20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always...

43
Analytical Strategy Forensic Analysis - Explosives 1

Transcript of 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always...

Page 1: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Analytical StrategyForensic Analysis - Explosives

1

Page 2: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

2

Dr. Sandro Imhasly

Head of Analytics/Explosives Unit

Bomb Disposal Expert

[email protected]

Page 3: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Organigramm FOR

3

FOR-ZED

Page 4: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Koordination

PyrotechnikEntwicklung Analytik/Sprengstoffe

Organization ZED

Page 5: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

ZEDBEXNEDEX

Entschärferstützpunkte CH

Page 6: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Service duties ZED

Page 7: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Explosion / Detonation

Page 8: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Explosions

mechanical explosion

gas/air explosion

detonation

Page 9: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Mechanical explosion

Page 10: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Gas/air explosion

Page 11: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Gas/air explosion

Page 12: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Gas/air explosion - trace pattern

large wreckage

no crater formation

Page 13: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Detonation

Page 14: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Detonation - trace pattern

Explosion centre with crater

Page 15: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Detonation

Page 16: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Detonation

Page 17: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Pressure/Push effect

Page 18: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Pull effect

Page 19: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Detonation

Page 20: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely
Page 21: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Question / Discussion

Page 22: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Question / Discussion

• What analytical methods would you propose for the determination of the diverse explosives components? What are the advantages and disadvantages of the proposed methods?

22

bulk / trace

Page 23: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Bulk explosives

• Explosive Testing Kits

• IMS

• IR

• Raman

• Flame test

• XRD / XRF

• Microscopy

• TLC

23

Page 24: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Raman – Attention!

24

• Do not use for bulk explosives! The added energy of the laser can cause the substance to explode.

Page 25: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

25

Trace explosives

• IC-MS

• GC-(MS)

• HPLC-DAD

• HPLC-MS

• ICP-MS

• AAS

• IMS

• DART-TOF-MS

• ect.

Page 26: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Question / Discussion

• What analytical methods would you propose for the determination of the diverse explosives components? What are the advantages and disadvantages of the proposed methods?

• How would you prepare the gathered evidence for instrumental analysis using the proposed methods?

26

bulk / trace

extractionwater/org. solvent

Page 27: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Explosives

27

Chlorate/Perchlorate mixtures Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil

• Always mixtures:• Al, Mg• Sugar• Fuel • Sulfur

• Black powder, flash powder

• Widely used in fireworks

• XRD/XRF

• IC-MS

• AAS

• ICP-MS

• IMS

Page 28: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Explosives

28

Hexamethylene triperoxide diamine (HMTD)

Triacetone triperoxide (TATP) Mannitol hexanitrate

• HPLC-MS (ESI/APCI)• GC-MS • IMS

• HME – homemade explosives

• Unsafe to handle

Page 29: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Explosives

29

Trinitrotoluene (TNT) Pentaerythritol tetranitrate (PETN) Cyclotrimethylenetrinitramine (RDX) Nitroglycerine (NG)

• HPLC-MS (ESI/APCI)

• GC-MS

• IMS

Page 30: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Explosives

30

Nitrocellulose

• Problem: not a "clear defined" molecule

• Trace analysis only possible by determination of additives• Camphor• Akardite• Centralite• Diphenylamine

• HPLC-MS / GC-MS

Page 31: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Question / Discussion• How would you proceed gathering evidence? What do you consider

important points?

31

Page 32: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Gathering evidence - Blown upmailbox

Page 33: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

33

Sampling material

Page 34: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Explosives residues set

2 m2

Page 35: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Documentation

Page 36: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Documentation

36

Page 37: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Question / Discussion• How would you proceed gathering evidence? What do you consider

important points?

37

Prevention of Mix-up

Prevention of Contamination

Gathering Reference Samples

Prevention of Degradation

Page 38: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Question / Discussion• How would you proceed gathering evidence? What do you consider

important points?

38

Prevention of Mix-up

Prevention of Contamination

Gathering Reference Samples

Prevention of Degradation

Page 39: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Reference Samples

39

August 2014: Einsatz Burg AG

Page 40: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Samples (???)

40

Page 41: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Question / Discussion• What is the point of quantitative analysis of traces of explosives in

offences?

41

Page 42: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Question / Discussion• What is the point of quantitative analysis of traces of explosives in

offences?

42

Conclusions on the quantity of explosives used can only bedrawn from the damage pattern.

Page 43: 20191203 Imhasly Presentation - ETH Z · 2020. 1. 6. · Ammonium nitrate / fuel oil •Always mixtures: •Al, Mg •Sugar •Fuel •Sulfur •Black powder, flash powder •Widely

Questions?