7/23/2019 Anlisis Jurisprudencial Sentencia c 093 de 1994

1/3

ANLISIS JURISPRUDENCIAL SENTENCIA C 093 DE 1994

ANLISIS, CONTRASTE Y CONFLICTOS DE LOS MTODOS INTERPRETATIVOSUTILIZADOS EN LA SENTENCIA C 093 DE 1994:

Cri!ri"# $! i%!r&r!'(i)% *i+i'$"# &"r +' -'."r/' $! +"# -'i#r'$"# *! $!(+'r'r"%

!2!*i+! !+ 'r/(*+" 50 $! +' +!. 6 $! 199 *! 7i"+'' !+ %*-!r'+ 5 $!+ 'r/(*+" 189 $!+' ("%#i*(i)% . "r'# $i#&"#i(i"%!# #*&!ri"r!#:

E% +' #!%!%(i' !#*$i'$' &"$!-"# &!r(''r%"# *! !+ -"$" *i+i'$" &"r +"#-'i#r'$"# *! $!(i$i!r"% +' !2!*ii+i$'$ $!+ 'r/(*+" -!%(i"%'$" '%!ri"r-!%!, *! !+i%!r&r!'i7" $! +' +!. &"r !2!%#i)% .' *! #! '-&+i) +' "r-' $! ("%(!ir . !%!%$!r +'&r";ii(i)% ("%#i*(i"%'+ ("%!%i$' !% !+ %*-!r'+ 5 $!+ 'r/(*+" 189 #*&!ri"r,$!#-!-r'r *% ('r" " &'r' #!r -i!-r" $!*%' ("r&"r'(i)% &?+i(' ., !#'%$" !% !B!r(i(i" $!+ -i#-", '#&ir' ' #!r !+!i$' &'r' "r'("r&"r'(i)% " ('r" (*." &!r/"$" ("i%(i$!, #i*i!r' &'r(i'+-!%!, ("% !+ *! 7!%/'!B!r(i!%$"@

P'r' !#! #!*%$" #*&*!#", !# *%$'-!%'+ '&r!(i'r &'r' +"# i%!# $! +' i%;'i+i$'$,!%r! *i!% ;' #i$" !+!i$" . $!#!-&!>' !+ ('r" " $!#i%" &?+i(" ("rr!#&"%$i!%! .*i!%, &!#! ;'!r #i$" !+!i$", %" ;' !B!r(i$" !+ !-&+!" " i%!rr*-&i) !+ r!#&!(i7"&!r/"$", .' *! #i #! &r!#!%' !+ &ri-!r !%)-!%" +' ("%#!(*!%(i' #!ri' +' i%;'i+i$'$ '$i!r!%(i' $!+ #!*%$" !7!%" !% *! i!% &*!$! *%' &!r#"%' ;'!r #i$" !+!i$' . %";'!r#! &"#!#i"%'$" !% !+ ('r", !# $!(ir &*!$! %" ;'!r !B!r(i$" $*r'%! !+ &!ri"$"*! +! ("rr!#&"%$/', " &*!$! ;'!r i%i(i'$" #* &!ri"$" . ;'!r+" i%!rr*-&i$" -!$i'%!#* r!%*%(i' "r-'+-!%! '(!&'$'@

P'r' +"# -'i#r'$"# *! $!(+'r'r"% +' !2!*ii+i$'$ $! !#' %"r-', !+ &!ri"$" !# $!

('r

7/23/2019 Anlisis Jurisprudencial Sentencia c 093 de 1994

2/3

E% !#' 'r*-!%'(i)% B*r/$i(' #! *i+i'% $i7!r#"# !+!-!%"# $! i%!r&r!'(i)% $! +'#+!.!#, !%r! !++"# !+ +i!r'+ " r'-'i('+, !+ ;i#)ri(" . !+ #i#!-'+" *! +' r!%*%(i' '(!&'$' $!+("%r!#i#' ("%#i*.! '+' '#"+*' . &r"$*(! +' 7'('%(i' $!+ ('r", &!r" $! %i%*%'

-'%!r' #! !#'+!(i) *! !#' r!%*%(i' i%!rr*-&i!r' !+ &!ri"$"@ P"r !+ ("%r'ri", +"#-i#-"# -'i#r'$"# *! $!(i$i!r"% +' !2!*ii+i$'$ !% +' #!%!%(i' r!("%"(i!r"% !+#!%i$" "B!i7" $!+ &!ri"$" .' *! !2&r!#'-!%! #!>'+'r"% *! *%' 7! "(*rri$' +'7'('%(i', !+ ("%r!#i#' $!! #!r #*#i*i$" $! -'%!r' $!i%ii7' &"r *i!% +" #i*! !% +'("rr!#&"%$i!%! +i#', ;'#' +' !r-i%'(i)% $!+ &!ri"$" +!i#+'i7"@

E# i-&"r'%! #!>'+'r ("-" !+!-!%" i%!r&r!'i7" #i#!-

7/23/2019 Anlisis Jurisprudencial Sentencia c 093 de 1994

3/3

C'r' P"+/i(' *! r!*+'% +' r!+'(i)% !%r! +"# !+!("r!# . +"# !+!i$"# $!%r" $!+ -'r("$! *%' $!-"(r'(i' i%!r'+@

D! +" '%!ri"r &"$!-"# i%!r&r!'r *! !+ !+!i$" &'r' "(*&'r *% ('r" &*+i(" &"r -!$i"$! !+!((i)% &"&*+'r, ' +' +* $! +' ("%#i*(i)% $! 1991, i!%! *%' r!#&"%#'i+i$'$ &"+/i('("% #*# !+!("r!#, .' *! !+ ("-&r"-i#" -/%i-" *! '$*i!r!% !#'# &!r#"%'# !# !+ $!(*-&+ir !+ &!ri"$" &'r' !+ (*'+ r!#*+" !+!i$", &"r ("%#i*i!%!, +"# -'i#r'$"#("%#i$!r'% *! +' &r";ii(i)% $!+ 'r/(*+" 189 "r$i%'+ 5 $! +' ("%#i*(i)% &"+/i(' ("%i*r'*%' i%;'i+i$'$ *! %" #! &*!$! #*#'%'r ("% +' r!%*%(i' $!+ !+!i$"@

INTERPRETACIN HISTRICA UTILIZADA EN EL SALVAMENTO DE VOTO:

L"# -'i#r'$"# ("%#i$!r'r"% *! +' i%;'i+i$'$ !#'+!(i$' !% !+ 'r/(*+" 189 "r$i%'+5!r' ("%("r$'%! ("% !+ #!%i$" ;i#)ri(" $! +' A#'-+!' N'(i"%'+ C"%#i*.!%!, .' *!!% +"# $!'!# $! '*!++' &"(', #! !7i$!%(i'' *! +' i%'+i$'$ $!+ !#'+!(i-i!%" $!i%;'i+i$'$!# ! i%("-&'ii+i$'$!# '%" ' ("%r!#i#'# ("-" ' "$"# +"# #!r7i$"r!#

&?+i("#, !%/' *%' (+'r' *%(i)% $! r!%"7'(i)% $! +'# ("#*-r!# &"+/i('# $! C"+"-i',$!i$" '+ r'% $!#&r!#ii" $! *! "''% +'# i%#i*(i"%!# !#''+!#, ("-" !+ ("%r!#"@

3@ CUAL DE LAS DOS POSICIONES CONSIDERA USTED UE ESTA RESPALDADAPOR LA MEJOR UTILIZACIN Y DESARROLLO DE LOS CRITERIOS DE i%!r&r!'(i)%K

D! '(*!r$" ("% +' +!(*r' $! +'# &"#i(i"%!# !%("%r'$'# !% +' #!%!%(i', r!#&'+$" !+'%