~ He XO~y 133TY AMe-
PHKY, ~ X01.IY )KHTb 13 CBOe}I
CTpaHe, ~ XOl.lY 13CBoeH 3eMfle
YMepeTb». A ee flHllIalOT rreH-
CHH, a 13ceMbC TpH HHBaflH~a:
OHa, MY)K H CbIH, HHBaflH~ rrcp-
BOIl rpyrrrrbI C ~cTcTBa. IIeH-
CH~ - 3'1'0 BCC, Ha ~TO OHH
)KHBYT. BOT H rrOflY'-IaeTC~,LITO
flY~llIec, ~TO MbI MO:>KCMC~C-
flaTb ~fl~ HHX, - 3'1'0 OTrrpa-
BHTb HX H3 CrpaHbI.
130». 3Ha~HT, C rreHCHll CHHMa"
10'1'Y)Ke cerO~H~, a ~TO TaKOC
BH~ Ha )KHTeflbCTBO, rro KaKHM
KpHTepH~M OH6y~eT ~aBaTbC51,
KaKHe OH 6y~eT ~aBaTb rrpaBa,
KaKOBbI CPOKH paCCMOTpeHyl51
3a~BfleHH}I 0 rrpe~OCTaBflcml J.1
BH~a Ha )KHTeflbCTBO - HCy]:l~
BCCTHO.IIpe~CTaBbTe cc6c 80fleTHero ~CflOBeKa, KOTOPOMY
MllrpaI(HOHHa~ cflY:>K6a «6JI<1
ropO~HO» rrpO~fleBaeT npallO
Ha rrOflY1.IeHHerreHCllH Ka:>K~b(('
TpH MeC~I(a, BC~KHH pa3 BPY
~a~ oepHI(HaflbHYIO 6YMary ('
rrpe~yrrpe)K~eHHeM, LITO, eCJl11
BH~ Ha )KHTeflbCTBO HC 6Y~CT
rrpc~b~BfleH, rreHCHH ero Jl~I'
llIaT!
o cHTyaI(HH C 6aKHHcK~1
MH apM~HaMH, 13 o~Ho1.IaCb(·
CTaBllIHMH HefleraflaMH, Y3IW'
flH 13 CIlIA. nfl~ 6aKHHCKI1X
apM~H, He HMeIOII(HX CTaTyca J.1
)KHBYII(HX 13 MOCKOBCKOMpc
rHOHe, OTKPbIflH rrporpaMMY
rro rrepecefleHHIO 13 AMepHKY,
MHorHe H3 HHX pa~bI. Ho BOT
KO MHe rrpHXO~HT )KeHlInma,
KOTOPOH85 fleT, y Hee y ~OCTO
Bepemle y~acTHHKa BeJIHKoll
OTe~ecTBeHHoH BOHHbI, 01111
CH~HTP~~OM co MHOH, ~ rrOMO
raIO eH 3arrOflHHTb alIKeTY II
AMepHKY. OHa rrfla~eT: «Bill
LITO,He rrOHHMaeTe,3'1'0MO~ po '
~HHa, - He A3ep6aH~)KaH, Il('
CTPOHTb HOBOe 3aKOHO~aTeflb-
CTBO HeH3BeCTHOHa ~eM (H 13
3TOM COBrra~aeM C OT3bIBOM
rrpaBOBOrO yrrpaBfleHH~ focy-
~apCTBeI-IHOH~YMbI, r~e HarrH-
CaHO, ~TO 3aKOH OCHOBbIBaeTC~
Ha rrOH~THH BH~a Ha )KHTeflb-
CTBO,a 3'1'0HHCTHTYT,KOToporo
POCCHHClwe rrpaBO He 3Ha-
eT, - rrpaB~a, rr01IeMY-TOrrpa-
BOBoe yrrpaBfleI-Ule rrpe~flaraeT
3'1'0'1'3aKOH rrpHH~Tb). 3aKOH
rrpHHHMaIOT. TYT )Ke MeI-meTC~
rreHCHOHHoe 3aKOHo~aTeflbCT-
130. 11 BOT 6e)KeHeI( H3 13aKY,
12 fleT )KHBYII(HH13POCCHH,Ha
CBO}I Borrpoc, rr01IeMY ero ceH-
1.IaCCHHMaIOTC rreHCHH, rrOflY-
~aeT OTBeT: <-,CorflaCHO BBe-
~eHHOMY 13~eHCTBHeC 1 ~HBa-
p~ HOBOMY rreHcHoHHOMY 3a-
KOHo~aTeflbcTBY HHocTpaHHble
rpa)K~aHe H flHI(a 6e3 rpa)K-
~aHCTBa HMeIOTrrpaBo Ha rreH-
CHIO HapaBI-Ie C rpa)K~aHaMH
TOJlbKOrrpH YCflOBl'IH rrOCTO~H-
Horo rrp0)KlmaHH~, TOeCTbrrpH
HaflH~HH BH~a Ha )KHTeflbCT-
mU'LleCKUX y6e)K8eHUU HaXO-
8umc.Jl 61le CmpaHbt C60eU zpa-
)K8aJ-lCKott npuHa8Jle)K1-LOCmU
U He MO)Kem nOJlb306ambC.Jl
3aU?UmOU amou cmpaHbl UJlU
He )/{eJlaem nOJlb306ambC.Jl ma-
Kott 3aU?UmOLt6CJle8cm6ue ma-
KUX onacellUU; UJlU, He UMe.Jl
onpe8CJleWLOZO Zpa)K8aHCm6a
U Hax08.JlCb 61-1ecmpaJ-lbl C60-
ezo npe)KHeZO 06bl1LHOZO Me-
cmO)KWneJlbCm6a 6 pe3YJlbma-
me n0806HblX c06blmuu, He
j'vLO)KCmUJlU lie )1<:eJlaem 6CP-
HymbC.Jl 6 Hce 6cJle8cm6UC ma-
KUX OnaCeHLtLt.
3TO orrpe~efleHMe B rrOfl-
HOH Mepe COOTBeTCTByeTorrpe-
~eJleHMIO 6e:>KeHl:(aB KotIBeH-
UMM OOH «0 cTaTyce 6e:>KeH-
ueB» 1951 ro~a, paTMqmUMpo-
BatIHOH P<l> B 1992 ro~y, o~-
HaKO rrOflO:>KeHMeC rrpe~ocraB-
JlemleM cTaTyca 6e:>KeHua rro
P<l> B ueflOM M B CaHKT-
ITeTep6ypre B qaCTHOCTMHeflb-
3H CqMTaTb y~OBfleTBopMTeflb-
HbIM. POCCMH, paTMcjYHUMpOBaB
KotIBeHUIUo OOH «0 cTaTyce
6e)KeHueB:» H EBporreHcKYIO
KOHBeHumo «0 3aruHTe rrpaB
qeflOBeKa M OCHOBHbIX CBO-
60~:» H rrpMHHB Ha ce6H rrpM
3TOM orrpe~efleHHble 06H3a-
TeflbCTBa rro c06flIO~eHMIO
rrpaB LleflOBeKa, B ~omKHoH CTe-
rreHU HX He BbIITOflHHeT. EOflee
Toro, P<l> Ha cerO~HHIlIHHVI
~eHb HBflHeTCH CTpaHOH, rropo-
:>K~aIOrueH 6e:>KeHueB - 3TO
rrpe:>K~e Bcero BbIXO~UbI H:l
LIeLlmI, KOTopble MruYT y6e:>KHo
rua B ~pyrMx eBporreMCKHX
CTpaHax.
C 1993 ro~a, TO eCTb C MO
MetITa rrpHHHTMH epe~epaflbHO
1'0 3aKOHa P<l> «0 6e)KeHuax»,
C03~aHMH MHrpaUHOHHoro op-
raHa M Haqafla npe~OCTaBfle'
HUH cTaTyca 6e:>KeHuaB P<l>, lW2002 ro~a 6e:>KeHuaMH 6bIJTO
npu3HaHo Bcero flHlllb OKOJIO
700 rpa:>K~aH H3 TpeTbYIX
cTpaH: He60flbilloe KOflWleCTBO
rpa:>K~aH I1paKa, PyaH~bI VI
~pyrHx cTpaH, OCTaflbHble atp-
raHUbI. )Jjrn TaKoH cTpaHbI, KaK
POCCMH, 3TO HMqTO>KHOMaflO.
ITo CaHKT- ITeTep6ypry CI1-
TyaUM5I Bblr flH~HT cfle~YIOruMM
06pa30M: 3a 9 fleT cyrueCTBO-
BaHHH MHrpaUHOHHoro opraHa,
C 1993 rro 2002 ro~, 6bIJTO
rrpH3HaHo 6e)KeHuaMII B 06ruell
CflO>KHOCTII He 60flee 110 qe-
flOBeK II3 TpeTbMx CTpaH. Oc-
HOBHbIM penIOHOM IIcxo~a HB-
fl5IeTC5I AepraHIIcTaH, OCTaflI,-
Hble - BbIXO~UbI M3 I1paHa,
PyaH~bI, Cy~aHa, YraH~bI 1'1
Afl:>KMpa. ITo JIeHIIHrpa~cKoti
06flacTM rrpII3HaHo 6e)KeHuaMH
Bcero flHlllb 10 LleflOBeK, Bce
OHM rpa)K~aHe AepraHMCTaHa.
ITOqTII rrOflOBHHa 6e)KeHl:(eB
rroflyqMfla 3TOT CTaTYCTOJIbKO
B nOCJIe~HHe ro~bI. Ha~o 3a-
MeTl1Tb, 'ITO, no ~aHHbIM
YnpaBfleHHH BepxoBHoro KO-
MMccapa OOH no ~eflaM 6e-
:>KeHIleB, TOflbKO rpa:>K~aH Aep-
raHIICTaHa Ha TeppMTopHII P<l>
HaXO~MTCH OKOJIO 1 SO TbICHq
(B CatIKT- ITeTep6ypre OKOflO
3 TbICHLI). nflH cpaBHemrn: no
~aHHbIM YBKE OOH, B3HTbIM
II3 rrpaBIITeflbcTBeHHblx MCTOLI-
HMKOB U orry6flMKoBaHHbIM B
MCCfle~OBammx UeHTpa J:(OKY-
MeHTal:(MM M MHepopMaIluM
OKeHeBa, 1999), CTpaHbI EBpO-
rrbI B TeqeHMe 1990 -1997 ro-
~OB rrpe~ocTaBHflII cTaTYc 6e-
:>KeHuanpMMepHo 17 TblCHLlaM
aepraHuaM, IIruyruUM y6e:>KIIrua
(113HUX fepMamm - 8700 qe-
flOBeKaM, HII~epflaH~bI-
5700 LlefloBeKaM).
no 1998 ro~a rrOqTU Bce
flUl:(a, Mruyruue B POCCMUy6e-
)KMrua, B TOMqIICfle M II3 Aepra-
HUCTaHa, rrOflYLlaflII OTKa3 B
rrpe~OCTaBfleHMII cTaTyca -
3TOrrpu TOM, 'ITO P<l>, KaK rrpa-
BonpeeMHMK CCCP, HaXO~IIT-
CH B HeorrflaTHOM ~oflry rrepe~
TbICHLlaMMaepraHueB, KOTopble,
6Y~YLIU BocrrIITaHbI B KOMMY-
HIICTMqeCKOM~yxe, BCTaflII Ha
HalllY CTOPOHYM BoeBaflM BMe-
CTe C COBeTCKIIMM Tor~a erue
COfl~aTaMII rrpOTUB cyrueCTBO-
BaBIuero B AepraHMCTaHe pe-
:>KUMa, B pe3Y JlbTaTe qero l:(e-
flble COUUaJIbHble rpyrrnbI TaM
3aOqHO rrpurOBopeHbI K CMepTII
II MO~)KaXe~aMH, H Taflu6aMII.
Cero~trn II3-3a HeCTa6IIflb-
HOCTM COIlIIaflbHO-3KOHOi\fWle-
CKot:'r 06CTaHOBKH B AepraHM-
CTaHe rrpIIHY ~IITeflbHOe B03-
Bparuemle B 3TY CTpaHY C03~a-
eT peaflbHYIO yrp03Y )KM3HII H
3~OPOBbIO .T[IO~elI.
O~lIaKO l\1UrpaIllIOHHbIH
opraH B CaHKT- ITeTep6ypre
CLIl1TaeT (3TO TOLIKa 3peHlIH
MlIrpaUUOHHbIX CflY)K6 TaK:>Ke
POCCl'Il1 B IleflOM), LITOBce flM-
Ua, IIruyrulIe y6e)KIIrua, - 3TO
«,,3KOHOMlILleCKHe MIIrpaIlTbI" ,
POCCl'rn ~flH HIIX npIIBfleKa-
TeflbHaH CTpaHa, C03~aIOIl:(aH
HeOrpaHlIqeHHble B03MO:>KHO-
CTlI KOMMepUIIII, YKflOHeHlIH OT
yrrflaTbI lIaflorOB, cB060~Horo
rrepe~BlI:>KeHlIH B cTpaHbI EB-
porrbI:» (3TO UIITaTa II3 3aKflIO-
l.J:eHIIH,rrpe~CTaBJleHHOro B <l>e-
~epaflbHbIH cy ~ CaHKT- ITeTep-
6ypra B 06bHCHeHHe OTKa3a B
npe~OCTaBfletIYII1 cTaTyca 6e-
)KeHIla rpa:>K~amUlY AepraHlI-
CTalIa).
B POCClIHCKOM 3aKOHo~a-
TeflbCTBe CO~ep:>KHTCHTaK)Ke
HopMa, KOTopa51 perYflIIpyeT
OTKa3 B paCCMOTpeHlIII xo~a-
1. A. Tep-Kapane~nlH, C. A. iaHHYWK\.1Ha, O. n. OC\.1nOBa-l..\e~m\.1HaHa CeM\.1Hape
HOHKOHBeHUIIII. 3TO H nOH~T-
HO, TaK KaK npe~OCTaBfleHHe
cTaTyca 6e)J{eHua - He Harpa-
~a fll-IUY 3a cBoeBpeMeHHoe 06-
paliIeIIHe 3a ero nOflyqeHHeM, a
3HaK YBa)KeHII~ no~nIIcaB-
IIJIIM KmIBeHUHIO rocy~apcT-
BOM (KaKHM ~Bfl~eTC~ POCCHt'1-
CKa~ <De~epaUlm) K TaKIIM
ueHHOCT~M, KaK qeflOBeL1eCKa~
)KlI3Hb H ~OCTOHHCTBO,H npH-
3HatIHe HX no OTHOIIJeHHIOKO
BceM fllo~m.l, BHe 3aBIICHMOCTII
OTpaCbI, PCfll'lflU1, rpa)K~aHCT-
Ba, npHHa~fle)KHOCTII K TOHHflH
IIHOH COUIIaflbHOH rpynne HflH
nOflIITHLleC1G-IX y6e)K~etIHt'I.
PaBHO II OTKa3 B npe~OCTaBfle-
HHII cTaTyca 6e)KeHua He MO-
)J{eT ~Bfl~TbC~ fIaKa3aHIIeM 3a
on03~amle. CTaTb~ 31 Km1-
BeHUIIII YKa3bIBaeT, qTO rocy-
~apcTBa He 6Y~YT HaJlaraTb
HIIKaKHX B3b1CKaHIIH 3a He3a-
KOHHbIH Bbe3~ IIflli He3aKOH-
Hoe npe6bIBaHIIe Ha IIX TeppH-
TOpIIII 6e)J{eHueB, B KaqeCTBe
no~06Horo B3bICKaHH~ He MO-
)J{eTBbIcTynaTb flIIIIJeHHe flHua
caMoH B03MO)J{HOCTII 06pa-
TIITbC~ C npocb60H 0 npH3Ha-
HIIII 6e)J{eHueM. I1Hoe 03HaLIa-
eT oTCTynfletIHe rocy~apcTBa
OT npIIH~TbIX Ha ce6~ 06~3a-
TeflbCTB.
PaCCMaTpIIB~ )J{afl06b1MII-
rpaHToB Ha ~eHcTBII~ MIIrpa-
xaMMa~ I16parIIM,' I16parIIM
Xa6lI6Yflfla, MoxaMM~ KaceM,
PaxMaTY Jwa CbIHXacax XaHa.
IIOCfle~HIIH 3~BIITeflb, rpa)K-
~aHIIH AcPraHIiCTaHa, ~Bfl~eTC~
ITOflKOBHHKOM, 0cPIIuepOM
MB)l, KaBaflepOM op~eHOB 3a
oTBary H MY)J{eCTBO,YLlaCTHII-
KOM 60eBbix ~eHCTBl'1HnpOTYIB
MO~)KaXe~OB II TaflII60B, TO
eCTb IIMeeT Bce OCHOBamm
6b1Tb ITpII3HaHHb1M6e)KeHueM,
HO OH on03~afl C 06paliIetIHeM
C xo~aTaHCTBOMHa 10 ~HeH, a
n09ToMY ero ~eflO no cyrueCT-
BY Bo06rue HIIKeM He paCCMaT-
pIIBaflOCb. IIOCfle~CTBIIejVI OT-
Ka3a B paCCMOTpeHIIII xo~a-
TaHCTBa 0 npe~OCTaBfleHIIlI
cTaTyca 6e)KeHua ITOCYliIeC'fBY
~Bfl~eTC~ He06xo~HMOCTb ~fl~
IIliIyruero y6e)J{Hrua nOKIIHYTb
TeppIITopliIO P<D B ~06po-
BOflbHOM IIflII npIIHY ~IITeflb-
HOMnop~~Ke.
B KOHBeHUIIII ,,0 cTaTyce
6e)J{eHueB>,>IIMeeTC~ HCLlepnbl-
BaIOll(HH nepeqeHb 06CTO~-
TeflbCTB, npII KOTOPbIXflIIUO He
MO)KeT6blTb npII3HaHO 6e)J{eH-
ueM. YKa3aHHbIt'1 nepeLIeHb He
co~ep)J{IIT TaKoro OCHOBaHII~,
KaK nponYCK cpOKa ~fl~ 06pa-
liIeHII~ C cooTBeTcTBYIOliIeH
npocb60H K ~oroBapIIBaIOruIIM-
C~ rocy~apcTBaM, npIIH~BIIJlIM
Ha ce6~ 06~3aTeflbC'rBa ITO~aH-
Horo cpOKa (CT. 4 n. 1nn. 3) B Cflyq~X, Kor~a HMe-
IOTC~ He 3aBHC~Il(He OT fllIua
06CTO~TeflbCTBa,npermTCTBYIO-
ruHe ero He3aMe~flHTeflbHOMY
06pau.:(eHHIOC xo~aTaHCTBOM0
npe~OCTaBfleHIIH CTaTyca 6e-
)J{eHua, MlirpaUI-IOHHbIe opraHbI
He BbmCHmOT 9TH 06CTO~Teflb-
CTBa Ha~fle)KaIUHM 06pa30M.
3a5IBIITeJ1~ BO BHHMaHIIe He
npIIHHMaIOTC~. TaK, OTKa3 B
paCCMOTpeHIIII xo~aTat'1CTBano
CyrueCTBY ITOJxyqlIflli OTMHrpa-
UIIOIIHOH cflY)K6b1 CaHKT- IIe-
Tep6ypra Cfle~YIoruHe rpa}J{-
~aHe AcPraHIICTaHa: MoxaM-
Ma~ BaflH CblH AXMa~ )l)J{aHa,
Myca XaH CbIH AH~apa, Mo-
TaHCTBa 0 npe~OCTaBfleHHH
cTaTyca 6e)KeHua no cyrueCTBY
(TO eCTb B ~onYCKe K caMoH
npoue~ype onpe~efleHH~ CTa-
Tyca 6e)KeHua) B CBmH C npo-
nycKoM 24-qaCOBOro cpoKa 06-
parueHH~ C xo~aTaHCTBOM
(CT. 5 n. 1 nn. 7 <D3 P<D ,,06e)KeHl(ax>,». XOT~ 3aKOH H
npe~nOflaraeT ITpO~fleHY1e ~aH-
He3HaHHe ~3b1Ka, POCCIIt'1CKIiX
3aKOHOB, CTPYKTypbl opraHOB
BflaCTII, OTCYTCTBlieIIHcPopMa-
UlilI 0 cpOKax 06parueHH~ II
npoue~ype ITpe~OCTaBfleHlI~
cTaTyca B nYHKTax nepeceL1e-
HII~ rpaHlIUb1, y~afleHHOCTb
MlirpaUIIOHHb1X cflY)J{6 B npe-
~eflax P<D H ~a)Ke 60fle3Hb1
i-9-A,#rt,M'ftn" ''::11' 7
[(110HHbIX opraHOB, CY,l(bI rrpl1-
3HaIOT OTKa3bI B rrpe,l(OCTaB.lIe-
HI1I1 cTaTyca 6e)KeH[(a He060c-
HOBaHHbIMI1. B HeKOTopbIX
CJIYlla51XCY,l(bIrrpl13HaIOT OTKa-
3bI B rrpe,l(OCTaB.lIeHI1I1cTaTyca
6e)KeH[(a HerrpaBOMepHbIMI1,
eCJIlI Ml1rpa[(110HHa51 c.lIY)K6a
I-IapYUIJ1.lIarrpo[(e,l(YPY orrpe,l(e-
.lIeHII51 CTclTyca 6e)KeH[(a:
Harrpl1Mep, rrpH c06ece,l(OBaHI1H
H.lIH aHKeTHpOBaI-IHH OTCYT-
CTBOBa.lI rrepeBO,l('-IHK. TaK,
B CaHKT- IIeTep6ypre 6bI.lIH
Y,l(OB.lIeTBOpeHbI)Ka.lI06bI rpa)K-
,l(aH A¢raHHCTaHa IIIaKlT.lIbI
MOXaMMa,l( OMapa 11 EaXbIT
I'YJI5I CbIHa Ma.lIlTXaHa. O,l(Ha-
KO rOBOplTTb 0 rrO.lIO)KlTTe.lIb-
HbIX TeH,l(eH[(lT51XB 06.lIaCTlT
rrpe,l(OCTaB.lIeH1151cTaTyca 6e-
)KeH[(a rrOCpe,l(CTBOMCY,l(e6HO-
I'0 06)Ka.lIOBaH1151OTKa30B He-
B03MO)KHO.
ElI{e O,l(Ha HeraTlTBHa51
TeH,l(ea[(M51Ha6JIIo,l(aeTC51B OT-
HOllleHl111 K BbIXO,l([(aM 113
cTpaH CHI' 11 EaJITHH, He
HMeIOI[(HM rpa)K,l(aHCTBa PeD.
1l0CTaTOllHO 06paTHTbC51 K
[(M¢paM, llT06bI YBlT,l(eTb, LITO
;cnOM KaTeropHH .lIH[( ¢aKTMlle-
CKH rrpeKpaI[(eHO rrpe,l(OCTaB-
.lIeHMe cTaTyca 6e)KeH[(a. TaK,
B 1997 ro,l(Y B PeD cTaTYc 6e-
)KeH[(a rrO.lIYllHJIH 6255 rpa)K-
,l(aH 6.lIH)KHerO 3apy6e)Kb51, B
1998 - 375, a B 1999100 '-Ie.lIOBeK. B CaHKT- II,>
Tep6ypre C 1993 rO,l(a rro TPC
TI1M KBapTa.lI 2001 ro,l(a CTau
TYC rrO.lIYlJ:M.lIH 158 lle.lIOBCI(
(84 CeMblT) H3 6bIBllll1X pce'
rry6.lII1K CCCP; Ha Tpendi
KBapTa.lI 2002 rO,l(a Ha y'-IeTc
B MMrpa[(HOHHOM opraHe co"
CTOHTBcero 32 '-IeJIOBeKa.
IIpaBO He 6bITb rrO,l(Bepr-
HYTbIM 3a,l(ep)KaHHIO H 3aKJIIO
'-IeHHIOrro,l( CTpa)KY 6e3 3aK01l
HbIX Ha TO OCHOBaHHM51B.lI51eT"
C51 ¢YH,l(aMeHTa.lIbHbIM rrpa--
BOM '-Ie.lIOBeKa. Me)KJ{Y TeM II
CaHKT- IIeTep6ypre CYI[(eCTBY'
eT HeMa.lIO C.lIY'-IaeB 3a,l(ep)Ka-
HH51H ,l(JIHTe.lIbHOrOCO,l(ep)Ka~
HH51rro,l( CTpa)KeM .lI11[(, HI[(Y-
lIrHX y6e)[<HI[(a, H 6e)KeHI{eB.
TaK, 3MHH6eM.lIH frOH,l(Y3 rro-
KHHY.lI A3ep6aM,l()KaH, onaca-
51Cb rrpeC.lIe,l(OBaHH51H I1Me51
060CHOBaHHbIMPlTCK, '-ITOrrpH-
3HaHO Me)K,l(YHapOIJ,HbIMHop-
raHH3a[(H51MH H YBKE OOH,
Ha OCHOBaHHH LIero rocY,l(ap-
CTBO IIIBe[(M51 rro Me)KrrpaBl1-
Te.lI~CTBeHHOMY cor .lIallleHlTIO
rrpHI-I5I.lIO ero B Ka'-IeCTBe 6c-)KeH[(a 11 BbI,l(a.lIO Bbe3,l(HYIO
BlT3Y B CTpaHY. II pH rrO.lIY'-Ie-
HHlT BbIe3,l(HbIX ,l(OKYMeHTOBIl
Y rrpaB.lIeHHH rracrropTHO- BH-
30BOl1 C.lIY)K6bI CaHKT- IIeTep-
6ypra OH 6bI.lI 3a,l(ep)KaH 11rro-
MeI[(eH B II30.lI51TOP BpeMeH-
Horo CO,l(ep)KaHlT513a,l(ep)KaH-
HbIX H 3aKJIIO'-IeHHbIX rro,l(
CTpa)KY (TIOPbMY), CPOK rrpe-
6bIBaHlT51B KOTOPOMHe Mo)KeT
rrpeBbIIllaTb 48 LIaCOB.51, a,l(-
BOKaT, 3aI[(HI[(aIOI[(HM ::lTOrO
6e)[(eH[(a, 60.lIee 5 ,l(Hel1Bo06-
lIre He Mor .lIa Y3HaTb 0 erOMe-
CTOHaXo)KJ{eHlTlTIT B TelleHlTe
20 ,l(HeM He MOrJla 03HaKO-
nplileM 6e)f{eHl..\eB B KOMlilTeTe
«rpa}l(,lJ,aHCKOe CO,[leViCTBlIle»
MHTbC51C ,l(OKYMeHTaMlT, Ka-
caIOI[(MMlTC51 OCHOBaHMM ero
3a,l(ep)KaHM51:MHe B ::nOM He-
rrpaBOMepHO OTKa3bIBaJII1. Ha
MOM MHorO'-IHC.lIeHHble )[(aJ1O-
6bI B CY,l(e6Hble opraHbI IT B
rrpoKypaTYPY rop0,l(a 51He rro-
.lIYlla.lIa OTBeTa B CP0K. IIoc.lIe
O'-Iepe,l(l-IbIX)[(a.lI06 M 06paI[(e-
ImM, B TOMllMC.lIe '-Iepe3 ,l(erry-
TaTOBI'OCY,l(apCTBeaaOM,l(YMbI
IT YBKE OOH, 6e)[(erre[( lT3
A3ep6aM,l()[{aHa 6bIJI OCB060)K-
,l(err rrOCTaHOB.lIeHlTeM I'eHe-
pa.lIbHOH rrpoKypaTypbI PeD.
OH CO,l(ep)[(a.lIC51rro,l( CTpa)[(eM
36 ,l(HeM, 6e3 BC51KMXHa TO 3a-
KOHHbIX OCHOBaHMM,6e3 caHK-
[(MM rrpoKypopa rop0,l(a M.lIM
,l(a)Ke palIOHa, 6e3 COOTBeTCT-
BYIOI[(erO cY,l(e6Horo perne-
HlT51; B OTHorneHHlT Hero He
npOBO,l(H.lIHCb KaKHe-.lIlT60
CJIe,l(CTBeHHble ,l(eMCTBM51,OH
He 3rra.lI, rra OCHOBarrMMLIero H
Ha KaKOH CPOK OH Bo06I[(e
B351T no,l( CTpa)KY. Bce ::lTO
BpeM51 rrpaBOOXpaHlTTe.lIbHbI-
MM opraHaMM paCCMaTpHBaJI-
C51 Borrpoc 0 ero BbI,l(alle B
A3ep6alI,l()KaH, Tor,zra KaK ero
BbI,l(a'-Ia 51BM.lIaCb6bI HapYllle-
HMeM CT. 60 MMHCKOM KOH-
BeH[(IIII CTpaH CHI' ~O rrpa-
BOBOM rrOMOI[(II M rrpaBoBbIx
OTHOrneHII51X rro rpa)[(,l(aH-
CKMM,ceMeHHbIM MyrO.lIOBHbIM
,l(e.lIaM~, a TaK)Ke CT. 33 (1)KOHBeH[(MII OOH «0 cTaTyce
6e)[(eH[(CB» II CT. 3 EBponeM-
CKOM KOI-IBeH[(IIM «0 3aI[(MTe
rrpaB '-Ie.lIOBeKa II OCHOBHbIX
cB060,l(~.
llpyrofI C.lIYllaM ,l(.lIMTe.lIb-
Horo HerrpaBoMepHoro cO,l(ep-
)[(aHM51 rro,l( CTpa)KeM 6e)KeH-
[(a - ::lTO 60.lIee '-IeM rro.lIY-
ToparO,l(MLIHOe 3aKJIIOlleHHe
MaH,l(aTHOro 6e)[(eH[(a, TaK)[(e
rrpII3HaHHoro OOH, rpa)[(J{a- 7
IU1Ha AHrOJIbI CHMOHa MaTo-
ca. OH 6bIJI rrOMeIIJ;eH rro)J,
CTpmKY )J,JI5Iero )J,erropTaL(HH
Ha P0)J,HHY B COOTBeTCTBHHco
CT. 31 3aKoHa ~O rrpaBOBOM
rrOJIO)KeHHH HHocTpmulbIx
rpa)K)J,aH B CCCP:i> OT 24 HIO-
H5I 1981 ro)J,a, KOTopbIfr 6e3Ha-
)J,e}KHOYCTapeJI H He OTBeqaeT
COBpeMeHIlbIM peaJIH5IM, HO
rrpOl~OJ1)KaeT )J,efICTBOBaTb B
P<D. COrJIaCHO )J,aHHOMY 3a-
KOHY, HHOCTpaHHbIH rpa)K)J,a-
HHH, KOTOPbIM HapywaeT )J,ei1r-
CTBYIOW)Ie rrpaBHJIa rrpe6bfBa-
HH5I B P<D, TO eCTb rrpO)KlmaeT
6e3 perHCTpaL(IUI HJIH BH)J,aHa
}KHTeJIbCTBOB P<D, BbI)J,BOP5I-
eTC5I B rrpHHY)J,HTeJIbHOM rro-
p5I)J,KeC ee TeppHTopHH. fpa-
)K)J,aHHH, YKJIOH5IIOIIJ;HHC5IOT
BbIe3)J,a, rrO)J,JIe)KHT 3a)J,ep}Ka-
HHIO. 3a)J,ep>KaHHe )J,orrYCKa-
eTC5IrrpH 3TOM Ha CPOK, He06-
XO)J,HMbIH )J,JI5I BbI)J,BopeHH5I.
KaKOH 3TOCPOK, ero MHHHMYM,
MaKCHMYM, npH KaKHX 06CT05I-
TeJIbCTBaX OH MO>KeT 6bITb
np0)J,JIeH HJIH COKpaIIJ;eH, B 3a-
KOHe He orrpe)J,eJIeHO. CPOK
rrpOlI3BOJIbHO npo)J,JIeBaeTC5I,
Ka>K)J,oenp0)J,JIeHlIe OCYIIJ;eCTB-
JI5IeTC5I CY)J,OMHa 90 CYTOK.
IIPII 3TOM rpa>K)J,aHIIH B CY)J,
He )J,OCTaBJI5IeTC5I,OH He HMeeT
B03MO)KHOCTH rrOJIb30BaTbC5I
YCJIyraMH a)J,BOKaTa, rrepeBO)J,-
"lfIIKa, npe)J,CTaBJI5ITb )J,OKa3Cl
TeJIbCTBa, OH Bo06IIJ;e He 3Hacr
o KaKOM-JIH60 npo)J,JIeHHH
CpOI{a ero cO)J,ep>KaHlI5I, Tal{
KaK HH O)J,HH)J,OKYMeHT,KOTO'"
pbIH eMY rrpe)J,CTaBJI5IeTC5I,If('
rrepeBO)J,HTC5I Ha ero pO)J,Hoii
5I3bIK.
OpraHbl, oCYIIJ;ecTBJI5IIO-
IIJ;He)J,enopTa1uno, rrplIMeH5IJI ~I
CJIe)J,YIollUle MOTHBHPOBKH
rrpOt(JIeIlIUI CpOKOB 3a)J,ep)Ka-
HH5I: <iIIpo)J,JIHTb CPOK HCl
90 CYTOK )J,JUI peWeHH5I BO-
rrpoca 0 rrpH06peTeHHH aBHa-
6HJIeTOB:i>,1.Iepe3 90 )J,HeH: «BHaCT05Ill(ee BpeM5I BbIe3)J, B
cTpmIY HeB03MO>KeHB CB5I3HC
Ha1.IaBWI1MI1C5I TaM 60eBbIMI1
)J,eHCTBH5IMH(OTCYTCTByeT CO-
06IIJ;eHHe C BHeWHHM MlIpOM),
TaK}Ke peWaeTC5I Bonpoc 0 )J,O-
KYMeHTHpOBaHHII rpa>K)J,aHH-
Ha nOCOJIbCTBOM CTpaHbI ero
rpa>K)J,aHCKOfI rrpHHa)J,JIe)KHO-
CTH:i>. 1{epe3 90 )J,HeH nOCJIe
06paIIJ;eHH5I )J,aI-lHOrOrpa>K)J,a-
HHHa 3a CTaTYCOM 6e>KeHL(a B
MHrpaUHOHHblfI opraH B rro-
CTaHOBJIeHHI1 cY)J,a 0 rrp0)J,JIe-
HHH cpOKa 3a)J,ep}KaHH5I 6bIJIa
CJIe)J,YIOIIJ;a5IepOpMYJIlIpOBKa:
~B CB5I3H C He06xo)J,HMOCTbIO
rrpHH5ITH5I peWeHH5I MIIrpaUII-
OHHOH CJIY>K60H II oepopMJIe-
HIIeM nOCOJIbCTBOM CTpaHbI
)J,OKYMeHTOB )J,JI5I B03BpaIIJ;e-
HII5I Ha P0)J,IIHY:i>. Eur;e "lfepe3
90 )J,HeH - TaKa5I epOPMYJIH-
pOBKa: <ifpa>K)J,aHIIH 06paTIIJI-
C5I B CY)J, )J,JI5I06)KaJIOBaHH5I
OTKa3a B cTaTyce 6e>KeHua,
Oqepe)J,Hoe npo)J,JIeHHe cpOKa
3a)J,ep)KaHH5I MO>KeT rroTpe60-
BaTbC5I )J,JI5IpaCCMOTpeHH5I BO-
npoca 0 cTaTyce 6e)KeHua CY-
t(OM:i> , II T.)J,. He BbI3bfBaeT co-
MHeHII5I, LITOTaKHe 060CHoBa-
HH5I npo)J,JIeHII5I CpOKOB 3a-
)J,ep)KaHII5I He3aKOHHbI, LITO II
6bIJIO HaMII )J,OKa3aHOB cY)J,e.
LI:aHI-IbIH rpa)K)J,aHHH 6bIJI OC-
B060>K)J,eH H3-rro)J, CTpa>KII II
OTrrpaBJIeH B eBponeHCKYIO
CTpaIIY, KOTOpa5I rrpHH5IJIa ero
B Ka1.IeCTBe6e>KeHua. B POC-
CHH >Ke OH 5IBJI5IJIC5I 3JIOCTHbIM
HapYIIIHTeJIeM rrpaBHJI rrpe6bI-
BaHH5I HHOCTpaHHbIX rpa)K)J,aH
H 6bIJI 6bI rrO)J,BeprHYTHaCHJIb-
CTBeHHOMY BbI)J,BopeHHIO B
AHrOJIY rrOCJIe )J,JIHTeJIbHOrO
CO)J,ep)KaHH5Irro)J, CTpa)KeH.
BCTyrrHBIIIHlI B )J,eHcTBHe
1 H05I6p5I 2002 rO)J,a 3aKoH
P<D <i0 rrpaBoBoM rrOJIO>Ke-
HHH HHocTpaHHbIx rpa)K)J,aH B
P<D:i>eIIJ;e60JIee ycyry6HJI CH-
TyaUHIO. 3aKOH He TOJIbKO He
pelliaeT 3a)J,a1.I rrpeCeqeHH5I
HeJIeraJIbHOM MHrpaL(HH H C03-
)J,aHH5I MexaHH3Ma JIeraJIH3a-
UHH JIHU, HMeIOIIJ;HXrrpaBO Ha
rrpO>KHBaHHeB P<D, HO, IIarrpo-
THB, )J,eJIaeT HeJIeraJIaMH Tex,
KTO Y>Ke MHorHe rO)J,bI rrpO>KII-
BaJI B P<D Ha 3aKOHHbIX OCHO-
BaHH5IX, - npH IIOJIHOM OT-
CYTCTBHH rrpaBOBbIX MexaHH3-
MOB at(MHHHCTpaTHBHoro BbI-
)J,BopeHH5I He3aKOHHO HaXO)J,5I-
IIJ;HXC5I Ha Tepp:YITOpHH P<D
:YIHOCTpaHHbIX rpa)K)J,aH. LI:JI5I
a)J,MHIIHCTpaTHBHoro BbIJ~BO-
peHH5I 3a ee rrpe)J,eJIbI OHH MO-
rYT IIOMeIIJ;aTbC5I B MeCTa or-
pamI1.leIIH5I CB060)J,bI Ha Heorr-
pe)J,eJIeJ-IHO )J,OJIrYIH CPOK -
CPOK, He06xo)J,HMbIH )J,JI5IBbI-
)J,BopeI-UI5I. Ero MaKCHMYM,
MHHHMYM, OCHOBaHH5I rrpo-
)J,JIeIIH51,nepHO)J,HQHOCTbrrpo-
BepKII 3aKOHHOCTH JIHWeHH5I
CB060)J,bI B CB5I3H C BbI)J,Bope-
HIIeM B HOBOM 3aKOHe TaK)Ke
OTCYTCTBYIOT.
BbI)J,BOP5ITbC5IMorYT )J,a>Ke
Te HHOCTpaHHbIe rpa>K)J,aHe,
KOTopbIe HMeIOT ceMbH H )J,e-
Tell Ha TeppHTopHH P<D, - B
HapyweHHe rrpHI-Iu:yma e)J,HH-
CTBa ceMbH. BOT O)J,HHH3 rrpH-
MepoB. MOH IIo)J,3aIIJ;HTHbIH,
rpa)K)J,aHHH KOHro 3BaJIaKa
KYMY .5PHC, 60JIee 13 JIeT
rrpO>KHBaeT B POCCHH. OH CO-
CTOIIT B 3aperHcTpHpoBaHHoM
6paKe C rpa>K)J,aHKoH P<D H
HMeeT MaJIOJIeTHerO COBMeCT-
HorO cHell: pe6eHKa. <DaKTII-
1.IeCIUI 3BaJIaKa KYMY .5PHC 9
rrpmKHBaJI H rrpmKHBaeT Ha
:>KHJIOMrrJIOlI(at!J'I )f{eHh1, KYtIa
OH BCeJIHJIC5IC cor JIaCH5I Bcex
rrp0:>KHBaIOlI(HX H 3aperHCTpH-
pOBaHHh1X B tIaHtIOM KBapTHpe
JIHIJ;. YKa3aHHh1l1 rpa)KtIaIIHH
Hero :>KeHa, rpa:>KtIaHKa Pet>,
HeOtIHOKpaTI-IO 06palI(aJIHCh C
rrpoch60M 0 JIeraJIH3aIJ;HH ero
rrpe6hIBaHIU1 Ha TeppHTopYIH
Pet> B opraHh1 rraCrrOpTI-IO-BY1-
30BOM CJIY)f{6h1paMOHa H ropo-
tIa CaHKT-IIeTep6ypra, B rrpo-
KypaTYPY Bh160prcKoro pal1-
aria CaHKT- IIeTep6ypra, B
rrpoKypaTYPY ropotIa CaHIZT-
IIeTep6ypra, B AtIMHHHCTpa-
IJ;HIOIIpe3HtIetITa Pet>, B Ml1-
HHCTepCTBO BHYTpeHHHX tIeJI
Pet>, B cYtI, HO Be3tIe rrOJIY'laJIH
cPopMaJIhHh1e OTKa3hI.
18 OKT5I6p5I 2001 rotIa
rp. 3BaJIaKa KYMY EpHc 6b1JI
Bh13BaH B OIIBC Bh160prcKo-
ro paMoHa, rtIe 6h1JI 3atIep)f{aH
Ha I'JIa3<lX )KeHh1 H rrJIa'lYlI(ero
MaJIOJIeTI-1erOpe6eHKa H rrOMe-
lI(eH B rrpHeMHHK-paCrrpetIe-
JIHTeJIh (MeCTO, He rrpetIHa3Ha-
'leHHOe tIJI5I tIJIHTeJIhHOrO CO-
tIep)[{aHH5I JIIOtIeM) BO HCrrOJI-
HeHHe peIIIeHH5I 0 BhItIBope-
HHH ero H3 Pet> B rrpHHYtIH-
TeJIhHOM rrop5ItIKe, KaK Hapy-
IIIHBIIIero II paBHJIa rrpe6hIBa-
HH5I HHOCTpaHHh1X rpa)KtIaH.
B Tel.leHHe 90 CYTOK rpa)KtIa-
HHH KOHro CotIep:>KaJIC5I Jl
OtIHHO'lHOM KaMepe B TIOphMe,
rrpH 3TOM OH rrotIBepraJIC51
YHyI)KaIOlI(eMY '-IeJIOBe'leCKOC
tIOCTOHHCTBO06palI(eHHIO; T<1-
Koe tIJIHTeJIhHOe 3atIep:>KaHI1C
rrpH06peTaJIO tIJI5I Hero BI1)l
Hecopa3MepHO )f{eCTOKOro lICl·o
Ka3aHI15I 3a COBepIIIeHHe BCC-
1'0 JIHIIIb atIMHHHCTpaTHBI-roro
npaBarrapyme1IH5f .
B CYtI, rrpO)l,JIHBmHl1 CPOI(
ero 3a)wp)KaHH5f Ha 90 CYTOI<,
3BaJlaKa KYMY EpHc tIOCTaB-
JleH He 6bIJ1, OHtIa)f{e He 3HaJI 0
COCT05IBIIIeMC5I B OTHOmeHIlI1
Hero cy tIe6HOM 3aCetIaHHH.
KaK JIHIJ;O,rrpI1BJIeKaeMOeI<a,ll-
MHHHCTpaTHBH011 OTBeTCTBeH-
HOCTH, OH 6b1JI mnueH peaJIb-
HOM B03MmI<HOCTI1 rrpetICTa-
BHTb tIOKa3aTeJIhCTBa cBoeH
HeBI1HOBHOCTI1; eMY He 6hIJIH
pa3b5ICHeHb1 ero rrpaBa I1 HC
6b1JII1 06eCrre'leHh1 YCJIOBH5IHX
peaJIH3aIJ;HH: OH 6h1JI JIHIIIeIJ
B03MO)f{HOCTH rrOJIh30BaThC51
YCJIyraMH atIBOKaTa, nepeBOtI-
l.IHKa, Bb1cTyrraTb Ha pOtIHOM
5I3bIKe, 06)KaJIOBaTb rrpHH5ITb1C
no ero tIeJIY peIIIeHH5I, HH OtIHlI
rrpetICTaBJIeHHh1M eMY tIOKY-
MeHT He 6h1JI rrepeBetIeH Ha ero
pOtIIIOM 5I3h1K. OH Bo06lI(e HC
nOHHMaJI, 3a 'ITO, Ha KaKOM OC-
HOBaHIUI H Ha KaI<OMCPOK OIJ
3aKJIIO'IeH rrOtI CTpa}I<Y.
Ero 06palI(eHHe 3a rrpe-
tIOCTaBJIeHHeM BI1tIa Ha :>KH-
TeJIhCTBO H rpa)KtIaHcTBa Pet>
B COOTBeTCTBHHC rpa:>KtIaHcT-
BOM ero cyrrpyrH Ha OCHOBa-
HHH CT. 18 II. a et>3 Pet> ~O
rpa:>KtIaHCTBe Pet>~ OT 28 HO-
5I6p5I 1991 rotIa 6hIJIO Henpa-
BOMepHO OTKJIOHeHO OIIBC
KpacHOrBaptIeMcKoro PYBn
CaHKT- IIeTep6ypra.
3atIep:>KaHHe H Bh1tIBope-
HHe 3Toro rpa:>KtIaHI1Ha KOHro
H tIpyrHx HHocTpaHHh1x rpa)K-
tIaH, HaXOtI5IlI(HXC5I B aHaJIO-
rH'IHOM cHTyaIJ;HH, TO eCTb CO-
CT05IlI(HX B 3aperHCTpHpOBaH-
Hb1X 6paKax H HMeIOlI(HX tIe-
TeM OT rpa)f{tIaH Pet>, 5IBJI5IeTC5I
a6COJIIOTHO He3aKOHHh1M H
rpy60 HapymaeT rrpaBo Ha
CB060tIy H JIH'lHYIO HenpHKoc-
HOBeHHOCTh H npaBo Ha ce-
MeMHYIO )f{H3Hh, rrpetIycMOT-
peHtIOe p5ItIOM Me:>KtIYHapOtI-
Ho-rrpaBoBh1x tIOKYMeHToB, pa-
mcPHIJ;HpOBaHHb1X Pet>: Bce-
06lI(eM tIeKJIapaIJ;HeM npaB l.le-
JIOBeKa, CT. 16 (3); Me:>KtIy-
HapotIHh1M rraKTOM 0 rpa)KtIaH-
CKHX H rrOJIHTHl.1eCKHXrrpaBax,
CT. 17 H 23 (1); Me:>KtIYHa-
P0tIHh1M naKTOM 06 3KOHOMH-
l.leCKHX, COIJ;HaJIhHh1XH Ky JIh-
TypHh1X npaBax, CT. 10 (1);EBporreMcKoM KOHBeHIJ;HeM~03a1l(I1TerrpaB H OCHOBHh1XCBO-
60tI ~ , CT. 8; KOHBeHIJ;HeM
OOB ~O rrpaBax pe6eHKa~,
CT_ 9,10.IIplmpHTeToM B Borrpocax
BOCCOetIyIHeHH5IceMhH tIOJI:>KHh1
rrOJIb30BaThC5I tIeTH BBHtIy rro-
TeHIJ;HaJIbHOrO YlI(ep6a, HaHO-
CHMaro HM tIJIHTeJIhHOMpa3JIY-
KOM C pOtIHTeJI5IMI1. Bo Bcex
CJIYl.la5IXrrepBool.1epetIHOe BHI1-
MaHHe tIOJI)f{HO y tIeJI5IThC5I
~HaHJIYl.IlueMY 06eCrreQe1IHIO
HHTepecoB pe6eHKa~.
B COOTBeTCTBHHco CT. 9KOHBeHIJ;HH OOB ~O rrpaBax
pe6eHKa~ pe6eHOK He MO:>KeT
6b1Th pa3JIYl.1eHCOCBOHMHPO-
tIHTeJI5IMH BorrpeKH HX :>KeJIa-
HHIO, 3a IICKJIIOl.1etIHeMCJIYl.1a-
eB, KOrtIa TaKoe pa3JIY'leHIIe
He06xotIHMO B HHTepecax pe-
6eHKa.
TaKHM 06pa30M, rrpH Bh1-
tIBOpeHIIII B rrpIIHytII1TeJIhHOM
rrop5ItIKe 3BaJIaKII KYMY EpH-
ca H tIpyrHx HHOCTpaHHh1X
rpa)f{tIaH HapYIIIa10TC5I He
TOJIhKO HX rrpaBa, HO II rrpaBa
IIX ceMeM: )f{eH (MY:>KeM) H
tIeTell. naHHa5I KaTerOpII5I
JIHIJ;He MO:>KeT6hITb Bb1tIBOpe-
Ha H3 Pet>, a COOTBeTCTBeHHO,
He MO:>KeT6hITh rrOtIBeprHYTa
3atIep:>KaHHIO BO HCrrOJIHetHle
rrOCTaHOBJIeHH5I 0 Bb1tIBOpe-
HHH, TaK KaK 3TO 03Hal.1aeT HX
pa3JlYl.1etIHe C ceMbel1, rrpaBo 1
IIOMOIQb EEiKEHQAMB 3AIIA,II,HOM EBPOIIE
JIHrH~, YJIbTparrpaBOM napTHH,
eDvIHH - O,l(HH 1'13 JIH,l(CPOB
COBpeMCHHoro HTaJIb5IHCKOrO
cj:>allIH3Ma) . 3TOT 3aKOH C03-
,l(aH ,l(JI5IToro, qT06bI 06'b5IBYITb
HCJICraJIbHbIX 6C)KeH.u;eB rrpc-
cTymIHKaMH. Tcrrcpb, eCJIH TbI
HCJICraJIB I1TaJIHH, TbI Mo)KCllIb
rrOJIYl.IIITb ,l(0 4 JIeT JIHllICHII5I
cB060,l(bI. TaKoc )KCCTOKOCHa-
Ka3aHHC - II Bcero JIHUlb 3a
HapYllIeHHc rrpaBHJI rrpc6bIBa-
HI-I5I, a BOBCCHe 3a HaCT05IlL[ee
ITpcCTyrrJIeHIIe!
Ha MOM B3rJI5I,l(, MHoroe Ha
3arra,l(e B orpOMHOM CTerrCHII
3amrCHT OTrr03IIL[HH o6r.u;ecTBa,
cpe,l(CTB MaccoBoM HHcj:>oprvra-
L[IH!. Tpe6yeTC5I rrOMep)KKa
IIMeHHO He ITOJIHTYIKOB,a rrpo-
CTOJIIO,l(eM, KOTopbIe XOT5ITrro-
MOl.lb 6e)KCHL[aM. [oCY,l(apCT-
BCHHbIC rrporpaMlVlbI ITO opra-
HH3a.u;HH rrpHCMa 6C)KCH.u;CB
,l(eMCTBYIOTOl.ICHbrro-pa3HOMY·
HCKOTopbIC 6C)KCHl[bI rrorra,l(a-
IOT B crrc.u;IIaJIbHbIt'I L[eI-ITp, r,l(C
IIX Ha6HpaCTC5I Ol.ICHb MHoro,
CKa)KCMl.ICJIOBCKl.IeTbIpCCTa, a
rrOTOMKa)K,l(bIM CJIyqaM pa36H-
paeTC5I oc060 1'1rro Ka)K,l(OMY
rrpIIHHMaCTC5I PCllICHIIC. HCKo-
TopbIe HCCqaCTHbIe rrorra,l(aIOT
B crre.u;IIaJIbHbIC TIOPbMbI ,l(JI5I
6e)KCH.u;CB, OTKa3bIBaIOll[HXC5I
rrO,l('-IHHIITbC5I ocj:>IILIIIaJIbHOMY
Tpc60BaHHIO rrOKHHYTb CTpaHbI
«8 EBpone AeHbrli1 HOBbie, a
OTHOWeHli1e K 6e>KeHl..\aM -
npe>KHee» (nnaKaT
«Me)K,lJ,YHapOAHOVi aMHIi1CTlilIi1»)
TeM, qTO rrpOHCXO,l(HTCCt'I1.IaCB
EBporre.
XapaKTcpHbIM rrpHMep -
HOBbIM 3aKOH, rrpHH5ITbIM B
11TaJIHH 1'1rrOJIyqHBllIHM Ha3Ba-
HHe 3aKOHa BOCCH - eDHHH
(BOCOI - rJIaBa «CCBCPHOt'I
JIaH,l(CKOro rrpcMbcp-MHHHCT-
pa, ,l(Cp)KaBllICrOC5IB CBOCBPC-
M5I BrrOJIHe )KeCTKOro rrOJIHTH-
qeCKOrO Kypca, B TOM l.IHCJICB
Borrpocax HMMHrpa.u;HH. IIo-
BH,l(HMOMY,pcaK.u;H5IJII06epca
Hcrrocpc,l(cTBCHHO CB5I3aHa C
JIT06epca. OH BbIcTyrracT
rrpoTIm ~,l(CMOHH3a.u;HH 1'1
KpHMHHaJIH3a.u;HH 06pa3a 6e-
)KeH.u;CBB 3arra,l(HOM rrOJIHTH-
KC». Mcml rrOpa3HJIa CTOJIb
PCllIHTCJIbHa5I KpHTHKa 3THX
cOBpeMcHHbIX cj:>0PM ,l(HCKPH-
MHHa.u;HH6C)KCH.u;CBco CTOPO-
HbI JII06cpca, B rrpOllIJIOM rOJI-
O. II. Ocuno6a-II.eUmJlUJ-ta,a0601<:am rOpOOCKOlt KOJlJle-2UU a060Kam06, 1.fJle1-lPOCCUlt-C1W20 KOMumema a060Kamoe6 3aU?Umy npa6 tteJl06eKa,10pucm cemu «!VI UZPal?U5l U
npa601> IIII. «MeMOpUaJl1>
KOH ~O BbIHY)K,l(CHHbIX rrcpc-
CCJICH.u;ax~, rrOCTaHOBJICHHC
II paBHTCJIbCTBa ~0 rrpc,l(O-
CTaBJICHHH BpcMcHHoro y6c-
)KHr.u;a~, HopMaTHBHbIC aKTbl,
orrpc,l(CJI5IIOr.u;HC rrOJIO)KCHHC
BbUIY)K,l(CHHbIX rrcpCCCJICHL[CIl
B PeD. B03MO)KHO, MHOnIe
rrpHI-I5ITbIC ccrO,l(H5I 3aKOHbI HC
rrO,l(KpCrrJIeHbI 3KOHOMH1.ICCKH,
TCM HC MCHec POCCH5I ,l(06po-
BOJlbHO B35IJIa Ha CC65I 9TH
065I3aTCJIbCTBa rrcpc,l( MC)K,l(Y-
Hapo,l(HbIM C006r.u;CCTBOM 1'1
,l(OJI)KHa HX HCrrOJIH5ITb.
51 XOqy CKa3aTb HCCKOJIb-
KO CJIOB 0 ,l(BH)KCHHH B rro,l(-
,l(CP)KKY 6C)KCH.u;CBB cBporrct'I-
CKHX cTpaHax. B EBporrc TO-
)KC ,l(aJICKO HC Bec B rrOp5I,l(KC,
XOT5I1'1JIY1.IllIC, qCM B POCCHH.
HC,l(aBHo 5I l.IHTaJI rrpecc-
PCJIH3 r JIaBbI KOMHCCHH rro 6c-
)KCH.u;aMrrpH OOH rocrrO,l(HHa
POCCH5I rrO,l(rrHCaJIa KOH-
BCH.u;HIOOOH «0 CTaTYCC6c-
)KCH.u;CB~, IIpoTOKOJI K Hct'r
1967 rO,l(a, EBporrct'rcKYIo
KOI-IBCH.u;HIO~0 3aI.u;HTC rrpaB
l.ICJIOBCKa 1'1 OCHOBHbIX CBO-
60,l(~, rraKT ~O rpa)K,l(aHCKHX
H rrOJIHTHQCCKHX rrpaBax~,
KOHBCH.u;HIOOOH «0 npaBax
pc6eHIza;,>, MHorHC ,l(Pynre MC-
)K,l(YHap0,l(HbIe ,l(OKYMCHTbI;
HMeeT pa3pa60TaHHoc 3aKOHO-
,l(aTeJIbCTBO 0 MHrpaHTax: 3a-
KOH PeD «0 6C)KCH.u;ax~, 3a-
Ha BOCCOC,l(HHCHl'lC1'1rrpo)KH-
BaHHC COBMCCTHO C KOTOPOM
OHH HMCIOT; rOCY,l(apCTBO
065I3aHO 06CCrrCqHTb HM B03-
MO)KHOCTb JICraJIH3a.u;HH (rro-
JIY'ICHH5I BH,l(a Ha )KHTCJIbCTBa
1'1rpa)K,l(aHCTBa) Ha TCPPHTO-
pHH PeD.
22
24
EBpOrrbI. CymecTByeT H TaK35I
O'-IeHb6bICTpa5! rrp0l(e.n.ypa, KO-
r.n.a JIIO.n.eM,HmymHX y6e)KHma
H rrpHeXaBIIHIX B [epMaHHro,
[OJIJlaH.n.HroHJIH BO <I:>paHl(HIO,
HarrpaBJI5!IOT B COOTBeTCTBYIO-
mHe l(eIUpbI H TaM cpa3Y
0cP0pMJI5!IOT HM OTKa3bI.
B TIOpbMax H B l(eHTpax
.n.JI5!6e)KeHl(eB pa6OTaIOT .n.06-pOBOJlbl(bI. HarrpHMep, B [OJI-
JIaH.n.HHeCTb 06meCTBO rrOMO-
mH 6e)KeHl(aM, H OHO Bcer.n.a H
BCIO.n.y opramI3yeT Ky JIbTYP-
Hble rrporpaMMbI. KaK MbI ro-
BOpHM, 9TO MaCJIO B MexaHlB-
Me. Eme 60JIee Ba)KHYlo pOJlb
HrparoT COl(HaJIbHble a.n.BOKa-
TbI, oco6eI-IHo B [OJIJIaH.n.HH,OT-
Ky.n.a 51PO.n.OM, - TaM O'-IeHb
MHoro a.n.BOKaTOB, 06eCrre'-IH-
BaIOmHX rroMOmb TeM, y Koro
HeT .n.eHer.
Oc06a5! cHTyal(H5! B03HH-
KaeT, Kor.n.a 6e)KeHl(eB BbICbI-
JIaIOT. IIOMHMO .n.erropTal(HH,
eCTb eme H HeKHM Cpe.n.r-IHMBa-
pHaHT. L(erropTal(H5! CTOHT .n.o-poro, H HY)KHO 3HaTb, OTKy.n.a
1.[eJIOBeK,KaKOBO ero rrOJIo)Ke-
HHe, Ky.n.a ero rrOCbIJIaTb H Ky-
.n.aHe rrOCbIJIaTb. II03TOMY He-
pe.n.KO 6e)KeHl(aM rrpOCTO ro-
BOP5!T: paccMOTpeHHe Balliero
.n.eJIa3aKOH'-IeHO. MM BpY'-IaIOT
rrHCbMO-YBe.n.OMJIeHHe,'-ITO '-Ie-
pe3 TpH .n.H5!,'-Iepe3 rr5ITb .n.He}I
OHH 065!3aHbI yexaTb H3 CTpiL
HbI. Ho 9TH JIIO.n.HO'-IeHb '-IaCTO
OCTaIOTC5!. OHH CTaHOB5!TCH
HeJIeraJIbHbIMH HMMHrpar-rra
MH - KaK rrpamIJIO, 9TO JIIO/lIl
H3 .n.aJIeKHX CTpaH. IIpHexall
llIHe H3 POCCHH, HarrpHMCp,
cmc MorYT .n.06paTbC5! .n.OMOn,
HO acPPHKaHl(bI 06bI'-IHO HC MO
rYT. B T<LI<HXCJIY'-Ia5!X Mo)KCT
nOH<L.n.06HTbC5I IOPH.n.H'-ICCIGUI
nOMOmb, BC.n.b pCllIcmIC 06 0'1'
K<L3Ccmc MO)KCT6bITb ocrropc
HO B cy.n.c. II09TOMY .n.JI5!6c)KCHl(CB, rrOJlY'-IHBllIHX rrHCbMil
C OTK<L3<LMII,ycrp<LHBaIOT KOII
cy JIbTal(IIII rro [OPH.n.WICCIGI1'1
H .n.pyrIIM BOrrpOC<LM. T<LK,UI
npHCMHa5! J(C}ICTBYCT B Ka)I{
.n.OM60JIbliiOM ropo.n.c, B cc pa~
60TC Y'-I<LCTBYIOTpa3Hblc opra-
HH3al(HH H JIHI.(a, B TOM '-IHCJIC,
KOHC'-IHO,H a.n.BOKaTbI. IIopoi:1
3TIIM .n.CJIOM3aHHMaIOTC5! l(cp-
KOBHbIC .n.C5!TCJIHH3 OT.n.CJIOIl
COl(HaJIbHOM rroMOmH; p51/l
I(CPKBCM IIMCIOT crrcl(HaJIbHbIe
COl(HaJIbHWC cTaHl(IIH .n.JI51
npHcMa HCJICraJIbHbIX 6C)KCH-
l(CB II rroMOmH HM.
130JIbllIYIO POJIb B .n.CJICrro-
MOll(H HCJICraJIaM IIrpaIOT II
rrOJIIITH'-ICCKIIC pa.n.HKaJIbI -
JIro.n.II, KOTOPbIC oc03HaroT HC-
crrpaBc.n.JIHBOCTb rocy.n.apCT-
BCHHOMrrOJIHTHKH H cTaparoT-
C5! XOTb '-ITO-TO c.n.CJIaTb .n.JI51
6C)KCHl(CB C06CTBCHHbIMII CH-
JIaMH. LIacTo 9TH rpyrrrrbI op-
raHH3yroT, HarrpIIMCp, MC.n.H-
l(HHCKYIO rrOMOmb. IIOPO}I 9TO
HCJICrKO: CKa)[(CM, YCTPOHTb
'-ICJIOBCKa B 60JIbHHl(Y CTOHT
O'-ICHb .n.oporo. 3aTO MO)KHO
.n.orOBopHTbC5! 0 rrpocToM 06-
CJIc.n.OBaHHHy .n.OIZTopa,B 9TOM
cJIY'-Iac .n.OCTaTO'-IHO3HaTb JIIO-
.n.eM .n.06pOM BOJIH cPC.n.H Bpa-
'-IeM. MHC .n.a)KCH3BeCTHO, '-ITO
B MTaJIHH, B MlwaHe, O.n.IIH
Bpa'-I C03.n.aJIaCCOl(IIal(Hro Me-
.n.IIKOB, '-IT06bI 6eCrrJIanIO rro-
MoraTb HCJIeraJIbHbIM 6C)KCH-
l(aM.
L(pyroe .n.eJIO - rrOlfCK
pa60TbI: Ha}ITII pa60TY O'-Ienb
CJIO)KHO, Be.n.b HCJIeraJIbHbIM
6C)KCHl(aM 3arrpCmeHO pa60-
TaTb. Ho BCC-TaKII eCTb H Ta-
KHe HHHl(HaTHBbI, KaK B AM-
CTcp.n.aMe, r.n.e OTKPbIJIII OcPHC
.n.JI5! KpaTKOCp0'-IHOrO Har'b\Ia
pa60THHKOB. KOHe'-IHO,BJIaCTII
cpa3Y rrOrrbITaJIHCb 3aKpbITb
9TOT 0cPHC, HO 9TO HM HC y.n.a-
JIOCb. IIpH.n.YMaHO 6bIJIO TaK,
6y.n.TO 9TO He HaCT05!ma5! pa-
6OTa, a pa60Ta BOJIOHTCPOBH
pa60To.n.aTCJlb rrJIaTHT KaKYIO-
TO CYMMY B BH.n.e Harpa.n.bI
.n.06POBOJIbl(aM, pa60TaIOmHM
6C3 3aprrJIaTbI, a 3Ha'-IHT, H 6e3
HaJIOrOB, - TaKa5! BOT KOH-
CTPYKl(H5!.
HaJIa)KCHa TaK)Ke rroMOmb
.n.eT5!M. ECTb 3aKoHbI, 3arrpc-
Il(aromHe Y'-IHTbC5I .n.eT5!M HC-
JIeraJIb HbIX HMMIIrpaHToB, H
llIKOJIaM rrpHxo.n.IITC5! .n.eJIaTb
BbI60p. Ha.n.o cKa3aTb, 'ITO
O'-ICHbl'vlHOrOllIKOJI Ha 3arra.n.e
PCllIHJIH BCC-TaKH rrpHH5!Tb
9THX .n.cTeM,XOT5IrocYLl.apCTBO
3a HHX He rrJIaTHT. L(pyrO}I
OCTPbI}! BOUPOC - 9TO )KH-
JIbe. )KHJIhC CTOHT J(oporo.
ECTb, KOHC'-IHO,HeJICraJIbI, KO-
Tophle cHHMaroT )KHJIbe co06-
ma, HO C TaKHMH KBapTHpI-IbIC
X035!CBa, rrOJIh3Y5ICbHX rrpaBO-
BOM 6e33amHTHOCTbIO, 06pa-
Il(aroTC5! O'-JCHbrrJIOxo: CJ.(aroT
HM MaJIeHbKYro KOMHaTY, rJ.(c
CCJI5!Tcpa3Y MHoro Hapo.n.y, 3a
60JIbllIHC J.(eHbfH. HCKOTopble
6C)KeHl(bI CCJI5!TC5!B J.(OMax-
CKBOTax H )KHBYT TaM HCJIC-
raJlbHO l(CJlbIMH rpyrrnaMH.
MHorJ.(a 6C)KCHl(a rrbITaIOT-
C5!HHTcrpHpoBaTb B rpyrrrry, IT
9TO OllCHb '-IaCTO 1I0JIY'-IaeTC5I
yJ.(a'-IHo, 1I0TOMY '-ITOCCTbMHO-
ro )KCJIaromHX rrOMO'-Ib CMY IT
QCJIOBCKKaK-TO 6bICTPCC BXO-
.n.ITT B 06mCCTBO. KpoMC Ta-
KHX opraHH30BaHHbIX rpyrrrr,
3Ha'-IITTCJIbHYro POJIb B )KIT3HIT
Tex, KTO HaXOLl.ITTC5!Ha HCJIC-
raJIbHOM nOJIO)KCHHII, ITrpaIOT
IT rrpOCTO 06mITHbI. Ha 3arra-
J.(CMHoro 06mITH IT J.(Hacrrop, B 25
2
KOTopble 06'be,ZJ;IIHeHbI rrpe,lJ,-
CTaBlUeJIlI MeHbIIIIIHCTB; OCO-
6etIHO 60JIbIIIOe 3Ha'IeIIHe
HMeeT 06IIIIII-Ia Y acPPHKaH-
CKHX 9MlIrpaHTOB.
Ha,ZJ;o CKa3aTb, 'ITO B ,ZJ;eJIe
3aIIIlITbI 6e)KeHIreB Ba)£{I-Ia He
TOJIbKO rrOMOIIIb, HO II rrOJIIITH-
'-IeCKoe ,ZJ;eikTBlIe, oc06etII-I0
Kor,ZJ;a pe'-Ib lI,ZJ;eT 0 ,ZJ;erropTa-
lIlI5IX H TIOpbMaX, r,ZJ;e CHl(5IT
TOJIbKO HMMHrpaHTbI IIJIH 6e-
)KeHlIbI. ITOJIIIT.H'-IeCKlIe ,ZJ;ei1:-
CTBII5I 6bIBaIOT O'-IeHb pa3HbI-
MH, B Ka)K,ZJ;oi1:CTpaHe 9TO rrpo-
HCXO,ZJ;IIT rrO-CBoeMY. Ba)KHa5I
pOJIb rrO'-ITH Be3,ZJ;e rrpHHa,ZJ;JIe-
)KIlT lIepKBII, rrOTOMY 'ITO xpaM
BocrrpHHHMaeTC5I KaK HeLITO
CB5IllieHHoe. HarrpHMep, B fep-
MaHIIH, eCJIII TbI HaXO,ZJ;HIIIbC5IB
3,ZJ;atIIIH lIepKBH, rrOJIlIlIet'rcKHe
He HMeIOT rrpaBa Te65I CXBa-
TIITb, rrOTOMY 'ITO 9TO He HX
TeppIITOplI5I, a TeppHTOpH5I
Dora II TaM ,ZJ;PyrlIe 3aKOHbI.
K CO)l{aJIeHIIIO, H 9TO He
Bcer,ZJ;a TaK: CKa)KeM, BO cDpaH-
lIHII 6bIJIO y)£{e He pa3, Kor,ZJ;a
Bce-TaKII IIITypMOBamI lIepKBH,
r,ZJ;e CH,ZJ;eJIO HeCKOJIbKO COTeH
HeJIeraJIOB. IToCJIe 9Toro HeJIe-
raJIbI CTaJIII opraHII30BbIBaTbC5I,
II P0,ZJ;IIJIOCb ,ZJ;BH)KeHlIe «Sans
papiers:i> «<DecrracrropTHble:i».
OHO cYIIIeCTByeT H Terrepb, ero
l' JIamIOe Tpe60BaHlIe - He-
Me,ZJ;JIeHHO JIeraJIlI30BaTb Bcex.B OLIeHb MHorHX cTpaHax eCTIJ
rro,ZJ;06Hoe ,ZJ;BH)KeHIle 3a JIera-
JIII3alIHIO, B TOM '-IlICJIe H B fOJI'
JIaU,ZJ;IIH. 11 9TH JIIO,ZJ;1IBCepbC:l
60PIOTC5I, rrOTOMY '-ITO OHII HC-
pe,ZJ;KO Y)Ke 60JIee 10 JIeT )£{H-
BYT B fOJIJIaH,ZJ;HH, Y HHX ,ZJ;a)KC
eCTb JIeraJIbHa5I pa60Ta, OWl
rrJIaT5IT HaJIOrlI H COlIHaJIbHbIC
HaJIOnI, a OT rocY,ZJ;apcTBa OWl
HH'-IerO He rrOJIY'IaIOT. 3TO
O'-Ienb HecrrpaBe,ZJ;JIHBO. Ho -
YBbI! - HOBbIe eBporrei1:cKHc
3aKOHbI H eBporrei1:clme ,ZJ;oro-
BOPbI TaKOBbI, '-ITO 60JIbIIIe He-
B03MO>KHO HHKoro JIeraJIlI30-
BaTb.
HarrOCJIe,ZJ;OK XO'IY CKa3aTb
HeCKOJIbKO CJIOB 0 ,ZJ;erropTalIlI-
5IX, HJIH BbICbIJIKaX JIIO,ZJ;ei1:.B
3arra,ZJ;Hoi1: EBporre rrplI,ZJ;YMaml
pa3,ZJ;eJIelme Bcex CTpaH B MH-
pe Ha 6e30rraCHble II orraCHbIe.
Ho 9TO crropHbIH Borrpoc, Ka-
Ka5I CTpaI-Ia 6e30rraCHa5I, a Ka-
Ka5I OrraCHa5I. KaK pa3 TaKHC
cTpaI-IbI, KaK fepMaHH5I, fOJI-
JIaH,ZJ;II5I,ABCTPH5I, O'-IeHb XOT5IT
COCTaBIITb crrlICOK orraCHbIX H
6e30rracHbIx cTpaH, rrplI'IeM
IIMeTb B03MO>KHOCTb 9TOT crrlI-
COK Bce BpeM5I MeH5ITb. Ha-
rrplIMep, OHII CKJIOHHbI C'-IlITaTb
11paH II 11paK 6e30rraCHbIMII:
Be,ZJ;b 1I3 9THX CTpaI-I O'IeHb
MHoro 6e)l{eHlIeB, a Kor,ZJ;a
CTpaHa 6e30rraCHa5I, TY,ZJ;aMO)£{-
HO ,ZJ;erropTlIpOBaTb, eCJIII )Ke
CTpaHa rrplI3HaHa orraCHOH, TO
,ZJ;eHcTByeT )KeHeBCKa5I KOH-
BeHlIlI5I 1951 rO,ZJ;a II Y nplIe-
xaBIlilIX oTTY,ZJ;a eCTb npaBo
y6e)KIIIIIa.
.l(OBOJIbHO '-IaCTO 6e)KeHlIbI
1I3 9TlIX cTpaH opraHlI3YIOT
rOJIO,ZJ;OBKII rrpoTecTa, oc06eH-
HO 3HaMeHlITbIMlI CTaJIII rOJIO-
,ZJ;OBKIIIIpaHlIeB II KYP,ZJ;OB- B
fepMaHlI1I 6bIJI lIeJIbIt'I neplIo,ZJ;,
Kor,ZJ;a KYP,ZJ;bI cOBepIIIaJIII ca-
MOCO)K)KeHII5I, rrpoTecTY5I rrpo-
TIIB ,ZJ;erropTalIlIlI. DJIaro,ZJ;ap5I
rro,ZJ;06HbIM BblcTyrrJIeHII5IM
9TlIM JIIO,ZJ;5IMrrOKa eIIIe Y,ZJ;aeT-
C5I ,ZJ;06IIBaTbC5I rrpaBa OCTaTb-
C5I XOTb BpeMeHHo. B fepMa-
HIIII rrOCJIe CaMOCO)K)KeHII5I
KYP,ZJ;OBlIepKoBb opraHH30Ba-
JIa rrepe,ZJ;BII)KHOe y6e)KlIllre,
Ka)K,ZJ;ble ,ZJ;Be He,ZJ;eJIII 6e)KeH-
lIeB rrepeB03lIJIlI B ,ZJ;PY1'0t'I
xpaM - II TaK rrOKa lIM He
rrpe,ZJ;OCTaBJI5IJIII y6e)KIIIIra.
TaKIIM )Ke crroc060M, HO He-
MHoro paHbIIIe rrOMOraJIlI 6e-
)KeHlIaM II B fOJIJIaH,ZJ;IIH.
.l(PyrlIM BH,ZJ;OMaKlIlIH rrpo-
TIIB ,ZJ;erropTalIlIlI CTaJIa 60pb6a
C HeKOTopbIMII aBlIaKOMrraHII5I-
MIl. O'-IeHb MHorlIe 3arra,ZJ;Hble
(II He TOJIbKO 3arra,ZJ;HbIe) aBHa-
KOMrraHlI1I 3a ,ZJ;eHbrlI ,ZJ;erropnI-
PYIOT JIIO,ZJ;eH - HarrplIMep,
rOJIJIaH,ZJ;CKa5I «KJIM:i> , HeMelI-
Ka5I «JIIOcPTraH3a:i> II ,ZJ;a)Ke
«3pcPpaHC:i>. AKTIIBIICTbI 3a-
XBaTbIBaIOT OcPlICbI TaKIIX KOM-
rraHIIH. 3TO 'IaCTO rrplIHOCIIT
pe3YJIbTaTbI: CKa)KeM, IIIBeH-
lIapCKa5I «CBIIC9HP:i> 06eIIIaJIa,
'ITO 60JIbIIIe He 6Y,ZJ;eT rrOMO-
faTb ,ZJ;erropTlIpOBaTb 6e)KeHlIeB
(rrpaB,ZJ;a, IIIBeHlIapCKlIe BJIaCTII
HaH5IJIII A9P0cPJIOT, KOTOPblt'I
COrJIaCeH Y'IaCTBOBaTb B ,ZJ;e-
rrOpTalIlI5IX) .
AKTIIBIICTbI rrplIBJIeKaIOT
BHIIMaHlIe K 9TOH rrp06JIeMe
TaK)Ke rrYTeM opraHlI3alIlIlI
JIeTHIIX H 3lIMHHX JIarepeH, r,ZJ;e
c06HpaeTC5I MOJIO,ZJ;e)l{b H rrplI-
HHMaeT Y'-IaCTlIe KaK B 06cY)K-
,ZJ;eHHH cHTyalIHII C 6e)KeHlIa-
MIl, TaK H B pa3Horo p0,ZJ;a ny6-
JIH'IHbIX rrpOTeCTax. BrrepBbIe
TaKOH JIarepb rr05IBIIJIC5I B
fepMaHIIH: ceTb rpyrrrr, Ha3bI-
BaIOIIIa5Ic5I «Kein Mensch ist
illegal:i> (<< LIeJIOBeK He MO>KeT
6bITb HeJIeraJIbHblM:i», opra-
HH30BaJIa Y rpaHlIlIbI C ITOJIb-
IIIeH JIarepb, r,ZJ;e He TOJIbKO
YCTpaHBaJIHCb ,ZJ;IICKYCCIIH, HO
H 6bIJI OCYIIIeCTBJIeH ,ZJ;eMOHCT-
paTHBHbIH 3aXBaT BOK3aJIa, OT-
KY,ZJ;a 'IaCTO ,ZJ;erropTlIpOBaJIII
6e)KeHlIeB II r,ZJ;e apeCTOBbIBa-
JIH HeJIeraJIOB. IT pOTeCTYIO-
IIIHe rrpOBO,ZJ;IIJIII CIIMBOJIII'Ie-
CKHe aKlIHII, TaKlIe KaK, HanpH- 27
,IJ;BII)KEHIIEllPOTIIBHEJIErAJIbHOM IIMMIIrPAll,IIII
Mep, ~JIeHTa l.IepeS rpamIIIY>->,
KOr,n:a Y'IaCTHMKM ,n:eMOHCTpa-
IIMM CT05IT BMeCTe Ha rpaHI1IIe,
BS5IBIIHICb sa PYKH.
Tenepb n05IBHJIOCb Ol.IeHb
MHoro TaKHX JIarepeH - ,n:a-
JKC B AMepMKC, Ha rpaHHIIe C
MCKCHKO:t"I,H TaM To)KC rrpOBO-
,n:5IT,n:HCKYCCHHH aKIIHH.
Ho eCTb eme H np5IMOe
,n:CHCTBlle, 60JIee )KeCTKa5I
npaKTHKa, Kor,n:a, ,n:onYCTHM,
I1CTOPH5I BOSHHKHOBC[-[H5I
3Toro Ll,BH)KeHH5I, 0 KOTOPOM
HeCKOJIbKO MeC5IIIeB Hasa/:(
BLI,Pyr sarOBOpHJIH CpCLI,CTBa
MaCCOBOH HHepopMaIIHH, BOS-
MO)KHO, XOPOIllO HSBeCTHa H
HH'ICM XOTb HeMHoro opHnI-
HaJIbHbIM He OTJIH'-IaeTC5I.TeM
He MCHee OHa B KOHIIeHTpHpo-
BaHHOM BH,n:e OTpa)KaCT orrpe-
Ll,eJIeHHble HaCTpOeHH5I POC-
CHHCIwro 06meCTBa, KOTOPbIC
He06xoLl,HMO Yl.IHTbIBaTb, rOBO-
p5I 0 rrp06JIeMaX MMrpaHTOB H
6e)KeHIICB, TeM 60JIee 'ITO 3TH
HaCTpOeHH5I nopoH HCKYCHO
rro,n:orpeBaIOTC5I OTLI,eJIbHbIMH
saHHTcpecoBaHHbIMH rpyrrrra-
MH, rrpecJICLI,YIOmHMH BrrOJIHe
YCTpaHBaIOTC}I rr06enI HS TIO
peM ,n:JI5I6e)KeHIIeB; He,n:aBHOII
AHr JIHH rrpOCTO rro,n:O)KrJIH T<l
KyIO TIOPbMY.
I1TaK, eCTb MHoro crroco
60B conpOTHBJIeHM5I pa,n:H SC1c
mHTbI 6e)KCHIIeB, KaK rrOJIHTl1
l.IecKoH, TaK H COIIHaJIbHotl.
ITO-MOCMY, 91'0 TO, l.ITOCJIe,n:yc'l'
rro,n:,n:ep)KHBaTb.
P. c.)I'lUm
KOHKpeTHble rrOJIHTHQeCIGIC
HJIH HHbIC HHTepecbr.
BHaqaJle 6hIJl IIorpoM
HarrOMHHM B Ll,BYX CJIOBaX
C06bITH5I, rrocJIY)KHBIlIHC (rrycTb
epopMaJIbI-IO) Ha'IaJIOM 06paso-
BaHH5I 9TOro Ll,BH)KeHH5I. CIIC-
HapHH H3BeCTeH rro MHOnI]\[
Ll,PynIM Me)K3THH'IeCKHM KOH-
epJIHKTaM. Hal.laJIOCb Bce B mo-
JIe 2002 roLl,a B MaJIeHbKOM
rro,n:MOCKOBHOMropo,n:Ke Kpac-
HoapMeHcKe C rrMIHOH Ll,paKH B
ropo,n:CKOM 6ape ~ITaJIbMa».
ITOCCOPHJIHCb Ll,BOe MY)K-
l.IHH - 43-JIeTHHH fapHK Ca-
5IH H 26-JIeTI-IH:t"I I1roPb CaMo-
JIIOK. Ca5IH HaHCCCBOCMYrrpo-
THBHHKY HOJKeBOC paHeHHC H
O'ICHb CIWPO 6bIJI sa,n:cpJKaH
MHJIMIIHe:t"r.BrrOCJIeLl,CTBHHeMY
6bIJIO ITpeLl,b5IBJICHO 06BHHC-
HHC rro CTaTbe 111 qaCTb 1,
rrpeLl,ycMaTp:YIBaIOIl(c:t"I HaKa3a-
IIHe sa YMbIIliJICHHOC npH'-IHHC-
HMe T5I)KKOrOBpCLI,aSJ(OPOBbIO.
Ha CJIeLl,YIOIl(H:t"[ Bel.ICp
rpyrrrra MeCTHblX ITOLl,POCTKOB
(rro pa3HbIM CBeLl,CHH5IMB HCC
BXOLl,HJIH 01' 20 Ll,0 30 qCJIO-
BeK), CHJIbHOHaBCCCJIC,BOOpy-
)K:YIBIlIHCb Ll,y6HHKaMH, CTaJIa
Ll,OMsa ,n:OMOM06XOLl,HTb aLl,pe-
ca, rro KOTOPbIM B KpacHoap-
MCHCKe rrpO)KHBaIOT rrpe,n:CTa-
BHTeJIH apM5IHCKOHLl,HaCrrOpbI.
ITOLl,POCTKH BpbIBaJIHCb B
KBapTHpbI apM5IH H IIO,n: rrpeLl,-
JIOrOM rrOHCKOB rrpeCJIOBYToro
Ca5IHa (KOTOpbIH Y)KC CYTKH
KaK 6bIJI SaLl,ep)KaH) Hs6HBaJIH
)KHJIbIIOB - B OCHOBHOM
MY)K'IHH, XOT5I SaOLl,HOLl,OCTa-
JIOCb H )KeHmHHaM. B PCsyJII,-
TaTe rrOCTpaLl,aJIO 60JICC Ll,BYX
Ll,eC5ITKOBl.ICJIOBeK,rrpHl.ICM BO-
ceMb HS HHX (BKJIIOqa5I OLl,HY
)KeHmHHY) 6bIJIH rOCITYITaJIH-
sHpoBaHbI C T5I)KeJIbIMH TpaB-
MaMH, - rro CJIOBaM PO,n:CT-
BeHHHKOB, Y rrOCTpaLl,aBIIIYIX
pa36HTbI rOJIOBbI, TpaBMHpoBa-
HbI BHYTpeHHHc OpraHbI. Eme
OKOJIO 15 apM5IH rrOJIYl.IHJIH
aM6y JIaTopHYIO rrOMOIl(b H
CMorJIH BepHYTC5I Ll,OMO:t"r.
J\!bp KpacHoapMcHcKa
BHTaJIYIH ITallicHIIcB Ll,OBOJIbHO
caMOKpHTH'-IHO Sa5IBHJI Ha
oepHIIHaJIbHOM caHTe rop0Ll,a:
«TpareLl,H5I, rrpOH,mIlICLI,lUa5I B
ropoLl,C B MHI-IYBlUee BOCKpece-
HbC, rrOKaSaJIa, "ITO rrpOCTbIe
)KHTeJIH 6c3SaIl(HTHbI rrepe,n:
opraHHsoBaHHo:t"I 6CC'IHHCT-
BYIOIl(eH TOJIrrOH. MHJIHIIH5I He
CMor JIa CBOCBpeMCHHO OIIe-
HHTb cHTyaIIluo H rrpCCelJb 6e3-3aKOI-IHYIO pacrrpaBY. fopo-
)KaHe, Ha r JIa3aX Y KOTOPbIX
paSBopa'IHBaJIHCb Bce C06bI-
TH5I, OKa3aJIHCb 6CSY'IaCTHbIMH
K rrpOHCXO,n:5ImeMY,BOBpeM5IHC
C006Il(HJIH 0 HHX B MHJIlU~HIO>->.
l(JI5I rrOJIHOTbI KapnIHbI
CTOHT3aMeTHTb, o,n:HaKO,QTOHS
HeCKOJIbKHXLl,CC5ITKOBrrorpOM-
mHKOB 3aLl,ep)KaHbI Bcero Ll,Ba
'IeJIOBeKa, a r JIaBHOe, yrOJIOB-
Hble Ll,eJIarrponIB HHX Bos6Y)K-
Ll,eHbI ITOCTaTbe 213 QaCTb 3 -
~xy JIYlraHCTBO>->. ITo CJIOBaM
COTPYLI,HHKOB rrpaBooxpaIIH-
TCJIbHbIX opraHoB KpacHoap-
MeHcKa, HeT OCHOBaHHHYTBep-
)KLI,aTb, 'ITO saLl,CpJKaHHbIe 5IB-
JI5IIOTOI Yl.IaCTHHKaMH MOJIO-
Ll,e)KHbIX 3KCTpeMHCTCKHX
rpyrrrrHpoBOK, H CJIYl.IHBlUCCC5I
HHKaK HeJIb35I C'IHTaTb rrp05IB-
JIeHHeM pacH3Ma HJIH MC)KHa-
- ~~~--~-- ------- - ~-- ---- - -- -.~
3
I(MOHaJIbHOMM Me)l(3THM'IeCKOM
p03HM. Borrpoc, oTKy):(a Y xY-
JIMraHOB B35IJIMCbCrrMCKMqaCT-
HbIX a):(peCOBrOpO)l(aH-apM5IH,
OqeBM):(HO,Hl1KOrO B MMJIl1I(HH
He 3al1HTepeCOBaJI.
MeHee He):(eJIHcrrYCT5I )1(11-
TeJIl1 KpaCHoapMeMCKa c06pa-
JIl1Cb rrepe):( 3):(ar-Il1eMM3pHH Ha
MHTHHr, KOTOPbLt'1ropo):(CKl1e
BJIaCTY1XOT5I 11He pa3pemHJIl1,
HO 11pa3rOH5ITb He CTaJIl1. Ml1-
THHr c06paJI po):(CTBeHHHKOBH
):(PY3eM3a):(ep)I(aHHb1X norpOM-
II(l1KOB, aKTl1BHCTOB (rrpHqeM
):(aJIeKO He TOJIbKO MeCTI-1bIX)
06II(eCTBa <<IIaM5ITb» 11 PHE,
pa3Bl1BlllHX, rro CJIY-lIaIO,aKTHB-
HYIO rrporraraH):(Y. Ha):(o CKa-
3aTb, ):(JI5I MaJIeHbKOro rop0):(Ka
CXO):(KanOJIY1.IHJIaCb):(OBOJIbHO
BHYlllHTeJIbHOM - OKOJIO n5I-
Tl1COT qeJIOBeK. II03HI(115I MH-
Tl1HrYIOII(l1X 6bIJIa ):(0 npe):(eJIb-
Horo 5ICHOM:MaJIb1.Il1Kl1):(eJIaJIl1
TOJIbKO TO, 'ITO Ha):(o 6b1JIO):(e-
JIaTb, TaK KaK MHJIHI~H5IHe 60-
peTC5I ):(OJI)I(HbIM06pa30M C He-
JIeraJIbHOM l1MMHrpaI(l1eM. 11
rrocTpa):(aJIH OHH JIl1111b3a 3'1'0,
XOT5I ropo):(CKHM BJIaCT5IM HX
rr06JIaro):(apl1Tb 6bI Ha):(o 6bIJIO.
Bb1cTyrrHJI OTeI( O):(Horo 1133a-
):(ep)l(aHHbIX, H TOJIrra ):(PY)l(HO
rrpOCKaH):(HpOBaJIa: ~CB060):(y
HalllHM ):(eT5IM!» 0'1' M3pl1l1 )l(e
c06paBllll1eC5I Tpe60BaJIH BbI-
CeJIl1Tb H3 KpacHoapMeMCIGl
apM5IHcKYIO ):(l1acrropy, B OC"
HOBHOM pa60TaIOII(YIO Ha Ta-
6a1.IHoM epa6pHKe 11 MeCTI-1b1X
CTpOMKax, H ):(PYfl1X HHOP01\-
I(eB. B OTBeTHa 3'1'0a):(MHHl1CT-
paI(H5I ropo):(a rrp113BaJIa rpa)[(-
):(aH BcnOMHHTb 06 HCKJIIOqH"
TeJIbHO 6bITOBOM rrpl1ql1He B03-
HHKHOBeHH5I KOHepJIl1KTa H He
Han1eTaTb Me)K3THWIeCKYIO
Harrp5I)KeI-IHOCTb. B 60JIec
n03):(HeM HHTepBb10 M3p Ha-
3BaJI npOHCXO):(5III(He B ropo):(c
C06h1TlUI rrp05IBJIeHl1eM ~6b1TO-
Boro HaI(HOHaJIH3Ma».
EYKBaJIbHO 1.1epe3 HC-
CKOJIbKO):(HCMO1.1eHbrrOXO)l(HC
C06bITl15I rrp01130111JIHB CH6H-
PH, r):(c B HOB001611pCKe B
MaCCOBOMrr060HII(C Orr5ITb rro-
cTpa):(am1 apM5IHe. A crrycHI
eII(e rrapy ):(HeM CMl1 H3Bec-
THJIl1 06II(ecTBeHHocTb 0 C03-
):(aHHl1 )lBIDKeHH5I rrpoTHB HC-
JIeraJIbHOM HMMl1rpaI(l1H H
YKa3aJIH BceM )l(eJIaIOII(HM a):(-
pec caMTa )lBl1)1(eHl15I, co06-
II(HB co CCbIJIKOM Ha 3'1'0'1'ca-
MbIM HCTOqHHK, 'ITO ~rr06Y):(11-
TeJIhHbIM MOTl1BOM ):(JI5I 06bC-
):(l1HeHl15I npOTHBHHKOB HeJIC-
raJIbHOM HMMl1rpaI(HH B POC-
cHlicKHe ropo):(a CTaJIH
"CTOJIKHOBeHH5I KopeHHb1X
)l(HTeJIel"1 nO):(MOCKOBHoro
r. KpacHoapMeMcKa 11 HOBO-
C116HpCKaC TOJIrraMH 6ecHYlo-
II(HXC5I HMMl1rpaHToB"».
l1HTepecHo B 3TOM l1CTOPl1H
BOT'ITO. MbI rrOCeTl1JIl1YKa3aH-
Hb1M caMT cpa3Y rrOCJIeorrHCbI-
BaeMb1X C06bITHM. OH 6bIJI
rrOJIHOCTbIOCepOpMHpoBaH, 06-
JIa):(aJIpa3pa6OTaHHb1M CTl1JIeM
H Ha pe):(KocTb xopollleM Tex-
Hl1qCCKOM6a30M, MaccoM no):(-
py6Pl1K H pa3JIl1qHb1X MaTe-
pHaJIOB. IIOBepl1Tb, 'ITO, Bep-
HYBlllHCb rrOCJIe Ml1THHra, Ha
KOTOPOM5IK06b1 6b1JIO3a):(YMa-
HO H CepOpMHpOBaHO3'1'0 ~CTH-
Xl1MHoe» ,):(BH)I(eHl1C, B03MY-
II(eHHbIl"1PYCC1<HMHapo):( 3a rra-
py ):(HeMC03):(aJI3'1'03JIeKTpOH-
Hoe H3):(aHHe, OqeHb TPY):(HO.
)la)l(e eCJIl1 rrpe):(rrOJIO)l(l1Tb,
'ITO rrp05IBJI5IBllll1e C caMoro
HaqaJIa 3Tl1X C06hITl1M aKTl1B-
HOCTbPHE H ~IIaM5ITb» OqeHb
rrOMOraJIH, ):(a)l(e eCJIl13aRBJIeH-
HbIe Ha caMTe MHOrOqHCJIeH-
Hb1C ~COqYBCTBYIOII(l1e» y):(aq-
HO OKa3aJIHCb rrpeKpaCHb1MH
Be6-):(113aMHepaMH... (CTOl1T
cpaBHHTb 3'1'0'1' caMT C
3JICKTPOHHb1MH CTpaHMI(aMl1
MHOrl1X ):(pyrHx OpraH113aI(HM
cxo)l(ero TOJIKa, HaXO):(5III(l1MH-
C5I06b1qHO B Ky):(a 60JIee 3arry-
II(er-IHOM COCT05IHHl1.) C Tex
rrop caMT rrOCT05IHHOrro):():(ep-
)l(l1BaeTC5I, e)l(e):(HeBHO rrorrOJI-
H5IeTC5ICBe)KHMl1HOBOCT5IMHH
~l1CCJIC):(OBaHl15IMl1»(0 KOTO-
PhIX rr03)1(e) H ):(a)l(e YKpaCHJI-
C5IapXHBOM, B KOTOPOMc06pa-
HbI aHaJIOrWIHb1e MaTepHaJIb1
He TOJIbKO3a rrpe):(b1):(YII(l1eMe-
C5II(hI, HO):(a)l(e3a rrpe):(b1):(YII(HM
ro):(! IIpl1 caMTe pery JI5IPHO
epYHKI(HOHHPYlOT 3JIeKTpOH-
HbIM epOPYM H ~qaT», Ha KOTO-
PbIX )l(eJIaIOII(He MorYT 06cy-
):(HTb Bce CB5I3aHHbIe C l1MMH-
rpaI(HCM BorrpOCb1 - l1JIl1, '1'01.1-
Hee, TY HX 1.IaCTb,KOTOpa5I HX
60JIec BOJIHyeT. II pHqeM Bce
pa3MeII(aCMb1e MHeHl15I CTporo
I(eH3ypl1pYIOTC5I HC3pHMbIM
6JIIOCTl1TCJICMqHCTOTb1HaI(HH
H caMTa, KOTOPbIM He TOJIbKO
~rrpOnaJlhIBaCT JIOrrYXH» (ca-
Moorrpe):(eJICHHe), HO l1Hor):(a H
OTBeqaeT ~rro CYII(eCTBY».
qeM u,eJIh OTJIlIQaeTCH OT
3a,[J,aQll?
IIorrp06yeM npOMTl1Cb no
MHor01.IHCJICHHbIM, XOTh 11
OqeHb OAHo06pa3HbIM no co-
):(ep)KaHl1IO py6pl1KaM cal"ITa.
IIepBoe, 'HO 6pOCaeTC5IB rJIa3a,
eCJIHB35ITbHa ce65I TPY):(rrOqH-
TaTb 3TY KpaMHe HCTepHqC-
CKyIO KOMrrHJI5II(l1IO, - rrOCTO-
5IHHbIC (HO OTHIO):(bHC CJlyqaM-
Hb1e) rrpOTl1BOpeql15I, TaK )l(e
KaK 11 06II(a5I IOpl1):(W1eCKa5IH
):(a)l(e rpaMMaTUqeCKaR 6e3rpa- 31
32
MOTHOCTb 6opUOB C «'-IY)KHMH»,
Y)K He rOBOp5I 0 CT11JIe.
IIoMHMO rrporpaMMHbIX
py6pHK (0 ,I(B11)lZeHI1H, UeJUI
H 3a,l(aqH, KaK BCTyrr11Tb?, Co-
paTHHKaM, AI<I{YI5I) H Y)Ke yrro-
MHHaBIlIHXC5I <D0PYMa II TIaTa,
OCHOBHble MaTepHaJIbI pa36H-
TbI ITO CJIe,l(YIOInIIM IIarrpaBJIe-
HII5IM: XpOl-IHKa HallIeCTBH5I,
MHpOBble nOBOCTH, 3aKOHbI,
I1cCJIe,l(OBamUl, PerraTpHali115I
B POCCYIIO. OTlZpbWaeTC5I caih
Kpaco'-IHbIM KOJIJ1a)KeM 113 cPO-
TorpacPHtt, KOTOPbIH Mo)KHO
6bIJIO 6bI rrpHH5ITb 3a aI-ITHpa-
CHCTCKHH rrmuz aT , eCJIH 6bI He
,l(OBepllIaIOll(HY[ KapTHHY POC-
CHHCKHH cPJlar C Ha,l(rrHCbIO:
«POCCYI5I rrpOTHB HeJIeraJIb-
HbIX HMMH1'paHTOB». HH)Ke
,l(Be cPpa3bI, KBYIHT3CCeHUH5I,
TaK CKa3aTb, B31'JI5I,l(OB C03,l(a-
TeJIeH caHTa. I1I-ITepeCHO, '-ITO,
HeCMOTp5I Ha ,l(OBOJIbHO BbICO-
KYIO rrOCell(aeMOCTb 3Toro pe-
cypca, HHKTO H3 «MHorO'-IHC-
JIeHHbIX copanlHKOB» He ,l(aJI
3HaTb aBTopaM, qTO TaK rro-
PYCCKH, YBbI, CKa3aTb HeJIb35I:
«MbI - X035IeBa B CBoeM ,l(0-
Me, a rrpaBO X035IeB caMIIM orr-
pe,l(eJI5ITb, B KaKOH KOMHaTe
rrOCeJIHTb rOCT5I, I-Ia KaKoe Bpe-
M5I, HJIH Boo6ll(e He rrYCTHTb B
,l(OM. HarrpHMep, Toro, KTO
5IBHJIC5I TOJIbKO 3aTeM, qT06bI
Te65I )Ke 060KpaCTb HJIlI Bo06llle H3 CBoero )Ke ,l(OMa Bh['-
rHaTb». TaK '-IeH )Ke ,l(OM?
BI-raqaJle MHOrOqHCJIell
Hble JI5IrrCYCbI II rpaMMaTWlC
CKHe H CTI1JIHCTI1'-IeCKVIe o1'pe'
XH I-IaCTOJIbKO 3a6aBJI5IIOT II
COce,l(CTBe C Tpe60BaHVICM
«BBeCTH 065I3aTeJIbHble ;:)J{:3C1
MelIbI ITO rOCY,l(apCTBeHHOiVl'y
5I3bIKY, HCTOPHH H TpaL(Hl(WI1'o-1
POCCHH, ,l(JI5I JIHU, B1,eXaBllIYlX
Ha TeppHTopmo CTpallhI C 5111
Bap5I 1991 rO,l(a Ha rrOCT0511I
Hoe rrpO)KHBam-re, rrOCT05111'
HYIO I1JIH BpeMeHHYIO pa60
TY», lITO XOqeTC5I HX rrpOCTO
BbII1HCbIBaTb H ,l(eJIHThC5I HMH I
KaK xopOllieH IlIYTKOYI, HO no
CTerreHI-IO HX KOJIHqeCTBO CTa·
HOBHTC5I Bce 60JIee H 60JICl'
YTOMHTeJIbHbIM, a 3aTeM fl
rrpOCTO rryraIOll(HM. I103TOM'y
rrpOCTO orOBOpHMC5I, '-ITO Bel'
UHTaTbI rrpHBO,l(5ITC5I «C co-
xpaHeHHeM CTHJI5I H opq)O'
rpacPHH rrO,l(JII-II-IHI-IIza».
HI1)Ke Hac )K,lI.eT HaI160J1C('
rrOrrOJIH5IeMa5I I1 CaMa5I 06·
IlIHpHa5I, rrO)KaJIyt'I, Py6p fl
Ka - C MHor03Ha'-II1TeJIbHbIM
Ha3BaHHeM «XpoHHKa HaIlIe'
CTBH5I». TaM c06paHbI CO BCCX
caHToB (OT 60Jlee HJIH MeI-IC(,
HeHTpaJIbHbIX I1HcP0pMaUHoll
HbIX ,l(O oTKpoBeHHo HaUHOlm
JII1CTH'-IeCKI-Ix) Bce B03Mo)K
lIble HOBOCTI1 0 rrpecTyrrJIeHI1-
5IX I1HOpo,l(ueB I1 oT,l(eJIbHbIX
cPaKTax «Y,l(aqHoH» 60Pb6bI C
HI1MI-I. I1HOH pa3 I1HcP0Pi\-Ia-
UI15I-TO Bp0,l(e H ,lI.OCTOBepHa5I,
VICCbIJIKa I1MeeTC5I Ha ,l(OCTOYI-
lIbIYI H 3aCJIY)KHBaIOll(HH ,l(OBe-
pH5I pecypc, HO H3JIO)KeHO Bce
C paccTaHoBKoH «I-IY)KHbIX»
aKueHToB, TaK qTO Y)KaCbI «Ha-
IlIeCTBH5I» H Brrp5IMb JIe,l(eH5IT
KpOBb. I1pwleM H He pa30-
6paTb 6bIJIO 6bI, me )KypHa-
JII-ICT «I13BeCTHH» HJIH HTB
rrHllIeT, a r,l(e - 60PUbI C He-
JIeraJIaMH, eCJIH 6bI, Orr5ITb )Ke,
,l(YPHOH CTHJIh H rrJIOXoe 3Ha-
HHe PYCCKoro 5I3bIKa, KaK OC-
JIHHbIe YllII1, C rOJIOBOH He BbI-
,l(aBaJIH 6bI 60PI~OB cpa3Y H
6e3011IH60'-IHO, ,l(a)Ke Ha cPoHe
He Bcer,l(a 6JIell(Yll(HX rpaMOT-
HOCTbIO )KypHaJUlcToB. A I-IHOt'I
pa3 ,l(OCTaTo'-IHo Ha,l( CYXHM
I-IHcP0pMaUHoHHbIM MaTepHa-
JIOM npHJIerrHTb lIa3BaHHe -
BOT HY)KHble BbIBO,l(bI H rOTO-
BbI: «Pa6bI B POCCI-IH. JIHKH
COBpeMeI-IHOH POCCHHCKOH
rrpecTyrrHocTH (KaK BceM H3-
BeCTHO, Y rrpecTyrrHocTH HeT
HaUI10naJIbHOCTH)>> , «ECJII-I
BJlaCTI-I He MorYT nOCTaBHTb
Ha MeCTO 3apBaBllIHXC5I neJIe-
raJIOB, TO 3a 3'1'0 6ePYTC5I MeCT-
Hble )KI-ITeJII-I», «MocKBa rrpe-
BpamaeTC5I B reTTO».
B py6pI1Ke «0 ,I(BI-I)KeHHI-I»,
KY,l(a, KOHeqnO, cpa3Y 06pama-
ellIbC5I 3a pa3b5ICHeHH5IMH, H3-
JIO)KeHbI «3a,l(aqI-I ,l(JI5I BbII10JI-
HeHI15I ueJIeH ,I(BI-I)KeHH5I» (TaK
I-I CKa3aHO), '-II-ICJIOM,l(eC5ITb, a
BOT B py6pI-IKe «UeJIH H 3a.l(a-
qI-I» I-I3JIo)KeHbI «HallIH Tpe60-
BaHI-I5I», I-I I-IX ueJIbIX ,l(Ba,l(uaTb
,l(Ba 3a,l(a'-IH ,l(JI5I BbII10JIHeHH5I
ueJIeYI CBO,l(5ITC5I K CTaH,l(apT-
HbIM cPopMaM Y)KeCTO'-IeHI-I5I
MI-IrpaUI-IOHHOH rrOJIHTHKH H
nporraran,l(e COOTBeTCTBYIOlllI-IX
H,l(eH, npI-IBO,l(I-ITb KOTopble Ha-
,l(06HOCTI-I HeT, O,l(HaKO HeKOTO-
pble I-I3 rrYHKTOB 06pamalOT Ha
ce65I BHHMaI-II1e.
I1YHKT 1: «I1poBe,l(eHHe
MaCCOBbIX aKUHH rpa)K,l(aH» . 33
4
KaKIIX, He YTOt.IH5IeTC5I. .llaJIee
rrYHKT 4: «C03,ll.aHIIe M06IIJIb-
HbIX OTp5I,ll.OBrpaJK,ll.aH, COBMe-
CTHOC rrpaBooxpaHIITeJIbHbIMII
opraHaMII, pellIaIOli(HX 3a,ll.aLJ:H
rro 60pb6e C HeJIeraJIbHbIMII
HMMIIrpaHTaMH~. VI HaKoHeu"
nYIIKT 6, COBceM IIHTepecHbIH:
«OKa3aHIIe IOpH,ll.Ht.IecKoH II
:mfoit rrOMOII(H rpa)K,naHaM, aK-
THBHO BbICTYIlHBWHMH npOTHB
HeJIeraJIbHot'r HMMHrpaUHII H
nonaBllIHMH no;( II peCJIe,ll.OBa-
HHe COBpeMemfbfX treCOBep-
llIetIHbIX 3aKOI-IOB>:>.OCTaBHM 13
rrOKoe Orr5ITb BbIpBaBllIl'IeC5I H3-
rro,ll. KOI-ITPOJI5I HenoKopHbIe
na,ll.eJKHII 06paTHMC5I K py6pH-
Ke «UeJIH H 3a,ll.at.IH~, HJIH, KaK
MbI YJKe BbI5ICHHJIH,K Tpe60Ba-
HH5IM,ll.BHJKemI5I, H rronp06yeM
cpaBHHTb, LJ:eM)Ke O,ll.HOOT,ll.PY-
roro OTJIHt.raeTC5I.
I10H5ITHO, LJ:TOrrepBoe Tpe-
60BaHHe - 3TO «,ll.erropTHpo-
BaTb Bcex HeJIeraJIbHbIX HMMH-
rpaHTOB C TeppHTopHH POC-
CHH~ (HeKOTOpa5I CBe)KeCTb
HMeeTC5IJIHllIb 13rrpe,ll.JIO>Kemm
BbI,ll.BOP5ITb H3 CTpaHbI «3a
CLJ:eT... Cpe,ll.CTBKOMMepLJ:eCKHX
CTPYKTYP Tex HaUHOHaJIbHbIX
,ll.Hacrrop, K KOTOPOH(TaK 13TeK-
CTe) rrpHHa,ll.JIeJKHTBbI,ll.BOp5Ie-
MbI:t'I~) . Ho KaK 3TOro ,ll.0-
CTHLJ:b?.llaJIbHeHllIIIe rrYHKTbI
06b5ICWnOT HaM 3TO: «C03,ll.aTb
13 KaJK,ll.OM perHOHe ueHTphl
BpeMeHHoro CO,ll.epJKaHH5I)(JI}I
Bcex He3aKOHHO npOHHKIll!'IX
Ha TeppHTopHIO POCCHH~, «Co:!
,ll.aTb 13Ka)K,ll.OMperHOI-Ie CTpil
HbI Ha6mo,ll.aTeJIbHbIe COBen I II
M06HJIbHbIe OTp5I,ll.bI H3 npell
CTaBHTeJIet'I .llBHJKeHH5I, 0611l('
CTBeHHOCTH H rOCY,ll.apCTBl:1I
HbIX CJIYJK6, MB.ll, no 60pL6c ('
HeJIeraJIbHot'I HMMHrpaL(Heii»,
Ha)(o 6bI ,ll.a)Ke «BBeCTH 133a[«()
HOJ(aTeJIbCTBO nOJIOJKeHIle ()
TOM, LITOnpH06peTetme )KVIJIO'
ro ,ll.OMa, KBapTHpbI, HHot'r Ill:-
,ll.BHJKHMOCTHHa TeppHTopHH
POCCHHHe 5IBJI5IeTC5I ,ll.ocraToll'
HLIM OCHOBaHHeM,ll.JI5InpH3Hl\'
HH5I 3aKOHHOCTH HaXO>K,ll.efHLH
Ha ,ll.aHHoH TeppHTopHH C Ul:-
JIbIO npO>KHBaHH5I>:>H, COBceM
HHTepeCHO C IOpH,ll.WreCKOI~i
TOt.IKH 3peHH5I, «HaJIO)KHTb
apeCT, H3b5ITb He3aKOHHO npH-
06peTeHHYIO HeJIeraJIbHbIMH
HMMHrpaHTaMH c06CT13eH-
HOCTb 13rrOJIb3Y rOCY,ll.apCT13a.
PaCTOprHYTb ,ll.OroBopbI 06
apeH,ll.e 3eMJIH~. O,ll.HaKO He
rrOMellIaeT H «YCTaHOBHTb ne-
pet.IeHb rrpoepeCCHH, He06xoJ(H-
MbIX ,ll.JI5I HYJK,ll. Ka)K,ll.Oro pe-
rHOI-Ia, C03,ll.aTbKBaJIYIepHI{aUH-
OHHbIe KOMHCCHH~. To eCTb,
rrOJIYLJ:aeTC5I,He BceX-TaKH 6y-
,ll.eM,ll.errOpTHpOBaTb, a TOJIbKO
HeHYJKHLIX?
B Tpe60BaHH5IX, KOHeLJ:HO,
MbI Orr5ITL HaXOJ(IIM 03a60LJ:eH-
HOCTbt.IHCTOTOHPYCCKOro 5I3bI-
Ka H He06xo,ll.HMOCTb CTPorHX
3K3aMeHOB (OH, He HaKJIHKaJm
6bI Ha CBOlOrOJIOBY!). Ho P5I-
,ll.OMeCTb II npel~JIO>KeHH5Irro-
cepbe3Hee: OrpaHH'leHHe 6pa-
KOB C mrop0J(uaMH, BBeJ(eI-IHe
OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH3a HeJ(OHece-
tIHe Ha npOJKHBaHHe HMMH-
rpaHToB HJIH J(a)Ke 3a OKa3a-
mIe HM YCJIyr H -- TOJIbKOMbI
Bpo,ll.e nOH5IJIH, t.leM 3aJ(at.IHJ(JI5I
ueJIeH OTJIWlaIOTC5I OT Tpe60-
BaHHH, - 3HaKOMoe no rrpe-
,ll.bI,ll.Yli(et'IPy6p!'IKe: «CM5Ir'lHTb
HaKa3aHYI51)~JI5I rpa)KJ(aH Poc-
CIIH, CJIHIllKOM aKTHBHOBbICTY-
nHBIllI1X npoTHB npecTYIlJIeHHH
HeJIeraJIbHbIX HMMHrpaHToB H
HeBOJIeHI-IapYllII1BllIIIX HbIHellI-
Hee POCcIIHcKoe 3aKOHOJ(aTeJIb-
CTBO~.
H y, a KaK BeHeIJ,Bcero 3TO-
ro - Tpe60BaI-IHe «coJ(et'IcT-
BOBaTb cKopeHllIeMY npHH5I-
TIIIO 3aKOHOB, I-IanpaBJIeHHbIX
Ha npeKpali(eHHe J(YXOBI-IOHH
ep113Ht.IecKoH ,ll.erpaJ(aIJ,H11IW-
peHHbIx Hap0,ll.OB POCCHH, Ha
3ali(HTY Tpa,ll.HIJ,HOHHbIX IJ,eH-
HocTeH~. TOJIbKO KaK )Ke
6bITb C «TpaJ(HIJ,HOHHbIMH
IJ,eHHOCT5IMH~ 13 KOHTeKCTe
BbIIlleII3JIO>KeHHbIX HJ(eH ,ll.0-
HOCIITeJIbCTBa 11CYJ(OBJIHwla
KaK He06xo,ll.HMbIX HOpM JK113-
HH PyccKoro LJ:eJIOBeKa?
IIpaB)J,a II 3aKoH
3aMeTHM OJ(HY06li(YIO TeH-
,ll.eIIIJ,HIO Bcex 3THX Tpe60Ba-
mIH, IJ,eJIeHH 3a,ll.at.I. I10CT05IH-
HO nOJ(LJ:epKHBaeTC5IHCKJIIOlIH-
TeJIbHa5I 3aKOHOrrOCJIYIIHIOCTb
aBTopOB, rrpaBJ(a, C3TaKHM KPII-
TWIeCKHM nOJ(XOJ(OM,KOTOPbIH
,ll.OJIJKeH YJIYt.IlUHTb POCCYIH-
CKHe 3aKOHLI, 3aCTaBJ1Tb HHO-
p0,ll.IJ,eB HX YBaJKaTb, a MIIJII1-
IJ,mo ,ll.eHCTBOBaTb 13 HY)KHOM
KJIIOt.Ie.He CJIyt.lat'mo J1TO, LJ:TO,
HeCMOTp5IHa 5IBHOeHerrpJ15ITHe
BcerOlIYJKep0,ll.HOrO VI npOTH-
BonOCTaBJIeHHe 3TOMY J1CTHH-
HO PYCCKOro, a13TopbIcat'ITa Ha-
CTaHBaIOT Ha 60pb6e HlvreHHOC
«HeJIeraJIaMH>:>... 3aOJ(IIO rrpeJ(-
JIara5I y6paTbC5I 11 BceM OC-
TaJIbHbIM (<<KHTat'rIJ,aMH ,ll.PY-
rHM BbIX01~uaM H3 BOCTOt.IHOH
EBporrbI~ - BOT TaKa5I reo-
rpacpl'I5I) .
TOH cat'rra, HeCMOTp5I
Ha 3TO, 3a,ll.aIOT «rrOJIOJKH-
TeJIbHbIe~ rrpHMepbI H3 Py6pH-
KH «XpmHIKa HallIeCTBH5I~
(BcrrOMHHM: «ECJIH BJIaCTI1 He
MorYT rrOCTaBHTb Ha MeCTO3a-
pBaBllIHXC5I HeJIeraJIOB, TO 3a
3TO 6epYTC5I MeCTHbIe JKHTe-
,JIH~), npH3bIBbI K C03J(aHI1IO 3
37
06m.eHlIe C Hap0,[l,OM
nOB, KOTOPYlO HY)KHO pe-
lliaTb, -- npOKypOPbl ,Ll,On)KHbl
cnYllIaTb ITpe3H,Ll,eHTa!>,>
CO)KaneHHIO, TPY,LIHOCTH HaM
C03,Ll,aIOTTe, '-lbIO pa60TY Mbl 11
npHHIJ.Hrre 13bIIIOJIH51eM,-
rrpaBooxpaHHTenbHble opraIIbl
H a,LIMHHHCTpaIJ.H51>'>.Bo06IIJ.C,
3ara,Ll,OLIHblHKOOp,LIHHCLTOpBCC
13peM51rrO,Ll,'-Iepl<YIBaeT:«Mbl HC
CTpa,LIaeM Mal-meP'I BenHLIH51 VI
He HaMepeHbl ,rraBaTb rrHlI(Y
nJI51 rrpOKypopOB. 2leJla}ITC
13bIBO,Ll,blcaMH - KTO co6paJI
mO,LIeH, KTO npHrnaCHJI "ITa-
M51Tb" H PHE, H T. ,LI.>'>.
HeCMOTp51 Ha Bce 3TH 5113-
Hble, YBbl, HeJIa,rrbl C 3aKOHOM,
3aCTa13n51IOlirHe,LIa)Ke 13epxyw-
Ky 2lITH11 YXO,LIHTb 13rrO,LIIlO-
JIbe, YTBep)K,LIcLeTC51,LITO<?MHO-
nle H3 copaTHHKOBi> 2lBH)Ke-
HH51 <?51Bn51IOTC51COTPY,L(HHKa-
MH rrpa1300xpaHHTeJIbHblX op-
raHOB, a HeKOTopble pa60TalOT
na)Ke 13a,Ll,MHHHCTpalum ITpe-
3H,Ll,eHTai>.
130JIeeToro, KaKYIO 6bl O'-le-
13H,LIHYIOOKoneCHIJ.Y HH CO,LIep-
)KaJIH MaTepHanbl caHTa, CKonb-
KO 6bl KceHoep06HH l'I Me)K3THH-
'-leCKot"l HeHaBHCTl'I HH BbIlwe-
CKl'IBMH Ol-IHHa LIl'ITaTeJI5I,13Ka-
LIeCTBe 06pa3IJ.a ,LIJI51 rrO,LIpa)Ka-
HH51 13 ,Ll,ene 60Pb6bl C l'IMMH-
rpaHTaMl'I H, MO)KHOCKa3aTb, PY-
JIeBOrO HeO,Ll,HOKpaTHOrrpl'IBO-
,LIl'ITC51npe3H,LIel-IT B. B. ITy-
Tl'IH. <?Kor,LIanpe3l'I,LIeHT ITYTHH
3a5113fl5leT0 np06JIeMe Henera-
M06l'InbHb1X OTp51,rr013,rrpOBe-
neHHIO <?MaCCOBbIXaKIJ.l'IHi>, He
r0130p51 Y)K 0 TpOraTeJIbHOH
oneKe Ha,L( rpa)K,LIaHaMH,
<?CJIHllIKOM aKTIIBHO BbICTY-
IlIIBllIIIMII npOTIIB rrpecTyrrne-
HIIP'I l-IeJIeraJIbHbIX HMMHrpaH-
1'013H He130ne}I HapYllIIIBllIHMH
HbIHeWHee POCCIIP'ICKoe3aKO-
HO,LIaTenbCTBOi>.
AprYMel-ITHpYlOTC51 3TII rro-
rpOMHble l-IaCTpOeHl'!5l 6e3YM-
I-IbIM, HH Ha '-IeM He OCHOBaH-
HblM 3a5113JrCHHeM2lBl'l}KeHl'I51
01' 14 HIOn510 <?TblCWlax POC-
CII51H, y6HTblx HeneraJlbHblMH
HMMIIrpaliTaMHi>, <?MHonlX H3-
HaCIIJI013aHHblX MaJIOneTHl'IX
,LIeT51XKopeHHblX )KHTeJleP'I» H
npyrHMH HCTepH'-IeCKHMH 13bl-
rra,LIaMH, 51BHOorrpoBepraIOIIJ.H-
MH npoB03r JIameHHblH aBTO-
paMH Te3HC: «ITpaB,Ll,a H 3a-
KOH Ha Hameti CTOpOl-Ie>,>.
11 Y)K COBceM Bpa3pe3 C
3THM 3a5113JleHHeMH,LIeTHHTep-
BbIO r JIa13HOrO KOOp,LIHHaTOpa
2lBH)Kemm, ,rraHHoe51K06bl KOp-
pecrroH,LIeHTY d13BecTHH>,>, HO
ra3eTO}I He ony6nl'IKOBaHHoe.
Ha caHTe 2lITH11 OHO BbIBe-
meHO rro,Ll, rraTenl'-IeCKHM Ha-
3BaHHeM <?PYCCKHe HMeIOT
rrpaBO Ha caMo060pOHY». Ko-
0p,LIHHaTOp rrpe,Ll,rrOLIHTaeT He
YKa3bmaTb CBoero HMeHH, 06b-
5lCH515131'0 TaK: «K rny60KOMY36
rrOMO)KeT H,Ll,e51M2lBH)KeHl'I51.
TOnbKO BOT HHTepeCHa51
TpaHCepOpMaIJ.l'I51: Ha rrpe,Ll,na-
raeMOP'I rOTOBOP'IKHOrrO'-IKe Ha-
3Bal-me CaP'ITaMel-meTC51,Bl'I,Ll,HO
,Ll,n51KpaTKOCTH, H rrpeBpanraeT-
BCTymITb 13 2lBH)KeHl'Ie, C51H3 <?21BYl}KemlerrpOTl'IB He-
OKa3bIBaeTC51, O'-IeHb rrpOCTO. neranbHOP'l HMMHrpaIJ.l'Il'Ii> rrpo-
Ha,Ll,o TOnbKO HamICaTb 3a51B- CTO13<?21BYI)KeHHe3a 2lerropTa-
neHl'Ie, 3arrOnHl'ITb aHKeTY H IJ.HIOi>.13e3 rr051CHel-UIH - KO-
OTOCnaTb ee 13IliTa6. Ho rrpl'I- roo
eM He rapaHTl'IpyeTC51 - a LITO OT,Ll,enbHble H HaH60nee
HMeHHO Mo)KeT rrOMewaTb lWH y6e,Ll,HTenbl-lble BblcKa3bIBaHH51
rrOMO'-Ib rrpHeMY, ,Ll,Ora,Ll,aTbC51rrocenneJIeP'r py6pHKH <,<1>0-
HeTpY,Ll,HO,CTOHTTOJIbKO rrpo- PYMi> (a Hl-Ior,Ll,a,rroxo)Ke, rrpo-
cMoTpeTb rrYHKTbI aHKeTbl: Ha- CTOero X0351eB) c06paHbl 1301'-
IJ.HOHanbHocTb, 13epOIIcrrOBe,Ll,a- ,Ll,enbHblP'I«IJ.l'ITaTHHKi> nO,LrHa-
l-me, cepII51 H HOMep rracrropTa, 3BaHHeM «CnoBo Hap0,Ll,a0 He-
oc06ble HaBbIKH... 3aTO, Y)K neranbl-IOP'I HMMHrpaIJ.HH H Ha-
BCTyrrHB, MO)KHO,Ll,enaTbO'-IeHb weM ,Ll,BII)KeHHHi>. He Y,Ll,HBH-
MHoroe -- 01' pacrrpoCTpaHe- Tenbl-IO, LITO «Cn0130i> Bcer,Ll,a
HH51nHCTOBOK,Ll,0Mano JIH LIe- OLIeHb HenaCKOBoe ,Ll,n51l'IMMII-
ro ... A, HeT, LIl'ITaeM ,Ll,anbllIe: rpaHTo13 H ,Ll,0130JIbHOneCTHoe
<?Cepbe3Hble ,Ll,eHCTBH51He06- ,Ll,n51X0351eB. 2lPynle )Ke cnOBa
XO,Ll,HMOcornaCOBbIBaTb C UeH- Ha ,Ll,l'IBO6blCTPO <?rrpoIlanbIBa-
TpanbHblM IliTa60M 2lBH)Ke- IOTC51i>C epoPYMa, ,L(a6bIHe 13130-
HH51i>.A TO KaK )Ke OHH HHa'-le ,Ll,HTbHHKoro 13HCKYllIeHHe. Ho
nOTOM 6y,rrYT Tpe60BaTb 13awe- no'-mTaTb II 31'0 rrone3HO, Be,Ll,b,
ro OCB060)K,Ll,eHH51H CM51r'-le- 3Ha51KOMrrneKCbl H np06neMbl
HH51cpOKa HaKa3aHH51? rrpOCTblX mO,LIeH, l'I Bnp51Mb
O,LIHaKO,LIeHbrHMO)KHOne- l'IHOr,LIaOXOTHOnOMep)KHBaIO-
peLIl'ICnHTb H He BCTyna51. B IIJ.HX He,LIaneKYIO W013HHHCTH-
py6pHKe <?ITOMOIIJ.b 2lBH)Ke- LIeCKYIOPl'ITOPl1KY, nerLIe C 3TH-
HHIOi> rrO,LIp06HO H3JIO)KeHO, MH 5l13neHII51MH 60POTbC51. A
KaK 31'0 c,LIenaTb. A MO)KHO 60POTbC51He06xo,LIHMO, H '-IeM
rrpOCTO rrOCTaBIITb 6al-IHep 60nbllIe LIHTaellib 31'01' caHT,I caiITa fla CBoli caliT, 31'0 TO)l{e TeM 31'0 naHOBHTCH1100WlIec.
___________________________________.1••••••••••••••• iiiiiii__ .-.1:1:1 ~M;;·.;;~=-======= =_=_ __
38
He Haxo.n.5I BI1HOBaTblX B CBO-
eM lIO.n.'IaC.n.eHCTBI1TeJIbHO6e.n.-CTBeHHOM rrOJIO)KeHI1I1, Hapo.n.
rpYCTHT 11He.n.oYMeBaeT: ~ITo-
'-IeMY K HaM e.n.eT O.n.HOOTpe-
6be?:;> 11 Y)KaCbI BC5IKI1e eMY
MepeIIIaTC5I: «B 06IIIeM, cpe.n.-
HeBeKOBa5I TYPlU15I Ha TeJIe
Pet>:;>. K TOMY )Ke Y coce.n.a
Bcer.n.a Bce Ka)KeTC5I JIY'-IllIe,
'-IeM Y ce65I, H, rJI5I.n.HllIb, BbI5IC-
H5IeTC5I, '-ITO ~rrO'IeMY-TO B
CIliA HI1KrO He YLJ.HBJI5IerC5I
TOMY, '-ITOHeJIeraJIOBB LJ.BaUle-
ra ca)J;5ITB 06e3b5IHHHKH H LJ.e-rropnIpYIOT 6e3 rrpaBa Bbe3.n.a
B crpaHY B 6YLJ.YIIIeM:;>.BOT 6bI
H Y Hac, .n.YMaeT rrOCenITeJIb
epOPYMa, ~CaLJ.ITJII1:;>6bI TaK B
~06e3b5IHI-IHKH:;>,H )KHTb CTaJIO
6bI JIY'-Ime.
MHO rITe paCCY)K.n.eHH5IHC-
KpemIHe, B ::nOM-ro 11HaLJ.OBI1-
.n.eTb yrp03Y, a He B XI1rpOBa-
rbIX, XOTb 11 rJIyrroBarbIX,
I1LJ.eOJIorax caHTa. BOT KTO-TO
ceTyer, 'ITO, He rrOJIb3yt'IC5I MbI
Bce LJ.emeBoH pa60'IeH CHJIOH
I1MMHrpaHTOB, OHI16bI H caMH
y6paJIHCb. A MbI I1X CaMI1, 113-
3a c06CTBeHHOH )Ka.n.I-IOCTI1
pa3BOLJ.HM,~JII1mb 6hI C3KOHO-
MI1Tb rrapy 6aKCOB I-Ia pa6-
CKOM TPy.n.e I-IeJIeraJIOB:;>.3I-Ia-
'-IHr, 3I-IaeT HapOLJ.rrpo pa6CKI1H
rpy.n.? 3I-Ia'-IHr, He Bce HeJIera-
JIbI B MepCeLJ.ecax, 0 'IeM HaM
TBep.n.5IT BO Bcex py6pHKax
caHTa? He.n.ocJIe.n.I1JI ~rrporra
JIbIBaTeJIb JIOrrYXOB»!
ITOBTOPI1MC5I,3TI1-TO HaHIl
HbIe ~rrporOBopKH:;> rryraIO'l'
60JIbme, 'IeM CTpamHJIKH, paco
CTaBJIeHl-Ible TYT 11TaM, 5IBHO('
YMbICJIOM H HeIWTopOH JIOnl'
KOt'r. B35ITb XOT5I 6hI BbI3Ball~
myIO Bce06IIIHt'I CO'-IY13CTBeu0
HbIH OTKJII1K HCTOPHlO 06 all)
raHlle- KBaPTI1pOCbeMU( vlKe, a
TO'-IHee, 0 BbmaBmeH H3 ero
OKHa Ha rrOLJ.OKOHHHKrrO'-ITeI-l-
Horo KOpel-IHOrO PyccKoro
rpa)K,lI,aHI1Ha rrpOCTITTYTKC
(npoITCXO)K.n.eHlIe He1I3BeCr-
HO). ~5I 6bI TO eure HWlero, HO
3Ta mJIIOxa pa36Y,lI,HJIa MOlO
MaJIeHbKYIO .n.O'Ib:;>, - B03MY-
UraeTC5I KopeHHOH PYCCKI1H
)K11TeJIb, .n.O'-Ib KOToporo C Tex
rrop CTpa.n.aeT HO'-IHbIMH KOIlI-
MapaMII. HeJIb35I He CorJIa-
CI1TbC5I, I1CTOPH5I rpycTHa5I,
OC06el-IHO eCJII1 Y'IeCTb, 'ITO
rrO,ll,6I1paTb C rro.n.OKOHHI1Ka
«TeTIO:;>OH He CTaJI H aHa I1C-
l[e3JIa 3a OKHOM ~B HO'II1:;>.Ho
rIOLJ.o6Hble HCTOPI1I1 Ka)KLJ.blt'I
pa3 cOrrpOBO)KLJ.aIOTC5IOTBeTa-
MI1 Y3HaBaeMoro rro CHIJIIO
~COBeT'-nrKa:;>,KOTOPblt'I nOJ~bI-
TO)KHBaeT KaK-HYI6YLJ.bBpo.n.e:
«BO-BO, TaKoe 6bI ceMeHcTBo
rrOCeJIHTb 13 coce.n.I1 K KA:>K-
,l(OMY, KTO 3.n.eChpaccY)KLJ.a-
eT 0 ,,13bIcOKOKBaJIHcjJI111HPO-
Bal-IHOH pa60'-Iet'I CHJIe" 11"Ha-
llHOHaJIbHOM paBeHcTBe"! >,'>
KaK rOBOpHTC5I, OTBeT He Ha
13onpoc, HO rro cym;eCTBY!
MHOfHe LJ.pyme coo6IIIe-
H115IHarrpaBJIeHbI Ha rrpeoLJ.O-
JIeH11e HallHOHaJIbHhIX KOM-
IweKCOB «<PYCCKHe YMeIOT
BoeBaTb, CTpOlHb KOCMH'-Ie-
CKHe Kopa6JIH H aTOMHble
nOLJ.BOLJ.HbleJIOLJ.K11!:;>- Ot'I, He
HaLJ.O6bI npo BoeBaTb H npo
nOLJ.BOLJ.HbleJIOLJ.K11!)- 11KaK
BbIBOLJ.,cpa3Y H 6e3 nepexo.n.a:
~PYCCKHe, pO)KaHTe 60JIbme
.n.eTeH H BocnHTbIBaHTe 11X 13
npaBHJIbHOM HallHOHaJIbHOM
LJ.yxe! CJIABA POCCI1I1!:;>
Ha et>opYMe TaK)Ke noCTO-
5IHHO nOLJ.'-IepK11BaeTC5IMbICJIb
a TOM, '-ITO ,l(BH)KeHHe LJ.eHCT-
ByeT H c06HpaeTC5I LJ.eHCTBO-
BaTb TOJIbKO 13 paMKax 3aKO-
Ha. TaK H rOBOpHTC5I: «MbI 3a
3TO, 3a c06JIIO,ll,eHHe 3aKO-
HOB!! !:;>11, Orr5ITb )Ke, He 6y.n.bTO TYT, TO TaM rrporOBopOK 0
BoopY)KeHHOM corrpOTHBJIe-
HHH, .n.aa HeC013epmeHCTBe3a-
KOHOB, ,lI,a0 CHH)KeIIHH CpOKOB
HaKa3aHI15I, TaK 6bI H nOBepHJI
3TOMY, ,lI,a H XO'-IeTC5IBe,ll,h Be-
P11Tb!
XO'-IeTC5I BepHTb, '-ITO, KaK
H11CTpal-IHO, y'-IaCTIIHKH ,l(B11-
)KeHH5I, Ha CJIOBaX 130BC5IKOM
CJIY'Iae, pemWreJIbHO npOTlm
Taro, '-ITOOr-IHHa3bIBaIOT «my-
B11HH3MOM:;>(3TOT HeOJIOrH3M
HeOLJ.HOKpaTIIO BCTpe'IaeTC5I
Ha cat'ITe). HeKOTopbIe ,lI,a)Ke
C'-IIITaIOT, '-ITO, OKa3bIBaeTC5I,
«I136IIBaTb '-IepHbIX Ha y JIHllaX
HII K '-IeMY xopOllIeMY He npH-
BO.n.I1T, II ,lI,eJI<1TbHX )KH3Hb
CJIQ)KHee TO)Ke He HY)KHO...
eCJIIr MbI BCTpeTIIM apM5IHIIHa
13 AHr JIIIII, TaK CKopeH Bcero
CMO)KeM 6bITb .n.PY3b5IMII!:;>,
BbIBOLJ.,3aKOHHbIt'I rrpWleM, ro-
TOB: .n.errOpTlrpOBaTh Bcex II
CKorrOM, 11Ha'-Ie,lI,eJIYHe rrOMO-
)KellIb. 0rrbIT 3arra,ll,HbIX KOJI-
JIer (TaKIIX )Ke «3aKOHHII-
KOB:;» rrpIIBO,ll,HTC5IrrOCT05IHHO,
H C 60JIbllIHM YBa)KeH11eM.
«IT pHMepHO Ha TaKOH )Ke
rrJIaTcjJopMe meJI :>KaH MaplI
.lIe ITeH 130et>paHll11H, 113a IIe-
ro rrporOJIOCOBaJI11nO'-IT1120%JI5IryrueK! CaMoe r JIaBI-IOe :no
Bcex 3T11X 6aH.n.lor BblrI-IaTh C
rr11HKOMrro,ll, 3a.n. IT rrpIT 3TOM
C06JIIO.n.aTb rrOJIHTWlecKYlo
-------~--~~ --.'l!l\!!i!c"""-
4
,llBH)I(etIHe npoTI'm HeJIe-
raJIbHot'I HMMHrpaUHII, KeM 6bl
OHO Ha caMOM ,ll,eJIe HH rro,ll,-
,ll,ep)I(HBaJIOCb 11 KeM 6bI HH
¢HHaHCIIpOBaJIOCb, OTpa)I(aeT,
K CO)I(aJIeHIIIO, Maccy Ol.feHb
pacrrpOCTpaHeHHblX cTepeOTH-
rrOB H rrpe,ll,paCCY,ll,KOB, CTpallI-
HbIe 5I3BbI B C03HaHHH HallIero
PbIi> (KOfO rrO,ll,,ll,ep)I(HBaeT Ha
BbI60pax 3TO ,llBII)I(etIHe, a
K01'O HeT, ra,ll,aTb ,ll,OJIro He
rrpIIXO,ll,HTC5I), HH TeM 60JIee
,,~aTepHaJIbl ,ll,Jl5I rrporra1'aH-
,ll,bIi>. IIOCJIe,ll,HHe 3aHHMa-
TeJIbHbl JIHllIb TeM, '-ITO rrpe,ll.-
JIaraeMble ,ll,JI}Ipa3HblX pe1'HO-
HOB JIHCTOBKH COBrra,ll,aIOT ao-CJl06'HO, TOJlbKO B HeKOTopbIX
HarrHcaHO: «Y,ll,apHblM OTp}I-
,ll,OM IIH03eMHot'l 3KcrraHCHlI
51BJI}IlOTC}I BblXO,ll,Ubl H3 KaB-
Ka3CKHX rOCY,ll,apCTBi>, a B Ile-
KOTOPblX CTOHT "BbIXO,ll,IIbI II3
KHTa5Ii>, B O,ll,tUlX: "E)I(eMe-
C5Il.fHO MHOrOMHJIJIIIOHHa5I
KaBKa3CKa5I ,ll,lIacfropa rrepe-
BO,ll,IIT orpOMHble CYMMbl (,ll,0
1 MJIP,ll, ,ll,OJIJIapoB) K ce6e Ha
PO,ll,HHYi>, a B ,ll,PyrHx -
"MHorOTbIC5ILIlIaH KHTat'I-
CKa5Ii> 11 B KHTaH, rrpHl.feM
Orr5ITb ,ll,0 1 MJIP,ll, ,ll,OJIJIa-
pOB - BH,ll,HO, Ha B31'JI5I,ll, aB-
TOpOB, KHTaMUbI pa60TaIOT
3Hep1'Hl.fHee!
)I(e 11 TYT JI51rrbl CJIY'-laIOTC51.
TaK, HarrplIMep, B aBrycTe rr051-
BIIJIOCb co06rueHIIe 0 TOM, '-ITO
B IIpare IIHOCTpaHeu y611JI HO-
)KOM rrOJIHueMCK01'O H paHIIJI B
MeTpo rraCCa)KHpOB, - BOT
rrYCKaM K ce6e 3TIIX HHOCTpaH-
ueB! A HeCKOJIbKHMH ,ll,H51MH
rr03)I(e rrpecce CTaJIO 1I3BeCTHO,
l.fTO HHoCTpaHeu OKa3aJIC51
PYCCKHM ... Ho 3Ta IIH¢opMa-
UII51 Ha caHT rrO'-IeMY-TO Y)I(e
He norraJIa.
Py6pHKa ,,3aKOHbIi> ny6-
JII'lKyeT P}I,ll, "rrpaBHJIbHbIX»
3aKOHOB, Ha KOTopbIe Ha,ll,O
paBH}ITbC51 HallIeMY 3aKOHO,ll,a-
TeJIbCTBY. 11 reorpa¢lI}I TaKa51
3HClKOMa}I: 3aKOHbI Bee CTaB-
pOrrOJIbCKHe, ,ll,a KpaCHO,ll,ap-
CKHe, ,ll,a rrapa JIY)I(KOBCKO-MO-
CKOBCKIIX. 5ICHO, C Koro Ha,ll,O
rrpHMep 6paTb.
HaKOHeu, py6pHKa ,,11c-
CJIe,ll,OBaHlI5Ii> rrpe,ll,JIaraeT 60-
1'aTbIt'l Bbl60p cTaTeH, B oc-
HOB HOM rrOCB}IrueHHblX ,,1'e-
HOUII,ll,Yi> 11 «BbIMHpaHIIIOi>
PYCCKoro Hap0,ll,a, '-IT06bl He-
06XO,ll,HMOCTb ,ll,eHCTBOBaTb
CTaJIa erue HarJI5I,ll,HeH. Ho
3TO Y)I( CKYl.fHO. IIOCMOTpHTe
ra3eTbI HallIlIX KpaHHe rrpa-
BbIX, H BbI rrO'-lTH 6e3 113MeHe-
HIIM HaH,ll,eTe Bce TO )I(e ca-
Moe. He HHTepeCHbl B 3TOM
CMbICJIe HH Py6PIIKH «Bbl60-
BOHCTlIHY, Bee 3TO 6bIJIO
6bl CMellIHO, eCJIII 6bl He 6bIJIO
TaK rpYCTI-IO ...
II pOJIIICTaeM 6blCTpellbl(o
,ll,PyrlIe Py6PIIKH, Be,ll,b II Tal,
Y)I(e MHoroe CTClJIO 51CHO 0
rrpHpO,ll,e ,llIIH11, ,ll,a)Ke KOM'
MeHTHpOBaTb rro'l
TII HeLlero. 3TII
MHorOCTpcllUI'-IHhl(\
TPY ,ll,bl rIbITaIOTC~1
rrO,ll,BeCHI ,,3aKOII
IlYlOi> H HHTeJIJIeK
TyaJlbl-lYID 6a3y
no,ll, Bce BbIlueH:l
JIQ)KetU:IOe.
Py6plIKa "MvlpOBble HOBOCTH»
3HaKOMHT '-IHT<1'
TeJI51 C OrrbITO~1
3ana,ll,HblX CTpaJ I,
onI1pa51Cb Ha I1X
,ll,elkTBIITeJIbHo 60
raTYIO rrpaKTIIK'y
MaCCOBblX ,ll,errop~
TaUHt'l lIMMII1'paHTOB, a TaK)K(,
npIIBO,ll,IIT npHMepbl 6ec'
'-IlIHCTB 11 KplIMIIHaJIbHblX ,ll,e}I'
HlIM lIMMlI1'paHToB 3a Py6cq
)I(OM. II plIMepbI ,ll,erropTaUlIoll'
HOM rrOJIIITlIKlI eBporreMCKHX
cTpaH, YBbl, nO'-ITII BCer,ll,CI
rrpaB,ll,HBble - HO 3TO pa3ro'
BOp OC06blM. C KplIMlIHaJIOM
KoppeKTHocTbl i> KaK CO'-le-
TaTb 1I3rHaHHe ~C rrlIHKOM rrO,ll,
3a,ll,i> C rrOJIlITH'-leCKOM KOp-
peKTHOCTbID, BH,ll,HO, Ha,ll,O Y
~JI51rYllIeKi> crrpallIHBaTb, He
HHal.fe. (O,ll,HaKO ,ll,PyroM Y'-Ia-
CTHHK ,ll,I1CKYCCl1I1rrO,ll,l.fepK:HBa-
eT: «,llJI51 He O'-IeHb Yl"IHblX 3a-
Me'-IY, '-ITO 3TO He I1MeeT IUI'-IerO
06uJ,ero C "JII13aHI1eM 3a,ll,HI1Ubl
3aml,ll,y"». IIPH-
,ll,eTC51 BepI1Tb Ha
CJIOBO... )
,lleMorpacp:H'-Ie-
CKa51 C¥ITyaUH51 B
CTpaHe, H Brrp51Mb
HeBeCeJIcill, CBO,ll,I1T-
C51 ,ll,JI51 rOCTeM
«<D0PYMai> K rrpo-
6JIeMaM MlIrpaUIII1,
H 3TOM rrp06JIeMe
rrOCB51rueHO HeMa-
JIO MeCTa. Be,ll,b
~KOHKpeTHO Y Hac
l.fYPKII pa3MHO)I(a-
IOTC51TOJIbKO-TOJIb-
KO MlIrpaUlIeM.
~eCTHoe HaeeJIe-
HlIe pa3MHO)I(aeTC51 eCTeCTBeH-
HblM crrOC060Mi>, rpycTlIT O,ll,lIH
1I3 rroCeTlITeJIeM. A pa3 Y)K OHII
He MorYT pa3MHO)I(aTbC51 ~ec-
TeCTBeHHblM crrOC060Mi>, TO Ha-
,ll,0 "BeCTII ce651 rrO-l.feJIOBel.fe-
CKII - CTaHOBIITbC51 PYCCKlI-
MII, KaK EarpaTHOH, IIYllIKlIH 11
T. ,ll,.i>.40
IIPOEJIEMbI ~blrAH-EE)I{EH~EB
06llJ,ecTBa. fOBOp5I 0 rrOJIO)Ke-
mUI MMrpaHTOB B HameR
cTpaHe, He06xo,Ll,MMOrroHMMaTb,
KaKa5I yrp03a TaHTC5I B pac-
rrpocTpaHemUI 9THX B3r JI5I,LI,OB,
H pal{MOHaJIbHYlo 60pb6y C
51 paCCKa)KY 0 Tex TPY,LI,HO-
curx, C KOTOPbIMII CTaJIKHBaeT-
C5I MHrpHpYIOliree lrbIraHCKoe
HaCeJIeI-IHe EBpOrrbI.
Kor,Ll,a pe'Ib H,LI,eT0 6e)KeH-
l{ax, MHe BCrrOi\-UIHaeTC5IO,Ll,MH
3aMe'IaTeJIbHbIH rpY3HHCKIIH
rrpaB03allJ,IITHIIK, KOTOPbIH B
1992 ro,Ll,Ye3,L1,HJIrro BceM rrpa-
B03aIIJ;HTHbIM KOH¢epeHl{IUIM.
3TOT 'IeJIOBeK Ka)K,LI,OMY,KTO
rOTOB 6bIJI BbICJIYllIaTb, paccKa-
3bIBaJI 0 Tpare,lJ:I-Ilf MecxeTIIH-
l{eB (HX Ha3bIBaIOT TaK)Ke TYP-
KII-MeCXeTIIHl{bI). Mx rrOJIO)Ke-
HIIe B KpaCHO,Ll,apcKoM Kpae
Terrepb rrOJIY'IHJIO HeKoToPYIO
II3BeCTHOCTb 6JIaro,Ll,ap5I %Me-
MOpHaJIY~· A B TO BpeM5I, rro-
CJIe pacrra,Ll,a COBeTCI{Qro Coro-
3a, MaJIO KOMY 6bIJIO H3BeCTHO
06 IIX 6e,Ll,ax. Tor,Ll,a BcrrblxHY-
JIH Hal{IIOHaJIbHbIe KOH¢JIHK-
TbI, Ha'IaJIHCb rrorpoMbI B <Dep-
raHe, r,Ll,e y6MBaJIH H oTKY,LI,a
BbIHY)K,LI,aJIM 6e)KaTb Mecxe-
THHIreB, 3a rrOJIBeKa,Ll,OToro Ha-
HMMM CTaBMTb B O,Ll,MH p5I,LI, ('
,LI,PyrMMM rrpMopMTeTHbIMM 3Clc
,LI,a'IaMH rroMOllJ,H 6e)KeHIlaM H
HMMMrpaHTaM.
1\If. COa.i\tmi
CMJIbCTBeI-IHO nepeCeJIeHHbIX
M3 fpY3HII B Y36eKHcTaH. OmlBepHYJIHCb B fpY3HIO, TaM IIX
BHaqaJIe rrpHH5IJIH, HO rrOTOMH
OTTY,LI,a BbIrHaJIlI. B KOHl{e
KOHl{OB OHH rrpIIUlJIH B Kpac-
HO,Ll,apCKlIHKpat'I, r,Ll,errOrraJIlI B
OTeIMHHOe rrOJfO)KeI-IHe: MeCT-
HbIe BJIaCTH C03,L1,aJIH,LI,JI5IHHX
'ITO-TO BpO,Ll,ereTTO, B KOTOPOM
MHorHe H3 HHX HaXO,Ll,5ITC5I,LI,O
CHX rrop. 3TOT rpY3HHCKMH
rrpaB03allJ,MTHMK e3,L1,HJIM BceM
06b5ICH5IJI, 'lITO Tpare,Ll,M5IMec-
XeTMHl{eB - 9TO Tpare,Ll,M5I
fpY3HH. OH rOBOpMJI, 'ITO, 6e-
)KeHl{bI-MeCXeTI-IHl{bI - rrp06-
HbIH KaMeHb H eCJIMfPY3H5I He
CMO)KeTpellIHTb MX rrp06JIeMY,
TO HMKOr,Ll,aHe 6Y,LI,eTB HeH HH
,LI,eMOKpaTMH, HM rYMaHHO-
ro 06llJ,ecTBa. ,l(eHcTBMTeJIbHO,
9TO 6bIJI KaKoR-To rrepeJIOM-
HbIR MOMeHT, KOr,Ll,aellJ,e MO)K-
HO 6bIJIO 'ITO-TO pemMTb rro-
'IeJIOBeeIeCKH. K CO)KaJIeHHIO,
O'IeHb qaCTO TaKHe rrpOTHBO-
pe'IM5I He rrpeO,Ll,OJIeBaIOTC5I
6JIarOrrOJIY'IHO BOBpeM5I, M B
l(aJIbHeHllIeM, KaK MbI 3HaeM,
pa3BHTIfe ,LI,eMOKpaTlfl-IeCKOro
06llJ,eCTBa - If B fpY3HH, M B
lwyrMx 6bIBllIHX pecrry6JIM-
Kax COI03a - rrpOHCXO,Ll,IfJIO
VI rrpOHCXO,Ll,MTrrJIOxo.
UbIraHe - 9TO M3BeeIHbIH
np06Hbr:it KaMeHb: eCJIlTKoro M
MQ}KrIO Ha3BaTb 6e)KeHl{aMIf,
TaK 9TO l{bIraH. EOJIee
1000 JIeT Ha3a,Ll,OHIf 6bIJIM If3-
OIaHbI M3 MH,LI,lTlTM CKHTaIOTC5I
rIO MHPY, Be3,L1,e M Bcer,Ll,aOCTa-
Ba5ICb6e)KeHl{aMIf. 3TO rrpOYIC-
XO,Ll,lTTrrOTOMY, 'ITO OHH He ac-
CHMMJIMPYIOTC5IB rrOJIlIOH Mepe
H Bcer,Ll,aOCTaIOTC5IcaMHMH CO-
60H. OTHOllIeI-Ilfe K l{bIraHaM
CJIY)KlTTCBoero p0,Ll,a6apoMeT-
POM: B 06llJ,eCTBe, r,Ll,e YMeHb-
llIaeTC5I TeprrMMOCTb, HeMe,n:-
JIeIH-IOYXY,LI,llIaeTC5IM OTHOllIe-
HHe K l{bIraHaM, TaM )Ke, r,Ll,e
M,LI,eTrYMaHlT3al{M5I 06llJ,eCTBa,
onIOllIeHMe K HMM YJIYeIllIaeTC5I
M OHH MorYT MHTerpHpOBaTbC5I
6e3 rrOJIHOHYTpaTbI ce65I H ac-
CHMHJI5Il{HH. II09TOMY pOCT
aHTHl{bIraHCKHX HaCTpOeI-IlfH,
OTKa3 rrpHH5ITb H rro.n:.n:ep)KaTb
9THX 'l3CeM'IY)KHX, HO TaKHX Ha
caMOM ,LI,eJIerrPMBbIeIHbIX JIIO-
,LI,eH,LI,OJI)I<:eHBocrrpIfHHMaTbC5I
B JII060M 06llJ,eCTBe KaK Tpe-
BO)KHbIH CHrHaJI.
CerO,Ll,H5I ,LI,eC5ITKHTbIC5I'I
l{bIraH B EBpOrre HY)K,LI,aIOTC5I
B y6e)KHllJ,e. IIpo6JIeMa JIera-
JIM3al{MM MHrpaHTOB M 6e)KeH-
l{eB rrO-npe)I{HeMY Tpe6yeT
pa3pellIeHM5I. Me)K,LI,Y TeM BCe
eUre HeT HM O,Ll,HOHCTpaHbI, r,Ll,e
6bI rrpHe3)KaIOllJ,HM MJIH rrOCTO-
5IHHO )KHBYULMM l{bIraHaM HH-
KOr,Ll,a He rrpe,Ll,JIaraJIM yexaTb
KY,LI,a-mI6Y,LI,belue.
M05I HH¢OpMal{M5I - H3
,LI,BYX HCTOelHHKOB:TO, 'ITO 5I 6y-
,LI,Y rOBopHTb 0 3arra,Ll,HOH H
UeI-ITpaJIbHOH EBporre, MHe H3-
BeCTHO lI3 rry6JIIIKal{HH EBpO-
rreHCKoro l{eI-ITpa no 3allIHTe
rrpaB lLbIraH (UeHTp HaXO,Ll,lIT-
C5IB EY,LI,arremTe, HO Ha6JIIo,Ll,a-
TeJIM pa60TaIOT BO MHOflIX
cTpaHax EBponbI), TO)Ke, 'ITO 5I
C00611IY 0 cluyal{lIH B P<D, -
pe3YJIbTaT MOlIX Ha6JIIO,LI,eHMHII
Ha6JIIO,LI,eHlIHMOMX KOJIJIer no
rrpoeKTY MOHlITopMHra C06JIIO-
,LI,eHH5IrrpaB l{bIraH B POCClIH-
CKOM<De,Ll,epal{lIH.
fOBOp5I 0 l{bIraHax - 6e-
)I{eHl{ax M3 UeHTpaJIbHOH EB-
porrbI, Ha,Ll,Orrpe,Ll,CTaBJI5ITbce-
6e, B KaKOM rrOJIO)KeHHlI OKa-
3aJIHCb 9TH JIIO,Ll,M,BbIHY)K,LI,eH-
HbIe rrOKHHYTb CTpaHbI, r,Ll,eHX
rrpe,Ll,KM)KHJIlI Y)Ke COTmI JIeT.
B HeKOTopbIX CTpaHax l{bIraH
O'IeHb MHoro: B PYMbIHHlI, Ha-
rrpHMep, ,LI,Ba C rrOJIOBlIHOH 43
MHJIJIHOHa, B KpOIIIe'IHOM CJIO-
BaKHH 600 TbIC5FI, B EOJIra-
pHYI 700 TbIC5FI. HecMoTp5I Ha
TO, LITO JJ;bIraHCKHe c006meCT-
Ba B 3THX MaJIeHbKHX CTpaHaX
HeBep05ITHO 60JIbIIIHe, JJ;bIraHe
He npH3HaHW nOJIHOnpaBHW-
MH LIJIeHa~UI 06meCTBa, OHO HX
OTBepraeT. 3TO npHBo,n:HT no-
pOI-i K CTpaIIIHbIM C06bITH5IM,
TaKHM KaK norpOMbI - Ha-
npHl"lep, B PYMbUIHH, Kor,n:a
MeCTHble )IUITeJIH HanaJIH Ha
nOCeJIeHHe IIbIraH, Haxo,n:HB-
IIIeeC5I TaM ,n:eC5ITKH JIeT, H
CTepJIH ero C JIHJJ;a 3eMJIH;
60JIbIIIa5I LIaCTb )KHTeJle:t'I 6bI-
JIa y6lua, OCTaJlbHble 6e)KaJIH
B JIec, Haxo,n:5ImlIMC5I p5I,n:OM. B
LIexHH ,n:o He,n:aBI-IerO BpeMeHH
IIblraHe He Mor JIH XO,n:IITb no
YJIIIJJ;e, He onaCa5ICb Hana,n:e-
HH5I CO CTOPOHbI HeOHaJJ;HCT-
Clm HaCTpoeHHbIX MOJIO,n:bIX
JIIo,n:eM, CKHHxe,n:OB. B 1990-e
ro,n:bI no 1.IexHH npOKaTHJIaCb
orpOMHa5I BOJIHa CKHHxe,n:CKO-
ro HaCHJIH5I, Kor,n:a y6HBaJIH
,n:eTe:t'I, Kor,n:a B,n:eC5ITepOM Ha-
rra.n:aJIH Ha O.ll:HOrO; y6HMCTBO
JJ;blraH CTaJIO y CKHHxe,n:OB
cBoe06pa3HoM HHHJJ;HaJJ;He:t'r.
He MeHee TparH'IHO CKJIa-
.ll:bIBaJIaCb cHTyaJJ;H5I H B BeHr-
PHH, r,n:e 6YJIb,n:03epOM CPbIJIH
,n:Be ,n:epeBHH; 6e)KeHJJ;bI H3
3THX ,n:epeBeHb OTnpaBHJIHCb
BO <DpaHJJ;HIO H nepe.ll: EBpO-
neMCKHM CY.ll:OM ,n:OJIro ,n:06H-
BaJIHCb nOJIY'IeHH5I cTaTyca
6e)KeHJJ;eB. IIo-HacT05ImeMY
Y)lG:1CHO:t'I craJIa cy,n:b6a MHO-
nIX JJ;blraH B 6 bIB IIIe:t'1 IOro-
CJIaBHH, r.ll:e OHH nOnaJIH B KO-
JIeco Me)l(3TI-Il'ILleCKoro KOH-
epJIHKTa. B KOCOBO, B XO.ll:e
CTOJIKHOBeHH:t'[ Me)Kt~y cep6a-
MH H aJI6aIll(aJ\lH, l~blraHe, KO-
Topble 6bIJIH 6mDKe ccp6aM,
CTaJIH )KepTBaMH HaClIJIH5I CO
CroPOIlbI aJl6a IILleB, 1000 Lle-
JIOBeK 6bIJIO y6mo, 100 TbICWI
6e)KaJIO II nOJIY'IllJlO BpeMCIl-
Hoe y6e)KllIIIe B ,n:pyrllx crpa-
Hax. MHonle H3 HllX B fepMa-
HHll H ACCTpHH IIOJlY<IHJIll
CTaTYC 6C)KeHIICB npHMepHO
Ha TpH ro.n:a. l.Iepc3 TpH ro,n:a
BJlaCTll 3TH X CTpaH CO<IJlll, LITO
np06JIeMbI B KOCOBO peIIIeHbI
II MO)KHO Bcex B03BpamaTb Ha
MeCTO. lleJIbIMH CeMb5IMll ,n:e-
nopTllpOBaJlH IIbIraH 06panw
Ha EaJIKaHbI, Ty,n:a, r,n:e llX
On5ITb OTKa3bIBaJIllCb npll-
H5ITb. EBpone:t'ICKllM JJ;eHTp no
npaBaM JJ;blraH 06b5IBHJI,lITO
ero npHHJJ;llnllaJIbHa5I n031I-
JJ;ll5I no 3TOMY Bonpocy TaKO-
Ba: Bce KOCOBCKHe JJ;blrmle,
Ha XO.ll:5ImHeC5I BHe KOCOBO,
,n:OJI)KHbI nOJIycrllTb CTaTYC 6e-
)KeHJJ;eB B TOM cTpaHe, r,n:e OlfH
naXO.ll:5ITC5I, TaK KaK HX )Kll3Hb
OKa)KeTC5I B onacHocTll, eCJIll
OHII 6y,n:YT BbIHY)K,n:eHbI Bep-
HYTbC5I.
LITO KaCaeTC5I crpaH 3ana,n:-
HOM EBponbI, TO llX nOJIllTllKa
no OTHOIIIeHllIO K JJ;blraHaM-6e-
)KeHJJ;aM orrpe,n:eJI5IeTC5I llMeHIlO
He)[(eJIaHlleM rrpllH5ITb rrpe,n:CTa-
BllTeJIeM 3Toro rOHllMoro MeHb-
IIIllHCTBa, rro,n:BepraromllXC5I
onaCHOCTll B JJ;eHTpaJIbHOeBpo-
neMCKllX CTpaHax. TaKoe OTHO-
,QeMOHCTpal..\II1H s nOHAoHe
s 3all\II1TY l..\blraH - 6e>t<eHl..\eB
111380CT04HOVi Esponbi
IIIeHHe OTLleTJIHBO npOCJIe)KH-
BaeTC5I He TOJIbKO B nOJIHTHKe
fepMaHHH II ABCTpHH, HO H B He
MeHbIIIeM CTeneHH B vITaJIHH, ,n:a
H B .n:pyrHx CTpaHax D1eHreH-
CKOro COrJIaIIIeHH5I. B 2002 ro-
,n:y B pacIIIHpmOIIIlIMC5I EBpO-
ne:t'IcluIM COI03 BOIIIJIH CJIOBa-
K1I5I, PYMbIHlI5I II errre HeCKOJIb-
KO cTpaH. I1x rpa)K,n:aHe nOJIY-
LIHJIII npaBo 6e3BH30Boro Bbe3-
,n:a BO Bce cTpaHbI EBpocOIo3a.
TeM He MeHee npe,n:-
CTaBYITeJIH O,n:HOM
rpynnbI 3THX rpa)K-
,n:aH Ha ,n:eJIe OKa3bI-
BaIOTC5l 3a'IaCTYIO
JIHIIIeHHbIMH 3Toro
rrpaBa, - norpa-
HWIHllKll He OTpllJJ;a-
IOT, 'ITO Bce ,n:eJIO B
llX HaIIllOHaJlbHO-
CTH. B HaLlaJIe
2002 ro,n:a npll
Bbe3,n:e B :vITaJIllIO
6bIJI 3a,n:ep)KaH BMe-
CTe C ceMbeM rpa)K-
,n:aHllH PYMbIHllll,
npwIeM, 3Ha5I, O<Ie-
Bll.ll:HO, 0 B03MO)K-
HbIX rrp06JIeMaX Ha
rpaHllIIe, 3TOT creJlO-
BeK Bce )Ke oepop-
MIIJl llTaJIb5IHCKlle
Bll3bI, XOT5I HMeJI
npaBo Ha 6e3Bll30-
BbIM Bbe3.ll:. Ha BO-
npOCbI npaB03aIUl1THl1KOB 0
nplT'II1HaX 3a.uep:>KaHI15I 3TOH
CeMbl1 I1Taflb5IHCKl1enOrpaH}~I-
JUIKI1OTBenWI1 He Ta5ICb: ~3TI1
mo.u11 BbI3bIBaIOT no.u03peHHe,
TaK KaK OHH lIbIraHe~.
3TOT cflyqaH Onl1CaH B
:>KypHafle ~ITpaBa pOMa~, B
CnelIl1aflbHO nOCB5IIUeHHOM
rrp06fleMe HMMHrpalImr B EB-
porry BbUIYCKe no.u 3ar flamIeM
~KperrOCTb EBpona~. TaM )Ke
orry6JIHKOBaH HHTepecHbIH .uo-
KYMeHT: npe.urrHcaJIHe HaLIaflb-
HHKa Ml1rpalIl10HHOH cflY:>K6bI
BeflHK06pl'ITaH11H, Tpe6YIOInee
OT CflY)Kam11X oc06eHHo TUIa-
TeflbHoH npOBepKI1 TaIG'IX-TO
flwIHocTeH, - B LIHCfle npo-
LI11XHa3BaHbI flIO.u11, KOTopbIe
30BYTC5I3THWIeCKI1M11IIbIrcula-
M11,ynOM5IHYTbITaK:>KeTa~IHflbI,
Kyp.ubI 11 T. .u. Ho, KaK rrpa-
B11flbHO rr11IIIYT a.uBOKaTbI 113
EBporreHCKoro lIeJITpa npaB
pOMa, HaLI110HaflbHOCTb lIblraH
Tenepb 06bILIHO He YKa3bIBaeT-
C5IB rracrropTe 11npe.un11CaIIHe
06paIUaTb BH11Mamre Ha lIbIraH
rrpoBolI11pyeT paC113M, a npe.u-
flO:>KeH11eonpe.uefl11Tb Ha r fla3,
KTOlIblraH, a KTO He lIbIraH, He
MO>KeTC'-II1TaTbC5I3aKOHHbIM.
Bce :>KeB EBpone pa3B11Ba-
IOTC5InpaBOBbIe 11HCT11TYTbI,no-
3BOJI5IIOIU11e3aIU11IUaTb npaBa
HalI110HaflbHbIX MeHbIIIHHCTB 11
6e:>KeHlIeB. O.u}IH 113TaKI1X 11H-
CT11TYTOB- EBpOneHCK11Hcy.u
B CTpac6ypre. B EBponeHCKOM
cy.ue 6bWO BbI11rpaHO, Hanp11-
Mep, .ueflO rrpOT11BEeflbrYII1 06
o.uHoBpeMeHHoH .uenopTalI1111
SO lIblraII. B cooTBeTcTBYIO-
IUeH eBponeHcKoH KOHBeHlI1111
eCTbrryHKT, 3arrpeUraIOIU11t'Il\IaC-
COBYIO.uerrOpTalIl'IIO: BblCbwaTb
MO>KHOTOflbKO HH.uI1BH.uyaflb-
HO. CeMbe, KOTOpa5IBbulrpafla
.ueflO, 6bwa BbIfIJIa'IeHa KOMneH-
calIl·I5l. Cet'rLlac T5IHeTC5ITaKOH
:>Ke npolIecc nponIB I1TaJIH11,
KOTOPM .uerropnrpOBaJla cpa3Y
HeCKOJlbKO COTeH afl6aHcKHx
IIblrarL
XOT5r no HeKOTopbIM OlIeH-
KaM 92% eBpOrreHCK11XlIblraH
Be.uYT oce.uflbIt'r 06pa3 :>K113H11,
MHOr11eH3 HHX Bce :>KeCKflOH-
HbI K MHrpalI11l1, 3Tl1M flIO.u5IM
HeCflO:>KHO6bICTPO CH5ITbC5I C
MeCTa 11Ky.ua-To nepeexaTb. B
cOBpeMeJIHot'r POCCI1I1He OCTa-
flOCb KOLIeBbIX lIblraH, o.uuaKO
MHorue LIaCTO rrepee3)KaIOT B
n011CKaX 3apa60TKOB. Bce lIbI-
raHe, KOTOPbIXMbI BI1.uHMB ro-
po.uax H .uepeBH5IX, - 3TO
mo.uH, r.ue-TO rrpOrrl1CaUHbIe.
KpOMe lIbIraH - POCC11H-
CKI1X rpa:>K.uaH B P<D MHoro
lIbIraH H3 pecrry6fll1K 6bIBIIIe-
ro CCCP: Ta.u:>KI1K11CTaHa,
Y36eK11CTaHa, MOfl.uamIH, C
KaprraT. 3TO rro.uB11)KHbIe,MO-
6HflbHbIe rpynrrbI HaCefleHl'I5l,
11X He O'IeHb MHoro, HO OHH
3aMeTHbI H y HeKOTopbIX BbI-
3bIBaIOT :>KeflaJIHe cpa3Y 11X
3aKJIeHM11Tb, B LleM-TO 06mr-
HHTb.
B 2002 ro.uy B MapTe, a 3a-
TeM B 11IOJIe - aBrYCTe npo-
IIIfl11 .uBe MHJI11lIeHCKHeonepa-
lIHI1, IIIHpOKO pa3peKflaM11pO-
BaHHbIe npeccoH. ITepBa5I Ha-
3bIBaflaCb ~Ta60p~, BTOpa5I
~Ta60p-2~ - Ha3BaH11e, .ufl5I
M11fll1lIeHCIWH orrepalIl'II1 He-
rrp}WWIHoe: 3TO KaK ecmr 6bI B
.upyroH cTpaHe onepalIH5I Ha-
3bIBaJlaCb ~06IU11Ha~ . Be.ub
Ta60p - 3TO He Ha3BaHHe
KaKot'r -fl1160 KpHM11HaflbHot'r
rpyrrrr11pOBK11 11 Bo06IUe He
Ha3BaH11e'lero-JII160 He3aKOH-
Horo, a fl11IIIb 0603Ha'leHHe
Tpa.uHlII10HHOH 60flbWOt'I lIbI-
raHcKoH CeMbl1 11fl11 KflaHa.
Tpa.ul1lI110HHOrO 06pa3a :>K113-
H11,c06cTBeHHo rOBOp5I.
M11fl11lI110HepbI OXOTHO
.uaBafl11 :>KypHaflHcTaM 11HTep-
BbIO 06 orrepalIl111 ~Ta60p~,
06b5ICH5IflH, 'ITO OHa HarrpaB-
fleHa npOTYIB M11rpHpYIOIUI1X
rpynrr lIbIraH, 'lTO 06flaBbI 6y-
.uYT npOBo.uHTbC5I Ha BOK3a-
JIax H B MeCTax CKOrrfleH115I
rpa:>K.uaH 3TOH KaTerOp11H 11
'lTO 6y.ueT rrpOBe.ueHa HX rro-
rOflOBHa5I .uaKT11flOCKOrrl15I
(HerrOH5ITHO, Ha KaKOM OCHO-
BaHI1Y!: BH.uHMO, npOCTO Ha.uo
Bcex Y'leCTb, pa3 OJIH lIbI-
raHe). EIUe HHTepeCHee 6bWO
3a5IBfleHI1e MHJII1lIl1I1 0 TOM,
LITO rrpl1I-IHMaeMbIe eIO MepbI
6y.uYT TaK:>Ke HarrpaBfleHbI
nponIB Tex, KTO .uaeT lIblra-
HaM yKpbITYre HflH OKa3bIBaeT
rro.u.uep)KKY. 3c15IBfl5IflOCb, 'lTO
B rrpOTHBHOM CflY'Iae Hapo.u-
Hblt'r nleB rrpOpBeTC5I caM, 6e3
rrOMoIUH MHfl11lIHH. B HeKOTO-
PbIX MeCTax OH HaLIaJI .ueikT-
B11TeflbHO rrpopbIBaTbC5I, HO
6bIJI nOXO>K He Ha Hapo.uHbIH
fHeB, a Ha opraHM30BaHHoe,
KOlvlY-TO HY:>KHOe .uetIcT-
BMe - TaK, 60flbIIIYIO aKTHB-
HOCTb npOHBHflO rro OTHOIIIe-
HHlO K IIblrauaM LLB11)KeI-Hre
rrpOTHB HefleraflbHo:t'r MMrpa-
IIMM. ITpe.uCTaBHTeflH LLBM:>Ke-
HI1H YTBep:>K.uaIOT, 'lTO OH11
no.u.uep)Kafll1 rrpowe.uLIII1e B
C116HpM B 11IOfle - aBrYCTe
2002 ro.ua CTHX11HI-IbleaHT11-
lIblraI-ICKHe .ueHcTBHH H MH-
T11Hf11 - 3aMeLlY: I-IeJIeraJIb-
HbIe, Hepa3peweHHble MHTI1H-
rH, C npH3bIBoM PYW11Tbrroce-
fleHHH npHiliJIbIX lIblfau, KO-
TOPbIX BflaCTb ue MotJla BbI-
ceflHTb, rrOTOMYLITO3TH mo.uH
3aIWHHO KynHfl11 CBOH.uOMa.
~HCKYCCHH HA CEMHHAPE
48
UblraHaM - rpa:>K,n,aHaM
HallIeM CTpaHbI 01IeHb TPy,n,HO
r,n,e-JUI60 rrOJIY1UITb y6e:>K:mue
H HaMTH pellIeHHe CBOHX lIa-
CYIUHbIX rrp06JIeM; eIUe MeHb-
llIe llIaHCOB Y Tex, KTO Haxo-
,n,HTC5IB Cpe,n,HeM A3HH, Kap-
rraTax H MOJI,n,aBHHH KTO 6bIJI
6bI pa,n,K HaM 6e)KaTb, HO Koro
TO)Ke JIOB5IT, BbICbIJIaIOT H ca-
:>KaJOT.5I 3HaIO CJIY'-IaH, Kor,n,a
UblraH TOJIbKO 3a TO, '-ITO OIIH
Haxo,n,HJIHCb B POCCHMCKOM
<De,n,epaUHH6e3 perHCTpa.l(I1H,
rrp0,Ll,ep:>KaJIH B H30JI5ITOpe
30 ,LI,HeM.
nOCJIe Toro KaK 6blJIH c,n,e-
JIaHbl ,n,OKJIa,n,bI,Ha'-IaJIOCb 06-
cY:>K,n,eHHepa3JIH'-IHbIX Bonpo-
COB, CB5I3aHHbIX C TeMot"l
ceMHHapa. B '-IaCTHOCTH,B XO-
,n,e,n,HCKYCCHH6bIJI rro,n,H5ITBO-
rrpoc 0 cy,n,b6e npe,n,CTaBHTe-
JIeMorrrr03HUHH H3 CTpaH CRr,
rrbITaIOIUHXC5I HaMTH B POCCHH
3aIUHTY OT rrpeCJIe,n,oBaHHM
BJIaCT5IMHCBOHXCTpaH. qacTo
3anpocbI Ha 3a,Ll,ep:>KaIUleH BbI-
,n,a'-lY TaKHX 6e:>KeHueB pac-
cMaTpHBaIOTC5I POCCHMCKHMH
rrpaBooXparIHTeJIbHblMH opra-
HaMH KaK ~:i3HYTpeHHHe~, T. e.
BbI,n,a'-Ia '-IeJIOBeKa B O,n,HY H3
5I B03BpaIUaIOCb K HalIaJIY
Moero ,n,0I<JIa,Ll,a , K 06pa3Y
rrp06Horo KaMH5I: rrOKa MbI,
eBporreMcKoe 06IUecTBo, 06-
IUeCTBO Ka)K,LI,OMCTpaHbI H BO-
06IUe Bcero MHpa, TaK H 6y-
,n,eM BbIHY:>K,n,aTb9THX TbIC5I-
'-IeJIeTHHX 6e)KeHueB K Be'-IHO-
MY 6ercTBY H K He06xo,n,HMO-
CTH 6eCKOHe'-IHO cKpNBaTbC5I
OT rrpeCJIe,Ll,OBaHH5I, MbI He
,n,OJI:>KHbIoc060 060JIbIUaTbC5I
Ha C'-IeT CBoero rYMaHH3Ma H
,n,elVlOKpanl3Ma.
C. KYJlaeea
CTpaH CRr BOCllpHHHMaeTC5I
KaK rrepe,n,alfa CBOHM KOJIJIe-
raM, - TOT cPaKT, '-ITO 9TO
,n,pyroe rOCY,Ll,apCTBO,POJIH He
HrpaeT. MMeJIH MeCTO TaK:>Ke
CJIYlfaH rrpO,Ll,a)KH6e)KeHueB B
,n,pyrHe rocy,n,apCTBa, Kor,n,a
POCCHMCKHe MHJIHUHOHepbI
1l0JIYlfaJIH ,LI,eHbrH OT CBOHX
3apy6e)KHbIX KOJIJIer 3a BbI,n,a-
'-IY no,n,03peBaeMbIX. O,n,HaIW
06bI'-IHO B TaKHX CJIY'-Ia5IX ,n,o-CTaTO'-IHOJIerKO opraHH30BaTb
lIepe3 YBK5 IIpe,n,OCTaBJIeI-IHe
y6e)KHIUa B CTpaHax 3arra,n,-
I-lOM EBPOllbI. Ko r,n,a pe'-Ib
H,n,eT 0 POCCYlMCKHXrpa)K,n,a-
Hax, rrpouecc rrpe,n,OCTaBJIe-
HH5I y6e:>KHIUa Ha 3arra,n,e 3a-
T5IrHBaeTC5I H KpaMHe pe,Ll,KO
y,n,aeTC5I ,n,06HTbC5I rrOJIO)KH-
TeJIbHOrO pe3Y JIbTaTa. O'-IeHb
60JIbillHe rrp06JIeMbI B03HHKa-
lOT C rrOJIY'-IeHHeM cTaTyca 6e-
:>KeHua y '-le'-IeHueB, TaK KaK
CTapaI-Ul5IMH POCCHMCKoro ro-
cy,n,apCTBa Ha 3ana,n,e C03J(all
BeCbMa HeraTHBHbJl:i HMH,n,)K
9TOM 9THH'-IeCIWM rpynIIbl.
CnJIOllIb H p5I,n,OMBCTpe'-IaIOT-
C5I rrpHMepbl 6IOpOKpaTWle-
CKOM BOJIOKHTN CO CTOPOHN
,n,HnJIOMaTH'-IeCKHX npe,Ll,CTa-
BHTeJIbCTB 3ana,n,HoeBpOlleM-
CKHX rocy,n,apCTB.
MHTepec ay,n,HTopHH Bbl-
3BaJIa ,LI,e5ITeJIbHOCTbUeI-lTpa
a,Ll,arrTaUHH H 06Y'-IeHH5I ,n,Jl5I
,n,eTeM6e:>KeHueB IIpH KOMHTe-
Te ~rpa)K,n,aHCKOe co,n,eMCT-
Bl'Ie~. B UeHTpe 3aHHMaIOTC5I
OKOJIO30 Y'-IeHHKOB, XOT5I :>Ke-JIaIOIUHX ropa3,n,0 60JIbllle.
)'leTH 6e)KelIueB He Bcer,n,a
HMeIOT B03MO:>KHOCTbXO,Ll,HTb
B IlIKOJIY, TaK KaK MOCKOBCKHe
BJIaCTH OcPHUHaJlblIO 3arrpenl-
JIH rrpHeM B llIKOJlY ,n,eTet:lHe-
rrporrHcaHHbIX po,n,HTeJIet:l; B
JII060M CJIY'-Iae OT llIKOJI Tpe-
6YIOT H3BeIUaTb opraHbI BIIYT-
peHHHX ,n,eJI0 po,n,HTeJI5IX, He
HMeIOIUHX perHCTpaUHH. Ko-
r,Ll,a)Ke y,n,aeTC5I,n,06HTbC5Ino-
cTyrIJIeHH5I pe6eHKa B llIKOJIY
BonpeKH BOJIeee PYKOBo,n,cTBa,
,n,JI5I pe6eHKa C03,L1,aJOTC5IHe-
BbIHOCHMble YCJIOBH5I.
r JIaBHa5I 3a,Ll,a'-Ia UeH-
Tpa - COUHaJIbHO-nCHXOJIO-
rH'-IeCKa5I a,n,arrTaUH5I ,n,eTeM H
1l0,n,POCTKOB-6e:>KeHueBH no,n,-
rOTOBKa K IIpo,n,OJI)KeHHIO
y'-Ie6bI B llIKOJle. Kor,n,a pe6e-
HOK ,LI,OrOI-I5:!eTHJIH ,l(a)Ke orre-
pe)lZaeT no ypOBHIO 3HaI-IHM
CBOHX 6Y,Ll,YIUHX o,n,HOKJIaCC-
I-II'lKOB B 06bI'-IHOt"[ IlIKOJIe, y
Hero pe3KO rrOBbIllIaeTC5I ca-
MOOueI-IIZa, OH CTaHOBHTC5IMe-
Hee '-IYBCTBHTeJIbHbIM K B03-
MO)lUlbIM IIpeCJIe,Ll,OBaHH5IM C
HX CTOPOHbI. KpQl\le Toro, B
UeHTpe y pe6eHKa B03HHKaeT
CB05I cpe,n,a H, COOTBeTCTBeHHO,
IlIKOJIbHa5I cpe,n,a CTaHOBHTC}I
,n,JI5I Hero MeHee 3Ha'-IHMOlI,
'-ITO oruYIUaIOT H ,LI,pynle y'-Ie-
HHKH. K CO:>KaJIeHHIO, OrrblT
UeHTpa YI-IHKaJIeH ,n,JI5I POC-
CHH, ,n,pyrHx TaKHX OpraI-IIBa-
UHM y'-IaCTHHKH ,l(HCKYCCHH
rrpHIIOMHHTb He CMOrJIH.
n paB03aIUIlTHbIM opraHH-
3aIlH5IM, pa60TaIOIUHM C 6e-
:>KeHuaMH H MeHbIlIHHCTBaMH,
'-IaCTO HeJIerKO HaMnI HY)K-
Hble Ka,n,pbI, oc06eHI-1O IOPH-
CTOB. 3TH Tpy,n,HOCTH 06y-
CJIOBJIeHbI I-Ie TOJIbKO He,n,o-
CTaTKOMcPHHaHCHpOBaHH5I, lIO
IIoi)po61lee C i)eRmeJlb1l0CmblO KO.MUmema ~TpaJKi)all-CKoe coi)eucm6ue~ U cemu ~MUl.pau,UR U npa6o~, C .Mame-puaJla.Mu ce.MUllap06, npo6oi)U.MblX amu.MU Opl.allU3au,uR.MUno npa606bl.M U Ullbl.M npo6Jle.Ma.M 6eJKellu,e6 U 6bl1-lYJKi)ell-llblX nepeceJlellu,e6, U i)pyl.OU Jlumepamypou no i)allllou me-.Me.MOJK1l0031laKO.MUmbCR6 6u6JluomeKe nemep6YPl.CKOl.O~M e.MopuaJla~.
11CTpaXOM JUO,l(eMrrepe,l( B03-
MQ)KHbIMl1 rrpeCJIe,l(OBaHl15I-
MIL TIo::nOMY TIU «MeMopl1-
aJI:;>,Harrpl1Mep, rrpe,l(rrO'-II1TaeT
6paTbC5I 3a Ha1160JIeeBa)KI-IbIe,
rrpeue,l(eHTI-IbIe ,l(eJIa. TIpH
::nOM ycrrexH 3aIUHTbI Ha npo-
ueccax rrpOTl1B 6e)KeI-IueB H
rrpe,l(CTaBlUeJIet'I MeI-IbllIl1I-ICTB,
KaKl1Ml1 6bI Ha,l(YMaIII-IbIMH HH
6bIJIH 06BIHIeHH5I, KaK npamI-
JIO, OqeHb OrpaHHqeHI-IW. Bpewrat'IIlIHX CJIY'-Ia5IXy,n:aeTC5I
,l(06HTbC5I HarrpaBneI-IH5I ,l(eJIa
Ha ,l(OCJIe,l(OBaHl1e - rrOCJIe
qero OHO 06bI'-mo HHKor ,[(a He
B03BpaII(aeTC5I B CY,l(. '-lame
Bcero rrO,l(CY,l(l1MbIMrrOJIY'-IaeT
CPOK «,l(0 oT6bIToro» H OCBO-
6Q)K,l«1eTC5IB 3ane cY,l(a. l(a-
)[{e rrpH OqeBH,l(HOM aJII16l'I,
HanH'-IHH CBH,l(eTeJIeMH T. rr.
qeJIOBeKa Bce paBHO rrpH3Ha-
lOT BHHOBHbIM. TIpH 9TOM JUO-
,l(H '-IaCTO rrOrra,l(alOT IIa CKa-
MblO rrO,l(CY,l(l1MbIX rro cepa6-
pHKOBaHI-IbIM 06mmeI-IH-
5IM - rrpOCTO rrOTOMY, '-ITO
eCTb YKa3aHl1e BJIaCTet'I «O'-IH-
CTHTb MOCKBY OT qe'-IeHueB:;>,
a IIaH60JIee Y,l(06HbIt'r crroc06
C,l(eJIaTb9TO ,l(JI5IMHJIHUHH ce-
rO,l(H5I COCTOHTB TOM, qT06bI
rrO,l(6pOCHTb'-IeJIOBeKYHapKo-
THKl1 H rroca,l(HTb ero 3a pe-
rneTKY Ha l\1I-I0rYre MeC5II(bI
HJIH ,l(a)Ke rO,l(bI. B e,l(HI-IHq-
HbIX CJIY'-Ia5IX 9Tl1 KOM6HI-ra-
UHH cpbIBalOTC5I 6JIaro,l(ap5I
C03HaTeJIbHOCTH corpa)[{,l(aH,
KOTopbIe He 605ITC5I BMelllaTb-
C5I B npouecc «rrpOBepKH ,l(0-
KYMeHTOB:;> l1JIH «o6bICKa:;>.
O,l(HaKO TaKHe rrpHMepbI
KpaMHe pe,l(Kl1 H3-3a rraCCHB-
HOCTH POCCYIMCKoro 06u_(e-
CTBa.
HaKOHeu, Cpe,l(H npHCYT-
CTBYlOmHX pa3rOpeJIC5I crrop
no Bonpocy 0 IIaUJIY'-IIlUIX
crroco6ax rrporraraI-I,l(bI TOJIe-
paHTHOCTU H' 0 B03MO)[{I-IO-
CT5IX ,l(HaJIOra C rrOJIUTH'-Ie-
CKHMl1H H,l(et'n-IbIMHorrrrOHeH-
Ta~nL O,l(I-Il1Y'-IaCTI-UIKHceMH-
I-Iapa naCTaHBanH Ha I-Ie06xo-
,l(HMOCTHnpOBO,l(HTb pa3Horo
po,l(a rry6JIWIHbIe aKUHH H
BCTyrraTb B rrp5IMYIO nOJIel\UI-
KY C rrpOTl1BHHKOM, TaK KaK
TOJIbKO TaKHM crroc060M
MO)[{HO rrpHBJIeqb BHl1MaHl1e
06meCTBeHHOCTl1 K rrp06JIeMe
HeTeprrl1MOCTll: 11 rrpeO,l(OJIeTb
6bITOBOMHaUHOHaJIH3M, npe,l(-
CTaBJI5IIOmHM C060M 6JIaro-
rrpl15ITHYIO rrOLIBY ,l(JI5I ,l(l1C-
Kpl1Ml1HaU110HHot'r npaKTl1KH
co CTOPOHbIBJIaCTeM. l(pyrue
3a5IBJI5IJIU 0 He06xo,n:HMOCTl1
06pamaTbC5I K 1lI11POIWMrry6-
JIl1Ke npe)[{,l(e Bcero C nOMO-
mbIO rre'-IaTHoro CJIOBa. l(Ha-
JIor C KpaMHHMl1 HaIJ.HOHaJIH-
l'TaMH, no HX MneHHIO, ne
TOJIbKO6eCrrOJIe3eH, ITOH Bpe-
/lCH, TaK KaK paUHOHanbHO
()CnOpHTb HX aprYMeHTbI I-Ie-
1l03MO)[{HO: peqb 3,l(eCb H,l(eT,
KaK npaBHJIO, 06 OCHOBaxMH-
pOB033peHH5I, T. e. B KOHe'-I-
IIOM HTore a Borrpocax BepbI,
a He 3HaHH5I. O,l(HaKO Te3HC a
TOM, '-ITO Heo6xo,l(HMO pa6o-
TaTb B IlIKOJIaX - KaK C
,l(eTbMl1, TaK H C rre,l(arora-
MH, - HH Y Koro lIe BbI3BaJI
B03pa)[{eHHM. TIp06JIeMa co-
crOHT JIHlllb B TOM, qTO qeJIO-
Be'-IeCKHXH rrpo'-UIX pecypCOB
,l(JI5ITaKot'r pa60TbI KaTaCTpo-
epH'-IeCKHHe XBaTaeT.
B. Hmarnbe6
1
.lb.F.: .: ••.- -•..: •.•: ::_::....-_~_---~--_--_--~ ~ _
________________________ ~...••.••••••illillllilt.!·f:!_tt 'tr
AHTIIrJIOEAJIII3M - HOBAJI TEMACIIOPOB AHTII<I>AIlIIICTOB
H 6JIH3KO C HHMH COTPY,T];HH-
1.IaIOUrHe.
He rrO,T];JIe)KHTCOMHemHO,
1.ITOCHMrraTHH aHTHepamHcToB
)],OJI)I{HbI6bITb Ha CTopOHe Tex,
KTO 3aIIJ;HIIJ;aeT ereJIOBe1.IeCKoe
)],OCTOHHCTBO,H He Ba)KHO, BbI-
CTyrraIOT JIH OHH 3a KarrHTa-
JIH3JVIHJIH rrpOTHB Hero, KaK
3ana,T];HbleaI-TTHrJI06aJIHCTbI.
TeM He Mel-lee OCTaeTCHHe-
pemeHHOM rrp06JIeMa rrOHCKa
06urero H3bIKa, 06IIJ;ero on-ro-
mel-nIH K npOmJIOMY H 06IIJ;e-
ro rrOHHMaHHH HaCTOHIIJ;ero.
I1MeHHo 9TH TeMbI BOJIHYIOT
3arra)],fIbIX afIHlepamHCTOB. AH-
THepaUII1CTbI06ecrrOKoeHbI Y1.Ia-
CTHeM B aHTHrJI06aJIHCTCKOM
)],BH)I{eI-IYII1pa3JIH~HbIX epamH-
CTCKHXrpynn H opraHH3aU;Ht"r.
cDamHCTOB npHBJIeI{aeT ,T];BH-
)Kel-IHe aHTHr JI06aJIHCTOB, no-
TOMY erTO OHH cerHTaIOT ero
60Pb60M co BceJVmpHbIM 3a-
rOBopoM KaKHX-TO TeMHbIX
CHJI. AHTHrJI06aJIHCTCKOMY
)],BH)KeHHIO rrpe)],cTOI1T ,T];JIH-
TeJIbHaH H Cepbe3l-IaH pa60Ta,
)],JIH Toro erT06bI ou;eHHTb
KpHTHKy B CBOM a,T];pec H 06-
mmeHHH B pacrrpoCTpaHel-II1H
H,T];eMHaU;HOl-IaJIH3Ma H aHHI-
ceMHTH3Ma.
MHorHe Haum 3arra,T];Hble
KOJIJIerH-aHTHepamHcTbI 6bI-
JIM nOpa)KeHbI rrOHBJIeHHeM
ro pa3JIWII1H Me)I{,T];Y BOC-
TO~HOeBpOrreMCKHM (pOCCHM-
CKHM) H 3ana)],HbIM aHTHr JIO-
6aJIH3MOM. Ow-raKO pa3JIWII1e
9TO CTaHOBHTCH 01.IeBH)],HbIM,
eCJIH rrpH paCCMOTpemm H,T];eM
TeX HJIH HHbIX aHTHrJI06aJIH-
CTOB B KaereCTBe caMoro
a)],eKBaTHoro KpHTepHH 6Y,T];eT
BbI6paHO HX OTHomeHHe K
cB060,T];e.
HOBwe rrpaBwe Bpo)],e
AJIeKCaH,T];pa Jlynu-ra HJIH
CTaJIHHHCTbI H3 PKPI1 (Poc-
cHMcKaH KOMMYHHcTHereCKa>I
pa60eraH rrapTHH) H )],pyrHe
KpacHo-KopwuleBble TOBapH-
IIJ;H c~HTaIOT, erTO aHHrr JI06a-
JIH3M - 9TO 60pb6a rrpOTHB
3arra)],Horo rrOHHMamTH CBO-
60,T];bIH 3a BOCKpemefIHe 6bI-
JIOM MOIIJ;HCOBeTCKO}r,T];ep)I{a-
BbI. BH,T];Hble3arra,T];HbleaHTH-
r JI06aJIHCTbI, TaKHe KaK Ka-
Ha,T];CKaHrrHCaTeJIbHHu;a Ha-
OMH KJIeMH HJIH HTaJIbHHCKHM
epHJIOCOepTOHH HerpH, cerHTa-
IOT aHTHr Jro6aJIH3M 60Pb60M
3a CB060)],y H )],eMOKpaTHIO
,T];JIH Bcex JIIo)],eM, 60Pb60M C
,T];aBJIeHHeMMOHOrrOJIHCTOBH
BceMHpHOM 9KCrrJIyaTaU;He}I.
B POCCHH eCTb aHTHr JI06aJIH-
CTbI, pa3,T];eJIHIOIIJ;HenO,T];06Hble
H,T];eaJIbI,eraIIJ;eBcero 9TO JIIO-
)],H, xopomo 3HaKOMble C 3a-
rra,T];HbIMH aHTHr JI06aJIHCTaMH
HamHX KOJIJIer - 3arra,T];HbIX
aHTHepamHcToB. C POCCHM-
CKOM T01.IKH 3peHHH 9Ta ,T];HC-
KYCCHH rrpe)],CTaBJIHeTCH Ma-
JIOrrOHHTHoM, no Kpa}IHeM Me-
pe eCJIH He rrpOBO)],HTb ereTKO-
06 aKryaJIhHOCTII
3TOH: L(I1CKYCCIIII
B rrOCJIe)],HHe rO,T];bIaHTH-
r JI06aJIH3M CTaJI rrpe)],MeTOM
rrOCTOHHHbIX cnopOB Cpe,T];H
54
PYCCK11X HaU:110HaJI11CTOB11
CTaJI11H11CTOBB p5.1~aX aHT11-
rJI06aJI11CTOB Ha ~eMOHCTpa-
U:1111B feHye B rrpOIlIJIOM ro-
~y. Ho He CT011T TaK Y)K
Y~11BJI5.1TbC5.1TOMY, 'ITO POC-
C11HCK11XCTaJIHH11CTOB rrpH-
r JIaC11JI11rrp11H5!Tb Y'IaCT11e B
3T11X BblcTyrrJIeHM5!X: Be~b
113BeCTI-IO,"lITO Ol.IeHb MHOHle
MapKC11CTCKO-JIeHMHCKMe op-
raH113aU:1111aKT11BHOYl.laCTBY-
101' B 3arra~HOM ~BM)KeHH11
aHT11rJI06aJI11CTOB. C ~PyroH
CTOPOHbI, ~B11)KeI-II1e aHTM-
r JI06aJI11CTOB BOBce He IlI11P-
Ma ~JI5.1 KOMMYHMCTI1'-Ie-
CK11X OpraH113aU:11H. Harrpo-
TMB, aHa Hal.laJIOCb KaK 06be-
~11HeH11e ~eMOKpaTH'IeCK11X
rpyrrrr. O~11H 113 OCHOBHbIX
rrp11HU:11rrOB3Toro COI03a -
~cor JIaCHe a Hecor JIaC1111:»,11B
HeM Y)Ke 3aKJIIOl.laeTC5.1np11-
3bIB K 11~eHHOMYIIJlIOpam13MY
11 rrpaKTH"lIeCKOMY COTPY~H11-
'IeCTBY· qT06bI 6bITb aHT11rJIO-
6aJI11CTOM,BaM ~a)Ke He 065.13a-
TeJIbHO Y"lIaCTBOBaTb B aH-
T11rJI06aJI11CTCKHX MHT11HraX
11JIH6bITb 'IJIeHOM 06ru:eH CC-
1'11. 11CXO~5.1 113 rro~06HO-
ro JI116epaJIbHOrO rrOH11Ma-
H115.1rrp06JIeMbI 5.1 XOTeJI 6bI
rrOrOBOp11Tb a HeKOTopbIX 113-
BeCTHbIX MHe epaKTax 11 06-
CT05.1TeJIbCTBaX,KOTopble MHe
rrpe~CTaBJIHIOTC5! Ba)KHbIMH M
3Ha'I11MbIM11.
KOPOTKO 0 3ana,n:HOM
aHTIIrJIo6aJIH3Me
qT06bI rrOH5.1Tb,'ITO TaKOC
aHT11rJI06aJI113M, Ha~o IIpe~-
CTaBJI5.1Tbce6e, 'ITO CT011T 3a
paCIIJIbIBl.laTbIM IIOH5.1T11CM
~r JI06aJIH3aU:115.1:».f JI06aJIH3a-
U:HeHCTaJI11Ha3bIBaTb rrpOl~ecc
3KOHOMH'IeCKOrO06be~HHeHlHI
M11pa, CTaBIlI11H Ol.IeBH~HbIM
IIOCJIe pacrra~a COBeTCKoro
COI03a. AHT11r JI06aJI11CTbIOCY-
)K~aIOT 3arra~Hble KOMrraHHH H
rrpaBHTeJIbCTBa 3a 11X He011M-
rrcp11aJI11CTHl.leCKYIOrrOJI11THKY,
U:CJIbKOTOPOH - JII06bIM rry-
TeM YBeJIH'-IHTb c06CTBeHHYIO
BJIaCTb Ha~ M11POM. IIpOTeCT
aHTHr JI06aJII1CTOB B IIepBYIO
O"lIepC~h BbI3bIBaeT TO, 'ITO
KpyrrHble 3aIIa~Hble KOlVIIIa-
H11H rrepeHeCJIH 3Hal.IHTeJIb-
HYIO "lIaCTb rrp0113BO~CTBa B
CTpaHbI, r~e JIIO~eH Jler'Ie 3KC-
rrJIyaT11pOBaTb, 11 TeM CaMbli\1
BbI3BaJI11 BOJIHY 6C3pa60T11U:bl
B pa3B11TbIX CTpaHax, r~e TPY~
OrrJIa"lI11BaCTC5.1Bblille. KpoMe
Taro, aHT11rJI06aJIHCTOBB03MY-
ru:aeT C11TyaU:H5.1,rrpH KOTOPOH
Hepery JIHpyeMble ~eHe)KHble
rrOTOK11 pacrrpOCTpaH5.1IOTC5I
rro BceMY M11PY, 'ITO Y)Ke He
pa3 rrp11BO~11JIOK 3Ha'IHTeJIb-
IlbIM ep11HaHCOBbIMKpH311CaM,
Il CBOIOO'Iepe~b C03~aBaBIlIHM
COU:11aJIbHYIOHeCTa611JIbHOCTb.
VI HaKOHCU:, aHTHr JI06aJI11CTbI
Ilhlpa)KaIOT CBOIO KpaHHIoIO
ma60'IeHHOCTb rro IIOBO~Y He-
()J[pe~eJIeHHOrO 6y~yru:ero 3a-
'Iil~HOH ~eMOKpaTlnI, IIOCKOJIb-
I<Y OT~eJIbHble ~eMOKpaTH'Ie-
CKHe rocy~apcTBa EBPOIIbI H
I\Mep11K11coe~HHHIOTC5! B EB-
pOrreHCK11H COI03 H NAFTA,
I«)TOpble He C'I11TaIOTC5.1~eMO-
I(paT11'IeCK11MMopraIIH3aU:M5.1-
MH. AHTHr JI06aJI11CTbI TaK)Ke
Kp11THKYIOTYCJIOBH5.1)K113HMB
;lana~HbIX CTpaHax, r~e CTPO-
"a5.1 3KOHOMI1'-IeCKa5.1~11CU:HII-
.JIHHa1111HTepeCbI6H3Heca IIO-
I«lBJI5.1IOT3a60TY a COU:11aJIb-
II.hIX HY)K~aX H KYJIbTYPHbIX
IIOTpe6HOCT5.1XHaCCJIeH115.1.
XapaKTepHOH OC06eHI-IO-
(,ThIO aHT11rJI06aJIH3Ma 5.1BJI5.1-
eTC5! IIPOT11BO~ej;'IcTBHeKaII11-
TaJI11CTH'IeCKHMCTpYI<TypaM 11
()6'he~HHeH115.1M,'IbH U:CHTpbI
paCIIOJI())KCHbI,KaK rrpaB11JIO,B
:liUIa~Hblx cTpaHax - B Ce-
IIcplmH AMCp11Ke H B cTpaHax
;~,lIIa~HoH EBPOIIbI. B oc06eH-
IIOCT1131'0 KacaeTC5.1TaK Ha3bI-
IlaCMbIX mpa1-lCHal~UOl-laJlbHbIX
l«)pnOpa~uu, K KOTOPbIMaHT11-
I"Jl06aJI11CTbIOTHOC5.1TC5.1 KaK K
"JraBHbIM BparaM ~eMOKpa-
THM. B03Myru:eHHe BbI3bIBaIOT
H MHOrO'IHCJIeHHble CJIY'IaH
HeMbICJI11MOH 3KCrrJIyaTarrHH
pa601.II1x B 6e~HbIX CTpaHax
A3H.H, H 6eC'IeJIOBel.IHOey6Hj;'I-
CTBO)KHTeJIeH CTpaH AeppHKH,
HaCeJI5.1IOru:HX3eMJIH, 60raTble
nOJle3HbIMH HCKorraeMbIMH, H
B03paCTaIOII~ee KOJIH'-IeCTBO
HaB5.131.IHBbIXMapKenUlrOBbIX
TeXHOJIOrHH B pa3BHTbIX CTpa-
Hax. C rrOCJIe~HHM XOPOiliO
3HaKOMbI H )KHTeJIH POCCYIH,
r~e ~eMOHCTpaIU-[5[ JII060ro
qmJIbMa no TeJIeBH~eHI1IO ~e-
C5ITbpa3 rrpepbIBaeTC5! peKJIa-
IvIOH, a 3BOH5!ru:ero B cnpaBOl.I-
HYIO CJIY)K6y 3aCTaBJI5!IOTBbI-
CJIYIlIHBaTb KY'IY HeHY)KHbIX
06b5IBJIeHHH.
KpoMe Taro, aHTYlrJI06aJIH-
CTbl OCY)K~aIOT (XOT5! H B
MeHbilieH CTerreHH) TaKHe Me-
)K~YHapO~Hble opraIIH3aU)UI,
KaK MB<D (Me)K~YHapOW-IbIH
BaJIIOTHbIH epOH~) H BceMHp-
HbIH 6aHK, rJIaBHbIM 06pa30M
3a TO, '-ITO 3TH opraHH3arrHH
HaB5I3bIBaIOT 6e~HbIM CTpa-
HaM - CBOHM ~OJI)KHHKaM
c06CTBeHHYIO BOJIIO, orrpe~e-
JI5I5.1 HX 3KOHOMH'-IeCKYIOnOJIH-
THKY, 'ITO Y)Ke He pa3 npHBO-
~HJIO K IIJIa'IeBHbIM ~JI5.1 3THX
CTpaH pe3Y JIbTaTaM. BOJIHe-
HH5!B ApreHT11He B 2001 ro~y
- )KHBOH TOMY rrpHMep. 11 55
MBeD, H BCeMHpHbIM 6aHI{ -
He 6JIaroTBopHTeJIbHble opra-
HH3aI~HH, 3a KaKOBble OHH rro-
pot'r rrbITaIOTC5Ice65I BbI)],aBaTb,
3TO, HarrpOTHB, OprafIJ13a~HH,
CTpeM5IIU;ITeC5IHCKJIIO'-IJ1TeJIb-
HO K )],OCTJ1)KefUUOCBoeM BbI-
rO)],bI H rrOJIY'-IemlIO Bce 60JIb-
lUeM BJIaCTH, 'ITO COOTBeTCTBY-
eT HHTepecaM ¥IX X035IeB -
CTpan 3arra)],a.
AHnlr JI06aJIHCTbI rrpOCJIa-
BHJIHCb rrpe)K)],e Bcero CBOHMH
KaMrramWMH rrpOTHB BCel\UIp-
HOli ToproBot'r opraHH3a~HH
(BTO), B KOTOPOM COCT05IT
rrO'-ITH Bce 3arra)],Hble H 1'IH)],Y-
CTpHaJIbHO pa3BHTble CTpaHbI.
Ha3I-Ia'IeHHe BTO - HaJla-
)KHBaHHe Me)K)],YHapo)],HbIX
ToprOBbIX CB5I3eM,HO 3THM ee
)],e5ITeJIbHOCTbOTHIO)],b He or-
paHWUIBaeTC5I. AHTHrJI06aJIH-
CTbIoc06eHHO B03MymeHbI TeM,
KaK BTO rrbITaJIaCb HaB5I3aTb
oc06ble Me)K)],YHapo)],Hble rrpa-
BliJIa, rapaHTHpYIOmHe CO-
xpaHHOCTb HHOCTpaHHbIX BJIO-
)KeHHl'!, 'ITO HeH36e)KHO rrpHBe-
J10 6b1 K HapYllIeHH5IM HHO-
CTpaHHbIMH KOMrraHH5IMH CO-
~HaJIbHbIX H 3KOJIOrH'IeCKHX
3aKOHOB OT)],eJIbHbIX CTpaH.
Ha 3ace)],amIJ1 BTO B CH3TJIe
B 1999 ro)],y 3TH 'IeCTOJII06H-
Bble rrJIaHbI He y)],aJIC~b BOrrJIO-
THTb B )J:{H3HbH3-3a BHYTpeH-
HHX pa3Hor JIaCHt'I, B TO )Ke
BpeM5I 3a CTeHaMH 3aJIa 3ace-
)],aHHM rrpOXO)],HJIa MaCCOBa5I
aHurr JI06aJIHCTCKa5I )],eMOHCT-
pal~H5I rrpOTeCTa.
AHTHr JI06aJIHCTbI Heco-
MHeHHO npaBbI, YTBep)K)],a5I,
lITO COBpeMeHHa5I 3KOHOMWle-
CKa5I CHCTeMa KanHTaJIH3Ma
HalIOCHT Bpe)], 3KOJIOrHH B JIIO-
60M TOlIKe nJIaHeTbI H pa3py-
llIaeT Tpa/l.H~HOHHble CO~H-
aJIbHble CB5I3H rrO'-ITH BO Bcex
co0611~eCTBax. Jhlurr JI06aJIH-
CTbI OTMe'-IaIOT OrpaHH'IeH-
HOCTb COBpeMeHHOM3KOHOl\UI-
'-[eCKot'r CHCTeMbI KarrHTaJIH3-
Ma. Bo MHorOM 3TOT aHaJIH3
He HOB - '-IaCTb rrOCTYJIaTOB
6bIJIa ctpOpMY JIHpOBaHa )],e-
C5ITKH JIeT Ha3a)],. 2lBJ1)KeHHe
aHTHr JI06aJIHCTOB OTJIWlaeTC5I
OT rrpe)KHet'I KpHTHKH KamITa-
JIH3Ma B OCHOBHOMOTIIOllIeml-
eM K cospeMemIOMY 06mecf-
BY. VIx rrOJIHTHKa - rrpe)K)],e
Bcero H r JIaBHbIM 06pa30M
rrpOTHBOCT05IHHe. AHTHr JI06a-
JIHCTbI cYMeJIH )],06HTbC5IToro,
'-ITOHX B3r JI5I)],bIrrOJIYlIJ1JIHH3-
Becn~ocTb KaK B cpe)],cTBax
MaCCOBOMHHepopMa~HH, TaK H
B PYKOBO/l.5ImHX CTpYKTypax
KOMrraHHM H Me)K)],YHap0)],HbIX
opramI3a~HM.
Y crrex alITHr JI06aJIHCTOB
rrpHBJIeK K HX )],eJIY HOBoe rro-
KOJIeHHe aKTHBHCTOB rro Bce-
MY MHPY, 'ITO YKperrHJIO /l.BH-
)KeHHe KaK KOaJIH~HIO pa3-
JIWIHbIX rrOJIHTH'IeCKHX rpyrrrr
H HarrpaBJIeHHM. Cpe)],H aHTH-
r JI06aJIHCTOB rrp0)],OJI)KaeTC5I
)],HCKYCCH5I0 CTpaTerHH 60Pb-
6bI B 6y)],ymeM, O)],HaKO 0)],-
HOBpeMeHHO CTaHOBHTC5I 5IC-
HO, 'ITO He)],OCTaTO'-IHOJIHllIb
CJIe)],OBaTbrrepBOHaqaJIbHOMY
HMrrYJIbCY 06be)],HHeHH5I C
e)],HHCTBeHHOM~eJIbIO rrpOTH-
BOCT05IHH5IBJIaCT5IM rrpe)],ep-
)KamHM 3arra)],Horo l\'lHpa.
BHYTPH )],BH)KeHH5I cymeCT-
ByeT MHO)KeCTBO HarrpaBJIe-
HHMH rpyrrrr rro HHTepecaM, He
06be)],HHeHHbIX HH 06mHMH
H)],e5IMH,HH )],eMCTBH5IMH.lIIO-
)],H CTapllIero rrOKOJIeHH5I, '-IeM
aKTHBH3M YKopeHeH B JIeBa~-
KOM )],BYDKeHHHXX BeKa, C'-IH-
TaIOT, 'ITO aHTHrJI06aJIH3M )],a-
eT HM B03MO)KHOCTb nOCTpo-
HTb HOBbIM JIeBblt'r epPOUT
rrpOTHB KarrHTaJIH3Ma. O)],Ha-
KO MHorHe )],pyrHe HaXO)],5IT
TaKOM rro)],xo)], )],orMaTH'-IHbIM
H YCTapeBllIHM.
CHJIbHa5I CTopOHa aHTH-
rJI06aJIHCTCKOro )],BH)KeHH5I-
B OTKPbITOCTH )],HCKYCCHM, B
cB060)],e pa3BHTH5I H)],eM0 Ha-
rrpaBJIeHH5IX )],e5ITeJIbHOCTH,
KaK cerO)],H5IlllHeMI,·'TaK H 6y-
)],ymeM. 3TO HaCT05Ima5I rro-
JIHTH3HpOBafIHOCTb. VI TO, KaK
HHepopMa~HmIHa5I ceTb «VIH-
)],HMC)],Ha",rrpe)],OCTaBJI5IeTJIIO-
60MY )KeJIaIOll~eMY B03MO)K-
HOCTb Herrocpe)],cTBeHHo rry6-
JIHKOBaTb H 06CY)K)],aTb HOBO-
CTH B VIHTepHeTe, H TO, KaK
MapKCHCTCKa5I H rrOCTMo)],ep-
HHCTCKa5I CPHJIOCOCPII5IHaxo-
)],5IT rryur C6JIH)KeHH5I, rrpe-
O)],OJIeBa5I rrpOTIIBOCT05IHIIe
rrpOllIJIbIX JIeT, rr03BOJI5IeT rro-
'IYBCTBOBaTb HOBH3HY H CBe-
)J:{eCTb5IBJ[eHII5I.
AHTHepamHCTbI 06
aHTHrJI06aJUICTaX
KOHe'-IHO, II aHTIIepallIH3M,
II aHUlr JI06aJIH3M - '-Ipe3BbI-
'-laMHO Ba)J:{Hble 5IBJIeHH5I co-
BpeMeHHoro 06I~ecTBa. O)],Ha-
KO eCTb MHOrO'-IHCJIeHHble
a)],errTbI Toro H )],pyroro, He )],e-
JIaIOmIIe Y)Ke rrO'-ITII HIIKalwro
pa3JIWIH5I Me)K)],y )],BYM5Ipac-
CMaTpIIBaelVIbIMH nOH5ITII5IMH.
eDpaH~Y3CKIIt'r )KypllaJI «No
pasaran!» - THrrII'-IHbIM TOMY
rrpHMep, TaK)Ke KaK, CKa)KeM,H
aMepHI{aHe~, rrpII)],YMaBllIIIM
rrOH5ITIIe «KoprropaTIIBHbIM
epalUII3M",. 3HaKOM5ICb C )],IIC-
KYCCH5IMII06 aHTIIr JI06aJIII3Me
B TaKIIX aHTHepallIHcTcKIIX
)KypHaJIaX, KaK «Searchlighb.
IIJIII «Antifaschistisches Info-
___________________________ ~ ...•••.••.•••,,_!_i •••• 1111111····.· ··Il'II!o· iIJ!!I!!,""-_-'-- _
blatt:;., MO:>KHO rrpl1HTII K BbI-
BOAY, 'ITO MHOrl1e 3arraWTbIe
JIeBbIe C'Il1TaIOT aHTl1rJIO-
6aJI113M rrpOAOJI:>KeHl1eM l1X
aI-ITIrepaIlIHCTCKOH 60pb6bI.
C03HaHHe OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH
aHTIlepallIHCTOB B03POCJIO B
CB5I3HC HaCHJIHeM, rrpHMeWle-
MblM 3arraAHbIMl1 rrpaBIUeJIb-
CTBaMH rro OTHOllIeI-UIIO K aH-
THrJI06aJIHCTaM,KorAa HX 6YK-
BaJIbHO paCCTpeJIHBaIOT 3a
BbIpa)KeHHe rrpOTeCTa H HeAO-
BOJIbCTBa,KaK, lIarrplfMep B fe-
Hye, rAe MHpHbIe AeMoHcTpalI-
TbI 6bIJI11y6HTbI rrOJIHlruei1.
Ho aHT11epanuICTaM eCTb
3a 'ITO H KPHTHKOBaTb alITH-
rJI06aJIHCTOB. C OAHOH CTO-
POHbI, HX lIeAOBOJIbCTBO BbI-
3bIBaeT HaJI11'IHe B AB11)KeHHH
aHTllr JI06aJIH3Ma epaIITHCT-
CKHX rpyrrrr 11 HAeH, C APY-
rOH - OH11CKerrTWIeCKH Ha-
CTpoeHbI rro OTHOllIeI-IHIO K
caMOH KOHuerrUH11 alITHrJIO-
6amI3Ma. AlITHepaIlIHCTbI, Ha-
rrpHMep rOJIJIaHACKaH rpyrr-
ITa «Fabel van de Illegaab
H3 JIei:'rAeHa, rrpeAyrrpe:>KAaJIl1
eIl(e AO C06bITHH B CH9TJIe,
'ITO CTpeMJIeH11e aHTHrJI06a-
JIHCTOB rrpe:>KAe Bcero 60-
POTbCH co BceMH MorYIl(ecT-
BeHHbIM11 Me:>KAYHaPOAHbIMH
KarrHTaJIHCTw-reCKHMH CTPYK-
TypaMH rrpHBJIe'-IeT B HX PH-
AbI I-IaUHOHaJIHCTOBH aHTHce-
MHTOB.
BecbMa rrpHMe'IaTeJIbHO,
'-ITOaHTllr JI06aJIHCTbI He 06cy-
)KAaIOT rrpIUIUIIrrbI aHTllepa-
IlIH3Ma, TorAa KaK aHTIIepaIlIH-
CTbI aKTHBlIO AHCKYTUPYIOT
06 alITHr JI06aJIII3Me. II09TO-
MY MHorIIe aHTllr JI06aJIIICTbI,
rrOXO:>Ke, lIe BocrrpHlIHMillOT
06BlUreHH5I CO CTOPOHbIaIUH-
epaUUICTOB. 11M, 6e3YCJIOBlIO
He XB<:UaeT rrOlIHMaHHH npo-
IlIJIOrO, TaK KaK 60JIbllIIUrCTBO
aHTHf JI06aJIHCTOB rrOJIaraIOT,
'-ITOOHH :>KIIBYT H AeikTBYIOT B
HOByro HCTopWIeCKYIO 9noxy,
VI ~[X He HlITepecyeT rrpeAllIe-
cTByrOIl{ee pa3BlUHe. 11 Bce
:>Ke lIeMaJIO alITHrJI06aJIHCTOB
06uapY:>KHBaIOT:>KHBYIOrOTOB-
I-IOCTbK 06CY:>KAemnOaHTVlepa-
IlIHCTCKOH KPHTHKH, 'ITO no-
3BOJI51eTaHTHepallIHCTaM BbI-
CKa3aTbCH H 6bITb YCJIbIllIaH-
HbIMH.
MO:>KlIOrrpOBeCTII HeKOTO-
pble VIAeOJIOrH'IeCKHe rrapaJI-
JIeJIH. 11 aHTHr JI06aJIIICTbI
H aHT11epaIlIIICTbIBbICTyrraIOT
npOTHB 3JIoyrroTpe6JIeHII5I
BJIaCTbIO H 3a AeMOKpaTIIIO.
,llpyroH 06Il(eH xapaKTepIICTH-
KOH CJIeAyeT rrpH3HaTb CKJIOH-
lIOCTb H Tex H ApyrIIx K 11Aea-
JIIICTHqeCKHM H YTorrH'IeCKHM
IIAe5IM H CTpeMJIeH11e H3Me-
HIITb MHp K JIY'IllieMY. 11 Ha-
KOHeu, paBHOAYIlIHe, HaCHJIHe
H UHHH'IHbIH aHTIIrYMaHH3M
HBJIHIOTC5106Il(HMH BparaMH
KaK aHTHrJI06aJIH3Ma, TaK H
aHTHepaIlIH3Ma.
TeM He MeHee aI-ITHrJI06a-
JIHCTM rrpHHHMaIOT rropOH
ctpaHI-Ible H rrapaAOKCaJIbHble
rrOJIHTH'-IeCKHepellielIH5I, Ta-
KHe, HarrpHMep, KaK HAeH
BCTaTb Ha 3aIl(HTY HaUHO-
HaJIbHbIX rOCYAapCTB. Co-
rJIaCHO HX rrpeACTaBJIeHH5IM,
rOCYAapCTBa 06eCrre'IHBaIOT
6e30rraCHOCTb rrYTeM pa3pe-
llIeHH51 KOHepJIHKTOB Me:>KAY
CHJIbHbIMH H CJIa6bIMH MHpa
cero. ,llJIH aHT11epaIlIHCTOB
BcerAa OCTaeTCH OTKpbITbIM
Borrpoc 0 TOM, HaCKOJIbKOXO-
POIli npHopIITeT rOCYAapCT-
BeI-IHOrOrrpaBorropHAKa H 3a-
KOHa. B CYIl(HOCT11,9TOorrHTb
:>Ke Borrpoc 0 pa3AeJIeHHH
BJIaCTlr. Or JI5IAbIBaHCbHa HC-
TOpHIOrrpOllieAlliero BeKa, MbI
5lCHOBHAHM, 'ITO HaUHOHaJIb-
Hble rOCYAapCTBa HHKaK He
orrpaBAaJIH B03JIaraBIlIHXC5I
Ha HHX HaAe:>KAH He CYMeJIH
06eCrre'IHTb MHp H rrpOUBeTa-
HHe CBOIIM rpa:>KAaHaM. He
YA11BHTeJIbHO, OAHaKO, 'ITO
rrporocy AapCTBeI-IHa5I rr03H-
UH5I, 3aHHMaeMa5I aHTHrJI06a-
JIHCTaMH, OKa3bIBaeTC51BeCb-
Ma rrpHBJIeKaTeJIbHOH AJI5I
BceB03MO:>KHbIX HaUHOHaJIH-
CTOB, rrOCKOJIbKYBrrOJIHe CO-
OTBeTcTByeTHX KOHcepBanIB-
HOMY BOCrrpH5ITHIOCOBpeMeH-
Horo MHpa.
YTBep:>KAeHHe HeKOTO-
PbIX aHTHepaIlIHCTOB, 'ITO aH-
THrJI06aJIHCTbICrroc06cTBYIOT
pacnpOCTpaHeHHIO aHTHce-
MHTH3Ma, rrpeACTaBJI5IeTCH
MeHee O'-IeBHAHbIM. fJIaBHbIM
aprYMeHTOM 3AeCb CTaHOBIU-
C51aHaJIH3 Toro, KaK aHTHr JIO-
6amrCTbI H306pa)KaIOT CBOIIX
BparOB - Kpymlblx Kamua-
JIHCTOB. MHorHe aHTHrJI06a-
JIHCTbI Bep51T B cyn{eCTBOBa-
HHe 3arOBopa rJIaB TpaHCHa-
UHOHaJIbHMX KoprropaUIIH H
'-IIUIOBHHKOB Me:>KAYHapOA-
HbIX opraHH3aUHH Tlma BTO,
MB<D 11 T. rr. HeKOTopble
rrJIaKaTbI aHTHrJI06aJIHCTOB
Bblr JIHA5IT BrrOJIHe aHTHce-
MHTCKH: HapHCOBaH, CKa:>KeM,
9TaKHH THrrWIHbIH TOJICTHK
eBpeHCKoro BHAa, C rra'-IKOH
AOJIJIapOB B KapMaHe, KypH-
Il(HH 60JIbllIYIO cHrapy II aJI'I-
HO B3HpaIOIl(HH Ha r JI06yc.
KpOMe Toro, HeKOTopble BIIA-
Hble aHTHr JI06aJIHCTbI Hrpa-
roT CTpaHHYIO pOJIb B rra-
JIeCT11HO-H3paHJIbCKOM KOH-
epmIKTe, rrOAAep:>KHBa51TOJIb-
KO 11 HCKJIIO'IHTeJIbHO rraJIe-
• HCTOPHH COnpOTHBJlCUHH
<l>PAH~Y3CKHE HHTEJIJIEKTYAJIbIII COIIPOTHBJIEHHE
MAPK 6JIOK
60
CTlmu:eB, BOBce He Bcer,na
MHpHbIX.
HaKoHeu:, cepbe3Hb1M IIO-
BO,nOM,nJ151KpHTHKH CJIY)KIIT
rrpHCYTCTBIIe rpynrr epallIII-
CTOB, CTaJIHHHCTOBH JIeHIIHII-
CTOB Ha aKU:H~X aHTIIrJI06a-
JIHCTOB. B 3arra,nHOH EBporre
CYII~ecTByeT ,norOBopeHHOCTb
o He,norrymeHHH ¢aIIIHCTOB
Ha aHTHr JI06aJIHCTCKHe MII-
TIIHrH, HO npHCYTCTBHe J1eHH-
HHCTOB He Bb13bIBaeT O,nHO-
3HaqHOrO rrpOTHBo,neHCTBII~.
KOHe'"IHO, H HX OCY)K,naIOT,HO
He BblrOH~IOT. I1,ne~ «JIeBOrO
COI03a~ Bce e1IJ:eCHJIbHa, XOT~
C II,neOJIOrHqeCKOH TOqKH
3peHH~ ,nBH)KetIHe aHTl1fJIO-
6a"1HCTOB Y)Ke He BnHCbIBa-
eTC~ B YCTapeBIIIHe rrpe,n-
CTaBJIeHH~ 0 rrOJIHTHqeCKOH
JIeBH3He.
Pa3MbIlliJleHHH
B TO BpeM~ KaK Mb1 Ka)K-
,nb1H ,neHb BH,nHM peCTaBpa-
UHIOTex CTPYKTYPBJIaCTY1,KO-
Topble He TaK ,naBHOJIe)KaJIH B
OCHOBeCOBeTCKoro TOTaJIHTa-
pH3Ma, rrpH TOM'"ITOyqamalOT-
C~ paCHCTCKHe,neMapIIIII H Ha-
na,neHH~, MO)KeT B03HHKHYTb
Borrpoc: «lloqeMY, c06cTBeHHo,
MbI ,nOJI)KHbI 6ecrroKoHTbC~
eme H 06 yxy,nIIIeHHH OTt10IIIe-
HHH 3arra,na C OCTaJIbHb1MM.II-
pOM?~
DOJIHTHqeCKOe pa3B.IITHe
3aBHCHT OT B3aHMo,neHCTB.II~
.II,neH. HaIll aHT.II¢aIll.II3M He
CMO)KeT npHBeCT.II K HY)KHb1M
.II Ba)KHb1Mpe3YJIbTaTaM, eCJIH
OH OKa)KeTC~ BHe B3aHMo,neH-
CTBH~ C ,npyrHMH 06JIaCT~-
MH rrOJI.IITHK.II. I1HTepHa1l.IIO-
HaJIH3M He06xo,n.IIivl HaM, no-
CKOJIbKY06m.IIe .II,neH.II ,neHcT-
BH~ 06be,nHH~T Hac C aHTM¢a-
IlllICTal\1M Bcero M.IIpa.
DOHCK lICT.IIHHOro rYMa-
HM3Ma Be,neT Hac Hepe,nKO B
pa3HbIX HarrpaBJIeHlI~X, nopoH
,na)Ke rrpMBo,n~ K rrpoTHBope-
'"IH~M. MbI OqeHb XOPOIllO 3ua-
eM, qTO HII MbI caMII, II HMKTO
,npyroH He MO)KeT ,naTb BceMY
B M.IIpe ::lJIeMeHTapHoe 06b~C-
HeHHe, KaK ::lTOrrbITaIOTC~ c,ne-
JIaTb HaIllII orrrrOHeHTbI ¢aIllII-
CTbI.
KaK aHTH¢aIIIIICTaM, TaK II
aHTHr JI06aJIIICTaM He06xo,nII-
MO 60POTbC~ C HecrrpaBe,nJI.II-
BOCTblO - BHe HaIIIIIX ,nB.II-
)KeHHH II BHYTPH IIX. 06cY)K-
,neI-IHe II KpHTllKa OCTaIOTC~
caMbIM YBJIeKaTeJIbHbIM ,ne-
JIOM B HaIlleH rrOJIllTllqeCKOH
)K1l3HH, rroToMY H 6bIJla HanII-
caHa ::lTa CTaTb~.
T. [Jpocnepo
OKKyrraUll~ <1>paHU:lllIrIIT-
JIepOBCKIIMII BOHcKaMII B
Mae - IIIOHe 1940 ro,na 3a-
BepIllllJIaCb rr030pHoH KarrllTY-
JI~U:lleH II C03,naHlleM Ha lOre
CTpaHbI ¢OpMaJIbHO «He3aBII-
CllMOro~ rocy,napcTBa (c rrpa-
BHTeJIbCTBOMB BHIllII BO r JIaBe
C repoeM DepBoH MIIpOBOH
B0I1HbI MapIllaJIOM DeTeHoM).
DOCKOJIbKYKpax TpeTbeH pec-
ny6JIllKII 6bIJI 6b1CTPbIMII CKO-
pOrraJIHTeJIbHbIM, a oKKyrraHTb1
He rrpeCJIe,nOBaJIll Herrocpe,nCT-
BeHHOH u:eJIH rrOJIHOrOYI-IIIqTO-
)KeHll~ KYJIbTypbI <1>paHUHII,TO
60JIbIllIIHCTBO ¢paHUY3CKllX
«JIIO,neH rrepa~ BbIHY)K,neHbI
6bIJIll BCTaTb rrepe,n ,nIIJIeM-
MOH: rrOMoraTb rrOJIllTllqeCKO-
MY CorrpOTIIBJIeHlllO, ,neHCT-
BeHHO 60POTbC~ C HaUIICTaMII
llJI.II rrbITaTbC~ rrepe)K,naTb
::lTOTHeHaBllCTHbIH pe)KHM -
u:eHOHTex HJIH HHbIX KOMrrpo-
MHCCOB. CJIyqaH rrp~Moro
KOJIJIa60paU:HOHH3Ma, aKTHB-
Horo rrOC06HllQeCTBa oKKynaH-
TaM (KaK y rrIICaTeJIeH JlplIe
,ne JIa POIIIeJI~ lI.lIlI JlYlI-<1>ep-
,nHHaH,na CeJIHHa) 6b1JIlI Bce
)Ke ,nOBOJIbHOpe,nKlI. B OTJIII-
qHe OT POCCHHCKHX (nOCJle
1917 ro,na) lIJIII HeMellKIIX
(HaQHHa5I C 1933 ro,na) BOJUI
IIHTeJIJIeKTyaJIbHoi:l ::lMlIrpa-
U:Hll, BO ¢paHu:Y3cKOM «3apy-
6e)Kbe~ 1940 - 1944 ro,nOB He
6b1JIOMHOrOQHCJIeHHOH,60JIee
HJIII MeHee e,nIIHOH H aBToplI-
TeTHOHHHTeJIJleKTyaJIbHOH,nlI-
aCIIopb1, XOT~ cpe,nH H3rHaH-
H.IIKOB 6b1JIH II TaKlIe lI3BeCT-
Hble ¢Hrypb1, KaK copaTHHK
,ne fOJIJI5I ¢HJIOCO¢ II COUHO-
JIor PeHMOH ApoH H OCHOBO-
rrOJIO)KHHK CTpYKTypaJIH3Ma
::lTHOJIOrKJIo,n JIeBll-CTpOCC.
Cpe,nII lI3BeCTHb1X ¢paH-
UY3CKHX HHTeJIJIeKTyaJIOB,
6lIorpa¢II~ KOTOPb1XCB~3aHa
C CorrpOTHBJ1eHHeM, HaH60JIee
3HaqllMb1M H ,na)Ke 6JIH3KHM
MHe IIpe,nCTaBJI~eTC~ rrpHMep
MapKa EJIOKa. CaMblH Kpyrr-
HblH ¢paHUY3CKHH HCTOPHK 61
XX BeKa, OH ,n:e5JTeJIbHOY1.Ia-
CTBOBaJI B nOBOpOTe HaYKH 0
npOIIIJIOM OT JIeTOIIlICaHH5J
BOHH H ,n:HnJIOMaTH'IeCKHX
XHTpOCrrJleTeI-IHH K rr03IIaIUnO
Typa epeo,n:aJIbHOrO06Ill,ecTBa,
H,HaKOHell"BorrpOCbIKOJIJIeK-
THBHOH rrCHXOJIOrHH ,n:eHcT-
BYIOIll,HX JIlIll, MHHYBiliero -
HanpHMep, 6JIeCT5JIll,HMaHaJIlI3
JIereH,n:bI 0 IWPOJI5JX-cry,n:o-
TBOpll,aX (noBepbe, COrJIaCHO
KOTOPOMY eppaHll,Y3cKHe KO-
POJIH MOrJIH HaJIO)f{eHlleM
PYK H3JIe'IHBaTb 60JIbHbIX 30-
JIOTYXOM). BMeCTe C JIIOcbe-
HOM cDeBpoM B npOBHHll,H-
aJIbHOM CTpac6ypre - B
HCTOPHH B l.IeJIOBe1.IeCKOMH
COll,HaJIbHOM H3MepeHIIH. Te-
MaJ\fH ero l1CCJIe,n:OBaI-IHHCTa-
HOBHJIHCb H arpapHa5J HCTO-
PH5JCpe,n:HeBeKOBb5J,H CTPYK-
rrpOTHBOBec KOHcepBaTHBHOM
Cop6mIHe H AKa,n:eMHH B IIa-
pH)f{e - EJIOK B KOHll,e
1920-x ro,n:OB OCHOBaJI )f{YP-
HaJI 4AI-IH:aJIbI COll,HaJlbHot'r H
3KOHOMlI'-leCKOM HCTOPHH:9,
KOTOPbIM nOJIO)f{HJI Ha1.IaJIO
o,n:HOHMeHHOMHaY'IHOM IIIKO-
JIe, no ceM ,n:eHb onpe,n:eJI5JIO-
Ill,eM 06JIHK COBpeMeHHOM HC-
TOpH'IeCKOM HaYKH, H ,n:aJIeKO
He TOJIbKO eppaHll,Y3CKOM.
EJIOK 6bIJI nOCJIe,n:oBaTeJIb-
HbIM pecny6JIl1KaHll,eM H naT-
PllOTOM: OH ,n:06POBOJIbHO
YIIIeJI 3aIll,llIll,aTb cDpaHll,HIo
JIeTOM 1914 ro,n:a 11 TaK )f{e
OTBeTCTBeHHOH cepbe3Ho rro-
,n:OIIIeJI K CBoeH cJIY)K6e rrpH
IIITa6e f JIaBI-IOrO KOMaH,n:OBa-
HH5J, Ha KOTOpYIO OH, BHOBb
no c06cTBeHHoMY )KeJla-
HHIO, rrocTyrrHJI B ClBrYCTe
1939 ro,n:a. He,n:aBHo Y Hac
H3,n:aTeJIbCTBOM POCCII3H
6bIJIa ony6JIHKOBaHa KHHra
MapKa EJIOKa 4CTpaIIHoe no-
pa)f{eHHe:9, Ky,n:a BOiliJUI ero
3aMeTKH, HanHcaHHbIe oceUbIO
1940 ro,n:a rro CJIe,n:aMHe,n:aB-
HHX C06bITHH. KPH3HC HHCTH-
TYTOB TpeTbeH pecny6JIHKH:
KOCHOCTb H 3aHOC'IHBOCTb
BbICilieH BoeHHoH KaCTbI, TPY-
COCTbH nOJIHTH'IeCKa5J6JIH30-
PYKOCTb 6YP)f{ya3HH, KJIaCCO-
BbIH 3r0113M npoepcoI03HbIX
BO)f{,n:eH - Bce 3TH epaKTopbI
BOCnpen5JTCTBOBaJIH, CorJIac-
HO MapKY EJIOKY, CKJIa,n:bIBa-
HHIO naTpHOTH'IeCKOrO ,n:yxa,
r JIaBHOM:,n:eikTBeHHOH CHJIbI B
npOTHBOCT05JHl1l1Bpary. B Te
)f{e caMbIe ro,n:bI ,n:pyroH Ta-
JIaHTJIl1BbIM: HCTOPHK, aBTOp
H3BeCTHOM:KHHrH 4I1,n:e5J HC-
TOpHH:9 aHrJIH'IaHHH P06epT
.1l)f{. KOJIJIHHrBY,n: ony6JIlIKO-
BaJI CBmo 4ABT06HorpaclmIO:9,
r,n:e B CXO)f{HX pe3KHx BbIpa-
)f{eI-IH5JXOCy,n:HJIMIoHxeHcKH:t'I
croBop H 6pHTaHcKYIO rrOJIl1-
THKY 4YMHpoTBOpeHH5J:9 fHT-
JIepa.
IIaTpHoTH3M EJIOKa, B,n:OX-
HOBJI5JBIIIHI~iero H B rro,n:rrOJIbe,
rrHTaJIC5JHe Hall,110HaJIH3MOM,
He 'IYBCTBOM npeBocxo,n:CTBa
I-Ia,n:rrpo'mMH Hapo,n:aMH. Ero
JII060Bb K cDpaHll,HH 03Ha1.IaJIa
He TOJIbKO rrpllB5J3aHHOCTb K
MeCTHbIM HpaBaM H Tpa,n:Hll,H-
5J!'I (opraHIIIZY KOTOPbIX, OH,
KaK l1CTOPllK, 01.IeHb XOpOiliO
l.IYBCTBOBaJI), HO B nepBYIO
O'Iepe,n:b C03I-IaIUle npeeMCT-
BeHHOCTH naTpllOTH1.IeCKllX
ll,eHHOCTeH rro OTHOIIIeHHIO K
H,n:eaJlaMcDpaHll,Y3cKOM peBO-
JIIOll,Hll H ,n:yxy II pOCBeIll,eHH5J.
I1MeHI1O n03TOMY EJIOK B Ha-
'IaJIe 1940-x ro,n:OB ny6JIH'IHO
OTBepraJI llHHll,HHpyeMYIO He-
Mell,KHMH oKKyrraHTaMll H,n:eIO
C03,n:aHH5JaBTOHOMHbIX eBpeM-
CKHX opraHII3all,HM (B ,n:eHCT-
BHTeJIbHOCTH3TO 6bIJ1O Ha1.Ia-
JIOM no,n:rOTOBKH eBpeMCKoro
reHOll,H,n:a). EJ10K MbICJIHJI ce-
651B nepBYIO O'Iepe,n:b B Ka'Ie-
CTBeeppaHll,Y3a H JIHilib B CB5J-
3H C 3THM - KaK eBpe5J. B
rrepBbIe ro,n:bI oKKynall,HH OH
npo,n:oJI)f{aJI cOTpy,n:HH'IaTb
(no,n: nceB,n:oHllMaMH) B HC-
TOpH'IeCKHX )f{ypHaJIaX, HO
C 1943 ro,n:a OKOH'IaTeJIbHO
64
YllIeJI Ha rrOJIHTYPIeCKYIOpa60-
TY B rrOll:rrOJIbe. KOHCrrHpa-
THBHa5IlI:e5ITeJIbHOCTb,5IpKHe H
OCTpble rry6JIHI(HCTWleCKHe
CTaTbH B rrepHOll:HKe Conpo-
THBJIeHH5I, pacrrpell:eJleHHe JIIO-
lI:et'r, rreperrpaBIZa OPY)KH5I,
CB5I3bco CTa'-IeLIHbIMH KOMHTe-
TaMH - BCe 3TO CTaJlO rrOBCe-
lI:HeBHbIMH H CJ\lepTeJlbHO
OrraCHbIMH 3aIUITH5IMH B'-Ie-
pallIHerO YHHBepCHTeTCIWrO
rrpoepeccopa H rrbIT JIl'IBoro HC-
CJIell:OBaTeJI5I. Ho, cYlI:5I no
BocrrOMHHaHH5IM COBpeMeHHH-
KOB, HM OH OTlI:aBaJlC5IC ropa3-
lI:O 60JIbllIeH CTpaCTbIO H Ca]\l0-
OTpe'-IeI-IHeM, '-IeM K DlTa6I-IOH
cJIY)K6e HaKaHYHe BotiHbI. B
MapTe 1944 rOll:a B JhwHe
Hap60HI-I (TaKOB 6bIJl rrceBlI:O-
HHM DJIOKa) 6bIJl CXBaLIeH H
nOCJIe rrbITOK Ka3HeH - 3a
lI:Ba MeC5II(a lI:O oCB06mKlI:eHH5I
IIapH)Ka. I13BecTHe 0 rYI6eJIYI
3Toro '-IeJIOBeKa pell:KOrO YMa
H 6JlarOpOll:CTBa C ropellbIO H
60JIbIO BOCrrpHH5IJlH H epPaII-
I(Y3CKHe pa60LIHe- rrOll:rrOJIb-
mHKH, H 3apy6e)KHble KOJlJle-
rH-HcTopHKH.
IIocJIe BOHHbI ypOKH H
HTorH CorrpOTHBJIeHH5I CTaJlH
orrpell:eJI5IromHMH lI:Jl5I HHTeJI-
JIeKTyaJIbHOrO KJlHMaTa et>paH-
I(HI1, BKJIro'-Ia5I He06bILIat'mYIO
rrorry JI5IPHOCTbHMeHHO JleBbIX,
rOllII1CTCKI1X Te'-IeHHH H rrpHI-I-
I(I1rrOB. 1980 - 1990-e rOll:bI,
HarrpOTHB, CTaJIH BpeMeHeM
rrepeOCMbICJleHH5I HaCJlell:H5I
rrpOllIJIOrO, BKJIIO'-Ia5III 3TY, re-
pOWleCKYIO, ero CTOPOI-IY.BHa-
LIaJle pa306JIa'-IeHH5I KOCHY-
JIHCb P5IlI:a 6bIBllII1X '-IHHOBI-IH-
KOB pe)KHMa BI1llIH, COll:eHCT-
BOBaBllIHX lI:enOpTaI(HH eBpe-
eB, 3aTeM I-IaCTaJIa O'-Iepell:b H
JIIOll:eH MbICJlH. IIoll: orOHb rro-
JleMHKH BCJIell: 3a KPyrrHet'I-
llIHM HeMeI(KHM epHJIOCOepOM
XaMlI:errepOM nonaJI BHlI:-
HbIH TeopeTHK nOCTMOll:epHH3-
Ma aMepHKaHcKHM JlHTepaTY-
POBell: IIOJIb lI:e MaH (B IOI-W-
CTH OH I1I1caJI CTaTbH B 6eJlb-
rHHCKot'I KOJIJIa60paI(HOHHCT-
CKOt'I npecce), a 3aTeM H 3I-Ia-
MeHI1TbIH eppaHI(Y3CKI1t'I KPH-
THK H mICaTeJIb MopI1c DJIaH-
llIO, COTPYlI:HH'-IaBllIHM B KOHI(e
1930- x B H3l1:aHYI5IX6y lI:ymHx
KOJIJla60paI(HOHHcTOB. IIo-
CJIell:HHM rOll: rrpe3HlI:eHTCKOro
cpoKa et>paHcya MHTTepaHa
6bIJI OTMe'-IeH pe3KHMH crropa-
MH 0 Mepe ero YLIaCTI15I B
lI:e5ITeJIbHOCTHall:MHHHCTpaI(HI1
IIeTeHa B HaLIaJIe 1940-x ro-
lI:OB, lI:O yxoll:a B Jlarepb lI:e
fOJIJI5I. He OCTaJIHCb B CTO-
pOHe OT ,:Horo rrOTOKa 06JlWle-
HHH H epHrypbI Hell:aBHHX
~BJIaCTHTeJIeM lI:YM~. B XOll:e
UpHCTaJIbHOrO HCTOpI1LIeCKOro
pa36HpaTeJIbCTBa CTaJIO OLIe-
13 HlI:HO, '-ITO HMeHHO BHlI:Hble
(PHJIOCOepbI)KaH- IIOJIb CapTp
H: MopHc MepJlo- IIOHTYI (KO-
Topble B KOHI(e 1940-x H B
1950-e rOll:bI O'-IeHb MHoro I1H-
CaJIH Ha TeMY OTBeTCTBeHHO-
CTHHHTeJIJIeKTyaJIOB, MOpaJIb-
Horo BbI60pa H BblcTynaJIH OT
HMeHH aHTHepallIHcTclwro lI:Y-
xa) B peaJIbHbIX C06bITH5IX
1940-x rOll:OB HrpaJIYI BeCbMa
rreoll:H03Ha'-IHYIO pOJlb. IIo 3a-
CJIY>KHBaromHM lI:0BepH5I lI:aH-
HbIM, MepJIo- II 0HTYI YKJIO-
H5IJIC5I OT BC5IKOM peaJlbHOrO
Y'-IaCTI15I B lI:eJlax aHTHHa-
I(HCTCKoro ConpOTHBJIeHH5I,
CCbIJIa5ICb Ha 3aH5ITOCTb.
CapTp He rrOCTeCH5IJIC5I 3a-
H5ITb B rrpeCTH>KHOM JIHI(ee
MeCTO YBOJIeHHOrO rrperrOll:a-
BaTeJI5I-eBpe5I (lI:a eme H rro-
TOMKa 3HaMeHHToro KanHTa-
Ha .llpeHepyca!), XOT5I H caM
C'-IHTaJIC5I He6JIarOHall:e>K-
HbIM - 11 rrOTOMY 6paJlc5I 3a
JII06yro pa60TY, LIT06 HMeTb
Cpell:CTBa K cymecTBoBaHHIO.
C06CTBeHHa5I lI:I1CKYCCHOHHa5I
rpyrrrra CapTpa, KOTOpa5I 6bI-
JIa C03l1:aHa BCKope nOCJle OK-
KyrraI(l1l1 H 3aHHMaJIaCb Hap5I-
lI:Y C pacrrpOCTpaHeHHeM JIHC-
TOBOK rrpeHMymecTBeHHo 06-
cY>KlI:eHHeM Ha lI:OBOJIbHO a6-
CTpaKTHOM ypoBHe BorrpocoB
COI(HaJIH3Ma, 60Pb6bI C HaI(H3-
MOM H epHJIOcoepCKoro BbI60-
pa, paCrraJIaCb Y)Ke B 1941 ro-
lI:Y. 060 Bcex 3THX rrepHneTH-
5IX cPpaHI(Y3cKHX lI:e6aTOB no-
CJIell:HHX JIeT BOKpyr ~6eJIbIX
n5ITeH~ l1CTOPl1H COrrpOTYIB-
JleHH5I H KOJIJIa60paI(HOHH3Ma
B CB5I3H co 3HaMeHHTbIMH rrH-
CaTeJI5IMH H epHJIOcoepaMH
paCCKa3aJI I-Ia CTpaI-IHI(aX
)KypHaJIa «HoBoe JIHTepaTYP-
Hoe 0603peHHe~ (2002,
NQ 55) neTep6yprcI<YIM HC-
CJIell:OBaTeJIb Cepret'I et>OKHH.
He 060llIJIa CTOpOI-Wt'I 3Ta
KaMnaHYI5I H HCTOPHIO llIIWJIbI
AHHaJlOB. Orry6JIHKOBaI-IHa5I
rreperrHCKa DJIOKa C copell:aK-
TOpOM «AHHaJIOB~ JIlocbe-
HOM et>eBpOM HaLIaJIa 1940-x
rOll:OB pHCOBaJIa KapTHHY,
BeCbMa lI:aJIeKYIO OT xpeCTO-
MaTHMHoro H306pa>KeHH5I OT-
HOllIeHHH lI:BYX 113BeCTHeM-
llIHX HCTOPHKOB-ell:HHOMbIllI-
JIeI-IHHKOB KaK ~lI:PY>K6bI Be-
JIYnWH H TpOraTeJIbHot'I~. BbI-
HY)KlI:eHHbIH BbI6HpaTb Me)K-
lI:Y COXpaHeI-IHeM ~AI-IHaJIOB~
6e3 DJIOKa (KaK eBpet'I, TOT no
HaI(HCTCKHM 3aKOHaM He Mor
6bITb '-IJIeHOM pell:aKI(HH) H
OTKa30M OT >KypHaJIa, et>eBp
BbI6paJI nepBoe, B TO BpeM5I
KaK caM DJIOK rrOHa'-IaJIY C'-IH- 65
.;f~.*'.::.;::.:;;.:<;.i:III:::lII:.::.r;.::.::IIiIIIi::::IlilIlI::.>:.:.:::.::•••iIirlIIoIIiioo _
--------------------------:.:;;;:1 · '.
,lJ,HM IIAMJITJInOE3)l;KA B nOJlbllIY
66
TaJI .3TO He):(OnYCTHMOM KanH-
TYJI51l(HeM. B OTBeTHOM nl1Cb-
Me EJIOKY cDeBp oceHb10
1941 ro):(a HanHCaJI He TOJIb-
KO 0 Ba)KHOCTH )KypHaJIa 6e3-
OTHOCI1TeJIbHOK nepCO:tIaM, HO
H 0 Ba)KHOCTH coxpaI-IeI-IH51
ero ):(JI51 ~MoeM CTpaHbI:i>; Y)Ke
caM BbI60p MeCTOHMeHHM
paCKpbIBaeT CJIO)KHOCTb H Ha-
np51)KeHHOCTb KOHCpJIHKTa. B
HTore EJIOK np113IIaJI npaBOTY
cDeBpa H ne~1aTaJIC51B «AHHa-
JlaX:i> no):( nceBJ~OHHMOM; XO-
T51, no Ol(eHKaM COBpeMeHHb1X
HcropHorpa<poB, 3TOT )KYPHaJI
B rO):(b1 oKKynal(HH He 6b1JI ca-
Mb1M CMeJIbIM H 6eCKOMnpo-
MHCCHbIM cpeW-I HCTopWle-
CKHX H3):(aHlIM. BrrpOLJeM, CJIe-
):(yeT 6bITb BJJ:BoI:IHe merre-
THJIbHb1M H OTBeTCTBeHI-Ib1M,
BbIHOC51ceI:ILJaCMOpaJIHCTH'Ie-
CKHe CY)KJJ:eI-IH5IOTHOCHTeJIb-
HO nepHo):(a, KorJJ:a KaKa5I-HH-
6Y):(b cyry60 HaY'-UIa5I ny6JIH-
Kal(H5I 06 HCTOPHH IIaJIeCTH-
HbI nepBbIX BeKOB HaweM 3pbI
rroJJ:BepraJIa aBTopa np5IMOM
orraCHOCTH H 6bIJIa aKTOM He-
MaJIOrO JIH'IHOrO MY)KeCTBa.
B03MO)KHOCTb Bb1)Klma-
HH5I B CMepTeJIbHO He6JIaro-
rrpH5ITHb1X YCJIOBH5IX, rpaHH-
l(bI JJ:orrycTHMoro pHcKa, He-
B03MO)KHOCTb 1-la6513b16a1-lU51
CaMOrrO)KepTBOBaHH51 KaK
eJJ:HHCTBeHHoro JJ:OcToMHoro
Bb1XOJJ:aJJ:JI5IBcex 11Ka)KJJ:oro,
OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb HCTOpHqe-
CKa5I H MOpaJIbHa51 - BOT Te-
Mb1, KOTopbIe BHOBb BCTaIOT B
pe3YJIbTaTe HOBoro B03Bpa-
memI5I K OnbITY ConponmJIe-
HH51, KorJJ:a MbI 3aJJ:YMbIBaeMC5I
HaJJ: rrOBeJJ:eHHeM HHTeJIJIeK-
TyaJIOB B 3rroxy, nOCJIe KOTO-
pOM HCTeKJIO Y)Ke 60JIee rro-
JIYBeKa. OJJ:HH H3 BbIBOJJ:OB
HCTOPHKOB: He CTOJIbKO aHTH-
<paWHCTCKHe JI03YHnI VI JIe-
BopaJJ:VIKaJIbHb1e rrpI1Hl(HrrbI,
CKOJIbKO OC03HarUIe npo<pec-
CHOHaJIbHOM aBTOHOMlUI, ca-
MOCT051TeJIbHoit 3Haq11MOCTH
CBoeM pa60Tb1, He3aBHC11MOCTb
OT BHeWHHX KpHTepHeB (rro-
JII1TI1LJeCKOM BOBJIeqeHHOCTH
HJIH rrorrYJI5IpHOCTI1 Y q:VITaTe-
JIeM) 06pamaJIH <ppaHl(Y3-
CKI1X HIUeJIJ1eKTyaJIOB K Kpy-
ry HJJ:eM11 JIIOJJ:eMConponIB-
JIeHH5I. I1Me1IHo 06pa3 Map-
Ka EJIOKa, I1CTopHKa-HOBaTO-
pa H LJeJIOBeKa, Cql1TaBWero
OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb rJIaBHOM 113
rrOJIHTHQeCKHX JJ:06pOJJ:eTeJIeI:I,
H CeMQaC CJIY)KHT opHeHTH-
POM B HaWHX pa3Mb1WJIeHH5IX
o npOWJIOM, OCTaIOmeMC51 C
HaMH, H 0 HaCT051IQeM, B KOTO-
POM Mb1 )KHBeM.
A.Il.JltUmpUe6
51 CHKX, KOTOPb1MP0JJ:HJIC51
H Bb1POCB JIoHJJ:oHe, H B JJ:eTCT-
Be 51 qaCTO CTaJIKHBaJIC5IC pa-
CHCTCKHM HaCHJIHeM. OJJ:Ha)K-
):(b1, KorJJ:a MHe ObIJIO JJ:eB5ITb
JIeT, Ha MeH51 HanaJIa l(eJIa51
6aH):(a: JJ:IO)KHHa60JIee B3POC-
JIb1X Hal(H-CKHHxe):(OB, KOTO-
pbIe H36HBaJIH MeH51 rro OLJepe-
JJ:H. BOJIOCb1 Ha rOJIOBe 6b1JIH
Bb1pBaHbI l(eJIbIMH KJIOLJb51MH.
M051 BHeWHOCTb H TO, KaK
paCHCTbI Ha Hee peanlpy-
IOT, - .3TO QaCTb J\weM HCTO-
p11H. 51 60JIee weCTH <PYTOB
POCTOM 11 HOWY Ha rOJIOBe
TIop6au - OJJ:HH H3 06513a-
TeJIbHb1X aTpH6YTOB B peJIH-
rHH CI1KXOB. Y MeH51 JJ:JIHHHbIe
BOJIOCbIH 60p0JJ:a, KOTOPb1XHH-
KorJJ:a He KaCaJIHCb HO)KHHl(bI,
TaK KaK BOJIOCbI CqHTaIOTC51
CB51meHHbIM JJ:apOM. B OCHOBe
paCH3Ma JIe)KaT CTepeOTHrrb1 H
605I3Hb KYJIbTypHb1X pa3JII1-
QHM, rrO.3TOMY M051 xapaKTep-
Ha51 BHeWHOCTb JJ:eJIaeT MeH51
Ml1weHbIO JJ:M rrOCT051HHOMHe-
HaBHCTI1, CB513aHHOMC HenpH-
51THeMHe3HaKOMbIX 06p5IJJ:OB.
51 JJ:OJIroeBpeM51MeqTaJI rro-
exaTb B IIOJIbwy, '-IT06bI rrpH-
H51Tb Y~IaCTHe B Me)KJJ:yuapoJJ:-
HOM weCTBHH )KHBymI1X, KorJJ:a
eBpel1 113 copOKa rr51TH CTpaH
HJJ:YTBMeCTe C TeMH, KTO rrepe-
)KHJI XOJIOKOCT. lIIecTBHe npo-
BOJJ:HTC51 BO BpeM5I Yom
Hashoah - 2lH51 rraM5ITH Xo-
JIOKOCTa,QT06bI rrO'-ITHTbrraJ\I5ITb
weCTH MHJIJIHOHOB y6HTbIX eB-
peeB 11'-IT06b1 C06paBIIIYIeC5I CO
Bcero CBeTa eBpeMcKHe rroJJ:po-
CTKH, rroceTI1B KOUl(eI-ITpal(IIOH-
HbIe JIarep5I Tpe6JIHHKa, MaM-
JJ:aHe1{H OCBeHl(HM - EHpKe-
Hay, Y3HaJI11 HCTOPHIO .3TorO
CTpaWI-IOrO rrpeCTyrrJIeHH51 rrpo-
THB qeJIOBeqeCTBa. Ka)KJJ:b1M
rOJJ:npHe3)KaeT OKOJIO' 500 '-Ie-
JIOBeK. BMeCTe C rrOCemeI-IHeM
JJ:pyrHx MeCT, I1Me10mHX oc060e
3Ha'-IeHHe JJ:JI5IeBpeikKoro Ha-
pOJJ:a(HarrpI1Mep, BapwaBcKoro
reTTo), .3TOilIecTBHe 51BMeTC51
QaCTb10 06pa30BaTeJIbHOM rrpo-
rpaMMbI JJ:M rrOJJ:pOCTKOB.OJJ:-
HY HeJJ:eJIIO OHH rrpOBOJJ:5ITB
IIoJIbwe, H3yqM CBoe rrpOWJIoe,
H OJJ:ny - B I13paHJIe. 67
· y·'6
IIepetJ, Te;-'I KaK OTflpamITb-
C51B IIoJIbUlY, }I rrorOBoprUI co
BceMH CBOHMH ,l(PY3b51MH, KOTO-
pble 3aHHM,HOTC51 rrpOCBeTYI-
TeJIbCKo:t'1 ,l(e51TeJIbHOCTbIO rro
TeMe XOJIOKOCTa. DOJIbIlIHHCT-
BO H3 HHX rOBOpHJIO MHe, 'UO B
IIOJIbllle 6e30rraCHO, HO 513a,l(a-
BaJI O,l(HII BrrOJIHe KOHKpeTHbIH
Borrpoc: ~CKOJIbKO "-IepHOKO-
JKHX JIIO,l(eH BbI mI,l(eJIH Ha YJIH-
ue? 1> 11 C YBepeHHOCTbIO Mory
CKa3aTb, "-ITO HHKTO H3 HHX He
rrpHrrOMHHJI HH O,l(HOro. Tor,l(a
51 rrorOBOpHJI C HeKoTopbIMH
CBOHMH eBpeHcKHMH ,l(PY3b51-
MH, H OHH TO>Ke CKa3aJIH, "-ITO
HHKOr,l(a He CTaJIKHBaJIHCb B
IIOJIbllle C 51pKHMH rrpe,l(CTamI-
TeJI5IMH KaKHX -JIH60 3THJIl.le-
CKHX MeHbIlIHHCTB.
5I CB513aJIC51 C JIIO,l(bMH H3
MeJK,l(YHapO,l(HOH rrporpaMMbI
rro MOHHTopHHry epallIHCTCKHX
rpyrrrr H OpraHH3aIIHt'I ~Search-
light1>, "-wit oclmc paCIIOJIO>KeH B
JIoH,l(OHe. O,l(IIH H3 HHX noco-
BeTOBaJI MHe H3 co06pa)I{eHl'IH
6e30nacHocTH exaTb B IIOJIblllY
B COC'faBe 60JIbiliOH rpynnbI.
Y3HaB, "-ITO51e,l(y O,l(IIH, OH CKa-
3aJI, 'ITO MHe CJIe,l(yeT 6bITb
KpaHHe OCTOPOJKHbIM.
Bce MOH 6eJIble ,l(PY3b51
C'IllTaJIH MeH51 HeMHoro napa-
HOHKOM. ~Ha,l(eIOcb, OHH rrpa-
BbI, - ,l(YMaJI 51, - H Bce
MOll CTpaXH JIHllib rrJIO,l( Bo06-
paJKeHH51». Ho KOr,l(a 51 roBO-
PllJI 0 TOM, "-ITOe,l(y B IIOJIbIlIY,
arm npocTo Tep51JIH ,l(ap pe'IH!
OmI 3HaJIH, "-ITO51 6y,l(y e,l(HH-
CTBeHHbIM CHKXOM BO BceH
IIOJIbllIe: rro HX MlIeHHIO, 3TO
caMO rro ce6e ,l(eJIaJIO ee ,l(JI51
MeH51 3anpeTHoH 30HOH.
MHe paCCKa3bIBaJIll 0 rrpo-
51BJIeHH51X OTKpbIToro aIITllCe-
MHTll3Ma B IIOJIbllIe, H 51rrOH51JI,
':ITO H caM He BCTpe"-IY rOCTe-
npHHMCTBa B 3TOH CTpaHe. 5ITaK orracaJIC51 B03MOJKHOrO pa-
CHCTCKoro HaCHJIII51, C KOTOPbIM
MOl' 6bI CTOJIKHYTbC51, "-ITO B
KOHue KOHUOB pellIIIJI rroexaTb
TOJIbKO Ha TpH ,l(H51.
B a3porropTY KpaKOBa Bce
MeH51 pa3r JI51,l(bIBaJIII, HO 51 He
IIMeJI HII"-Iero rrponm, TaK KaK
3TO 6bIJIa cOBepuremro HOp-
MaJIbHa51 peaKUH51. B aBT06y-
ce, rro ,l(opore II3 a3porropTa B
OTeJIb, 51 pa3rOBOpHJIC51 C aMe-
pHKaHcKIIMH TypIIcTaMH, II MbI
XOPOIliO rrpOBeJIl'I BpeM51.
Pa3MeCTHBllIHCb B rOCTH-
HHue, 51 pellIHJI rrpory JI51TbC51
,l(0 )KeJIe3HO,l(OpOJKHOH CTaH-
UIIH, paCrrOJIO>KeHHot'I HerrO,l(a-
JIeKY· Kor,l(a 51 BOllleJI B 3,l(a-
HHe BOK3aJIa, Bce 3aMOJIKJIH. 5IrrpoHrHopIIpOBaJI 3TO H rrpo-
CTO rrpIICOe,l(IIHHJIC51 K ,l(JIIIH-
HOH o"-lepe,l(ll, "-IT06bI KyrrIITb
6IIJIeT B OCBeHUHM, ropo,l(, B
KOTOPOM 6bIJIII pacrrOJIO)I{eHbI
HaUIIcTcKHe JIarep51 cMepTH.
B KOHue KOHUOB 51 KyrrHJI
6HJIeT H HarrpaBIIJIC51 K BbIXO-
,l(Y· OrJI51,l(eBIlIHCb, 51, K cBoeMY
Y)I{acy, YBH,l(eJI rpyrrrry CKHH-
Xe,l(OB, KOTOpa51 ,l(BHraJIaCb
rrp51MO B MOIO CTOPOHY. 5I CKa-
3aJI ce6e: ~ Y crrOKOHC51 H He
rrOKa3bIBaH rrpH3HaKOB CTpa-
xa» , - CTpax MO>KeT TOJlbKO
Bce IIcrropTHTb. 5I MOJIHJIC51 0
TOM, "-IT06bI OHII OKa3aJIHCb
CKHHXe,l(aMH -aHTYlepaIlIIICTaMH,
TaK KaK He Bce CKHHXe,l(bI pa-
CHCTbI. 3aTpY,l(HeHHe 6bIJIO B
TOM, 'ITO OHH 6bIJIH OJIeTbI TaK
)Ke, KaK CKHHXe,l(bI Ha 06JIO>KKe
JKypHaJIa ~Searchlight», r,l(e
6bIJIa nOMelileHa epOTorpacPH51
HaUllCTCKoro Mapilia B OCBeH-
UHMe. OIm rrO,l(OIliJIl'I 6JIJI)I{e H
3arOBOpHJlll CO MHO:t'I nO-rrOJIb-
CKII, 51 llX He rrOHHMaJI. 3aTO 51
TIOH51JI, KOr,l(a OHII Ha"-laJIH KPll-
"-IaTb ~Sieg heil» II rrO,l(HHMaTb
PYKH B HaUllCTCKOM np"IBeTCT-
BllII.
KaK BbI nOHHMaeTe, 516051JI-
C51 3a CBOIO 6e30naCHOCTb, TaK
KaK CTaHOBHTbC51 JKepTBOH Ha-
UHCTCKoro HaCHJIII5I 6bIJIO J\1He
He B HOBHHKY. IIoCKOJIbKY 51
3aHHMaJIC51 60eBbIMII IICKYCCT-
Ba]'vIII, TO 3HaJI, "-ITOB CJly"-rae Ha-
rra,l(eHII51 cMory rrOCT051Tb 3a
ce651. 5I rrOBHHMaTeJIbHee rrpH-
I'Jl51,l(eJIC51 K 3THM 6pHTOrOJIO-
BbIM, TaK KaK y HHX MOrJlH
6bITb HOJKH HJlII ,l(pyroe onac-
Hoe opY)KHe. 5I CMOTpeJI Ha
HHX H ,l(YMaJI, "-fTO, eCJIH OI-III
aTaKYIOT rrepBbIMH, 51 cMory
,l(aTb HM OTrrop. K C"-IaCTbIO,
OHII He HarraJIll Ha MeH51. B03-
70
MO/KHO, 11X OCTaHOB11JI MOH
pOCT. KTO 3HaeT, MOEeT 6bITb,
OH11rrpOCTO XOTeJI11rrOrrpaKT11-
KOBaThC5IHa KOM-H116Y,l{bB Ha-
U11CTCKOMrrp11BeTCTB1111!Ko-
po'-Ie rOBop5l, 516bIJI He B caMOM
rrp1151THOMpaCrrOJIO)KeH1111,l{Y-
xa, TaK KaK, rrp06bIB B ITOJIbille
MeHbille qaca, ycrreJI CTOJIK-
HYTbC5I C rrOJIbCK11M,l{B11)KeH11-
eM 6p11TOrOJIOBbIX, qero MHe
KaK pa3 XOTeJIOCb1136e)KaTb.
f JIaBI-IbIM 06pa30M MHe
6bIJIO rpYCTHO rrOTOMY, qTO 51
XOTeJI Bcero JI11IIIb OT,l{aTb
,l{aHb YBaEeHlI5I B .lleHb rraM5I-
T11 XOJIOKOCTa, a He BB5I3bI-
BaTbC5I B rrOTeHu11aJIbHbIe ,l{pa-
K11 co CK11HXe,l{aM11.ITo ::HOH
rrp11q11He 51 6bIJI oc06eHHO
6,l{11TeJIbHbIM. 5I ,l{OJIEeH 6bIJI
rrOCTapaThC5I He rrorraCTb B He-
rrp1151THOCT1111COXpaH11Tb 60,l{-
POCTb H crrOl<OHCTB11e,l{yxa.
B ueHTpe rop0,l{a, KY,l{a 51
3aTeM OTrrpaB11JIC5I,6bIJIO MHO-
ro 6eJIbIX TYP11CTOB-eBporreH-
ueB. lIecTI-IO Mory CKa3aTb, qTO
3a ,l{OJIr11e rO,l{bI 51 CTaJI 3KC-
rrepTOM B Borrpoce 0 TOM, 113
JII060rrbITCTBa Ha Te651r JIa3eeT
qeJIOBeK 11JI11rrOTOMY, qTO OH
paC11CT.BOT qTO CO MHOH rrpo-
1130IIIJIO.
MeH5I pa3r JI5I,l{bIBaJIH Bce
rrpoxO/K11e. Ha MeH5I Kp11qaJ!l'[,
063bIBa51 BceB03MOEHbIM11 pa-
C11CTCK11M11KJIWIKaM11 Ha pa3-
HbIX eBpOrreHCK11X 513bIKax.
MeH5I 3aCTaBJI5IJIH qYBCTBO-
BaTh ce651 He,l{OqeJIOBeKOM
rrpOCTO rrOTOMY, '-ITO51C11KX11,
eCJIH H,l{T11,l{0 KOHUa, e,l{11HCT-
BeliHbIH He6eJIbIH B 11X rrOJIe
3peHH5I. HeCMOTp51 Ha OC-
Kop6JIeHH5I, 51xpa6po rrp0,l{OJI-
EaJI CBOH rrYTb, 11 TYT rro,l{O-
IIIJIH ,l{Ba rrOJI5IKa 11 rrpOCTO
rrJIIOHYJI11 MHe B JI11UO. 5I no-
,l{YMaJI C HpOH11eH: %O'-IapOBa-
TeJIbHO... 3nI, rro KpaHHeii Me-
pe, OTKpOBeHHbI>'>.
ATl\JOccPepa 6bIJIa O'-IeHb
HarrpmKeHHOH, 113TO 6bIJI rro-
HaCT05lIIIeMY T5IEeJIbIH ,l{JI5I
MeH5I OrrbIT, 113Tex, qTO rrO,l{pbI-
BaIOT ,l{OBep11e 11 JII060Bb K
JIIO,l{51M.%He C0611paIOCb YCTY-
rraTh 3T11M TBep,l{oJI06bIM pa-
C11CTaM>,>,- ,l{YMaJI 51 11 rrpo-
,l{OJIEaJI 6PO,l{HTb rro ropo,l{Y,
XOT5I ,l{eJIO Mor JIO rrp11H5ITb
orraCHbIH 060pOT. XOTeJIOCb
,l{OKa3aTb, qTO 11MMeH5I He 3a-
rryraTh 11 He 3anpeT11Tb -
rrp5lMO HJI11 KOCBeHHO - rre-
pe,l{BHraTbC5I CB060,l{HO.
5I CBepHYJI Ha OtJ;HY11360-
KOBbIX YJIOqeK, 11MHe rrOKa3a-
JIOCb, '-ITO51B11EY ,l{YPHOH COIL
K MoeMY YEacy, Ha CTeHax B11-
ceJI11 aHT11CeM11TCK11enJIaKaTbI
C 11306paEeH11eM f11TJIepa CO
BCKHHYTOH PYKOH. 5I qYBCTBO-
BaJI ce651 r JIy60KO OCKop6JIeH-
HbIM.
3aTeM 51 OTrrpaB11JIC5I ,l{0-
MOH, peIII11B npo ce651, qTO Ha
3TOT ,l{eHb xpa6pOCT11 XBaT11T.
CTaHOBHJIOCb TeMHO. B OTeJIe
51CB5I3aJIC5ICOCB011MKOHTaKT-
HbIM JI11UOMB BapillaBe, MbI3a-
nJIaHHpOBaJIH BCTpeTHThC5I Ha
CJIe,l{YIOIII11H,l{eHb B OCBeHuH-
Me. 5I paCCKa3aJI 3TOH )KeH-
IIIHHe 11CTOPHIOCO CK11HXe,l{a-
M11, H OHa nOCOBeTOBaJIa 6bITb
OqeHb OCTOP0)KHbIM. OHa pac-
CKa3aJIa, qTO CK11HXe,l{bIHarra-
JI11Ha ,l{BYX ,l{eBOqeK H3 rpyrr-
rrbI eBpeHCK11X rrO,l{pOCTKOB,
nOCeIIIaBIII11X C11Harory B Bap-
IIIaBe; TOr,l{a OTMeqaJIC5I .lleHb
He3aB11C11MOCTH,11HaU110HaJI11-
CT11qeCKHe qYBCTBa 6bIJIH 3a-
MeTHO rrO,l{orpeTbI.
B peCTopaHe npH OTeJIe 51
3aKa3aJI BereTap11aHCKYIO e,l{Y:
)KapeHYIO KapTOlliKY 116YThIJI-
Ky rrerrCI1-KOJIbI. 5I C11,l{eJIH OT-
,l{bIXaJI, I1 TYT rrapa, CH,l{51IIIa5I3a
coce,l{HI1M CTOJIHKOM, HaqaJIa
BbIKp11KHBaTb MHe qTO-TO
OCKop611TeJIbHOe rrO-rrOJIbCKH.
OH11 rrOKa3bIBaJI11 Ha MOIO 60-
P0,l{Y I1 TIOp6aH 11, rrO-BH,l{HMO-
MY, XOTeJIH,qT06bI5I CH5IJITIOP-
6aH. lITO 11HTepeCHO, 0cPHu11-
aHTKa rrpOCTO CT05lJIa P5l,l{OM C
H11M11I1 He rrbITaJIaCb OCTaHO-
B11TbrrOTOK OCKop6JIeHHH. IIo-
BepbTe MHe, 51 e,l{Ba JIH 6bIJI
Y,l{HBJIeH! 5I He Mor ,l{a)Ke OTBe-
THTb HM, TaK KaK He rOBOpIO
rrO-nOJIbCKH. LIepe3 HeKOTopoe
BpeM5I 3THM JIIO,l{51M,KOTopble
TaK OClwp6HJI11 MOlO peJIHrII03-
HYIO BHelliHOCTb, Ha,l{OeJIO PY-
ranc5I H OHH OCTaBHJII1rronbIT-
KH BbIBecnI MeH5I H3 ce651.
IIocJIe I3cero 3Toro Ha rro-
e3,l{e exaTb He XOTeJIOCb. KTO
6bI Mor rropY'-IHTbC5I, '-ITOTaM He
6Y,l{eT CKHHXe,l{OI3? B rrpo-
IIIJIOM 6p11TOrOJI0I3ble Cbe3)Ka-
JIHCb I3 OCBeHUHM Ha ,l{eMOHCT-
paUHH C ueJIbIO rrp11BJIeqb BH11-
Mal-IHenpeccbI H, rJIaBlIOe, ,l{Oca-
,l{HTb eBpeHcKoMY co06IIIecTBY·
I1TaK, H3 '-IYBcTBa caMOCO-
xpaHeHH5I 51peIIIHJI B351TbTaK-
CH. DOJIbIIIYIO '-IaCTb cBoei::'rC03-
HaTeJIbHOH E113HH 51rOTOBHJIC5I
K 3ToI:'I rrOe3,l{Ke, H MHe XOTe-
JIOCb ,l{06paTbc5I ,l{0 MeCTa ue-
JIbIM H HeBpe,l{HMbIM.
Ha CJIe,l{YIOlUHI:'I ,l{eI-Ib 51
npocrrYJIc5I parro H )K,l{aJI, rrOKa
rrpH6y.n;eT Moe TaKCH. BO,l{H-
TeJIb OKa3aJIC5I OqeHb ,l{PYEe-
JII06HbIM. MHe rraKoHeU-To
Y,l{aJIOCb HeMHoro oCMoTpeTb
,l{OCTorrpHMeqaTeJIbHOCTH, He
605lCb, qTO KTO-HH6y.n;b pac-
KBaC11TMHe JIHUO TOJIbKO rro-
TOMY, '-ITO51CHKX. 5I 6bIJI rrOJI-
HOCTbIO rrorpYEeH B MbICJI110
,l{He, KOToporo TaK .n;oJIro 71
it!W" t$llSt'TlYtWtr'tT f· hn
72
)I<.n;aJI.Ha no.n;"be3.n;eK OCBeH-
I(HMY .n;0po)KHble 3HaKH 6bIJIH
pa3pHCOBaHbI aHTHceMHTCKH-
MH rpacj)(j:n'lTH, H306pa)I{aIOII(H-
MH 3Be3.n;y lI:aBYr.n;a,BHC51lI(YIO
Ira BHCeJIYrI(e. EbIJIO 60JIbHO
cMoTpeTb Ha 3TO OTI<pbIToe
rrp051BJIeHHe HeHaBHCTH K eB-
pe5lM B KOHlle 1990-x ro.n;oB.
HaKoHell 51 BOmeJI B rre-
qaJIbHO 3HaMeHHTwe BopoTa
OCBeHI(HMa. llaCTb eBpet'[-
CKIIX no.n;pocTKOB npHeXaJIa
3a HeKoTopoe BpeM5l nepe.n;
UlecTBHeM, QT06bI noceTHTb
MeMOpHaJI. JIHqHOe HMYlI(ecT-
BO eBpeeB, HX BOJIOCbI,BbICTaB-
JIeHHble B BHTpHHax MY3e51,
rrpe.n;cTaBJI51JIHC060H no- Ha-
CT05llI(eMY .n;ymepa3.n;HpaIOIllee
3peJIHII{e. 51 6bIJI rrepenOJII-IeH
CKop6bIO. O.n;HH3KcnOHaT 6y-
KBaJIbHO 3aCTaBHJI MeWI nJIa-
KaTb: BH.n; .n;eTcKot'r o.n;e)K.n;bI
rrpWIHH5IJI HaCT05llI(ee cTpa.n;a-
HHe. 51 .n;oJIro pa3MbIlliJI51JI 0
.n;eTcKHx cy.n;b6ax. 3aTeM 51
rromeJI nOKJIOHHTbC51 CTeHe
cMepTH, Y KOTOPOH6bIJIO Ka3-
HeHO MHoro nOJI51KOB.TaK )I{e
CHJIbHO MeH5l rrOTp5lC BH.n; ne-
"'-IeHB JIarepe.
C06paJIOCb MHoro 0PTO-
.n;oKCaJIbHbIX eBpeeB co Bcero
cBeTa, OHHMOJIHJIHCbHa .n;peB-
HeeBpeHCKOM 513bIKe. lI:JI51 Me-
H51 npHcYTcTBOBaTb Ha lI:He
rraM5ITH XOJIOKOCTa 6bIJIO
60JIblliHM .n;YllieBHbIM rroTp51-
ceHHeM. Tpy.n;HO nepe.n;aTb
CJIOBaMH MOH "'-IYBcTBa, HO 51
.n;OJI)I{eH6bIJI Qepe3 3TO npOH-
TH, qT06bI oT.n;aTbJ{aHb naM51TH
TeM, KTOrronr6.
~He HaKoHell y.n;aJIOCb
BCTpeTHTbc51 co CBOHM KOH-
TaKTHbIM JIHI{OM - HHPOH,
KOTopa51 .n;OJI)I{Ha 6bIJIa pac-
CKa3aTb MHe 06 OCTaJIbHbIX
C06bITH51X 3Toro .n;H51. OHa
6bIJIa O"'-IeHb.n;06pa co MI-Iati H
rrOCOqYBcTBOBaJIa MOHM 3JIO-
KJIIO"'-IeHH5lM.~O)I{eTe JIH BbI
rrpe.n;craBHTb, "'-ITO3Ha"'-IHTHC-
rrbITaTb Ha ce6e paCHCTCKoe
OTHOllieHHe H He HMeTb HHKO-
ro, C KeM MO)KHO6bIJIO 6bI rro-
.n;eJIHTbC513THM? 51 n06JIaro-
.n;apHJI ee 3a TO, qTO aHa no-
3BOJIHJIa MHe npHH51Tb yqa-
CHIe B nOMHHaJIbHOH cJIY)K6e,
KOTopa51 .n;OJI)I{Ha6bIJIa COCTO-
51TbC51 B EHpKeHay. HHpa
6eCnOKOHJIaCb 0 MoeH 6e30-
rraCHOCTHH nOCOBeTOBaJIa.n;o-rOBOpHTbC5I C TaKcH, qT06w
OHO Ha BC51KHHCJIY"'-IaH)I{.n;aJIO
MeH51B EHpKeHay. EOJIblliHH-
CTBO eBpeHcKHX no.n;pocTKOB
rrpHeXaJIH B aBT06ycax, B Ka-
)I{.n;OMH3 KOTOPbIX 6bIJIH ox-
paHHHKH. CTapmHt'r ocjmI(ep
oxpaHbI CKa3aJI, qT06bI 51 He
6po.n;HJI HHr.n;e B O.n;HHo"'-IecT-
Be. OH BeJIeJI MHe .n;ep)I{aTbC51
B cepe.n;HHe meCTBH51. 51 no-
CJIe.n;OBaJIero COBeTY.
~bI C06HpaJIHCb B KOJIOH-
HY .n;JI51 ~e)I{AYHapo.n;Horo
weCTBH51 )I{HBYlI(HX, H 51 BH-
.n;eJI BOKpyr ce65l MHO)I{eCTBO
.n;pY)I{eJII06HbIX JIHI(. 51 "'-IYB-
CTBOBaJI ce65l nO-HaCT05llI(e-
MY JIerKO B OKpY)KeHHH eB-
pet'rcKoro 06lI(eCrBa. 3TH
JIIO.n;H6bIJIH KaK OAHa 60JIb-
wa5l ceMb51, H HH OT Koro H3
HHX He HCXOAHJIO HeHaBHC-
TH. lI:YMaIO, HeKOTopble H3Y-
MHJIHCb, YBHAeB CHKxa, npH-
HHMaIOlI(erO yqaCTYre B HX
UleCTBHH. TOJIbKO npeA-
CTaBbTe ce6e: TbIC51"'-IHeBpeeB
H OAHH CHKX! H3paHJIbCKHe
no.n;pOCTKH nOAOWJIH Ccj:>OTO-
rpacj:>HpOBaTbC51 co MHOH, H
HaM 6bIJIO TaK)I{e OqeHb HH-
TepeCHO 6eceAOBaTb .n;pyr C
.n;pyrOM. ~eH5l Aa)I{e CHHMa-
JIH Ha BHAeo.
Ka)I{.n;bIHnOApOCTOK,npeA-
CTaBJI5IBWHHKaKYIO-JIH60CTpa-
HY, Aep)KaJI CBOHHallHOHaJIb-
HbIH cj:>JIar.~He BbmaJIa qeCTb
rrpeACTaBJI5lTb BeJIl'1K06pHTa-
HHIO, TaK KaK B 3TOMro.n;y HH-
KTO H3 MOHX corpa)I{AaH He
npHeXaJI Ha IlleCTBYle. Bo
r JIaBe IllecTBH5l WJIH H3pa-
HJIbCKHe nOApocTKH. 51 pe-
WHJI, qTO To)Ke XOqy HATH BI1e-
pe.n;H rrOCJIe Bcero Toro KOlli-
Mapa, KOTopblt'r 51HCnbITaJI, .n;o-6Hpa5ICb CIo.n;a.
P51.n;OM C rrOApOCTKaMH
mJIH Te, KTO nepe)I{HJI XOJIO-
KOCT; OHH paCCKa3bIBaJIH MO-
JIOAe)KH 0 CBoeM npOWJIOM -
o TOM, qTO 6y.n;YlI(He rrOKOJIe-
HH51He .n;OJI)I{IIbI3a6bIBaTb.
HY)KHO 6bIJIO npOHTH
rreWKOM .n;BeMHJIH OT OCBeH-
I(lIMa .n;o EHpKeHay, - 3TO
6bIJIO r JIaBHOe C06bITYre AH51.
Bce MbI C06paJIHCb B OCBeH-
I(HMe, "'-IT06bI npOAeJIaTb TOT
)I{e nYTb, "'-ITO1'16eC"'-IHCJIeIiHble
eBpeH, KOTOPbIX rFlaJIH ~Map-
weM CMepTH» B ra30Bble Ka-
MepbI EHpKeHay.
Ka)I{.n;blt'r HCTIbITbIBaJI I(e-
JIYIO raMMY "'-IYBCTB.~Honre
rro.n;pOCTKH 06HHMaJIH .n;pyr
.n;pyra, qTo6blrrpH060.n;PHTbC51,
HeKOTopble 6bIJIH MOJIqaJIHBbI
H THXO )I{.n;aJIHHa"'-IaJIaUleCT-
ElI5I. EbIJI AaH CHrHaJI K Ha"'-Ia-
JIY, H Bce MbI Me.n;JleHHOTPO-
HYJIHCb B nYTb. 51 Ha"'-IaJIMO-
JIHTbC51npo ce65I, APynle Ha-
rreBaJIH rreCHH 0 MHpe. 51 3a-
MeTHJI rpacj:>cj:>HTH,CAeJIaHHble
HeOHaI(HCTaMH. O.n;Ha Ha.n;-
TIHCb r JIaCHJIa: ~HeMeI(KHH
KYJIbTYPHbIH I(eHTp~ - H
CTpeJIKa, YKa3bIBaIOlI(a51 Ha
OCBeHI(HM. 51 rrpo.n;OJI)I{aJI
H.n;TH, YCTpeMJI5I51 Bce CBOH 73
MbICJHI K rrOrIr6IIIHM B KaTa-
CTpOepe.
O,lJ,Ha)KeHIlIHHa, rrepe)KHB-
IIIa51 XOJIOKOCT, IIIJIa OKOJIO
MerI5I, BCrrOMHHaJIa CBoe rrpo-
UIJIoe H pa3rOBapHBaJIa C ,lJ,e-
BO'-IKaMH, Be,lJ,YIlI:HlvlHee rro,lJ,
PYKH.
Bce rrO,lJ,,lJ,ep)KHBaJI¥I,lJ,Pyr
,lJ,Pyra. EBpe~CKa51 oxpaua
6bIJIa ua BH,lJ,Y. Y cTaplUero
oepHuepa, C KOTOPbIM 51rOBO-
PHJI, 6bIJI 6HHOKJIb, H OH CMOT-
peJI llepe3 3a60pbI B,lJ,OJIb.l(0-
porH, ue cKpbIBaeTc51JIH 3a UH-
MH KaKa51-JIH60 orraCHOCTb. 51TO)Ke ,lJ,ep)KaJIyxo BOCTPO --
CBoero p0,lJ,a YCJIOBHbI~ peep-
JIeKC, Bblpa60TaBlUHt'rc51 BO
BpeM51 ;:'lT0~ rrOe3,lJ,KH,TaK KaK
51 rrYTelUecTBOBaJI B O,lJ,HHO'-Ie-
CTBe.
ITPHCYTCTBOBaJla TaK)Ke
rrOJIbCKM "rIOJIHUH51:oua ,lJ,OJI)K-
ua 6bIJIa He ,lJ,OrrYCTHTbCTOJIK-
HOBeuH51C HeOHaUHCTaMH, KO-
Topble KOr,lJ,a-TO yrpO)KaJIH,
'-ITO Uarra,lJ,YT Ha eBpe~CKHX
rrO,lJ,pOCTKOB.MbI rrpH6JIH)Ka-
JIHCb K BXO,lJ,YB .6HpKeHay.
Cep,lJ,ue Y MeH513a6HJIOCb 6bI-
CTpee. Kor,lJ,a MbI BOlUJIH, 51
6bIJI B CJIe3ax. 51 BH,lJ,eJI,lJ,eBO'-I-
Ky-rrO,lJ,pOCTKa, KOTopa51 rrJla-
KaJIa, JIe)Ka Ha )KeJIe3HO,lJ,0-
PO)KHbIX rrYT51X. ITO,lJ,06HbIX
XBaTaIOIlIHX 3a )KHBOe cueH
6bIJIO MHO)KeCTBO. O,lJ,Horo
CTapHKa rrpHlUJIOCb rrO,lJ,XBa-
THTb rro,lJ, PYKH - OH ue Mor
H,lJ,TH6e3 rrOCTopOHHe~ rrOMO-
IlIH. ITcHXOJIOrWleCI<H Bce 3TO
6bIJIO O'-IeHb T51)KeJIO.MHorHe,
BKJIIO'-IM MeH51,MOJIHJIHCb,rro-
Ka lUJIH rro peJIbCaM ,lJ,0pa3Ba-
JIHH ra30BbIX KaMep.
OCBeHUHM - .6HpKeHay
6bIJI caMbIM 60JIblUHM KOH-
ueHTpaUHOtIHblM JIarepeM, rro-
CTpoeHHbIM UaI.rHCTa~IH. MbI
Bce xpaI-IHJIH i\fOJI'-laHHe. ITo-
MHHaJIbUa51 i\lOJIHTBa '-UITa-
JIaCb Ha :YIBpHTe Ha MeCTe 0,lJ,-
liO~ H3 ra30BbIX KaMep.
BblcTyrramr rrO,lJ,poCTKI1
H3 pa3HbIX cTpaH, OrHI 3a'-lH-
TbIBaJIH crrHCOK H3BeCTHbIX
)KepTB. HeI{QTopble rOBopH-
JIH TpOraTeJIbHble pe'-HI.
O,lJ,:YIHH3 BblcTyrraBlUHx CKa-
3aJI, '-ITOHe rrpOUIJIO H 50 JIeT,
KaK Y)Ke CTam'I rr051BJI51TbC51
Te, KTO YTBep)K,lJ,aeT, '-ITO Xo-
JIOKOCTa Bo0611Ie He 6bIJIO.
OH ,lJ,06aBHJI, '-ITO epH3Wle-
CKHe ,lJ,OKa3aTeJIbCTBa 3TO~
Tpare,lJ,HH He Be'-IHbI H '-ITOMbI
He ,lJ,OJI)KHbI rmI{Qr,lJ,a 3a6bI-
BaTb 0 TOM, '-ITO 3,lJ,eCbrrpo-
H30lUJIO. MHe 6bIJIO rrpH51THO
YBH,lJ,en Cpe,lJ,H ,lJ,pyrHx epJIa-
rOB rrOJIOTHHllIe C Ha,lJ,rrHCbIO
~ITOJIbCKHe ,lJ,PY3b51 .I13pa-
HJI51~.
IIocJIe 3Toro Ka)K,lJ,bI~CMor
nO,lJ,O~TH K MeMOpHaJIbHOMY
MeCTY· 5I yrraJI Ha KOJIeHH y
pa3BaJIHH ra30BblX KaMep H
MOJI'-IarrJIaKa.JI.51 MOJIHJIC513a
1I0JITOpa MHJIJIHOHaeBpeeB CO
Bce~ EBporrbI, KOTopble rrorII6-
JIH 3,lJ,eCb.51 rrOKJI51JIC51HHKO-
r,lJ,a He 3a6bIBaTb Toro, '-ITO
UPOH30lUJIO,H 60POTbC51C TO~
neHaBHCTbIO, KOTopa51 CTaJIa
IIpH'-mHO~ CMepTH 60JIee '-IeM
lIIeCTH MHJIJIHOHOBeBpeeB. 51:la)Ker CBe'-lYB HX rraM51Tb. Bo
BpeM51 uepeMOHHH 6bIJIO 3a-
)K)KeHO lUeCTb CBe'-Ie~ - B
naM51Tb 0 lUeCTH MHJIJIHOHaX
CBpeeB, rrorH6lUHX BO BpeM51
XOJIOKOCTa.
B O,lJ,HOMH3 6apaKOB CO-
6paJIHCb rrO,lJ,pOCTKH, '-IT06bI
1I0CJIYlUaTb )KHBbIX CBH,lJ,eTe-
JIe~ TeX C06bITH~. O,lJ,Ha CTa-
pa51 )KeHIl(HHa rrOKa3aJIa Me-
CTO, r,lJ,eOHa paHblUe crraJIa, a
TaK)Ke paCCKa3aJIa 0 Tex, KTO
lIe BbI)KHJI. Ha Bcex rrpOH3Be-
Jm CHJIbHOe Brre'-IaTJIeI-me
paCCKa3bI 0 TOM, KaK 3TO Bce
6bIJIO Ha caMOM ,lJ,eJIe.51 3HaIO,
llTO ,lJ,JI51JIIO,lJ,e~,KOTopble 3TO
rrepe)KHJIH, 6bIJIO O'-IeUb He-
JIerKO CHOBa BcrrOMHHaTb
rrpOlUJIOe.
51 B rrOCJIe,lJ,HH~pa3 OKH-
lIY JI B3r JI51,lJ,OM.6HpKeHay, C
rre'-IaJIbIO pa3MbllUJI51510 TOM,
KaK MbI MO)KeM )KHTb B Ta-
KOM )KeCTOKOM MHpe, H Ha-
rrpaBHJIC51 K aBT06ycaM, KO-
Topble Y)Ke C06HpaJIHCb OT-
npaBJl51TbC51 B 06paTI-IbI~
rrYTb. Moe TaKeH O)KH,lJ,aJIO
MeH51. MbI C HHPO~ rrorrpo-
llIaJIHCb, H 51 rr06JIarO,lJ,apHJI
ee 3a ,lJ,06POTYH rrOMOllIb, no-
3BOJIHBIIIHe ~IHe npHH51Tb
Y'-Iacnle B illecTBHH H B Me-
MOpHaJIbHO~ cJIY)K6e_ OHa
Bce eUre 6eCrrOKOHJIaCb 0 MO-
e~ 6e30rraCHOCTH H XOTeJIa
y6e,lJ,HTbC51, liTO 51 crrOKO~HO
ye,lJ,y ua TaKCH.
Ha CJlC,lJ,YIOIl(H~,lJ,eHb51PC-
lUHJI rrOCCTHn cpa6pIIKY
illHH,lJ,JIepa H CHHarory, KaK
COBCTOBaJIa HHpa. cDa6pHKa
OKa3aJIaCb HC TaKO~ 60JIblUO~,
KaK B epIIJIbMC, H 51HC O'-ICHb
,lJ,oJIro XO,lJ,HJIrro He~, TaK KaK
rrpHBJIeKaJ1 CJIHlUKOM rrpH-
CTaJIbHOe BHHMaUHe MeCTHoit
rry6JIHKH. Ha CTCHax 51 YBH-
,lJ,eJI MHO)KeCTBO rpaepepH-
TIl, HCrrOJIHCrrHbIXHerraBHCTH:
CBaCTI-IKIl, "white power~
( @JlaCTb 6eJIblx» ) , " GAS
JEWS~ (~EBpeeB - B ra30-
Bble KaMepbI~). 5I He XOTeJI
CTOJIKHYTbC51C TeMIl, KTO 3TO
Bce rrHCaJI...
ITo ,lJ,opore B CHHarory, B
HeCKOJIbKHX 51p,lJ,axOT Hec, 51
YBIl,lJ,eJIeUre O,lJ,HHrrJIaKaT: TpH
-~-"-"--: M
76
0PTO,l(OKCaJIbHbIX eBpe51 B rre-
pe'-IepKHYTOM Kpyre (HeT BXO-
,l(a eBpe51M). XOT51 51 He Mor
rrpo~eCTb TeKCT rro,l( H306pa-
)f(eHHeM, IIJIaKaT 6bIJI 6e3 CO-
MHeHH51 aHT¥IceMHTCKHM. YMetI5I, He3aBHCHMoro Ha6mo,l(a-
TeJI51, HaXO,l(51merOC51BrIe eB-
peHCKO~I BepbI, 3Ta OTKpbITa51
,l(el\IOHCTpaIIH51rrerraBHCTH Bce
eme CTOHT rrepe,l( rJIa3aMH. 51I1CrrbITaJI OCTPYIO ,l(YIIIeBHYIO
60JIb, OC06eHI-IO KOr,l(a BcrrOM-
Hl1JI, lUO B ITOJIbIIIe 6bIJIO '-Ie-
Tblpe tIaIIHCTCKHX JIarep51
CMepTH.
MHe rrpHIIIJIOCb rrOKHHYTb
cHHarory, TaK KaK CTaHOBHJIOCh
TelVIlIO H 51, '-IeCnIO rOBop51, He
'-IYBCTBOBaJIce651B 6e30rraCHO-
CTH. ITo ,l(opore B OTeJIb MeH51
On51ThBCTpeT¥IJInOTOK OCKop6-
JIetIHH, XOT51Ha 3TOM 3Tane 51
peIIIHJI, ~TO paCHCTCKoe onIO-
IIIeHHe 3THX JIIO,l(eit KO MHe -
3TO HX c06CTBetIHa51 np06JIe-
Ma. C MoeH TO'-IKH 3peHH51, 51
n06e,l(HJI: Be,l(b 51 CYMeJI rrpH-
H51Th y~acTHe B nHe rraM51TH
XOJIOKOCTa HeCMOTp51Ha Tex,
'-IbHM HaMepeHHeM 6bIJIO 3aCTa-
BHTb MeH51nO~YBCTBOBaTh ce-
651 He)f(eJIaHHbIM rOCTeM. 51npHBhIK HMeTh ,l(eJIO C paCH3-
MOMH paCHCTaMH, TaK KaK 3TO,
xo~eIIIb He xo~eIIIb, ~aCTb MoeH
)KH3HH.
HaYTpo 51Y)Ke C HeTeprre-
HHeM )K,l(aJI, KOr,l(a CHOBa OKa-
)f(YCb ,l(OMa! ne)f(ypHa51 rro
oTemo, rrOJIbKa Cpe,l(HHX JIeT,
CrrpOCHJIa, BepHycb JIH 51eme B
ITOJIbIIIY. aHa o~eHh TerrJIO KO
MHe OTHOCl1JIaCb,H 51HHKOr,l(a
He 3a6y,l(Y ee ,l(06POTY, oc06eH-
HO ,l(parOIIeHHYIO ,l(JI51 MeH51
TOr,l(a, KOr,l(a 51CTaJIKIIBaJIC51co
Bce06meH HeHaBHCTbIO KO
MHe.
B a3porropTY, rrpoxo,l(51 pe-
rHcTpaIIHlo, 51YBH,l(eJI rpynny
nO)f(HJIbIX MOHaxHHb, B rrOBe-
,l(eHHH KOTOPhIX no OTHOIIIe-
HHIO KO MHe 6hIJI BH,l(eH TaKoH
HerrpHKphIThli:"I pacH3M, ~TO 51
CrrpOCHJI ce651, KaK OHH MorYT
C'-IHTaTb ce651 CJIyraMH focrro-
,l(a. MHe O'-IeHh XOTeJIOCb OT-
BeTI1Th 11M JJ:OCTOHHhIM06pa-
30M. Y Bac, B03MOlKHO, CJIO)f(H-
JIOCb Erre'-IaTJIeHHe, '-ITO 51 '-Ie-
pec~yp ~YBCTB11TeJIeH, ~TO
OHH, Bep051THO,CMe51JIHChHa,l(O
MHOH 6e3 3JIOrO YMhICJIa, HO
Ha,l(O 6bIJIO BYI,l(eTb 3TO CBOH-
M11rJIa3aM11, '-IT06bI nOH51Th,Ha-
CKOJIhKO HeYMeCTHbIM 6bIJIO
HX rrOBe,l(eHHe.
MeH51 BOCrrHTa.TIH B YBa-
)f(eHHH rro OTHOIIIeHHIO KO
BceM peJIHrH51M, 51,l(a)f(e O,l(Ha-
)K,l(bI rrOCeTHJI IIepKOBb B Kpa-
KOBe. MOHaXHH51M, rrO,l(YMaJI
51, He06xo,l(HMO rroceTHTb CB51-
LiletIHeHIIIee ,l(JI51CHKXOB Me-
CTO - 30JIOTYIO ~aCOBHIO B
11H,l(HH. 30JIOTa51 '-IaCOBH51
I1MeeT '-IeTblpe BXO,l(a, 11 3TO
CHMBOJIH~eCKH 0603Ha'-IaeT,
lITO 3,l(eCb rrpHBeTCTBYIOTC51
Bce MHpOBhle peJIHrHH H '-ITO
OHH paBHbI Me)K,l(Y c060i:"1.
B03MO)KHO, eCJIH6hI 3TH MOHa-
XHHH XOTh pa3 n06hlBaJIH TaM
11YBH,l(eJIH, C KaKoi:"I TenJIOTOH
I1X BCTpe'-IaIOTB HaIIIeM 06me-
CTBe, OHH 6bI rrOH51JIH, Ha-
CKOJIbKO HeJIerr peJIHrYI03HhIH
epaHaTH3M.
51 B03Bpama.TIC51B JIOH,l(OH
3MOIIHOHaJIbHO HCTOII~eHHbIM.
3a 3TH TpH ,l(H5151HeCKOJIbKO
pa3 ycrreJI peIIIHTh, '-ITO HHKO-
r,l(a He BbI6epYCh )KHBhIM H3
ITOJIbIIIH.
EOJIb, KOTOpYIO51HCrrbITaJI,
CJIblIIIa paccKa3bI 0 XOJIOKO-
CTe Herrocpe,l(CTBeHHo OT Tex,
KTO ero rrepe)KHJI, He Hc~e3HeT
HHKor,l(a. 113 a3porropTa MHe
Ha,l(O 6bIJIO exaTb Ha JIOH,l(OH-
CKOM MeTpo. OHO )KHBO Ha-
rrOMHHJIO MHe peJIbCbI, Be,l(Y-
mHe B ra30Bhle KaMephI EHp-
KeHay. B BarOHe 51 BH,l(eJI
MHO)KeCTBO c~aCTJIHBbIX
JIHI! - H ,l(YMaJI 0 TOM, KaKO-
BO rrpHXO,l(HJIOCb eBporreH-
CKHM eBpe51M B ~noe3,l(aX
CMepTH~. Ha Ka)f(,l(OM mary
MHe BCTpe~aJIHCb HarrOMHHa-
HH510 MoeM ne'-IaJIhHOM rrYTe-
IIIeCTBHH.
51 Bcer,l(a rrpl1,l(ep)KHBaJIC51
TO'-IKH3peHH51, ~TO paCH3M -
3TO HeBHJ(HMa51TpaBMa H '-ITO
TeM, KTO He OmYTl1JI ero rra ce-
6e, B03lVIO)KHO,HeJIerKO nO-Ha-
CT05IIll.eMY OC03I-IaTh 3TO 51B-
JIeHHe. 51 l1MeJIlleCTb BCTpe-
'-IaTbC51 B JIoH,l(OHe C rrepe-
)Kl1BIIIHMH XO.TIOKOCTmO,l(bMH,
H OHH Bccr,l(a OTHOCHJIHCbKO
MHe C 60JIbIIIOH ,l(06poToi:"r, XO-
T51516bUI ew,mCTBeHHhIM CHK-
XOM B HX 06IIIeCTBe. O,l(HH H3
HHX rOBOpHJI MHe, '-ITO O'-IeHb
06ecnOKoeH POCTOM KOJIH'-Ie-
CTBa HCOHaIIHCTCKHX aTaK Ha
npe,l(CTaBHTeJIeH 3THl1~eCKl1X
MeHhIIII1HCTB B JIoH,l(OHe.
Ba)KHO rrOMHHTh, '-ITOHaIIHCTbI
He HC'-Ie3JIl1, XOT51H 6hIJIH rro-
6e)K,l(eHbI BO BTopoi:"r MHpOBOH
Boi:"IHe, H '-ITOOHH He rrepeCTa-
.TIlT COBepIIIaTb HaCHJIHe no
OTHOIIIeHHIO K eBpe51M H ,l(PY-
rHM 3THH'-IeCKHM MeIIbIIIHHCT-
BaM.
Ha,l(eIOCb, ~TO MOH pac-
CKa3 He rrOJIY'-IlTJIC51 aHTH-
nOJIhCKHM. 51 TBep,l(O 3HaIO,
~TO OTHIO,l(h He Bce rrOJI51KH
aHTHceMHThI. MI-IOrYre rrOJI51-
KH pHCKOBaJIH CBOHMH )KH3-
H51MHBO BpeM51BOHHhI, '-IT06hI
crraCTH eBpeeB. 51 ~TY HX
xpa6pOCTb. 77
,"kft- rt det
.lIHCTCKHMHO~1epKaMHH Ol(err-
KaMH B 3TOMno TOKe Bce 60.lIee
3aMeTHbI 3KCrrepTI-Ib1e aHa.lIH-
TH~IeCKHeMaTepHa.lIb1 HCTOPH-
KOB, COIJ;HO.lIOrOBH I-OPHCTOB.
Cep,"eii fiE.lIHKOB
Cepreii neJIHKoB. BpI1TOrOJIOBbre:Bee 0 eKHHxe~ax.3KCKJII03I1BHbIeMaTepHaJIbI.M., 2002. - 175 c.AJIeKCaH)l,p BepxoBcKHii. rocy~apcTBo rrpoTHBpa~HKaJIbHOrO HaI.(HOHaJIH3Ma.qTO ~eJIaTb H qero He~eJIaTb? M.: POO «I(eHTp "I1aHopaMa"», 2002. - 220 c.B.sIqeCJIaB JIHXaqeB. HaU;H3MB POeeHI1.M.: POO «I(eHTp"I1aHopaMa"», 2002. - 176 e.
}
.6PHToronoBhlE
JII1TepaTypa, rrOCB5Ill(eIIHa51
HaIJ;H3MYB cOBpeMer-IHoHPoc-
CHH, MHo)KI1TC5I - rro~ CTaTb
POCTy caMoro 5IB.lIeHH5I,K CO-
)Ka.lIeHHIO. BMeCTe C )J{ypHa-Capa6a)f(U CWiZX
~OCKaMI1, rrOTOMY ~ITOrro HO-
~IaM rrpHXO~5IT CKlIHxe~bI 11
6pocaIOT B HHX 6eH3HHOBble
60M6b1.
51 Ha~eIOCb, ~ITO MOH pac-
CKa3 ~OCTHrHeT Tex, KTO HH
pa3Y He CTaHOBH.lIC5I06beKTOM
paCHCTCKoro rrpeC.lIe~OBaHH5I,
H rrOMO)J{eTHM rrOH5ITb,~ITO3TO
TaKoe.
HanOC.lIe~OK 5I rrp¥IBe~y
3HaMeHHTYIO IJ;HTaTYH3 Map-
TI11'1aHHMe.lI.lIepa, HeMeIJ;Iwro
JII-OTepaHCKoro rraCTopa, KO-
TOPb1H 6b1.lI apeCTOBaH Ha-
IJ;HCTaMH H OTrrpaB.lIeH B Jla-
repb l(axay B 1938 ro~y: %B
fepMaI-IHH HaL~HCTb1crrepBa
rrpHlll.lII1 3a KOMMYHI1CTaMH,H
5I He B03pa3H.lI, TaK KaK He
6bIJI KOMMYHHCTOM. 3aTeM
OHH npHIIIJIH 3a eBpe5IMH, H 5I
CHOBa He B03pa3I1.lI, TaK KaK
He 6b1.lI eBpeeM. 3aTeM OHH
rrpI1111.lIH3a rrpoepCOI03HbIMH
~e5ITe.lI5IMH, H 5I He B03pa3H.lI,
TaK KaK He 6bI.lI rrpoepCOI03-
HbIM ~e5ITe.lIeM. 3aTeM OHI1
rrpI1111.lII13a KaTO.lIHKaMH, H 5I
He B03pa3H.lI, TaK KaK 6b1.lI
rrpOTeCTaHTOM. 3aTeM OHH
rrpHlll.lII1 3a MHOH, H K TOMY
BpeMeHH He OCTa.lIOCb Y)Ke
HI1KOrO, KTO 6bI Mor B03pa-
3HTb:l>.
MHe rOBOpIVII1, LITO, B03-
MO)J{HO, 5I BCTpeTIfJI CTO.lIbKO
HeHaBI1CTI1 rrpocro rrOTOMY,
LITOMHe He rrOBe3.lIO. KaK 6bI
TO HI1 6bIJIO, MOH orrbIT He
6bIJI C.lIY~IaHHbIM, 5I 3HaIO
MHoro ~PyrI1X rro~06HWX
rrpI1MepOB. TypoK 6bI.lI I136I1T
MeCTHbIMI1 rrO.lI5IKaMI1. 51 ro-
BOPI1.lIC O~I-IOHeBpet'IKOH, LIb5I
~OLJb-rrO~pOCTOK rrO~Bep-
r .lIaCb Harra~eHI1IO CKI1HXe-
~OB: OHI1 6poca.lII1 B Hee 11ee
~Pyra rrYCTble 6YTbI.lIKI1, IW-
r ~a Te BbIlll.lIlI 113 OTe.lI5I. 51rOBOplI.lI C rrO.lIbCKOH ~eBYlll-
KOH, MO.lIO~OH~Ie.lIOBeKKOTO-
pOH - ~IepI'IOKO)J{I1H, II OHlI
rrepe)KlI.lIlI HeCIW.lIbKO rro~06-
HbIX - paCI1CTCKI1X - Ha-
rra~er-IIIH.
II paB03all(lITHble OpraI-III-
3aIJ;lIH I1MeIOT ~OKYMeHTbI,
rrO~TBep)K~aI-Oll(He, LITOrroCTO-
5IHHOHMlIllleHbI-O ~.lI5I Harra~e-
HI1H CKI1HXe~OB 5IB.lI5IIOTC5I
l~blraHe. IIO.lIMI1.lI.lIHOHa IJ;bI-
raH 6bI.lIH y6I1TbI BO BpeM5I
BTOPOH MHpOBOH BOHHbI; ce-
rO~H5I OHH rrpO~OJI)KaIOT
CTpa~aTb OT 3KCTpeMa.lIbHbIX
rrp05IB.lIeHHH paCI1CTCKOro Ha-
CH.lIH5I 11 OTI<PbITOH ~HCKPH-
MHHaIJ;I1H.11M He ~03BO.lI5IeT-
C5I rroKyrraTb e~y I1.lIH HHbIe
TOBapbI B IJ;eHTperopo~a. OK-
Ha HX ~OMOB 3aKO.lIO~IeHbI78
KpaTKO npOCJIeJ],MTb OCHOB-
Hble LIepTbI ::nOH CTaHOB5IIIIeH-
C5I MCCJIeJ],OBaTeJIbCKOHMHJ],Y-
CTpMH M npM3BaHa HaIlla pe-
IleH3M5I.
IIepBa5I H3 paCCMaTpMBae-
MbIX KHHI', «npMTOI'OJIOBble:i>
CepI'e5I neJIHKOBa, nOHaLIaJIY
npOM3BOJ],HT BrreqaTJIeHMe XO-
pOIlleH :>KypHaJIMCTCKOHpa60-
TbI. ABTop npOLleJI J],OBOJIbHO
lVIHOI'O JIMTepaTypbI, XOPOIllO
3I-IaeT CHTyaruTIO B CKMH-J],BM-
)KeHMH He TOJIbKO B PoconI
(BKJIlOLIa5I TaIOKe H perMOHbI),
HO H 3a Py6e:>KOM, rJ],e M P0J],M-
JIaCb cy6KY JIbTypa CKMHxe-
J],OB. II03HlU15I aBTopa BnOJIHe
Het'ITpaJIbHa H no npeMMYIIIe-
CTBY orrHcaTellbHa: OH pMcyeT
CKMHOBKaK KOHTPKYJIbTypHoe
J],BM:>KeI-IHe,rrpM06peTIllee TaK-
:>Ke 3KCTpeMMCTCKYlO nOJIHTM-
LIeCKYIOOKpaCKY, B oc06eHlIO-
CTH B POCCMH. ABTop BMJ],HTB
pOCTe nony JI5IPHOCTHCKHHxe-
J],OB B nOCJIeJ],HMe rOJ],bI (Ha
MOH B3rJI5IJ]" HeCKOJIbKO 3TOT
BCnJIeCK npeYBeJIHLIMBa5I) Tpe-
BO:>KHbIH CMrrMTOM: %CKMH-
J],BH:>KeHMe BbII10JIlmeT Ba:>K-
HYIO epYHKIlHlO B IlenM epaIllH-
3aIlMH 06IIIeCTBa, pa3:>KHI'aeT
paCH3M H KceHoep06HlO B MO-
JIOJ],e:>KHOH cpeJ],e. npMTOrOJIO-
Bble C03J],alOT aTMocepepy
CTpaxa M )KeCTOKOCTH cpeJ],H
(onpeJ],eJIeHHOH LIaCTM) Hace-
JIeHH5I POCCMM:i>(c. 170).nemmoB 06paIIIaeTC5I K
Ba:>KHOHH TpeBo)KHoH np06JIe-
Me: npJIl-UmaM pacrrpOCTpaHe-
HH5I HJ],et'ICKHHOB B MOJIOJ],e:>K-
HOt'I cpeJ],e, HCTOKaM60JIee HJIH
MeHee TOJIepaHTHoro OTHOIlle-
HH5I K HMM BJIaCTH, npaBOOX-
paHMTeJIbHbIX opraHOB M J],a-
)Ke 06IIIeCTBa - %MOJI, pe65IT-
KH-TO J],HKOBaTbI, HO B 06IIIeM
TepneTb Y)Ke I-IeJIb35I:i>... ,l.(et'I-
CTBVITeJIbHO,CKVIHb[VIHX HJ],eo-
JIOrH Ha 3arraJ],e II B POCCIIII
crreKY mIpYlOT IIa peaJlbHblX
Tpyt~HOCT5IX COBMecTHoro rrpo-
)KHBaHH5I mOJ],et'r pa3HbIX IlII-
BHJIH3aIlMH H KYJlbTYP: BbI-
XOJ],IleB H3 A3HM HlIH AeppH-
KH - B EBpone, JIloJ],eu C lOra
Hl[H KaBKa3a - B POCCMH-
CKHX ropoJ],ax. ne3YCJIOBHO,
nOJ],JIMJIa MaCJIa B orOHb KaB-
Ka30ep06HH H LleLIeHCKa5IBOH-
Ha. B CTOJIHIle M KpyrrHblx 1'0-
poJ],ax aKTHBHO J],eHCTBYlOT3T-
HHLIeCKMe rrpeCTynHble rpyrr-
rrHpoBKH. OJ],HaKO, LIHTa5I ne-
JIHKOBa, HeBOJIbHOHaLIHHaeIllb
J],YMaTb, LITO CJIHIllKOM rrpM-
CTaJIbHOe 3HaKOMCTBOC HJ],eo-
JIOrHeH Taro MJIH HHoro J],BH-
:>KeHM5I (M y:>K TeM 60JIee
%BKJIlOLIeHHOe Ha6JIloJ],eHMe:i»
rrOLITH HeH36e:>KHOCKa3bIBaeT-
C5IH Ha C03HaHHH caMara aHa-
JIMTMKa. BOT LITOneJIHKOB no-
XOJ],5I 3a5IBJI5IeT a LIeLIeHIlax:
%BeJ],b3TOT HapoJ], KaK BO Bpe-
M5I BOHHbI, TaK M nOCJIe nOCJIe-
J],YlOIIIeI'O MHpHOI'O cOCYIIIeCT-
BOBaHH5I HH Ha MHr He 3a6bI-
BaJI J],eMOHCTpHpOBaTbOTKPbI-
Toe npeHe6pe:>KeHMe, HaCMeIll-
KH H YI'p03bI B aJ],pec PYCCKDrO
HapoJ],a M POCCHHCKOH (sic!)
BJIaCTH:i> (c. 39). Pa3Be 3TO
aHTYrepaIllMcTCKa5I n03HIlyI5I?!
He CTOHT np5ITaTb rOJIOBY B
neCOK, HrHopMpY5I J],eHcTBH-
TeJIbHble COIlMaJIbHble H rrOJIM-
THLIeCKHe npWIHHbI Me)KI-Ia-
IlHOHaJIbHbIX TpeHHH M npOCTO
arHTMpY5I B J],yxe %Bce JIlOJ],H
6paTb5I:i>, HO TaKHe 3a5IBJIeHH5I
B KHHre LIHTalOTC5InpMMepHO
TaK )Ke, KaK eCJIM 6bI KTO-TO
nbITaJIC5I OIleHMBaTb HaCTpoe-
HH5I POCCM5IH B OTHOllIeHMM
J],pyrHx Hap0J],oB mOJlbKO Ha
OCHOBeCBOJ],OKa HarraJ],eHM5IX
CKHHxeJ],OBH 3aLIHCTKax epeJ],e-
paJIbHbIX CMJI B 1.IeLIHe.
KlUIra 3KcnepTa M npaBO-
BeJ],aAJIeKcaHJ],pa BepXOBCKO-
1'0 a Mepax I'OCYJ],apCTBeHHoro
npOTHBOJ],eHCTBM5I paJ],HKaJIb-
HOMY 3KCTpeMH3MY B POCOIH
npoJ],OJI)KaeT cepHlO Y:>Ke OTpe-
IleH3MpOBaHlIbIX B %TYM-6a-
JIaJIaHKe:i>HCCJIeJ],OBaI-IHHa Ha-
IlMOHaJIMCTHLIeCKHXopraHH3a-
IlH5IX. IIepeJ], HaMM HTor 1'0-
J],HqHOrO HCCJIeJ],OBaTeJIbC~OrO
rrpoeKTa Ilelupa %IIaHopa-
Ma:i>; Hap5IJ],y C nOCTaHOBKOH
3aKOHOJ],aTeJIbHbIX np06JIeM B
KHHre nOMelIleHbI KOMMeHTa-
pHH 3KcrrepTOB (~HXaHJIa
KpaCIIOBa, JIbBa JIemmcoHa,
POMaHa Cano)KHMKOBa M J],p.)
OTIIOCHTeJIbHOMep no 60pb6e
C lIaIlHOHaJIbHO-3KcTpeMHcT-
CKHMM opraHH3aIlH5IMH. Oco-
6eHHo IleHHbI 3aMeLIaHH5I B
CB5I3H C 3aKOHOM %0 npoTH-
BOJ],et'rcTBHH 3KcTpeMHcTcKOH
J],e5ITelIbHOCTH:i>,HHHIlHMpoBaH-
HbIM II pe3HJ],eHToM B Mae -
HlOJIe 2002 rot~a. OqeBHJ],HO,
LITO rrpe3HJ],eHTCKYlO cTopony
He CTOJIbKO 6eCrrOKOMJI pacT
aKTHBHOCTMrrpaBopaJ],HKaJIOB,
CKOJIbKO MHTepeCOBaJIO 3ep-
epeKTHBHoe BbICTpaMBaHMe
%ynpaBJI5IeMOH J],eMOKpaTMH:i>:
B HTore orrpeJ],eJIeHMe 3KCTpe-
MM3Ma B 3aKOHe, KaK OTMeLIa-
JIM MHorHe rrpaB03aIIIHTHHKM,
nOJIyqHJIOCb CTOJIb paCT5I:>KH-
MbIM, LITO MOrJIO BKJIlOLIaTb H
60pb6y TPYJ],5IIIIHXC5IC rrpeJ],-
rrpHHHMaTeJI5IMH, M J],e5ITeJIb-
HOCTb peJIMrH03HbIX opI'aHH-
3aIlHt'I, H MHoroe J],pyroe.
1.IacTb 3KcrrepToB npM3bIBaJIa
aKTHBHee MCnOJIb30BaTb HMelO-
lIlMeC5I B HaJIWIHH 3aKOHOJ],a-
TeJIbHbIe aKTbI H KapaTeJIbHble
MepbI, a He Y)KeCTOLIaTb M
82
npH.n:YMbIBaTh HOBhle. B KHH-
re CO,ll.ep)l{HTC5I TaK)I{e HH-
¢OpMaTHBHOe H nOfle3HOe
npHflO)l{eHHe C TeKCTaMH ,ll.eM-CTBYIOIIIHX (Ha fleTO 2002 ro-·
,ll.a) 3aKOHOB H rrOflo)Ke}IHe
YK no 60ph6e C 3KCTpel\IH3-
MOM (c. 137 -204). Bhl3hIBa-
lOT Y,ll.HBfleHHe flHllIh HeKOTO-
phle Ol~eHKH 3KcrrepTOB; TaK,
rOBOp5I 0 ueB03MO)l{HOCTH
rrOflHoro nO,ll.aBfleHH5I Ha~HO-
Ham'lcnPIeCKHX HaCTpoeHHM B
06IIIeCTBe B rrpHI-I~Hrre H 0
60flhllIeM rrOfle3HOCTH CKopee
Orpa}IHqHTeflhHbIX, 1.leMKapa-
TeflbHhlX Mep, Bfla,ll.HMHp
IIpH6hWOBCKHM cpaBHlW 3TO
C He06xo,ll.HMOCThIO rrepeHoca
B H01.IHOM 3¢Hp H306pa}Ke-
HH5I HaCHflH5I H <i'rofly60M~
rrpOrraraH,ll.hl (c. 80) HaBep-
HO, 51CflHllIKOM pe,ll.KOCMOTPIO
TefleBH30p (HflH BKm01.laIO He
Te KaHaflhl), HO BOT qero 51
TaM HHKOr,ll.a He BH,ll.efl, TaK
3TO <i'rofly60M rrpOrraraH,ll.hl~.
Ho, eCflH rOBopHTh cephe3Hee,
TaI<He cpaBHeHH5I - He3aBH-
CHMO OT flWIHhlX BKYCOB H
rrpHCTpaCTHM aBTopa - He
,ll.eflaIOTeMY qeCTH, TeM 60flee
KOr,ll.a OH 6epeTC5I 3a aHaflH-
THqeCKHMKOMMeHTapHM.
HaH60flee B3BellIeHHOM H
HHTepeCHOMH3 Tpex pe~eH3H-
PyeMhlx KHHr MHe rrOKa3aflaCh
pa60Ta B5IqeCflaBa JIHXa1.leBa.
KHHra COCTOHT H3qeThlpex
r flaB: <i'PYCCKlIM nOp5l,ll.OK no
EapKallIOBY~ - 06 PHE,
<i'lloMH,ll.OPHhIMTeppopH3M~ -
06 HEll H .llynme, <i'T5I)I{e-
flhle 60THHKH ,ll.fl5I YflH1.IHhIX
60eB~ - nOCB5IIIIeHa CKHHxe-
,ll.aM, <i'CerO,ll.H5IMhl CO)l{)I{eM
3TY cHHarory~ - 0 pa,ll.H-
KaflhHhlX Ha~HOHam'lCTaX BpO-
,ll.e EOH,ll.apHKa. KUHra 3Ta BO
MuorOM olIlIpaeTC5I ua aHam'l-
nFlCCKHe MaTep'YIaflhl H 6HO-
rpa¢H1.IecKHe ,ll.aUHhle, npe.n:-
CTaBfleHHhle B H3,ll.aHH5IX~eH-
Tpa <i'llaHopaMa~ , KOTophle
Y}Ke pe~eH3HpoBaflHch Ha
CTpa}IH~aX «TYM-6aflaMKH~.
.ll06aBfleHbI H HOBeMlliHe CBe-
,ll.eHH5I06 H,ll.eMHblx H opraHH-
3aIlHOHHhlX rrepeMeIIIeHH5IX B
npaBOpa,ll.HKaflhHoM flarepe
(¢aKTHqeCKHM pacrra,ll. PHE,
pa3pbIB Me)l{,ll.Y .llYrHHhIM H
HEll H ,ll.p.). lloMeIIIeHHhle B
KOH~e Ka)K,ll.OMH3 r flaB CBe,ll.e-
HH5I 0 ,ll.BYX caMhlX H3BeCT-
HhIX ,ll.e5ITefl5lXToro HflH HHO-
ro Kphwa Ha~HOHaflHCTOB no-
3BOfl5lIOT HaM flyqrne rrpe.n:-
CTaBYITh ce6e, KaKoro p0,ll.a
mO,ll.HH 3aqeM ,ll.eflalOT cTaBKY
ua ¢allIHcTcKHe fl03YHrH H
~eUHOCTH. llo-cBoeMY 3aMe-
qaTefleH pa3,ll.efl 0 CHflhHO
pa3,ll.YTbIX, HO Bp5I,ll.flH MH¢H-
qeCKHX CB5I35IXEapKarnoBa H
Be,ll.eHKHHa CO cneIlcflY}K6a-
MH (c. 43 - 50) . B KHHre
eCTb TaK)Ke H36paHHa5I 6H6-
flHOrpa¢H5I, KOTOpa51 rrOMO-
)KeT qHTaTemo, HHTepecYloIIIe-
MYC5I ,ll.aHHOM - MaflonpH-
BfleKaTeflbHOM C 06IIIeqeflOBe-
lJeCKOMTOqKH 3peHH5I - Te-
MOM.
TaKHM 06pa30M, HH,ll.YCT-
pH5I H3Y1.leHH5IcOBpeMeHHblx
POCCHMCKHX YflhTpanpaBblx
Y)I{e CTaHOBHTC5In01.ITH nony-
JI5IPUOM,HO H B HeM np06fleMa
}KeCTKOro H 0,ll.H03HaqUOrO
,ll.HCTaH~HpOBaHH5I OT H,ll.eM,
TeopHM H ,ll.a)KenochwoK, pa3-
,ll.efl5leMblX <i'nO,ll.OnhITHhIMH~
06bel<Ta]\IH, ,ll.0 KOH~a eIIIe He
pa3pellieHa. BnpOqeM, 3TO
np06fleMa He CTOflhKO caMHX
HCCfle,ll.OBaTefleM,CKOflhKOBce-
ra Harnero 06IIIeCTBa: npH TOM
1.ITO Ha~HOHaJIHCTHqeCKH-pa-
,ll.HKaflhHa51 H,ll.eOflOrH5I H ee
npe,ll.CTaBHTeflH nOflh3YIOTC5I
BeCbMa OrpaHHqeHHOM rrorry-
fl5IPHOCThIO, BceCTopOHHero H
pernHTeJIbHOra rrponIBO,ll.eMCT-
BH5I 3THM 5IBfleHH5IM, Ha MOMB3r fl5l,ll., rrOKa 5IBHOHe,ll.OCTaeT.
A. JIYW1-lCKUtl
,n:eHCTBOBaTb 6epJI1'1HCKOro
HYHUII5I (npe,n:CTaBIITeJI5I Ba-
TIIKaHa). 113 3Toro H1'1'IerO He
BbIIIIJIO. Ha'I1'1HaeTC5I 6eCKO-
He'-IHoe H 1I3MaTbIBaIOIUee rrpe-
CJIe,n:OBaIIHe O,n:IIHO'-IKOt'1CTpalll-
HOro 3JIa, 1I306peTeHHoro XX
BeKOM; plUM 3TOH rOHKII -
JIeHTMOnIB cj:>IIJIbMa: CTYK KO-
JIec BarOI-IOB ,n:JI5ICKOTa, YXo,n:5I-
IUIIX Ha BOCTOK C 3aKpbITbIMH
,n:Bep5IMII II B03BpaIUaIOIUIIXC5I
C OTKpbITbIMH - 3a HOBOH
nopU1'1et'I '-IeJIOBe'-IeCKoro MaTe-
pHaJIa ,n:JI5IHeHaCbITHo:t'1 MaIIIII-
HbIIICTpe6JIeHH5I.
OT :5epJIYlHa ,n:o He,n:OCTyn-
HOH Ulua,n:emI BaTHKaHa, r,n:e
«HlI'-IerO He Be,n:aIOIUerO~ nany
3aIUHll~aJIH OT rrpaB,n:bI ero rrpe-
JIaTbI II npH,n:BopHbIe, HeMeUKHH
y'-IeHbIH CTY'-IaJIC5I BO Bce ,n:Be-
PH, '-IT06bI 3aCTaBHTb ce65I yc-
JIbIlliaTb. Ho YCJIbIlllaJI ero
TOJIbKO O,n:HH. :5JIaro,n:ap5I no-
MOIUH MOJIo,n:oro He3YHTa P1'1-
Kap,n:o <DOHTaHa, ,n:orrYIUeI-lHOrO
K CB5ITOMYnpeCTOJIY (ero POJIb
CbIrpaJI MaTbe KaccoBIIU),
fepIIITaHH CHOBa 1'1CHOBa np1'1-
BO,n:HJI CBOH CBH,n:eTeJIbCTBa. 11
Bce }Ke, HeCMOTp5I Ha rrpe,n:cTaB-
JIeHHbIe HM cTpaIIIHbIe UHcj:>PbI
IIJIH, TO'-IHee, HMeHHO no npH-
'IHHe IIX '-Iy,n:OB1'1IUHOCTH, ero
npe,n:rrO'IJIII He rrOH5ITb II KaK
MO}KHO CKopee BbIIlpOBo,n:IITb
OTKPbIBlllHMC5I rrpeCTynJIeH1'1-
eM H K TOMY }Ke 6y,n:y'-IH peBHO-
CTHbIM npOTeCTaHTOM, OH np1'1-
coe,n:HH5IeTC5I K 60pb6e xpHcnI-
aH npOTHB 3Toro BapBapCTBa,
pa3BepHYBllleHC5I rro BceH
CTpaHe. O,n:HaKO HaY'IHble 3a-
CJIynI fepIIITaHHa np1'1BJIeKa-
IOT K HeMY BHHMaHHe 3C3COB-
ueB, 1'1 OHH rropY'IaIOT eMY
npo,n:OJI}KaTb HCCJIe,n:OBaHH5I
CBOHCTB pa3JIH'-IHbIX ra30B ,n:JI5I
CaHl'ITapHbIX HY)IZ,n: apMlHI, a
rr03}Ke OTnpaBJI5IIOT ero Jlet'TTe-
HaHTOM B caHHTapHbIe Bot'ICKa
Ha BOCTO'-IHbIH cj:>POI-IT.CJIHlll-
KOM n03,n:HO OH rrOHIIMaeT, tITO
BeIUeCTBO, peKOMeH,n:yeMoe HM
,n:JI5IO'-IHCTKII BO,n:bI, UHKJIOH :5,
MO}KeT HMeTb ropa3,n:0 60JIee
ry61'1TeJIbHOe npIIMeHeI-IHe B
ra30BbIX KaMepax AYIIIBHua H
npO'-IHX JIarepeH CMepTII.
Ha'IHHa5I c 3Toro MOMeHTa
feplllTaHH CTaJI H CBH,n:eTeJIeM,
H COY'IaCTHHKOM, H 60PUOM C
npecTynJIeHIIeM, rrOCKOJIbKY,
COXpaH5I5I CBOIO ,n:OJI}KHOCTb B
BOHCKax CC, OH HCnOJIb30BaJI
Bce B03MO}KHOCTII ,n:JI5I Toro,
'-IT06bI MlIp Y3HaJI 3aMaJI'-IHBae-
MbIH Y}Kac JIarepeH CMepTII.
BHa'IaJIe, Bep5I B ,n:06poco-
BeCTHoe HeBe,n:eHHe 3apy6e}K-
HbIX rrOJIIITIIKOB, OH nbITaftC5I
nplIBJIe'-Ib BHHMaHlIe IIIBe,n:CKO-
ro ,n:lIrrJIOMaTa II 3aCTaBIITb
no nOBO,n:y npecTynJIeHlTt'I cj:>a-
lll1'1CTOB B nep1'1O,n: r1'1TJIepOB-
CKOro pe}K1'1Ma), HO ,n:a}Ke acj:>1'1-
llla Ci)HJIbMa, C03,n:aHHa5I 1'13-
BeCTI-IbIM 1'1TaJIb5IHCK1'1M,n:1'13aH-
HepOM OJI1'1BbepO TOCKaHl'I:
KaTOJIlpIecKHt'r KpeCT Ha Het'r
npeBpalnaeTC5I B HaU1'1CTCKYIO
CBaCT1'1KY. )leJIO ,n:OIIIJIO ,n:o cy-
,n:a (no 1'1HHUlIaT1'1Be KaTOJIH'Ie-
CKlIX opraH1'13aUHH), o,n:HaKO
cy,n: OTBepr nOnbITKlI 3arrpe-
T1'1TbpeKJIaMHblt'I nJIaKaT, 1'1TbI-
C5I'-I1'1ero Korr1'1t'1n05IB1'1JI1'1Cb Ha
YJI1'1uaX ropo,n:OB <DpaHU1'11'1.
Kor,n:a }Ke BblIIIeJI caM cj:>HJIbM,
TO He Bce K1'1HOTeaTpbI COrJIaC1'1-
JIHCb Ha ero npOKaT. O}K1'1B-
JIeHHa5I ,n:1'1CKYCC1'15I1'1,n:aJIee CO-
npOBO}K,n:aJIa ero nOBCIO,n:y .
. . .B 1940 ro,n:y B HaU1'1CT-
CKOt'I fepMaH1'1H ,n:YIIIeBH060JIb-
HbIX JIIo,n:eH y61'1BaIoT yr JIeK1'1C-
JIbIM ra30M. IIJIeM5IHI-IHua XlI-
M1'1Ka KypTa fepIIITaHHa, POJIb
KOTOPOro CblrpaJI Y JIbP1'1X TIO-
KIOP, OKa3bIBaeTC5I B 1'1X'I1'1CJIe,
H, XOT5I HaCT05IIua5I rrpH'-IlIHa
CMepnI OT ero ceMbH cKpbIBa-
eTC5I, fepIIITaHH Y3HaeT cTpalll-
HYIO rrpaB,n:y. IIOTpHceHHbIH
BOKpyr cj:>HJIbMa ",AM1'1Hb~,
BbIllle,n:lllero BO <DpaHUIIH B
2002 ro,n:y H Y'IaCTBOBaBIIIero
B KOHKypce 52-ro :5epJIHHCKO-
ro cj:>ecnmaJI5I, - KaK II BO-
Kpyr MHorIIX ,n:pyr1'1x qmJIbMOB
pe}KIICCepa KOHcTaHTIIHa Koc-
Ta- faBpaca - cpa3Y )Ke pa3-
pa31IJIC5I CKaH,n:aJI. Ha 3TOT pa3
cKaH,n:aJIbHOH OKa3aJIaCb He
TOJIbKO TeMa (KapTIIHa rro,n:H1'1-
MaeT 60JIe3HeHHbIH Bonpoc 0
MOJI'IaHIIII PHMCKO-KaTOJIII'-Ie-
CKOH uepKBII 1'1narrbI IIII5I XII
«AMJIHb»
•
86
H3 BaTHKaHa, ,n;aB JIHIIIb HeOrr-
pe,n;eJIeHHble 06eIIIaHHH. C
BOJIHeHHeM CTaJI )l(,n;aTb OH B
fepMaHl'lH pO)l(,n;eCTBeHCKOM
rrpOrrOBe,n;H CBHTOrO OTua, HO
HH CJIOBO«eBpeHi>, HH XOTH 6bl
HaMeK Ha KOHuelITpaUHOHHble
JIarepH Tal{ H He rrp03BY'-IaJIH B
HeM. 11 JIHIIIb 06JIaBa B caMOM
PHMe, B ,n;BYX IIIarax OT rrarr-
CKoro ,n;BOPUa, Kor,n;a 3C9COBUbI
,n;06paJIHCb H ,n;o «eBpeeB rra-
rrbli> , BbIHy,n;IIJIa BaTlIKaH K
CJIa60MY oepHUHaJIbHoMY rrpo-
TecTY, HeYBepeHHo YKa3aBIue-
MY fepMaHHH, '-ITO «BceMY JKe
eCTb rpaHHUbli>.
Ho 3Toro MaJIO, 3TO JIIIlle-
MepHO, 3TO CJIHIIIKOM rr03,n;HO...
CBmueHHHK PHKap,n;o <!>OH-
TaHa, y6e,n;HBIIIHcb, '-ITO rrOJIO-
JKeHHe BeIIIet'I H3MeHHTb lIeB03-
Mo)KHO, rrpHIIIHBaeT K cBoeM cY-
TaHe )l(eJITYlo IIIecTHKoHe'-IHYlo
3Be3,n;y H OTrrpaBJIHeTCH BMeCTe
C eBpeHMH B cTpaIIIHblM rrYTb,
3aKaH'-IHBaIOIIIHMCH cMepTblo.
CJIe,n;YH JIOrHKe XPHCTlIaHCKO-
ro CBH,n;eTeJIbCTBa'-Iepe3 OT,n;a-
'-lY ce6H B )l(epTBY, CBHIIIeHHHK,
He crroc06HblM rrOMO'-Ib MY'-Ie-
HI'IKaM, peIIIHJI ,n;o KOHua 6bITb
C HHMH H pa3,n;eJIHTb HX
Y'-IaCTb. IT03)Ke fepIIITaMH pa-
3bICKaJI <!>OHTaHa B JIarepe,
'-IT06bI crraCTH ero, HO TOT, rrOCJIe
Bcero ymI,n;eHHoro H rrepe)l(H-
Toro, KaTeropH'-IeCKH OTKa3aJI-
CH OT rrOMOIIIH, ,n;a H 3a fep-
IIITat'IHOM Y)l(e CJIe,n;HJIero Bpar,
UHHlI'UIbIM H BcerrOHHMaIOIIIHM
KOJIJIera rro CC ... 3pHTeJIb He
YBH1J:HTKOHua PHKap,n;o <!>OH-
TaHa; JIHIIIb MeJlbKOM KaMepa
rrOKaJKeT pa60TarOIIIero B
Mpa'-IHoM rro,n;BaJIe 3aKJIIO'-IeH-
HorO, KOTOPbIM C He,n;0YMeHHeM
CMOTPHT Ha JIeJKaIIIYlO B KY'-Ie
o):(e)l():(bl cYTaHY KaTOJIH'-IeCKO-
fO cBHIIIeHHHKa C )KeJITot'r eB-
peMCI<Ol13Be3,n;oM.MOpaJIbHO YHH'-ITOJKeHIIbIt'r,
OCTaBJIeHI-IbIM CBOHMH ,n;PY3bH-
MH-XpHCTlIaHal\'lH H3-3acBH3et'I
C CC, HrIIOpHPyeMbIM HJIH ro-
HHMbIt"r orracaloIIIHMHCH ero co-
Tpy,n;HHKaMH-3c3coBuaMH, fep-
IIITat'IH 6bIJI apeCTOBaII B KOHIJ:e
BORHbI COI03HHKaMH KaK Ha-
UHCT, COBepIInIBIInrM rrpecTyrr-
JIeHHH rrpoTHB '-IeJIOBe'-IeCTBa, H
rrOKOH'-IHJI C C060M B TIOpbMe.
B 3aKJIlO'-IHTeJIbHOM Ka,n;pe
epHJIbMa 3c3coBeu - Bpa'-I JIa-
repeM cMepTH, HeBpe,n;HMbIM
YIIIe):(IIIHM OT rrpaBocy,n;HH KOJI-
JIera fepIIITaMHa, YJIbl6aHCb,
rrpHHHMaeT H3 PYK BaTHKaH-
CKoro rrpeJIaTa rracrropT C BH30M
,n;JIH Bble3,n;aB ApreHTHHY. 3TOT
rryTb, C rroMoIIIbIO H rro,n; rrpH-
KpbITHeM CHHcxo,n;HTeJIbHOM
uepKBH, rrpo,n;eJIalOT n03)l(e Tbl-
CH'-IHHaUHcToB, H HarrOMHHamre
#fff'
06 3TOM «,n;opore MOHacTblpeMi> ,
TaK)l(e oKpeIIIeHHoM «KPbICH-
HbIM rrYTeMi>, B03BpaulaeT 3PH-
TeJIH K CHMBOJIHKe cKaH):(aJIb-
HOMaepHIIIH, Ha KOTOPOMHe rro-
HHTHO, r):(e KOH'-IaeTCHKpeCT, a
r,n;e Ha'-IHHaeTCH CBaCTHKa...
B epHJIbMe «AMHHbi>, KaK H
B ,n;PyrHx CBOHX KapTHHax,
KocTa- faBpac 06paIIIaeTCH K
TeMe O,n;HHO'-IKH,npoTHBoCTOH-
IIIero TH)l(eJIOM H 6ecrrOluallHot'I
MaXHHe. <!>HJIbM «Zi> 0 rpe'-Ie-
K. KocTa-faBpac
CKOM CJIe,n;oBaTeJIe, KOTOPbIM
rrbITaeTCH pacrrYTaTb 3aroBop,
CKpbIBaIOIIIHM rrOJIHTH'-IeCKOe
y6HMCTBO, «IT pH3HaHHei>
(<<L'aveui» 0 rrpouecce ApTY-
pa JIoH):(OHa B t.IexOCJIOBaKHH,
«Ee3 BeCTH rrporraBIIIHMi>
(<<Missingi» 0 '-IHJIHMCKOMrre-
peBopOTe 1973 ro,n;a - Bce
3TH CTaBIIIHe 3HaMeHHTblMH
rrOJIHTH'-IeCKHe epHJIbMbI BHOBb
H BHOBb BOCC03):(arOT6H6JIet'I-
CKYlO 6HTBY ,lJ,aBH,n;a rrpOTHB
fOJIIlaepa.
Ka3aJIOCb 6bl, repOH 3Tot'r
KapTlIHbI KOCTa- faBpaca BO-
rrHlOT B rrYCTbIHe, CTaJIKHBaHCb
CO Bce06IIIHM 6e3pa3JIWIHeM
HJIH UHHH3MOM, H YMHpaIOT
HH'-Iero He ):(06HBIIIHCb. «]\110MepHJIbM e):(HHCTBelIHO 0 MOJI'-Ia-
HHH H 6e3pa3JIH'-IHH. 11 TO H
):(Pyroe Be'-IHO. fOBOpHTb 0
rrpOIIIe,n;IIIeM - 3Ha'-IHT rOBO-
pHTb 0 TOM, '-ITO npOHcxo,n;HT
cero,n;HHi>. Pe)l(HCCep ,n;06aB-
JIHeT, O):(HaKO,'-ITOepHrypa O,n;H-
HOKoro '-IeJIOBeKa, OTI{a3bIBaIO-
IIIerOCH CMHPHTbCH, OTBe'-IaeT
rroTpe6HOCTH 3pHTeJIH OTO-
)l(,n;eCTBHTbce6H C repoeM, rro-
CTaBHTb ce6H Ha ero MeCTO.
«JIlO,n;H '-IepnalOT Ha,n;e)l(,n;y H
CHJIbI, BH,n;H,'-ITOKTO-TO 60peT-
CH, rOBopHT "HeT" orpOMHot'r
MaIIIHHe HecrrpaBe,n;JIHBO-
CTH, - C'-IHTaeT OH. - 3TO
,n;OKa3bIBaeT, '-ITO rrpOTIIBO-
CTOHHHe Bcer,n;a B03MO)l(HOi>.
KYPT fepIIITaMH - HCTO-
pH'-IeCKOe JIHUO, 0 HeM 6bIJI
orry6JIHKOBaH pH,n; HaY'-IHbIX
HCCJIe):(OBaHHt'r. OHH H rrOMor-
88
JIM KOCTa- faBpacy 11 ero co-
aBTOpy rro CIJ;eHap1110/KaH-
KJlo):(y fpYM6epry B C03):(a-
H11H 06pa3a HaIJ;HCTCKoro
oqmIJ;epa, KOTOPbIH WITHaeT
ce6~ coyqaCT11eM B rrpecTyrr-
JIem'IHX, ):(JI~Toro qT06bI 6bITb
B COCTO~H11HCB11):(eTeJlbCTBO-
BaTb 0 TBOp11MOMY)Kace. II TO
)Ke KacaeTC~ MOJlo):(oro 11e3Y-
11Ta (e):(11IICTBemIbIH BbIMbIlII-
JleHlIbIH rrepCOlIa)K qnwbMa),
TO :=lTOC0611paTeJlbHbIH 06pa3
MHOr01I11CJleIUIbIX xpHcnralI,
rrponIBocTo~BlIIHX 3i:UIHTOH
IJ;epKOBblO rr0311IJ;11HH BbICTY-
rraBIIIHX rrpoTHB XOJlOKOCTa
BO <DpaHIJ;HH, B HTamuI, B
IIOJIbIlle - rroBcIo):(y. «E6J1b-
Illa~ 11XqaCTb OKOlIq11J1aCBOH
):(IUI B Jlarep~x~, - co06IIIa-
eT KOCTa- faBpac.
Pe)K11Ccep He rrOKa3bIBaeT
B CBoeM ep11J1bMeCaM11KOHIJ;elI-
TpaIJ;110HHbIe Jlarep~: «MlIe
rrpe):(CTaBJI~eTC~ He):(orrYCT11-
MbIM 11CKYCCTBeHIIOBOCC03):(a-
BaTb :=lTOTY)Kac~. He CTaJl OII
CHHMaTbTaK)Ke CIJ;eHbI,r):(e aK-
TepbI 11rpaJl11 6bI rOHHMbIX H
rr03)Ke YI-II1qTO)KeHlIbIX eBpe-
eB, - 3a 11CKJIIOQeH11eMMHH11-
MaJlbHOrO KOJl11QeCTBarrepco-
Ha)KeH, He06xo):(11MbIX):(JI~1130-
6pa)KeH11~ 06J1aBbI B P11Me B
1943 ro):(y. Bce, QTO XOTeJl
CKa3aTb pe)K11Ccep, HaM rrepe-
):(alOT HeHTpaJlbHbIe, Ka3aJlOCb
6bI, HO HCrrOJlHelIHbIe He06bI-
QaHHOH CHMBOJlHQeCKOHCHJlbI
rroBTopmoIIIHec~ lIa rrpOTR)Ke-
IIHH Bcero epHJlbMa Ka):(pbI:
CTpeM11TeJlbHO6erYIIIHe rroe3-
):(a, KOTopble OTrrpaBJI~IOTC~ H
B03BpaliiaIOTc~, - KaK rrpH-
3bIB K CP0"'-IHOMY):(eHCTB11IO,
KaK CTpaIIII-IbIH Kp11K 0 rrOMO-
III 11, KaK CQeTyrrYIIIeHHbIx MH-
IIYT. 3MOIJ;110HaJlbII0 He MeHee
lIaCbIIIIe.HI·Ia H CIJ;eHa,BO BpeM~
KOTOPOH fepliiTaHiI, BrrepBbIe
rrpHr JlalIIeHHbIH rrOCMOTpeTb
"'-Iepe3r Jla30K B ):(BepH ra30BOH
KaMepbI Ha HOBoe 11CrrOJlb30Ba-
Hue IJ;HKJlOlIa E, Y3l-IaeT lIe-
B03MO)I{IIYIO, HenepeIIOC:H1'vIYIO
rrpaB):(Y: CTeHbI rrOMeIIIelI11~
):(pO)I{aTB TeQelIHe lIeCKOJlbKHX
lIaBO):(~III11XY)I{ac ceKYII):(, He-
KOTopbIe :=lC:=lCOBIJ;bIOTBO):(~T
B3rJI~):(, 113pHTeJlb rrOH11MaeT,
QTO reHOIJ;11):( rrp11II~JI rrpo-
MbIIIIJlelIlIbIe MaClIITa6bI. ..
KOCTa-faBpac B3~JI 3a OC-
HOBY CBoero CIJ;elIap11~ rrbecy
«BHKap11H~ POJlbepa XOKXYTa,
KOTOP~ BrrepBbIe paCCKa3aJla
o 60pb6e fepUlTaHHa 11 crrpo-
BOIJ;11pOBaJlarpOMK11tI CKaH):(aJl
B 1963 ro):(y, Kor):(a 6bIJla rro-
CTaBJlelIa Ha CIJ;elIe. JJ:eHCTB11-
TeJlbHO, BrrepBbIe 06IIIecTBeH-
Hoe BHHMaHIIe 6bIJlO rrp11BJle-
qelIO K rrp06J1eMe OTBeTCTBeH-
HOCTHBbICOKOHKaTOJlWIeCKOH
11epapX11113a HeKOTopbIe Mpaq-
IIbre CTpaH11IJ;bI:=lTOrOTparWIe-
CKoro rrep11o):(a11CTOpml.
«BrrepBble ep11rypa IIH~
XII, CQ11TaBlIIeroc~ ):(0 Toro
CB~TbIM QeJlOBeKOM,6bIJla rro-
CTaBJleHa no):( COMHeHHe, -
rOBOp11Tpe)I{HCcep. -- IIbeca
B03bIMeJla ):(eHCTB11e,H60 rr06y-
):(HJla J\lIIorOQ11CJlelIlIbIX HCTO-
pHKOB 3alI~TbC~ H3YQeHHeM
POJl11BaTHKaHa BO BpeM~ BotI-UbI. Cero):(II~, lIaKOlIeIJ;, Bce CO-
)KeT 6bITb, YCJIO)KH~TbTeM ca-
MblM YQaCTb M11J1J11101I0BXPH-
CT11aHB EBporre, - B TO Bpe-
M~ KaK MO)I{HOT~HYTb BpeM~ C
rJlaCHbI, \ITO rrarra O"'-IeHbpaHO
Y3HaJl 06 HCTHHIIOM rrOJlO)I{e-
H11H):(eJl,HOIIHKaK lIe oCY)K):(aJl
YHH"'-ITO)I{eHlIeeBpeeB. CJlOBO
«eBpeH~ IIHKor):(a ):(a)I{e lIe rro-
~BJI~JlOCb B ero BbICTyrrJleH11-
~x. <DHJlbM roBOpHT H 0 ):(py-
nIX, KTO 3HaJl H lIe rrpOTeCTO-
BaJl, 0 PY3BeJlbTe lIarrpHMep, 06
06IIIeM 6e3pa3J1H"'-IHH,IIO rrarra
Be):(brrpeTeH):(OBaJlHa MOpaJlb-
HbIH aBTopHTeT... Ero MOJl"'-Ia-
HHe 11MeJlOoc06eHHoe 3HaQe-
HHe~. 3aQeM BbI3bIBaTb nIeB
KaHIJ;Jlepa fHTJlepa - H MO-
rrOJ\IOIIIblOKpacHBbIX, CM~rQaIO-
III11X):(YlIIY rrporroBe):(eH. «Moe
cepw~e 06J1HBaeTC~KpOBblO 3a
)KepTB, ~ MOJlIOCb3a H11X~, -
90
3a5lBJI5leT rrarra B CaMbI:H pa3-
rap YH:WITO>KeHlm.IIarra IIH:H XII - O,n:HOH3
HaH60JIee crropHbIX ,n:e:HCTBYIO-
llIHX JIHII B HCTOPHH UepKBH.
EllIe 6y,n:yqH HYHIIHeM B Eep-JIlme, OH Be,n:eT rreperoBopbI 0
KOHKop,n:aTe C rHTJIepOBCKHM
pe:>KHMOMB 1933 ro,n:y. IIHt'I
XI (YMepIlIl'I11: rrpII rro,n:03pH-TeJIbHbIX 06CT05lTeJIbCTBax) B
1930 ro,n:y c,n:eJIaJI era Kap,n:II-HaJIOM. B 63 ro,n:a CB5lllIeHHHKEBreI-IHo IIaLleJIJIH CTaJI rrarrO:H
IIHeM XII. OH rr03,n:paBHJI IIC-
rraHCKoro ,n:IIKTaTopa (DpaHKo
C ero KaTOJIIIqeCKO:H rr06e,n:0:HHa,n: ~KpacHbIMII~ - COIIHa-
JIIICTaMH, aHapxHcTaMH H KOM-
MYHHCTCiMII,a era rrepBoe BbI-cTyrrJIeHHe rrpoTIIB eBpet'IcKoro
reHOIIII,n:a (OTpa)KeHHOe B
<pIIJIbMe) ,n:e:HCTBIITeJIbHO,n:a-
THpyeTC5l 1943 ro,n:OM, Kor,n:a BPHMe IIIJIH MaCCOBble 3C3COB-
CKHe 06JIaBbI, a COI03HIIKII Ha-
XO,n:MJIMCbY)f(e rro,n: HearrOJIeM.
IIarra ocy,n:MJI HaIIM3M JI.HIIIb B
1945 ro,n:y ...
IIM:H XII HeHaBH,n:eJI PYC-
CKMX60JIbIIIeBMKoB, 60PIIOB 3aaTeM3M M MaTepMaJIM3M, 60JIb-IIIe, qeM HeMeIIKMX HaIIMCTOB.
K TOMY)Ke era rrOJIMTWleCKH:HBbI60p Bcer,n:a 3aBHCeJI aT Me-
H5lBilierOC5l COOTHOIIIeHH5lCHJI
Me)K,n:y rr06e:>K,n:aIOUIMMM HrrpoMrpbIBaIOllIMMM. Era rr03M-IIM5l 6bIJIa TeM 60JIee He,n:o-CTO:HHO:H,LITOIIHt'r XI, era rrpe,n:-
IIIeCTBeHHMK,B 1937 ro,n:yocy-
,n:MJIHaIIM3M B rrpOCJIaBJIeHI-IO:H3HIIMKJIHKe ~Mit BrennenderSorge~ (HamrCaHI-IOt'I Ha He-
MeIIKOM 5l3bIKe!).
Blma rrarrbI, o,n:HaKO, HH-
CKOJIbKO He ,n:OJI)KHaYMaJI5lTb
3HaLleHH5l MY)KeCTBeHHbIX,n:e:H-
CTBMt'I OT,n:eJIbHbIX ,n:YXOBHbIXJIHII - B clmJIbMe MX CHMBO-
JIH3lIpyeT 06pa3 PHKap,n:o(DOl-ITaHa, - ,n:e:HCTBOBaBIIIHX
BO Bcex KOl-I<peCCII5lXII Ha Bcex
YPOBH5lX IIepKOBHO:H lIepap-XHII. Era II peOCB5IllIeHCTBoerrlICKon MOHT06aHa Teac 3a5l-
BHJI rrOCJIe cBoero oCB060:>K,n:e-
HII5l B aBrycTe 1944 ro,n:a (OH6bIJI apecToBaH HaIIIICTaMH 3a
yqaCTlie B ConpOTIIBJIeHlI1i H
3a rroMOllIb eBpe5lM): ~CB5l-
llIeHHoe IIlIcaHlie oCY)K,n:aeT
rraCTbIpe:H, rro,n:06HbIX "HeMbIM
ncaM, He MorYllIliM JIa5lTb"
(l1c. 56, 10).51 He XOTeJI6bITb
HeMbIM rrCOM, H rrepe,n: orraCHO-CTbIO 5l B03BbICHJI CBOt'I rOJIOc.
3TO 6bIJIO MOMM,n:OJIroM; MoeMOWIaHHe c-raJIO 6bI npe,n:a-
TeJIbCTBOM~.IIana }Ke XOTeJI onpaB-
,n:aTb ce65l nepe,n: l1CToplIe:H,YTBep}K,n:a5l, LITO OH rrbITaJIC5l
1I36erHYTb xy,n:IIIero - pe-rrpeCCII:H npOTIiB BCe:HKaTOJIM-qeCKot'I 06llI1IHbI. He06xo,n:IIMO
nplI3HaTb, qTO OH,n:e:HCTBHTeJIb-
HO Haxo,n:HJIC5l B 3aTpy,n:HII-!TeJIbHOMrrOJIO}I(eHIIH,o,n:HOBpe-/
MeHHO 5lBJI5l5lCbnOJIHTHLleCKHM
rJIaBO:H rocy,n:apCTBa BaTHKaHII xpliCTlIaHCKIiM r JIaBO:HIIepK-
BM. BaTYIKaH, XOTb H n03,n:HO,Bce )Ke rrplmec H3BHHeHII5l eB-
pe:HCKO:H06llIlII-Ie. Ho ellIe He
YCTaHOBJIeHbI Bce IICTHHHbIeMOTIiBbIMOJIqamm 3Toro narrbI,
nplIqlICJIeHlIe KOToporo K JIHKY6JIa)KeHHbIX 6bIJIO OTKJIOHeHO
rrarrO:H l1oaHHoM -IIaBJIOM II.JIIIIIIb OTKpbITHe apXHBOB rro-3BOJIMJIO 6bI OKOl-IqaTeJIbHO
rrpOJIIITb CBeTHa MI-Ioroe, a oco-
6eHHo - Ha no,n:JIHHHyro POJIbBaTHKaHa B C03,n:aHI'lHTat'IHbIX
,n:lIrrJIOMaTWleCKIiX rrYTe:H ,n:JI5ln06era TbIC5lq HaIIIICTOB rrOCJIe
OKOHqaHM5l BO:HHbI B JIaTIIH-
CKyIOAMepliKY M Ha EJIII:>KHH:H
BOCTOK, r,n:e MHorHe H3 HIiX rre-
peKBaJIH<pMIIlIpOBaJIHCb B co-MHIITeJIbHbIX BOeI-IHO-nOJIH-
IIe:HCKIiX 3KcrrepToB, ellIe He
pa3 rrp05lBMBIIIHX ce65l B xo,n:e
XOJIO,n:HO:HBO:HHbI.
25 HIOJI5l 1945 ro,n:a fep-IIITa:HH 6bIJI Ha:H,n:eH rrOBe-
IIIeHHbIM B CBOe:H KaMepe BO-eHHO:HTIOpbMbI I1lepIII- MH,n:H
B IIapH)Ke. He1I3BecTHo, 6bI-
JIO JIH 3TO y6H:HCTBO HJIH ca-Moy61I:HCTBO. B JII060M CJIY-qae ,n:JI5l CTpa)KHHKOB 3TO6bIJI JIHilib ~Oqepe,n:Hot'I 3C3-
cOBeII~ ... Ho rrepe,n: cMepTbIOfepIIITa:HH ycrreJI HaUHCaTb
rro,n:p06HYIO 06b5lCHHTeJIb-
HYIO 3arrHcKY, B KOTOpOt'I OH
,n:aBaJI 6ecIIeHHble CBH,n:e-TeJIbCTBa 06 opraHlI3aIIHH
HaIIIICTaMII reHOIIH,n:a.B aBrYCTe 1945 ro,n:a
BCTaeT Borrpoc a rrpJoIH:a,n:JIe}K-
HOCTH fepIIITa:HHa K ,n:BH}I(e-HHIO CorrpOTHBJIeHHSiI. IIoJIro-
,n:a crrycT5l, B 5lHBape 1946 ro-,n:a, 06b5lCHI-ITeJIbHa5l 3arrHCKafepiliTat'ma 6bIJIa IICrrOJIb30-
BaHa B xo,n:e HlopH6eprcKoro
rrpollecca.B 1950-M era B,n:OBY JUI-
IIIIIJIIi rreHCMII II OTKa3aJIH B
pea6lIJIHTaIIlIli ee MY)Ka, BceellIe CqHTaBilierOC5l HaIIIICTOM.
B 1953 ro,n:y 06b5lCHIITeJIbHa5I
3arrlICKa fepIIITa:HHa 6bIJIa
orry6JIMKOBaHa. B 1963 ro,n:yrrbeca ~ BIiKapM:H~ c,n:eJIaJIa
HCTHHY a fepUITa:HHe ,n:OCT05I-
HlieM IIIlIpOKO:H 06llIeCTBeHI-IO-
CTII...B 1965 ro,n:y KYPT fep-
IIITa:HH6bIJI HaKOHeII pea6HJIH-
THpoBaH.
llMp 9PUCC01-l 91
KOH<I>EPEHQIIR UNITED
B HalIaJIe OKT5I6p5I
2002 rO,l{a B CTOJIHI(e Py-
MbIHHH nyxapeCTe rrpOiliJIa
OlJepe,l{Ha5I KOHepepeHI(lI5I
~ UNITED for Intercultural
Action~ - eBporreticKoti op-
raHH3aI(HH, 3a,l{alJeti KOTOPOti
5IBJI5IeTC5I 6opb6a rrpOTHB Ha-
I(HOHaJIH3Ma, paClI3Ma, epaIlIlI3-
Ma H rrO,l{,l{ep)KKa MlIrpaHToB H
6e)KeHI(en. aHa HOCHJIa Ha-
3BaHlIe ~JhIIJ:OM K JIHl(Y C
orraCHOCTbIO: MOJIO,l{e)KHa5I
cTpaTerH5I npoTlIB pacH3Ma II
CB5I3aHHbIX C HlIM epOpM ,l{HC-
KplIMlIHal[HH B EBporre~.
PacH3M rrOKa3bIBaeT HaM
CBOH HOBbIe JIHI(a: KpatiHe
rrpaBble rrOJIyqaIOT Ha BbI60-
pax Bce 60JIbilie rOJIOCon, Heo-
HaI(lICTbI - 3TO Y)Ke He rrpo-
CTO HeopraHH30BaHHble rpyrr-
rrbI CKHHXe,l{OB, HO H ~YBa}Kae-
Mble~ JIIO,l{H B KOCTIOMaX; pa-
CH3M rrpOHHKaeT Bce r JIy6)Ke B
rrorr-KYJIbTYPY H cnopT. ll,eJIb
KOHepepeHI(HH 6bIJIa B TOM,
lIT06bI MOJIO,l{ble aKTHBHCTbI lI3
pa3HbIX CTpaH, c06paBililICb
BMeCTe, BO- rrepnbIX, rrOrrbITa-
JIlICb rrOH5ITb, HaCKOJIbKO Bce-
06lI(HH XapaKTep HOCHT 3Ta
TeH,l{eHI(H5I B rOCY,l{apCTBaX
3arra,l{HOH, ll,eHTpaJIbHOH II
BOCTOl{HOH EBpOrrbI, B '1eM
CXO,l{CTBO H B LIeM OTJIWIH5I
3THX rrp0I(eCCOB B Ka)K,l{oti
KOHKpeTHoti CTpaHe. Bo-nTO-
PbIX, Yl{aCTI-IHKlI ,l{OJI)KHbI 6bI-
«npeKpan1Te 1-13roH~Tb6e)f{eHL1eS»
JIH Bblpa60TaTb HJIH XOT5I 6bI
HaMeTHTb HeKHe HOBbIe CTpa-
TerHH B 60pb6e C 3THMH HOBbI-
MH rrp05IBJIeHH5IMH paclI3Ma.
B OWIH H3 ,l{Het'I YlJaCTHHKaM
6bIJIO rrpe,l{JIO)KeHO pa3,l{e-
JIHTbC5I Ha HeCKOJIbKO pa60-
lIHX rpyrrrr, B KOTOPbIX ,l{OJI}K-
HbI 6bIJIH H,l{TlI ,l{HCKYCCHH Ha
60JIee KOHKpeTHble TeMbI: pa-
CH3M B rrorr-KY JIb Type H crrop-
Te, ~YBa)KaeMble~ rrpaBble, aH-
THrJI06aJIlI3aI(lI5I II paClI3M (B
3TOti pa60l{eH rpyrrrre CJIYlIHJI-
C5I caMblti )KeCTKlIti 3a BCIO
KOI-IepepeHI(lIIO crrop Me)K,l{Y
arrOJIOreTaMlI aHTHr JI06aJIH3-
Ma, ClIHTanIlIHMH, ,LITOcaMa rro-
CTaHOBKa Borrpoca HeYMeCTHa,
H TeMlI, KTO Cl{HTaJI, lITO HeJIb-
35I 3aKpbIBaTb r JIa3a Ha ~Bce-
5I,l{HOCTb~ aHTlIrJI06aJIHCTCKO-
ro ,l{BlI}KeHlI5I, K KOTOPOMY
Ol{eHb lIaCTO rrplIMbIKaIOT
Kpat'U{e rrpaBble), paClI3M H
CM:vI, paCH3M H 06pa30BaHlIe.
He 060IlIJIOCb II 6e3 He-
rrpH5ITHbIX He,l{Opa3YMeHlIti.
TaK, BO BpeM5I cBoe06pa3Hoti
«pa3MlIHKlI~, C KOTOPOti HalIa-
JIaCb KOHepepeHI(H5I, KOr,l{a
rrpHcYTcTBYIOlI(lIe, pa3,l{eJIlIB-
IlIHCb Ha rpyrrrrbI, ,l{OJI}KHbI6bI-
JIH Ka)K,l{blt'I 06'b5ICHlITb, lITO OH
HJIH OHa rrOHHMaIOT rro,l{ nOH5I-
TlI5IMH «epaIlIH3M~ II «aHTlI-
epaIlIlI3M~, «HaI(HOHaJIH3M~ II
~aHTHHaI(lIOHaJIlI3M~, ~pa-
CH3M~ II «aHTHpaClI3M~, O,l{lIH
lI3 Yl{aCTHlIKOB H3 nOCHlIlI II
fepI(erOBHHbI nOBe,l{aJI HaM,
'ITO OH JIlIl{HO HHl{erO rrpOTHB
rOMoceKcyaJIlICTOB He HMeeT,
HO HaXO,l{HTbC5I C HHMlI B O,l{-
HOti KOMHaTe He MO)KeT, a TaK-
)Ke 'ITO I(blraHe, KOHelIHO, rrpe-
KpacHblti HapO,l{, HO OHH caMlI
BHHOBaTbI, 'ITO MbI He Mo}KeM
HM rrOMOlJb, TaK KaK HM Hpa-
BHTC5I )KHTb B rp5I3H II rrpory-
JIlIBaTb 3aH5ITlI5I B IlIKOJIe.
LJ:Pyroti CJIyqati 6bIJI eIl(e 60-
JIee yp0,l{JIHBbIM: B pa60lIeti
rpyrrrre, 06cY}K,l{aBilieti pOJIb
peJIHrHH B, )KH3HlI 06lI(eCTna,
YlIaCTHHK C KlIrrpa HeO)KH,l{aH-
HO BblcTyrrlIJI C rrJIaMeIIHoti pe-
lIbIO, CMbICJI KOTOpoti CBO,l{HJI-
C5I K TOMY, lITO flIT JIep 6bIJI,
pa3YMeeTC5I, rrpecTynHHKoM, HO
H Cai\UI eBpelI XOPOUIJII, CTOHT
TOJIbKO nOlIHTaTb «II POTOKO-
JIbI CHOHCKHX MY,l{peI(oB~. Ka-
3aJIOCb 6bI, oTKY,l{a 3TlI JIIO,l{HB
aHTHpacHcTcKOM ,l{BH}KeHlIH,
KaKHM BeTpoM 3aHeCJIO HX Ha
3TY KOI-IepepeHI(HIO? B TO )Ke
BpeM5I rrO,l{06Hble ,l{eMapiliH
6bIJIlI OqeHb rrp0.LIYKTYIBHbI,
TaK KaK BbI3BaJIH )KyIBOe o6cy-
)K,l{eHHe H HarrOMHHJIH YlIaCT-
HlIKaM, lITO rrpaB03alI(HTIIOe II
aHTHpaCHCTCKoe ,l{BH)KeHHe He
CTOJIb Y)K O,l{HOP0,l{HO, lITO Bce
MbI rrpOCTble JIIO,l{H, Y KOTOPbIX,
MorYT 6bITb CBOH rrpe,l{paccy,l{-'
KH H 3a6JIY)K,l{eHH5I. 3Ta ClI-
Tyal(H5I JIHIlIHHt'I pa3 ,l{OKa3aJIa,
'ITO HeJIb35I 3aMaJIlJlIBaTb rrpo-
THBOpel{H5I Cpe,l{H ~CBOHX~.
B 3TOT pa3 Ha KOI-IepepeH-
I(HH rrpHCYTCTBOBaJIa ueJIa5I
rpyrrrra Tex, KTO 60peTC5I C pa-
CH3MOM B crropTe. 3TO 6bIJIH
rrpe,l{CTaBHTeJIH IIOJIbCKoti ac- 93
COl.{fIal.{MI1 ~Nigdy Wi~ncej»
(<<HI1Kor.n:a60JIbllIe~), KOTOPCUI
rrpOBO.LJ:lU KaMrraHI1IO ~ <DYT-
60JI rrpOTI1B paCI13Ma~, .n:aTCKOH
KaJVIIIaHl111~CrrOpT rrpOTI1B pa-
CI13Ma~ 11 KaMrraHI111 ~Show
racism the red card~ (~IIoKa-
)K11paC113MY KpaCHYIO KapTO'I-
KY~) H3 BeJIllK06p11TaH1111. I1x
pa60Ta rrpOH3Bo.n:I1T 60JIbliiOe
Brre~aTJIeH11e H o~eHb BOO.n:y-
llIeBJI5IeT. Eopb6a C paC113MOM
cpe.n:11cPYT60JIbHbIX cPaHaToB,
.n:a I1 cpe.n:11 caMHX cPYT6oJlI1-
CTOB I1 11X TpeI-IepOB, - o.n:I-Ia
113caMbIX Ba)KHbIX qaCTeH aH-
T11paCI1CTcKott pa60TbI, KOTO-
pOH B POCCIIH, K Co)KaJIeHI1IO,
.n:OJI)KHbIM06pa30M He 3aHHMa-
eTC5I HI1KTO. TeM, KTO 3a11HTe-
peCOBaJIC5I3TO}I TeMO}i, HaCT05I-
TeJIbHO peKOMeH.n:yIO rrOCeT11Tb
caHT www.TheRedCard.org.
PYMbIHCKI1H cPOJIbKJIOPHbIH
aHCaM6JIb YCTP011JI .n:JI5I Hac
y.n:HBI1TeJIbHOerrpe.n:CTaBJIelII1e;
6bIJIO orpoMHoe KOJIJ1lIeCTBO
pa3roBopoB, llIYTOK, crropoB,
3HaKoMcTB, rrJIaHOB H pa3JIl1q-
I-IbIX Brre~aTJIeHI1H. KmIcPe-
peHl.{I'15I y.n:aJIaCb, XOT5I rro cy-
TI1 cBoeH MaJIO ~eM OTJIHQa-
JIaCb OT Bcex OCTaJIbHbIX KOH-
cPepeHl.{HH UNITED. KaK
MeTKO BbIpa3I1JIC5I rrpe.n:CTaBl'I-
TeJIb 6pHTaHcKoro )KypHa-
JIa ~Searchlighh (~IIpo-
)KeKTop~) Capa6.n:)KH CI1I-Irx,
~KoHcPepeHl.{HH UNITED -
3TO CBoero po.n:a rrcHxoTepa-
rrH5I .n:JI5IBcex Hac, KOTopbIe .n:o-
Ma l.IYBCTBYIOT ce65I I-ICMI-IOrO
H30JIHpOBaHI-Io» .
TOT, KTO XOTeJI 6bI rroJIY-
~I1Tb 60JIee rro.n:po6HbI}I OT~eT
o .n:e5ITeJIbHOCTH IW)K,l(OH H3
pa6o~Hx rpyrrrr Ha 3TOl':'IKOI-I-
cPepeHI~HH, CMo)KeT Ha}ITH ero
Ha ca}ITe:
www. uni teclagainstracism. org.
Co6. KOpp.
paCKOJIOTa5I CBaCTI'lKa ~rro
MonIBaM~ ~AHTHcPallIHcT-
CKoro MOTHBa~ (BTOpOH HO-
MCP )KypHaJIa pa3.n:aBaJIC5I
:1l)HTeJI5IM rrepe.n: crreKTaK-
.IICM). KYKJIbI )Ke rrOpa)KaJIH
pU3MepaMH, pa3Hoo6pa3HeM
cP0PM H / He06bI~HOCTbIO
TpaKToBoK Tpa.n:Hl.{HOHHbIX
rrepCOHa)Ke:i1. AHTHepallIl1CT
KOJI060K, HeepopJVIaJI H 6ec-
rrpH30pHI1K, HeBOJIbHO BbI3bI-
BaJI B rraM5ITH crapyIO llIYTKY
o 6PHTOM e)KHKe. 3JIo.n:eeM-
Hal.{HoHaJIHCTOM OKa3aJIC5I
IIeTpYllIKa, a EypaTHHo, CTa-
pbIH H 06JIe3JlbIH, IIoCTpa.n:aJI,
KaK HaM 06b5ICHHJIH, OT CO-
BeTCKOH BJIaCTVI.
Bce 3TO BbIr JI5I.n:eJIO5IpKO
H 3ar-muro Ha epOHe CKYl.IHeH-
llIHX rrepepopMaHCOB H I1H-
CTaJIJI5Il.{I1H, aBTopbI KOTOPbIX
CJIOBHO peIIlHJIH 6POCHTb Bce
CHJIbI Ha 60pb6y C KaKHM 6bI
TO HH 6bIJIO CMbICJIOM. XOTI1M
rrO)KeJIaTb aHTHcPallIHcTCKOMY
TeaTpy BCWIeCIwro rrpl13Ha-
HH5I - xy.n:O)KHHKaMH, 3pHTe-
JI5IMH, JIIO.n:J)MIL..
C. C651mOMUKOJl06
AHTII<I>AIllIICTCKIIH TEATP )l;ETII ITPOTIIB BOHHbI
94
II PI15ITHOH HeO)KH.n:aI-IHO-
CTbIO OKa3aJIOCb .n:JI5IHac Ok
HO xy.n:O)KeCTBeHHoe C06bITHe
113 )KH3HI1 ropo.n:a. Ha BbI-
CTaBKe cOBpeMeHHoro I1CKYC-
cTBa, rrpoxo.n:I1BllIeH B aBrYCTe
2002 ro.n:a B rreTep6yprcKoM
MaHe)Ke, 6bIJI rrpe.n:cTaBJIeH
aHTl1cPallIl1CTCKI1H CrreI<TaKJIb
~TeaTpa TeXHOJIOrI1H~. Ero
aBTopbI C03.n:aJIH 3aMe~aTeJIb-
HbIX KYKOJI I1 rrpOCTbIe, HO
BbIpa3l1TeJIbHbIe .n:eKOpal.{HH,
Ha O.n:HOH 113 KOTOPbIX -
B H05I6pe 2002 ro.n:a MbI
lIe rrpoBo.n:I1JII1 Tpa.n:Hl.{110HHOH
.YJIH~HOH aKl.{I1I1,rrOCB5IIl.{eHHoH
j(HIO 60Pb6bI C epallIH3MoM.
I[o.n:roToBKa TaKOH aKl.{1111
J(OJI)KHa rrpoxo.n:I1Tb B KOHl.{e
OKT5I6p5I, a MOCKOBCKl1eC06bI-
TH5I Toro BpeMeHI1 He paCIIO-
JIaraJIH K YJII1~HOH pa60Te.
BMecTo 3TorO B H05I6pe aHTH-
cPallIl1CTCKa5I KOMHCCH5I06Il.{e-
CTBa ~MeMOpl1aJI~ opraHH30-
BaJIa BCTpeQy-KOHl.{epT .n:JI5I
.n:eTeH, rrpl1ypo~eHHYIO K ,llHIO
TOJIepaHTHOCTI1. ,lleTH H rro.n:-
POCTKH 6bIJIH I1 CJIYllIaTeJI5IMI1, 95
H apTHCTaMH. I1x BbIcTynJIe-
HH5I Y)Ke nOTOMY OTBe'-IaJIH
,Z:(YXYMe)KHaUHOHaJIbHO.t'I Tep-
nHMOCTH H ,Z:(PY)K6bI, '-ITO Ka)I{-
,Z:(bIHHCnOJIH5IJI neCHIO Ha CBO-
eM 5I3bIKe, 3HaKOMHJI Bcex
np0'-IHX C ,Z:(Pyroit KYJIbTypO.t'I,
,Z:(eJIHJIC5I HaCJIe,Z:(HeM CBOHX
npe,Z:(KOB.
Y'-IeHHKH IlIKOJIbI B nOceJI-
Ke AJIeKcaH,Z:(pOBCKa5I nOIOT Ha
pa3HbIX 5I3bIKaX H YMeIOT pa-
,Z:(OBaTbC5I HaUHOHaJIbHO-KYJIb-
TypHOMY pa3Hoo6pa3HIO CBoeH
IlIKOJIbI. ITOIOT 11 TaI-IUYIOT ,Z:(e-
TH H3 UbIraHCKHX, MOJI,Z:(aBaH-
CKHX,apM5IHCKHX,rpY3HHCKHX
H, Kone'-IHO, PYCCKHX ceMeH.
I1cnOJIH5IeT rpYCTI-IbIe H Bece-
JINe eBpeHCKHe MeJIO,Z:(HH HX
ne,Z:(aror EopI1C AJIeKCeeB. A
,Z:(eTYIH3 60JIbIlIO.t'I peJIHrH03-
HOH ceMbH CaBocTHUKHX no-
IOT ,Z:(,=UKeno- JIaTbIHI1. I1cnoJI-
I-IeHHbIH HMI1 Ha 3TOT pa3 Ka-
HOH «Dono nobis pacem~
BeCbMa no,Z:(xo,Z:(HJI K 06IIIeMY
HacTpoeHHIO BCTpe'-IH. %)la.t'I
HaM MHP~, -- neJII1 ,Z:(eTH no-
JIaTbIHH, lIIOJIOM-aJIe.t'IKYM Hr-
paJI EOPHC Ha KJIapIleTe, a
3Ha'-IHT 3TO nO'-ITH O,Z:(HOH TO
)Ke, MOJIIITBa 0 MIIpe - ,Z:(peB-
H5I5I, KaK caM MI1p.
KpOMe aJIeKcaH,Z:(poBcKIIX
lIIKOJIbHIIKOB B MOJIo,Z:(e)KHOM
KJIy6e %KgC~ C06paJIIICb Y'-Ia-
I.IJ:HeC5I ,Z:(PYfJIX lIIKOJI, OHII TO-
)Ke neJIH, IIrpaJIH Ha fHTapax,
cHHTe3aTope, caKco¢OHe. 3BY-
'-IaJIH neCHH OKY,Z:()KaBbI II :U05I,
Bce 6e3 HCKJIIOQeHH5I OHII 6bI-
JIII 0 HenpII5ITYII1 BO.t'IHbI, 0 He-
06XO,Z:(HMOCTHTpe60BaTb MHpa,
o fope, KOTopoe npIIHOCIIT Ha-
CIIJIHe. 3TO HOBoe 110KOJIeHIIe
)KI1TeJIeH HallieH cTpaHbI On5ITb
paCTeT B Hel\IHpHOe BpeM5I.
amI npOTI1B BO.t'IHbI. XOPOlIIO,
'-ITO XOTb OHH rrOHHMaIOT.
C. Cc,mnO.MU1WJlOC
B nOMem:eHHH o6m:eCTBa«~eMopHa~» pa60TaeT
aHTH4>amHcTcKau 6H6~HOTeKa.
B ¢oH,Z:(ax 6H6JII10TeKI1 XpaH5ITC5I KHHrI1 no np06JIeMaM
¢aIIIH3Ma, HaIJ;I13Ma, TOTaJII1TapI13Ma, npaB03aI.QI1TIla5I JII1Teparypa.
I1MeeTC5I YHI1KaJIbHa5I KOJIJIeKUH5I aHrn4>amHcTcKHX nepHO,ll;H-'IeCKHX H3,ll;aHHH, BbIXO,Z:(5IIIII1XB POCCI1I1, BeJII1K06pI1TaHI1H,
fepMaHI1I1, <t>PaHUI1H, lliBeUHH, HopBerHH, )laHHH.
qHTaTeJIH MorYT BOCnOJIb30BaTbC5I aJI4>aBHTHoH H CHCTe-MaTH'IeCKOH KapToTeKoH cTaTeH H KHH)I{HbIX 113j(aUHH j~aI-IHOH
TeMaTI1KH, COCTaBJIeHHOH Ha OCHOBe MaTepHaJIOB POCCHHCKOH
HaUlIOHaJIbHOH 6H6JIHOTeKH H co,Z:(ep)KaIIIeH HII¢opMallHIO no
¢OH,Z:(aM MHorHX 6H6JIHOTeKPOCCHH.
BH6JIHOTeKa OTKpbITaB nOHe,ll;eJIbHHK H cpe,ll;YC 11 ,ll;O 17 'IaCOB,B 'IeTBepr C 14 ,ll;O20 'IaCOB.
CnpaBKH no TeJIe4>oHY314-23-68 (,ll;06aBO'lHbIH 3).A,a;pec: YJI. Pa3'be3)KaH, ,ll;. 9(BXO,ll; co ,ll;BOpa).
96
••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••Yqpe,lUfTeJIb: CaHKT-IIeTep6yprcKoe 06UleCfBO <lMeMOpUaJI!>
191002, CaHKT-IIeTep6ypr, YJI. Pa3be3)KaH, 9.
~pec pe,/(aKI(Uu: 191002, CaI-IKT-IIeTep6ypr, YJl, Pa3be3)[(aH, 9.http://tumbalalaika.memo.ru
THpa)K 800 3K3.JII06ble nepeneqaTKH npHBeTcmYloTCH.
IIpocHM no B03MO/KHOCTHCCbIJlaTbCHHa HCTO'IHHK.
••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••