4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

download 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

of 54

Transcript of 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    1/54

      "

    "# $%& '($$&) *+ $%& (),"$)($"*#

    ,&$-&

    # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # ##########$%&'($%) *((&+%)) ),%-., /0)%1,23 %33(4'%&'($ /

    /56 /

    /&7, $%&'($%) *((&+%)) ),%-., /%89 :; 4).+ H %HH=IA?@A=8/&=J KD0?H=L ,HMFA>D7D?@ND> ?Q8L ))0

    RDSS>DG )6 TDHHBD>L ,HMFA>DK?5A9 ->DD8HU?8L ,HMFA>DR=8?@N?8 %J==8?L ,HMFA>DR=N8 36 &HINA>EAL ,HMFA>D

    *=> $?@A=8?B *==@C?BB )D?EFD/%9=BUN=6 %6 +A>IN '''L ,HMFA>DTD5A8 ?L ,HMFA>DO6 +FIVBDG +>AEEHL ,HMFA>D+>==V -?>9A8D>L ,HMFA>D%VA8L -FJUL 3@>?FHHL 7?FD> P *DB9L ))0

    K?8ADB )6 $?HNL ,HMFA>D3@?IDG ,AHD8H@DA8L ,HMFA>DR?JDH ,6 &GHHDL ,HMFA>D

    R=8?@N?8 +6 VH%>CA@>?@=> ## $=8#'8WF>G ->AD5?8ID 0?8DB %U>AB ""L ;X"Y

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    2/54

      ;

    *./0/10 203 (4253

    "6  ,278951:03

    (8 R?8F?>G ;;L ;X"ZL @ND $?@A=8?B *==@C?BB )D?EFD 0B?GD>H %HH=IA?@A=8 [\$*)0%]^

    SABD9 ? 8=8#A8WF>G E>AD5?8ID [\->AD5?8ID]^ ?E?A8H@ @ND $?@A=8?B *==@C?BB )D?EFD [\$*)]^ ?89?BB :; $*) 4BFCH [\4BFCH]^ UF>HF?8@ @= %>@AIBD _: =S @ND %FEFH@ _L ;X""L 4=BBDI@A5D+?>E?A8A8E %E>DDJD8@ [\4+%]^6 $*) ,`6 "6

    (8 *DC>F?>G aL ;X"ZL @ND $*)

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    3/54

      :

    (8 %FEFH@ ""L ;X"ZL ' Q?H A8S=>JD9 @N?@ @ND 0?>@ADH N?9 N?9 9AHIFHHA=8H ?C=F@>DH=B5A8E @ND ->AD5?8ID6 ' ?E>DD9 @= @ND 0?>@ADHd >DMFDH@ @N?@ ' N=B9 JG 9DIAHA=86 ' >DIDA5D9 ?HD>ADH =S SF>@ND> >DMFDH@H ?HVA8E @N?@ ' N=B9 JG 9DIAHA=8 CD@QDD8 %FEFH@ ;X"Z ?89 *DC>F?>G;ZL ;X"YL QA@N @ND B?H@ >DMFDH@ ?HVA8E @N?@ ' N=B9 JG 9DIAHA=8 F8@AB IN :"L ;X"Y6

    %CHD8@ HD@@BDJD8@L ' 8=Q =SSD> JG (UA8A=8 ?89 %Q?>96

    ""6  )123;2. =IDD9 ?H S=BB=QH/

    •  3DI@A=8 ''' =F@BA8DH @ND AHHFDH U>DHD8@D9 ?89 @ND >DBADS H=FEN@ CG @ND $*)0%6

    •  3DI@A=8 'b U>DHD8@H ? HFJJ?>G =S @ND 0?>@ADHd =5D>5ADQ ?>EFJD8@H6

    •  3DI@A=8 b 9D?BH QA@N @ND @N>DHN=B9 AHHFD =S >AUD8DHH6

    •  3FCHDMFD8@ HDI@A=8H U>DHD8@ @ND 0?>@ADHd AHHFD#HUDIASAI ?>EFJD8@H ?89 JG ?8?BGHAH?89 9DIAHA=8 =8 D?IN =S @ND IF>>D8@BG I=8@DH@D9 AHHFDH/

    3DI@A=8 b'/ )D?5D QA@N 0?Go  3DI@A=8 b''/ KAHIAUBA8?>G (SSAID>o  3DI@A=8 b'''/ &NA>9#0?>@G %95AHD>H ?89 '89DUD89D8@ %UUD?B ,`UD>@H6o  3DI@A=8 'e/ 4=F8HDBA8EL &>D?@JD8@L &ND>?UGL ,8N?8ID9 3FUD>5AHA=8

    •  3DI@A=8 e HFJJ?>AfDH JG 9DIAHA=8H6

    """6  "==:>= ?5>=>03 203 )>@/>A B1:9C<

    %H SABD9 =8 R?8F?>G ;;L ;X"ZL @ND ->AD5?8ID IN?BBD8ED9 @D8 HUDIASAI ?HUDI@H ; =S @ND$*) 0D>H=8?B 4=89FI@ 0=BAIG ?88=F8ID9 CG 4=JJAHHA=8D> -==9DBB =8 KDIDJCD> "XL ;X"_[\$DQ 0=BAIG]^6 &ND ->AD5?8ID ?HVD9 S=>/

     

    % 9DIB?>?@A=8 @N?@ \@N=HD HUDIASAI ?HUDI@H =S @ND $DQ 0=BAIG QNAIN ?>D A8I=8HAH@D8@QA@N @ND 4+% g?>Dh A85?BA9]i ?89

    •  %8 \=>9D>] @N?@ \@ND )D?EFD 6 6 6 ID?HD ?89 9DHAH@ S>=J HDDVA8E @= AJUBDJD8@ @NDJ A8I=8@>?5D8@A=8 =S @ND 4+%6]

    ; &ND ->AD5?8ID IN?BBD8ED9 @ND S=BB=QA8E ?HUDI@H =S @ND $DQ 0=BAIG/"6

     

    0B?IDJD8@ =S UB?GD>H =8 @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> ,`DJU@ )AH@6;6

     

    &ND 9AHIAUBA8?>G =SSAID>6:6  &ND U>=C?@A=8?>G UD>A=9 ?89 U>D#ND?>A8E I=89A@A=8H6_6

     

    KAHIAUBA8?>G FHD =S I=F8HDBA8EL D9FI?@A=8L @>D?@JD8@L => @ND>?UG6

    Z6 

    +?8AHNJD8@6Y6  4=JJF8A@G HD>5AID6j6  ,8N?8ID9 HFUD>5AHA=86a6

     

    '89DUD89D8@ D`UD>@H @= >DI=JJD89 ? 9DIAHA=8 =8 ?UUD?B6c6  4=8IBFHA5D 8?@F>D =S ? I=F>@dH 9AHU=HA@A=8 ?89 S?I@F?B SA89A8EH6"X6  '85=B5DJD8@ =S @NA>9#U?>@G ?95AHD>H A8 =@ND> U?>@H =S @ND 9AHIAUBA8D U>=IDHH6

    $*) ,`6 " ?@ ;#a6

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    4/54

      _

    $*)0% 0>D#7D?>A8E +>ADS ?@ Z [\0%0>D7+]^6

    '8 A@H 0>D#7D?>A8E +>ADSL @ND $*)0% H@?@D9 @N?@ \gAh8 @NAH ->AD5?8IDL @ND $*)0% N?HIN?BBD8ED9 @ND $DQ 0=BAIG A@HDBS CDI?FHD @N?@ 0=BAIGk"+ 1,8 952$kI=8SBAI@H QA@N @ND 4+%L@ND U?>@ADHd IFH@=J ?89 U>?I@AIDL ?89 @ND lB?Q =S @ND HN=U6d] 7-6 ?@ "X6

    KF>A8E @ND I=F>HD =S @NDHD E>AD5?8ID U>=IDD9A8EHL @ND $*)0% N?H 8?>>=QD9 A@HIN?BBD8EDL ?HVA8E @N?@ @ND %>CA@>?@=>/

    gKhDIB?>D A85?BA9L ?89 AHHFD ? ID?HD ?89 9DHAH@ ?89 I=JUBA?8ID QA@N @ND 4+% =>9D>L?E?A8H@ @ND S=BB=QA8E U>=5AHA=8H =S @ND $DQ 0=BAIG/

    "6  &ND $DQ 0=BAIGdH \)D?5D QA@N 0?G] U>=5AHA=8 A8 A@H D8@A>D@GL A8IBF9A8EA@H UF>U=>@D9 FHD =S @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> ,`DJU@ )AH@ [$*) ,`6 ;Z ?@XXX"":#"_^i

    ;6  &ND $DQ 0=BAIGdH 9DBDE?@A=8 =S @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH D`IBFHA5D?F@N=>A@G \@= J?VD @ND A8A@A?B 9DIAHA=8 =8 9AHIAUBA8D] @= ?\9AHIAUBA8?>G =SSAID>] [1-6 ?@ XXX""_^i

    :6  &ND $DQ 0=BAIGdH U>=5AHA=8 @N?@ \g9hAHIAUBA8D J?G ?BH= A8IBF9D>DMFA>DJD8@H @= HDDV =8E=A8E I=F8HDBA8EL @>D?@JD8@L => @ND>?UGQND>D ?UU>=U>A?@D ?H QDBB ?H @ND AJU=HA@A=8 =S D8N?8ID9HFUD>5AHA=8] [1-6 ?@ XXX""Z^L BD?5A8E @ND )D?EFD @= A8H@D?9 ?UUBG @ND\,5?BF?@A=8L 4=F8HDBA8E ?89 &>D?@JD8@] U>=5AHA=8 =S @ND ;XXj0D>H=8?B 4=89FI@ 0=BAIG [$*) ,`6 ;c ?@ XXX";a^L @= QNAIN @ND .8A=8?E>DD9 ?89 QNAIN @ND $*) ?UUBAD9 A8 HFCHDMFD8@ 0D>H=8?B 4=89FI@0=BAIADH U>A=> @= @ND $DQ 0=BAIGi ?89

    _6 

    &ND $DQ 0=BAIGdH U>=5AHA=8H ?BB=QA8E S=> =F@HA9D U?>@ADH @=U?>@AIAU?@D A8 @ND I=8SA9D8@A?B ?89 I=BBDI@A5DBG#C?>E?A8D9 9AHIAUBA8?>G?89 ?UUD?BH U>=IDHHDHi HUDIASAI?BBGL @ND U>=5AHA=8 ?BB=QA8E @NA>9#U?>@G ?95AH=>H \@= ?HHAH@ g@ND 9AHIAUBA8?>G =SSAID>h A8 D5?BF?@A8E ?U=@D8@A?B 5A=B?@A=8] =S @ND $DQ 0=BAIGL ?89 @ND U>=5AHA=8 @N?@ @ND\4=JJAHHA=8D> J?G 8?JD ? U?8DB @N?@ I=8HAH@H =S A89DUD89D8@D`UD>@H @= >DI=JJD89 ? 9DIAHA=8 =8 @ND ?UUD?B] [$*) ,`6 ;Z ?@XXX""ZL XXX""j^6

    $*)0% 0=H@#7D?>A8E +>ADS ?@ Y: [\0%0=H@#7+]^L

    '8 ?99A@A=8L @ND $*)0% ?HVH @N?@ @ND %>CA@>?@=> \AHHFD ?8 =>9D>L UF>HF?8@ @= %>@AIBD ;L

    3DI@A=8 _[C^ =S @ND 4+%L @= g9A>DI@ @ND $*) @=h ID?HD ?89 9DHAH@ S>=J AJUBDJD8@A8E @ND?JD89JD8@ @= 3DI@A=8 "j6"_[%^ =S @ND $*) 4=8H@A@F@A=8 ?89 +GB?QH: [$*)0% ,`6 "_^ =8 @NDE>=F89 @N?@ A@ 5A=B?@DH ?89m=> >D89D>H JD?8A8EBDHH @ND U>=5AHA=8H =S @ND 4+% @N?@ U>=@DI@UB?GD>H S>=J I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B ?I@A=8 U>A=> @= ? SA89A8E =S EFAB@ ?89 @ND =UU=>@F8A@G S=> ?ND?>A8E6] 7-6

    : 7D>DA8?S@D>L \4+)6]

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    5/54

      Z

    "D6  $C> ?25=E (59:;>05G/>4

    '8 @NAH 3DI@A=8 ' C>ADSBG H@?@D @ND =5D>?BB UD>HUDI@A5D =S D?IN HA9D QA@N >DE?>9 @= @NAHE>AD5?8ID6 ' U>=5A9D 9D@?ABH =S @ND 0?>@ADHd ?>EFJD8@H =8 @ND HUDIASAI?BBG IN?BBD8ED9 DBDJD8@H=S @ND $DQ 0=BAIG B?@D> A8 @NAH (UA8A=8 ?89 %Q?>96

     (6  $C> #+H?(E= ?1=/AD5?8ID \IN?BBD8EDH HUDIASAI ?HUDI@H =S @ND $*) 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH 8DQ0D>H=8?B 4=89FI@ 0=BAIG 6 6 6 QNAIN Q?H F8AB?@D>?BBG AJUBDJD8@D9 CG @ND )D?EFDL QA@N=F@I=BBDI@A5D C?>E?A8A8EL ?89 5A=B?@DH @ND 4+% A8 HD5D>?B =S A@H VDG SD?@F>DH6] [0%0>D#7+ ?@ "^6

    %H @ND $*)0% HDDH @ND J?@@D>/

    &ND $*) ?88=F8ID9 @ND $DQ 0=BAIG =8 KDIDJCD> "XL ;X"_ ?H @ND )D?EFDdH >DHU=8HD@= J=8@NH =S A8@D8HD JD9A? I>A@AIAHJ ?AJD9 ?@ @ND $*)dH N?89BA8E =S ? 8FJCD> =S\I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B] I?HDHL A8IBF9A8EL J=H@ 8=@?CBGL @ND 2?G 2AID A8IA9D8@6 &ND>D AH8= 9AHUF@D @N?@ @ND )D?EFDdH N?89BA8E =S HFIN I?HDH 8DD9H AJU>=5DJD8@kCF@ @ND$*) JFH@ AJUBDJD8@ ?8G IN?8EDH A8 ? J?88D> I=8HAH@D8@ QA@N @ND @D>JH =S @ND 4+%"/ @ND $*) JFH@ I=BBDI@A5DBG C?>E?A8 QA@N @ND .8A=8 @= J=9ASG @ND 4+%6 &ND4=JJAHHA=8D> J?G N?5D C>=?9 ?F@N=>A@G @= 9DSA8D QN?@ I=8H@A@F@DH I=89FI@9D@>AJD8@?B @= @ND )D?EFDL CF@ A@ AH 8=@ F8SD@@D>D9 ?F@N=>A@Gi HUDIASAI?BBGL ND I?88=@5A=B?@D @ND @D>JH =S @ND 4+% => UB?GD>Hd >AEN@H6 &NFHL ND Q?H 8=@ ?@ BACD>@G @= AJU=HD@ND $DQ 0=BAIG ?@ NAH QNAJL QA@N=F@ >DE?>9 @= @N=HD 4+% BAJA@?@A=8H6 'S @ND $*)CDBAD5DH @N?@ SA`A8E A@H 0D>H=8?B 4=89FI@ 0=BAIG >DMFA>DH IN?8EDH @= @ND 4+%L @ND8 A@H=8BG >DI=F>HD AH @= I=BBDI@A5DBG C?>E?A8 ?89 >D?IN ?E>DDJD8@ QA@N @ND .8A=8 =8 ?8GIN?8EDHL QNAIN N?H 8=@ =IIF>>D96

    7-6 ?@ ;6

    &ND $*)0% DJUN?HAfDH @N?@ A@H \E>AD5?8ID 9=DH +",  IN?BBD8ED @ND $*)dH ?F@N=>A@G @=F8AB?@D>?BBG AHHFD 5 $DQ 0=BAIG H= B=8E ?H A@ AH I=8HAH@D8@ QA@N @ND U?>?JD@D>H HD@ S=>@N A8 @ND4+%i A@ IN?BBD8EDH =8BG @N=HD ?HUDI@H =S ,:$ $DQ 0=BAIG @N?@ ?>D 1+2"+818,$+,  QA@N @ND 4+%6 'S@ND $*) QAHNDH @= IN?8ED @ND 4+%L A@H =8BG >DI=F>HD AH I=BBDI@A5D C?>E?A8A8E6] 7-6 ?@ Z[DJUN?HAH A8 =>AEA8?B^6

    %II=>9A8E @= @ND $*)0%L \g?hB@N=FEN @ND $*) N?H U>=JFBE?@D9 U>A=> 5D>HA=8H =S @ND0D>H=8?B 4=89FI@ 0=BAIG QA@N=F@ @ND $*)0%dH ?E>DDJD8@L @ND $DQ 0=BAIG J?>VH ? 9DU?>@F>DS>=J U?H@ U>?I@AID CDI?FHD A@ S?IA?BBG I=8SBAI@H QA@N @ND 4+% A8 JG>A?9 >DHUDI@H6 ;"+$ =S @NDIN?BBD8ED9 ?HUDI@H =S @ND $DQ 0=BAIG ?UUD?>D9 A8 A@H U>A=> A@D>?@A=8HL ?89 5%% I=8SBAI@ QA@N

    HUDIASAI ?89 F8?JCAEF=FH @D>JH =S @ND 4+%6] 0%0=H@#7+ ?@ " [DJUN?HAH A8 =>AEA8?B^6

    '8 @ND $*)0%dH 5ADQL QNABD @ND \4=JJAHHA=8D>dH I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B ?F@N=>A@G J?GCD C>=?9L 6 6 6 A@ AH 8=@ F8BAJA@D96 &ND ;X"" 4=BBDI@A5D +?>E?A8A8E %E>DDJD8@ [l4+%d^ k J=H@HAE8ASAI?8@BGL 0?>?E>?UN "Z =S @ND 3@?89?>9 *=>J $*) 0B?GD> 4=8@>?I@ ?89 %>@AIBD _Y kD`U>DHHBG BAJA@H @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B U=QD> ?H A@ ?UUBADH @= $*) UB?GD>H6D=5D>L @ND 4+% @>FJUH ?BB =@ND> $*) U=BAIADH ?89 9=IFJD8@HL A8IBF9A8E @ND $*)4=8H@A@F@A=8 ?89 +GB?QHL ?89 J?G 8=@ CD ?JD89D9 QA@N=F@ Q>A@@D8 ?E>DDJD8@ =S @ND$*)0%6 @6 ;L nn "L _[?^6] 7-6 ?@ "6

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    6/54

      Y

    '89DD9L ?II=>9A8E @= @ND $*)0%L \gUh?>?E>?UN "Z =S @ND $*) 0B?GD> 4=8@>?I@L ?HA8I=>U=>?@D9 A8 @ND 4+% [8$$ 1-6L %>@6 _L n "^L AH @ND I=BBDI@A5DBG#C?>E?A8D9 H=F>ID =S @ND4=JJAHHA=8D>dH ?F@N=>A@G @= 9AHIAUBA8D $*) UB?GD>H S=> I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?Bi @ND>D AH 8==@ND> E>?8@ =S UB?GD> ?F@N=>A@G S=> @ND AJU=HA@A=8 =S 4=JJAHHA=8D> 9AHIAUBA8D =8 UB?GD>H[QNAIN =8BG @ND .8A=8 I?8 E>?8@ =8 CDN?BS =S A@H JDJCD>HNAU^6] 0%0>D7+ ?@ Z6

    ,6  $C> #+HE= ?1=/

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    7/54

      j

    HFIN SF@F>D I?HDH C?HD9 =8 HUDIFB?@A=8 ?89 QA@N=F@ ? U>=UD> S?I@F?B C?HAH AH 8=@UD>JA@@D9 F89D> @ND 4+%6

    $*) 0>D#7D?>A8E +>ADS ?@ "#; [\$*)0>D#7+]^6

    D6  $C5>=C1@3 "==:>I )/.>0>==

     (6  $C> #+HE= ?1=/DHN=B9 J?@@D>L @ND $*) I=8@D89H @N?@ ' HN=FB9 9AHJAHH @NAH E>AD5?8ID ?H ?U>DJ?@F>D >DMFDH@ S=> ?8 \?95AH=>G =UA8A=8L] QNAIN A@ I=8@D89H ' ?J 8=@ ?F@N=>AfD9 F89D>@ND 4+% @= >D89D>6 7-6 ?@ ;:#;_6 %II=>9A8E @= @ND $*)/

    %>@AIBD _: UD>JA@H E>AD5?8IDH A85=B5A8E @ND A8@D>U>D@?@A=8 =SL ?UUBAI?@A=8 =SL =>I=JUBA?8ID QA@N U>=5AHA=8H =S @ND 4+% ?89 $*) 4=8H@A@F@A=8L ?H B=8E ?H @NDG\UD>@?A8gh @= @ND @D>JH ?89 I=89A@A=8H =S DJUB=GJD8@ =S $*) UB?GD>H6] @6_:6 +F@ @ND $*)0% AH 8=@ IN?BBD8EA8E @ND ?UUBAI?@A=8 =S @ND 0=BAIG @= ?8G U?>@AIFB?>UB?GD>i >?@ND>L A@ AH HAJUBG IN?BBD8EA8E @ND ?88=F8IDJD8@ =S @ND 0=BAIGL =8 @NDE>=F89 @N?@ @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH AJUBDJD8@?@A=8 =S @ND 0=BAIG A8 @ND SF@F>D JAEN@5A=B?@D @ND 4+%6

    7-6 ?@ ;_ [S==@8=@D =JA@@D9^6

    g&hND $*)0% N?H A8?UU>=U>A?@DBG ?HVD9 @ND ?>CA@>?@=> @= 9DIA9D N=Q @ND4=JJAHHA=8D> JAEN@ ?UUBG @ND 0=BAIG A8 D`D>IAHA8E NAH C>=?9 %>@AIBD _Y 9AHI>D@A=8 A8@ND ?CH@>?I@L >?@ND> @N?8 ?HHD>@A8E @N?@ @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> N?H ?I@F?BBG 5==%1$-   @NDU=BAIG \A8 ? J?88D> @N?@ 5A=B?@DH @ND I=8@>?I@F?B >AEN@H] =S ? JDJCD> =S @NDC?>E?A8A8E F8A@ \A8 ? U?>@AIFB?> I?HD6] +DI?FHD 8= UB?GD> N?H IB?AJD9 A8WF>G @= 9?@DC?HD9 =8 @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH ?I@F?B ?UUBAI?@A=8 =S @ND 8DQ 0=BAIGL @NAH S?IA?B

    IN?BBD8ED @= @ND 0=BAIG AH U>DJ?@F>D ?89 F8>AUD S=> U>DHD8@ ?9WF9AI?@A=86

    7-6 ?@ ;Y [DJUN?HAH A8 =>AEA8?Bi IA@?@A=8H =JA@@D9^6

    ,6  $C> #+H?(E= ?1=/A8D =S \>AUD8DHH] QD>D \CA89A8E =8@ND 0?>@ADH ND>DL] QNAIN A@ >DWDI@HL @N?@ 9=I@>A8D \=8BG =UD>?@DH @= U>D5D8@ l?95AH=>G=UA8A=8Hd 9DIA9A8E l?CH@>?I@ 9AH?E>DDJD8@Hd CD@QDD8 0?>@ADH6] 0%0=H@#7+ ?@ Zc6 %II=>9A8E@ND $*)0%/

    &ND>D AH 8=@NA8E \?CH@>?I@] ?C=F@ @ND $DQ 0=BAIG => @ND I=8SBAI@A8E 4+% U>=5AHA=8H6

    &NDG ?>D HUDBBD9 =F@L A8 @ND >DI=>9L ?89 A8 DSSDI@6 &ND $*)0% N?H U>DHD8@D9 D5A9D8ID=S @ND $DQ 0=BAIG CDA8E ?UUBAD9 8=Q g?89h ? SD9D>?B I=F>@ N?H ?B>D?9G NDB9 @N?@\g@hND>D AH 8= 9AHUF@D @N?@ @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> AJU=HD9 0D@D>H=8dH 9AHIAUBA8D F89D>@ND $DQ 0=BAIG]6 6 6 6

    D=5D>L @ND .8A=8 AH IN?BBD8EA8E S?IA?B 4+% 5A=B?@A=8H A8 @ND $DQ 0=BAIGL QNAIN CG9DSA8A@A=8 9= 8=@ >DMFA>D ? I?HD#CG#I?HD ?8?BGHAH6 &ND 4+% HUDIASAI?BBG U>=5A9DH @N?@A@ @>FJUH \?8G =@ND> 9=IFJD8@ ?SSDI@A8E @D>JH ?89 I=89A@A=8H =S DJUB=GJD8@ =S

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    8/54

      a

    $*) UB?GD>H6] &ND $DQ 0=BAIG AH HFIN ? 9=IFJD8@ ?89 AH CDS=>D @ND %>CA@>?@=>6$=@NA8E J=>D AH >DMFA>D9 S=> @NAH E>AD5?8ID @= CD \>AUD6]

    7-6 ?@ Zc#YX [IA@?@A=8H ?89 S==@8=@D =JA@@D9^6

    J6   (02@K=/=

    ONABD @ND $*) IA@DH HD5D>?B 8=8#$*) ?F@N=>A@ADH A8 HFUU=>@ =S A@H U=HA@A=8L $*) 0=H@#7D?>A8E +>ADS ?@ ;:#;Z [\$*)0=H@#7+]^L A@ N?H 8=@ H=FEN@ @= >DCF@ @Q= $*) ?>CA@>?B 9DIAHA=8H>DBAD9 =8 CG @ND $*)0% @N?@ ?>D 9A>DI@BG =8 U=A8@L ?@ @ND BD?H@ QA@N >DE?>9 @= JG ?F@N=>A@G ?H? @N>DHN=B9 J?@@D> @= ?99>DHH @ND $*)0%dH I=8@D8@A=8H6

    %H U=A8@D9 =F@ CG @ND $*)0%L A8 @ND >"35%,3 ?%5(8$ .18=(,$ [;XXX^ [+B=INL %>C6^LQNAIN A85=B5D9 ? E>AD5?8ID I=8ID>8A8E \? IB?FHD A8 UB?GD>Hd I=8@>?I@H @N?@ J?9D @NDA>HAE8A8E C=8FH I=8@A8ED8@ =8 8=@ J?VA8E UFCBAI H@?@DJD8@H I>A@AI?B =S @ND 4BFCL] 0%0=H@#7+?@ YXL \gHhA8ID @ND IB?FHD N?9 GD@ @= CD D8S=>ID9 ?E?A8H@ ? UB?GD> [QNAIN AH 8=@ @ND I?HD ND>D^L@ND )D?EFD ?>EFD9 @N?@ @ND E>AD5?8ID Q?H lU>DJ?@F>Dd ?89 lHDDVA8E ?8 ?95AH=>G =UA8A=8dC?HD9 =8 lHUDIFB?@A5Dd ?>EFJD8@H6 %>CA@>?@=> +B=IN 9AH?E>DD9L SA89A8E CDS=>D NAJ l? IF>>D8@?89 >D?B 9AHUF@Dd @N?@ Q?H >AUD S=> NAH >D5ADQ6] 7-6 ?@ Y" [IA@?@A=8H =JA@@D9^6 %H %>CA@>?@=>+B=IN UF@ @ND J?@@D>/

    &ND I=>D ?89 IN?>?I@D> =S @NAH 9AHUF@D AH QND@ND> @ND 4BFCL CG @ND H=BD ?I@ =SC?>E?A8A8E [QA@N @ND UB?GD>^ @ND ND>D#9AHUF@D9 B=G?B@G U>=5AHA=8L N?H 5A=B?@D9 @ND4+%6 &N?@ ?I@ A@HDBSL =8D I=8IBF9DHL AH U>=UD>BG >D5ADQ?CBD6 4BD?>BGL A@ AH ? 9AHUF@DA85=B5A8E @ND A8@D>U>D@?@A=8 =S @ND 4=BBDI@A5D +?>E?A8A8E %E>DDJD8@6 %>@AIBD b'''6 &NDMFDH@A=8 ?HVD9 AH QND@ND> @ND 4BFC N?H C?>E?A8D9 ? I=8SBAI@A8E U>=5AHA=8L @ND>DCGD`U?89A8E @ND D`AH@A8E 4+% >DH@>AI@A=8H =8 J?`AJFJ 9AHIAUBA8D6 'S A@ N?H 9=8D H=L A@AH CG JD?8H =S ?8 ?I@ o C?>E?A8A8E @ND B=G?B@G IB?FHDmC=8FH S=>SDA@F>D @D>JH o @N?@N?H ?B>D?9G CDD8 ?II=JUBAHND9 ?89 8DD9 8=@ ?Q?A@ AJU=HA@A=8 =S ?8G D8S=>IDJD8@

    ?I@A=86 &ND C?>E?A8D9 @D>JH =S @ND I=BBDI@A5D C?>E?A8A8E ?E>DDJD8@ @?VD U>DID9D8IDA8 @ND D5D8@ =S ? lI=8SBAI@6d &ND 9AHUF@D A8 @NAH I?HD ID8@D>H HMF?>DBG =8 QND@ND> HFIN? I=8SBAI@ D`AH@H6 'S @ND B=G?B@G IB?FHD U=HDH HFIN ? I=8SBAI@L @ND I=8SBAI@ ?>AHDH CDI?FHD=S @ND IB?FHDdH D`AH@D8IDL 8=@ CDI?FHD =S A@H D8S=>IDJD8@6 &ND I?HD AH >AUD S=>>DH=BF@A=86

    >"35%,3 ?%5(8$ .18=(,$ ?@ Y#j6

    %BH= UD>@A8D8@ AH @ND $*)0%dH >DBA?8ID =8 @ND ?Q?>9 =S %>CA@>?@=> T?HND> A8 '()*$+,$- ./()L ? I?HD QA@N HFCH@?8@A?B ?89 @DBBA8E HAJAB?>A@ADH @= @NAH =8DL A8 QNAINL ?HU=A8@D9 =F@ CG @ND $*)0%/

    g&hND JD>D AJUBDJD8@?@A=8 =S ? 9AHUF@D9 U=BAIG CG @ND )D?EFDL CDS=>D D8S=>IDJD8@?E?A8H@ A89A5A9F?B UB?GD>HL Q?H HFSSAIAD8@ @= J?VD @ND .8A=8dH E>AD5?8ID >AUD6 &NAHQ?H 8=@ A8 9AHUF@D ?89L A8 S?I@L @ND 0?>@ADH H@AUFB?@D9 @= @ND >AUD8DHH =S @ND J?@@D>6]

    0%0=H@#7+ ?@ Y"L S8 ;YL IA@A8E '()*$+,$- ./() ?@ ;X6

    %II=>9A8EBGL ' SA89 @NAH E>AD5?8ID AH 8=@ U>DJ?@F>D6

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    9/54

      c

    D"6  H>2G> 4/ #>4 ?1@/7KE= L=> 1A ?2/3 (3;/0/=2G> 203

    J1;;/==/10>5 &M>;.< H/=<

     (6  $C> #>4 ?1@/7KE= NH>2G> 4/=5AHA=8 U>=5A9DH/

    H>2G> 4/?@A5D BD?5D => =8 @ND4=JJAHHA=8D> ,`DJU@ )AH@ F89D> DA@ND> =S @ND S=BB=QA8E IA>IFJH@?8IDH/

    *A>H@L G=F ?>D S=>J?BBG IN?>ED9 QA@N ? I>AJD =S 5A=BD8IDL JD?8A8E @N?@ G=F?>D ?IIFHD9 =S N?5A8E FHD9 UNGHAI?B S=>ID => ? QD?U=8 @= A8WF>D => @N>D?@D8?8=@ND> UD>H=8L =S N?5A8E D8E?ED9 A8 ? HD`F?B ?HH?FB@ CG S=>ID => ? HD`F?B?HH?FB@ =S ? UD>H=8 QN= Q?H A8I?U?CBD =S EA5A8E I=8HD8@L =S N?5A8E D8E?ED9A8 =@ND> I=89FI@ @N?@ U=HDH ? ED8FA8D 9?8ED> @= @ND H?SD@G => QDBB#CDA8E =S?8=@ND> UD>H=8L => =S N?5A8E D8E?ED9 A8 ?8AJ?B ?CFHD6 &ND S=>J?B IN?>EDHJ?G CD A8 @ND S=>J =S ?8 A89AI@JD8@ CG ? E>?89 WF>GL @ND SABA8E =S IN?>EDH CG ?U>=HDIF@=>L => ?8 ?>>?AE8JD8@ A8 ? I>AJA8?B I=F>@6

    3DI=89L AS ?8 A85DH@AE?@A=8 BD?9H @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> @= CDBAD5D @N?@ G=F J?GN?5D 5A=B?@D9 @NAH 0=BAIG CG I=JJA@@A8E ?8G =S @ND I=89FI@ A9D8@ASAD9 ?C=5DLND J?G ?I@ QND>D @ND IA>IFJH@?8IDH ?89 D5A9D8ID Q?>>?8@ 9=A8E H=6 &NAH9DIAHA=8 QABB 8=@ >DSBDI@ ? SA89A8E =S EFAB@ => A88=ID8ID ?89 QABB 8=@ CD EFA9D9CG @ND H?JD BDE?B H@?89?>9H ?89 I=8HA9D>?@A=8H @N?@ Q=FB9 ?UUBG A8 ?I>AJA8?B @>A?B6

    '8 I?HDH A8 QNAIN ? 5A=B?@A=8 >DB?@A8E @= ? I>AJD =S 5A=BD8ID AH HFHUDI@D9 CF@SF>@ND> A85DH@AE?@A=8 AH >DMFA>D9L @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> J?G 9D@D>JA8D @= UB?ID ? UB?GD>=> =@ND> DJUB=GDD =8 BD?5D QA@N U?G =8 ? BAJA@D9 ?89 @DJU=>?>G C?HAH @= UD>JA@ @ND

    BD?EFD @= I=89FI@ ?8 A85DH@AE?@A=86 +?HD9 =8 @ND >DHFB@H =S @NAH A85DH@AE?@A=8L @NDUB?GD> => DJUB=GDD J?G CD >D@F>8D9 @= 9F@GL CD UB?ID9 =8 BD?5D QA@N U?G S=> ?B=8ED> UD>A=9L => CD HFCWDI@ @= 9AHIAUBA8D6

    % UB?GD> QN= AH UB?ID9 =8 @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> ,`DJU@ )AH@ J?G 8=@ U>?I@AID =>?@@D89 E?JDHL CF@ QA@N @ND IBFCdH UD>JAHHA=8 ND J?G CD U>DHD8@ ?@ @ND IBFCdH S?IABA@G=8 ? >D?H=8?CBD C?HAH S=> JDD@A8EHL A89A5A9F?B Q=>V=F@HL @ND>?UG ?89 >DN?CABA@?@A=8L?89 =@ND> UD>JA@@D9 8=8#S==@C?BB ?I@A5A@ADH6 $=8#UB?GD> DJUB=GDDH UB?ID9 =8 U?A9?9JA8AH@>?@A5D BD?5D J?G CD U>DHD8@ =8BG =8 HFIN C?HAH ?H AH ?UU>=5D9 CG @ND4=JJAHHA=8D> => @ND BD?EFD 9AHIAUBA8?>G =SSAID> ?89 =8BG F89D> IA>IFJH@?8IDH A8QNAIN @NDG ?>D 8=@ UD>S=>JA8E @NDA> >DEFB?> 9F@ADH6

    )D?5D QA@N U?G QABB ED8D>?BBG B?H@ F8@AB @ND BD?EFD J?VDH ? 9AHIAUBA8?>G9DIAHA=8 ?89 ?8G ?UUD?B S>=J @N?@ 9AHIAUBA8D AH SFBBG >DH=B5D96 

    $*)0% ,`6 " ?@ _#Z6

    ,6  $C> #+H?(E= ?1=/9A8E @= @ND $*)0%L \@ND $DQ 0=BAIG U>=5A9DH S=> @ND F8U>DID9D8@D9 FHD =S @ND4=JJAHHA=8D> ,`DJU@ )AH@ [@ND l,`DJU@ )AH@d^ ?H ? 5DNAIBD S=> A8@D>AJ 9AHIAUBA8DL QND>DCG ?

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    10/54

      "X

    UB?GD> 8(8=$2,$-   =S I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B AH A85=BF8@?>ABG HFHUD89D9 QA@N U?G ?89 C?>>D9S>=J U?>@AIAU?@A8E A8 U>?I@AIDH ?89 E?JDH @$9"/$ @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> 9D@D>JA8DH QND@ND> @NDUB?GD> AH EFAB@G =S I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B ?89 @$9"/$ @ND UB?GD> N?H ?8 =UU=>@F8A@G @= N?5D NAH4+% >AEN@ @= ? ND?>A8E => @= ?UUD?B ?8G HFIN 9AHIAUBA8?>G 9D@D>JA8?@A=86 DBG ?@=99H QA@N @ND I=BBDI@A5DBG#C?>E?A8D9 S=>J $*) 0B?GD> 4=8@>?I@ [8$$ 4+%L %>@6 _L n "^6] 0%0>D#

    7+ ?@ ; [DJUN?HAH A8 =>AEA8?B^6

    *F>@ND>/ 

    %H UB?A8BG Q>A@@D8L @ND 0B?GD> 4=8@>?I@ =8BG UD>JA@H @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> @= @?VD ?I@A=8?E?A8H@ ? UB?GD> S=> I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B CG AJU=HA8E [A^ ? \ !"#$L] \ %&%'$#(%")#* L]\?89m=>] \+$,-"#.+(")#* ] =S @ND 0B?GD> 4=8@>?I@L [AA^ 59,$/ @ND UB?GD> N?H CDD8 S=F89\ /&"0+1 =S 6 6 6 I=89FI@ >D?H=8?CBG WF9ED9 31 +4$ 5$./&$ 6)--"%%")#$, @= CD9D@>AJD8@?B] @= @ND )D?EFD [8=@ JD>DBG 8(8=$2,$- =S I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B^L 5+-  [AAA^\)#01 .!+$,  )1A1+) 0%53$/ ,:$ "=="/,(+1,3 9"/ 5 :$5/1+)6] 7- 6 &NFHL 0?>?E>?UN "ZUB?A8BG BAJA@H C=@N 74$# @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> I?8 D`D>IAHD NAH I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B?F@N=>A@G ?89 74.+ %'$8"!"8 .8+")#% @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> J?G @?VD6 

    0?>?E>?UN "Z U>=5A9DH @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> QA@N 8= SF>@ND> I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B?F@N=>A@G6 7D J?G =8BG SA8DL HFHUD89L ?89m=> @D>JA8?@D ? UB?GD>dH I=8@>?I@k8==@ND> >DJD9A?B ?I@A=8 AH U>=5A9D9 S=>k?89 J?G 9= H= =8BG 59,$/ ? SA89A8E =S \EFAB@gh]?89 \"+%3 59,$/ ]  ?8G ?UUD?B =S HFIN SA89A8E [16$6L @ND \ND?>A8E]^6 &ND U>=5AHA=8 AHD`N?FH@A5D ?89 HD>5DH ?H ? UB?A8 BAJA@ =8 @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B?F@N=>A@G QA@N >DHUDI@ @= UB?GD>H F89D> @ND 4+%6

    0%0=H@#7+ ?@ Y [DJUN?HAH A8 =>AEA8?B^6

    %B@N=FENL A8 @ND $*)0%dH 5ADQL \0?>?E>?UN "Z HN=FB9 @NFH CD @ND CDEA88A8E ?89 D89

    =S @ND A8MFA>G ?C=F@ QND8 ?89 N=Q ? UB?GD> I?8 CD UF8AHND9 CG @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> S=>I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B 6 6 6 A@ AH 8=@?CBD @N?@ @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B ?F@N=>A@GQA@N >DHUDI@ @= UB?GD>H AH HAJAB?>BG BAJA@D9 CG @ND @D>JH =S %>@AIBD a6":[%^ =S @ND $*)4=8H@A@F@A=8 ?89 +GB?QH6 $*)0% ,`6 ;L 4=8H@6 P +GB?QHL n a6":[%^ [lOND8D5D> @ND4=JJAHHA=8D>L .!+$, #)+"8$ .#9 4$.,"#/L 9DIA9DH @N?@ 6 6 6 ?8G UB?GD> 6 6 6 N?H CDD8 => "%

     /&"0+1 )! 8)#9&8+ 9$+,"-$#+.0  6 6 6 @ND8 @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> HN?BB N?5D I=JUBD@D ?F@N=>A@G @=/["^ 3FHUD89 ?89m=> SA8D 6 6 6 i ?89m=> [;^ 4?8IDB ?8G I=8@>?I@ 6 6 6 6d^6] 0%0=H@#7+ ?@ c [ID>@?A8IA@?@A=8H ?89 S==@8=@D =JA@@D9i DJUN?HAH A8 =>AEA8?B^6

    '8 @ND $*)0%dH 5ADQL \HFHUD8HA=8gHh QA@N U?G] N?5D HD>A=FH ?95D>HD I=8HDMFD8IDHS=> UB?GD>H/

    g.h89D> @ND $DQ 0=BAIGL ?8G UB?GD> QN= @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> CDBAD5DH N?H  ="881@%3I=JJA@@D9 ? I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B 5A=B?@A=8 AH HFCWDI@ @=  1+A"%(+,5/3   UB?IDJD8@ =8@ND ,`DJU@ )AH@ k C?88A8E @ND UB?GD> S>=J E?JDH ?89 D5D8 U>?I@AID k A89DSA8A@DBG6&NAH HFHUD8HA=8 QA@N U?G =IIF>H @$9"/$ @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> SA89H ? UB?GD> EFAB@G =SI=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?BL @$9"/$  @ND AJU=HA@A=8 =S ? HUDIASAI UD8?B@G [@= @ND D`@D8@ ?UD8?B@G AH D5D> AJU=HD9^L ?89 @$9"/$ ? UB?GD> AH ?SS=>9D9 NAH >AEN@H =S ?UUD?B F89D>@ND 0B?GD> 4=8@>?I@ ?89 %>@AIBD _Y6

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    11/54

      ""

    *=> D`?JUBDL ? 4=JJAHHA=8D> A85DH@AE?@A=8 I=8IBF9A8E @N?@ ? UB?GD> Q?H +",EFAB@G =S I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B Q=FB9 H@ABB >DHFB@ A8 @N?@ UB?GD> N?5A8E CDD8 C?>>D9S>=J E?JDH ?89 U>?I@AIDH S=> ?8 F8BAJA@D9 UD>A=9 =S @AJD6 &ND H?JD N=B9H @>FD S=> ?4=JJAHHA=8D> A85DH@AE?@A=8 @N?@ >DHFB@H A8 9AHIAUBA8D QNAIN AH @ND8 =5D>@F>8D9 =8@ND UB?GD>dH %>@AIBD _Y ?UUD?B6 &ND SF89?JD8@?B U>=CBDJ AH @N?@ HFIN FHD =S @ND,`DJU@ )AH@ ?H U?>@ =S @ND 9AHIAUBA8?>G U>=IDHHL U>A=> @= ?8G 9D@D>JA8?@A=8 =S ?

    I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B 5A=B?@A=8L AH SB?@BG U>=NACA@D9 CG @ND 4+%6

    0%0>D7+ ?@ ""6

    '8 ?99A@A=8 @= A@H =@ND> ?>EFJD8@HL @ND $*)0% I=8@D89H @N?@ @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH FHD=S @ND ,`DJU@ )AH@ ?H ? 5DNAIBD S=> AJUBDJD8@A8E NAH )D?5D QA@N 0?G U>=ID9F>D AH A85?BA9LHA8ID @ND ?JD89JD8@ @= @ND $*)dH 4+) @N?@ E?5D \@ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> HFIN 8DQ ,`DJU@ )AH@?F@N=>A@G 6 6 6 I?88=@ CD ?UUBAD9 @= UB?GD>H QA@N=F@ ? I=BBDI@A5DBG C?>E?A8D9 J=9ASAI?@A=8 =S@ND 4+% ?89 ?E>DDJD8@ =S @ND .8A=86] 7-6 ?@ :6 

    J6  $C> #+HE= ?1=/DWDI@H @ND $*)0%dH \?>EFJD8@H IN?BBD8EA8E @ND 0=BAIG U>=5AHA=8 F89D>QNAIN UB?GD>H J?G CD UB?ID9 =8 @ND l4=JJAHHA=8D> ,`DJU@d BAH@ 6 6 6 C?HD9 =8 A@H IB?AJ @N?@HFIN U?A9 BD?5D JFH@ CD I=8HA9D>D9 l9AHIAUBA8?>Gd A8 8?@F>D6] $*)0=H@#7+ ?@ cL IA@A8E 0%0>D#7+ ?@ "X#"a6 '8 @ND $*)dH 5ADQL \?UUBAI?@A=8 =S U?A9 BD?5D ?H I=8@DJUB?@D9 CG @ND 0=BAIG AH8=@ 9AHIAUBA8D6 2?@ND>L @ND 0=BAIG S=>J?BAfDH @ND U>?I@AID @N?@ N?H D`AH@D9 S=> J?8G GD?>HLU>D5A=FHBG F8IN?BBD8ED9L F89D> QNAIN @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> N?H @?VD8 AJJD9A?@D ?I@A=8 @=?99>DHH 5A=BD8@ ?89 =@ND> HD>A=FH A8IA9D8@H =S I>AJA8?B CDN?5A=>L =8 ? @DJU=>?>G C?HAHL9F>A8E @ND UD89D8IG =S ? BD?EFD A85DH@AE?@A=8 A8@= QND@ND> 9AHIAUBA8D HN=FB9 CD AJU=HD9 A8@ND SA>H@ UB?ID6] 7-6 ?@ "X6

    &ND $*) ?BH= 9AH?E>DDH QA@N @ND $*)0%dH I=8@D8@A=8 @N?@ @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH

    U>=JFBE?@A=8 =S @ND )D?5D QA@N 0?G HDI@A=8 =S @ND $DQ 0=BAIG AH A8 I=8SBAI@ QA@N 0?>?E>?UN"Z6 '8 A@H 5ADQL \gEhA5D8 @N?@ 0?>?E>?UN "ZL =8 A@H S?IDL ?UUBADH =8BG 59,$/ @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>9D@D>JA8DH @N?@ ? UB?GD> N?H D8E?ED9 A8 I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?BL @N?@ U>=5AHA=8 I?88=@ U=HHACBGBAJA@ @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH 9AHI>D@A=8 A8 UB?IA8E ? UB?GD> =8 U?A9 BD?5D UD89A8E ?9D@D>JA8?@A=8 A8@= QND@ND> ND HN=FB9 CD 9AHIAUBA8D9 A8 @ND SA>H@ UB?ID6] $*)0>D#7+ ?@ "a6*F>@ND>L U=A8@A8E =F@ @N?@ 0?>?E>?UN "Z \>DSD>H @= ?8 l=UU=>@F8A@G S=> ? ND?>A8Ed A8I=88DI@A=8 QA@N @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH U=QD> @= lHFHUD89d UB?GD>HL lSA8Dd UB?GD>HL => @D>JA8?@D@NDA> I=8@>?I@HL] @ND $*) ?HHD>@H @N?@ UB?IA8E ? UB?GD> =8 U?A9 ?9JA8AH@>?@A5D BD?5D => =8 @ND,`DJU@ )AH@ AH8d@L I=8@>?>G @= @ND $*)0%dH I=8@D8@A=8L \? HFHUD8HA=8 QA@N U?G6] $*)0=H@#7+?@ "X6 &NFHL A8 @ND $*)dH 5ADQL \gChDI?FHD ? UB?GD> =8 U?A9 BD?5D AH 8=@ lHFHUD89D9d QA@NA8@ND JD?8A8E =S @ND 4+%L U?A9 BD?5D 9=DH 8=@ D5D8 S?BB F89D> U?>?E>?UN "ZdH UB?A8 @D>JH6] 7- 6[S==@8=@D =JA@@D9^6

    '8 ?99A@A=8 @= A@H I=8@D8@A=8 @N?@ U?A9 BD?5D AH8d@ ? \HFHUD8HA=8L] @ND $*) ?HHD>@H @N?@\U?A9 BD?5D ?BH= lAH 8=@ A8@D89D9 @= CD 9AHIAUBA8?>G6d] 7-6L IA@A8E &>6 :a"6 \2?@ND>L] H?GH @ND $*)L\I=8HAH@D8@ QA@N NAH DH@?CBAHND9 ?F@N=>A@GL @ND 0=BAIG U>=5A9DH @N?@ @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> J?GL9DUD89A8E =8 @ND IA>IFJH@?8IDHL UB?ID UB?GD>H =8 U?A9 BD?5D l=8 ? BAJA@D9 ?89 @DJU=>?>GC?HAH @= UD>JA@ @ND BD?EFD @= I=89FI@ ?8 A85DH@AE?@A=8d A8@= I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B J?@@D>H6 7-6?@ "X#"" [IA@?@A=8 =JA@@D9^6 \$=>L] H?GH @ND $*)L \I?8 @ND 0=BAIGdH FHD =S @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH,`DJU@ BAH@ A8 I=88DI@A=8 QA@N U?A9 BD?5D CD I=8HA9D>D9 9AHIAUBA8?>G6 6 6 6 g&hN?@ BAH@ AH JD>DBG? >=H@D> 9DHAE8?@A=8 I=8@>=BBD9 [?H A@H 8?JD HFEEDH@H^ lg=h8BG gCGh @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>Ld QN=

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    12/54

      ";

    N?H ?BQ?GH N?9 H=BD l?F@N=>A@G @= 9D@D>JA8D 6 6 6 QND@ND> ? UB?GD>dH @AJD =8 @ND ,`DJU@A=8BAH@ QABB CD SA8A@Dd => A89DSA8A@D6] 7-6 ?@ "" [IA@?@A=8H =JA@@D9^6 '8 ?99A@A=8L \g?hB@N=FEN 8=@A@HDBS 9AHIAUBA8?>GL @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH ,`DJU@ BAH@ N?H CDD8 l>=F@A8DBGd FHD9 A8 I=88DI@A=8QA@N 9AHIAUBA8?>G ?I@A=8HL A8IBF9A8E C=@N A8 @>?8HA@A=8A8E HFHUD89D9 UB?GD>H @= ?I@A5D H@?@FH?89 A8 D8HF>A8E @N?@ @NDG ?>D U?A9 QNABD =8 BD?5D [?H A8 @ND I?HDH =S 0D@D>H=8L 7?>9GL ?894?>>F@N^6 %H @ND $*) N?H ?>EFD9L ?89 ?H ? 9ASSD>D8@ $*) ?>CA@>?@=> I=8SA>JD9L 8=@NA8E A8 l@ND

    4=BBDI@A5D +?>E?A8A8E %E>DDJD8@d U>D5D8@H @ND FHD =S @ND BAH@ A8 I=88DI@A=8 QA@N ?9AHIAUBA8?>G A85DH@AE?@A=86 ,`6 aX [0D@D>H=8 ->AD5?8ID^ ?@ Yi 8$$ ,`6 a" [0D@D>H=8 &>6^ ?@ c[CDI?FHD 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH ,`DJU@ H@?@FH QA@NA8 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH H=BD 9AHI>D@A=8L l8=@NA8E A8@ND 4+% 6 6 6 A8 ?8G Q?G D8@A@BDH 6 0D@D>H=8 @= 9DJ?89 @N?@ NAH H@?@FH CD IN?8ED9d UD89A8EA85DH@AE?@A=8^6] 7-6 ?@ ""#"; [IA@?@A=8 =JA@@D9^6

    *A8?BBGL @ND $*) I=8@D89H/

    &ND FHD =S U?A9 BD?5D 9F>A8E @ND UD89D8IG =S ? 9AHIAUBA8?>G A85DH@AE?@A=8 AH ?BH= SFBBGI=8HAH@D8@ QA@N DH@?CBAHND9 B?C=> B?Q U>DID9D8@6 %>CA@>?@=>H \N?5D I=8HAH@D8@BG NDB9@N?@ ? HFHUD8HA=8 UD89A8E A85DH@AE?@A=8 AH 8=@ 9AHIAUBA8?>G6] '8 S?I@L UB?IA8E ? UB?GD>=8 U?A9 BD?5D AH I=8HA9D>D9 8=@ JD>DBG ?  =$/*1881@%$  8=8#9AHIAUBA8?>G ?I@A=8 CF@ED8D>?BBG \U>DSD>?CBD6] 0?A9 BD?5D ?BB=QH \DJUB=GD>H @= D8E?ED A8 ? I==BA8E =SSUD>A=9] U>A=> @= J?VA8E ? 9AHIAUBA8?>G 9DIAHA=8 A8 =>9D> @= ?BB=Q @NDJ @= I=89FI@ ?@N=>=FEN A85DH@AE?@A=8L 1-6L QNAIN AH =8D =S @ND 0=BAIGdH UF>U=HDH6 &NAH U>=ID9F>D?BH= D8HF>DH @N?@ @ND UB?GD> QABB I=8@A8FD @= CD U?A9 UD89A8E ? BD?EFD => I>AJA8?BA85DH@AE?@A=8L ?89 FHA8E @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH ,`DJU@ BAH@ HUDIASAI?BBG D8HF>DH @N?@ @NDIBFC QABB 8=@ CD S=>ID9 @= @D>JA8?@D NAH I=8@>?I@6]

    7-6 ?@ "; [4A@?@A=8H ?89 S==@8=@D =JA@@D9^6

    P6   (02@K=/=

    &ND $*)0% IN?BBD8EDH @ND $DQ 0=BAIGdH )D?5D QA@N 0?G U>=5AHA=8 A8 A@H D8@A>D@GLA8IBF9A8E A@H FHD =S @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> ,`DJU@ )AH@6

    ' ?99>DHH @Q= >DB?@D9 AHHFDH6

    ' I=8HA9D> A8 HFCHDI@A=8 \?] QND@ND> 4=JJAHHA=8D> -==9DBB N?9 @ND ?F@N=>A@GF8AB?@D>?BBG @= HD@ >FBDH ?89 U>=ID9F>DH U>=5A9A8E @N?@ F89D> 9DSA8D9 IA>IFJH@?8IDH ?UB?GD> I=FB9 CD UB?ID9 =8 \U?A9 ?9JA8AH@>?@A5D BD?5D6] ' @ND8 I=8HA9D> A8 HFCHDI@A=8 \C]QND@ND> @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> I=FB9 U>=UD>BG FHD @ND ,`DJU@ )AH@ @= ?II=JUBAHN @NAH=CWDI@A5D6_ 

    &ND )D?5D QA@N 0?G U>=5AHA=8 =S @ND $DQ 0=BAIG A8A@A?BBG H@?@DHL U>DHFJ?CBG >DSD>>A8E @= ?BBQN= ?>D HFCWDI@ @= @ND $DQ 0=BAIGL A8IBF9A8E CF@ 8=@ BAJA@D9 @= UB?GD>HL @N?@ \gGh=F J?G CD UB?ID9 =8?9JA8AH@>?@A5D BD?5D => =8 @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> ,`DJU@ )AH@6 6 6 6 ] &ND AJJD9A?@DBG S=BB=QA8E U?>?E>?UN9D?BH QA@N UB?IA8E \? UB?GD> => =@ND> DJUB=GDD =8 BD?5D QA@N U?G =8 ? BAJA@D9 ?89 @DJU=>?>G C?HAHL]QA@N=F@ >DSD>>A8E @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> ,`DJU@ )AH@6 &ND 8D`@ U?>?E>?UN 9AHIFHHDH ? \UB?GD> QN= AHUB?ID9 =8 @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> ,`DJU@ )AH@] ?89 \g8h=8#UB?GD> DJUB=GDDH UB?ID9 =8 U?A9?9JA8AH@>?@A5D BD?5D6] &ND SA8?B U?>?E>?UN 9AHIFHHDH N=Q B=8E \gBhD?5D QA@N U?G QABB ED8D>?BBG B?H@]QA@N=F@ >DSD>D8ID DA@ND> @= U?A9 ?9JA8AH@>?@A5D BD?5D => @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> ,`DJU@ )AH@6

    ?"+,1+($- "+ +$B, =5)$6

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    13/54

      ":

    26  "= $C>5> 2 H/;/< 10 J1;;/==/10>5 Q113>@@E= (: 4=8@>?I@ U>=5A9DH @N?@ ? UB?GD> \?IV8=QBD9EDH NAH?Q?>D8DHH] @N?@ AS ND AH \EFAB@G =S ?8G 6 6 6 S=>J =S I=89FI@ >D?H=8?CBG WF9ED9 CG @ND )D?EFD4=JJAHHA=8D> @= CD 9D@>AJD8@?B @= @ND )D?EFD => U>=SDHHA=8?B S==@C?BBL @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>QABB N?5D @ND >AEN@L CF@ =8BG ?S@D> EA5A8E 0B?GD> @ND =UU=>@F8A@G S=> ? ND?>A8E ?@ QNAIN NDJ?G CD >DU>DHD8@D9 CG I=F8HDB =S NAH IN=AIDL @= SA8D 0B?GD> A8 ? >D?H=8?CBD ?J=F8@i @=HFHUD89 0B?GD> S=> ? UD>A=9 ID>@?A8 => A89DSA8A@DBGi ?89m=> @= @D>JA8?@D @NAH I=8@>?I@6]

    %>@AIBD a6":[%^ =S @ND $*) 4+) AH DHHD8@A?BBG @= @ND H?JD DSSDI@6 '@ U>=5A9DH A8 U?>@/

    [%^ OND8D5D> @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>L ?S@D> 8=@AID ?89 ND?>A8EL 9DIA9DH @N?@ g?h UB?GD> 6 6 6N?H DA@ND> 5A=B?@D9 @ND 4=8H@A@F@A=8 ?89 +GB?QH =S @ND )D?EFD => N?H CDD8 => AH EFAB@G=S I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B @= @ND QDBS?>D =S @ND )D?EFD => U>=SDHHA=8?B S==@C?BBL @ND8 @ND4=JJAHHA=8D> HN?BB N?5D I=JUBD@D ?F@N=>A@G @=/

    ["^ 3FHUD89 ?89m=> SA8D HFIN UD>H=8 A8 ?8 ?J=F8@ 8=@ A8 D`IDHH =S SA5DNF89>D9 @N=FH?89 9=BB?>H [pZXXLXXX^ 6 6 6 i ?89m=>[;^ 4?8IDB ?8G I=8@>?I@ => ?E>DDJD8@ =S HFIN UD>H=8 QA@N @ND )D?EFD => QA@N?8G JDJCD> @ND>D=Si6 6 6 6

    &ND>D ?>D 9ASSD>D8IDH CD@QDD8 0?>?E>?UN "Z ?89 %>@AIBD a6":[%^L CF@ 8=8D ?>D

    J?@D>A?B @= @NAH E>AD5?8ID6Z

      &NFHL A8 JG 5ADQL @ND MFDH@A=8 @= CD 9DIA9D9 AH QND@ND> @ND

    2D?9 ?H ? QN=BDL A@ ?UUD?>H @N?@ @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH A8@D8@ Q?H @= AJUBDJD8@ @ND )D?5D QA@N0?G U=>@A=8 =S @ND $DQ 0=BAIG CG UB?IA8E UB?GD>H =8 @ND ,`DJU@ )AH@L QA@N @ND ?99A@A=8?B H@?@FH =SCDA8E =8 U?A9 ?9JA8AH@>?@A5D BD?5DL QA@N =@ND> DJUB=GDDH =8BG CDA8E A8 @ND U?A9 ?9JA8AH@>?@A5D BD?5DH@?@FHL HA8ID ["^ @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> ,`DJU@ )AH@ =8BG I=5D>H UB?GD>H ?89 [;^ @ND>DdH 8=@NA8E A8 %>@AIBD"j6"_[?^L @ND 4+) U>=5AHA=8 I=5D>A8E @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> ,`DJU@ )AH@L @N?@ HUDIASADH QND@ND> @NDUB?GD> AH @= CD U?A9 => 8=@ [A8 I=8@>?H@ QA@NL S=> D`?JUBDL %>@AIBD "j6""L QNAIN U>=5A9DH @N?@HFHUD89D9 UB?GD>H ?>D 8=@ D8@A@BD9 @= I=JUD8H?@A=8^6

    7D8ID JG I=8IBFHA=8L QA@N >DE?>9 @= UB?GD>HL AH @N?@ ' 8DD9 @= D5?BF?@D C=@N @ND4=JJAHHA=8D>dH ?F@N=>A@GL A8 @ND I=8@D`@ =S @ND $DQ 0=BAIGL @= UF@ ? UB?GD> =8 U?A9 ?9JA8AH@>?@A5DBD?5D ?89 @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH ?F@N=>A@G @= UF@ ? UB?GD> =8 @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> ,`DJU@ )AH@6

    Z 0?>?E>?UN "Z E=DH CDG=89 %>@AIBD a6":[%^ A8 E>?8@A8E @ND UB?GD> ? >AEN@ @= CD >DU>DHD8@D9 CG

    I=F8HDB ?@ @ND ND?>A8E6

    0?>?E>?UN "Z ?BH= ?BB=QH @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> @= SA8D 0B?GD> A8 ? \>D?H=8?CBD ?J=F8@L] >?@ND>@N?8 H@?@A8E @ND \8=@ A8 D`IDHH =S 6 6 6 pZXXLXXX] BAJA@?@A=8 A8 a6":[%^L ?89 @NFH J?G U>=5A9D @ND4=JJAHHA=8D> J=>D BDDQ?G =8 ? SA8DdH ?J=F8@L FU => 9=Q8L @N?8 a6":[%^6 3A8ID C=@N 0?>@ADH ?E>DD@N?@L A8 @ND D5D8@ =S ? I=8SBAI@L 0?>?E>?UN "Z I=8@>=BH =5D> %>@AIBD a6":[%^L @ND H@?89?>9 S=>

    ?"+,1+($- "+ +$B, =5)$6

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    14/54

      "_

    ?I@A=8H @N?@ @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH $DQ 0=BAIG ?BB=QH ?>D QA@NA8 => =F@HA9D @ND J?89?@DH =S0?>?E>?UN "Z ?89 %>@AIBD a6":[%^6

    &ND $*) I=8@D89H @N?@ HA8ID \0?>?E>?UN "ZL =8 A@H S?IDL ?UUBADH =8BG 59,$/ @ND4=JJAHHA=8D> 9D@D>JA8DH @N?@ ? UB?GD> N?H D8E?ED9 A8 I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?BL @N?@ U>=5AHA=8I?88=@ U=HHACBG BAJA@ @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH 9AHI>D@A=8 A8 UB?IA8E ? UB?GD> =8 U?A9 BD?5D

    UD89A8E ? 9D@D>JA8?@A=8 A8@= QND@ND> ND HN=FB9 CD 9AHIAUBA8D9 A8 @ND SA>H@ UB?ID6] $*)0>D#7+ ?@ "a6

    ' ?E>DD QA@N @ND $*)dH 5ADQ6 &ND>D AH 8= =@ND> H=F89 >D?9A8E =S @ND B?8EF?ED A8 C=@N0?>?E>?UN "Z ?89 %>@AIBD a6":[%^6 +=@N U>=5AHA=8H 9D?B D`UBAIA@BG QA@N ?I@A=8H @ND4=JJAHHA=8D> J?G @?VD ?S@D> SA89A8E ? UB?GD> [=>L A8 @ND I?HD =S %>@AIBD a6":[%^L =@ND>H^\EFAB@G] =S \I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B6] $DA@ND> I?8 >D?H=8?CBG CD >D?9 ?H HUD?VA8E @= QN?@ @ND4=JJAHHA=8D> J?G => J?G 8=@ 9= U>A=> @= >D?INA8E @N?@ I=8IBFHA=86 &NFHL D`IDU@L U=HHACBGLS=> @ND \HFHUD8HA=8]#>DB?@D9 AHHFD @N?@ ' 9D?B QA@N A8 @ND AJJD9A?@DBG S=BB=QA8E HDI@A=8L @ND)D?5D QA@N 0?G U>=5AHA=8 =S @ND $DQ 0=BAIG AH 8=@ I=8@>=BBD9 CG DA@ND> 0?>?E>?UN "Z =>%>@AIBD a6":[%^6

    //6 

     (02@K=/=I P1 J1;;/==/10>5E= H>2G> 4/@AIBD a6":[%^ AH =8 @ND UD>A=9 ?S@D>?8 A8A@A?B I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B 9DIAHA=8 AH J?9DL 8=@ =8 QND@ND> @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> I?8 @?VD?I@A=8 A85=B5A8E ? UB?GD> CDS=>D @N?@ A8A@A?B 9DIAHA=8 AH J?9D6 +F@ @NAH AH 8=@ ?B=8D HFSSAIAD8@@= I?>>G @ND 9?G S=> @ND $*)6 &N?@dH CDI?FHD @ND B?8EF?ED =S C=@N 0?>?E>?UN "Z ?89 %>@AIBDa6":[%^ ?BH= >DMFA>DH @ND I=8IBFHA=8 @N?@ ASL ?H @ND $*)0% ?>EFDHL ? \)D?5D QA@N 0?G] ?I@A=8=S @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> AH ? HFHUD8HA=8L ?H @N?@ @D>J AH FHD9 A8 0?>?E>?UN "Z ?89 %>@AIBDa6":[%^L @ND8 @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> JFH@ EA5D @ND UB?GD> 8=@AID ?89 @ND =UU=>@F8A@G S=> ?ND?>A8E A8 QNAIN @ND UB?GD> AH >DU>DHD8@D9 CG I=F8HDBL 8=8D =S QNAIN AH U>=5A9D9 S=> A8 @ND

    $DQ 0=BAIG6

    (8 @ND =@ND> N?89L AS ?8 ?I@A=8 =S @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> F89D> @ND \)D?5D QA@N 0?G]HDI@A=8 AH8d@ U>=UD>BG IN?>?I@D>AfD9 ?H ? HFHUD8HA=8L ?H @N?@ @D>J AH FHD9 A8 U?>?E>?UN "Z?89 %>@AIBD a6":[C^L @ND8 A@ Q=FB9 S=BB=Q 8DA@ND> 0?>?E>?UN "Z 8=> %>@AIBD a6":[%^ ?UUBADH6

    &ND $*)0% IN?>?I@D>AfDH @ND $DQ 0=BAIGdH )D?5D QA@N 0?G U>=5AHA=8 ?HL S=> D`?JUBDLN?5A8E \@N>DD U?A9 HFHUD8HA=8 HID8?>A=H] [0%0=H@#7+ ?@ _"^i ?H A85=B5A8E \U>D#ND?>A8EHFHUD8HA=8H] [7-6 ?@ "^L \HFHUD8HA=8 QA@N U?G] [7-6^L \lU>D#9AHIAUBA8D 9AHIAUBA8D A8 @ND S=>J =S? HFHUD8HA=8 QA@N U?G] [0%0>D#7+ ?@ ""^i ?89 ?H \@ND DMFA5?BD8@ =S ? 9AHIAUBA8?>GHFHUD8HA=8] [$*)0% ,`6 YL 0$,$/8"+ %>@6 _Y 7>dE &>6 "Xc/;#a [TDHHBD>^^6 '@ ?HHFJDH @N?@ ?8G?I@A=8 =S @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> @N?@ N?H @ND U=@D8@A?B ?95D>HD AJU?I@H =8 ? UB?GD> @N?@ A@

    9D@D>JA8A8E @ND 5?BA9A@G =S ? SA8D AH QND@ND> A@dH \>D?H=8?CBDL] QNAINL 9DUD89A8E =8 @ND S?I@HL I=FB9?>EF?CBG CD BDHH @N?8 => J=>D @N?8 @ND pZXXLXXX BAJA@ A8 %>@AIBD a6":[%^6

    0?>?E>?UN "ZdH \HFHUD89 0B?GD> S=> UD>A=9 ID>@?A8 => A89DSA8A@DBG] B?8EF?ED J?VDH D`UBAIA@QN?@ AH AJUBAIA@ A8 a6":dH E>?8@ =S ?F@N=>A@G @= \HFHUD896]

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    15/54

      "Z

    I=8@D89H I?8 >DHFB@ S>=J ? UB?GD>dH CDA8E UF@ =8 BD?5D QA@N U?G JFH@ CD 9DDJD9 @= CD ?HFHUD8HA=86

    &ND $*) ?>EFDH @N?@/

    g0h?>?E>?UN "Z HUDIASAI?BBG >DSD>H @= ?8 \=UU=>@F8A@G S=> ? ND?>A8E] A8 I=88DI@A=8

    QA@N @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH U=QD> @= \HFHUD89] UB?GD>HL \SA8D] UB?GD>HL => @D>JA8?@D@NDA> I=8@>?I@H6 0B?GD> 4=8@>?I@ q "Z6Y +F@ ? \HFHUD89D9 UB?GD>gh] AH ? 9DSA8D9 @D>JA8 @ND 4+%i A@ JD?8H ? UB?GD> QN= AH =SS ? @D?JdH ?I@A5D >=H@D> 5+-   8=@ \D8@A@BD9 @=I=JUD8H?@A=86] 4P+ n "j6"" [\g&hND 4=JJAHHA=8D> J?G HFHUD89 ? UB?GD> 6 6 6 KF>A8E@ND UD>A=9 =S HFHUD8HA=8L 5 =%53$/ 8:5%% +", @$ $+,1,%$- ," 2"*=$+85,1"+ ?89 HN?BB CDA8DBAEACBD @= UB?G QA@N ?8G IBFC6]^6 %B@N=FEN @ND $*)0% ?@@DJU@H @= IN?>?I@D>AfD U?A9BD?5D ?H ? \HFHUD8HA=8 QA@N U?GL] $*) ,`DIF@A5D %9=BUN= +A>IN I=8SA>JD9 @N?@ @ND>DAH 8= HFIN @NA8E F89D> @ND U?>@ADHd 4+%6 6 _"Z [\g1h=F 9=8d@ ED@ U?A9 =8 >DHD>5DHFHUD89D96 6 6 6 OD 9=8d@ HFHUD89 QA@N U?G6]^6 +DI?FHD ? UB?GD> =8 U?A9 BD?5D AH 8=@\HFHUD89D9] QA@NA8 @ND JD?8A8E =S @ND 4+%L U?A9 BD?5D 9=DH 8=@ D5D8 S?BB F89D>U?>?E>?UN "ZdH UB?A8 @D>JH6

    $*)0=H@#7+ ?@ "X [S==@8=@D =JA@@D9^6

    ' 9=8d@ ?E>DD QA@N @ND $*)dH H@?@DJD8@ @N?@ \? lHFHUD89D9 UB?GD>ghd AH ? 9DSA8D9 @D>JA8 @ND 4+%6]j &N?@ H?A9L @ND $*)dH ?>EFJD8@ @N?@ @ND 4+% [?89 @ND 4+)^ I=8HAH@D8@BG BA8VHFHUD8HA=8 @= ? UB?GD>dH 8=@ CDA8E D8@A@BD9 @= I=JUD8H?@A=8 9DHD>5DH QDAEN@ A8 9D@D>JA8A8EN=Q @= B?CDB @ND ?I@A=8H ?F@N=>AfD9 A8 @ND )D?5D QA@N 0?G U=>@A=8 =S @ND $DQ 0=BAIG6

    ' ?J ?BH= A8SBFD8ID9 CG @ND SA89A8EH =S %>CA@>?@=> T?HND> A8 L %>C6^6 %>CA@>?@=> T?HND> I=8HA9D>D9 6 3I=@@dH IB?AJ @N?@ ND N?9 CDD8AJU>=UD>BG UB?ID9 =8 \$=8#*==@C?BB '8WF>G] [\$*']^ H@?@FH ?89 \HFHUD89D9 S=> @NA>@G [:X^9?GH QA@N=F@ U?G CG @ND 4=QC=GH6] 7-6 ?@ _L ;6

    &ND %>CA@>?@=> S?ID9 @ND @N>DHN=B9 MFDH@A=8 =S QND@ND> @ND 4BFC N?9 @ND CF>9D8 =SU>=5A8E A@ N?9 WFH@ I?FHD S=> N=Q A@ 9D?B@ QA@N 6 3I=@@ => QND@ND> 6 3I=@@ N?9 @= U>=5D@N?@ @ND 4BFC 5A=B?@D9 @ND 4=BBDI@A5D +?>E?A8A8E %E>DDJD8@ C?HD9 =8 NAH CDA8E UB?ID9 =8 $*'H@?@FH QA@N=F@ U?G6 '8 @ND %>CA@>?@=>dH 5ADQL ND N?9 @= 9D@D>JA8D \QND@ND> bAI@=> 3I=@@ Q?HHFHUD89D9 ?89 UB?ID9 =8 @ND $*' BAH@ => QND@ND> ND Q?H =8BG UB?ID9 =8 @ND $*' BAH@6] 7-6 ?@"_6

    %>CA@>?@=> T?HND>dH ?8?BGHAH =S QND@ND> @ND 4=QC=GHd UB?IA8E 6 3I=@@ =8 $*' H@?@FHQA@N=F@ U?G I=8H@A@F@D9 ? \HFHUD8HA=8] AH UD>@A8D8@ @= QND@ND> @ND )D?5D QA@N 0?GU>=5AHA=8 =S @ND $DQ 0=BAIG [QA@N A@H >DSD>D8ID UB?IA8E ? UB?GD> =8 \U?A9 ?9JA8AH@>?@A5DBD?5D => @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> ,`DJU@ )AH@]^ AH ?UU>=U>A?@DBG IN?>?I@D>AfD9 ?H ? HFHUD8HA=8 ?H

    @N?@ @D>J AH FHD9 A8 0?>?E>?UN "Z => %>@AIBD a6":[%^6 ONABD 8=@ CA89A8E U>DID9D8@L HA8ID

    Y %>@AIBD a6":[%^ AH @= @ND H?JD DSSDI@6

    j \3FHUD89D9 UB?GD>] AH 8=@ I?UA@?BAfD9L ?H AH 8=>J?B S=> 9DSA8D9 @D>JHi 8=> 9=DH A@ ?UUD?> A8

    4+% %>@AIBD 'L K,*'$'&'($36

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    16/54

      "Y

    CA@>?@=> T?HND> S=F89 @N?@ @ND D5A9D8ID CDS=>D NAJ9A98d@ HFUU=>@ ? SA89A8E =S \HFHUD8HA=8] QND8/

    •  6 3I=@@ \I=8@A8FD9 @= CD >DHU=8HA5D @= @ND 4BFC 9A>DI@A5DH]i

    •  &ND \4BFC I=8@A8FD9 @= SFBSABB A@H =CBAE?@A=8H ?H DJUB=GD> F89D> @ND 9>FE U>=E>?J@D>JH U>=5A9A8E >DN?CABA@?@A=8 ?89 I=F8HDBA8E HD>5AIDH @= @ND ->AD5?8@]i ?89

    •  &ND>D Q?H \A8HFSSAIAD8@ D5A9D8ID A8 @NAH >DI=>9 @= DH@?CBAHN @N?@ DA@ND> @ND 4BFC =>@ND I=JJAHHA=8D> A8@D89D9 @= l9AHIAUBA8Dd bAI@=> 3I=@@ => AJU=HD 9AHIAUBA8D FU=8bAI@=> 3I=@@ @N>=FEN HFHUD8HA=86] 7-6 ?@ "Z#"Y6

    %>CA@>?@=> T?HND> >D?IND9 @N?@ I=8IBFHA=8 D5D8 @N=FEN ND ?BH= S=F89 @N?@ \@ND

    >DHFB@ =S CDA8E UB?ID9 A8 $*' H@?@FH I?FHD9 bAI@=> 3I=@@ @= HFSSD> ? HAE8ASAI?8@ B=HH A8I=JUD8H?@A=86] 7D I=8IBF9D9 @N?@ \@N?@ S?I@ ?B=8D 9=DH 8=@ A89AI?@D @N?@ @ND 4BFC => @ND4=JJAHHA=8D> AJU=HD9 ? 9AHIAUBA8?>G HFHUD8HA=8 S=> @ND UF>U=HD =S I=>>DI@A8E 3I=@@rH9AHID>8D9 AJU>=UD> CDN?5A=>6] 7-6 ?@ "Y6

    % BG8INUA8 =S @ND $*)0%dH ?>EFJD8@ @N?@ )D?5D QA@N 0?G ?J=F8@H @= ? HFHUD8HA=8 AHA@H 5ADQ =S @ND HD>A=FH AJU?I@ A@ N?H =8 ? UB?GD>6 &ND $*)0% I=8@D89HL S=> D`?JUBDL @N?@/

    g&hND 4+% D`U>DHHBG BAJA@H ?8G HFHUD8HA=8 @= CD AJU=HD9 CG @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> @=59,$/   EFAB@ N?H CDD8 ?HHDHHD9 ?89 ? ND?>A8E N?H CDD8 ?SS=>9D9 @= @ND UB?GD> @=I=8@DH@ @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH ?I@A=86 &NAH AH CDI?FHDL ?H 9AHIFHHD9 9F>A8E @ND ND?>A8ELBD?5D QA@N U?G S=> U>=SDHHA=8?B S==@C?BB UB?GD>H ?J=F8@H @= HD5D>D 9AHIAUBA8D ?H A@

    C?>H @NDJ S>=J U>?I@AIA8E ?89 UB?GA8E A8 E?JDHL QNAIN HN=>@D8H ?89 @N>D?@D8H @NDA>?B>D?9G#C>ADS I?>DD>HL QNABD ?BH= U>D5D8@A8E @NDJ S>=J D?>8A8E UD>S=>J?8IDA8ID8@A5DH6 7>dE &>6 :Z/:#:j/"jL Za/";#Zc/;; [TDHHBD>^i 1-6 ?@ :_c/"a#:Z;/YL :a"/;;#:a:/j [KD0?H=^6 6 6 6 '@ AH @NAH F8AMFD ?@@>ACF@D =S U>=SDHHA=8?B S==@C?BB UB?GD>H @N?@EA5DH I=8@D`@ @= QNG 0?>?E>?UN "Z BAJA@H @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH ?F@N=>A@G @= @?VDI=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B ?I@A=8k16$6L SA8DL HFHUD89L ?89m=> @D>JA8?@Dk@= ? @AJD 59,$/  EFAB@ N?H CDD8 S=F89 ?89 @ND >AEN@ =S ?8 ?UUD?B ND?>A8E N?H CDD8 U>=5A9D96

    0%0=H@7+ ?@ ;Z#;Y6

    ' ?E>DD QA@N @ND $*)0% @N?@ @ND>D J?G CD ?I@F?B 8DE?@A5D AJU?I@H =8 ? UB?GD> UB?ID9=8 BD?5D QA@N U?G6a +F@ UB?IA8E ? UB?GD> =8 )D?5D QA@N 0?GL QND@ND> =8 U?A9 ?9JA8AH@>?@A5D

    a &ND $*) DJUN?HAfDH A@H A8@D8@ @= JA@AE?@D ?8G AJU?I@/

    &ND .8A=8 ?BH= ?>EFDH @N?@ UB?IDJD8@ =8 @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH ,`DJU@ BAH@ F89D> @ND0=BAIG 2"(%-   I=8IDA5?CBG >DHFB@ A8 N?>J @= @ND UB?GD> @N?@ DMF?@DH @= 9AHIAUBA8D6 D#7D?>A8E +>6 "Y#"a6 +F@ @ND F8>DCF@@D9 @DH@AJ=8G ?89 9=IFJD8@?>G D5A9D8ID J?VDH IBD?>@N?@ @ND $*) N?H 8= A8@D8@A=8 =S ?UUBGA8E @ND 0=BAIG U>=5AHA=8H >DE?>9A8E @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH

    ?"+,1+($- "+ +$B, =5)$6

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    17/54

      "j

    BD?5D ?89m=> =8 @ND ,`DJU@ )AH@ AHL SA>H@L J?@D>A?BBG 9ASSD>D8@ S>=J CDA8E HFHUD89D9L ?H @N?@@D>J AH FHD9 A8 @ND 4+) ?89 ?H A@ Q?H 5ADQD9 CG %>CA@>?@=> T?HND> A8 IN^ [9AHIFHHA8E @ND UF>U=>@D9 \QABBA8E8DHH @= >D5ADQ] N=Q @ND$DQ 0=BAIG AJU?I@H UB?GD>H^6 '8 S?I@L @ND )D?EFD N?H \A89AI?@D9 @N?@ @NDG I=FB9 8=@ J?VD @NDUB?GD> "XXs QN=BDL @NDG J?9D A@ 5D>G IBD?>L U?>@AIFB?>BG QA@N >DHUDI@ @= A8ID8@A5DH @N?@ @NDUB?GD> JAEN@ N?5D B=H@ ?H ? >DHFB@ =S CDA8E =8 @ND >=H@D> D`DJU@ BAH@6] 7- 6 ?@ :a_/"Y#:aZ/";[KD0?H=^6 %89 QA@N >DHUDI@ @= E?JDH B=H@L ?H 6 +A>IN @DH@ASAD9L \gQhD I?8d@ E= C?IV A8 @AJD?89 UF@ @ND UB?GD> C?IV A8 @ND E?JD6] 7- 6 ?@ Z"X/a#;X [+A>IN^i 8$$ 5%8" 1- 6 ?@ :cZ/"_#:cY/Z

    [KD0?H=^6 D=5D>L AS ?S@D> ? I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B SA89A8E ? UB?GD> AH D`=8D>?@D9L @ND )D?EFDN?H H?A9 A@ AH \8=@ QABBA8E @= ?E>DD @N?@ @NDG Q=FB9 @>D?@ NAJ D`?I@BG ?H AS ND QD>D 8=@ =8 @ND>=H@D> D`DJU@ BAH@ S=> @N=HD U?>@AIFB?> QDDVH6 6 6 6 3=L A@dH 8=@ ? QAUD#@ND#HB?@D#IBD?8 H=>@ =S?UU>=?IN 6 6 6 6] 7- 6 ?@ :a_/Z#"_ [KD0?H=^6

    0%0=H@7+ ?@ ZY#Zj6

    ' >D?IN JG 9DIAHA=8 QA@N=F@ >DH=B5A8E @NDHD 9AHUF@DH => ?HHFJA8E ?8G HFIIDHHSFB JA@AE?@A=86

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    18/54

      "a

    U>?I@AID => ?@@D89 E?JDHL CF@ QA@N @ND IBFCdH UD>JAHHA=8 ND J?G CD U>DHD8@ ?@ @ND IBFCdHS?IABA@G =8 ? >D?H=8?CBD C?HAH S=> JDD@A8EHL A89A5A9F?B Q=>V=F@HL @ND>?UG ?89 >DN?CABA@?@A=8L?89 =@ND> UD>JA@@D9 8=8#S==@C?BB ?I@A5A@ADH6] $DQ 0=BAIG ?@ Z6

    3DI=89L UB?IA8E ? UB?GD> =8 )D?5D QA@N 0?GL ?H @N>=FEN CDA8E UB?ID9 =8 @ND ,`DJU@)AH@L ?UUD?>H @= N?5D BDHH ?I@F?B AJU?I@ =8 @ND UB?GD> @N?8 NAH CDA8E UB?ID9 A8 $*' H@?@FHL

    QNAINL F89D> @ND S?I@H =S CA@>?@=> T?HND> S=F89 @N?@ @ND>D Q?H 8=@ HFSSAIAD8@ >DI=>9D5A9D8ID @= DH@?CBAHN ?8 A8@D8@ @= 9AHIAUBA8D6 ONABD ' 9=8d@ 8DIDHH?>ABG ?E>DD QA@N %>CA@>?@=>T?HND> @N?@ @ND HFCWDI@A5D A8@D8@ =S @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> HN=FB9 CD UD>@A8D8@ @= JG 9DIAHA=8?C=F@ QND@ND> @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH UB?IA8E ? UB?GD> =8 )D?5D QA@N 0?G UD89A8E NAHI=8HA9D>?@A=8 =S QND@ND> ? UB?GD>dH ?I@A=8 A85=B5D9 I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?BL @ND>DdH 8= C?HAH A8@ND >DI=>9 CDS=>D JD @= I=8IBF9D @N?@ @ND $DQ 0=BAIGdH )D?5D QA@N 0?G U>=5AHA=8H A85=B5D ?HUDIASAI A8@D8@ @= 9AHIAUBA8D ? UB?GD> => @= AJU=HD 9AHIAUBA8D @N>=FEN HFHUD8HA=86

    %H ? >DHFB@L ' SA89 @N?@/

    •  %@ BD?H@ =8 @NDA> S?IDL @ND \)D?5D QA@N 0?G] U>=5AHA=8H =S @ND $DQ 0=BAIGL A8IBF9A8EUB?IDJD8@ =8 @ND ,`DJU@ )AH@L 9= 8=@ ?J=F8@ @= ? HFHUD8HA=8 ?H @N?@ @D>J AH FHD9 A80?>?E>?UN "ZL %>@AIBD a6":[%^L @ND 4+%L ?89 @ND 4+)6

    •  &NFHL 8DA@ND> 0?>?E>?UN "Z 8=> %>@AIBD a6":[%^ C?> => BAJA@ @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH?F@N=>A@G @= U>=JFBE?@D @ND )D?5D QA@N 0?G U=>@A=8H =S @ND $DQ 0=BAIG6

    &NAH I=8IBFHA=8 9=DH8r@ AJJD9A?@DBG BD?9 @= @ND ?99A@A=8?B I=8IBFHA=8 @N?@ @ND

    4=JJAHHA=8D> N?H @ND ?F@N=>A@G F89D> @ND 4+% ?89 @ND 4+) @= @?VD @ND ?I@A=8H U>=5A9D9 S=>A8 @ND )D?5D QA@N 0?G 3DI@A=86 '@ =8BG JD?8H @N?@ @ND J?89?@DH =S 0?>?E>?UN "Z ?89 %>@AIBDa6":[%^ 9=8d@ U>DIBF9D @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> S>=J UB?IA8E ? UB?GD> =8 ?9JA8AH@>?@A5D BD?5DQA@N=F@ U?G ?89 =8 @ND ,`DJU@ )AH@ ?CHD8@ 8=@AID ?89 ? ND?>A8E QA@N I=F8HDBL ?89 @N?@ @ND$*)0% AH A8I=>>DI@ A8 IB?AJA8E @N?@ 0?>?E>?UN "Z ?89 %>@AIBD a6":[%^ A85?BA9?@D @ND )D?5DQA@N 0?G U=>@A=8H =S @ND $DQ 0=BAIG6

    ///6   (02@K=/=I ?:5 %2G> (:ADSL @ND $*)0% I=8@D89D9 @N?@ A@ \AH =8BG @N>=FEN @ND 4+%kUF>HF?8@ @= 0?>?E>?UN "Z =S @ND I=BBDI@A5DBG#C?>E?A8D9 S=>J $*) 0B?GD> 4=8@>?I@ [4+%L %UU6

    c 4+%L %>@AIBD a6"[?^[A^ ?89 [AA^L ?@ :_ ?89 %>@AIBD ;Y6; [A^ ?89 [AA^6

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    19/54

      "c

    %L q "Z^k@N?@ @ND $*)0% ?E>DD9 @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> Q=FB9 N?5D @ND ?F@N=>A@G @= 9AHIAUBA8D$*) UB?GD>H S=> lI=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?Bd @= @ND )D?EFD6] 0%0>D#7+ ?@ "6

    '8 A@H U=H@#ND?>A8E C>ADSL ?B@N=FEN A@ >DHABD9 S>=J A@H DJUN?HAH =8 \9AHIAUBA8DL] @ND$*)0% >DDJUN?HAfD9 @ND AJU=>@?8ID =S 0?>?E>?UN "ZL I=8@D89A8E @N?@ A@ \IA>IFJHI>ACDH @ND4=JJAHHA=8D>dH I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B l>AEN@gHhd6 6 6 6 &ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH =8BG I=89FI@

    9D@>AJD8@?B >AEN@H ?>D @=kS=BB=QA8E ? SA89A8E =S EFAB@ ?89 @ND =UU=>@F8A@G S=> ? ND?>A8EkSA8DL HFHUD89L ?89m=> @D>JA8?@D ? 0B?GD> 4=8@>?I@6] 0%0=H@#7+ ?@ "c6

    -A5D8 @NAH BAJA@?@A=8 =8 NAH U=QD>L @ND $*)0% HDDH 4=JJAHHA=8D> -==9DBBdHAJUBDJD8@?@A=8 =S @ND )D?5D QA@N 0?G DBDJD8@ =S @ND $DQ 0=BAIG ?H ?8

    AJUD>JAHHACBD D89#>F8 ?>=F89 @ND 4+% 6 6 6 6 ?8?B=E=FH g@=h !"#$%%$gLh QND>D @ND)D?EFD ?>EFD9 @N?@ \@NAH I?HD AH U?>@AIFB?>BG AJU=>@?8@ CDI?FHD A@ I=8ID>8H @ND9AHD?HD ?89 HI=F>ED =S 9>FE ?CFHD6] !"#$%%$L HBAU =U6 ?@ ;a6 KDHUA@D @NAH I=8@D8@A=8?89 @ND =C5A=FH AJU=>@?8ID =S @ND AHHFDL %>CA@>?@=> T?HND>/

    I=8IBF9Dg9h @N?@ QND8 @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> DH@?CBAHNDH U=BAIADH => U>=ID9F>DHLQNAIN N?5D @ND DSSDI@ =S >FBDH => >DEFB?@A=8HL gh @N=HD U=BAIADH ?89U>=ID9F>DHL QNAIN ?>D AJU?I@D9 CG @ND I=BBDI@A5D C?>E?A8A8E >DB?@A=8HNAUL?>D 8=@ UBD8?>G A8 8?@F>D6 :0$#.,1 .&+4),"+1 "% ;.3%)0&+$< ), ;=&.0"!"$9<.&+4),"+1> +4.+ "% #)+ +4$ %8)'$ )! +4$ 6)--"%%")#$,?% .&+4),"+1 $,

    +4$ +$,-% )! +4$ 8)00$8+"@$ 3.,/."#"#/ ./,$$-$#+A 

    7- 6 ?@ Y;6 &ND>DL @ND $*)dH =8BG H=BF@A=8 Q?H @= >D@F>8 @= @ND C?>E?A8A8E @?CBD QA@N@ND $*)0%L 8=@ @= F8AB?@D>?BBG AJU=HD U>=ID9F>DH ?89 U=BAIADH @N?@ 5A=B?@D @ND 4+%6&ND H?JD >DJ?A8H @>FD @=9?G6

    0%0=H@#7+ ?@ ;a#;c [DJUN?HAH A8 =>AEA8?B^6

    &ND $*) 9AH?E>DDH/

    $=@QA@NH@?89A8E @ND .8A=8dH ?HHD>@A=8 @N?@ @ND =8BG \H=F>ID] =S @ND4=JJAHHA=8D>dH ?F@N=>A@G A8 I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B J?@@D>H AH U?>?E>?UN "Z =S @ND$*) 0B?GD> 4=8@>?I@L 6 6 6 @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH ?F@N=>A@G =>AEA8?@DH A8L ?89 AH 9DSA8D9CGL U>=5AHA=8H A8 @ND 4P+6 %B@N=FEN @ND $*)0% HFEEDH@D9 ?@ @ND ND?>A8E @N?@ @ND4P+ U>AJ?>ABG I=8ID>8H @ND >DB?@A=8HNAU ?J=8E @ND BD?EFD ?89 A@H IBFCHL A@ AH SA>JBGDH@?CBAHND9 @N?@ @ND 4P+ AH \A8I=>U=>?@D9 CG >DSD>D8ID A8 @ND I=BBDI@A5D C?>E?A8A8E?E>DDJD8@6] '()*$+,$- ./() 0/")/5*L ?@ Y"i 8$$D $6)6L "8 '+)$%$8 !5*8L ?@c ["caa^ [T?EDBL %>C6^ [UB?GD> ?E>DDJD8@ A8I=>U=>?@DH 4P+L QNAIN AH CA89A8E =8UB?GD>H^6 0B?GD>H ?IV8=QBD9ED A8 @ND $*) 0B?GD> 4=8@>?I@ @N?@ @NDG ?>D C=F89 CG

    IBFC ?89 BD?EFD \>FBDH ?89 U>=ID9F>DHL] A8IBF9A8E @ND 4P+6 4=8@>?I@ q "_[\2FBDH]^i 4+% %>@6 " [\l$*) 2FBDHd JD?8H @ND 4=8H@A@F@A=8 ?89 +GB?QHL gD@I6h]^6 *?>S>=J 9DSA8A8E @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH ?F@N=>A@GL @ND 4+% o A8IBF9A8E @ND UB?GD> I=8@>?I@A@HDBS o \52E+"C%$-)$8  g@ND UB?GD>dHh ?Q?>D8DHH]  =S   @ND ?F@N=>A@G E>?8@D9 @= @ND4=JJAHHA=8D> A8 @ND 4P+6 0B?GD> 4=8@>?I@ q "Z6

    .89D> @ND 4P+L @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> AH ?F@N=>AfD9/ @= \A8@D>U>D@ ?89 S>=J @AJD@= @AJD DH@?CBAHN U=BAIG ?89 U>=ID9F>D] QA@N >DHUDI@ @= @ND \D8S=>IDJD8@] =S NAHI=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B ?F@N=>A@G [4P+ n a6Z^i @= AJU=HD 9AHIAUBA8D =8 UB?GD>HL

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    20/54

      ;X

    A8IBF9A8E @N>=FEN HFHUD8HA=8HL SA8DHL ?89 I=8@>?I@ @D>JA8?@A=8H [1-6 n a6":[%^^i @=9AH?UU>=5D UB?GD> I=8@>?I@H S=> I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B [1-6  nn a6"_[%^ P "Z6_^i @=9DIB?>D ?8G UB?GD> A8DBAEACBD @= UB?G [1-6 n "j6";^i @= ?>CA@>?@D ?8G 9AHUF@D A85=B5A8EUB?GD> I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B J?@@D>H [1-6  n a6:[K^^i ?89 \A8 ?99A@A=8 @= NAH =@ND>U=QD>H 6 6 6 @= C?> ?89 U>=NACA@] ?8G A89A5A9F?B \S>=J D8@>G @= ?8G H@?9AFJ => U?>VFHD9 CG @ND )D?EFD => A@H JDJCD> IBFCH => ?SSABA?@DH S=> @ND U>?I@AID => D`NACA@A=8 =S

    U>=SDHHA=8?B S==@C?BB] [n a6":[K^^6 &ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> AH ?BH= ED8D>?BBG DJU=QD>D9@= \@?VD => ?9=U@ ?UU>=U>A?@D BDE?B ?I@A=8 => HFIN =@ND> H@DUH => U>=ID9F>DH ?H ND9DDJH 8DIDHH?>G ?89 U>=UD> A8 @ND CDH@ A8@D>DH@H =S] S==@C?BB QA@N >DE?>9 @=A8@DE>A@G =S @ND E?JD J?@@D>H6 AJD8@?B4=89FI@L] ?99>DHHDH @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH C>=?9 ?F@N=>A@G @= 9DSA8D ?89 ?99>DHH QN?@I=8H@A@F@DH \I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B 6 6 6 @= @ND )D?EFDL A@H JDJCD> IBFCHgLh =>DJUB=GDDH6] &ND B?8EF?ED =S @NAH U>=5AHA=8L QNAIN N?H CDD8 U?>@ =S @ND 4+% S=> =5D>_Z GD?>HL 8$$ "cYa $*) ?89 %*) 4=8H@A@F@A=8L %>@AIBD $#b''' ?@ $#a6;L ?UUBADH @= @ND4=JJAHHA=8D>dH ?F@N=>A@G @= ?I@ QA@N >DE?>9 C=@N @= @N=HD QN= ?>D \8=@ ? JDJCD>]=S @ND )D?EFDL ?H QDBB ?H @= UB?GD>HL 16$6L @N=HD \DJUB=GD9 CGL => I=88DI@D9 QA@N @ND)D?EFD => ?8G JDJCD> @ND>D=S6] 4P+ n a6Yi 8$$ ;$C F/%$5+8 A@G S=> @N?@ I=8IBFHA=8 AHL A8 S?I@L @ND

     '()*$+,$- ./() 9DIAHA=8 =S %>CA@>?@=> T?HND>L IA@D9 CG C=@N HA9DH6

    ONABD 8=@ =8 ?BB S=F>HL @ND>D ?>D HFCH@?8@A?B S?I@F?B HAJAB?>A@ADH CD@QDD8 '()*$+,$-./()  ?89 @NAH J?@@D>6  *F>@ND>L @ND>D ?>D H@>=8E U?>?BBDBH CD@QDD8 @ND ?>EFJD8@H UF@S=>Q?>9 CG D?IN HA9D A8 @NAH ->AD5?8ID ?89 @N=HD @NDG J?9D A8 '()*$+,$- ./()6

    %>CA@>?@=> T?HND>dH 9DIAHA=8 A8  '()*$+,$- ./()  AH 8=@ JD>DBGL @= @ND D`@D8@?UUBAI?CBDL CA89A8E U>DID9D8@i A@ ?BH= U>=5A9DH ?8 ?UU>=U>A?@D ?8?BG@AI S>?JDQ=>V S=>?UU>=?INA8E ?89 >DH=B5A8E @ND 0?>@ADHd 9AH?E>DDJD8@H =5D> @ND )D?5D QA@N 0?G HDI@A=8 =S @ND$DQ 0=BAIG ?89 @NDA> 9AH?E>DDJD8@H =5D> =@ND> DBDJD8@H =S @ND $DQ 0=BAIG6

    %H H@?@D9 CG %>CA@>?@=> T?HND>/

    '8 @NAH %>CA@>?@=>dH =UA8A=8L @ND I?HD CDS=>D FHL A8 ED8D>?B @D>JHL >DU>DHD8@H ? IB?HHAI9AHUF@D =S I=8@>?I@ A8@D>U>D@?@A=8L A8 QNAIN @ND MFDH@A=8 AH QND@ND> ID>@?A8 >D@?A8D9J?8?EDJD8@ >AEN@HL A8 @NAH I?HD @N=HD D`D>IAHD9 CG ? @NA>9 U?>@GL @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>=S @ND )D?EFDL ?>D A8 I=8SBAI@ QA@N ?89 @NFH HFUD>HD9D9 CG HUDIASAI ?E>DDJD8@ >AEN@H6

    "X ' H?G \ED8D>?BBG] CDI?FHD @ND>D ?>D AHHFDH >DB?@A8E @= @ND ?UUBAI?CABA@G =S %>@AIBD _Y ?89 @=

    U=HHACBD I=8H@>?A8@H =8 @ND FHD =S @ND ,`DJU@ )AH@ @N?@ ' 9D?B QA@N B?@D> A8 @NAH (UA8A=8 ?89 %Q?>96

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    21/54

      ;"

    %B@N=FEN I=F8HDB S=> @ND 0?>@ADH D?IN H@?@D9 @ND AHHFD H=JDQN?@ 9ASSD>D8@BGLA8 HDJ?8@AI @D>JHL @ND F89D>BGA8E MFDH@A=8 S=> @NAH %>CA@>?@=> @= 9D@D>JA8D AHQND@ND> @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> =S @ND $*)L A8 @ND S?ID =S ID>@?A8 U>=5AHA=8H =S @NDI=BBDI@A5D C?>E?A8A8E ?E>DDJD8@L U>=UD>BG D`D>IAHD9 NAH ?F@N=>A@GL ?H @N?@ ?F@N=>A@GAH I=8@?A8D9 A8 @ND >DBD5?8@ HDI@A=8H =S @ND 4=8H@A@F@A=8 ?89 +G#)?QH ?89 @ND

    I=BBDI@A5D C?>E?A8A8E ?E>DDJD8@L QND8L =8 RFBG jL "caYL ND ?88=F8ID9 @ND A8H@A@F@A=8=S ? S?>#>D?INA8EL I=JU>DND8HA5DL ?FEJD8@D9 9>FE U>=E>?J6

     '()*$+,$- ./() ?@ _:#__6 'S B?8EF?ED >DB?@A8E @= @ND $DQ 0=BAIGdH ?88=F8IDJD8@ QD>DHFCH@A@F@D9 S=> @N?@ >DB?@A8E @= @ND ?88=F8IDJD8@ =S @ND ?FEJD8@D9 9>FE U>=E>?JL @ND WFH@#MF=@D9 H@?@DJD8@H =S %>CA@>?@=> T?HND> Q=FB9 HFIIA8I@BG ?89 ?IIF>?@DBG I?U@F>D C=@N @NDI?HD CDS=>D JD o ? IB?HHAI 9AHUF@D =S B?C=>mJ?8?EDJD8@ I=8@>?I@ A8@D>U>D@?@A=8 o ?89 @NDF89D>BGA8E MFDH@A=8 ' N?5D @= 9D@D>JA8DL QND@ND> DBDJD8@H =S @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH $DQ0=BAIG ?>D A8 I=8SBAI@ QA@N @ND 4+% ?89 4+)6

    '8 %>CA@>?@=> T?HND>dH 5ADQL F8@AB %>@AIBD eee' =S @ND "ca; I=BBDI@A5D C?>E?A8A8E?E>DDJD8@ BAJA@D9 NAH U=QD>L \4=JJAHHA=8D> 2=fDBBDL HA8ID NAH ?UU=A8@JD8@ ?H4=JJAHHA=8D> A8 "cYXL N?9 D`D>IAHD9 UBD8?>G ?F@N=>A@G =5D> JAHI=89FI@ CG $*) UB?GD>HLA8IBF9A8E ABBDE?B 9>FE FHDL QND>DL A8 NAH =UA8A=8L HFIN I=89FI@ JAEN@ N?5D ? 9D@>AJD8@?BAJU?I@ =8 @ND A8@DE>A@G =S ?89m=> UFCBAI I=8SA9D8ID A8 @ND E?JD =S U>=SDHHA=8?B S==@C?BB6] 7-6?@ ZX6 %>CA@>?@=> T?HND> S=F89 @N?@/

    g*h=> J?8G GD?>HL ?@ BD?H@ ?89 F8@AB KDIDJCD> ""L "ca;L @ND U=BAIADH ?89 U>=ID9F>DHS=> 9>FE ?CFHD D9FI?@A=8L 9>FE ?CFHD 9D@DI@A=8L 9>FE ?CFHD >DN?CABA@?@A=8 ?89 ?S@D>I?>DL ?89 UD8?B@ADH S=> @ND JAHFHD =S 9>FEH QD>D DH@?CBAHND9 ?89 AJUBDJD8@D9D`IBFHA5DBG CG @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> =S @ND $*)6 ONABD UB?GD>H U?>@AIAU?@D9 ?89I==UD>?@D9 QA@N @ND )D?EFD A8 D9FI?@A=8?B ?89 UFCBAI HD>5AID DSS=>@HL ?89 ?B@N=FEN@N=HD UB?GD>H QD>D ?SSABA?@D9 QA@N @ND $*)0%L A@ AH IBD?> @N?@ U>A=> @= KDIDJCD> =S

    "ca; @ND>D QD>D 8= >AEN@H ?89 =CBAE?@A=8H >DE?>9A8E D9FI?@A=8L @DH@A8E ?89m=>@>D?@JD8@ =S UB?GD>H A85=B5D9 A8 9>FEH QNAIN QD>D DH@?CBAHND9 CG C?>E?A8A8E?E>DDJD8@ => F89D>H@?89A8EL ?89 Q=FB9 @NFH ?>EF?CBG UB?ID >DH@>AI@A=8H FU=8 @ND4=JJAHHA=8D>dH ?F@N=>A@G A8 @NAH ?>D?6 7-6 ?@ ZZ6

    %S@D> HD@@A8E =F@ NAH F89D>H@?89A8E =S VDG D5D8@H 9F>A8E @ND "ca; 8DE=@A?@A=8HBD?9A8E FU @= @ND ?9=U@A=8 =S %>@AIBD eee' [ 1-6 ?@ ZY#YX^L %>CA@>?@=> T?HND> I=8HA9D>D9 @ND\?BBDED9 lI=8SBAI@Hd CD@QDD8 @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH ?F@N=>A@G ?89 @ND I=BBDI@A5D C?>E?A8A8E?E>DDJD8@L] >D?INA8E @NDHD I=8IBFHA=8H ?C=F@ @N=HD I=8SBAI@H [1-6 ?@ YX#Ya^/

    &ND>D I?8 CD 8= MFDH@A=8 @N?@ @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> =S @ND $*) N?H C>=?9 ?F@N=>A@GF89D> @ND 4=8H@A@F@A=8 ?89 +G#)?QHL QNAIN ?>D A8I=>U=>?@D9 CG >DSD>D8ID A8 @ND

    I=BBDI@A5D C?>E?A8A8E ?E>DDJD8@L @= DH@?CBAHN U=BAIG ?89 U>=ID9F>D ?89 @= @?VD?I@A=8 QNAIN Q=FB9 U>=@DI@ @ND A8@DE>A@G =SL ?89 UFCBAI I=8SA9D8ID A8 @ND E?JD =SU>=SDHHA=8?B S==@C?BB6 &ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> N?H @ND U=QD>L >DI=E8AfD9 CG @ND I=BBDI@A5DC?>E?A8A8E ?E>DDJD8@L @= J?VD >FBDH ?89 D8S=>ID @NDJ6 7-6 ?@ Y"6

    gOhD JFH@ I=8IBF9D @N?@ QND8 @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> DH@?CBAHNDH U=BAIADH ?89U>=ID9F>DHL QNAIN N?5D @ND DSSDI@ =S >FBDH ?89 >DEFB?@A=8HL @N?@ @N=HD U=BAIADH ?89U>=ID9F>DHL QNAIN ?>D AJU?I@D9 CG @ND I=BBDI@A5D C?>E?A8A8E >DB?@A=8HNAUL ?>D 8=@UBD8?>G A8 8?@F>D6 0BD8?>G ?F@N=>A@G AH 8=@ l?CH=BF@Dd => \F8MF?BASAD9d ?F@N=>A@Gi @N?@

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    22/54

      ;;

    AH 8=@ @ND HI=UD =S @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH ?F@N=>A@G F89D> @ND @D>JH =S @ND I=BBDI@A5DC?>E?A8A8E ?E>DDJD8@6] 7-6 ?@ Y;6

    &NAH SA89A8E AH 8=@ JD?8@ @= AJUBG @N?@ 4=JJAHHA=8D> 2=fDBBD 9=DH 8=@ >D@?A8 C>=?9?89 HUDIA?B U=QD>H @= 9D?B QA@N AHHFDH @N?@ A85=B5D @ND lA8@DE>A@G =S @ND E?JD6d3DI@A=8 "" =S %>@AIBD b'' ?89 %>@AIBD b''' =S @ND I=BBDI@A5D C?>E?A8A8E ?E>DDJD8@ CD?>

    H@>=8E QA@8DHH @= @ND S?I@ @N?@ @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> =S @ND $*) N?H HUDIASAI?BBG >D@?A8D9S?>#>D?INA8E ?F@N=>A@G @= ?99>DHH ?89 >DH=B5D A8@DE>A@G =S @ND E?JD J?@@D>H6] 7-6

    &ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH ?FEJD8@D9 9>FE U>=E>?JL AHHFD9 A8 ?II=>9?8ID QA@N @ND4=JJAHHA=8D>dH ?F@N=>A@G QNAIN AH 9D>A5D9 S>=J @ND ED8D>?B B?8EF?ED =S @ND4=8H@A@F@A=8 ?89 +G#)?QH ?89 @ND I=BBDI@A5D C?>E?A8A8E ?E>DDJD8@L AH ? l9=IFJD8@?SSDI@A8E @D>JH ?89 I=89A@A=8H =S DJUB=GJD8@ =S $*) UB?GD>HdL ?89 QND>D A@ I=8SBAI@HQA@N ID>@?A8 HUDIASAI U>=5AHA=8H =S @ND I=BBDI@A5D C?>E?A8A8E ?E>DDJD8@L A@ AHHFUD>HD9D9 A8 @N=HD ?>D?H6 7-6 ?@ Y_6

    g'8 @ND 8DE=@A?@A=8H BD?9A8E FU @= @ND "ca; I=BBDI@A5D C?>E?A8A8E ?E>DDJD8@Lh @ND4=JJAHHA=8D>dH 9AHIAUBA8?>G ?F@N=>A@G A8 J?@@D>H A85=B5A8E 9>FE JAHFHD ?89 ?CFHDQ?H BDS@ A8@?I@i N=QD5D>L ID>@?A8 =@ND> HFCWDI@ ?>D?HL HFIN ?H 9>FE @DH@A8E ?89 @NDD5?BF?@A=8 =S INDJAI?B 9DUD89D8IG @>D?@JD8@ S?IABA@ADHL QD>D ?99>DHHD9 CG @NDI=BBDI@A5D C?>E?A8A8E ?E>DDJD8@ ?89 >DU>DHD8@D9 BAJA@?@A=8H =8 @ND IBFCHd ?89m=>@ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH >AEN@H @= IN?8ED @NDA> ?E>DDJD8@H6 7-6 ?@ YY6

    g&hND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH >FBD#J?VA8E ?F@N=>A@G Q?H HFUUB?8@D9L A8 ID>@?A8 >DHUDI@HL CGHUDIASAI ?E>DDJD8@ B?8EF?ED A8 %>@AIBD eee'L QNAIN DH@?CBAHND9 IBD?> U>=ID9F>DHI=8ID>8A8E @ND INDJAI?B 9DUD89D8IG U>=E>?JL @DH@A8E ?89 @ND I=8SA9D8@A?BA@G =SJD9AI?B >DU=>@ @GUD =S J?@D>A?BH6 %H ? 8DIDHH?>G I=>=BB?>GL QD SA89 @N?@ @ND $*)0%L9F>A8E @ND >DID8@ >=F89 =S 8DE=@A?@A=8H ?H QDBB ?H A8 U>D5A=FH I=8@>?I@HL I=8ID9D9ID>@?A8 ?F@N=>A@G @= @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> A8 @D>JH =S NAH I=8@A8FD9 >AEN@ @= DH@?CBAHN

    U=BAIADH ?89 U>=ID9F>DH ?89 @= ?99>DHH ?89 >DH=B5D J?@@D>H QNAIN AJU?I@D9 FU=8@ND A8@DE>A@G =SL => UFCBAI I=8SA9D8ID A8 @ND E?JD =S U>=SDHHA=8?B S==@C?BB6] 7-6 ?@ YY#Yj6

    OA@NA8 @N?@ S>?JDQ=>VL %>CA@>?@=> T?HND> 5ADQD9 NAH @?HV ?H 9DIA9A8E \QNAIN 8DQU>=ID9F>DH =S 4=JJAHHA=8D> 2=HDBBDdH ?FEJD8@D9 9>FE U>=E>?J I=8SBAI@ QA@N @ND HUDIASAIU>=5AHA=8H =S %>@AIBD eee' ?89 QNAIN 8DQ U>=ID9F>DH 9= 8=@6] 7-6 ?@ Ya6 7D H?A9 @N?@ ND Q?H\BAJA@D9 CG @ND HUDIASAI B?8EF?ED =S @ND I=BBDI@A5D C?>E?A8A8E ?E>DDJD8@ 5AH ? 5AH @ND 8DQU>=ID9F>DH DH@?CBAHND9 CG 4=JJAHHA=8D> 2=fDBBDdH 9>FE U>=E>?J6 OD I?8 =8BG 9DIA9DLQND>DL ?89 ASL I=8SBAI@H D`AH@ CD@QDD8 @NDHD @Q= 9=IFJD8@HL ?89 @ND8 9A>DI@ @ND U?>@ADH ?H @=QNAIN U>=ID9F>DH =S @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH 9>FE U>=E>?J J?G CD AJUBDJD8@D9 QA@N=F@5A=B?@A8E @ND I=BBDI@A5D C?>E?A8A8E ?E>DDJD8@6] 7-6 ?@ Yc6

    7D NDB9 @N?@ \U?>@ =S 4=JJAHHA=8D> 2=fDBBDdH ?FEJD8@D9 9>FE U>=E>?JL QNAINDH@?CBAHNDH F8HIND9FBD9 9>FE @DH@A8EL AH A8 I=8SBAI@ QA@N HUDIASAI U>=5AHA=8H =S %>@AIBD eee'?89 AH @ND>DS=>D HFUD>HD9D9 CG @ND ?E>DDJD8@dH B?8EF?ED6] 7-6 ?@ j;6 7D =@ND>QAHD >DWDI@D9@ND $*)0%dH I=8@D8@A=8H @N?@ =@ND> U?>@H =S @ND ?FEJD8@D9 9>FE U>=E>?J QD>D A8 I=8SBAI@QA@N %>@AIBD eee'6 &NFHL S=> D`?JUBDL ND S=F89 @N?@ @ND \4=JJAHHA=8D>dH HUDIASAI?@A=8 =SU?>@AIFB?> U>=NACA@D9 HFCH@?8IDH] Q?H 8=@ A8 I=8SBAI@ QA@N %>@AIBD eee'L A8IBF9A8E \@ND HI=UD=S @ND INDIVA8E U>=ID9F>DH DH@?CBAHND9 A8 %UUD89A` KL] QNAIN 9A9 8=@ \BAJA@ F>A8?BGHAHINDIVH @= U?>@AIFB?> INDJAI?B HFCH@?8IDH6] %H ? >DHFB@L ND I=8IBF9D9 @N?@ @ND>D Q?H \8=

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    23/54

      ;:

    5A=B?@A=8 =S @ND I=BBDI@A5D C?>E?A8A8E ?E>DDJD8@ CG @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH >DH@?@DJD8@ =S NAHED8D>?B >AEN@H @= AJU=HD 9AHIAUBA8DL QNAIN >AEN@H ?>D DH@?CBAHND9 ?89 >DI=E8AfD9 F89D>%>@AIBD b''' =S @ND I=BBDI@A5D C?>E?A8A8E ?E>DDJD8@6] 7-6 ?@ jZ#jY6

    OA@N @NAH S>?JDQ=>V A8 JA89L QN?@ AH @ND AJU=>@ =S  '()*$+,$- ./() S=> =F> I?HDt

    %@ BD?H@ QA@N >DE?>9 @= @ND IN?BBD8ED9 )D?5D QA@N 0?G U>=5AHA=8H =S @ND $DQ 0=BAIGL@ND ?8HQD> AH H@>?AEN@S=>Q?>9L HA8ID 'd5D ?B>D?9G S=F89 @N?@ 0?>?E>?UN "Z ?89 %>@AIBDa6":[%^ 9=8d@ ?UUBG @= @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH )D?5D QA@N 0?G ?I@A=8HL QND@ND> UB?IA8E ? UB?GD>=8 U?A9 ?9JA8AH@>?@A5D BD?5D => =8 @ND ,`DJU@ )AH@6  '()*$+,$- ./() HFUU=>@H @NDI=8IBFHA=8 @N?@L BAVD 4=JJAHHA=8D> 2=fDBBDdH ?FEJD8@D9 9>FE U=BAIG ?89 U>D9DIDHH=>U=BAIADHL @ND $DQ 0=BAIG ?89 U>D9DIDHH=> UD>H=8?B I=89FI@ U=BAIADHL QD>D 5?BA9BG AHHFD9UF>HF?8@ @= @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH \C>=?9] [ '()*$+,$- ./() ?@ Y"^L \S?>#>D?INA8E] [7-6 ?@ Y;^L?89 \UBD8?>G] [D`IDU@ QND>D \A@ I=8SBAI@H QA@N ID>@?A8 HUDIASAI U>=5AHA=8H =S @ND I=BBDI@A5DC?>E?A8A8E ?E>DDJD8@] g7-6 ?@ ZXL Y;L Y_h^ ?F@N=>A@G \F89D> @ND 4=8H@A@F@A=8 ?89 +G#)?QHLQNAIN ?>D A8I=>U=>?@D9 CG >DSD>D8ID A8 @ND I=BBDI@A5D C?>E?A8A8E ?E>DDJD8@L @= DH@?CBAHNU=BAIG ?89 U>=ID9F>D ?89 @= @?VD ?I@A=8 QNAIN Q=FB9 U>=@DI@ @ND A8@DE>A@G =SL ?89 UFCBAII=8SA9D8ID A8 @ND E?JD =S U>=SDHHA=8?B S==@C?BB6] 7-6 ?@ Y"6

    &NAH I=8IBFHA=8 9=DH8d@ D89 JG I=8HA9D>?@A=8 =S @ND )D?5D QA@N 0?G U>=5AHA=8 =S @ND$DQ 0=BAIGL 8=> 9=DH A@ 8DIDHH?>ABG JD?8 @N?@ @ND>D >DJ?A8H 8= HFCH@?8@A5D C?HAH =8 QNAININ?BBD8EDH @= HUDIASAI A8H@?8IDH =S AJUBDJD8@?@A=8 =S @ND )D?5D QA@N 0?G U>=5AHA=8 I?8 CDJ?9D6

    *A>H@L @ND>D AH @ND MFDH@A=8 QND@ND> %>@AIBD _Y ?UUBADH @= ? 4=JJAHHA=8D> ?I@A=8UF>HF?8@ @= @ND )D?5D QA@N 0?G U>=5AHA=8H =S @ND $DQ 0=BAIG6 ' 9D?B QA@N @NAH AHHFD A8 @NDHDI@A=8 \A5L] QNAIN AJJD9A?@DBG S=BB=QH6

    3DI=89L @ND>D AH @ND MFDH@A=8 QND@ND>L D5D8 ?IIDU@A8E @N?@ @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH

    ?F@N=>A@G @= UB?ID ? UB?GD> =8 @ND ,`DJU@ )AH@ AH8d@ IA>IFJHI>ACD9 CG 0?>?E>?UN "Z =>%>@AIBD a6":[%^L @ND>D ?>D =@ND> 4+% => 4+) BAJA@?@A=8H =8 @N?@ ?F@N=>A@G CDG=89 %>@AIBD _Y6 '9D?B QA@N @NAH AHHFD A8 HDI@A=8 \5L] 1+9/56

    *A8?BBGL ' 8=@D ND>D @N?@L ?B@N=FEN A@dH 8=@ IBD?> S>=J %>CA@>?@=> T?HND>dH (UA8A=8 ?89%Q?>9 QND@ND>L ?89 AS H=L N=QL A8  '()*$+,$- ./()L @ND $*)0% >?AHD9 @ND \MFDH@A=8 =S @ND>D?H=8?CBD8DHHL A8 QN=BD => A8 U?>@L =S @ND ?FEJD8@D9 9>FE U>=E>?J]"" [1-6 ?@ Y_^L %>CA@>?@=>T?HND> ?99>DHHD9 @ND AHHFD [1-6 ?@ Y:^/

    %>CA@>?@=>H =S B?C=> J?8?EDJD8@ 9AHUF@DH ?>D >DEFB?>BG I=8S>=8@D9 QA@N ?BBDE?@A=8H@N?@ ?8 DJUB=GD>rH >FBDH => >DEFB?@A=8H ?>D I=8@>?>G @= @ND HUDIASAI @D>JH =S ?I=BBDI@A5D C?>E?A8A8E ?E>DDJD8@ ?89L @ND>DS=>DL HN=FB9 CD 5A@A?@D96 '8 HFIN I?HDH @ND

    IN?BBD8EA8E U?>@G S>DMFD8@BG ?>EFDHL A8 @ND ?B@D>8?@A5DL @N?@ @ND >FBDH ?>D ?>CA@>?>G

    "" &ND $*) I=8@D89D9 @N?@ @ND \4=JJAHHA=8D>dH lA8@DE>A@G =S @ND E?JDd ?F@N=>A@GL A8H=S?> ?H A@

    Q?H D`D>IAHD9 =8 RFBG jL "caY CG @ND ?88=F8IDJD8@ =S ?8 ?FEJD8@D9 9>FE U>=E>?JL 6 6 6 AH =8BGE=5D>8D9L A8 5ADQ =S @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH QA9D B?@A@F9D @= I=8@>=B I=89FI@ QNAIN ND 9D@D>JA8DH Q=FB9CD 9D@>AJD8@?B @= @ND AJ?ED =S @ND )D?EFDL CG @ND >FBD =S >D?H=86] '()*$+,$- ./() ?@ Y"6

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    24/54

      ;_

    ?89 F8>D?H=8?CBD ?89 @ND>DS=>D @NDG HN=FB9 N?5D 8= DSSDI@ FU=8 DJUB=GDDHr @D>JH?89 I=89A@A=8H =S DJUB=GJD8@6

    7D S=F89 @N?@L \QA@N @ND U=HHACBD D`IDU@A=8 =S @ND $*)dH A8@D8@A=8 @= I=89FI@ @Q= [;^F8HIND9FBD9 F>A8?BGHAH @DH@H 9F>A8E @ND >DEFB?> HD?H=8L @N?@ @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH ?FEJD8@D99>FE U>=E>?J ?UUD?>H @= CD >D?H=8?CBD =8 A@H S?ID] [ 1-6K ?89 @N?@ \g?hS@D> I=8HA9D>?@A=8 =S

    @ND D5A9D8IDL QNAIN HFUU=>@H ? SA89A8E @N?@ @ND IF>>D8@ 9>FE U>=E>?J AH HFCWDI@ @=AJU>=5DJD8@ A8 ID>@?A8 ?>D?HL 6 6 6 @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH ?FEJD8@D9 9>FE U>=E>?J AH>D?H=8?CBDL UD> HDL QND>D A@ ?99>DHHDH @NDHD HFCWDI@ J?@@D>H6] 7-6 ?@ Y:#Y_6

    '8 @NAH I?HDL A8 ?99A@A=8 @= J=F8@A8E ? S>=8@?B ?@@?IV I=8@D89A8E @N?@ @ND )D?5D QA@N0?G U>=5AHA=8H =S @ND $DQ 0=BAIG ?>D A85?BA9 HA8ID A8 I=8SBAI@ QA@N @ND 4+%L @ND $*)0% N?HI>A@AIAfD9 HUDIASAI ?HUDI@H =S @ND U>=5AHA=8HL HFIN ?H A@H ?BB=QA8E \UB?GD>H @= CD C?88D9 S>=JUB?GA8E => U>?I@AIA8E S=> ?8 A89DSA8A@D UD>A=96] +F@ @ND $*)0% N?H 8=@ ND>D S=>J?BBGIN?BBD8ED9 @ND >D?H=8?CBD8DHH DA@ND> =S @ND $DQ 0=BAIG => =S @ND HUDIASAI U>=5AHA=8H =S @N?@U=BAIG @N?@ A@ N?H I>A@AIAfD9 A8 @NAH U>=IDD9A8E6 7D8IDL \>D?H=8?CBD8DHH] AH 8=@ ?8 AHHFD CDS=>DJDL ?89 ' D`U>DHH 8= =UA8A=8 =8 A@6

    /G6 

     (02@K=/=I P1>= (5 Z[ (..@K 5 (7 4/4

    ?1@/7KR

    @ @ND ?99A@A=8?B I=8IBFHA=8 @N?@ @ND>D ?>D8= BAJA@H =8 @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH ?F@N=>A@G QA@N >DE?>9 @= )D?5D QA@N 0?G => =8 @NDAJUBDJD8@?@A=8 =S @ND )D?5D QA@N 0?G U>=5AHA=8 =S @ND $DQ 0=BAIG6 '8 IN?BBD8EA8E @ND4=JJAHHA=8D>dH I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B ?F@N=>A@GL @ND $*)0% >DBADH 8=@ JD>DBG =8 0?>?E>?UN"Z CF@ ?BH= =8 %>@AIBD _Y =S @ND 4+%6

    ' ND>D ?99>DHH @ND MFDH@A=8 QND@ND> %>@AIBD _Y ?89 A@H U>=ID9F>?B >DMFA>DJD8@H

    ?UUBG @= 4=JJAHHA=8D> ?I@A=8H F89D> @ND )D?5D QA@N 0?G U>=5AHA=8H =S @ND $DQ 0=BAIGLA8IBF9A8E UB?IA8E ? UB?GD> =8 U?A9 ?9JA8AH@>?@A5D BD?5D => =8 @ND ,`DJU@ )AH@6

    S6  ?>50< ?51G/=/10= 1A (5 Z[

    %>@AIBD _Y6"[?^ =S @ND 4+% HD@H U>=ID9F>DH S=> N?89BA8E ID>@?A8 9AHUF@DHL A8IBF9A8E9AHUF@DH =5D> \? SA8D => HFHUD8HA=8 AJU=HD9 FU=8 ? UB?GD> S=> I=89FI@ =8 @ND UB?GA8E SADB9LA8IBF9A8E F88DIDHH?>G >=FEN8DHH => F8HU=>@HJ?8BAVD I=89FI@] ?89 9AHUF@DH =5D> \?I@A=8@?VD8 ?E?A8H@ ? UB?GD> CG @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> S=> I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B @= @ND A8@DE>A@G =SL =>UFCBAI I=8SA9D8ID A8L @ND E?JD =S U>=SDHHA=8?B S==@C?BB6] &NDHD ?>D @= CD \U>=IDHHD9D`IBFHA5DBG ?H S=BB=QH/ @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> QABB U>=JU@BG HD89 Q>A@@D8 8=@AID =S NAH  ?I@A=8 @=@ND UB?GD>L QA@N ? I=UG @= @ND $*)0%6 OA@NA8 @N>DD [:^ CFHA8DHH 9?GH S=BB=QA8E HFIN Q>A@@D8

    8=@ASAI?@A=8L @ND UB?GD> ?SSDI@D9  @ND>DCGL => @ND $*)0% QA@N @ND UB?GD>dH ?UU>=5?BL J?G?UUD?B A8 Q>A@A8E @= @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>6] %>@AIBD _Y6;[?^ ?89 [C^ U>=5A9D @N?@ S=> ?UUD?BHF89D> %>@AIBD _Y6"[?^/

    •  &ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> QABB DA@ND> ?UU=A8@ ? ND?>A8E =SSAID> ?S@D> I=8HFB@?@A=8 QA@N @ND,`DIF@A5D KA>DI@=> =S @ND $*)0% => NAJHDBS HD>5D ?H @ND ND?>A8E =SSAID>i

    •  &ND UB?GD> J?G CD ?II=JU?8AD9 CG I=F8HDBi ?89

    •  &ND $*)0% ?89 @ND $*) J?G ?@@D89 @ND ND?>A8E ?89 U>DHD8@ D5A9D8ID6

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    25/54

      ;Z

    %>@AIBD _Y6"[?^ 9D?BH C=@N QA@N 9AHUF@DH A85=B5A8E ? UB?GD>dH =8#SADB9 I=89FI@ ?899AHUF@DH A85=B5A8E \I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B] CG ? UB?GD>6 %>@AIBD _YdH U>=ID9F>DH JFH@ CDS=BB=QD9 QA@N >DE?>9 @= \? SA8D => HFHUD8HA=8 AJU=HD9 FU=8 ? UB?GD> S=> I=89FI@ =8 @NDUB?GA8E SADB9] ?89 ?8 \?I@A=8 @?VD8 ?E?A8H@ ? UB?GD> CG @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> S=> I=89FI@9D@>AJD8@?B6] &NFH ? 9AH@A8I@A=8 AH 9>?Q8 CD@QDD8 HUDIASAI?BBG 9DSA8D9 ?I@A=8HL A85=B5A8ESA8DH => HFHUD8HA=8H S=> ? UB?GD>dH UB?GA8E SADB9 I=89FI@L ?89 ?8G 4=JJAHHA=8D> \I=89FI@

    9D@>AJD8@?B] ?I@A=8 A85=B5A8E ? UB?GD>L U>DHFJ?CBG A8IBF9A8E CF@ 8=@ 8DIDHH?>ABG BAJA@D9 @=SA8DH ?89 HFHUD8HA=8H6 0?>@AIFB?>BG EA5D8 @ND WF`@?U=HA@A=8 =S @ND HUDIASAI ?I@A=8HL \SA8D] ?89\HFHUD8HA=8L] S=> =8#SADB9 I=89FI@ ?89 @ND ED8D>?B \?I@A=8] S=> I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?BL @ND =8BG>D?H=8?CBD >D?9A8E =S %>@AIBD _Y6"[?^ AH @N?@ A@ ?UUBADH @= ?8G \?I@A=8L] 8=@ WFH@ SA8DH ?89HFHUD8HA=8HL @?VD8 \?E?A8H@ ? UB?GD> CG @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> S=> I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B6]

    \6  P1>= J1;;/==/10>5 $28> N(75 A15 J103:7< P>00 %> ";.1=>=

    H>2G> 4/5 #>4 ?1@/7KR

    ' 8=Q I=8HA9D> QND@ND> ?8 ?I@A=8 CG @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> A85=B5A8E UF@@A8E ? UB?GD>=8 U?A9 ?9JA8AH@>?@A5D BD?5D => =8 @ND ,`DJU@ )AH@ @>AEED>H @ND U>=ID9F>DH =S _Y6"[?^ ?89_Y6;[?^ P [C^6

    &ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> @?VDH \?I@A=8] QND8 ND UB?IDH ? UB?GD> =8 U?A9 ?9JA8AH@>?@A5DBD?5D => =8 @ND ,`DJU@ )AH@6

    %>@AIBD _Y AH @>AEED>D9 AS HFIN ?8 \?I@A=8] AH CDA8E \@?VD8 5)51+8,  @ND UB?GD>] ?89 AS@ND \?I@A=8] AH \ 9"/  I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B] [DJUN?HAH ?99D9^6

    ' SA89 @N?@ F89D> @ND I=JJ=8 JD?8A8E =S @ND Q=>9HL \?E?A8H@] ?89 \S=>L] @ND ?I@A=8HU>=5A9D9 S=> A8 @ND )D?5D QA@N 0?G HDI@A=8 A8 @ND $DQ 0=BAIG ?>D \?E?A8H@ @ND UB?GD>] ?89\S=> I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B6] 4=JJ=8 JD?8A8EH =S \?E?A8H@] A8IBF9D \A8 =UU=HA@A=8 @=L]

    \?95D>HD @=L] \@=Q?>9L] ?89 \FU=86]";

      .89D> ?8G =S @N=HD JD?8A8EHL CF@ U?>@AIFB?>BG @NDB?@@D> @Q=L ' SA89 @N?@ @ND Q=>9 AH ?UUBAI?CBD @= ?I@A=8H =S @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> F89D> @ND )D?5DQA@N 0?G U>=5AHA=86 ,MF?BBGL QNABD @ND )D?5D QA@N 0?G U>=5AHA=8 AH D`UBAIA@BG S>?JD9 A8 @D>JH=S @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH ?I@A=8H U>DID9A8E ?89 UD89A8E NAH I=8HA9D>?@A=8 QND@ND> ? UB?GD> AHEFAB@G =S I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B ?89L AS H=L QN?@ >DJD9A?B ?I@A=8 @= @?VDL ' SA89 @N?@ HA8ID @ND>D?H=8 \S=>] ?8G )D?5D QA@N 0?G ?I@A=8 >DB?@DH @= I=89FI@ @N?@ ?UUD?>H @= S?BB QA@NA8 @ND>FC>AI =S I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?BL @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH ?I@A=8 S?BBH QA@NA8 @ND ?JCA@ =S \S=>I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B6]

    V6  N(7O

    %8 ?99A@A=8?B MFDH@A=8 I=8ID>8A8E QND@ND> %>@AIBD _YdH U>=ID9F>?B >AEN@H ?>D

    @>AEED>D9 CG @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH UB?IA8E ? UB?GD> =8 U?A9 ?9JA8AH@>?@A5D BD?5D => =8 @ND,`DJU@ )AH@ >DB?@DH @= QND@ND> @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH \?I@A=8] JFH@ CD 9DDJD9 @= A85=B5D\9AHIAUBA8D] A8 =>9D> S=> %>@AIBD _Y @= ?UUBG6

    "; 

    L6)6L N@@U/mm9AI@A=8?>G6>DSD>D8ID6I=JmC>=QHDm?E?A8H@ 6

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    26/54

      ;Y

    &ND 0?>@ADH N?5D D`@D8HA5DBG C>ADSD9 @ND MFDH@A=8 =S QN?@ AH ?89 AH8d@ \9AHIAUBA8DL] A8@ND I=8@D`@H =S @ND )D?5D QA@N 0?G AHHFD ?89 =S @ND =@ND> DBDJD8@H =S @ND $*)0%dH E>AD5?8ID6

    ONABD J?A8@?A8A8E @N?@ @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> Q=FB9 N?5D @ND ?F@N=>A@G @= AJU=HD U?A9?9JA8AH@>?@A5D BD?5D => @ND ,`DJU@ )AH@ F89D> @ND $DQ 0=BAIG F89D> NAH C>=?9 9AHIAUBA8?>G?F@N=>A@GL @ND $*)dH SA>H@ BA8D =S ?>EFJD8@ AH @N?@ \@ND U>=U=HD9 FHD =S @ND BAH@ ?88=F8ID9 A8

    @ND 0=BAIG AH 8=@ 9AHIAUBA8?>G CF@L ?H @ND .8A=8 I=>>DI@BG ?IV8=QBD9EDHL AH FHD9 lU>A=> @= @NDAJU=HA@A=8 =S 9AHIAUBA8D6d ,`6 " [->AD5?8ID^ ?@ _6] $*)0>D#7+ ?@ "j6 *F>@ND>L ?II=>9A8E @= @ND$*)L A@ \AH QDBB HD@@BD9 @N?@ UB?IA8E ?8 DJUB=GDD =8 U?A9 BD?5D UD89A8E ?8 A85DH@AE?@A=8 9=DH8=@ I=8H@A@F@D 9AHIAUBA8D6] 7-6  [IA@?@A=8H =JA@@D9^6 '8 @ND $*)dH 5ADQL @ND $DQ 0=BAIG\S=>J?BAfDH @ND U>?I@AID @N?@ N?H D`AH@D9 S=> J?8G GD?>HL U>D5A=FHBG F8IN?BBD8ED9L F89D>QNAIN @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> N?H @?VD8 AJJD9A?@D ?I@A=8 @= ?99>DHH 5A=BD8@ ?89 =@ND> HD>A=FHA8IA9D8@H =S I>AJA8?B CDN?5A=>L =8 ? @DJU=>?>G C?HAHL 9F>A8E @ND UD89D8IG =S ? BD?EFDA85DH@AE?@A=8 A8@= QND@ND> 9AHIAUBA8D HN=FB9 CD AJU=HD9 A8 @ND SA>H@ UB?ID6] $*)0=H@#7+ ?@"X6

    &ND $*)0%dH U=HA@A=8 =8 @ND AHHFD =S QND@ND> QN?@ A@ I?BBH \U>D#ND?>A8EHFHUD8HA=8H] F89D> @ND $DQ 0=BAIGL 0%0=H@#7+ ?@ "L AH \9AHIAUBA8D] N?H D5=B5D9 9F>A8E @NAHE>AD5?8ID U>=IDD9A8E6

    '8 A@H R?8F?>G ;jL ;X"ZL E>AD5?8IDL @ND $*)0% I=8@D89D9/

    •  \g&hND >D5AHD9 0D>H=8?B 4=89FI@ 0=BAIG AJU=HDH ? 8DQ S=>J =S UB?GD> 9AHIAUBA8DU>=NACA@D9 CG @ND 4+%L CG U>=5A9A8E @N?@ @ND $*) J?G F8AB?@D>?BBG UB?ID ? UB?GD> =8@ND l4=JJAHHA=8D> ,`DJU@ )AH@L] ?89 9F>A8E @N?@ @AJD @ND UB?GD> AH U>=NACA@D9 S>=JU>?I@AIA8E => U?>@AIAU?@A8E A8 ?8G E?JDH6] $*) ,`6 " ?@ ;6

    •  &ND \$*) 4=8H@A@F@A=8 ?89 +GB?QHL QNAIN 9DSA8DH @ND FHD ?89 HI=UD =S @ND4=JJAHHA=8D> ,`DJU@ )AH@L 9=DH 8=@ U>=5A9D S=> @ND )AH@ @= CD FHD9 A8 HFIN ?9AHIAUBA8?>G J?88D>6] 7-6 ?@ _6 

    • 

    \&ND>D AH 8= U>=5AHA=8 A8 @ND 4+% => @ND 4=8H@A@F@A=8 ?89 +GB?QH S=> @ND4=JJAHHA=8D> @= FHD @ND ,`DJU@ )AH@ ?H ? JD?8H =S UF@@A8E ? UB?GD> =8 U?A9HFHUD8HA=8 ?H ? U?>@ =S ? 9AHIAUBA8?>G U>=IDHH6] 7-6 ": 

    ": &NDHD 5ADQH QD>D I=8HAH@D8@ QA@N @ND U=HA@A=8 @ND $*)0% H@?VD9 =F@ A8 KDIDJCD> ;X"_ A8

    @ND  '-/15+ 0$,$/8$+ ?UUD?B CDS=>D 6 7D89D>H=86 '8 @ND 0$,$/8$+ J?@@D>L ?S@D> @ND D`UA>?@A=8 =S ?8?E>DDJD8@ @N?@ 6 0D@D>HD8 Q=FB9 CD UB?ID9 =8 @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> D`DJU@ BAH@ 9F>A8E @ND UD89D8IG=S NAH I>AJA8?B U>=IDD9A8EHL 6 0D@D>HD8 ?89 @ND $*)0% =CWDI@D9 @= @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH I=8@A8FA8EUB?IDJD8@ =S 6 0D@D>HD8 =8 @ND BAH@6 6 TDHHBD> I=8@D89D9 @N?@ UB?IA8E 6 0D@D>HD8 =8 @ND D`DJU@BAH@ =5D> @ND =CWDI@A=8 =S 6 0D@D>HD8 \Q?H @ND DMFA5?BD8@ =S ? 9AHIAUBA8?>G HFHUD8HA=8 CDI?FHD ' I?8@DBB G=F @N?@ @ND>D AH 8= C?HAH A8 @ND $*) I=8H@A@F@A=8 S=> WFH@ UF@@A8E H=JDC=9G =8 @ND

    4=JJAHHA=8D>dH D`DJU@ BAH@ QA@N 8= >D?H=86 3= A8 DSSDI@L @NDG QD>D 9AHIAUBA8A8E NAJ 6 6 6 6]

    *F>@ND>L ?II=>9A8E @= 6 TDHHBD>L \g@hND 4=JJAHHA=8D>rH D`DJU@ BAH@ N?H 8D5D> U>D5A=FHBGCDD8 FHD9 @= UF@ H=JDC=9G =8 g@ND BAH@h QN= AH ?IIFHD9 =S I>AJA8?B ?I@A5A@GL @= =F> V8=QBD9ED6 6 6 6 &ND=8BG @AJD QD N?5D D5D> HDD8 4=JJAHHA=8D> D`DJU@ FHD9L @= =F> V8=QBD9EDL Q?H gQND8h A@ Q?H FHD9S=> UB?GD>H QN= QD>D F8?5?AB?CBD @= UB?G S=> H=JD >D?H=86 &N?@ N?H 8=@ CDD8 @>?9A@A=8?BBG @ND >=BD =SND 4=JJAHHA=8D> D`DJU@ BAH@6 '@ N?H ?BH= CDD8 FHD9 H=JD@AJDH ?H ? Q?G =S C>A8EA8E C?IV ? UB?GD>S>=J 9>FE HFHUD8HA=8H @N?@ @NDG I?8 U>?I@AID CDS=>D @NDG I=F8@ ?E?A8H@ @ND >=H@D>L CDI?FHD ND AH 8=@?5?AB?CBD F89D> ? HFHUD8HA=8 @= UB?G6 +F@ ?H S?> ?H QD ?>D I=8ID>8D9L A@rH 8D5D> CDD8 FHD9 @= U>D5D8@

    ?"+,1+($- "+ +$B, =5)$6

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    27/54

      ;j

    '8 A@H 0>D#7D?>A8E +>ADSL @ND $*)0% D`U?89D9 =8 A@H U=HA@A=8 @N?@ @ND>D \AH 8= 4+%U>=5AHA=8 S=> lU>D#9AHIAUBA8D 9AHIAUBA8Dd A8 @ND S=>J =S HFHUD8HA=8 QA@N U?G =8 @ND ,`DJU@)AH@] [0%0>D#7+ ?@ ""^6 '@ ?HHD>@D9/

    g&hND $DQ 0=BAIG U>=5A9DH S=> @ND F8U>DID9D8@D9 FHD =S @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> ,`DJU@

    )AH@ [@ND \,`DJU@ )AH@]^ ?H ? 5DNAIBD S=> A8@D>AJ 9AHIAUBA8DL QND>DCG ? UB?GD>8(8=$2,$-   =S I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B AH A85=BF8@?>ABG HFHUD89D9 QA@N U?G ?89 C?>>D9S>=J U?>@AIAU?@A8E A8 U>?I@AIDH ?89 E?JDH @$9"/$  @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> 9D@D>JA8DHQND@ND> @ND UB?GD> AH EFAB@G =S I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B ?89 @$9"/$ @ND UB?GD> N?H ?8=UU=>@F8A@G @= N?5D NAH 4+% >AEN@ @= ? ND?>A8E => @= ?UUD?B ?8G HFIN 9AHIAUBA8?>G9D@D>JA8?@A=86 DBG ?@ =99H QA@N @ND I=BBDI@A5DBG#C?>E?A8D9 S=>J$*) 0B?GD> 4=8@>?I@ [8$$ 4+%L %>@6 _L n "^L QNAIN HUDIASAI?BBG D8FJD>?@DHk?89D`U>DHHBG BAJA@Hk@ND AJU=HA@A=8 =S 4=JJAHHA=8D> 9AHIAUBA8D @= ? @AJD 59,$/ @NDUB?GD> N?H CDD8 S=F89 \EFAB@G] =S I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B 5+-   \"+%3 59,$/ EA5A8E 0B?GD>@ND =UU=>@F8A@G S=> ? ND?>A8E ?@ QNAIN ND J?G CD >DU>DHD8@D9 CG I=F8HDB =S NAHIN=AID 6 6 6 6] 7-6L %UU6 %L q "Z [DJUN?HAH ?99D9^6 &ND I=BBDI@A5DBG#C?>E?A8D9 0B?GD>4=8@>?I@ @NFH U>=NACA@H HFIN \U>D#ND?>A8E 9AHIAUBA8DL] ?89 @ND>D AH 8= U?H@ U>?I@AID=> U>DID9D8@ S=> @NAH FHD =S @ND ,`DJU@ )AH@6 &NAH I=8IBFHA=8 AH F89D>HI=>D9 CG @NDS?I@ @N?@ @ND $*) N?9 @= 5=@D @= ?JD89 A@H 4=8H@A@F@A=8 ?89 +GB?QH @= EA5D @ND4=JJAHHA=8D> HFIN 8DQ ,`DJU@ )AH@ ?F@N=>A@GL ?8 ?JD89JD8@ QNAIN I?88=@ CD?UUBAD9 @= UB?GD>H QA@N=F@ ? I=BBDI@A5DBG C?>E?A8D9 J=9ASAI?@A=8 =S @ND 4+% ?89?E>DDJD8@ =S @ND .8A=86

    7-6 ?@ ;#: [DJUN?HAH A8 =>AEA8?B^6

    %HVD9 @= 9D?B A8 A@H 0=H@#7D?>A8E +>ADS QA@N \QND@ND> ?89L AS H=L N=Q ' HN=FB9 9>?Q ?BA8D 9AH@A8EFAHNA8E CD@QDD8 [?^ UB?GD>#>DB?@D9 ?I@A=8H =S @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> @N?@ HN=FB9 CD

    B?CDBD9 l9AHIAUBA8Dd ?89 [C^ 9DIAHA=8H =S @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> @N?@ >DMFA>D UB?GD> ?I@A=8 @N?@HN=FB9 8=@ CD B?CDBD9 l9AHIAUBA8DLd] @ND $*)0% ?>EFD9 ?H S=BB=QH/

    &ND $*)0% HFCJA@H @N?@ @ND $*) N?H @>FJUD@D9 @ND \9AHIAUBA8D] 5D>HFH \8=8#9AHIAUBA8D] 9DC?@D ?H ? H@>?Q J?8 AHHFD A8 @NAH U>=IDD9A8E6 $=QND>D 9=DH 0?>?E>?UN"Z U>=5A9D @N?@ @ND BAJA@?@A=8H =8 @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B?F@N=>A@G ?UUBG =8BG @= \9AHIAUBA8?>G] ?I@A=86 &ND Q=>9 \9AHIAUBA8D] 9=DH 8=@ ?UUD?>A8 0?>?E>?UN "Z6 2?@ND>L 0?>?E>?UN "Z IA>IFJHI>ACDH @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH I=89FI@9D@>AJD8@?B \>AEN@gHh6] 4+%L %UU6 %L q "Z [AS UB?GD> \AH EFAB@G =S ?8G =@ND> S=>J =SI=89FI@ >D?H=8?CBG WF9ED9 CG @ND )D?EFD 4=JJAHHA=8D> @= CD 9D@>AJD8@?B 6 6 6 L @ND4=JJAHHA=8D> 7"00 4.@$ +4$ ,"/4+ L CF@ =8BG ?S@D> EA5A8E 0B?GD> @ND =UU=>@F8A@G S=> ?ND?>A8E 6 6 6 +) !"#$ 6 6 6 L +) %&%'$#9 6 6 6 i .#9B), +) +$,-"#.+$]^6 &NFHL @ND MFDH@A=8 =S

    QND@ND> \I=F8HDBA8E] => \U?A9 BD?5D] => ?8G@NA8E DBHD 9=DH => 9=DH 8=@ I=8H@A@F@D9AHIAUBA8D AH A>>DBD5?8@ @= ?UUBGA8E @ND BAJA@?@A=8H =S 0?>?E>?UN "Z6 [&ND H?JD AH ?BH=@>FD =S @ND $*) 4=8H@A@F@A=8 ?89 +GB?QHL QNAIN BAJA@H @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH ?F@N=>A@G

    @ND UB?GD> S>=J UB?GA8E QN= Q?H >D?9GL QABBA8EL ?CBD @= UB?G ?89 8=@NA8E H@=UUD9 NAJ ?89 @ND>DS=>DLQD @NA8V A@ HN=FB9 CD @>D?@D9 ?H @ND DMFA5?BD8@ =S 9AHIAUBA8D6] $*)0% ,`6 YL 0$,$/8$+ %>@6 _Y 7>dE &>6"Xc/Z#"Xi ":Y/"_#"Yi ":j/";#":a/"[TDHHBD>^

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    28/54

      ;a

    A8 ? HAJAB?> J?88D> QA@N >DHUDI@ @= UB?GD>H QA@N=F@ JD8@A=8A8E @ND Q=>9\9AHIAUBA8D6] @AIBD _Y AH ND?9D9 \4=JJAHHA=8D> KAHIAUBA8D]i %>@AIBD _YL 3DI@A=8 "LAH ND?9D9 \)D?EFD KAHIAUBA8D6] OD>D @NDHD ND?9A8EH @= CD EA5D8 9AHU=HA@A5D QDAEN@L A@ Q=FB9S=BB=Q @N?@ S=> @ND U>=ID9F>?B U>=5AHA=8H =S %>@AIBD _Y @= ?UUBGL @ND \9AHUF@D] ?>AHA8E S>=J ?8\?I@A=8 @?VD8 ?E?A8H@ ? UB?GD> CG @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> S=> I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B] Q=FB9 N?5D @=A85=B5D H=JD S=>J =S 9AHIAUBA8D6 7=QD5D>L @ND 4+%dH \%>@AIBD jXL -(b,2$'$- )%O %$K02'$4'0),3L @AIBD a6":[%^ ?UUBG [?HL S=> D`?JUBDL CDI?FHDUB?IA8E ? UB?GD> =8 )D?5D QA@N 0?G JFH@ CD 9DDJD9 ? HFHUD8HA=8^6 7=QD5D>L ' N?5D S=F89@N?@ @ND HUDIASAI U>=ID9F>?B J?89?@DH =S %>@AIBD _Y 9= ?UUBG6

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    29/54

      ;c

    &NFHL ' SA89 @N?@ AS @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> 9DIA9DH @= UB?ID ? UB?GD> =8 U?A9?9JA8AH@>?@A5D BD?5D => @ND ,`DJU@ )AH@ UF>HF?8@ @= @ND )D?5D QA@N 0?G U>=5AHA=8H =S @ND$DQ 0=BAIG/

    •  &ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> JFH@ U>=JU@BG HD89 Q>A@@D8 8=@AID =S NAH ?I@A=8 @= @ND UB?GD>L

    QA@N ? I=UG @= @ND $*)0%i

    •  &ND UB?GD>L => @ND $*)0% QA@N @ND UB?GD>dH ?UU>=5?BL J?G QA@NA8 @N>DD 9?GHS=BB=QA8E Q>A@@D8 8=@ASAI?@A=8 ?UUD?B A8 Q>A@A8E @= @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>6

    •  ,A@ND> @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> => NAH 9DHAE8DDL ?UU=A8@D9 ?S@D> I=8HFB@?@A=8 QA@N @ND,`DIF@A5D KA>DI@=> =S @ND $*)0%L QABB HD>5D ?H ND?>A8E =SSAID>6

    •  %@ @ND ND?>A8EL @ND UB?GD> J?G CD ?II=JU?8AD9 CG I=F8HDB ?89 C=@N @ND $*)0% ?89@ND $*) J?G CD U>DHD8@ ?89 U>DHD8@ D5A9D8ID6

    '@dH 8=@DQ=>@NG @N?@ @ND HFCWDI@ J?@@D> =S HFIN ? ND?>A8E QABB CD 9ASSD>D8@ @N?8 @NDHFCWDI@ J?@@D> =S ?8 %>@AIBD _Y ND?>A8E I=89FI@D9 ?S@D> @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> N?H >D?IND9 ?89DIAHA=8 @N?@ ? UB?GD> AH ?I@F?BBG EFAB@G =S I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B ?89 9DIA9D9 =8 QN?@ @ND

    >DJD9A?B ?I@A=8 @= @?VD6

    ' 9= 8=@ 9DIA9D ND>D QND@ND> @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> AH =CBAE?@D9 @= H@?G ?I@F?BBG UB?IA8E? UB?GD> =8 )D?5D QA@N 0?G UD89A8E @ND %>@AIBD _Y ND?>A8E6"_ 

    "_ ' N?5D 8=@D9 D?>BAD> @ND $*)dH I=8@D8@A=8 @N?@ ? \U>?I@AID @N?@ N?H D`AH@D9 S=> J?8G GD?>HL

    U>D5A=FHBG F8IN?BBD8ED9L F89D> QNAIN @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> N?H @?VD8 AJJD9A?@D ?I@A=8 @= ?99>DHH5A=BD8@ ?89 =@ND> HD>A=FH A8IA9D8@H =S I>AJA8?B CDN?5A=>L =8 ? @DJU=>?>G C?HAHL 9F>A8E @ND UD89D8IG=S ? BD?EFD A85DH@AE?@A=8 A8@= QND@ND> 9AHIAUBA8D HN=FB9 CD AJU=HD9 A8 @ND SA>H@ UB?ID6] $*)0=H@#7+ ?@"X6

    ' ?BH= 8=@D @N?@ @ND AHHFD =S @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH =CBAE?@A=8 @= H@?G AJUBDJD8@?@A=8 =S ?0D>H=8?B 4=89FI@ 0=BAIG 9AHIAUBA8?>G 9DIAHA=8 Q?H D`UBAIA@BG 9D?B@ QA@N A8 D?>BAD> 0D>H=8?B 4=89FI@0=BAIADH6 &NFHL ?S@D> @NDA> CDA8E 8= JD8@A=8 =S ? \H@?G] A8 @ND %FEFH@ ;aL "ccjL ?89 (I@=CD> "ccabA=BD8@ 4>AJD 0=BAIADH [$*) ,`H6 : P _^L @ND 0D>H=8?B 4=89FI@ 0=BAIADH =S

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    30/54

      :X

    ^6  J20 J1;;/==/10>5 L=> &M>;.< H/=< =F89 @N?@ A@ 5A=B?@DH ?89m=> >D89D>H JD?8A8EBDHH @ND U>=5AHA=8H =S @ND 4+% @N?@ U>=@DI@UB?GD>H S>=J I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B ?I@A=8 U>A=> @= ? SA89A8E =S EFAB@ ?89 @ND =UU=>@F8A@G S=> ?ND?>A8E6] 0%0=H@#7+ ?@ Y:6

    &ND $*)0% ?I@F?BBG N?H @Q= ?>EFJD8@H6 '@H SA>H@ AH >DSBDI@D9 A8 @ND WFH@#H@?@D9 >DBADS>DMFDH@ o @N?@ @ND ?JD89JD8@ @= @ND ,`DJU@A=8 )AH@ AH A8I=8HAH@D8@ QA@N 4+% U>=5AHA=8HU>=@DI@A8E \UB?GD>H S>=J I=89FI@ 9D@>AJD8@?B ?I@A=8 U>A=> @= ? SA89A8E =S EFAB@ ?89 @ND=UU=>@F8A@G S=> ? ND?>A8E6] &NAH AH @ND H?JD ?>EFJD8@ @ND $*)0% J?VDH QA@N >DE?>9 @= @NDD8@A>D $DQ 0=BAIGdH )D?5D QA@N 0?G U>=5AHA=86 'd5D 9D@D>JA8D9 @N?@ @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> N?H@ND ED8D>?B ?F@N=>A@G @= AJUBDJD8@ @ND )D?5D QA@N 0?G U>=5AHA=8 ?89 @N?@ ?F@N=>A@G AH8d@ A8I=8SBAI@ QA@N 0?>?E>?UN "Z => %>@AIBD a6":[%^L H= @NAH ?>EFJD8@ ?BH= S?ABH @= @ND D`@D8@ A@ AHHUDIASAI?BBG 9A>DI@D9 ?@ @ND ,`DJU@ )AH@ AHHFD6

    &ND MFDH@A=8 @N?@ >DJ?A8H AH QND@ND> @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH FHD =S @ND ,`DJU@ )AH@L ?H\I=8SA>JD9] [?II=>9A8E @= @ND $*)^ A8 @ND ?JD89JD8@ ?@ AHHFDL AH A85?BA9 CDI?FHD @ND?9=U@A=8 =S @ND ?JD89JD8@ 5A=B?@D9 %>@AIBD ;6_[?^ =S @ND 4+%L QNAIN U>=5A9DH @N?@ \AS ?8GU>=U=HD9 IN?8ED A8 @ND $*) 4=8H@A@F@A=8 ?89 +GB?QH I=FB9 HAE8ASAI?8@BG ?SSDI@ @ND @D>JH?89 I=89A@A=8H =S DJUB=GJD8@ =S $*) UB?GD>HL @ND8 @ND $*) QABB EA5D @ND $*)0% 8=@AID =S?89 8DE=@A?@D @ND U>=U=HD9 IN?8ED A8 E==9 S?A@N6]

    .89D> @ND ND?9A8EL \)AH@A8E =S 0B?GD>HL] %>@AIBD "j6"_[%^ =S @ND 4+) U>=5A9DH @N?@

    \g?hBB UB?GD>H JFH@ CD BAH@D9 CG @ND IBFC =8 =8D =S @ND S=BB=QA8E BAH@H/ %I@A5D )AH@gLh 2DHD>5D)AH@gL ?89h ,`DJU@A=8 )AH@L] @ND8 9DHI>ACDH @ND ,`DJU@A=8 )AH@/

    &ND ,`DJU@A=8 )AH@ AH ? HUDIA?B UB?GD> H@?@FH ?5?AB?CBD @= IBFCH =8BG A8 F8FHF?BIA>IFJH@?8IDH6 &ND )AH@ A8IBF9DH @N=HD UB?GD>H QN= N?5D CDD8 9DIB?>D9 CG @ND4=JJAHHA=8D> @= CD @DJU=>?>ABG D`DJU@ S>=J I=F8@A8E QA@NA8 @ND %I@A5D )AH@ BAJA@6%8G >DMFDH@ S=> ?8 ,`DJU@A=8 JFH@ CD HD8@ @= @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> CG $*)$D@L D#J?ABLS?IHAJABD => =@ND> HAJAB?> JD?8H =S I=JJF8AI?@A=8L ?89 JFH@ A8IBF9D I=JUBD@D S?I@H?89 >D?H=8H @= HFUU=>@ HFIN >DMFDH@6 (8BG @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> N?H @ND ?F@N=>A@G @=UB?ID ? UB?GD> =8 @ND ,`DJU@A=8 )AH@i IBFCH N?5D 8= HFIN ?F@N=>A@G6 ,`IDU@ ?HU>=5A9D9 A8 U?>?E>?UN ["^ =S @NAH HFCHDI@A=8 [%^L 8= D`DJU@A=8L >DE?>9BDHH =SIA>IFJH@?8IDHL AH ?F@=J?@AI6 &ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> ?BH= N?H @ND ?F@N=>A@G @= 9D@D>JA8D

    A8 ?95?8ID QND@ND> ? UB?GD>rH @AJD =8 @ND ,`DJU@A=8 )AH@ QABB CD SA8A@D => QABB

    *F>@ND> D5A9D8ID ?C=F@ N=Q @NDHD H@?G#>DB?@D9 IN?8EDH I?JD ?C=F@ Q=FB9 BAVDBG CDUD>@A8D8@ A8 ?8G B?@D> U>=IDD9A8E A8 QNAIN @ND AHHFD =S @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D>dH H@?G#>DB?@D9 =CBAE?@A=8HQ?H 9A>DI@BG >?AHD96 )==VA8E H=BDBG ?@ @ND D5=BF@A=8 =S @ND @D`@ =S @ND 0=BAIADHL ? SF@F>D 9DIAHA=8#J?VD>JAEN@ SA89 HAE8ASAI?8@ @ND D5=BF@A=8 S>=J 8= JD8@A=8 =S ? H@?GL @= @ND U>=5AHA=8 =S ? H@?G >DB?@A8E @=\@ND D8S=>IDJD8@ =S 9AHIAUBA8DL] @ND8 @= ? 8?>>=QD> H@?G U>=5AHA=8 >DB?@A8E =8BG @= @ND \D8S=>IDJD8@=S ? HFHUD8HA=8L] ?89 SA8?BBG @= 8= JD8@A=8 =S ? H@?G6

  • 8/18/2019 4/11/16 - Personal Conduct Non-Inj Arb

    31/54

      :"

    I=8@A8FD F8@AB @ND 4=JJAHHA=8D> 9DDJH @ND D`DJU@A=8 HN=FB9 CD BAS@D9 ?89 @NDUB?GD> >D@F>8D9 @= @ND %I@A5D )AH@6 6 6 6

    (8 KDIDJCD> "YL ;X"_L JDJCD>HNAU =S @ND $*) U?HHD9 2DH=BF@A=8 -#;L QNAINU>=5A9D9/

    &NAH AH @= I=8SA>J @N?@ @ND